second judgment Error lies in Ban. Regis or in Com. Ban. Nat. br 21. G. 14 Edw. 3. Error 6. 8 Eliz. Dyer 250. pl. 86. Judgment in London Custom viz. before the Mayor shall be redressed in Com. Ban. or Ban. Regis Nat. br 20. E. 23. A. B. But a judgment before the Sheriffs of London London shall be redressed before the Mayor and Aldermen in their Hustings Nat. br 22. H. which is the highest Court And judgment before the Mayor and Sheriff shall be redressed by Commission directed to certain persons at St. Martins the Great Nat. br 23. E. 18 Edw. 3.8 But by 34 Hen. 6.42 pl. 14. the Mayor and Aldermen have forty days to advise of their judgment and then the Recorder certifies it forthwith if they do not reverse it Note Note this manner of proceeding is given by the Stat. of 28 Edw. 3. cap. 10. scil that the error shall be redressed within the City and if they do not redress it then there shall be a commission and if error be found they shall forfeit to the party his treble dammages and to the King 1000 Marks c. but by the 1 Hen. 4. cap. 5. their Fine is at the discretion of the Commissioners Judgment given in the Cinque-ports Cinque-ports shall not be redressed in com ban or ban regis but only by the Warden of the 5 Ports at the Court at Shepewaye si falsum fuerit revocabitur Major Jurati qui dederunt Judicium fecerint fines Major deponetur ab officio 23 Eliz. Dyer 376. pl. 23. The Writ to the Cinque-ports shall be directed Custodi quinque portuum vide 30 Hen. 6.6 Pole But 30 Hen. 6.6 the Barons of the five Ports are Judges there Upon a Custom in Village or Town to hold in all manner of Pleas Village and a judgment thereupon given error lies in ban regis 21 Edw. 3.40 37 Assize pl. 5. Nat. br 20. D. 2 Hen. 7.19 pl. 4. 18 Edw. 4.12 Mich. 10 Jac. ban regis Godson versus Duffeild Or in com ban Nat. br 20. D. Common right Marshalsey Judgment in the Marshalsey shall only be redressed in ban regis per 5 Edw. 3. cap. 2. 10 Edw. 3. cap. 3. Lib. intra 297. coram ipso rege Judgment in Court of Pypowders shall be redressed in ban regis Pypowder or com ban Nat. br 20. D. Who shall have a Writ of Error He that confesses the Action shall not have a Writ of error against his own confession Parties Nat. br 21. K. 34 Hen. 6.41 For he hath lost all that advantage by his confession Conusor of a Statute shall have a Writ of error if execution be not well sued out against him Conusor 18 Edw. 3.25 for to overthrow the execution And although he were outlawed if he be pardoned for then he is enabled again to sue 29 Assize 47. Nat. br 22. B. A Corporation shall have a Writ of Error jointly for a judgment given against them Corporation but no single person of them 21 Edw. 4.58 Townesend For they are all but one body and cannot sever nor be severed in pleading or in being impleaded He that disclaims shall not have it Disclaim Nat. br 22. C. Coke 8. part 6. B 62. A. viz. the thing sued for whereupon judgment is given But if one plead Non-Tenure and it be found against him Non-Tenure yet he shall have it 6 Edw. 3.188 pl. 17. Nat. br 22. C. For that is but a plea to the Action A brought a Praecipe against B who infeoffs C judgment is given for A yet B shall have error 21 Edw. 3.53 12 Assize 41.20 of Assize 2. 50 Assize 3. Coke 1. part 111. Albanies case because the judgment is against him and not the Feoffee Judgment was given against the Defendant in debt and after because he paid it not nor rendred his Body c. judgment was given upon a Scire facias against the Bail and they all join in a Writ of error and therefore held not good because one of them is not party to the judgment given against the other Mich. 9. Jac. Regis Wildgoose against Duport but they are distinct and several judgments given against them severally and ought to have several Writs of error Trespass against two where one was within age and appears by Attorney and judgment Quod capiantur they join in a Writ of error because the judgment is entire Hil. 9. Jac. Ban. Regis Orme Bird and good though the judgment was well given against one of them Surviving joint-tenant shall have error of all the judgment given against both Survivor for he is only now concerned 19 Edw. 3. Error 1.19 Assize pl. 8. Two outlawed upon a Capias in Redisseisin with force one shall have error sole Outlawed 8 Hen. 4.3 For the Outlawry is as two Outlawries viz. against each one of them particularly Judgment against two in conspiracy Conspiracy one dies the other shall have a Writ of error 24 Edw. 3.76 pl. 99. else it would be mischievous to him if the judgment be erroneous if he may not reverse it Mich. 30 31 Eliz. ban regis Pigot being an Infant and another levies a fine Infant Pigot sole brought error and good for this is error in fact therefore it shall be brought by him it most concerns which here is the Infant If one makes a Retraxit viz. upon the Roll Retraxit that he will not proceed yet he shall have error Coke 8. part 62. A. Beechers case For the Retraxit was but till the judgment The King shall have error Reversion 15 Edw. 3. Error 72. and that is but reasonable He in reversion disseises two joint-Tenants for Life and suffers an erroneous recovery the wife releases with warranty and dies this warranty is a bar to the Writ of error because by his own Act he had disabled himself to take benefit of the forfeiture Coke 3. part 61. A. Lincoln-Colledg case Q. De cest case A recovers a Moyety of a Mannor against B which infeoffs C B Heir and C makes partition B dies his Heir shall have a Writ of error and by Newton if A had issue a Son and a Daughter by one Venter and another Daughter by another Venter and dies the Son enters and dies the youngest Daughter is found Heir in a Nuper obiit they make partition the eldest Daughter shall have a Writ of Error 19 Hen. 6.25 A. For the judgment binds her interest till it be reversed Prayer in Aid shall have a Writ of error Nat. br 21. C. Coke 3. part 3. B. 4 Assize Pray in Ayd pl. 7. For the praying in Aid is but to satisfie his Title which he had before Patron after Aid Patron Prayer shall have error 12 Hen 8.8 Pollard For the Judgment concerns his Title notwithstanding the Aid-Prayer Garnishee shall have a Writ of error 21 Hen.
Transcript and if Error appears they shall send for the note it self and reverse it 21 Edw. 3.24 16 Edw. 3. Record 35. 40 Assize pl. 29. For otherwise perchance the Fine may not be ingrossed which may prove mischievous 1 Mariae Dyer 89. pl. 4. Lib. Intra 296. A. sect 1. Fines Nat. br 20. B. But note 5 Mariae Dyer Record 79. the Record shall be certified and no other proclamation shall be made This is intended of a Fine with Proclamations But 1 Mariae Dyer 89. pl. 4. è contra Ergo quaere Upon a transcript in Parliament error is assigned for the Chief Justice brought up the Record and reported it Ban. Regis 8 Hen. 5. Error 88. 23 Eliz. Dyer 375. pl. 19. 22 Edw. 3.3 pl. 25. But in another Court it is otherwise 40 Assize 29. Nat. br 20. F. Quaere rationem It seems because all Courts agree not in one way of proceedings Upon an award by the Justices upon return Priviledge upon a writ of Priviledge no writ of Error lies Coke 8. part 127. B. case of the City of London for this is no judgment upon Record Upon allowance of claim by the Justices of the Forest Claim 21 Edw. 3.48 pl. 70. error lies vid. antea for it is in nature of a Judgment Record removed Upon a Judgment in an annuity and after that a Judgment in a Scire facias upon the judgment Error is brought upon the former judgment the Record shall be removed 11 Hen. 4.4 viz. the whole Record as it seems Error upon a Fine with proclamations Proclamations the proclamations shall be certified Com. 265. A. Fishes case for they are part of the Record by virtue of the Statute A Writ of Error shall not be awarded until the final judgment be given Award Coke 11. part 40. A. Metcalfs case 7 Rich. 2. Error 68. for the tenour of the Writ supposeth the judgment to be given Unless the Award be ad grave dampnum Coke 11. part 41. A. Metcalfs case for then it seems a necessity to grant it before As in Debt against many by several Praecipes and judgment is given against one he shall have error and the pleadings shall be several from the original and if Error be in the original tenore tantum shall be certified Coke 11. part 41. A. Judgment in an Account quod computet Account error lies not until the final judgment Coke 11. part 38. B. 21 Edw. 3.9 1 Hen. 7.2 B. for the judgment is not perfect and entire before nor the Record made up When an Action of Trespass is in part determined Trespass error lies not until it be determined all 32 Hen. 6.5 pl. 5. 36 Hen. 6. Coke 11. part 39. B. for before the whole Action is not determined and so no compleat judgment So in a Formedon 12 Eliz. Dyer 291. pl. 67. Coke 11. part 39. B. Formedon So in Trespass against two Trespass 34 Hen. 6.41 pl. 9. So in a Quare Impedit 34 Hen. 6.41 Quare Impedit Partition So in Partition Mich. 40 41 Eliz. Com. Ban. Countess of Warwick against Henry Lord Barkley All upon the same ground If error be brought before the fourth day in Com. Ban. yet it is good Day because of Record at the Commencement 34 Hen. 6. Quaere whether so in Banco Regis In an Assize of Darrein Presentment a Writ was awarded to the Bishop and the Assize is for dammages error brought and allowed 17 Edw. 3.5 pl. 12. for this was a judgment Error upon a judgment in a Scire facias upon a Fine Record and no Record removed but the proceedings upon the former judgment and yet good 20 Edw. Error 2. viz. the Fine which is a Judgment in its nature and the Scire facias is but to have Execution upon it yet it seems better if all were removed Praecipe quod reddat Upon a Praecipe quod reddat judgment is given and error brought the original nor the judicial Writ nor the essoyn shall be removed 2 Edw. 3. Error 2. Thorpe 37. Assize 5. but only the Record of the judgment for there the error is only supposed Unless Error be assigned in the Original 24 Edw. 3.24 and then it must be removed viz. the tenour of it And then the transcript of the Record only shall be removed Transcript 34 Assize 7. 36 Hen 6.13 for the Record is supposed not to be erroneous Error upon an execution upon a Statute-Merchant Statute-Merchant and error in process assigned the original shall be removed 18 Edw. 3.24 for the original is part of the process Ancient Demean And if it be of Ancient demesn Lands the Original shall be removed 34 Assize 7. out of that Court. But Error upon a judgment in Ireland the Original shall not be removed 74 Assize 7. 37 Assize 15. Finchden Quaere rationem it seems because it is a Record of another Kingdom Fine and Recovery Error lies not upon a Fine or Common recovery for false Latin rasure interlining mis-entry of the warrant of Attorney Proclamation mis-returned or not return of the Sheriff or default of form in words 23 Eliz. cap. 3. This Statute was made in favour of Fines and to support them because they are the common Assurances of the land And by 27 Eliz. cap. 9. this extends to Fines in Wales and Recoveries there But if the fine be passed before the Kings Silver be entred it is Error No. Lib. Intra 231. A. sect 2. viz. for the not entring of it which is paid pro licentia concordandi If a Writ of Covenant be returned before the Teste this shall be amended Coke 5. part 45. B. Gages case for it is the misprision of the Clerk The Caption before the Teste of the Dedimus is no error No. Lib. Intra 255. C. Sect. 11. for the same reason Pasch 1. Jacobi Regis Rot. 426. the Countess of Bedford against Foster 1. Error assigned was because the Writ of Covenant was of eight Messuages and two Tofts and the Fine certified is of eight Messuages and two Messuages but non allocatur because the Record hath relation to the Writ of Covenant 2. Error assigned because the Indorsement was Executio istius brevis patet in quadam panella c. where it should be in quadam schedula sed non allocatur because in substance it is the same thing expressed by divers names Mich. 30 Eliz. Ban. Regis Austein Steede versus Conaway Webbe a Fine was levied of two Tenements and void because a Praecipe lies not of it this case is entred Hill 30 Eliz. Rot. 165. for a Tenement is a thing incertain of which a Fine cannot be levied Infancy good Error in a Fine Infancy Nat. br 21. D. 3 Hen. 6.16 B. 2 Rich. 3.1 17 Edw. 3.53 pl. 33. 27 Assize pl. 53. if it be brought during his Minority that he may be inspected by the Court and
Writ of Error lies upon this in Parliament viz. upon a judgment given in the Kings Bench. Iudgment given in Chancery according to the Common Law that is on the Petty-bag side shall be redressed in Parliament 37 Hen. 6.13 11 Edw. 4.8 Choke So it seems of a judgment in the Exchequer-Chamber Or in ban regis 14 Eliz. Dyer 315. pl. 100. and so it seems 37 Hen. 6.13 8 Edw. 3.25 17 Assize pl. 24. com 393. A. 39. Assize 18. And in case of Partition one Scire facias was brought in Chancery upon Error and good 42 Assize 22. If Letters Patents are enrolled in Chancery there shall be a Scire facias to reverse it there 16 Edw. 3. bre 651. 2 Rich. 3.1 A. if erroneous But another Subject upon this being grieved shall have this redressed in Parliament 16 Edw. 3. bre 651. 37 Hen. 6.13 But no Writ of Error lies altogether upon a Decree in Chancery because in their proceeding the Court is not a Court of Record 37 Hen. 6.13 27 Hen. 8.15 Rnightley but meerly arbitrary A Judgment given in com ban if it be erroneous in Process Com. Ban. or in default of Clerks it shall be redressed in the same Court the same Term without a Writ Nat. br 21. I. 15 Edw. 4.7 8. 7 Hen. 6.28 pl. 22. 19 Hen. 6.2 pl. 2. viz. upon a motion at the Bar. But for Error in Law in the same Term or other Error in another Term this shall be redressed in ban re only Nat. br 21. I. Coke 8. part 5. A. 5 Mariae bre commission 25. It shall not be redressed at the Council-Table 39 Edw. 3.14 pl. 28. For that is not a Court of Law but of State Judgment given before the Barons of the Exchequer Exchequer shall be redressed in the Exchequer-Chamber before the Chancellor of England Treasurer Barons and Justices 31 Edw. 3.12 A. 37 Hen. 6.15 8 Hen. 7.13 pl. ult com 260. B. Coke 1. part 11.34.3 part 11. B. 8. part 58. A. 65. B. 15 Edw. 4.18 39 Hen. 6.52 6 Hen. 7.15 Inferior Court The Statute of Merton cap. 3. makes the Sheriff Judge of Record in redisseisin and Error lies upon a judgment given by him in ban regis Coke 6. part 12. a Gentlemans case Judgment given at the Assizes in the Countrey Assizes shall be redressed in ban regis 33 Edw. 3. Verdict 48. 7 Eliz. Dyer 235. pl. 21. 23 Eliz. Dyer 375. pl. 19. 2 Rich. 3.1 pl. 1.10 Assize pl. 25. Or in Com. Ban. Nat. br 25. E. But judgment given at the Assizes in Com. Monmouth shall be redressed only in ban reg and not in the com ban because the other Iustices at the Assizes are by Letters Patents 8 Eliz. Dyer 250. pl. 87. and if the Assizes be adjourned in com ban and judgment given there it shall be redressed in ban regis 8 Hen. 6.17 And if judgment be given at the Assizes in a Quare Impedit Error lies in ban regis 6 Edw. 6. Dyer 76. pl. 34. But judgment given at the Assizes shall not be redressed at the Council-Table 39 Edw. 3.14 pl. 28. vid. antea rationem quare non Oyer and Terminer Upon Commissions of Oyer and Terminer by Iustices of the Peace the judgment given by them shall be redressed in ban regis 29 Edw. 3.30 5 Mariae brev Commissions 25. But Error lies not upon a thing done before the Iustices of the Peace 4 Hen. 6.24 Martin For such things are not accounted judgments but may be rectified in some cases upon a motion made to that power But Error was brought upon an Utlawry upon an Indictment taken before Iustices of the Peace 11 Hen. 4.53 For an Outlawry is a kind of a judgment given by the Coroner though the Indictment pended before them Conusance granted to a City or Village corporate Judgment Conusance of pleas granted to a City or Village corporate their judgment shall be redressed in Ban. Regis Or to a Body Natural and not Corporate for such are judgments upon pleading For a judgment in Chester Error lies in Ban. Regis Coke 2. part 89. B. 19 Hen. 6.12 6 Hen. 4.8 pl. 30. But note Note in a Writ of Error upon a Judgment given in Chester day shall be given for so long time that three Counties may be held there before the return of the Writ in Ban. Regis within the which time the Justices or Lieutenant of the same County may redress the Error by the usuage of the said County Regist orig 17. A. if they please But in a Writ of Error upon a Writ of Error depending there they have no such power but the Record and the process ought to be remanded at the first County or Court into Ban. Regis Regist orig 17. A. Lib. intra 290. A. sect 1. Chester And by usuage in the same County of Chester nine County-Courts shall be held one year and eight another year c. Regist orig 17. A. The usuage is to have a Writ out of the Chancery retornable in Ban. Regis for Writs of Error are excepted in the Charters granted to Chester And in this Error there the Justices may award a Scire facias against the Defendant returnable at the next County and if the Judgment be affirmed the party may have a special Writ of Error reciting the former Writ and have the Records and Process of both Judgments removed in Ban. Regis there to be examined and a Scire facias awarded against the Tertenant ad audiendum errores for otherwise the party shall not be restored to that which he lost 15 Eliz. Dyer 321. pl. 20. 21 Hen. 7.34 pl. 32. Fineux 34 Hen. 6.42 6 Hen. 4.8 pl. 36. Lib. intra 290. B. sect 1. Chester And by 18 Eliz. Dyer 345. pl. 6. if the judgment be reversed the party shall be restored and the Judges there forfeit to the King 100 l. although the Judgment was given by their Predecessors But then it is not intended of Error in fact but only of Error within the Record or Process No. Lib. intra 231. A. sect 2. Upon a Claim allowed by the Justices of the Forest Error lies upon it in Ban. Regis Forest 21 Edw. 3.48 pl. 70. For such Allowance is a Judgment in its nature If eroneous Judgment be given in the Stannaries Stannaries it shall be redressed first before the Warden of the Stannaries and after before the Council of the Prince and after before the King himself as supream Judge It seems at the Council-Table and not in the Kings Bench. Pasch 7. Jac. Regis per Flemming chief Justice a Writ of Error or false judgment lies not upon judgment given in the Court of the Stannaries as was resolved by all the Justices and it seems the reason is because it is but an English Court and not a Court of Record Judgment in the County Palatine of Durham shall be redressed by a Writ of Error there and upon Error in this
