Exod. 16. 23. was a permission not a command or for preparation onely not for eating the day following Yea they not only might fast but did it usually at lest to the twelft houre as Hooker proveth by testimonies out of Josephus Justinus Suctonius Balsam upon the 66. Canon called the Apostles saith Wee fast not upon the sabbath 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 lest wee should seeme to imitate the Jewes Augustine saith God spake nothing concerning dining or fasting upon the sabbath when he sanctified the seventh day nor afterward when hee gave precepts concerning it to his people Of these differences the reader may finde more in Altare Damascenum page 667 668 669. The Jewish sabbath which was the seventh day from the creation was abolished at the resurrection of Christ because it had types and ceremonies annexed to it which were shadowes of things to come The ground ceasing the observation of that day ceased also for the shadowes flee away when the body commeth in place Yea further I will yeeld that the abrogation was meant by the Apostle Coloss. 2. 17. and under the name of sabbath there is to bee meant onely the weekly sabbath which is more then White craveth Not that I thinke they answer sufficiently to those who will have the word to be applied to the first and last day of anniversary feasts which were also called sabbaths But because I thinke these to bee comprehended under the name of feasts whereof these sabbaths were the principall and most solemne dayes So that here is a perfite division of all their solemne dayes to wit that they were either feasts to wit anniversarie dayes or new moones which returned monethly or the sabbath which returned weekly I so thinke the rather because we have the like division 1 Chron. 23. 31. where the Levits office is set downe to offer burnt sacrifices unto the Lord in the sabbaths in the new moones and on the set feasts And againe in Esay 1. 13 14. wee have the like As for that that the word Sabbath is in the plurall number it crosseth not this sense for so is the weekly sabbath usually expressed by the Greek translaters of the old testament and in the new testament also Matth. 12. 1 5 10 11 12. Matth. 2â— 1. Mark 1. 12. Mark 2. 23 24. Mark 3. 2 4. Luk. 4. 31. Luke 6. 9. Luke 13. 10. Act. 13. 14. Act. 16. 13. In these places the word is taken either for one sabbath-day onely or for moe And so it may bee taken in this place Coloss. 2. and translated either sabbath or as the late english translation hath sabbath dayes The sabbath-day is expressed in the plurall number for the frequent and often returning By the way observe that the old sabbath was not reckoned among the Jewish festivall dayes Sâ—atiger saith Manifestò sabbata distinguuntur to wit Esay 1. 13 14. à magnis diebus The sabbaths are â—early dâ—stinguished from the great dayes which were all one with Chaggim The Iewish sabbath then seeing it shadowed things to come behoved to bee abolished Suppose it had not beene a shadow yet even as it was but a circumstantiall point of the fourth precept which is morall positive it might have beene changed for a greater reason then was the occasion of the choice of the former For the resurrection of Christ and beginning of his triumph after he had ended his course of humiliation was a greater reason for making choice of the first day of the weeke then resting from the worke of creation was for the seventh day before The first respect of necessitie required abolition The 〈…〉 congruity The first day of the weeke succeeded in the roome of the last day of the weeke and hath beene observed in the Christian Church from her infancie to this day without any change or contradiction The Apostles were conveened together that day when the holy Ghost descended upon them Act. 2. When Paul had stayed at Troas seven dayes upon the first day of the weeke being the seventh day of his abode the disciples conveened together to break-bread and Paul preached and conferred with them till break of day Act. 20. 7. 11. The originall hath upon one of the sabbath but sabbath is put for weeke because from the sabbath as the principall day they numbred the rest of the dayes of the weeke to the next sabbath in order first second third fourth c. of the sabbath and distinguished them not by the names of the planets As when the pharisie said I fast twice in the sabbath that is twice in the weeke Luke 18. 12. When Jesus was risen early the first day of the sabbath that is of the weeke Mark 16. 9. And Levit 23. 15. seven sabbaths shall bee compleat that is seven weekes Likewise one according to the forme of speach familiar to the Hebrewes is taken for first The evening and morning were one day that is the first day This place cannot bee trâ—â—slated one of the sabbaths for the Apostle stayed but seven dayes in which there was but one sabbath day Nor yet is it likely that the Christians did assemble upon the Iewish sabbath to their exercises Howbeit the Apostle went in to their synagogue Act. 13. upon their sabbath that was not for the observation of their sabbath but because hee could not finde the Iewes assembled together at any other time or place that hee might have occasion to winne them as yee may see at that time hee found occasion to deliver a word of exhortation Wee have the first day of the weeke expressed with the like phrase 1 Corin. 