summ of this alledged out of St. Paul's practice to justifie set-Forms of Prayer whose Desire and Prayer to God for Israel was That they might be saved as Romans the 10th Vers 1. amounts to this That St. Paul Sosthenes Silvanus Timotheus and the brethren with Paul at Rome did put up their Prayers to God for his bestowing spiritual blessings upon the several Churches of Christ through the word of â—â—ace did put them up I say in a Common-Prayer in a set-composed or as the Separatists call it stinted Form of Prayer And considering that the afore-mentioned Christians and Saints continued so long in a Common set-Form of Prayer for those Churches I cannot think but the pride ignorance heady and high-minded Spirits of these men had they lived in days together would have charged St. Paul and the rest that joined with him in Devotion for the Churches with what they cast upon the painful orthodoxal conformable Clergy of our Church in the seventh Consideration where they call them Ignorant Scandalous Lazy and Formal Priests and Ministers to the deceiving and utter undoing of precious souls and should they have had but such Revenues Salaries Tithes and Gleabs gone along with their Labours as our reverend Bishops Deans and Chapters and some of our Clergy had with theirs their Conformity and Uniformity in Prayer especially it being so short how holy soever their lives had been was crime enough for their Houses to have been Plunder'd their Estates Sequestred and their Persons Imprisoned And now to leave off the further confirmation of this unjustly condemned Practice of Devotion by the use of set-Forms of Prayer in the times of the Old and New Testaments and in the times of the Antient Churches before Popery and in the days of the Reformed Churches fallen from the Pope I shall only commend to your consideration the Prayer of St. Chrysostom wherewith we even close our dayly Devotions as in all probability he and the people he was over did conclude their Worship of God in their set-Forms of Prayer Almighty God who hast given us Grace at this time with one accord c. I confess 't is not the Forms of Prayer be they never so Admirable as to Expressions without the fervent desires of the Heart be the man never so righteous that utters them that do avail ought with God but when a man from the ground of the heart ascends up to God in Forms be they never so antient short or Common provided they be lawful as to the Matter and laudable as to the manner of the Expression supplicating praying interceding and giving of thanks then they become at the Throne of Grace such as St. John in the 5th of the Revelations Vers 8. saw in Heaven when the 24 Elders fell down before the Lamb namely barps and golden vials full of odours even the prayer of Saints And hereupon was the exellency of David's Prayer of which he speaks Psalm 11â— Vers 58. I made my petition with my whole heart There are recorded in the Scripture divers Forms of Prayers and Thanksgivings Composed by David and other devout Worshippers of God questionless for the use of themselves and others in the frequent Commemorations of God's Mercies to them and for their Supplications to be made unto God their wants being again the same or alike as formerly But now that which made these Forms of Prayer effectual David mentions in the same place where he saith he did it with his whole heart All the powers and faculties of his Soul were now acting in their several places so as he might prevail with God to supply his wants And a devout soul setting dilligently to this as St. Peter and the rest of the Twelve resolved to do Acts the 6th Vers 4. namely give themselves much to prayer as David did namely petition the Lord with his whole heart let it be in a set-Form that that praying soul goes to God that soul cannot want success long For if the Spirit it self as St. Paul speaks Romans the 8th Vers 26. be not yet helping his Infirmities it will not be long before he be with him making Intercessions for him i. e. working in him gronings that cannot be uttered nor long unanswered by his God if the things petitioned may be consistant with God's glory and the petitioners true good and what hinders that this soul praying to or praising God in a Form as before limited may not be accepted of God seeing God hath his whole demand of him in a way not inhibited by him as is evident Prov. 23. Vers 26. My son give me thy heart So that what St. James said of faith without works and of faith with works may be said of Common or set-Forms of Prayer without the heart going up to God with them and with the heart going up to God in or by them In the 17 Verse of the second Chapter he saith that faith if it hath not works is dead being alone and in Verse the 26th as the body without the spirit is dead so faith without works is dead also faith with out works is like the body without the spirit it acts nothing to the good thereof Even so the best Forms of common-Common-Prayer if there be wanting in the man that utters or uses them a spirit or heart of supplication they prevail nothing with God for him they may be Vials but they are without Odours or Incense and so no sweet savour to God But then in the 22 Vers the Apostle that faith by works was made perfect and in the 23 Vers that by virtue thereof faith was imputed to Abraham for righteousness and he was called the friend of God Even so Common Forms for Prayer by fervent earnest supplicating hearts going to God in them the Common Prayers but as dead in themselves are thereby made perfect yea lively and the praying man thereby is owned of God and dealt by as his friend I shall now end my reasoning for the lawful and justifiable use of Common Forms of Prayer that suit our wants our hearts being in a praying condition with the practice of our Saviour in his bitter Agonies Matth. 26. Vers 39 and 42. there is mention of Christ's praying to the father for the Cup to pass from him and having no grant and resolving to seek God further for it in the 44 Vers 't is said he went away again and prayed the third time saving the same words And lastly To prevail with ye to come off from the dangerous Frrour ye are in as concerning the present I shall mind ye with the Reasons King Charles the First of most blessed memory hath laid down for the present purpose in his Observations upon the Ordinance against the Book of Common-Prayer I will write down some Paragraphs in that Tractate that they that have not his Book may read the Judgment of that blessed Martyr concerning the matter now in hand In the sixth Paragraph his Words are these For the manner of using set