6.35 B. Paston 7 Hen. 6.41 Coke 5. part 99. B. Hoes case Garnishee For he is bound by the judgment Garnishee in London upon an Attachment according to the Custom shall have error 22 Edw. 4.30 31. For the judgment is in part against him Tenant per Receipt shall have error Coke 3. part 3.4 Assize 7. 20 Edw. 3. Error 2. Tenant For by the Receipt he is made party to the Suit and concerned in the judgment Vouchee shall have a Writ of error 8 Hen. 4. 3. Nat. br 21. C. 4. Assize 7. 17 Edw. 3. Error Vouchee 90. Nat. br 21. M. 108. A. For by the Voucher he is called in and made a party And the Tenant shall have another Writ of Error 8 Hen. 4.3 21 Nat. br 21. C. for they are severally concerned But if the Vouchee release before Error brought the Tenant shall not have it 17 Edw. 2. Recovery in value 32. for by the release he is barred viz. a release of Errors or of his right Heir general shall have a Writ of Error 20 Edw. 4.13 Lib. Intra 269. A. Sect. 1. for he is prejudiced by the Judgment And if the Ancestor be outlawed of Felony Heir general he viz. the Heir shall have it Nat. br 21. N. viz. to reverse the Outlawry and to gain his own interest But not for High Treason per 28 Eliz. cap. 2. because thereby the blood is corrupt and disabled The Heir special shall have it for the Lands to which he is heir Heir special 3 Hen. 4.19 Nat. br 21. K. 9 Hen. 6.47 1 Mariae Dyer 90. pl. 5. but he must have a special Writ as it seems Executor shall have Error upon judgment for debt or dammages Executor Nat. br 21. M. given against the Testator for the regaining of the Testators estate Although that he be Executor to the Bishop Parson or other sole Corporation Nat. br 22. A. Coke 4. part 65. A. Fulwoods case 8 Hen. 6.25 A. Martin for that makes no difference in the case And this upon the Statute of 29 Eliz. cap. 8. Coke 6. part fol. ult Executor shall have error upon an Outlawry of the Testator and restitution of the goods lost by the Outlawry 11 Hen. 465. pl. 22. 5 Edw. 4.7 Although that the Outlawry be for Felony Coke 5. part 111. A. vid. antea Administrator shall have error in the same manner as Executor shall have Administrator Nat. br 21. M. 6 Edw. 6. Dyer 76. pl. 31. for he hath the same interest in the Intestates personal estate A Successor shall have error for a thing which toucheth the Succession Successor to a thing whereof he is so Nat. br 22. A. 16 Edw. 3. Error 69. 8 Hen. 6.25 A. Martin The King collates A to a Chappel King against whom an Action is brought A resigns to the King the King collates B Judgment is given pro querente B shall have Error 15 Edw. 3. Error 7. 15 Assize 8. for now the interest concerns him But for Debt or Dammages recovered against a Bishop Bishop c. or against any Secular sole Corporation the Successor shall not have Error Nat. br 22. A. for the dammages concern the Executor and not the Successor and so he hath no right to sue He in Reversion after the particular estate ended shall have Error at Common Law Reversâ—on and not before Coke 3 part 4. A. 21 Hen. 6.29 Newton 3 Hen. 4.6 32 Edw. 3. Error 73. 4 Hen. 8. Dyer 6. pl. 5. com 24. B. Weston for before he is not concerned in the Judgment Q. And per 9 Rich 2. cap. 3. he shall have it during the Estate for life Coke 3. part 4. 22 Edw. 4.31 A. Vavisor 3 Hen. 4 6. 12 Hen. 8.9 A. Brudnell And this seems reasonable for he may be prejudiced by the delay Q. And by equity he in the remainder shall have it Nat. br 108. A. 1 Mariae Dyer 90. pl. 5. But at Common Law the Donor in tall shall not have it altogether com 241. B. Q. And yet he shall not have Error during the estate Tail because he is not within the Statute of 9 Rich. 2. cap. 3. Coke 3. part 61. A. Lincoln Colledge case 10. part 44. B. Portingtons case But after the Estate tail ended he shall have it because the Law reserves the reversion in the Donor Coke 3. part 3. B. And although Tenant in tail suffered a Common Recovery and released Errors and yet â—â—ings error and is barred and dies without issue â—et the Donor or he in Remainder shall have Erâ—or 3 Eliz. Dyer 188. pl. 9. to reverse the Recovery â—or if that be erroneous then the Estate â—ail is not barred by it Note regularly no Stranger shall have Error Estranger â—2 Edw. 4.31 per Brian viz. a Stranger to the Judgment but this holds not always Conusor aliens Execution is sued erroneously Conusor the Alience shall have error Nat. br 22. B. 4 Hen. 8. Dyer 1. pl. 5. 17 Assize 24. 18 Edw. 3.25 pl. 17. Crooke 6 Hen. 8.169 A. Pollard for his title is concerned A claims wood in a Forest Tenant and this allowed before two Justices of the Forest B C which claim Estovers brought a writ of Error in Ban. Regis 21 Edw. 3.48 pl. 70. and good to reverse this allowance which is in nature of a Judgment and binds their right to the Estovers The Tenant in a Praecipe enfeoffs B Judgment given pro quer B shall have Error for the mischief that may fall to him by the Judgment 21 Edw. 3.53 21 Assize 41. 20 Assize 2. 50 Assize 3. But quaere 50 Assize 3. if the Tenant in the Praecipe aliens to B which releases to the Feoffor for life and judgment pro querente if B shall have Error per 9 Rich. 2. cap. 3. It seems he shall for all his interest is not gone by the release Where the King is party to the judgment King there shall be Error against him but not before Petition made to the King Pasch 12 Jac. Ban. Regis Davies case 23 Edw. 3.12 pl. 14. 18 Hen. 6.17 22 Edw. 3.3 pl. 25. 24 Edw. 35. pl. 43. for it may be that upon the Petition the King will let the judgment be reversed without Suit and it is not fit to sue the King where one may have right of him for asking it without suit The Writ of Error The Writ ought to make mention of him which was summoned and severed 9 Hen. 6.38.13 because he was once party to the suit An Action of Covenant is brought against A as Assignee and judgment given against him he brought Error the Writ needs not mention him as Assignee because this Addition was not of substance 19 Eliz. Dyer 356. pl. 41. Q. for then he must be called Lessee which properly he is not but by construction of Law The Process in Error 1. Vpon Judgment in Ireland 2. Vpon a Bill sealed 3. Judgment in another Court Error brought
upon a Judgment given in Ban. Regis in Ireland Ireland there shall be a Scire facias in the Writ of Error against him that had the judgment for by Sharde this is the usage and in no other manner 34 Assize pl. 7. and it is dangerous to alter the ancient practice of proceedings in Law In Error upon a Bill sealed Bill sealed there shall be a Scire facias against the Justices which sealed it ad cognoscend Sigilla c. per Westm 2. cap. 31. Lib. Intra 293. C. Sect. 1. 11 Hen. 4.92 This is where Error is brought upon a Bill of exceptions But the Justices may deliver it in Court by their own hands 11 Hen. 4.52.92 and then there shall be no Scire facias for thereby they acknowledge their hands The Process in a writ of Error against the Judges to whom the Writ is directed is Alias Process Pluries and Attachment Nat. br 22. G. if they do not certifie the Record which is before them Errors â—ssigned When the Record is removed after Errors assigned the Plaintiff shall have a Scire facias against the Defendant ad audiend Errores Nat. br 22 E. 10 Edw. 4.13 3 Eliz. Dyer 195. pl. 38. 201. pl. 63. 17 Edw. 3.5 This is to give him notice that the Record is removed and of his proceeding thereupon And upon two Nihils a Non est inventus returned the Court shall come to examination of the errors 3 Eliz. 201. pl. 63. without the Defendants in the writ of Errors appearance But until Error assigned the party shall not have a Scire facias 24 Edw. 3.31 pl. 8. for it is to no purpose for his appearance is to hear the cause And if he assign that for Error which the Court takes clearly to be no error he shall not have a Scire facias 18 Hen. 6.17 for that would be to trouble the Court to no purpose but if it be colourable it is otherwise But in Error brought against the King there shall be no Scire facias because the King is intended to be always in Court Nat. br 21. H. either himself or his Counsel for the Judges are of his Counsel The Writ needs not mention the names of the Tertenants Against whom a Sci. fac in Error shall be sued because it is of common form used otherwise 8 Hen. 4.17 pl. 3. and the naming of them is not material If the Sheriff return that the Heir is not in his Bailywick Other County and the Tertenant shews that he is in another County there shall go a Scire facias into that other County 8 Hen. 4.18 pl. 3. Q. if he remove out of that into another if another Scire facias shall issue and so till he is found If a Recoverer make a Feoffment Tertenant and die without Heir it seems there that a Scire facias lies against the Tertenant only and a Writ of Error 8 Hen. 4.17 pl. 3. 9 Hen. 6.49 B. pl. 30. Q. whether not against the Lord by Escheat also because he comes in by virtue of the Judgment Former Judgment But the 9 Hen. 6.46 B. pl. 30. a Writ of Error lies against none but the party or them that are privy to the former Judgment Q. if not against privities in Law as well as in fact Gardein in right Gardein in right of the ward recovers in a Quare Impedit and dies the Defendant brought Error and a Scire facias against the Heir of the Recoverer and against the Heir of him from whose right he took his title and against the Incumbent without naming the Executor yet good because he recovers as Gardein in right but the contrary as Gardein in deed 8 Hen. 6.35 pl. 1. for there it seems the Executor is concerned for the wardship is a Chattel False Judgment Error upon false Judgment in Oxford viz. for Land the party being dead that hath the Judgment there shall go a Scire facias as well against the Heir of the Recoverer as against the Ter-tenant 8 Hen. 4.18 pl. 3. A Scire facias needs not be sued against the Tertenant before the Judgment be reversed 47 Edw. 3.7 for before that the Tertenants estate is not stirred But before that he enter he shall have a Scire facias against the Tertenant for otherwise he shall be a Disseisor 4 Hen. 7.10 47 Edw. 3.7 but by the Scire facias it appears that he enters not as a Disseisor But if the Recoverer make a Feoffment to his own use and then the Judgment be reversed Feoffment there needs no Scire facias against the Feoffâ—e for this is aided per the Stat. of 1 Rich. 3. 26 Hen. 8.2 Scire facias in Felony Error upon an Outlawry in Felony the Plaintiff ought to have a Scire facias to all the Lords mediate or immediate 7 Hen. 7.5.53 4 Edw. 4.10 11 Hen. 4. because they are intitled by the Outlawry And also against the party at whose Suit and the Tertenants Lib. Intra 308 B. Sect. 3. And in a writ of Error Delay if the Plaintiff hasten not his Suit the Defendant shall have a Scire facias against the Plaintiff to shew cause why he should not have Execution 24 Edw 3.24 9 Hen. 6.13 or else he may proceed in Court to have the Judgment affirmed And in such case upon two Nichils returned the Defendant shall have execution but after this the Plaintiff shall have a Scire facias 9 Hen. 6.13 Q. for then it seems to be too late Diminution in Error 1. by whom 2. in what cases 3. at what time 1. The Plaintiff in Error may alledge Diminution Nat. br 25 A. that is alledge that a whole Record is not removed The Defendant may do it also 28 Hen. 6.11 15 Eliz. Dyer 321. pl. 21. for if the Record be not wholly removed the Court cannot judge of it nor can the parties tell how to assign Errors But this alledging of Diminution is now used mostly for delay Error in London 2. Error upon a Judgment in London the Recorder certifies the Record yet he is held to do according to the custome Quaere if Diminution shall be alledged 34 Hen. 6.42 it seems it should When all the Record is not removed Diminution may be alledged Nat. br 25. A. vide the Writ there Diminution may be alledged in 1. The Essoin Lib. Intra 290. C. Sect. 1. 1 Hen. 7.2 2. Continuance of the Jury Lib. Intra 290. D. Sect. 2. 3. Words in title in Assize Lib. intra 290. D. sect 3. or any thing material in the body of the Record Diminution shall not be alledged upon a Bill sealed because the bill is not of Record 11 Hen. 4.52 Hull 65. but is given in to the Court by him that takes the exceptions 3. After in nullo est erratum pleaded in another Term the Plaintiff may not alledge Diminution Diminution 28 Hen. 6.11
for then he hath pleaded to the Record as it is and acknowledged it to be rightly removed But the Defendant may 28 Hen. 6.11 for he hath done nothing to conclude himself But per 7 Edw. 4.25 Error 45. the Defendant may not Q. But Coke 5. part 37. B. Bishops case after in nullo est erratum pleaded no Diminution shall be alledged by either party for if it should be suffered it would cause great delay The Plaintiff to the Writ before that he assigns Errors or a Scire facias ad audiend errores may alledge diminution and by this means the Defendant may not afterwards alledge Diminution 16 Eliz. Dyer 330. pl. 18. vide 13 Hen. 4 Error 92. because it is done already and it seems it may not be twice done But note Note that the Defendant after that he had rejoyned in the Writ alledged Diminution No. Lib. Intr. 232. B. Q. The Plaintiff may not alledge Diminution for any Error in fact after a Scire facias awarded 22 Edw. 4.45 but only for matter in Law for the Scire facias admits the matter of fact to be right The Assignment of Errors 1. by whom 2. at what time 3. upon what Record 4. of what things Assignment of Errors is in place of a Declaration 9 Edw. 4.32 for therein the Plaintiff declares why the Defendant should not have execution upon his Judgment Assign Errors If one brings a Writ of Error and he and another assign Errors this is good as to him that brought the Writ of Error and void as to the other for that was but superfluous but if two brought error and one assign errors this is not good to either because the Writ was joynt Mich. 9 Jac. in the Chequer Chamber Shakely versus Porter Conusor of a Fine shall not assign error in the Conusance to reverse his own Fine Conusor which is his own act neither the Conusee in the Grant and Render which is his act neither the Recoverer in the Recovery Coke 5. part 39. B. for they ought not to defeat but to maintain their own acts Executor in Error by him upon a Judgment given against him Executor shall not assign for error that the debt was but upon a simple Contract Com. 182. A. 10 Hen. 6.24 for he might have pleaded it in barr of the Action Party shall not shew error in Process Party unless he shews that it is for his advantage in his prosecution 7 Edw. 3.25 Coke 8. part 59. A. Nat. br 21. F. But may afterwards shew that the Judgment is erroneous by reason of such Error Coke 8. part 59. A. Beechers case 14 Eliz. Dyer 315. pl. 99. and then is his proper time to do it Reversioner not being made a party shall not assign for Error Reversioner that the Sheriff made a warrant to the Baily to make a pannel where the party was guisdable 3 Hen. 4.6 for the trial concerns him not The Successor shall assign for error Successor that his Predecessor was but named Gardein 15 Edw. 3. Error 7. where he ought to have been otherwise named Error shall be assigned before a Scire facias shall be awarded 24 Edw. 3.31 pl. 8. Scire fac for that is the ground of the Scire facias For after a Scire facias awarded the Plaintiff cannot assign error in deed 22 Edw. 4.45 for upon the return of the Scire facias the Defendant is to come in and to hear the errors assigned upon the Record Upon a Judgment given upon a Demurrer in Law and a Writ to enquire of dammages awarded Demurrer and a Writ to enquire of dammages awarded a Writ of Error was brought and he assigned errors 17 Edw. 3.5 and good as it seems Quaere tamen If the Record and the Writ of Error do not agree Error cannot be assigned upon that Record Record Error cannot be assigned upon that Record 9 Hen. 6.4 2 Eliz. Dyer 180. pl. 48. 28 Hen. 6.11 for it shall not be judged to be the same upon which the Writ of Error was brought New Writ of Error If the Writ of Error be faulty in substance errors shall not be assigned upon the Record but shall have a new Writ Quod coram vobis residet 3 Hen. 6.3 26.5 Mariae Dyer 164. pl. 58. that is upon the Record which is removed and remains where the new Writ is brought False Judgment But if it be false Judgment then there must be a new Writ to the Suitors who were the Judges for it is not of Record 3 Hen. 6.26 Error without a day If Error be put without a day there shall be a new Writ before that error be assigned 26 Hen. 6. Scire facias 33. Nat. bâ— 20. G. for the old Writ is null and so the Judgment stands as if no writ had been brought Bill sealed Upon a Bill sealed a man shall assign error per Westm 2. cap. 31. 11 Hen. 4.52 27 Hen. 8.15 25. Coke 9. part 13. B. Dowmans case 9 Assize 8. 14 Hen. 4.15 4 Hen. 6.15 A. Martin 33 Hen. 6.34 Littleton pl. 9. 7 Hen. 6.37 10 Hen. 7.8 And if the bill is refused to be sealed the party shall have a writ to compel them to seal it Regist orig 182. A B. But by Hill Justice it is intended of a thing pleaded in Court for otherwise it shall not be sealed for the Judges are not to take notice of it Challenge in an Assize was put in a bill sealed Challenge and good 9 Assize 8. 21 Edw. 4.11 20 Edw. 3.63 Lib. Intra 346. C. 27 Hen. 8.24 25. Priviledge claimed and not allowed Priviledge there may be a bill sealed 22 Edw. 4. Priviledge 1. Conusance claimed Conusance if the plea be challenged by one that is not party there cannot be a bill sealed 20 Edw. 3. Conusance 46. for it concerns him not A Patent to three to take an Assize where two take it there may be a bill sealed Patent and error upon it 29 Assize 42. 11 Hen. 92. Assize Bill sealed the Tenant shews that the Sheriff was beyond Sea and had a bill sealed of it 1. Although the bill did bear date after the Record removed yet it is good 2. Although the party did not bring it within the bill but the Justices yet good 3. The party shall have a writ to the Justices commanding them to seal it where they do refuse to do it 4. A writ to the Justices ad cognoscenda sigilla vid. antea 5. Two Justices seal it yet one of them may deliver it for the sealing not the delivery is the principal matter 6. The party brought a Scire facias ad cognoscend sigilla before the Justices come in Court yet good for after that they come the bill was of Record ab initio and so the Scire facias may have a good relation Upon a transcript of the note of a Fine error shall be assigned
his Age proved But if he come to full age it is not for then he is not in the same condition as he was when he levied the Fine 17 Edw. 3.53 pl. 33. Greene 17 Assize pl. 17. no◠can it be so well tried And although the other ject a protection yet if the Infant be inspected when he comes to full age he shall have the benefit of his nonage 22 Edw. 3.6 pl. 24. 21 Assize pl. 10. for the Infant could not proceed to reverse the Fine during his Infancy by reason of the protection Feme Covert Feme Covert as Feme sole levies a Fine this shall bind all but the Husband Coke 7. part 8. Bedfords case 17 Edw. 3.52 78. 7 Hen. 4.23 because as to him she was covert and could not act without him though not in respect of others But if the Husband enters and dies Husband the Fine is void without more suit to all parties concerned Coke 7. part 8. Bedfords case 7 Hen. 4.2.23 for that shews his disagreement to his Wives act But if living the former Husband and she take a second Husband and they levy a Fine this is utterly void because the second Marriage is void 7 Hen. 4.24 B. Gascoign 9 Hen. 6.34 B. pl. 3. This was before the Statute of Jac. against having two wives or two husbands Note Note when a thing is amendable before the Writ of Error brought it is amendable as well after and this by a Superiour Court as well as an Inferiour Court Coke 8. part 162. A. Blackamores case for the Writ of Error doth not hinder such amendments Note Note that those things that are not amendable and yet vicious are Errors at this day for there is no other way to redress them When Judgment is given but not upon a verdict of 12. upon Issue joyned there are 7 Errors not amendable Coke 8. part 162. A. Blackamores case as upon a Judgment by default by Nihil dicit non sum informatus or upon a Demurrer c. Vid. some alterations by a late Statute temps Caroli Secundi concerning Errors Want of the Original Writ 1. Original No. Lib. Intra 246. D. Misprision of the form of the Original 2. Form false Latin in it or variance from the Register Material variance between the Original and the Count or Declaration 3. Count. as C.W. in the Writ and W. W. in the Count Coke 5. part 37. Bishops case Jeosail 4. Pleading fault of Colour insufficient pleading or some default of the person or of his Counsel Error or misprision of the Judges in another Term Misericordia pro Capiatur è contra Coke 8. part 59. A. 41 Eliz. Dyer 315. pl. 99. Want of warrant of Attorney 6. Warrant Error in pleas of the Crown and Appeals 7. Appeal or in proceedings upon them they are not amendable for they are excepted out of the Statute of Amendments and also Error in the exigent to make one to be outlawed Coke 8. part 162. A. Blackamores case Br. 10. This is in favour of life and liberty and property What things are amendable after verdict 1. Material variance When Judgment is given upon a verdict of 12. men upon issue joyned there are 10. Misprisions not to be remedied or amended Coke 8. part 163. Blackamores case Material variance between the Original and the Count Coke 5. part 37. Bishops case The Original is Barbara and the Count is Barbaria this is erroneous Mich. 9 Jac. Ban. Regis Harrison Fettiplace for they are two several names and so may be two several persons Waste brought in Burrum Appleby and Flackbridge and the Count is of waste made in Burrum Appleby Flackbridge Park in Langton and it is variance because there is more in the Count than in the Writ Hill 12 Jac. Com. Ban. Countess of Cumberlands case and so it may not be for one and the same matter When the Original and the Count differs in the substance Coke 5 part 45. Husband and wife brought debt or an Action for rent due to them where it was due to the wife before Coverture this is aided by the Statute and good after verdict Trin. 9 Jac. Ban. Regis Peore versus Boule Hill 36. Eliz. Ban. Regis Rot. 610. Griffin versus Elliot Ejectione firmae wants vi armis this is but a fault in form and shall not stay Judgment after Verdict and then it was also said that these words are not material for it may be without them 7 Hen. 6.4 17 Edw. 3.1 Q. 3. Misprision of the Visne When the Venue is mistaken The Issue was that within the Mannor of Wargrave and it was of the Mannor of Wafield demisable by Copy of Court Roll c. the Venue was of the Mannor of Wargrave and good because the issue was upon the Custome within the Mannor of Wargrave Coke 11. part 18. A. Nevils case but if one Mannor was in one County and another in another then it is otherways Mich. 11 Jac. Ban. Regis in the same case for then that Jury could not try the issue 1. Trin. 11 Jac. Ban. Regis Morton versus Orde resolved in a Writ of Error 1. Infancy during Nonage shall be tried by the Justices by inspection and other proof in Court Coke 9. part 30. 17 Edw. 2. Account 122. 46 Edw. 3.8 48 Edw. 3.11 14 Hen. 4. after Nonage by a Jury 2. If it be doubtful to the Justices the Infant and the Witnesses shall be examined in Court 25 Edw. 3.42 50 Edw. 3.5 3. If he be of full age in Actions reals it viz. the Issue shall be tried where the Land lies 21 Edw. 3.28 38 Edw. 3.17 44 Assize 10. 46 Edw. 3.7 13 Hen. 4.3 19 Hen. 6.51 for the Land is the principal matter 4. If it be an Action personal as Ejectione firmae it shall be tried where the Action is brought 21 Edw. 3.7 3 Hen. 6.40 34 Hen. 6.50 and so it was adjudged because it is transitory and not fixt to a place 4. Sheriffs Retorn When the Retorn is by the Sheriff where it ought to be by the Coroners or è converso for such is no retorn because made by a wrong Officer When the Sheriff puts not his name to the Retorn of the Jury 5. Jury as he ought to do for else it cannot be known to be his Retorn 6. Venire facias When there is no Retorn indorsed upon the Venire facias so if the name of the Sheriff be not put to the Writ of Inquiry of Dammages Mich. 9. Jac. in the Chequer Chamber Shackly versus Porter for these are things of substance When one gives the Verdict that was not returned in the Venire facias 7. Verdict though he be sworn When it appears to the Court by all the Record 8. Action that the Plaintiff had no cause of Action for the Court is to judge of the Record In Appeal 9. Crown or Pleas of
