Temporalty with the Judges opinions 35. An Act for the Kings General Pardon Private Acts. 36. An Act for the Confirmation of Wadham-Colledge in Oxon and the Possessions thereof 37. An Act for the Naturalizing of Philip Burlemacchi 38. An Act for the Naturalizing of Giles Vandeput 39. An Act to enable William Earl of Hereford and Sir Francis Seymor Knight to sell Lands for the paiments of Debts and establishing other Lands 40. An Act for the Naturalizing of Sir Robert Anstrother Sir George Abercromy Knights and Iohn Cragge Doctor of Physick 41. An Act to confirm the Copiholders Estates of Stepney and Hackney according to a Decree in Chancery between the Lord of the Manor and the said Copiholders 42. An Act to confirm an assurance of Lands sold by Sir Thomas Beaumont Knight and his wife to Sir Thomas Cheek Knight 43. An Act to erect a Free-school and Alms-house and House of Correction in Lincolnshire 44. An Act to enable Martin Calthorp to sell Lands for preferment of younger Children and paiment of Debts 45. An Act for setling the Manor of Goodneston and other Lands of Sir Edward Ingram Knight 46. An Act to enable Dame Alice Dudley wife of Sir Robert Dudley Knight to assure the Manor of Killingworth and other Lands to Prince Charls 47. An Act to confirm an Exchange of Lands between Prince Charls and Sir Lewis Watson Knight and Baronet 48. An Act for the setling of the Lands of Anthony Vicount Montague for paiment of his Debts and raising of Portions 49. An Act to enable Sir Richard Lumley Knight to sell Lands for the paiment of his Debts and preferment of Children 50. An Act to confirm a Decree in Chancery made by the consent of the Lord of Painswick in Com. Glouc. and his Customary Tenants there 51. An Act for the Naturalization of Sir Francis Steward Knight Walter Steward James Maxwell William Car and Iames Levingston Esquires 52. An Act for the Naturalization of Iohn Young Doctor of Divinity 53. An Act for the Naturalizing of Iane Murrey Widow and William Murrey Esquire 54. An Act to make good a Conveyance of Little Munden made from Sir Peter Vanlore Knight and Sir Charls Caesar Knight unto Edmond Woodhall Esquire and his heirs 55. An Act to enable Vincent Low to sell Lands for paiment of his Debts 56. An Act to enable Toby Palyvicine to sell Lands for the paiment of Debts and preferment of Children 57. An Act for Naturalizing of Sir Robert Car Knight 58. An Act to confirm the Manor of New-Langport and Seavans and other Lands late being the Inheritance of Sir Henry James Knight in a Premunire convicted unto Martin Lumley Lord Mayor of London Alice Woodriff widow and Edward Cropley c. 59. An Act for Naturalizing of Sir Stephen Leisure 60. An Act for Naturalizing of Iames Marquis of Hamilton 61. An Act for Naturalizing of Sir William Anstrother Knight Doctor Balcanqual and Patrick Abercromy 62. An Act to confirm the Sale of Lands made by Sir Edward Heron Knight unto Bevel Moulsworth Esquire and to enable the said Sir Edward to sell other Lands for paiment of Debts and to settle other Lands upon Robert and Edward Heron. 63. An Act for the Naturalizing of Abigal Little and William Little her son 64. An Act for the etablishing of Lands upon Iohn Mohun Esquire son of Sir Rowland Mohun Knight and Baronet according to the Agreements made between them 65. An Act to enable Edward Alcoâ—k to fell the Manor of Rampton and other Lands 66. An Act to explain a Statute made Anno 13 Eliz. for assuring of Eighty two pounds ten shillings per annum to the Bishop of Coventry and Lichfield for ever out of Manors and Lands thereby assured to Edmund Fisher and his heirs 67. An Act for the establishing of Three Lectures in Divinity according to the Will of Thomas Wettenhall Esquire 68. An Act for the repairing of the River running to Colchester and paving of the Town there 69. An Act to enable Francis Clerk Knight to sell Lands for the paiment of Debts and raising of Portions 70. An Act for altering of Gavelkind-Lands being late the Lands of Thomas Potter Esquire Sir George Rivers Knight and Sir Iohn Rivers Baronet and to settle the Inheritance of them upon Sir Iohn Rivors and his heirs 71. An Act to make the Lands of Thomas Earl of Middlesex subject to the paiment of his Debts 72. An Act for the Sale of the Manor of Abbots-Hall late the Possessions of Sir Iames Pointz deceased that the Monies thereby raised may be distributed amongst his Creditors according to his Last Will. 73. An Act for the Naturalizing of Elizabeth Vere and Mary Vere the Daughters of Sir Horatio Vere Knight This Summer Four Regiments of Foot were raised for the service of the United Provinces to be imployed against the Emperor under the Command of four Noble Colonels the Earls of Oxford Essex and Southampton and the Lord Willougby The Town of Frankendal having been sequestred into the hands of the Archduchess Isabella Clara Eugenia Infanta of Spain for the term of Eighteen moneths and that time now growing to an end being to expire about the middle of October next The King commanded those Lords and others that were Commissioners in that Treaty between his Majesty and the Archduchess to assemble and deliberate what was fit to be done concerning the remanding receiving and ordering of that Town The Commissioners unanimously were of opinion That it was fit for his Majesty both in Honor and Interest to remand it and according to the Capitulation to place therein a Garrison of Fifteen hundred Foot and Two hundred Horse with sufficient Victuals for six moneths and a sufficient quantity of all Munition The Infanta having accorded in the Treaty to give them a passage through the King of Spain's Low-Countries The King approved and resolved to follow the Advice and gave Order to the Council of War to consider and discuss the manner of demanding the Town and the way and means of raising the men and conducting them thither and of maintaining and supplying the Garrison with Munition and all things necessary On the day that Frankendal was to be redelivered Spinola with his Forces marcheth out of the Town and finding none of the King of Great Britains Forces ready to enter it instantly re-enters and takes possession pulls down the King of England's Arms and sets up the King of Spain's Yet did the Noble Spaniard leave standing the Monument of two Brothers fighting and stout Enemies of theirs in opposition of whose valor the Spaniard had gained much honor but overcame them at last The Monument is standing in the Dutch Church in Frankendal upon a fair Tomb with this Inscription In beatissimam memoriam Dom. Generosi Gulielmi Fairfax Anglo-Britanni Honoratissimi Domini Thomae Fairfax de Denton in Com. Ebor. Equitis Aurati filii Cohortis Anglicani Ducis insignis Qui annis natus circiter XXVI post animi plurima edita
no man amongst the Thebans was to take upon him any Place of Government in the Commonwealth if that he were a Merchant unless there were ten years distance between And the reason is this Because Merchants are used to buying and selling It is their Trade and Art to to 〈◊〉 Money so that their fingers are accustomed to that which they cannot leave when they come to Places of Trust and Judicature Nay further in honor of the Merchants He is accounted the wisest Merchant that gains most so that if any such comes to Offices and Places of Trust he thinks it best to advance his profit Next to the Pagans the Popes a Generation full of Corruption yet they by their Bulls are full of Declamation against such And this is plain by a Bull of Pius Quintus who lays the Penalty of Confiscation of Goods of any that do for money acquire any Offices and condemns them by his Papal sentence to be great sinners So Gregory the Thirteenth condemns the like And now to come nearer home to come to that which will principally lead your Lordships which are the Judgments of your Ancestors in Parliament wherein it appears by the Statute of 5 H. 6. that the same Statute condemns the Seller and Receiver as well as the Buyer and Giver It further appears by the Preamble of that Statute that such offences were against the Law and they foresaw the Corruptions of those that came into those Places by those means and that it is a hinderance of sufficient and worthy men from those Places And also 2 3 E. 6. which was likewise cited in the Case of the Duke of Somerset by which he was to forfeit his Estate that one thing was for selling of Places in the Commonwealth for money And certainly with your Lordships favor it is most just and probable that they that profess themselves to be Patriots and shew by their actions that they aim at their own lucre and labor to hinder the distributing of Iustice it is most just and proper that those men should return back again to the Publick Treasury of the King and Kingdom what they have by their unsatisfied lucre gotten And so my Lords craving Pardon of you for my boldness confusion and distractions in going through this business I humbly leave my self to the judgments of your favors and charities and this Great man the Duke to your wise Censure and Justice Then was read the Eleventh and Twelfth Articles XI That he the said Duke hath within these ten years last past procured divers Titles of Honor to his Mother Brothers Kindred and Allies as the Title of Countess of Buckingham to his Mother while she was Sir Thomas Compton's wife the Title of Earl of A. to his younger Brother Christopher Villiers the Titles of Baron of M. P. Vicount F. and Earl of D. to his Sisters Husband Sir W. F. the Titles of Baron of S. and Vicount P. to Sir Iohn Villiers elder Brother unto the said Duke and divers more of the like kind to his Kindred and Allies whereby the Noble Barons of England so well deserving in themselves and in their Ancestors have been much prejudiced and the Crown disabled to reward extraordinary Vertues in future times with Honor while the small Estates of those for whom such unnecessary Advancement hath been procured ar◠apparently likely to be more and more burthensom unto the King notwithstanding such Annuities Pensions and Grants of Lands annexed to the Crown of great value which the said Duke hath procured for those his Kindred to support these their Dignities XII He the said Duke 〈◊〉 contented with the great Advancement formerly received from the late King of famous memory by his procurement and practice in the Fourteenth year of the said King for the support of the many Places Honors and Dignities conferred on him did obtain a grant of divers Manors Parcel of the Revenue of the Crown and of the Duchy of Lancaster to the yearly value of One thousand six hundred ninety seven pounds two shillings halfpenny farthing of the old Rent with all Woods Timber Trees and Advowson part whereof amounting to the sum of Seven hundred forty seven pounds thirteen shillings four pence was rated at Two and thirty thousand pounds but in truth of a far greater value And likewise in the Sixteenth year of the same Kings reign did procure divers other Manors annexed to the Crown of the yearly value at the old Rent of Twelve hundred pounds or thereabouts according as in a Schedule hereunto annexed appeareth In the Warrant for passing of which Lands he by his great favour procured divers unusual Clauses to be inserted viz. that no Perquisites of Courts should be valued and that all Bailiffs Fees should be reprised in the particulars upon which those Lands were rated whereby a president hath been introduced which all those who since that time have obtained any Lands from the Crown have pursued to the damage of his late Majesty and of our Soveraign Lord the King that now is to an exceeding great value And afterwards he surrendred to his said Majesty divers Mannors and Lands parcel of those Lands formerly granted unto him to the value of Seven hundred twenty three pounds eighteen shillings and two pence half-penny per annum in consideration of which surrender he procured divers other Lands of the said late King to be sold and contracted for by his own Servants and Agents and thereupon hath obtained grants of the same to pass from his late Majesty to several persons of this Kingdom and hath caused Tallies to be stricken for the money being the consideration mentioned in those Grants in the Receipt of the Exchequer as if any such monies had really come to his Majesties Coffers whereas the Duke or some other by his appointment hath indeed received the same sums and expended them upon his own occasions And notwithstanding the great and inestimable gain by him made by the sale of Offices Honors and by other Suits by him obtained from his Majesty and for the countenancing of divers Projects and other Courses burthensom to his Majesties Realms both of England and Ireland The said Duke hath likewise by his procurement and practise received into his hands and disbursed to his own use exceeding great sums that were the monies of the late King of famous memory as appeareth also in the said Schedule hereunto annexed And the better to colour his doings in that behalf hath obtained several Privy-Seals from his late Majesty and his Majesty that now is warranting the payment of great sums to persons by his named causing it to be recited in such Privy-seals as if those sums were directed for secret Services concerning the State which were notwithstanding disposed of to his own use and other Privy-seals by him have been procured for the discharge of those Persons without accompt and by the like fraud and practice under colour of free gifts from his Majesty he hath gotten into
