by vertue and power of Gods decree And this againe was in tymes past an heresy of Simon (d) VinceÌ„t Lirin Magus and of (e) Eusebius l. 5. c. 20. Florinus 3. Both teach that good works be not necessary to saluation and that fayth is ynough But this was an heresy of the same Simon (f) Iren. l. 1. c. 20â— Magus and of (g) Aug. haer 54. the Eunomians about the yeare of Christ 360. 4. Both also teach that syns though neuer so many and great do not hurt him who hath fayth for that the malice of them is not imputed to him who beleeueth And this was also in tymes past an heresy of the (h) Aug. haer 54. Eunomians and of Basilides and Carpocrates as witnesseth Irenaeus l. 1. c. 23. 24. 5. Caluin denyeth the reall presence of Christs body in the Eucharist But this was againe an heresy of Berengarius about the yeare of our Lord 1051. Where it is to be noted first though some priuately before Berengarius doubted of that matter and moued the question about it yet none was so hardy as to professe it in publike as testifieth Hugh of Langres and Adelman of Bressia in their epistles to Berengarius and Paschasius in his booke of the words of the Institution of this Sacrament In so much as this was the constant and vniforme doctrine of the Church not opposed against by any arch-heretike vntill the tyme of Berengarius Secondly that Berengarius his opinion was whiles he yetlyued condemned in fiue Councells and that Berengarius himselfe thrise abiured his opinion and in conclusion died very penitent in the Catholike fayth He being dead the same heresy lay buried vp welneere two hundred yeares vntill the tyme of the Lollards who brought it to light againe as is gathered out of Trithemius in his Chronicle about the yeare 1315. After this againe VVicliffe held the same as appeareth by his third article After his death againe there was a deep silence of that matter for the space of an hundred yeares vntill Swinglius renewed it and Caluin and some others after him Whereby it euidently appeareth that this opinion was euer in the Church held for a manifest heresy therfore eyther the Church hath euer erred in a principall article of fayth and so consequently it was neuer Christs Church or that opinion which abrogateth and disclaymeth from the Reall presence of Christs body is an heresy indeed 6. Both take away all traditions and would haue all things to be comprehended in Scriptures alone The same was the heresy of the Arians as is recorded by S. Augustine also of Nestorius l. 1. contra Maxim c. 2. vlt. Dioscorus and Eutiches as is declared in the seauenth Synod Act. 1. 7. Both deny the Sacraments of Penance and of Confirmation The Nouatians taught the same opinion long ago as witnesse S. Cyprian l. 4. epist 2. l. 3. baer fabularum and S. Theodoret 8. Both teach that the Church consisteth of good alone and that the Church in former tymes visible perished notwithstanding for many ages that in this tyme it only remayneth in their congregations The very like was the heresy of the Donatists as testifieth S. Augustine l. de vnit Eccl. c. 12. 9. Both of them teach that prayer is not to be made for the dead that 〈◊〉 fast of Lent or any other stable fasts be not to be keep but euery one is then to fast when it shall to him seeme good The Aerians taught the very same in former ages if we beleeue Epiphamus haer 75. and S. Augustine l. dehaer c. 33. 10. Both deny the veneration of holy Reliques of Christs and Saints Images and call it Idolatry Vigilantius did no lesse many ages past as witnesseth S. Hierome The same did the Image breakers as testify Zoneras Cedrenus and Nicephorus touching them who made war against Images By these it is more then manifest that the chiefest opinions whereof Lutheranisme and Caluinisme consist be ancient heresyes long since condemned by the Church and that the same were alwayes held in the Church for heresyes The same may we easily exemplify and declare touching the rest Vide Bellar de notis Eccl. c. 9. Coccius de signis Eccl. l. 8. art 3. Wherehence it followeth that these Religions be nothing but the very sincke of heresyes of old longe ago put to silence and now in these latter dayes brought to light againe The XI Reason From the want of a Rule of Faith THESE new Religions haue no certaine rule of Faith to follow therfore they are not to be receyued For the principall heads of Religion must be determined certaine and withall immutable And that they haue not any certaine rule of beliefe whereby it may be resolued what is necessary to be beleeued and what not is euident First for that they admit neyther the traditions of the Church nor the authority of generall Councells nor the iudgment of the ancient Doctors of the Church and of those who flourished and liued before these our Controuersies Luther reiecteth all traditions in c. l. 4. c. 8. §. 6.7 8 in Antid ad 4. fesâ— Conc. Trident 1. ad Galatas as doth Caluin also l. 4. Instit and they teach that nothing is to be beleeued nothing to be receyued an holy Scripture Luther so contemneth Generall Councells which haue hitherto had most great authority in Gods Church for they be as it were the Parlaments of Princes In art 115 sequentib Peers in Christs Kingdome as he will haue the definitions therof subiect to the iudgment and censure of euery priuate person And he further sayth that it is a mad thing that the Councells will conclude what is to be beleeued And in the same place he teacheth that what is to be beleeued what not is to be left to the iudgment of euery spirituall man Caluin insinuateth no lesse l. 1. c. 7. § 1.2 4. when he sayth that it is not for the Church to iudge what books be Canonicall but that appertayneth to the inward spirit alone Finally as touching the Fathers Luther careth not for a thousand Augustines l. contra Regem Augiae a thousand Cyprians Caluin also in very many places contemneth them and affirmeth that they erred Wherefore none of all these is vnto them a rule of fayth But say they The Scripture it selfe is vnto vs a rule of fayth it caÌ„not erre But it is an easy matter â—o shew that this rule serueth not the turne First because we by this rule cannot iudge of the Scripture it selfe and so the rule it selfe will remayne vnto vs vncertain which yet should haue the greatest certitude of all For by the Scripture it cannot come to be knowne for certaine that such a book is truly Scripture is not Apocripall nor composed by some deceiptfull person that this or that sentence is not peruerted northrust in Finally that nothing is added or taken
