Church And this is a Glorious Priviledge indeed if they could prove that they had it and that it would be so certain a remedy against Heresie and give a final Decision to all Controversies But there is not one tittle of all this of which they are able to give any tenable Proof For 1. All the pretence for their Infallibility relyes upon the truth of the former Proposition That the Church of Rome is the Catholick Church and That they say is Infallible And I have already shewn that That Proposition is not only destitute of any good Proof but is as evidently false as that a Part of a thing is the Whole 2. But supposing it were true That the Roman Church were the Catholick Church yet it is neither evident in it self nor can be proved by them that the Catholick Church of every Age is Infallible in deciding all Controversies of Religion It is granted by all Christians that our Saviour and his Apostles were Infallible in the delivery of the Christian Doctrine and they proved their Infallibility by Miracles and this was necessary at first for the Security of our Faith but this Doctrine being once Delivered and Transmitted down to us in the Holy Scriptures Written by the Evangelists and Apostles who were Infallibly assisted by the Holy Ghost we have now a certain and Infallible Rule of Faith and Practice which with the assistance and instruction of those Guides and Pastors which Christ hath appointed in his Church is sufficiently plain in all things necessary And as there is no evidence of the Continuance of Infallibility in the Guides and Pastors of the Church in the Ages which followed the Apostles because Miracles are long since ceased so there is no need of the Continuance of it for the Preservation of the True Faith and Religion because God hath sufficiently provided for that by that Infallible Rule of Faith and Manners which he hath left to his Church in the Holy Scriptures which are every way sufficient and able to make both Pastors and People wise unto Salvation 3. As for a certain Remedy against Heresie it is certain God never intended there should be any no more than he hath provided a certain Remedy against Sin and Vice which surely is every whit as contrary to the Christian Religion and therefore as fit to be provided against as Heresie But it is certain in Experience that God hath provided no certain and effectual Remedy against Sin and Vice for which I can give no other reason but that God does that which He thinks best and fittest and not what We are apt to think to be so Besides that Infallibility is not a certain Remedy against Heresie The Apostles were certainly Infallible and yet they could neither prevent nor extinguish Heresie which never more abounded than in the Apostles Times And Saint Paul expresly tells us 1 Cor. 1. 19. That there must be Heresies that they which are approved may be made manifest And St. Peter the 2 Epist. 2. 1. That there should be false Teachers among Christians who should privily bring in damnable Heresies and that many should follow their pernicious ways But now if there must be Heresies either the Church must not be Infallible or Infallibility in the Church is no certain Remedy against them I proceed to the next Step they make viz. 6ly That Christ hath always a Visible Church upon Earth and that They can shew a Church which from the time of Christ and his Apostles hath always made a Visible Profession of the same Doctrines and Practices which are now believed and practised in the Church of Rome but that We can shew no Visible Church that from the time of Christ and his Apostles hath always opposed the Church of Rome in those Doctrines and Practices which we now revile and find fault with in their Church That Christ hath always had and ever shall have to the end of the World a Visible Church Professing and Practising his True Faith and Religion is agreed on both sides But We say that he hath no where promised that This shall be free from all Errors and Corruptions in Faith and Practice This the Churches Planted by the Apostles themselves were not even in Their times and during Their abode amongst them and yet they were true parts of the Christian Catholick Church In the following Ages Errors and Corruptions and Superstitions did by degrees creep in and grow up in several parts of the Church as St. Austin and others of the Fathers complain of their Times Since that several Famous Parts of the Christian Church both in Asia and Africa have not only been greatly corrupted but have Apostatiz'd from the Faith so that in many Places there are hardly any Footsteps of Christianity among them But yet still Christ hath had in all these Ages a Visible Church upon Earth tho' perhaps no Part of it at all times free from some Errors and Corruptions and in several Parts of it great Corruptions both in Faith and Practice and in none I think more and longer than in the Church of Rome for all she boasts her self like Old Babylon Isa. 47. 7 8. That she is a Lady for ever and says in her heart I am and none else besides me And like the Church of Laodicea Revel 3. 