the Crown or in any proceedings upon them Antea Statutes penal Or to the Writ Bill or Action Informations upon popular or penal Statutes 10. Law Judgment Error in Law by misprision of the Judges in the judgment entred in another term Coke 5. part 57. B. Specots case but in the same term it may because all that term the judgment is in the breast of the Judges Action upon the Case in Cur. Wallingford the judgment was quod defend capiatur this is Error being but an Action upon the case Trin. 9 Jac. Ban. Regis Northcot versus Heywood for the Judge ought to be defendens in misericordia for it is capiatur only where the Action is vi armis in respect of the fine to the King Concessum est pro Consideratum est Concessum est where it should be Consideratum est this is Error although there are 21. Presidents in my Lord Cokes Reports to the contrary for by Man Secondary the Books are false printed Mich. 8. Jac. Ban. Regis Rot. 641. and by Williams if it be videbitur Curiae this is erroneous for the Court is not to vary from their forms in such high matters as Judgment are If it be Capiatur against the Defendant in an Ejectione firmae Mich. 8 Jac. Ban. Regis Rot. 232. Dolby versus Holbrook it is error for it should be ideo in misericordia JurisdictioÌ„ of Court It is ordained per 27 Eliz. cap. 8. that if Error be brought in the Chequer upon a judgment in Ban. Regis they shall not assign it in the Jurisdiction of the Court or in form of the Writ Return Plaint Bill Declaration Pleading Process Verdict or Proceedings but only insist upon the matter in Law And also there is a Proviso that it shall be in Debt Detinue Account Covenant Ejectione firmae Traverse Action upon the Case and not in other Actions of a higher nature In process The party cannot shew Error in Process in delay of the Defendant unless he shew that it is for his disadvantage and that he is injured thereby 7 Edw. 3.25 Coke 8. part 59. A. Beechers case Nothing that is done contrary to the Office of a Judge shall be assigned for Error Judge Nat. br 21. B. 7 Hen. 7.4 for their Authority shall not be questioned this way Granting of Aid where it should not be is not Error so of Receipt 7 Edw. 4.12 21 Edw. 4.65 B. 5 Hen. 7.8 8 Hen. 7.9 11. 14 Hen. 6.5 pl. 25. but if it be denied where it ought to be granted it is Error for none is prejudiced by the former but by the latter the Defendant is prejudiced So of Garnishment 14 Edw. 4.1 pl. 3. So of making of an Attorney Nat. br 22. D. 21 Edw. 4.77 But denial of Aid or Receipt Visne where it ought to be is Error Edw. 4.65 B. 5 Hen. 7.8 8 Hen. 7.9 vid. antea When the Visne is mistaken Visne it is error for there is no right trial In Replevin Replevin the Defendant prescribes to have all the Pasture of such a place in W. except Common for the Inhabitants of D. and the Prescription being traversed the Jury was of the Visne of W. only and this was ruled good in Error brought because the words of exception to the Inhabitants of D. was void therefore this was not put in issue Trin. 11 Jac. Ban. Regis Wicker versus Stockeman and so nothing in Dale was put in issue In waste In Waste brought the Issue was for certain Oaks cut for repairing of the Castle of Burrum the Visne was of the Village of Burrum where it should have been of the Castle of Burrum this is Erâ—or Hill 12 Jac. Com. Ban. the Countess of Cumberlands case for a Castle and a Village are two different places Trover Conversion Trover and Conversion brought in Coventry upon not guilty pleaded the Visne was De Vicineto Civitatis Coventriae and this shewed in arrest of judgment sed non allocatur and error upon in brought and it seems that by Williams and Yelverton Justices that it is error for it should be of Coventry for Vicinetum is of the Neighborhood of Coventry and excludes the City and the Sheriff of the Country ought to make it out 7 Hen. 6.36 B. 4 Edw. 4.39 7 Hen. 4.12.80 Inquest 36. Quare tamen for the Court did advise about bringing of a new Action and did not determine the Question Pasch 9. Jac. Ban. Regis Procter versus Clifton Trespass for lopping of Wood in Hurslay Trespass the Defendant pleads that the place is parcel of the Mannor of Mamden in the Parish of Hurslay and the Custom is that the Copy-holder may cut c. and found for the Plaintiff and the Visne was of Hurslay and it was moved that it was not good for the Parish is not certain because it may comprehend more Villages but it was good per Curiam because Hurslay shall be taken to be a Village and Parish and shall not be intended that there are more Villages in one Parish except it be shewed 5 Edw. 3.20 Mich. 9. Jac. Ban. Regis Brocke versus Spencer Condition to pay money Hill 9. Jac. Ban. Regis Savil Cavendish Condition to pay money in the Church porch of the Parish of H. and pleads performance the Visne was of H. and yet good for as it seems the Village and Parish shall be intended all one and the Parish shall not be intended to comprehend more Villages Debt upon an Obligation to perform Covenants Obligation and declares of the breaking of the Condition because a stranger recovered the Land at Westminster upon a good title where the Land lies in Com. Berks the Defendant said that it was by Covin without this that it was upon a good Title the Plaintiff said that it was upon a good Title the Visne shall be of the County of Berks where the Issue is joined upon the good Title and where the Land lies but contrary if the issue be joined upon the Covin for that is alledged at Westminster but it was said if it were a personal Action it shall be where the Recovery is alledged Mich. 9. Jac. Ban. Regis Hansaker versus Kirby Ejectione firmae of Land in S T the Defendant pleads a Feoffment of the Land by Deed at S. the Plaintiff said non feoffavit Ejectment c. the Visne was of S. and T. and good for the alledging of the Feoffment at S is idle for it cannot be but upon the Land which is alledged to be in S. and T. Mich. 9. Jac. Ban. Regis and so the Venue is rightly laid there Debt for 20 l. the Defendant pleads that at another time the Plaintiff sued him in London Debt in such a Parish for the same debt and shews the Record certain c. and that he had execution in another Parish c. the Plaintiff said that it was in debt for another
20 l. for the which execution was awarded absq hoc that the plaint and the execution was for the same 20 l. yet the Visne shall be in both Parishes because the issue is as well of the execution as of the plaint 5 Edw. 4.110 A vouches B who vouches C and after issue tried the former Vouchee viz. B. dies this shall not be pleaded in arrest of judgment against A but it is error if judgment be given 21 Hen. 7.80 pl. 1. Crooke but if A die it shall abate the Writ in facto ibidem because he is Defendant and so no judgment can be given In detinue against A he prays garnishment against B which comes and pleads and they are at issue A dies the Writ abates ibidem Bar in Error No bar to say that the former Writ depending Feofment the Plaintiff did infeoff another for he remains Tenant notwithstanding the Feoffment 21 Edw. 3.53 20 Assize 2. 12 Assize 41. Coke 1. part 111. Albanyes case because the Feoffment was made pendente lite In nullo est erratum In nullo est erratum a good Bar 28 Hen. 6.10 9 Edw. 4.32 15 Eliz. Dyer 321. pl. 21. For it destroys the very supposal of the Writ But note upon Error in Deed this is no plea. 7 Edw. 4.16 9 Edw. 4.32 3 Edw. 6. Dyer 65.2 Mariae Dyer 104. pl. 10. Lib. intra 288. D. sect 1.289 D. sect 1. No. Lib. intra 233. B. because that doth not appear upon the Record Release of Errors is a good Bar Release 20 Edw. 3. Error 2. Littleton 116 B. Coke 8. part 152. Althams case 6 Hen. 4.8 pl. 36. 5 Edw. 4.96 B. For the release of Errors makes the judgment good were it never so vicious But a release of Actions reals and personals it is no Bar in error of an Outlawry Coke S. part 152. Littleton 116. B. For the Outlawry concerns the Commonwealth which interest cannot be released by a private person If the Defendant be outlawed in Redisseisin a release of all demands is no Bar because the Original and the Judgment are the process upon the Outlawry 11 Hen. 4.6 The Release of the Vouchee shall bar the Tenant 17 Edw. 2. Error 90. for the Tenant recovers in value against him Release of Errors by Tenant in Tail is no bar to the issue although it be tried against the Tenant in Tail 3 Eliz. Dyer 188. pl. 9. For the issue in Tail is not bound by the judgment for the issues derives paramount the tenant in Tail viz. performam doni But if he in reversion in Tail disseises Tenant in Dower and suffers an erroneous Recovery and Tenant in Dower releases with warranty and dies this is a good Bar Coke 3. part 60 61. Lincolne Colledge case because the recovery cut off the entail A Release of one bars another when two are to recover a personal thing in respect of their joint-interest but when they are to dischage themselves it is otherwise Coke 6. part 25. Ruddocks case As where an Action is brought against two jointly to one thing it seems if one confess the Action this shall not bind the other If an Action be brought against two jointy and a judgment is thereupon had against them and one of them releaseth errors this shall not hinder the other to bring a Writ of Error because he is to be charged by the judgment The King brought Error Scisune it is no plea that his Ministers have seized the Land unless the King agree to it 39 Assize pl. 18. For the King shall not be bound by the Act of his Officers without his consent Yet Q. if it be done by an Officer of Record The Judgment in Error 1. For the Plaintiff 2. For the Defendant 3. For both In Error two things are to be done 1. To reverse the judgment 2. That the party be restored to all that he lost by reason of the judgment 9 Hen. 6.47 B. Martin Coke 5. part 39. B. Tayes case Q. Whether he shall be satisfied for all his dammages It seems he shall The judgment was that the Plaintiff should not be restored to the Land Assise with the mean profits 11 Hen. 4 93. pl. 49. Q. For a several Action lies for the mean profits And 8 Hen. 6.2 A. Rolfe that he shall recover the Land and the Issues of the Land that is the profits Information upon Intrusion The judgment was Quod judicium reversetur adunlletur quod Defendens de intrasione intrusione transgressione contemptu convincatur à possessione amoveatur capiatur c. quodque recordum mittatur in Scaccarium pro executione habenda c. Coke 1. part 40. A. Altonwoods case The Action and judgment were in the Exchequer In a Quare Impedit that former judgment should be void Quare impedit and the Plaintiff restored to all that he lost 18 19 Eliz. Dyer 353. pl. 30. Gardein recovers in a Quare Impedit in right of the Ward the Defendant at full age of the Ward brought error and a Scire facias against the Ward the Ward entitles himself by his ancient right and found for him 1. The judgment shall be reversed against the Gardein and yet the Defendant shall not be restored because he is barred by the plea of the Ward 9 Hen. 6.47 B. Newton The judgment was that the judgment shall be reversed Redisseisin and that the Plaintiff be restored to the Land and to the issues taken in the mean time 9 Hen. 4.6 pl. 19. that is to the mean profits of the Land taken pendente lite The judgment was upon an Utlawry in felony Utlawry that the Utlawry should be reversed and he restored at the common Law to all that he had lost by this cause 11 Hen. 4.53 pl. 32. 7 Hen. 4.40 B. And that he should be restored at the Common Law to that he had lost 3 Eliz. Dyer 196. pl. 39. viz. by reason of the Owtlawry Error by Executors of the Testators being utlawed was that the Utlawry be reversed and that they shall be restored to the goods of their Testator seized by reason of it 11 Hen. 4.65 pl. 22. It shall be Quod judicium redditum staret in omni robore per Coke Chief Justice Pasc 12. Jac. Ban. Regis Sir John Heydons case and yet 21 Edw. 4.44 A. was quod judicium redditum remanebit stabile in perpetuum nor the form is let judgment be affirmed Et ulterius concessum est quod praedictus A recuperet versus praefat This is the Judgment for dâ—mnâ—ges B. 10. l. eidem A. per Curiam Domini Regis hic adjudicat juxta formam Statuti inde nuper edit c. promisis costagiis dampnis suis quae sustinuit occasione dilatationis executionis praedict praetextu prosecutionis dicti brevis Domini Regis de errore c. Lib. intra 244. B. sect 8. 292. B By the Statute of 3 Hen 7. cap. 10. if error be sued before execution and afterwards be discontinued by default of the party that brings it or he be nonsuited or judgment affirmed the other shall recover his costs and dammages by the discretion of the Judges An Infant and another levie a Fine this may be reversed to the Infant by a Writ of Error but it shall be good against the other Coke 1. part 76. B. Bredons case No. Lib. intra 255. C. sect 11. For the Fine shall stand good as far as by Law it may But if the Husband and Wife levy a Fine of the Land of the Wife and they reverse it for Error they shall be restored forthwith because the Husband is joyned with his Wife but for conformity Coke 2. part 77. B. Cromwels case For the Estate passeth only from the Wife Though Execution be reversed the judgment is yet good Coke 5. part 32. Pettifers case and a new Execution may be taken out A Fine reversed for fault in the Proclamations only remains a good Fine at the common Law for the other is but a Discontinuance 4 Eliz. Dyer pl. 54. and is nothing to vitiate the Fine Execution in Error Lib. intra 307. C. sect 1. FINIS
29. Nov. 1677. I do allow the Reprinting the SVRVEY OF THE LAW as it is now Corrected and Inlarged Fra North. THE COMMON LAW EPITOMIZ'D WITH Directions how to Prosecute and Defend Personal Actions Very useful for all Lawyers Justices of Peace and Gentlemen To which is annexed The nature of a Writ of ERROR and the general proceedings thereupon WITH A plain TABLE for the easie finding out of every particular By William Glisson and Anthony Gulston Esquires Baristers at Law The Second Edition revised explained and much enlarged by W. S. of the Inner-Temple Esquire Good communicated doubles it self Vivere nemo Nunc sine Lite solet nec sine Lege potest LONDON Printed by the Assigns of Rich. and Edw. Atkins Esq for Hen. Brome and Tho. Basset and are to be sold at the Gun in St. Pauls Church-yard and at the George in Fleetstreet MDCLXXIX The Epistle Dedicatory TO THE Professors Practisers OF THE COMMON LAW OF ENGLAND Candid Reader THis Tract in French was bequeathed to me by an alliance William Glisson Esquire deceased which I have translated into our own Language for the Common benefit of all I am not singular in it for daily experience manifests the contrary neither is it a Novelty for Law-books to appear in this dress Antiquity may be pleaded Sr. Germin Perkins Stanford Crompton Lambert Sir Henry Finch Dalton and divers others have in former days troden this path My desires are that it may not be perused by those who read only to fault what they cannot mend but by those whose judicious Pen will correct the errors as Cognizances of humane frailty I wish it successful to all be he Pleader or Practiser and that the Common Law of England may shine forth in these Cloudy and Eclipsed days is the Prayer of him who is Stâ—ple Iune January 20th 1658. A Well-wisher to the Laws HEN. APPLEGARTH To the READER Ingenuous Reader THese ensuing Lines were not fixed to this Treatise to commend its worth unto thee for if I can judge rightly it needs them not as I doubt not but thou wilt confess upon the perusal of it And this made me some years past take some pains in correcting many Errataes of the Press and explaining many obscurities I met with and in shewing the reason of the Law in many places without any other aim than my own private satisfaction But since that understanding an intent of Re-printing of the Copy I thought it not amiss to impart what I had done to the Undertakers thereof not only for their benefit but for the Readers clearer information and easier understanding of the greater variety of the matters therein contained and in the former Edition very briefly and in many places obscurely set forth If my pains herein may prove profitable to any I shall think it well bestowed however I shall rest satisfied with this perswasion That neither the Printers nor Readers can be prejudiced by these my well intended endeavours William Style THE CONTENTS OF THE BOOK 1. Accompt 2. Case Assumpsit 3. Trover 4. Covenant 5. Detinue 6. Debt 7. Ejectment 8. Quare Impedit ne admittas quare non admisit quare incumbravit 9. Replevin 10. Trespass 11. Error VVherein is plainly set down and demonstrated 1. What their several natures are 2. How many fold they are 3. In what Court they most properly lye 4. Who may best bring them 5. Against whom they lye 6. For what causes they lye 7. What be good Pleas and Barrs to the several Actions 8. What Judgements and Executions may be given in them The TABLE Account ACcount Fol. 1 Account against a Guardian in Soccage Fol. 1 In what Court Account lieth against a Guardian in Soccage Fol. 1 Who shall have a Writ against Guardian in Soccage Fol. 2 Against what person Account lieth as Guardian in Soccage Fol. 3 For what things Account lieth Fol. 4 The Account against a Guardian Soccage Fol. 5 The Process against a Guardian Soccage 1. before appearance 2. after appearance Fol. 6 Bar by a Guardian in Soccage 1. to the Action of Account 2. before Auditors Fol. 7 The Judgment against a Guardian in Soccage 1. of Account 2. to recover the thing Fol. ib. Execution against a Guardian in Soccage 1. per Common Law 2. per Statute Law Fol. 8 Ex parte talis Fol. ib. Account against a Baily 1. of a Court or Hundred 2. of a Mannor-house c. Fol. 9 In what Court it lies against a Baily Fol. ib. Who shall have an Account against a Baily 1. of a Court 2. of a Mannor Fol. ibid. Against whom an Account lieth as Baily 1. of a Court or Hundred 2. of a Mannor c. Fol. 12 For what things Account lieth against a Baily 1. of a Court 2. of a Mannor Fol. 14 The Account against a Baily 1. Of a Court or Hundred 2. of a Mannor c. Fol. 15 The Writs against a Baily 1. of a Court or Hundred 2. of a Mannor c. Fol. 16 The Process against a Baily 1. before appearance 2. after appearance Fol. 18 Bar to a Baily 1. to an Action of an Account 2. before Auditors Fol. 19 Judgment against a Baily 1. of Account 2. to recover the thing Fol. 21 Execution against a Baily 1. per Common Law 2. per Statute Law Fol. ibid. Ex parte talis by a Baily Fol. 22 Account against a Receiver 1. In Law 2. in Deed Fol. 23 Against whom Account lies as Receiver Fol. 26 For what things Account lieth against a Receiver Fol. 29 The Account against a Receiver 1. by others hands 2. by his own hands Fol. ibid. The Judgment against a Receiver 1. of Account 2. of a Receiver Fol. 37 The Writ against a Receiver Fol. 38 The Process against a Receiver 1. before appearance 2. after Fol. 39 Bar by a Receiver 1. to an Action of Account 2. before Auditors Fol. 41 Execution against a Receiver 1. per Common Law 2. per Statute Law Fol. 43 Action upon the Case QUid Quotuplex In what Câ—urt it lieth Fol. 46 For doing of wrong to the dammage of another touching things hereditary Fol. 47 Against whom this lieth Fol. 49 For what things this Action lies Fol. 51 The Writ Fol. 62 The Process 1. before appearance 2. after Fol. ib. The Judgment Fol. 63 For what things it lies For. ib. For doing of wrong to the dammage of another touching his body Fol. 69 For doing a thing to the dammage of another touching his name which is slander Fol. 72 For the doing wrong to the dammage of another touching suits in Law Fol. 83 For not doing that which ought to be done by the Law touching a thing hereditary to the dammage of another Fol. 91 For not doing of things which ought to be done by the Law to the dammage of another concerning Chattels Fol. 95 For the not doing of a thing which ought to be done by the Law to the dammage of another touching his body Fol.