hast standred thine own mother's son In the third place God's Spirit denys ye to be Churches of Christ or else at least he charges ye with such evil Customs as none of them have or at least as they ought not to have for those words of the Apostle 1 Corin. 11. v. 16. belong to you and to such as you are If any man seem to be contentious we have no such custome neither the Churches of God The Factions do not only seem contentious they have too deeply engaged themselves therein for either their own or others spiritual good In the last place Ye are by the Apostle deliver'd with the incestuous person up to Satan As I may say he hath excommunicated you Romans 16. v. 17. Mark them that cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine ye have learned and avoid them If ye will be holding forth the Word as ye call it the Apostle would have ye have no other Auditors than the Walls and Stools are with ye he orders all to avoid ye none to hear ye or associate with ye unless for your conversion And now from my Heart for your conversion to us in the Apostle's words to the Corinthians the 1st Epistle chap. 1. vers 10. I do exhort ye and beseech ye in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ That ye all speak the same thing that there be no divisions among you but that ye be perfectly joyned together with us in the same mind and in the same judgment And to prevail with ye all to joyn with us speedily in Worshipping the God of Peace and Unity I convince ye in the words of the Apostle Philippians 2. vers 1 2 3. If there be therefore any consolation in Christ if any comfort of love if any fellowship of the spirit if any bowels and mercies fulfil ye my joy that ye be like minded have the same love being of one accord of one mind with us Let nothing henceforth be done through strife or vain-glory but in lowliness of mind let each esteem other better than themselves So biddeth farewel to ye all Richard Lewthwat February 26. 1677. Mr. Lewthwat I Have heard read and consider'd of your Treatise Intituled A Justification of set Forms of Prayer and in especial of the Liturgy of the Church of England in Answer to and Confutation of Vavasor Powel's Fourteen Considerations against Composed and Imposed Forms c. And upon the whole matter I conceive it may be very Useful and Profitable especially to the vulgar sort of seduced Dissenters to with-draw them from their former Errors and procure their Return to the Way of Divine Worship prescribed in the Church of England if you will be perswaded to permit it to be made Publick by the Press Hen. Nerford B. D. Rector of Attleburgh Norf. I Edward Atkinson Rector of Bunwell Norf. desire the same thing To the Composers Imposers Readers and Hearers of common-COMMON-PRAYER to the Disputers and Writers for common-COMMON-PRAYER I Would desire ye all in the Name and Fear of the All-seeing Almighty and All judging God to set these following and the like Considerations to your Hearts and your Hearts to them First How jealous the Lord of Heaven and Earth is of his own Worship and of all the Parts and Circumstances thereto belonging Deut. 5.9 Hos 5.11 Matth. 15.3 Col. 2.21 Rev. 22.14.20 2. How abominable and unacceptable to this holy just God have been and is all Idolatrous Superstitious and False Services and all that do serve him in any way or thing which he hath not himself commanded and appointed Deut. 7.25 26. Isa 30.22 and the 66.3 4. Jerem. 9.13 14. Ezr. 20.4 3. How sorely and severely hath he punished those Kings Priests Prophets and people that have been false Worshippers and swerved from his holy Commandments 1 Kings 11.6 Numb 11.34 4. Consider whether God doth call upon any of you all to offer him any such Service as this is and whether he may not say to you as he did once to Judah Who hath required this at your hand Isai 1.12 5. How inconsistant with the day and light of the Gospel is this Service God having sent his Word more fully and plainly to direct his Ministers and People and given his Spirit in a more abundant measure to help and enable them to call upon him 6. How little good if any at all hath been done by the long use of the Service-Book though men have prayed long by it that the rest of their lives might be holy and righteous and yet they still continue profane and unrighteous 7. How much hurt it hath done in sholdering and thrusting out many godly painful soul-saving Preachers and in bringing in and maintaining so many ignorant scandalous lazy and formal Priests and Curats to the deceiving and utter undoing of precious souls 8. Whether the imposing of the Scotish Liturgy which in some things was better though in some others was worse than the English was not the beginning and the first cause of the late grievous Wars and if so whether men should not be more cautious to do the like for the future 9. Whether if the truth were throughly and truly weighed and examined the first end of Composing the Common-Prayer-Book which do's so much symbolize with the Mass was not to bring Papists to Church but it effected so little therein not because they so much disliked it as because it was not in Latin and commanded by the Pope that it rather confirm'd them in their Mass-service 10. Whether some may not intend by the re-establishing this Book to oppose and put down that excellent and gracions Spirit of Prayer and Preaching which God hath poured out upon his Ministers and to make this a snare and net against all Preachers and people that out of Conscience cannot conform thereto 11. Whether any persons can produce any such Liturgy or Form of Prayer from the beginning of the World either among the Jews or Geztiles till above three hundred years after Christ when Anti-Christ began to exercise Papal Power 12. Whether if there were no other reason but that this Book hath been so much Idoliz'd by the generality of men and offensive to so many Christians it should not be done with as the Brasen Serpent was by Hezekiah 1 Kings 13. Whether one end of Christ's coming into and one part of his work in the World was not to redeem men from the Rudiments and Traditions of men of which this is one And whether it be not a sin against the Blood and Spirit and Gospel of Christ to impose maintain and continue still the use of the same 1 Pet. 1.18 19. Heb. 9.10 11. 14. Whether at the great and terrible day of Judgment any Magistrates and Ministers or People can justifie before Christ the making imposing reading or hearing of this or the like Service And whether good men as far as they build with this Material will not suffer loss And whether those can stand then in the Judgment