16. 2. where the Corinthians are directed to lay aside some thing for the poore the first day of the sabbath that is of the weeke or every first day of the weeke Now although this text of S. Paul maketh no expresse mention of Church assemblies this day yet because it was the custome of Christians And likewise it is a thing convâ—nient to give almes upon the church-dayes it cannot wâ—ll hee gainsaid but that if in Corinth and Galatia the first day of evâ—ry weeke was appointed to be a day for almes and charitable contributions the same was also the Christians weekly holy day for their religious assemblies saith White and to this purpose citeth Chrysostome in 1 Corin. hom 43. where he sheweth that the time was fit for collections because that day they had receaved many great benefites and the first of the sabbath hee interpreteth the Lords day So do the translations of the Bible expound both the former and this place of the first day of the week the Belgike the French the Italian the Spanish the late English Beza's and Tremellius out of the Syriack With frivolous cavillâ—tion doe some few to their great discredite preasse to another sense which is to the full overthrowne by Walâ—eâ—s and Amesius This first day of the weeke Revel 1. 10. is called not the day of the Lord as sometime in
that purpose which is called the feast of the resurrection Sâ—â—rez having reckoned the many prerogatives of the Lords day as that Christ rose that day the holy Ghost descended upon the Apostles c. hee willeth us to observe that howbeit all these prerogatives might have beene considered in the determination of the day yet the day of it selfe and directly was not instituted for the peculiar commemoration of these â—â—rkes of God but to worship God for himselfe and his owne exellencie Nihilominus per se ac directè non referri vel istitui hunc diem ad peculiaerem commemorationem illorum operum Dei sed ad Deumipsum propter se colendum propter suam excellentiam majestatem It wee had no dayes but festivall for some particular benefits we should have no day for the worship of God in generall The Lords day therefore may justly bee called the schoole-day of Christians as Petrus Ramus calleth it Thirdly as the sabbath of old was distinguished from the yearly feast which were called good that is merrie dayes so is the Lords day from the yearly feasts invented afterwards by men Vpon the anniversarie feasts called good dayes they might not fast as yee have heard before Mirth and mourning could not stand together But upon the sabbath they might lawfully fast Ne quando sanctificaâ—it De is diem septimum quia in illo requievit ab omnibus operibus suis aliquid de jejunio vel prandio expressit nec cum postea populo Hebraâ— de ipsius dici observatione mandavit aliquid de alimentis sumendis vel non sumendis locutus saith Augustâ—ne that is God enjoyned nothing concerning fasting or eating either the first time that he sanctified the seventh day or afterward when he gave the manna The Lords day succeeding in the roome of the old sabbath as it standeth in the decalogue is of the same qualitie Wee may lawfully fast upon the Lords day which were absurd to d ee upon our anniversarie feast dayes It is true that in the ancient Church it was thought a hainous thing to fast upon the Lords day So did they also forbid to pray kneeling that day to signifie their joy for Christs resurrection This use of signification or testification was the fountaine of much superstition and brought in a heap of ceremonies some of which the Papists themselves were â—shamed of long since The same ceremonie of not kneeling in time of prayer upon the Lords day is worne out of use nigh 500 yeares since saiâ—h Bellarmine If the reason of the institution had beene solide it should become us no lesse then them to pray standing upon the Lords day But the ground was naught The like may bee said of not fasting upon the Lords day Some reason they had indeed not to fast upon this day when the Manichees and Priscillianists fasted for the Manichees fasted ordinarily upon the Lords day lest they should seeme to rejoyce for the resurrection of Christ which they beâ—eeved not The Priscillianists fasted likewise ordinarily upon the Lords day and the nativitie day But when there are no knowne Manichees nor Priscillianists there is not the like reason for not fasting But the extremities should be avoided To thinke it unlawfull to fast that day or unlawfull to dine and breake our fast are both without warrant and superstitious But to fast upon occasion or in time of any imminent judgement is lawfull When Paul continued preaching upon the sabbath till midnight at Troas before the tasted any thing or the rest were refreshed with meat this conceat of not fasting upon the Lords day had not entred in the Church Was Paul a Manichaean saith Hierome because hee and those who were with him fasted on the Lords day His words are extant in Gratians decree Atqui utinam omni tempore jejunare possimus quod in Actibus Apostolorum diebus Pentecostes die dominico Apostolum Paictum cum eo credentes fecisse legimus Non tamen Manicheae haereseos accusandit sunt If any had resolved to fast seven dayes or moe he might have fasted upon the Lords day included as ye may see in Balsamo and Zonaras upon the constitutions falsly called apostolicall and Augustine epist. 