shew in those wordes I answere it is to be said that one thing may be said to be before another two waies Tho. Aq. 22. q. 4. ar 7. one way of it selfe another way by accident and of it selfe faith is the first of all other vertues for as in things agible and to be done the end is the beginning as is abouesaid it is behoofefull that the Theologicall vertues which haue the last end for their obiect be the first and take place of other vertues and for the last end it selfe it is behoofefull that first it be in the vnderstanding then in the will because the will is not carried vpon any thing but as it is apprehended in the vnderstanding therefore for that the last end is in the will by hope and charitie and in the vnderstanding by faith Tho. Aqu. 12. q. 34. art 4. ad princip art q. 13. art 3. it is behoofefull that faith be the first of all vertues because naturall vnderstanding cannot reach vnto God as he is the obiect of blisse in which sort hope and charitie aymeth vnto him yet accidentally another vertue may be before faith for the cause which is accidentally is accidentally the first Now to remoue the impediment appertaineth to that cause which is accidentally as it is manifest by the Philosopher accordingly Aristoteles in 8. Phisuli 8. text 32. to 2. whereunto some vertues may bee said accidentally to be before faith in how much they remoue the impediments of beleeuing as fortitude remoueth inordinate feare hindering faith humilitie pride by which the vnderstanding refuseth to submit it selfe to the truth of faith and the same may be said of some other vertues although they be not truly vertues vnlesse faith be presupposed Augustin contra Iouinianum l. 4. cap. 3 tom 7. as it appeareth by Saint Augustine in his booke against Iouinian Hence it appeareth by this Doctor that if faith be wanting no Christian can haue that reuealed knowledge which necessarily for his saluation hee is bound to haue and therefore I incessantly laboured to finde out the assurednesse of this faith and the more that I thought how I might finde out this faith so necessarie to saluation it pleased God to suffer me to proceede in my search for some infallible rule by which I might measure without danger of mistaking the true faith of Christ and thereby be most comfortably led as with the fierie pillar like the Israelites by night through the wildernesse of this world Exo. 13. vers 22. vnto the most desired land of euerlasting happinesse and securitie where that promise of God made by the mouth of his Prophet may be verified of vs Esay 32. vers 18 My people shall dwell in a peaceable habitation and in sure dwellings and in quiet resting places CHAP. VI. Containing the fourth fundamentall obseruation about the rule and straight mete-wand of the true Christian faith BEing thus arriued by Gods grace to discouer and rightly to obserue how important a thing it is to build vpon this foundation of true faith The true Canonicall Scriptures the chief rule of faith without which all the building of our soules would be but weake and soone fall to ruine I felt my selfe most forcibly moued by Gods Spirit with all humilitie and diligence to search out the most straight rule where no crookednesse should appeare with the which I might so truly measure out the right faith and true Church of God which Saint Paul calleth the Piller and firmament of truth In the desire whereof occurred vnto my memorie the Angell that talked with Saint Iohn Apocal. 21. vers 15. hauing a golden reed in his hand to measure the spirituall Hierusalem with all the gates the walles the foundations and all the parts of that great citie wishing that it would please God to bestow vpon me such a golden reed wherewith I might measure out the true faith and Church of God that all that are crooked in faith and misproportioned in their liues might find out the truth and be in the number of those of whom the Psalmist saith Psalme 32.11 Laetamini in domino exultate insti gloriamini omnes recti corde Be glad ye righteous and reioyce in the Lord and bee ioyfull all yee that are vpright in heart Whereupon I began to reflect vpon the chiefest rules spoken of either by the Church of Rome or other Churches pretending reformation and examining with a great desire of truth whether visibilitie and continuance of personall succession of Bishops in any Church or whether the Popes sole iudgement and definitiue sentence either with a Councell or tanquam ex Cathedra without a Councell or whether vnwritten traditions or whether the written word and facred Scriptures could be vnto me a straight rule of true faith and of the true Church of Christ me thought I found by all probable euidences and allowed testimonies that only and principally the written word of God I meane the true canonicall Scriptures could be the golden rod and straight mete-wand wherewith the true proportion and frame of Christian faith could bee measured in so much that me thought I might well say to my inexplicable comfort and to the honor of God as that high soaring Eagle Saint Iohn said Apoc. 11. vers 1. There was giuen me a reed like vnto a rod and it was said vnto mee rise and mete the Temple of God and the Altar and them that worship therein 2 But heere thou wilt say gentle Reader that this is but an imagined golden reed Obiections against Scripture as the chiefe or certaine rule and that this is but as crooked a measure as any other in respect of the many difficult places of Scripture which tire out the braines of the most learned as also in regard of the diuersitie of iudgements that is found about the sence of Scriptures for that the translations hauing been diuers it is hard for any man to iudge which is the truest but all these mists of but apparent reasons will easily be disperst if thou wilt please but heedily to peruse the proofes and authorities I bring for this my sure and strongest fundamentall obseruation I know onely but three kinds of strong arguments that may be produced for any veritie as namely the sacred Scriptures the authoritie of the learned and the force of natural reasons all which three do proclaime with a loud voice vnto vs that the written word is the most certain sufficient and infallible rule of faith that we can haue in this world and consequently the true golden mete-wand of Gods eternall truth and all Christian reuealed verities 3 This haue I gathered first out of the Scriptures By proofe of Scripture Esay 8.20 for I find in Esay the Prophet that we must repaire to the Law and to the testimonie if any speake not according to that word Prou. 2. vers 1. Prou. 2. vers 9. there is no light in them I
and when I noted that I could neuer heare any one Iesuit to speake reprouingly of it and further heard some very rashly and foolishly to cast the imputation of inuenting it vpon the best States-men of this land as a traine to make Catholikes the more odious to the State I began to obserue a custome vsed by some which is without any regard of truth or knowledge to speake the worst they can to blemish the reputation of their aduersaries so I heard a certaine young Iesuit report when Garnet was in the Tower A pretty deuice that day and night oyle was put into his eyes with feathers and other means vsed to keepe him from sleepe that so being weakened both in bodie and minde he might be easily drawne to confesse all he knew which circumstances with diuers others belonging to this vnmatchable treason though they made mee not then abandon the faith and beleefe of those that were actors thereof yet did they sow such seedes of doubtfulnesse and care in me to be sound in faith that the effects and fruits issuing from them of doctrine concerning disallegeance to the King which is contained in the Popes Breues hath much auerted me since as namely the doctrine of Bellarmine teaching that the Apostles were not subiect to temporall Princes de iure but de facto retracting the former opinion Bellarmin cont Barclaium tract De potest summi Pontificis in rebus temporalibus ca. 3. fol. 48. extant in his controuersies these many yeares now holding the quite contrarie notwith standing it is a doctrine of faith that as well the Clergie as the Laitie are subiect to Kings and Princes because obedience to Kings whether they be good or wayward in Scripture is commended vnto all 1. Petri 2.18 behold here the second occasion 7 A third occasion concurring to my conuersion Conference with others was conference with others into whose companies by chance I haue falne as once with a learned Knight who not knowing me to be a Priest conferred with me as with a professor of the Romane faith who winded me into such a circle about the Scriptures and the Church that I could neuer winde my selfe out of it till I winded my selfe out of the Romane Church and stayed my selfe vpon a ground not admitted there which is that the Scriptures are the most sufficient and certaine rule of faith that Christians haue which if you take away all religion all faith all knowledge of God falleth to the ground And another time I fell into dispute with a graue ancient Iustice of Peace who pressed me so farre that I promised to send him some principall doctrines of the Roman Church so sufficiently proued by Scriptures by Fathers and by naturall reason that if they could bee answered I would subscribe to his Church but in the examination of the proofes of those very points brought in by Bellarmine and due consideration of them I found them to be of very little force to proue the verities intended as hereafter shall appeare concerning the Masse Transubstantiation the ministration of the Sacrament vnder one kinde to lay people Pardons auricular confession and others whereupon I haue proued since as good as my promise in ioyning my selfe to the Church of England 8 A fourth occasion of examining more carefully the controuersies hath been grounded vpon his Maiesties Title His Maiesties Booke in his Premonition to Christian Princes stiling himselfe the Defendor of the true Christian Catholike and Apostolike faith which seemed so strange vnto me at the first considering that no Church more chalengeth the name of Catholike than the Church of Rome that I began to consider with my selfe whether I could finde any capitall points of faith taught now by the present Church of Rome that were not taught and professed by the ancient and Primitiue Church and now impugned by the Church of England and finding that the doctrine of deposing Princes and Kings by the Pope was not ancient nor Transubstantiation nor the Masse as now it is practised nor the Sacrament as now it is ministred by the Church of Rome nor Pardons nor prohibition of Priests marriages I haue since beene enforced to conclude that certainely the present Church of Rome professeth not in those points the true Christian Catholike and Apostolike faith Further as I noted the profession his Maiestie maketh in his Premonitorie Epistle to Princes Praemonit ful 35 acknowledging himselfe to be such a Christian Catholike as beleeueth the three Creedes that of the Apostles that of the Councell of Nice and that of Athanasius admitting the first foure generall Councels as Catholike and Orthodox the ioint consent of Fathers in the Primitiue age the authoritie of Scriptures c. I could not but conceiue at last that his Maiestie went vpon the strongest foundations of the Catholike faith that could bee layed to auoid the danger of new doctrines which obseruations did much facilitate my search and scrutinie into the true grounds and reasons of faith besides many other occasions of priuat conference with diuers particular persons who thought themselues much tempted in matters of faith and religion because they could hardly beleeue what the Church of Rome teacheth or at least not without great difficultie Whereby you may see courteous Reader the prouidence of God working in me by degrees towards my conuersion affoording mee the occasions and meanes first of searching and examining which brought me at length to the motiues of resoluing as hereafter you shall vnderstand more at large when I shall first haue layd downe vnto you certaine fundamentall obseruations as grounds on which the true Christian Catholike faith must of necessitie stand and the whole frame thereof be surely builded CHAP. III. Containing the first fundamentall obseruation of the end of man and his chiefe happinesse AFter the manifestation of the occasions which by Gods prouidence occurred to forward this worke of my conuersion The chiefe businesse of man is to seeke his end the next thing to be spoken of is to acquaint thee deare Christian Reader with those fundamentall obseruations which made further way to the complete perfection thereof the first of which was of that nature that I assure my selfe no man who hath care of his soule and saluation can chuse but allow for I assured my selfe that if I went vpon such sure foundations and principles as religion ought to stand vpon I could neither stay in error nor fall into any Hence I was moued to resolue most constantly that the most immoueable foundation that all my sp rituall building should stand on should be a frequent consideration that the chiefe and most principall affaire and businesse of greatest importance in this world wherein it was my dutie to employ my endeuors ought to be the saluation of my soule and my future happinesse in the life to come since to this end God created me to his similitude and likenesse redeemed mee with the most precious bloud of his most
the true Church of Christ and which was Gentilisme but now it is no way knowne vnto those which desire to know which is the true Church but onely by Scriptures wherefore because all these things which belongs so properly to Christ in truth heresies haue the same also in schisme Churches likewise holy Scriptures likewise Bishops likewise and other orders of Clerkes Baptisme likewise the Eucharist and all the rest lastly Christ himselfe One therefore that desireth to know which is the true Church whence shall he know it in the confusion of such likenesse but only by the Scriptures Note this likewise heretofore they were knowne by miracles who were true Christians who false How false Christians either could not do miracles as true Christians did or else they could not do such as true Christians did But now the working of miracles is altogether taken away and it is more found that false miracles are wrought by those who are false Christians as Peter according to Clement expouÌ„deth also power is to be also giuen of doing ful miracles vnto Antichrist Likewise heretofore the Church of Christ was vnderstood by their maners when the conuersation of al or most Christians was holy which was not among the wicked But now either such or worse Christians are become then Heretikes or Gentiles And moreouer greater continencie is found amongst those who liue in scisme then among Christians He therfore that will know which is the true Church of Christ whence shall he know it but only the Scriptures Note this The Lord therefore knowing that such a confusion of things should come in the last dayes he therefore commandeth that Christians who are in the Christianitie being desirous to obtaine firmenesse of the true faith should flie vnto nothing but vnto the Scriptures Note againe For otherwise if they haue regard to other things they shall be scandalized and shall perish not vnderstanding which is the true Church and by this they shall fall into the abomination of desolation which shall stand in the holy places of the Church Whereby it appeareth that the only means to find out the true Church is the canonicall Scriptures especially in these latter times to which we are now arriued 5 To our purpose also Gregorie Nissen calleth the Scriptures Other fathers Orat. de eis qui adeunt Hierosolimam A straight and inflexible rule I obserue also Saint Augustine to ioyne with the former who saith The Scripture pitcheth downe the rule of our faith De bono vid. cap. 1. And againe hee saith This controuersie depending betweene vs requireth a Iudge and let the Apostle Paul iudge with him because Christ also speaketh in his Apostle De nupt cencup ad Vater lib. 2. cap. 33. Epist 112. ad Paulin. In another place If a matter be grounded on the cleere authoritie of the holy Scripture such I meane as the Church calleth canonicall it is to be beleeued without all doubt but as for other witnesses and testimonies vpon whose credit any thing may be vrged vnto vs to belieue it it is lawful for thee either to credit or not to credit them according as thou shalt perceiue them of waight to deserue or not to deserue credit He saith besides De doctrin Christiau lib 2. cap 9. Ibid. cap. 42. All points which concerne faith and good life are found in those things which are plainly set downe in Scripture And againe in another place Whatsoeuer it be that a man learnes out of the Scripture if it be hurtfull there it is condemned if it bee profitable there it is found Tract 3. in 1. epist Ioh. Contra lit Petilian Dâ—â—at lib. 3 cap. 6 de vnit Eccles cap. 11. Againe hee saith The Church is our mother her breasts are the two Testaments of the Scripture whence she giueth her children milke Againe further If we or an Angell from heauen declare vnto you either concerning Christ or his Church any other matter or any thing belonging to our faith or life but what you haue receiued in the Legal and Euangelicall Scriptures let him be accursed The same famous Doctor likewise reuoketh from miracles to Scriptures De vnit Eccles cap. 16. saying Say not these things are so because such a one did such and such marualles but let them proue their Church by the canonicall bookes of Scripture and by nothing else These are the demonstrations of our cause these are our foundations these are our grounds whereupon we build And againe Our faith shal reele totter if the authoritie of the Scriptures stand not fast By all which according to this famous Doctor who is termed malleus haereticorum the hammer of heretikes you see this rule of faith most cleerely approued and iustified 6 Neither doe other auncient Writers swarue from the same doctrine Other fathers De error prophan relig p. 61. for Iulius Firminus sayth Let the venerable mysteries of the Prophets be opened let the credit of the holy Oracles stand by vs. Origen further sayth Hom. 1. in Ierem We must of necessitie call the Scriptures to witnesse for our sences and interpretations without them are of no credit Cyrill the Bishop of Hierusalem sayth Concerning the holy and heauenly mysteries of faith Catech. 4. pag. 15. we must not deliuer any thing though neuer so small Note this without the holy Scripture neither may we be led away with probabilities and shew of words neither yet beleeue me barely saying these things vnto you vnlesse thou also beleeue the demonstration thereof from the Scripture for the securitie of our faith ariseth from the demonstration of the holy Scripture The Emperour Constantine in his speech to the Bishops of the Nicene Councell hath this memorable saying Theod Hist li. 1. c. 7. pag. 284. We haue the teaching of the holy Ghost written for the Enangelicall and Apostolike bookes and the Decrees of the old Prophets doe euidently teach vs the things that are needfull to be knowne concerning God Therefore laying aside all contention let vs out of the dinine inspired Scripture take the rersolution of those things we secke for Neither will I let my penne paste another notable saying of Saint Augustine which is diligently to bee noted saying In Io. tract 21. Some may obiect we doe rashly in discussing and searching out the wordes of God but way are they vttered if they may not be knowne Why haue they sounded if they may not be heard and why are they heard but that we should vnderstand them Thus the Ancient resolued me in the securitie of this rule 7 And not onely these Proofes of late Writers but also the moderne Writers of the Church of Rome forgetting themselues as it seemeth in their writings euen against their owne grounds about the rule of faith haue giuen me no lesse euidence for this most straight and sufficient rule of the sacred letters and Canonical bookes than the former For first their great
learned Doctor whom they call the Angelicall Doctor sayth Tho. Aqu. lec in 1. Tim. 6. The doctrine of the Apostles and Prophets is called Canonicall because it is as it were the rule of our vnderstanding 1. q. 1. ar 4. And againe our faith resteth and stayeth it selfe vpon the reuelation giuen to the Apostles and Prophets which writ the Canonicall bookes 1. q. 1. ar 8. and not vpon reuelation if any such haue beene made to other Doctors And also in another place hee sheweth how all iudgement of truth is to be referred to the Scriptures saying In arguing it properly vseth viz. the said reuealed knowledge Tho. 1 q. part 1. q. 1. ar 8. ad 2. whereof he speaketh of necessitie the authorities of Canonicall Scripture but the authorities of other Doctors of the Church as it were arguing out of her owne but probably For our faith doth relie vpon the reuelation made to the Apostles and Prophets who wrote the Canonicall bookes nd not vpon any reuelation made to other Doctors Therefore Augustine sayth in his Epistle to Hierome Epi. 19. Paulo post princip to 2. I haue learned to giue this honor to the onely bookes of Scriptures which are called Canonicall as to beleeue most firmely that not one author of them hath erred in writing but others I reade so that with what soeuer holinesse and learning they are endued as not therefore to thinke any thing a truth because they haue held or written so And in another place Faith doth cleaue vnto all the articles of faith for one medium to wit for the first truth proposed vnto vs in Scriptures according to the doctrine of the Church vnderstanding rightly and therefore hee that swarueth from this meane doth totally want faith Antoninus the Archbishop of Florence writeth expressely Sum. part 3. tit 18. c. 3. ff 3. That God hath spoken but once and that in the holy Scripture and so plentifully to meete with all temptations and all cases that may fall out and all good workes that as Gregorie in the two and twentieth booke of his Morals expounds it he needes no more speake vnto vs concerning any necessarie matter seeing all things are found in the Scripture Gerson a great man in the Councell of Constance sayth De com sub vtraque specie The Scripture is the rule of our faith which being well vnderstood no authoritie of men is to be admitted against it Durandus sayth That generally in the things that touch our faith wee must speake to that which the Scripture deliuereth Praef. in sent least any man fall into that which the Apostle noteth 1. Cor. 8. If he thinke he knoweth something yet the knoweth nothing as he ought to know for the manner of our knowledge must be not to exceede the measure of faith and the holy Scripture expresseth the measure of faith Alliaco the Cardinall sayth 1. Sent. q. 1. ar 3. The verities themselues of the sacted Canon be the principles of Diuinitie because the finall resolution of Theologicall discourse is made into them and originally from them is drawne euery conclusion of Diuinitie Conradus Clingius sayth Locor l. 3. c. 29. pag. 290. The Scripture is the infallible rule of truth yea the measure and iudge of the truth Peresius the Diuinitie Reader at Barcelona in Spaine sayth The authoritie of no Saint is of infallible truth Iac. Per. de ratio con li. 2. c. 19. for Saint Augustine giues that honor onely to the sacred Scriptures Whereupon I frame this reason That onely is the infallible rule which is of infallible truth but the Scripture onely is of infallible truth therefore the Scripture onely is the infallible rule 8 Bellarmine also writeth thus Other late Writers De verbo Dei li. 1. cap. 2. The rule of faith must be certaine and knowne for if it be not certaine it is no rule at all if it be not knowne it is no rule to vs but nothing more certaine nothing better knowne than the sacred Scripture contained in the writings of the Prophets and Apostles wherefore the sacred Scripture is the rule of faith most certaine and most safe and God hath taught vs by corporall letters which wee might see and reade what he would haue vs beleeue concerning him Whence I gather that if the Swenckfeldians are to bee drawne to the written Text then ought those of the Church of Rome also be recalled to the same rule from their vncertaine traditions from the Popes sole definitiue sentence and from their Councels not teaching by Scriptures If nothing be more knowne nothing more certaine as the Cardinall confesseth than the Scriptures why doe they reiect them from being the rule as not sufficient to preserue from error not knowne ynough The same Cardinall sayth in another place De not eccles c. 2. ff respond Simpliciter The Scripture is better knowne than the Church in some case as namely where it is receiued and speaketh plainly and the question is of the Church Willauincentius confesseth The Scriptures and they alone are able to teach vs to saluation De ratio stud Theol. li. 1. c. 31. pag. 21. as the Apostle in the third chapter of his second Epistle to Timothie affirmeth saying All Scripture is inspired of God in which words the Apostle comprehendeth all things that are needfull to the saluation of man Comment in 2. Tim c 3 in vers 15 16. Espenceus writeth That if any thing be needfull either to be knowne or done the Scriptures teach the truth reproue the false reclaime from euill persuade to good neither yet doe they make a man good in some sort but perfect yea they can teach a man to saluation and make him learned sufficiently Panormitane writeth thus One faithfull man Part 1. de elect polest ca. significa though priuate is more to be beleeued than the Pope or a whole Councell if he haue better reason on his side and authoritie of the Old and New Testament And Gerson more sully De exemp doct part 1. considera 5. The examination and triall of doctrine concerning faith belongeth not onely to the Pope and Councell but to euery one also that is sufficiently seene in the holy Scripture because euery one is a fit iudge of that he knoweth And againe some lay-man not authorised may be so excellently learned in the Scripture that his assertion shall be more to be credited than the Popes definitiue sentence for the Gospell is more to be credited than the Pope Therefore if such a lay man though he be priuate teach a truth contained in the Gospell and the Pope either know it not or will not know it yet it is euident that his iudgement is to be preferred Costerus Cesterus sayth That such verities concerning our faith as are absolutely necessarie to be knowne and beleeued of all men are plainely taught in the Scriptures themselues Doctor Saunders sayth Rock pag. 193. Wee