the old Rent remaining still the Land may be surendred at the same value Whether this have been practised he could not affirm not having had time to examine it yet he desired the Lords to enquire after it the rather for that the Manor of G. in Lincolnshire being dismembred and Seventeen pounds of the old Rents sold out of it was by a Surrender turned back upon his Majesty 4. The fourth point of this Branch was The colourable Tallies divers parcels of these Lands had from the Crown in lieu of this surrender being sold and contracted for by his own Agent and the money received by himself or to his use and yet Tallies were stricken out as if it had really come to the Exchequer for his Majesties service This is to be proved by his own Officers by the Officers of the Exchequer and by the Tallies themselves which Tallies amount unto 20563 l. 16 s. 8 d. Whence he observed First That there ran a trade of Falshood toward the King throughout all this his dealing Secondly That this was a Device thought upon to prevent the wisdom of Parliament for by this means the Grant seems to have the face of valuable purchases whereas they were indeed free gifts Thirdly If the Title of those Lands should prove questionable it appearing by Record as if the King had received the money he was bound in honor to make restitution and yet the Duke had the profit But it may be said This was the Purchasors desire for their own security Of which objection he made this use That the Subjects generally took notice of so much Lands given to the Duke that there is good cause 〈◊〉 expect a Resumption In the second general branch of this Article concerning Money the first point observed was the Total sum received by him in Ten years space amounting to 162995 l. besides the Grant he hath of the Overplus above Three thousand pounds per annum to be made of the Third imposed upon Strangers goods and besides the Moyetie of Seven thousand pounds out of the Customs of Ireland which he is bound to pay to the King but whether it hath been paid or no is doubtful This he delivered as a Sum Estimative yet so computed as it may be more but not less And this Total ariseth by free gifts by Pensions to himself else by profit of Farms by Pensions to others For Offices whereof he received the profit as the Admiralty and Mastership of the Horse All which appear by a Schedule annexed to this Charge The Grievances consist in this That the Commonwealth hath been bereaved of the use and imployment of so Publick Treasure in a time of as great want and great occasions in this State as it hath had in many Ages when the expences of the Kings Court can hardly be supplied when his Houses and Castles are unfurnished when the Seas have been unguarded the Coasts subject to the incursion and spoil of Enemies by default of provision in the Navy to the dishonor of the Nation and damage of the Subjects and the hazard of the whole And the offence in this that the wants in the Navy and the Stores being within his own Charge he was no more sensible of them whereby it appears he preferred the serving of his own turn before his duty and before the safety of this State The second point observed in this branch was That the Duke under pretence of secret services hath procured great sums of money to be issued by Privy-seals to sundry persons named by himself but afterward imployed to his own use Hereof two instances are propounded The one of Eight thousand pounds paid to Sir Robert Pye 12 Aug. 1620. and by him disbursed for the Dukes purchase of Burleigh and Sir Robert Pye discharged by another Privy-seal 4 Iunii following The second instance is of Sixty thousand pounds paid to Burlimach by a Privy-seal in September 1625. Which time he rather noted because the Parliament at Oxford was broken up a little before out of discontent that the King was not supplied for the setting out of the Fleet which would have been done with a less sum For the proof of that the House of Commons will offer to your Lordships Witnesses The quality of this offence he left to their Lordships judgment yet propounding some things by way of enquiry from whence it might receive measure and proportion 1. Whether it had not affinity with the Crime in the Civil Law called Crimen peculatus which was when a man did unjustly turn to his own use that money which was either sacra dedicated to Gods service religiously or religiosa used about Funerals and Monuments of the dead or publica of which kind the matter now in question is And this offence by that Law was Death and Confiscation of goods and estate Which he notes the rather that their Lordships might perceive that in the wisest State the Publick Treasure was held in the same reputation with that which was dedicated to God and Religion 2. And whether it doth not resemble◠other Crime in the same Law termed Crimen falsi and is defined to be when a man shall imitatione veri suum compendium alieno dispendio per dolum facere by semblance of truth make gain to himself of other mens losses Which in the case of a Bondman was Death and in case of another man Banishment and Confiscation or otherwise very penal as the Judges should find cause of moderation or rigor in the nature and circumstances of the Fact 3. Whether their Lordships will estimate it according to any Sentences in the Star-chamber which have been very frequent in cases of Fraud Or according to the Common-Law which so much detests this kind of dealing as that they term it Covin and make it vitiate ordinary and lawful actions Or lastly whether they will measure it by that Judgment which the Duke hath pass'd against himself in the guilt of his own Conscience Direct Actions are not afraid to appear open-faced but Injustice and Fraud desire to be masked with Subtilty and Closeness It were offence enough if there were no more but a cunning concealing of unthankfulness to hide his Majesties bounty or guilt of unworthiness as if he durst not avow the receit of that which he had not merited both which proceed from Malum culpae Or else that other kind of guilt which proceeds from Malum poenae the fear of punishment foreseeing this Inquisition into his actions and hoping under this disguise of Publick service to escape their Lordships censure The third point in this branch is That he hath received sundry sums of money intended for the maintenance of the Navy whereof there are two instances the one whereof is 20000 l. the other of 30000 l. both in Ianuary 1624. By Privy-seal by the which these sums are issued they appear to be Free gifts But by the affirmation of some in answer for the Duke it hath been said He was only the hand
a Treaty of a Match since in Eighty Eight even while there was a Treaty of Peace their Armado came upon us Again we shall find it was forbidden in the best people in the world to marry with a differing Religion The injunction the reason and the effect are laid down in Deuteronomy to the Jews And if we descend to our own Books and Chronicles we shall find that God hath crossed if not cursed our alliance and association particularly with the Spanish Nation the position of that Country and the disposition of that People being as it were so malignant and ill-agreeing with us The Prince of the greatest performance that ever this Kingdom or Christendom had was the Black Prince Yet our Chronicle records that going into Spain to settle Don Pedro in that Kingdom besides the monstrous ingratitude and peafidiousness of the Spaniard who failed in the performance of those Conditions he had promised which caused the miserable Revolt in France to the loss of our inheritance the Prince was so poisoned in that Country that he never had his health after Moreover he beseeched his Lordship to observe that all the Marriages which the Heirs and Princes of this Crown have made in England for these last six-score years except the several second Matches of Henry the Eight have been onely and no-where else but with Spain which how little God hath blest the success shews Prince Arthur married the Spanish Kings daughter We know God took him away suddenly within a very small time and without any issue In a Politick respect we would yet make a second Match so Prince Henry afterwards King married the same daughter But doubtless God was less pleased with that Match which was less lawful and therefore God took away all the male-children of it and left only a daughter in whose short Reign was shed more blood for the true Religion in six years then for the false in these succeeding sixty years We made then a third Adventure and Marriage with Spain Queen Mary with King Philip which was so discontenting to the People that it caused Wyats Rebellion so discomfortable to the Queen that it brake her heart being left and neglected of her Husband and so dishonorable and prejudicial to the Kingdom that merely for the Spaniards sake we having no difference at all with France we lost Calis in six days which had been above two hundred years in our possession He added lastly Though I have not so much judgment nor so little wit as to presume to advise where to match yet I assume so much as to think a Match at home cannot be held any ways inconvenient We find the first and the last of our Kings that ever matched with their Subjects were Ed. 4. and Hen. 8. From which two Matches God as it were to shew the less we rely upon others abroad the more he will help us himself at home gave two daughters two Elizabeths two such Queens then which there were never two more blessed Instruments of Gods glory and this Kingdoms good by establishing Peace in the Land and Religion in the Church until his Majesties happy coming who brought both with him The French were very jealous of the Conjunction between Spain and England and thought it the safest way to make peace at home and imploy their strength to bound the Incroachments of Spain and the House of Austria By which means a bitter Persecution ceased in that Kingdom The Protestants of France were permitted to call home their banished Ministers to build their ruined Temples and to enjoy their liberty in Religion This benefit did the Kings closing with Spain procure to a people almost ruined But after all the Kings concessions the Spaniards contrived new delays and proposed harder terms The Pope had obliged the Catholick King to see the Conditions performed and to protract the Marriage till matters in England were in perfect execution Whereupon the Divines advise that King that the Promises of Marriage be made presently but the Consummation thereof and the delivering of the Infanta be deferred till May the year following And the death of Pope Gregory did strengthen this contrivance For the Spanish Ministers pretended that in regard there was no Contract but a Treaty only on foot the Dispensation which lay in the Nuncio's hands was by the Popes death suspended and a Ratification from the new Pope was requisite before any further progress could be made Cardinal Barberine was chosen Successor to Gregory the Fifteenth and took the name of Urban the Eight Soon after his election he wrote these ensuing Letters the one to King Iames the other to Prince Charls Serenissimo IACOBO Magnae Britanniae Regi Illustri URBANUS P. â— VIII SErenissime Rex salutem lumen Divinae gratiae Scotiae regnum quod inclytos terris Reges sanctissimosque coelo cives peperit cum ad Cardinalatus nostri patrocinium pertinuerit laetitiae simul ac moeroris uberem nobis materiam afferebat Exultabamus gaudio cogitantes in ea Regione quam Romanorum arma expugnare omnino non potuerunt Romanae Ecclesiae fidem feliciter triumphasse Scotumque Regem nullum hactenus extitisse qui Pontificiae authoritatis hostis obierit At enim vertebatur in luctum cythara nostra cum ad praesentium temporum miserias oculos lachrymis manantes converteremus Videmini enim laborante discordiarum patre obliti esse eum qui nutrivit vos contristati nutricem vestram Hierusalem Quare Apostolica sedes quae populos istos jampridem Christo genuit moerore conficitur dum tam praeclaâ—am haereditatem verti videt ad extraneos damnique sui magnitudinem Britannorum Regum laudibus istarumque Provinciarum gloria metitur Id vero praeter caetera dolendum orbi Christiano videtur Jacobum regem Catholicorum regum prolem sanctissimae Parentis filium à Pontifice Maximo atque à Majoribus suis in Religionis cultu dissentire Si enim sublime istud ingenium quod literarum studiis prudentiae artibus Rex celeberrimus excoluisti affulgenti Patri luminum assentiretur facilè conjicit Christiana Respublica quanto publicae concordiae bono factum esset ut Nationes istas Insulasque aut montium claustris aut Oceani gurgitibus dissitas Scoticus rex imperio conjungeres Videtur enim Majestas tua ob eam rem facta esse tot Provinciarum domina ut ab eo cui parent facilius celeriusque Regna ista medelam ac salutem acciperent Quare assiduis precibus jam tum eum venerabamur qui dat salutem Regibus ut to Divinae clementiae beneficia quibus in conspectu Potentium admirabilis es ad Britanniae incolumitatem Ecclesiae gaudium conferret Affulsit autem nobis non ita pridem beata spes oriens ex alto cum te Austriacae affinitatis cupidum cognovimus ex Catholica matre progigni exoptantem eos qui tuam haereditatem adire populosque istos ditione tenere debent
avaritious men who adored their Mammon deterred men from that noble and pious work They were then but Panick terrors clouds cast before the Sun which now shines out so bright as all those mists are vanished His Majesty calls to us for aid he invites us to it and he that was born to Command now vouchsafes to entreat us Now if ever now is the time to do our Country good Do we desire to sweep all Grievances out of this Land Do we desire to extinguish the care of them that they may never more germinate in this Commonwealth Do we desire to destroy those Spiders that spin this Net Now if ever now is the time to effect it And to arive at this blessing methinks I discover a plain and easie way let us please the King first and I speak it with Faith He will be gratiously pleased to reward us Prove rich Merchants and make a brave return Great and generous spirits are then most apt to make requests when first they have obtained their own In the Region of Kings the way to conquer is to submit and nothing more obligeth an honest heart to perform what is expected then to believe and trust in him This is the way to make his Majesty not onely love but fall in love with Parliaments This is the way to recal them home from exile and again render them frequent amongst us This is the way to fix this until we have purchased present ease and future happiness to our Country Let his Majesty have hearts ease amongst us and we shall receive from his Royal Hand that Dictamum which must expel these Arrows that hang in the sides of the Commonwealth Thus have I delivered my opinion which if it be not the same with every one here present I shall beg that favorable censure which Charity commands me to afford to all Let him believe I have spoken my Conscience as I shall of him though he happen to dissent from my opinion For from what Circumference soever the Lines be drawn the Center is the same which is our Countreys good at which the desire of every man ought to aim and the duty of every man ought to desire He that would take another course and have Grievances first preferred if he wished that out of a good to his Countrey as unwilling to innovate antient proceedings of this man I will onely say Optime sentit Cato sed nocet interdum Reipublicae But if there be any other who out of a corrupt and imposthumate heart looking to false and foreign ends would endeavor to put a Partition-Wall between the King and his people this man I dare pronounce neither good Subject nor good Englishman nor good Christian but the Agent of base and beggerly Promoters needy and greedy Projectors and a friend to those Monsters which I hope have no Generation who not born to any Fortune nor having Vertue nor Industry by which they might hope to obtain any yet like Harpies greedy to devour other mens Possessions care not what way they take to become masters of them sleighting the latter day of Judgment so they may