86. ad Casulanum Whitaker defending the occasionall fasâ—s of our Church telleth Duraeus that the respects the ancients had concerne not us Etsi illîs temporibus die dominica jejunare nefas fuit propter haerelices Judaeos qui Christi resurrectionem impugnabant jam dudum tamen illa offensio nullum in ecclesia locum habet ut planè nugatorum sit quod tu de nostris in Anglia Scotia◠〈◊〉 calumniaris quasi eò spectent ut his cuniculis resurâ—â—ctiâ—â—â— fidem evertamus In a pronounciall synod holden at Dort anno 1574 it was ordained that there bee three sermons on the Lords day when a fast is to be keeped on â— It is to observe a day to say the morne is the Loâ—ds day therefore it is unlawfull to fast saith Chamter Alstedius Jejunandum etiam die dominica si necessitas flagitet What need I multiply testimonies that is sufficient which Augustine saith What dayes wee ought to fast and what not I finde it not defined by any precept given by our Lord or any of the Apostles Quibus diebus non oporteat jejunare quibus oporteat praecepto Domini vel Apostolorum non havenio definitum epist. 86. But if the Lords day were a festivall day it should follow that we should not not fast on it at all Now we proceed in our reasons against festivall dayes THE II. REASON NOne appointed holy festivities under the laws when the times were more ceremonious but God himselfe The dayes of Purim were called simply the dayes of Purim not the holy dayes of Purim They were not called Chaggimâ— No peculiar sacrifice was appointed nor any holy convocation of the people enjoyned The ordinance required but feasting and joy and sending of portions to other The rest mentioned Esther 9. was onely from their enemies So much worke as might stand with a feasting day was not forbidden Suppose they had rested altogether from worke that would only prove an idle day but not an holy day Our Doctour therefore hath no warrant to say that they were made holy dayes by Mordecay Afterward it 〈◊〉 true whâ—n the Jews become more superstitious they read the book of Estheâ— after the reading whereof they spâ—nt the rest of the day in revelling and riotousnesse Next these dayes were instituted by Mordecai and therefore were called Mordecai's dayes 2 Maccahab last chap. vers 37. Sixtus Senensis saith he is thought to be the penman of the booke of Esther he was one of the 120. of which the great synagogue consisted of which number were Zacharie Daniel Ezra and Malachie Whitaker thinketh Mordecai did this God inspiring him or perhaps by the advice or warrant of some Prophet and doubteth not
import this gesture because I will have occasion to treat of them in the second part Only let it be observed that the occasionall circumstances of the first supper were not followed as the gesture was but upon speciall occasion By the practise of the Apostles wee see the time was indifferent Act. 2. and 20. Neque Apostoli ad tempus vespertixum sese adstrinxerunt sedipro oâ— asione coenam administraruâ—t alià s dâ—urno tempore 〈◊〉 legeâ—e est Act. 2. 46. alià s intempesta nocte ut Act. 20. quo pacto satis ostenderunt tempus câ—enae esse indiâ—â—eâ—ens As for the denomination of supper it doth not import that we should celebrat ever at night It is true in our language this word Supper signifieth only the evening meal but the originall word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 signifieth indefinitly the repast that a man takeâ—h any time of the day The proper Greek word for a supper is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 I referre the Reader for further clearing of this point to Câ—saubon his exercitations The like may be said of the number the sex the parlour the manner of sitting c. They were not continued by the Apostolical Churches as sitting was which was also continued at some times and in some places in the ages following CHAP. III. That sitting in the act of receaving hath continued to our times HOwbeit the supper of the Lord soone after the Apostles dayes began to bee stained with some rust as M. Calvine observeth yet was this gesture of sitting continued at some times namely upon the Thursday which is now called Maundie thursday the day of the Lords supper because upon that day the Lords supper was fâ—rst celebrate and institute Mornaeus reporteth that in the monasteries of S. Bennet they have no other forme of Masse for three dayes before Easter but this following The Abbot sanctifieth