haue most plaine Scriptures in all points for the Catholike faith he meaneth the faith of the present Church of Rome Doctor Hill in his quart of reasons the eight reason And Doctor Hill seemes willing to haue it thought that they build vpon the Scriptures in all points of doctrine when he sayth Neither may here the Protestants reply and say that the Papists build vpon miracles visions prophecies and vpon such like but not vpon the Word for all that they alledge are most agreeable to the word of God neither doe they teach any doctrine but such as is deriued out of the holy Bible This affertion sheweth much weaknesse of iudgement and little skill euen in the grounds of Diuinitie for who is so ignorant that knoweth not the Papists doe build vpon miracles visions prophecies And who so simple amongst them that know not that they build least vpon the word when they generaly teach that the written word is not sufficient for faith without traditions And what a foule misbeseeming vntruth is it for a Doctor to say That all that they alleadge are most agreeable to the word of God when they ordinarily obiect that the perpetuall virginitie of the virgine Marie the assumption of her bodie into heauen the baptizing of reasonlesse children the keeping of the Sunday and others the like are not to be proued by the word of God but are built onely vpon traditions Is not this then a very grosse forgetfulnesse to affirme That they teach not any Doctrine but such as is deriued out of the holie Bible And yet he forgetteth himselfe so much that againe in the same reasons hee saith euen for the time past That the Catholikes meaning Papists euer squared their Doctrine by the Line and the Leuell of the word of hir Spouse and therfore neuer had cause to reiect the least iote of the holie Bible and at one word the Catholikes follow the Bible By all which it seemeth most apparent that the learned doe approue the word of God that is the Canonicall Scriptures to be the most certain sufficient and most infallible rule that can be assigned What reason then haue I to forsake the iugement of so many learned men both ancient and moderne Writers who heerein are most conformable to Scripture it selfe 9 For if we consider rightly of the nature of faith Natural reason sheweth this rule obseruing that the knowledge whereto it consenteth and the end to which it leadeth are supernaturall nothing can seeme more agreeable to naturall discourse than to gather also that only that book which containes Gods reuealed verities can be the sufficientesi means to know them which is the holy writings of the old and new Testament If a man should aske me why I beleeue the creation of the world all the miracles wrought by Moses Elias and Elisaeus that there is a God that Christ is is the sonne of God that he was borne of a virgine I cannot answere with assurednesse because this Priest or that Priest teacheth me so for reason will obiect that hee may erre or that all Priests agree not therein or that first I must be assured he teacheth me doctrine of such a Church as cannot misinstruct me which I must know by some other meanes Therefore my only answere must be that I beleeue because those Scriptures reuealed from God doe teach me which are the most sufficient rule whereby I can haue assured knowledge of truth reuealed from God by all which it seemed most cleare vnto m that onely the Scriptures can be the most assured sufficient and infallible rule by which I am to measure my faith and all vertues belonging thereunto and therefore all other rules are verie subiect to the crookednesse of many errors Siluest vers 60. fides Nu. 2. Hence I began to see my former error in holding with Siluester that the Pope as the vice gerent of Christ vpon earth was to be my rule according to his assertion taken out of Saint Thomas The Pope hath the primacie of the vniuersall Church to whom it appertaineth to determine those things which belong to faith 22. 1. 11. ar 3. that they may bee held of all with a constant faith and in him resideth the authority of the vniuersall Church Therefore it belongeth to faith to adhere vnto the sentence of the chiefe Bishop in those things which belong to faith yea also in those things which belong vnto good manners because in such the Church cannot erre nor consequently her head as head or as Bishop which I vnderstand alwaies to be true when in doubts he is required not as a learned man or such a person but as the head of Christianity or according to Archidiaconus Note this when he determineth with the Councell of Cardinals but the first is better because the Pope may be without Cardinals But when I remembred that two Popes namely Sixtus and Clemens set out two Bibles within two yeares space for Sixtus Bible came forth in the yeare 1590. and Clements in the yeare 1592. with commaundement to be read and followed vpon penalties mentioned in their seuerall breues wherein many disagreements contradictions and contrarieties appeared in so important a matter of faith as the appointment of what is Scripture and what is not that herein Pope Sixtus grieuously erred I concluded that the Popes sentence definitiue could not bee a sufficient rule for me to measure my faith by vnlesse I would be like vnto a principall Romane Clarke of this land affirming that heere in England he thought the opinion of Cardinall Bellarmine the best to be held concerning deposition of kings namely that the Pope hath his dominion in temporalties onely indirectly yet if he were in Rome he would follow the opinion of Bosius that he hath it directly as the most plausible there And much wondering that such an assertion should passe from the mouth of so graue a man I began to inferre that if but place or persons were the rule of such mens faith in matters of such waight it was time for me who regarded but the saluation of my soule to seeke after some better rule more sure and infallible 10 Now then courteous Reader hauing found out this most sufficient rule of faith namely the holy Scriptures I referre my selfe vnto your impartiall censure to iudge whether I could doe lesse then to measure all the doctrinall points of my faith by this golden meet-wand and therewith measure out the spirituall and true Church of Christ which if thou shalt iudge fit for me I hope such shall be the care of thine owne saluation as to vse it alwaies in like manner for thy selfe that thy faith may be free from all crookednesse of heresies and thereby be made partakers of Gods promises for the manifold diuisions about the Church the diuers errours taught by those that pretend to bee other mens Teachers and euen the loue of thy selfe may well make thee say with holy Dauid following the
light of Scriptures Psal 119. vers 10.4 Psal 119. vers 18. vnto thy Lord God Lucerna pedibus meis verbum tuum lumen semitis meis Thy word is a lampe vnto my feete and a light vnto my path And againe Open thou mine eyes that I may behold wonderous things out of the Law 11 Yet thou art to haue great care that thou make not this rule longer than it is nor shorter for this is forbidden by Christ himselfe speaking against such a one saying I protest vnto euery man that heareth the words of the prophecie of this Booke Apoc. 22.18 19. if any man shall adde vnto these things God shall adde vnto him the plagues that are written in this Booke and if any man shall take away from the words of the booke of this prephecie God shall take away his part out of the Booke of life and out of the holy Citty and from the things which are written in this Booke This fault of adding to the Books of holie scripture is very notorious in the Church of Rome as I haue duly obserued Ses 41. For the Councell of Trent addeth to the Canon of the old Testament diuers Apocriphall Books which must be beleeued as Canonicall Scriptures as namely Tobias Iudith Hester and the two bookes of the Macchabees Esdras Wisedome and Ecclesiasticus all which are learnedly proued to be Apocriphall by the right reuerend Father in God my Lords grace of Canterburie in his answer to master Doctor Hill his eight reason Num. 3. sequent the consideration whereof made me plainely conclude that heerein the Church of Rome giues great and apparent occasion for any to iudge that she erreth and consequently not to heare her voice thus vttering falshood for trueth giuing equall authoritie to the Apocriphall Bookes with the holy canonicall Scriptures CHAP. VII Containing an obseruation how the Ministerie of the true Church of Christ is the meanes of teaching the true sense and vnderstanding of Scriptures where and when it hath a visible and externall gouernement ALthough I haue cleerely discouered The externall ministe rie of the Church an ordinarie meanes to know the true sense of Scripture that the sacred Scriptures are the chiefe infallible rule of faith and most sufficient in the precedent obseruation yet could I not rest satisfied till I found also a meanes for the simple and vnlearned to ground their faith vppon because Deus vult omnes saluos fieri ad agnitionem veritatis venire God will haue all to be saued 1. Tim. 2.4 and come to the knowledge of his trueth And as well as he in the gouernment of his creatures hath his end to which he designes them so also by his wisedome he doth most prudently substitute subordinate means for the full accomplishment of such his designements now therefore how those that are neither able to reade the scriptures or though they be able haue not sufficient skill and knowledge to consider the circumstances of Texts and by the analogie of faith not learned enough to find out the true meaning of the Scriptures nor haue the gift of interpretation as many and most haue not whereupon arise many deprauations of Scriptures how such should be directed in the right vse of the rule of Scriptures in finding out the right meaning of them I thought it a matter of great weight wel to discouer and by the declaration thereof to affoord a stay to weake consciences in this behalfe In the scrious discussion of which point it pleased almightie God so to second my carefull Labours and indeuours herein as that I receiued ful satisfaction in mine owne iudgement by this conclusion namely That the most ordinary externall direction left by God especially to direct vnlearned men in the finding out of the true sense and meaning of the Scriptures is the ministerie of the true visible Church of Christ assisted by the holie Ghost and the Church in this respect is called 1. Tim. 3.15 Matt. 5.14 The pillar of truth and the ministers thereof The light of the world 2 And therefore as master Harding himselfe confesseth True vnderstanding of Scripturs only in the Church Doctor Hard. conâ—ut of the Apologie of the Church of England fol. 36. Mester Celuine admonisheth very well That it is especially to be noted that out of the Church there is no light of the sound vnderstanding of the Scriptures But the inconsiderate Doctour maketh a verie fond inference vpon this ground saying This ground being laid on which each part must sland and be tried in crow no more against vs boast your selues no more we feare not the iudgement of the holie Scriptures nay it is your selues that feare this iudgement for your owne conscience telleth you that on this ground you are the weaker side Jnstit lib. 4 cap. 8. num 7. hee forgot that master Caluine said Let this be a firme axiome That no other word of God is to be had to which place must bee giuen in the Church than what is maintained first in the Law and Prophets then in the writings of the Apostles neither is there anie way of teaching in the Church of God but by the prescript and rule of his word If master Harding had well obserued this hee would not haue made such an inference or affirmed that the Protestants feare this iudgement but rather would haue concluded as I doe That since both stand vpon the outward ministerie of the true Church let vs seeke the true Church of Christ and hauing found it The deuties of the true church then heare and follow her doctrine teaching according to Scripture and out of Scripture 3 The due obseruation whereof sheweth That the true visible Church is to represse the deprauations of Heretickes and partly to informe those that are vnlearned and to exercise euen the obedience of those that are learned and by the externall ministerie of teaching the true sence of Scriptures is to giue directions and is duetifully by her members to bee heard and followed Which assertion I find not to make either for the present Church of Rome or of Engl. or any other particular Church till it bee prooued which of them is the true Catholike Ancient and Primitiue Apostolike Church teaching the sound Doctrine of the first pure and vntainted ages whereof I am to speake in the Chapter following CHAP. VIII Containeth a fundamentall obseruation how that consormity of doctrine with the ancient doctrine of the Primitiue Church may bee a good meanes in these latter ages to know the true Church of Christ. AFter that I had thus discouered both the most sufficient rule of faith to be the canonicall and true Scriptures and the most ordinarie externall meanes to find out the true sence to be the ministerie of the true Church Antiquitie a good inducement to the true Church I could not yet giue sufficient contentment to my vnderstanding vntill such time as I had found out also
adore it but all the rest standing by and that are present although they receiue not Fourthly when it is set forth vpon the Altar for publike praier as experience sheweth in their fortie houres prater By which it is apparent how frequently the Church of Rome enforceth men to giue that worship which is only due to God vnto the Creature which is by them to bee worshipped as God For the Councell wordes are these Sess â—3 can 6. de sacr Euchar. If any shall say that Christ the only begotten Sonne of God is not to be adored in the holy Sacrament of the Eucharist with the worship of Latria yea externall and therefore not to bee worshipped with any peculiar festiuall collebritie nor the bee carried solemnely in Processions according to the laudable and vniuersall rite and custome of the holy Church or not to bee proposed to the people to bee adored and the adorers thereof to be Idolaters be he accursed Here is a strange peece of doctrine yet is it not vnaccompanied with the malediction of the Bishop of Rome I cannot obserue any place or passage of Scripture that makes for this doctrine no neither doth Stephanus Durantus cite either Scripture or other auncient Father that maketh for this Latria worship whence it followeth that it is a new doctrine vnheard of in the primer ages of Christs Church onely this I note that he citeth some auncient Fathers seeming to approue the worship of Christ in Heauen when they behold the Sacrament yea and also some kind of reuerence to the Sacrament but no such as is due to God but rather as may be thought such a kind of reuerence as is vsed in Baptisme and fit to bee vsed in the vse of signes of holy things and therefore to conclude since in the sacrifice of the Masse where the consecrated Hoast must be adored with Latria-worship most detestable Idolatrie is committed I could not but with a great dislike of so foule an abuse in doctrine disauow that Sacrifice of the Masse and hold it most abhominable in the sight of Almightie God Hence I conceiued the more worthily of his Maiesties iudgement and learning for if the verie essentiall parts of the publike sacrifice of the Masse haue no warrant in Scripture and the essentiall part thereof so idolatrous he might well confidently affirme of priuat Masse Praemonit If the Romish Church hath ioyned new articles of faith neuer heard of in the first 500 yeres after Christ I hope I shall neuer be condemned for an Heretike for not being a Nouleist Such are the priuat Masses where the Priest playeth the part both of the Priest and of the people For what an absurd thing is it for the Priest to say Dominus vobiscuÌ„ or orate fratres The Lord be with you or pray ye brethren or to turn about as if there were people to answere when nothing but bare wals appeareth saying Ite Missâ— est Go ye Masse is done Nay what a ridiculous prayer is it wheÌ„ the Priest saith vnto God none being present but either a man or a woman playing the office of a clerke Memento Domina famuloruÌ„ famularum In Can. Missae que tuaruÌ„ omniuÌ„ circuÌ„stantiuÌ„ queruÌ„ ubi fides cognita est nota deuotio pro qubius tibi offerimus c. Remember O Lord thy men-seruants and women-seruants and all that stand round about whose faith and deuotion is manifest and knowne vnto thee This is as ridiculous a false prayer as that which the Priests alwayes say vpon the feast of an ordinarie Confessor Ad sacrum cuius tumulum frequenter Membra languentum modo sanitati Quolibet morbo fuerint grauata Restituuntur Breuiar in com mu. Confessorum Vnder nunc noster chorus in honorem Ipsius hymnum canit hunc libenter Vt pijs eius meritis iuuemur Omne per aeuum Englished thus At whose sacred Tombe sicke people Euen now often with whatsoeuer Diseases they are oppressed are restored To health Our Quier therefore now in honor Of him singeth this Hymne willingly That by his pious merits we may be Holpen for euer Is not this strange that so notorious a lye must by millions of Romish Priests be sung and said vpon the Feasts of such Confessors at whose Tombes not so much as a lame dogge was euer cured and yet they sticke not to say that often and from euerie disease they are cured But by this it may be gathered that the Romish Church hath little care what she alloweth or practiseth how grosse or absurd soeuer it be so long as her erronious doctrines may either be beleeued or practised and hence shee suffereth the Latria-worship of the Hoast to be instilled into the vulgar sort of people without any remorse or scruple for so vnwarrantable an error 5 Now as for the ceremonies of the Masse The ceremonie of the Masse hath no certaine signification as I haue beene carefull to learne their meaning and significations thereby haue I also found as great cause to disgust the sacrifice of the Masse as for the former for so vncertaine is the disagreement of Romish Authors about them as none can be greater Michael the Suffragane of Mets tels vs The Amies that the Humerale which is made of thinne linnen Michael Suffragan Mongunt explic myst sacrosanct nus yet pure and cleane couering the Priests head signifieth Christs Diuinitie couered with fraile humane flesh free and cleane from sinne In another place he sayth That it designeth the indefatigable labour of doing good and chastitie of bodie and minde but Iacobus de Voragine sayth Iac. de Vor. ser de Sanct. de celibrat Mis ser 1. De ritibus eccle Catho c. 9. ff 6. Lib. 2. de sacra part 4. Part. 4 q 26. That it signifieth the Helmet of Saluation because he must appoach to the Altar with hope and confidence Stephanus Durantus that thereby is vnderstood the custodie of a mans mouth Hugo de Sancto victorie and Alexander de Ales thinke it signifieth the vaile wherewith the perfidious Iewes did couer the face of Christ The Albe according to Michael the Suffragane because it is cleane and closed round about the Priest designeth the most entire conuersation of Christ amongst all The Albe Ibid. And in another place he sayth it admonisheth vs of the innocencie and puritie we receiue in Baptisme But Iacobus de Voragine Ibid. Vbi supra more like a souldior will haue it signifie Loricam iustitiae because that as the Albe couereth the Priest all ouer so doth Iustice with other vertues couer the soule Ibid. nu 9. Stephanus Durantus will haue it signifie the perseuerance of good workes Germanus will haue it signifie the brightnesse of the Godhead In Theor. rerum Ecclesiast and the shining conuersation of a Priest Againe it representeth the white garment wherewith Herode did mocke Christ Stephanus Eduensis Bishop sayth that it designeth the glorie of
and wine passe into the substance of the body and bloud of Christ yet so as the nature of bread and wine ceaseth not and they are turned into the diuine substance yet the bread and wine still remaine in the propertie of their nature If this be true that the nature of bread and wine ceaseth not and that the bread and wine still remaine in the propertie of their nature then can not transubstantiation stand For hereby Gelasius confuted Eutiches the Heretike holding that Christ had but one nature and that in regard of the vnion the humanitie was turned into the Deitie against which error he opposed the doctrine of the Eucharist shewing that as therein bread and wine after consecration were honoured with the name of his body and bloud and receiued grace to their nature to bee a holy Sacrament though still they remained in their former nature and propertie So the humanitie of Christ receiued grace by the hypostaticall vniting it to the God-head and yet still retained the former propertie to be humane flesh Therefore had Gelasius beliefe beene answerable to the present Church of Rome concerning Transubstantiation he not only could not thereby haue confuted Eutiches but Eutiches might by that very doctrine most probably haue confuted him Who might right well haue argued thus Thou Gelasius thinkest the Sacrament a resemblance of the incarnation of Christ and the vnion of his two natures but in the Sacrament the bread and wine after consecration remaine no more but are turned into the flesh and bloud of Christ and so there is but one substance After this manner may I likewise say in the Incarnation after the vnion the humanitie remaineth no more but is changed into the Diuinitie and the Nature is but one What could Gelasius haue answered to this Argument if hee had held the doctrine of Transubstantiation Hence it is euident both by his wordes and the scope of his disputation that he held it not Not vnlike to Gelasius is the doctrine of Theodoret Dial. immuta fol. 8. writing thus Our Sauiour in deliuering the Sacrament called his body bread and that which is in the cup he called his bloud he changed the names and gaue his body that name which belonged to the signe and to the signe that name which belonged to his body The reason why he thus changed the names was because he would haue such as partake the diuine Sacraments not to heede the nature of those thinges which are seene but for the change sake of the names to beleeue the change that is made by grace For he called it wheat and bread which by nature is his body and againe on the other side he called himselfe a Vine Thus honoring the simbols and signes which are seen with the name of his body bâ—oud not by changing their nature but by adding grace to nature And further the same Author in an other place reprehending the Eutichian heretike saith Dialog 2. Inconfusus You are caught in your owne net for the mysticall signes after consecration do not depart from their nature but they abide in their former substance form and figure and may be seen touched as before If they depart not from their nature if they abide in their former substance figure and forme if Christ changed not the natures but the names adding grace to nature how can the doctrine of transubstantiation in the iudgement of this writer stand free from the impeachment of an erroneous innouation 7. How moderne Authors of the Church of Rome shew the doctrine of transubstantiation to be nouell De verit corp sang p. 46. And so I find euen by the confession of the learnedst moderne Writers this doctrine is but nouell and of small antiquitie and hath not been beleeued as a matter of faith in the purest ages of the Primitiue Church for it is well knowne that before the Councell of Laterane no man was bound to beleeue Transubstantiation as themselues confesse Tonstal sayth It was free for all men till that time to follow their owne coniecture as concerning the manner of the Presence Scotus and Biel are reported by the later Schoolemen to haue been of minde That the opinion is very new and lately brought into the Church Soto 4. d 9. q. 2. art 2. 4. Suar. tom 3. d. 5.4 d. 10. q. 2. ad arg pro prima sect 1. and beleeued only vpon the authoritie of the Laterance Councell And Scotus himselfe saith We must say the Church in the Creede of the Laterane Councell vnder Innocent the third which begins with the words Firmiter credimus declared this sense concerning transubstantiation to belong to the verity of our faith Besides Scotus Bellarmine confesse Scot. d. 11. q. 3. Bellar. Euchar. lib. 3. cap. 23. Turrec tract 13. q. 49. There is no Scripture to conuince it vnlesse yee bring the Church of Romes exposition that is to say the Popes authoritie in whom they thinke the power of the vniuersall Church in determining matters of faith principally resides Now therefore if this doctrine bee no more ancient than the Councell of Laterane as it is cleare I oppose against the accurse of the Councell of Trent the malediction of blessed Saint Paul a better man than any in the Councell of Trent who pronounceth a direfull Anathema against any that shall teach other doctrine than what he taught how fearefull a state then doe all Popish Priests stand in that teach this noueltie of Transubstantiation diametrally contrarie to the places of S. Paul before cited 1. Cor. 10.16 1. Cor. 11.26 Vers 27. Vers 28. Euagrius 4. lib. Hist c. 35. Niceph. lib. 17. cap. 25. Hiesich l 2. super Leuit. cap. 8. Euseb lib. 7. c. 8. August cont lit Petil. lib. 9. c. 30. It is well knowne that it was an vsuall thing in former ages in diuers places to giue the residues of the Sacrament to little children as Euagrius and Nicephorus haue left recorded to posteritie Yea and in other places of the Christian world as Hesichius teacheth neither hath it beene thought much in former times to giue the bread of the Sacrament into the peoples handes and sometimes permitted them to carry it home which is a signe that they conceipted not then the doctrine of Transubstantiation which hath caused it since to be adored and haue made it a sinnefull act for Lay people to touch the Sacrament yea and haue brought it to such a fond esteeme that if a Flie or a Spider fall into the wine or any like thing which can not without vomit or danger of death be taken downe the Flie or Spider or what else must be taken out and washed as warily as may be in a Chalice and the Priest must take the ablution but the Flie or Spider must be burnt Ibidem eodem cap. Or if a sick man vomit vp the body of the Lord it must bee taken vp againe as diligently as may be and taken by a
by the secret vertue of the Stone after an inuisible manner adioyning the Rings together a goodlie entire Chaine was made of them Euen so dearely beloued Christian Reader I finde Christ Iesus to haue beene such a powerfull and attractiue Loadstone vnto my Soule by the precedent obseruations lincking the one vnto the other with such infallible truth that therewith euen as with a most strong chaine of his excessiue loue and charitie hee hath now at the length drawne mee to the knowledge of his true Faith rightly taught and professed in the Church of England 2 It is no other than a chaine of Charitie A briefe recapitulation of the premised obseruations by which hee hath drawne mee to write this Treatise for the manifestation of his truth to those that are ignorant thereof It was a chaine of his prouidence by ministring occasions of times persons and places concurring to my conuersion It is a chaine of truth that euery mans chiefe businesse in this life must bee to attaine vnto the end he is created vnto by God or else hee receiueth his soule in vaine It is a chaine reaching from heauen that a supernaturall and reuealed knowledge from God is necessarie to saluation The obseruation also of an absolute necessitie of a supernaturall Faith is a strong chaine to draw any man to search diligently after it The knowledge likewise of the right rule and golden mete-wand of true Faith consisting of GODS sacred Word is a most forcible chaine to drawe Christians vnto the right knowledge of GODS truth The true knowne visible Church of Christ teaching the true sense of Scriptures is a powerfull chaine to draw men vnto the right faith of CHRIST IESVS Conformitie of Doctrine with the ancient doctrine of the Primitiue Church being a proper marke of the true Church of God is likewise a most attractiue chaine drawing to the true knowledge of right Christianitie The wonders and supposed miracles which Christ fore-told the Pseudo-Christs and false Prophets should doe for the seducing of Gods Elect if it were possible are also a strong chaine to draw any man from the Church of Rome The great hypocrisie of false Teachers fore-spoken of in the holy Scriptures agreeing chiefly with the Church of Rome are a chaine of great strength and power to draw any man from that Church The fruits by which false Prophets are to bee knowne and discerned abounding in the Church of Rome are also a powerfull chaine to draw any man of true iudgement from the abhominiations of that Church The discouerie of the Sacrifice of the Masse to bee Idolatrous which is accompted by the Church of Rome the chiefest act of religion that can bee done to God is a most forcible chaine to draw any man to the knowledge of CHRIST IESVS once offered for vs procuring our Sanctification Is not the proofe of Transubstantiation also to bee a noueltie a potent chaine to draw any man from Rome to the Church of England where the Sacrament is freed from such disgrace Is not the Amputation also of the holy Eucharist a powerfull chaine to draw men from the Church of Rome that they may rightly according to Christs institution bee partakers of the Lords Supper else where Is not also the noueltie of the Popes Pardons and Indulgences which is annexed to Crosses Graines and Meddals a powerfull chaine to draw any man that is not ridiculously childish a stronge chaine to draw him from the Church of Rome If the false doctrine of seuen Sacraments be well discouered by any man bee can not want a strong chaine to draw him to acknowledgement of two true Sacraments instituted by Christ if the doctrine of the Virgin Maries conception in originall sinne bee doubtfull in the Church of Rome the truth of Scriptures shewing it certaine may serue for a strong chaine to draw any man from that doubtfulnesse If the pretended chastitie of the Romish Clergie doe make the Church of Rome seeme more pure and holy than any other the prohibition of lawfull marriage to Priests and the dispensation and permission of vnlawfull marriage to kindred may bee as a strong chaine to draw deceiued soules from the filth and impurities of her hypocriticall holinesse By these the mightie strength power of all those chaines hath the goodnesse of almightie God deliuered my long estraied soule out of her dangerous waies setled me in the happie societie of his true faithfull beleeuers teaching the true ancient Catholike and Apostolike faith Oh how truly may I now say with holy Dauid in humble acknowledgement of Gods singular mercies vnto my soule Maruailous are thy workes Psal 139.14 O Lord and that my soule knoweth right well 3. Now it is time To all Seminarie Priests O all yee Seminarie Priests in this Land or else where who labour still in the same blindnesse and errours wherein hitherto I haue beene my selfe inwrapped as in a darke cloude that out of that true charitie and zeale of your soules good and happinesse wherewith I haue cause to be affected towardes you I direct my speech a while vnto you and manifest the sincere candor of my heart and affections to pittie your case as I haue had cause to bee sorrie for it heretofore in my selfe and therefore I can not but admonish you of the perill you liue in both of body and soule for looking no better into the doctrines which you teach You pretend to bee the salt of the earth Math. 5. vers 13. and the light of the world therefore you haue cause to see well that your doctrine bee sound wherewith you season mens soules and that the example of your vertues and life bee not hypocriticall and superstitious if your salt bee infatuated with nouelties and corrupt doctrines all the world will trample vpon you and you are only fit to bee cast out vnto the dunghills if your liues giue no true light but bee a couered vnder the appearance only of vertues as vnder a bushell where there is no corne your poore followers will bee hunger starued and runne into darkenesse and neuer finde the true light of the world CHRIST IESVS Who illuminateth as Saint Iohn saith Ioh. 1. vers 9. euery man comming into this world If it bee true that CHRIST saith Hee that doeth and teacheth Math. 5.19 shall bee called great in the Kingdome of hâ—auen Vnlesse both these duties goe together without mixture of falshood and finne you can neither bee great in Heauen nor in Earth but certaine I am your paines will bee great in the deepedungeon of hell Examine well your owne consciences both for doctrine and conuersation build not vpon other mens bookes only but examine their doctrines by the infallible rule of Scriptures send your Disciples vnto Christ as Saint Iohn Baptist did not to the Popes who can and haue erred both in doctrine and manners say vnto your Children as Christ our Lord and Master said Search the Scriptures c. because