and Anabaptists are at bitter wars one with another about many points of fayth and do impeach one the other of heresy The Lutherans do dissent both among themselues in many things and from Luther himselfe â—heir Father and Apostle in so much as at this tyme there be reckoned thirty one principal Sects of Lutherans different in name and disagreing in many points of doctrine The Caluinists be at variance among themselues especially in the Article touching the head of the Church For a great part of them giueth that power to the secular Prince though she be a woman and these be called Protestants Others of them hold the same for impiety and blasphemy and those they call Puritaus The Anabaptists differ among themselues in very many things so as of them there be numbred 14. diuers Sects distinct both in names and in points of doctrine Finally it is now come to this that where euery one followeth this rule of Scripture alone and relyeth vpon it there be almost as many heresyes as there be heretiks For the greater part of them especially the more simple affirme that they little regard or care what Luther or Caluin taught sith they cleaue fast to the holy Scriptures and recur to the word of God in which there cannot be any errour and so they thinke themselues very secure And euery one vnderstandeth the Scripture according to his own capacity and sense Wherhence it followeth that where they thinke they haue the Scripture for an infallible rule of their beliefe insteed of Scripture they haue and follow their owne imagination For whatsoeuer they imagine to be signified meant by the words of scrip ture they take for the true fense of Scripture and so lookehow many diuers imaginations of men there be so many rules there be of beliefe But whence is it that to euery one his owne imagination should seeme the most true verity and the very fense of Scripture It procedeth partly of a certaine exceeding selfe-pleasing lone and estimation For he who maketh any great reckoning of himselfe easily perswadeth himselfe that all his owne innentions and conceipts of mind be great and extraordinary partly by working of the Diuell who doth in wardly pernert mensphanfyes so as what they apprehend they forth with for euery most light and idle poore reason thinke to be most cuident truth For whiles men wearied with the auncient Religion loathing it do auerse the truth longe to heare nouâ—lt yes they are by Gods iust iudgment suffered to be begnyled by the Diuell Whereupon whiles he worke the inwardly in their senses they thinke themselues to haue recevued the light of Gods spirit and vnto it they referre all iudgment touching matters of fayth Hence it is that to euery sect almost to euery priuate man their owne apprehension seemeth to be the pure word of God neyther care they for all the reasons that are brought to the contrary The Apostle insinuateth no lesse when he sayth 2. Thes 2. For that they haue not receyued the Charity of truth that they might be saued therefore God will send them the operation of errour that they may belieue lying He shall send not by way of commaund but by giuing more power to the Diuell for the deceyuing of them who haue contemned the truth or ancient Religion and the thrusting of them into a thousand errors But the most of them especially the simple say God will not permit them to be deluded who search the truth with an humble hart for the hath promised that he will giue a good spirit to them who aske him And this do I for I make my petition to God that he would please to illuminate me open vnto me the true sense of the Scriptures and I cease not continually to search them This is a great deceipt of the Diuell For how do they with an humble hart search out the truth who contemne makeno esteeme of the iudgment of the Doctors of the Church of the interpretation and exposition of the holy Fathers and of the definitions of Generall Councells who refuse to vse the way appointed and shewed by God and require vnnecessary reuelations For from them they might vnderstand the truth and exempt themselues from all errour but they haue not a will to submit themselues vnto them thinking that they may by their owne industry their owne wit and priuate spirit with a more facility and certainity find the truth out of the bare naked Scriptures As though the holy Fathers Doctors and Prelats of the Church did eyther not search the Scritures or wanted the spirit of God and sound iudgment so as it passed their skil to ariue to the true vnderstanding therof What greater pride can there be thought then that a priuare person and comonly an Idiot ignorant of all antiquity and good literature should prefer himselfe before so great authority and holynes and so great a number of Doctors And therfore they must not thinke thatso longe as they be of that mind they shall obtaâ—ne any thing at our Lords hands because they aske both yll and prowdly but that they shall rather be deceyued by the spirit of pryde and of lying whereunto they are by Gods iust iudgment for so great a cryme delyuered This is that spirit whereof all heretiks though they be