sum this is no discharge of it And yet a release of the promise is a discharge of it And if A promise to me that if Hil. 16 Jac. B. R. Briscoe versus Heires I S doe not pay to me an hundred pound 1 Octobris that hee doth owe me that A will pay me the hundred pound 1º Novembris and I 10º Septembris release to him this debt or all actions demands in this case this release is not good to discharge this promise But by a release of the promise the same is discharged If a man release to another all actions and doe not say further Of actions Bro. Release 29. which he hath against him this is as good a release as if these words were inserted Quod necessario subintelligitur non deest And all these releases must be made by apt words and such as Co. 9. 53. law shall judge sufficient for that purpose And in all these cases care must be had there be no mistake Bro. Release 56. 58. for mistakes will make releases and confirmations void as well as other grants And therefore if A make a release to B in this manner Noveritis c. me A de B remisisse c. B omnes actiones quas idem B habet versus A whereas it should be quas idem A habet versus B this release is void If there be Lord and tenant and the Lord purchase the tenancy 8. What shall be said a Release in law Or not And how Co. super Lit. 264. by this means the services are released and extinct in law And if the Lord disseise his tenant and make a feoffment in fee by deed or without deed this is a release in law of the seigniory Of a seigniory Of a right to land If a disseisee disseise the heir of the disseisor and make a feoffment Co. idem with or without a deed this is a release in fee in law of the right And if he make a lease for life this is a release in law of the right so long as the lease doth last If a creditor as an obligee or the like make a debtor as the Of a right of action Co. super Lit. 264. 8 E. 4. 3. 21 E. 4. 2. obligor c. his executor by this means the action is released by act of law and yet the duty remains still for the executor may Executor retain so much of the goods of the testator And if the creditor be a woman and she mary with the debtor by this the debt is released in law And if there be two obligees or debtees and one of them being a woman is maried to the obligor this is a release in law of the debt albeit the creditor be an infant But if there be a woman executrix to the debtee and she take M. 30 31 El. B. R. Adjudge Co. 8. 136. the debtor to husband this is no release in law And if an obligor be made administrator of the goods and chattels of the obligee this is no release in law Where divers join in any suit or action to recover any personall Co. 6. 25. 5. 22. Bro. Release 84. 94. stat 23 H. 8. ch 3. 9. The force and virtue of it And how it shall enure and be construed and taken thing of which they are to have the joint benefit or interest when the law doth not compell them to join there the release of one of them shall bar all the rest And therefore if two men join in an action of debt trespassel or the like and one of them alone 1. In respect of the persōs And where a release made by one shall binde another And where not And where a release made to one shall enure to others Or not doth release to the defendant this is a barre to the other plaintiffs also So if a statute or an obligation be made to two or more and one of them release it to the conusor or obligor this is a discharge of the whole duty and a bar to the rest so that they can make no use of the statute or obligation But if divers be charged in any action and they for the discharge of themselves only join in a suit or action where also they can doe no otherwise being compelled by law to join in this case the release of one of them shall not hurt the others And therefore if divers join in a writ of Error Attaint or Audita querela and one of them release to the defendant in the writ this will not bar the rest of their remedy but they may goe on in their suit notwithstanding If there be two or more executors and one of them alone release 1◠H. 7. 4. Executors a debt or duty to the testator before judgement had in a suit had by all the executors against the debtor this will bar all the rest But otherwise it seems it is after judgement had If a writ of ward be brought by two and one of them release Co. super Lit. 205. this shall not bar his companion but shall enure to his benefit for hereby he shall have the whole ward A release made to the tenant in tail or for life of the right Lit. Sect. 452. 470. Co. super Lit. 275. 290. 267 268. Co. 8. 351. to the land shall avail and enure to him that hath a reversion or remainder in deed And so è converso A release made to him that hath a remainder or reversion will avail and enure to the benefit of him that hath the estate tail for life or years precedent As if a disseisor make a lease for life and the disseisee release to the tenant for life this shall enure to the disseisor So if he or a tenant for life make a lease for life the remainder for life the remainder in tail the remainder in fee and the disseisee or first lessor doth release all his right to any one of them in remainder this shall enure unto and benefit all the rest And if the husband make a lease of his wives land to one for life the remainder to another in fee and the wife after his death doth release all her right in the land to him in remainder this shall enure to the lessee for life If a disseisor make a lease for life and the disseisee release all Co. super Lit. 275. his right to the tenant for life this shall enure to the benefit of the disseisor But if the disseisee release no more to the tenant for life but all actions this release will not benefit him in remainder or reversion after the death of the tenant for life If a disseisor make a feoffment to two in fee and the disseisee Lit. Sect. 472. release to one of the feoffees this shall enure to both If tenant in tail be disseised by two and he release to one of Co. super
doe any thing against them By this release also of all actions a debt due to be paid upon a statute or an obligation at a day to come albeit the release be before the day is discharged and by this also the statute it self if it be at any time before execution is discharged And if one be to pay forty pound at four days and some of the days are past and some to come and the debtee make such a release by this the whole debt is discharged Also in a Scire facias upon a Fine or a Judgement this release is a good plea in bar But this release of all actions will not discharge Executions or bar a man of taking out of Executions except it be where it must bee done by Scire facias Neither will it discharge or bar a man of suits by Audita Querela or writ of Error to reverse an erroneous judgement neither will it discharge covenants before they be broken nor will it discharge any thing for which the relessor had no cause of action at the time of the release made as if a woman have title of dower and doe release all actions to him that hath the reversion of the land after an estate for life or a man is by an award to pay me ten pound at a day to come and before the time I make such a release or I make a lease rendring rent or an annuity is granted to me and before the rent-day I make the lessee or the grantor such a release in these cases and by a release in these words without more the dower debt rent or annuity is not discharged And if a man have two remedies or means to come by land Lit. sect 496 497. as action and entry or by goods as action and seisure or the like in this case by a release of all actions he doth not barre himself of the other remedy Et sic è converso And if a man doth covenant to build an house or make an estate and before the covenant broken the covenantee doth release unto him all actions by this the covenant it self is not discharged And yet after the covenant is broken this release will Co. super Lit. 292. discharge the action of covenant given upon that breach By a release of all a mans right into any lands or tenements Of all right Co. 8. 151. Plow 484. 6 H. 7. 8. Co. 3. 29. 6. 1. super Lit. 345. without more words is released and discharged all manner of rights of action and entry the relessor hath to in or against the land for there is jus recuperandi prosequendi intrandi habendi retinendi percipiendi possidendi and all these rights whether they accrue by fine feoffment descent or otherwise are extinct and discharged so that if the relessee have gotten into the land of the relessor by wrong by this release the wrong is discharged and the relessee is in the land by good title Also by this release are discharged and released all titles of dower and titles of entry upon a condition or alienation in mortmain And if a woman have title of dower after an estate for life and make such a release to him in reversion this doth barre her By such a release also from the Lord to the tenant the services are extinct But this release will not bar a man of a possibility of a right Co. 10. 47. super Lit. 289. that he hath at the time of the release or of a right that shall descend to him afterwards And therefore if the conusee of a statute before Execution release all his right into the land to the terretenant or the heir of the disseisee in the life-time of his father doe release to to the disseisor all his right these releases doe not bar them Nor will this release bar a man of an Audita Querela and such like things And yet if the tenant in a reall action after the demandant hath recovered the land release to him all his right in the land this doth bar him of a writ of Errour for any errour in the proceeding in that suit And if there be Lord and tenant by fealty and rent and the Co. super Lit. 150. Dier 157. Lord by his deed reciting the tenure doth release all his right in the land saving his said rent by this release the right of the seigniory save only of the seigniory of the rent and fealty is extinct And if the Lord release to his tenant all his right to the land and seigniory salvo sibi dominio suo c. hereby the services only not the tenure is extinct And if one have a rent-charge out of my land and make such Perk. Sect. 644. a release of all his right to the land to me that am the terretenant without exception of the rent hereby the rent is extinct and gone for ever By a release of all a mans title into lands or tenements without Kelw. 484. 6 7 8. Co. super Lit. 265. 345. more words is released and discharged as much as is released Of all title by the release of all a mans right and both these releases have the like operation for howsoever title strictly and properly is where a man hath lawfull cause of entry into lands whereof another is seised for which he can have no action yet it is commonly taken more largely and doth include a right also And Titulus est justa causa possidendi quod nostrum est By a release of all entries or rights of entry a man hath into Co. 8. 15â—â— Or entry or right of entry lands without more words a man is barred of all right or power of entry into those lands upon any right whatsoever And if a man have no other means to come by the land but by an entry and he hath released that by these words he is barred for ever But if one have a double remedy viz. a right of entry and an action to recover his right by and then release all entries by this he is not barred of his action By a release of all actions reall without more words are discharged Of actions reall Lit. sect 492 493. 495. Co. 8. 151. Lit. sect 115. 500. Co. super Lit. 288 289. all reall and mixt actions then depending and all causes of reall and mixt actions not depending And therefore all causes of suing of assises writs of Entry Quare Impedit actions of wast and the like which the party hath at the time of the release made are hereby discharged But this release will not bar him that doth make it of any causes of action that shall arise and accrue afterwards Neither will it bar him of an appeal of death or robbery writ of Error or any such like thing Nor of any thing which a release of all actions will not bar And yet when land is to be restored or recovered by judgement in a writ of Error this