DOCTRINALL AND MORALL OBSERVATIONS CONCERNING RELIGION WHEREIN THE AVTHOR DECLARETH THE Reasons of his late vn-enforced departure from the Church of ROME and of his incorporation to the present Church of ENGLAND teaching maintaining and defending the true Christian Catholike and Apostolike Faith professed by the ancient Primitiue Church most conspicuous in the outward vertues and constant sufferings of many holy Bishops and other good Christians glorious in the crowne of Martyrdome By IOHN COPLEY Seminarie Priest LVKE 22.23 When thou art conuerted strengthen thy brethren IAMES 5.20 He which maketh a sinner to be conuerted from the error of his way shall saue his soule from death and couereth a multitude of sinnes LONDON Imprinted by W. S. for Richard Moore and are to be sold at his Shop in Fleet-street in Saint Dunstans Church-yard 1612. TO ALL SEMINARIE PRIESTS MONKES FRIERS IESVITES AND ALL LAY-PROFESSORS of the present Romane falsely pretended Catholike faith grace and true conuersion in Christ IESVS VVHereas now some monthes are ouer-passed since my conformitie to the Church of England wherof I haue hitherto beene silent withdrawing myselfe to further the contemplation of those inducements which lead mee hereunto my zeale of truth and knowledge of your great spiritual miseries who liue wrapped in a cloud of ignorance depriued of the most comfortable beames of true Christian faith working by the heate of charitie in mens soules enforceth me to dedicate these my doctrinall and morall obseruations vnto your selues as standing in most need of them My intention in dedicating them to you is no other then true compassion of your soules dangerous estate not seeing nor knowing your owne erroneous doctrines taught in the present Romane Church of which I dare say many of you are sincere zealous professors with onely regard to your soules health and the kingdome of heauen esteeming that aboue all things to bee the cheifest to bee sought for in this world is in truth it is and therefore your case the more worthie of Christian commiseration and true Apostolicall endeauours for your deliuerie out of your so perillous and lamentable a condition which according to the small portion of that talent that Almightie God hath vouchsafed to bestow vpon mee I haue endeuoured to shew vnto you by this Treatise desiring you curteously and charitably to accept in good part with no lesse humility and care of your owne soules good then I do present it vnto you with a sincere desire thereof in the most tender bowels of Christ Iesus Vouchsafe to reade it with deliberate iudgement examine well the spirit wherewith it is written weigh the substance and contents rather then the manner or circumstances of my writing the stile is but plaine and familiar you shall find no affectation of eloquence in it because my labours and paines taken herein haue been rather for the profit of your soules then for the recreation of your wits I know well that neither the planting of Saint Paul nor the watring of Apollo can redound to your profit vnlesse God giue encrease and prosper the successe and therefore leauing the encrease to God and desiring you most attentiuely to reade these my obseruations deliberately to ponder them and effectually to follow them I most kindly take my leaue of you with Saint Pauls charitable words Pax Dei quae exuperat omnem sensum custodiat corda vestra intelligentias vestras in Christo Iesu Philip. 4.7 The peace of God which passeth all vnderstanding keepe your hearts and intelligences in Christ Iesus Resting this 13. day of Iune Anno Domini 1612. A most zealous friend and louer of your soules IOHN COPLEY ¶ Aduertisements to the Reader ALbeit to my singular comfort Christian Reader I might in the Sunne-shine of mine owne happinesse haue enioyed to my selfe the great benefite of Gods fauour shewed mee in my conuersion from Romish nouelties to the ancient Catholike Faith taught in this Kingdome yet for that I had diuers reasons inuiting mee to the participation thereof vnto other mens knowledge that what was priuate to my selfe might be also a publique good vnto others I haue thought it expedient with the promulgation of it for thy better information concerning my selfe to propound vnto thee some particular Aduertisements whereby thou mayest the better know mee and my meaning who am otherwise perhappes vnknowne vnto thee and accordingly with moderation of iudgement void of impatient humour or partialitie censure my proceedings in the matters handled in this Treatise 2 First therefore I would haue thee take notice that some few more zealous and earnest than charitable or wise followers of the Church of Rome sticke not to obiect vnto mee That they cannot be perswaded that I am truly in iudgement vnderstanding a sincere Professor of the faith of England otherwise than for some priuate respect eyther of liberty or other contentment or preferment whereby you may well inferre that they haue no great opinion of any ignorance in me of their Doctrine nor of actual miscarriage in maners that should make me forsake their communion since they thinke I haue too much knowledge to be in heart of any other and yet can charge mee of no misdemeanour for mine owne part I must needes tell you that herein they are either very ignorant in their vnderstandings or malitiously affected in their willes ignorant of the true knowledge of Gods fauour in conuerting sinners and malitious to the Church of England whereunto I haue incorporated my selfe and therefore to disgrace it they are willing without either true vnderstanding or vertue to cast any sinister imputation they can vpon my person which I doubt not but by Gods assistance and the endeuors of patience and diligence I shall turne to their owne shame and to the further manifestation of the wicked doctrines and impieties of their Romish Church without any indignitie or disgrace to the Church to which I am now incorporated 3 Secondly I would further haue thee know that some few Priests of their Church hauing growne debauched in their liues and conuersations and after their forsaking communion with the Church of Rome for a cloake of liberty to their lewd inclinations haue proued most treacherous to those vnto whom before they professed friendship remaining in their owne consciences perswaded they did not well in discouering Priests and causing them to be apprehended and ransacking the houses of Recusants more for their own profits than for any desire of seruice to the state or zeale to the Church of England giuing ouer all exercise both of vertue or learning fit for Cleargy men Hereupon diuers of the Romaine Church haue made their aduantage for the iustification of their owne Religion and reproofe of theyr aduersaries faith insomuch that I heard a Iesuit of good reputation say that a great noble man of this realme being in conference with others of his rancke should say that he much wondred why such men as were vertuous in their cariages so long as they were
of the Church of Rome when they came to the Church of England they prooued dissolute of life most licentious in their conuersations whereas such as went from the Church of England to the church of Rome though they were neuer so disorderly before they afterward were reformed in their conuersations and most religiously exemplar in their behauiours Now therefore to shew that this obseruation proueth not alwayes so and that those of the English Church might not bee deceiued with this illusion of the Diuell you may from me take notice that it hath pleased almighty God heretofore to cōuert diuerse who haue liued with good fame in the Church of England and of late one master Richard Sheldon whose both learning vertuous conuersation euen in the Church of Rome hath beene such as is vnimpeachable by any of his Aduersaries as farre forth as euer I could heare and so still manifesteth as much in religious zeale to the Church of England and for mine owne part I can boldly say that I find as good curbes by the Doctrine of the Church of England to keepe men from sinne as in the Church of Rome by vertue whereof I doubt not but with Gods assistance I shall liue to serue him in this Church with lesse sinne than euer I could haue done in the Church of Rome 4 Thirdly I must giue you further notice that it is a thing wel knowne that there are in this realme many dissembling Protestants which outwardly doe all the acts of Religion belonging to this Church of England either to stay in their places in the common-wealth or to anoyde their penall lawes and yet in their hearts are resolued beleeuers of the Roman Faith egregiously dissembling both with God and men and practising most notorious equiuocation aswell in matters of faith as manners who will not sticke to take oathes receiue Sacraments go to Church and commit many a like act directly against their consciences perswasion which according to Saint Paul is sinne Rom. 14. vers 23 nay I dare affirme that it is a hainous mortall sinne approaching neare to that sinne against which Christ himselfe pronounceth a dangerous threatning ful of terror to any considerat heart saying That he that sinneth against the holy Ghost shall neuer be forgiuen Luc. 12. vers 10. neither in this world neither in the world to come Whence it may appeare that such men as they are most treacherous to God so may it be probably thought they cannot be loyall vnto men and therefore are they to bee held the most dangerous men that can be in any Common-wealth preferring the glorie of men before the glorie of God which being a thing much practised by some affected to the Church of Rome I haue beene the more willing both for their better information to publish these my obseruations as also to giue satisfaction to the Church of England concerning my selfe who am I thanke God most free from so hatefull a crime odious both to God and man 5. Fourthly I am further to let you vnderstand that my intention in these my Obseruations being more for the instruction of the Professors of the Church of Rome than for those of the Church of England who stand in no neede of so meane a scholler as my selfe I haue cited often the Authors of that Church euen against themselues thinking no way better to confute their Doctrines than by their owne grounds and their owne Teachers And although I handle not all points controuersed betwixt Rome and the reformed Churches at this day yet doe I so entreat of the chiefest points of Practise and Doctrine that all those being discouered to be but erronious and nouell and such as cannot stand with the true grounds of Christianitie I thinke there is no man of sound iudgement can thinke I had iust cause to stay any longer in that Church or that themselues can be partakers of Saluation remaining in the same 6. Fifthly my further desire is that thou who vouchsafest to be the Reader of these my vnpolished lines wilt with as fauourable a minde entertaine them for thy profit as I out of charitable affection to Gods seruants doe most freely publish them to the world desiring Almightie God to giue thee grace to reade them with due attention and to ruminate vpon them with mature deliberation laying aside all partialitie in thy censures or inordinate desire of any curious nouelties my resolution in the writing of them being more for the profit and spirituall good of others than for any purchase either of praise or estimation to my selfe desiring that the naked truth set forth without any colours of art or elocution may shew it owne power and force to preuaile against falshood And so wishing you all happinesse both temporall and eternall I leaue thee to the protection on of Almightie God Yours zealously affected in Christ Iesus I. C. A table of all the matters contained in this booke of Doctrinall and Morall Obseruations CHAP. I. COntaineth the first obseruation shewing the reasons of this Treatise Fol. 1. Chap. 2. Containeth an obseruation of Gods prouidence in ministring occasions of times places and persons concurring to the Authours conuersion Fol. 15. Chap. 3. Containeth the first fundamentall obseruation of the end of man and his chiefe happinesse Fol. 26. Chap. 4. Containeth the second fundamentall obseruation of the supernaturall and reuealed knowledge which is necessarie to saluation Fol. 30. Chap. 5. Containeth the third fundamentall obseruation about the absolute necessitie of supernaturall faith Fol. 34. Chap. 6. Containeth the fourth fundamentall obseruation about the rule and straight mete-wand of the true Christian Faith Fol. 38. Chap. 7. Containeth the fift fundamentall obseruation how the Ministerie of the true Church of Christ is the meanes of teaching the true sense and vnderstanding of Scriptures where and when it hath a visible externall gouernement Fol. 52. Chap. 8. Containeth the sixt fundamentall obseruation how that conformitie of doctrine with the ancient doctrine of the primitiue Church may be a good meanes in these latter ages to know the true Church of Christ Fol. 55. Chap. 9. Containeth an obseruation of the wonders and supposed Miracles which as Christ hath fore-told the Pseudo-Christs and false Prophets shall doe for the seducing of Gods Elect if it were possible Fol. 72. Chap. 10. Containeth an obseruation of the great hypocrisie of false teachers fore-spoken of in the holy Scriptures Fol. 100. Chap. 11. Containeth an obseruation of the fruits by which false Prophets are to be knowne and discerned Fol. 113. Chap. 12. Containeth an obseruation about the Sacrifice of the Masse which is accompted by the Church of Rome the chiefest act of Religion that can be done to God Fol. 133. Chap. 13. Containeth an obseruation about the doctrine of Transubstantiation which is a principall noueltie taught in the Church of Rome Fol. 160. Chap. 14. Containeth an obseruation about the Sacrament ministred but vnder one kind to Lay-people in the Church
of Rome Fol. 171. Chap. 15. Containeth an obseruation of the Pardons and Indulgences which the Pope annexeth to Crosses Graines and Meddalls Fol. 180. Chap. 16. Containeth an obseruation about the number of seuen Sacraments admitted by the Church of Rome Fol. 189. Chap. 17. Containeth an obseruation about the doctrine of the Virgine Maries conception in originall sinne Fol. 206. Chap. 18. Containeth an obseruation of the honorable state of Marriage prohibited by the Church of Rome to Priests who by Gods law may lawfully liue in it and allowed to those who by Gods law can not liue together without Incest Fol. 214. Chap. 19. Containeth the Conclusion to the Reader with a recapitulation of all the precedent obseruations for the Readers profit Fol. 213. DOCTRINALL and Morall Obseruations concerning Religion CHAP. I. Containing the first obseruation shewing the reasons and occasions of this Treatise AMONGST all the things which draw men into admiration Great is the benefit of true conuersion because it manifesteth the power of God and which doe see me to happen contrarie vnto common course and order worthily may the conuersion of soules from the waies of sinne and iniquitie chalenge the first place and is to be esteemed as the greatest for this is the most excellent worke the Heauens doth affoord vs and the most wonderfull that the infinite power of God infinitely powerfull can performe This the prime Doctor of the Romane Church most clearely intimateth Tho. Aquin. 12. q. 113. saying Maximum opus Dei est iustificatio impij The iustification of a sinner is the greatest worke of God according to that of the Kingly Prophet Miserationes eius super omnia opera eius Psal 144. vers 9. his mercies are aboue all his workes yea and the Church of Rome to keepe fresh the memorie of this document prayeth to God yearely in these words Deus qui omnipetentiam tuam parcendo miserando maxime manifestas In Dom. 20. post Pent. O God that by pardon and mercie chiefely manifestest thy Almightie power Which veritie also S. Augustine confirmeth saying vpon those words of S. Iohn Greater workes than these shall he doe Ioh. 14. v. 12. August tract 72. in Ioh. post Med. tom 9. Maius opus est vt ex impio iustus fiat quam creare coelum terram it is a greater worke for a sinner to be made righteous than to create heauen and earth This though it seeme a paradox is most true for certainely albeit the creation of the world was a maruellous worke yet the iustification and conuersion of a sinner is much fuller of admiration God framed and moulded the world almost in a moment of time and brought foorth all creatures in a short time as it were into the field but to abolish the turpitude and foulenesse of onely one originall sinne he vsed the delay of fiue thousand yeares and to bring this worke to perfection his onely sonne Christ Iesus endured three and thirtie yeares exile from his heauenly Kingdome For the worke of creation God did but speake Psal 148. vers 5. Dixit facta sunt but for this other worke Christ was to suffer and die Oportebat Christum pati Luk. 24. vers 16. ita intrare in gloriam suam it was behoofefull for Christ to die and so to enter into his glorie therefore Saint Augustines sentence of true conuerts is to be noted Augustin in Sermon saying Conuersio ad bonum non homini sed Deo adscribenda the conuersion of a sinner vnto good is not to be ascribed vnto man but vnto God who of himselfe can doe all things by his power 2 Now verily as iustification and remission of sinnes is the greatest worke of God Great also because it manifesteth the glorie and wisdome of God manifesting his infinite power and mercie so neither is there any worke of his more forcible to set out his glorie and wisedome vnto the world than the same It is a glorie vnto the artificer to delineate most perfect colours of Emblemes vpon base yron and hard steele The skill also of the Physitian is praise-worthie when hee freeth one from danger that is poysoned and swolne by the biting of a Viper with a present Antidote so the glorie of God and his goodnesse chiefely shineth in the conuersion of sinners So it shined in Saint Paule the Apostle when hee being infected with the poyson of infidelitie and swolne therewith Spirans minarum caedis Actor 9. vers 1. breathing forth threatnings and slaughter against the Disciples of the Lord Christ appearing verie oportunely vnto him cured him and strengthened him in faith Hereby appeareth the frailtie of humane nature and the power of Gods grace which redoundeth much vnto the glorie of his Saints whilest calling vnto their remembrance their passed dangers they behold their happie securitie of present glorie euen as the Mariner after the danger of shipwracke reioyceth as a sicke person reioyceth after therecouerie of a perillous disease and as conquering souldiors triumph and glorie the more in their victories by how much their hazards and encounters were strong This Saint Augustine teacheth most elegantly saying Nimis exultant Sancti dum praeteriti periculi memores dicunt 4 Confess cap 3. dextra Domini fecit virtutem dextra Domini exaltauit me the Saints doe verie much reioyce when mindfull of passed danger they say the right hand of the Lord hath done his power the right hand of the Lord hath exalted me So did Saint Paule reioyce when of a persecutor he was made a vessell of election So also Saint Mathew when of a Customer he was made an Euangelist So Saint Marie Magdalene when from being a vessell of contumelie and disgrace shee was translated into a vessell of glorie So Saint Peter when after the denying of his Master he was made a constant pillar of truth by his personall perseuerance in faith obtained him by Christs prayer who said Ego rogani pro te Petre Luke 22.32 vt non deficiat fides tua I haue prayed for thee Peter that thy faith faile not 3 The obseruation hereof gentle Reader maketh mee truly to discouer An acknowledgement of the benefit of conuersion as the case standeth the obligation I am bound in to God for Almightie God of his infinite goodnesse and out of the vnexhausted riches of his mercie hauing blessed my soule with a true and vnfained conuersion from the superstitious idolatrous and hereticall religion of the Romane Church vnto the perfect knowledge and practise of the Religion established in this Realme touching that faith which is conformable to that which was taught by the Ancient Primitiue Apostolike and Catholike Church which is maintained and defended by his Maiestie with whom I may presume boldly to say maugre all the Church of Rome I will neuer be ashamed to render an account of my profession Praemonit to all Christian Monarchs and of that hope that
is in me as the Apostle prescribeth Hauing I say beene made partaker of this benefit onely through Gods working in my soule as I can doe no lesse in the dutie of gratitude than to manifest the same vnto you so must it be a part of my care not onely to acknowledge the same my selfe but to be an occasion that others may partake of the like blessing with me who liue blinded with the same vaile of errors and hereticall inuentions as I did till it pleased God to draw away that darke curtaine of implicite faith viz. that the Romane Church is the true Church of God from mine eyes and to giue me grace clearely to behold the explicite nouelties strongly and cunningly maintained therein which enforceth me now to make the confession of my faith saying no longer the Creede of Rome made by the Pope and recorded in the Councell of Trent but with his Maiestie Praemonit fol 35. I am such a Catholike Christian as beleeueth the three Creedes that of the Apostles that of the Councell of Nice and that of Athanasius c. I also acknowledge for Orthodox all those other formes of Creedes that either were deuised by Councels or particular Fathers against such particular Heresies as most raigned in their times I reuerence and admit the foure first generall Councels as Catholike and Orthodox c. I also concerning the Fathers hold as his Maiestie doth the Scriptures also I beleeue as for the Apocripha I hold them in the same account that the Ancients did c. And so of the other points of doctrine according to the most iudicious profession which his Highnesse in the Church of England maketh doe I beleeue 4 Here at I know gentle Reader thou maiest much maruaile God the cause of my conuersion that I who was borne of such parents as professed the Romane faith and lost much of their temporall estate diuers yeares together for the same who haue beene trained vp therein from my youth who haue practised the function of my Priesthood these nine yeares according to the fashion of that Church who haue beene readie and prompt in ministring their Sacraments in preaching their Doctrine in offering their Sacrifices who dedicated my life and labors most willingly for the aduancement of that faith who am allied to diuers of the better sort of England professing that religion who was befriended of many and to my knowledge hated of none should quit alliance with that Church and take acquaintance with this of England where I haue scarce any acquaintance at all What should cause such a change I answer thee gentle Reader that my desire is thou shouldest be rightly informed assured thereof then say with me as I say most sincerely with inexplicable ioy to mine own soule This is a change of the right hand of the highest Psal 76. vers 11. And for this cause doe I here present vnto you the obseruations both of doctrine manners which haue caused this my vnexpected change and heauenly metamorphosis not engendred by anie wauering disposition or inordinate passion too often seene in trouble some times but begun and effected with mature and ripe deliberation reason and knowledge most orderly drawing the chariot of my will and affections vnto the loue of truth and dislike of falsehood and therefore a worke as I hope wrought by the onely strong hand of God long inuiting and leading my soule hereunto and often displaying the bright beames of his extraordinarie grace most efficaciously enforcing me thereunto after many great conflicts and combats within my selfe in which conuersion of mine though some reioyce yet others out of rash iudgement and indiscreet passion and their implacable hatred to the Church of England ioyned with extreame ignorance and that by the deceitfull ground of their implicite faith and beliefe of whatsoeuer the Church of Rome teacheth not considering the defection and Apostasie of faith foretold by our Sauiour himselfe in the Scriptures vnder the parable of cockle and tares Matth. 13. vers 25. of heresies and nouelties ouersowed by the enemie man after the sowing of the good seed when all were asleepe doe labour by all meanes to obscure and endarken with vntrue reports and most vnconscionable calumniations some giuing oute that I was euer of a presumptuous spirit but they are such as haue against all conscience and good nature most vnnaturally wronged mee as diuers of the best Papists haue heretofore iudged and can yet witnesse Others that I am bereaued of my right wits and assuredly distracted in minde but they I presume are such as either know me not or else such as thinke there can be no greater madnes than to forsake the Church of Rome out of a misconceited persuasion they haue that truth is on their side whereof they haue such a preiudicate opinion without knowledge that they will not sticke to say that should they abandon the Romane faith they would sooner become Turkes than Protestants Others that I am drawne either by the desire of worldly libertie and preferments or by some carnall allurements to performe the will and desires of the flesh against all which vnchristian suggestions although I could in respect of my selfe with the buckler and safegard of patience and silence possesse mine owne soule in quietnesse and comfort knowing that the greatest temporall happinesse of a Christian is the testimonie of a good conscience yet notwithstanding for that my conscience giueth euidence that by them Gods singular mercie and prouidence most clearely shining in my conuersion should be eclipsed and his glorie most iniuriously wronged and many ouer-credulous spirits too too much abused I can doe no lesse in my thankfull dutie for so singular a receiued benefit than to illustrate the same to the eyes of the world that all seeing it Gods holy name may be glorified herein and others that walke awry be inuited and edified by my example which I cannot better performe then by giuing publike testimonie to the world in writing of the true occasions meanes and motiues of my conuersion as by these my doctrinall and morall obseruations I trust through Gods grace I shall performe 5 The truth is and I cannot denie it The difficulties of my conuersion that this my change and conuersion from the faith of Rome to the faith of England was euen beset with manifold difficulties oppositions barres and obstacles long hindering delaying this worke which consisting of the inward act of resolution in the soule strengthened by Gods especiall grace with comfort Tho. Aq. 12. q. Cxiij art 7. at length was performed in an instant For first it is wel knowne I was armed against it by my continuall education and example of my parents in the doctrine and practise of the Romane faith which I was persuaded to haue been Catholike Education one let euen from my first yeares of vnderstanding for common experience sheweth that of the Poet to be most true Quo semel est
