plead in person afterwards that he is Prior of the Church of St. Peter and Paul for that is parcell of the name which cannot be pleaded after Imparlance for that doth notstand with c. 35 H. 6. fol 37. Trespasse against J.S. of D. after Imparlance he demands Judgment of the Writ for day of the Writ purchased he was dwelling at S. and not at D. and shall not have it for it is contrary to the name which the hath affirmed by the Imparlance 32 H. 6. fol 35. After Imparlance the Defendant cannot plead that he is dwelling in another place then is in the Count 19 H. 6. fol 1. 35 H. 6. fol 43. Debt against J. S. as Executor of J. D. and he imparles he shall not say after that he is Administrator and nor Executor 32 H. 6. fol 32. The same 36 H. 6. fol 17. 37 H. 6. fol 32. If the Defendant in personall action imparle and at the day makes default Judgment shall be given and in a reall action shall be awarded a Pettie Cape 7 H 6. fol 30. The same 11 H 7 fol 5.38 H. 6. fol 36.39 H. 6. fol 17. 4 H. 7. fol 12. If a man in debt upon an Obligation imparle before he demands hearing of the Obligation and Condition and hath that entred he cannot plead the Condition afterward for he shall not have hearing of that if he do not alledge variance 13 H. 7. fol 17. Precipe of Lands in D. the Tenant imparles and at the day he may say no such Town 9 Ed 4. fol 33. the same 7 Ed 4. fol 1. Trespas 16 H. 7. fol 17. Debt by Prior the Defendant imparles and at the day saith that the Plaintiffe is deposed for that goes in Bar. 7 Ed. 4. fol 1. Trespas against J.S. de D. in the County of Middlesex after Imparlance the Defendant cannot say no such Town D. within the said County but he may say there is over D. and nether D and none without addition 22 Ed 4. fol 1. the same 9 Ed. 4. fol 38. Precipe after Imparlance one may plead Non-tenure and Joyntenancie But in Precipe of Lands in D. and S. the Tenant Imparles and at the day saith That D. is an Hamlet of S. without that that there is any Town or place known out of the Town named D. in the same County Judgment of the Writ and hath the Plea by the whole Court 9 Ed. 4. fol. 42. Debt against Executors after Imparlance he cannot say that the Testator dyes intestate and that the Administration was committed to him Judgment of the Writ for he is estopped by the Imparlance but he may plead never Executor nor ever administred as an Executor for that is with the c. 32 H. 6. fol. 32. the same 18 Ed. 4. fol. 19. Writ is abated by death and abateable by Joyntenancie and severall tenancie and where a man is made knight or a woman takes an husband and such like and saith where a Writ is abateable if he Imparle or take continuance he cannot plead in abatement But otherwise it is if it were abated See 7 H. 6. fol. 16. and 20 H. 6. fo 17. And note that it pleaded there that the Plaintiffe is a knight 44 Ed. 3. fol. 4. After Imparlance the Defendant may plead to the Action as to say that the Plaintiffe is a Channon professed c. But he cannot plead to the Writ unlesse he come after the Continuance unlesse it were for that that the Writ is abated as death c. 20 Ed. 4. fol. 9. Debt upon a Lease of a Corodie the Defendant imparles and after that shall not have hearing of the Deed. See 4 H. 7. fol 12. 4 H 7. fol. 17. Replegeare against three which imparle joyntly and one makes default the other cannot plead no such in being as one is which makes default 11 H. 7. fol. 5. Debt for Corn the Defendant imparles and at the day makes default there shall go a Writ to inquire of the value See 37 H. 6. fol. 32. 15 H. 7. fol. 14. Attorney for Corporation after Imparlance he cannot plead that they are corporate by another name 32 H. 6. fol 12. Where a Writ is abated he may plead that though there be a Continuance as to say that the Plaintiffe is dead or hath an Husband day of the Writ but if it be abateable it is otherwise he may say that after the last continuance is made knight Judgment of the Writ c. where it is abateable 34 H. 6. fol 49. Debt upon Obligation by three the Defendant pleads not his Deed yet he may plead that after the last continuance one Plaintiffe is dead 22 Ed 4. fol 36. Trespasse The Defendant after Imparlance may say that the Plaintiffe is his wife Judgment if Action or that the Plaintiffe is a Monk professed And in Mordancester that the Demandant is a Bastard And in Debt against Executors after Imparlance he may say he was never Executor nor ever administred as Executor for these are disabilities which go in Bar. 32 H. 6. fol 32. It seems a man may plead after a Continuance that the Plaintiffe is a stranger born or Monk professed Judgment if Action and not to the person 36 H. 6. fol 7. 7 H. 6. fol. 39. It seems that after Imparlance one cannot plead to the Jurisdiction unlesse it be after speciall Imparlance saving all advantages as well to the Jurisdiction of the Courts as to the Writ and Declaration 19 H. 6. fol. 7. Debt by Executor which shews the Will as it behoveth and after the Defendant imparles there he shall not have reading of the Will again 38 H. 6. fol. 2. But if he plead variance he shall have Reading and so in Debt upon Obligation 16 Ed. 4. fol. 4. Debt upon specialtie the Defendant may plead Out-lawrie in the Plaintiffe though he hath parled for that is a Bar and intitles the King 4 Ed. 4. fol. 15. Debt after Imparlance one space in the Count cannot be amended in another tearm 39 H. 6. fol. 22. Debt upon arrerages of annuitie after Imparlance the Defendant cannot have hearing of the Deed But if the Defendant plead that it was made in another County then where the Writ was brought and then he shall shew 39 H. 6. fol. 17. the same Pleas after day given IF the Defendant imparle and make default he shall be condemned and upon day given shall issue Processe 7 H. 6. fol. 42. 19 H. 8. fol. 6. Note by all the Prothonotaries that day given is ever before the Count and Imparlance is after the Count and therefore where three Capias and Exigent is awarded and the Defendant appear upon the Exigent and hath day given and after makes default Distringas shall go and upon that returned Nihil other 3 Capias and Exigent and upon default in persâ—r all action he shall be condemned See 7 H. 6. fol 42. 20 H. 6. fol 17. Trespas the Defendant at the day which he hath by
Imparlance saith that the Plaintiffe was knight day of the Writ purchased not named knight Judgment of the Writ and had plea by Judgment Otherwise it is said after continuance by day given 42 Ed 3. fol 1. Debt the Defendant came at the Exigent by Reddidit se and was bayled and the Plaintiffe came and prayed day by Prece partium and had it notwithstanding that the Defendant was by Bayl for that is by agreement of the parties 8 H. 5. fol 8. After day given and after speciall Imparlance the Defendant may plead in abatement and not after generall Imparlance 14 H. 4. fol 14. If the parties be at Issue and the Demandant releases to the Tenant and he takes continuance by request of the parties he shall not plead the release 22 Ed 3. fol 8. The Tenant after the request of the parties was received to plead Joyntenancie by Fine Pleas after Issue and at the Nisi prius day in Bench and after Verdict DOwer by Thorpe the day of the Nisi prius and the day in Bench is not all one to all respects for a Writ purchased mean between the Nisi prius and day in Bench shall abate for the first Writ is hanging till Judgment be given notwithstanding the Plaintiffe was non-suited at the Nisi prius But when to plead any Pleas which come mean between them there shall be one same day 40 Ed 3. fol 38. 28 H. 6. fol 1. A man may plead a Plea after last continuance at the Nisi prius Inquire what Pleas. 34 H. 6. fol 45. At the day of the Nisi prius the Defennant pleads to the Writ that one of the Plaintiffes was dead after the last continuance at D. in the County of Darby Judgment of the Writ and had it 47 Ed 3. fol 2. If it be found against the Plaintiffe at the Nisi prius and the Plaintiffe makes default at the day in Bench yet Judgment shall be upon the Verdict for that is all one day and the day of the Nisi prius 10 H. 7. fol 21. Debt upon a Lease for yeers and the Issue was levyed by distresse or not And now at the Nisi prius he could not plead a Release made after the last continuance 19 H. 6. fol 36. Forging of false Deeds against many they were at Issue Processe continued against the Enquest till the Jury appeared at which day the Defendant pleads arbitrement after the last continuance and upon this the Jury was discharged 21 H. 6. fol. 10. Nisi prius was returned Octa Mich that is the day in Bench and one Plaintiffe dyed after Octa Mich and before Judgment given upon the Verdict And the Defendant may plead that for Judgment shall have relation to Octa Mich and then the Defendant cannot have remedie by Writ of Error Audita querela nor otherwise therefore he shall have the Plea again But it seems that the Defendant cannot plead Release made to him by the Plaintiffe after Verdict for he shall have an Audita querela contrary of his death the day of Nisi prius and the day in Bench were all one self same day and no mean time and therefore Release made mean between these two cannot be pleaded at the day in Bench notwithstanding it seems at the day of Nisi prius before the Jury taken The Release which is made mean between the Award of the Writ of Nisi prius and the day of the Nisi prius may be pleaded at the Nisi prius See 10 H. 6. tit 53 and tit 55. Br. 22 H. 6. fol 1. Dower It seems if the Plaintiffe release to the Defendant mean between the award of the Nisi prius and the day of the Nisi prius there if the Jury remain for default of Jurors the Defendant may plead this Release at the day in Bench after the last continuance though he did not offer it at the day of Nisi prius and contrary it seems if the Jury had been ready at the Nisi prius 36 H. 6. fol 24. At the Nisi prius the Enquest past for the Plaintiffe and he released before the day in Bench the Defendant shall have an Audita querela and of this it follows that the Defendant cannot plead that at the day in Bench after the last Continuance 34 H. 6. fol 3. 21 H. 7. fol 33. After the Enquest taken by default the Defendant cometh before Judgment and pleads that he and the Plaintiffe have put themselves to Arbitrement after the last Continuance c. And by the opinion of the Court he hath no day in Court to plead that Plea And it was said that he shall plead no plea in such case but as a freind to the Court But of matter apparent he shall be received but in the Kings case he shall have that by plea for he hath no other remedie But in the case between common persons he shall have Audita querela contrary against the King 11 H. 7. fol 10. tit B. 61. 38 H. 6. fol 33. Debt by Moyle the Defendant after that he was at Issue might once plead plea after the last Continuance as release or such like notwithstanding no oftner then once 41 Book of Ass 19. If Verdict passe for the Plaintiffe and the Defendant get a release before Judgment yet he cannot plead that 21 Ed 4. fol 52. Adjudge that the Defendant cannot plead Release made mean between the Nisi prius and the day in Bench. 16 Ed 4. fol 5. A man may plead a Plea after the last Continuance after Issue joyned and in another Tearm And therfore it seems that the parties have day in Court as well after Issue joyned till Verdict as before 50 Ed 3. fol 4. Imparlance at a day in the same Tearm and at a day and Tearm between and Imparlance of the Plaintiffe COntinuance by Capias ought to be made from Tearm to Tearm and cannot have other Tearm between for that that the party shall not stay so long in prison but continuance by distresse may be made by a Tearm between as from Michaelmasse Tearm to Easter 8 Ed 4. fol. 13. 12 H. 7. fol Common recoveries for assurance the Tenant tenders Issue the Demandant may Imparle to a day in the same Tearm 44 Ed 3. fol 16. If a man Imparle to another day in the same Tearm or till the next day yet that is a new day at which the parties are demandable 37 H. 6. fol 27. Debt Defendant pleads misnaming of himself and the Plaintiffe Imparles and had it 22 Ed. 4. fol. 19. Where the Defendant in appeal of Robbery by which he put his life in jeopardie the Plaintiffe shall not Imparle to that and therefore ruled that he should answer the Court sitting What Pleas he shall have after the last Continuance WHere the parties and Jury appear at the fourth day in the Common Bench and are adjourned at another day a man may plead a Plea after the last Continuance 28 H. 6. fol. 1. 8 Ed. 4. fol. 9. Where