96 For not doing of a thing that ought to be done by the Law to the dammage of another touching suits in Law Fol. 97 Assumpsit FOr the not doing of a thing which ought to be done by the agreement of the party to the dammage of another touching things hereditary Fol. 98 Assumpsit quid Quotuplex Fol. ib. General Bar Fol. 99 For not doing of a thing which ought to be done by the agreement of the parties touching Chattels Fol. 102 The Judgment Fol. 114 The Writ Fol. ibid. For not doing a thing which is to be done by agreement touching the body Fol. 115 The Writ Fol. ibid. For not doing a thing which is to be done by agreement of the parties touching suits in Law Fol. 116 For not doing a thing where a man is bound to do it in one manner and he doth it in another Fol. ibid. For negligent suffering a thing to be done to the dammage of another Fol. 117 Bar Fol. 118 For deceit in bargains and agreements with warrant Fol. 122 For deceit in bargains and agreements without warranty Fol. 124 Trover and Conversion QUid Quotuplex Fol. 125 Of what things it lies Fol. 126 Covenant IN what Court Covenant lies 1. personal 2. real Fol. 131 Who shall have a Covenant 1. personal 2. real Fol. 132 Against whom Covenant lies 1. personal 2. real Fol. 137 The Count in Covenant 1. personal 2. real Fol. 145 Writ in Covenant 1. personal 2. real Fol. 147 The Process in Covenant 1. before appearance 2. after Fol. 148 Bar in Covenant 1. personal 2. real Fol. 149 Judgment in Covenant 1. personal 2. real Fol. 150 Detinue 1. QUid Fol. 154 2. Quotuplex ib. In what Court detinue lies 1. of Chattels 2. of Deeds for Landâ— Fol. 155 Who shall have a Detinue 1. of Chattels 2. of Deeds Fol. ibid. Against whom Detinue lies 1. of Chattels 2. of Deeds Fol. 163 For what things Detinue lies 1. of Chattels 2. of Deeds Fol. 167 Count in Detinue 1. of Chattels 2. of Deeds Fol. 169 The Writ in Detinue 1. of Chattels 2. of Deeds Fol. 173 The Process in Detinue 1. before appearance 2. after Fol. 174 The Garnishment in Detinue 1. of Chattels 2. of Deeds Fol. 175 Enterpleader in Detinue 1. Of Chattels 2. Of Deeds Fol. 176 Bar in Detinue 1. Of Chattels 2. Of Deeds Fol. 178 Execution in Detinue 1. Of the Defendant 2. against The Judgment in Detinue 1. Of Chattels 2. Of Deeds Fol. 182. the Garnishee 3. of what Lands 4. of what Goods Fol. 184 Debt DEbt in what Court it lies Fol. 191 Who shall have Debt Fol. 193 Against whom Debt lies Fol. 203 For what things Debt lies Fol. 216 Judgment in Debt Fol. 227 The Writ in Debt 1. in the County 2. in Com. Ban. Fol. 234 The Process in Debt 1. before appearance 2. after Fol. 239 The Bar in Debt Fol. 240 The Judgment in Debt Fol. 265 Execution in Debt Fol. 269 Ejectment IN what Court it lies Fol. 272 Who shall have an Ejectione firmae Fol. 273 Against whom Ejectment lies Fol. 276 Of what things an Ejectment lies Fol. 278. The Count generally Fol. 281 The Writ Fol. 283 The Process 1. before appearance 2. after Fol. ibid. The Bar. Fol. 284 The Judgment Fol. 285 Quare Impedit QVid Fol. 286 In what Court it lies Fol. 287 Who shall have a Quare Impedit Fol. 288 Against whom a Quare Impedit lies Fol. 311 Quare Impedit of what disturbance it lies Fol. 312 Quare Impedit of what things it lies Fol. 313 The Count in Quare Impedit Fol. 315 The process in Quare Impedit 1. before appearance 2. after Fol. 317 Barr in a Quare Impedit 1. by the Ordinary 2 by others Fol. 319 Good causes of refusal in a Quare Impedit Fol. 322 These are not Fol. ib. These are likewise good causes of refusal Fol. 323 Who shall plead plenarty and who not Fol. 327 Against whom plenarty was is no plea Fol. 328 Judgement in a Quare Impedit 1. when be shall have Judgement 2. of what things he shall have Judgement Fol. 330 The Writ to the Bishop to whom it shall be directed Fol. 334 Process in the writ to the Bishop Fol. 336 Of what things a man shall have Judgement Fol. ib. A Writ to the Bishop and single dammages Fol. 338 A Writ to the Bishop and double dammages Fol. 340 Single dammages and no Writ to the Bishop Fol. ib. Double dammages and no writ to the Bishop Fol. 341 Two writs to the Bishop Fol. ib. In what Court and what Judges have power to award a writ to the Bishop Fol. 342 Ne Admittas WHat person shall have it Fol. 342 In what cases it lies Fol. ib. Within what time this ought to be brought Fol. 343 The Writ Fol. 344 The Process Fol. ib. Quare non Admisit OVt of what court this issues Fol. ib. What person shall have it Fol. 345 Against whom it lies Fol. ib. In what case it lies Fol. 346 The Writ Fol. ib. The Count. Fol. 347 The Bar. Fol. ib. The Judgement Fol. 348 Quare Incumbravit IN what Court it shall be brought Fol. 348 What person shall have it Fol. 349 Against whom it lies Fol. ib. In what cases this lies not Fol. ib. The writ Fol. 350 The Count. Fol. 351 The Process Fol. ib. The bar Fol. 352 The judgement Fol. ib. Replevin IN what Court it lies Fol. 353 Who shall have a Replevin Fol. 354 Against whom a Replevin lies Fol. 356 Of what things a Replevin lies Fol. 357 The writ Fol. 359 The process 1. of a man replevied 2. of chattels Fol. 361 Second Deliverance Fol. 362 In what case a man may distrain Fol. 364 Of what things a man may distrain Fol. 369 What person shall distrain Fol. 373 At what time a man may distrain Fol. 374 In what place a man may distrain Fol. 375 What distress shall be sold Fol. 378 What shall not be said to be a distress excessive Fol. ib. 1. The Bar 2. Justification 3. Conusance 4. Avowry Fol. 379 Who shall avow Fol. 381 For what things a man may avow Fol. 384 Seifin in avowry in whom it may be alledged Fol. 386 By what hands Seisin shall be alledged Fol. 386 In what time Seisin ought to be alledged Fol. 388 When it is not requisite to alledge Seisin ib. What Seisin shall be good ib. Bar to an Advowry Fol. 390 Judgment 397 Trespass IN What Court Trespass lies Fol. 405 Who shall have Trespass Fol. 407 Against whom Trespass lies Fol. 422 For what matter Trespass lies viz. for the doing of wrong to the dammage of another 1. Touching Inheritance 2. Touching Chattels 3. Touching the body Fol. 432 Error IN what Court Error shall be redressed Fol. 453 Who shall have a Writ of Error Fol. 461 The Writ of Error Fol. 468 The Process in Error 1. upon a judgement in Ireland 2. upon a Bill sealed 3. judgement in another Court
consideration on his part A being a Copyholder makes B his Executor and intends to surrender to the intent that B should satisfie a debt to D the Son of A promises A that if he do not surrender but suffer the Land to descend he will satisfie the debt A dies B shall have an Action against the Son for it is a good consideration Hill 9 Jac. Ban. Regis Gray versus Gray yet continuing Tabling Lodging A promises to pay to B for his reasonable board for such a time as he shall be with him B shews that he was with him ten months and that 5 s. the month is reasonable amounting in all to 50 s. this is good Pasch 30 Eliz. Ban. Begis Floyd Irish A being sick in an Inne B promises to pay as much as shall be due for all necessaries that the Inn-keeper shall provide for A yet in the Action the Inn-keeper shall say generally in the Writ and Count that he did provide necessaries from such a day until c. in all to the value of 20 l. forasmuch as the promise was general the Writ and Count is good though it be not particular 2. It is inconvenient and dangerous to shew all things that he did provide c. the same Law is for Physician per Doderidge Justice Pasch 13 Jac. Ban. Regis Crips Baynton for he may not remember all particulars and so may mistake 1. For money upon the sale of any personal things Vendor 33 Hen. 8 br Action upon the Case 105 110. 2 Rich. 3.14 Com. 102. upon an indebitatus assumpsit for the Law creates a promise For in every Contract there is an assumpsit implied Coke 4. part 94. Slades case the Count needs not shew but saepius requifitus Pasch 28 Elis. Com. Ban. Q. 2. In an Action for money upon the sale of a thing he needs not count that he was possest ut de bonis propriis Trin. 7 Jac. Ban. Regis Fitz Williâ—â— Blackman viz. before the sale for the Law implies they were his else he would not have sold them 3. Against a Purveyor or Servant that bought goods for his Master and promises payment Dyer 230. pl. 56. 12 Hen. 8.12 Q. if it lies not also against the Master 4. Against him that promises to a Baker to pay so much as he shall deliver in Bread to B 29 Hen. 8.25 for it may be intended he gave B the Bread 5. Upon a promise to pay for Cloth bought iâ— B doth not 12 Hen. 8.12 for there he becomes iâ— the nature of a Surety for the payment for it 6. A brought an action and shews that he sold a Horse to B at such a day year and place to be payed at a day to come and the Defendant ad tunc ibidem ratione praemissorum assumes to pay if c. B did not this is nought for the Contract and the giving of day to B ne fuit ad instantiam of the Defendant but the Contract was compleat before Pasch 28 Jac. Ban. Regis Farmer Field without any relation to the Defendant and his promises ex post facto and grounded upon no consideration 7. A promises to pay to B such sums of money as B shall disburse of his own money for Cloth to the use of A the Defendant this is a good consideration for by the buying of the Cloth the property was in A forthwith Trin. 9 Jac. Ban. Regis Moore Moore for it was bought for him 8. A sold to B two ways of Barley for as much as he sold to others the Plaintiff in the Action ought to count 1. For what price he sold to others 2. he ought to give notice of this to B. So if A promise to B 20 l. if he marry C yet B ought to give notice of the marriage but a Tayler may have an Action for as much as he shall deserve and is not bound to give notice what he shall deserve because it is not incertain Hill 13 Jac. Ban. Regis Hall Heminge Q. for he must demand a certain sum and this is notice 1. Against a Seller of Corn to be delivered at a certain day and doth not Vendee 21 Hen. 6.55 20 Hen. 7.9.28 Hen 8. Dyer 22. pl. 138. fol. 113. pl. 55. Coke 4. part Slades case 94. B. Quaere it no damage appear 2. For delivering good and merchantable Corn and doth not 6 Edw. 2.6 Dyer 75. pl. 23. Lib. Intra 4. B. sect 2. but special dammage must be alledged The Judgment For not delivering of grain yearly quaere if the Plaintiff shall recover dammage as well pro tempore futuro quam pro praeterito 3 Mariae Dyer 113. pl. 56. Administratrix promises to pay a debt c. and the Action is brought against Baron and Feme then the judgment against him shall be general praedictus P. M. uxor ejus in misericordis Coke 9. part 93. Banies case No. Lib. Intra 2. C. Sect. 3. But upon plea that the Testator did not assume costs and dammages shall be de bonis propriis if the Testator had not sufficiâ—nt No. Lib. Intra 1. B. sect 1. for the false plea. The Writ Upon assumpsit by the Husband and Wife made to the Wife dum sola fuit the Writ shall say ad dampnum ipsorum for the Husband shall have the dammages ideoque fuit ad dampnum ipsorum Hill 9 Jac. Ban. Regis Wolverton and his Wise against Day For not doing a thing which ought to be done by Agreement touching the body 1. Against a Barber that takes upon him to raze the Beard Barber and doth it with an unwholsom Razor Lib. Intra 2. C. sect 1. for the body is endangered to be hurt thereby Physician or Chirurgeon 2. Against a Physician or Chirurgeon for not curing a malady or not applying a medicine 14 Hen. 6.18 43 Edw. 3.33 21 Hen. 6.55 48 Edw. 3.6 pl. 11. Regist orig 105. B. 112. A. 3. For advising his patient to apply a certain medicine to cure him and it did not 19 Hen. 6.49 quaere For commanding his Servant to apply a medicine and he doth it not 11 Edw. 4.6 Q. 4. For applying a medicine that impairs the Mayheme 11 Rich. Action upon the Case 37.11 Hen. 6.18 pl. 10. 21 Hen. 6.55 B. But note in all these cases he ought to take upon him the Cure absolutely 19 Hen. 6.49 48 Edw. 3.6 else the Action lies not The Writ The Writ ought to shew the place where he took upon him the Cure 48 Edw. 3.36 for it is issuable If A promise to cure me in London and apply unwholsom medicines in Middlesex the Action shall be in Middlesex because there was the wrong 11 Rich. 2. Action upon the Case 37 and where the wrong is there must the trial be For not doing of a thing which ought to be done by agreement of the parties touching Suits in Law Assumpsit Against a Clerk that promises
Littleton so that the bale be not broken But otherwise it lies not Nat. br 138. A. 22 Hen. 8. Dyer 22. pl. 137. for then the money cannot be known Note a Detinue was brought for one piece of Dornex of the value of 22 s. and tried at Gloucester Assizes 5 Martii 15 Jac. Q. what Judgment Vide tamen 21 Hen. 7.82 pl. 3. Detinue brought of a piece of silver Quaere what piece It lies of Rationabile parte bonorum Rationabile parte bonorum Heir 17 Edw. 3.9 pl. 29. by custome See before Custome that the Heir shall have the principal goods Detinue lies for them 30 Edw. 3.2 pl. 9. 39 Edw. 3.6 pl. 24. fol. 9. pl. 15. See before Land leased with implements Implements at the end of the term Detinue lies for them although wasted 20 Hen. 6.16 pl. 2. See before Goods lost If goods are lost Detinue lies Nat. br 138. E. against him that finds them or a Trover Goods bail Goods bailed to deliver over Detinue lies Nat. br 138. A. 18 Hen. 6.9 A. against the bailee by the party to whom they should have been bailed over See before A. bails goods to B. which are stole Detinue lies against B. for them Coke 4 part 84. Southcots case Vid. antea But if he receive them to keep as he doth his own goods and they are stole it lies not Coke 4. part 83. Southcots case 9 Edw. 4.40 pl. 22. Danby Antea Carrier loseth goods Carrier loseth goods or is robbed yet Detinue lies against him Coke 4 part 84. 2 Hen. 7.11 B. Townsend Antea A. contracts for Corn to be delivered at a day to come Corn. he shall have a Detinue at the day for this No. Lib. Intra 169. B. sect 1. for by the contract he had a property in the Corn. After divorce it lies for goods given in marriage Divorce Nat. br 139. A. 26 Hen. 8.7 pl. 1. 28 Hen. 8. Dyer 13. pl. 61. Vid. antea It lies of a Horse Cow c. or more Cows oâ— Horses Nat. br 138. A. be the number what it will It lies for the Plaintiff in Replevin Replevin for goods taken in Withernam because he from whom they were so taken had not the property in them 2 Hen. 4. br debt 51. 6 Hen. 7.8 B. Quaere if the Avowant shall have a Detinue for his goods taken in Withernam after appearance and claim of the property 11 Hen. 4.10 pl. 21. for he claim makes not the property Tender amends in Replevin The Plaintiff in a Replegiare after return irreplevisable upon tender of amends shall have a Detinue for the goods Coke 8. part 147. A. for he had the property in them 10 Eliz. Dyer 280. pl. 14. notwithstanding such Writ Vid. antea Corn. Wine A delivered B Corn and Wine c. and they perish yet Detinue lies for them Doct. Stud. 129. A. Q. what shall be recovered dammages â—t videtur But if it be a thing that be to be redelivered Horse as a Horse c. if it be used in other manner than was agreed and if it perish in default of the party to whom it was delivered and Action lies Doct. Stud. 129. A. Vid. antea But if it be used but in such manner as it was agreed and it perish but not by default of the party to whom it was delivered Action lies not Doct. Stud. 129. A. Vid. antea Note Note in brevi de chartis reddendis semper debet poni cerius numerus chartarum vel scriptorum Regist orig 159. B. Nat. br 138. B. Et sic ut videtur est de aliis bonis catallis The Count in Detinue 1. Of Chattels 2. Of Deeds The Count ought to name all things certain Count. and the value 1 Rich. 3.20 A. 3 Hen. 6. viz. time and place The Count was Bailment that such a year day and place A bailed to B bona catalla c. scilicet one Cup of Silver c. ad valentiam c. salvo custodiend eidem querenti cum inde requisitus fuisset redeliber and. c. Lib. Intr. 212. B. A counts de bailment of Spoons Spoons c. ad valentiam c. Lib. Intr. 211. D. sect 2. naming the number The Count was Devenerunt Ag. Executors quod cum ipse the year day and place deliberasset W. in vita sua catalla c. posteaque praedictus W. obiit c. post ejus mortem praedictam c. devenerunt such a day year and place to the hands of the aforesaid Executors praedictus W. nec praedicti Executores c. Lib. Intra 212. C. Sect. 4. This against an Executor Per Executor Count per Executor Com. 275. A. Foxes case vid. the Count there Count upon bailment to B Trover which loses it and that the Defendant found it and yet detinet lies Lib. Intra 212. B. sect 3. for neither by the bailment nor by the losing and finding it is the property altered or divested out of the Bailor Count of a Horse found No. Lib. Intr. 169. D. Sect. 2. A counts upon a bargain for Corn to be delivered at a day to come Contract that such a day year and place he bargained for eight quarters of Corn ad valentiam to be delivered c. No. Lib. Intra 169. B. sect 1. Vid. antea by the contract the property was divested out of A. For two Obligations Obligation Lib. Intra 220. A. Sect. 1. Husband and Wife for box with deeds The Husband and Wife count that they were possessed of a Box sealed with Deeds concerning Lands of the Wife c. and lost them and they came to the hands of the Defendant such a year day and place per Trover c. Lib. Intra 209. B. Sect. 3. Count of a box with Deeds Lib. Intra 202. B. Sect. 7. Though unsealed yet it lies Q. whether he must not shew what deeds particularly Heir against husband and wife Counts that his Brother whose Heir he is was seized of Land in Fee and of a box sealed with Writings touching the Land and he lost the box and it came to the hands of the wife dum sola fâ—it and that his brother dies without issue and the Lands descended to him and that the woman takes a Husband per quod c. Lib. Intra 209. D. sect 4. the Action lay against them for the marriage gains no property where the wife had none before Heir against Executors Heir Lib. Intra 210. A. sect 5. of the Ancestor for things touching the Lands he inherits The heir in a Detinue for a box with deeds ought to count that it was sealed for otherwise it belongs to the Executors 36 Hen. 6.27 pl. 26. 39 Edw. 3.7 8. 41 Edw. 3.2 11 Hen. 49. A. Paston Q. how the sealing should make a difference And yet the sealing is not traversable 41