the bread and the wine and the Monks do communicate sitting receaving the elements out of the Abbots hand and this forme is by them called Mandatum the commandement But Bullinger more plainlie that not only in the monasteries of the Benedictines but also in the cathedrall kirks upon this day the tables are set in order they sit downe break bread and reach the cup every one to other every man following the footsteps of the ancient supper Vnde nimirum ritus ille ad nos dâ—manavit quo vel hodie incathedralibus ecclestis in Monasteriis Benedict â—orum â—n die coenae Domini ante parasceuen Coeâ—â—a Doâ—iâ—â— palam splendidius celebratur Nam Evangelium Iohannis à diacono publice praelegitun dulcissima câ—llo â—uia Christ 〈◊〉 abiturus cum discipulis habuit recitaâ—â—ur iâ—terim or 〈◊〉 disposi is mensis convivae assident panem azymum frangen es calioem invicem propinantes in toâ—um veteris coenae vestigium praeferentes Now it was the custome of old not onlie for the Monks but also other Christians to communicate upon this day except offenders as appeareth evidently in Gratians decree And therefore the glosse both old and new upon that place hath these words Sic olim modo non sic est sed Monachi faciunt that is It was so of old that the faithfull did communicate but it is not so now only the Monks doe it Augustine epist. 18. ad Ianuarium reporteth that in his time the custome was in many kirks to communicate after supper upon Thursday And whereas there is sundrie Canons for communicating fasting yet that anniversarie Thursday was excepted as yee may see in Concâ—l Carthag 3. can 31. Ne Sacramenta altaris nâ—si a jejunis hominibus celebrentur excepto uno die annâ—versario quo coena Domini celebratur What the Monks of S. Bennets order retained wee may verie well judge it to have beene the auncient forme of celebration upon that day For no doubt in that other Christians celebrated after meat which they needed not they neglected not sitting and distributing The two thousand souldiers who were reconciled to the Emperour Mauritius about the year 590. by the travell of Gregorius Bishop of Antioch receaved the Sacrament sitting upon the ground as Euagrius reporteth Doctor Lindsay alledgeth the like done to the Scottish armie at Bannockburn in the dayes of King Robert Bruce But beside this day which was called Coena Domini that all the faithfull did communicate wee finde that at other times also the people communicated in sundrie places immediatly after meat as Socrates reporteth of the Aegyptâ—ans who dwelt neere to Alâ—xandrâ—a and the inhabitants of Thebais Nam ubiepulati sunt varâ—is cibariis se saturâ—runt sub vesperam oblatione fact a mysteriis communicant Niâ—ephorus reporteth the same Balsamo upon the 90 〈◊〉 of Concilium Trullanum saith the devoter sort upon Saturday at midnight fate in the kirk and communicate Alexander de Holes in the second part of his tractat concerning the Masse sayeth The Pope communicateth sitting in remembrance that the Apostles at the last supper communicated sitting Si quaeratur quare Dominus Papa sed endo communicat Potest dici quod hoc fit in recordationâ—m quod â—eatus Petrus alii Apostoli sedendo corpus Domini in coena ultima acceperunt The Waldensâ—s who are justly called the pure seed of the auncient kirk and have continued since the dayes of Pope Silvester some think from the dayes of the Apostles saith Rainerius the Inquisitor and their enemie celebrated the Communion sitting Concernâ—ng the supper of the Lord their faith was that it was ordaâ—nâ—d to be eaten and not to bee shewed or worshipped for a memoriall not for a sacrifice to serve for the present ministration and not for reservation to be received at table and not to be carried out of doores according to the use of the primitive Church when they used to communicat sitting and this they prove by an old Chronicle called Chronica gestorum saith Master Fox in his acts and monuments His warrant I finde in their apologie against one Doctour Augustine which is extant in Lydii Waldensia Existo manifestum est quod primitiva ecclesia hane fidem habuit illam confessa est non fecit reverentiam huâ—c sacramento quia illo tempore exemplo Christi sedentes statim acceperunt nihil retinuerunt nec extra domum extulerunt haec institutio diâ—stetit sicut Chronica gestorum estendunt The like they have in the confession of their faith sent to Vladiflaus king of Hungarie Namque discipulis Christus discumbentibus dedie utendum Luther expounding the epistle upon Saint Stephens day saith Christ so instituted the sacrament that in it wee should sit at the sacrament But all things are changed and the idle ordinances of men are come in place of divine ordinances Zwinglius setting downe the forme of câ—lebration used at Berne Zurick Basile and other neighbour townes saith Sedentes tacite auscultantes