neuer so different in Doctrine haue their part and vaunt themselues and of which euery one thinketh the truth to be reuealed vnto him which certes he that is not blinde may casily obserue and see because Gods spirit reucaleth not contraryes Moreouer the holy Scripâ—ure no where remitteth priuate men in doubts of fayth to the fearch of the Scriptures but to the Church and to them who be the Prelats of the Church So in Deuâ—eronomy c. 17. in matters of doubt they are remitted to the Priests who haue charge and rule for the tyme whome he that shal refuse to obay is sentenced to dy Therfore hath God appointed pastors doctors in his Church therfore would he haue it conspicuous to the whole world to be the pillar and firmament of truth that all might with case make their recourse vnto it and most securely repose vpon the determination of it There is not giuen to all the spirit of vnderstanding the Scriptures as is plaine by testimony of the Apostle 1. Cor. 12. 1. Ioan. 4. 2. Cor. 11. We are not to giue credit to euery spirit but the spirits are to be tryed if they be of God Wherfore though your spirit suggest vnto you something you are not therefore secure for you are not sure that it is of God For it is certaine that infinite numbers haue been and are deceyued cuery heretike vaunteth himselfe of this spirit The Angell of Sathan oftentymes transfigureth himselfe into an Angell of light Wherefore by what hath been said it is most euident that a priuate spirit cannot possibly carry it selfe for the rule of beliefe The XII Reason Drawne from Absurdity
remission of Synns they explicate of not imputation only not acknowledging any inward renouation by inherent iustice and the infused gifts of God after which manner the Catholikes do hold that sinnes are forgiuen By these it is manifest how great a difference there is in the vnderstanding of the Creed Seing therfore that there is but only one truth and this in our Consultation we haue shewed to be among Catholikes it necessarily followeth â—â— one God Creator of all thinges because his Alcoran doth teach him so which he thinketh to be written by the spirits of God his faith albeit he belieue that which is true relyeth vpon a false and deceytfull reason by the force whereof he is moued to belieue many false and blasphemous thinges as that there are not three Persons in the B. Trinity and that Christ is not God and that Christ is inferiour to Mahomet and that Circumcision the like are still to be kept That faith therfore by reason of the foundation is both deceitfull and hurtfull the same hapneth vnto alheretikes the which being supposed I vrge the argument in this manner That faith which relieth vpon a false foundation albeit it belieueth somethings which are true cannot be sufficient to saluation but the faith of all the sects of this tyme relieth vpon a false foundation it cannot be therefore sufficient for saluation The first proposition is manifest in it selfe for how can that which is deceitfull vncertayne be the â—oundation of our eternall 〈…〉 How can the true Religion whereâ—â— we please God be grounded in a false deceitfull faith Truly it is no lesse repugnant to reason then if thou shouldest say that truth is grounded vpon lyes wisdome vpon error and vertue vpon folly The second proposition The faith of all sectaries dependeth vpon a false ground to wit that all Sects are grounded vpon a false and deceitful foundation I proue in this manner for eyther they belieue their opinions for the authority of their Apostles Luther Caluin Melancthon Zwinglius c. whom they iudge to be endewed with the spirit of God or because euery one of them in their owne priuate iudgement do beleeue those things to be coÌ„teyned in holy Scripture or lastly because their owne priuate spirit doth inwardly testify vnto them that those things are true or that this is the meaning of holy Scripture for whatsoeuer the sects of these tymes do belieue they are moued thereunto by one of these three reasons and they appoint one of them to be the foundation or reason of their beliefe but these foundations and reasons be altogeather false and deceitfull As for the first reason to wit the authority of Luther Caluin and the rest who first inuented these new Religions that it is deceitfull is many fest because we see by experience that both they might and haue byn often deceyued for they haue reuoked many things corrected many things and in many things haue they contradicted themselues as hath byn declared in our Consultation of Religion in the 9. Consideration and the sixt Reason Hence it commeth to passe that few now adayes will rely vpon their authority because they say they were men and therefore subiect to error wherfore their followers also do leaue them at their owne pleasure when they thinke they haue found any thing fitter for their purpose their authority therfore is deceitfull vncertayne euen by the iudgement of their owne schollers and followers Neyther is the other to wit the priuate iudgment whereby they expound the holy Scripture lesse deceitful for many false thinges by that priuate iudgement seeme to be true and many things which before seemed true are afterward iudged false From hence ariseth so great variety and inconstancy in many of them concerning matters of faith because indeed mans iudgement is weake especially in the mysteries of our fayth and the vnderstanding of holy Scripture the which far exceedeth the reach of mans wisdome and reason Many do answere that they do not rely vpon their iudgment in matters of faith but vpon the holy Scriptures which cannot erre Whether all sectaries do rely vpon the Scripture wherin how miserably they are deceiued by this appeareth because almost all the sects do say that they rely vpoÌ„ holy Scripture wheras notwithstanding they differ among