and that they should speake as vnderstanding the matter not as they seemed to doe by custome and habite of the Schooles Diuers draughts were made by both sides to expresse these mysteries and some were composed by taking some thing from either partie But none gaue satisfaction especially to the Nuncio Verona who was the principall Superintendent in this matter It was determined in the generall Congregation to vse as few words as was possible and to make an expression so vniuersall as might bee accommodated to the meaning of both parties and the care heereof was committed to some Fathers and Pheologues with the superintendencie of the foresaid Nuncio In the end of this Congregation it was proposed that a collection should The abuses occurring therein rre noted be made of the abuses occurring in this matter with remedies against them and in the Congregations following many were recounted That in some particular Churches the Sacrament is not kept and in others is kept very vndecently That when it is carryed in the streeâ—e many doe not kneele to it and some scarce vouchsafe to put off their caps That in some Churches it is kept so long that it becommeth putrified That in administring the holy Communion great indecencie is vsed by some parish Priests who haue not so much as a cloath for him that communicateth to hold in his hand That which is of most importance the communicants doe not know what they receiue nor are instructed of the dignity and fruit of this Sacrament That Concubinaries Concubines and other enormous sinners and many who know not the Pater noster and Aâ—â—e Maria are admitted to the Communion That money is demanded at the Communion in the name of almes and which is worse there is an vse in Rome that he who is to communicate doeth hold a burning candle in his hand with money sticking in it which together with the candle after the Communion remayneth to the Priest and he that beareth not a candle is not admitted to the Communion To remedie part of these and other abuses flue Canons were made And fiue Canons made to redresse them which had a faire proheme In which it was constituted that the Sacrament beeing lifted vp on the Altar or carryed by the way euery one should kneele and vncouer his head That the Sacrament should bee kept in euery Parish Church and renewed euery fifteene dayes and haue a lampe burning before it night and day That it bee carryed to the sicke by the Priest in an honourable habite and alwayes with light That the Curates teach the people what grace is receiued in this Sacrament and execute against them the penalties of the Chapt. Omnis Vtriusque sexus That the Ordinaries should haue care of the execution chastising the transgressours with arbitrary punishments besides those which are set downe by Innocentius the third in the Chapt. Statuimus and by Honorius the third in the Chapt. Sane The reformation was handled at the same time when there was disputation in matter of faith but by other Congregations in which the Canonists did assist which discussions not to interrupt the matter I haue brought all together to this place And because the purpose was to reforme the Episcopall iurisdiction this place requireth for the vnderstanding of what will be sayd vpon this and many other occasions hereafter that the originall should bee declared and how beeing mounted to so great power it became suspected to Princes and terrible to the people CHRIST hauing commanded his Apostles to preach the Gospel and administer the Sacraments hee left also to them in person of all the faithfull this principall precept To loue one another charging them to make peace betweene those that dissented and for the last remedie giuing the care thereof to the body of the Church promising it should bee bound and loosed in heauen whatsoeuer they did binde and loose on earth and whatsoeuer two did aske with a common consent should bee granted by the Father In this charitable office to giue satisfaction to the offended and pardon to the offender the Primitiue Church was alwayes exercised And in conformity of this Saint Paul ordayned that brothers hauing ciuill suites one against another should not goe to the Tribunals of the Infidels but that wise men should be appoynted to iudge the differences and this was a kind of ciuill Iudgement as the other had a similitude of a criminall but were both so different from the iudgements of the world that as these are executed by power of the Iudge who enforceth submission so those onely by the will of the guilty to receiue them who refusing them the Ecclesiasticall Iudge remaineth without execution and hath no power but to foreshew the iudgement of GOD which according to his omnipotent good pleasure will follow in this life or the next And indeed the Ecclesiasticall iudgement did deserue the name of charitie The Reformation is handled at the same time with the Doctrine but in diuers Congregations in regard that it only did induce the guilty to submit and the Church to iudge with such sincerity that neither in the one any bad effect could haue place nor iust complaint in the other and the excesse of charitie in correcting did make the corrector to feele greater paine then the corrected so that in the Church no punishment was imposed without great lamentation of the multitude and greater of the better sort And this was the cause A discourse of the Authour concerning 〈…〉 opall Iurisdiction why to correct was called to lament So Saint Paul rebuking the Corinthians for not chastising the incestuous said You haue not lamented to separate such a transgressour from you And in another Epistle I feare that when I come vnto you I shall not finde you such as I desire but in contentions and tumults and that at my comming I shall lament many of those who haue sinned before The iudgement of the Church as is necessary in euery multitude was fit that it should be conducted by one who should preside and guide the