release is a bar to the writ of Error So if a judgment be given upon a false verdict in a reall action a release of all actions reall is a bar in an attaint By a release of all actions personall without more words are Of actions personall Bro. Release 47. Co. super Lit. 285. 9 H. 6. 57. Lit. Sect. 502. discharged all personall actions then depending and all causes of personall actions wherein a personall thing only is to be recovered and therefore hereby are discharged all causes of suing out of actions of debt trespasse detinue or the like Also all mixt actions as actions of wast Quare Impedit an assise of novel disseisin writ of annuity appeal of maihme and the like And if debt c. or damages be recovered in a personall action Co. super Lit. 289. by false verdict and the defendant bringeth awrit of attaint or if a writ of Audita Querela be brought by the defendant in the former action to discharge him of execution by this release the defendant in both cases is barred of his suit Also when by a writ of Error the plaintiffe shall recover or Co. super Lit. 288. Lit. Sect. 503. be restored to any personall thing only as debt damage or the like as if the plaintiffe in a personall action recover any debt c. or damages and be outlawed after judgement in this case in a writ of Error brought by the defendant upon the principall judgement this release will bar him But where by a writ of Error the plaintiffe shall not be restored to any personall or reall thing this release is no bar as if a man be outlawed in an action personall by processe upon the originall and bring a writ of Error and then release this is no barre to him If a man by wrong take or find my goods or they be delivered Lit. Sect. 497 498. 500. to him and I release to him all actions personall notwithstanding this release I may in this case take my goods again albeit I be barred of my action by this release Neither is this release a bar in an appeal of robbery or death Neither will it bar in any case where a release of all actions will not bar Neither is it any bar to an action of debt brought for an Co. super Lit. 292. 285 annuity granted for a term of years for any arrearages that shall grow due after the release Nor for any rent of sum of nomine pene when the release is before the same day or nomine pene happen Neither is it a bar in such reall actions wherein damages are recoverable only by the statute and not by the common law as in a writ of dower entry sur disseisin in le per Mordancester Aile c. By a release of all debts without more words are discharged Of debts Co. super Lit. 76. 291. Fitz. Audita Querela 3. and released all debts then owing from the relessee to the relessor upon especialties or otherwise all debts due also upon statutes And therefore if the conusor himself or his land be in execution for the debt and he hath such a release he must be discharged and so he cannot be upon a release of all actions By a release of all duties without more words is a relessor Of duties Co. 8. 153. super Lit. 291. barred and the relessee discharged of all actions judgements and executions also of all obligations And if the body of a man be in execution and the plaintiffe make him such a release hereby he shall be discharged of execution because the duty it selfe is discharged And if there be rent or services behind to the Lord from his tenant and the Lord make such a release to his tenant by this it seems the arrearages are released This word is of somewhat a more large extent then actions Co. 8. 154. 157. 5. 70. super Lit. 291. Of Suits for by a release of all suits without more words is released and discharged as much as by a release of all actions And hereby also are discharged al executions in the case of a subject But in the case of Prerogative the King it doth not release executions And this doth not release a covenant before it be broken By a release of all quarrels without more words all actions Co. super Lit. 292. 8. 157. 5. 70. Of Debates quarrells controversies reall and personall and all causes of such actions are released and discharged So likewise by the release of all controversies or by the release of all debates But this will not bar the relessor of any causes of suit that shall arise after and was not at the time of the release as the breach of a covenant which shal be after albeit the covenant be before is not discharged hereby By a release of all covenants without more words all covenants Of Covenants Co. 1. 112. 10. 51. super Lit. 292. then broken and all that shall be after broken that were then made and in being are discharged Qui destruit medium destruit finem And therefore if a lessee doe covenant to leave a house leased Adjudge Hil 4 Jac. B. R. Hancocks case to him at the end of the terme as it was at the beginning of the terme and the lessor before the end of the terme release to the lessee all covenants this doth discharge the covenant But this release doth discharge nothing else but covenants By a release of all Statutes from the conusee to the terre-tenant Of Statutes Co. 10. 47. without more words the Statute is discharged And yet if he release all his right in the land of the conusor this will not discharge the land of execution By a release of all errors and writs of error all errors and Co. 2. 16 Lit. Sect. 503. Of Errors writs of error and that before they be brought are extinct and discharged And if a man be outlawed in a personall action by processe upon originall and make such a release this will barre him By a release of all warranties or covenants reall all warranties Lit. Sect. 148. Of Warranties then made and being are for ever discharged By a release of all legacies without more words a man doth Co. 10. 51. Dier 56. Co. super Lit. 76. Of Legacies barre himselfe of all the legacies given him in presenti or futuro so that if he be to have a legacy at 24. yeares old and at 21. yeares of age he release to the executor al legacies or this legacy in particular this is a barre to him of this legacy for ever And yet a release of all demands in this case is no discharge of this legacy By a release of rent the rent is extinct and discharged whether Co. super Lit. 292. Of Rent the day of paiment be come or not But a release of all actions will not
same Court A recovery being matter of Record is much of the nature of a Co. 5. 41. 10. 37. 39. 3. 5. 6. 41 42. Doct. et Stud. 41. 49 50. stat 13 Eliz. cap. 5. 23. cap. 3. 7 11. 8. cap. 4. 4. The use nature and operation of it fine and such a thing as whereof the law taketh notice for it is now become a formall and orderly manner of Assurance of lands and one of the Common Assurances of the Kingdome or a common way and meanes to passe land from one to another And therefore if a tenant for life suffer such a recovery of his land it is a forfeiture of his estate an use may be averred upon it as well as upon Forfeiture Averment Covin a fine and it may be avoyded for covin as well as any other kind of conveyance But it is of speciall use and hath a speciall virtue to barre and binde estates in taile and all the remainders and reversions thereupon And because many of the Inheritances of the kingdome doe depend upon this Assurance and it is oft times the greatest security purchasors have for their money therefore it hath much favour from the law at this day And therefore the law will not endure it shall be disputed against for Communis error facit jus And hence it is that it shall not be avoyded for small errors for it is another rule of law Consensus tollit errorem And if a recovery be suffered by a tenant in taile hereby he hath not only discontinued barred and destroyed the estate taile and so defeated himselfe and his issues the former owner of the land and all the remainders and reversions thereupon that should take place after the estate taile whether they be in esse or contingent only but also all former estates leases and charges made by him in remainder or reversion Co. 1. 62. 25. Doct Stud. 49. 44 Ed. 3. 22â— for as when the estate taile in possession is not barred by a recovery the estates in reversion or remainder are not barred for Quod non in magis propinquo non in magis romoto valebit So it is è converso where the estate taile in possession is barred by the recovery all the remainders and the reversions Conditions charges incumbrances and estates dependent upon it are barred also except it be in some speciall cases where the remainder or reversion is in the King And therefore if A be tenant in taile the remainder to B in taile the remainder to C in fee and B or C doth make a lease for years of the land or grant a rent charge out of the land or enter into a Statute or the like or grant the remainder or reversion upon condition and after A doth suffer a common recovery of the land and after dieth without issue in this case the recoveror shall hold the land discharged of all these estates and charges in remainder But otherwise it is if A himselfe make a lease or enter into a Statute and then suffer a common recovery of the land in this case this recovery doth not avoyd but affirme the lease or charge for whereas it was before voydable by the issue in taile or him in remainder or reversion now it is good against them all and the recoveror also shall hold it charged and subject to the lease and charge of the tenant in taile This kind of Assurance therefore is in some respects better then a fine for a fine will barre the heire in taile but not him that is in the remainder or reversion but a recovery will barre them all In every good and binding common Recovery these things are 5. What shall be said a good Common Recovery And who shall be barred and bound thereby or not West Sym. ubi supra Co. super Lit. 372. requisite 1. That there be a demandant a tenant and a vouchee as the efficient causes thereof for if either of these be wanting it is not a compleat recovery And therefore if a common recovery be had against a tenant in taile without a voucher this is voyd And for this it is to be knowne that such persons and by such names may be demandants tenants and vouchees in recoveries as may be cognisors and cognisees in fines a Benets case Hobarts Rep. 275. Pasc Pasc 9 Jac. Earle of Newports case adjudged And therefore a recovery suffered by an Infant appearing by his Guardian is good and will Infant Woman covert bind him and all others b Co. 10. 43. Plow 515. 2 Doct. stud 52. Co. 5. 40 41. West ubi supra So also a recovery had against a woman that hath a husband being joyned with her husband will bind her and all others 2. That there be land demanded as the matter and that the thing be demandable And for this it is to be known that of such things and by such names as a writ of Covenant for the levying of a fine may be had a writ of entry for the suffering of a recovery may be had save only it may not be de fossato stagno piscaria un ' Carucat ' terre estoveriis homag fidelitat ' de servitiis â—aciendis de bovata marisci de selion ' terre de gardino cottagio crofto virgata terre fodina minerae mercatu nec de superiori camera And yet of some of these also it may be by other names Also a recovery may be had of a rent common advouson franchises and the like but not of an annuity 3. That it be had and Co. 3. 3. stat 23 Eliz. cap. 3. suffered in that order and forme as law requireth viz. that there be a writ of entry brought an appearance of the tenant in fait a voucher and an appearance of the tenant in Law the vouchee Judgement and Execution in manner as aforesaid for if there be any substantiall defect in these things the recovery may be thereby avoided by writ of error but if it be only in forme it will not hurt 4 That there be a lawfull tenant to the Precipe i. that the writ Dier 252. Co. super Lit. 46. 3. 6. of entry be brought against one that at the time of the writ brought is tenant of the â—reehold either by right i. that hath an estate for life at least in the land or by wrong i. that is a disseifor of the land demanded and whereof the recovery is had And therefore Co. 3. 6. super Lit. 46. Lit. Bro. Sect. 519. Plow 514 Doct. Stud. 49. See infra in this case the course is where the land to be recovered is in possession and a fine and a recovery is had of it together the fine is sued out first for this doth make the Conusee tenant of the free-hold of the land and then the recovery is had against him And when the recovery is to be had of a reversion and that there is an estate for life in being
judgment is given by the Court that the demandant or recoverer shall recover the land demanded against the tenant and that the tenant shall recover so much land of I. S. of his own land in recompence for the land recovered from him which he ought to have warranted and defended but suffered to be lost And this recovery over is called Recovery in value or pro Rata Quid. F. N. B. 1 34 Co 9. 6. a recovery in value or pro Rata But if the recovery be with a double voucher or a treble voucher I. S. is upon his appearance to call or vouch to warrant I. D. and to alleage in the same manner as the tenant doth and so pray that I. D. may come in and thereupon I. D. doth appeare and make default And so if there be more vouchers and then there must be severall recoveries over in value against every one of them but he that is the last vouchee is alwaies the common voucher who is one of the â—ryers of the Court of Common Pleas a man not worth any thing and one that hath no land to render in value upon the supposed warranty And by his devisei grounded upon the strict Principles of law the first tenant doth wllingly let goe the land for the assurance of the Purchasor and yet in truth hath no recompence over because the vouchee hath no land to â—ender in value And by this meanes if one have â—n estate taile in lands which he is desirous to sell or to convert into an estate in fee simple the same is commonly done for the tenant in taile doth cause the purchasor or some friend of his to bring a writ of entry against him for this land and he appeareth to the writ and in pleading â—aith that the land came to him or his Ancestors from such a man or his ancestors who in the conveyance bound themselves to warrant it And thereupon that man is called in who doth appeare and make default and thereupon Judgement is had against him in manner as aforesaid Or if he would have the recovery with a double voucher then doth he by fine feoffement or deed of bargaine and sale inrolled discontinue the land and then cause the recoveror that is to have the land to bring his writ of entry against the discontinuee and he doth vouch the tenant in taile who doth vouch over the common vouchee and so it is done and by this the estate taile that the tenant in taile hath or had is barred and bound for that it appeareth now he had no power to entaile the land whereunto he had no just title and besides â—â—e shall recover a recompence over in value and this is adjudged in law to goe in succession of estate as the land should have done which is the reason why the recovery is a barre to all that are in remainder and reversion aswell as to the issues in taile And in the suffering of these recoveries the tenants and vouchees Experientia doe appeare most commonly in person in Court and so the recovery is finished in the court presently without more doing but sometimes they will not or cannot appeare in person and then they doe use to appear and suffer the recovery by Atturney And in that case there must be a Conusance for a warrant of Atturney Warrant of Atturney taken to authorize the Atturney or Atturneys in this manner if it be for a treble voucher Glouc'ss Prec ' A S B uxori ejus quod juste c. redd ' C D Manerium West Sym. ubi supra de N cum pertinen ' c. que clam ' esse jus â—t hered suam in que iidem A B non habent ingress nisi post disseisinam quam H H injuste fine Judicio fecit prefat ' C infra 30. Annos jam ultim ' â—lapsos c. ut dic ' c. Glouc'ss A S B po lo suo W W R R Aâ—tornat sâ—â—os conjunctiâ— divisim versus C D de placito terre Glouc'ss M M gen quem A S B vocant ad warrant po lo. suo I I L L Attornat ' suos conjunctim divisim versus C D de placito terre Glouc'ss G W gen quem M M voc inde ad warrant ' po lo. suo R G R S Attornat ' suos conjunctim divisim versus C D de placito terre And in these cases to make two atturneys at the least and to Co. 10. 