The Catholick HIERARCHIE OR The Divine Right of a SACRED DOMINION IN CHURCH AND CONSCIENCE Truly Stated Asserted and Pleaded Put them in mind to be subject to Principalities and Powers to obey Magistrates and to be ready to every good work Tit. 3.1 Give none offence to Jews nor Gentiles or to the Church of God 1 Cor. 10.32 The spirit of a man is the candle of the Lord searching all the inward parts of the belly Prov. 20.27 LONDON Printed for Sam. Crouch at the Princes Arms in Popes-head-Alley in Cornhil and Tho. Fox at the Angel in Westminster-hall 1681. TO A WORTHY GENTLEMAN SIR WHen the mindes of men are blinded with Interest and Errour or vitiated with Prejudice and Partiality the wonted manner of opposing Truth is fortiter calumniari being not able any longer to defend themselves by subtile Sophistry and cunning Evasions from the convincing evidence and demonstration thereof Hence it must be either stigmatized with terms of Opprobry and Contempt or its right names exposed by a proverbial and malicious abuse to the scorn and derision of the Ignorant and unstable Vulgar most easily by artificial pious Fraud inspired with a fond Opinion and through the enchantment of that Opinion transported into a furious Zeal for or against such things as they never weighed in any balances of right Reason or duely examined the goodness or evil of and hence are carried this way or that way as designing men shall lead them or as the wind of Popularity raises the swelling Surges of boundless Passions and Affections verifying the Saying of the old Poet 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Menand Opinion more than Truth impression makes On th' Vulgar and as more perswasive takes And truely Sir among good words perverted from the right meaning and abused to Reproach none have been more than those two which the Author of this small Treatise hath dignified his Title-page with A Catholick in our days is become as contemptible as a Puritan formerly or a Phanatick now whenas every good Christian is really a Catholick and doth approve himself so in his Principles and Practice is a Member of the Catholick Church hopes to be saved by the common i. e. the Catholick Faith exerciseth Catholick Holiness in his life and conversation holding a Catholick Communion with all visible Catholicks And this is the Christian that is likeliest to contribute most to the healing the manifold heart and Church-divisions among us And as for Hierarchy it 's well known how our Age hath delivered it up to the infamous usage of scurrilous Tongues and Pens notwithstanding its venerable and never-enough to be admired significancy that the very naming it calls for Reverence and Devotion yea it s very letters and syllables will be a Monument of Renown maugre all the designes of ill-minded men to abandon the Churches glory and to convert all Ecelesiastical Decency and Order into a confused Chaos of phantastical Imaginations or a miscelany of private Humours and Interests And do men know what Hierarchy is that speak so irreverently of it is it not a Sacred Jurisdiction and where is it seated and exercised is it not in the Church and Conscience seats of its dominion so sacred that no Secular Power can aspire unto without the highest usurpation And there is no true Church and sound Conscience in which the Hierarchy doth not exert its power and is not as freely submitted unto with all due homage and obedience And whatever some licentious Protestants may pretend to and raise so much dust of contention about or of whatever Churches of unquoth names and worse natures they profess themselves Members if ever they intend to be saved they must notwithstanding all their religious Huffs at last be found Members of the Catholick Church and be subjected to the Catholick Hierarchy thereof And till this professed subjection become more universal among Christians Religion will still be splitting on the Rocks of Faction Schism and Phanaticism Sir you will finde the principal designe of those few sheets submitted to your judgment is to recommend this Panacaea or Catholick Remedy for the sound healing of of our morbid Church which seems to labour under some Disease not unlike the Microcosmick Scorbet being according to the account of late Physicians a complication of all Distempers or transforming it self Symptomatically into the shapes of all diseases of the Body natural Without doubt our Remedy being prepared and applied S. Artem Spiritualem may contribute towards the recovery of our thrice-honoured but languishing Mother more than all the essential or golden purging Spirit of Cochlear in London can do to the restoring of one Scorbutick body neither is it prepared in every Elaboratory He saith there is one at Westminster can do more towards it than any in England besides He tells me also of one admirable Vertue that it doth wonderfully pacifie the disquieted Archeus of a Body Politick and if it be so I will assure you it 's to be preferred beyond all compare for the plain truth of it is the old Remedies of purging and bleeding do but scurvily agree with it and it 's very apt to Relapses after those rugged Medicines as we finde by sore experience Sir my Friend hath taken some pains out of love to his Country to clear up the nature and demonstrate the necessity of a Catholick Hierarchy though you must not expect to finde that word often mentioned the Vulgar being so apt to start at it as a hard dangerous word pregnant with a Pope Sir I had not obtained leave of my Friend to present these Papers to your view but upon condition that I would apologize on his behalf for the plainness of his Stile saying that he is naturally a stranger to the smooth dresses or high strains of Rhetorick indeed it 's my judgment that the plain