came with him to the Assise staid with him pray'd the Sheriff to make an indifferent pannell which is the same maintenance and it is a good Plea 11 H. 6. f. 39. Generall Attorney which sues and is not skilled in the Law may well meddle but he cannot proffer Money to a Jury but may pray them to appeare 34 H. 6. fol. 27. By Choke Maintenance he cannot justifie for that that he was an Attorney retained with him and that by commandement of his Master he retained Councell and gave to them forty pence of his Masters Money and good Inquire if an Attorney cannot retaine Councell without the commandement of his Clyent and if he may not disburse of his proper Moneys for the time But Attorney cannot give of his proper Money nor of his Masters money to Jurors 36 H. 6. fol. 29.11 H. 6. fol. 13. the same Maintenance the Defendant saith that he was an Attorney in the action Judgment if action and good But he cannot give any thing to the Jury but as an Attorney and give Evidence to the Jury for his Clyent he may 13 H. 4. f. 19. If a man maintaine a quarrell by his Attorney action of maintenance lies against the Master 22 H. 6. f. 24. And by Newton If a man of great power in the Countrey will say in the presence of the people that he will spend twenty pound for one party or will give twenty pound to labour for the party though he give nothing is maintenance see before 9 H. 7. fol. 18. Maintenance against a Servant of one by Fortescue if he meance Jurors to out them of their Tenures if they do not paâ—e with his Master this is special Maintenance in the Servant 19 H. 6. f. 30. A man skilled in Law may do his endeavour for his Client and it is no maintenance if the Plaintiff cannot alleadge other special matter forbidden by the Law 8 H. 4. f. 6. B. Embraceor is he which comes to the Barr with the party and speaks in the matter or is there to overlook the Jury or to put them in feare but men skilled in Law may speak in the Cause for their Money but they cannot labour the Jury and if they take money to do that they are Embraceors Fitzh f. 71. A. Tenures and Services It is expedient to know the Services and Tenures which your Tenants shall do and first of the Tenure in cheif and other Tenures of the King and then of other Lords FIrst Tenure in cheif is called where one holds of the King meerly as of his Crown which is a Signiory ingrosse for that it is held of him which is alwayes King and not of the King as of his Mannour of D. c. Fuzh. 3. D. If any Land be held of the King as of the Honour Castle or Mannour such Lands are not held of the King in cheif and this is proved by the Writ of Right which shall be directed in such a Case to the Bailiffs of the Honour Castle or Mannour Also the Statute of Magna Charta chap. 31. is if any hold of any Escheat as of his Honour of Wallingford Nottingham Bullo gne Lancaâ—â—er and of other Escheats which are in Our hand and are of Baronies and dies his Heir shall not give other releif nor make to us other Service then the Barons should make if that Barony were in the hands of the Baron and we in the same manner will hold it as the Baron held it 1 Ed. 6. chap. 4. also is that where a King hath or after shall have any Dukedomes Baronies Castles Mannours Land Tenements Fees or Signiories by Attainder Conviction Outlary or by Dissolution of Monasteries which Lands held of them by Knights Service Socage or otherwise shall not be construed to hold in chief nor as Tenure in cheif See in Br. Tit. Tenures 100. Littleton fol. 31. Tenure of the King in Burgage is where an ancient Town is of which the King is Lord and those which have Tenements within the Borough hold of the King their Tenements that every Tenant by his Tenure ought to pay to the King a certain Rent by the year and such Tenure is but Tenure in Socage Fitzh 6. D. Lands and Tenements within Cities and Townes are held of the King in Burgage Tenure and it behoveth that a Writ of Right Patent of them shall be directed to Mayors Sheriffs and Bailiffs as Bailiffs and Officers of the King as if Lands were held of the King as of any Honour Castle or Mannour by which it appears Tenure in Burgage is Socage Tenure and not Socage in cheif Fitzh fol. 1. J. the same Stamford 13. If one hold of the King in Burgage the King shall not have first Seisin but otherwise it is where he holds of the King by Knights Service in cheif or by Socage in cheif for the Statute of the Kings Prerogative chap. 3. is the King shall have the first Seisin after the Death of them which of him held in cheif of all Lands and Tenements of which they were seised in their Demesn as of Fee whatsoever age their Heirs were of and that is taken as well of Socage in cheif as otherwise in cheif 7 H. 6. fol. 3. The King shall have first Seisin where his Tenant dies seised in his Demesne as of Reversion 47 Ed. 3. fol. 21. If the King purchase Lands which is held of others by this all the Services are extinguished and if he infcoff others to hold of him he shall hold of his Crown in cheif by Finchden and also when an Honour is seised into the Kings hands and a Mannour is held of that Honour which escheats unto him as of common Escheat if he alien to hold of him he shall hold as he held before of the Honour and by the same Services but if he come in as by Forfeiture by Warr or Escheat which is because of his own person and he seise and infeoff others they shall hold in cheif if the King do not expresse other Tenure 33 H. 6 fol 7. By Prisot if the King seise Land by Forfeiture of Treason and grant that over to hold of the cheif Lord by the Service due c. that in this case he shall hold of the cheif Lord as it hath been adjudged 44 Ed. 3. f. 45. The King gives Lands to one to hold to him and his Heirs by the Services due c. and by all the Justices that is Tenure by Knights Service 11 H. 4. fol. 71. It was recorded in the Exchequer that such a one holdeth so much Land of our Lord the King by Serjeanty to finde one Man for the Warr wheresoever within the four Seas and by Hank it is great Serieanty to be made by the Body of a Man 13 H. 7. fol. 16. If one hold of the Dutchy of Cornwall it is in cheif for it was ancient Lands of the Crown Fitzh 165. A. To hold Land to pay certain Rent to the Keeper of the Castle of
so high and not upon bare matter DEbt upon arrearages of Annuity the Defendant saith that he let the Mannour of D. to him in recompence and it is no Plea for it is not so high 19 H. 8. fol. 9. Trespasse upon the Statute of Rich. The Defendant pleads in Barre warranty of the Ancestor of the Plaintiffe and demands Judgement if against the warranty c. and it is no Plea for Damages is onely to berecovered 10 H. 7. fol. 12. Trespasse the Defendant may plead Fine with Proclamation Judgement if Action but not to relie upon the estoppell 27 H. 8. fol. 27. 14 H. 4. fol. 27. Debt upon a Lease by Indenture the Defendant saith that he hath bestowed the Rent upon reparations by commandement of the Plaintiffe and it is not good for it is not so high 10 H. 7. fol 4 Debt upon arrearages of a Lease for years the Defendant pleads agreement and it is not so high 1 H. 7. fol. 14. The Defendant cannot avoid specialty by bare matter as to say the specialty was delivered to him in place of an acquittance for it is not so high 10 Ed. 4. fol. 18 Debt upon an Obligation endorsed with condition that if the Defendant serve him in all his lawfull commands c. the Defendant may plead that he discharged him and it is good without specialty for the condition is matter in deed 18 Ed. 4. fol. 9 If one covenant by Indenture to make me a house before such a day and he plead that I discharged him before the day it is good without specialty for I cannot come upon his Land after discharge 19. Ed. 4. fol. 2 the same 21 H. 6. fol. 36. Trespasse of taking his Apprentice the Defendant saith that the Plaintiffe discharged him before the Trespasse of taking and it seems no Plea for that he is an Apprentice by Indenture and the discharge without specialty and to another person 9 Ed. 4. fol. 57. Annuity the Defendant pleads levied by distresse in another County and so that he owes him nothing and it is good but that he owes him nothing onely is no Plea against specialty 3 H. 6. fol. 41. Scire facias upon recovery of arrerages of annuity Defendant pleads that the Deed of annuity was delivered to him in lieu of an Acquittance and it is no Plea against a recovery 11 H. 4. fol. Debt upon arrerages before Auditors the Defendant pleads that he hath an obligation for the same and it is no Plea for it is not so high 11 H. 7. fol. 13. VVaste Defendant pleads an agreement between him and the Plaintiff and it is no Plea for the Inheritance is to be recovered in this writ and for that it is no Plea Scire facias upon a Recognisance to have one here at a certaine day to appeare it is no Plea to say I have been there without shewing his appearance of Record for it is not so high 7 H. 6. fol. 26. B. Debt upon arrerages of account before Auditors the the Defendant pleads Abitrement and it is no Plea against matter of Record before Auditors 3 H. 6. f. 55. 8 H. 5. f. 3. the same 10 H. 6. tit 44. 4 H. 6. fol. 17. and 3 H. 4. f. 7. H. 4. f. 6. adjudged Debt upon an obligation the Defendant cannot plead payment for it is not so high 1 H. 7. fol. 14. Debt upon an obligation endorced upon condition the Defendant may plead that the Plaintiff hath retained parcell of the smaller summ hanging the VVrit and it is good in abatement without specialty 5 H. 7. f. 4. Action upon the Statute of Rich. If the Defendant plead Act of Parliament by force of which he was seised till the Plaintiff entered upon him upon which he re-entered the which is the same Trespasse c. and concludes Judgement if action it is good 3 Ed. 4. fol. 6. Annnity by grant the Defendant saith in abatement that after the action brought that the Plaintiff hath retained part of the arrerages and it is no Plea without specialty for it is not so high 22 Ed. 4. fol. 51. Debt upon an obligation the Defendant pleads receit of parcell hanging the VVrit Judgment of the writ and it is not good without specialty 7 Ed. 4. fol. 15. 15 H. 7. fol. 10. Debt upon a single obligation of twenty pound the Defendant pleads that the Plaintiff hath received parcell hanging the VVrit and demands Judgment of the VVrit and it is no Plea without shewing Acquittance for it is not so high VVaste the Defendant pleads agreement to make fludgates only and agreement is no Plea in this action for it is not so high for Land is to be recovered 13 H. 7. f. 20. 11 H. 7. f. 13. Covenant upon specialty the Defendant pleads arbitrement and it is not good for it is not so high 3 H. 4. fol. 2. Debt upon obligation the Defendant cannot plead that the Plaintiff delivered this obligation again to him in place of an Acquittance and took it again from him for it is not so high 5 H. 4. fol 2. Debt for Rent upon a Lease by Indenture the Defendant cannot plead payment for it is not so high but payment and so he owes him nothing is good but where a Lease is by word payment in Debt upon that is good 1 H. 5 fol. 6 See 46 E. 3. f. 1. See 10 H. 7.24 b. 11 H 7.4 b. 20 H. 6.20 b. 9 Ed. 4.27 Debt upon obligation upon condition the Defendant may plead payment according to the condition without specialty 5 H 7 fol. 41. 5 Edw. 4 fol 5. the same Debt for Rent upon a Lease payment is no Plea without saying and so he owes him nothing but payment in another County is good without concluding and so he oweth him nothing 33 H 6 fol 4. 10 H 7 fol 4.3 H 7 fol 3. Debt upon a bargaine where the Defendant may wage his Law he cannot plead payment in another County 18. H 6 fol 13. 10 H 7 f 4. 11 H 74 b. Count. Count shall be more certaine then a Barr and yet sometimes it is good by intendment that is if Common reason do not imply contrary to the Count it is good by intendment DEbt upon obligation without date yet the Plaintiff ought to count when it was made But otherwise it is if the Defendant plead an Acquittance without date 3 H. 4. f. 5. 6 Ed. 4. f. 11. Debt or annuity without date the same 5 H. 7.24 B. of annuity Quare impedit If the Plaintiff counts that foure persons were seised of a Mannour to which the Advowson is appendant whose Estate he hath it is not good without counting how he hath it otherwise it is in Barr 2 H 6. fol. 10. Action upon the case of borrowing a Horse to ride to York and counts that he rode him further he ought to count in what County York is 21 Ed 4. fol 79 b Debt and counts that if the Defendant make voluntary wast