light to deceiue my soule withall and so I confessed them as ordinarie temptations against faith till at length with a more powerfull light it pleased the true Sonne of iustice and God of glorie to enlighten my vnderstanding in such sort that all the clouds of error and endarkened affections were dispersed like mist before the Sunne what before I held to be hereticall I approued to be most Catholike what before was falsehood was now truth what before was darknesse was now light I found my selfe suddainely in my meditations vpon the grounds of true faith and beleefe like S. Paul enuironed not with a corporall but with a spirituall and most comfortable light from heauen placing my vnderstanding in the paradise of truth and all her delights struck downe to the ground in the humble acknowledgement of mine vnworthinesse and terrified with a voice from heauen not sounding in the eares of my bodie by their corporall Organs but sweetly making a most delightfull harmonie in my soule mollifying the obdurate crust of my heart and forcing me to say Act. 9. vers 6. Domine quid me vis facere O Lord what wilt thou haue me to doe with perfect true conformitie of all my thoughts actions and endeauors answerable to his will Hence was I moued with great power working euen with comfort to my soule to call to mind innumerable passages of Scriptures and auncient Fathers in former times obserued and other reasonable congruencies moouing me most effectually to conuert my selfe to the onely Apostolike Primitiue and Catholike faith truly professed in the Church of England as it were destined hereunto by a presage in my youth when being borne beyond the seas I was by Gods directing prouidence inspiring my parents mindes by my nurse and her husband who were purposely sent for out of England sent into this Realme when I was but few daies old to be nursed here which was a great furtherance and meanes that now in the ninth yeare of my Priesthood I am in this Realme nursed and growne to such a spirituall strength as to embrace the right faith of a true Christian which heretofore I wanted And although lately since my conuersion one said vnto me that it had been better if I had been drowned at sea in the great storme which happened in my passage into this Realme so young which I escaped with exceeding great danger being forthwith entertained into the Castle by the Captaine thereof for my fathers sake than at riper yeares thus to liue an Apostata and to be a scandale vnto the Church of God Yet I trust that I shall make it apparant that it was much better I escaped Gods prouidence in the first escape of my bodie foreshewing a more dangerous second escape from the shipwracke of my soule whereby his glorie in my happinesse may be manifested to the good of many that they may truly say Exod. 1. vers 19. Digitus Dei est hic the finger of God is here 7. The working of the Trinitie in my conuersion the first cause of this treatise Hereby you may see courteous Reader whether I haue not iust cause to make knowne to the world this my conuersion and the true occasions and motiues thereof that all that beare of it may say as I haue cause to say in mine owne soule The finger of God is here For first you may obserue that whilest I wandered out of the right way of true Catholike doctrine Gods goodnesse following the Church of Rome the finger of Gods mercie and goodnesse directed and pointed me which way to take into the right path of heauen most fauorably bestowing vpon me beartie contrition for my former errors both in faith and manners more than euer before Secondly the finger of his wisdome Gods wisdome euen when I was most addicted to the studies of the Roman doctrine occasion being giuen me of conference with some Protestants requiring satisfaction of me in some capitall points of controuersie which I promised either to proue by the Scriptures ancient Fathers and naturall reason or else to embrace the Protestants faith as Catholike therewithall intending to impugne the doctrine of the Religion here professed in England directed my vnderstanding so to examine the controuersies weighing all Cardinall Bellarmines reasons for both sides that doing it with sinceritie I fell into such doctrinall and morall obseruations vpon the grounds of the Romane faith that I most cleerely discouered the darke clouds of error and ignorance wherewith my iudgement and reason were ouercast I found the weakenesse of their grounds the fallacies of their reasons and the insufficiencie of iudgement shewed in most of their controuersies I found many places of Scripture impertinently alledged diuers citations of auncient Fathers fondly wrested against their true vnderstanding many naturall reasons alledged most repugnant to reason Lastly the finger of his Almightie power Gods power as efficaciously as the Load stone draweth yron vnto it drew all the affections of my heart to a firme resolution no longer to sleepe or slumber in my errors but to breake off all the bands of erronious and superstitious doctrine and nouelties wherewith the present Church of Rome holdeth soules in slauerie to Sathan and to embrace the truth of the Ancient Catholike and Apostolike doctrine which I found to bee most purely taught in the Church of England according to the primitiue sinceritie Hence it is most cleerely apparant how much the glorie of God appeareth in my conuersion and the three diuine attributes of goodnesse wisedome and power of the blessed Trinitie Qui tribus digitis appendit molem terrae Esay 40. vers 12 who weighteth the earth with three fingers in the contemplation of which great benefit I may well crie out with holy Saint Paul Rom. 12. vers 33 O the depth of the riches both of the wisdome and knowledge of God how vnsearchable are his iudgements and his waies past finding out for who hath knowne the mind of the Lord or who hath bin his counsellor Or who hath first giuen to him and it shall be recompenced vnto him againe for of him and through him and to him are all things to whom be glorie for euer For to God himselfe must I needes attribute this fauour hauing iust cause for the same with the kingly Prophet to say Psal 34. vers 2. I will alwaies praise the Lord his praise shall be alwaies in my mouth who chiefly hath wrought in my soule the vnderstanding the will and the accomplishment hereof which I can doe no lesse in gratitude than make knowne that his name may be glorified therein Satisfaction the second cause Secondly if my blinded zeale of your soules good did so much transport me in my ignorance and errors as to imploy my best endeuours yea and to venter my life for your good and for the reducing of any in this Realme to the pretended Catholike faith which then I professed without feare of incurring
Christian Princes After this I fell by a meere chance vpon the booke of the now Lord of Canterburies written in confutation of some of Master Doctor Hilles quarterne of reasons Next met I with the Bishop of Lincolnes answere to Parsons with some others All which I perused diligently and with great attention in which writings although some doctrinall points much distasted my palate by reason of my setled affection to the Romane faith yet I found many points both doctrinall and morall verie remarkable and powerfull to moue strong doubtes had I not by the implicite faith of whatsoeuer the Romane Church teacheth folued them all and so consequently held them as matters of scandall and temptation the first of which ought not to moue a setled constancie nor the second to finde any entertainment but euen at the verie first occurrence to be reiected yet notwithstanding at the last reflecting vpon many former obseruations I conceiued that ground of implicite faith to be subiect to the daunger of errour and held it fit to examine verie diligently the groundes of the true Church especially for a Cleargie-man who is to yeelde a reason of his faith and to giue satisfaction vnto others and chiefely in such times as the question is to be discussed which is the true Church a man ought to heare to beleeue and to follow if hee will not be esteemed as a Heathen and Publicane Then began I to reflect more seriously vpon the former points and to grow very familiar with the aforesaid bookes and with much stay to examine the reasons and solutions of Cardinall Bellarmine to his aduersaries in the chiefest points of Doctrine now controuerted where finding manie friuolous arguments and idle solutions I grew into much greater care to discusse matters than euer before least whilest I thought to goe the right way to Heauen and to lead others thither wee went both blindfolded to hell 6 Next vnto this occasion happened another The powder-treason another occasion and that was the most vnmatched Pouder-treason as I thinke the most odious conspiracie that euer was inuented or intended by the braine of man the hatefull memorie whereof will proue euerlastingly to all posteritie a spot indelible not onely to the actors but also to all that shall maintaine approue and allow of the same wishing it had had the intended effect acknowledging no other faultinesse therein but the want of that successe which no honest or good Christian minde could euer endure This was so great a scandale to many that had they not beene otherwise confirmed in the faith of Rome they would forthwith haue abiured it and for my selfe in particular when I heard the names read in the proclamation of those who were the chiefe agents therein I stood amazed fearing that it had beene approued by the Pope vnder-hand because I thought if Garnet Gerralde and Greeneway were either agents or concealers thereof the prouidence of the Iesuites was such that they would neuer whatsoeuer they thought in their iudgements of the lawfulnesse thereof haue giuen consent thereunto without the approbation of higher authoritie and my conclusion in iudgement was that if euer I could be assured that the Pope allowed by any conniuencie whatsoeuer of the fact I should therein rather acknowledge him to be the Vicar of hell than the Vice-gerent of Christ And further I was much more amated when I heard that Garnet should acknowledge himselfe to haue heard of it in Sacramentall confession and yet to conceale it from the State and to denise no means or way to discouer the fact without opening himselfe or his penitent which the doctrine of his owne Church obliged him vnto Siluest verbo Confessio §. 3. num 2. prope finem Emanuel Sa Aphoris verbo Confessor S. Thom. addit q. 1. de sigill confes art 1. id primum circa finem colligitur a simili for the auoidance of so publike a harme at least in generall this made me very much to suspect that in his iudgement he approued it whatsoeuer he pretended to the contrarie For though he had made conscience to haue reuealed his penitent yet stood he bound in charitie and iustice to haue reuealed so much in generall by some way or other as sufficient notice might haue been giuen to auoid the publike harme and desolation that should haue ensued to the State thereby which no doubt he might haue done if hee had would by some meanes or other Besides another thing which bred a great maruaile in me was The Pope exalted him soon after to the dignity of Poenitentiarius in Rome that the Pope himselfe did neither chastise Greenway for the same considering the euidence giuen by his brother Garnet no nor so much as far as euer I could vnderstand as giue any publike intimation of dislike of that hatefull designement which he might haue done by either of his Breues to the comfort and satisfaction of his children here in England and chiefely to the State who for his silence therein haue iust cause to suspect that he either winked at it in secret before hand or at least after the successe thereof would haue ratified it for the most heroicall stratageme that euer Catholikes performed and haue placed him in the Calender of his famousest Martyrs as M. Wilson hath alreadie done of Garnet and Owldcorne in his English Martyrologe who as the head Iesuit hath reported fathereth vpon himselfe that most infamous libell called Pruritanus a booke so full of blasphemous application of Gods sacred word so vnrespectiue to his Maiestie so iniurious to the State and so enterlaced with lasciuious and beastly scurrilitie that it would shame any honest man to be esteemed the author thereof therefore the Iesuites doe deale politikely in ascribing it to a secular Priest to make the secular Clergie as odious to the State as themselues since it is well knowne and that not to a few that the first inuenter of the greatest part of that booke was a faire young Iesuit sometimes a student in the Vniuersitie of Louaine who sent his first inuentions thereof to Parsons and others at Rome who made themselues full merrie with them and well approued them insomuch that father Talbot the Master of the Nouices ingeniously confessed that the reading of some of them caused him much to be distracted in his prayers and it is to be thought that that Iesuit who may best chalenge the first inuention of that libelling art when he shall come to read his Breuiarie by the memorie of them he will offer vp a very vnsauorie incense in the sight of God at these words Et dixit omnis populus fiat fiat and will proue such a merrie mad petitioner as will make all the black guard of hell attending him to dance for ioy But to returne to the consideration of the treason when I arriued beyond the seas and heard some to tearme it but an inconsiderate act as though the substance of the designement were not faultie
some kind of guidance vnto the true Church In the serious contemplation of which point I thought that the most assured course I could take herein was to lay downe such a direction as is approued both by the Church of England and by the Church of Rome and truly to examine some principall points of doctrine in question betweene the English and Romane Church by this meanes of triall whereunto if I should find either the first agreeable or the second disagreeable I resolued that I might haue a strong inducement to conclude which was the true Church of Christ and which the false whose doctrine might be esteemed Christian and whose doctrine Antichristian 2 By which inducement I was the more earnestly moued to make triall then by any other It is approued by Fathers for that I found the ancient Fathers very frequent in giuing of this marke of antiquitie for Tertullian saith By the order it selfe Lib. de praescrip aduers Her that is made manifest to be of our Lord and true which is first deliuered and that externe and false which is sent in afterward And in another place writing against Marcion he saith Lib contra Marcion I affirme that my Gospell is true Marcion saith as much for his who shall determine this controuersie betwixt vs but the difference of time prescribing authoritie to that doctrine which shall be found more ancient and adiudging corruption to that which shall be conuinced to be the later Saint Gregorie Nazianzen vrgeth the Apolinaristes thus Greg. Naz. epist 2. ad Cledonium Hieron epist ad Pamach Ocean de errori bus Origenist Hieron contra Luciferianos If the faith began but thirtie yeares since whereas there be almost foure hundred years from the manifestation of Christ certainly both our Gospell and faith were vaine and void for this long time And Saint Hierome questioneth with the Origenists of his time after this manner Why goest thou about after foure hundred yeares to teach vs that which wee knew not before The Christian world was without this doctrine vntill this day And against the Luciferians he saith I will declare vnto thee my opinion briefly and plainly we must remaine in the Church which being founded by the Apostles hath endured to this day and all others euen in this that they were instituted after shew themselues to be Heretikes Vincent Lyrinens in cap. 26. 27. With which Fathers Vincentius Lyrinensis accordeth when explicating that of Saint Paul O Timothie keep that which hath bin left vnto thee He saith This depositum is that which hath been committed to thee not which hath been inuented by thee that which thou hast receiued not that which thou hast deuised a thing brought vnto thee not vttered by thee in which thou must not be an author but a keeper not an instructer but a follower not a leader but one that is directed Now therefore thus finding so many ancient Fathers making antiquitie a neere adiunct vnto Catholike and Orthodox truth and noueltie to be the vsuall badge of Herretikes I began with great diligence and care to examine two maine points of religion now controuerted and much disputed on as well by the most learned of the English as of the Romane Church viz. of the doctrine of iustification by faith alone and of the imperfection of our good workes that being according to knowledge grounded in religion my zeale therein might be the greater and my assurednesse of a sound ground cause me to stand the more strongly and to labour in others spiritual profit with the greater constancy and courage as since it hath succeeded through Gods especiall grace to the vnspeakable comfort of my soule affording me grace and abilitie of bodie to performe this so profitable a worke begun and ended by him whom I do most humblie desire to be the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of all my endeuours 3 Now as I proceeded on further by degrees Antiquitie a good way of triall to compare the doctrine of the Church of England and that of Rome concerning the two points aboue specified with the doctrine of the ancient Church by this meanes of antiquitie I found the doctrines of iustification by faith only and of the imperfection and demerit of good workes as they are taught in the present Church of England most deseruedly to claime the priuiledge of antiquitie as taught by many both Latine and Creeke Fathers Iustification by faith alone proued by Greeke Fathers Ses 6. Can. 9. Origen lib. 3. Rom. 3. notwithstanding that the Church of Rome accurseth al that hold the contrarie in expresse termes saying If any shall say that a wicked man may be iustified by faith alone c. let him be accursed Against which definitiue sentence of the Councell of Trent I find first of the Greeke Fathers Origen to be most cleare who vpon those words of Saint Paul to the Romans We therefore thinke that man is iustified by faith without the workes of the law writeth thus The Apostle in these words saith that iustification by faith alone sufficeth so that a man onely beseeuing is iustified although he performe no worke And if an example be required who was euer that without good workes was iustified by faith alone I think that thiefe may suffice who crucified with Christ cried vnto him on the crosse Lord Iesus remember me when thou shalt come into thy kingdome Neit her is there any good worke of his described in the Cospell But for this faith alone Iesus saith vnto him Amen I say vnto thee This day thou shalt be with me in Paradise This thiefe therefore is iust fied by faith without the workes of the law because the Lord did not aske what worke hee did first neither did he expect what worke hee had done when he belieued but being iustified by faith alone when he was to enter into Paradise he tooke him for his companion and it is related in the Gospell according to Saint Luke vnto the woman without any worke of the law and for faith alone hee said thy sinnes are forgiuen thee And againe Thy faith hath made thee safe goe in peace And in many places of the Gospell wee reade that our Sauiour vsed this speech to shew that the faith of the beleeuer is the cause of his saluation Hitherto Origen Neither is Saint Basil of other opinion who writeth thus The Apostle saith Basil cōcione dehumilit he that reioyceth let him reioyce in the Lord saying that Christ is made vnto vs from God Wisedome Iustice Sanctification and Redemption that as it is written he that is to reioyce let him reioyce in the Lord for this is perfect and entire reioycing in God when a man is not exalted for his owne righteousnesse but acknowledgeth true righteousnesse to bee wanting in him and to bee iustified by faith alone in Christ And Paul reioyceth in that he despiseth his owne righteousnes and in that by
Rome tending to presumption in good workes and to shew the imperfection of the best of them in respect of our selues yet doth it not follow that good workes are not necessarie to saluation Why are good workes necessarie for they are necessarie for diuers other respects First that our workes may giue testimonie of our faith that by them as by the fruits our faith may bee knowne because that without them faith is dead Jac. 2.18 2. Pet. 1.8 Secondly that wee may be certaine and confirmed of our election and saluation for workes Ibid. though they bee not the causes yet they are the way to saluation Thirdly that our faith may be exercised nourished confirmed 2. Tim. 1.6 2. Pet. 1.8 and promoted Fourthly that wee auoide temporall and eternall paines which God threateneth to inflict vpon transgressors of the Law Fifthly Rom. 8.13 2. Thes 4.6 that our liues may answere our professions for if we be children of light it is behoofefull for vs to walke like children of light Sixtly that not doing euill wee may not contristate the holy Ghost 2. Cor. 5.15 Philip. 2.15 1. Thes 5.19 but that wee may obtaine both temporall and spirituall rewards which God hath promised to those that doe well Seuenthly that they may be done for the good of others 1. Tim. 4.8 Psal 5. v. vlt. that the good may be edified by our example and that we may not giue a scandale to those that are without that by our holy liues as much as lyeth in vs we may gaine others 2. Cor. 6.3 1. Pet. 2.22 and by doing good we may put the wicked to shame and that wee may stop the mouthes of calumniators 2. Pet. 2.12 3 for our workes 16. ad Tit. 2.58 though they are vnperfect yet are they gratefull vnto God not for any perfection or dignitie in them but because they are of the holy Ghost in vs and of faith which purifieth our hearts because all their imperfection is pardoned couered Psal 32.2 and not imputed 13 Hence I obserue How faith and good workes may goe together that a iustifying faith and good workes may goe together the first as the cause the other as the effects and therefore considering the true nature of a good Christian hauing that faith which worketh by charitie my thinkes I behold him in the mysterious vision which the Prophet Ezechiel beheld of the foure beasts Ezech. 1 10. neere the riuer Chobar flying vp to heauen with wings and hands vnder the wings who amounting to heauen according to the number of wings had also sixteene hands which they made-shew of as it were to insinuate that they did not onely amount vp by the helpes of their wings but also by the strength and force of their hands which being vnder their wings moued and supported them For herein I behold a proper resemblance of a true iust and righteous Christian who to ascend vnto heauen and to amount himselfe from all earthly and terrene comforts and to make his conuersation with God in heauen doth not performe this flight onely by the wings of faith but is also therein by the hands of charitie and good workes to helpe and support them without which hee falleth downe to the ground so that now wee see against the Church of Rome that faith alone iustifieth without good workes and that good workes without faith cannot iustifie through their imperfection which in respect of man are so absolutely imperfect and impure as the precedent places of antiquitie doe testifie and therefore I find the most probable inducement of antiquitie in those two points to leade mee vnto the Church of England 14 Now courteous Reader when I had obserued the Church of Rome to faile thus in the triallof antiquitie My feeling vpon the consideration of this obseruation about the two aforesaid points of doctrine concerning faith and good workes attributing too little to the one and too much to the other and the Church of England to haue Antiquitie on her side for the establishment of the aforesaid points I beganne more seriously to behold mine owne estate and to see the former danger of my soule with the great perill of diuers others whose carefull instructer I haue beene in the contrarie nouelties I beganne with amazement to reflect more studiously and feelingly vpon the seuere wordes of S. Paul denouncing an accurse vpon the teachers of nouelties when he said Gal. 1.8 Though an Angell from heauen should preach vnto you otherwise then that which wee haue preached vnto you let him be accursed In the feare of which curse as I discouered my errour so I determined it to bee high time for mee to shake handes and bidde adieu to the Church of Rome which by her nouell doctrines entangleth the soules of many in the nets of eternall perdition Now could I not but with teares of compunction for my former professed nouelties beginne to mollifie the hardned crust of deformitie which they had wrought in my soule and also with teares of compassion bewaile the miserable estate of those soules as I knew to be defiled with the spots of like errours now could I no but most earnestly prostrate my selfe vpon the ground before the Throne of Gods mercie both for them and my selfe beseeching him to bee propitious and fauourable to vs all in the most tender bowells of Christ Iesus his Sonne cauing pardon and mercie only by him of the Father whose pardon and mercies are aboue all other his workes that we might all who were miserably seduced by the nouelties of Rome discouer and detest them as abhominations in the sight of God and constantly resolue neuer to participate more with her erroneous doctrines and nouelties which were sowed by no other then Sathan and his Ministers but to enter into the happy felloship and societie of that Church that teacheth the contrarie verities standing vpon sure Antiquitie And now did I further with all humilitie of my heart and humble acknowledgment of this great fauour from God in affording mee the meanes of discouer such falshoods yeeld him humble thankes offering vp withall into his holy handes my soule my body with all the powers and faculties of either with the whole residue of my life to come to be imployed hereafter in the conuersion of soules to the present Church of England which I found notwithstanding all pretences to the contrarie to bee Apostolicall and most Ancient grieuing much for my former Oath taken in Rome betwixt the handes of Robert Parsons some twelue or thirteene yeares since to the contrarie in the forme following word for word The Oath of the English Seminaries EGO N. N. Collegij Anglorum alumnus c. I Iohn Copley Collegiall of the English Seminarie duely considering the great benefits which Almightie God hath bestowed vpon me and that especially whereby hee hath drawne mee out of my Countrie infected with Heresie and made mee a member of his