17. which said I am rich and increased with Goods and have need of nothing When the Spirit of God saith that she was wretched and miserable and poor and blind and naked and knew it not Thus the Church of Rome boasts that She hath in all Ages been the True Visible Church of Christ and none besides her free from all Errors in Doctrine and Corruptions in Practice and that from the Age of Christ and his Apostles she hath always professed the same Doctrines and Practices which she does at this day Can any thing be more shameless than this Did they always believe Transubstantiation Let their Pope Gelasius speak for them who expresly denies that in the Sacrament there is any Substantial change of the Bread and Wine into the Body and Blood of Christ. Was this always an Article of their Faith and necessary to be believed by all Christians Let Scotus and several other of their Schoolmen and Learned Writers speak for them Was Purgatory always believed in the Roman Church as it is now defined in the Council of Trent Let several of their Learned Men speak In what Father in what Council before that of Trent do they find Christ to have Instituted just Seven Sacraments neither more nor less And for Practices in their Religion they themselves will not say that in the Ancient Christian Church the Scriptures were with-held from the People and lockt up in an Unknown Tongue and that the Publick Service of God the Prayers and Lessons were Read and the Sacraments Celebrated in an Unknown Tongue and that the Sacrament of the Lords Supper was given to the People only in one Kind Where do they find in Holy
them under an Inconvenience when they shall come at Age. And can we think them of discretion sufficient at that time to do a thing of the greatest Moment and Consequence of all other and which will concern them to all Eternity namely to chuse their Religion There is indeed one Part of one Religion which we all know which Children at Seven Years of Age are fit I do not say to judge of but to be as fond of and to practise to as good purpose as those of riper Years and that is to worship Images to tell their Beads to say their Prayers and to be present at the Service of God in an unknown Tongue and this they are more likely to chuse at that Age than those who are of riper and more improv'd Understandings and if they do not chuse it at that time it is ten to one they will not chuse it afterwards I shall say no more of this but that it is a very extraordinary Law and such as perhaps was never thought of before from the beginning of the World Thus much for Children As for grown Persons who are of a very low and mean capacity of Understanding and either by reason of the weakness of their Faculties or other Disadvantages which they lye under are in little or no probability of improving themselves These are always to be considered as in the condition of Children and Learners and therefore must of necessity in things which are not plain and obvious to the meanest Capacities trust and rely upon the Judgment of others And it is really much wiser and safer for them so to do than to depend upon their own Judgments and to lean to their own Understandings and such Persons if they be modest and humble and pray earnestly to God for his Assistance and Direction and are careful to practise what they know and to live up to the best Light and Knowledge which they have shall not miscarry meerly for want of those farther degrees of Knowledge which they had no Capacity nor Opportunity to attain because their Ignorance is unavoidable and God will require no more of them than he hath given them and will not call them to account for the improvement of those Talents which he never committed to them And if they be led into any dangerous Error by the negligence or ill conduct of those under whose Care and Instruction the Providence of God permitted them to be placed God will not impute it to them as a Fault Because in the Circumstances in which they were they took the best and wisest course that they could to come to the knowledge of the Truth by being willing to learn what they could of those whom they took to be wiser than themselves But for such Persons who by the maturity of their Age and by the natural strength and clearness of their Understandings or by the due exercise and improvement of them are capable of enquiring into and understanding the Grounds of their Religion and discerning the difference betwixt Truth and Error I do not mean in unnecessary Points and matters of deepest Learning and Speculation but in matters necessary to Salvation it is certainly very reasonable that such Persons should examine their Religion and understand the Reasons and Grounds of it And this must either be granted to be reasonable or else every man must continue in that Religion in which he happens to be fixt by Education or for any other Reason to pitch upon when he comes to Years and makes his free Choice For if this be a good Principle that no Man is to examine his Religion but take it as it is and to believe it and rest satisfied with it Then every Man is to remain in the Religion which he first lights upon whether by Choice or the Chance of his Education For he ought not to change but upon Reason and Reason he can have none unless he be allowed to examine his Religion and to compare it with others that by the Comparison he may discern which is best and ought in reason to be preferred in his Choice For to him that will not or is not permitted to search into the Grounds of any Religion all Religions are alike as all things are of the same Colour to him that is always kept in the dark or if he happens to come into the Light dares not open his Eyes and make use of them to discern the different Colours of things But this is evidently and at first sight unreasonable because at this rate every Man that hath once entertained an Errour and a false Religion must forever continue in it For if he be not allowed to examine it he can never have Reason to change and to make a change without Reason is certainly unreasonable and mere Vanity and Inconstancy And yet for ought I can see this is the Principle which the Church of Rome doth with great Zeal and Earnestness inculcate upon their People discouraging all Doubts and Inquiries about their Religion as Temptations of the Devil and all Examinations of the Grounds and Reasons