43. Co. 1. 94. give them an authority joyntly and severally that if one of them dye before the recovery be suffered the other may have power to doe and dispatch it And these warrants of Atturney for the suffering of recoveries are to be knowledged and certified in the same manner as the conusances of fines knowledged in the Country are save only that Recognisances for warrants or atturney for recoveries may be taken by any Judge of the Court of Common Pleas or any Serjeant at law without a Dedimus Potestatem But if any others take it they use to doe it by a speciall Dedimus Potestatem Dedimus Potestatem which is to command the Commissioners therein named to come to such persons and to take the names of their atturney or atturneys in the suit and to certifie the same into the Chancery under their Seales such a day And if there be any woman covert that is to make the conusance it seemes shee is to be examined as in the Examination case of the conusance of a fine And when this is done the recoveries may be suffered by the atturneys without the personall appearance of the parties And this is as good a recovery as the other which is suffered by the persons themselves appearing in Court but that it will require longer time for the perfection of it for in this case there must goe forth a Summoneas ad warran ' which must have nine Returnes ere the recovery can be perfected and by that time one of the parties may be dead And when the recovery is thus suffered by the parties in person or by their atturneys the same is to be entred by some one of the Clarks of the Court of Common Pleas upon the Rolles of the same Court there to remaine upon Record And herein there must goe forth a writ of Execution called an Habere facias seisinam which is sent to the Sheriffe of the Habere facias seisinam County where the land doth lye to put the Recoveror in possession of the land except the recovery be of a reversion of land after a lease for years of it in which case the reversion shall be in the recoverors by a claime without any writ And this writ the Sheriffe doth returne as executed according to the contents thereof albeit in truth he never doe any thing upon it And after this all the same proceeding is to be Exemplified by the Clarke of the
therefore if there bee tenant in taile the remainder in taile or in fee and he in the remainder perceiving the tenant in taile doth intend to sell the land and barre him by a common recovery doth sell his remainder by deed inrolled to the King and after the tenant in taile doth sell the land by common recovery for good consideration in this case the purchasor shall avoid this deed to the King whereby also appeareth that a fraudulent conveyance within this statute may be by way of bargaine and sale And so was it ruled by the Lord Chiefe Justice Hide in evidence to a Jury at Guildhall 3. Car. And if there be a lease for years and the lessor make a fraudulent conveyance in fee M. 4. Jaâ— Cowell Bart. case and then for good consideration maketh another lease to begin at the end of the former lease this conveyance shall be void as to the second lessee And if A make a lease to B for years upon good considerations Per. 2 Iust Hil. 18 Jac. B. R. and after he makes another lease to C of the same thing for the same term to begin at the same time upon good valuable consideration and B doth not discover this but drives this bargaine with C and is witnesse to this second lease and the first lease is not excepted in the second lease it seems in this case the first lease shall be void as to C. And in all these and such like cases albeit the purchasor before he make his bargaine have notice of the fraudulent Co. 5. 60. Co. 3. 83. conveyance yet shall he avoid it as if he were ignorant of it But such conveyances and deeds made as before shall never be said to be fraudulent and void as against him that shall have the thing afterwards if he do not give a valuable consideration for it And therefore if one make a lease that would be fraudulent void as to such a purchasor to A and after make another lease bonâ fide to B but without any rent or fine given for it in this case the first lease shall not be said to be fraudulent as against the second lessee and therfore not void So if one covenant for the advancement of his heirs males c. to levie a fine of land by a day to the use of himself for life and after of his issue male and before the day he make a lease that is fraudulent for many years of purpose and after he doth levie a fine accordingly in this case this lease is good and shall not be said to be fraudulent and void by this Statute as against the issue in taile So if a man that is somwhat foolish and given to wast be perswaded to settle his lands upon some of his friends of purpose to maintaine himself with it and after some of his lewd companions inveigle him and get him for a small sum of mony to conveigh it to them in this case the conveyance first made shall not be said to be fraâ—dulent as against these purchasors and therefore it is good against them And if one that hath a terme for 60. years if he live so long make it away Co. super Lit. 3. and then hee doth forge a lease for 90. yeares absolutely and after by indenture reciting this forged lease for valuable and good consideration doth bargaine and sell this forged lease and all his interest in the land to I S in this case it seems that the first lease is not void and that the purchasor shall have nothing but the forged lease A deed also made of any thing with intent and purpose to deceive Stat. 3 H. 7. 4. 2 R. 2. ch 3. 1â— El. ch 5. Co. 3. 82. 2 To deceive creditors and others of debts and such like duties and defeate Creditors of their just debts and duties is void also as against such persons For it is provided to this purpose by other Statutes That all feoffments gifts grants alienations bargaines and conveyances of lands tenements hereditaments goods and chattells or any rent profit or commodity out of land made by fraud or collusion of trust to him that made the same or otherwise with intent to hinder and delay or put off or put by Creditors or others of their just and lawfull actions suites debts accompts damages penalties forfeitures hariots mortuaries or reliefes shall be void as against them to whom such thing shall belong and hee may recover the thing notwithstanding but all such as are made bonâ fide and upon good consideration are not to be accounted fraudulent by this Statute For the better understanding whereof these cases following are to be heeded If a man a little before his Co. 5. 60. 3. 82. Dyer 295. death make a conveyance of his land to his children or friends of his bloud with a proviso to make it void at his pleasure and he take the profits of it as his own or make a conveyance of it to friends to the intent they shall not be subject to the payment of his debts having bound himselfe and his heires by any especialty or to the intent that a warranty and assets shall not bind his sonne for other land or the like in this case this conveyance shall be void as to them that should have reliefe upon this land by the dissent and especially when the conveyance is made after suites begun and more especially when any judgment is had upon the suits against him that doth make the deed And so also is the law for goods And therefore if one be indebted to A 20l. and to B 40l Co. 3. 80. 83. Bro. Done 20. Plow 54. and be possessed of goods to the value of 20l. and A doth sue the debtor for his 20l. and hanging this suite the debtor secretly makes a generall deed of gift of all his chattels reall and personall to B in satisfaction of his debt and yet doth afterwards continue the occupation and use the goods as his own and after A getteth judgment and execution in this case the deed of gift to B shall be said to be fraudulent and therefore void as against A. So if in this case he give all his goods to B in satisfaction of his debt and before any suite begun by A with any expresse or implicite trust as to the intent that B shall be favourable to the debtor or that if the debtor provide the mony that he shall have the goods again or that he shall suffer the debtor to enjoy and use the goods and pay him as hee can in these and the like cases the deeds shall bee said to bee fraudulent and void for howsoever it bee made upon good consideration yet it is not made bonâ— fide So if one in consideration of naturall affection or for no consideration give all his goods to his child or cousin bonâ fide this shall be a void deed as to the Creditors Et sic de similibus
Co. super Lit. 391. attained of treason or felony hereby the warranty is gone and albeit he doe afterwards obtaine his Pardon yet the warranty is not revived If a feoffment with warranty be made to two or more and they Co. 6. 12. being Jointenants doe after by deed make Partition by this the warranty is determined So if two Jointenants be and one of them disseise the other and he that is disseised doth recover in an assise and hath Judgement to hold in severally hereby the warranty is determined * Adjudge Hil. 22 Jac. B. R. Eustace Sholes case So if A and B be Jointenants of white acre for life and A by fine doth grant to B totum quicquid habet in tenemeutis hereby the warranty is gone But if a Partition be made by Judgement upon a writ by force of the Statute of 13 H. 8. this doth not defeat the warranty fallen to them but it shall be divided between them and they shall all of them take advantage of it If one enfeoffe three with warranty to them and their heires Co. super Lit. 385. and one of them release to one of the other two hereby the warranty is gone for that part But if one of them release to the other two in this case the warranty is not gone but doth continue and they may vouch upon it If one enfeoffe two men and their heires and one of them doth Co. super Lit. 385. make a feoffment in fee hereby the warranty is not determined but the other may take advantage of it notwithstanding If the party that hath the warranty or the estate to which the Co. super Lit. 393. 392. Lit. Sect. 748. Release warranty is annexed release to him that is bound to warrant all warranties or all covenants reall or all demands by either of these releases the warranty is gone So also if by a defeasance made Deseasance between the parties it be agreed the warranty shall be void by this defeasance the warranty may be avoided also Or if it be so agreed that the warrantee or his heires c. shall not vouch or have a Warrantia cartae by this the warranty is avoided in part If tenant in taile doth enfeoffe his Uncle which doth enfeoffe another Co. super Lit. 391. in â—ee with warranty if in this case the feoffee release the warranty to his Uncle hereby the warranty is extinct But if a gift in taile be made with warranty in this case a release made by the tenant in taile of this warranty will not extinguish it If the parties between whom the warranty is intermary hereby Co. super Lit. 390. the warranty is suspended during the coverture in some cases If tenant in taile doth make a feoffment in fee with warranty Co. super Lit. 330. and disseiseth the discontinuee and dieth seised this doth suspend the warranty If two make a feoffment in fee and warrant the land to the Co. super Lit. 393. feoffee and his heires and the feoffee doth release the warranty to one of the feoffors this doth not determine the warranty of the other as to the moity So if one doth infeoffe two with warranty and the one of them doth release the warranty this doth not extinguish the warranty for the other moity but it doth continue still A warranty also may lose his force by taking benefit or making use thereof for after a man hath once taken advantage thereof in some cases he can make no further use of it of which read Co. super Lit. 393. And now having done with Deeds in generall and some of the parts thereof in speciall we are in order to come to some speciall kinds of deeds wherein we will first begin with a deed of Feoffment CHAP. IX Of a Feoffment FEoffamentum i. Donatio feodi strictly and properly is the gift 1. Feoffment Quid. New termes of the law Co. super Lit. 9. Lit. Sect. 57. or grant of any honors castles manors messuages lands houses or other corporall immovable things of like nature which be hereditable to another in fee simple i. to him and his heirs for ever by the delivery of seisin and possession of the things given And from hence comes the word Infeoffe for by this word and the Infeoffe words Give and Grant as the most apt words for that purpose is this kind of conveyance most commonly made Hence also it is that he that makes this feoffment is called the feoffor and he to whom it is made the feoffee Also it is sometimes but improperly Feoffor Feoffee called a feoffment when an estate of freehold only doth passe This kind of conveyance albeit it may be made in most cases by 2. Quotuplex See West Sym. 1. part Sect. 235. Co. super Lit. 6. word without any writing â—et it is most commonly done by writing and this writing is then called a Deed or Charter of feoffment but hence is the division of a feoffment by word or a feoffment by writing The ancient formes and examples of these deeds are very briefe and and yet they had these parts contained in them 1. The Premisses 2. The Habendum 3. The Tenendum 4. The Reddendum 5. The Clause of warranty 6 The In cujus rei testimonium 7. The Date 8. The clause of Hiis testibus Haec fuit candida illius aetatis â—ides simplicitas quae paâ—câ—lis lineis omnia fidei firmament a posueruut * Co. super Lit. 49. 