rest secured from yielding any account in this World I have no more to say but that God would be pleased to incline our hearts to do that which may be most for his glory next for the Kings service then for the Countreys happiness SInce Supply unto his Majesty is now in question of which I hope there will be no question I humbly ask leave of this Honorable Assembly to speak my Opinion assuring you That when a Treaty of Grievances shall be on foot it shall appear I will not sit silent if I find my self able to say any thing that may lend a hand to unload my Country of that heavy burthen it now groans under by reason of the innumerable number of Monopolies which like so many Incubusses and Succubusses exhaust the Vital spirits and so press down those Parts which ought to enjoy free respiration as without some speedy remedy is like to run to extreme hazard But this I refer to its proper time and reserve my self for it and now proceed to the matter in hand Sure I do think there are very few that serve in this House if there be any who do not confidently believe that the chief Motive which induced his Majesty at this time to assemble this Parliament was a meer Necessity to be by us enabled for the Recovery of the Patrimony belonging to the King of Bohemia now almost traversed from him and in the possession of a powerful Enemy If there be any who doubt of this truth I hope he may easily rest satisfied when I shall assure him out of my own knowledge that many days before this Session his Majesty commanded a select number of Noblemen and Gentlemen the most part whereof have been Commanders in the Wars and some yet are to consult together of what Number of men an Army ought to be composed which might be able to recover the Palatinate and protect it from a second Invasion These according to his Majesties good pleasure divers days met together at one appointed place and there contributed their best endeavors At least they have finished their task advised the King of the Number of Soldiers they have estimated the present Charge his Majesty must be at for the Relieving Arming Clothing Munition and Habiliments of War These have likewise calculated the Annual Expence for the maintenance of them The first I will now inform you And for the last Point because of a greater Charge and Consequence I will allow more time of Consideration Twenty five thousand Foot and Five thousand Horse is the portion they all agree on and less they could not consider to be sent considering they were to combat with an Enemy so far from hence already in possession of a great part of the Country well fortified in many places Master of an Army composed with Twenty thousand Foot and Four thousand Horse most Veterane Soldiers commanded by the best Captains now known in the Christian world except the Prince of Orange after whom to be esteemed second is the highest praise I say all these respects duly weighed there could not in their judgments be abated of this proportion And this Army was framed on that mould which the Secretaries of State gave them of the Enemies strength The issue of Battels is in the hands of God The eyes of Humane providence cannot see beyond its horizon It cannot ascertain future Contingents it can only judge of what seems fit to be done guided by the Rules of Probability and Reason Events happen often contrary and never more contrary then in matters of Warfare Yet admit a sinister success to happen a Counsel wisely taken ought not therefore to lose the due commendations Sirs I have told you the Number You now expect to know the present Charge in which I shall deal most truly with you Believe me His Majesty must disburse Thirty thousand
pounds for provision of Necessities to furnish such an Army to be sent The most part of the Provisions must be made beyond the Seas for there Arms are best and best cheap This Army must if such an Army go by the end of April It was God that said Let there be light and it was so Kings though they be stiled Gods enjoy no such power incommunicable to any Kings Whatever their ends or desires are they must allow time to the consummation of them They be Soveraigns over us but subject unto Time But what need I add spurs to a forward horse In my conscience there are few Members in this House that to that Holy War as I may justly stile it would not as willingly and as heartily contribute the service of their persons as the assistance of their purses I know I speak the Language of all your Hearts let us shew our Faith by our works Time was to have done much better then now we can time is that we may do well but if we attend somewhat longer time will be past So as all we do then will be so out of season as it can produce neither any great nor any good effect But stay methinks I hear some say Why his Majesty told us that by way of Treaty he hoped so to prevail as the Palatinate should be restored I confess I heard so to and Heaven be pleased to crown his actions with success as the piousness of his intentions deserves But I must be excused if I doubt it if I fear it if I despair of it For it is no article of my Faith to believe in Miracles But suppose this might be brought to pass what then shall this gift of ours be lost or cast away No sure it will be well bestowed if as a Sacrifice of our thankfulness we offer it unto his Majâ—sty by whose Wisdom that is regained which certainly by any other course must needs have exposed our persons to great danger and our purses to much more expence And in this we shall do as he that receiveth a rich present and returns a small reward Perhaps this way may not quadrate with every mans conceipt if not then let this which his Majesty demands to make provision for a Foreign Army be employed in rearing a Magazin here at home since so great is the want of Munition as I wonder we all cry out for want of Money and never think how to be stored of that which of the two is more necessary Seeing by the one we are onely enabled to live more plenteously and sumptuously and by the other our lives are preserved free from misery and slavery In matters of moment I know it is as laudable to use Deliberation before a Resolution as after that once taken Celerity in execution Council is the Compass by which all great Actions ought to be guided it is the Stear by which wise men do shape their courses I allow it I commend it I advise it yet to be so slow so discussive so long in resolving all we then can do will be no more worth then a Physitian after death Sure such a dulness must needs accuse us of much weakness if it admit of no worse construction bis dat qui cito dat freeness in giving graceth the gift dimidium facti qui bene coepit habet We have a long journey to go and to set forward is half the way How pressing the occasion is my Tongue faints to tell Vox faucibus haeret The Foxes have Holes and the Birds of the Air have Nests but the Daughter of our King and Kingdom scarce knows where to lay her head or if she do not where in safety Lastly When we had no other object in our Contemplations but the memory of her vertue which remaineth in durable Characters in the heart of every honest man what a forwardness and ferventness did we express in these our voluntary contributions notwithstanding that some base sordid and avaritious men who adored their Mammon deterred men from that noble and pious work They were then but Panick terrors clouds cast before the Sun which now shines out so bright as all those mists are vanished His Majesty calls to us for aid he invites us to it and he that was born to Command now vouchsafes to entreat us Now if ever now is the time to do our Country good Do we desire to sweep all Grievances out of this Land Do we desire to extinguish the care of them that they may never more germinate in this Commonwealth Do we desire to destroy those Spiders that spin this Net Now if ever now is the time to effect it And to arive at this blessing methinks I discover a plain and easie way let us please the King first and I speak it with Faith He will be gratiously pleased to reward us Prove rich Merchants and make a brave return Great and generous spirits are then most apt to make requests when first they have obtained their own In the Region of Kings the way to conquer is to submit and nothing more obligeth an honest heart to perform what is expected then to believe and trust in him This is the way to make his Majesty not onely love but fall in love with Parliaments This is the way to recal them home from exile and again render them frequent amongst us This is the way to fix this until we have purchased present ease and future happiness to our Country Let his Majesty have hearts ease amongst us and we shall receive from his Royal Hand that Dictamum which must expel these Arrows that hang in the sides of the Commonwealth Thus have I delivered my opinion which if it be not the same with every one here present I shall beg that favorable censure which Charity commands me to afford to all Let him believe I have spoken my Conscience as I shall of him though he happen to dissent from my opinion For from what Circumference soever the Lines be drawn the Center is the same which is our Countreys good at which the desire of every man ought to aim and the duty of every man ought to desire He that would take another course and have Grievances first preferred if he wished that out of a good to his Countrey as unwilling to innovate antient proceedings of this man I will onely say Optime sentit Cato sed nocet interdum Reipublicae But if there be any other who out of a corrupt and imposthumate heart looking to false and foreign ends would endeavor to put a Partition-Wall between the King and his people this man I dare pronounce neither good Subject nor good Englishman nor good Christian but the Agent of base and beggerly Promoters needy and greedy Projectors and a friend to those Monsters which I hope have no Generation who not born to any Fortune nor having Vertue nor Industry by which they might hope to obtain any yet like Harpies greedy to devour other mens Possessions care
with Brick which he intendeth onely for the Beauty and more â—afety of the City therefore he will go through with it and if the Commissioners offend herein let the party aggrieved complain and he will redress it that the form of proceedings used by the Commons in this Parliament is also a grievance unto his Majesty for that they did not call the Commissioners whom they complained of before them touching their complaint against Doctor Aynan his Majesty said their oath of Supremacy forbids them to meddle with Church matters besides they complain against him and never heard him Touching their complaint against the Apothecaries his Majesty protested his care therein to be onely for his peoples health it is dangerous for every one to meddle with Apothecaries ware and the Grocers have a Trade beside His fourth grievance is that Seditious Books are so frequently printed which he will be carefull to prevent hereafter Fifthly for calling in so many Patents appointing the Patentees to wait so many days with their Council and never to hear them wherefore his Majesty warned them to call for no more hereafter unless they first knew them to be grievous to the people and so his Majesty concluded with thanks for the Commons good carriage towards him and his Lords this Session Then the Lord Keeper spake to the particulars of the Speakers Speech and by his Majesties command approved them all alluding the general consent of both Houses to the Septuagint directed by the Holy Ghost and touching the Speakers desire for the Kings assent to the Bills past both Houses he said the royal assent is proper to the Lawgiver and shewed that it is best for the people that this is in his Majesties power and not in themselves for the King knoweth what is best to be granted unto his people as may appear by the Petition that Bathsheba made to King Solomon to give unto Adonijah Abishag to wife which had Solomon granted he had given Adonijah means to usurp the Kingdom contrary to Bathsheba's meaning and such is his Majesties intent this day for such Bills which he will not pass That his Majesty had given his consent to all the Bills of Grace and to the Bill of the continuance of some Statutes and repeal of others so necessary and for the good of the people That his Majesty accepteth in good part their thanks for his general Pardon which he hath so freely granted unto his Subjects but his special command is that those that are in Office do look strictly to the execution of Laws against Recusants the Subsidies his Majesties graciously accepteth and therefore imitates not the Story in Macrobius of one who had all his debts paid and instead of thanks answered mihi nihil though this be given to the Palatinate his Majesty interpreteth it as given to himself and rendreth to you all hearty thanks for the same The Lord Keeper having ended his Speech the Clerk of the Crown stood up and read the title of the Bills passed both Houses and the Clerk of the Parliament read his Majesties Answer to each Bill which being done his Majesty remembred the breaking up of three Parliaments together and the happy conclusion of this Session and puts the Commons again in minde that at their next meeting they do so carry themselves that this Parliament may be as happily continued to the end At the Parliament holden at Westminster by Prorogation the Nineteenth day of February Anno Regis Iacobi Angliae Franciae Hiberniae vicesimo primo Scotiae quinquagesimo septimo These Acts were passed 1. AN Act for making perpetual an Act made Anno 39 Eliz. Entituled An Act for the Erecting of Hospitals and Workhouses for the Poor 2. An Act for the quiet of the Subject against Concealments 3. An Act concerning Monopolies and Dispensations with Penal Laws 4. An Act for ease of the Subjects concerning Informations upon Penal Statutes 5. An Act That Sheriffs their Heirs c. having a Quietus est shall be discharged of their Accompts with the Judges opinion therein 6. An Act concerning Women convicted of small Felonies 7. An Act to repress Drunkenness and to restrain the haunting of Inns c. 8. An Act to punish Abuses in procuring Supersedeas of the Peace out of the Courts at Westminster and to prevent the Abuses in procuring Writs of Certiorari out of the said Courts c. 9. An Act for the Free Trade of Welsh Clothes c. in England and Wales 10. An Act to repeal a Branch of the Statute An. 34 H. 8. Entituled An Act for certain Ordinances in the Kings Dominions and Principality of Wale 11. An Act for Confirmation of a Judgment given for his Majesty in a Scire facias against Henry Heron and for Declaration of the Letters Patents therein mentioned to be void 12. An Act to make perpetual the Act for ease in pleading against troublesom Suits prosecuted against Justices of the Peace Mayors c. 13. An Act for the further reformation of Jeofails 14. An Act to admit the Subject to plead the General Issue in Informations of Intrusion brought on the Kings behalf and to retain his Possession till Trial. 15. An Act to enable Judges and Justices to give restitution of Possession in certain cases 16. An Act for Limitation of Actions and for avoiding of Suits in Law 17. An Act against Usury 18. An Act for the Continuance of a former Statute made 4º Iac. Entituled An Act for the true making of Woollen Clothes 19. An Act for the further Description of a Bankrupt and relief of Creditors against such as shall become Bankrupts and for inflicting of Corporal punishment upon them in some Cases 20. An Act to prevent Swearing and Cursing 21. An Act concerning Hostlers and Inholders 22. An Act explaining a Statute An. 3 4 5 E. 6. concerning the Traders of Butter and Cheese 23. An Act to avoid Delaies by removing of Actions out of Inferior Courts 24. An Act for relief of Creditors against such as die in Execution 25. An Act for relief of Patentees Tenants and Farmers of Crown-Lands and Duchy-Lands 26. An Act against such as shall levy any Fine suffer any Recovery knowledge any Statute Recognisance Bail or Judgment in the name of any person not privy thereunto 27. An Act to prevent the murthering of Bastard-children 28. An Act to continue divers Statutes and repeal others 29. An Act to enable Prince Charls to make Leases of Lands parcel of the Duchy of Cornwal or annexed to the same 30. An Act to assure York-House and other Lands to the King and to assure the Manors of Brighton Santon and other Lands to the Archbishop of York c. 31. An Act for the good Government of the Makers of Knives in Hallam-shire in the County of York 32. An Act to make the Thames Navigable from Bercot to Oxon. 33. An Act for the Subsidies of the Clergy 34. An Act for Three Subsidies Three Fifteens and Tenths granted by the