themselues in most of the matters one teaching contrary vnto another the which could by no meanes come to passe if they did not rest vpon their owne iudgments but vpon the lawfull and common vnderstanding of the holy Scripture for the holy Scripture is no where contrary vnto it selfe neyther doth it any where disagree from it selfe that therefore they so greatly iarre disagree among themselues is caused by that they make a sense to the holy Scripture according to their owne priuate iudgment the which is diuersly framed by them according to the diuersity of iudgments and vnderstanding among them they rely therfore vpon the holy Scripture not as it is interpreted by the Catholike Church the holy Fathers but as they in their priuate iudgment do interprete it for the vertue and force of the holy Scripture doth not only consist in the bare words but in the sense and meaning therof but the priuate iudgment inuenteth this sense and ioyneth it to the words of the Scripture as lyfe vnto the body the whole reason of their fayth therefore is their priuate iudgmeÌ„t the which how deceitfull oftentymes it is may easily be declared by the disagreement of so many sects For it is all one whether thou saist that thou reliest vpon Scripture as it is interpreted by thy proper iudgment or that thou reliest vpon thy owne iudgment precisely in it selfe Finally the third reason whereupon many now adayes do rely is most deceitfull and skornfull of all a manifest signe wherof is that among the Anabaptists who aboue all others are guyded by the instinct of the spirit there is the greatest variety of sects and disagrement of faith the which could not be but that the spirit whereupon they rely and by whome they are gouerned is deceitfull and variable The same also is to be seene among Caluinists and Lutherans and amongst their sects and diuers factions for their owne opinion is certayne and euident vnto euery one of them by the testimony of their owne priuate iudgment the which inwardly teacheth euery one of them and affoardeth the testimony of truth vnto euery one of them whereby it is manifest that this spirit is not the holy Ghost the spirit of truth who cannot teach contraryes or be opposite vnto it selfe but it is a wicked spirit the spirit of error who is a lyar from the begining and the father of lyes who worketh in the children of incredulity of whome the Apostle saith Because they haue not receiued the charity of truth 2. Thess 6. he will therefore send them the operation of error that they may belieue in lyes And in another place 2. Tim. 4. In
no small matter but euen such as all other things be they good or bad are nothing in comparison therof And this damnation or saluation dependeth of good or bad Religion If thy Religion be good it shall be easy for thee to obtaine saluation but if it be euill it is impossible for thee to be saued By euill or false Religion thou canst not please God Hebr. 11. consequently not obtayne pardon of thy sinnes not true Iustice nor yet by any meanes be made partaker of Christs redemption but remaynest in death and the wrath of God remayneth vpon thee For that all men without the redemption of Christ Rom. 3.4 and liuing againe in him do remayne in death of sinne are the sonnes of wrath but whosoeuer imbraceth not true Religion is made voyd of the Redemption and quickening of Christ wherefore of necessity he must remaine in death and be the sonne of wrath and fewell for eternall fire Furthermore true Religion is only one and not manifold for that there is but one verity one faith Ephes 4. one baptisme one God Lord of all wherof it followeth by consequence First that all Religion all Faith all Confessions of faith besides this only one are false hurtefull pestilent and brought in by the Diuell as author therof and the Father of lyes Secondly no man that hath not this onely Faith can possibly obtaine euerlasting faluation and all that shall be destitute therof although otherwise they liue neuer so well shall infallibly perish eternally 1. Cor. 13. For that which the Appostle saith of charity to wit If I should speake which the tongues of men Angells if I should know all mysteries if I should distrâ—bute all my goods to be meate for the poore if I should deliuer my body so that I burne and haue not châ—â—rity it doth profit me nothing may with better reasoÌ„ be spoken of true faith religion which is the vary foundatioÌ„ of charity and of all other christian vertues Thirdly it is a very grosse errour of certaine simple people that thinke it to be inough to their saluatioÌ„ if they belieue in Christ and that he dyed for their sinnes although they belieue not many other things for examples sake those which belong to Sacraments sacrifice of the Church and other such like pointes of faith for so should almost all Sects of beretikes be saued for that all except some few do imbrace Christ or els they should not be heretikes but Apostataes and belieue that he dyed for their sinnes And so by this meanes shal be saued the Montanistes Nonutiam the Donatistes and Sabellians the Arrians Macedonians Aerians Eutichians Monethelites and such like pestes of the Church Tit. 3. Wherefore then hath the Church in all ages vehemently opposed therselfe against heresies wherfore doth the Apostle command vs to aouyd an hereticall man after one or two reprehensions 2. Tim 2. Wherfore should we beware of their very speaches as a certaine infectious canker In vayne then are all these thinges spokeÌ„ and done if saluation may be obtayned togeather with heresy Then truly is that a meere forged tale against the consent of all Ages which S. Augustine reciteth in these wordes Constituamus aliquem c. Let vs imagine saith he a man to be chast continent not couetous not a seruer of Idols liberal to the poore no mans enemy not contentious