9. Co. 1. 111 112. Plow 554. 9 H. 7. 24. 39 H. 6. 43. Co super Lit. 237. Perk. Sâ—ct 210. 24 E. 3. 70. Co. 1. 121. Co. 6. 70. Bro. scire facias 88. Plow 423 424. And this manner of conveyance as it is the most ancient kind 3. The nature and operation of it of conveyance so is it the best and most excellent of all others and in some respects doth excell the conveyance by â—ine or recovery for it is of that nature and efficacy by reason also of the livery of Seisin evermore inseparably incident to it that it cleereth all disseisins abatements intrusions and other wrongfull and defeasible titles and reduceth the estate cleerly to the feoffee when the entry of the feoffor is lawfull which neither fine recovery nor bargaine and sale by deed indented and inrolled will doe when the feoffor is out of possession And it passeth the present estate of the feoffor and not only so but barreth and excludeth him of all present and future right and possibility of right to the thing which is so conveyed insomuch that if one have divers estates all of them passe by his feoffment and if he have any interest rent common or the like into or out of the land it is extinguished and gone by the feoffment And further it barreth the feoffor of all collaterall benefits touching the land as condition power of revocation writs of error attaint and the like
57. Co. 1. 113. 174. possibilities albeit they be not grantable over to another person yet may they be released to him that hath the present estate of the land And therefore if a man possessed of a terme devise it to A for life the remainder to B and his heires males during the terme in this case albeit B may not grant his interest over yet he may release it to A. And if A devise to B twenty pound when he comes to the age of twenty foure years and die in this case B after he is of the age of twenty one years may release this legacy So a covenant to doe a future act may be released before it be broken And it seems also the conusee of a Statute or recognisance may release to a feoffee of part of the land and so barre himselfe of execution of that land And if I grant to I S that if he doe such a thing he shall have an annuity of twenty pound for his life in this case it seems I S may release this before the condition be performed And if I make a feoffment to I S to divers uses with power to revoke it I may release this power to one that hath an estate of free hold in possession reversion or remainder in the land And yet if I make a feoffment to I S with proviso that if B revoke that the uses shall cease in this case B cannot release this power And a remote possibility that is altogether incertaine cannot be released And therefore if the sonne of the disseisee release to the disseisor in the life time of his father this release is void And so if the conusee of a Statute release his right to the land of the conusor before execution this release is void And so if a plaintife release to a Baile in the Kings Bench before Judgement given this release is void So if one promise to pay me tenne pound upon the surrender Adjudge Tr. 14. Jac. B. R. of my land to him and that if he shall sell it for above fifty pound that then he shall pay me tenne pound more and I release this to him before he doe sell it and before I do surrender im this case this doth not release the second promise because it is not releasable Also debts legacies and other duties may be released and See inâ—â— discharged thereby before or after they become due And therefore a rent or annuity may be released before the day of paiment And so also may a debt due by obligation Judgements Executions Recognisances and the like by apt words be discharged by release If the charge or duty grow by record the discharge and release 5. How and after what manner these things may be released thereof must be by record also And if it grow by writing the discharge and release must be by writing also Nihil est magis rationi consentaneum quam eodem modo quodque dissolvere quo constatum est And therefore a duty growing by a verball agreement may in some cases be released by word without writing But regularly lands and tenements cannot be given nor rights and titles to lands and actions be discharged by release without a deed in writing A release that doth enure by way of mitter le estate mitter le Condition Defeasance Co. super Lit. 274 Perk. Sect. 718. Lit. 467. Co. 1. 111. 21 H. 7. 24. droit or extinguishment may be made upon condition or with a defeasance so as the condition or defeasance be contained in the release or delivered at the same time with it for no defeasance made after can avoid the force of a release made before And yet a release may be delivered as an escrow and so the force of it may be suspended for a time But a release of a condition may not be made upon a condition Nor may a release of a chattell be upon a condition subsequent but it may be upon a condition precedent * Curia B. R. Hil. 9 Car. Barkley Perkes case Dier 307. 21 H. 7. 24. Co. super Lit. 274. Lit. Sect. 467. And therefore if a man release a debt to another upon condition that the relessor may have such a debt owing from a third person to the relessee this is a good coÌ„dition A release of all actions may be made untill a time past as untill the first of May last or untill the day of the date of the release and this will discharge all actions till then and none after But a release cannot be made of a right or action for a part of an estate or for a time only as for one year or untill Michaelmas next or the like for a release of such a thing for one day or for one hour is a release of it for ever And yet a man may release his right in a part of the land And therefore if a man be disseised of two acres he may release his right in one of them and enter into the other acre Also a release in the nature of an acquitance may Adjudged Barkley Perkes case Hil. 9 Car. B. R. be of part of a debt And therefore if one be bound in an obligation of foure hundred pound to pay two hundred pound at Michaelmas and at Christmas after the obligee by his deed releaseth three hundred ninty pound parcell of the said foure hundred pound this is a good release for so much and no more * 6. What releases may be made of lands or tenements And what shal be said a good release in deed Or not And by what words it may be made 1. When it doth enure by way of enlargement or passing of an estate 1. In respect of the estate of the relessor In every good release in deed howsoever it enure these things are requisite 1. That there be a good relessor and a good relessee and a thing to be released 2. That the deed be well sealed delivered c. And if it tend and enure by way of enlargement of estate then these things are further required to make the release good 1. He that doth make the release must have such an estate in himselfe as out of which such an estate may be Dier 251. derived and granted to the relessee as is intended by the release as if he have the reversion in fee of lands he may release to a tenant for years and thereby encrease his estate to an estate for life or in taile or he may passe his whole fee simple by the release But if there be lessee for years rendring rent and the reversion is Per Justice Jones 5 Car. Dier idem granted for life the remainder over in fee and the grantee of the reversion release all his right to him in remainder and then he in the remainder grant the reversion and the tenant for life release to the grantee also in this case it seems both these releases are void and cannot
discharge a rent before the day of paiment come By a release of all promises or Assumpsits without more Of promises Adjud Hil. 16 Jac. B. R. Briscoe vers Heires Co. 10. 51. words a man may barre himselfe of a contingent or future thing that by other words could not be released as if a man promise to me that if I S doe not pay me one hundred pound the tenth of March next that he will pay it me the twentieth of that moneth and before the time I release to him all actions and demands this will not discharge the promise But if I release to him all promises this will barre mee Et sic de similibus By a release of all Judgements without more words is he Lit. Sect. 507. Co 8. 151. super Lit. 290. that maketh it barred of the effect of any Judgement he hath Of Judgements Of Executions against the relessee for if execution be not taken out he is now barred of it And if the relessee or his land c. be in execution he and it shall be discharged thereof by Audita Querela And by a release of all executions without more words a man is barred of taking or having out of any execution upon any Judgement either before Scire facias or after But if after execution be made by Capias ad Stat. Elegit or fieri facias the Audita Querela plaintife release to the defendant all executions he cannot plead such a release but he must have an Audita Querela and that he may have to discharge him of execution By a release of all appeales are discharged all appeales of Co. super Lit. 287 288. felony of death of robbery of rape of burning of larceny Of Appeales depending and all causes not yet moved also By this release of all advantages it seems actions of debt upon Of Advantages account are discharged Co. 8. 150. By a release of all conspiracies all conspiracies past are discharged Kelw 113. Of Conspiracies and such also as are only begun and shall be prosecuted and perfected after the release are likewise hereby discharged By a release of all forgeries before publication the forgery is Of Forgeries Co. 10. 48. discharged but not the publication and therefore the relessor may take his remedy for that notwithstanding A release of all demands is the best release of all and this Of Demands or Clâ—imâ—s Co. super Lit. 291. Co. 8. 54. Lit. Sect. 501 509 510. word is the most effectuall word of all and doth in deed include and comprehend within it most of all the releases before By a release therefore of all demands without more words are released all rights and titles to land warranties conditions annexed to estates before they be broken or performed and after they be broken Also by this release are released and discharged all Statutes Obligations Contracts Recognisances Covenants Rents Commons and the like Also all manner of actions reall and personall Appeales Debts duties Also all manner of Judgements Executions Also all Annuities and Arrearages of Annuities and Rents And therefore if a man have a title of entry by force of a condition c. or a right of entry into any lands by such a release the right and title is gone And if a man have a rent-service rent-charge estovers or other profit to be taken out of the land by such a release to the tenant of the land it is discharged and extinct And therefore if a termor for yeares grant the land by indenture to A rendring rent and at the end of the first yeare Adjudg B. R. pasc 17 Jac. Wottons case he release to the grantee all demands the rent is hereby extinct during all the time And a release of all claimes it seems is much of the same nature But by a release of all demands or of all claimes is not released Co. 5. 70. any such thing as whereof a release cannot be made as a meere possibility or the like Neither will this release discharge a covenant or promise that Hil. 4 Jac. B. R. Hancocks case adjudge is future and contingent before it be in being Nor a covenant before it is broken and therefore if the lessee of a house covenant to leave it as well in the end of his terme as it was in the beginning of his terme and before the end of the terme the lessor release to the lessee all demands this is no barre to an action brought for a breach of the covenant afterwards And if a man in consideration of a summe of money given to Hil. 6 Jac. B. R. Belcher Hudsons case him by a woman sole assume to her that if shee mary one M that he will pay to her after the death of M one hundred pound by the yeare if shee survive him and shee mary him and the husband release all demands and then die this is no barre to the duty So if one promise a woman that if shee will mary him that he will leave her worth one hundred pound if shee doe survive him and before the mariage shee release to him all actions and demands this doth not discharge the promise And note that all these words are of the same force when they are joined with other words as when they are alone Note If two tenants in common of land grant a rent-charge of Co. super Lit. 267. forty shillings out of it to one in fee and the grantee release to one of them this shall extinguish but twenty shillings for that the grant in judgement of law is severall If one have severall causes of action against two and make a joint release to them this shall be taken to be a release of all 19 H. 6. 4. joint and severall causes of action So if an executor have some cause of action for himselfe and Bro. Release 31. 29. some for his testator and he release all Actions indefinitly this release doth discharge both sorts of actions If the tenancy be given to the Lord and a stranger and to the heires of the stranger and the Lord release to his companion Co. super Lit. 280. all his right in the land this shall enure not only to passe his estate in the tenancy but also to extinguish his right in the Seigniory If there be Lord and tenant of two acres and the Lord release all his right in one of them to the tenant hereby the Perk. Sect. 71. Bro. Release 85. 9 E. 3. services are extinct for both So if one have a rent charge out of twenty acres and release all his right in one acre hereby all the rent is extinct And yet if A lease white acre to B for life rendring rent and afterwards doth release part of the rent this is good only for such part If I be seised of land in fee and I make a lease of it to one for life and after I
other is extinct It is a discharge in writing of a summe of money or other 10. Acquitance Quid. Termes of the law duty which ought to be paid or done As if one be bound to pay money on an obligation or rent reserved upon a lease or the like and the party to whom the money or duty should be paid or done upon the receipt thereof or upon some other agreement betweene them maketh a writing under his hand witnessing that he is paid or otherwise contented and therefore doth acquite and discharge him of the same The which is such a discharge and barre in the law that he cannot demand and recover the same againe contrary thereunto if the acquitance be shewed The obligor is not bound to pay money upon a single bond 22 E. 4. 6. 41 E. 3. 25. 1 H. 7. 15. 22 E. 4. 6. Bro debt 43. Oblig 10. 11. Where a man is not bound to pay money without he hath an acquitance unlesse the obligee will make to him an acquitance or release Nor is he bound to pay it before he hath the acquitance And in this case the obligor may compell the obligee to make him an acquitance And so also it is in case of a Statute Merchant one is not bound to pay the money thereupon before he hath the acquitance or release of the plaintife But otherwise it is in case of an obligation with a condition for there a man may averre paiment And because Statutes Recognisances and Obligations are often used and tend to the strengthening of the Common Assurances of the kingdome we may not in any wise passe them over but must take some surveigh of them And first of a Statute CAP. XX. Of a Statute A Statute is a Bond or Obligation of Record But this word is 1 Statute Quid. Terms of the Law Stat. de Mercatoribus Acton Burnell 11 Ed. 1. sometimes used in another sense viz. for a Decree made in Parliament called an Act of Parliament And of these Obligations there are three kinds 1. A Statute 2 Quâ—tuplex Statute Mechant Quid. Merchant 2. A Statute Staple 3. A Recognisance The Statute Merchant is a Bond acknowledged before one of the Clerks of the Statute Merchant and Mayor and chief Warden of the City of London or two Merchants of the said City for that purpose assigned or before the Mayor chief Warden or Master of other Cities as York Bristow or the like or the Bailisse of any Burrough or Village or other sufficient men for that purpose appointed and Authorised Sealed with the seal of the Debtor or Recognisor and of the King which is of two pieces the greater whereof is kept by the Mayor or chief Warden and the lessor by the said Clerk And the form of it is thus Novertis c. me A B teneri C D in Centum libris solvend eidem ad Festum S. Mich. proxim Et nisi fecero concedo quod currat super me haeredes meos districtio paena in Statuto domini Regis edito apud Westin Dat. c. And this albeit at first it was ordained and used for Merchants only yet at this day it is and may be used and given by any others and is become one of the common Assurances of the Kingdome The Staple doth signifie this or that Town or City whither the 27 Ed. 3. Stat. 2 cap. 1 â—â—3 c. Merchants by common order and commandement doe carry their Statute Staple Quid. commodities as Wooll and the like to utter by the great And the 27 Ed. 3. Stat cap. 9. 22 H. c. â— Coo. super Lit. 289. 15 H. 7. 16. Statute Staple is either properly or improperly so called That which is properly so called is defined to be a Bond of Record acknowledged before the Mayor of the Staple in the presence of one or two Constables of the same Staple and is sealed with the Seale of the Staple and sometimes also with the Seale of the party the which it seemes is not necessary And this is founded upon the Statute of 27 Ed. 3. cap. 9. and was invented and is used only â—or Merchants and Merchandizes of the same Staple This is of the same nature the Statute Merchant is That which is improperly so called is also called a Recognisance which is also a Bond of Record Recognisin â— Quid. testifying that the Recognisor doth owe to the Recognisee a summe of money And of these there are divers kinds for thre is one Recognisance founded upon the Statute of 23 H. 8. cap. 6. The forme whereof is this Noveritis c. me A B teneri C D in Centum libris solvend eidem ad Festum S. Mich. proxim Et si defecero in solutione debi praedict volo concedo quod tunc currat super me haeredes executores meos poena in Statuto Stapulae debit pro Marchandisis in eadem emptis recuperand ordinat provis Dat. c. And this is alwayes to be acknowledged before the chiefe Justice of the Kings Bench or of the Common Pleas in the Terme time or in their absence out of Term before the Mayor of the Staple at Westminster and the Recorder of the City of London for the time being And it is to be sealed with the Seale of the Conusor and with the Seale of the King appointed for that purpose and with the Seale of the chiefe Justice Mayor and Recorder before whom it is acknowledged and they before whom it is taken doe subscribe their names to it And this was ordained and may be and is used by Merchants or any other whomsoever for paiment of debts or assurance of other things And this also is of the same nature the Statute Merchant is And both this and the two former are much of the nature of judgements had upon Suits in the Courts of Kings Coo. 8. 153. Bench and Common Pleas and therefore they are called Pocket Pocket Iudgements judgements There are also divers other kinds of Recognisances that are See Statute 33 H. 8. c. 22 39. 3 H. 7. c. 1 10 H. 6. c. 1 Dyer 315. 307. F N B. 251. f. 132 c. 133. a. 68. a. taken by and acknowledged before the Lord Keeper Master of the Wards Master of the Rolls Master of the Chancery Justices of the one Bench or of the other some of which are called Bailes Barons of the Excheker Judges in their Circuits Baile Justices of the Peace Sheriffs and others some whereof are by the Common Law and some by certaine Statutes And amongst these some are without Seale and recorded only and some are sealed and recorded also And some of them are in a sum certaine as the Recognisances taken in the Common-Pleas for Baile are and some of them are incertaine as those Recognisances that are taken for Baile in the Kings Bench which are after this manner Si Judicium redditum c. tunc volo concodo
payment of his own debts only a Trin. 1â— Iac. Co. 〈◊〉 Woâ—se Heideâ—â— case And if in this case the Executor of the Executor take upon him the Administration of the goods of the first Testator he cannot refuse the Administration of the goods of the latter but he may take upon him the latter and refuse the former But if the Executor refuse to administer to the first Testator Dyer 372. before the Ordinary or die before the Probate of the Will and hee hath made a Testament and appointed an Executor therein in these cases it seemes the Executor of the Executor shâ—d not administer the goods of the first Testator but the Ordinary must grant the Administration thereof And 〈◊〉 all the residue of the goods of the first Testator be given by the Testament to the first Executor after the debts be paid in this case albeit he die before Probate of the Will yet his Executor shall be Executor also to the first Testator or else he shall have the Administration of his goods and chattels granted unto him And therefore if A make his Will and Adiudged in Hâ—ll 〈◊〉 Car. in Dâ—â—s case give Legacies to B and D and give all the rest of his goods and chattels after debts and Legacies paid to C his wife and make heâ— his sole Executrix and shee die before Probate of the Will or any election made not knowing of the Will and E sue out an Administration of the goods of A and pay the Legacies to B and D and F sue out an Administration of the goods of C in this case the Administrator of C and not of A shall have the goods for the Law doth judge them in C after the debts and Legacies paid without any election If an Executor after hee hath proved the Testators Will die Bâ—oo Executor 117. 〈◊〉 H. 〈◊〉 7. Coo. 1 96. Dâ—er 372. Termes of the Law tit Administration Intestate in this case the Administration of the goods of the first Testator not administred in the hands of the Executor must be granted to whom the Ordinary shall think fit And if the Ordinary please hee may grant the Administration de bonis non administratis of the first deceased and of the goods of the second deceased to one and the same person And herein the Administrator must take care that his Administration have speciall words for the granting of an Administration of the goods of the first Testator not administred * Fiz Administrator 9 for howsoever some hold that by the generall Administration the Administrator shall have not only the goods of the Executor but the goods fo his Testator also yet it seemes this is not taken to be Law at this day If there be two Executors made and one of them doth refuse Dyer 160. before the Ordinary and the other doth prove the Will and make a Will himselfe and appoint an Executor and then die in this case it seemes the Executor of the Executor that did prove the Will alone shall have the disposition of all the estate and be Executor to the first Testator and that the surviving Executor shall not meddle therewith for that his Election by the deaâ—h of his companion is gone And if one make two Executors and one of them doth Litt. Broo. Sect. 17â— Bâ—oo Executor 49. 99. â—â—tz Executor 12. 113. Dyer 187. make an Executor and die and the other that doth survive hath accepted the Executorship in this case the surviving Executor shall have the sole disposing of the estate and the Executor of the deceased Executor shall not intermeddle therewith And if therefore the surviving Executor die Intestate an Administration de bonis non Aaministratis of the first Testator shall be grantted And if the Executor of the dâ—â—eased Executor have any of the estate in his hands the surviving Executor may take or recover it from him And if two bee maâ—e Executors and one of of them is uncapable in this case he that is capable shall administer alone If one that is Administrator of another mans goods doe make Dyer 372. 112. Coo. 5. 9 his Will and make an Executor and die oâ— doe die Interâ—ace and the Administration of his goods is granted to some body in the first of these cases the Executor and in the last the Administrator unlesse he be made Administrator of these goods also shall not meddle with these goods of the first deceased but the administration of the goods of the first deceased in the hands of the Administrator not administred must be granted againe And hence it is that if the Administrator of my goods have a judgement for a debt due to me and he dye before execution and make an Executor oâ— die intestate that in this case his Executor or Administrator shall never have execution of this judgement And the same law is of the Administrator of my Executor in this case An Executor or Administrator may accept or refuse the executorship Coo. 〈◊〉 37. 37 Hâ— 6. 27. 28. 20. H. 6. 1. 24. Where an Executor â—r Administratâ—r maâ— accept or refâ—â— the Executoâ—ship 〈◊〉 Administâ—â—â—on and hoâ— And wheâ—â—â—e may bâ—â— Executor 〈◊〉 â—e hath â—â—â—ed 〈◊〉 And whaâ— a 〈◊〉 intermâ—dling with the goods of the dead shall bâ—â— said an Admâ—â—â—stration and what not or the administration at his pleasure and therefore he may at any time before he hath intermedled with the estate as Executor or Administrator refuse it and if he be sued by any as Executor or Administrator he may plead ne unques Executor i. e. he was never â—xecutor or Administrator and did never administer and if it be true he shall by this meanes avoid the suite for a man shall not be compelled to take such a charge upon him whether he will or no Iâ— therefore there bee many Executors or an admâ—nistration bee granted unto many and one of the Executors prove the Will in the name of the rest or one accept the administration in the name of all the rest yet the rest may refuse to accept it and plead in any â—uite against them that they are not Executors or Administrators But as an Executor or an Administrator after he hath once legally refused the executorship or administration can never after intermeddle therewith so after he hath once legally accepted thereof that is hath done any thing as Executor or administrator and which is proper only for an executor or administrator to doe he can never after refuse it And his acceptance of part in this case will make him chargable with all except it bee in the case before of an Executor who may accept of the last Executorship and refuse the first If the Executors being cited to come in and prove their Will appeare Coo. c. 37. Fitz. administration 6. 11. Bâ—oo Administration 32. Executors 117. Coo. 5. 28. Peâ—k Sect. 4â—5 Dyer 1â—0 21. Eâ— 23. before the Ordinary and refuse to administer and to prove the Will they