without fear shame and sorrow that have cast out persecuted imprisoned or otherwise afflicted the true Preachers and Servants of God who did choose to obey God rather than men And to observe his Divine Will rather than the Traditions of men Consider what I say and the Lord give thee you understanding in all things 2 Tim. 2.7 I esteem all thy precepts concerning all things to be right and I hate every false way Psalm 119.128 With these fourteen Considerations Vavasor Powel begins his Invectives against Liturgies set-Forms of Prayer and Common-Prayer Books c. which was Printed at London for Livewell Chapman Anno 1661 and was deliver'd to me to peruse and to give my judgment thereof the fore-mention'd part whereof I have consider'd and according to promise do return some of my thoughts upon these considerations in the following words To the Opposers Contemners and Neglecters of common-Common-Prayer and to the Disputers and Writers against common-Common-Prayer I Would desire you all in the Name and Fear of the All-seeing All-mighty and All-judging God to set these following Propositions Conclusions c. to your Hearts and your Hearts to them being evidently enough though secretly closed and couched in the wombs of the fore-mentioned Considerations But before I come to open the Contents of the Considerations which I presume are framed especially for a Scare-crow to the Worshippers and Servers of God in the Way of our Church of England by the Book of Common-Prayer and by a Composed Form or Forms of Prayer by the Ministers before their Sermons I desire all that admire the reasons laid down against this kind of Worship to consider that the Author doth not intend only the Condemnation of our Common-Prayers but of any Common-Prayer whatever hath been Composed or shall be for he writes to the Disputers and Writers for Common-Prayer and to the Composers Imposers c. of Common-Praver which terms are indefinite and are equipollent in Logic to Universality so that the Author is against all Common-Prayer whatever have been or shall be Composed or Imposed c. so that you may see by the Immediate succeeding discourse there is no less then a condemnation by the Author of David of St. Paul of all the ancient and modern Churches and Divines yea and of Jesus Christ himself that came into the World to seek and to save that was lost And now to shew ye the blindness of this Guide Disputing and Writing against Common-Prayer and the danger of them that follow him and such as are of his erroneous Judgment First I desire ye to search the Scriptures as concerning this matter where we find Records that Common-Prayers and set-Forms have been Composed Imposed and Used by them that were sanctified yea by them that had Authority from Heaven to instruct and guide men in the Worship and Service of God In the 1 Chron. 16. vers 7. Then on that day David delivered first this Psalm to thank the Lord into the hand of Asaph and his brethren if ye look upon what follows ye have the form of the Thanksgiving If ye look before that 7th Verse ye shall see the occasion thereof and the Quire appointed to sing it unto the Lord in the Ears of the Congregation But come we to look into the Gospel and that in the 11th of St. Luke at Verse the first our Saviour's Disciples desired him to teach them to pray as John also taught his Disciples hereupon Christ composed a Prayer the Form being Our Father which art in Heaven c. yea and imposed it upon them to be used by them when ye pray say Our Father which art in Heaven c. Now this Prayer was and is Common-Prayer 't is a Prayer belongs to every one of Christ's Disciples because it sutes all their occasions and 't is commanded That they use it as oft as they pray When ye pray say Our Father c. but yet not so injoined that they should use no other when they pray but that as good Expositors give the meaning as is the practice of the best Reformed Churches and men of the soundest judgments they should either at the beginning or ending or in some part of their Devotions send up the desires of their hearts to God in that form of Prayer And if upon these Considerations that Prayer be not Common or a set-Form of Prayer I know not what is meant by the notions of Common or set-Form of Prayer King Charles the First of most blessed memory in his Contemplations upon the Ordinance against the Common-Prayer-Book saith of this our Lord's Prayer that it is the warrant and original pattern of set-Liturgies in the Christian Church Further considering Christ's Disciples request there 't is more then probable that John the Baptist had Composed a set-Form of Prayer to be used by his Disciples in their Devotions and Service of God One Precedent more I shall mind ye of for justification for Composing and Using set-Forms of Prayer in the Churches of Christ which I bring from the practice of St. Paul in the beginning of his Epistles to the several Churches of Christ St. Paul knowing as he saith in the 1 Corinth Chap. 3. Verse 6 7. That 't is not of his planting nor of Apollo's watering by the word alone that Grace is begotten or increased in men but that 't is by God's blessing the word thereto doubtless hereupon it was that he ever began his Epistles with prayer to God for spiritual blessings to be to them through the word he sent them And if ye peruse the beginning of his Epistles he being to bring down the same blessings upon the several Churches from God by his Epistles and Prayer to God he useth ever the same set-Form of Praâ—er Rom. 1. Vers 7. and Ephes 1. Vers 2. his Prayer for them is in the same form of words Gâ—ace be to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ See St. Paul having the same mercies of Grace and Peace to seek at God's hand to be power'd down upon those Churches by his Epistles to them his heart ascends up in desire to God for their spiritual benefit thereby in the same words Nay and 't is not a Common-Prayer or Liturgy for himself only to pray by but for others also for himself and Sosthenes 1 Corinth Vers 2. for himself and Timothy 2 Corin. Chap. 1. Vers 2. and Philip. Chap. 1. Vers 1 2. and Colos Chap. 1. Vers 1 2. Yea 't is a set-Form for himself Silvanus and Timotheus Epist 1. Thessal 1. Vers 1 and 2. Thessal Chap. 1. Vers 1 2. Yea further 'T is a set-Form for himself and the Brethren with him at Rome praying to God through the means of that Epistle for the re-establishing the Galatians in the Gospel from which they were fallen 't is the Prayer for them all Grace be to ye and peace from God the Father and from our Lord Jesus Christ Galat. Chap. 1. Vers 1 2 3. So that the