of their Religion as an inclination and dangerous step towards Heresie For what else can they mean by taking the Scriptures out of the hands of the People and locking them up from them in an unknown Tongue by requiring them absolutely to submit their Judgments and to resign them up to that which they are pleased to call the Catholick Church and Implicitly to believe as She believes tho they know not what that is This is in Truth to believe as their Priest tells them for that is all the teaching Part of the Church and all the Rule of Faith that the common People are acquainted with And it is not sufficient to say in this matter that when Men are in the Truth and of the right Religion and in the Bosom of the true Church they ought to rest satisfied and to examine and enquire no farther For this is manifestly unreasonable and that upon these Three accounts 1. Because this is a plain and shameful begging of the thing in Question and that which every Church and every Religion doth almost with equal Confidence pretend to That Theirs is the only right Religion and the only true Church And these Pretences are all alike reasonable to him that never examined the Grounds of any of them nor hath compar'd them together And therefore it is the vainest thing in the World for the Church of Rome to pretend that all Religions in the World ought to be examined but Theirs Because Theirs and none else is the true Religion For this which they say so confidently of it That it is the true Religion no Man can know till he have examined it and searched into the Grounds of it and hath considered the Objections which are against it So that it is fond Partiality to say that Their Religion is not to be examined by the people that profess it but that all other Religions ought to be examined or
and by consequence all those Truths which have a necessary Connexion with those Articles and are implied in them and by plain Consequence are to be deduced from them It is not the doubtful and uncertain Traditions of Men nor the partial Dictates and Doctrines of any Church since the Primitive Times which are not contained in the Holy Scriptures and the Ancient Creeds of the Christian Church but have been since declared and imposed upon the Christian World though with never so confident a pretence of Antiquity in the Doctrines and of Infallibility in the Proposers of them These are no part of that Faith which we are either to profess or to hold fast because we have no reason to admit the Pretences by virtue whereof those Doctrines or Practices are imposed being able to make it good and having effectually done it that those Doctrines are not of Primitive Antiquity and that the Church which proposeth them hath no more claim to Infallibility than all other Parts of the Christian Church which since the Apostles time is none at all In a word No other Doctrines which are not sufficiently revealed in Scripture either in express Terms or by plain and necessary Consequence nor any Rites of Worship nor Matters of Practice which are not commanded in Scripture are to be esteemed any part of that Faith in Re-Religion the Profession whereof the Apostle here Commands all Christians to hold fast without wavering much less any Doctrines or Practices which are repugnant to the Word of God and to the Faith and Practice of the first Ages of Christianity of which kind I shall have occasion in my following Discourse to instance in several Particulars In the mean time I shall only observe That that Faith and Religion which we profess and which by God's Grace we have ever held fast is that which hath been acknowledg'd by all Christian Churches in all Ages to have been the ancient Catholick and Apostolick Faith and cannot as to any part or tittle of it be denied to be so even by the Church of Rome her self I proceed to the II d Thing which I proposed to consider namely how we are to hold fast the profession of our Faith or what is implied by the Apostle in this Exhortation To hold fast the profession of our Faith without wavering And I think these following Particulars may very well be supposed to be implied in it 1. That we should hold fast the Profession of our Faith against the Confidence of Men without Scripture or Reason to support their Confidence 2. And much more against the Confidence of Men contrary to Scripture and Reason and the common Sense of Mankind 3. Against all the Temptations and Terrours of the World 4. Against all vain Promises of being put into a safer Condition and groundless Hopes of getting to Heaven upon easier terms in another Religion 5. Against all the cunning Arts and Insinuations of busie and disputing Men whose Design it is to unhinge Men from their Religion and to gain Proselytes to their own Party and Faction I shall go over these with as much Clearness and Brevity as I can 1. We should hold fast the Profession of our Faith against the Confidence of Men without Scripture or Reason to support that Confidence All Religion is either Natural or Instituted The Rule of Natural Religion is the common Reason of Mankind The Rule of Instituted Religion is divine Revelation or the Word of God which all Christians before the Council of Trent did agree to be contained in the Holy Scriptures So that nothing can pretend to be Religion but what can be proved to be so One or both of those ways either by Scripture or by Reason or by both And how confident soever Men may be of Opinions destitute of this Proof any Man that understands the Grounds of Religion will without any more ado reject them for want of this proof and notwithstanding any pretended Authority or Infallibility of the Church that imposeth them will have no more Consideration and Regard of them than