is one Lord. q Jer. 10.10 But the Lord he is the true God he is the living God and an everlasting King How many persons are there in the Godhead r Mat. 28.19 Go ye therefore and teach all Nations baptizing them in the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost s 1 Joh. 5.7 For there are three that bear record in Heaven the Father the Word and the Holy Ghost and these three are one What are the Decrees of God t Eph. 1.11 Being predestinated according to the purpose of him who worketh all things after the counsel of his own will 12. That we should be to the praise of his glory How doth God execute his Decrees u Rev. 4.11 Thou hast created all things and for thy pleasure they are and were created w Dan. 4.35 He doth according to his will in the army of heaven and among the inhabitants of the earth What is the work of Creation x Gen 1.1 In the beginning God created the Heaven and the Earth y Heb. 11.3 Through faith we understand that the worlds were framed by the word of God so that things which were seen were not made of things that do appear z Gen. 1.31 And God saw every thing that he had made and behold it was very good and the evening and the morning were the sixth day How did God create man a Gen. 1.27 So God created man in his own Image in the Image of God created he him male and female created he them b Col. 3.10 And have put on the new man which is renewed in knowledg after the image of him that created him Eph. 4.24 And that ye put on the new man which after God is created in righteousness and true holiness c Gen. 1.28 And God blessed them and God said unto them Be fruitful and multiply and replenish the earth and subdue it and have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the fowl of the air and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth What are Gods works of Providence d Psal. 145.17 The Lord is righteous in all his ways and holy in all his works e Isa. 28.29 This also cometh forth from the Lord of hosts which is wonderful in counsel and excellent in working f Heb. 1.3 Upholding all things by the word of his power g Psal. 103.19 His kingdom ruleth over all Mat. 10.29 Are not two sparrows sold for a farthing and one of them shall not fall to the ground without your Father What special act of Providence did God exercise towards man in the estate wherein he was created h Gal. 3.12 And the law is not of faith but the man that doth them shall live in them i Gen. 2.17 But of the tree of knowledg of good and evil thou shalt not eat of it for in the day thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die Did our first Parents continue in the estate wherein they were created k Eccl. 7.29 God hath made man upright but they have sought out many inventions What is sin l 1 Joh. 3.4 Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law for sin is the transgression of the law What was the sin whereby our first Parents sell from the estate wherein they were created m Gen. 3.6 And when the woman saw that the Tree was good for food and that it was pleasant to the eyes and a tree to be desired to make one wise she took of the fruit thereof and did eat and gave also to her husband and he did eat 7. And the eyes of them both were opened and they knew that they were naked 8. And Adam and his wife hid themselves from the presence of the Lord among the trees of the garden Did all mankind fall in Adams first transgression n Gen. 1.28 And God blessed them and God said unto them Be fruitful and multiply and replenish the Earth Gen. 2.16 And the Lord God commanded the man saying Of every Tree in the Garden thou maist freely eat 17. But of the Tree of the knowledg of good and evil thou shalt not eat of it for in the day thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die o Rom. 5.18 By the offence of one judgment came upon all to condemnation Into what estate did the fall bring mankind p Rom. 5.12 By one man sin entred into the world and death by sin and so death passed upon all men for that all have sinned Wherein consists the sinfulness of that estate whereunto man fell q Rom. 5.19 By one mans disobedience many were made sinners r Rom. 3.10 There is none righteous no not one s Eph. 2.1 You hath he quickened who were dead in trespasses and sins Psal. 51.5 Behold I was shapen in iniquity and in sin did my mother conceive me t Mat. 15.19 For out of the heart proceed evil thoughts murders adulteries fornications thefts false-witness blaspemies 20. These are the things which defile a man What is the misery of that estate whereunto man fell u Gen. 3.8 Adam and his wife hid themselves from the presence of the Lord God amongst the Trees of the Garden 24. So he drove out the man w Eph. 2.3 And were by nature children of wrath even as others Gal. 3.10 Cursed is every man that continueth not in all things which are written in the Book of the Law to do them x Rom. 6.23 The wages of sin is death Mat. 25.41 Then shall he say unto them on the left hand Depart from me ye cursed into everlasting fire prepared for the Devil and his angels Did God leave all mankind to perish in the estate of sin and misery y Eph. 1.4 According as he hath chosen us in him before the foundation of the world z Rom. 3.21 But now the righteousness of God without the law is manifested being witnessed by the Law and the Prophets 22 Even the righteousness of God which is of Faith by Iesus Christ unto all and upon all that believe Who is the Redeemer of Gods Elect a 1 Tim. 2.5 For there is one God and one Mediator between God and men the man Christ Iesus b Joh. 1.14 And the word was made flesh and dwelt among us c Rom. 9.5 Whose are the Fathers and of whom as concerning the flesh Christ came who is over all God blessed for ever d Heb. 7.24 But this man because he continueth ever hath an unchangeable priesthood How did Christ being the Son of God become man e Heb. 2.14 For as much then as the children are partakers of flesh and blood he also himself likewise took part in the same f Mat. 26.38 Then saith he unto them My soul is exceeding sorrowful even unto death g Luk. 1.31 Behold thou shalt conceive in thy womb and bring forth a Son and shalt call his Name Iesus 35. The holy Ghost shall come upon thee and the power of the highest shall over-shadow thee h Heb. 7.25 Such a High-Priest became us who is holy harmless undefiled
understanding will and subsistence by it self and distinguished from any thing else by some peculiar property that belongs to it and to nothing else besides it self as there is something peculiar in every one man to distinguish him from another this for a person in general But now for a Divine person or a person in the Godhead 'T is a substance that is undivided and absolutely perfect in Being Understanding Will and manner of Subsistence yet actually really and eternally distinguished from any other person by some relative property that belongs to it and not to that person 2. For the number of the persons in the Godhead they are three not only in the reckoning of man or according to humane apprehension but also in reality and in Gods account whether men should reckon them so or no and are therefore called a Trinity of Persons Yet 3. though they be so distinguished one from another as that the Father is not the Son and the Son not the Father and the Holy Ghost neither Father nor Son yet they are not cannot be divided or separated one from another because the whole and single Godhead is wholly coequally and coessentially in all three by virtue whereof 't is said these three are one i. e. one God A. 7. The Decrees of God are his eternal purpose according to the counsel of his own will whereby for his own glory he hath fore-ordained whatsoever comes to pass Artic. xvij Everlasting purpose of God whereby before the foundations of the world were laid he hath constantly decreed by his counsel secret to us c. Expl. 7. In this A. we have 1. the nature and properties of Gods Decrees they are like Himself from everlasting whatever God did purpose and determine to do or permit to be done he did thus purpose from eternity 2. Here is the Rule of Gods Decree the counsel of his own Will and yet nothing that he decrees can be any other than reasonable and good because by reason of the infinite perfection of his Nature his Will is essentially just and holy and cannot be otherwise 3. The matter of his Decrees is whatsoever comes to pass though there be never so much of that which we call hap-hazard in them 4. The end of his Decrees for his glory for God neither does nor designs any thing but for the highest end and that is his own glory A. 8. God executeth his Decrees in the Work of Creation and Providence Homil. xvij Praise of Almighty God in the consideration of the marvelous Creation of this world or Conservation and Government thereof wherein his great Power and Wisdom might excellently appear to move us to dread and honour him Expl. 8. Here is shew'd how God doth bring to pass what he hath purposed 1. In the work of Creation by which we are to understand not only Gods making the world and all things therein in six days but also Gods producing or bringing into Being every thing else that came into Being since that time to the worlds end whether it became a Being in an ordinary way and by means as in the natural generation of things or in an extraordinary way by the immediate or miraculous power of God 2. In the work of Providence which is not only to be restrain'd to what is naturally good as every creature of God is but also reaches to what is naturally evil as affliction and to what is morally evil as sin A. 9. The work of Creation is Gods making all things of nothing by the word of his power in the space of six days and all very good To. 2. Hom. viij God through his Almighty power wisdom and goodness created in the beginning Heaven and Earth the Sun the Moon the Stars the Fowls of the Air the Beasts of the Earth the Fishes in the Sea and all other Creatures for the benefit and use of man Hom. xij Among all the Creatures that God made in the beginning of the World most excellent and wonderful in their kind there was none as the Scripture beareth witness to be compared in any point almost unto Man who in Body and Soul exceeded Expl. 9. By the work of Creation we are to understand Gods making of the world in time or in the beginning according as he had purposed from eternity or before all beginning of time and here it is observable 1. That this work is ascribed only to God the true God in opposition to Idols yet is not so to be ascribed to any one person in the Godhead as to exclude the other for all the three persons sc. Father Son and Holy Ghost being one in Essence or Godhead they must necessarily be one in working or as it were joyn hand in hand in all external works