and prescribed Forms there is no doubt that wholsome words being known and fitted to mens understandings are soonest received into their hearts and aptest to excite and carry along with them judicious and fervent affections In the eighth Paragraph thus he writes I could never fee any reason why any Christian should abhor or be forbidden to use the same Forms of Prayer since he prays to the same God believes in the same Saviour professeth the same Truth reads the same Scriptures hath the same Duties upon him and feels the same dayly wants for the most part both inward and outward which are common to the whole Church In the ninth Paragraph he goes on thus Sure we may as well before hand know what we pray as to whom we pray and in what words as to what sense when we desire the same things what hinders we may not use the same words our appetite and digestion too may be good when we use as we pray for our dayly bread I will write down here the thirteenth Paragraph which though it justifies Common Forms of Prayer yet condemns not but rather approves what our Adversary so magnifies as to down with set-Forms of Prayer provided it be done with a religious and prudential care His words follow Though I am not against modest discreet and humble use of Ministers Gifts in publick the better to fit and excite their own and the peoples affections to the present occasions yet I know no necessity why private and single abilities should quite justle out and deprive the Church of the joynt Abilities and concurrent Gifts of many learned and godly men such as the Composers of the Service-Book were who may in all reason be thought to have more Gifts and Graces inabling them to Compose with serious deliberations and concurrent advice such Forms of Prayers as may best fit the Churches common wants inform the hearers understandings and stir up that fiduciary and fervent application of their Spirits wherein consists the very life and soul of Prayer then any private man by his solitary abilities can be presumed to have with what they are many times even there where they make a great noise and shew the affectations emptiness impertinencies rudeness confusions flatness obscurity vain and ridiculous repetitions the sensless and oft-times blasphemous Expressions all these burthen'd with a most tedious and intolerable length do sufficiently convince all men but those who glory in that pharisaick way And the said King Charles having in the 15th Paragraph shewed the necessity of the use of Forms of publick Composure in the performance of Sacramental Administrations and the like in the 16th Paragraph his words are as follow A serious sense of which Inconvenience in the Church inavoidably following every mans several manner of Officiating no doubt first occasioned the Wisdom and Piety of the Antient Churches to remedy those Mischiefs by the use of constant Liturgies of Common Composure And now for a close at present as to my Meditations upon the present subject of common-Common-Prayer what can solidly or commendably be said against the Use of Set and Composed Forms of Prayer to put up to God the servent desires of our hearts by If the said Forms be lawful laudable and convenient as to the Matter and Expressions suiting together with our wants seeing we have such a cloud of Authentick Authors for it as David Jesus Christ our Saviour St. Paul John the Baptist besides the Fathers the Antient Churches the devout and pious Modern Divines yea and I might have recounted even all late Reformed Churches till these late upstart anti-Christian heady high-minded late Factions arose disturbing the Unity and blessed Peace of our and other true Churches of Christ denying the Lord that bought them and without Repentance bringing upon themselves and their Proselytes swift destruction And now I shall end my Meditations as to what preceded the Author's proposed fourteen Considerations following now to be considered of in the very Words of the before quoted King Charles of Blessed Memory with which he ends his Observations upon the said Ordinance against the Book of Common-Prayer I wish saith he their Repentance may be their only Punishment that seeing the mischeif the disuse of publick Liturgies hath already produced they may restore that Credit Use and Reverence to them which by the Antient Churches were given to Set Forms of sound and wholesome Words And now having shewed the groundless Oppositions of the Author to Common and Set Forms of Prayer given me to peruse and to give my opinion concerning the aforesaid subject and having also from the Sacred Scriptures and otherwise justified the Use and manifested the Aptness of Common-Prayers for our Devotions Worship and Service to be put up and performed to God I now come to speak to the Fourteen Considerations which the Author proposeth to the World as unanswerable Evidences in his judgement to make the aforesaid kind of Worship and Service though never so Conscientiously Sincerely and Heartity performed to be damnable because abominable to God and not required of us by him as is to be collected out of his four first Considerations I shall therefore now spend a little time about the said Considerations and look into the Bowels of them they being in the whole like the great Horse framed at the Seige of Troy in the Body whereof were inclosed men enough to deliver up the City to Destruction For in this Fabrick and Womb of these Considerations are inclosed conclusions and opinions enough to deliver up treacherously the City of God the Souls Redeemed by Christ's Blood to Hell and its Assistants the Beseigers thereof to Eternal Destruction if impenitently followed and persevered therein I will therefore open the Door of this Monster composed by deceitful Workers having transformed themselves in the Apostle's sence into the Ministers of Christ And letting out the deadly Enemies therein the false conclusions shall slay them with the two edged Sword of God's Word and known Truth That they make no further devastation hereabout upon them for whom Christ dyed In he Considerations the Author falls from the way he begâ—n in as to the quantity of a proposition namely the universality of his condemnation of Common-Prayer in his Indefinite term for now he endeavours especially to keep the Common-Prayer Book of our Church of England from a glorious Resurrection which had been Crucified Dead and Buried so long time by the long Parliament and their Armies For all his Magazine is spent in killing again what they thought they had killed before for ever namely the Common-Prayer Book In the four first Considerations are contained four positive Conclusions which the Author endeavours to make good by Scripture and thereby to overthrow the Common-Prayer Book of our Church for which purpose even the whole part of the following Pamphlet is spent Look upon the first Consideration beginning thus How Jealous the Lord of Heaven and Earth is of his own Worship and of all the parts