in Maintenance if he justifie he shall say he shall say without that that he maintained in other manner 32 H. 6. f. 1 Trespasse of Assault and threatning the Defendant saith that the Plaintiff called him Traitor and he said thou lyest in thy throat it is no Plea for he doth not confesse any threatning 37 H. 6. f. 3 Conclude Order and form how one ought to conclude in his Plea WHere to a Bar there ought to be a Reply the Conclusion of his Plea shall be and this he is ready to prove c. and where but ready that so there it is otherwise 33 H. 6. f. 21 12 Ed. 4. f. 13 the same As in Dower the Tenant pleaded not ever seised that Dower he ought to conclude and of this he puts himself upon the Country for no Reply shall be but ready that so Where the Defendant pleads to the Issue the conclusion shall be and of this he puts himself upon the Countrey and where the Plaintiffe pleads to the Issue he shall say and he desires that this may be inquired by the Countrey 26 H. 8. f. 4. If one plead a Plea which is not traversable as no wrong or generall Issue or Record as Outlawry he need not in his conclusion averr his Plea that is and this he is ready to prove c. 36. H. 6. fol. 17. When the Defendant justifies he ought to conclude and this he is ready to prove c. and when he pleads the generall Issue he need not 6 H. 4. fol. 18. and the Book of Entries fol. 152. the same Quare impedit If the Defendant plead that it is incorporated by another name Judgement if Action this conclusion is not good but he ought to conclude Judgement of the Writ 26 H. 8. fol. 1. â—nd 4 H. 6. fol. 27. Where the Defendant saith that the Parties to the Fine have nothing but one such a one whose estate he hath he ought to conclude and this he desires may be inquired by the Countrey and the aforesaid Plaintiffe likewise it shall be entered for here needs no Reply but ready that so as above 12 Ed. 4. fol. 13. Debt upon Obligation the Defendant saith that it was endorsed upon Condition to perform Covenants of an Indenture and that part was read and part not and that he was a man unlearned there he ought to conclude Judgement if Action the same Law is where he saith it was made by constraint or that he was under age or that it was delivered as an Eserow 7 Ed. 4.3 B. he ought to say Judgement if Action 14 H. 8. fol. 30. Debt upon obligation to plead payment and delivery of that in place of an Acquittance he ought to conclude judgement if action but if he avoid that for that it is raced or interlined there it shall be concluded not his deed for where a Deed is void he ought to conclude not his Deed and where voidable or matter in Law judgment if action 1 H. 7 f. 14. Debt upon Obligation to say he is a man unlearned and this was read to him to be with Condition and so this Obligation being single is not his Deed 7 Ed. 4. fol. 5. 15 Ed. 4. fol. 17. 16 Ed. 4. f. 1. the same 9 H. 5. f. 15. and 3 H. 6. fol. 52. Debt upon a Lease to plead payment in another County or levyed by Distresse without concluding and so he ows him nothing is good 9 Ed. 4. fol. 57.3 H. 7. fol. 3. and 33 H. 6. f. 4. the same but levied by Distresse or payment in the same County is not good without concluding and so he owes him nothing Debt for Wages upon a Bargain to plead payment in the same County and conclude and so he oweth him nothing is good 40 Ed. 3. fol. 24. Debt upon a Lease by Indenture for the defendant to plead payment in the same County it is no Plea without concluding and so he oweth him nothing to the point of the Writ 1 H. 5. fol. 6. Where he ought to conclude and so not his Deed. DEbt upon a single Obligation the Defendant saith that he is a man unlearned and this was read to him with a Condition and so not his deed 1 H. 6. fol. 3 H. 6. fol. 38. Debt by a Husband and his Wife of an Obligation made to them the defendant being Executor J.S. pleads Release of the Husband made to him and the Release was of all actions and demands as Executor and all actions personalls and other demands and the Plaintiffe saith that he is a man not learned and it was read for Actions as Executor and so not his deed and good See 3 H. 7. fol. 5. and 19 H. 8. 1 H. 7. fol. 14. If the defendant confesse that once by his own Plea his deed he cannot afterwards conclude and so not his deed As if an Infant makes a deed or a man by constraint if he plead these matters to avoid that he cannot conclude and so not his deed but where an Obligation is void he ought to conclude and so not his deed as where an Obligation is made by a married Wife or a deed raced or interlined 1 Ed. 3. fol. 5. the same Where he ought to conclude according to his matter pleaded LIttleton f. 39 Six manner of men are against which if they sue Actions Judgement may be demanded if they shall be answered in the Conclusion of his Plea and first if he say that the Plaintiff is his Villain he shall say Judgement if he shall be answered second is outlawed third is a stranger born fourth is one attaint in a Premunire fifth is professed in Religion sixth is excommunicated the Defendant may plead these and demand Judgement if the Plaintiff shall be answered 34 H. 6. fol. 9 If the Tenant plead Joint-tenancy or other Plea in Abatement he ought to conclude Judgement of the Writ and where one pleads in Barr he ought there to conclude Judgement if Action 49 Ed. 3. f. 24 Account of Receit in C. the Defendant saith that C. is within the five Ports Judgement if the Court will acknowledge it and so alwayes to the Jurisdiction that is Conclusion as Parson sue for Tithes c. In divers Cases they ought to conclude in the Negative where so to the Affirmative pleads that his Plea is but as an Argument and not full Answer and also to make the matter in Law plain SCire facias against a Parson of Arâ—erages of an Annuity the Defendant pleads that before the Writ purchased he resigned and so not Parson and it is good 7 Ed. 4. fol. 16 10 H. 7. f. 4 Said in Debt upon a Lease for the Rent behinde if the Defendant pleads Payment in another County this is good without concluding and so he owes him nothing c. But if he plead Payment in the same County it is no Plea without concluding and so he owes him nothing 9 Ed. 4. f. the last 9 Ed. 4. fol. 15 Debt
made before the Statute of quia em tores terrarum after the time of memorie and the Lord said that he did not give after the time of memorie and is good notwithstanding it be a pregnant Negative 39 H. 6. f. 8. Debt upon Obligation the Condition to repair a House and saith that A. disturbed him by the Plaintiffes command the Plaintiffe saith that he did not disturb him by his commandement and it is a pregnant Negative and double and for that saith that he did not command him and took the other by Protestation 9 H. 6. f. 44. Debt upon Obligation the Defendant saith it is indorsed upon condition to be at the arbitrement of B. so that it be delivered to the parties before such a day the Defendant saith that the Arbitrators made no such Award and delivered to the parties and it is good notwithstanding that it be a pregnant Negative for that it is Condition and is the whole Condition 10 Ed. 4. fol. 6. Debt upon the statute against a Vicar for taking Farmes he had not nor held not against the forme of the statute is good though it be a pregnant Negative for that it is to the point of the statute 27 H. 8. f. 25. Action upon the Case against a common Inholder of his Goods taken where they were laid the Defendant saith that they were not taken in default of him nor of his Servants and it is not good for it is a pregnant Negative the same Law is where the Defendant saith that he delivered to the Plaintiff the Key of his Chamber and he carried A. and B. with him which carried out the Goods the Plaintiff saith that A. and B. which he brought in with him did not carry out his Goods and it is not good for it is a pregnant Negative 22 H. 6. fol. 22. Waste of ten Oakes the Defendant saith that the Plaintriff gave them to J. S. and commanded the Defendant to cut them and to give them to J. S. which he did 〈◊〉 the Plaintiff saith he did not cut them by his dommandement and it is not good for it is a pregnant Negative and for that he saith that he did not command 21 H. 6. fol. 49. Action upon the Case of his House burnt in dosaâ—â—â— of good keeping the Fine of the Defendant the Defendant saith that the House was not burnt in default of his good keeping of his fire in manner and forme and it is a pâ—egnant Negative and was pleaded in Ariest of Judgement for that that in this are comprised two Sentences one that the House was not burnt the other that it was not in default of the Defendant 28 H. 6. f. 8. Obligation Here I intend to shew to you how the Condition of Obligations ought to be pleaded performed WHere one pleads Conditions performed and his Plea is in the Affirmative he ought to plead in certain as where the Condition is to discharge the Obligee it is no plea to say that he hath discharged him but he ought to plead now he hath discharged certainly 5 H. 7. f. 8. 6 H. 7. f. 5. But if the Condition be to save him without damage to pleade in the Negative he was not â—amnified is good 7 H. 4. f. 13.38 H. 6. f. 14. 10 H. 7. f. 13. By Hussey if Condition be to save the Plaintiff harmlesse to plead he was not damnified is good but it the Condition be to discharge or acquiâ— him he ought to plead how specially he hath acquitted and discharged him 22 Ed. 4. f. 43.35 H. 6. f. 13. 40 Ed. 3. f. 20. If the Condition be that if the Defendant acquit the Plaintiff against J. S. and he pleads that J. S. released to the Plaintiff at his request and this is a good Acquittall 1. H. 7. f. 30. Condition was to discharge a Sheriff it was held clear that the Defendant shall say generally that he hath discharged him without shewing how for he cannot shew speciall discharge where there was no Charge I suppose this was for that it was infinito◠〈◊〉 Ed. 〈◊〉 f. 10. 21 H. 7. fol. 30. Condition that if he keep J.S. discharged of all Escapes of all Felone in such a Prison the Defendant saith there were but two Prisoners that is J.S. and R.K. and that he was not damnified and a good Plea If the Condition be to gather all the green Wax of the County the Defendant may plead generally that he gathered all without shewing specially what that is for that that it is infinite 2 H. 7. fol. 15. If Condition be that if the Defendant serve the Plaintiffe without absence for seven yeares speciall license excepted the Defendant may plead that he hath served the Plaintiff this seven yeares and not absented himselfe speciall license excepted and it is good for it may be he hath licensed him diverse times and he need not shew all 6 Ed. 4. fol. 2. If the condition be that if the Defendant finde sufficient Meat Drink and Apparrell to one till he be of the age of twenty foure yeares it is a good Plea to say that he hath found him Meat Drink and Apparrell sushcient at D. for all the time aforesaid without shewing in speciall what Meat and what apparrell and the Plaintif takes Issue that he did not finde to him sufficient Apparrell And took not Issue upon all for doublenesse 12 H. 7. f. 14. If condition be that if the Defendant shall not prove that J.S. was not presented and instituted to the Church of D. that then c. The Defendant may say that J.S. was not instituted and it seems good for the condition is negative and therefore it sufficeth to say as above in the negative The same Law is if the condition were that if the Defendant prove that he oweth nothing to the Plaintif it sufficeth to say he owes nothing The same Law is if the condition be that if I prove my Wife not guilty of such a Trespasse it sufficeth to say that she is not guilty 15 Ed. 4. fol. 25. If the condition were that if he prove within one year that it was the will of J.S. to say that J.S. made this Will which he brought to the Plaintif within one year written is not good But by 3. Justices proof of that by two Witnesses to plead that is good though it be not by Jury 10 Ed. 4. fol. 11. If the condition be that if he do not enter and claime the House the Defendant may plead that he did not enter nor claime that and the Plaintiff shall say that he claimed and shew the manner of that 4 H. 7. f. 13. Condition if the Defendant make an estate to the Plaintif before P. as it shall be demised by the Councell of the Plaintif The Defendant may plead that the Councell gave no advise or no advise was given by Councell and good in the negative and the Plaintif then in the affirmative cannot say that the Councell did give advise
Steward and that in a Leet was presented that the Plaintif is a Felon and that he shewed his Rolls to the Justices at the Session which commanded him to shew that to the Jurors which inquired for the King which he did and saith that that is the same for by Englefield when the Defendant pleads a Conspiracy which is iustifiable he ought to shew that it is the same Conspiracy 27 H. 8. fol. 2. Annuity is brought of six and twenty shillings and eight pence the Defendant saith that he held of the Plaintif by six and twenty and eight pence of Rent which is the same Rent and is not good for it cannot be the same 33 H. 6. f. 38. Debt upon Obligation the Defendant saith it was made by threats the Plaintif saith that he let the Land to the Defendant rendering Rent and saith if he would not seal the Obligation to him for the Rent behinde he would sue him at the Common Law which is the same threatning and it is no good Plea for this is lawfull and not a threatning 16 Ed. 4. f. 7. Br. Tit. Duresse 23. Maintenance the Defendant saith that he carried the Money of him which the Plaintif supposed he maintained to his Counsel which is the same Maintenance and this is no plea for this is no Maintenance 34 H. 〈◊〉 fol. 19. Replication Where a faulty Barr is made good by Replication and where not TRespasse the Defendant pleads an Agreement to pay Money and to make Windows and said that he paid the Moneys and nothing of the Windows and the Plaintiff replied and said no such Agreement and yet the Plaintiff in Barr pleaded an Agreement and that not executed is not made good by the Replication for the Barr is not good to no intent and the Replication cannot make that good 6 H. 7. f. 10. But count where a Barr may be made good by a Plea of the other party where the Count or the Barr is uncertain as where the Plaintiff counts of an Obligation in Debt and doth not count where it was made and the Defendant pleads Release and acknowledge it and the Conisee where the place should be in is now outed and need not to have that the same Law in Trespasse where a man pleads Arbitrement and doth not shew the place where the Submission was that is not good but if the Plaintiff reply and saith that he discharged the Arbitrators before the Award now it is good for that which was ill is now confessed 10 H. 7. f. 24. 