action propose the matters and collect the points to bee consulted on This care due to the most principall and worthy person was alwayes committed to the Bishop And where the Churches were many the propositions and deliberations were made by the Bishop first in the Colledge of the Priests and Deacons which they called the Presbyterie and there were ripened to receiue afterwards the last resolution in the generall Congregation of the Church This forme was still on foote in the yeere two hundred and fiftie and is plainely seene by the Epistles of Cyprian who in the matter concerning those who did eate of meates offered to Idols and subscribe to the Religion of the Gentiles writeth to the Presbytery that hee doeth not thinke to doe any thing without their counsell and consent of the people and writeth to the people that at his returne hee will examine the causes and merits thereof in their presence
sint vel minus boni quam caeteri mortales esse solent Englished thus No man expects any sanctitie in Popes now a dayes they are thought to be excellent Popes if they haue neuer so little honestie or be not so wicked as other men vse to be Last of all thou mayest reade an Epistle written by that famous Prelate Bishop Iewell as an answere to a friend of his who liued neere the place and in the time of this vnlawfull assembly or conuenticle at Trent In it thou mayest finde reason enough why the Church of England did neither send Prelates to it nor receiue afterwards the Decrees and Constitutions of it As likewise the Church of France refused to doe though their Bishops were present in it When thou hast read these things consider well of them and the Lord giue thee a true vnderstanding in all things GREGORIE GREGORIE to the Emperour MAVRICIVS concerning IOHN Bishop of Constantinople who hath assumed the name of Vniuersall Bishop Chap. 76. OVrmost religious Lord whom God hath placed ouer vs Ep. 32. amongst other weighty cares belonging to the Empire doth labour by the iust rule of holy writ to keepe the Clergie in peace and charitie Hee truely and piously considereth that no man can well gouerne matters terrene except he can manage well things Diuine also and that the Common-wealths peace and quiet depends vpon the tranquillity of the Church Vniuersall For most gracious Souereigne what humane power or strength would presume to lift vp irreligious hands against your most Christian Maiestie if the Clergie being at vnitie amongst themselues would seriously pray vnto our Sauiour CHRIST to preserue you who haue so well deserued of vs or what Nation so barbarous as would exercise such cruelty against the faithfull except the liues of vs who are called Priests but indeede are not were most depraued and wicked But whilest we leaue those things which belong not vnto vs and imbrace those things for which wee are not fitte wee raise the Barbarians vp against vs and our offences doe sharpen the swordes of our enemies by which meanes the Common-wealth is weakened For what can wee say for our selues if the people of God ouer whom wee are though vnworthily placed bee oppressed by the multitude of our offences if our examples destroy that which our preaching builds and our works giue as it were the lye to our doctrine Our bones are worne with fasting but our mindes are puft vp Our bodies are couered with poore clothing but in our hearts wee are as braue as may be We lie groueling in the ashes but ayme at matters exceeding high Wee are teachers of humilitie but patternes of pride hiding the teeth of wolues vnder a sheepes countenance The end of all is to make a shew to men though God knoweth the trueth Therefore our most pious Souereigne hath been most prudently carefull to set the Church at vnitie that hee might the better compose the tumults of warre and to ioyne their hearts together This verily is my desire and doe yeeld for my part due obedience to your souereigne commands Howsoeuer in regard it is not my cause but Gods and for that not I onely but the whole Church is troubled because religious Lawes venerable Synods and the very precepts of our Lord IESVS CHRIST are disobeyed by the inuention of a proud and pompous speech my desire is that our most Religious Souereigne would lance this sore and would tie the partie affected with the cords of his Imperiall authoritie in case hee shall make his resistance By binding of 〈◊〉 the Common-wealth is eased and by the paring away of such excremen 〈…〉 as these the Empire is inlarged All men that haue read the Gospel doe know that euen by the very words of our LORD the care of the whole Church is committed to S. Peter the Apostle Prince of all the Apostles For to him it is sayd a Iohn 21. Peter louest thou me Feede my sheepe b Luke 22. behold Satan hath desired to winnow thee as wheate and I haue prayed for thee that thy faith should not faile and thou being at the last conuerted confirme thy brethren To him it is said c Matt. 16. Thou art Peter and vpon this rocke I will build my Church and the gates of hell shall not preuaile against it And to thee I will giue the Keyes of heauen and whatsoeuer thou bindest on earth shall be bound also in heauen and whatsoeuer thou shalt loose on earth shall bee loosed also in heauen Behold he hath the Keyes of the Kingdome and the power of binding and loosing is giuen vnto him The care and the principalitie of the whole Church is committed to him and yet is not called Vniuersall Apostle howbeit this most holy man Iohn my fellow Priest laboureth to bee called Vniuersall Bishop I am inforced to crie out and say Oh corruption of times and manners Behold the Barbarians are become Lords of all Europe Cities are destroyed Castles are beaten downe Prouinces depopulated there is no husbandman to till the ground Idolaters doe rage and domineere ouer Christians and yet Priests who ought to lie weeping vpon the pauement and in ashes desire names of vanitie and doe glory in new and profane