and circumstances thereto belonging Deut. 5. vers 9. c. and withall look upon the latter part of the second Consideration at these words All that do serve him in any way or thing which he hath not himself commanded or appointed Deut. 7. vers 25 26 c. And ye shall see thus much to be imply'd and inserred The Proposition The Lord in the Scriptures hath set forth his own Worship and Service for us to perform and observe as to all the parts circumstances way and things thereto belonging Parts Circumstances any way and things are his own words as ye may read in the first and second Considerations and are secretly affirmed there by the Author of the Worship and Service of God to the same purpose I have predicated them in the Proposition To which I thus Answer As to the essential and absolutely necessary parts of our Worshipping and Serving God or as to what is to be believed and morally done by us to be saved I do grant they are contained and set forth first fully in the Old Testament and that by Moses from the Mouth of God though not so cleerly as since because of the Vail that was over so that then they could not steadfastly see to the end of them as St. Paul speaks 2 Cor. 3. vers 13. And they are again fully set forth in the New Testament and that by Jesu◠Christ from the Father John 12. vers 50. Whatsoever I speak therefore even as the father said unto me so I speak Whereupon Christ is called the Word John 1. vers 1. that is the Word of the Father because as the Father taught him so he spake John 8. vers 28. Therefore in respect to the setting forth fully the Worship and Service of God and way to Salvation as to the essential parts thereof both Christ and Moses have approbation by the Author to the Hebrews cap. 3. vers 1 2. Consider the Apostle and high Priest of our profession Christ Jesus 〈◊〉 faithful to him that appointed him as also Moses was faithful in all his house But to grant that the Worship and Service of God set forth so sufficiently by Moses or Christ as before granted was directed and order'd as to all the circumstances words ways and things by them or any under them is to grant more than can be proved by the Scriptures For to instance in one particular essential part or duty of Worship or Service we see that when God by Moses or his Son or by any under them have commanded men to call upon God by Prayer in time of need or to praise him for his goodness to them all the Circumstances of this Duty as to words or forms or places or number of times of Praying to God or Praising of him are not fully set forth by them neither by Precept nor Example for we see the Examples herein dissering Psal 119. vers 164. the Psalmist is at his Devotion seven times a day and Daniel is but three times Daniel 6. vers 10. And so as to the Posture or Gesture in performance of the Duty have not been the same Daniel's posture was kneeling in the place aforesaid Luke 18. vers 13. the Publican's was standing Deut. 9. vers 18. Moses's posture was sometimes falling down upon his Face at his Prayers And as much may be shewed as to other Duties So that from this hath been said 't is evident the circumstances wayes and things as the Author calls them as to the Worship and Service of God were not all commanded and appointed by God in the Author's sence Wherefore I cannot see but that our Church Liturgies are more justifiable than either the set Forms of the factious Persons which some of them desire should not seem to be set Forms by reason of their disuse of them for some considerable time yea and more justifiable than their Extemporary Prayers which they falsely and blasphemously call Praying by the Spirit Considering that both in their Composed Forms and Extemporary Prayers for the most part if not always they consent not to wholsome Words even the Words of our Lord Jesus Christ nor to the Doctrin which is according to Godliness to use the Apostle's Phrase in the first to Timothy cap. 6. vers 3. with neither of which can they charge our former or present Common-Prayer Book Look upon the former part of the second Consideration which begins thus How abominable and unacceptable to this holy just God have been all Idolatrous superstitious and false Services The Proposition is this as the Author's opinion All Idolatrous Superstitious and false Services are abominable and unacceptable to God Answer This Proposition I grant to be a Truth for God wills us to own him to be God yea and him alone 2 Kings cap. 19. vers 15. and Exod. 20. vers 2 3. I am the Lord thy God which brought thee out of the Land c. Thou shalt have no other gods but me As to godship lordship and absolute Supremacy God will indure no Corival in the heart of Man And whosoever ascribes to any Creature what the Scriptures have peculiarly attributed to God is guilty of Idolatry and Superstition also All therefore that is to be faulted in this consideration is the Author's misapplication of the Proposition for he applies it to them that worship God devoutly and call upon him fervently in a justifiable Form of Prayer And I see not but the Author in so applying the forementioned Proposition issuing out of that consideration how he can be guilty of less than Blasphemy in terming that Service of ours Idolatrous seeing we worship the true God rightly Where is our Idolatry or false Service in that Worship and Invocation Is it in our going to God by Prayer in time of need through the only Mediator betwixt God and Man Christ Jesus our Saviour As we do confessing with our Mouths because believing with our hearts that God is both able and willing to supply our wants as is necessary to be in devout souls in order to obtain at God's hands Hebrews 11. vers 6. In all this I hope we are neither Idolatrous nor false in our Service The Author might rightly have applied to himself and his Proselytes the Doctrin or Proposition considering his words in the seventh Consideration where he terms their own Speakers Soul-saving Teachers for in so saying he is both Idolatrous and Superstitious in ascribing that to themselves which is the peculiar of the infinite Wise God Isaiah 43. ver 11. I even I am the Lord and beside me there is no Saviour Is he not therein Idolatrous and Superstitious in ascribing to their own Teachers to be both the Fountain and Cunduit-pipe of Salvation or saving Grace as there he doth If not so I am sure he falls thereupon under St. Paul's reprehension of the carnal and ignorant Factions in the 1 Corimh cap. 3. ver 6. For indeed it will be evident when I come to speak of the aforesaid consideration that