that he was robbed Robbery Coke 4. part 84. Southcots case 〈◊〉 Hen. 7.11 B. Townsend but they must take their remedy against the Thieves and they are by Law answerable to the owners of the goods So if goods are delivered to keep Coke 4. part 83. B. for such an acceptance implies a warranty to keep them safe and to redeliver them But it is a good plea if they are taken to keep as my own Coke 4. part 83. for there is no such warranty implied Vid. antea Recovery in Trespass a good barr in Detinue Recovery 20 Hen. 7.58 B. Crooke for there shall not be a double recovery for one thing The bailment is not traversable where he may wage his Law Travers 8 Edw. 4.3 pl. 7. for there his Oath that he detains not is sufficient for if he detains not there could be no bailment No barr that the Horse was sold in a Market overt unless it were tolled Vendee according to the Statute 1 2 Phil. Mariae cap. 7. for no property is altered by such a sale Vid. antea Detinue for Deeds as Heir Bastardy Bastardy is a good plea 35 Hen. 6.9 pl. 12. for if a Bastard he is no Heir A bailed to B to rebail and dies Feostment having two Sons which makes partition he which had the Land comprehended in the deed delivered enfeoffs B this is a good barr 17 Edw. 3.12 pl. 45. for by the purchase the deed belongs to B. Warranty and Assets is no barr against the issue in Tail in Detinue Warrant 9 Hen. 6.15 pl. 5. 4 Hen. 7.10 pl. 4. for he comes in by the Donor Rebailment in another County a good barr Rebailment because he cannot wage his Law 22 Hen. 6.15 pl. 27. because the bailment was in one County and the Action is brought in another County Release per the Plaintiff a good barr Release Lib. Intra 290. B. Sect. 1. for by the Release the property was altered The Defendant pleads bailment of deeds by the Plaintiff Retainer upon condition that if his wife the Plaintess survive the Plaintiff that the Defendant should retain it and that his wise is alive a good barr but then he ought to shew what Lands they concern 18 Edw. 4.18 that it may be known unto whom the deed belongs Infancy is no plea Infancy because he may avoid an obligation in debt 14 Hen. 6.11 pl. 41. by pleading deins age A good bar that the Garnishee brought a Detinue against the Defendant Recovery and prays Garnishment against the Plaintiff which makes default and he had judgment 34 Hen. 6.47 pl. 13. 21 Hen. 6.35 pl. 2. per Newton Garnishee pleads release between the time of this Action brought Release and the delivery quaere 20 Hen. 6.28 pl. 23. 49 Edw. 3.13 But 39 Edw. 3.13 adjudged that it is a good barr and so it seems the Law to be The Judgment in Detinue 1. Of Chattels 2. Of Deeds Against the Defendant 1. Quod praedictus W. recuperet versus praefat J. praedicta octo quarteria frumenti vel valorem eorundem No. Lib. Intra 169. C. Sect. 1. Lib. Intra 218. B. Sect. 4. dampua sua c. and upon the return of the Writ if it appears that W. did not deliver the Corn then the judgment shall be for the value with dammages and costs So see the difference where the Plaintiff himself delivers the thing and where another The Plaintiff shall have judgment to recover the thing named Plaintiff 17 Edw. 3.45 1 Rich. 3.1 2. or the value of it and dammages for detaining of it as appears above The judgment was that he should recover his Chattels and his dammages 21 Hen 6.36 A. Bracton Lib. 3. fol. 102. B. non tenetur precise ad rem restituend sed sub disjunct vel ad rem vel ad pretium either the thing or the value of it indammages Against the Defendant The judgment was that he should recover the deeds if they are found and also dâ—mmages for the detainer and if not found then all in dammages 7 Hen. 6.31 pl. 25. 22 Hen. 6.41 pl. 17. as well for the deeds as for the detainer of them And this shall be although it be proved that the Defendant burnt the deed 17 Edw. 3.45 pl. 1. for that shall not excuse Ideo confideratum est quod praedictus A. recuperet versus praefat B. pyxidem praedictam cum chartis c. Lib. Intra 218. A. Sect. 1. the box with the writings The Heir in Detinue had judgment to recover one box with as much as was in it contained that belongs to him 5 Edw. 3.159 B. intended to be of writings Against the Defendant and the Garnishee The judgment was that he should recover the deeds against the Defendant haberet liberationem versus the Garnishee 21 Hen. 6.36 A. Lib. Intra 219. D. sect 17. 9 Hen. 6.38 pl. 13.7 Hen. 6.45 pl. 27. This is a double judgment viz. of the right and of the possession But if Judgment be given upon default of the Garnishee before appearance no dammages shall be given 20 Hen. 6.4 pl. 27. for this is not the Defendants fault If the Plaintiff and Defendant make default the Garnishee shall have Judgment and the Plaintiff and Defendant in misericordia 40 Edw. 3.39 pl. 15. for his unjust vexation Execution in Detinue 1. Of Defendant 2. Against the Garnishee 3. Of what Lands 4. Of what Goods Execution against the Defendant by distress for the thing detained and recovered Chattels Nat. Lib. Intrâ— 169. C. sect 1. 20 Edw. 4.3 pl. 12. No. Lib. Intrâ— 170. D. 17. A. 6 Rich. â— Execution But if the thing be not delivered to the Plaintiff then he shall have execution for the dammages by Capias Lib. Intra 216. B. sect 6. 20 Edw. 4.3 pl. 12. against the person of the Defendant For a Capias was given in the main Process per 25 Edw. 3. cap. 17. and by consequence a Capiâ—â— ad satisfaciend in execution by the equity of that Statute At the Common Law execution was for dammages by fieri facias and also for the goods Lib. Intra 216. B. sect 8. to be levied upon the goods of the Defendant For dammages by fieri facias and for the thing by distress of the Goods and Chattels 6 Rich. 2. Execution 45. The Plaintiff and Defendant make default Garnishee had Judgment and distress against the Defendant 40 Edw. 3.39 pl. 15. Vid. antea Distress issued forth in execution Lib. Intra 215. C. sect 1. 20 Edw. 4.3 pl. 12. 22 Hen. 6.41 pl. 17. But Capias lies not 5 Eliz. Dyer 223. pl. 24. 21 Hen. 6.42 vid. antea If the deeds concern Lands 8 Hen. 6.29 pl. 24. 14 Hen. 6.1 pl. 1. But for the dammages if they will not deliver them a Capias lies 22 Hen. 6.41 pl. 17. 20 Edw. 43. pl. 12. If deeds are in a box
assets for it shall be intended unless the contrary be shewed 18 Eliz. Dyer 344. pl. 2. 11 Hen. 6.2 pl. 6. and if he have not he may plead riens per descent For nothing by descent in Fee-simple is a good bar by him Lib. Intra 172. B. Sect. 1. the day of the purchase of the Writ But debt lies not against an heir upon a Statute-Merchant Staple or Recognizance because he is not bound Coke 3. part 15. A. Harberts case but the Lands are bound and may be extended Goaler suffers an escape his heir shall not be charged 15 Eliz. Dyer 322. pl. 25. for this is a personal wrong and only dammages recoverable Grandfather Father and Son or Father and his two Sons or Grandfathers two Sons who have two Sons the heir mediate shall be sued in debt as well as if they were immediate heirs 22 Dyer 368. pl. 14.7 Eliz. Dyer 239. pl. 39. that is in case the heir immediate die for the heir mediate is bound by the word Heir A Right shall not be Assets for it is a disputable thing and no certainty of it to be reduced into possession What shall be Assets to the Heir Disselsee obliges him and his heirs and dies this is not Assets for it is but a Right descended Pasch 6. Jac. Com. Ban. Molineux versus Molineux for his Ancestor died out of possession Right without an estate in Possession Reversion or Remainder is not Assets until it be reduced into possession Coke 6. part 58. Bredimans cases and then it shall release to the time of the death of the Ancestor Land in ancient demesn shall be Assets 7 Hen. 4.14 pl. 11. Q. to whom and where pleadable Copyhold Land is not Assets to the heir Coke 4. part 22. A. for it doth not descend but depends upon the Lords admittance If an heir alien bona fide before the Action brought it shall not be Assets Coke 5. part 60. A. Gooches case 27 Edw. 3.78 pl. 16.10 Hen. 7.8 pl. 17. 19 Hen. 6.46 pl. 95. 42 Edw. 3.10 pl. 12. 48 Edw. 32. pl. 22. Vid. antea for he is not tied from sâ—lling the Land If Land descend to the heir although he enter not yet it is Assets 42 Edw. 3.10 pl. 12. for he might have entered and may do when he will the Grandfather makes a Fâ—offment in Fee to the use of the heir of his body and dies per 26 Hen. 8. the Father enters and obliges him and his heirs and dies quaere 182 Mariae Dyer 111. pl. 46. whether the Grandchild be bound A Reversion expectant upon an estate Tail is not Assets because it lies in the will of Tenant in tail to dock and barr it at his pleasure Coke 6. part 58. B. Bredimans case 42. A. Mildmays case Q. if it be Assets when it happens Franktenement descendible express is not Assets Coke 10. part 98. A. Seymors case for it is an incertain estate Rent-seck descendible is not Assets until seisin of it Coke 6. part B. Bredimans case for before seisin he hath no estate in it If the heir had Assets in debt brought against him and afterwards Assets come to his hands the first judgment is no barr of the Action 19 Hen. 6.37 A. Markham because there was no satisfaction made which may now be by matter ex post facto The profits taken by the heir at the time of the descent are sufficient and if this be shewed to the Court and the heir cannot deny it there shall be a general judgment against him per Dyer 18 Eliz Dyer 344. pl. 1. to pay the debt and dammages quod querens recuperet The heir confesses the action and says that he had nothing but a Reversion descended to him there the Plaintiff shall have judgment to recover upon the said Reversion and the Debt to be levied when it comes in possession and the Plaintiff shall have a special Writ of extent 23 Eliz. Dyer 373. pl. 14. mentioning the special matter If the Father recover and Error be brought against the Son and a recovery against him he shall not render dammages unless he hath Assets of Land in Fee-simple from his Father If one be robbed Hundred he shall have debt against the Hundred per 27 Eliz. cap. 13. antea Debt lies against a Lessee at will for rent during the Term Lessee Coke 5. part 10. antea Quaere if he hold over So against a Lessee for years Nat. br 120. H. And this during the term Coke 4. part Or after the term ended by effluction of time Coke 3. part 23. B. for rent due during the term By limitation ended By condition in Law or in deed Common Law Nat. br 120. H. Statute Law 19 Hen. 6.42 A. waste Nat. br 120. H. re-entry Coke 3. part 23. B. Walkers case 30 Edw. 3.7.17 Edw. 3.48 fol. 73. pl. 107. It lies not against Tenant for life so long as his estate continues Life Coke 4. part 49. A. 11 Hen. 6.14 pl. 4. viz. for rent for the Land is charged But yet by the Statute 32 Hen. 8. cap. 37. the Executors of a Lessor for life shall have debt during the estate for life Coke 4. part which seems but reasonable Debt lies not against the Master upon the buying of the Servant Master unless it comes to his use or by his assent Doct. Stud. 137. A. for otherwise it might be mischievous to the Master Debt lies against an Ordinary Ordinary when a man dies intestate Nat. br 120. D. Coke 5. part 83. A. Snellings case 9. part 39. B. 11 Hen. 7.12 9 Edw. 4.33 Danby 18 Hen. 6.23 com 277.8 Eliz. Dyer 247. if the goods come into the hands of the Ordinary The Ordinary administers and then grants Administration yet debt lies against the Ordinary but it was said that such Administration ought to be alledged in the Diocess of the Ordinary 12 Rich. 2. Administrator 21. else it might be prejudicial to the Creditors But note no Debt lies against the Ordinary after that he hath committed Administration to another 8 Eliz. Dyer 247. pl. 73. viz. where he never administers Debt was brought against the Father for the Sons Commons in a Colledge in Oxon although the Father had delivered it to the Tutor of the Son Pasch 9. Jac. Ban. Regis St. Johns in Oxford against Brickâ—nden for the Father and not the Tutor is hable yet quaere for this is not usually practised Debt lies against him that becomes pledge without deed Pledge Nat. br 122. K. 18 Edw. 3.13 pl. 7. Finchden if the principle pay it not A borrowed of B 20 l. to pay it at Michaelmas at which day D prays B to take him for his Debtor and he gives him day over and D obliges him to pay it by one Tally ensealed Debt lies not against D because A was not by this discharged 44 Edw. 3.21 pl. 23. and so he may recover one Debt twice if D should be chargeable A
is an escape in the old Sheriff but not in the new for the new is not charged with him but if the old Sheriff die the other ought to take notice of the prisoners but if the escape be in the vacancy viz. before the new Sheriff is elected and sworn debt lies not Coke 3. part 71 72. Westbyes case 10 Edw. 3.375 pl. 28. for before he was not chargeable for he was no offender in Law If one be in execution yet debt lies against the Sheriff 7 Eliz. Dyer 241. pl. 47. 16 Edw. 4.3 pl. 7. Q. de hoc The Plaintiff and chief Justice assent for â—oe time that the prisoner shall go at large and after he suffers an escape debt lies 10 Eliz. Dyeâ— 275. pl. 46. for this was not a finall discharge dâ— the prisoner Q. A capias upon a recognizance in Chancery the party taken escapes debt lies Coke 8. part 142. Druries case for this is in nature of an execution The Writ was that 6 were in execution and escaped and the doubt was whether they might count for one only and by the better opinion 〈◊〉 was good Crooke 26 Hen. 7.67 pl. 11. Q. If one be Marshal of the prison whether it be by right or wrong Marshal debt lies against him 39 Heâ— 6.33 A. for the Plaintiff is not to examine his Title Count that he was in execution in C and removed to the upper Bench prison and committed to the Marshal which suffers him to escape debt lies 38 Hen. 6.28 pl. 10. for it is all one as I he had been originally committed thither Deputy of a Marshal suffers an cescape â—eputy debt lies against him 11 Eliz. Dyer 278. pl. 5. viZ. the Marshal himself Q. if not against the Deputy Debt lies against a Mayor of the Staple upon recognizance taken before him Mayor de Staple 5 Hen. 6.11 Heâ— 6.49 B. 12 Hen. 6.2 pl. 9. if he suffer 〈◊〉 Prisoner to escape The count Lib. intra 171. D. sect 6. Dean and Chapter of Pauls having return 〈◊〉 Writs Lord de Franchize and making a Bayliff that suffers an escape Action lies not against the Dean and Chapter because cause they are not Bayliffs Pasch 14 Eliz. Com. Ban. but against the Bayliff for he is the Officer the Law takes notice of Q tamen For a Nomine poenae granted this is casual yet debt lies for it Nat. br 120. M. 2 Hen. 8.8 Dyer Grant penalty 24. pl. 149 for it is a duty ab origine if forfeited And this is but hac vice if there be no other words to shew the continuance of it 32 Hen. 6.10 A. Billinge And so upon any grant hac vice certain or uncertain Q. 2. Annuity or Rent-charge granted for years Annuity debt lies not during the term But the 5 Edw. 4. 42 B. debt lies and it seems this is Law if it lie not it seems it is because the Grantee may distrain and charge the Land But against a customer it lies if it be to be paid out of the customs of London after delivery of a Liberate Nat. br 121. F. for then it is a duty vested It lies for Executors or administrators of the Grantee per Stat. 32 Hen. 8. cap. 37. viz. of an Annuity or Rent-charge And after the term ended it lies for the Grantee Lib. Intra 151. C. sect 1. for then there is no other remedy for it 3. Annuity for life For Life debt lies not for this during life 19 Hen. 6. 42 A. 37 Hen. 6.35 A. But a Distress or a Writ of Annuity and the Land is chargeable But against a customer it lies Nat. br 121. F. â—ntea for his person is chargeable ratione officii Also if a Parson or Prebend c. hath such annuity and resigne or be dispossessed it lies for the arrerages Coke 4. part 48. B. Ognels case For by his resignation it is meerly a personal thing and the Land is not chargeable So his Executors shall have debt by the common Law Coke 4. part 49. A 22 Eliz. Dyer 37. pl. 62. Coke 10. part 61. B. For it is accounted part of the Testators personal estate But if it be a Rent-charge seck or service debt lies not for any so long as the Estate continues Coke 4. part 49. A. Ognels case For there the person is not chargeable Although it have continuance but to a special intent Coke 7. part 39. B. For the Law takes not notice of such intents but looks on it as upon a continuing Estate But after it be determined debt lies for the party or his Executor Coke 4. part 49. Ognels case Nat. br 121. E. Coke 4. part 49. Ognels case 27 Hen. 6.1 pl. 4. because the realty is resolved into the personality and so the person chargeable 4. Annuity in Tayl general or special debt lies not during the annuity Coke 4. part 48. B. for the former reason So of a Rent-seck service or charge vid. antea But if the estate be determined quaere at the common Law But by the 32 Hen. 8. cap. 37. the Executor or Administrator shall have debt for the Arrerages Annuity in fee during the annuity debt lies not Annuity or Rent in Fee Coke 4. part 48. B. 6 Hen. 4.7 pl. 33. Unless it be in a special case as when a Parson or Prebend resignes Coke 4. part 49. A. Nat. br 121. D. 19 Hen. 6.41 42. Nat. br 121. Hâ—ntea For there the estate is determined as to him that resignes So if a Parson dies his Executors shall have debt Nat. br 120. L. Coke 4. part 49. A. 37 Hen. 6.8 pl. 18. For there is no other remedy for to recover it And by the 32 Hen 8. cap. 37. the Executors or Administrators of every one shall have debt But after the Annuity determined every one shall have debt by the common Law Coke 4. part 49. A. 45 Edw. 3.45 execution 71. Judgment given In Court of Record Superior Parliament Ban. Regis Chancery Com. Ban. Exchequer Prescription Inferior by Custom Patent Common-Right Not of Record Court Baron For principal County For dammages and losses Ancient Demesn in any Mannor For Fine or Amerciament Out of Court Statute Marchant Staple According to 23 Hen. 8. Recognizance Account at common Law Arbitrement By Law or Ordinance Judgment given in debt for the principal If a man brings debt upon a recovery in com Ban. he ought to bring it in Middlesex where the Record is because it is the Original upon the which the Action is brought but a scire facias to execute a Judgment shall be where the original Action was brought because it ought to follow it Hil. 9 Jac. Ban. Regis Musgrave versus Wharton for the scire facias is in pursuance of it and to have execution upon it Upon Arrerages recovered in a scire facias upon a Judgment in Annuity brought against the predecessors debt lies upon it Nat. br 122. E. 22 Edw. 4.1 pl. 6.