hath assets in his hands to pay all men and besides untill this be done he cannot deduct to satisfie his own debt first and barr other men by Plea But of the other side when he hath made and exhibited a true and perfect Inventary of all the goods and chattels it shall be presumed against him that he hath so much as is contained in the Inventary and no more unlesse more can be proved by Witnesses 3. The third thing whereof the Executor or Thirdly in Probate of the Will See Probate infra at Numb Administrator is to take care is to prove the will if there be any And this the Ordinary will compell him to do but otherwise he may do any thing as Executor save only sue actions as well before Probate as after 4. The fourth thing whereof the Executor or Administrator must take care is to sell and make money of the goods Fourthly in payment of Debts and Legacies and the order of payment of Debts and Legacies Coo. 9. 88. Plow 184. 545. Dyer 80. Doct. St 75. 76. 77. 78. 132. Stat. 33. H. 8. cap. 39. Coo. 5. 28. 4. 54. 59. 60. 8. 132. Dyer 232. 32 21 Ed. 4â— â—21 Bâ—oo Executors 88. 172. Coo. 8 132. Dyer 32. Plow 279. 280. Broo. Executâ—rs 103. Kelw. 74. and chattels and to receive the debts due to the deceased and then to pay the Debts and Legacies due to the Creditors and Legataries wherein the Executor or â—dministrator must be very cautious and wary And for this purpose let him observe That all the debts must be paid before any Legacies be paid or delivered and if there be not enough besides to pay the debts any thing given by way of Legacy may be sold to make money to pay the debts and the Legataries must loose their Legacies for Lâ—gatarii contendunt de lucro captando Crediteres autem de damno vitando And in payment of debts this decorum must be observed 1. Amongst persons that are Creditors the executor or administrator himselfe shall be preferred so that if any debt be due to him he may deduct to satisfie himselfe first albeit others loose their whole debt thereby and especially then when his debt is in equall degree with others debts 2. After the executor or administrator is served and satisfied his debt then the King is to be preferred so that if there be any debt due to him and he begin his Suit for it before any other man can get a Judgement for his debt against the executor or administrator his debt shall be paid before any others 3. After the King is served and satisfied his debt then the debts of common persons must be paid And these also must be paid in this order or manner 1. The debts due by Record by any judgement had against the deceased in any judiciall proceeding in any Court of Record 2. The debts due by Statutes or Recognisances ented into by the deceased for the debts due upon judgements must be satisifed before these sit judâ—cium prius velposterius 3. The debts due by Obligations and penall and single Bils for these are in equall degree and these are to bee paid after Statutes and Recognisances And yet if the Statute or Recognisance be only for performance of Covenants and no Covenant is broken an Obligation for the payment of present money shall be discharged before it 4 The debts due for rent upon Leases of Land or grants of rents but some say that debts due for rent in the Testators life time be the rent reserved upon Leases made by or without deed for years or at will are in equality of degree with debts due upon Especialties 5. The debts due for servants wages and workmen 6. The debts due upon shop-books and verball Contracts and yet it is said Addition to Iust Dodridge 92. by some That Legacies are to be paid before debts due by shop-books bills unsealed or contracts by word Quod non credo And amongst debts also that are in equality of degree those that are due are to be paid before those that are not due and those whose day of payment is already come before those whose day of payment is not yet come And yet if the Creditor whose day of payment is already come doe not sue for his debt untill his debt whose day of payment is at a day to come become due the Executor or Administrator may satisfie which of them he will first And amongst debts that are due and already to be paid those that are first sued for are to be first paid Or if the Creditors begin their Suites together the Executor or Administrator may pay which he will of them first and to pay debts in any other order is dangerous And therefore for the purpose if the deceased are two severall debts of 10l a piece to two severall Creditors by severall Obligations and the Executor or Administrator hath enough only to pay one of them he that can first get Iudgment and Execution shall first be satisfied and if the Executor or Administrator doe afterwards pay the other his debt he must satisfie the first out of his own estate If one that hath a debt due to him from the deceased upon a simple Contract or the like sue the Executor or Administrator for it and there bee debts due to others upon bonds and bills unsatisfied in this case the Executor or Administrator may not pay this debt nor may hee suffer the Plaintiffe to recover in his Action for if he doe and he have not Assets besides to satisfie the debts due upon Bills and Bonds he must satisfie so much out of his own estate as hee hath so paid or suffered to bee recovered from him for in the case of an Action brought he is to plead and to set forth these debts upon Especialties and to say that he hath no more but what is sufficient to satisfie them c. and thereby he shall barre the Plaintiffe in his Action In like manner it is if one that hath a debt due to him from the deceased upon an Obligation sue the Executor or Administrator thereupon and there be debts due to others upon Iudgements Statutes or Recognisances and the Executor or Administrator suffer the Plaintiffe to recover the debt due upon the Obligation for want of pleading the Iudgements c. or doth voluntarily pay that debt and he hath noâ— Assets besides to pay the debts due upon Iudgements c. in this case he must pay so much out of his own estate towards the satisfaction of the said debts due upon Iudgements c. as he hath paid of the debt due upon the Obligation But here it must be noted that no Iudgement or Statute that is discharged or is left and suffered to lie by agrement to barre others of their debts shall be any barre to others that sue for their due debts upon Obligations c. and Covin therefore if any Executor or Administrator shall
plead any such Iudgement c. in barre of any other debt sued for by any other Creditor the Creditor may by speciall pleading set forth this matter of Covin and avoid the plea and barre of the Executor or Administrator If one Creditor whose debt is in equall degree and presently due and to be paid begin a Suit against the Executor or Administrator for his debt and hee hath notice that the Suit is begun against him or the Action is laid in the County where the Executor or Administrator doth dwell or as some have said in London in both which cases it seemes he is bound to take notice thereof at his perill and after this Suit begun hee doth make voluntary payment of another debt in equall degree in all respects for which no Suit is begun this is a devastavit in the Executor or Administrator and if he have not Assets to satisfie him who began his Suit first he shall be compelled to satisfie so much thereof as he doth voluntarily pay to the other and that out of his own estate And yet an Executor or Administrator may make voluntary payment of any debt due by Record as by Iudgement Statute c. after such a Suit begun and justifie it If two Creditors in equall degree to all purposes begin to sue for their debts at one time in this case the Executor or Administrator cannot safely make voluntary payment to either of them unlesse he have enough to pay them both but his safest way is to pay him first that in a due and legall proceeding for he may not covinously help one of them to a Iudgement sooner can first recover it by Iudgment and Execution And yet if in this case no Suit be begun the Executor or Administrator may make voluntary payment to either of them in equall degree of his whole debt albeit he have no Assets left to pay unto the other any part of his debt If A and B be two Creditors in equall degree and A begin his Suit first and after B doth begin his Suit and it happeneth that B bonâ fide without any Covin or agreement between him and the Executor or Administrator doth get Iudgement and Execution first in thiâ— case the Executor or Administrator may make payment â—o B first of all But if the Executor or Administrator doth by any Covin and agreement help B to his Iudgement and Execution first and by this meanes he is first satisfied if there be not Covin enough left to satisfie A he must satisfie him out of his own estate If two Suits begin at or about one time upon two severall Obligations and the Executor is forced to plead to them both before either of them hath a Iudgement so that he cannot plead the Iudgement that the other hath against him and he hath not Assets to satisfie both the debts sued for and after the Plaintiffs in both the Suits get Iudgement and Execution Quaere what the Executor or administrator may doe in this case And here note by the way that it is policy for a Creditor that hath cause to sue an executor or administrator to bee doing bâ—times and to get judgement and execution assoone as he may for it falleth out in this case That he that doth first come shall bee first served After all the debts are paid in such order and manner as before then is the executor or administrator to pay and to deliver the Legacies and herein the executor may preferre himselfe so that if any Legacy be Doct. St. 34. Plow 54â— Swinb 110. 114. given to him he may detaine and deduct it albeit there be nothing left to discharge the Legacies given to others and after he hath satisfied himselfe he may satisfie and deliver what Legacies he will albeit there bee not enough to satisfie all the Legatees or he may pay to each of the Legatees a part of their Legacy and deduct a part out of every Legacy where there is not enough to satisfie all the Legacies But if any particular thing as a Lease or a horse or the like be given this must be delivered accordingly and may not be sold by the executor or administrator to pay others all or any part of their Legacies and if there be enough to pay all the Legacies they must be paid all according to the Will and it is said by some that if an executor or administrator make no Inventary of the goods that he must pay all the Legacies whether he have Assets or not The last thing an executor or administrator is to take care of Swinb Part. 6. Sect. 17. is to make an account for it is â—eld that an executor or administrator Fifthly in making an Account is not bound in Law or Conscience to make restitution for personall wrongs wherein this is to be known That the Ordinary may if he will call the executor or administrator to account concerning the goods and chattels of the deceased either generally or particularly as the case requireth and that with or without the Creditoâ—s or Legataries instigation within a year or what time he will unto which account he may call all the Crâ—ditors and Legataries and therein the executor or administrator must shew what he hath received and what he hath laid out and provâ—â—â— in such sort as the Ordinary shall like And then if it be found he hath faithfully and fully administred the Ordinary may acquit him of the burthen and then hee is discharged of all Suits in the Spirituall Court but this account and discharge will not help nor availe him at all to discharge him of Suits at the Common-Law The Office and duty of the Ordinary after the death of any Coo. 5. 83. 9. 39. Litt. Broo. Sect. 233. F. N. B. 120. Dâ—er 23. Doct. St. 132. person within his Diocesse is if he hear of any Will made and any Executor appointed to cite the Executor and to compell him to come in and prove the Will and to accept and take upon him the administration of the goods or to refuse it and if the Executor Broo. Executor â—0 Testament 27. Stat. 31. Ed. 3. c. 11. 13 Ed. 1. c. 19. 21 H. 8. c. 5. refuse or if there be a Will made and no Executor appointed the Ordinary must commit the administration cum testamento annexo to whom he shall think fit and take Bond of the admistrator to performe the Will And if there be no will made he is to grant the administration of the goods to the next of kinne if he or they require it and if not to whomsoever besides shall desire it or if no body seek it he may grant letters to whom he will ad colligendum bona defuncti and thereby take the goods of the deceased into his own hands and then it seemes hee is to pay therewith the debts and Legacies of the deceased so farre as the same will reach in such order as the Executor or administrator is