State when they were none Recovered Henry the Fourth of France his Kingdom when he had nothing left but the Town of Diep Conquered the Invincible Navy of Spain in Anno 1588. Took Towns in Portugal the Year following and marched One hundred miles upon the Firm ground Fired or brought away the Spanish Navy before Cadiz and sack'd the Town took the Spanish ships daily and spoiled the Port-Towns of the West-Indies never losing but one ship during the Spanish War reducing the Condition of that King from a Fifth Monarchy to so low an Ebb that in one Year he paid Two thousand five hundred Millions of Duckets for Interest so as after he was enforced to beg Treaties of Peace and low Terms at the last Queen-Regents hands III. The Cause of the good Success then A Carriage and readiness to assist their Soveraign in purse and person A Wisdom and Gravity of Council who ordered nothing but by publick Debate and then assisted with the Military Professors either by Land or Sea of the best repute and such only imployed IV. In what Condition we now stand By the loss of Reputation by the ill success in the Voyage for Algier in the Palatinate in the Expedition with Mansfield in the last to Cadiz The Reasons are The uncheerfulness we have either to adventure our purses or persons occasioned by a distrust we have of the success the want of the like Courses and Councils that were formerly used It was wished that for every of the Four Heads there were a particular Committee to examine and prepare a Report for the Houses and the House upon every Report to put it self into a Committee of the whole Assembly and after a full and deliberate Debate to order a Model or Form for a Conference with the Lords and so together humbly to present to his Majesty a Remonstrance of their Labor offering withall a second Consultation and Debate amongst themselves for finding out the fittest means both for the defence of the State and our Allies Reformation of the Errors and a constant way to raise such Supplies as may enable his Majesty to proceed cheerfully and as they hoped assuredly in this his glorious Action not only for himself and State but all that profess the same Religion and are like to be overwhelmed in the Ambition of the Spanish Monarchy Also a Committee was named concerning Religion and the Growth oâ— Popery and Montague's Appeal to Caesar was again brought in question This Book the Commons referred to the Committee for Religion from whom Mr. Pym Reported to the House the several Erroneous Opâ—nions therein contained and the House passed their Votes thereupon That Mr. Montague endeavored to reconcile England to Rome and to alienate the Kings affections from his well-affected Subjects The Articles exhibited against him were these Articles exhibited by the Commons against Richard Montague Clerk THat he the said Richard Montague in or about the 21. year of the Reign of our late Soveraign Lord King Iames of famous memory hath caused to be Printed and in his name to be Published one Book called An Answer to the late Gagg of Protestants and in or about Anno 22. of the same King he caused to be Printed and Published one other Book Entituled A Treatise of the Invocations of Saints and likewise in the First year of his Majesties Reign that now is he procured to be Printed and in his name to be Published another Book Entituled An Appeal to Caesar In every of which Books he hath maintained and confirmed some Doctrine contrary or repugnant to the Articles agreed by the Archbishops and Bishops of both Provinces and the whole Clergy holden in the Convocation at London Anno Domini 1562. according to the computation of the Church of England for avoiding Diversity of Opinions and for establishing Consent touching true Religion All which appears in the places hereafter mentioned and in divers other places and passages of the same Books And by his so doing hath broken the Laws and Statutes of this Realm in that Case provided and very much disturbed both the Peace of Church and Commonwealth I. Whereas in the Five and thirtieth Article of the Articles aforementioned it is declared That the Second Book of Homilies doth contain a Godly and wholesom Doctrine in the sixteenth Homily of which Book it is determined That the Church of Rome as it is at present and hath been for the space of Nine hundred years and odd is so far wide from the nature of a True Church that nothing can be more He the said Richard Montague in several places of his said Book called The Answer to the Gagg and in his other Book called The Appeal doth advisedly maintain and affirm That the Church of Rome is and ever was a True Church since it was a Church II. Whereas in the same Homily it is likewise declared That the Church of Rome is not built upon the Foundation of the Prophets and Apostles and in the Eight and twentieth Article of the said Articles That Transubstantiation overthroweth the nature of a Sacrament and in the Five and twentieth of the same Article That five other reputed Sacraments of the Church of Rome are not to be accounted Sacraments yet contrary and repugnant hereunto he the said Richard Montague doth maintain and affirm in his Book aforesaid called The Answer to the Gagg That the Church of Rome hath ever remained firm upon the same Foundation of Sacraments and Doctrine instituted by God III. In the nineteenth of the same Article it is further determined That the Church of Rome hath erred not onely in their living and matters of Ceremony but also in matters of Faith He the said Richard Montague speaking of those Points which belong to Faith and good manners Hope and Charity doth in the said Book called The Gagg affirm and maintain That none of these are controverted in their Points meaning the Protestants and Papists and notwithstanding that in the One and thirtieth Article it is resolved That the Sacrifice of Masses in which as it is commonly said the Priest did offer Christ for the Quick and the Dead to have remission of Pain and Guilt too is a Blasphemous Fable and dangerous Deceit this being one of the Points controverted between the Church of England and the Church of Rome The said Richard Montague in his Book called The Gagg doth affirm and maintain That the controverted Points are of a lesser and inferior nature of which a man may be ignorant without any danger of his Soul at all a man may resolve to oppose this or that without peril of perishing for ever IV. Whereas in the second Homily Entituled Against Peril of Idolatry contained in the aforesaid Book of Homilies approved by the Seven and thirtieth mrticle aforementioned It is declared That Images teach no good Lesson neither of God nor Godliness but all Error and Wickedness He the said Richard Montague in the Book of Gagg aforesaid doth affirm and maintain
Barnardiston of the County of Suffolk and William Coriton Esq of the County of Cornwal were secured in the County of Sussex Sir Harbotle Grimston of the County of Essex and Sir Robert Points were secured in Northamptonshire Iohn Hampden Esq and others of the County of Bucks were secured in Hampshire and the like course was taken with the Gentry of other Counties who refused the Loan And the Council ordered that all those Refractory persons before-named for so they are called in the Order who are appointed by his Majesties command to their several Commitments shall presently obey the Order of the Board sent with their Messenger in that behalf or be committed close prisoners any pretence of inability want of conveniency or any excuse whatsoever notwithstanding Many of those Gentlemen were afterwards sent for by Pursevants out of those Counties where they were confined by Order of the Council and committed to several Prisons some to the Fleet some to the Marshalsey and Gatehouse and others remained in the custody of the Messengers And from the Gatehouse Sir Iohn Elliot sends this Petition to his Majesty To the Kings most Excellent Majesty The humble Petition of Sir Iohn Elliot Knight Prisoner in the Gate-house concerning the Loan Sheweth THat your poor Suppliant affected with sorrow and unhappiness through the long sense of your Majesties displeasure willing in every act of Duty and Obedience to satisfie your Majesty of the loyalty of his heart then which he hath nothing more desired that there may not remain a jealousie in your Royal Brest that stubbornness and will have béen the motives of his forbearing to condescend to the said Loan low as your Highness foot with a sad yet a faithful heart for an Apology to your Clemency and Grace he now presumes to offer up the Reasons that induced him which he conceiveth necessity of his Duty to Religion Justice and your Majesty did inforce The Rule of Iustice he takes to be the Law impartial Arbiter of Government and Obedience the support and strength of Majesty the observation of that Iustice by which Subjection is commanded This and Religion added to this Power not to be resisted binds up the Conscience in an Obligation to that Rule which without open prejudice and violence of these duties may not be impeached In this particular therefore of the Loan being desirous to be satisfied how far the Obligation might extend and resolving where he was left Master of his own to become Servant to your Will he had recourse unto the Laws to be informed by them which in all humility he submitteth to your most Sacred view in the Collections following In the time of Edward the First he findeth that the Commons of that age were so tender of their Liberties as they feared even their own frée acts and gifts might turn them to a Bondage and their Heirs Wherefore it was desired and granted That for no business such manner of Aids Taxes nor Prizes should be taken but by common assent of the Realm and for the common profit thereof The like was in force by the same King and by two other Laws again Enacted That no Tallage or Aid should be taken or levied without the good will and assent of the Archbishops Bishops Earls Barons Knights Burgesses and other Freeman of the Land And that Prudent and Magnanimous Prince Edward the Third led by the same Wisdom having granted That the greatest gift given in Parliament for the Aid and speed of his matchless undertaking against France should not be had in Example nor fall to the prejudice of the Subject in time to come did likewise adde in Confirmation of that Right That they should not from thenceforth be grieved to sustain any Charge or Aid but by the Common Assent and that in Parliament And more particularly upon this point upon a Petition of the Commons afterwards in Parliament it was established That the Loans which are granted to the King by divers persons be released and that none from henceforth be compelled to make such Loans against their Wills because it is against Reason and the Franchises of the Land and Restitution be made to such as made such Loans And by another Act upon a new occasion in the time of Richard the Third it was ordained That the Subject in no wise be charged with any such Charge Exaction or Imposition called a Benevolence nor such like Charge and that such like Exactions be damned and annulled for ever Such were the Opinions of these times for all these Aids Benevolences Loans and such like Charges exacted from the Subject not in Parliament which they held to be Grievances contrary to their Liberties and illegal and so pious were their Princes in Confirmation of their Liberties as having secured them for the present by such frequent Laws and Statutes they did likewise by them provide for their Posterity and in some so strictly that they bound the Observation with a Curse as in that of 33 Edw. 1. And also under pain of Excommunication as by the other of the Five and twentieth of the same King which was to be denounced against all those that violate or break them which Act extends to us And these Reasons he presents to your Majesty as the first Motive taken from the Law There are others also which in his humble apprehension he conceived from the Action it self which he likewise tenders to your most Excellent Wisdom First That the Carriage and Instructions accompanied with the Authority of the Great Seal imported a Constraint such Requests to Subjects being tacite and implied Commands and so preventing that readiness and love which in a frée way would have far excéeded those Demands whereas the wonted Aids given to your happy Ancestors were Ex spontanea voluntate charitate populi whereby they made that Conjunction of their Hearts at home which wrought such power and reputation to their acts abroad Whereas the firmest Obligation of that readiness and love is the benignity of Princes giving and preserving to their People just and decent Liberties which to this Kingdom are derived from the Clemency and Wisdom of your Progenitors to whom there is owing a Sacred Memory for them He could not as he feared without pressure to these immunities become an actor in this Loan which by imprisonment and restraint was urged contrary to the Grants of the Great Charter by so many glorious and victorious Kings so many times confirmed being therein most confident of your Majesty that never King that raigned over us had of his own benignity and goodness a more pious disposition to preserve the just Liberties of his Subjects then your Sacred Self Though we were well assured by your Majesties Royal Promise whose words he holds as Oracles of Truth that it should become a president during the happiness of your Raign the long continuance whereof is the daily subject of his Prayers yet he conceived from thence a fear that succeeding Ages might thereby take occasion