whether of Creation or Providence And therefore when the Creation is ascribed in the Apostles Creed to the Father Almighty it doth not exclude the Son or Holy Ghost from being Almighty or from joining with the Father in the work of Creation but only because the Father is the first in order of the three persons when we conceive of them and because there might be in the Church an outward distinction made but no real separation among the three persons in those works which are more eminently and peculiarly affirmed of each person as that the Father creates the Son redeems and the Spirit sanctifies 2. That he did not as an Artificer begin his work upon or out of materials which is beyond the skill of art and power of nature 3. Without any instrument or help for 1. There was nothing then in Being when he began his work therefore no instrument 2. He needed none being infinite in power 3. To have used any would not have been so consistent with the glory of his Wisdom and Power 4. Obs. That he did his work in six days that we might see it was a work of Wisdom and Counsel and not of Chance and to set us an example to work six days and rest the seventh 5 ly That he made all very good in their nature in their order and in their end A. 10. God created man male and female after his own image in knowledg righteousness and holiness with dominion over the creatures Homil. xij He was made after the similitude and image of God endued with all kind of heavenly gifts he had no spot of uncleanness in him was sound and perfect in all parts both inwardly and outwardly his reason was uncorrupt his understanding was pure and good his will was obedient and godly he was made altogether like unto God in righteousness and holiness in wisdom and truth to be short in all kind of perfection God made him Lord and Ruler over all the works of his hands Homil. viij Whom also he had created to his own image and likeness and given him the use and government over them all to the end he should use them in such
sort as he had given them in charge and commandment and also that he should declare himself thankful c. Expl. 10. God created man male and female i. e. in both Sexes man out of the dust of the earth and the woman of the Rib that he took out of the mans Side which creation is to be understood concerning the bodies of both not of the soul of either of them for the soul was not made of any materials at all but the reasonable soul was immediately infused into their bodies when God breathed into them the breath of life so that the soul is q.d. the breath of God There is a twofold image of God 1. That which is in God and so Christ the Second person in the Trinity is said to be the express image of the person of God the Father because in him the fulness of the Godhead dwells bodily 2. There is the image of God which is out of God or external to him and such an image of God was man in his first Creation 1 st In respect of his soul and that more generally in the nature of it God is a Spirit and so is mans soul God's immortal so that But more particularly 1. In knowledg of what was necessary to be known by him in order to Gods glory or his own happiness 2. In righteousness or uprightness i. e. his will did freely and fully comply with the will of God the Law of God being written in his heart 3. In holiness or with a power to do Gods will perfectly 2 dly In respect of his body wherein he did resemble the majesty not the spirituality of God for there was so much of majesty especially in mans countenance that the inferior creatures did stand in awe of him 3. In respect of the whole man because in his dominion over the creatures he did resemble his Creator in his dominion over the world A. 11. Gods works of Providence are his most holy wise and powerful preserving and governing all his creatures and all their actions Homil. xvij Conservation and governance of the world of liberal goodness which he daily bestoweth on us his reasonable creatures for whose sake he made the whole universal world with all the commodities and goods therein Take him for God omnipotent invisible having rule in Heaven and Earth having all things in subjection and will have none in counsel with him nor any to ask the reason of his doing for he may do what liketh him and none can resist him Dan. 11. For he worketh all things in his secret judgment to his own pleasure yea even the wicked to damnation saith Solomon Prov. 16. God hath not so created the world that he is careless of it but he still preserveth it by his goodness he still stayeth it in his creation To make our humble suits in prayers to his fatherly Providence Expl. 11. By Gods actual Providence we are to understand his ordering of all things in time according to his eternal purpose or the counsel of his own will or in plain English 't is his doing what he will in the world whether it be in Heaven or Earth For further explanation of this matter we are to know 1 st That according to our apprehension there are these distinctions and kinds of Providence 1. We have his eternal Providence or his decreeing purposing designing Providence which is nothing else but that frame method or order of government which was in the mind of God from everlasting before there was a world or any creature in it to be govern'd and of this was spoken before 2. His actual Providence which he hath exercised ever since he