of the confident Dictates and Assertions of any Enthusiast whatsoever because there is no reason to have regard to any Man's Confidence if the Arguments and Reasons which he brings bear no proportion to it We see in Experience that Confidence is generally ill grounded and is a kind of Passion in the Understanding and is commonly made use of like Fury and Force to supply for the weakness and want of Argument If a Man can prove what he says by good Argument there is no need of Confidence to back and support it We may at any time trust a plain and substantial Reason and leave it to make its own way and to bear out its self But if the man's Reasons and Arguments be not good his Confidence adds nothing of real Force to them in the Opinion of Wise men and tends only to its own Confusion Arguments are like Powder which will carry and do execution according to its true strength and all the rest is but noise And generally none are so much to be suspected of Errour or a Design to deceive as those that pretend most confidently to Inspiration and Infallibility As we see in all sorts of Enthusiasts who pretend to Inspiration although we have nothing but their own word for it for they work no Miracles And all pretence to Inspiration and Infallibility without Miracle whether it be in particular Persons or in whole Churches is Enthusiastical i. e. a Pretence to Inspiration without any Proof of it And therefore St. Paul was not moved by the Boasting and Confidence of the false Apostles because they gave no Proof and Evidence of their Divine Inspiration and Commission as he had done for which he appeals to the Sense of Men Whether he had not wrought great Miracles which the false Apostles had not done though they had the confidence to give out themselves to be Apostles as well as he 2 Cor. 12. 11 12. I am says he become a fool in glorying ye have compelled me And truly the signs of an Apostle were wrought among you in all patience in signs and wonders and mighty deeds And Rev. 2. 2. Christ there commends the Church of Ephesus because she had tried them which said they were Apostles but were not and had found them liars And as we are not to believe every one that says he is an Apostle so neither every one that pretends to be a Successor of the Apostles and to be endued with the same Spirit of Infallibility that they were For these also when they are tried whether they be the Successors of the Apostles or not may be found Liars And therefore St. John cautions Christians not to believe every spirit that is every one that pretends to divine Inspiration and the Spirit of God but to try the Spirits whether they be of God because many false Prophets are gone out into the World 1 Joh. 4. 1. And therefore the Confidence of Men
a Man should be very fit and able to judge of that which they esteem the main and fundamental Point of all namely which is the True Church and Religion and of the Reasons and Arguments whereby they pretend to demonstrate it and of the true Meaning of those Texts of Scripture whereby they pretend to prove theirs to be the only True Church and yet should be wholly unable to judge of particular Points of Faith or of the True Sense of any Texts of Scripture that can be produced for the Proof of those Points Is it so very prudent in all the particular Points of Faith for a Man to rely upon the Judgment of the Church because She is infallible and not to trust his own Judgment about them because He is fallible and may be deceived And is it prudent likewise for this Man to trust his own Judgment in the main Business of all namely Which is the true Church and Religion concerning which he is as fallible in his Judgment and as liable to be deceived as in the Particular Points And if he be mistaken in the main Point they must grant his Mistake to be fatal because his Sincerity as to all the rest depends upon it This is a great Mystery and Riddle that every particular Man should have so sufficient a Judgment as to this main and fundamental Business Which is the True Church and Religion and should have no Judgment at all about particular Points fit to be trusted and relied upon As if there were a certain Judgment and Prudence quoad hoc and as if all Men's Understandings were so framed as to be very judicious and discerning in this main Point of Religion but to be weak and dangerous and blind as to all particular Points Or as if a Man might have a very good Judgment and be fit to be trusted and relyed upon before he come into their Church but from the very moment he enters into it his Judgment were quite lost and good for nothing For this in effect and by interpretation they say when they allow a Man to be very able to judge which is the true Church and Religion but so soon as he hath discovered and embraced that to have no Judgment of his own afterwards of any Point of Religion whatsoever and a very tempting Argument it is to any Man that hath Judgment to enter into that Church 2. Another Art they use with their intended Proselyte in order to his makeing a right choice of his Religion is to caution him to hear and read only the Arguments and Books which are on one side But now admitting their designed Proselyte to be just such a Judge and so far as they will allow him to be and no farther viz. Which is the true Church but to have no Fitness and Ability at all to judge of particular Points of Faith yet methinks they put a very odd Condition and untoward Restraint upon this Judge in telling him as they certainly use to do those whom they would pervert That he must have no Discourse nor read any Books but only on that side which they would gain him to because that is the way to perplex and confound him so that he shall never be able