true Catholike Church and desiring not to shew my selfe altogether ingrate vnto Gods so great mercie I haue freely decreed to consecrate and offer vp my selfe wholly vnto his diuine seruice for attaining as much as in me lieth to the end of the said Colledge and I doe promise and confirme by this mine Oath vnto Almightie God that I am and shall bee euer most ready in minde by the assistance of his holy Grace to receiue in due time holy Orders and to returne into England there to gaine soules whensoeuer the Superiour of this Colledge shall thinke good by vertue of his office to command me thereunto For the taking of so vnlawfull an Oath in such my blindnesse against the lawfull power and authoritie of the Gouernours of this Realme with contempt of their Lawes to the contrarie as also for the practise of the contents therein specified vpon false supposition of gaining soules to God whilest I drew them from God from my heart I repent me crauing pardon of God and his Maiestie with diuers others whom I haue offended and grieuously prouoked their iust indignation against me acknowledging that I may truely say vnto God with the prodigall Sonne that wasted his substance in a farre Countrie I will goe to my Father and say vnto him Father I haue sinned against heauen and against thee Luke 15. v. 21. I am no more worthy to be called thy Sonne If thou curteous Reader art as I was glorifie the name of God in the view of thy errours which I hope by this Treatise sufficiently to lay open vnto thee turning to God who is mild and mercifull to all true penitent sinners purposing amendment and acknowledging their sinnes and if thou art otherwise let mee intreat thee for the loue of God to giue him thankes for mee and thou thy selfe to bee constant and firme in the Faith of the present Church of England which teacheth the true Christian Apostolike and Ancient faith in which through Gods grace we may be saued CHAP. IX Containeth an obseruation of the Wonders and supposed Miracles which as Christ hath fore-told the Pseudo-Christs and Prophets shall doe for the seducing of Gods Elect if it were possible AMongst the diuers markes which Cardinall Ballarmine brings to shew vs which is the true Church Miracles make more for the Church of England than for the Church of Rome and to which societie of Christian beleeuers were ought to ioyne our selues to bee true children of Christ hee vrgeth for his eleuenth Marke the glorie of Miracles in these wordes Miracles are necessarie to perswade men to a new faith Bellarm. de notis Eccles l. 4. c. 14. in Epitome or to an extraordinarie mission and are sufficient and efficacious to proue the same so that where true Miracles are found without doubt there is the true Faith Which Assertion when I considered deepely with due obseruation of all points of doctrine concerning the working of Miracles I found this Marke to make as much for the Faith of the present English Church for that it is the same which being new in the Apostles time was confirmed in the hearts of all beleeuers by the Miracles of the Apostles and holy Men of the Primitiue Church at the first planting of the Christian Faith and hereby I am put in minde that as Aristotle saith Aristoteles Prudentis est distinguere it is the part of a prudent man to distinguish betwixt times times betwixt doctrines faithfully compare the beleeuers of the first Ages euen of Rome it selfe with those of after-ages which as I indeuoured to performe in examining this marke of miracles I obserue that vnlesse it were done with great prudence infinite numbers may bee carried simply and ignorantly into grosse errors to the great impeachment of Gods glorie and miserable seduction of their owne soules and therefore to lay downe this obseruation I thought it good to vse extraordinary diligence that therewith all I might be the more assured of truth that the world may clearely see that this pretence of Miracles maketh nothing at all for the present faith of Rome but onely against it shewing the Professours thereof not to bee true Christians 2 For albeit it be a truh not to be denied al that do miracles doe not true miracles that all true miracles can onely be done by God yet doth it not follow that all that doe miracles doe true miracles and such as are done by him for to euery true miracle foure things are required as a learned Roman Teacher affirmeth First Foure thinges required to true miracles Io. de Combis in compend Theolog verit lib. 1. ca. 20. it must be of God Secondly it must be beyond nature Thirdly it must be euident Fourthly it must be fore the corroboration of Faith Therefore if any of these foure be wanting it may bee called a Maruell but not a Miracle Therefore it is also to bee knowne that the Diuell can doe miracles though not true miracles yet such miracles as to men may seeme true miracles for Thomas Aquinas saith and that very truly out of S. Augustine That miracles by art Magicke are made Aug. lib. 83. q. 79 Tom. 4. Part. 1. q. 14. q. 4. Sed contra which are altogether like vnto those miracles which are done by the seruants of God which he explicateth dogmatically after this manner If a miracle be taken properly the Diuels cannot doe miracles nor any other creature but onely God because a miracle properly is termed that which is beyond the order of anie nature created Yet sometimes in a large sense that is called a miracle which exceedeth the faculty and vnderstanding of man and so the diuells can doe miracles which men admire in that they exceede their power and knowledge For one man when he doth any thing tha is aboue the power and knowledge of an other man he leadeth the other into an admiration of his worke that in some sort he seemeth to do a miracle Yet it is to be vnderstood that albeit such workes of Diuells which seeme miracles vnto vs reâ—ch not vnot the true nature of miracles they are notwithstanding sometimes true things As when sire fell from heauen and with one blowe consumed the familie of Iob with all the heards of his cattell and a whirlewinde ouerthrew the house Aug. 20. de Ciuitae Dei c. 19. slew his children which were the workes of Sathan were not fantasmes as Augustine saith And therefore well doth Saint augustine say in an other place speaking of the lying miracles of Antichrist as he same Doctour noteth That the workes of Antichrist may bee called signes of lying Li. 83. q. 79. to 4. eyther because hee will deceiue mortall senses by phantasmes seeming to doe that which hee doth not or because that if they bee true Prodigies yet they drawe those that shall beleeue them to a lie Hence the same Doctour Saint Augustine saieth Aug. li. 83. q. 79. a
medio tom 4. That when Sorcerers doe those thinges which Saints doe they are don for a different end and by a different power for Sorcerers doe them seeking their owne glorie Saints doe them seeking the glorie of God Sorcerers doe them by certaine priuate contracts Saints doe them by publique administration and commaund of God vnto whom all things created are subiect 3 Now therefore since seeming miracles done by the Diuell The true Catholike church the approuer of true miracles exceeding the ordinarie power of Nature may deceiue many if they iudge their Doctrine by them and for that it is hard for a man to bee able to say whether a miracle bee done by the power of almighty God or by the power of the Diuell because both exceede our vnderstanding and the ordinarie course of Nature it stoode mee vppon to search out some infallible meanes by which I might bee assured that they were true miracles and such as I might confidently relie vppon In which scrutinie I could finde no better rule than to obserue whether they bee done in the Catholique Church or no which I doe learne out of Saint Augustine Aug. de vnit Eccles ca. 16. saying Whatsoeuer things of this quality are done in the Catholicke Church Therefore they are to bee approued because they are done in the Catholicke Church Therefore shee is not manifested Catholicke because those thinges are done in her Whereby it is cleere that miracles absolutely are not a proofe of the Catholicke Church but the Catholicke Church an approouer of true miracles whence it followeth That the miracles of the Primitiue Church were not so much a confirmation of her truth as her truth a confirmation of them Whence I obserue further That the present Church of Rome not beeing the true Catholicke Church because shee teacheth not the true Catholicke ancient Faith without mixture of many nouelties doth in vaine all eadge miracles in her behalfe which for that they are done out of the true Church are to bee reckoned amongst Antichrists lying signes prodigies Therefore I may pronounce confidently with S. Aug. vnto the Papists I say not that these things are so Aug. de vnit Eccles ca. 16. because such a one did such and such maruailes but let them proue their Church by the Canonicall bookes of the Scripture and by nothing else these are the demonstrations of our cause Note this these are our foundations these are our grounds whereupon we build Whereby wee see Miracles excluded from beeing a marke of the Church as the Cardinall Bellarmine would faine perswade the world that so his Romaine Church might bee approued for the true Church of God Vnapproueable therefore is the assertion of master D. Hill who chalengeth much vnto the Roman Church by her glorie of miracles wrought by her Saints his words are these The tenth reason of this quarterne Now it is so manifest that there haue beene an infinite number of miracles wrought by those who were of the Catholicke Romaine Religion and neuer any by them who were not of that Church since Christs time as he who shall deny it may bee prooued no lesse impudent and shamlesse than bee who shall denie that euer there was any Masse said in times past in England or that euer there were any warres betweene Turkes and Christians or that there bee any such countries as the East and West-Indies which thing if a man should denie would hee not of all men be deemed not only impudent but madde drunken or afoole In which words because Master Doctor Hill seemeth much to forget himselfe I must needs refresh his memorie with some few interrogatories What master Doctor I pray since Christs time did not Simmon Magus worke miracles who as Baronius saith Baron an 68. nu 22. made images to walke and would lie in the fire without hurt and flie in the ayre and make bread of stones hee could open doores fast shut and vnloose bands of iron and had many shadowes following him as it had been men Will you say he was a Roman Catholike Tacit. lib. 4. did not Vespasian the Emperour at Alexandria restore a blind man to sight will you say hee was a Roman Catholike Who be they Christ spake of when he said Matth. 7 22. Many will say to me in that day Lord haue we not by thy name prophesied and by thy name cast out diuels and by thy name done many great workes and then will I professe to them I neuer knew you depart from me yee that worke iniquitie What will you say that these workers of miracles and also of iniquity were of your Catholike Romane religion What think you of those Saint Augustine speaketh of August de vnit Eccles cap. 16. saying If there be done some miracles of heretikes we ought the more to take heed because when the Lord had said that there should be some deceiuers who by doing many signes should deceiue the very Elect if it were possible he did adde commending it vehemently said behold I haue foretold it vnto you What will you grant all these were of the Catholike Romane religion August tract 13. in loan What will you say vnto the same ancient Doctor in another place where he saith Against these miracle-mongers as I may so call them my God hath made mee warie saying In the last times there shall arise false Prophets doing signes and wonders What will you grant none of these to be yet come or will you grant them all to be of your religion What will you say to your Country-man Prompt mor. part aestiu pag. 627. dom 24. nu 4. Master Doctor Stapleton publike professor of Diuinitie in Louaine and if I mistake not your acquaintance in Doway who saith For the more triall of the godly not onely Antichrist himselfe and his nearest forerunners but all heretikes also may do true miracles by the permission of God as the sorcerers may doe Will you grant such forerunners and Heretikes to be of your Catholike Romane religion or will you say Doctor Stapleton erreth in calling them true miracles or will you recant your former assertion acknowledging your former mistaking and then shall I be as glad as now I haue commiseration of your error beseeching God in the meane time of his infinit mercie that you may see both your owne error and the errors of others of the present Romane religion and how different it is from the ancient Roman religion which in Saint Pauls dayes was famous through the world For my part I could not but vpon these and other considerations obserue the Church of England to be free from such false Prophets and Pseudochrists that they miracles as Christ fore told should deceiue the very Elect if it were possible for neither doe they pretend themselues to worke miracles and so to hunt after their owne estimation and applause for their holines as the teachers of the Roman Church do neither do they hold
it absolutely necessary that God should continue that faith by miracles which was formerly planted by them but rest themselues contented with the former of the Primitiue Church lest otherwise they should be subiect to seduction whence I concluded to my selfe that vnlesse the Church of Rome could proue her selfe to be true Catholike and ancient Primitiue I ought not to be led by her pretended miracles in regard that Doctor Stapleton saith Heretikes and the forerunners of Antichrist may do true miracles by Gods permission for the triall of the good which neither my selfe nor any manelse ought to beleeue because Christ hath armed vs with a warning caueat against them saying Nolite eis credere 4 Which Pretence of miracles a signe of false teachers Matth. â—4 24 how true it is I appeale to the holy Scriptures themselues our Sauiours words are most plaine There shall arise false Christs and false Prophets shall shew great signes and wondes so that if it were possible they should deceiue the verie Elect behold I haue told you before but beleeue them not by which warning aduice is giuen to beware of them to discerne them and not to giue credit vnto their teaching notwithstanding all their miracles Neither is Saint Pauls prediction lesse significant of them who remembreth vs 2. Thess 2.9 That the comming of that sonne of perdition is by the working of Satan with all power and signes and lying wonders and in all deceiue ablenesse of vnrighteousnes among them that perish because they receiued not the loue of the truth Apocal cap. 13.13.14 that they might bee saued Saint Iohn also in his Reuelations speaking of the second beast saith He did great wonders so that he made fire to come downe from heauen on the earth in the fight of men and deceiued them that dwellon the earth by the signes which ae permitted to him to do in the sight of the beast Apocal. cap. 16.13 Afterwards we heare also againe that three vncleane spirits like frogs came out of the mouth of the Dragon and out of the mouth of the beast and out of the mouth of the false Prophet for they are the spirits of diuels working miracles And moreouer lastly we find in the same booke That the beast was taken and with him that false Prophet Apocal. cap. 19.20 that wrought miracles before him whereby he deceiued them that receiued the beasts marke Now what is to bee vnderstood by powers signes and wonders I will cite the words of Ioannes Vignerius Institut Christ cap. 9. §. 2. vers 3. Hebr. 2. Matth. 24.24 who saith That miracles in the sacred Scriptures are tearmed powers signes wonders and portentes for Hebrewes the second it is said God witnessing in signes and portents and diuers powers and Matthew the foure and twentieth they are called prodigies which differ thus in that because they exceed the facultie of nature they are termed powers but in that they are ordained to the manifestation of grace they are called signes and for their excellencie they are termed wonders and prodigies as it were shewing things far off So that putting all these places together I could not conclude otherwise then vnlesse I would beleeue these false Prophets vnlesse I were willing to be an Entertenido to the son of Perdition and bee deluded most notoriously by lying wonders vnlesse I would be a perpetuall consort vnto the frogs vamped forth of the Dragons mouth vnlesse I would bee wilfully deceiued as one that had receiued the beasts marke then to shake hands with the present Church of Rome boasting so much in her miraculous powers signes wonders and prodigies for in the reformed Churches I find no such illusions pretended nor the least danger thereof nor any where else but in the present Romane Church 5 By which obseruation Miracles not to be expected in the latter times I was the rather induced to this conclusion for that I finde diuers inclining to thinke it too much curiositie now that the faith is planted and after so long continuance to seeke it out by more miracles Therefore first I will set downe the Doctrine of an old Dominican Friar distinguishing the times of doing miracles whose words are these The Church hath a three-fold state viz. Iacob de Vorag de sanctis in die ascensio ser 6. The Primitiue the moderne and the last In the Primitiue state miracles were wrought often but now seldom and in the last state that is of Antichrist they shall be done most seldome In the Primitiue state they were done often because according to Saint Chrysostome the ancient miraracles haue admiration profit and necessitie Therefore then according to Saint Chrysostome miracles were done as well for admiration because men being then accustomed to their senses were therefore to be lifted vp as for profit because then many were infirme and oppressed of diuels and for necessitie because they were infidels and wrapped vp in errors But in the moderne state they are seldome done because necessitie requireth them not men being now beleeuers yet sometimes they are wrought because profit and vtilitie exalteth them for that sometimes men are found weake and to stand in need of them And why miracles are not done now so frequently as they were in the Primitiue Church there is a threefold reason one is for the strength of faith because now the Church is strengthened and established in faith This reason Bernard assigneth putting an example of the plant into which we power water till we see it fastened in the earth secondly for the profitable example of the world De ciuit Dei lib. 22. This reason Augustine assigneth saying whosoeuer requireth yet wonders that he may beleeue he is a great wonder himself who beleeueth not when the world beleeueth Thirdly for the greater merit of faith because according to Saint Gregory faith hath no merit where humane reason prouoketh it but in the end they shall bee wrought but seldome for three reasons that Isidorus teacheth either that the hand of the persecutors may become more bould or that the patience of the Saints may be the more proued or that the lightnes may be the more shewed of those which shall fall Who speaking heere of the miracles of Saints in these three states of time she weth they shall be scanty in the middle ages after Christ and very raw in the last ages which if it be true what can I do but suspect the pretended miracles of the Church of Rome which swarmeth with so many bookes replenished with their narrations in such strange and vnheard manner as there were neuer the like and therefore they easilie seeme to surmount all beliefe and I may more largely presse those words against those of the Church of Rome which this Authour pointeth at saying to all her followers out of Saint Augustine De ciuit Dei lib. 22. Why say they are not the miracles now done which you doe preach to haue beene done I might
say that before the world did beleeue they were necessrie to this end that the world might beleeue but whosoeuer doth enquire after wonders that hee may beleeue hee himselfe is a great wonderment who beleeueth not now the world doth beleeue By which words I obserue a necessitie why men should look for miracles in the Primitiue Church but none why wee should expect them now but rather why wee should feare to bee deceiued by beleeiuing false ones for true ones and therefore Saint Augustine giueth another stronger reason to hold him in the Church than the continuance of miracles saying Contra Epi. fundamenti The consent of people and nations doth holde me there doth hold mee an authoritie which was begunne with miracles nourished by hope encreased by charitie confirmed by antiquitie by which I obserue though hee shew the authoritie of that sacred doctrine confirmed in the beginning by miracles as a menes to hold him yet hee speaketh of no continuance of them but leaueth confirmation to the authoritie of sacred doctrine it selfe which must bee the strongest hold of the Churches claime De vera relig cap. 25. Saint AuguStine also in another place saith Since the Catholike Church is diffused through the whole world and grounded neither are these miraculous things permitted to endure vntill our times lest the mind should alwayes seeke visible things and by the custome of them man-kind should waxe cold at the new appearance whereof it was all on fire Mor. lib. 27.11 And Saint Gregorie saith most plainely What maruaile is it if the faith being propagated miracles be not oft done since euen the very Apostles in many which were alreadie faithfull did not doe them Neither is Isidorus any whit discordant from Saint Augustine aboue recited who seemeth to insinuate as much in these words Miracles are a signe Isidor lib. 1. de summo bono not necessarie for the faithfull who now haue beleeued but to the vnfaithfull that they may bee conuerted for Paul for the infidelitie of not beleeuers cureth the father of Publius by miracles from the infirmitie of an ague but sicke Timothie who was a faithfull not by prayer but medicinally that thou mayest know miracles to be done not for the vnfaithfull but for the faithfull So I find Didacus de la Vega not to swarue much from this doctrine Conc. quadrag feria 4. post primam dominicam quadrag Matth. 12. vers 39. who vpon these words Generatio male adultera signum quaerit signum non dabitur ei nisi signum Ionae Prophetae An euill and adulterous generation seeketh a signe but no signe shall be giuen vnto it saue the signe of the Prophet Ionas saith The Scribes and Pharisies approach vnto Christ to require signes and wonders from heauen by the which hee should shew himselfe the true Messias promised in the Law whome hee reprehendeth with sharpe wordes and confoundeth them calling them an euill and adulterous generation and their demaund required no milder wordes but was worthie of such an answere For the comming of the Sonne of God into the world was not so hidden but that it was preuented many ages before and announced by the heauenly Oracles of the Prophets Whereupon I obserued that if the Scribes and Pharsies were reprehended so seuerely for requiring signes from heauen because they had Christ foretold by the Prophets then could I not but assure my selfe that the followers of the Church of Rome are worthie of as great a reprehension euen of the same nature of adulterous generation that after the faith so long planted and begunne with miracles and confirmed by antiquitie boast so much on their owne miracles and strange wonders Doctor Stapleton vpon these words of Christ Iob. 4. Prompt mor. Dom. 20. post Pent. soco 5. Nisi signa prodigia viderit is not creditis Vnlesse you see signes and wonders you beleeue not hath these words worthie of note and obseruation The ruler is checked because that being brought vp amongst the Iewes and instructed in the Law hee would not beleeue by the authoritie of the Scriptures but by signes but expect the extreame daunger of his Sonne that hee might see a signe This was an incredultie almost common to all the Iewes which in another place Christ taxeth most sharpely for certaine of the Scribes and Pharisies comming vnto him and saying Master wee will see a signe of thee Matth. 12. answering hee said vnto them Matth. 16. a wicked and adulterous generation asketh a signe Which words againe hee answered at another time when the Sadduces empted him in like manner and calleth them a wicked and an adulterous generation which seeketh signes because they did euill in tempting God and such an euill was this that they shewed their soules not to bee the true spouses of God by faith but adulterous friends of transitorie things For euen as a wife which truely loueth her husband desireth not to see any extraordinarie signes of her husbands loue towards her as that her husband should as it were cast himselfe into the fire or water for his wiues sake but resteth contented with that true internall loue which hee carrieth her and the common externall signes of a husbands loue towards her So the faithfull soule which by faith and charitie is espoused vnto her God if shee bee such a one doth see so many signes in her selfe the loue of God so vehement and sincere so many embracings of Gods loue towards her so many and frequent sweetnesses from aboue so many daily graces fauours and benefits lastly that peace of her God which passeth all vnderstanding that to seeke other signes for confirmation of her faith in God or the charitie of God towards her she esteemeth it not onely idle but also most impious For as it is an argument of chast loue to cleaue only to God so is it the signe of an adulterous soule in slipperie things to seeke externall signes Further as the ancient Iewes were contented with the signes of their Elders done in the desert in the red sea on mount Sina Deut. 32. in the passage of Iordan according to that Interroga patres tuos dicent tibi Aske thy Fathers and they will tell thee So the Iewes when Christ teacheth and all Christians at this day must be cōtented with the old signes either typically done before Christs comming of which it was not fit the Iewes should be ignorant and chiefely the Scribes and Pharisies and the Princes of the people amongst which this Ruler seemeth to be one or performed by Christ himselfe which are sufficient for our faith Therefore all this curiositie and shew of incredulitie and fornication from God is worthily taxed by Christ either in this Ruler or in the standers by or in both whose hearts he saw By which Lobserued how worthie of reprehension of the Church of Rome is which for confirmation of her doctrine euen vntill his day standeth still vpon miracles as
great and more in number then euer before well she may be termed wicked and adulterous herein if when I consider what strange yea and often ridiculous miracles she pretendeth not only to iustifie falsehood sinne and impietie but also by them to commend the actors of them before all ancient Saints 6 Whereof I will now gentle Reader giue thee a taste by some few presidents happened in these latter ages of the world Examples of false miracles in the Church of Rome as the bookes and publike writings of the Church of Rome haue left recorded to the world which as they moued me to see mine owne former ouer-credulous spirit so haue they not strengthned me in the true faith wherunto through Gods exceeding great mercy I am now arriued And first for the iustification of Garnets innocencie in the busines of the Powder Treason what a ridiculous inuention is published and hath bin preached to the world by Costerus the Iesuite in Bruxells vpon the report but of a bare Letter from England some few yeres since when I liued in Louaine of a certaine prodigious straw in which a little bloud hath made such a liuely resemblance of his face that as it is by his fauorers reported and with mine owne eares I haue heard it it is one of the most stupendious miracles shewing Gods loue to their societie that euer hapned therfore since that time one M. Iohn Wilson the Author as is saide of the English Martirologe assuming vnto himselfe Papall Iurisdiction hath canonized him for a Saint in heauen who was put to death for concealement of treason against his King and Countrey whilest hee liued vpon earth Indeed I must needes confesse it a stupendious worke which since the first appearance thereof in print hath assumed not onely one but diuerse shapes for first at Louaine I saw it drawn with three horns of haire vpon his head ouer his forehead so that it appeared more like a monster than a man I saw him at Antwerpe after that drawne without those hornes yet a starre shining in the middest of his forehead in great glorie of which kind I saw many pictures in paper tendred by a Iesuitesse woman as she seemed by her habite and carriage to bee sold as the chiefe pictures then in request since that time here in England I haue seene a Latine booke in which another miracle as it should seeme hath beene added vnto it representing two Seraphines vnder his beard as it were holding vp his chinne that men might the better beholde his glorie But besides all these transformations one thing is most remarkable which I haue heard reported by diuers that is some can see this goodly Image at the first looking on it others canno see it till one of a better sight oint where it is and others can not behold the glorie thereof at all I haue spoken with some of those three kindes of beholders who according to the measure of their eie sight haue tolde mee as much besides at the first the picture of this miracle was very small but now it is greater and perhappes it will carry yet a greater shape and be the mother of miracles increasing to the end of the world and so surpasse all the miracles done in Christs time which were not permanent but transitory about which if a man should aske the Author of Pruritanus that monstrous and athisticall libell how so strange a miracle could be done he would soone no doubt answer you according to his sacrilegious manner of applying the sacred Scriptures with the Diuell quia scriptum est maiora hijs facietis Which words Saint Augustine expoundeth of the conuersions of sinners by the ministery of Preachers because the conuersion of sinners is the greatest worke of God Now beloued Reader how could I with any reason giue credite to this miracle howsoeuer at the first report I was ouer-credulous when I obserued the maner how it was carried and if such reuerend Fathers of the christian world will stand in defence of it and beknaue better men than themselues without regard to the magistracie as I heard one principal Father do in Bruxels in great choler indignation against those that should gainsay it I may beloued wel call in doubt enter into a iealous suspition of many other strange miracles deuised for the maintenance of vntruth falshoode by others of the Roman Church Secondly I remember an other strange miracle had it not proued false for the great credit of the Iesuites and their holysocietie in Persia Not long before the discouery of the Powder treason ther was dispersed by thē among some of their Catholike friends here in England a litle Pamphlet in the French tongue reporting the miraculous conuersion of the King of Persia The miracle of Persia by one Campion a Iesuit and Englishman that dispossessed one which had a diuell who commanded the diuell at his departure out of the body to giue a signe therof by striking downe the top of a steeple whereupon followed the Kings conuersion with many of the nobilitie to the Roman faith with liberty to preach it publikely and to build vp Churches and monasteries throughout all his Dominions Which of many here in England was beleeued to be true especially by a friend of mine vnto whom that Pamphlet was sent who requested me to say masse in thankesiguing to GOD for so great a benefit but in the end that Iesuit who sent the Pamphlet gaue out that it was but a thing deuised by French Hugonets to disgrace their societie What strange deuises are these What hatefull illusions wherewith honest sincere soules are made gulls through deceitfulnes and diuelish policies vsing all things for nothing but their owne ends I can not but now smile at my selfe to remember the plaine sinceritie of my heart in beleeuing this prettie inuention and with how thankefull a minde I offered vp the sacrifice of the Masse with a tacite and silent wish that God by the like meanes would procure the conuersion of England 7 Thirdly Other pretended miracles in the Church of Rome I will not omit here to call to mnind two strange miracles inuented to the honour of S. Francis that people might be the more excited to pray to him before all others The first I heard preached at S. Iames Church in Antwerpe in the Lent time some fiue yeres since by a Capuchine Friar and affirmed to be such an euident truth that no iust exceptions might be entertaind against it before a great assemblie and confluence of people Of one that roasted her childe with many particular circumstances of place and persons which made it carrie the more likeliehood of truth with it and since that time I know where it hath been related by the Prouinciall of the Franciscans here in England The storie in briefe is this in effect A certaine Gentlewoman there was in a towne in Sicilie some few yeeres since that longing much to taste of