made the world as 1. In the conservation of things in their beings so that of all the species or kinds of creatures which he made he has lost none Individuals indeed do dye and perish and return to their dust but the species or kinds of creatures do not men dye this and that and t'other individual person in reference to their bodies but man does not or rather mankind does not 2. In the actual government of all things by his wisdom which he doth preserve by his infinite power for God does not do by the World as the Ship-Carpenter by the Ship build and leave it and never look after it more but he doth look after the preservation of it as the Owner and the government of it as the Pilot. Other distinctions there are of Providence as 2. That it is either mediate and ordinary as where God makes use of means and second causes and therein does observe the order which he has set in nature as Hos. 2.22 and this order in nature is called the Law of nature Or else immediate and extraordinary when in the works of Providence as well as of Creation he works without means as in the preserving of Daniel in the Lyons Den. 2 dly For the matter and extent of Providence it reaches to all creatures even to the Sparrows and to the hair of the head 3 dly For the manner and this 1. Holy or most perfect or in a way suitable to the perfection of his nature 2. Wise for he does not only do all in the best way but for the highest end 3. Powerful for he brings to pass what he will have done with an almighty easiness and without any difficulty to himself A. 12. When God had created man he entred into a Covenant of life with him upon condition of perfect obedience forbidding him to eat of the tree of the knowledg of good and evil upon pain of death To. 2. Homil. xxi God as soon as he had created man gave unto him a certain Precept and Law which he being yet in the state of innocency and remaining in Paradise should observe as a pledg and token of his due and bounden obedience with denunciation of death if he did transgress and break the said Law and Commandment In the which obedience if man had continued still there had been no poverty no diseases no sickness no death c. Expl. 12. The wise and gracious Creator having made man a reasonable creature and having also stampt his own image upon him and thereby rendered him fit for and capable of happiness in the enjoyment of himself and there being no other way to this enjoyment but by union and communion with himself he was most graciously pleased in order thereunto to make a Covenant with man giving a Law to him as soon as he had made him and in him with all his posterity wherein he promised life to him and in him to all mankind upon condition of perfect and personal obedience And that God might try him how he would carry it being now brought within the bounds of this Covenant he was pleased to lay this particular positive Precept upon him That he should not eat of the tree of knowledg of good and evil c. upon pain of death which Precept he
having broken became liable unto death or to the curse of the Law This Covenant which God entered into with the first Adam was in Paradise a Covenant or Law of Works Do this and live But that Covenant which God hath establisht in Christ the second Adam with all Believers since the Fall whether in the Old or New Testament 't is a Covenant of Grace and the grand Condition of this Covenant on mans part or the qualification whereby he is fitted and capacitated to receive the benefit of this Covenant 't is the righteousness of Faith for it runs thus Believe and live not that the Covenant of Grace whether in the Old or New Testament does not require new obedience but that it does not require this in order to justification for this new obedience or this obedience of Faith it is rather the fruit or effect than the instrumental cause means or condition of justification But more distinctly amongst those many differences which are wont to be assigned by Divines betwixt the Covenant of Works and the Covenant of Grace we may take notice of these 1. The Covenant of Works was made with man before the Fall before he had sinned against God the Covenant of Grace afterward 2. The Covenant of Works did not promise pardon upon repentance the Covenant of Grace does because Christ the Mediator of this Covenant has purchased pardon for all penitent sinners who have but a hand of Faith to receive it 3. The Covenant of Works was without a Mediator for till man had sinned he needed none to mediate peace betwixt God and him but the Covenant of Grace is established in the hands of a Mediator sc. Christ Jesus perfect God and perfect man that he might make a reconciliation betwixt God and Man 4. In the Covenant of Nature or Works Adam was only the Son of God by Creation but in the Covenant of Grace those who were children of wrath do through Faith become the Children of God by Grace and Adoption 5. The Covenant of Works had for its Seals of confirmation or for the Sacraments of it the Tree of life so called because it did sacramentally confirm the promise of life upon condition of perfect obedience and the Tree of knowledg of good and evil which was so called from the event because man having sinned in eating the forbidden fruit he presently came to know by a sad experiment what an infinite good he had lost in losing Gods favour and what misery and mischief he had