Aug. l. 4. cont Donat cap. 8. patient quiet emulating or enuying no maÌ„ sober frugall c. but yet an hereticke let there be no doubt at all to any but that such a one for this only thing in that he is an heretike shal not possesse the kingdome of God For as that man as witnesseth S. Iac. 2. Iames who offendeth in one commandement is made guilty of all looseth his whole iustice although he keep the rest of the commandementâ— because he contemneth the lawmaker himselfe who made the whole law eueÌ„ so he that denieth obstanately but one article of faith though he retayne the rest iâ— made guilty of his whole Religion looseth all his Faith and Religion because he contemneth the Author therof For that the chiefe supreme Verity being one and the same hath reuealed all the articles of faith and doth propose the same to be beleeued of vs by the Church her spouse 1. Tim. 3. which is the pillar and firmament of truth He therfore that doth obstinately reiect but any one the least article of Faith not relying vpon the iudgment of the Church by that very act is he iudged to contemne the Author of the first principal Verity whose preacher interpreter instrument is the Church and by this meanes he looseth al his liuely faith which is necessary to saluation Neyther helpeth it any thing at al that he yet beleeueth some principall heads or articles of faith because he beleeueth them not with a liuely faith which coÌ„sisteth vpon only diuine authority proposed vnto vs by infallible means els he should belieue the rest also that are propounded to him by the same meanes but he belieueth them with a certaine humane faith that is to say because by his owne priuate iudgment or opinioÌ„ he so thinketh them to be belieued taking vnto himselfe authority to iudg and discerne what things are to be belieued and what are to be reiected so as the chief reason of his beliefe is his priuate iudgment and therfore all that faith and beliefe is humane and of no value For most certaine it is that as true Iustice doth extend it selfe to all the commandements so doth true faith in like maÌ„ner which is required to saluation extend it selfe to all those things that are reuealed vnto vs from God in such sort that we eyther expressoly belieue or be ready to belieue them all if they be accordingly proposed vnto vs. Wherby it is manifest how carefully we ought to endeauour to obtaine true faith and Religion seing that the same is the very foundation of all our saluation and without which most certaine damnation is to be expected Wherfore I haue thought good in this place to set downe certaine Considerations or Reasons manifest and perspicuous to euery one of ordinary capacity wherupon may be framed a certaine and infallible Deliberation concerning this busines of Religion I. CONSIDERATION Of the desyre of perfection wherunto Christian Religion leadeth THAT Religion is alwayes to be preferred that sauoureth of purity and holines of life That ChristiaÌ„ Religion leadeth to desyre of PerfectioÌ„ which draweth our myndes from earthly affections and styrreth vs vp to the loue of heauenly For that the chiefe end and scope of Religion is to sequester mens affections from these base and temporall things and to lift them vp to meditate loue and pursue celestiall and euerlasting Such is the only Catholike Religion and no other For she persuadeth to abstaine from pleasures of the flesh and alluiements of this life She teacheth to
Apostles or their sucessours to gouerne the people And therfore it is cleere that the Church of Christ is not with them The III. Reason From the defect of their Mission THE third reason is because these Religions were brought in by them that were sent by no lawfull authority but came of themselues and for this cause are they and their Authors worthily to be suspected of errour least perhaps they proue to be wolues and seducers For that no man may preach in the Church vnlesse he be sent by lawfull authority according to that of the Apostle How shall they preach Rom. 10. vnlesse they be sent otherwise there should soone arise a great confusion in the Church for that euery one might take vpon him the office of preaching and gouerning the Church and sow abroad what errors he listed And if in a temporall Common wealth humane Policy no man may intrude himselfe and take vpoÌ„ him the office of a magistrate to gouerne the people in temporall things only pertaining to this life but that he must first be appointed therunto by the Prince How much lesse then in the Church and spirituall kingdone of Christ may any man assume vnto himselfe the office of Pastour to gouerne the people in those things which belong to eternall saluation but he that is ordained and appointed therunto by the supreme rector of the Church and Prince of Holyes For that confusion in gouerment of the Church is much more to be auoided theÌ„ in Policy when as the one threatens destruction to the soule the other only losse of goods and fortune Againe Ioan 10. he that entreth not by the dore into the theepfold but climbeth vp some other way is a theefe and robber saith our Lord. But he that taketh to himselfe the office of a Pastour in the Church without lawfull Mission and Auchority he entreth not in at the dore but climbeth vp some other way as the holy Fathers do commonly expound the place and is manifest of it selfe For what is it to enter in at the dore but to enter by the lawfull way and by lawfull authority The dore is the ordinary way and made of purpose wherby to enter into the sheepfold and wherby is designed that authority by which the Ministers of the Church are to be admitted into the sheepfold of Christ to gouerne and feed his sheepe Furthermore our Lord saith in S. Iohns Ghospell Ioan. 7. he that speaketh of himselfe seeketh his owne glory but he that seketh the