as the Church of Rome teacheth who being deuoted much to the virgine Marie prayed often vnto her to bee deliuered from this doubt Who being one day at Masse the Hoast before the saying of the Pater noster was gone out of his sight whereof as hee was in a great amazement the virgine Marie appeared vnto him holding her sonne Iesus betwixt her armes and said vnto him This is he whom I brought into this world this is he whom you haue consecrated this is he whom you haue held and touched with your hands and shewed to the people to be adored which you eate and drinke in the Sacrament behold here I giue you my Sonne with reuerence and deuotion to be receiued of you and so as shee presented him vnto him he changed at that instant againe into the forme of bread whom he receiued and so his doubt ceased Here you see courteous Reader strange miracles alledged by the Papists in confirmation of their doctrine one while the bread is vnseene then Christ and our Ladie and then againe the forme of bread another while a Mule forsaking his prouender to adore God in the Sacrament whether these be not such signes wonders and great prodigies as may seduce the elect if it were possible I leaue to the holy Ghost to informe you the truth saying Nolite eis credere beleeue them not And one more yet I will relate vnto your memorie which hath beene wrought of late yeares and may be esteemed for a notable lie Till Bred. 7. Col. sac c. 7. There was a certaine Caluinist that married a Catholike woman that is Papist that long endeuoured to induce her to heare a Caluinist Minister preach The wife after she had a long time contradicted him was at last constrained to goe by the rigorous speeches and threatnings of her husband yet did she first acquaint her ghostly father there with who aduised her to obey the commaundement of her husband and to goe onely once to the said Sermon yet with condition to goe first to Confession and to the Communion The woman hauing performed the aduise of her ghostly father strengthned with the Sacraments went to the Sermon and she was no sooner entred but the Preacher became as silent and mute as a fish yet said at last after a little pause Here is some bodie present that hath eaten of the bread of Papists which is the cause that I will now giue ouer preaching hoping to make recompence another time The husband who was present seeing the Preacher A pretie fiction to disgrace Caluinists by Gods permission to become silent and disabled to prosecute his matter for the presence of one that had receiued the holy Communion who being returned home enquired of his wife whether shee had not receiued the Communion that morning or not she without dissimulation answering yes her husband suddainly knew that this doctrine of the Caluinists was false and accursed in that being placed with the light of the Sacraments of the Catholike Church it withered so and came to nought whereupon presently he made a good fire burned all his bookes to pouder and ashes and became himselfe a child of the Catholike Church In which miracle first I obserue that the ghostly father of this woman gaue her leaue for obedience to her husband to go to the Church of Caluinists which how it can hang with the doctrine of Paule the fifths Breue who sheweth it vnlawfull for English Catholikes to goe to the Churches of Heretikes viz. of all Caluinists and Protestants that are so in his iudgement vnlesse it be said that the Church of Rome holds one doctrine of faith lawfull at one time that is not lawfull at another time I should be glad to be resolued But this I obserue to proceede from Gods prouidence that the inuentors of these and the like miracles for the confirmation of their doctrine in one point doth often in some circumstance or other shew such ignorance or falsehood that discouereth them either not to approue the matter they intend or else runneth into some other error lesse tolerable shewing them most plainely to be such signes and wonders as Christ giueth a Caueat of them Not to be beleeued Many other miracles I might here insert but that I will not be too tedious in such idle tales fitter to be told amongst children as fables than to any men of more ripe iudgement yet are they amongst the Clergie of Rome of such account that their Sermonists are stuffed with them as may be obserued in Iacobus de Voragine Iohannes Meff Bernard de Bust Philippus Dies and many the like and are held more profitable for the people than any other manner of doctrine Yet I obserue one thing by reading of their liues of Saints that many miracles which were authenticall for many hundred yeares past are now growne to be Apocryphall as may be seene by comparing the auncient liues of S. George S. Katherine the Queene and others with them as they are of late yeares corrected and written by Lipeloo following Baronius and other writers of the same kind 12 Now therefore to draw neere my conclusion My conclusion about miracles what fruit could I better gather vpon the due obseruation of Christs warning vnto the world Not to beleeue such miracles than that the Church of Rome cannot bee the true Church of God that either winketh or authoriseth infinite numbers in the same nature as these are of which I haue alreadie recorded out of her owne Writers for which cause I could not but abandon her Communion and flye to that Church which like a faithfull Spouse resteth contented with the former miracles where with Christs Church was begun and chiefely relying vpon the holy Scriptures and the auncient doctrine of the Primitiue Church Yet is not my opinion in this point of miracles so to bee vnderstood as that I doe thinke no true miracles at all shall euer be done in the declining age of Gods Church but I would haue it knowne that my iudgement is that none are to be beleeued which are pretended to be done in confirmation of new doctrines not taught in the Scriptures not knowne to the auncient Church because it is most euident that Christ hath forbidden all beleefe of them and therefore not to be esteemed of otherwise than as of illusions of Sathan wherewith to enchant soules and to make them beleeue lyes in stead of truth and verities Oh what a miserie is it to see how many simple sincere and ouer-credulous Christians are cousened with these deceits and illusions of the Diuell and the true markes of Antichrist Let me therfore entreat thee courteous reader to remember the predictions of these signes and wonders aboue mentioned forespoken of by Christ S. Paule and S. Iohn and not so fondly to be lead blind-folded to the eternall destruction of thy soule by too much credulitie Be not like the Scribes and Pharisies seeking after signes from heauen for the faith least you
proue one of those that are tearmed by Christ a wicked and adulterous generation CHAP. X. Containeth an obseruation of the great hipocrisie of false Teachers fore-spoken of in the holie Scriptures AMongst the many testimonies recorded in holy Scriptures concerning false Teachers The hypocrisie of false teachers shewed in the Scripture by which I might further discouer the erroneous doctrin of the Church of Rome and make comparison of her doctrine with other reformed Churches the next which represented themselues were such places as describe the dissimulation and hipocrisie of false Teachers and inuite men to take heede of them to preuent all their dissimulations and impostures by which they seduce simple soules from the knowledge of truth lead them by cunning art of wordes to follow leasings and false Gods This I noted first out of Christs wordes describing the manner of Heretikes comming and giuing a preuenting Caueat to take heede of them Math. 7. vers 15 where he said Attendite à falsis Prophet is qui veniunt ad vos in vestimentis ouium intrinsecus autem sunt lupi rapaces Beware of false Prophets which come to you in sheepes clothing but inwardly they are rauening wolues as if he should say take heede of the hipocrisie of those Prophets who seeme to be one thing and are an other of whom S. Paul saith Rom. 16. vers 18. Per dulces sermones benedictiones seducunt corda innocentium With faire speech and flattering they deceiue the hearts of the simple who in another place speaking of the heretikes of latter times saith In hipo crisi loquuntur mendacium 1. Tim. 4. vers 2. cauteriatam habent cōscientiam Who speake-lies through hipocrisie hauing their consciences burned with a hot yron Further Christ dehorreth all from hipocrisie when he said Math. 5. vers 20 Nisi abundauerit institia vestra plus quam Scribarum aut Pharisaeorum non intrabitis in regnum coelorum Except your righteousnesse exceede the righteousnesse of the Scribes and Pharisees yee shall not enter into the Kingdome of heauen Now how the iniustice of the Pharisees was a foure-fold Hipocrisie is also plaine by the Scriptures The Pharisees four-fold Hipocrisie The first consisted in externall righteousnesse without internall whereof Christ speaketh saying Vos Pharisei quod deforis est calicis catini mundatis quod autem intus est vestrum plenum est rapina iniquitate Stulti nonne qui fecit quod deforis est Luc. 11. v. 36. etiam quod deintus est fecit Yee Pharisees make cleane the outside of the cup and of the platter but the inward part is full of rauening and wickednesse Yee Fooles did not hee that made that which is without make that which is within also And againe Vae vobis Scribae Pharisaei Hipocritae similes estis sepulchris dealbatis quae a foris apparent hominibus speciosa intus vero plena sunt ossibus mortuorum omni spurcitia Math. 23. v. 27. Sic vos aforis apparet is hominibus iusti intus autem pleni estis hipocrisi omni iniquitate Woe be vnto you Scribes Pharisees Hipocrites for yee are like vnto whited tombs which appeare beautifull outward but are within full of dead mens bones and of all filthinesse For so are yee also for outward yee appeare righteous vnto men but within yee are full of Hipocrisie and iniquitie The second consisted in an externall holinesse also but preposterous and defectiue because they were scrupulous in trifles large or of no conscience therefore Christ said vnto them Vae vobis Pharisaeis Luc. 11. v. 42. qui decimatis metham rutam omne olus preteritis iudicium charitatem Dei Woe be vnto you Pharisees for yee tithe the mint and rue and all manner herbs and passe ouer iudgment and the loue of God or as S. Matt. saith Math. 23. v. 23. Et reliquistis quae grauiora sunt legis iudicium misericordiam fidem And leaue the waightier matters of the law as iudgement and mercie fidelitie The third hipocrisie of the Pharisees was verbal not real a fained not a true obseruation of Gods commandements which Christ taxed in them saying Math. 23. v. 3. Quaecunque dixerint vobis c. Whatsoeuer they bid you obserue that obserue and doe but doe not according to their workes for they say and doe not And againe If you be the children of Abraham doe the workes of Abraham The fourth hipocrisie of the Pharisees was vaine glorious who in all their actions of religion sought the glorie and praise of men Christ saying Math. 6. v. 5. They fast and pray Vt videantur ab hominibus That they may be seene of men from all which foure-fold hipocrisie wherein consisted the vnrighteousnesse of the Pharisees Christ dehorteth all Christians by a motiue of heauenly blisse saying as before Vnlesse your iustice abound more then the Scribes and Pharisees you shall not enter into the Kingdome of heauen Hence it followeth that in what Church soeuer a proper resemblance of this Hipocrisie is found The hipocrisie of the Church of Rome there may wee well presume the false Prophets to be which Christ biddeth vs beware of and therefore since I obserue it abundantly to appeare in the present Church of Rome the Teachers of that Church as false Prophets comming vnto vs are the reuenous wolues in sheepe-skinnes whose iustice doth no lesse abound then that of the Scribes and Pharisees which will keepe them from entring into the Kingdome of heauen For so long as I haue beene in that Church I haue seene much externall righteousnesse as long praiers much whipping with disciplines much fasting many miraculous cemonies of religion strange mortifications and all this without the true faith by reason of the many nouelties crept into that Church and without charitie the inward life of the soule whence it proceedeth that there is much dissension amongst all sorts many diuisions amongst the learned many back-bitings amongst religious persons many wrongs and iniuries offered without conscience much violation of morall honestie and ciuilitie enuie amongst most detraction amongst all wicked life without measure rash iudgements without any consideration lying reports against one an other traducing of one the others reputation by writings by wordes by secret complotments and macheuillian deuises without all feare of God or loue of honestie Religious men are poore in the outward shew of their profession Once acertain Capuchine said as a Iesuit hath related when one said that the Iesuites and his Order proceed well together that the cause was because the Iesuites desired to haue al and they desired to haue nothing but who abound more in common than the landed Monkes and well monied Iesuites They are chast in the outward vowes but many of them most lasciuious in heart as by the one Author of the Pruritanus may bee iudged of many besides Who more blindly
esteemed of the Church of Rome as a Doctor of Paris who liued two hundred yeares since Hemang de stat eccles p. 53. spake of Friars saying They are worse than the Pharisies rauenous wolues in sheepes clothing who in wordes pretend the forsaking of the world and in deeds with all possible fraud deceit and lying hunt after it The like vnto these did Saint Iohn Baptist call Genimina viperarum the brood of Vipers Matth. 3. because inwardly they carried poyson howsoeuer outwardly they glistered in the vanity of virtues and perfect zeale And Iob seemes prettily to describe them saying Iob. 39. Penna struthionis similis est Herodii accipitris the hawke and storke surpasse other birdes in the speede of their wings vnto which the Struthio is like in fethers Herodius but not in flight because they can but moue their wings to flie yet neuer flie euen such doe I find to be the false prophets of the Church of Rome who by diuers externall actions seeme to haue their wings raised to flie yet with their heart and soule they cleaue to the earth they forsakenot the world tast only terrene things there are like fishes swimming in their vncleannes Wolues in their mallice Foxes in their craftines birdes in their vaineglorie yet doe they transfigure themselues into the Angells of Light dissembling mortification 2. Tim. 3. to deceiue the simple and vnder the pretence of pietie to take their prey whome the holy Apostle Saint Paul calleth Voluptatum amatores magis quam Dei habentes speciem quidem pietatis virtutem autem eius abnegantes louers of pleasures more than of GOD hauing the shew of pietie but denying the power thereof and therefore to bee auoyded and warinesse to be taken of them as Christ himselfe forewarned CHAP. XI Containeth an obseruation of the fruits by which false prophets are to be knowne and discerned BY the former obseruation of the false prophets hypocrisie A way for Papists to discouer the truth which Christ teacheth to be auoyded I haue in some sort beene induced to behold the false pretended catholike religion of the Church of Rome and to conceiue what a zealous detestation a man of vnderstanding ought to haue of that faith and religion which is taught by such hypocriticall teachers yet when I considered further more particularly the meanes which in the iudgement of Papists themselues our Sauiour teacheth euery man to vse for the discouerie of them much more haue I beheld the corruption of the Roman religion and beene moued to beartier repentance and greater commiseration of poore seduced Popists here in England who in a good sinceritie and erroneous assurance of their religion are ignorantly led by many of their teachers into a wonderfull blind obedience not onely to the temporall detriment of their states and fortunes and hazard of worldly meanes for their posterities but also which is worse to the great perrill of their soules euerlasting ruine and destruction for whose good also I haue thought good to giue them some meanes of redresse by explicating vnto them the meanes discouered by Christ wherewith they might helpe themselues as also the maner of my proceeding in the consideration of this point 2 In my scrutinie therefore and search into the truth of religion and discouerie of falshoode False prophets to be discouered by their fruits I conceiued nothing more important for the better successe in my businesse than to obserue out of the Scriptures some probable way and meanes allowed of by the Papists themselues by the which I might cleerely distinguish betwixt false and true teachers for that I perceiued that al pretend truth pretend the church pretend Christ pretend the saluation of soules pretend the knowledge of Scriptures yea and the falsest teachers carrie the outward appearance likewise of good shepheards And I found that Christ who forewarned vs to beware of the bad hath also giuen vs aduise to hearken vnto the good and withalll a good instruction euen in the iudgement of the Romanists how to discerne and distinguish the one from the other Matth. 7. when hee said By their fruits you shall know them doe men gather grapes of thornes or figges of thistles Euen so euery good tree yeeldeth good fruit and the euill tree yeeldeth euill fruits A good tree cannot yeelde euill fruites neyther can an euill tree yeelde good fruits Doctour Stapletons explication of Christs meaning euery tree that yeeldeth not good fruites shall be cut downe and shall be cast into the fire Therefore by their fruites you shall know them 3 For D. Stapleton a principall Romanist hath thus interpreted our Sauiours speech saying In this place the fruites by which heretickes must bee knowne are neyther some true things which they teach neyther are they alwayes the workes which they doe whether good or euill but they are partly the hereticall doctrines themselues which are false and impious which are proper to euery hereticke and of euery arch-heretike properly inuented partly also certayne ill workes proper to heretikes and growing foorth from the roote it selfe of heresie for such are theyr owne proper fruites as haue theyr owne Authors and Parents 4 Concerning the first Two wayes heretikes may be knowne by their doctrine Ibid. The faithfull people may two wayes knowe heretickes from theyr owne doctrines as by theyr proper fruites first by theyr doctrine generally receyued namely as if it be new and vnheard and otherwise than by the knowne rule of faith which anciently they receiued for so the Scripture exhorteth faithfull people when shee giueth warning to beware of heretickes saying If any shall euangelize vnto you otherwise than you haue receyued let him be accursed An other way by theyr false dostrine an hereticke is knowne as by his owne fruite when by the doctrine it selfe euill workes are engendred or when the doctrine it selfe leadeth men vnto wickednesse of life and manners as at this day very many doctrines of other herotickes doe 5 Concerning the latter the euill workes proper to heretikes and by which they may be knowne as by their owne proper fruits How here tikes may be known by their works are a certaine pride not vulgar but especiall against the present and all auncient Doctours of the Church Likewise an hatred not of this man or of that man but of the whole Church or truly of her superiors pertinacie anuy inobedience ambition couetousnesse and a singular kind of hypocrisie And further which vseth to issue out of these-spoile and destructions of Churches subuersion of kingdomes and common-wealths the dissolution of the whole people These fruits of Heretikes the Scripture teacheth and all antiquitie hath obserued So the Anostle there shall be men louing themselues hautie proud and hauing the shew of pietie 2. Tim. 3. but denying all the power thereof that is the Gospell in their mouth charity in their tongue hatred of the Church in their heart sacriledges in their deeds pride in
their breast Againe Rom. 16. not seruing the Lord but their belly by sweet speeches they seduce the hearts of innocents 2. Cor. 11. And againe such false Apostles are craftie worke-men transfiguring themselues into the Apostles of Christ. 1. Tim 4. So vnto Timothie certaine shall depart from the faith attending to the spirits of error and doctrines of diuels speaking a lie in hypocrisie 2. Pet. 2. Further Peter They shall make merchandize of you in couetousnesse with fained words And lastly Titus 1. Paul vnto Titus Teaching the things which behooue not for filthie lucres sake By these fruits wolues are knowne vnder the garments of sheepe and heretikes vnder the title of the Ministers of the Word De vtil credendi cap. 1. Therefore Augustine defineth an Heretike thus An Heretike is he that either begetteth or followeth false and new opinions for temporall commoditie and chiefely for glorie and dominion sake For euery Heretike forsaketh the vnitie and faith of the Catholike Church either for temporall commoditie or to get the praise of his name By all which we see these words of our Sauiour explicated not by any but such a one as in all things fauoureth the Romane church to point out the right way to iudge false teachers by all which the more I duely obserued the more did I find iust cause to forsake the Church of Rome and to abandon all longer communion therewith 6 For first concerning their doctrines The Bishops of Rome haue beene authors of many false doctrines Sess 24. Can. 3. I haue found the Bishops of the Church of Rome to haue been the authors of many erronious nouelties For Pius Quartus decreed at Trent that it should be lawfull for him to allow those degrees to marrie together which God in Leuiticus had forbidden and to forbid those which God had allowed this was ex Cathedra an hereticall decree who can excuse it but this was not his heresie alone for against true faith and beliefe many Popes haue taught the like marriages Summa Angelica verbo Papa nu 1. Martine the fifth allowed one to keep in marriage his owne sister Of late yeares another Pope allowed King Henrie the eighth to marrie his brothers wife in which case of affinitie Ioannes Viguerius teacheth that the Pope hath no lawful power to dispeÌ„ce And another Pope taught Emmanuel King of Portugale to marry two sisters By which dispensations and doctrine Osor de gest Eman. lib. 2. I perceiued both heresie to be taught by Popes and to be practised Celestine Pope ordained marriage to be void Hadrian quod lib. 6. pag. 34. when either of the parties fall into herefie Pope Steuen the sixth decreed in a Councell that such as were ordained Bishops by Pope Formosus his predecessour were not lawfully ordained Sigebert chron an 902. Sigon de Reg. Jtal. lib. 6. an 896. Baron an 897. nu 6. b de consecrat d. 4. à quodam 32.77 quod proposuisti Ibid. §. sed illud Ambr. Concil Senens apud Baron an 303 nu 89. Caranza in Marcel Tom. 2. an 302. nu 102. Athanas epist ad solitar fas tem an 353. Baron an 357. num 43.44 because Formosus was an euill man which tasteth flat Donatisme Pope Nicholas decreed that to Baptise onely in the name of Christ is good Baptisme contrarie to the decrees of Gregorie and Pelagius Pope Gregorie decreed that a man might take another wife in case his wife were so diseased that she would not yeeld him the debt of mariage the which saith Gratian is contrarie to the sacred Canons and to the doctrine of the Apostles and Euangelists Marcellinus committed idolatrie and offered sacrifice to Iupiter Saturne Hercules and the Pagan gods and was thereupon examined and condemned by a Councell of three hundred Bishoppes Which storie Baronius confesseth was from the beginning beleeued with a generall consent and kept in the ancient Martirologies and Breuiaries of the Romane Church Liberius who was Pope about the yeare three hundred and fiftie fell into Arianisme subscribing to the vniust condemnation of Athanasius whereupon Athanasius fell from his communitie and himselfe as an obstinate Heretike was deposed and cast out of the Church Honorius the first that was Pope in the yeare 626. was a Monotholite Heretike whose heresie was that Christ had but one will and so withall but one nature for the which the Church condemned him in three generall Councels In which matter Caius against Pighius saith Synod 6. act 4.12.13 Synod 7. act vlt. Synod 8. act 7. How can Pighius cleare him whom Psellus Tharasius Theodorus with his Councell at Hierusalem Lâ—â— liv 〈…〉 p. â—lt Epiphanius and Pope Adrian affirme to haue beene an Heretike And Dominicus Bannes deriding Pighius calleth it a iest that now after nine hundred yeares Pighius can find all those wickednesses to be forgers 22. Pag. 91. I haue read that in the yeare 1408. in the Councell of Pâ—sa consisting of a chousand Diuines and Lawyers they were faine to depose two Popes at once Gregorie the twelfth and Benet the thirteenth â—hcodor â—â—c meas de 〈…〉 sum hist 〈◊〉 3 〈…〉 cap ◠§ 3. 〈…〉 Atten. vbi supra cap. 6. § 2. Sess 11.12 the tenours of whose depriuation cals them Notorious Scismatikes obstinate maintainers of Seism Heretikes departed from the faith scandalizing the whole Church vnworthie the Papacie cut off from the Church 〈…〉 Benet continued Pope still for all this a second Councell holden at Constance deposed him againe and declared that he had no right to the Papacie commanding all men to esteeme him as an Heretike and Scismatike The same Councell deposed also another Pope for heresie namely Iohn the three and twentieth against whom it was prooued that he held and defended as his iudgement that there is no eternall life Bian pag. 1384. Sess 34. nor no immortalitie of the soule nor resurrection of the dead Not long after the Councell of Basil deposed Eugenius the fourth See AEn Silu. qâ—aest Concil Basil lib. 2. apud Fascir expetend pag. 20. inde Declaring him to be a rebell against the sacred Canons a notable disturber and scandalizer of the peace and vnitie of the Church a Simonist a periured wretch incorrigible a Scismatike an obstinate Heretike By which exampics of Popes teaching false doctrines against faith and notable heresies I obserued the Church of Rome to haue been cleerely deciphered hauing such false prophets and teachers as Christ speaketh of easie to be discerned by the fruits of their doctrines either taught or professed or both And so this way of iudging Heretikes by their doctrine makes exceedingly against the Romane Clergie especially when I reflect vpon all the nouelties taught and confirmed euen by Popes approuing them as concerning the prohibition of Priests marriages the tolleration of the Stewes and Brothel-houses in Rome and other places adoration of the Eucharist with the worship of Latria with