to come to a clear Judgment and Resolution in the Matter But will any Man admit this way of proceeding in a Temporal Case This is just as if in a Cause of the greatest consequence the Councel on one side should go about to persuade the Judge that it is only fit to hear what he hath to say in the Case that he will open it very plainly and state the Matter in difference of clearly and impartially and bring such strong Reasons and Proofs for what he says that he shall not need to hear any thing on the other side but may proceed to Judgment without any more ado But if when the matter is thus laid before him so plainly and is even ripe for Judgment he will trouble himself needlesly to hear the other side this will cast him back where they first began and bring the Matter to an endless wrangling and so confound and puzzle his Understanding that he shall never be able to pass any clear Judgment in the Cause What think we would a Judge say to such a bold and senseless Pleader The Case is the same and the Absurdity every whit as gross and palpable in pressing any Man to make a Judgment in a Matter which infinitely more concerns him upon hearing only the Reasons and Arguments on one side 3. Another Art which they use in makeing Proselytes is to possess them that there is but One thing that they are mainly concern'd to enquire into and that is this Since there is but one true Catholick Church of Christ upon Earth out of which there is no Salvation to be had Which that True Church is And when they have found that out that will teach them in a most Infallible way the True Faith and Religion and all things that are necessary to be believed or done by them in order to their Salvation so that they have nothing to do but to satisfie themselves in this single Enquiry Which is the True Catholick Church of Christ This is the Vnum necessarium the one thing necessary and when they have found out this and are satisfied about it they need to enquire no farther this Church will fully instruct and satisfie them in all other things And this I cannot deny to be a very Artificial way of proceeding and to serve their purpose very well for they have these two great Advantages by it 1. That it makes the work short and saves them a great deal of labour by bringing the whole Business to one single Enquiry and when they have gained this Point that this single Question is all that they need to be satisfied in then they have nothing to do but to ply and puzzle the Man with their Motives of Credibility and Marks of the true Church and to shew as well as they can how these Marks agree to Their Church and are all to be found in it and in no other and to set out to the best advantage the Glorious Priviledges of Their Church the Miraculous things that have been and are still daily done in it and the innumerable multitude of their Saints and Martyrs and if these General Things take and sink into them their work is in effect done 2. Another great Advantage they have by it is That by bringing them to this Method they divert and keep them off from the many Objects against their Church and Religion namely the Errors and Corruptions which we charge them withal For this is the thing they are afraid of and will by no means be brought to to vindicate and make good their Innovations in Faith and Practice so plainly in many things contrary to Scripture and to the Faith and Practice of the Primitive Church as the Doctrines of Transubstantiation of Purgatory the Popes Supremacy
of the Infallibility of their Church of their Seven Sacraments Instituted by Christ and of the Intention of the Priest being necessary to the Validity and Virtue of the Sacraments and then several of their Practices as of the Worship of Images of the Invocation of Angels and Saints of the Service of God and the Scriptures in an Vnknown Tongue and the Communion in one Kind and several other things so plainly contrary to the Scriptures and the Practice and Usage of the Primitive Church that almost the meanest Capacity may easily be made sensible and convinced of it These are sore places which they desire not to have touched and therefore they use all possible Artifice to keep Men at a distance from them partly because the particular discussion of them is tedious and it requires more than ordinary Skill to say any thing that is tenable for them and so to paint and varnish them over as to hide the Corruptions and Deformities of them but chiefly because they are conscious to themselves that as in all these Points they are upon the Defensive so they are also upon very great Disadvantages and therefore to avoid if it be possible being troubled with them they have devised this shorter and easier and more convenient way of making Proselytes Not that they are always able to keep themselves thus within their Trenches but are sometimes whether they will or no drawn out to Encounter some of these Objections but they rid themselves of them as soon and as dexterously as they can by telling those that make them that they will hereafter give them full Satisfaction to all these Matters when they are gotten over the first and main Enquiry Which is the true Church For if they can keep them to this Point and gain them to it they can deal with them more easily in the rest for when they can once swallow this Principle That the Church of Rome is the One True Catholick Church and consequently as they have told them all along Infallible this Infallibility of the Church once entertained will cover a multitude of particular Errors and Mistakes and it will very much help to cure the weakness and defects of some particular Doctrines and Practices and at least to silence and over-rule all Objections against them So that