second fall But that specification of persons bound to 〈◊〉 worke was not a ceremonie but a needfull 〈◊〉 in respect of the time The reason in the precept is morall and the end of the cessation and rest is morall to wit to sanctifie and keepe holy the sabbath-day To sanctifie is taken in a generall notion and without reference to ceremoniall exercises or legall more then evangelicall The legâ—ll offices were commanded by other lawes which were positive But White to prove that the word sanctifie is taken in a particular notion alledgeth Deut. 5. 12. Remember to sanctifie the sabbath-day as the Lord thy God â—ath commanded thee This maketh nothing to the purpose for the word sanctifie may be still taken in a generall notion to sanctifie the sabbath as the Lord commanded before at the deliverie of the law Suppoâ—e the word were to be taken in a particular notion in that place Moses applying it as an interpreter and expounder to that present time it followeth not that it was so taken at the promulgation and engraving in â—ables of stone for at that time there was no sacrifices appoâ—â—ed for the sabbath but afterward Numb 28. and sâ—â—â—ing on the shew-bread Levit. 24. But these things were ceremoniall belonged onely to the priests and not to all and every one of the people and were commanded afterward So was the precept of kindly fire which was but temporall and that the sabbath be observed as a memoriall of their deliverie out of Egypt Deut. 5. 15. which saith Master Ainsworth seemeth to have fallen forth upon the sabbath day To be a signâ— that the Lord did sanctifie them was also set downe afterward as one of the ends of the observation Exod. 31. but yet that was not to be signum obsigâ—â—ns a sealing ligne or sacrament but onely a declarative sigâ—â— or indicant or document that God was the santifier of his people or an argument as others call it or a publick note and signe of their profession to distinguish betweene the observers of the sabbath as a holy and sanctified people from others But this may bee common to Iewes and Christians The mutabilatie of the seventh day from the creation maketh it not ceremoniall for a thing may bee mutable and not ceremoniall To appoint the seventh day to bee observed and sanctified is not a ceremonie unlesse the word ceremonie be abused and taken more largely then for a thing significant or typicall It is properly but a politick order determining a time for the worship of God To bee a memoriall of the creation and Gods rest the seventh day followed indeed upon the observation of that day but was not the only nor principall end of the institution for then that should have beene the chiefe or onely exercise on that day to contemplate and meditate upon the creatures God propoundeth his worke of creation and resting the seventh day not as the onely subject to bee mused upon but as an example for the observation of a seventh day sabbath Howbeit of the setting of that seventh day from the creation the prerogative it had to bee the day of Gods rest from the worke of creation and therefore made choise of yet perse directè of it selfe and directly as Suarez speaketh it was not appointed for commemoration of such a worke but to worship God for himselfe for his owne majestie and excellencie To end this point wee must not confound precepts concerning obâ—ervancies and ceremonies with morall The ceremonials are only appendicles and have their owne positive lawes for their ground If because there be some ceremoniall precepts concerning the sabbath delivered afterward or apart from the promulgation of the decaloguâ— the fourth precept shall be holden partly morall partly ceremoniall by that reason other precepts also of the decalogue shall bee partly morall partly ceremoniall for both the ceremoniall and judiciall law saith Master Dow have in them something which is juris moralis and so farre forth are contained under the morall precepts Swarez likewise saith Nihilominus tamen in illis ceremoniis seu observant iâ—s sunt quaedum rationes generales que secundum se pertinent ad moralem rationam virâ—utum uâ— de se abitrâ—hunt à particulari significatione ritu veteris legis In a word there is nothing ceremoniall in the fourth precept no positive worship either legall or evangelicall enjoyned but only sanctification in generall without determination either of the one or other no type or signification of things to come expressed yea or intended saith Swarez but only the institution it selfe renewed with accommodation to the state of man after his fall of which I made mention a little before All the determination which is added over the naturall and morall obligation to se apart a time to holy exercises is divine positive not ceremoniall or typicall for divine postive is more generall and comprehendeth also other lawes imposed by God for order and policie in his Church Howbeit wee 〈…〉 distinguish betwixt in the fourth preâ—ept concerning the sabbath and the sabbath as it was observed by the people of God upon the imposition of more precepts concerning ceremonies and observances yet even in their observation wee may observe some markes whereby it might be discerned from their anniversarie feasts and to bee ordained prâ—marly for a