17 Hen. 7.40 pl. 12. It seems not for there may be more due and therefore it ought to be put in issue In debt upon a sale that he owes nothing by the Law a good bar although the Defendant bought it of the servant of the Plaintiff for the contract of the Servant is the contract of the Master 30 Edw. 3.19 pl. 27. If the Servant had authority to buy and sell or that the thing bought came to the Masters use Unless the Contract be by deed 39 Hen. 6.35 pl. 46. Which must be avoided by Deed and not by the Oath of the party Debt against the Husband and Wife upon a contract of the wife dum sola fuit the Husband wages his Law as now he may for now it is his debt but if at the day of the doing of his Law the Wife be not there the Husband shall be condemned 33 Hen. 6.43 pl. 23. For the debt originally was hers and therefore she must join That he recovered in an Action upon the Case upon an Assumpsit a good bar Coke 4. part 94. B. Slades case in debt upon a Contract for it was in his election to bring his Action upon the Case The breaking of the Prison by Enemies or a Tempest Escape a good bar 33 Hen. 6.1 pl. 3. in debt against a Gaoler upon an escape for he could not prevent it nor can have satisfaction But not by Rebels 33 Hen. 6.1 pl. 3. For Rebels may be compelled to make the Gaoler satisfaction The Sheriff pleads that his predecessor suffered him at large and that he did take him again c. a good bâ—r 2 Edw. 6.67 pl. 17. in debt brought against him for an escape in his predecessors time Enfancy no plea because the Statute is general Doct. Stud. 147. B. In debt for necessaries vid. antea Debt against a Bayliff because the Sheriff had not made out his Warrant for apprehending one in execution and yet returns that he was taken and was not quaere whether the Bayliff shall say no such Warant against the return of the Sheriff 5 Edw. 4.1 It seems not but must have his remedy against the Sheriff Non permisit ire ad largum a good bar 10 Hen. 4.10 38 Hen. 6.29 3 Mariae Dyer 121. pl. 18. in debt brought upon an escape for this is a direct tender of an issue that there was no escape A Return by a Bayliff of a Liberty that the Precept was not come to him at the time and that afterwards he was not in the Liberty 18 Edw. 3.35 is a good bar in debt against him Taken again before the Action brought a good bar if that he agree not to the escape and make fresh suit Coke 3. part 52. Rigwayes case 34 Edw. 1. debt 162. Otherwise not for then he is particeps criminis That he owes nothing is no Plea because this Action is brought not upon a contract but upon a special clause of the Statute 2 Rich. 2. Issue 160. Which cannot be discharged by a plea parol but he must answer to the Statute Account upon a recovery of dammages and the party committed in execution Nul tiel record a good bar 30 Hen. 6.6 For the Action is grounded upon the Record and if there be no such Record there can be no Action Judgment in Court Debt upon a Judgment in Pypowders a good bar that he was taken in execution 7 Hen. 6.18 upon the Judgment given in the Court of Pypowders Upon a recovery in a Court Baron if an Action of debt be brought the Defendant shall say that he owes nothing by the Law 49 Edw. 3.3 A. Hanmer 13 Hen. 7.3 B. Conesby For such recoveries are of an inferior nature Debt for dammages Debt for Dammages recovered in Assize of the Plaintiff after Verdict and before Judgment pleaded quaere 2 Mariae Dyer 107. pl. 24. Levied by the Sheriff a good bar 11 Hen. 4.58 pl. 8. For that is satisfaction in Law as to the party Elegit pleaded in Bar good 13 Eliz. Dyer 299. pl. 34. For by the Elegit he hath elected his Execution Upon a recovery of Dammages in ancient demesne debt is brought against the Defendant he shall not say that he owes nothing but shall plead Non tiel Recovery quare 34 Hen. 6.49 A. pl. 15. Littleton For it seems he may as well here as upon debt brought upon a recovery in a Court Baron vide antea For an Amerciament in a Leet that he owes nothing For fine or amerciment by the Law no plea. 12 Rich. 2. Law 33. For a Court-Leet is the Kings Court and not a base Court For an Amerciament in a Court-Baron that he owes nothing by the Law a good plea 12 Rich. 2. Stathan debt 35. No. Lib. intra 119. A. sect 1. vid. antea In Debt upon a Statute Merchant with a defeasance the Defendant said that he was a Lay-man and not Learned and that the condition should have been but to bind him to pay 40 l. and it was made 60 l. This is a good plea for the Action is brought as upon an Obligation with a condition but otherwise if execution be sued upon it as a Statute Hil. 9. Jac. Banc. Regis Fox versus Brooke For then such plea comes too late for the Statute is extended as a Judgment Arbitrement is no Bar in debt for arrerages of account before Auditors Arbitrement because the sum being due by matter of Record ought to be answered by matter of as high a nature 3 Hen. 4.5 pl. 23. 6. Hen. 4.6 pl. 28. 8 Hen. 5.3 pl. 13. Hâ—ll 3 Hen. 6.55 A. quaere 4 Hen. 6.17 pl. 3. 10 Hen. 7.4 A. which an Arbitrement is not Debt upon an in simul computaverunt that he was not accountable by the Countrey no bar for where the Defendant may wage his Law the Contract is not traversable Crooke 13 Hen. 7.39 pl. 4. For the Action supposeth that he assented to the accompt so that that is not to be put in issue Nullum fecerunt arbitrium a good Bar because this lies in notice of the Countrey Crooke 13 Hen. 7.39 pl. 4. In action of debt upon a Bond to perform an award But if he plead such a plea he cannot rejoyn afterwards and say that the Arbitrators gave no notice but must plead it in Bar and not by way of Rejoynder Crooke 7 Hen. 8.155 pl. 8. For such a Rejoynder confesses an Award and the Bar denies it so that the Bar and the Rejoynder cannot stand together The Arbitrators gave no notice no Bar unless the submission be so viz. that the Arbitrators should give notice for else the parties are to take notice at their peril The Defendant said that before the Arbitrement made he discharged the Arbitrators this is a good Bar 21 Hen. 6.30 28 Hen. 6.6 Coke 8. part 82. B. Vniors case and needs not to aver that the Arbitrators had notice for they must be discharged without notice Debt upon an Obligation
for it was implied before Mich. 15 Jac. Ban. Regis per Montague Chief Justice Woolridge Banbury for such a Lease could be made but conditionally A Condition to deliver such a Lease as shall be devised by the Judge of the Court of Audience Non devisavit aliquid c. is no barr for he ought to procure him to make one at his peril Coke 5. part 23. B. Lambs case the Pleading No. Lib. Intr. 130. A. for the Condition is for the Obligors benefit and therefore he must do his best to see it performed Impossible condition A is obliged to B in 20 l. upon Condition to pay 10 l. to such a person at such a place and time as B should name in his Will B makes his Will and names none the Executors shall not have it for the Condition is become impossible for he ought to be named in deed Trin. 12 Jac. Com. Ban. Pease alii versus Mead Mich. 11 Jac. Rott 945. The Defendant said that he made another obligation to the Plaintiff the which he did accept in satisfaction of the former this is no barr because it is but a thing in Action Mich. 12 Jac. Com. Ban. Rand. Strut Trin. 6 Jac. Com Ban. Rott 10001. Lovelace and one thing in action cannot be discharged with another thing in action Payment according to the Condition a good barr Coke 8. part 58. A. Beechers case Payment but he must shew the place where he made the payment 9 Edw. 4.141 B. becauss it is material Payment of parcel hanging the Writ is not good to abate the Writ without an Acquittance 3 Hen. 7.3 pl. 12. 5 Hen. 7.10 pl. 15. 7 Edw. 4.15 Vide 28 Hen. 8. Dyer 6. pl. 3. because the duty was by specialty A is bound to B in 10 l. and after the date is a clause that he shall pay him 5 l. the Obligation is void as to the 10 l. payment there without Acquittance is good 30 Edw. 3.3 pl. 12. Q. because the Obligation is void But payment after the day is not good without Acquittance 46 Edw. 3.29 pl. 23. 47 Edw. 3.13 pl. 14. 5 Hen. 7.41 pl. 5. because then it is a duty vested A is bound to pay 20 quarters of Maule and if he pay it not at the day then 40 quarters in Debt for the 40 quarters he may plead payment of the 20 quarters without Acquittance because it is to save a penalty but not in debt for the 20 quarters 28 Hen. 8. Dyer 24. pl. 154. 1 Hen 5.7 A. because that was the original duty Three are bound to pay their Rent one pays it the other pleads payment without Acquittance 45 Edw. 3.4 pl. 9. and good for the payment of one is the payment of all and he may not have an Acquittance A is bound by an Obligation dated 17th of November 12 Jac. with condition of payment the 19th November next ensuing per Curiam payment 19th November 13 Jac. is sufficient for it shall not be intended 19th November in the same month Mich. 13 Jac. Com. Ban. Price Coe for it shall not be intended that an Obligation should be made for two days and the next ensuing shall relate to the month and not the day Conusee of a Statute had Execution for 20 l. and by Indenture grants that if the Conusor pay 8 l. at a day to come the Statute shall be void this is a good discharge 20 Assize pl. 7. Quaert whether the Statute or the Execution shall be void Payment to a Deputy a good barr 42 Edw. 13. pl. 35 Q. what Deputy Payment to the Baily of a Bishop without his command is a good barr 22 Edw. 4.25 pl. 5. for it is payment to the Bishop But payment to a Servant without command is no barr unless it comes to the use of his Master Doct. Stud. 38. A. for a Servant as a Servant is no Receiver Payment to a Creditor of the Obligee by his command is a good barr 46 Edw. 3.33 pl. 45. Perkins 145. A. for it is a payment to himself being for his benefit But then he ought to shew that the Creditor was the Creditor of the Obligee 27 Hen. 6.6 pl. 1. viz. in his plea. In debt upon an Obligation with a Condition to pay 20 l. to B assoon as he comes to the Age of 21 years 1. The Defendant ought to shew in performance of the Condition that B is of full Age. 2. He ought to shew the place where he paid it for otherwise there cannot be any traverse Mich. 12 Jac. Ban. Regis Halse Condition to permit one to enjoy Permit c. he pleads that he did permit him and good 10 Eliz. Dyer 279. pl. 6. for that answers the Condition fully The Defendant said that the Plaintiff was indebted to him Retainer and that he commanded him to retain it a good barr 22 Edw. 4.25.65 for such retainer is satisfaction in Law Barr general to an obligation Acquittance Acquittance a good barr from the party himself But an Acquittance by a general Receiver without receipt of the money by his Master is not good unless he be Receiver by deed and hath authority to make Acquittances Doct. Stud. 137. B. for then his Master shall be estopped by the deed to say he was not his Receiver A brought debt in Ban. Regis against B and that depending brought debt for the same debt in London and had goods attached in the hands of C and had judgment upon them this is a good barr in debt brought by B against C for the goods attached but if A brings debt against B and after the debt is attached in London and Judgment given there if the Creditor sue B he cannot plead the Attachment in barr because he might have pleaded it to the Action brought against him in Com. Ban. Mich. 39 40 Eliz. Com. Ban. Jaques versus Lewkner in barr of the Action brought in London and so have avoided the Attachment A Debt is attachable before the day in which it is payable because it is a duty and the debtor debet although non detinet but an obligation made to perform Covenants is not attachable Mich. 39 40 Eliz. Com. Ban. Beacher versus Minors for this is incertain whether it may ever become a duty Coverture a good barr Coverture Lib. Intr. 168. B. sect 1. in an Action of debt brought against a Feme Covert upon an obligation made during Coverture Infancy a good barr Infancy Lib. Intra 163. A. sect 1. for an Infant cannot be bound nor contract to his prejudice Non est factum Non est factum a good barr but not if the deed be inrolled 16 Hen. 5. B. 9 Hen. 6.60 A. Babington 39 Hen. 6.32 pl. 45. because the party hath acknowledged it to be his deed before the Judge or Master of the Chancery When a deed is but voidable non est factum no plea Coke the 5. part 119. A.
tamen For it may be more certain It lies not of a piece of ground called Michels piece Trin. 38 Eliz. Ban. Regis Rot. 450. Palmer Humphreys for that is incertain both in the quantity and quality and other Lands may be called of the same name and so that makes no certainty in it It lies not of a virge of Land 38 Eliz. Rot. 453. Mell versus Moor for that may be incertain and may differ in respect of the place The Count Generally If it be of a Lease made by a Bishop Bishop it ought to count upon the Deed No. Lib. Intr. 186. D. Sect. 2. and set it forth because it is not an ordinary Lease whereof the Law takes notice But if it be of a Lease made by the husband and wife Husband and wife he needs not count that it was by Indenture Lib. Intra 252. C. Sect. 8. Coke 2. part 61. B. Wiscots case but it sufficeth to say that they lett and the Law will supply the rest If it be of a Lease made by a Person tunc adâ—uc seized of the Reversion Person it is good without averring of the life of the person 13 14 Eliz. Dyer 304. pl. 52. for the Lease is good whether he be alive or not If the Account be of a Lease made by three where two have nothing in it it is not good although they all joyned in the Lease for they could not all lett but contrary if he count by him only that hath right per Williams Crooke Mich. 10 Jac. Ban. Regis Longs case for he did only in truth lett though the others joyned A Lease to commence at Michaelmas next after the death of A Lease the Count ought to shew that A is dead 1 Mariae Dyer 97. pl. 46. fol. 89. 19 Eliz. Dyer 357. pl. 46. for else the Plaintiff shews no title but shews matter against himself The Plaintiff Counts that A demised to him per Indenture dated 27 Martii Demise 11 Jac. primum delibat 10. decimo Aprilis eodem anno for 21 years from Michaelmas next before and the Ejectment 12 Aprilis this is good though the year be mistaken or he may Count that by Indenture dated 27 Martii primum delibat 10 Aprilis Mich. 11 Jac. Ban. Regis Michels case which is more plain and certain The Count upon the Imparlance Roll was upon a Lease made 10. of December 10 Jac. and upon the Plea-roll it was upon a Lease made 30 Januarii 10 Jac. babendum from the 20. of Decomber before this is not good Hill 14 Jac. Milward Wats Ban. Regis for it cannot be the same Lease upon which he counted so there is no certainty in the pleading to which the Defendant may answer The Count was that J. S. was seized and so seised leased to the Plaintiff 9 Eliz. Dyer 258. pl. 16. Com. 416. A. Bracebridges case Com. 187. A. Adams case Com. 223. B. Barkleys case Com. 530. B. Howel Crosts case here is a good colour of a Title to his Lessor and to his own Lease But 14 Eliz. Dyer 340. pl. 57. he doth not count of the seisin Coke 11. part 3. B. Coke 3. part 16. A. Borastons case Coke 3. part 45. Browns case Coke 4. part 96. A. Lamberts case Com. 459. B. Studs case Com. 504. B. Snowes case but only declares upon a Lease made unto him by the Lessâ—r and it seems good enough The Writ In Wales it may be by plaint without an original Writ for this action is out of the Statute 26 Hen. 8. cap. 6. Hill 36 Eliz. Ban. Regis 610. Griffin â—â—â—sus Eliot Wilkins and is there still as it was 〈◊〉 the Common Law It is Vi armis 1 Hen. 5.3 Coke 9. part 78. 1. Petoes case 21 Edw. 4. pl. 1. Choke which alâ—â—ys supposeth breach of the publick Peace But Hill 36 Eliz. Ban. Regis Rott 610. Griffin â—â—â—sus Eliot Wilkins in Error that it may be without Vi armis 7 Hen. 6.4 17 Edw. 3.1 It â—â—â—ms it was so held because the Defendant might â—â—â—er by colour of title to the Land Fuit ad terminum qui nondum praeteriit 2 Marie Dyer 116. pl. 71. but there 's not the certainty of the time for that is not material Et est pone per vad salvos pleg 21 Edw. 4.10 〈◊〉 1. 31. pl. 25. Brian that is the taking of bail It may be bonis catallis Com. 228. B. Lib. Intra 252. B. Sect. 7 8. Although Regist orig 227. B. says to the contrary Quaere ergo But it may be without it Com. 229. A. 199. A. Adams case The Process 1. before 2. after appearance The Process is Attach and Distress and Process of Outlawry Nat. br 220. H. 35 Hen. 6.6 per Wangford Moyl Com. 228. B. Coke 9. part 78 A. Peytoes case Attachment against the person Distress against the goods Outlawry against person and goods and lands The last Process in Law is the strictest and most severe The Barr. Accord with satisfaction a good barr Accord Coke 〈◊〉 part 78. A. Petoyes case because it is but in the nature of a Trespass for here is no land in question but only a possession Duress a good barr Duress Lib. Intra 253. B. sect 10. viz. that the Plaintiff gained the Lease by distess for the Law hates fraud and force and will protect no person in them Non ejecit a good barr Ejecit si bona catalla are not in the Writ 7 Edw. 6.89 pl. 111. 19 Hen. 6.56 for that is a barr only as to the Land for a man cannot be properly said to be ejected out of goods Quaere But if such words be in quaere whether it be good It is a good barr Entry that the Lessor had it but in right of his wife and he entered after the death of the Lessor in right of his wife Lib. Intra 252. D. sect 8. That he surrendred before the Action brought Surrender quod non ejecit a good barr 21 Edw. 4.10 pl. 1.30 pl. 25. Q. if there should not be a traverler it seems it needs not The Judgment The judgment shall be quod recuperet against â—â—e Defendant terminum suum praedictum venturum 〈◊〉 in c. ac dampua sua occasione c. quod â—â—â—end capiatur this supposeth a Vi armis 〈◊〉 â—liz Dyer 258. pl. 16. 7 Edw. 6. Dyer 89. pl. 109. 〈◊〉 420. A. Bracebridges case 5â—5 Snowes case 〈◊〉 Intra 253. A. sect 8.256 C. sect 13.259 C. 〈◊〉 15. No. Lib. Intr. 188. A. pl. 7. â—03 A. Sect. 8. 〈◊〉 D. Sect. 11.216 B. Sect. 13. Com. 526. A. â—â—â—nthams case But note this is when the term is not ended Note 〈◊〉 9. part 80. A. Peytoes case 4. part 104. Lamâ—â—s case Nat. br 220. H. 7 Edw. 4.6 13 Hen 7. 〈◊〉 B. Wood for if the term be ended then there 〈◊〉 to term to come to