truth especially when it acts polemically requires it not but is usually delighted in a garb most like it self and thereby is rendered most acceptable to every good man and solid judgment He likewise humbly desires that you will deliberately read and not suddenly censure any thing as dissonant to truth till you have duely weighed it in it self as in its dependencies and suppositions on which it is built Sir to conclude I humbly crave pardon for the trouble I have given you though I am fully satisfied the subject will not be unpleasant to you whom I know to be an Ecclesiastical Adeptus In respect of your Catholick spirit superlative love to the Church and singular devotion towards the Hierarchy That you may long live and continue in the same minde and practice and many follow your worthy Example is the devout Prayer of SIR Your most humble Servant Catholicus Verus The CONTENTS Chap. 1. OF a Twofold Jurisdiction which a Christian by the Law of Christ is subjected unto Chap. 2. Of a Legislative and Executive Power Chap. 3. Of Christ's immediate Legislative Power Chap. 4. Of Christ's mediate
Catholick unless it be in the visible universal Head and if it be said that a National Church may positively determine in this kind then why not a Provincial as well the one being a subordinate Church as well as the other But if the Decree be onely National as many various interpretations and sences may be put on a place of Scripture as there are Nations which will lay an ample foundation for variety of Sects Schisms Heresies c. Whereas if all National Churches were bound to one Catholick determination there must needs therehence ensue the admirable effect of Uniformity in Doctrine and Practice all Churches believing as the Vniversal Church believes and that as the Head doth Besides if it be of such dangerous consequence for Christians as private persons to put their interpretation on Scripture in laying the foundation of variety of Sects Schisms Heresies c. how much more dangerous for particular Churches because the determination of a Church reacheth further and is more attended unto and more become seduced and leavened with errour thereby if it be erroneous Hence to believe as the Catholick Church believes hath more concern in it than those imagine that endeavour to blast it with the ridicle of the Colliers Faith for it 's not as the National Church believes but as the Catholick Church believes Neither is it an implicit Faith in any things but controversal and dubious matters above ordinary scrutiny and vulgar capacity and therein we had better rest satisfied in Catholick Authority than run the risk of adhering to the Opinion of private persons and Churches which must be done also by an implicite Faith and who is likely to have the most unerring Spirit a Church or particular Person and if a Church the most Catholick is the most unerring § 13. Thirdly From the Necessity of a Catholick determination of Decency and Order That is decent which by the Universality is reputed and judged so for one Countrey doth usually call that decent which others repute undecent And there are no Protestant Prelates but have do and will say That Christ hath left it to the Church to determine all matters of Decency and Order and 't is absurd to say that this or that Church may do it when no such is the Church eminently When 't is said the Church determines Decencies What Church is that Is it a Parish-Church Nay then Parish-Churches should rule Diocesan by a Law Again if Diocesan Churches should have power to determine their Decencies either Provincials must be subject to some one Diocesan which might regulate all the rest or else Diocesan Churches would differ so much in their decencies that there would be no Uniformity in the Provincial Church And if Provincials might determine each one its Decencies and Order it must needs break Vniformity in National Churches But I know where the Protestant Prelate will be he will say presently it 's the National Church that he means when he speaks of the Churches determination of Decency and Order To which I reply that he may with as good ground say that he means a Parish-Church and that by giving this power to a National Church he gives a greater advantage to Schism and lays a greater bar against Vniformity For the more comprehensive the Church is in which the Schism is the greater it is and the more uniform the Schismatical Church is of the more dangerous consequence it is to the Catholick Church In vain do men plead for Vniformity in the Church who in asserting the principles of Vniformity in a National Church do thereby extirpate Vniformity in the Catholick for National Vniformity unless it be Catholick is but Vniformity in a Schism For if every National Church may determine of Decency and Order there will be as great a diversity if not contrariety in several Churches affairs as in the affairs of several States one Nation determining that Ceremony to be decent which another determines to be undecent absurd and disorderly and so Churches will be as divers in their Fashions as English Dutch Spaniard c. And there will be no end of Ceremonies and new-fangled Garbs in the Church if a Nation may of themselves and when they will constitute ordain and appoint them at their pleasure alter and null old Ceremonies and invent new and shall have as great difficulty intricacy and multiplicity of Church-Laws as State-Laws if at every Convocation Decency and Order may be determined § 14. From the necessity of a Catholick composure of Church-Prayers the more private and singular the conception of Church-prayers are the more Schismatical And divers Liturgies in one and the same National Church may not be allowed neither that every Province and Diocess compose their own