morall use The sabbath was observed every where throughout the land and abroad where they remained in the wildernesse in the places of their captivity and dispersion The ceremoniall feasts on 〈◊〉 Iâ—rusalem whither Iews and proseâ—iâ—s resorted from all countries as at the Pentecost when the firle tongues were sent downe and whereat the Apostle Paul hastened to bee present Next the ceremoniall feasts had some sâ—crifices and ceremonies appropriate unto them which might not bee used at other times The sabbath had only the doubling of the daily sacrifice at the appointed place beside the ordinarie exercises throughout the land Thirdly the sabbaths of anniversarie feasts were transfeâ—red to the ordinarie or weekly sabbath if it was to follow immediatly because the dead corps and meat prepared specially of herbs could not be preserved without spilling or putrifying specially in those hote countries Non facimus inquâ—â—â— duo contin a sabbatha propter olera propâ—et mortuos 〈…〉 restraineth this custome to the store moneth Tâ—â—ri But the ordinarie or weekly sabbath was not drawne to the sabbaths of these anniversarie feasts Fourthly at the anniversarie feasts they might not fast they were dayes of joy and festivity which â—orreth not with mourning of fâ—sting See Nehem. 8. 10. Exod. 12. 14. Num. 29. 15. And therefore these dayes were called Chaggim which is derived from a word signifying wheeling about leaping or dancing The most solemne day of these feasts was called jom tob a good or merrie day The ordinarie sabbath-day was not called jom tob See Casaubonus nor yet Chag They were not forbidden to fâ—st yet they might fast That injunction
then to designe a place for the congregation to meet in but a matter belonging to order But there was more required to this day For it was not instituted only for order and policie that the people might know what dayes to conveene to publike exercises howbeit it was one respect Times may bee appointed for preaching and prayer on the weeke dayes by any particular Church But there is more required here a day to be obseved holy by the universall Church not only for publike worship but also for privat not onely for externall but also for internall which could not be done but by divine authoritie which is supreme and onely able to binde the conscience to internall as well as externall to privat as well as to publick worship as I have said before The last point which I am to touch is concerning the strictnesse of the observation Whither we be bound to as strict observation of the Lords day as the Jewes were of their sabbath The superstitious observation of the Iewes wee are not bound unto For they observed that day more precisely then God required They found fault with Christ healing of the sicke man upon the sabbath and the sicke mans carrying home of his bed They have had and have many foolish observations as not to pull to an herb on the sabbath nor to eat an aple which they pluck upon that day nor claw with their nailes in publike nor catch a flea unlesse it bite Let us then see what God hath forbidden them They were bidden â—ake that which they had to bake upon the sixt day and seeth that they had to seeth Exod. 16. 23. and forbidden to kindle a fire upon the seventh day But that which was baken and seethed upon the sixt day a part of it was not reserved to the seventh day but that which remained over unbaken and unsodden The text importeth no further for if it had beene baken or sodden they would perhaps have attributed the not putrifying upon the seventh day to the baking or seething It was food that might bee eaten without baking like comfites or fruit It seemeth then this injunction was given onely during the time the manna rained If this direction had beene to bee observed afterward they might not have eaten any thing which was baken two dayes before Is it likely that Christ and others bidden to the Pharisees house upon the sabbath-day had no meat dressed for them by baking of seething The kindling of fire was forbidden not simply but for baking or seething the manna as some thinke and therefore endured onely so long as the manna lasted howbeit the most superstitious sort of the Jewes in later times observed it It is noted of the Essens a strict sect of the Jewes as singular in them that they kindled no fire upon the sabbath-day They were commanded Exod. 16. 29. to abide every man in his place and not to goe out of their tents at lest out of the campe This was but temporarie Afterward they might take journey upon the sabbath to the Prophets or synagogues 2 King 4. 23. Levit 23. 