the benefit and advantage of this Method is visibly and at first sight very great and therefore no wonder they are so steady and constant to it and do so obstinately insist upon it But how convenient soever it be to them it is I am sure very unreasonable in it self and that upon these Accounts 1. Because the True Church doth not constitute and make the True Christian Faith and Doctrine but it is the True Christian Faith and Doctrine the Profession whereof makes the True Church and therefore in Reason and Order of Nature the first Enquiry must be What is the True Faith and Doctrine of Christ which by him was delivered to the Apostles and by them publish'd and made known to the World and by their Writings Transmitted and Conveyed down to us And this being found every Society of Christians which holds this Doctrine is a True Part of the Catholick Church and all the Christians throughout the World that agree in this Doctrine are the One True Catholick Church 2. The Enquiry about the True Church can have no Issue even according to their own way of proceeding without a due Examination of the particular Doctrines and Practices of that Church the Communion whereof they would perswade a Man to embrace We will admit at present this to be the first Enquiry Which is the True Church Let us now see in what way they manage this to gain Men over to their Church They tell them that the Church of Rome is the One True Catholick Church of Christ. The truth of this Assertion we will particularly examine afterwards when we come to consider the next step of their Method in dealing with their Converts At present I shall only take notice in the General what way they take to prove this Assertion namely That the Church of Rome is the One True Catholick Church and that is by the Notes and Marks of the True Church which they call their Motives of Credibility because by these they design to perswade them that the Church of Rome is the One True Catholick Church I shall not now reckon up all the Notes and Marks which they give of the True Church but only observe that one of their Principal Marks of the True Church is this That the Faith and Doctrine of it be agreeable to the Doctrine of the Primitive and Apostolick Church i. e. to the Doctrine delivered by our Saviour and his Apostles And this Bellarmine makes one of the Marks of the True Church And they must unavoidably make it so because the True Faith and Doctrine of Christ is that which indeed Constitutes the True Church But if this be an Essential Mark of the True Church then no Man can possibly know the Church of Rome to be the True Church till he have examin'd the particular Doctrines and Practices of it and the Agreement of them with the Primitive Doctrine and Practice of Christianity and this necessarily draws on and engages them in a dispute of the particular Points and Differences betwixt us which is the very thing they would avoid by this Method and which I have now plainly shewed they cannot do because they cannot possibly prove their Church to be the True Church without shewing the Conformity of their Doctrines and Practices to the Doctrine and Practice of the Primitive and Apostolick Church and this will give them work enough and will whether they will or no draw them out of their Hold and Fastness which is to amuse People with a general Enquiry Which is the true Church without descending to the Examination of their particular Doctrines and Practices But this they must of necessity come to before they can prove by the Notes and Marks of the True Church that theirs is the True Church And this is a Demonstration that their Method of Satisfaction as it is Unnatural and Unreasonable so it cannot serve the purpose they aim at by it which is to divert Men from the Examination of the particular Points in Difference between the Church of Rome and Us and to gain them over to them by a wile and trick because the very Method they take to prove themselves to be the True Catholick Church will enforce them to justifie all their particular Doctrines and Practices before they can finish this Proof And here we fix our foot That the single Question and Point upon which they would put the whole Issue of the Matter cannot possibly be brought to any reasonable Issue without a particular Discussion and Examination of the Points in Difference betwixt Their Church and Ours and when they can make out these to be agreeable to the Primitive Doctrine and Practice of the Christian Church
we have reason to be satisfied that the Church of Rome is a Church in the Communion whereof a Man may be safe But till that be made out they have done nothing to perswade any Man that understands himself that it is safe much less necessary to be of their Communion But if particular Points must be discussed and cleared before a Man can be satisfied in the Enquiry after the True Church then they must allow their intended Convert to be a Judge likewise of particular Points and if he be sufficient for that too before he comes into their Church I do not see of what use the Infallibility of the Church will be to him when he is in it A SERMON ON HEB. X. 23. Let us hold fast the Profession of our Faith without wavering for he is faithful that promised I Have already made a considerable Progress in my Discourse upon these Words in which I told you there is an Exhortation to hold fast the profession of our Faith without wavering and an Argument or Encouragement thereto because he is faithful that promised I am yet upon the First of these the Exhortation to hold fast the profession of our Faith without wavering by which I told you the Apostle doth not intend that those who are capable of examining the Grounds and Reasons of their Religion