20 H. 7. f. 12. By Hussey if one plead Joint-tenancy day of the Writ purchased it is not good for that he might be sole Tenant after if the Demandant saith sole Tenant and doth not demurr it is made good by Replication 5 H. 7. f. 14. The same Law if in Debt against Executors they plead nothing in their hands day of the Writ purchased and do not say nor ever after the plea is not good but if the Plaintiff reply and say that they have Assets and that is found he shall have Judgement 3 H. 7. fol. 8. accordingly False Imprisonment the tenth day of May the Defendant saith that the Plaintiff made an affault in the Court before the Steward and for his disturbance of the Peace in the Court he was committed to ward the Plaintiff saith of his own wrong without such cause and now though the Defendant hath not shewed what day the Court was yet by the replication it is made good for now the day is not materiall 21 H. 7. f. 32. If double Plea be pleaded and the Plaintiff replies and rakes Issue of one matter and that is found he cannot after plead in arrest of Judgment for by the Replication it is made good 18 Ed. 4. fol. 17. Debt upon in Obligation the Defendant pleads a defeasance which is that if the Defendant deliver to the Plaintif in London certaine Clothes of Kersey of as good Stuff and of as good making as before these times have been made in the Town of D. in the County of Darby that then the Obligation should be void and saith that he hath delivered to the Plaintif in London the Clothes of as good c. According to the condition and this Plea is not good for that that it cannot be tried for those of London cannot try if they were as good c. But the Plaintif replied and said that the Plaintif did not deliver to us any manner of Cloth in London ready c. and now by the Replication it is good 22 Ed. 4. fol. 2. Debt the Plaintif counts upon a Lease for terme of yeares and doth not shew where it was made and the Defendant traverses the Lease and the Plaintif replies and joynes Issue and after acknowledges the action and after pleads in arrest of Judgment for that the Plaintiff hath not declared in what place the Lease was made and yet he had Judgment for when the Defendant hath in Barr gainsaid the Lease he hath admitted the count good 18 Ed. 4. fol. 17. And in Debt if I Plead the Release of the Plaintif and do not shew where it was made and the Plaintif replies and pleads not his Deed the Plea of the Defendant is made good by his Replication Br. title Repleader 38. Annuity for Counsell given and to be given and counts that he hath given to him Councell in doing his businesses and though he do not shew in what businesses it is good for if the Defendant saith that he doth not give to him Councell against the Plaintif in his replication he may shew in what things he gave Councell and so the replication hath made all good and the Count was good generally 39 H. 6. fol. 33. By Vanisor Replication may make an ill Barr good as I plead in Barr grant of Reversion and omit attornement if the Plaintif reply and confess and avoid the grant by speciall matter then is the Barr good 11 H. 7.24 By Read in Debt against one as Executor which pleads nothing in their hands day of the Writ purchased which is no Plea for that that he may have assets afterwards But if the Plaintif reply that he hath assets and that found by Verdict is good 6 H. 7. fol. 6. The same Law if the Tenant in Precipe plead non-Tenure day of the Writ and the Plaintif replies that he was Tenant And now though by the statute of 32 H. 8. chap. 30. It was enacted that if any Issue be tryed by the Oath of 12. in any of the Kings Courts of Record that Judgment shal he given any mispleading not having colour insufficient pleading or Jeofaile not worrant of Attorney put in any mis-construction or discontinuance misjoyning of Issue or other default or negligence of parties their Councellours or Attorneys had or made to the contrary notwithstanding and that the Judgement shall be in force and shall not be reversed by Writ of Errour And yet at this day one may plead in arrest
yet the Land shall be ancient Demesne as it was before By Knivet Fine levied in ancient Demesne is nothing worth for it is no Conrt of Record but common recoveries are used there to cut off an intaile 50 Ass 9. No Land may be pleaded there by right close and not else where How Land in ancient demesne is made frank Fee for a time and how for ever DUring the time that Lands in ancient Demesne is in the hands of the King it is Frank Fee but if the King grant that over to hold of the Mannor againe it is ancient Demesne againe 21 Book of Ass 13. If Recovery or Fine be in Common Bench of Land in ancient Demesne the Land is Frank fee till it be defeated by the Lord by Writ of Deceit and when that is defeat it is void to bind the parties 8 Ed. 4. fol. 6. See 3 H. 4. fol. 6. accordingly If the Tenant in ancient Demesne enfeoffe his Lord of the Mannour being common person and not King the Lordship is Frank see for ever 9 H. 6. fol. 24. B. 3 H. 4. fol. 16. the same Where the King gives Land of ancient Demesne to hold in Franke Almaigne that is Franke fee 6 H. 4. fol. 2. Where a Fine is in common Bench of Land in ancient Demesne is Frank fee so that after if a Recovery of that be in ancient Demesne it is void and before not a Judge 7 H. 4. fol. 3. B. 7 H. 4. fol. 29. the same If the King was once seised of Land in ancient Demesne and lett that for life it is Frank fee for the time 11 H. 4 fol. 84. Where Land in ancient Demesne is forfeit to the King by attainder and the King grants that over to another and his heires now they are Frank fee for ever 13 H. 4. fol. 7. Where a Fine is levyed of Land in ancient Demesne in the Common Bench the Lord may defeat that by a Writ of Deceipt and yet if he to whom the Fine was c. hath a Release with confirmation of the party made after the Fine his Estate is good notwithstanding that the Fine be defeated Fitzh 98. a. The Lessor by his confirmation to his Tenant may make the Land in ancient Demesne Frank fee but if he confirme to hold by meaner services it is no Frank fee 30 Ed. 3. fol. 16. Where Land in ancient Demesne Escheats to the Lord for that that the Tenant dyes without heire generall or speciall are Frank fee for ever for he holds them now of the Lord Paramount 18 Ed. 3. fol. 19. If the Tenant in ancient Demesne answer the action in Precipe in the Common Bench yet it is no Frank fee before Judgement given 2 Ed. 4. fol. 26. The Lord by his confirmation may alter the tenure but not the estate of the Land where he confirmes to hold at the Common Law 49 Ed. 3. fol. 7. Fine at the common Law recovery or where he is in by the Kings Charter or by feoffment of the Lord these prove the Land frank Fee and not ancient Demesne Fitzh fol. 13. C. If the King be seised of Land in ancient Demesne this is Frank fee but if the King demise it to another the Land is ancient Demesne again 17 Ed. 3. fol. 52. A man recovers in ancient Demesne Lands which were at the common Law against a man by Verdict of a Jury and he against whom the recovery was brought an Assise upon that and awarded that he should recover Seisin 30 Ed. 1. Tit. Assise 379. Note the tenure and tryall of ancient demesne and who shall plead ancient demesne LAnds which are ancient Demesne are Soccage Fitzh fol. 11. Tenants in ancient Demesne are those which hold of the Mannors which were in the hands of Saint Edward the Confessor at the time that the Book of Doomsday was made but the Lands written in that Book to be in other mens hands are not ancient Demesne Fitz. 16. E. All the Lands which were in the seisin of Saint Edward the Confessor when the Book of Doomsday was made are called ancient Demesne and the Lands in other hands c. Frank fee Natura brevium fol. 14. If the Land be ancient Demesne or not shall be tryed by the Book of Doomsday 49 Ed. 3. fol. 22. In Monstraverunt Assise The Tenant pleads that the Land was ancient Demesne and it was tryed by Assise in the Book of Notting and also North. 8 Ed. 2. Statham fol. 20. Triall of ancient Demesne is by the book of Doomsday and by that it was certified that London was not ancient Demesne 7 H. 6. fol. 34. In Assise of Mortdancester ancient Demesne was tried by the Country 8 Book Ass 35. 9 Book Ass 9. the same In Assise the tenant saith that it was parcell of the Mannor of B. which is ancient Demesne and the other saith that it is not parcell and upon this at issue and that was tryed by Assise 12 Book of Assises 18.22 Book of Assises 45. the same Assise none shall plead ancient Demesne but he which is Tenant and not the Disseiâ—or 21 Book of Ass 2.41 Ed. 3 tit 22. the same If Land be in the book of Doomsday written under the Title Land of the Bishop and not Land of the King yet though it be in the book of Doomsday it is no ancient Demesne 40 Ed. 3. fol. 45. Form of Pleadings that the Land is ancient Demesne and how he shall sue for ancient Demesne and for Copy-hold in ancient Demesne BY Prisot he which pleads ancient Demesne shall say that the Land is held of the Mannor of D. which is ancient Demesne and pleadable by a petty VVrit of Right close from time out of minde and demand judgment if the Court will acknowledge 36 H. 6. fol. 18. 3. H. 6. fol. 48. But see by Thirne and granted that frank Fee may be held of a Mannor of ancient Demesne 11 H. 4. fol. 85. Precipe the Tenant saith that the Land was parcell of the Mannour of D. which is ancient Demesne and pleadable by petty VVrit of right close time out of minde and demand judgment if the Court will acknowledge and it is no Plea for the Demandant to say to that that it is frank fee for that that it doth not gainsay but that the Mannor is ancient Demesne and that this is parcell but he ought to plead specially how it is become frank fee 41 Ed. 3. f. 22.12 Book of Ass 16.22 Book of Ass 45. Right close lieth alwaies between Plow-holders and no Plow-holder may implead another Plow-holder of Lands in ancient Demesne unlesse by this VVrit and shall make in this his protestation to sue in nature of what VVrit he will as his case is Nat. Brevium fol. 11. They call Tenants in ancient Demesne Sokemaines Britton fol. 105. Copy-holder of base Tenure shall not have a Right close but ought to sue by Bill in the Lords Court but copy-holder in ancient Demesne of free-tenure
shall have that Fitzh fol. 11. The King shall have yeare day and wast of Lands in ancient Demesne if it be so that the Tenant have sold them against his Lords will and yet not the Lands past by surrender Stam. fol. 50. Note this is where the copy-holders in ancient Demesne have used time out of minde to sue for them by petty Writ of Right close and so is 14 H. 4. fol. 1. by Hank and 14. H. 4 fol. 34. and see 3 Ed. 3. Br. tit copy-hold 22. And in these surrenders of Lands in ancient Demesne of frank tenure it is not used to say to hold at the will of the Lord in these copies but to hold according to the custome of the Mannor by the Services before due and is not said there at the Will of the Lord. Ancient Demesne is Socage Tenure for they are called Sokemaines Fitzh 14. C. By what Writ Execution shall be in ancient Demesne and by what not and shall be free of Toll c. EXecution of Writs in ancient Demesne cannot be for that Execution is given by Westm 2. chap. 18. and that the Statute is if they be ejected of those Tenements they have to recover by a VVrit of new Disseisin 22 Book of Ass 45. Upon a Statute Merchant execution was awarded of Lands in ancient Demesne Br. Tit. 37. Debt against Heire if he hath Lands in ancient Demesne they shall be charged as Assets 7 H. 4. fol. 15. Those Tenants of ancient Demesne are quit of Toll and passages for Goods sold and bought in Faires and Markets and to be quit of Taxe and Tallage of Parliament unlesse they be taxed by the Parliament and to be quit of expences of Knights of Parliament and shall not be put upon Juries and Inquests out of ancient Demesne for Lands of ancient Demesne Eitzh 14. Court of Pipowders Let us see the nature and authority of Court of Pipowders COurt of Pipowders is a Court of Record and the Steward is Judge for that that there are no Suitors there and for that error lieth there upon erronious judgment given and not a VVrit of false judgment 6 Ed. 4. fol. 3.7 Ed. 4. fol. 23. That errour lieth there It was held that a Court of Pipowders may be by custome in a City without Faire or Market and therefore where it was assigned for error upon a Record given in a Court of Pipowders according to the custome of the City held c. And though it be not in full Market or Faire it was adiudged no errour 13 Ed. 4. f. 8. Trespasse of Goods taken the Defendant iustifies as Bailif of the Town of Rippon by vertue of a command of execution of a iudgment given against the Plaintif in Debt in Court of the said Faire at Rippon and for that that the Plaintif did not make agreement for the Debt recovered against him within ten daies after iudgment given he makes price of the Goods by Merchants of the Town of Rippon and for that makes agreement with the party and this Justification was good 20 Book of Assise 90. It was enacted that no Steward shall hold Plea in this Court unlesse the Plaintif or his Attorney makes Oath that the fact or contract was made within the Faire and if it were the contrary he should forfeit 100 s. 17 Ed. 4. chap. 2. tit Faires the fourth In Court of Pipowders the Plaintif or his Attorney shall be examined by Oath if the matter rose within the Faire and the Defendant also may pleade that this arose in a forrain place 1 R. 3. chap. 6. Debt in the common Bench against Mawd and counts that he had recovered ten Markes