titles Doe I most Religious Souereigne pleade herein mine owne cause Doe I vindicate a wrong done to my selfe and not maintaine the cause of God Almighty and of the Church Vniuersall Who is hee who presumeth to vsurpe this new name against both the law of the Gospel and of the Canons I would to God there might bee one called Vniuersall without wronging of others We know that many Priests of the Church of Constantinople haue been not onely heretiques but euen the chiefe leaders of them Out of this schoole proceeded Nestorius who thinking it not to be possible that God should be made man did beleeue that IESVS CHRIST the Mediatour betweene God and man was two persons and went as farre in Infidelitie as the Iewes themselues Thence came Macedonius who denied the holy Ghost consubstantiall to the Father and the Sonne to be God If then euery one in that Church doth assume that name by which hee maketh himselfe the head of all good men the Catholique Church which God forbid must needes bee ouerthrowen when hee falleth who is called Vniuersall But let this blasphemous name be farre from Christians by which all honor is taken from all other Priests while it is foolishly arrogated by one It was offered to the Bishop of Rome by the reuerend Councell of Chalcedon in honour of S. Peter Prince of the Apostles but none of them either assumed or consented to vse it lest while this priuiledge should be giuen to one all others should bee depriued of that honour which is due vnto them Why should we refuse this name when it was offered and another should assume it without any offer at all This man contemning obedience to the Canons is the rather to be humbled
Baptisme and of the Communion of the flesh of CHRIST What other spirituall things are there beside these And if there were how can hee who is partaker of these which are the chiefest be sayde absolutely in generall termes to be vncapeable of spirituall things But they sayd that the Minor was false also that causes appropriated to the Episcopall iudicature are spirituall For all either delicts or contracts which considering the qualities giuen by the holy Scripture to spirituall things are as farre from being such as earth is from heauen But the opposition of the better part could not ouercome the greater and so vpon the spirituall power giuen by CHRIST to the Church to binde and loose and vpon the institution of Saint Paul to compose contentions betweene Christians without going to the tribunall of Infidels in much time and by many degrees a temporall tribunal hath beene built more remarkeable then euer was any in the world and in the midst of euery Ciuill gouernement another instituted not depending on the Publike which is such a kinde of Common-wealth as not one of as many as haue written of gouernments would haue imagined could subsist I will omit to speake how the paines of so many besides the obtaining of the wished end To make themselues independent of the publike haue before they were aware raysed an Empire there being a more difficult opinion sprung vp taking root with admirable progresse which giueth to the Pope of Rome as much at once as hath in 1300. yeeres beene gained by so many Bishops by such extraordinarie meanes not making the power to binde and loose the foundation of iurisdiction but the power of feeding and so affirming that all iurisdiction was giuen the Pope by CHRIST in the person of Peter when he sayd to him Feede my sheepe For so it will be said in the third reduction of the Councell when great tumults were raised by this opinion which shall then be recounted But by that which hath been now declared euery one may of himselfe conceiue what remedies were necessarie to giue a tolerable forme to a matter broken out into so great corruptions and compare them with these that were proposed In Trent there were two defects considered that is that the charitie of the superiours was turned into domination and the obedience of the inferiours into complaints subterfuges and lamentations and they first thought of prouiding in some sort against them both But in prosecuting the first which is the fountaine from whence the second is deriued they vsed onely an exhortatorie remedie to the Prelates to take away domination and restore charitie And for the inferiours many subterfuges beeing mentioned to delude iustice three heads onely were taken Appeales absolutorie graces and complaints against the Iudges Iohannes Groperus who assisted in that Councell as a Diuine and a Lawyer spake honourably of Appeales and sayd that while the heat of faith remained in the brests of Christians Appeales were not heard of But charitie in the Iudges waxing colde and place being giuen to passion they entred into the Church for A discourse of Iohannes Groperus concernâ—ng Appeales the same reasons which brought them into the secular Courts that is for the ease of the oppressed And as the first iudicatures belonged not to the Bishop onely but to him with the councell of his Priests so the Appeale was not deuolued vnto one man but vnto another Congregation But the Bishops taking away the Synods did institute Courts and officers like the seculars Neither did the mischiefe stoppe there but passed to greater abuses then in the Secular court For there the first Appeale is onely to bee immediate superiour neither is it lawfull to leape to the highest nor permitted in the articles of the cause to appeale from the Decrees of the Iudge which they call interlocutories but it is necessarie to expect the end But in the Ecclesiasticall Courts one may appeale from euery acte which maketh the causes infinite and immediately to the highest Iudge which carryeth them out of the Countreys with great charges and other intolerable mischiefes This hee said hee did declare to conclude that if they would reforme this matter which is wholly corrupted and doeth not onely hinder residencie as in the Congregations of so many worthy