brought upon himself But now the Seals or Sacraments of the Covenant of Grace were under the Old Testament Circumcision and the Paschal Lamb and now under the New Testament Baptism and the Lords Supper 6. In the Covenant of Works there was no place at all for Gods further exercising of his patience grace and mercy but in the Covenant of Grace his mercy most is signally display'd yea and that which is a mystery as well as a miracle of Divine Wisdom here we may see mercy and justice kiss each other in the satisfaction that Christ has made And as the Covenant of Grace and the Covenant of Works do differ in the foregoing particulars so doth the Covenant of Grace under the Old Testament differ from the Covenant of Grace under the New Testament though these are not two but one Covenant in substance in clearness for till the Law or from Adam to Moses the Promise of Grace was more obscure under Moses more clear from Moses to the Prophets yet more clear from them to Iohn the Baptist yet more clear and from him to Christ yet more clear and under the preaching of Christ whilst he was fulfilling the Promises yet abundantly more clear than under Iohn but most clear of all when Christ had finished the work of Redemption by price and was ascended into Heaven and had sent down his Spirit upon his Apostles in that plentiful effusion of the Spirit at the time of Pentecost Act. 2. A. 13. Our first Parents being left to the freedom of their own will fell from the state wherein they were created by sinning against God To. 2. Hom. xiij Par. 2. When our great Grandfather Adam had broken Gods Commandment in eating the Apple forbidden him in Paradise at the motion and suggestion of his wife he purchased thereby not only to himself but also to his posterity for ever the just wrath and indignation of God who according to his former Sentence pronounced at the giving of the Commandment condemned both him and all his to everlasting death both of body and soul. Expl. 13. Here for explanation sake we may observe 1. That our first Parents were created with freedom of will i. e. if they would have continued in their obedience they might for they had a power to obey God perfectly and if they would sin they might God left them and that very justly to themselves he being not bound to hinder them though he could from sinning against him 2. That by their sinning against God they lost this freedom and with it all that happiness which did belong to a state of innocence and integrity for by their fall they were so bruised in all their powers and faculties that they became unable to serve God and so bemired with the guilt and pollution of sin that they were altogether unfit to enjoy God A. 14. Sin is any want of conformity unto or transgression of the Law of God Expl. 14. This description of sin doth agree to sins of all sorts original or actual and these whether in thought word or deed whether of omission or commission of ignorance or of knowledg of infirmity or presumption and to sins of all degrees and sizes whether great or small for in all sin whatsoever whether it be of men or Devils there is a want of conformity to the Law of God and a violation of his just will as well as a repugnancy to the holiness of his nature Neither is it improper to place the nature of sin in a privation or want of conformity for it is that which doth deprive and rob the rational creature of the rectitude or moral perfection of his own nature which doth consist in his being like to God and in being conformable to his will A. 15. The sin whereby our first Parents fell from the estate wherein they were created was their eating the forbidden fruit Homil. xij This first man Adam who having but one Commandment at Gods hand namely that he should not eat of the fruit of knowledg of good and evil did notwithstanding most unmindfully or rather most wilfully break it in forgetting the strait charge of his Maker and giving ear to the crafty suggestion of that wicked Serpent the Devil Expl. 15. In this A. there are two things remarkable 1. That our Parents by sinning lost that state of perfection which they had in Paradise and Christ only excepted whatever some Quakers dream there was never any
applying of the Redemption purchased by Christ to all those whom he has redeemed by his blood Not that the Spirit may be said to believe in the elect but that he doth work that faith in them whereby they as Members are united to Christ their Head and so do mystically and spiritually but really become one with him for they that are thus joined to the Lord are one spirit and so being one with Christ what was done for them by Christ as their Mediator Head and Husband is accounted as done by themselves he having pay'd their debt as their Surety they receive their discharge and shall never come into condemnation or be cast into Prison after they are once thus one with Christ and effectually called by the Spirit A. 31. Effectual Calling is the work of Gods Spirit whereby convincing us of our sin and misery enlightning our minds in the knowledg of Christ and renewing our wills he doth perswade and enable us to embrace Jesus Christ freely offered to us in the Gospel Artic. X. The condition of man after the fall of Adam is such that he cannot turn and prepare himself by his own natural strength and good works to faith and calling upon God Wherefore we have no power to do good