against the said Mawd in Court of Pipowders at Everwick and the Plaintif by Certiorare removes the Tenor of the Record in the Chancery and from thence by Mittimus into the common Bench to have execution and attachment was made upon the Originall at the ninth houre and he appears and pleaded and a Venire facias went out returnable at the third houre after the ninth and so in Court of Pipowders the processe is from houre to houre 7 H. 6. fol. 19. The book of Entries fol. 167. See there the form of the Count and Precipe of summoning in this Court and the Processe of Capias and proceeding in Debt in this Court and Debt against a Jaylor for escape in Title Debt The book of Entries fol. 18. See Scire facias to have execution upon iudgment given in a Court of Pipowders in an action of account brought there and removed into the common Bench to have execution of that iudgment And it seems breifly that nothing shall be sued here unlesse the contract or deed were made within the Precinct of the Faire or Market as it appeares above and for that Informations of penall Statutes ought not to be sued in this Court of things and Offences made out of Faires and Markets as insufficient tanned Leather carryed to be sold in Faires against the Statutes also this Court is ordained only for hasty redresse of things there during the Faire Court of Marshalsey FIRST In the booke called the Diversity of Courts fol. 110. It is said that the Court called the Marshelsey is an ancient Court of Record and made to have good government and order within the Kings House for preservation of the King and his Servants and to this Court are certaine bounds limited by 13 R. 2. chap. 3. that in all places where the King in his own person shall come and make stay there within the Verge limited to his Graces Court that it shall not passe the space of twelve Miles to be accounted from his Lodging Fitzh 141. B. And in diversity of Courts it is said that this Court hath power to inquire of Treason Murder and Felony and to take appeales of them and also of Maymes if they be made within the Verge and between persons of the Kings House And said there also that if one of the House of the King sue another which is not of the House he shall plead to the Jurisdiction of the Court and if they will not this exception allow he shall have a VVrit of Errour and that shall be reversed in the Kings Bench Fitzh 242. A. Seek in trespasse And the Judges in this Court are the Steward and Marshall of the Kings House for in these is the order of the Kings House Note that by the Statute Articuli super chartas c. 3. that the Steward and the Marshall shall hold no Plea of Freehold nor of Debt Covenant nor of any bargain made between any of the Kings People but only of trespas made within the Kings House or other trespasse made within the Verge and of Contracts and Covenants which one of the Kings House made with another in the same House and not otherwhere And they shall plead no Plea of trespasse except the parties were arrested by them before the King departed the Verge where the trespasse was committed and
23 H. 8. chap. 15. If any be troubled by attachment or arrested by Latitat or in London or in a Court which hath liberty to hold Plea and no Count be put in within three daies after the Baile put in otherwise appeares unlesse the Court of discretion gives longer day the Defendant shall recover costs and dammages the same Law is if a Suite be discontinued after Count or that the Plaintiff be non-suited then the Defendant forthwith by discretion of the Court shall recover costs and the Statute gives Debt for the costs 8 Eliz. Chap. 2. But one arrested by Bill of Middlesex shall not recover costs though the Plaintiff do not count to be nonsuited If a matter passe against an Informer by Verdict or Judgment the party shall have costs and shall have execution by a Capias to satisfie fieri facias or Elegit but these two last Statutes do not extend to a Court-Baron 18 Eliz. C. 5. 22 H. 8. B. Tit. Costs 25. in quare impedit the Plaintiff shall not recover costs for that the dammages are great 35 H. 8. Tit. 258. 2 Ma. Tit. Costs 23. Debt by Lessor if he be non-suted or bar'd the Defendant shall recover costs by the Statute for it is upon a contract for Rent 2 H. 7. f. 13. Account the Plaintiff shall not recover costs but where the Defendant is adjudged to account and pleads Barr c. It is otherwise 9 H. 6. fol. 66. He shall not recover costs for that the dammages are tremble by the Statute 14 H. 6. fol. 13. forcible entry the same In London by act of common Councell in trespasse by force of Armes and in all other Actions personalls if the Plaintiff be non-suited or a Verdict against him and Judgment upon it or Judgement upon demur against him the Defendant shall recover his costs by discretion of the Court but if the Plaintiff sue as Executor or Administrator which is not upon his own act the Defendant there shall not recover costs and yet trespasse by force of Armes is not within the Statute 23 H. 8. chap. 14. to have costs Damages IT seems if one take my Beasts and after they return to me again I shall have trespasse for taking but upon the evidence I shall not recover the value though the value be in the Writ 11 H. 4. fol. 23. 1 H. 6. fol. 8. 19 H. 6. fol. 34. In what plaints Damages shall be recovered in Court-Barons and in what cases in Court-Barons and other Courts and in what not In plaint in nature of Assise of novell disseisin Grandfather and Great Grandfather Entry by disseisin Dower Nuper obiit Mortdancester Cozenage Replegiare Covenant Debt Action upon the Case Deceit and trespasse Damages and costs shall be recovered by the Plaintiffe Eight Marks were given in plaint of Land in Court-Baron Plowdens Commentaries f. 394. B. If any avow for Rent or doing damage custome or service if the Plaintiffe be non-suited or otherwise barred then the Avowant shall recover damages and costs as the Plaintiffe ought See 19 H. 8. fol. 8. 12 H. 8. chap. 19. Rast tit Avowry 1. Discent THen for that that the second Article is to inquire who is Tenant and what advantage the Lord shall have by the death of his Tenant It behoveth to know who is in by discent to be your Tenant that you may know of whom to have releife and who to be in Ward and who not and who shall be sayd in by discent and where by purchase and where hee shall not be in by discent Gift to one in taile remainder to the right heires of J. S. which was dead T. S. hath that as right heire and is in by purchase and shall not pay releife nor be in ward 40 Ed. 3.9 32 Ed. 3. Fitzh Discent 8. Lord and Tenant the Tenant aliens in Mortmain and the Alience is disseised and the Disseisor dyeth seised his Heire is in by discent yet the Lord may enter within the yeare for he hath only a Title to enter and cannot have an action but contrary of him that hath right of entry and may have action 1 Ed. 6. Tit. Mortmaine 6. Bro. Lease for life the remainder to the right Heires of J.S. the Tenant for life dies living J.S. the remainder is void and J.S. nor his Heires shall not be said in by discent to pay releife nor otherwise shall have the Land as purchasor 9 H. 6. f. 24. Perkins f. 12. the same Lease for life the remainder to the right Heires of J.S. and J.S. dies Tenant for life hath aid of T.S. Son and Heire of J.S. and though he were within age he shall not have his age and shall not pay releife nor be in ward if they hold by Knight service and be within age for that he is in as a Purchasor 11 H. 4. f. 74. Lease for life the remainder to another in taile which dies his Issue within age and after the Tenant for life dies the Issue is in by discent and if he be within age and hold by Knight service he shall be in ward to the Donor 33 H. 6. f. 5. And for that that in the said second Article of Charge you ought to inquire if any Tenant be dead who is his next Heire Let us now see where a Woman is with child at the time of the death of her Husband Tenant and by whom she shall be Judged with child and who shall be said in after the death of the Husband as Heire and shall be Tenant to the Lord and who not IF the Husband Tenant dye seised and his Wife with Child and a Brother of the Husband enter as Heire as he may and after Issue is born this Issue is Heire to the Husband and Tenant to the Lord and not the Brother though he were Tenant and Heire before the Issue was borne 41 Ed. 3. fol. 11. A man Tenant hath a Daughter his Wife with child with a Son and makes a Feoffment upon condition and dies and the Daughter enters for the condition c. and after the Son is born this Son shall not be Heire nor Tenant of this Land the same Law is where there is a Lease for life the remainder to the right Heires of J.S. Tenant for life dies the Daughter enters and after the Son is born he shall not be Heire and Tenant of that Land 9 H. 7. f. 25. Plow f 56. Daughter enters after the Death of her Father Tenant and takes profits and after the Son with which the Wife was with child is borne he may enter and have that as Heire and shall be in by discent and Tenant but hath no remedy for the profits taken by the Daughter before he was born 9 H. 6 fol. 26. If a Woman Tenant seised in Fee hath a Daughter and being with Child with a Son the Husband dies and after the Wife is ravished and consents to the Ravishor and the Daughter enters by the Statute as next of blood as
number as the Steward pleaseth and to be at his choise how many shall be sworn of a Jury and how many shall be impannelled is inconvenient where there are more within the Mannor to be impannelled and 40 Ed. 3. f. 1. Where conusance is granted to one Court to have conusance if this Court faile that it cannot make Law and Right conusance shall not be in this case allowed and for that that at the Exigent Bailiffs demand conusance and shall not have it for they cannot pronounce Out-lawrie upon that and in Quare impedit they shall not have conusance for they cannot award a Writ to the Bishop 42 Ed. 3. f. 3. Where one was out-Lawed conusance was demanded and could not have it for that he could not award Capias utlegatum there and so it seems if there be not twelve to try the Issue they faile of power to minister Law and to do Justice and Copy-holder may sue by Bill in Chancery where there are not twelve homagers within the Mannor or in action of of trespasse at the common Law and the party ought to be admitted in the Lords Court to the intent to bring trespasse at the common Law and there Law is more truly administred then in Court-Barons and also if any sue in Court-Baron for Copy-hold he shall make his protestation to sue in nature of his Writ at common Law and the processe and proceedings shall be according to the course of the common Law and they shall joyne Issue according to the course of the common Law and there Venire facias is that they shall cause to come twelve free and lawfull men according to the course of the common Law and for that it seems that triall of Issues there between parties shall be by twelve and not by lesse And by Fortescue fol. 54. 57. sworn together in the form aforesaid twelve good and lawfull men so it appeares by him that every Issue in every Court shall be tryed by twelve and not by lesse Enquest shall be by custome of the Realme between party and party in a Court of Record by twelve at the common Law Doctor and Student f. 14. Verdict of 11 shall not be taken 41 Ass 11.41 Ed. 3. f. 31. 29. Ed. 3. f. 33. accordingly Every Inquisition taken in the Sheriffs Turn shall be by twelve and the same Law is said there in a Leet by the Equity of the Statute of 6 H. 4. fol. 3. Notwithstanding seek if less then twelve may try Issue between parties in the Court of a Lord of copy-hold or not where there are not twelve within the Mannor for it is held by some that it shall be tryed by lesse and I have seen a triall by three or foure But I intend it is hard and specially where there are twelve and more copy-holders within the Mannor and also it appeares in the Register that an Action was removed out of the Court-Baron because there were but foure Suitors and so I conclude Issue for Copy-holders shall not be tryed by lesse then by twelve 6 H. 4. f. 1. 18 H. 4. fol. 2 Charter of exemption that he shall not be Impannelled shall not be allowed unlesse a full Jury appeare 39 Ed. 3. Tit. 23 A Writ of not putting in Assises shall not be allowed in an Attaint nor in a Writ of right 21 Ed. 4. f. 53. If a man have a Charter of Exemption and that shewed to the Sheriff and he notwithstanding impannells him trespasse upon the case lies against him Fitzh 205. A. A Writ not to be put in Assises and Juries is founded upon the Statute of Westm 2. chap. 39 and upon Articuli super Chartas which Statutes declare that persons shall not be impannelled that is who is sick lame and above 60. yeares old Fitzh 266. Clerkes which have Lands by discent or by purchase shall be impannelled 5 Ed. 3. f. 26. Presentment in Leet by foure and not by twelve that one had dewelt within the Leet a yeare and a day not sworn was traversed but it seems if he were presented by twelve it shall not be traversed but if it were false he shall have recovery by Writ of false presentment seek of this Writ 45 Ed. 3. f. 26. Presentment in Leet that one hath dwelt there by a yeare and day and not sworn shall be by twelve otherwise it is traversable 3 H. 7.4 If there be not twelve to be sworn the Steward may sweare a stranger which comes within the view to be sworn in Leet The Lord may hold Court-Baron though there are but two Tenants 23 H. 8. and 33 H. 8. and then two may present Articles for the Lord but where Issue is between party and party it shall be by twelve for the Venire facias is twelve free and lawfull men which is triall by common Law and that seems shall be the triall of Copy-hold Land yet Fitzh 41. in right shall be great Assise that is 24 of a Jury and attaint shall be 24. but if in Court-Baron the Mise be ioyned to be tryed by great Assise there shall go a Prohibition c. Fitzherbart 107. C. Enquest of office as in a Writ to inquire of waste it may be inquired by six or eight 2 H. 4. f. 7. 