Doctours and Fathers was considered but corrupteth the whole discipline and is a grieuance charge and scandall to the people it was fit to reduce it to its beginning or as neere to it as might bee setting a perfect Idea before their eyes and ayming at that to come as nigh to it as the corruption of the matter doth comport That the well instituted monasticall religions haue forbidden all appeale that this is the true remedie Hee that hath not beene able to goe so high hath moderated them granting them within their order and forbidding them without which succeeding well as appeareth to keepe those gouernments in order it would worke the same effect in the publike gouernments of the Church if the Appeales were confined within the same Prouince And to effect this and to bridle the malice of the litigants it is sufficient to reduce them to the forme of the Common lawes forbidding the Leap that is to go to the highest without passing by the intermediate superiours and by forbidding Appeales from the Articles or the interlocutory Decrees with which prouisions the causes will not goe farre will not be drawne in length will not cause excessiue charges and other innumerable grieuances and that the sentences may passe with sinceritie to restore the Synodals which are not subiect to so great corruptions remouing those officers by whom the world is so much scandalized because it is not possible that Germany should endure them This opinion was not willingly heard except by the Spaniards Dutch-men But the Cardinall the Nuncio of Siponto were displeased that hee went so farre For this was to take away not onely the profit of the Court but the honour also no cause would goe to Rome and by degrees euery one would forget the superioritie of the Pope it beeing an ordinary thing with men not to esteeme that Superiour whose authoritie is not feared or cannot be vsed Therefore they caused Iohn Baptista Castellus of Bolonia to speake in the next Congregation in the same matter in such sort as that without contradicting Groperus the appearance which the reasons alleadged by him did make should bee darkened Hee beganne with the prayses of the ancient â—n opposition whereof Iohannes Baptista Castellus maketh another discouâ—se by direction of the Presidents Church yet dexterously touching that in those same times there were imperfections in some part greater then in the present He thanked GOD that the Church was not oppressed as when the Arians did scarce suffer it to appeare and said that antiquitie ought not so to be commended as that something in the latter age may not bee reputed better Those who praise the Synodall iudicature haue not seene their defects
needes bee a power of iurisdiction Concerning Order hee said a Bishop was of an higher degree then a Priest hauing all the power of him and two powers more yet notwithstanding cannot bee called his superiour as a Subdeacon is foure degrees higher then a doore-keeper yet not superiour vnto him Hee prooued this his opinion by the generall vse of the whole Church and all Christian Nations and alleadged diuers authorities out of the Fathers Finally hee came to the holy Scripture citing many places of the Prophets to shew that this authority is called the authority of a Pastor saying that the vniuersalitie of it was giuen to S. Peter when CHRIST said Feede my Lambes and some of it imparted by Peter to the Bishops when he bad them Feede the flocke which they haue in their custodie And this opinion had great applause But before those of this fourth ranke made an end of speaking the Spanish Prelates resoluing the point should bee handled whether Bishops are instituted by CHRIST after they had consulted together did conclude that it was better the first motion should begin in the Congregations of the Diuines that themselues might with more shew of reason resuming the things spoken before discourse vpon them and compell others to doe the like Therefore in the Congregation of the first of October Michael Oroncuspe a Diuine of the Bishop of Pampelona said to the seuenth that being to qualifie or condemne a proposition which hath many significations it was necessary to distinguish them and afterwards to examine them one by one and hee thought the proposition whether Bishops bee superior to Priests to be such For one must distinguish whether they be superiours de facto or de iure That they are superiours de facto it cannot be doubted because present experience and the Histories of many ages doe shew that Bishops haue exercised superiority and Priests obedience Therefore this Article being without question the other de iure remaineth to bee discussed Wherein there is another ambiguitie also whether Iure Pontificio or Diuine In the first sense the case is cleere that they are superiours there beeing so many Decretals which say it expressely which howsoeuer it bee true and certaine yet the Lutherans are not in this regard to be condemned for heretiques because that cannot bee an article of faith which is grounded only vpon the law of man and deserue to be condemned for denying the superiority of Bishops onely in case it bee dâ—iure Diuino He added that he thought this point very cleere and that he could euidently prooue it and resolue anything alleadged to the contrarie saying hee must not proceed further beeing prohibited to speake of it And here he shewed that the Ministery of Confirmation and Ordination is proper to Bishops And hauing spoken vpon the eighth Article in conformitie of the others he ended his discourse Iohannes Fonseca a Diuine of the Archbishop of Granata followed who The institution of Bishops is discussed entred brauely vpon the matter saying it neither was nor could be forbidden to speake of it For the Article being proposed to be discussed whether it be hereticall or no it is necessary to vnderstand whether it bee against fayth against which it cannot be if it doe not repugne to the Law of GOD. He