that have been and are but such as our Saviour said the Scribeâ— Pharisees and Hypocrites were Mat. 23 ver 13. where he said they did Shut up the Kingdom of Heaven against men did neither go in themselves nor suffer them that were entering to go in But before I pass from the Consideration and Proposition I must touch a little upon the latter part thereof which is also by the Author misapply'd to our Liturgy and them that use it He looks upon our Worshipping of God in that form to be a false Service and the chief places he brings to discover what a false Service is are Isaiah 66. ver 3 4. and Jerem. cap. 9. ver 13 14. where the Prophets give the reasons why God had no respect to Israels offerings and why he gave up the Land to perish and to be burnt and it was they say because the People had forsaken God's Laws and followed their own ways and their own abominations Now all this makes nothing against our Liturgy or the Worshippers of God by it for our Service-Book hath nothing in it against the Will of God or his Worship set forth in the Scriptures I conclude therefore that had the Author applied the false Service he there spake of and the recited places out of Isaiah and Jeremiah to himself and the rest of the Factious as to their Worship and Service he had done rightly for I am sure that their Service both as to Prayer and Instruction in most things was truly what they falsely charge upon us namely a false Service As to their Prayers King Charles the First of most Blessed memory hath evidenced the falseness of their Service seeing God by St. Paul to Timothy 1 Epist cap. 2. ver 1 2. exhorts That Prayers and Supplications should be made for Kings and all in Authority For in the last Paragraph but one in his Observations upon the Ordinance against the Common-Prayer Book His words follow thus One of the greatest faults some men found with the Common-Prayer Book I believe was this that it taught them to pray so oft for me to which Petitions they had not Loyalty enough to say Amen Nor yet Charity enough to forbear reproaches and even Cursings of me in their own Forms instead of Praying for me Look upon the third Consideration beginning thus How sorely and severely hath he punished those Kings Priests Prophets and People that have been false Worshippers and swerved from his holy Commandments 1 Kings 11.6 Num. 11.34 The Author's Proposition in this Consideration is as followeth God hath sorely and severely punished those Kings Priests Prophets and People that have been false Worshippers and swerved from his holy Commandments His Proofs as before Answ The Proposition is true but nothing concerns them that worship God by the Common-Prayer Book nor are the places he quotes for Proof against them that serve God that way for that the Prayers of our Church are put up to the true God we are not gone to the Abominations of this Amorites nor to the Abominations of this Author nor of his Followers the Lord keep us in the Worship we are in and of his Mercy bring them back to us To the fourth Consideration I shall say no more nor otherwise than the Author hath there said to us mutatis mutandis Let them consider whether God doth call upon any of them to offer him any such Service as theirs is and hath been And whether he may not say to them for their so doing as they have done as he did once to Judah Who hath required this at your hands Isa 1.12 Look into the fifth Consideration being this How inconsistent with the Day and Light of the Gospel is this Service God having sent his Word more fully and plainly to direct his Ministers and People and given his Spirit in a more abundant measure to help and enable them to call upon him This Consideration in the beginning of it considering what in the beginning of the Treatise the Author writes to the Composers Imposers c. of common-Common-Prayer contains manifestly in the Author's opinion this following Proposition as a truth To make use of set Forms of Prayer in the time of the Day and Light of the Gospel to put up the desires of our Hearts to God by is no way justificable 'T is plainly his opinion for he saith that this kind of Service is inconsistent with the Day and Light of the Gospel And the following part of his Consideration is in manner of a reason to confirm it for he saith that in the Day and Light of the Gospel God hath sent his Word more fully and plainly to direct his Ministers and People and given his Spirit in a more abundant measure to help and enable them to call upon him than by that way of Common or Set Forms of Prayer In the beginning of my Confutation of this Author in my justifying set Forms of Prayer as there limited and that from the practice of our Saviour in his drawing up and commanding the use of his set Form As also from the practice of David of St. Paul Timothy and others I have sufficiently overthrown this Proposition and his Argument and Reason also brought for confirmation of it considering that it was the time and day of the fullest Light and Promulgation of the Gospel and of God's enabling Men by his Spirit to call upon him that ever was since in which was the justification of set Forms of Prayer after by the forementioned Examples and Precedents Well but yet for further Answer let enquiry be made what time the Author here means by the Day and Light of the Gospel in which he says the Spirit was given in a more abundant measure to help c. For satisfaction herein It was not meant of the time of Moses David Christ John Baptist or the Apostles for as hath been shewed set Forms were consistent with those Days of Light and help of the Spirit to call upon God 'T is certain therefore that by these words in his consideration namely the Day and Light of the Gospel the Author means the times of the late Wars and horrid Rebellion the times he wrote and inveighed against the best set Form for publick Worship and Service of God that ever was extant before it namely the Common-Prayer Book before this And now as for a fuller Answer I grant that with those their Days of Light which was as great a darkness as ever was since Christ as to Spiritual things the Glorious Liturgy of our Church was inconsistent being a Worship and Service according to God's and Christ's Rule and Doctrine for that the practice of the Opposers of the Common-Prayer Book was diametrically opposite to the Day and Light of the Gospel of Christ and his Apostles and therefore could have no more Concord together than St. Paul said 2 Cor. 6.17 Christ and Belial could have which was none at all therefore it was notable policy though nothing of true