executor or administrator of a Gardian in Chivalry that E N B. â—6 doth commit waste in the Wards lands shall be charged and may be sued for the heire for it If a man possessed of a term of years devise it to another and Coo. 5. 12. Coo. 8. 94. the executor or administrator of the Devisor before the assent to the Legacy doth commit Waste in the land in Lease in this case he shall be charged with and may be sued for this Waste by him in reveâ—sion But if the executor die his executor shall not bee charged with it for it is a personall wrong that dyeth with the person If a Bishop grant an annuity out of his lands to I S for life and Dyer 370. die in this case it seemes the executor or administrator of the Bishop shall bee charged with the Arrerages due in the Bishops time If a Lease for yeares be made rendring rent and the rent is behind Broo. Executor 127. Coo. 3. 24. 22. and the Lessee die in this case the executor or administrator of the Leassee shall be charged for this rent So also if Leassee for yeares assigne over his Interest and die his executor or administrator shall be charged with the Arrerages before the assignment but not with any of the Arrerages due after the assignment The executor or administrator of a Customer or Controller shall Broo. Exeâ—oâ— 157. be charged upon a Taile of the Exchequer showed to the Testator The executor or administrator shall bee charged for a Ravishment West◠〈◊〉 c. 35. or â—jectment of Ward by the deceased The Executor or Administrator may be charged in the Spirituall Trin. 7. Ia. B. R. 〈◊〉 N B. 51. all Court for Tythes due from the deceased buâ— he may not as it seemes be sued in any Temporall Court for them The executor or administrator of a man that recovereth a debt Curia 21. Ia. B. R. upon a judgement had by the deceased shall be chargable with restitution if the judgement be reversed for error An executor or administrator shall not be charged for any personall Coo. 9. 87. F N B. 117. Dyer 322. 〈◊〉 H. 4. 46. Doct. St. 76. Coo. 8. 94. 133. wrong done by the deceased and therefore no action may be brought against him for any such cause as because the deceased did burne the Deed of the lantiffe suffer a Prisoner at his suite to escape cut down his trees cat up his grasse beate or wound the body of the Plantiffe defame him in his name or the like for all these are said to be personall actions that dye with the person neither is there any remedy to be had against the executor or administrator in equity in these cases neither shall he be charged in any action of accompt for any receit or occupation by the deceased And yet perhaps an action of the case may lie in this case neither will an action of debt lie against him upon the simple contract of the deceased but an action of the case only r Adiudge Hill 40. â—liz B. R. Bowyeâ—â— case Neither will an action lie against an executor or administrator upon an arbitrement made in the life time of the deceased albeit it be made in writing s Hâ—â—l 7. Ia. BR â—per 3 Iustices Neither will any action lie against any Executor or administrator for costs given in the â—tar chamber or Chancery against the deceased in a Suite there but when the party dieth the same is lost and Coo 9. â—9â— 40 Broo. Executor 78. 136. 136. Fitz. Briefe 34â— where a man doth sue an executor or administrator in a Suite hee must charge him as he is v. z. if he be an Executor he must sue him by that name if an administrator then by that name And where there be many Executors and have all accepted they must be all sued but if some of them have refused perhaps the Suite may bee good enough against the rest But otherwise one Executor cannot be charged without his companions except it be in the case of Summons and Severance and in some speciall case where one alone doth the wrong and the like as where one Executor alone doth detain the deeds from the heir for in this case he alone may be charged See more infra at Numb 39. 21 Ed. 4. 25. 4 H. 7. 4. 16. H. 7. 4. Broo. Executors 66. 30. 65. 9. Ed. 4. 12. Fitz. Executors 10. All the Executors where there be more then one be they never 30. What act one Executor or Administrator alone may do And where the act or laches of one may prejudice or barr his companion and where not so many in the eye of the Law are but as one man in which respect the Law doth esteeme most acts done by or to any one of them as acts done by or to all of them And therefore the possession of one of them of the goods and chattels of the deceased is esteemed the possession of them all paiment of debts by or to one of them is esteemed a payment by or to them all the sale or gift of one of them of the goods and chattels of the dâ—ceased the sale and gift of them all a Release made by or to one of them is a Release made by or to them all and the assent of one of them to a Legacy the assent of them all * Adiudge M. 39. 40. Eliz. B. R. And therefore if there be two Executors and one of them deliver up the Obligation to the Debtor whereby he is bound the other Executor shall not recover him in a Detinue So if two Executors have lands or goods in execution and one of them release all his interest this is a totall discharge of the execution * Crompt Iac. 45. 4â—â— 7. 4. And yet if in this case there be any practise between the executor and the Creditor in this matter and there be not Assets besides to pay all the Debts and Legacies here perhaps the other Executor may have remedy in equity against his Co-executor and the Creditor But how the Law is of Administrators quaere for some think that one of them also may sell-goods release debts plead to actions or the like without the other If one Executor atturn to the Grant of a reversion or a rent Dyer 210. Coo. 4. 31. Additioâ— to â—ust Doâ—â—dge 4â— this is as good as if they did all atturn and bind all the rest as in case of assent to a Legacy for in this case the assent will bind all the rest albeit there be not enough to pay the debts besides the Legacy given away by assent but his assent shall not hurr his Co-executors in a Devastavit If one Executor appear to an action sued against them all or Coo. 9. 38. Dyerâ— 10. plead a Plea to it this for the most part shall be said to be the appearance and plea of them all and shall bind the rest
be found for him this will barre the Plaintiffe And if he doe intermeddle and take upon him the administration be may plead if the case be so that he cannot recover the goods of the deceased for he shall bee charged for no more then what he can gâ—t in his possession Or he may plead that he hath fully administred all the goods and chattels of the deceased and hath nothing left to administer or he may plead that he hath paid so much of his own money as the goods in his hands do amount unto Or if he be sued for debts due by obliligations or such like Especialties entred into by the deceased hee may plead that there are debts due and yeâ— to pay on Iudgements had against the deceased or that there are debts due and yet to pay on Recognisances or Statutes entred into by the deceased and that he hath no more then enough to satisfie them Or he may plead that there are Iudgements had against him for other debts of the deceasEd in equall degree with the debt sued for and that he has no more then enough to discharge them so as these former debts on and for which these Iudgements were had and Statutes given bee bonà fide duâ— and the Iudgements Recognisances and Statutes in truth continued for the same for if there be any fraud in the case viz. that either the Iudgements Recognisances or Statutes werâ— at first entred into or are afterwards continued of purpose to deceive or delay others of their due debts when either the debt is satisfied or compounded for lesse or the like in these cases this plea will not serve but this matter being disclosed by the Plaintiffs pleading he will avoid it And if he be sued for a debt due upon a simple Contract or promise of the Testator he may plead there are debts to pay due by Obligations and other especialties entred into by the deceased and that he hath no more then enough to satisfie those debts and this will barre the Plaintiff in his Action And therefore if an executor or administrator plead a Iudgement in barre of an Action of debt upon an Obligation hee must shew also that the Suit whereupon the Iudgement was had was upon an Obligation for if it were on a simple Contract it is no barre And if the Executor be sued for debt on an Obligation he may plead he made voluntary payment of other debts due upon Obligations or gave new security for them in his own name before the Suit began and that he hath no more then enough to satisfie them But to plead such a voluntary payment or giving of new security after Suits begun upon this Obligation now in Suit is no good plea. If an Action bee brought against an Executor or Administrator on an Especialty for money it is no good plea in barre of this Action to plead a Statute or Recognisance with Defeasance to performe Covenants when there is no Covenant broken If a Suit be against an Executor or Curia Trin. 37 Eliz. Administrator for a Legacy it seemes it is no good plea to plead a Bond with Condition for performance of Covenants or for the doing of any other collaterall thing that is contingent only and not yet broken Is is no good plea in an Action for an Trin. 39. Eliz. B. R. executor or administrator to say that the deceased was Out-lawed An Executor or Administrator may make himself chargable of 38. Where and in what case an Executor or Administrator shall be charged by his own act or pleading upon his own goods and where Execution shal bee de bonis propriis and where not his own goods either by omission as when he being sued upon 2 H. 6. 12. Dyer 185. 80 Coo. 9. 90 94. 9 H 6. 57. 3â— H 6. 45. Broo. Executor 141. 105 Litt. 〈◊〉 Sect. 29. Klew 61. Broo. Executors 164. an Obligation or the like and there is a Iudgement against him or the deceased in force and he hath but enough to satisfy that Iudgement and he doth not plead this in barre of the present action but doth suffer the Plaintiffe to recover against him in this case he must satisfy this second debt out of his own estate or by Commission and that either by doing as when he doth any act that is a waste in him and thereupon a Devastavit is returned against him for in this case he must answer so much as he hath wasted out of his own estate or by saying as when a Suite is against and he doth plead such a false plea therein as doth tend to the perpetuall barr of the Plaintiffe in the action and yet it is of a thing that doth lie within his perfect knowledge as when hee doth plead he is not Executor nor did ever administer â—s Executor and upon tryall of this issue against him it be found hee is a rightfull or wrongfull Executor in this case he must satisfy this debt out of his own estate whether he have Assets or not and the execution had upon the Iudgement had in this Suite shall be de konis propriis And if an executor or administrator be sued and he plead to the action plenè administravit and upon tryall it is found against him in this case if he have any of the goods of the deceased left in his hand the execution shall be of them but if he have none of the goods of the deceased left the execution shall be and he shall be charged for so much as is found to be in his hands de bonis propriis But where he is sued upon a promise made by the Testator and he plead non assumpsit to it and where he is sued upon a Deed made by the Testator and he plead no â—est factum to it or the like and these issues upon tryall are found against him or when he shall confesse the action or suffer a Iudgement to go by default against him or plead any vain plea in all these cases he shall not be chargable of his own estate neither shall the judgement and execution in these cases be de bonis propriis but de bonis Testatoris only for the debt and de bonis propriis for the costs And yet if an executor or administrator shall entreate a Creditor to forbeare his debt untill a day and then promise to pay him by this promise he hath made himselfe chargable as for his own debt howbeit it shall be allowed him upon his Account But in all these cases and such like where a man shall be charged of his own estate and the execution shall be de bonis propriis Atworths case Micâ—h 38. 39. Eliz. it seemes the Iudgement is alwayes de bonis Testatoris and the course is this the first execution is against the executor de bonis Testatoris and not de bonis propriis And after a Devastavit 34 H. 6. 45. 46 Ed. 3. 9. Fitz. Executor 9. Coo. 5. 32. 8.