sayd hee knew not whence the report came that one might not speake of it because by the very proposition of the Article it was commanded to be discussed And here hee proceeded to handle not the superiority alone but the institution also affirming that Bishops are instituted by CHRIST and by his diuine ordination superiours to Priests He said that if the Pope be instituted by CHRIST because hee hath said to Peter I will giue thee the keyes of the Kingdome and Feede my Lambes Bishops are likewise instituted by him because he hath said to all the Apostles That which you bind on earth shall be bound in heauen and whose sinnes you remit they are remitted saying to them afterwards Goe into the whole world and preach the Gospel And which is more he said vnto them As my father hath sent me so I send you And if the Pope be successour of S. Peter the Bishops are successors of the Apostles alleadging many authorities out of the Fathers that the Bishops are successours of the Apostles And in particular he recited a long discourse of S. Bernard in this point to Eugenius the Pope and a place of the Actes of the Apostles where S. Paul saith to the Ephesians that they were made Bishops by the holy Ghost to gouerne the Church of GOD. Hee added that to bee confirmed or created by the Pope did not conclude that they were not instituted by CHRIST or had not authority from him For the Pope himselfe is created by the Cardinals and yet hath his authoritie from CHRIST and Priestes are created by the Bishop who doeth ordaine them but receiue their authoritie from GOD So the Bishops receiue the Diocesse from the Pope and authoritie from CHRIST Their superiority ouer Priests he proued to be iure diuino by authoritie of many Fathers who say that Bishops doe succeed the Apostles and Priestes the seuenty two disciples Concerning other particles of this point he said the same things which others had spoken before Cardinall Simoneta was impatient and turned often to his Colleagues and was about Which vexeth Cardinall Simoneta to interrupt the discourse but being entred into vpon so good reason and heard by the Prelates with such attention hee knew not how to resolue After him followed Antonius Grossetus a Dominican Friar who hauing briefly passed ouer the other articles insisted vpon this Hee stood much vpon the wordes of Saint Paul spoken to the Ephesians in Miletum exhorting them to haue a care of the flocke ouer which the holy Ghost had made them ouerseers vpon which place hee made many obseruations He sayd it was first necessary to declare that Bishops haue not commission for their office from men for so they would be hirelings to whom the Lambes doe not belong because the man who had committed the care vnto them beeing satisfied they had no more to thinke on But Saint Paul sheweth that the commission to gouerne the people of GOD is diuine giuen by the holy Ghost to conclude that they could not be excused by any dispensation of man He alleadged the famous passage of Saint Cyprian that euery Bishop is bound to giue an account of CHRIST onely Then he added that the Bishops of Ephesus were not of those who were instituted by CHRIST our LORD while hee was in the flesh but by Saint Paul or some other Apostle or disciple yet no mention is made of the ordainer but all is attributed to the holy Ghost who hath not giuen authority to gouerne but diuided a part of the flocke and consigned it to be fed And here hee made an inuectiue against those who a few dayes before sayd that the Pope doeth disturbe the flocke
inculcating that it was not well spoken and that it would bring againe into vse that which Saint Paul did detest I am of Paul and I am of Apollo He sayd the Pope was the ministeriall Head of the Church by whom CHRIST the principall Head doeth worke vnto whom also the worke ought to bee ascribed saying according to Saint Paul that the holy Ghost doth giue the flocke to be gouerned For the worke is neuer ascribed to the instrument or minister but to the principall Agent that this forme of speach hath alwayes beene vsed by the Ancients that GOD and CHRIST doe prouide the Church of gouernours that Saint Paul wrote to the Ephesians that CHRIST ascending to heauen hath furnished the Church with Apostles Euangelists Pastours and Masters shewing plainely that he did prouide Pastours after he was ascended into heauen and that the institution of Pastours and Masters in which number Bishops are ought as much to be ascribed vnto CHRIST as vnto the Apostles and Euangelists themselues The Theologue perceiued that he displeased the Legates and some more besides and fearing some bad Antonius Grossetus excuseth himselfe incounter as had happened vpon other occasions hee added that hee had spoken without premeditation beeing caried along by consequence of wordes and heat of discourse not remembring that that point was forbidden to be spoken of And entring againe to examine the proper offices of Bishops and contradicting the Lutherans who holde them for superfluous shewing they haue been very ancient in the Church and come from Apostolicall tradition he concluded The Legats did perceiue that this was the arte of Granata and the other Spaniards to giue the Prelats a field to enlarge themselues in this matter Therefore they tooke order that the contrary opinion should be defended by some of the foure Prelates who onely remayned to speake the next day and the Popes Prelats vsed to this arte were prepared to contradict the Spanish Bishops if they had begun to speake of this matter in the Congregations The next day the second of October two Diuines went about to prooue that as the superioritie of Bishops was certaine so it was hard to bee decided quo iure and in case it were would be of no fruit and therefore was to bee omitted Two others maintained that it was de iure Pontificio And Friar Simon a Florentine and a Diuine of Seripando discoursed according to the opinion of Caietanus