3. Yea if they were not to journey for that the Scribes prescrived to them 2000 cubits that is a mile or thereabouts out of a towne or citie which was called the sabbath-dayes-journey But afterward they became more superstitious not taking up the Lords intent in that place of Exodus as the Jew that would not be drawne out of the jackes wherein he had fallen upon the sabbath-day So howbeit the Iewes should be superstitious now in not kindling fire that is no warrant that the direction was not â—â—â—oratie Some thinke this prohibition served onely during the workmanship of the tabernacle But let it bee granted that both the one direction and the other were to endure during the policie of the Iewes I denie that they were forbidden by vertue of the fourth precept of the decalogue They would and might have kindled fire notwithstanding of the fourth precept Their rest upon the sabbath was ceremoniall and figurative And because ceremoniall and figurative therefore saith Bellarmine and Dow after him with others it behoved to be more strict exact and rigid For the more exact the figure is the better it representeth and signifieth So granting that dressing and preparing of meat by fire were not a temporarie precept during the manna yet it depended upon the ceremoniall rest and typicall state of Gods people under the law They abstained from the buriall of the dead upon the sabbath-day 2 Maccab. 12. 39. because if any touched the dead or entred into the house where the dead lay or touched a grave was uncleane seven dayes Numb 19. 14. 16. and consequently they might not enter into the tabernacle Here a duty forbidden for legall uncleannesse which bindeth not us The prophanation of the sabbath was a capitall crime Exod. 31. 14. but this law bindeth not us The workes depending upon the ceremoniall rest or any particular ceremonie bindeth not us but only the workes inhibited in the fourth precept wherein the ceremoniall and iudicall precepts are not included but onely annexed to them as peculiar unto that people which was under the tutorie and paedagogie of the law Aquinas saith that the ceremoniall and judiciall precepts are not contained in the decalogue Ad secundum dicendum quod judicialia praecepta sunt determinationes moralium praeceptorum prout ordinantur ad proximum sicut ceremonialia sunt quaedam determinationes praceptorum moralium prout ordinatur ad Deum unde neutra praecepta continentur in daecalogo If then these workes were not forbidden by vertue of the fourth precept we are not bound to for beare them If our observation of the Lords day praefigure that blessed and glorious life which we expect as some doe hold then our rest should be also as exact and rigid because figurative Dominicus dies qui Christi resurrectione sâ—â—xatâ—â—e â— â—e ernam requiem spiritus corporis praefigurat saith Augustine But wee will not build strictnesse of rest upon such a weake ground It may bee fill drawne to resemble heavenly and spirituall things but that is not any end of the institution It is not â—â—puâ—destinatuâ— instituted for any shadow or signification though â—t may befitly applied unto such an use saith Willet Our rest upon the Christian sabbath is only subservient to the sanctifying of the day The strictnesse required of old by the vertue of the fourth precept is required of us As Whit maketh sunday an holy day only by the ordinance of the Church pag. 109. 150. so the particular forme and circumstances of resting are prescribed unto us saith hee by the Church pag. 135. meaning the Church governours the prelates So doth Bellarmine allow such workes as shall be permitted by the prelats or have beene used by long custome Tertiopera concessa à pralatis Quartò opera quae ex consuetudine sunt licita Our holy fathers the prelats paternes
be observed as holy Ratio convenientiae non fuisset sufficiens nisi praecessisset mandatum divinum Rivetus in Decalogum pag. 167. Christs actions did no more consecrate the times wherein they were wrought then his body did the manger or the crosse by touch And suppose this might have beene it would not follow that all mangers and crosses are consecrated no more would it follow that every 25. day of December should bee consecrated and made holy because that whereon he was borne I put the case it were true was consecrated Verum etiam non est dies illos fuisse consecratos per actiones aut passiones quae talibus diebus acciderunt Idenim si verum esset nullus fuisset dies qui aliqua Christi actione non esset nobilitatus consecratus Rivetus in Decalogum pag. 204. As for remembring of Christs nativitie no man denieth but it is needfull and so it is wheresoever the Gospel is preached But we deny that the memorie of it must be celebrated with the solemnitie of a festivall holy day with cessation from worke with feasting or forbearance of fasting and a proper service THE V. REASON SUppose the observing of holy dayes had at the first beene a matter indifferent yet seeing they have beene abused and polluted with superstition they ought to bee abolished Upon this ground Zâ—nchâ— us inferreth Non ma è igitur f'cerunt qui omnia proâ—er diem dom nicum aboleverunt They have therefore not done amâ—sse who have abolished all other holy dayes but the Lords day If Ezekias fact in breaking the brazen sâ—rpent belandable by which he confirmeth that pule then their fact is laudable also But sure it is that in former ages holy dayes have not onely beene abused with prophane and licentious revelling