3 H. 6. f. 29. the same 13 H. 8. f. 13. Where a Lord of Parliament is arraigned there shall be eighteen or twenty Lords of the Enquest and they shall not be sworn 20 H. 7. fol. 3. Jurors may drink after their Charge and before their agreement at their own proper charges it seems their Verdict is good for there doth not appear any corruption in them nor that they drank for any corruption for all drank together and every one was in as good plight to resist as others are c. 19 Ed. 4. f. 6. After the Jury sworn and before they enter into a House and before their departure from the Barr they drink by license of the Justices and by the consent of the parties and their Verdict good 10 H. 4. f. 10 After the Jury was sworn the Plaintiff delivered a writing to a Juror without the Court and he shewed that to his companions in the House and the Jury gave Verdict and he shall not have Judgment 11 H. 4. fol. 17. the same Plowd Com. fol. 519. the Jury gave a speciall Verdict and a Box of Barbaryes conserved Sugar Candy and Licorish was found with one J.M. one of the Jury after that he was departed from the Barr J. M. was committed to the Fleet till he had paid a Fine and the Verdict good see 8 Ass 35. and 20 H. 6. f. 26. Tryall IN Court-Baron the triall is there by waging Law but by the consent of the parties it may be by the Country 33 H. 8. B. Tit. Triall 143. 3. Ed. 6. Tit. Pannell 2. Where the Jury is of two tongues for that that the one is an Alien and the other an English man there shall be six Denizens sworn and
have a Scire facias and upon that an Elegit or a Fieri facias Upon a Recognizance there shall go no Capias but it is used otherwise at this day that is Scire facias returnable into the Chancery and they use now to award a Capias Fieri facias or Elegit 48 Ed. 3. fol. 14. Statute Merchant hath two Seals and one is the Seale of the paray and for that upon that he may have Debt to have execution but Statute staple onely the Seale of the party 15 H. 7. fol. 15. A man may sue Debt upon the Statute Merchant Staple or Recognizance See Statute Merchant Fitzh 122. D. and fol. 77. the same Note that there are foure manner of Executions and note Covin to defeat them void THere are foure manner of Executions that is of body by Capias of Chattels by Fieri facias of Lands by Elegit and after the yeare after Judgement by action of Debt 11 H. 4. fol. 42. Debt upon Recovery shall not be within the yeare after Judgement but after the yeare 5 Ed. 4. fol. 1. If after Judgement one gives his Goods to one to defraud me of execution and notwithstanding takes the profit of them I shall have Execution of these Goods 22 Booke of Assises 72. 3 R. 2. the same and 50 Ed. 3. the same All Conveyances of Lands and Hereditaments Goods and Chattels Leases Rent Common or Profit or charge out of Land Judgment Execution Deeds by fraud or Covin to the intent to defraud Creditors and others of their just and lawfull Actions Suits Debts Accounts Damages Forfeitures Harriors and Releifs are voyd onely against the persons their Heires Successors Executors Administrators and Assignes and every of them whose Actions Suits Debts Accounts Damages Forfeitures Harriots and Releifs by such fraud shall be or may be hindred delayed or defrauded notwithstanding fained consideration expressing of use or any other matter or thing to the contrary 13 Elizabeth chap. 5. Debt against Executors they plead gift of all the goods of their Testator by Deed without that that they administred other Goods and the Plaintiffe averrs that the gift was made to defraud the Creditors 13 H. 4. fol. 9. See 16 Ed. 4. fol. 9. Issue was taken if the Goods were made away to defraud Execution or not 43 Ed. 3. fol. 3. Where Debtors make Gifts and Feoffments fained of their Goods and Lands to their Freinds and others and take Priviledges Rastall Debt 5. and take profits of their Lands and Goods so given by fraud shall be a Capias and Proclamation and after Execution of his Lands and Goods 2 R. 2. Stat. 2. chap. 3. Where Debtors make Gifts and Feoffments Rastall execution 5. as it is sayd in the Statute of 2 R. 2. and flye to places priviledged and take profits that the Creditors shall have Execution of the sayd Goods and Chattells as if no such Gift had been made 50 E. 3. chap. 6. 26 H. 8. fol. 2. If a man takes a Wife which hath Goods and aliens them by Covin supposing a Divorce to follow and after they are divorced the VVife may averr the Covin and have her Goods againe 33 H. 6. fol. 5. One buyes in Market open Goods taken by wrong if the buyer have knowledge of the wrong the property is not altered 14 H. 8. fol. 9. by Brook If I by fraud and Covin cause one to take your Goods and to sell them to me in an open Market yet that shall not change the property for that I am party to the Covin At Northampton before the Lord Dyer there was a Deed of gift of Goods shewed and in that it was exprest by words to the use of the Donee and yet it was averred that it was by Covin 44 Ed. 3. fol. ult A VVoman hath good cause to be endowed and shee procured J.S. to out the Tenant and then shee brought a Writ of Dower against J. S. and recovered and had Execution the Tenant may have an Assise against her and recover 22 Book of Ass 1. Assise The Tenant hanging the Assise enfeoffs another or suffers another to enter end recover by Formedon by elder gift this Covin shall not hurt the Plaintiffe but that he may recover 38 Book of Assises VVhere one was outlawed of Felony alleadges Imprisonment at the time of the Outlawry and it was replyd that he was in Prison by his owne Covin and issue upon that 41 Book of Assises 2. A man hath right of Action and makes one by Covin to enter upon him which is in by discent and recovers he shall be adjudged to be in as an Abator and not by Title Evidence AND for that that you have not many times Councell in your Court Barons and for that that it is many times pleaded to the generall Issue where it ought not It is now expedient to shew what matter may be given in evidence upon generall Issue and what not And first where the Defendant pleads the generall Issue and shews in evidence that the Plaintiffe hath no such cause of Action as is brought nor no cause of Action this is good evidence upon generall Issue Action upon the Statute of Parco fracto not guilty and evidence that hee hath no Park is good 19 H. 6. fol. 7. Trespasse in VVarren not guilty and evidonce that he hath no VVarren is good 10 H. 6. fol. 17. and 34 H. 6. fol. 7. Trespasse by VVarden of the Fleet not guilty and evidence that he is not VVarden is good 4. Ed. 4. fol. 7. and 12 E. 4. fol. 7. Trespasse of a House broken not guilty and evidence that the Plaintiffe hath no House there is good 22 H. 6. fol. 7. Trespasse not guilty and evidence that the place where the Trespasse was done is the free-hold of another and not of the Plaintiffe is good 4 E. 4. fol. 5. Debt against a Vicar for holding Farmes He hath not against the forme of the Statute and evidence that hee had for maintenance of his House it is good 27 H. 8. fol. 25. Action upon the Case of finding his Goods and converting them to the use of the Defendant not guilty and evidence that they were not the Goods of the Plaintiffe is good 3 Mar. and 33 H. 8. Action upon the Case 109. Otherwise it is in Trespasse 27 H. 8. fol. 25. Debt upon arrearages of account hee oweth him nothing in manner and forme and evidence that there was no such account is good 2 H. 6. fol. 26. Debt upon arrearages of Rent upon a Lease for yeares he owes him nothing and evidence that hee did not demise is good 7 H. 7. fol. 3. Debt upon sale of a Horse for forty shillings the Defendant may plead he oweth him nothing in manner and form and evidence that the sale was of two Horses for forty shillings or that it was of an Oxe for forty shillings is good 21 E. 4. fol. 26. and 9 E. 4. fol. 1. by Moyle VVaste no waste made and
said that Scandulum is a Greek word which goes to the overthrowe of one and for that it hath been thought that if the words intend to the destruction of the Plaintiff that he shall have an action upon the case and for that where the Defendant saith that the Plaintiff was infected with the robbery of Jerom H. and smels of it the opinion was that action upon the case for those words doth not lie Adjudged in London that an action upon the case lies brought by Huson Inholder for that the Defendant said falsely that he had buryed divers which died of the Plague in his house in his Garden when the plague was not in his house by which his guests refused to come to his house Also it was the opinion of the Kings Bench that an action upon the case doth not lie for calling the Plaintiff false knave Essex in the Kings Bench Roll. 149. Hill Terme 26. Eliz. Rich. Kerby Gentlemen brought his action upon the case against John Waller for saying these words that is thou Kirby art a false cozening knave and hath falsely cozened my two Kinsmen William Walker and Thomas Walker Brothers of the said William of Lands worth 6000 l. the manner of Pyâ—on in Rameshold and I will bring thee to stand upon the Pillory for that And adjudgad that the action doth not lie and the Jury taxed damages to a 100 l. and upon that adjudged that the action did not lie London Thomas Gittens Carpenter Anno 26. brought his action upon the case against James Redforne in the Exchequer for saying these words Thomas Gittens is a cozening knave and I have proved him a cozening knave before my Lord Maior of London for selling a Saphir for a Diamond and adjudged that it doth not lie Action upon the case upon a warrant â—f a thing sold and upon knowledge without wairant ACtion upon the case lies for selling corrupt wine and the writ is knowing it to be corrupt and warrant is not to purpose for it is ordained that none shall sell corrupt victual if he know it and so the Issue was whether it were good and not corrupt An action upon the case lies for selling corrupt victual if he know it and so the issue was whether it were good and not corrupt an action upon the case lies for selling so much Cloth and not well fulled where he warrants it 11. H. 6. fol. 22. Note the use where Measel Porks are fold at Rumford to have restitution of his money if they prove Measel 9 H. 6. fol. 53. 7 H. 4. fol. 16. Action upon the case lies for selling corrupt wine knowing c. the Defendant saith that he tasted it and accepted it for good the Plaintiff saith he accepted it for good upon condition if he liked it after it came to his house c. 19 H. 6. fol. 49. If one sell wine without warranty if that be corrupt action upon the case lies for it is prohibited by law 7. H. 4. fol. 76. 13 H. 4. fol. 2. If one sell to me a Horse apparent blind and warrant him sound of all his Members and I see him I shall have no deceit for that I might see it otherwise it is of a disease within his body there upon the warrant I shall have deceit But if one sell a blind horse and warrant him to one that doth not see him deceit lies If one sells to me wine and I bid my Servant to taste it deceit doth not lie if it be corrupt for that he hath tasted it Fitzh 94. C. If a man sell a horse to another and warrant him to be sound and good c. If the horse be lame or diseased that he cannot work action upon the case lies And so if one bargain and sel to one certain Pipes of wine and warrant them to be good and they are corrupt action upon the case lies against him and by Fitzh it behoveth that he warrant the horse and also the wine otherwise action upon the case doth not lie inquire of the wine Fitzh 98. K. If a man sell Clothes and warrant them to be of a certaine length if they be not of such a length he he which buyes them shall have a Writ of Deceit against him but if the warranty be made after the bargain is otherwise 11 Ed. 4. fol. 7. Where one sells Clothes and warrants them to be of such a length and they are not deceit lies for he could not know but by measure and he beleeved him but it is said if he warrant Seeds to grow that is in Cod or that a Horse shall carry one ten miles in two houres which is to come or warrant Cloth to be murrey where it is blue and see it deceit doth not lye but if he warrant Cloth to be of such a Country when it is not deceit lies 11 R. 2. Statham If one sell a Horse knowing him to be lame and warrant him to be sound the Defendant saith that he sold him sound without that that he warranted him 31 H. 6. fol. 11. Statham If one sell a Horse knowing him to be lame and do not warrant him action upon the case doth not lye 20 H. 6. fol. 37. By Paston and not denied if a man sell a horse which hath a disease the Buyer may have action upon the case that the Defendant knowing his Horse to be diseased sold him though he do not warrant him to be sound notwithstanding it seems otherwise where the Buyer may see the disease by looking upon him as a splint a spavin or an eye 9 H. 7. f. 22. If one sell a thing and warrant that at the same time he may have deceit notwithstanding that he hath not paid the Money for that that he might have debt at his pleasure for the Money Action upon the case for cosenage and deceiving of one ACtion upon the case was brought against W. C. for that the Defendant took eight Oxen of J.S. and offered to sell them to the Plaintiff as his proper Goods and by this salsity the Plaintiff trusting to the honesty of the Defendant bought them and paid seven pound and after the owner tooke the Oxen by which the Plaintiffe lost the Oxen by this falsity to his wrong and damages c. Book of Ass 8. 20 H. 6 fol. 25. Deceit was brought for that the Defendant was his Attorney and ought to have taken an Obligation of J.S. for a hundred pound to the Plaintiff and he took it to himselfe and it is sayd he ought to declare that he took a Fee of him And so lyeth an Action upon the Case for such Cosenage and Deceits VVhich note 9 E. 4. fol. 12. By Littleton Debt against two as Executors and one is no Executor nor never administred c. Yet he acknowledged the Action and the other made default the Plaintiffe recovers the other hath no remedy but an Action of Deceit that is Upon the Case for he is party to the Judgement 42