and Catharinus in this forme that Bishops are instituted by CHRIST to gouerne the Church that his Maiesty did create Bishops all the Apostles when he said I send you as I haue beene sent by the Father that this institution was personall and ended with them that one of them was constituted to remaine perpetually in the Church which was Peter when he said not to him alone but to all his succession Feede my lambes that Saint Austin did meane so when he said that Peter did represent the whole Church which was neuer spoken of any of the other Apostles that Saint Cyprian said that Saint Peter is not onely a Type and figure of the vnity but that the vnity doeth begin from him In this power giuen onely to Peter and his successors the care of gouerning the Church is contained and of ordaining other Rectors and Pastors not as Delegates but as Ordinaries diuiding particular Prouinces Cities and Churches Therefore when it is demanded whether any Bishop bee de iure diuino one must answere affirmatiuely One onely the successour of Peter Besides the degree of a Bishop is de iure diuino so that the Pope cannot take order that there may be no Bishops in the Church but euery particular Bishop is De iure Pontificio Whence it commeth that he may create and translate them diminish or enlarge their Dioces giue them more or lesse authority suspend them also and depriue them which he cannot doe in that which is de iure diuino For from a Priest he cannot take away authority to consecrate because he hath it from CHRIST but may take iurisdiction from a Bishop because he hath it from himselfe And thus the famous saying of Cyprian must bee expounded there is but one Bishopricke and euery Bishop holdeth a part thereof in solidum otherwise it cannot bee defended that the gouernement of the Church is the most perfect of all that is Monarchicall and must necessarily fall into an Holigarchie which is the most imperfect and condemned by all those who write of gouernment Hee concluded that quo iure Bishops are instituted by the same they are superiour to Priests and that when this matter is to bee discussed the declaration is to bee made thus Hee alleadged Saint Thomas who saith in many places that euery spirituall power dependeth on that of the Pope and that euery Bishop ought to say I haue receiued part of that fulnesse He said that the old schoole-men were not to be regarded because none of them had handled this matter but the Modernes hauing after that the heresie of the Waldenses arose studied the Scripture and the Fathers haue established this trueth The last Diuine laboured to contradict him in that he said the Apostles were ordained Bishops saying when he sent them as himselfe was sent by the Father that he sent them to preach and to baptize which belongeth not to a Bishop but to a Priest and that onely Peter was ordained a Bishop by CHRIST who after the ascension ordained the other Apostles Bishops Concerning the other parts of this Article and the next they all agreed to comdemne them And so the Congregations of the Theologues were concluded After which the Legates beeing obliged to propose the reformation considering with themselues what particulars might be proposed not preiudiciall and yet might giue satisfaction were much troubled For that which would be gratefull to the Ambassadours would damnifie the Court and distaste the Bishops neither could they meddle with any thing that wold please the Bishops which would not bee preiudiciall to Rome or the The Legates demand of the Pope by letters what they shall doe concerning the reformation Princes Their resolution was to dispatch a Currier to the Pope and expect an answere and in the meane time to draw the businesse in length by making the Prelates speake in the matter of Order In particular they gaue his Holinesse an account of the contention which they did foresee concerning the Article of the superioritie of Bishops in regard of the petition made by the â—panish Prelates and the entrance made by their Diuines And howsoeuer they knew not their ende yet obseruing how earnest their request was and knowing how the Spaniards doe vsually ayme at things farre off they could not choose but suspect They put him in minde that this was the time in which they promised to speake of residence whereof some motion was made already For the Archbishop of Mesina demanded of those of Cyprus and Zara what their opinion would bee in case it were
and the trueth onely aymed at But if Religion and godlinesse bee openly beaten downe if tyrannie and ambition bee established if men studie faction gluttonie lust there is nothing more pernicious for the Church of God All this I haue spoken hitherto as if this Councell which you call so did subsist somwhere and were indeed a Councell which I thinke absolutely to be none Or if it be one and subsist any where sure it is an obscure one and kept very close For though we are not very farre off yet we can by no meanes learne what is done there what Bishops haue met or rather indeed whether any at all are met Nay besides aboue twentie months since when this Councell was first summoned by Pope Pius the Emperour Ferdinand answered that though all other matters were accommodated yet hee did much dislike the Place which the Pope had made choice of for himselfe For Trent though a prety Citie yet neither was commodiously enough seated for the receipt of so many Nations nor able to receiue so great a multitude of men as were likely in reason to meete at a Generall Councell The same answere was returned from other Christian Princes and from some much sharper Therfore wee beleeued that all these things together with the Councell it selfe had beene vanished away into smoake 7 But I pray you who is he that hath summoned this Councell and called the world together You wil say Pope Pius the fourth And why he rather then the Bishop of Toledo For by what power by what example of the Primitiue Church