glory of him that sent him he is faithfull and in him there is no iniustice By which words we are warned not to belieue them who are not lawfully sent but come of themselues because they seeke their owne glory and therfore they do not speake for truth but for their owne praise and comodity and thither do they direct all their doctrine And finally the Apostle in the Epistle to the Hebrews doth account this mission so necessary that he doth require the same in our Sauiour Christ saying Neyther doth any man take the honour to himselfe but he that is called of God as Aaron Hebr. 5. So Christ also did not glorify himselfe that he might be made a High Priest but he that spake to him My Sonne art thou this day haue I begotten thee Wherby our Sauiour did so often inculcate to the Iewes his mission to wit that he came not of himselfe but was sent of his Father and confirmeth the same many wayes From whence it is cleerly deduced that Luther Caluin and the rest of these new Doctours are not to be heard but their doctrine altogeather to be shunned because it is manifest that they were not sent by any lawfull authority but came of themselues It is also manifest that they vsurped vnto themselues the offices of magistrates and Pastors the Authority of reforming the Church It is manifest I say that they came not in at the dore and by the lawfull way but clâ—mbed ouer some other way into the sheepfold and therfore according to our Sauiours iudgment and sentence they are to be accompted for theeues and robbers Perhaps they will say that they were sent of Christ immediatly as in old tyme the Prophets were sent by God in an extraordinary manner to reforme the people and as the Apostles were sent by Christ our Sauiour to coÌ„uert the world and as S. Paul after the Ascension of our Lord who was not sent of men nor yet receiued the Ghospell from men but immediatly froÌ„ God himselfe To this I answere first it is not inough to say and stoutly to affirme but it must be proued and conuinced to be true least it may seeme to the people ordinary pastors to reiect them as deceauers for a lawfull cause as the Prophets and Apostles did not only say that they were sent of God but shewed the same also abundantly by heauenly signes Secondly all Archeretikes and false Prophets throughout euery age haue affirmed the same to wit that they were sent of God from him receaued their Authority And therfore eyther we must receaue them all or none For why should I for example sake rather belieue that Caluin was sent of God then Luther or Menno or Munzer Arius or any other Archeretike when as he can produce no greater signes or testimonies for his mission then they Thirdly if Caluin were sent of God then Luther was not sent of God and so likewise to the contray Because if two men do prophesy coÌ„trary things and that the one doth condemne the others prophesy and doctrine of errour and heresy the one doth so destroy the others religion and therfore if they were both sent of God it seemes that the spirit of God doth oppugne deny and ouerthrow it selfe destroying by one what he had built by another But amongst the Prophets truly sent by God there hath alwaies bin a principal vnity and consent in doctrine Fourthly if Luther or Caluin were set of God to reforme the Church I demaund then what tyme and in what place God gaue them this Office what words did he vse vnto them cyther internall or externall In what manner did he declare vnto them the chiefe heads and points of this Reformation what order and manner did he prescribe them How or in what forme did he appeare vnto them Externally in a visible shape as he did to S. Paul or internally by imaginary vision in some extasis as he did to the Prophets to S. Iohn Euangelist in the Apocalyps For that he is wont to obserue al these things with those whome he sendeth And the Prophets themselues presently in the beginning of their preaching did explicate and declare all these things to the people that they might vnderstand of whome they were sent or what commanÌ„dement was giuen vnto them to performe as out of the Prophesyes of Isay Ieremy Ezechiel Daniel and others is manifest that they were all wont to premit these things first of all And
away that maketh to the substance of doctrine All this cannot to be known by Scripture but proued only by certaine humane weake coniectures if you take away the traditions of the Church and so the whole foundatiō of our fayth shall rely vpon vncertaine coniectures Moreouer the vertue and efficacy of the Scripture consisteth not in the sound of the words but in the sense meaning which is the life and soule of the Scripture But there may be a thousand controuersies about the sense which cannot in any sort be decided by the Scripture it selfe if you take a way Traditions and the exposition of the Fathers as experience teacheth For about the sense of these words Hoc est Corpus meum and of many more there is most eager disputation betwene the Lutherans and Caluinists c. If you say with Caluin that the iudgment touching the Scriptures and the vnderstanding of them belongeth to an inward spirit this is nothing but the dictamen of an internall spirit that is for the priuate iudgment of euery particular person to set down the first rule how to beleeue For euery one may say that he hath the spirit and by the inspiration therof can iudge and determine that this part or booke is holy Scripture and not that that this is the sense not that So a◠Lutheran out of his spirit giueth iudgment In prologonou◠Testamer ti that S. Iames Epistle is a strawy Epistle and the Apocalyps of S. Iohn of doubtfull authority But the Caluinist out of his soiri◠iudgeth the one and the other to be the word of God So Luther out of his spirit iudgeth that this false opinion is to be abolished that there be foure