were brought by the Plaintiff and another and the Plantiff is non-suit 5 E. 157. pl. 10. For thereby he desists in his Claim No such Church No such Church in the same County is no Bar 8 Hen. 6.37 pl. 69. 9 Hen. 6.17 Q. But 45 Edw. 3.36 pl. 2. è contra Q. Pardon of the King for alienation is no Bar Pardon if the Church be void before the pardon 27 Edw. 3.38 For then the pardon works not upon the precedent right Plentary a good Bar Plentary though the Patron his no notice of the Avoidance for this is to stop the Collation of the Ordinary but not the Presentation of the Patron Pasch 39 Eliz. Com. Bâ—â— Seriven against the Bishop of Lincolne Plenarty of a Frank Chappel is no Bar for if he shall be put to his Quare impedit then it shall be presentative afterwards 22 Hen. 6.25 B. Which is mischievous to the Patron in making it subject to the visitation of the Ordinary The Church is said to be full against a common person by Institution 22 Hen. 6.27 A. 14 Hen. 8 2. Brudenel 12 Hen. 4.38 For by that the Clerk is approved and Induction is but as it were giving of possession And against the King by Induction 22 Hen. 6.27 B. which makes him a compleat Incumbent to all intents and purposes He that pleads plenarty ought to say that it is full of his own presentment and not of anothers for if the Defendant be disturbed he shall not be punished and if he hath title he ought to shew it 3 Hen. 6.20 Br. plenarty 6. 16 Edw. 4.11.8 Edw. 3. Statham He shall plead that he was in per 6 Months of his Presentment before the purchase of the Advowson by the Plantiff But if it be of a presentment of the predecessor of the Plaintiff yet it is good 8 Edw. 3. presentment 5. The 6 Months shall be accounted according to the Kalendar Coke 6. part 61 62. Catesbyes case and not after 28 days to the Month for that is the ancient account used in Law Who shall plead Plenarty and who not Incumbent pleads Plenarty of himself Incumbent ex praesentatione B. viz. the Plantiff Coke 6 part 48.2 Hen. 6.14 pl. 22. No. Lib. intra 265. A. absque hoc that it was void for the Incumbent is not able to plead it otherways per 25 Edw. 3. cap. 7. But 16 Edw. 4.11 pl. 6. Com. 501. A. Manwood è contra Ergo Q. Because he that pleads this ought to say that the Incumbent is in of his own presentation 2 Rich. 2. Incumbent 4. Belknap 46 Edw. 3.19 18 Edw. 3. Quare Impedit 48. and not of anothers But per 4 Edw. 4.13 The Incumbent pleads that the Plaintiff or his predecessor presented him Q. For it seems to be uncertain Parson imparsonee cannot plead plenarty because that he cannot say that he is in per six Months of his own presentment 38 Hen. 6.20 B. 33 Hen. 6.12 pl. 27. Com. 501. A. Manwood 39 Hen. 6.20.46 Assize pl. 4. A Stranger or he that claims nothing in the Patronage cannot plead Plenarty 7 Hen. 4.34 per Fitz James For it lies not in his mouth to say whether the Church be full or not Against whom Plenarty is no Plea Against the Lord that enters for Mortmain it is no Plea because the Lord hath liberty by the Law to enter at any time within the year 21 Edw. 3.27 pl. 25. 29 Edw. 3.10 pl. 31. Thorpe 47 Edw. 3.11 pl. 8. But after the year it is a good plea 25 Edw. 3.34 26 Edw. 3. Quare Impedit 163. For then he is in the condition of another Petron Quaere if it be good against the Lord by â—â—â—cheat â—â— Hen. 8.14 Brudenel It seems it is for he shall be in no better condition then than the Patron that died without Heir It is no plea against the King 35 Hen. 6.26 A. 1 Edw. 3.17 pl. 9. 8 Edw. 3.304 pl. 55. 43 Edw. 3.14 pl. 8. For it is not a Plea in chief to determine the right but only delatory and the King shall not be delayed But against the Queen Mother or Consort it seems to be good 18 Edw. 3.13 pl. 9. 44 Edw. 3. Br. Plenarty 4. For she is but a subject and shall be in no better condition in the eye of the Law A good Bar to say Presentation that the Plaintiff presented his Clerk and that he was inducted before the Writ purchased 12 Hen. 4.11 pl. 21. vide Crooke 12 Hen. 7.20 pl. 6. For then he could have no cause of Action A Recovery in another Quare Impedit Recovery no Bar against the King for he may make another Title Nat. br 35. P. than was made before and a better it may be A Recovery by by the Plaintiff against another in a Quare Impedit for the same Advowson no Bar for there might be two disturbers Recovery by a Stranger in another Quare Impedit no Bar Crooke 18 Hen. 7.49 pl. 4. For nothing concerns the present Plaintiff That the Plaintiff is a Recusant Convict Recusancy a good Bar for the Presentment is given to the University per 3 Jac. And therefore the Plaintiff can have no cause of Action Release of Actions Personals a good Bar Release 22 Hen. 6.25 vel 27. Littleton fol. 116. A. 30 Hen. 6. Bar. 59. For this is a mixt Action and so it is personal in part So of Actions real Litteton 116. A. 9 Hen. 6.57 Martin For being next it is also real as well as personal If a Presentment be alledged in the Ancestry of the Plaintiff it is a good Bar to plead a Release and Quit claim of the Ancestry pro fine 8 Edw. 2. Quare Impedit 166. For thereby the Plaintiffs cause of Action is extinct If there be more Plaintiffs in a Quare Impedit than one the Release of one is no Bar but for him only that released Coke 5. part 97. B. Nor. thumberlands case 30 Hen. 6. Bar. 59. Fortescue For their Titles may be distinct and several Judgment in a Quare Impedit 1. When he shall have Judgment 2. Of what things he shall have Judgment Upon default after apppearance Upon default the Plaintiff shall have Judgment and Dammages 2 Hen. 4.1 pl. 3. Nat. br 38. S. For this is as it were the confession of the Plaintiffs Title But upon default after a continuance Distress shall issue out only 6 Rich. 2. viz. before apparence make him to appear Upon Default at the grand Distress the Plaintiff shall have Judgment Lib. intra 507. A. sect 1 2 3. For that is the last process to bring in the Defendant and the Plaintiff can proceed no further upon mean process In a Quare Impedit against two and one makes default after appearance the Plaintiff shall have Judgment against him that makes default Nat. br 39. B. But not against the other for anothers default shall not prejudice him If in a Quare Impedit against
double dammages because the six Months were passed and also a Writ to the Bishop and his Clerk instituted because the Bishop did not collate but this was not done by the party 8 Edw. 3.280 pl. 9. Q. A man shall recover double dammages although he recover all before the six Months pass 13 Edw. 4.3 Littleton by the Stat. of W. 2. Single dammages and no Writ to the Bishop Before the return of the Writ to enquire of dammages the six Months pass the Bishop collates yet but single dammages 24 Edw. 3.35 pl. 13. 27 Edw. 3. Dammages 106. But the reason it seems is because of the former Judgment that he shall have a Writ to the Bishop and this being of Record shall stop him from double dammages for he is to have his Clerk thereby admitted 22 Hen. 6.28 Dammages but no Writ to the Bishop Quare Impedit against a Parson imparsonee and found for the Defendant he shall have dammages but no Writ to the Bishop Nat. br 38. L. 26 Hen. 6. bre Episcopo 6. for such Writ would be to no purpose Double dammages and no Writ to the Bishop Quare Impedit against the Ordinary and B the Ordinary confesseth the Action and it is found against B and that the Church is full of the presentment of B the Plaintiff shall have double dammages but no Writ to the Bishop or shall have single dammages and a Writ to the Bishop at his election 39 Edw. 3.15 but not both for the double dammages are in recompence of his presentation The Ordinary intitles himself by Lapse the Patron and Incumbent confess the Action the Plaintiff shall have double dammages against the Patron and Incumbent 34 Hen. 6.41 34 Hen. 6.39 because the Church is full Quare Impedit against the Patron and Incumbent they traverse the Title the six Months pass the Plaintiff if he recovers shall have double dammages against both 46 Edw. 3.15 pl. 5. Vid. the Stat. Two Writs to the Bishop The Defendant in a Quare Impedit brought a Darrein presentment against the Plaintiff the Plaintiff is nonsuited in the Quare Impedit the Defendant recovers in the Darrein presentment the Defendant shall have Judgment to have two Writs to the Bishop but shall not have dammages twice Nat. br 39. D. viz. upon the Plaintiffs nonsuit one and upon his own recovery another for that would be double amends In what Court and what Judges have power to award a Writ to the Bishop Justices of Nisi prius have power per Westm 2. cap. 30 40. 14 Edw. 3. cap. 16. 9 Eliz. Dyer 260. pl. 21. 6 Edw. 6.76 pl. 34. The Lords it seems of Mannors Judges in Wales have not power 36 Hen. 6. B. Fortesâ—ue 35 Hen. 6.30 pl. 35. 3 Edw. 3.63 pl. 35. 8. Edw. 3.319 pl. 15. 24 Edw. 3.33 pl. 26. Regist orig 31. A. for the Bishops are not tied to take notice of their Writs Lord in ancient Demesn hath no power to award a Writ to the Bishop 7 Hen. 6.35 for this is an inferiour Court circumscribed within its own Jurisdiction The Five Ports cannot award a Writ to the Bishop 21 Hen. 7.88 pl. 7. Crooke for these are particular Franchises within themselves Ne Admittas What Persin shall have it The Plaintiff in a Quare Impedit or Darrein Presentment shall have it Nat. br 35 F. So the Defendant shall have it Nat. br 37. H. In what Cases it lies When a Quare Impedit or Darrein Presentment is depending and the Plaintiff or Defendant supposeth that the Bishop will admit the Clerk of the other then a Ne admittas lies Nat. br 37. F. Regist orig 31. A. 21. Hen. 44. Newton Vet. Nat. br 24. B. to hinder the Bishop from admitting any Clerk till the right be determined If one of the Writs be not depending then it Its not Nat. br 37. H. viz. a Quare Impedit or Darrein Presentment for this Writ supposeth a Title in question which must be by one of those Writs For if the right of Advowson is depending it lies not because the Presentation is not to be recovered in it Nat. brâ—â— 48. Q. and so the admittance of a Clerk is not in question But note Note that this lies before any Certificate made that a Quare Impedit or Darrein Presentnent is depending Nat. br 37. H. for depending of the Writs rests not upon the Certificate Yet the party grieved by the Ne admittas shall have a Writ to the Chief Justice to certifie if any Writ be depending and if he certifie none then a Supersedeas shall be awarded Nat. br 37. H. to supersede the Ne admittas Note Note that this Writ does not hinder the Ordinary but that he may present by Lapse unless he be party Nat. br 48. L. Vet. Nat. br 24 25. â—iz party to the Suit for else it concerns him not Within what time this ought to be brought Within six Months and not after by reason of Lapse Locum habet infra tempus semestre non pâ—stea quia Diocesanus illam conferat per Lapsum temporis ad sex menses quia Diocesanus ilâ—ud spectaliter â—t induâ—tum Regist orig 37. F. Yet for the King it always keeps place Regist orig 31. A. Nat. br 37. F G. vide Br. for nullum tempus occurrit Regi the King is not tied to circumstances of time or place c. The Writ The Writ shall be alone although the Bishop be party as where not Tamen olim fuit ne conferatis alicui Ecclesiam de N. quae vacat Regist orig 31. A B. Nat. 38. A. The Process Is Prohibition Attachment and Distress Nat. br 24 25. Quare non admisit Out of what Court this issueth It issueth out of the Com. Bau. because it issueth out of the Rolls of the Court Regist orig 32. A. Vet. Nat. br 25. B. 12 Edw. 3. Quare non admisit 6. For this is a Judicial Writ Vet. Nat. br 25. B. Regist orig 32. A. 12 Edw. 3. Quare non admisit 6. per Nat. br 47. C. grounded upon a Record of Court This may issue out of the Chancery in the Vacation also for in the Vacation it cannot issue out of the Common Pleas. If the King recover in Com. Ban. in Quare Impedit he may have this Writ in Ban. Regis Nat. br 47. D. for this Writ is but to have the effect of his Suit and he may seek for his right in any of his Courts What Person shall have it Every one that recovers if the Bishop will not admit his Clerk shall have it Nat. br 47. C. Vet. Nat. br 25. B. or else his Suit would be but fruitless if it were not compulsory Against whom it lies It shall be brought against the Bishop although the Vicar general made the refusal Vet. Nat. br 26. A. Nat. br 47. J. 13 Edw. 36. Quare non admisit 4. for the Law takes notice of him only as a more publick person concerned It was
Retorno habendo Null 1. The Defendant said that the place is ancient demesn c. if the issue be found for him the Plaintiff shall not have a return 21 Edw. 3.7 pl. 18. 2. If one justifies for Services and makes no Avowry he shall not have a return although it be found for him 15 Edw. 4.29 5 Edw. 4.6 34 Hen. 6. Avowry 47. for there is difference betwixt Avowing and Justifying Avowing supposeth tenure but Justifying doth not If one make a Conusance as Bailiff he shall have a return No. Lib. Intra 591. A. sect 9. viz. for his Master 3. The Plaintiff in a Recaption dies the Lord shall have return if another Writ be purchased 11 Hen. 6.14 pl. 3. Q. If the Plaintiff be Nonsuited Returno habendo the other shall have a return Lib. Intra 570. D. sect 1 2. 11 Eliz. Dyer 280. pl. 14. 35 Hen. 6.47 pl. 12. 17 Hen. 8. br second Deliverance 15. 22 Hen. 7.92 pl. 7. Crooke and this although the other do make no Avowry 16 Hen. 6. return of Cattel 1. 2 Hen. 5.6 for the Nonsuit confesseth the Distress well taken and so the Avowry is needless But otherways he may abate the Writ by pleading 9 Hen. 6.4 pl. 10. 11 Hen. 6.5 B. Danby 35 Hen. 6.40 pl. 1. But if the Count abate or if he count not of the place of the taking yet he shall not have a return before an Avowry 35 Hen. 6.40 pl. 1. because that is but for want of good pleading and he may have just cause of complaint notwithstanding for ought that appears to the Court. The second Deliverance he shall not have it without Avowry per Newton 16 Hen. 6. return of Cattel 1. for it is grounded upon a Title shewn The Defendant cannot claim a property in Repleg to have a return because he ought to claim at the time of the Repleg sued 31 Hen. 6.12 pl. 1. and now it is too late The Plaint is removed and it abates for default of the Sirname there was a return awarded without an Avowry 27 Hen. 6.3 pl. 35. for here is no right party complained of Repleg against C and D C pleads he took them not D justifies in right of C and found for him yet he shall not have a return 22 Hen. 6.52 pl. 27. because he justifies in the right of another who disclaims the distress The Defendant pleads property in another and found so there he shall have a return without an Avowry for the Plaintiff had deliverance without cause 39 Hen. 6.35 pl. 47. Prisott because the Cattel belonged to another One avows for rent at two days one whereof is not come the Plaintiff is Nonsuited there shall be a return in respect of the rent due for one day because he is not meerly an Actor per 4. Justices against three But Newton said he ought to have several Avowries Q. At the Common Law a return irreplevisable was but when it was found against the Plaintiff 1. Return irreplevisable 1. At Common Law 2. At the Statute Law by an issue tried 36 Hen. 6.8 pl. 24. Babbington for then the matter was fully tried If the Defendant doth not answer to the Avowry there the Cattel shall be irreplevisable Lib. Intra 571. A. sect 4. for he thereby confesseth the distress lawful 2. Return irreplevisable after Westm 2. cap. 2. is but upon a Nonsuit in second Deliverance 2 Hen. 4.23 pl. 9. Lib. Intra 571. A. sect 4 5. Upon a Nonsuit in Repleg it shall not be 24 Edw. 3.33 pl. 22. if it be not after verdict 14 Hen. 7.6 pl. 14. for he may have just cause of complaint though he be Nonsuit but by the verdict it appears he had not If the Plaintiff be Nonsuited in a Replevin and after in a second deliverance there shall be a return irreplevisable before Avowry but quaere if he shall have dammages before Avowry 10 Eliz. Dyer 280. pl. 14. It seems he shall for this double Nonsuit admits the taking lawful If the Plaintiff be Nonsuited when the Jury comes again and gives their verdict yet there shall not be a return irreplevisable 34 Hen. 6.5 pl. 14. 14 Hen. 7.6 pl. 14. for it may be he hath better evidence which he then failed of The Plaintiff in Repleg makes default at the Nisi prius they shall not be irreplevisable because it is out of the Law 3 Hen. 6.8 pl. 24. The Plaintiff in a Repleg is Nonsuited and a return awarded the King demises the pledges being warned come not quaere if the return shall be irreplevisable 1 Edw. 7. pl. 13. Or upon a Return awarded in second deliverance 2 Hen. 4.23 pl. 9. Q. Or upon a judgment against the Plaintiff upon a Demurrer 2 Hen. 4.23 pl. 9. 14. Hen. 7.6 pl. 14.2 3 Mariae Dyer 118. pl. 77. Q. Upon a Demurrer upon a plea to the Writ and judgment for the Defendant they shall not be irreplevisable 34 Hen. 6.37 B. br Repleg 6. for that is not upon the merits of the cause Or upon issue tried 2 Hen. 23. pl. 9. the Defendant in a Repleg pleads to the Writ and found by the Jury so there shall be a return irreplevisable the contrary upon a Demurrer upon a Writ or Concession 34 Hen. 6.37 B. br Repleg 6. for a verdict is of a higher account than a Demurrer or Concession If the Plaintiff upon a second Deliverance suffer the plea to be discontinued there it shall be irreplevisable 17 Hen. br second Deliverance for the Court will not be troubled with Suits to no purpose Dammages by Statutes Note that at this day dammages are given where the Plaintiff is Nonsuited or found against him or otherwise barred in Conusance Avowry or Justification for Rents Customes or Services per 7 Hen. 8. cap. 4. com 82. B. Crokers case 14 Mariae Dyer 141. pl. 46. 19 Hen. 8.11 pl. 7. And for dammage feasant per 21 Hen. 8. cap. 19.1 3 Mariae Dyer 118. pl. 77. 4 Mariae Dyer 141. pl. 46. But if it be for an Estray he shall not have dammages because the Statute extends not to it â—asch 34 Eliz. Ban. Regis Rot. 292. and being penal it shall not be expounded by equity But at the Common Law the Avowant shall not recover dammages 35 Hen. 6. pl. 12. for it was though enough for him to have return of the distress If one have a return irreplevisable upon a Non-suit in second deliverance it is doubted whether he shall have dammages before Avowry 11 Eliz. Dyer 280. pl. 14. It seems he shall because there needs no Avowry Quaere tamen for it appears not to the Court that he had cause to distrain TRESPASS Quid. Quotuplex 1. Court 2. Plaintiff 3. Defendant 4. Thing 5. Writ 6. Process 7. New Assignment 8. Barr. 9. Judgment 10. Execution Trespass is either by Common Law upon the doing of wrong to Inheritance Corporate Castle House Mill. Columbary Toft Garden Land Meadow Pasture Wood. Park Forrest
br 87 H. Regist orig 95. A. for the dammages do concern the Husband 21 Hen. 6.30 pl. 16. Lib. Intr. 6.50 C. Sect. 3. and the Count shall be bona catalla of the wife 7 Hen. 7.2 vide 14 Eliz. Dyer 305. pl. 59. the Count Lib. Intra 650. C. Sect. 3. Husband and wife may joyn in Trespass for the beating of the wife 46 Edw. 3.3 pl. 5. 22 Assize 60 87. Regist 105. B. Lib. Intra 612 668. C. Sect. 4. for he is damnified by it as well as his wife viz. by losing his labour and society So for imprisonment of the Wife Coke 5. part 59. A. Fosters case for the same reason But if they joyn for battery of both this abates for the battery of the Husband 9 Edw. 4.54 3 Edw. 3. brev 737. For the battery of the Husband is not the battery of the Wife and so as to that she hath no cause of Action And if they brought a Trespass for beating and taking away of Goods during the coverture thé Writ shall say de bonis of the Husband for the Wife cannot have a property during the coverture Regist orig 105. B. And if the Husband and Wife are beaten they shall have several Actions Regist orig 105. in the Note quia transgressio personalis ought to be brought only by the person injured Trespass quare domum suam fregit maremium iude asportavit c. being the house of the Wife is good by the Husband alone because he may pull it down and sell it 43 Edw. 3.16 pl. 15 fol. 26. pl. 6. Q. It seems so because he cannot be sued for it during the coverture So for entring and chasing and carrying away of the Deer in a Park although the Wife had a joint Estate with her Husband yet it is a personal thing in the Husband 43 Edw. 3.8 pl. 23. So for Deeds concerning the Land of the Wife 8 Hen. 5.9 pl. 13. For Deeds are Chattels though they concern the Realty So in trespass upon the Statute of 5 Richard 2. cap. 7. because he only shall have dammages 38 Hen. 6.3 pl. 9.4 Edw. 4.13 if he recover So for taking away of his Wife and his Goods Nat. br 89. O. 14 Hen. 6.2 pl. 11. 6 Edw. 3.208 pl. 2. 43 Edw. 3.23 pl. 15. 44 Assize pl. 13. Regist orig 97. A. for this is given by Westm 1. cap. 12. Westm 2. cap. 34. It seems this Statute was but in affirmance of the common Law Quando breve fertur ab aliquibus ad liberum tenementum annexis fiat in nomine amborum Nota. sed si sit de rebus libero tenemento non annexis in nomine viri tantum sed si sit de domo fracta sit in nomine amborum sed alii Clerici dicunt quod fiat in nomine viri tantum Regist orig 108. B. This is when trespass is brought concerning House and Lands of the Wife being covert Vide tamen in nomine amborum de clauso fracto bona c. Lib. intra 640. B. sect 4. fol. 662. D. sect 21 Rich. 2. brev 933. Q. Chaplain of a Chappel The King collates and the Sheriff puts him in who is collated he shall have trespass Nat. br 37. D. if the Trespass be done after he be put in A Commoner shall not have Trespass for any thing in the Land Commoner viz. the soil of a Common 4 Hen. 7.3 15 Hen. 7.13 pl. 1. fol. 12. pl. 23. For he hath only an interest in the Herbage Q. tamen He that hath not soil A lets Land to B for to sow and A to have the Moiety of the Corn yet B cannot have trespass Quare clausum fregit against him for wasting of the Corn for he hath interest in the whole Crop Hill 30 Eliz. Hâ—re versus Oakley And although this was not pleaded in abatement yet the special matter being found the Plaintiff shall not have judgment because it appears to the Court they cannot be disjoined to have an action in such form For they are upon the matter joint-tenants of the Land He to whose use He to whose use shall not have Trespass in his own name but in the name of the Feoffees Crooke 17 Hen. 7.41 pl. 2. For the Estate in Law is in them A Copy-holder shall have trespass for the breaking his Close and cutting his Trees Copy-holder 2 Hen. 8.4.12 Coke 4. part 21. B. No. Lib. intra 644. C. sect 3. the pleadings For he hath an interest in both to some purposes He shall have it against the Lord 20 Edw. 3. â—0 Coke 4. part 22. A. For the Lord in this â—espect is in no better condition than a stranger Disseisee shall have Trespass for the mean profits Disseisee and all other things after his re-entry Coke 11. part 51. A. Liffords case 3 Hen. 4.13 pl. 18. Gascoigne 37 H. 6.7 pl. 13. but not before because then he had no interest in the Land but a bare right But before his entry he shall not have Trespass 32 Hen. 6.32 A. 38 Hen. 6.28 A. Fortescue viz. against one that entred before he was disscised Q. Unless in case of necessity as Tenant for the Life of another is disseized and he for whose life he hath it dies or Tenant for years is outed and the years expire they shall have Trespass asore the entry and recover the mean profits 38 Hen. 6.28 B. Where there is a necessity the Law doth give way to usual things rather than there should be a failure of Justice An Executor shall have Trespass for Goods taken out of the possession of the Testator Executor Nat. Br. 87. E. Regist 98. A. in respect of his interest by his Executorship And the Writ shall not say ad grave damnum neque in retardationem executionis testamenti Regist orig 98. A. the Count Lib. intra 640. A. sect 2. But this was given by the Stat. of 4 Edw. 3. cap. 6. 14 Hen. 7.13 And at this day an Executor of an Executor shall have such an Action Regist 98. A. the rule there it seems upon the equity of the former Statute But he should not have had it before 25 Edw. 3. viz. at the Common Law cap. 5. Com. 290. A. Chapmans case But an Executor shall not have such Action De clauso fracto 11 Hen. 4.3 pl. 8. 4 Edw. 4.8 A. Catesby viz. in vita Testatoris for this is not within the Statute Neque de Arboribus succisis tempore Testatoris 18 Edw. 4.16 A. Pigott Nor this and so both are left at the Common Law An Executor shall not have Trespass before probate of the Will unless it be for a thing taken out of his own possession Com. 281. Q. rationem differentiae One Executor shall have Trespass for a thing taken out of his possession with his companion 42 Edw. 3.26 pl. 12. 2 Rich. 2. Executor 75. For Executors are but as one person in Law or he