by what right doth hee this Did Peter Linus Cletus Clemens thus tosse and tumble the world with their Proclamations This was alwayes whilest the Empire flourished the proper right of the Emperours of Rome But now since the power of the Empire is lessened and Kingdomes by succession share part of the Imperiall power that power is communicated to Christian Kings and Princes Search the Annals lay together the memorials of all Antiquitie you shall finde the ancientest Councels the Nicene the Ephesine that of Chalcedon that of Constantinople to haue beene called by the Roman Emperours Constantine Theodosius the first Theodosius the second Martian not by the Popes of Rome 8 Leo the Pope a man otherwise louing enough to himselfe and no way neglectfull of the authority of his Sea did humbly beseech Mauritius the Emperour that hee would summon a Councell to be held in Italie as beeing the fittest place All the Priests sayes hee beseech your Clemencie that you would command a Generall Councell to bee held within Italie But the Emperour caused that Ceuncel to bee assembled not in Italie which the Pope earnestly laboured but at Chalcedon in Bithynia to shew that that was his right and belonged to him onely And when Ruffinus in that bickering which hee had with Ierome had alleadged a certaine Synod Tell mee sayes Ierome what Emperour caused it to bee called Ierome did not thinke the authoritie of a Generall Councell firme enough vnlesse an Emperour had called it I demand not now what Emperor hath commanded the Bishops to be called to Trent at this present But with what Emperor did the Pope that hath taken thus much to himselfe aduise of holding the Councell what Christian King or Prince did hee make priuy to his designe To intrude vpon anothers right by fraude or force and to vsurpe for his owne what belongs to others is iniurious dealing But to abuse the Clemency of Princes and to rule ouer them as his vassalls is an egregious and an intollerable disgrace to them But for vs by our complying to goe about to backe such an iniurie and disgrace were no lesse iniurie Wherefore if wee should onely say thus much that this Trent Councell of yours is not lawfully called that Pope Pius hath done nothing rightly or orderly no man could iustly find fault with our absence 9 I passe ouer the wrongs which the Popes of Rome haue done vs That they haue as often as they pleased armed our People against their Soueraigne That they haue pulld the Scepters out of our Kings hands and the Crownes from off their heades That they would haue the Kingdome of England to bee theirs and held in their name and our Kings to Reigne by their fauour That within these later yeares they haue stirred vp against vs somtimes the French somtimes the Emperor What the intentions of Pius himselfe haue beene towards vs what hee hath done what hee hath spoken what hee hath practised what hee hath threatened t' is needlesse to rehearse For his actions and his words are not so close so concealed but that the aime of both may be discouered By what courses hee was made Pope and by what steps hee mounted to so great a dignity I say nothing I doe not say that he aspired to the Popedome by corrupting of Cardinals buying of voices by price and purchase by vnderminings and ambushes I doe not say that lately beeing not able to quitt skores hee cast Cardinall Caraffa into prison and there murthered him by whose assistance he had compassed the rest of the Cardinals voyces to whom for that seruice he owed a great summe of money These and diuers other things I leaue to you who both behold them at a neerer distance and better vnderstand them And can you wonder then that wecome not to a man of Blood one that purchases voyces that denies to pay his debts to a Simoniacal person to an Heretique Beleeue me it is not the part of a wise man wilfully to runne into a place infected and to consult of Religion with the enemies of Religion My mother sayes one forbade mee the company of infamous persons Iohn the Apostle durst not sit in the same Bath nor wash with Olympius lest he should bee strucke from heauen with the same thunder I haue not sate sayth Dauid in the assembly of Vanitie neither will I walke with the workers of iniquitie 10 But admitte that this is the Popes proper right let it bee in his power to call Councels to gouerne the whole world Let those things bee false and vaine whatsoeuer wee haue spoken concerning the power of the Emperour and the right of Kings Grant that Pope Pius is an honest man that he was duely and lawfully made Pope that he sought no mans life that he did not kill Caraffa in prison yet it is fit that Councels should be free that euery man may be present that will and those with whose conuenience it stands not may bee absent And such was anciently the equitie and moderation of those better men The Princes were not then called together in such a slauish manner that if any one of them had stayed at home or had not sent Ambassadours to the Councell presently euery eye was vpon him euery finger pointing at him In the Nicen Councel in the Ephesine in that of Constantinople what spie obserued who were absent But there was neuer an Ambassadour then neither from