Gospells for that S. Iohns Gospell is but one faire true and principall and to be far preferred before the other three In like manner S. Paules and S. Peters epistles do sar go beyond sayth be the three Gospells of Mathew Marke and Luke He would willingly haue reiected them because they plainely proue establish the merit and necessity of good works and the obseruation of the commaundements and do recommend chastity and pouerty But when he durst not cleane reiect them he would extennate their authority and insinuate that they were not written with the spirit of God In like maner Caluin out of his own sense iudgeth that these words Hoc est Corpus meum haue this meaning This breed is the figure of my body and Luther will haue it This bread is truly my body I omit other thing without nūber by which it appeareth that euery ones priuate iudgment is proposed for arule of beleefe or which is the same that the Scripture it selfe is expounded and interpreted according to euery ones priuate iudgment Secondly that is not any fit rule of beliefe that is a like accommodated to contrary doctrines but the scripture is accommodated to contrary Religions and doctrines for as much as all the Sects of this time though they do in an hostile manner dissent and contend in very many and those the most inportant heads and grounds do neuertheles make this rule to serue their turne and doe vse it for the mantayning of their opinions and heresyes For the Lutherans say they rely vpon Scripture the Caluinists affirme the same the Anabaptists also are nothing behind them in auerring that the Scriptures be for them And no meruaile because euery one of them taketh and interpreteh the Scripture not conforme to the comon vnderstanding of the Church or the common exposition of the Fathers as do the Catholikes but according to the sense of euery priuate spirit in which sort it may bee easilie accommodated to all heresies Whence it is euident that this rule so taken serueth not the turne whiles all is reduced to the iudgment of euery ones priuate spirit Thirdly if there were some iudge who in euery Controuerly wherein he were to giue sentence should so doe it as it could not be certainly vnderstood for whether party he pronounced the sentence but both partyes should contend that the matter were adiudged and determined on their side and that the sentence of the Iudge was expresly plainly pronounced for them such an one in the opinion of all men could not be thought a competent Iudge sith no matter in cōtrouersie could bee determined or ended by sentence giuen by him For after sentence there would bee as greata contention about the sentence it selfe whether of them it might seeme to fauour as there had been before about the right that ech party had And such a Iudge is Holy Scripture if you take away the Churches interpretation and declaration and the exposition of the holy Fathers for as much as the sentence therof is euer such as it cannot bee euident to both parties whether of them it fauoureth whiles the one and the other doth stifly maintaine that it is most plaine that it holdeth and standeth for them And hence it is that controuersies bee neuer ended and therefore it is not onely a vaine but also a ridiculous thing to appoint the Scripture alone for Iudge For in euery controuersy there ought such a Iudge to be designed who may so giue sentence as it may be manifest to all and most of all to those parties on whose behalf the cause is adiuged otherwise such a controuersy can neuer be ended Wherfore those who make the Scripture alone the Iudge of matters in question do therin plainely manifest that they admit not any iudge at all by whome the cause may be determined besids their priuate iudgment alone For they do as if Titus and Caius hauing a suite at Law would not haue any other Iudge in the matter but Iustinian his Code together with the Pandects without hauing any thing to do with the interpretation of Doctors and Titus producing for his owne right some law should by it maintayne that the cause was manifestly adiudged for him And Caius againe should deny it who by citing an other law for himselfe should say that it was cleare that that law fauoured made for him which Titus would in lake manner deny and so they should both depart without any decision of the cause or controuersy in hand would it not be a matter worthy of laughter and all would say that neyther of them desired the determination or decision of the cause And that neyther admitted other Iudge then his owne iudgment In the very like manner in this that they wil not haue any other Iudge then Scripture and euery one reserueth the interpretatiō thereof to his owne spirit they plainely shew that they haue no will that the cause should be decided or defined by any lawfull way nor to admit any Iudg but their owne iudgment Fourthly how very insufficient this rule of beliefe is experience it selfe plainely teacheth For we see that there is not any end of controuersies among them euen about the greatest matter of fayth sith at this very tyme the Lutherans Caluinists