not know By Moyl but he ought to answer that he did not worry the Sheep 41 Ed. 3. fol. 24. If a man ought to grinde his Corne at the Mill of the Defendant without paying Tole and the Miller take Tole trespasse by force of Armes lyes and so it is said where he takes more Tole then he ought but if one hinder people to come to my Market Action upon the case lies 13 H. 4. f. 12. Action upon the case lies for that that he hath a Leet in the Mannor Eyer and Court from three weeks c. There hath the Defendant held Court within the same Mannor and hath distrained his Tenants by great and often distresse and hath impoverisht them that they cannot pay their Rent Fitzh 94. E. the same 33 H. 6. f. 16. Action upon the case lies where his Steward comes to hold a Leet and the Defendant disturbs him 11 H. 4. fol. 45. Schoole-Master shall not have an action of the case against another for setting up another School that he cannot have so many Schollars as he had before for the profession is free and is for the Common-wealth the same law of erecting a Mill upon his own land though the Plaintiffs Tole be diminished he shall not have an action upon the case 22 H. 6. f. 14. Mill levied 48 Ed 3. f. 25. Action upon the case lies against Tenant at will which makes wast or burning a House willingly and not an action of waste Lit. 14. 21 H. 6. fol. 43. 7 H. 4. f. 8. Action upon the case lies for that that the Defendant ought to repaire a certaine wall upon the Thames and doth it not by which the land of the Plaintiff is drowned Fitzh 93. E. the same 7. H. 4. fol. 16. Account doth not lye against a Bailiff or Servant for driving his Plow in which default the Beasts perished but an action upon the case lyes for his negligence for default of good keeping 2 H. 7. f. 11. Action upon the case lies for negligent keeping my Sheep and the same Law for negligent carrying my Pots or glasse and where one keeps my Horse and starves him for Meat 7 H. 4. f. 45. Action upon the case lies by the Lord of B. against him which bought and sold in the Market of B. without paying Tole and though the VVrit was Tollenam asportavit yet it was also and he denied to pay it and for that it was awarded good for the first words are void and the last sufficient 11 H. 4. f. 25. If a way belonging c. be stopped Assise of Nusance lies but for stopping of a way ingrosse he shall not have an Assise of Nusance but action upon the case 14 H. 8. f. the last VVhere part of a River or way is stopt which is narrow action upon the case lies and where the whole an Assise of Nusance an action upon the case lies where he hath no other remedy 11. Ed. 4. f. 23. It seems there that a good Pleader may frame actions upon the case for many matters which are in the Chancery 26 Book of Ass 79. Action of the case lies against the Sheriff which quashed an Essoyne erroniously for false Judgment doth not lye unlesse it were Judgement of the Suitors Fitzh 114. D. If one Person of his malice and by his false imagination labour and cause another to be iudicted falsly the party which is so indicted shall not have a Writ of conspiracy but an action upon the case against him which caused him to be so indicted Fitzh 95. D. If one play with others at Dice and hee hath false Dice and wins Money of others with false Dice Action upon the Case lyes for this deceit 13 H. 7. fol. 26. Action upon the Case lyes where one hath a Water-course by Prescription to Brew and water Beasts there hath the Defendant made Lime-pits c. 4 Book of Ass 3. See Nusance for Lever Tozaile to the annoyance of the Free-hold Action upon the Case for mis-using an Officer in his Office ACtion upon the Case lyes against a Sheriffe where the Plaintiffe hath Charter of exception that he shall be impannelled upon no Jury and shews that to the Sheriff and yet he impannels him 18 H. 8. fol. 5. 21 H. 7. fol. 22. by King Where the Sheriffe serves a Fieri facias and levies the sum and doth not returne the Writ the party may have trespasse against him for levying that the same Law if by a Capias the Sheriffe arrest one and doth not returne the Writ false Imprisonment lyes 20 H. 7. fol. 13. 21 H. 6. tit 6. B. 6 H. 6. Tit. 9. Trespasse upon the Case was brought against an Escheator because he found an Office that the party held of J. S. and he returned an Office That the party held the moity of the King in Cheife and by the Court it lyes for he and the Sheriff are Officers of Record but not Justices of Record for there it was agreed that an Action doth not lye against a Justice of Record 9 H. 6. fol. 60. the same 12 H. 6. fol. 3. 47 Ed. 3. fol. 15. Conspiracy in the nature of an Action upon the Case was brought for that that the Defendant procured and caused a false Office to be found by which the Mannor was seised into the Kings hands and he sued that out to the Losse 21 Ed. 4. fol. 43. If the Sheriffe upon a Writ of second deliverance makes deliverance to the Plaintif of the distresse and will not returne the Writ so that the Defendant may constraine the Plaintif to come and count so that he may avow the Defendant shall have remedy against the Sherif and this seems by an Action upon the Case 8 H. 6. fol. 1. Where in Precipe the Sherif returnes a Summons where he was not summoned by which hee looses his Land Action upon the Case lyes against the Sherif See that deceit lyes 19 H. 6. fol. 29. Action upon the Case lyes against the Sherifs Deputy for imbezzeling a Writ of Habeas corpora and it lyes as well against him that stirrs up another to doe it as against a doer 16 H. 6. tit 38. by Paston If the Sherif returne a man sufficient upon a Venire facias by which the next Sherif iâ— charged of the Issues he shall have an Action upon the Case against the Predecessor for he cannot returne nihil against the returne of his Predecessor 1 H. 6. fol. 1. Precipe Where the Tenant looseth his Land by default upon a false returne of the Sherif as he returnes the Tenant summoned where he was not deceit lyes but if the Summoners were dead Action upon the Case lyes 38 Book of Ass 13. Action upon the Case lyes against the Sherif where he made a Precept to one which was no Bailif of the Franchise which returnes a Jury by which this was quasht to the damages c. 41 Book of Ass 12. Deceit in the nature of an Action upon the Case lyes
our Law and if he sue for that ten pounds in Court Christian Prohibition lies but if he promise one with his Daughter in Marriage ten pounds he shall sue for that in Court Christian 17 Ed. 4. fol. 4. If a man promise a certain summ of Money to another to marry his Daughter or Servant which he marries accordingly Debt doth not lie for it is Spiritual contrary Rogers and Sulyard for it is one for another though it were said contrary and the reason was it shall be sued in the Spiritual Court for this Cause 22. Book of Assises 70. If one promise that if he will marry his Daughter he shall have ten pounds this is a Contract this is a Promise in our Law and he shall have Debt but if he say he will give with his Daughter ten pounds he ought to demand that before the Ordinary 45 Ed. 3. f. 24. Where Covenant was by Deed between the Plaintiff and Defendant that if the Plaintiff took to Wife the Daughter of the Defendant that then he shall be bound to him in a hundred pounds and if he takes her to Wife Action of Debt lies and the Court shall not be out of Jurisdiction though that touch Matrimony for that that this was by Deed but otherwise it is if it were without Deed. 37 H. 6. f. 9. By Prisot if an Agreement be made that A. shall take the Daughter of B. in Marriage and if he marries her there it is said that he shall not have Debt for it seems it is not Quid pro quo Inquire for if one sels a Horse for ten pounds and hath no Horse yet he shall have Debt for that and yet it is not one for another and where I sell my Land in D. for ten pounds Debt lies and yet he hath not the Land before Livery 27 Book of Assises 29. Where a man sels all the Trees in his VVood and agrees that the same Buyer shall not cut them before Michaelmas next if Hauks in the mean time are in the Trees it seems that the Seller shall have them 14 H. 8. fol. 1. If a man let Land except the VVood and under-wood and Hernes and Shovelers make their Nests in the Trees the Lessor shall have them for the Trees are excepted and the Nests in the Trees and the same Law of Akorns which come by reason of the Trees 7 H. 7. fol. 5. If a man sell a Lease of Land and certain Cloth for ten pounds the Contract is intire and cannot be severed and if one of them were by defeasible Title and devested from the Vendee yet the Seller shall have the whole summ for the Contract is intire and cannot be severed See 12 H. 8. f. 13. 9 Ed. 4. fol. 1. 9 H. 7. f. 22. If a man sell stuff for forty pounds and deliver the stuff and no Money paid nor Day appointed yet it is a good Bargain and he shall have Debt for the forty pounds but 11 H. 4. f. 33. If one assume to make the Plaintiff a House before such a Day and doth not unlesse it be for such a summ of Money Action upon the Case doth not lie for it is a naked Bargain 9 Ed. 4. f. 54. By Littleton if a man recovers in Debt upon a Contract and doth not take Execution yet he cannot have new Action of Debt upon the Contract for the Contract is determined by the Judgement and the nature of the Duty changed to a Record And by Danby and Moyle in Account Debt Trespasse and such like it is no Plea that the Plaintiff at another time recovered in them unlesse he said that he had Execution also contrary Littleton and Choke See there in Debt upon an Obligation seems contrary 2 R. 3. f. 14. Where one brings Detinue and is barrd by Law waging he shall not have an Account afterwards for Detinue affirmes property in him and Account disaffirmes that 12 Ed. 4. fol. 13. Where is a Barr by waging of Law in Detinue one shall not have after an Action upon the Case for negligent keeping the thing as it seems 40 E. 3. fol 27. Where in Trespasse one recovers in London and be brought in the thing judged he cannot refuse this Judgement and sue for the Trespasse in a higher Court. 20 H. 6. fol. 12. Trespasse of Goods taken it is a good Plea that you at another time brought Trespasse against me and J. S. and that J. S. appeared and pleaded not guilty and it was found against him and that the Plaintiff had Judgement for it is carried in Damages and reduced into the thing judged and may have Execution at his pleasure but otherwise it is in Debt for there it is not a good Barr unlesse he pleads that he had Judgement and Execution against one 23 H. 8. Tit. 105. Action upon the Case Debt of twenty pounds if the Defendant hath waged his Law in this Action and the Plaintiff brings an Action upon the Case it is a good Plea for the Defendant to say that at another time he was barred in Debt for the same by waging of Law 2 R. f. Trespasse if in Debt or other Action in the common Bench the Defendant pleads Recovery of that in a Court of Franchise or that the Plaintiff is barred in a Court of Franchise though it be not of Record here yet it seems that the Defendant shall have advantage of Record and otherwise shall be a mischeif 46 Ed. 3. f. 17. 17 Ed. 3. Tit. Barr 246. Debt upon an Obligation it is no Plea that at another time before the Mayor of London the Plaintiff recovered upon the same Obligation against the Defendant and had Execution it is no Plea for that that the Obligation was not Damnum nor the Defendant doth not shew Acquittance and the Plaintiff by Award of the Court recovered 4 H. 7. f. 8. Three bound in an Obligation joyntly and severally it is no Barr for one to say that he recovered against another but that he recovered and had Execution is good and he ought to shew Acquittance of the Payment or otherwise he shall be charged 5 Ed. 4. fol. 5. Debt by severall Precipes against two by Choke where he hath Execution against one he shall not have against the other afterwards 22 Ed. 4. fol. 7. Two are bound in an Obligation joynty and severally if I have Execution against one this is a Barr against the other but not Judgement onely Husband and Wife What Contract and Act of a married Wife Bailiff and Servant shall binde the Husband or Master and what not A Married Wife hath no Will but the Will of her Husband and for that if a married Wife sell or give Goods and the Husband agree before or after it is good and it is his Will and his Sale and if the Bargain be advantage or disadvantage to the Husband Agreement of the Husband makes it good the same Law of an Assumpsit made to a married Wife to deliver one out