Vain-glory or of Covetousness even by the same Spirit or ends our Saviour said was in the Scribes Pharisees and Hypocrites whose Prayers were lengthned for a shew or for pretences Luke 20.47 and Matt. 23. vers 14. But let 's see what can be said for their pretended more abundant help of the Spirit in respect to their Extemporary and Unpremeditated mode of Praying To this I answer If any will go thus to God in Prayer in private but especially in publick that is without a due premeditation and consultation with himself of the mercies received he and the people are to be thankful for or of the things they stand in need of and are to beg of God 't is no less than unwarranted singularity and rash presumption in respect to authentick and Scripture Precedents and Instructions and to term it praying by the help of God's Spirit 't is no less than Blasphemy in the highest nature Let 's look into the Scriptures for the truth hereof Gen. 24. vers 63. And Isaac went out to meditate in the field Another Translation renders it he went out to pray And the reason of these differing Translations Vatablus affirms to be because the word in the original which is Suach signifies both to Meditate and to Pray so that it might have been render'd Isaac went out to Meditate and to Pray And then it commends thus much to our Practice and the present purpose First we must meditate of God's goodness to us and our wants and that done then put up our Praises and Prayers to God being by that premeditation better inabled to perform that Duty than without it A Marginal Note upon this place saith That this was the Exercise of the godly Fathers in those times to meditate of God's merciful Pronuses and then to pray for the accomplishing of them And this was the practice of David Psal 63 vers 5 6 7. My mouth shall praise thee with joyfullips look on and you shall see David will not enter upon this Duty rashly without meditation of God's help and goodness what it was this he said he would do when he had remembred him upon his bed and meditated on him in the night watches because he had been his help The resolution of the Twelve Acts the 6th vers 4. will joyn in condemnation of this their mode of praying without premeditation at least there the Twelve said we will give our selves unto prayer continually and to the ministry of the word I presume that by their resolution of giving themselves much to prayer they neither meant a constant heathenish nor pharisaical length of prayer nor at all the late 〈…〉 kind of unpremeditated supplication both which modes have been and yet are too much in use No the Twelve by giving themselves to prayer considering the practice of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in the Scriptures 〈◊〉 by the same Spirit with the Twelve it was â—eâ—…t of Composing Forms of Prayer for themselves and others to put up their Prayers by or at least of searching to know by meditation their own and others 〈◊〉 they were to take care of and then to seek up with Mâ—sâ—s David and others inabled by the same Spirit of Prayer such arguments and reasons from consideration of God's promises and properties and of Christ's undertakings and from considerations of mens wants and necessities that thereby they might put up to Godâ—… effectual and servent Prayers for themselves and those they were setover by Christ Which gloss may very well be admitted as the meaning of the twelve Apostles there considering St. Paul's direction concerning Prayer who was of the same dedication with the twelve both as to Prayer and the Ministry of the Word 1 Tim. 2. vers 1 2 3. the Apostle there directing Timothy and all other Ministers of Christ after him as to the manner of praying to God He doth not there exhort to the performing of that duty in such way as that praying in this or the fore mentioned mode or manner it should be done according to God's will His Exhortation is not that men pray for Kings and all in Authority The Original is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 I exhort that Prayers be made which word bears to be composed prepared or made ready as in a form up to God to put the desires of their hearts for all men for Kings and all in Authority that we may lead a peaceable and quiet life in all godliness and honesty 'T is confest that in the Apostles times among other miraculous gifts of the holy Ghost some had their Extemporary Effusions 1 Cor. 11.14 15. and with the 2â—th Every one of you hath a Psalm c. but the Apostle observing that this begâ—t so much Emulation Faction and confusion among them he restrained the use of those Gifts and injoyned that all things should be done decently and to that effect that they should be done 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 according to rule appointment and order vers 23. and the 40th Or again the former gloss upon the resolution of the twelve Apostles of giving themselves much to Prayer may be admitted as their meaning there considering what it was for them to give themselves to the Ministry of the Word for what is meant of giving themselves to the word is meant of giving themselves to Prayer Now the Apostles by giving themselves to the Ministry of the Word was meant their searching into the will of God their studying and meditating of the mind of Christ by comparing as St. Paul speaks spiritual things with spiritual Scripture with Scripture and by consulting one with another of the sure way of salvation as we see was their practice when the difference arose about Circumcision Acts 15. from vers 1. to the 30th Which thing is also evident from the practice of the Apostle St. Paul whose giving himself to the Ministry of the Word was doing what he commended in others 1 Tim. 5. vers 17. namely labouring in the Word and Doctrine by study and meditation of the word of God joyned to the assistance of God's spirit that was helping of him So that I see not but that that place where the twelve Apostles resolved to give themselves much to Prayer rightly expounded gives a suffrage with the practice of Isaac David and others in condemning this mode of unpremeditated praying to God And so I shall end my declamation against it with part of the second Verse of the fifth Chapter of Ecclesiastes the end whereof before with other places of Scripture gave sentence against the heathenish and pharisaical mode of Prayer Be not rash with your mouths and let not your hearts be hasty henceforth to utter any thing before God for God is in heaven and you upon earth But though I have said thus much against the two former modes of Prayer as they be used by the factious against both Scripture Precedents and Rules for Devotion yet I would have the Adversaries know that I am not so against sudden and unpremeditated Prayers or