and surfetting but also polluted with the opinion of worship merite necessitie and a judaicall conceat that the devill is not so bold to tempt men on these dayes as at other times And therefore saith Zanchius Magicians observe holy dayes to exercise their magâ—call feats with the greater efficacie The Lords day it selfe may bee abused but because the observation is necessarie in respect of divine institution it cannot bee removed for the abuses of men But the festivall dayes were not appointed by God The number the abuses the will-worships of feasts so increased that there is nothing so unsavourie to God so pernicious to men as to sanctifie such and so many dayes faith the same Zanchius Holy dayes devised for the honour of Christ drew on holy dayes to saints Easter brought on a superstâ—tions lent to attend upon it made baptisme wait for her moone conformed our Lords supper unto the Jewish passeover in unleavened bread It was the first aple of contention among Christians the first weapon wherewith the bishop of Rome played his prâ—ses against other Churches and after flew so many Britons with by Austin the Monke saith Doctour Ames Even in Chrysostomes time the people would forbeare to communicate at other times But at Easter they would communicate howbeit they had committed recently some hainous sinne whereupon he exclameth O consuetudinem o presumptionem O custome O presumption Because people ranne superstitiously to that holy action at Easter as if the time gave vertue to the sacrament and were carelesâ—e the rest of the yeare our reformers appointed other times free of superstition as ye may see in the first booke of discipline pag. 58 59. Therefore seeing the observation of festivall dayes is not commanded by God and it cannot be denyed but it hath beene much abused it ought not to be continued farre lesse introduced where it hath beene disused suppose it might be now used without these abuses because it may degener after the same manner as before But what if it be not nor cannot be free of abuse and superstition They say they esteeme them not holier then other dayes or place any worship of God in the observation of them but only keep them for order and policie that the people may be assembled to religious exercises and instructed in the mysteries of religion But that is false howbeit an old shift The Papists themselves confesse that one day is not holier then another in the owne nature no not the Lords day but in respect of the use and end And in this respect our Formalists esteeme their festivall dayes holier then other dayes call them holy dayes and maintaine as yee have heard before that they may be observed as holy dayes If the observing of a day holy for the honour of a saint be a worshipping of the saint the observing of a day to the honour of Christ cannot bee without opinion of worship If the observing of the Lords day as a festivall as it is in their accompt be worship the observing of their holy dayes is worship Whereas they alledge that it is not worship because they hold not the like necessitie in observing the one as the other it will not helpe them For that doth not alter the nature of worship but maketh the one necessarie because God instituted it the other arbitrarie and voluntarie and consequently will-worship The same matter forme and end is in both but God instituteâ—h the one and therefore lawfull the other is instituted at the pleasure of man so it is worship but a vicious worship Further some other Formalists have of late maintained the mutabilitie of the Lords day it selfe What our Doctour will doe now let any man judge who knoweth him to be temporizâ—r and a sceptike Master Dow p. 58. saith as other holy dayes it goeth paripassu in their canons and ancient statutes which require the same observances under the same penalty Thâ—y are not only holy dayes but also mysticall howbeit the Doctour denieth it For els he must disclaime his ancienâ—s who call them so Are they not appointed for the solemnitle of some mysterie of religion Doe they not carrie the names of Christs nativitie passion ascension c. Are they not ordered according to the knowne or supposed times when such things fell forth If it were for order and policie they were observed that the people may assemble and be instructed wherefore is there but one day betweene the passion and the resurrection fourty betwixt the resurrection and ascension and then againe but ten betwixt the ascension and whitsontide Wherefore follow wee the course of the moone in our moveable feasts and observe not a certaine day in the moneth as we doe for other If we observed dayes only for order and policie then wee would not sticke to dayes as we doe for the commemoration of Christs nativitie passion ascension c. The Doctour saith we do not observe festivall dayes as the Jewes did which were holy not only for the use whereunto they were appointed to serve as circumstances but by reason also of their mystik signification and of the worship appropriated to them which might not bee performed at