Liturgy as being a matter of dangerous consequence to the National Church How then comes it to pass that our National Church may compose its own Liturgy distinct from another Is not this of as dangerous consequence to the Catholick Church And is' t not more conducing to the Peace Beauty Uniformity and Honour of the Church to have a Catholick Liturgy Whereas otherwise every Nation will be setting up the price of their own prayers above others whence ariseth heart-burning Divisions and Schisms National in the Catholick Church were it not much better that all Nations should bring their Liturgies and lay them down at the feet of Mother-Church and submit them to her Judgment in the Supreme Head from whose blessed hands she may receive one of such Catholick composure that might produce a perfect Harmony in the affections and petitions of all the Churches in the world in good assurance of a Catholick Amen attending the conclusion of all Besides if a National prayer be more available than a Provincial or Diocesan Why should not a Catholick Church-prayer be most of all available § 15. Fifthly The necessity of a Catholick Canonization of Saints For supposing the Necessity of the Observation of Saints days as the Protestant Prelates zealously assert it is requisite to enquire who or what Church Canonized the Saints which are already honoured with Saintship Titular and Days devoted to their remembrance and who dedicated and consecrated Churches on the same account was it not the Catholick Church by her Catholick Pastors If every Church suppose National should have the like liberty to canonize Saints at their pleasure all the days in the Year yea in an Age would be little enough for All Hollan-tide And if the observation must be Anniversary there would be a necessity of robbing Peter to pay Paul which would be doing evil that good may come of it it being as great a sin to rob Peter of his fishing-nets as to rob Paul of his cloak and parchments Besides this Absurdity would fall in that one Nation would canonize that for a Saint which another would anathematize to the Devil As for Example Michaelmas-day is devoted to St. Michael the Archangel which Feast was instituted by Felix the Third the 48th Oecumenical
other Pastors subordinate infallible And it is the greatest reason that he that hath the greatest Charge should have the best understanding to know how to manage it And to what purpose is it for us to seek after further light by going to those that the Church hath further entrusted if they be not holier wiser and juster men than our selves yea than all their inferiour Officers And what is it we aim at most in such Enquiries is it Fallibility or Infallibility Would any one in his best wits be deceived and would the Church deceive any but use the best ways and means for enlightning mens Understandings and reducing them from darkness and errour § 9. Arg. 6. I argue from the nature of the Church in which this Subordination is required That Church must be understood to be the universal visible Church and not any particular Church 1. From the usual acceptation of Church in the like sence when we say The Church with an Emphasis 2. There is no more reason the Church should be understood of one kind of particular Church more than another a Provincial Church or Diocesan may be called the Church by way of eminency as well as the National and if there be more reason because the National is comprehensive of them then much more that the Catholick should be understood by it because it comprehends Nationals and is most comprehensive of all Churches on Earth So that it will unavoidably follow that if there be a Subordination of Pastors in the Church it is in the Catholick Church and the more large the Church is the more extensive is the power of the Pastor and the most comprehensive Church hath a supream Pastor to the Pastors of all other Churches subordinate to it Obj. But the universal Church Visible is not Organical and therefore not capable of an Oecumenical Pastor Answ It is Organical for it 's made up according to our present Phainomena of a Church of visible organized or organical parts comprehending each other and therefore must needs have a visible organical Head principium sensus motus animating all the parts in their respective Subordinations and Relations It 's absurd to say that the hand organized with fingers and joynts the feet with toes and all its parts and so of the other members that these united in one body make not up an organized body and have not one Head common to the totum to communicate respective vigor to each of these members So to say that in the Church there is National Churches organized c. so Provincial c. Diocesan organized and not that the universal Church visible is organized with and influenced by a visible Head is most absurd Again there is the same and greater reason upon the forementioned grounds for the Organization of the Catholick Church than for the organizing of a National Provincial or of any of the inferiour Subordinate Churches for if Order and Uniformity and due administration of Government cannot be maintained in one but by Organization how can they by any other means be obtained in the other And if Order Uniformity c. be not onely comely and beautiful but most necessary to the well-being of a National Church and that the more because it is so comprehensive of other Churches subordinated to it how much more requisite is it to the well-being of the Catholick Church which comprehends National and all others § 10. Arg. 7. That this Catholick Headship is inseparable from a co-ordination of Pastors in the Church may be evinced from these following Necessities 1. A necessity of a Catholick judgment of Schism 2. Of a Catholick interpretation