works pleasant and acceptable to God without the grace of God by Christ preventing us that we may have a good will and working with us when we have that good will Hom. II. Of Alms p. 2. The good deeds of man are not the cause of making him good but he is first made good by the Spirit and grace of God that effectually worketh in him and afterward he bringeth forth good fruit God of his mercy and special favour towards them whom he hath appointed to everlasting salvation hath so offer'd his grace especially and they have so received it fruitfully that though by reason of their sinful living outwardly they seemed before to have been the children of wrath and perdition yet now the Spirit of God mightily working in them unto obedience to Gods will and commandments they declare by their outward deeds and life in the shewing of mercy and charity which cannot come but of the Spirit of God and his especial grace that they are the undoubted children of God appointed to everlasting life Expl. 31. That we may the better know what effectual Calling is we are to consider of a double Call which doth many times prove ineffectual as 1. Outward in the preaching of the Word and the voice of the Rod or any Providence whatsoever which doth call men to repentance faith and holiness but notwithstanding all these outward Calls there are Millions in the world who turn the deaf ear to God and will not return to him by repentance nor come to Christ by faith 2 dly There is an inward Call which is no less ineffectual than the former and it is the Spirits Call as when he proceeds no further than that which Divines call a common work as 1. Common illumination or some kind of floating knowledg in the head concerning the word of God and spiritual matters and no doubt but many men who have wicked hearts and lead bad lives may be well stored with gifts of this kind as Iudas for one 2. Some kind of flashy affections excited and stir'd up in the Soul towards good things called foretasts of the powers of the world to come and such was in Herod and Balaam 3. Some kind of faint languishing inclinations in the will to obedience such as Herod had when he did many things 4. Some kind of sense of sin both in its guilt and horrour such as Iudas had and yet notwithstanding all this inward work of the Spirit his Call may be ineffectual And if all this may be without success then no wonder if the Arminians Call that of moral suasion or of arguments do prove no better But then 2 dly There is another inward Call of the Spirit which is effectual to the Elect sc. that whereby the Spirit doth not only call but enable them to come at his call as when he doth renew the mind and change the will sanctifie the heart purifie the conscience and affections and doth work a lively faith in such persons and repentance from dead works A. 32. They that are Effectually called do in this life partake of Justistification Adoption Sanctification and the several benefits which in this life do either accompany or flow from them Artic. xvij They through grace obey the Calling they be justified freely they be made Sons of God by Adoption they be made like the image of his only begotten Son Jesus Christ they walk religiously in good works and at length by Gods mercy they attain to everlasting felicity Expl. 32. Into the nature of these particular Benefits of Effectual Calling there will be occasion to enquire hereafter but as to the certainty of the thing that all that are effectually called shall partake of these is evident from these grounds 1. In that Christ did purchase these benefits not for himself but for them nay he had never laid down such a price in his Fathers hands but for the sake of Believers 2. The tenour of the Covenant of Grace doth ascertain this for when God the Father and Son did treat together concerning the redemption of the Elect it was upon these terms sc. That upon the Sons undertaking to satisfie both the Law and Justice of God and upon the full performance of this undertaking all those that do believe in Christ though by nature they had been children of wrath as well as others should upon their believing be justified adopted sanctified and saved 3. Upon their believing they do receive Christ and he gives himself freely to them and how shall they not with him have all things else they stand in need of A. 33. Justification is an Act of Gods free-grace wherein he pardoneth all our sins and accepteth us as righteous in his fight only for the righteousness of Christ imputed to us and received by faith alone Artic. II. We are accounted righteous before God only for the merit of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ by faith and not for our own works or deservings To. I. Hom. III. Because all men be sinners and offen-ders and breakers of his Law and Commandments therefore can no man by his own acts works and deeds seem they never so good be justified and made righteous before God but every one is constrained to see for another righteousness and this which we so receive of Gods mercy and Christs merits embraced by faith is taken accepted and allow'd of God for our perfect and full justification Part 3. Our works do not merit or deserve remission of our sins and make us of unjust just before God but God of his own mercy through the only merits and deservings of his Son Jesus Christ doth justifie us Nevertheless because Faith