he grants where he was never in the Warrs it is a good grant for the recitall is matter in deed not materiall 9 H. 7. fol. 7. If the King make a Denizen and recite that where he was borne in France where indeed he was borne in Spain this grant and making him Denizen is a good grant and the recitall is not materiall 3 H. 6. fol. 9. Where processe is miscontinued and Judgment given by default this Judgment upon miscontinuance is errour and may be assigned for errour but where it is miscontinuance of processe and the party appear and pleads and Judgment upon Verdict is given this cannot be assigned for errour See 3 H. 7. f. 8. 1 H. 7. f. 12. Errour was assigned for that it was contained in the Record that in base Court the Entry was that the Court was held upon Tuesday that is the third day of March where Munday was the third day of March and this was adjudged errour and the Videlicet c. materiall 4 H. 7. f. 6. Where one is named Executor where that name Executor is not materiall the Writ shall not abate 17 Ed. 4. f. 2. Where the Defendant in trespasse pleads that the plaintiff bargained and sold to him ten acres of Corn though he do not say ten Acres sowne with corn it is not materiall for it is usually so called and a good Plea 1 H. 7. f. 21. A certaine Memorandum was entred that is to say Memorandum that Simon Wiseman came this 31 day of November this Tearme of S. Michaell 2 H. 7. f. 11. If processe be miscontinued and the party appear and pleads to the Issue and Judgment is given there the miscontinuance is not materiall and is no Errour 9 Ed. 4. f. 42. Trespasse of a Bagg taken with Money the Defendant saith that the Plaintif was indebted to him in a certain summ and delivered that unto him for discharge and is good though he do not shew for what cause he was indebted for this is not traversable and for that is not materiall Manner and Form Manner and Form where it is materiall and where not MAaintenance The Defendant iustifies for that that he is his Neighbour and informed him of a man learned in the Law The Plaintiffe saith that he gave money the Defendant saith that he did not maintain in manner and Form and it is no Plea without answering to the speciall matter 13 Ed. 4.14 Trespasse The Defendant saith that the Plaintiffe is Villain regardant to the Mannour of D. the Plaintiffe saith he is free and not Villain in Manner and Form and Manner and Form is not material but if he be a Villain or not 13 Ed. 4. f. 4. Debt of the sale of a Horse for sorry Shillings where the Bargain was for two Horses the Defendant pleads that he oweth him nothing in Manner and Form the Jury ought to find for the Defendant for that that the Bargain was for two Horses 40. s. and Manner and Form there is materiall and parcell of their Charge and so it is in every Case where the Action varies from the Bargain 21. Ed. 4. f. 22. Debt upon sale simply the Defendant saith that the Sale was upon condition without that that the Plaintiffe sold that in Manner and Form and is good 1 H. 7. f. 13. Trespasse the Defendant justifies for that the Plaintiffe held of him by Homage Fealty Suit of Court and ten Shillings four pence the Plaintiffe saith that he held by Fealty and ten shillings without that that he held in Manner and Form and found by Verdict that he held by ten Shillings four pence and not by Homage and the Plaintiffe had Judgement for that that part is found against the Defendant and Manner and Form is not materiall 31 H. 6. f. 12. 9 H. 7. fol. 12. Entrie in Casupro viso and Counts of alienation in Fee the Defendant saith that he did not alien in Manner and Form as the Plaintiffe hath counted and found that he aliened in Tail the Demandant shall recover for Manner and Form are but words of Form here but whether he aliened or not is the substance Littleton fol. 113. Lord and Tenant and the Tenant brings Trespasse against his Lord and Justifies for that that he held of him by Fealty and Rent and for the Rent behind that he took his beasts and demands Judgement of the Wriâ— by force of Arms against him the Plaintiffe saith that he doth not hold of him in Manner and Form and though it be found that he holds by Fealty onely yet the Writ shall abate for Manner and Form is not materiall Littleton f. 113. Trespasse of Batterie or of goods taken the Defendant pleads not guilty in Manner and Form as the Plaintiffe supposeth and is found guilty in another â—own or at another day yet the Plaintiffe shall recover Littleton fol. 114. Action upon the Case by a Husband alone upon an Assâ—â—â—â—t to him by Tatam the Defendant saith he did not allume in Manner and Form and the Plaintiffe gives in evidence of an Assampsit made to his Wife and his agreement afterwards and it is good and Manner and Form is not materiall 27 H. 8. f. 29. Cessavit That the Defendant held divers Lands by intire Service he may plead that he held not in Manner and Form and give in evidence that he held by severall Service and it is good 10 H. 7. f. 24. An Array of a Pannell was challenged for that it was made by the Sheriffe Cozen to the Plaintiffe and shews how he is Cozen the other saith he is not Cozen in Manner and Form as c. and he is found Cozen but this is found to be in another Manner and yet good for Manner and Form is not materiall 19 H. 8. fol. 7. Assise the Tenant pleads a Feofment of J.S. by Deed the Plaintif intitles him without that that J.S. enfeofed him in Manner and Form and could not give in evidence a Feofment without Deed and traverse that with Manner and Form is good to avoid a Negative pregnant and in Sine assensu Cantuli the Defendant shall not say that he did not alien without the consent of the Chapter but that he did not alien in Manner and Form to avoid a pregnant Negative 22 Ed. 4. f. 4. Negative Pregnant Where a Negative pregnant may be and where not WAste The Defendant saith that he did not let to him for years it is no Plea for it is a pregnant Negative but he shall say that he did not let at all 43 Ed. 3. f. 13. Action upon the Statute of Rich. he did not enter against the Form of the Statute is good though it be a pregnant Negative for that that it traverseth the point of the Writ 31 H. 6. f. 12. Consimili Casu Issue was if he aliened in Fee or not aliened in Fee which is a pregnant Negative and allowed the reason is plain 38 H. 6 f. 3. Lord and Tenant the Tenant pleads a Feoffement
goods and chattels aforesaid formerly taken and you cause them to be delivered to the said A. B. to be detained untill you may cause the goods and chattells formerly taken to be restored to the said A.B. and you put the said C.D. by Sureties and safe pledges that he be before us in the moneth of Easter whersoever we then shall be in England to answer as well as of the contempt and as also the said A.B. of his dammages and iniuries in that behalf illated and that you have there this Writ witnesse c. A Scire facias for an Executor to renew a Judgement after a year and a day THe Keepers c. greeting whereas A.B. Executor of the last Will and Testament of C. D. lately deceased lately in the Court before us in the upper Bench at Westminster by Bill without our Writ and by the iudgement of the same Court recovered against E.F. thirteen pounds of Debt and also one and twenty shillings for his damages which he sustained as well by occasion of detention of that Debt as for his costs and charges by him about his suit in that behalf disbursed whereof he is convicted as it doth appear to us of Record and that the said C. D. after Judgement aforesaid in Form aforesaid rendred at London made his last VVill and Testament and thereby did appoint and ordain the said A.B. his Executor and afterwards there died and now on the behalf of the said A. B. in the Court before us in the upper Bench at Westminster have accepted that although the Judgement be thereof rendred yet the Execution of the Debt and dammages aforesaid doth yet remain to be made whereupon the said A.B. hath supplicated us accordingly to provide remedy for him in that behalf and we being willing in that behalf to do that which is iust we command you that by honest and lawfull men of your Bailywick you make known to the said E.F. that he be before us in the upper Bench at Westminster on Fryday next after c. to shew if he hath or knoweth any thing to say for himself wherefore the said A. B. ought not to have the Execution of the Debt and Dammages aforesaid according to the force form and effect of the recovery aforesaid if he think good to try and further to do and receive that which the same Court before us in the upper Bench at Westminster shall consider of in that behalf and then you have here the names of them by whom you made known to him and this Writ witnesse c. The same in an Action of Eiectment the Plaintiffe a woman after Judgement being married THe Keeper c. Greeting whereas A.B. lately before us in the upper Bench at Westminster recovered against C.D. her Term then and yet to come of and in one Messuage with the Appurtenances in E. in the Parish of F. in your County that is to say from the last day of March in the year of our Lord one thousand six hundred and fifty untill the end and Term of five years to be fully compleat and ended and afterwards the said A.B. at E. aforesaid took to her Husband one C.G. and now on the behalf of the said G. H. and A. B. in the Court before us in the upper Bench at Westminster as we have accepted that although the Judgement aforesaid be rendred yet the Execution of that Judgement doth yet remain to be made whereupon the said G. H. and A.B. have supplicated us accordingly to provide remedy for them in that behalf and we being willing in that behalf to do that which is lust we command you that by honest and lawfull men of your Bailiwick you make known to the said C.D. that he be before us in the upper Bench at Westminster on c. reciting the Return to shew if that he hath or knoweth any thing to say for himself wherefore the said G.H. and A.B. his Wife ought not to have Execution of the Iudgement aforesaid if he think good to try and further to do and receive that which the Court shall consider of in that behalf and then you have here the names of them by whom you made known to him and this Writ witnesse c. The same for an Administrator in Debt The Keepers c. Greeting whereas A. B. lately in the Court before us in the upper Bench at Westminster recovered against C.D. twenty pounds Debt and also one and twenty shillings for his dammages which he sustained as well by occasion of detention of that Debt as also for his costs and charges by him about his suit in that behalf disbursed whereof he is convicted as it doth aprear to us upon Record and afterwards the said A.B. at London aforesaid died intestate as it is said and the Admistration of all and every the Goods and Chattels Rights and credits which were of the said A.B. at the time of his death at London were committed to one E.F. as by the insinuation of the said E.F. in the Court before us in the upper Bench at Westminster we have accepted yet the Execution of the Debt and dammages aforesaid doth yet remain to be made whereupon the said E. F. hath supplicated us accordingly to provide remedy for him in that behalf and we being willing to do that which is iust in that behalf we command you that by honest and lawfull men of your Bailiwick you make known to the said C.D. that he be before us in the upper Bench at Westminster on c. reciting the Return to shew if he c. as above in the former Writ untill the end The same against an Executor of a Sheriff where the Sheriff returned that he had caused the Goods of the Defendant to be levied but hath not paid the Money coming thereof THe Keepers c. to the Sheriffe of Middlesex greeting whereas A.B. lately in the Court before us in the upper Bench at Westminster recovered against C.D. one hundred pounds of Debt and also five pounds for his dammages which he sustained as well by occasion of detaining of that Debt as for his Costs and Charges by him about his Suit in that behalfe expended whereof the said C.D. is convicted as it doth appeare to us of Record And whereas also E.F. Esq Sheriff of the County of E. hath returned to us upon a certain Writ issuing forth of the same Court before us upon the judgment aforesaid that he had caused to be taken the Goods and Chattells of the said C.D. to the value of the Debt and damages aforesaid that is to say the one hundred and five pounds and the Mony coming thereof that is to say the said one hundred and five pounds before us at the day and place in the said Writ mentioned He had prepared to deliver to the said A. B. according to the Exigent of the Writ aforesaid as by the return of that Writ in the same Court before us remaining of Record doth manifestly appeare And