What things be required for the searching out of the truth and vertue But one thing there is that is most of all wont to hurt this sincere deliberation and that is a certaine anticipating and foregoing opinion that possesseth very many touching the Idolatry superstitions and abuses of the Catholike Church Wherefore let them in the first place for a time lay aside this their precipitate and fore-running iudgment and thinke that they may be deceiued in the matter For it seemeth a thing beyoud beliefe that most holy and most learned men such as the Church euer had very many did either not see this Idolatry if there were any or if they saw it did not onely not reiect it but also did with all diligence retaine and imbrace it This is a calumniation of old both of the Mahometans and of the Image-breakers And there neuer was yet any Sect of heretiks which did not with extreme rancour and malice oppugne and oppole it selfe against the Church and impose very sore and great errors and abuses vpoÌ„ her For such a pretence meete was it for them to vse that they might seeme to haue had iust cause of their reuolt and departure from the Church Secondly let them not cease to craue light from God whereby they may clearly vnderstand which is Christs true religion and true Church and let them yeald themselues ready to imbrace it For fayth is Gods gift Ioan. 6. None saith he can come vnto me vnles my Father shall draw him None can come to Christ by true fayth without light giuen him from the father of heauen and therefore let them labour to procure this illustration this light and this drawing by earnest and contynuall prayer let them say with the prophet Psal 12. Lighten mine eyes that I may neuer sleep in death least when I am to depart out of this life myne enemy may say Psal 42. I haue preuayled against him Put forth thy light and thy truth let them conduct and bring me vnto thine Holy mount Psal 1 42. and into thy tabernacles Make known vnto me the way where in I may walke because vnto thee haue I lifted vp my soule Deliuer me out of the hands of the enemies of my soules good O Lord to thee haue I fled for succour teach me to do thy will because thou art my God And the like To prayer let them ioyne almes and beneficence towards the poore and needy For how much these two auaile and profit towards the obtaining of light for the imbracing of the true religion is manifested by that example of Cornelius the Centurian Act 10. to whome it was said by an Angell Cornelius thy praiers and thine almes haue ascended to be remembred in the sight of God And now send to Ioppa and send for one Simon who is sirnamed Peter he shall tell thee what thou must doe Let them therefore propose this example vnto themselues and imitate it who in this busines of true religion haue a desire to be directed of God In the meane tyme let them with diligence and with an earnest desire of knowing the truth ponder and consider those things that be in this Consultation proposed and if they find therein any thing eyther doubtfull or not sufficiently vnderstood let them repaire to Catholike doctors who will with facility giue them such satisfaction in all matters as their mind may in conclusion find full repose and quiet in the light of true religion This is that which we desire and craue and with most humble petition and suite beseech at thy hands o true light light eternall and the light both of men and Angells For notwithstanding they haue been seduced misled and carried away by the guile and deceipt of the deuill and haue reuolted from thee and thy Church and haue made war against thee and it yet they be thy creatures formed to thine Image and likenes redeemed and ransomed with the price of thy bloud made and called to the inheritance of heauen and to be consorts in thy kingdom Let not so noble a worke of thine perish which cost thee so dearely which will yeald thee eternall praises if it once know the truth and which will to thy glory shine for all eternity Dissperse and dirue away the foule darkenes that hath now possession of their mind Disolue vndoe the deuills bewitchings of them whereby the eyes of their mind be blinded their fancy and imagination peruerted Put into them a true and sensible apprehension and feare of that inextinguible and euerlasting fire prepared for all those who haue not communication with the true religion Inspiâ—e them with a burning loue and desire of vnderstanding the truth of procuring their owne saluation Present vnto them the light of thy mercies that they may know thy fold and haue a true vnderstanding of the fold wherin they formerly were that it was not thine but the diuells in which all such as contynue as sheepe be reserued not to life but to vtter perdition to be food for the fire meate for death Death shall feede vpon them Psal 4â— Reduce and bring them backe againe into thy fold that in it they may refresh theÌ„selues with the healthful refectioÌ„ of thy doctrine and by thy wonderfull Sacraments may receyue cure of the old wounds that Sathan had formerly giueÌ„ them and increase in thy spirit in the spirit of humility and feare of our Lord in the spirit of meeknes and charity and may receyue forces and strength to life euerlasting wherin made together with vs after the instant of this life companions of thy glory and blisse they may praise thee An admonition to Catholikes and glorifie thee for euer and euer And now am I in the second place briefly to admonish Catholiks that they duly ponder with themselues how exceding great a benefit this is of true religion which hath by diuine fauour hapned to them before infinite others who are debarerd of it and how much by occasion of ye they be obliged and bound to the Diuine maiesty This is the gift priuiledg but of a few if we consider the infinite number of such as go astray or stand in doubt and therefore for this respect the more is it to be esteemed Let them thinke that in humane things nothing is to be compared with it not pleasures nor honors nor millions of gold and syluer no not Scepters Kingdomes or Empires The margarite perle of true religion doth exceed all these by infinite degrees and he that is possessed of it though he want other things and is most poore of al tertene things is most truly rich as beeing a cittizen with the Saints the sonne of God an heyre of a Kingdome and coheire with Christ yet so as he must haue a will to lyue conformably thereunto He that wanteth it is thrice miserable indeed though he otherwise abound in all the goods of this life and hath them at his will This is