134. Dye 185. 32. returned by the Sheriffe against the executor or administrator and not before a new execution is directed to the Sheriffe to levie the debt de bonis Testatoris and if there be none of them to be found in his hands then to levie them de bonis propriis And therefore if an Executor or Administrator be sued by a Creditor and the Executor or Administrator plead a plenè administravit generally or plead specially that he hath no more but to satisfie a Iudgement or the like and upon tryall this issue is found against him and it is found he hath in all or part enough to satifie the debt in these cases the Judgement is de benis Testatoris and thereupon an Execution is as in other cases to levie the debt de bonis Testatoris in the hands of the Executor or Administrator and for the costs de bonis propriis And upon the returne of the Sheriffe a speciall execution doth issue forth to levie the money de bonis Testatoris Et si constare poterit that he hath wasted the goods then that he shall make the execution d bonis propriis And hâ—reupon also the Plaintiffe may if he will have a Capias against the body or an Elegit against the lands of the Executor or Administrator and no other course of proceeding can or may be had against the Executor or Administrator in this case An action of debt was brought against two Executors and one Dyer 21â— of them did appeare and confesse the action and the other made default and thereupon Judgement was given to recover against them both de bonis Testatoris in their hands and execution accordingly and upon this execution the Sheriffe did returne a Devastavit against the Executor that made default only and hereupon a Scire facias went out against him alone and afterward an execution against him alone de bonis propriis Assets in this case is said to be where one dieth indebted and Termes of the Law Coo. super Litt. 374. maketh his Executor or dyeth intestate and the Executor or Administrator Assets Quid. hath sufficient in goods or chattels or other profits to pay the debts or some part thereof this is said assets in his hands and for so much he shall charged All those goods and chattels actions and commodities which were the deceaseds in right of action or possession as his own and 3â— What shall be said to be Assets in the hands of an Executor or Administrator to charge him Or not so continued to the time of his death and which after his death the Executor or Administrator doth get into his hands as duly belonging to him in the right of his Executorship and Administration and all such things as do come to the Executor and Administrator in liew or by reason of that and nothing else shall be said to be assets in the hands of the executor or administrator to make him chargable to a Creditor or Legatee And herein these things are to be known 1. That Assets in the hands of one of the executors shall be said to be Assets in the hands of all the executors Kelw. 51. 2. That Assets in any part of the world shall be said to be Assets Coo. 6. 47. in every part of the world and therefore if that point be in issue and it appeare that there is Assets in the hands of any one of the executors or in any County or place whatsoever the Iury must find that there is Assets 3. All goods and chattels of what nature or kind whatsoever that are valuable as oxen kine corne c. Coo. super Litt. 388. shall be esteemed Assets But such things as are not valuable as a Presentation to a Church and the like shaâ—l not be accounted assets 4. All the goods and chattels that come to the executor or administrator in the right of their executorship or administration and Coo. super Litt. â—88 5. 3â— that are by Law given to them by vertue thereof in the right of the deceased for which See before at Numb 25. and which Dyer 361. Kelw. 63. are in possession shall be esteemed Assets in his hands a Coo. super Litt. 54. Dyer 36â— And therefore if a Feoffment be made to the use of the Feoffor for life and after to the use of his executors and assignes for 20 yeares in this case it seemes this 20 yeares shall be said to be assets in the hands of the executor of the Feoffor b 20 H. 7. 4. Broo. aâ—sets 22. And goods pledged to the deceased and not redeemed or the money wherewith it is redeemed when it is redeemed shall be said to be assets in the hands of the executor or administrator c See Before Numb And if the deceased doth appoint that the executors shall sell his land to pay his debts the money that is made of the land when it is sold shall be said to be assets in his hands 5. All the goods and chattels in action or in possibility Coo. super Litt. 124. 5. 31. Broo. Assets 24. Dyer 264. 121. 2 H. 4. 21. Coo. 6. 58. Kelw. 63. Dyer 362. at the time of the death of the deceased that are afterwards recovered and are gotten in possession into the hands of the executot or administraror when they are so recovered ate esteemed assets in his hands But they are never accounted assets untill they are recovered and come in possession and therefore if there be debts owing to the deceased upon Statutes or Obligations or otherwise these are never esteemed assets in the hands of the executor or administrator untill he hath recovered them So likewise if there be debt or damages recovered by a Iudgement had by the deceased but no execution is done untill execution be made this shall not be esteemed assets in the hands of the executor or administrator So if the executor bring an action of trespasse against another de bonis asportatis in vita Testatoris and he have a Iudgement for damages in this case untill he hath recovered it by execution it shall not be esteemed assets in his hands And if the Indgement be erroneous and the execution avoidable in this case albeit it bee recovered and gotten in possession yet it shall Curia Mich. 13. B. R. not be esteemed assets And therefore if one sue another and recover against him as Administraror of I S and after a Testament made by I S is produced and proved and thereby an Executor is made in this case the money recovered by the Administrator shall not be said to be assets in his hands as to any of the Creditors because the Executor may recover it from him or the debtor will have it againe And if the Executor or Administrator do never recover and get the thing into his possession he shall never bee Coo. 1. 98. Plow 84. 292. charged especially there where he hath done his best to get
hurt and for some cause make void the deed as in some cases it may there it shall not relate But if relation may helpe it as in case where a feme sole deliver an Escrow and before the second delivery she is married or dieth in this case if there were not a relation the deed would be void and therefore in this case it shall relate So if one disseise me of two acres of land in D and I release to him all my right in my lands in D and deliver it to an estranger as an Escrow c. untill a time and before that time he disseise me of another acre there in this case this release shall not by relation extend to this other acre to barre me of that also But as to collaterall acts there shall be no relation at all in this case And therefore if the obligee release before the second delivery the release is void and will not barre the party obligee of the fruit of his obligation If a man that is party or privy in estate or interest or one that doth justifie in the right of one that is such a party or privy shall 9. When and where a deed must be shewed in Court And how long it shall abide there And who may take advantage of it Co. 10. 92. super Lit. 267. 317. 225. 231. 5. 74 Lit. Sect. 375. plead a deed in any Court although he claime but parcell of the originall estate yet in this case he must shew the originall deed to the Court and the reason of this is to the end that the legall part of the deed the triall whereof belongeth to the Judges may approve it selfe i. that it may be seen whether the composition of words be sufficient in Law or not and then that it may appeare whether the estate be with Condition Limitation or with power of revocation c. to the end that if there be any such thing in it and there be no other part of it the other party may take advantage of it and then that it may appeare to be without resure or interlining and the like and also that it may appeare to be well sealed and delivered the triall whereof doth now belong to the Country But strangers to estates that are neither parties nor privies shall not be compelled to shew the deed though they make use of him And when a deed is thus shewed in Court it must remaine in that Court all the Terme wherein it is shewed in the custody of the Custos brevium and at the end of the Terme if the deed be not denied the Law doth adjudge the possession of the deed in him to whom it doth belong But if the deed be denied then it is to be kept there untill it be determined Also when a deed is shewed in Court the adverse party may take any advantage by it that it will afford him as if a feoffement be made by deed poll on condition and the feoffee doth breake the condition and the feoffor doth enter and the feoffee doth sue him and makes his title by that deed the feoffee may take advantage of the Condition Any man that that occasion to use or plead a deed may set forth 10. Where one may say his deed was delivered at another time or in another place the delivery thereof to be at any time after the date of the deed Dier 315. 12 H. 6. 1. Co. 2. 4 5. and in some cases he must doe so if he will have any advantage by it As if he plead a release to an obligation and it beareth date before the obligation in this case he must averre that it was delivered after or it will not availe him But a man may not in pleading set forth the delivery of a deed to be before the date of the deed And yet if it be so that a deed be dated after the time of the delivery of it the deed is good and therefore if he that doth use such a deed doe plead and set it forth as a deed made before the time of the delivery and the party that made it plead non est factum to the deed a Jury upon the triall may finde the truth of Estoppell the case but if hâ— by his pleading set forth the deed to be delivered before the time of the date then the Jury is concluded aswell as the party himselfe for a Jury is estopped to finde any thing contrary to that which is apparently admitted in the record In 12 H. 6. 1. debt brought by an executor the defendant pleaded the release of the Testator which did beare date after the death of the testator but he did averre the delivery of it in the life time of the testator and the Court did not allow of this plea. Sometimes Antiquity added a place where the deeds were made Co. super Lit. 6. as Datum apud B and this was in disadvantage of him to whom the deed was made for if the deed be in generall and without this addition he may alleage the deed to be made where he will An Co. super Lit. 261. obligation made beyond the Seas may be sued here in England in what place the obligee will and if it beare date at the Burdeux in France it may be alleaged to be made in quodam loco vocat Burdeux in France in Islington in the County of Middlesex and there it shall be tried for whether there be such a place in Islington or not it is not traversable in that case Non est factum is an answer to a declaration whereby a man 11. Non est factum Quid. And where this may be pleaded to a deed or not denieth that to be his deed whereupon he is impleaded If any deed or writing be used against a man in any Court and it want writing sealing or delivery or it be not sealed written and delivered as before is set forth the party that is sued upon it or against whom it is pleaded may plead this plea to it So also if a deed by any Alteration of rasure c. become void in this case the party may plead this plea to avoid it So also where a deed doth become void or lose his virtue by the not reading or not true reading of it to an illiterate man or by refusall or disagreement as in the cases before the party may plead this plea to avoid it But in all cases where the deed is voidable and so remaineth at the time of the pleading as if an Infant or man of full age by duresse seale and deliver a deed or if an obligation be well sealed and delivered by two and the deed be joynt and the obligee sue one of them in these and such like cases the party bound by the deed may not plead Non est factum for in the first and such like cases he must avoid it by speciall pleading with conclusion of Judgment si Action c.
and in the last he must plead in abatement of the writ c. And if an obligation or any other deed be by any speciall act of Parliament made void the party that is bound by it cannot plead this plea of Non est factum to it but he must avoid it by speciall pleading of the matter and taking advantage of the Statute and so with conclusion of Judgement si Action c. And now we come to the Exposition of deeds CHAP. V. Exposition of Deeds IT is further to be observed that Deeds for the most part consist of these things viz. the Premisses Habendum Tenendum Reddendum or reservation Condition Warranty and Covenant And in the Premisses there is sometimes a Recitall and somtimes an Exception contained but all these are not essentiall parts of a deed for a deed may be good albeit it have not all these parts or it be not so formall and orderly drawn and made The Premisses of a deed is all the forepart of the deed before the Co. super Lit. 6. 7. Co. 11. 51. 2. 55. Plow â—96 Habendum And yet this word is sometimes taken for the thing 1. Premisses Quid. demised or granted by the deed And the office of this part of the deed is rightly to name the grantor and grantee and to comprehend the certainty of the thing granted either by expresse words or by that which by reference may be reduced to a certainty and the exception or thing to be excepted if there be any And in this part of the deed is the Recitall if there be any in the deed for the most part contained And herein also is sometimes though improperly set downe the estate The Habendum of a deed is that part of the deed which doth 2. Habendum Quid. begin with To have and to hold And this doth properly succeed Co. super Lit. 6. 7. 10. 107. the Premisses And the office hereof is to set downe againe the name of the grantee the estate that is to be made and limited or the time that the grantee shal have in the thing granted or demised and to what use And herein also is sometimes though needlesly set downe againe the thing granted But the deed that doth usually consist of all these parts may be good notwithstanding some of 3. Where a deed is good notwithstanding some seeming fault in the Premisses or Habendum them be omitted and it be not so formally made For an estate may be made by a deed without any Habendum at all As if one give or grant land to another and his heires without any more words in the deed or if one give or grant land to another and limit no estate without any Habendum in the deed and seale and deliver this deed and make Livery accordingly in both these cases the deed is good and in the first case an estate in fee simple is made and in the last case an estate for life is made And if the name of the grantee be not contained in the Premisses yet if it be in the Habendum it may be good enough As if one give or grant land Habendum to B and his heires and he is not named in the Premisses yet this is a good deed to make an estate in fee simple And yet if the thing granted be only in the Habendum and not in the Promisses of the deed the deed will not passe it And therefore if a man grant Plow 152 Dier 96. Perk. Sect. 251. blacke acre only in the Premisses of a deed Habendum blacke acre and white acre white acre will not passe by this deed But if the thing newly added be implied in the thing granted by the Premisses of the deed as being an incident thereunto or otherwise or it be the same thing and expressed in other words only in these cases the Premisses and the Habendum may stand together As if one grant a manor Habendum the manor with the Advowson appendant to the manor or if one grant a Reversion of land by the name of a reversion in the premisses Habendum the land it selfe in both these cases the deed is good and the advowson and reversion will passe So also if livery of Seisin be made of the thing newly added in this case perhaps it may passe by the Livery And if the thing granted be lefâ— out in all or in part in the Habendum yet the grant is good And thereof if one grant land to A Habendum to A his heires c. or if one grant white acre and blacke acre to A Habendum white acre to A and omit black acre yet these deeds are good and all that is contained in the premisses of the deed doth passe in both cases And if a feoffement be made to one Habendum Lit. 1. Co. super Lit. 46. Co. 6. 35. New Terms of the Law tit Assignes to him and his heires without the word Assignes this is a good feoffement and the estate thereby made is assignable as where a lease is made to one his executors and administrators without the word Assignes this is a good Lease and assignable So if one grant land to A Habendum to him for 100. years or Habendum to him and his assignes for 100. years these are as good leases as the lease that is made by these words Habendum to A his executors administrators and assignes for 100. years So if a lease of land be made to A Habendum the land to him and his heires for 100. years this is a good Habendum and the word heirs is void and it shall goe to his executors c. As also where land is granted to A Habendum to him and his Successors for 100. years this is a good lease and the word Successors void for it shall goe to executors c. And if a lease be made Habendum for years and say not how many years this is a good Habendum and a lease for two years A Recitall is the setting down or report of somthing done before 3. Recitall Quid. 4. Where it is needfull or not When a man is to take any new estate from the King of a thing Co. 1. 45. Dier 77. whereof there is any estate in being there the former estate if it be good and of record must be rehearsed and recited in the deed or else the second grant will not be good but in case of a common Person there needs no such recitall neither when a man is to derive an estate out of a former or assigne over a terme of years is it needfull there should be any recitall of the former estate in being 5. Where misrecitâ—lâ— will hurt a deed or not If one recite or rehearse an estate made foâ— terme of years and Co. 1 74. then after grant over that terme to another and mistake in the recitall this mistake may make all void As if a Fieri facias come to a Sheriffe to levy a debt