when the end may be the service of his Majesty and the good of the Commonweale But on the contrary when against a Parliament Law the Subject shall have taken from him his goods against his will and his liberty against the Laws of the Land shall it be accounted want of duty in us to stand upon our Priviledges hereditary to us and confirmed by so many Acts of Parliament In doing this we shall but tread the steps of our forefathers who ever preferred the Publick Interest before their own right nay before their own lives nor can it be any wrong to his Majesty to stand upon them so as thereby we may be the better enabled to do his Majesties service but it will be a wrong to us and our posterity and our consciences if we willingly forego that which belongs unto us by the Law of God and of the Land and this we shall do well to present to his Majesty we have no cause to doubt of his Majesties gracious acceptation This Debate said Sir Tho. Wentworth carries a double Aspect towards the Soveraign and the Subject though both be innocent both are injured and both to be cured Surely in the greatest humility I speak it these illegal ways are punishment and marks of indignation the raising of Loans strengthned by Commission with unheard of Instructions and Oathes the billetting of Soldiers by the Lieutenants and Deputy Lieutenants have been as if they could have perswaded Christian Princes yea worlds that the right of Empires had been to take away by strong hands and they have endeavored as far as possible for them to do it This hath not been done by the King under the pleasing shade of whose Crown I hope we shall ever gather the fruits of Justice but by Projectors who have extended the Prerogative of the King beyond the just Symetry which maketh a sweet harmony of the whole They have brought the Crown into greater want then ever by anticipating the Revenues And can the Shepherd be thus smitten and the Speep not scattered They have introduced a Privy-Council ravishing at once the Spheres of all ancient Government imprisoning us without either bail or bond they have taken from us what shall I say indeed what have they left us All means of supplying the King and ingratiating our selves with him taking up the root of all propriety which if it be not seasonably set again into the ground by his Majesties own hands we shall have insteed of beauty baldness To the making of those whole I shall apply my self and propound a Remedy to all these diseases By one and the same thing have King and People been hurt and by the same must they be cured to vindicate what new things no our ancient vital Liberties by reinforcing the ancient Laws made by our Ancestors by setting forth such a Character of them as no licentious spirit shall dare to enter upon them and shall we think this is a way to break a Parliament no our desires are modest and just I speak truly both for the interest of King and People if we injoy not these it will be impossible for to relieve him Therefore let us never fear they shall not be accepted by his goodness wherefore I shall shortly descend to my motions consisting of four parts two of which have relation to our persons two to the propriety of goods for our persons first the freedom of them from imprisonment secondly from imployment abroad contrary to the ancient Customs For our goods that no Levies be made but by Parliament secondly no billetting of Soldiers It is most necessary that these be resolved that the Subject may be secured in both Sir Benjamin Rudyard stands up as a Moderator and spake thus This is the Chrysis of Parliaments we shall know by this if Parliaments live or die the King will be valued by the success of us the Councils of this House will have opperations in all 't is sit we be wise his Majesty begins to us with affection proclaiming that he will relie on his peoples love preservation is natural we are not now on the bene esse but on the esse be sure England is ours and then prune it Is it no small matter that we have provoked two most Potent Kings we have united them and have betrayed our selves more then our enemies could Men and Brethren what shall we do is there no balm in Gilead if the King draw one way the Parliament another we must all sink I respect no particular I am not so wise to contemn what is determined by the major part one day tells another and one Parliament instructs another I desire this House to avoid all contestations the hearts of Kings are great 't is comely that Kings have the beter of their Subjects give the King leave to come off I believe his Majesty expects but the occasion 't is lawfull and our duty to advise his Majesty but the way is to take a right course to attain the right end which I think may be thus by trusting the King and to breed a trust in him by giving him a large Supply according to his wants by prostrating our Grievances humbly at his feet from thence they will have the best way to his heart that is done in duty to his Majesty And to say all at once Let us all labor to get the King on our side and this may be no hard matter considering the neer subsistence between the King and people Sir Edward Cook spake next Dum tempus habemus bonum operemur I am absolutely to give Supply to his Majesty yet with some caution To tell you of Forein dangers and inbred evils I will not do it the State is inclining to a consumption yet not incurable I fear not Forein Enemies God send us peace at home for this disease I will propound remedies I will seek nothing out of mine own head but from my heart and out of Acts of Parliament I am not able to fly at all Grievances but only at Loans Let us not flatter our selves who will give Subsidies if the King may impose what he will and if after Parliament the King may inhaunce what he pleaseth I know the king will not do it I know he is a Religious King free from personal vices but he deals with other mens hands and sees with other mens eyes will any give a Subsidy that may be taxed after Parliament at pleasure the King cannot tax any by way of Loans I differ from them who would have this of Loans go amongst Grievances but I would have it go alone I le begin with a noble Record it cheers me to think of it 25. E. 3. it is worthy to be written in letters of gold Loans against the will of the Subject are against reason and the Franchises of the Land and they desire restitution what a word is that Franchise The Lord may tax his Villain high or low but it is against the Franchises
Petition his Majesty made this reply Mr. Speaker and Gentlemen when I sent you my last Message I did not expect a reply for I intended it to hasten you I told you at your first meeting this time was not to be spent in words and I am sure it is less fit for disputes which if I had a desire to entertain Mr. Speakers preamble might have given me ground enough The question is not now what Liberty you have in disposing of matters handled in your House but rather at this time what is fit to be done Wherefore I hope you will follow my example in eschewing Disputations and fall to your important business You make a Protestation of your affection and zeal to my Prerogative grounded upon such good and just Reasons that I must believe you But I look that you use me with the like charity to believe what I have declared more then once since your meeting with us that I am as forward as you for the preservation of your true Liberties Let us not spend so much time in this that may hazard both my Prerogative and your Liberties to our enemies To be short go on speedily with your businesses without any more Apologies for time calls fast on you which will neither stay for you nor me Wherefore it is my duty to hasten as knowing the necessity of it and yours to give credit to what I say as to him that sits at the Helm For what concerns your Petition I shall make answer in a convenient time FRom this time to the 25th of the same Moneth the House in a grand Committee spent most of their time in Debate about Martial Law and part thereof in giving the Lords a meeting at two Conferences concerning some Resolves in order to a Petition of Right transmitted by the Commons to their Lordships at which time Sir Robert Heath and Serjeant Ashley the Kings Councel were permitted to argue against the same and Serjeant Ashley in his discourse said The Propositions made by the Commons tended rather to an Anarchy then a Monarchy 2. That if they be yielded unto it is to put a Sword into the Kings hand with one hand and to take it out with the other 3. That they must allow the King to govern by Acts of State otherwise he is a King without a Councel or a Councel without a Power 4. That the question is too high to be determined by Law where the Conqueror or conquered will suffer irreparable loss For which expressions the Lords called the Serjeant to an account and committed him to custody and afterwards he recanted what he said Friday 25 of April The Lords had a Conference with the Commons where the Lord Archbishop of Canterbury spake as followeth Gentlemen of the House of Commons THe Service of the King and safety of the Kingdom do call on my Lords to give all speedy expedition to dispatch some of these great and weighty Businesses before us For the better effecting whereof my Lords have thought fit to let you know that they do in general agree with you and doubt not but you will agree with us to the best of your powers to maintain and support the fundamental Laws of the Kingdom and the fundamental Liberties of the Subject For the particulars which may hereafter fall into Debate they have given me in charge to let you know That what hath been presented by you unto their Lordships they have laid nothing of it by they are not out of love with any thing that you have tendred unto them They have Voted nothing neither are they in love with any thing proceeding from themselves For that which we shall say and propose is out of an intendment to invite you to a mutual and free Conference that you with a confidence may come to us and we with confidence may speak with you so that we may come to a conclusion of those things which we both unanimously desire We have resolved of nothing designed or determined of nothing but desire to take you with us praying help from you as you have done from us My Lords have thought of some Proposions which they have ordered to be read here and then left with you in Writing That if it seem good to you we may uniformly concur for the substance and if you differ that you would be pleased to put out adde alter or diminish as you shall think fit that so we may come the better to the end that we do both so desirously embrace Then the Propositions following were read by the Clerk of the upper House THat his Majesty would be pleased graciously to Declare That the good old Law called Magna Charta and the six Statutes conceived to be Declarations and Explanations of that Law do still stand in force to all intents and purposes 2. That his Majesty would be pleased graciously to Declare That according to Magna Charta and the Statutes afore named as also according to the most ancient Customs and Laws of this Land every free Subject of this Realm hath a fundamental Propriety in his Goods and a fundamental Liberty of his Person 3. That his Majesty would be graciously pleased to Declare That it is his Royal pleasure to ratifie and confirm unto all and every his Loyal and faithful Subjects all their ancient several just Liberties Priviledges and Rights in as ample and beneficial maner to all intents and purposes as their Ancestors did enjoy the same under the best of his most noble Progenitors 4. That his Majesty would be further pleased graciously to Declare for the good content of his loyal Subjects and for the securing of them from future fear That in all Cases within the Cognizances of the Common Law concerning the liberties of the Subject his Majesty would proceed according to the Common Law of this Land and according to the Laws established in the Kingdom and in no other maner or wise 5. As touching his Majesties Royal Prerogative intrinsical to his Soveraignty and betrusted him withal from God ad communem totius populi salutem non ad destructionem that his Majesty would resolve not to use or divert the same to the prejudice of any his loyal People in the propriety of their Goods or liberty of their Persons And in case for the security of his Majesties royal Person the common safety of his People or the peaceable Government of this Kingdom his Majesty shall finde just cause for reason of State to imprison or restrain any mans Person his Majesty would graciously Declare That within a convenient time he shall and will express the cause of the commitment or restraint either General or Special and upon a cause so expressed will leave him immediately to be tryed according to the common Justice of the Kingdom After the reading of the Propositions the Archbishop said THis is but a Model to be added unto altered or diminished as in your reasons and wisdoms ye shall think fit after ye