of Scripture it being not of private interpretation 3. Of a Catholick determination of Decencies and Order 4. A Catholick composure of the Prayers of the Church 5. A Catholick Canonization of Saints 6. A Catholick convention or call of Oecumenical Councils § 11. The first Necessity is for a Catholick judgment of Schism for if it be not determined by a Catholick judgment these absurdities will follow 1. National Churches may be Schismatical and no competent judge of them it being not fit that one National Church should judge another they being co-ordinate equally concerned of equal authority latitude and fallibility Neither may a Provincial be judge of National Schism they being subordinate to the National and included in it for they are bound up in the determination of the National and is accountable to it and if it declares against the National as guilty of Schism and upon that account separates from it she shall be judged as Schismatical from the National and so Schism will be committed on Schism and none healed 2. If there be no Catholick determination of Schism there can be no Catholick punishment of Schism from the Catholick Church for the punishment must be preceded by a Law-determination And hence if a National Church be Schismatical from the Catholick it cannot receive any Catholick punishment and it will follow that such a sin may be committed in the Church on which she is not capable to inflict a punishment in any measure proportionate to it 3. If a National Church hath power to judge of the Schism of a Provincial Church and a Provincial Church of the Schism of a Diocesan and a Diocesan of the Schism of a Parochial then by the same reason may the Catholick Church judge of the Schism of a National Church otherwise Schisms will be equally multiplied with National Churches and no redress to be made of them 4. If there be not a Catholick determination of Schism all Churches will not be agreed about Schism so that whilst there is a perpetual controversie in the Church what Schism is and what is not Schism perpetually remains and false judgment still passed upon some Churches these calling that a Schismatical Church which is not so others owning another Church as not Schismatical which is really so All which tends to a necessary and unavoidable confusion for want of a Catholick determination whereas if it may determine by its visible Head all those Controversies would be ended for if the members of the Body complain one of another the whole Body must determine the matter by the Head where there is a concurrence of all parts for the good of the whole § 12. Secondly From the necessity of a Catholick determination of dubious places of Scripture This can be done by none but the Church Catholick on Earth for no Scripture being of private interpretation where shall such an interpretation be found that is not private but in such as is of the Catholick Church where the concurrent judgment and faith of all Churches may be heard 2 Pet. 1.20 the word is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of private Solution i. e. not of particular persons or Churches private Solution but such as is universal and commonly received by all Churches and Christians according to the analogy of faith Now where can this be found and rested in as
indifferency of any thing to impose it as necessary But in Spiritual concerns the indifferency of any thing is a reason against the imposition of it as necessary because such an imposition takes away the Formal use as an indifferency 3. What Christ hath revealed as indifferently requisite he hath required a Christian to use indifferently by the judgment of discretion for every action concerning Christ's worship is to be performed as Christ hath prescribed the nature of it necessary things to be done necessarily by us but not to be imposed on us and indifferent things indifferently Therefore an Imposition to enforce the use of indifferent things necessarily and necessary indifferently is unlawful as contrary to the Will of Christ 4. We have before proved that neither Church nor State can change an Evangelical Indifferency in the Worship of Christ into a Necessity § 10. Arg. 3. To exercise Dominion over Mens Faith is unlawful but for Church or Magistrate to impose a set Form of Prayer is to exercise Dominion over Mens Faith Ergo. The Major is without question and to exercise such a Dominion is to prescribe what we shall believe and practice or to enforce us to practice in Sacred things without believing The Minor is true because there can be no greater exercise of Dominion over Faith than in imposing on us a Form of Prayer for every Prayer is to be prayed in Faith or else it is sin Now to impose a Form on me being to enforce me to that Prayer that I be not satisfied in is to impose on my Faith i.e. to prescribe what I should believe for practice in Prayer or to enforce me to practice that which I do not believe i. e. to pray that Prayer and that constantly in such a part of Worship which I cannot do believingly § 11. Arg. 4. If one Church may enforce a Form of Prayer by a Penal Law then another may i. e. if a National Church may enforce a Form of Prayer on all her Subordinate Churches and Members then the Vniversal visible Church may on the National which are her Members and if the National can punish the Diocesan or Parochial for Non-conformity in this kind why may not the Catholick punish the National for the same fault i. e. for using a Form of Prayer not sufficiently allowed or prescribed by the Catholick and if the National can interdict an inferiour Church or Excommunicate a particular person for refusal of such Obedience why may not the Catholick deal with the National in the same kind This must needs be conceded but that it