Roman clergy of Kings that they care not how vnreuerently they speake against them their Magistrates and officers and others as they list some will not stick to say that Priests are not subiects to Kings nor are bound to giue answere truly to the temporall Magistrates or Bishops here in England further then they please Others will make no scruple to say that they may lawfully without sin if they can free themselues from being apprehended resist yea and kill his Pursuiuants in defence of themselues though others approuing also the same doctrine more milde and moderate will say it is better and a greater act of perfection to let themselues bee apprehended then so to resist as also because it may proue scandalous but in conclusion all hold it lawfull and all teach it and their ground is naturale est vim vi repellere it is a natural thing to repel force by force as also because no temporall or ciuill authoritie is sufficiently valued against the Priests of the Romane Church I will not relate what libertie the Romane doctrine against Princes giueth to sawcie subiects to speak what they list and to report such things against our late deceased Queene and his Maiestie now raining as are odious euen vnto mens minds to thinke of my hart trembles to remēber what horrible crimes I haue heard them charged with and no modest Christian would euer open his mouth or giue eare vnto them the disgust that such speeches haue giuen me is farre greater then I can expresse because all the world knowes them to be most hatefull lies and calumniations which only could be suggested by the diuell who is father of all lies and vntruthes and master of such Heretikes as the Apostle Iudas describeth Epist. Judae vers 8. dominationē spernunt despise power but no maruaile if men yeeld to such suggestiōs of the diuel since experiēce teacheth that this doctrine of the Popes supereminent power hath stirred many not only to speake but also to attempt diuers trecherous and rebellious enterprises against the late Queene deceased and much more horrible against his Maiesty al his roial Progeny without all mercy either to friend or foe as the discouerie of the powder treason plotted and designed by diuers giddy and inconsiderat heads associated with some of the society of Iesus hath of late made manifest to the world nay which is more odious such as are as they thinke themselues religiously affected to the society of Iesus Ioan. Wilson in mart Anglica haue not sticked to make some of the abetters of that hateful cōspiracy martyrs of the Roman Church as namely Garnet Ouldcorne wheras it is wel knowne as the right Honorable the Earle of Northhampton sheweth My Lord of Northhampton in his speech to Garnet Garnet was not called to the barre for any matter of conscience as some perhaps may publish out of rancor or peruersity of hart to set a faire glosse vpō the groūd of his professiō proueth it many waies by diuers presidents of fauor and therfore wel might he say to Garnet as he did foreseeing how his fellowes would be ready to canonize him In the same speech S. Augustine speaketh of some hot-headed fellowes in his time that not withstāding their life led in this world more latronū like theeues yet in their ends affected cultum honorem martyrum the seruice and honor of martyrs among whom I shall euer rancke with iust cause these powder-men But this proceedeth as many other actions of disalleagiāce do frō no other groūd then frō that noted doctrine of the Popes illimited power trāscendent authority in ciuil matters ouer Kings which he challengeth when Card. Bellar in his book against D. Barkley Note this in Bell. goeth so farre that contrary to his former doctrine he teacheth now that the Apostles were not subiect to ciuil power de iure but de facto Wherby we may see in time into what a gulfe and ocean of errors the doctrine of Rome if it be not prudētly preuented wil drowne the world in which principally carieth the clergy vpon a higher waue of pride then any in so much that the L. of Northamp out of the multiplicity of his reading In his speech to Garnet most prudētly noteth that by the course recourse of times accidents wise men obserue that very seldome hath any mischieuous attempt been vndertaken for disturbance of a state without the counsel and assistance of a Priest in the first in the middle or last act of the tragedy and that all along with such a a chorus of confedraes to entertaine the Stage whiles the liues hnd fortunes of great Princes being set vpon the tenter-hookes aue put all in hazard Which obseruation I would wish that all Priests would diligently marke and then doubtlesse they would bee carefull of their owne reputations and be more reuerently affected to higher powers than they are as it gladdeth mee to see some haue beene of late as Master Blackwell Master Warmington in his moderate defence and others whose good examples I heartily wish many more may embrace and follow not doubting but God by such beginnings may draw them so from step to step as perfectly to see and discouer the erroneous doctrines of the Church of Rome as well in other points of doctrine as in that of the Popes pretended authoritie ouer Princes in temporalls as he hath drawne lately master Sheldon a prisoner for the Roman faith and my selfe though no prisoner as I hope for our soules euerlasting good so also for the future benefit of many others and the fuller accomplishments of his more mercifull designements to others thereby who doubtlesse will so doe if we by our ingratitude and forgetfulnesse of so rich a benefite prouoke not his indignation against vs by euill conuersation and bad carriage of our liues as others haue done before vs to the aduantage of those whose communion they forsooke and disgrace of them to whose congregations they were conioyned Which doubtlesse we may doe if beholding the abhominations of the Church of Romes corruptions we consider them rather with a mind to reforme our own faults to draw others from them than to lay any disgracefull imputation vpon others further than to demonstrate the naughtinesse of the tree by the naughtie leaues floures and fruits that grow forth from it which in very truth is the onely cause why I haue so farre entred into this discourse because Christ saith According to Doctour Stapletons rule Ex fructibus eorum cognoscetis cos by their fruits ye shal know them Now therfore since out of the fruits of the Roman doctrine I find the teachers thereof to be such as Christ bids vs beware of I must say Father I haue sinued against heauen and against earth and therfore with humble acknowledgement of my faults desire that I may againe be receiued into his fauor 9 Now it resteth that I make trial of the
tell which was the true Pope but it was doubted throughout the christian world Hereupon som 30. yeres after the schisme begaN the Cardinalls meeting at the Councel of Pisa elected a third Pope so there were three Popes whereof Bellarmine saith It could not easily be iudged which of them was the true and lawfull Pope De Rom. Pontif. li. 4. ca. 14 euerie one of them hauing most learned Patrons Shortly after the Councell of Constance deposed them all three and created Martine which yet did not so extinguish the schisme but that in the Coun cell of Basil it brake out againe Naucl. gen 48. where the Duke of Sauoy was made Pope against Eugenius and was called Felix betweene whose resignation and the election of Clement against Vrban was seuenty yeeres for Clement was elected Anno 1379. Clem elected Felix resigned Anno 1449. which schismes as they ouerthrowe that article of faith I beleeue the holie Catholike Church for Zabarell saith To suffer many in the Papacie Zabar de susp Pauli post init is to offend that article of faith one holie Catholicke so are they such fruits as doe cleerely demonstrate the teachers of that Church which Christ biddeth vs take heede of Which fruits of schisme as they haue abounded in the Papacie so doe they euen till this day no lesse abound amongst the whole Clergie for mine owne experience teacheth me so much that there is such a rooted schisme and diuision betwixt those of the societie of Iesus and of the order of Saint Benet as also betwixt the secular Priests and the said societie that it is impossible euen for the Pope himselfe to make a quiet attonement between them and so different are the incorporations of the Romane Clergie euery one ambitiously ayming to outgoe each other in the fauor of the layty that whilst they striue to aduance themselues they hinder one another only the poore seculars whom the Iesuites seeke to calumniate with most impudent vntruths are likeliest thogh they be the honestest amongst them to go down the wind for want of Bishops among them to be their heads which is vnlikely to be obtaind in haste if the religious can hinder them by any cunning sleights and slie deuises yet in fine if the Papacie continue the Capuchines are most likely to preuaile because as one of them answered to one that wondered their Order liued in peace with the Iesuites which other Orders could not doe saying the cause was because the Iesuites desired to haue all and they desired to forsake all and to haue nothing wittily taxing the couetous desire of the Societie so may I conclude because the Capuchines desire to haue least most Papists in time will be enclined to fauour them as least burthensome to their Commonwealths 11 But now I must a little further the better to examine the Church of Rome by the workes and fruits of her teachers enter into the consideration of some of her Popes Martin Polon an 1607. Plat. in Siluest 2. fas cic temp an 1004. whom we shall finde to haue beene as wicked men if any credit is to be giuen to Stories as euer liued It is written of Siluester the second Other fruits of diuers particular Popes that being a Monke he forsooke his Monasterie and giuing himselfe to the Diuell followed him and did homage to him that all things might propser according to his minde which thing the Diuell promised him And so by briberie he obtained the Archbishoprickes of Rhemes and Rauenna and at last the Popedome also by the helpe of the Diuell vpon this condition that after his death he should be his bodie and soule In the end as he was saying Masse by the noyse of Diuels about him he vnderstood he should die whereupon confessing his sinne before the people he desired all the members of his bodie wherewith he had serued the Diuell to be cut off and the trunke of his bodie to be layed in a Wagon and buried where the horse would draw it Of whom Caesar Baronius Anno 991 nu 7. though he doth his best to excuse him confesseth notwithstanding That he forsooke his Monasterie and became a Courtier and in talking babling slaundering detracting flatterie and doublenesse of minde being made to deceiue he out-went all men Now as for Boniface the seuenth Baro. an 985. nu 1. Baronius writeth That he was a very villaine and a Church-robber a sauage theefe the cruell murderer of two Popes the inuader of Peters Chaire that had not so much as the haire of a Pope but was to be reckoned amongst the ransackers and spoylers of their countrey such as were Scilla and Catilione which were not comparable to this theefe that murdered two Popes Here are goodly fruits for the Vicar of Christ yet I find Pope Iohn the thirteenth farre more fruitfull than the former whome the Stories call a a Platin. in Io. 13. Naucler anno 956. Monster of a man b Platin. in Io. an 13. one from his youth vp defiled with all vice and turpitude more giuen to hunting than prayer when he could tend it for lecherie c Sigon reg Ital. l. 7. anno 963. Onuch annot Plat. in Io. 8. Luitprand l. 6. c. 6 7. quem refert Bar. an 963. accused and detected before the Emperour in a Synod of Bishops of Murthers Adulteries Incests Periuries and other vices of all sorts His whores that he kept are named Reynera a widow Stephana his fathers Concubine and her sister Ioane Anne and diuers others He turned the Palace of Laterane into a Stewes he would forcibly rauish wiues widowes and maides that came from other places to Rome on Pilgrimage the fame whereof made them afraid to come Hee would giue them Saint Peters golden Challices and Crosses for a reward He vsed Hunting openly and Dicing and Drinking at dice hee would call vpon the Diuell to helpe him drinke healths to the Diuell set mens houses on fire reuell it vp and downe the Citie in armour He ordained a Deacon in his Stable amongst his Horses a Bishop of tenne yeares old and made Bishops for money He put out his Godfathers eyes cut off his Cardinals members one mans tongue he cut out and maymed two Cardinals more cutting of ones nose and anothers hand d Anton. Chron. port 2. tit 16. c. 1 ff 16. fassic Tep anno 944 Baron anno 964. nu 17. in the end as he was committing adulterie with a mans wife hee was suddenly slaine by the Diuell and died without repentance Many others could I record whose fruits are most irksome to behold and vnholsome to taste but one Alexander the sixt shall serue for all who liued about a hundred yeares since Do Princip c. 18 of whom Machiauell writeth That hee did nothing but play the deceiuer of mankind he gaue his mind to nothing but villanie and fraud whereby to deceiue men He got the Papacie by Symonie Onuph vit Alex
Christs resurrection which the Angels reporting appeared in white garments The girdle Explicat myst sacr Miss The Girdle wherewith the largenesse of the Albe is tyed about signifieth according to Michael Suffragan of Mets that Christ often tyed his most high and perfect conuersation and so tempered it according to our infirmities and accommodated himselfe vnto our manners that by his actions we might be the better instructed vnto the knowledge of saluation And in another place sayth That it designes how wee ought to restraine the limbes of our minde least chastitie be dissolued with the prouocations of concupiscence Lib. 5. in Leuit. Isychius by the Girdle vnderstandeth fortitude therefore God said vnto Iob. comforting him in his afflictions Accinge vt vir lumbos tuos Girt thy loynes like a man The Manuplo Ibid. The Manuple sayth Michael the Suffragan signifieth the fruit of good workes wherewith we must be comforted when we are exercised with the calamities of this world And in another place hee sayth That it signifieth Christs immunitie from all peruerse and sinister actions But Iacobus de Voragine otherwise sayth De celebrat Missae it signifieth the buckler of faith And Bonauenture sayth The Manuple on the left hand signifieth the humilitie of Christ in this life In exposit myst sacr Miss or else the Manuple on the left hand noteth the combat of Christ for iustice sake The Stole Ibidem The Stole signifieth the voluntarie obedience of Christ as Michael the Suffragan of Mets sayth but Iacobus de Voragine will haue it meane a double-edged sword Iacob de Vor. de celebrat Missae lib. de sacra Altar cap. 10. In exposit myst sacr Missae The Vestment In exposit myst to out both with word and example And Stephanus Eduensis sayth That the Stole signifieth the obedience of the sonne of God but otherwise Bonaventure saith it signifieth the passion of Christ The Vestement saith Michael Suffragan of Mets hath two parts the first part which is the lesser signifieth the Church before Christs Passion the hinder part which is the greater signifieth the people of the Church vnited together after his Passion or otherwise he sayth that it designeth the charitie wherewith all the members of Christ must be conioyned to one the other But Innocentius sayth That the Vestement euery whit entire signifieth the vnitie of Faith Lib. 1. myst Missae c. 58. Germanus sayth it signifieth the Purple Garment which the wicked mocking Iesus put vpon him By these varieties of coniectures about the onely apparell of the Priests that must offer the sacrifice of the masse therein I obserued that there was no one true meaning appoynted by the Church for those ceremonies and that euery man may frame what symbolicall conceits they list vpon them therefore are they vnporofitable and rather to please the simple withshews than with any other assured sense so doth it appeare to be in other the ceremonies of the masse which as they are different in sense so are they ridiculous to practise or to behold The Introite signifieth the Fathers expectation of Christ as Michael Suffragane telleth vs Introite in explic mister mis or if we will beleeue Ioannes de Combis it signifieth the beginning of a good worke and it is doubled because in our beginning we must doe good and decline from euill or if we will giue credite to Germanus it signifieth the comming and entrance of the Sonne of God into this world The nine times repeating Kyrie Eleyson and Christè Eleyson is to the three Persons in Trinity as the chiefest of all prayers for the imploration of Gods mercy as Michael the suffragane of Metz noteth In explic myst sacr mis In comp Theol. verit li. 9. ca. 18. But Iohannes de Combis saith more that is That it signifieth the inuocation of Gods mercy whereof wee stand in neede many wayes the first three for remission of sinnes committed in heart tongue or worke concerning contrition confession satisfaction the second three waies for the grace of faith hope and charitie the third three wayes for glorification whereby wee shall reioyce in God aboue vs in our selues of our selues and for our neighbors about vs. Yet if wee may beleeue Iacobus de Voragine he teacheth that the 9. repetitions are in honor of the nine Orders of Angells In celeb Miss serm 2. which wee honor in such maner that we may attain vnto their societie which are distinguished into three Ternaries or Tertians and are sung 9. times because the Angells are distinguished into 3. Hierarchies or 9. orders Lib. 2. myst mis cap. 19. 4 part q. 37. offic mis 2. but otherwise teacheth Innocentius tertius and Alexander de Ales saying That they are said 9. times against 9. kinds of sins as appeares there at large Part 3. q. 83. art 4. yet if we please to credit Th. Aquinas saying thrice 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is for the person of the Father thrice 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is for the person of the Son then is added again thrice 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for the person of the holy ghost against the threefold misery of ignorance Fraction of sin of penalty Now as for the fraction of the hoast into 3. parts Iacobus de Voragine teacheth that this ceremony was ordained by Pope Sergius as Albert. Magnus also thought De celeb mis ser 2. De ritibus eccle cap. lib. 1. de frac sacr Host. De sacra alt cap. 18. but Steph. Durant affirmes that it was instituted long before now wherfore it is thus thrice brokē Steph. Eduensis saith That the heast dedicated to the holy Trinity is diuided into 3. parts wherof the one is put into the chalice and drownd in the bloud for that part of the Church being tossed in the storme of this world which is crossed with many afflictions the other two without the challice are for those whereof the one is of the faithfull which is in purgatorie tried with fire the other of Saints which raigne euerlastingly with Christ But Th. Aquin. otherwise teacheth Part. 3 q. 83. artic 5. that the fraction of the hoast signifies 3. things 1. the diuision of Christs body in his passion 2. the distinction of his mystical body according vnto their diuers estates 3 the distribution of graces proceeding from the passion of Christ Cap 3 eccles Hier. teacheth Yet otherwise may it be vnderstood if we wil beleeue Iac. de Voragine who teacheth that it is broken into 3. parts to shew it is offred to honour the B. Trinity or to shew that in Christ there were 3. substances he flesh the soule and his godhead or to shew that it is offred for the mysticall body of Christ which is diuided into 3. parts of those that are to be saued virgins continent persons and those that are maried Now it is here to be noted how this Author contradicteth himselfe
I might well thinke my selfe bereâ—uâ—d of my right wittes if I should any longer offend GOD by the still offering of it as I haue done too often and by continuing the practize thereof to the eternall damnation of other mens soules Therefore curteous Reader if thou art a child of the Church of Rome follow no longer such a stepmother leading thee by publique appearances to thine owne ruine and to the dayly prouocation of Gods wrath against thee hate her fooleries detest her idolatries and abandon her communion if thou wilt not eternally perish albeit thou hâ—st long laine asleepe in the deadly lethargie of Romish superstitions awaken at last and breake off all the bands of thy sinfully-habituated affections to that Antichristian monarchie esteeme no longer that to be white which is blacke that to bee holie which is most vngodlie feare not the curses of the Pope in denying the Sacrifice of the masse to be propitiatorie for sinnes his excommunication will haue no such force as Antoninus the Archbishop of Florence had Lipelo in vita Ant. 2. Maij. who denouncing the sentence of excommunication vpon a white loafe of bread made it as blacke as a coale and freeing it afterward from the same curse it returned to be as faire as it was before All the Popes Anathemaes can not make the bread of the masse otherwise than it is idolatrous all the white flower in it cannot make it pleasing vnto GOD or a Sacrifice allowable for Christians Therefore say thou with mee from thy heart with mee in true detestation of all the abhominations committed by such Idolatrie Deus propitius esto mihi peccatori Lord bee thou mercifull vnto me a sinner CHAP. XIII Containing an obseruation about the doctrine of transubstantiation which is a principall noueltie taught in the Church of Rome AFter the former obseruations had sufficiently alienated by iudgement and affections from further approbation of the faith of Rome My proceeding about the doctrine of transubstantiation yet because I thought that I could not bee sufficiently enough armed against those errours and falshoods wherein from my youth both my vnderstanding and affections had beene habituated which would be powerfull still to incline and leade my soule againe vnto those Romish abhominations which long custome had made familiar and in conceit religious I still proceeded further to the discussion and discouerie of other errors false doctrines secceeding nouelties taught in that Church that more and more beholding her spirituall fornications and disloyalties I might in my soule bee the stronger to oppse against them and the better able to relinquish and abandon with assurance of truth of my side and securitie to mine owne conscience all communion and participation with her sinfull heresies and nouelties and happily auoyde Gods iust punishments which are threatned by the holy Scripture against her disloyalties to the faith of Christ her heauenly Spouse 2 Amongest all which there was scarce any one thing that wrought more powerfully and fearefully in mine vnderstanding It ought to be a great terror to adore the creature for the Creator euen to the terrour of mine owne soule for my erroneous doctrine deliuered to others than the discouery of this late new-sprung-vp doctrine of transubstantiation which sets vp such an Idoll of bread in the Church of Rome to be adored as God that that seemeth to be truly verified of her which was vttered long before Colet Deum quem ignorauerunt patres eius auro Argento lapide pretioso rebusque pretiosis Dan. 11.38 He shall honour the God whome his fathers knew not with gold and siluer with precious stones and with pleasant things The gainsaying of which doctrine vnto the Church of Rome seemeth so vnlawfull that shee pronounceth most bitter execrations against those that shall so doe Sess 13. an 2. If any shall say sayth the Councell of Trent that in the holy Sacrament of the Eucharist there remaineth the substance of bread and wine together with the bodie and bloud of our Lord Iesus Christ and shall denie that admirable and singular conuersion of the whole substance of bread into the bodie and of the whole substance of wine into the bloud the formes of bread and wine still remaining which conuersion the Catholike Church most fitly calleth Transubstantiation be he accursed 3. Yea The Church of Rome hateth the reformed Churches for nothing more than for impugning the doctrine of Transubstantiation Pet. Besseus concept Theolog. Quadraeg dom 3. Dan. 13. the Teachers and Preachers of that Church doe not hate the worthie Professors and Arch-Doctors of the Gospell for any point of doctrine more than for impugning this of Transubstantiation Peter Besse the great and famous French Preacher against Master Caluin and Luther speaketh thus Two wicked old men of vnbridled lust did wickedly accuse the most chaste Susanna of Adulterie notwithstanding that shee was the most chast and honestest that was to be found in the whole Kingdome of Babylon here againe wee see two craftie knaues marching out vpon the Stage Luther and Caluin that accuse the chaste Susanna viz. the holy sacred Sacrament of the Eucharist and Transubstantiation the chiefe member thereof of Idolatrie then the which notwithstanding there is nothing to be found in the world more holy or diuine And the samd Author soone after for the same point compares them to the two witnesses of most deperate audacitie that gaue false witnesse against Christ adding further That as Christ was crucified in the middle betweene two theenes Ibid. so likewise wee see it fareth with the Sacrament of the Altar where being placed betweene two theeues two most desperate Heretikes it is assaulted with diuers blasphemies who a little after speaketh vnto the Idoll in this manner and also to God saying Worthily therefore O sacred Eucharist thou mayest crie out Dirupisti vincula mea Psal 115. tibi sanctificabo hostiam laudis And thou O Lord Saepe expugnauerunt me a iuuentate mea For often O Lord haue they persecuted thee often haue they blasphemed against thee shot their arrowes at thee and chiefely at Transubstantiation This Preacher it should seeme hath forgot that the doctrine of Transubstantiation is a noueltie of no greater antiquitie than the fourth Councell of Laterance Iacques Gualter Chron. de Pestat du Christianis tries siecle Can. 1. which was held but in the yere 1215 vnder Innocent the third which is not yet 400 yeres since where that doctrine was deliuered in these wordes But the bodie of Christ and the bloud in the Sacrament of the Altar is contained vnder the formes of bread and wine the bread being transubstantiated into the bodie and the wine into the bloud by Gods power This it seemeth his Maiestie very iudiciously obserued when after he had said If the Romish Church hath coyned new articles of Faith neuer heard of in the first fiue hundred yeares after Christ I hope I shall neuer be
because so it wanteth an essentiall part thereof Therefore very iustifiable is his Maiesties assertion when reckoning vp the nouelties of the Church of Rome amongst the rest he ranketh the amputation of the one halfe of the Sacrament from the People Praemonit 4 Secondly that the doctrine of the Church of Rome doth crosse Christs institution It also crosseth Christs institution is also most cleere to any iudiciall man for as my Italian master teacheth me That the Eucharist was instituted in the last Supper Tract 4. de sacra c. 1. dico 2. after the washing of feet before the vsuall Supper the first is a matter of faith out of the Gospell and it is defined in Clementine Vnico in the Tridentine Councell where it sayth Ses 13. c. 1. 2. This is the tradition of the auncient Fathers Now then if this be so we must examine whether Christ did institute it vnder both kindes or not for if he did then certainely it is also so to be ministred likewise to the people because hee bid that to be done in remembrance of him which he himselfe did then his meaning not being to institute two Sacraments of the Supper whereof the one for the Priestes should consist of two parts or of two kindes the other for the people but of one I finde Saint Matthew to record Christs institution in this manner As they did eate Iesus tooke the bread Mat. 26. v. 26.27.28.29 and when he had blessed it he brake it and gaue it to the Disciples and said Take eat this is my bodie Also he tooke the Cuppe and when he had giuen thankes he gaue it them saying Drinke ye all of it for this is my bloud of the New Testament that is shed for many for the remission of sinnes I finde aso Saint Marke to set it down thus Mark 14. v. 22. And as they did eate Iesus tooke the bread and when he ahd giuen thankes hee brake it and gaue it to them and said Take eate this is my bodie And also hee tooke the Cuppe and when hee had giuen thankes gaue it to them and they all dranke of it and hee said vnto them This is my bloud of that New Testament which is shed for many S. Luke records it thus Luk. 22.19 20 And he tooke bread and when he had giuen thankes he brake it and gaue to them saying This is my bodie which is giuen for you doe this in remembrance of me Likewise also after supper he tooke the Cup saying This Cup is that new Testament in my bloud which is shed for you 1. Cor. 11. v. 23 24.25.26 27.28.29 And S. Paule most largely explicates the same Institution saying I haue receiued a Precept of the Lord which I also haue deliuered vnto you that the Lord Iesus in the night when he was betrayed tooke bread and when he had giuen thankes he brake it and said Take eat this is my bodie which is broken for you this doe ye in remembrance of me After the same manner also he tooke the Cup when he had supped saying This Cup is the new Testament in my bloud this doe as oft as ye drinke it in remembrance of me for as often as ye shall eate this Bread and drinke this Cup ye shew the Lords death till he come Wherefore whosoeuer shall eat this Bread and drinke the Cup of the Lord vnworthily shall be guiltie of the bodie and bloud of the Lord. Let euery man therefore examine himselfe and so let him eat of this Bread and drinke of this Cup for he that eateth and drinketh vnworthily eateth and drinketh his owne damnation because he discerneth not the Lords bodie Now out of all these places of S. Mathew S. Marke S. Luke and S. Paule I finde both kindes instituted by Christ and so inseparably intimated with a copulatiue coniunction that whosoeuer separateth them can but most insolently oppose himselfe against Christs institution and the essence of the Sacrament What greater pride can there be than when Christ sayth in expresse words Drinke ye all of this as well as eate the bread than with the Church of Rome to contradict him teaching the people onely to eat the bread and not drinke the wine Or what greater presumption than so rudely to thwart S. Paule who calleth the institution of the Sacrament a Precept which he deliuereth to the people specifying both formes of bread and wine commaunding as well the receiuing of the wine to be drunke in remembrance of Christ as the bread to be eaten and therefore if the one bind lay people the other also doth as strongly oblige them especially since S. Paule in another place sayth thus 1 Cor. 10.16.17 The Cup of blessing which we blesse is it not the communion of the bloud of Christ The bread which we breake is it not the communion of the bodie of Christ for we that are may are one bread and one bodie because we doe partake of one bread and one Chalice The Church of Rome taking away the participation of the Chalice in ministring the Sacrament to lay people onely vnder the forme of bread maketh S. Paule to speake false who ioyneth both formes together with a coniunction copulatiue shewing that we are many one bodie because wee participate of both making vs all one And it is here to be noted how the Bibles printed amongst our aduersaries doe varie about this Text and may be suspected that they haue played Legier du maine with the Bible as well in their last corrected Latine as in the Greeke concerning this Text for in them both of one Chalice is left out and yet in an olde Manuscript which I haue now in my hands and in another Bible printed at Paris in the yeare of our Lord 1583 the text is That omnes quidem de vno pane de vno calice participamus We all partake of one bread and of one Chalice Whereby it is more than probably to be feared some notorious imposture hath beene committed in leauing out the Chalice in the latest vulgar editions So that now all these places of Scripture being iudicially weighed the amputation of one part of the Sacrament seemeth not onely to controll Christs owne institution but also his absolute commandement 5 Besides that it is a meere noueltie It is also a noueltie Lib. de Eccles obseruat c. 19. p. 388. Thom. in 1. Cor. 11. lect 5. 6. Aeneas Sil. Hist Bohem. c. 52. Bellar. de Euehalib 4. cap. 26. not grounded vpon antiquitie is most apparant to all that rightly examine the matter for at the first the people receiued the cup as well as the bread afterward sayth Micrologus the Romane Order commandeth the wine also to be consecrated that the people may fully communicate and this was approued by many learned Writers Yet in time the Councell of Constance See 13. ff item ipsae forbad it and then all of the Church of Rome began to change