unto the said Information the benefit whereof was by order of the Court reserved unto the Defendant to be debated and considered of at the hearing of this cause and of divers other matters now urged for the Defendant both to have justified his the said Defendants attendance in Parliament and his not residence in person in the County whereof he was then Sheriff and amongst other things that it properly belonged to the house of Parliament to judge of the justness or unjustness of the said Election and upon grave and mature consideration thereof had and taken by the Court their Lordships did not onely conceive the said Demurrer and Plea and other the Arguments and Reasons used by the Defendant and his Council to be of no weight or strength but also to be in opposition and derogation of the Jurisdiction of the Court the reasons moved and urged for the Defendants excuse or justification being clearly answered and the charges of the Information made good by Mr. Atturney General and others of his Majesties Counsel learned And therefore the whole Court were clear of opinion and did so declare That the said Defendant who at that time as high Sheriff had the custody and charge of the County of Wilts committed unto him by his Majesty and had taken his Oath according to the Law to abide in his proper person within his Bayliffwick during all the time of his Sheriffwick as aforesaid and whose trust and imployment did require his personal attendance in the said Countie had not onely committed a great offence in violating the said Oath so by him taken but also a great misdemeanor in breach of the trust committed unto him by his Majesty and in contempt of his Majesties pleasure signified unto him by and under his Highness great Seal when he granted unto him the said Office of Sheriffwick aforesaid For which said several great Offences in breach of his said Oath neglect of the trust and duty of his Office and the great and high contempt of his Majesty their Lordships did hold the said Defendant worthy the sentence of the Court the rather to the end that by this example the Sheriffs of all other Counties may be deterred from committing the like offences hereafter and may take notice that their personal residence and attendance is required within their Bayliffwicks during the time of their Sheriffwick The Court therefore thought fit ordered adjudged and decreed That the said Defendant should stand and be committed to the prison of the Tower there to remain during his Majesties pleasure and also pay a Fine of two thousand Marks to his Majesties use and further make his humble submission and acknowledgement of his offence both in the Court of Star-Chamber and to his Majesty before his thence enlargment The same Term Mr. Mason argued in the kings Bench for Sir Iohn Elliot against the Information preferred against him amongst others by Sir Robert Heath the kings Atturney General and the same day the Atturney General argued in maintenance of the said Information the Judges also the same day spake briefly to the Case and agreed with one Voyce That the Court as this Case is shall have Jurisdiction although that these offences were committed in Parliament and that the imprisoned Members ought to answer Iones began and said That though this Question be now newly moved yet it is an ancient Question with him for it had been in his thoughts these eighteen yeers For this Information there are three Questions in it 1. Whether the matters informed be true or false and this ought to be determined by Iury or Demurrer 2. When the matters of the Information are found or confessed to be true if the Information be good in substance 3. Admit that the offences are truly charged if this Court hath power to punish them and that is the sole Question of this day And it seems to me that of these offences although committed in Parliament this Court shall have jurisdiction to punish them The Plea of the Defendents here to the jurisdiction being concluded with a Demurrer is not peremptory unto them although it be adjudged against them but if the Plea be pleaded to the jurisdiction which is found against the Defendant by verdict this is peremptory In the discussion of this point I decline these Questions 1. If the matter be voted in Parliament when it is finished it can be punished and examined in another Court 2. If the matter be commenced in Parliament and that ended if afterward it may be Questioned in another Court I question not these Matters but I hold That an Offence committed criminally in Parliament may be questioned elsewhere as in this Court and that for these Reasons First Quia interest Reipublicae ut malesicia non maneant impunita and there ought to be a fresh punishment of them Parliaments are called at the Kings pleasure and the King is not compellible to call his Parliament and if before the next Parliament the party offending or the witnesses die then there will be a â—ayler of Justice Secondly The Parliament is no constant Court every Parliament mostly consists of several men and by consequence they cannot take notice of matters done in the foregoing Parliament and there they do not examine by oath unless it be in Chancery as it is used of late time Thirdly The Parliament cannot send Process to make the offenders to appear at the next Parliament and being at large if they hear a noise of a Parliament they will fugam facere and so prevent their punishment Fourthly Put the case that one of the Defendants be made a Baron of Parliament now he cannot be punished in the House of Commons and so he shall be unpunished It hath been objected That the Parliament is the Superior Court to this therefore this Court cannot examine their proceedings To this I say That this Court of the Kings Bench is a higher Court then the Justices of Oyer and Terminer or the Justices of Assize But if an offence be done where the Kings Bench is after it is removed this offence may be examined by the Justices of Oyer and Terminer or by the Justices of Assize We cannot Question the Judgments of Parliaments but their particular offences 2. Obj. It is a Priviledge of Parliament whereof we are not competent Iudges To this I say That Privilegium est privata lex privat legem And this ought to be by grant prescription in Parliament and then it ought to be pleaded for the manner as is 33 Hen. 8 Dy. as it is not here pleaded Also we are Judges of all Acts of Parliament as 4 Hen. 7. Ordinance made by the King and Commons is not good and we are Judges what shall be said a Session of Parliament as it is in Plowden in Patridges Case We are Judges of their lives and lands therefore of their Liberties And 8 Eliz. which was cited by Mr. Atturney it was the opinion of Dyer Oatlyn Welsh Brown
per Annum by raising a certain value upon their Lands and some other impositions which requiring a long Discourse by it self I will omit it here setting it down in my Instructions it will save your Majesty at least One hundred thousand pounds per Annum to make it pain of death and confiscation of goods and lands for any of the Officers to cousen You which now is much to be feared they do or else they could not be so rich and herein to allow a fourth part benefit to them that shall find out the cousenage Here is not meant Officers of State as the Lord Treasurer c. being Officers of the Crown The summe of all this account amounteth unto two Millions or Twenty hundred thousand pounds per Annum Suppose it be but one Million and a Half as assuredly your Majesty may make by these courses set down yet it is much more then I promised in my Letter for your Majesties service Besides some sums of mony in present by the courses following Imprimis By the Prince's Marriage to make all the Earls in England Grandees of Spain and Principi with such like priviledges and to pay twenty thousand pounds apiece for it 2. As also if you make them Foeditaries of the Towns belonging to their Earldoms if they will pay for it besides as they do to the King of Spain in the Kingdom of Naples And so likewise Barons to be made Earls and Peers to pay ninteen thousand pounds a piece I think might yield five hundred thousand pounds and oblige them more sure to his Majesty 3. To make choice of two hundred of the richest men of England in estate that be not Noble-men and make them Titulate as is used in Naples and paying for it that is a Duke thirty thousand pounds a Marquis fifteen thousand pounds an Earl ten thousand pounds and a Baron or Viscount five thousand pounds It is to be understood that the antient Nobility of Barons made Earls are to precede these as Peers though these be made Marquesses or Dukes this may raise a Million of pounds and more unto your Majesty To make Gentlemen of low quality and Francklines and rich Farmers Esquires to precede them would yield your Majesty also a great sum of mony in present I know another course to yield your Majesty at least three hundred thousand pounds in mony which as yet the time serveth not to discover untill your Majesty be resolved to proceed in some of the former courses which till then I omit Other courses also that may make present mony I shall study for your Majestie 's service and as I find them out acquaint you withall Lastly to conclude all these discourses by the application of this course used for your profit That it is not onely the means to make you the richest King that ever England had but also the safety augmented thereby to be most secure besides what shewed in the first part of this Discourse I mean by the occasion of this Taxation and raising of monies your Majesty shall have cause and means to imploy in all places of the Land so many Officers and Ministers to be obliged to you for their own good and interest as nothing can be attempted against your Person or Royall State over land but some of them shall in all probability have means to find it out and hinder it Besides this course will detect many disorders and abuses in the publick Government which were hard to be discovered by men indifferent To prohibite gorgeous and costly apparell to be worn but by persons of good quality shall save the Gentry of the Kingdom much more mony then they shall be taxed to pay unto your Majesty Thus withall I take my leave and kiss your gratious hands desiring pardon for my error I may commit herein Pasc. 5. Caroli Regis B. R. The Reports of the following Arguments were taken by Mr. Widdrington of Gray's-Inn UPon the Habeas Corpus out of this Court to bring here the body of one William Stroud Esq with the cause of his imprisonment to the Marshall of the Kings Bench it was returned in this manner That William Stroud Esq was committed under my custody by vertue of a certain Warrant under the hands of twelve Lords of the Privy Councill of the Lord the King the tenour of which Warrant followeth in these words You are to take knowledge that it is his Majesties expresse pleasure and commandment that you take into your custody the body of William Stroud Esq and keep him close-prisoner untill you shall receive other order either from his Majesty or this Board for so doing this shall be your Warrant Dated the 2 d of April 1629. And the Direction thereof was To the Marshall of the King's Bench or his Deputy He is likewise held in prison by vertue of a certain Warrant under the hand of the King himself the tenour of which Warrant followeth in these words Carolus Rex Whereas you have in your custody the body of William Stroud Esq committed by the Lords of Our Privy Councill by Our speciall command you are to take notice that his commitment was for notable contempts by him committed against Our Self and Our Government and for stirring up of Sedition against Us For which you are to detain him in your custody and keep him close-prisoner untill Our pleasure be further known concerning his deliverance Given at Greenwich the 7 th of May 1629. in the 5 th year of Our Reigne And the direction was To Our Marshall for Our Bench for the time being And these are the causes of the taking and detaining of the foresaid William Stroud c. And upon another Habeas Corpus to the Marshall of the Houshold to have the body of Walter Long Esq he made the same Return as above Ask of the Inner Temple of Counsell with Mr. Stroud moved That the Return was insufficient The Return consists upon two Warrants bearing severall Dates which are the causes of the taking and detaining of the Prisoner For the first Warrant which is of the Lords of the Councill that is insufficient because no cause is shewn of his commitment which is expresly against the resolution of the Parliament and their Petition of Right in the time of this King which now is to which he had likewise given his assent so his taking by vertue of the said Warrant is wrongfull And for the second Warrant it is insufficient also and that notwithstanding that it be the Kings own for the King himself cannot imprison any man as our Books are to wit 16 H. 6. F. Monstrance de faits 1 H. 7.4 Hussey reports it to be the opinion of Markham in the time of Edw. 4. and Forrescue in his Book de laudibus Legum Angliae cap. 18. And the reason given is because no action of false imprisonment lies against the King if the Imprisonment be wrongfull and the King cannot be a wrong doer The Statute
it particular It hath been confessed by one that argued on the other side that there is a generall in a particular C. 4. Hollands case there is the most generall and there is generall in particular as the State Ecclesiasticall 3 ly There is more particular as Colledges Deans and Chapters This being in a case of Return upon Habeas Corpus no precise certainty is required In an Indictment a certainty of all circumstances is requisite in Pleading a certainty is required in Counâ—s a more precise certainty in Barrs a certainty to a common intent is enough There is not such precise certainty required here as in Indictment or Count because the party ought to answer unto them nor so much certainty is required in this as in a Bar. And the Return is not incertain for as it is said in Plowden 202. and 193. a thing is incertain where it may be taken indifferently one way or the other But where the intendment the one way exceeds the intendment the other way it is not uncertain as it is here The words are for notable contempts against Us and Our Government for stirring up of sedition against Us Here is certainty of intendment one way There are many Writs which are more uncertain thâ—â— this Return here is yet good The Writ concerning the taking of an Apostate is general Quod spreto habitu Ordinis and yet there are more sorts of Apostasies In the Writ concerning the amoving of a Leper the words are generall and yet it appears by F. N. B. that there are two kinds of Lepers one outward and the other inward and for the latter the Writ concerning amoving a Leper So the Writs concerning the burning of an Heretick and concerning the examining of an Idiot are general and yet there are sundry kinds of Hereticks and Idiots also But it hath been objected that Sedition is not a Law-tearm nor known in the Law of which the Iudges can take no notice but the words to expresse offences of this nature are Murder Treason Felony c. and that no Indictment of Sedition generally was ever seen To this I answer Perhaps it is true that no Indictment was ever seen made because the form of an Indictment is precise words of art are required therein as appears in Dyer 69.261 C. 4. Vaux's case yet in 5 E. 6. Dyer 69. it is said that Furatus implies Felonicè cepit although the contrary hath been objected In a Return words by Periphrasis are sufficient The Warrant of a Iustice of Peace to apprehend I. S. because of prepensed malice interfecit I. D. is good enough although there wants the word murdravit In 5 R. 2. F. tryal 54. Belknap saies That a miscreant shall forfeit his land Out of which it may be gathered that a man may be Indicted for miscreancy And it seems likewise that an Indictment of