hee saith The other Apostles were that which Peter was and had the same fellowship of honour and power Saint Hierome saith the authoritie of the world is greater then that of one Citie Why doe you extoll the custome of one Citie Why doe you make a paucitie whence pride began to giue lawes to the Church Wheresoeuer any Bishop is whether at Rome or at Eugubium or at Constantinople or at Rhegium hee is of the same desert and Priesthood The strength of riches or humblenesse of pouertie maketh a Bishop neither greater nor lesse Gregorie sayth Peter is the chiefe member in the bodie Iohn Andrew Iames are Heads of particular people yet all of them are members of the Church vnder one Head Nay the Saints before the Law the Saints vnder the Law the Saints vnder the Gospel and all that make vp the bodie of the Lord are to bee accounted members and none was euer willing to bee called Vniuersall 29 This is that power which some doe so strenuously defend at this day which whatsoeuer they thinke of the Popes life and religion they would haue to bee most religiously maintained as if the Church could not subsist without it or as if a Councell were no Councell except the Pope did will and command it to be so or as if the whole world must needs be deceaued if it should thinke otherwise Wherefore now that you see that all things are most vniustly handled that nothing is sincerely and fairely caried in Councels you may not wonder that our men had rather tarry at home then take so long and so idle a iourney in which they shall both lose their labour and betray their cause 30 You will say it is not lawfull to make change in Religion without order from the Pope and the Councell Yet the Popes haue changed almost the whole state of the Primitiue Church without any Councell at all You vse a faire smooth speach but it is to couer foule errours The purpose is onely to keepe mens minds in expectation that being wearied with tedious delayes they may at the last despaire of any good For what while the Pope assembleth a Councell while the Bishops and Abbots returne home will they haue GOD's people in the meane while to bee deceiued to erre to mistake themselues to bee ouerwhelmed with errours and want of the knowledge of GOD and so to bee carried to euerlasting destruction Is it not lawfull for any of vs to beleeue in CHRIST to professe the Gospel to serue God aright to flie superstition and idolatrie except they will be pleased to giue vs leaue The state of God's children were most miserable if there being so many errors so generally spread so grosse so blind so foule and so perspicuous and manifest that euen our aduersaries themselues are not able to denie them nothing could be done without the whole world should meet in a generall Councell the expectation whereof is very vncertaine and the euent much more In times past when the Persians inuaded Greece and began to lay all waste if then the Lacedemonians whose virtue was then most eminent amongst the Grecians whose help was requisite as soone as might be had expected a more seasonable moone to make warre in for it was an ancient superstition which proceeded from Lycurgus not to goe forth to fight but in a full moone their Countrie might haue beene spoiled whilst they deferred the time They say delay breeds danger The safetie of God's Church is in question the Deuill goeth about roaring like a Lion seeking whom he may deuoure Simple men are easily deceaued and though they be often touched with a zeal towards God yet they persecute the sonne of God before they be aware And as Nazianzen saith when they purpose to fight for Christ they fight against him Nay the Bishops themselues who ought to haue a care of these things are as though they were but Ghosts carelesse of them or to speake truth they increase the error and make the mist that is in their Religion twice as great as it was Must wee therefore sit idle expecting how these Fathers will handle the matter must wee hold our hands together and doe nothing Nay saith Cyprian there is but one Bishoprique of which euery one holdeth an intire part whereof he is to giue account to the Lord. I will require saith the Lord their bloud at thy handes If any shall put his hand to the plough and looke backe and be sollicitous what others thinke and expect the authoritie of a generall Councell and hide the Lord's treasure in the meane while he shall here this O euill and faithlesse seruant take him away and cast him into outward darkenesse Suffer saith Christ the dead to burie their dead but come thou and follow mee In humane counsels it is the part of a wise man to expect the iudgment and consent of men but in matters diuine Gods word is all in all the which so soone as a godly man hath receiued hee presently yeeldeth and submitteth himselfe he is not wauering not expecteth others Hee vnderstandeth that he is not bound to giue care to the Pope or the Councell but to the will of God whose voice is to be obeyed though all men say nay The Prophet Elias presently obeyed God's command though he thought he was alone Abraham being warned of God went out of Chaldea Lot went out of Sodome the three Israelites made a publike confession of their Religion and did publiquely detest Idolatry without expecting a generall Councell Goe saith the Angel out of the midst of her and partake not of her sinnes lest you tast of her Plagues Hee saith not expect a Synode of Bishops So God's trueth was first published and so it is now to be restored The Apostles first taught the Gospell without a publique Councell in like manner the same Gospell may be restored againe without a publique Councell If at the first Christ and his Apostles would haue caried and differred all vntill a generall Councell when had their sound gone forth into all lands how had the kingdome of heauen suffered violence and how had the violent taken it by force Where now would the Gospell and the Church of God haue beene As for our parts we do not feare and flie but desire and wish for a Councell so that it bee freely ingenuous and Christian so that men doe meet as the Apostles did so that Abbots and Bishops be freed from their oath by which they are bound to the Popes so that that whole conspiracie be dissolued so that our men may be modestly and freely heard and not condemned before they be heard so that one man may not haue power to ouerthrow whatsoeuer is done But seeing it impossible as the times now are that this should be obteyned and seeing that all absurd things foolish ridiculous superstitious impious are defended most pertinaciously and that for custome sake because they haue beene once receiued we haue thought it fit to prouide for our