Hen. 6.23 7 Hen. 4.18 pl. 22. 11 Hen. 7.12.17 Edw. 2. brev 8 22. as Ordinary for he hath a kind of property in it But not for a thing which was not in his possession Nat. br 92. A. Coke 9. part 39. A. Henslees case 7 Hen. 4.18 pl. 22. For the Law takes no notice of his right without a possession A Parson shall have Trespass for Tithes taken after severance of the 9 parts Parson 10 Hen. 4.2 pl. 2. Gascoign 21 Hen. 7.27 pl. 5. before any seisure because it is certain by the severance what was his and the Law casts the possession and property upon him Com. 281. A. Foxes case But not of a Mortuary before seisure Com. 281. A. 10. Hen. 4.1 but there is but a bare customary right A Parson or Vicar shall have Trespass for the Walls or Glass of the Church or Grass or Trees in the Church-yard c. or Glebe-Land 11 Hen. 4.12 pl. 25. 8 Hen. 6.9 pl. 20. 11 Hen. 6.4 B. Danby Q. For the Church belongs to the Parishioners and the Chancel to the Parson yet the free-hold of the Church is in the Parson Parson imparsonee shall have Trespass against any that is admitted and inducted into the said Church if he intermeddle with the Glebe or Tythes Com. 500. B. 38 Hen. 6.24 39 Hen. 6.24 27. because they belong unto him Protected person He that hath a protection Royal shall have Trespass against him that takes his Goods Nat. br 92. B. though if not protected he might take them for during the protection he is not to be molested and so hath wrong done him If one hath the possession of a thing Possessor he shall maintain an Action against him that hath no right Com. 546. A. whether his possession be lawful or not But note Note that upon a possession in Law only he shall not have Trespass 22 Hen. 6.49.5 but it must be an actual possession for that is visible and notorious and the other is not so but may be disputable But if A gives Goods to B B shall have Trespass before possession for he hath the property in Law in them 2 Edw. 4.25 per 2 Justices Coke 3. part 26 27. Butler Baker and property in Law is made then a possession in Law In a Trespass brought it was found by office that another was Tenant and that it escheated to the King this shall abate the Writ as to the things upon the Land Com. 488. B. Nichols case 546. A. 19 Edw. 4.2 pl. 5. because the Land was the Kings and not the Plaintiffs He that enters upon the possession of the King shall not gain possession therefore he shall not have Trespass Com. 546. A. Paramors case 2 Hen. 4.7 pl. 29. For nothing can pass out of the Crown but by matter of Record Or upon a Farmer of the King 2 Hen. 4.7 pl. 29. For he is in upon the Kings right and the prejudice done unto him is done unto the King immediately But against him that outs the Farmer the King shall have Trespass Com. 546. A. Paramors case Q. whether the Farmer may not also have Trespass The King shall have Trespass King Nat. Br. 90. I. Regist orig 99. A. And in this case the party cannot make fine because the dammages are to the King himself to Hen. 4.3 pl. 7. and the fine shall be included in the dammages Q. tamen For it seems he shall make fine But for Trespass in the Rings Lands there uses to be an information in the Exchequer Nat. br 90. I. This is not by way of English Bill but on the Pleas side Q. if it may not be by an English Bill And in such case the judgment is that the party shall be removed and put out of possession although that it be but a personal Suit and the removal shall be by Writ formed in the case ditected to the Sheriff Com. 561. B. This Judgment is by way of Decree ergo on the Pleas side But the King may have a Trespass quare clansum fregit Nat. br 90. I. if he will The Queen shall have Trespass without the King Queen Nat. Br. 101. for Lands belonging to her Revenue and she is not in the nature of another Feme covert Revusancy shall be pleaded in disability to sue an Action of Trespass for as many Hereditaments as are not seised into the Kings hands Recusant 3 Jac. cap. 5. For such as are seised concern not the Recusant A Bishop shall not have an Action of Trespass for a Trespass made in a vacancy of the Bishoprick Bishop 39 Edw. 3.12 pl. 18. 18 Edw. 2. Trespass 237. For that could not concern him but the Guardian of the Spiritualties as it seems Vide tamen Regist 101. A Writ formed in such case for the succeeding Bishop Ergo. Q. Master of an Hospital A Master of an Hospital shall have an Action of Trespass for a thing done in the time of his Predecessor for the dammage redounds to the House Nat. br 89. G. Regist orig 196. B. the Writ there And by the same reason why may not the Bishop for a Trespass done in the Vacancy Tenant at will Tenant at Will shall have Trespass against a Stranger 19 Hen. 6.45 pl. 94. 12 Edw. 4.8 pl. 20. 35 Hen. 6.5 pl. 7. For he hath a Title against him For entring his Close and burning his Hay 35 Hen. 6.5 pl. 7. Copy-holder shall have Trespass Copy-holder Coke 4. part 31. A. 2 Hen. 4.12 pl. 49. Coke 4. part 4.21 B 23. B. and this before his admission per descent for his admission is but a Ceremony yet essential to his Estate Tenant in common Tenants in Common join in Trespass touching their Tenancies Littleton sect 315. 18 Hen 6.5 14 Hen. 6.9 pl. 38. 12 Hen. 6.4 pl. 11. 45 Edw. 3.13 5 Hen. 4.1 14 Hen. 4.31 43 Edw. 3.24 pl. 3 22 Hen. 6.12 in respect of their common and undivided interests But if one dies the other shall have an Action for all the Trespass 43 Edw. 3.24 pl. 3. For it survives with the Land They ought to join in Trespass 5 Rich. 2. cap. 7. 34 Hen. 6.32 pl. 16. 4 Edw. 4.18 21 Hen. 7.22 because it concerns them both in common and undividedly Note For battery they shall not join Reg. orig 105. B. For that is a distinct Trespass for the beating of one is not the beating of the other A had Male Swans B Female which having young ones for the young ones they shall join if they be taken away because they are Tenants in Common Coke 7. part 17. A. 2 Rich. 3.15 16. of the Swans and the young ones One Tenanant in common shall not have Trespass de bonis asportatis against his companion that takes them Lib. Intra 653. B. sect 3. because he hath an interest in them Tenant for anothers life Tenant for anothers Life is disseised he for whose life he held dies Tenant
that he lost his Service Battery Mayheme and Imprisonment per quod c. Trespass lies Crooke 7 Hen. 8.80 pl. 4. If the Count be not per quod Servitium amisit although that Verdict pass for the Plaintiff yet he shall never have Judgment 21 Hen. 7.71 pl. 15. Crooke for there appears no dammages by the Plaintiffs shewing For enticing my Servant to depart Trespass lies not but an Action upon the Case 11 Hen. 4.3 pl. 46. for here is no vi armis in the case as all Trespasses do imply For taking away his Apprentice Apprentice Regist orig 109. A. per quod c. Q. whether he need to count so for it seems it must be so intended For a Goaler for taking away his Prisoner Prisoner Regist orig 104. A. 4 Edw. 4.6 pl. 7 antea For taking his Captive from him Captive Regist orig 95 A. 102. B. Nat. br 88. A. Q. what Captive whether one taken in the Wars Chattels personals Living Si quis distringit ordine non observato facit transgressionem Bracton Lib. 4. fol. 217. A. for the Law requires regularity and order in doing of things Trespass quare Averia cepit abduxit Regist orig 97. B. The Count Lib. Intra 628. B. Sect. 1. 670. B. sect 1. Note for live Cattel the Writ shall be cepit abduxit Nat. br 88. B. 21 Hen. 6.39 pl. 5.12 Hen. 8.9 B. if dead cepit asportavit And the Writ for live Cattel shall be Averia sua or shew the thing in certain 21 Hen. 6.39 pl. 5. And if the thing be dead or alive it is not material whether the Writ be pretii seu ad valentiam Nat. br 88. L. Q. for if alive it seems it should be pretii if dead ad valentiam For taking away his Boar Regist orig 110. B. Boar. For taking away his Oxen Regist orig 110. B. Oxen. For taking away his Mastiff Coke 7. part 18. Mastiff A. 12 Hen. 8.3 Regist orig 109. A. but he shall not say pretii or ad valentiam because a Dog is not a Marketable creature though valuable to the Owner 12 Hen. 8.5 A. Elliot Regist orig 109. A. For taking away his Capons Capons the Writ was bona catalla and good 17 Edw. 3.41 pl. 19. for they are general words and extend to all manner of goods proprietory whatsoever For taking away his Conies out of his Close Conies the Writ shall be suos Nat. br 87. A. Regist orig 93. B. 102. A. for the Owner of the Close hath a property in them Quaere if not tame Conies So if it be in a Park Regist 110. B. because he hath a property in the game in respect of the enclosure But if it be for entring into his Warren and taking his Conies he shall not say suos for he hath them but ratione privilegii viz. of hunting them 3 Hen. 6.55 pl. 34. Regist orig 110. A. Coke 7. part neither shall he declare of the value 8 Edw. 4.5 pl. 16. Lakin Quaere differentiam The Writ was Quare Warrennam intravit cuniculos cepit asportavit without saying ibidem and yet good 43 Edw. 3.13 pl. 7. for it shall be intended that he took them there where he entred for the Conjunction Et couples all together If Conies go out of a Warren any may kill them in his own Land and no Action lies Coke 5. part 104. 43 Edw. 3.13 pl. 7. For they cannot be said to have animum revertendi and so the property is gone Deer if they be tame Deer he shall say suas but then he ought to shew that they were tame 43 Edw. 3.24 pl. 2. For if he declare generally it shall not be intended that they were tame for tame Deer is but a rarity and not usual But if it be in a Park or Chase he shall not say suas because he hath them but ratione privilegii viz. of the place where they are so long as he can keep them there which is uncertain For taking away young Hawks he shall say suos Hawks because he hath a property possessory in them for he might have taken them when he pleased Coke 7. part Regist orig 93. B. 96. B. 110. B. Nat. br 89. K. So if they be reclaimed Hawks that is Hawks made tame or managed which were wild before For taking away a Horse Regist orig 95. A. Nat. br 87. M. the Count No. Lib. intra 666. B. sect 15. Lib. intra 682. D. For his Sheep taken away Regist orig 110. B. For taking his Fish Fish this is good although the Count be of a hundred Fishes because this word Piscis est nomen collectivum 4 Hen. 6.11 Coke 5. part 35.21 Hen 6.39 and comprehends any number as well as one Fish But the Count ought to shew the nature and number of the Fishes particularly Coke 5. part 35.31 Hen. 6.39 though the Writ be general that the dammage may be known De tauro suo libero Bull. Oves captae fugatae Regist orig 109. A. Oves fugatas per quod morierunt Lib. intra 616. B. sect 1. Nat. br 89. L. Regist orig 97. A. Porcos fugatos per quod interierunt Hogs Regist orig 97. A. Nat. br 89. L. Capta fugata imparcata There he shall say the price where he declares of a taking because Cepit implies that he had gained a property but it is otherwise if this word be put out 1 Hen. 5.3 4. But Regist orig 97. B. fuit Cepit abduxit without shewing the price of them and good because it may be he was seised of the Cattel Cepit in S. interfecit at W contra pacem Capta interfecta c. is nought because Cepit implies a property and then contra pacem is not good for he might kill them if they were his own 27 Assize 64. Averia ad loca incognita fugata upon the Stat. Districta of Marlebridge cap. 4. Regist orig 97. A. 102. A. 30 Assize 38. Nat. br 89. N. De Com. in com ibidem imparcata upon the Stat. of Marlebridge cap. 4. Westm 1. cap. 16. 1 2 Mariae cap. 12. Regist orig 97. B. 1 Eliz. Dyer 168. pl. 20. 2 Eliz. Dyer 177. pl. 32. Nat. br 89. P. And there are two causes of bringing this Action 1. He cannot give them Meat 2. They cannot be replevied 22 Edw. 4.11 Q. For he might lose his Cattel and have no remedy if he might not have this Action of Trespass Note Note upon these cases upon the Statute the Writ shall not be general but special upon the Statute 43 Edw. 3.30 pl. 16. as it is usual in all other such like cases The Action was of a Cow the Count Lib. intra 464. C. Pound For Marlebridge cap 4. saith districtiones but not upon 1 2 Mariae cap. 12. for the Statute saith Cattel and upon the second branch it lies well
3.72 pl. 1. Testamentum abstulit asportavit Will. Regist orig 107. B. Tunicam sc a Coat Armor Coat 9 Edw. 4.14 pl. 8. Five Tuns of Wine Wine the Writ was bona catalla and good Wine taken and carried away 39 Edw. 3.18 pl. 17. Lib. intra 684. A. sect 1. The Count Lib. intra 684. A. sect 1. Vestimenta 11 Hen. 4.31 pl. 57. Q. whether he must not shew what Cloaths Trespass Quare spinas suas crescent Thorns cepit asportavit ad valen c. Good without shewing the number of Loads for this is special and the value reduces it to a certainty Mich. 15. Jac. Ban. Regis Jones Wilson But if it be quasdam garbas tritici it is not good for the uncertainty what is meant by Garbes Shocks of Wheat Trin. 7 Jac. Ban. Regis For it seems a Garb may be more or less ERROR Error is either by 1. Common Law 1. Judgment in Court of Record 1. Out of the Realm 1. Ireland 2. Wales 2. In the Realm 1. Superior 1. Parliament 1. Parliament the Sheriff in Redisseism per Merton cap. 3. 1. Assizes 2. Oyer Terminer 3. Conusance of Pleas. 1. Village 2. Single person 4. Forest 5. Stannaries 2. Ban. Regis 3. Com. Ban. 4. Chancery 5. Exchequer 2. Inferior prescription 1. In him and his Successors 2. In him and his Heirs 3. In him and whose Estate he hath 2. Agard Execution 3. Other Record Fine Grant of the King 4. Custom 1. London 2. Cinque ports 3. In any Village 5. Common Right 1. Pypowders in Fair or Market 2. Marshalsey Coke 10 part 69. B. 3. Tourne 4. Leet 2. Statute Law Westm 1 2 cap. 30. upon a Bill of exception 5 Edw. 3. cap. 2. Error in Marshalsey Redress in Ban. Regis 9 Rich. 2. cap. 8. He in Reversion his Heirs or Successors shall have Error upon Judgment against Tenant for life c. and by equity he in Remainder 34 Hen. 8. cap. 16. Error upon Judgment before the Justices in the grand Sessions in Wales shall be redressed in Ban. Regis in England if it be in plea real or mixt but for personal matters it was to be redressed before the President and Council in Wales 23 Eliz. cap. 3. False Latine rasing interlining mis-entring of a Warrant of Attorney or Proclamation Mis-return or not Return of the Sheriff or fault of form in words shall not be Error in Fine or common Recovery 27. Eliz. cap. 9. ordains that this Statute of the 23 Eliz. cap. 3. extends to Fines and Recoveries in Wales 27 Eliz. cap. 8. Judgment given in Ban. Regis shall be redressed before the Judges of the Common Pleas and Barons of the Exchequer but then it ought to be in Debt Detinue Account Covenant Ejectione firmae Trespass Action upon the Case and there shall be nothing assigned in the Jurisdiction of the Court or in form in a Writ returned Plaint Bill Declaration Pleading Process Verdict or Proceedings 31 Edw. 3. cap. 12. Error redressed in the Exchequer-Chamber before the Chancellor and the Treasurer calling to them the Barons of the Exchequer and Justices 31 Eliz. cap. 1. The not coming of the Chancellor shall not make a Discontinuance of the Error in the Exchequer-Chamber And for Error therein sued upon a Judgment in Ban. Regis three of the Justices or Barons may adjourn it and it shall be no discontinuance Error In what Court Error shall be redressed Upon Judgment in Court out of the Realm Ireland JUdgment given in Ban. Regis in Ireland Error lies in Ban. Regis in England 15 Edw. 3. Error 72 37 Assize pl. 7. 5 Edw. 2. Error 89. 36 Assize 5. Nat. br 22. E. Coke 7. part 18. Calvins A. case But not upon a Judgment given in another Court in Ireland 5 Edw. 2. Error 89. Nat. br 22 E. but they shall be as it seems reversed in the Kings Bench there if they be erroneous and not trouble the Kings Bench here Erroneous Judgment in Wales shall not be redressed in Ban. Regis in England Wales Dodderidge De Principalitate Walliae fol. 18. because Wales was not parcel of the Crown of England 27 Hen. 7.33 pl. 32. but a Principality of it self belonging to the Crown But Crooke 11 Hen. 8.202 pl. 19. è contra for there it is said it is parcel of England Q. But in Parliament this ought to be reversed 19. Hen. 6.12 Ascue And also before Justices itincrant there 19 Hen. 6.12 Newton viz. in Wales But at this day Judgment given at the Grand Sessions in Wales in a plea real or mixt shall be redressed in ban regis in England per Statute 34 Hen. 8. cap. 26. But in plea personal it shall be redressed before the President of the Council in Wales by Bill exhibited before him But Judgments given in the Assizes in Wales cannot be redressed in Com. Ban. here 8 Eliz. Dyer 250.87 Isle of Man Erroneous Judgment given in the Isle of Man may not be redressed in England because it is not parcel of England Crooke 11 Hen. 8.202 pl. 19. Upon a Judgment given in ban regis Error lies in the same Court per Common Law 2. Within the Realm in Court superior as Parliament Ban. Regis if it be upon Error in Process or default of Clerks Nat. br 21 I. 7 Hen. 6.28 pl. 22. 19 Hen. 6.2 pl. 2.15 Edw. 4.7 8. 3 Eliz. Dyer 196. pl. 39. 27 Hen. 8.15 B. Knightley But if it be Error in Law which is the fault of the Justices it shall not be redressed but by Parliament per Common Law Nat. br 21. I. 9 Edw. 4.3 3 Eliz. Dyer 196. pl. 39. 201. pl. 64. 23 Eliz. Dyer 374. pl. 19. 27 Hen. 8.25 B. Fitz-James For they shall not reverse their own Judgments But Error in process or default of Clerks ought to be reversed in the same Term or otherwise it lies not in the same Court as it seems by the Justices Trin. 7. Jac. ban regis Prowse Skeynner Q. But one case was Mich. 41 42 Eliz. Rot. 639. which is a rule that Error lies in another Term upon Error in Process when the party cannot have Error in the Exchequer Chamber But by the Stat. of 27 Eliz. cap. 8. if Judgment be given in ban regis upon a Suit commenced there the Writ of Error lies in the Exchequer-Chamber before the Iustices of the Common Ban. and Barons of the Exchequer or six of them Coke 3. part 7. B. 4. part 53 86. A. 5 part 18. B. 28. A. 43. A. 97. B. But then it ought to be in Debt Detinue Account Covenant Ejectione firmae Trespass upon the case and no other Actions for the Stat. shall not be largely expounded And also nothing shall be assigned for Error in the jurisdiction of the Court or form of the Writ Return Plaint Bill Declaration Pleadings Process Verdict or Proceedings but only in matter in Law And also a