sedition may be good for in some cases it is Treason I agree Peaks case which hath been obiected that for these words seditious fellow no action lies and so is C. 4.19 b. because those words do not import an act to be done but onely an inclination to do it but if a man say such words of another which import that he hath made sedition they are actionable as it was resolved in Phillips Badby's case 24 Eliz. C. 4.19 a. Thou hast made a seditious Sermon and moved the people to sedition this day adjudged actionable So in the Lord Cromwells C. 4.12 13. the action would have lain for those words You like of those that maintain sedition against the Queens proceedings if there had not been another matter in the case I agree the case of 21 E. 3. Sir John Garboyls case 42. E. 3. for in those cases sedition was only taken adjectively and shewes an inclination onely to do a seditious act in such sense sedition may be applyed to other offences then treason In 31 E. 1. f. gard 157. Gardein in Socage made feofment of land which he had in Ward This is forfeiture saies the Book for the treason which he did to the Ward so there one thing is called treason which is onely a breach of trust In an appeal of Mayhem it is felonicè and yet 6 H. 7.1 it is not Felony But felony is there onely put to expresse the hainousnesse of the offence it is as it were a felony The Statutes of 2 H. 4.1 Mar. 13 Eliz. 35 Eliz. 17 R. 2.3 4 E. 6.14 Eliz. which have been objected have the word Sedition but not applyable to this case Bracton in his Book de Corona saies Si quis c. If any by rash attempt plotting the Kings death should act or cause any to act to the sedition of the Lord the King or of his Army it is treason And Glanvil in as many words saies That to do any thing in sedition of the Kingdom or of the Army is high-treason And Britton fol. 16 It is high treason to â—â—herit the King of the Realm and sedition tendeth to the disheritance of the King for as it hath been said Seditio est quasi seorsum-itio when the people are severed from the King or it is Seperans à ditione when the people are severed from the power of the King And in this sense Sedition is no stranger in our Law and such sedition which severs the people from the King is Treason But it hath been objected that by the Statute of 25 E. 3. the Parliament ought onely to determine what is treason what not To this I answer That upon the said Statute the positive Law had alwaies made explication and exposition Br. treason 24. the words are Compasse or imagine the death of the King and there it is taken that he that malitiously deviseth how the King may come to death by words or otherwise and does an act to explain it as in assaying harnesse this is treason 13 Eliz. Dy. 298. Story 's case he being beyond-sea practised with a forraign Prince to invade the Realm and held treason because invasion is to the perill of the Prince and so within the Statute of 25 E. 3.4 Mar. Dy. 144. The taking of the Castle of Scarborough was treason in Stafford by 30. ass p. 19. which was presently after the making of the Statute of 25 E. 3. A man ought to have been hanged and drawn that brought Letters of Excommengement from the Pope and published them in England And it is to be noted that at the same time there was no Statute to make it treason but upon construction of the said Statute of 25 E. 3 though now it be made treason by the Statute of 13 Eliz. if it be with intention to advance forraigne power Perhaps the sedition mentioned in this Return is high treason and yet the King may make it an offence Finable for he may prosecute the offendor in what course he pleaseth and if it be treason then the prisoners are not baylable by the Statute of Westm. But suppose
by Mittimus for there never was any president thereof and the Book of the House of Commons which is with their Clerk ought not to be divulged And C. Littl. is that if a man be indicted in this Court for Piracy committed upon the Sea he may well plead to the jurisdiction of this Court because this Court cannot try it 2 ly It appears by the old Treatise de modo tenendi Parliamentum that the Iudges are but assistants in the Parliament and if any words or acts are made there they have no power to contradict or controul them Then it is incongruous that they after the Parliament dissolved shall have power to punish such words or acts which at the time of the speaking or doing they had not power to contradict There are superiour middle and more inferiour Magistrates and the superiour shall not be subject to the controle of the inferiour It is a Position that in pares est nullum imperium multò minus in eos qui majus imperium habent C. Littl. saies that the Parliament is the supream Tribunal of the Kingdom and they are Iudges of the supream Tribunal therefore they ought not to be questioned by their inferiours 3 The offences objected do concern the priviledges of Parliament which priviledges are determinable in Parliament and not else-where as appears by the presidents which have been cited before 4 The common-Law hath assigned proper Courts for matters in respect of the place and persons 1 st for the place It appears by 11 E. 4.3 old Entries 101. that in an Ejectione firme it is a good plea that the land is antient demeasne and this excludes all other Courts So it is for land in Durham old Entries 419. for it is questionable there not out of the County 2 ly For persons H. 15. H. 7. roll 93 old Entries 47. If a Clerk of the Chancery be impleaded in this Court he may plead his priviledge and shall not answer So it is of a Clerk of the Exchequer old Entries 473. then much more when offences are done in Parliament which is exempt from ordinary jurisdiction they shall not be drawn in question in this Court And if a man be Indicted in this Court he may plead Sanctuary 22 H. 7. Keilw 91. and 22. and shall be restored 21 E. 3.60 The Abbot of Bury's case is to the same purpose 5 For any thing that appears the House of Commons had approved of these matters therefore they ought not to be questioned in this Court. And if they be offences and the said House hath not punished them this will be a casting of imputation upon them 6 It appears by the Old Entries 446 447 that such an one ought to represent the Borough of St. Jermans from whence he was sent therefore he is in nature of an Ambassadour and he shall not be questioned for any thing in the Execution of his office if he do nothing against the Law of Nature or Nations as it is in the case of an Ambassadour In the time of Queen Elizabeth the Bishop of Rosse in Scotland being Ambassadour here attempted divers matters against the State and by the opinion of all the Civilians of the said time he may be questioned for those offences because they are against the Law of Nations and Nature and in such matters he shall not enjoy the priviledges of an Ambassador But if he commit a civill offence which is against the Municipall Law onely he cannot be questioned for it as Bodin de Republica agrees the case Upon the Statute of 28 H. 8. c. 15. for tryall of Pirats 13. Jac. the case fell out to be thus A Iew came Ambassador to the United Provinces and in his journey he took some Spanish ships and after was driven upon this coast And agreed upon the said Statute that he cannot be tryed as a Pyrat here by Commission but he may be questioned civiliter in the Admiralty For Legati suo Regi soli judicum faciunt So Embassadors of Parliament soli Parliamento to wit in such things which of themselves are justifiable 7 There was never any president that this Court had punished offences of this nature committed in Parliament where any plea was put in as here it is to the jurisdiction of the Court and where there is no president non-usage is a good Expositor of the Law Lord Littl. Section 180. Co. Littl. f. 81. saies As Usage is a good interpreter of the Lawes so Non-usage where there is no example is a great intendment that the Law will not bear it 6 Eliz. Dy. 229. upon the Statute of 27 H. 8. of Inrolments that bargain and sale of a House in London ought not to be enrolled the reason there given is because it is not used 23. Eliz. Dy. 376. No errour lies here of a Iudgment given in the five Ports because such Writ was never seen yet in the diversity of Courts it is said That errour lies of a Iudgment given in the five Ports 39 H. 6.39 by Ashton that a protection to go to Rome was never seen therefore he disallowed it 8 If this Court shall have Iurisdiction the Court may give judgment according to Law and yet contrary to Parliament Law for the Parliament in divers cases hath a peculiar Law Notwithstanding the Statute of 1 H. 5. c. 1. that every Burgesse ought to be resident within the Burrough of which he is Burgesse yet the constant usage of Parliament is contrary thereunto and if such matter shall be in question before ye ye ought to adiudge according to the Statute and not according to their usage So the House of Lords hath a speciall Law also as appears by 11 R. 2. the Roll of the Processe and Iudgmen which hath been cited before to another purpose where an appeal was not according to the one Law or th' other yet it was good according to the course of Parliament 9 Because this matter is brought in this Court by way of Information where it ought to be by way of Indictment And it appears by 41 ass p. 12. that if a Bill of Disceit be brought in this Court where it ought to be by Writ This matter may be pleaded to the Iurisdiction of the Court because it is vi armis and contra pacem It appears by all our Books that informations ought not to be grounded upon surmices but upon matter of Record 4 H. 7.5.6 E. 6. Dy. 74. Information in the Exchequer and 11 H. 8. Keilw 101. are this purpose And if the matter be vi armis then it ought to be found by Enquest 2 E. 3.1 2. Appeal shall not be grounded upon the Return of the Sheriff but the King ought to be certified of it by Indictment 1 H. 7.6 and Stamf. f. 95. a. Upon the Statute of 25 E. 3. c. 4. that none shall be imprisoned but upon Indictment or Presentment and 28 E. 3. c. 3. 42 E. 3. c. 3. are to the same purpose
for a word and lay a snare for him that reproveth in the gate and turn aside the just for a thing of nought Blame not before thou have examined the truth understand first and then rebuke answer not before thou hast heard the cause neither interrupt men in the midst of their talk Doth our Law judge any man before it hear him and know what he doth King Agrippa said unto Paul Thou art permitted to speak for thy self Thou shalt not wrest the judgment of the poor in his cause thou shalt not respect persons neither take a gift for a gift doth blind the eyes of the wise and pervert the eyes of the righteous Woe to them that devise iniquity because it is in the power of their hand and they covet fields and take them by violence and houses and take them away so they oppress a man and his house even a man and his heritage Thus saith the Lord God Let it suffice you O Princes of Israel remove violence and spoyl and execute judgment and justice take away your exactions from my people saith the Lord God If thou seest the oppression of the Poor and violent perverting of judgment and justice in a Province marvel not at the matter for he that is higher then the highest regardeth and there be higher then they Per me Richard Chambers Afterwards in the Term of Trinity the 5 yeer of King Charls it is found in the great Roll of this year that there is demanded there of Richard Chambers of London Merchant 2000 l. for a certain fine imposed on him hither sent by vertue of a writ of our said Lord the King under the foot of the great Seal of England directed to the Treasurer and Barons of this Exchequer for making execution thereof to the use of the said Lord the King as is there contained and now that is to say in the Utas of the Blessed Trinity this Term comes the said Richard Chambers in his own proper person and demands Oyer of the demand aforesaid and it is read unto him and he demands Oyer also of the Writ aforesaid under the foot of the Great Seal of England hither sent and it is read unto him in these words CHarls by the Grace of God of England Scotland France and Ireland Defender of the Faith c. To his Treasurer and Barons of his Exchequer health The extret of certain fines taxed and adjudged by Us and our said Council in our said Council in Our Court of Star-Chamber in the Term of St Michael the Term of St. Hillary and the Term of Easter last past upon Thomas Barns of the Parish of St. Clements Danes in the County of Middlesex Carpenter and others severally and dividedly as they be there severally assessed We send unto you included in these presents commanding that looking into them you do that which by Law you ought to do against them for the levying of those fines Witness our Self at Westminster the 21 of May in the yeer of Our Reign the 5 Mutas And the tenor of the Schedule to the said Writ annexed as to the said Richard Chambers followeth in these words IN the Term of Easter the fifth year of King Charles of Richard Chambers of London Merchant 2000 l. which being read heard and by him understood he complains that he is grievously vexed and inquieted by colour of the Premises and that not justly for that protesting that the said great Roll and the matter therein contained is not in Law sufficient to which he hath no need nor is bound by Law to answer yet for Plea the said Richard Chambers saith That he of the demand aforesaid in the great Roll aforesaid mentioned and every parcel thereof ought to be discharged against the said Lord the King for that he said That he from the time of the Taxation oâ— the aforesaid Fine and long before was a Freeman and a Merchant of this Kingdom that is to say In the Parish of the blessed Mary of the Arches in the Ward of Cheap London And that by a certain Act in the Parliament of the Lord Henry late King of England the Third held in the ninth year of his reign it was provided by Authority of the said Parliament That a Freeman shall not be amerced for a little offence but according to the manner of the said offence and for a great offence according to the greatness of the offence saving to him his Contenement or Freehold and a Merchant in the same manner saving unto him his Merchandize and a Villain of any other then the King after the same manner to be amerced saving his Wainage and none of the said Amercements to be imposed but by the Oaths of good and lawful men of the Neighbourhood And by a certain other Act in the Parliament of the Lord Edward late King of England the first held in the Third year of his reign it was and is provided That no City Burrough or Town nor any man should be amerced without reasonable cause and according to his Trespass that is to say A Freeman saving to him his Contenement A Merchant saving to him his Merchandize and A Villan saving to him his Wainage and this by their Peers And by the same Act in the Parliament of the said Lord Henry late King of England the Third held in the ninth year of his reign aforesaid it was and is provided by Authority of the said Parliament That no Freemen should be taken or imprisoned or disseized of his Freehold or Liberties or free Customs or outlaw'd or banish'd or any way destroyed And that the Lord the King should not go upon him nor deal with him but by a lawful judgement of his Peers or by the Law of the Land And by a certain Act in the Parliament of the Lord Edward late King of England the Third held in the fifth year of his reign it was and is provided by the Authority of the said Parliament That no man henceforward should be attached by reason of any Accusation nor pre-judged of Life or Member nor that his Lands Tenements Goods or Chattels should be seized into the hands of the Lord the King against the form of the great Charter and the Law of the Land And by a certain Act in the Parliament of the Lord Henry late King of England the seventh held in the third year of his reign reciting that by unlawful Maintenances given of liveries signes and tokens and retainders by Indentures Promises Oaths Writings and other Imbraceries of the Subjects of the said Lord the King false Demeanors of Sheriffs in making of Pannels and other false returns by taking of money by Jurors by great ryots and unlawful assemblies the policie and good Government of this Kingdom was almost subdued and by not punishing of the said inconveniences and by occasion of the Premises little or nothing was found by Inquisition by reason thereof the Laws of