Pretensions in appointing a Committee of Bishops for that purpose where and when Bishop Reynolds had the Chair So that indeed all that can be said as to the Book in the intention of any of the Composers thereof as concerning net or snare in respect to the Penalties made thereby to be inflicted upon the Nonconformists to it they were only made against perverse obstinate and wilful opposers of the same and so are to be clear'd from the charge of any evil intention against tender Consciences To the 11th Consideration Whether any person can produce any such Liturgy or Form of Prayer from the beginning of the World either among Jews or Gentiles c. As to the justification of Liturgies and set Forms of Prayer I have spoken at large in the beginning of this Fractate and shall therefore answer the Author's Question in this Consideration no otherwise than as our Saviour answer'd the Question put to him in the Temple Mark 11. vers 29 30. And that is by giving a Question to him and his followers to answer and it is this Whether any persons can produce any such long tautological extempory nonsensical Prayers or any such soul-destroying damning Doctrins or Sermons since the beginning of the World either among the Jews or Gentiles or any Churches of Christ till this Rebellion in Scotland and England as theirs were Let any of them answer me this Question and I will answer further to this 11th Consideration To the 12th Consideration Whether if there were no other reason but that this Book hath been so much idolizeâ— by the generality of men and offensive tâ— so many Christians it should not be done with as the brazen Serpent was by Hezekiah 2 Kings 18. vers 4. The opinion of the Author may be set forth in this Proposition The generality of men have much Idolized the Book of Common-Prayer and 't is a just offence to many Christians also Here the Author chargeth first a great evil to have been committed by most men in praying unto God and in worshipping of him in thaâ— Form of the Common-Prayer Book And that is that they have Idolized it Now to Idolize a Creature or Thing is taken several ways out of mentioning two of them is first to esteem it as their God or Saviour In this respect it may be the Author means the generality of men Idolized the Service-Book To which I answer I am confident there 's not a man will set hiâ— heart to that part of the Consideration for who can think men so ignorant as to esteem that their God or Christ to save them which is that Form whereby they go to God and Christ their Redeemer and Mediator for forgiveness of sins and salvation But then secondly To idolize any thing is inordinately to set the heart upon it trusting in it more than in God and above him in this respect Covetousness is called Idolatry Colos 3. vers 5. Thus Mr. Wilson in his Christian Dictionary But thirdly We commonly say men idolize a thing when they have a greater respect to and esteem of a thing than it deserves In this respect I presume the Author means most men did idolize the Service-Book which he thinks sufficiently manifested by their so constant and frequent Worshipping and Invocating of God thereby To which I answer Considering the Counsel or rather the Command of God as to the frequent performance of this Duty of Prayer and Thanksgiving by St. Paul 1 Thess 5. ver 17 18. where he bids us Pray without ceasing and in every thing give thanks because 't is the will of God in Christ Jesus Considering that I say King Charles the first of most blessed memory in his Observations upon the Ordinance against the Common Prayer Book doth fully make void the Author's fore-mentioned Charge and Reason alledged for defence of it in the Eighth and Ninth Paragraphs The King's words I could never see any reason why any Christian should abhor or be forbidden to use the same Form of Prayer since he prays to the same God believes in the same Saviour professeth the same truths reads the same Scriptures hath the same Duties upon him and feels the same daily wants for the most part both inward and outward which are common to the whole Church Sure we may as well before hand know whâ—â— we pray as to whom we pray and in what words as to what sense when we desire the same things what hinders we may not use the same words our appetite and digestion too may be good when we use as we pray for our daily bread Now considering all this where is any cause for taking away this Book of Common-Prayer from the people as the brazen Serpent from them of Israel and Judah But 't is no marvel that the Author and his Followers charge men with Idolizing this Book in offering in Publick unto God their Prayers and Thanksgivings thereby according to the Order and Authority of the Church when I have heard them charge men with idolizing the Lord's Prayer using it but according to the Command of Jesus Christ himself that is in the several Services and Prayers of the Church fitted and appointed to be used upon several occasions before Mattens or Even song be over whereof by especial command of Christ the Lord's Prayer is to be part Luke 11. vers 2. When I consider the impudent Charge I my self heard from one of the Author 's chief fellow Chaplains against some of the Petitions of the Lord's Prayer in condemning one of them in the Pulpit unlawful as to the matter and another not fit to be used by most Hugh Peters at Norwich said of that Petition thy will be done c. What said he pray for an impossible thing and condemning another Petition said See what the Petitions are of that you call the Lord's Prayer as also when I consider the total neglect of our Lord's Prayer in these mens Devotions drawn up by Christ for a Form of Prayer as well as for an help to compose our own Prayers by I say when I consider these things then what David said seeing the transgressions of the wicked of his heart I say of mine namely thus I have said in my heart that they say in their hearts though not in right down words that Christ in Composing and Commanding that Prayer to be said as oft as men pray is accessary to a very great and general guiltiness of Idolatry in this last respect at least Or if they should not own this yet I am sure the total neglect of using it in their Devotions prove plainly they look upon it as a Prayer unworthy to be used which is no less than in their hearts to blaspheme the Saviour of the World But then further he saith the Book was offensive to many Christians He doth not say it was offensive to the Brethren or the weak Brethren as is usually the Phrase in the Scriptures in such cases as this here of the Author And