their mindes Afterward the Councell of Basil released the decree of Constance to some as to the Bohemians and the Councell of Trent confirmed it againe Ses 21. c. 2. Whereby it is apparant that the moderne Church of Rome hath swarued in this point of faith from which it beleeued formerly and since it began to be the seat of Antichrist The most ancient Liturgies in their owne forme shew Cyril Cath. mystag 5. Liturg. Marci pag. 62. Thom. p. 3. q. 80. art 12 q. 3. Hom. 16. in nu 1 that the people receiued the wine as well as the bread And Caietane sayth This custome endured long in the Church and that they had ministring cuppes for the nonce to serue the people with wine which none will denie Origen sayth plainegly Christian people were accustomed to drinke the bloud And S. Cyprian How doe we make them fit for the cup of Martyrdome Epist. 2. if first we doe not admit them by the right of communication in the Church to drinke the cup of the Lord The same Author or another as ancient Serm. de coena Dom. in another place sayth The Law doth prohibit the eating of bloud the Gospell commaundeth that it be drunke That the Chalice also was vsed in S. Ambrose his time himselfe sheweth Apud Theod. 5. Hist 15. In 2. Malach. speaking to Theodosius With what boldnesse wilt thou partake with thy mouth the cup of precious bloud S. Hierome sayth in expresse tearmes The Priestes which make the Eucharist and distribute the bloud of the Lord to the people And Paschasius sayth Super cap. 15. Drinke ye all of this as well the ministers as the other beleeuers Apud Gratian. can Comperimus de consecrat dist 2. Gelasius sayth We finde that some receiuing onely the portion of the sacred bodie abstaine from the cup of sacred bloud Who doubtlesse because I know not by what superstition they are taught to be obliged either let them receiue the entire Sacraments or let them be expelled from the entire Sacraments because the duision of one and the same mysterie cannot be without grat sacriledge All which places doe most liuely expresse the faith and practise of the ancient Church to haue beene otherwise than it is now in the present Church 6 Is it not a lamentable thing to see Obserue well this Councell Ses 13. that the Councell of Constance confesseth That Iesus Christ instituted and administred the Sacrament vnder both kinds and that in the Primitiue Church this Sacrament was receiued by the faithfull vnder both kinds And yet against Christs institution and the practise of the Primitiue Church the same Councell most blasphemously complaineth That in some parts of the world some rashly presume that Christian people ought to receiue the Sacraments vnder both kinds and thus censures it to be presumption and rashnesse to follow Christ Of the Fathers of that Councell with the Pope himselfe I may well say Concilium inierunt vt caperent Iesum in sermone Exod. 7. But as the Serpent of Moses deuoured the Serpents of the Sorcerers so Christ will ouercome the malice and craft of such wicked counsellors It is a folly for our aduersaries to say That when Christ said Doe this in remembrance of me he spake onely to Priests for then it would follow that the lay people may be debarred of both kinds and it is as impertinently obiected that the Apostles were Priests therefore Christs Precept Drinke ye all of this belongs to Priests onely for then the Primitiue Church did amisse and S. Paule the Apostle also who deliuered the Supper to the lay people without amputation of either kind in such manner as he had receiued it of the Lord. My conclusion vpon the precedent obseruation Now therefore vpon due consideration of all the premisses finding the Church of Rome to adulterate the word of God to ouerthrow the nature of the Sacrament to goe against the doctrine of the Primitiue Church and to checke most impudently Christs owne institution cursing them that beleeue as Christ teacheth and doe as he commaundeth in drinking as well of the Cup as in eating the Bread of the Sacrament without diuision or amputation I see no ground of faith to warrant the doctrine of the Church of Rome in this case and therefore it is to be feared vnlesse God shew her the greater mercie for all her maledictions and curses to the terror of poore simple Christians shee her selfe will one day inconsolably tast of the bitter cup of Gods wrath and indignation which vpon the suddaine will be poured vpon her to her vtter ruine and destruction and shee that hath so much afflicted and tormented others will find it true that Horrendum est incidere in manus Dei viuentis It is a horrible thing to fall into the hands of the liuing God CHAP. XV. Containing an obseruation of the Pardons and Indulgences which the Peope annexeth to Crosses Graines and Meddals I Haue obserued in reading the liues of Saints a storie worth the noting of Iohn the Bishop of Hierusalem Metaph. in vita S. Epiph. Laurent Surius 12. Maeij who hauing with his honors changed also his minde being surprised with extreame couetousnesse he grew to heape vp great store of treasures beyond all reason or measure which Saint Epiphanius vnderstanding endeuoured to draw him to some liberalitie towards the poore but he who preferred his gold before all other workes of charitie cared not for the poore Epiphanius seeing this obtained of him a certaine summe more by force than by loue which he distributed amongst the poore with great ioy Few daies after the Bishop redemanded againe his money with great importunitie vnto whom Epiphanius gaue good wordes promising to repay him soone after but the Bishop was not contented but vsed him with some violence vttering iniurious speeches against him calling him impostor and cosener Epiphanius nothing troubled spit in his face wherewith instantly strucken blind he fell to the ground whereupon at length he acknowledged his fault crauing pardon Then Epiphanius shewed him into what a gulfe of couetousnesse hee was plunged putting his hand vpon his head restored him his right eye againe who praying him to restore him also his left eye the holy man refused it to the end he should be alwaies warned by that marke euer after to vse more modestie and more carefully to auoid that plague of couetousnesse In this example courteous Reader you haue a liuely representation of the Bishop of Rome his insatiable auarice now that hee is come to such temporall greatnesse in this world and consequently of the spirituall blindnesse wherewith God hath strooken him for the same not suffering him to see the light of truth but to runne head-long into diuers inextricable heresies as a iust punishment for such his greedy desires for the nouelties which are now broched in the Church of Rome were not knowne till this hateful sinne of auarice tooke
sweet prouidence and mercie for those that liue in a most blinded and yet zealous ignorance of the errors they are in wrapped in by the slights of their false teachers seducing them who are much more industrious and laborious for the kingdome of Antichrist than the true professors of the Gospell are for the kingdome of Christ according to our Sauiours owne words Prudentiores sunt filij tenebrarū quam filij lucis in generatione sua The children of darknesse are more prudent in their generation than the children of light Against whom I will daily pray that those who stand as sentinels ouer the reformed Churches may both haue aud carefully practise our Sauiours words in another place as an holesome Autidote Estote prudentes sicut serpentes simplices sicut columbae Be ye prudent like serpents and simple like doues vsing serpentine prudence to defend their faith and soueraigne rulers as their heads though with hazard of their owne bodies and liues and not omitting such a sweet doue-like simplicity and mildnesse without gall of malice that their aduersaries may be ouercome by the obseruation of their wisdome and their Christian-like charitie towards them 3 But to returne whence I am digressed The Church of Rome by terrors more thē by proofes endeuors to plant the beliefe of seuen Sacraments I discouer the idlenesse of the Romish Anathema by the error and noueltie of the doctrine of seuen Sacraments for the desence wherof the Councell hath thundered it out for I can find no Scriptures making properly for seuen no nor any one ancient Father reckoning seuen onely and no fewer nor more as for Baptisme and the blessed Eucharist there is no doubt to be made for all the things which the Church of Rome requireth to a Sacrament properly taken do concurre therein Belarm lib. 1. de sacra Bapt. cap. 1. Hebr. 6. vers 4. Ephe. 5. vers 26. Iohn 3. vers 5. the externall right is expressed in Saint Paul calling it The lauer of water in the word of life The institution and commandement vnlesse a man be borne of water and the spirit he cannot come vnto the kingdom of God c. and in going teach ye al people baptising them in the name of the Father Mark vlt. v. 16. and of the Sonne and of the holy Ghost the promise of grace who beleeneth and is baptised shall be saued but who beleeueth not shall be damned So likewise in the Eucharist the externall rite is found to be bread and wine Mat. 26. vers 26 Ioh 6. vers 57. The institution and commandement at the last supper do this in remembrance of me The promise of grace he that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood abideth in me and I in him Whereby it is apparent that of these two Sacraments the Scriptures shew al the things most plainly belonging vnto a Sacramēt properly taken as the Church of Rome vnderstandeth of Sacrament with all the things necessarily belonging thereunto and therefore that these two are Sacramnts is cleere in their vnderstanding which the Church of England according to all antiquitie doth admit but the other fiue receiued by the Church of Rome either in one effētiall thing or other belonging to a Sacrament properly taken are defectiue as either in the sensible signe or in the institution and commandement or in the promise of grace notwithstanding that all must concurre according to the Church of Rome to a true Sacrament Now therefore although I could particularly shew by the disabling of the other fiue that there are not seuen Sacraments as the Councell of Trent defineth yet because I will auoid prolixitie I will only proue it by shewing that penance is no such Sacrament 4 All Diuines of the Church of Rome do ioyntly agree that euery Sacrament consisteth of matter and forme Penance no Sacrament properly neither is auricular confession any essentiall part thereof Tho. Aquin. part 3. quaest 84. art 2. in corp S. Tho. part 3. vbi supra art 3. in corp the matter say they of this sacrament are cōtrition cōfession and satisfaction for the sinnes on the behalfe of the penitent the forme is the words of absolution pronounced by the Priest Thomas of Aquine their cheefe Doctor saith thus The nearest matter of this Sacrament are the acts of the penitent whose matter are sins which he repenteth which he confesseth and for which he satisfieth And in the next article he sheweth the forme saying It is cleare that this is the most conuenient forme of this Sacrament I do absolue thee With whom Viguerius also agreeth saying Ioannes Viguer Instit cap. 16. vers 1. The nearest matter of the Sacrament of Penance are the acts of the penitent contrition confession and satisfaction the matter of which acts are sinnes which the penitent repenteth which he confesseth and for which he satisfiesh In whose assertions I obserue two notable errors first that they count Penance a Sacrament which is onely a vertue disposing men to the Sacrement of the Eucharist according to that Probet seipsum homo sic de pane illo edat Let a man proue himselfe and so eat of that bread which prouing must be by repentāce And secondly that they make auricular confession consisting in a circumstantiall enumeration of sinnes in their numerall distinct kinds to a Priest an effentiall part of that Sacrament neither of which can bee proued in Scriptures I cannot but admire to see so great a Doctor as Thomas Aquinas was Tho. Aquin. part 3. de sacra poenit art 1. sed contra Act. 8. to make a most weake argument for proofe of this Sacrament saying that as Baptisme is adhebited for the purification of sinne so Penance Therefore Peter said to Simon do penance for this thy wickednesse but Baptisme is a Sacrament as is said before therefore Penance also for the like reason Heere is a stout reason and of great force certes especially when we consider that the Angelical doctor following the vulgar translation misalleageth the Scripture for in the Greeke set out by Arias Montanus the Greeke word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 signifieth not do penance Arias Montan. in 8. Act. Apost vers 22. but repent thou as the same Author though a Romanist translateth it Neither is it heere to be omitted how notoriously the Rhemists do depraue the same place of Scripture who in excuse of their following the vulgar translation adde a notable falsehood and vntruth saying In annot Act. 8. vers 22. That the Greeke 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 doth signifie as much is it not strange then that Arias Montanus I thinke as good a Grecian as any of them would haue swarued from their translation but their imposture in this place is most inexcusable shewing that they care not what they say so they may crosse the reformed Churches as appeareth when in the table before the new Testament printed anno 1600 wherin they charge the English editions of false translation
is a Sacrament since neither hee nor any other can shew any such institution But it followeth by him notwithstanding that as I my selfe haue cited the afore said place of Genesis it well prooueth the state of marriage to haue beene ordayned by GOD. For which as the Scripture saith a man shall forsake his father and mother Verse 29 and hee shall cleaue vnto his wife and they shall bee two in one flesh 3 Which first institution was renued by Christ when he said Haue yee not read Diuers reasons grounded vppon the Scriptures for the approbation of priests marriages Matth 19. Hebr. 13.14 that hee which did make from the beginning made them male and female and hee said for this cause man shall leaue father and mother and shall cleaue to his wife and they two shall be in one flesh That therefore which God hath ioyned together let no man separate And the same Institution is Declared to be honourable among all men and their bodies vndefiled if therefore among all men then also among Priests if it were honourable for respect of the Author that ordained it which was GOD himselfe why shall it not also bee honourable for his Priests If it were honorable in the time of innocencie before it was decayed why should it not be honorable in the time of grace wherein man is repaired as wel for Priests as others if it were honourable because it was ordained in Paradise the happiest place of the world why shall it not also be honourable in the Church of Christ amongest Church-men who honour God in the happiest places that is in the Churches ordayned to Gods honour besides since God the Sonne honoured the state of mariage with his presence at Canaan of Galilee where hee wrought the first miracle that euer he did turning water into wine with his praiers comparing the kingdome of God to a wedding and holinesse to a wedding garment why should wee thinke that Christ will not be well pleased that his Priests should honor that state with their owne persons is not increase multiplication of children which is one principall end of marriage as honorable a blessing in Priests as in others or is not the inconuenience of solitarinesse signified in these words It is not good for man to bee alone that is without a helpe and comfort which is an other end of marriage as fit for Priests as for Lay peopleâ— or is it not as fit that Priests should haue a remedy for fornication aswel as other men taketh their preshood from them the nature of men or can their dignities in the Church of God giue them leaue to liue lasciuiously in a single life are all Priests assured that during their liues they shall alwayes enioy the gift of continencie or is it absolutely in mans power to haue it or not to haue it why then doth S. Paul say Quipotest capere capiat he that can take it let him take it no no they haue as much neede of such a helpe as any other How comes it that many yea most of the Clergy in the country of Liege and diuers other places keep concubines what is the cause that most of the Priests of Brittaine haue also their bedfellows liuing in the house with them in the state of whoredome but their want of mariage whence so many deâ—â—ourings of virgins so many fornicatioÌ„s so many adulteries so many bestialities recorded by diuers authors amoÌ„g Clergy men in the church of Rome but the want of this remedie instituted by God practised in the old Lawe by the holiest as Henoch Noah Abraham Dauid Ezechiel Aaron and other high Priests approoued by Christ called honourable by S. Paul amongest all men What is not the doctrine of S. Paul to be approoued who alloweth the marriage and the bed vndefiled to all men excluding none when he saith 1. Cor. 7.2 Because of fornication let euerie man haue his owne wife Here we see marriage is prescribed a remedy for euerie man 4 And if wee looke into the practise of the Primitiue Church The new Testament maketh for the marriage of Priests we shall find the same remedy to haue beene vsed without checke or controule May we thinke that S. Paul excluded Priests when hee said 1. Cor. 9. It is better to marry than to burne Doth his Doctrine debarre Priests of marriage when hee saieth If thou takest a wife thou sinnest not 1. Cor. 28. Doth not Saint Paul sharpely reprooue them that shall forbid marriages when hee saieth In the latter dayes some shall depart from the faith and shall giue heede vnto spirites of errour Note this and doctrines of diuells which speake lies through hypocrisie and haue their consciences burned with a hot yron forbidding to marrie 1. Tim. 4.1.2 3. By diuers of my former Chapters I haue shewed the Church of Rome to haue departed from her former faith now it is apparent they teach doctrine of diuells because they forbid Priests to marrie and teach the Doctrine to bee good Is it to bee thought that Saint Paul did not allow Priests to marrie when hee said A Bishoppe must be vnreprooueable the husband of one wife hauing children vnder obedience with all honest 1. Timoth 3.2.4 And when hee said Let Deacons be the husbands of one wife and such as can rule their children well and their owne housholde 1. Timothy 3.12 Can it bee said that Saint Paul doeth not approoue marriage in Priests and Deacons when he alloweth them one wife children and housholde to haue care of What may bee probably inferred vpon the wordes of Saint Paul to the Philippians the last chapter translated by the Rhemists thus I beseech thee my sincere companion By occasion of which words Cardinall Bellarmine saith that it is more probable Saint Paul had no wife Clem. Alexand. 3 stromat Ignatius epist ad Philadelph against Clemens Alexandrinus and Ignatius in some Editions who holde he had a wife which standeth well with the translation of the Church of England saying My faithfull yoake fellow I will not stand much vpon this place leauing the probabilitie thereof to the Reader But sure I am that Saint Peter had a wife for Saint Matthew saith Matth. 8.14 That our Sauiour entred into Saint Peters house and sawe his wifes mother I trow this is plaine enough that he had a wife It is left also recorded That Philip the Euangelist which was one of the sâ—auen Deacons had foure daughters virgins which did prophesie Acts 21.8 9. Ignatius the disciple of Saint Iohn Euangelist writing to the Philadelphians Ignat. ad Philadelph maketh report That Peter Paul and other Apostles were married Clemens Alexandrinus writing against those that reprooued marriage Ecclesiast hist libr. 3 cap. 3â— amongst other things speaketh thus What doe they reprooue the Apostles Peter and Philip had wiues and they gaue also their daughters in marriage to men Neyther doth Saint Paul the Apostle thinke
Instit christ ca. 16. § 7 vers 9. non modicum not of small importance whether the Pope can dispence in the first degree of the first kinde of Affinity that two brethren may successiuely haue the same wife or two sisters the same husband It seemeth that hee can not because the Pope cannot dispence in the Law of Nature But the first aforesaide degree of Affinitie is prohibited by the Law of Nature Thou shalt not reueale the turpitude of thy Brothers wife because it is thy turpitude for that as Rabbi Moyses saith the Lawe giuen in that place excludeth onely those persons from marriage who are to conuerse and dwell together amongst whom the one is to keep the others pudicicitie and so only he excepteth them which by the law of nature are excepted from matrimony since the text brings a naturall reason saying Because it is the turpitude of thy brother And the refore herein the Lawe is not figurall but morall and no dispensation can be made of morall precepts And of this opinion S. Thomas seemed to bee for hee saieth In. 4 dist 39. q. 1 art 3. ad tertium that that Law doth yet continue because if Infidells and he speaketh not of Iewes but absolutely of all Infidells before they are conuerted haue contracted matrimony against that law after faith receiued they cannot continue in such matrimony Therefore this Law is morall and not iudicial And although from the beginning of mankind when the Author of nature dispenced for the fewnesse of men to contract marriages in the same degree yet not after multiplication because the dispensation and inclination of contracting ceased not only in consanguinitie but also in Affinitie And although God haue dispensed with the Iewes yea also cammanded a brother to take his brothers wife to raise his brothers seede that his brother might haue children that his name might not bee blotted out of Israel But if the brother had children it was forbidden Deuteronom 25 Leuiticus 20. for it is said Hee that shall marry the wife of his brother shall do an vnlawfull thing Since therefore that of raysing the brothers seed was a iudiciall Lawe and all the iudiciall Lawes were finished in the death of Christ and God dispenceth not in them it followeth that neyther the Pope can dispence with it because it is morall and naturall neyther is it alike in a Vowe and an Oath with the aforesaid degree of Affinitie or Consanguinitie because although Christ gaue power ouer all contracts and consents of men to annull them or change them Vt habetur in cap. quemad de iureiurando Because in all such the condition is to bee vnderstoode if it please the Superiour yet hee gaue them not power to chaunge Nature which should bee done if hee should dispence in the first degree of Affinitie and in others recited in Leuiticus and if sometimes it may bee found that dispensation hath beene giuen to some hoc fuit de facto sed non de iure This was a matter of fact not of right Hitherto Viguerius By which discourse it is cleare that hee holdeth the precept of one brother not to marry his brothers wife nor contrariwise to be a moral precept which admits no dispensation and therefore if the Pope dispence in it he doth more than belongeth to his ecclesiasticall power and authority whereby we see now that which I said in the beginning of this chapter to be specified viz. that the Church of Rome attributing too much by an ouer-deeming conceit of her owne power vnto marriage one way allowing it where it is vnlawfull and derogating from marriage an other way by restrayning it where it is by God allowed she is miserably deluded by the Diuell 9 Now therefore curteous Reader this being so My conclusion vpon the premisses haue I not had reason to flie from her daunger obseruing the reformed Churches to haue discouered this perillous deceit of the Diuells Had I not reason to vnite my selfe to them especially this of England from the which my Parents before mee were most vnfortunately seduced to the iust punishment of my name and family euer since not thinking it fit to rest vpon the example of Eutiches the heretike saying That as he had learned of his Fathers and beleeued in the faith wherein hee was borne euen so hee desired to die but rather to giue eare unto the Councell of God Concil Calced art 2. declared by the mouth of his Prophets properly agreeing to my selfe Walke not yee in the ordinances of your Fathers neyther obserue their wayes nor defile your selues with their Idolles Ezec. 20.18 19. I am the Lord your God walke in my Statutes and keepe my iudgements and doe them CHAP. XIX Containeth the Conclusion to the Reader with a recapitulation of all the precedent obseruations for the Readers profit WHen I turne backe my memorie courteous Reader vpon all the precedent obseruations contained in this hooke An acknowledgement of Gods mercie and loue in drawing me to his truth Osee 11. verse 4. by the which I see my selfe to haue bin drawne as it were with so manie Ropes of Gods bountifull loue and singular mercie from the manifolde errours nouelties and the most sinnefull Idolatries of the Church of Rome vnto the true Faith and Religion of Christ Iesus Mee thinketh I doe feele my selfe possessed with a burning loue of Gods goodnesse enforced to rancke my selfe as one of the number of those whome God by the mouth of his holy Prophet Osee promised to drawe vnto him saying Traham eos in funiculis Adam in vinculis Charitatis I will draw them in the ropes of Adam in the chaines of Charitie Could God drawe mee by stronger chaines of Charitie than such are as hee hath drawne mee by from darkenesse to light from ignoraunce to the knowledge of his trueth when with a true feeling I doe reflect vppon my former obseruations I beholde mee thinketh our Sauiour Christ Iesus shooting foorth the bright beames of his wisedome vpon my endarkened Soule by the which hee hath as it were drawne me and guided my wayes vnto him as comfortably as he did the Sages of the East to adore and worship him in his Cribbe at Bethlem which doeth exceedingly replenish my heart with true ioy and comfort in Christ Iesu our Lord and Sauiour In the serious speculation of which great fauour from heauen I am compelled to call to remembraunce that straunge thing which Saint Augustine in his Booke De Ciuitate Dei and ninth chapter vt refert Cornel. Muss auerreth himselfe to haue seene seeming to the hearer to bee a great prodigie and a most wonderfull myracle of Nature who reporteth that hee sawe a Loadstone of so great power and efficacie that it drew manie Rings vnto it which were one of them behinde the other placed farre off asunder first one then that drew the other the third the fourth and so consequently all the rest vntill that at length