will be said we do not know Where to find the Catholick Church and though the Church of Rome calls herself so yet she is not to be believed she bears witness of herself and that witness is not true I only reply We can as easily and more find the Catholick Church as a National for there hath been always a Catholick Church but there never hath been nor will be a National Gospel organized Church in the world And we may as well believe a pretending Church calling herself Catholick as a pretending Church calling herself National when as they are equally to be accounted as no Churches of Christs Ordination as I can easily manifest when time shall serve Well then the National Church lyes liable to the censure of the Church Catholick for using a distinct set Form of publick Prayers established by her self whereby she renders herself a gross Non-Conformist to the Catholick Church and an Independent in respect of all other National her Form of Prayer being not Uniform with theirs If it be said the Church may compose and impose a Form of Prayer we must know what Church that is and not be deluded with a Name Is it the Catholick Church if so why have we not a Catholick set Form of publick Prayers and all National Churches bound to the use of it And why on the contrary doth every National Church make and use Forms of their own And if it be said The National is the Church it 's false for it 's not the Church by way of Eminency it 's not the most Generical Church because it 's not the only Church there are many National and there are many other sort of Churches that will put in for as good a right as the National and if every National under the Name of the Church may do this and have a distinct Form of Prayer what will become of Catholick Vniformity And if the Church as Provincial or Diocesan what will become of National Vniformity And if this power be granted to any or all these subordinate Churches Actum erit de Vniformitate Catholicâ § 12. But the great plea for a Form of Prayer in the Church is Vniformity for this cannot be say some Men without it Answ Uniformity in the Church cannot be by particular National Forms it must be by a Form Catholick 2. Can there be no Vniformity in the Church without a sameness in Words and Sentences in prayer there scarcely being two Scripture-Prayers that are altogether the same in Words and Sentences Doth not Uniformity consist rather in agreement in Principles and the Analogie of Faith submission to and closing with the same King Priest and Prophet conforming to and walking by the same rule of the Gospel an influence and guidance by the same Spirit 3. If Uniformity of the Church lyeth in such Externals why is not a set Form of Preaching established that none shall use any other besides such Homilies 4. If a set Form of some Prayers be necessary to Vniformity why not of all as well of private as publick for if the Church be not close tyed in bond of Vniformity by uniting Families and Individuals it will break to pieces for all a publick Form The first and main Union in the Church is that which knits every purticular Member to the whole by joynts and bonds and that there may be true Uniformity this must be carefully maintained but it 's 〈◊〉 which the great contenders for a pretended Uniformity least 〈◊〉 themselves about § 13. Another great plea for publick Forms of Prayer is the 〈◊〉 ness ignorance and laziness of many Ministers Rep. The 〈…〉 holds for set Forms of publick Sermons the necessity of which for a time was well considered at our first coming out of Antiâ—â—â—â—an darkness and any one that could read but a Chapter Prayer and Homily in the Mother-Tongue did a great deal of service to God and the people But there is not the same reason now the Church is better provided with able Labourers or at least might be if she would 2. It is the ready way to fill the Church with this sort of Cattle those lazy ignorant scandalous Priests for Mother-Church not only to connive at them but to countenance them and maintain them in their pride and sloth and by making their Exercisâ—s for them whilst they be idle debauched and prophane minding nothing but the profits pleasures and Honours of this Life 2. The only way Ignavum fucos pecus a praecipibus arcent is to banish these droans from the Church and not to turn all the Church unto droans and nothing starves them sooner than to leave them to their own stock for Praying and Preaching and it 's best that their Ignorance be bewrayed that they may be ashamed and get better instruction and exercise in Spiritual things which are to be guides to other Mens Souls or if they be not ashamed the people may have a full knowledge of them and be wiser than to entrust their Souls in their hands Therefore it 's good that the Props be taken away and it will soon appear whether such pretended Church-pillars be sound or rotten § 14. What is alleadged about Ministers abuse of parts in publick Prayers or want of sufficiency is no forcing Argument for imposing a Form for the abuse of good things is no argument against the use we may as well say Because some will be Drunk therefore none must drink Wine or Beer 2. Insufficient Ministers are to be removed or further instructed if they be capable and willing as Apollo was 3. Are not Church-Prayers lyable also to abuse when used by sottish Priests in a formal customary slovingly and prophane 〈…〉 and a hundred times more wrong done thereby to the honour of Religion and the poor Souls of the people than by some weak expressions and sentences or words struck out of joynt by the laborious faithful and zealous Ministers that conscientiously endeavour to use and improve the Talents given them to the service of Christ the conversion and edification of the Souls of the people FINIS