the Land had little effect in their execution to the increase of Murders Robberies Perjuries and Insecurities of all men living to the loss of their Lands and Goods to the great displeasure of Almighty GOD It was ordained for Reformation of the Premises by Authority of the said Parliament That the Chancellour and Treasurer of England for the time being and the Keeper of the Privy-Seal of the Lord the King or two of them calling to them one Bishop one Lord temporal of the most honourable Council of the Lord the King and two chief Justices of the Kings Bench and Common pleas for the time being or two other Justices in their absence by Bill or Information exhibited to the Chancellour for the King or any other against any person for any other ill behaviours aforesaid have Authority of calling before them by Writ or Privie-Seal such Malefactors and of examining them and others by their discretion and of punishing such as they finde defective therein according to their demerits according to the form and effect of the Statutes thereof made in the same manner and form as they might and ought to be punished if they were thereof convinced according to the due course of Law And by a certain other Act in the Parliament of the Lord Henry late King of England the eighth held in the one and twentieth year of his reign reciting the offences in the aforesaid Statute of the said late King Henry the seventh beforementioned by Authority of the said Parliament it was and is ordained and enacted That henceforward the Chancellour Treasurer of England and the President of the most honourable Privy-Council of the King attending his most honourable person for the time being and the Lord Keeper of the Privy-Seal of the Lord the King or two of them calling to them one Bishop and one temporal Lord of the most honourable Council of the Lord the King and two chief Justices of the Kings Bench and Common Pleas for the time being or two Justices in their absence by any Bill or Information then after to be exhibited to the Chancellour of England the Treasurer the President of the said most honourable Council of the Lord the King or the Keeper of the Privy-Seal of the Lord the King for the time being for any misdemeanour in the aforesaid Statute of King Henry the seventh aforesaid before recited from henceforth have full power and authority of calling before them by Writ or by Privy-Seal such Malefactors of examining of them and others by their discretion and of punishing those that are found defective according to their demerits According to the form and effect of the said Statute of the aforesaid Lord King Henry the seventh and of all other Statutes thereupon made not revoked and expired in the same manner and form as they might and ought be punished if they were convicted according to the due order of the Laws of the said Lord the king And by the aforesaid Writ under the foot of the great Seal it manifesty appears that the said Fine was imposed by the Lord the king and his Council and not by the Legal Peers of the said Richard Chambers nor by the Law of the Land nor according to the manner of the pretended offence of the said Richard Chambers nor saving unto him his Merchandize nor for any offence mentioned in the said Statutes all and singular the which the said Richard Chambers is ready to verifie to the Court c. and demands judgment and that he be discharge of the said 2000 l. against the said Lord the now King and that as to the premises he may be dismissed from this Court Waterhouse With this Plea he annexed a Petition to the Lord Chief Baron and also to every one of the Barons humbly desiting the filing of the Plea with other Reasons in the manner of a motion at the Bar because he said Counsel would not move plead nor set hand to it as further appeareth The Copy of the Order upon Mr. Atturneys motion in the Exchequer the 17 Iuly 1629. after the Plea put in and order to file it Per the Lord Chief Baron TOuching the Plea put into this Court by Richard Chambers to discharge himself of a â—ine of 2000 l. set on him in the Star-Chamber Forasmuch as Sir Robert Heath Kniâ—â—â— his Majesties Atturney General informed this Court that the said Chambers in his said Plea recites divers Statutes and Magna Charta and what offences are punishable in the Star-Chamber and how the proceedings ought to be and upon the whole matter concludes That the said fine was imposed by the King and his Council and not by a Legal judgment of his Peers nor by the Laws of the Land nor according to the manner of his offence nor saving his Merchandize nor for any offence mentioned in the said Statutes Which Plea Mr. Atturny conceiving to be very frivolous and insufficient and derogatory to the honour and jurisdiction of the Court of Star-Chamber Humbly prayeth might not be allowed of nor filed It is therefore this day ordered That the said Plea shall be read on Saturday next and then upon hearing the Kings Counsel and the Counsel of the said Richard Chambers this Court will-declare their further order therein and in the mean time the said Plea is not to be filed nor delivered out In Michaelmas Term following Mr. Chambers was brought by a Habeas Corpus out of the Fleet and the Warden did return THat he was committed to the Fleet by vertue of a Decree in the Star-Chamber by reason of certain words he used at the Council Table viz. That the Merchants of England were skrewed up here in England more then in Turky And for these and other words of defamation of the Government he was censured to be committed to the Fleet and to be there imprisoned until he made his submission at the Council Table and to pay a fine of 2000. l. And now at the Bar he prayed to be delivered because this Sentence is not warranted by any Law or Statute For the Statute of 3 Henrici 7. which is the foundation of the Court of Star-Chamber doth not give them any authority to punish for words only But all the Court informed him That the Court of Star-Chamber was not erected by the Statute of 3 H. 7. but was a Court many years before and one of the most high and honourable Courts of Justice and to deliver one who was committed by the Decree of one of the Courts of Justice was not the usage of this Court and therefore he was remanded As a concurrant proof of these Proceedings concerning Mr. Chambers we shall insert here a Petition of his though out of time to the Long Parliament and afterwards renewed to the succeeding Parliament viz. To the Parliament of the Commonwealth of England Scotland and Ireland The brief Remonstrance and humble Petition of Richard Chambers Merchant late Alderman and Sheriff of the City of
losers whereby having your Lands free and renting it out to the true value as it is most in use and not imployed as heretofore at an old Rent and small â—ines you may then rent it out for at least four or five times more mony then the old Rent comes unto So as if your Majesties â—onds be already but sixty thousand pounds per Annum by this course it will be augmented at the least two hundred thousand pounds per Annum and to buy out the Tenants estates will come to a small matter by the course to make them no losers considering the gain they have already made upon the Land And this is the rather to be done and the present course changed because it hath been a custom used meerly to cousen the King Item Whereas most Princes do receive the benefit of Salt in their own hands as a matter of great profit because they receive it at the lowest price possible and vent it at double gain yearly the same course used by your Majesty were worth at least one hundred and fifty thousand pound per Annum It is likewise in other parts that all Weights and Measures of the land either in private Houses Shops or publick Markets should be viewed to be just and sealed once a year paying to the Prince for it which in England applyed to your Majesty with order to pay six-pence for the sealing of each said Weight or Measure would yield near sixty thousand pounds per Annum Item Though all Countries pay a Gabella for transportation of Cloth and so likewise in England yet in Spain there is Impost upon the Wools which in England is so great a wealth and benefit to the Sheep-Masters as they may well pay you five pound per cent of the true value at the shearing which I conceive may be worth one hundred and forty thousand pounds per Annum Item Whereas the Lawyers Fees and gains in England be excessive to your Subjects prejudice it were better for your Majesty to make use thereof and impose on all Causes sentenced with the party to pay five pound per cent of the true value that the Cause hath gained him and for recompence thereof to limit all Lawyers Fees and gettings whereby the Subject shall save more in Fees and Charges then he giveth to your Majesty in the Gabella which I believe may be worth one year with another fifty thousand pounds Item Whereas the Innes and Victualling-houses in England are more chargeable to the Travellers then in other Countries it were good for your Majesty to linâ— them to certain Ordinaries and raise besides a large Imposition as is used in Tuskany and other parts that is a prohibiting all Innes and Victualling-houses but such as shall pay it and to impose upon the chief Inns and Taverns to pay ten pounds a year to your Majesty and the worst five pound per Annum and all Ale-houses twenty shillings per Annum more or lesse as they are in custom Of all sorts there are so many in England that this Imposâ— may well yield one hundred thousand pounds per Annum to your Majesty Item In Tuscany and other parts there is a Gabella of all Cattle or Flesh and Horses sold in Markets paying three or four per cent of what they are sold for which by conjecture may be worth in England two hundred thousand pounds per Annum using the like Custom upon Fish and other Victualls Bread excepted and for this cause Flesh and Fish and Victualls in the Markets to be priced and sold by weight whereby the Subject saveth more in not being cousened than the Imposition impaireth them Item In Tuskany is used a Taxation of seven per cent upon all alienation of Lands to the true value As also seven per cent upon all Dowries or Marriage-monies The like if it be justly used in England were worth at least one hundred thousand pound per Annum with many other Taxations upon Meal and upon all Merchandises in all Towns as well as Port-Towns which here I omit with divers others as not so fit for England And in satisfaction of the Subject for these Taxes your Majesty may be pleased to release them of Wardships and to enjoy all their Estates at eighteen yâ—ers old and in the mean time their profits to be preserved for their own benefit And also in forfeitures of Estate by condemnation your Majesty may release the Subject as not to take the forfeiture of their Lands but their Goods High-Treason onely excepted and to allow the Counsell of Lawyers in case of life and death as also nor to be condemned without two Witnesses with such like benefit which importeth much more their good then all the Taxations named can prejudice them Item Some of the former Taxations used in Ireland and in Scotland as may easily be brought about by the first example thereof used in England may very well be made to increase your Revenue there more then it is by two hundred thousand pound per Annum Item All Offices in the Land great and small in your Majestie 's grant may be granted with condition to pay you a part yearly according to the value This in time may be worth as I conceive one hundred thousand pound per Annum adding also Notaries Atturneys and such like to pay some proportion yearly towards it for being allowed by your Majesty to practise and prohibiting else any to practise in such places Item To reduce your Majesties houshold to Board-wages as most other Princes do reserving some few Tables this will save your Majesty sixty thousand pounds per Annum and ease greatly the Subject besides both in Carriages and Provision which is a good reason that your Majesty in honour might do it Item I know an assured course in your Majestie 's Navy which may save at least forty thousand pounds per Annum which requiring a whole Discourse by it self I omit onely promise you to do it whensoever you command Item Whereas your Majesties Lawes do command the strict keeping of Fasting-daies you may also prohibit on those daies to eat Eggs Cheese and White-meats but onely such as are contented 〈◊〉 pay eighteen pence a yeer for the liberty to eat them and the better sort ten shillings The employment of this may be for the defence of the Land in maintaining the Navy Garrisons and such like much after the fashion of a Crusado in Spain as your Majesty knoweth being first begun there under the pretence to defend the Land against the Moors And the same used in England as aforesaid may very well yield one yeer with another one hundred thousand pounds without any disgust to any because it is at every ones choice to give it or no. Lastly I have a course upon the Catholicks and very safe for your Majesty being with their good liking as it may be wrought to yield you presently at least two hundred thousand pound