should not have the Liberty to do it nor that when upon due Enquiry they are as they verily believe established in the true Faith and Religion they should obstinately refuse to hear any Reason that is fairly offered against their present Persuasion And then I proceeded to shew positively First What it is that we are here exhorted to hold fast viz. The Confession or Profession of our Faith the ancient Christian Faith of which every Christian makes Profession in his Baptism For it is of that the Apostle here speaks as appears plainly by the Context Secondly How we are to hold fast the Profession of our Faith And of this I gave Account in these following Particulars 1. We should hold fast the Profession of our Faith against the Confidence of Men without Scripture or Reason to support that Confidence 2. And much more against the Confidence of Men contrary to plain Scripture and Reason and the common Sense of Mankind of which I gave you particular Instances 3. Against all the Temptations and Terrors of the World 4. Against all vain Promises of being put into a safer Condition and groundless Hopes of getting to Heaven upon easier Terms in some other Church and Religion I am now upon the 5. And Last Particular I mentioned namely That we are to hold fast the Profession of our Faith without wavering against all the cunning Arts and Insinuations of busie and disputing Men whose Design it is to unhinge Men from their Religion and to make Proselytes to their Party and Faction I have already mentioned some of the Arts which they use I mean particularly them of the Church of Rome in making Proselytes to their Religion and I have shewn the Absurdity and Unreasonableness of them As First In allowing Men to be very competent and sufficient Judges for themselves in the Choice of their Religion i. e. which is the True Church and Religion in which alone Salvation is to be had and yet telling them at the same time that they are utterly incapable of judging of particular Doctrines and Points of Faith As for these they must rely upon the Judgment of an Infallible Church and if they do not they will certainly run into damnable Errors and Mistakes And they must of necessity allow them the first a sufficient Ability to judge for themselves in the Choice of their Religion Otherwise in vain do they offer them Arguments to perswade them to Theirs if they cannot judge of the Force of them But now after this to deny them all Ability to judge of particular Doctrines and Points of Faith is a very absurd and inconsistent Pretence Secondly Another Art they use in order to their making a right Choice of their Religion is earnestly to perswade them to hear and read only the Arguments and Books on Their side Which is just as if one should go about to persuade a Judge in order to the better understanding and clearer Decision of a Cause to hear only the Council on one side Thirdly They tell them that the only thing they are to enquire into is which is the True Church the one Catholick Church mentioned in the Creed out of which there is no Salvation and when they have found that they are to rely upon the Authority of that Church which is Infallible for all other things And this Method they wisely take to avoid particular Disputes about the Innovations and Errors which we charge them withal But I have shewn at large that this cannot be the First Enquiry Because it is not the true Church that makes the true Christian Faith and Doctrine but the Profession of the true Christian Faith and Doctrine which makes the true Church Besides their way of proving Their Church to be the only true Church being by the Marks and Properties of the true Church of which the Chief is The Conformity of their Doctrines and Practices with the Primitive and Apostolical Church this unavoidably draws on an Examination of their particular Doctrines and Practices whether they be conformable to those of the Primitive and Apostolical Church before their great Enquiry Which is the True Church can be brought to any Issue which it is plain it can never be without entring into the Ocean of particular Disputes which they desire above all things to avoid So that they are never the nearer by this Method they can neither shorten their Work by it nor keep off the Examination of their particular Errors and Corruptions which are a very sore place and they cannot endure we should touch it I shall now proceed to discover some other Arts and Methods which they use in seducing People to Their Church and Religion and shall be as brief in them as I can Fourthly They pretend that the Roman Church is the Catholick Church i. e. the Visible Society of all Christians united to the Bishop of Rome as the Supream Pastor and Visible Head of Christ's Church upon Earth from whence it clearly follows That it is necessary to all Christians to joyn themselves to the Communion of the Roman Church otherwise they cannot be Members of the Catholick Church of Christ out of which there is no Salvation We grant the Consequence That if the Roman Church be the Catholick Church it is necessary to be of that Communion because out of the Catholick Church there is ordinarily no Salvation to be had But how do they prove that the Roman Church is the Catholick Church They would fain have us so civil as to take this for granted because if we do not they do not well know how to go about to prove it And indeed some things are obstinate and
Scripture or in the Doctrine and Practice of the Ancient Christian Church any Command or Example for the Worship of Images for the Invocation of Saints and Angels and the Blessed Virgin which do now make a great part of their Religion Nay is not the Doctrine of the Scriptures and of the Ancient Fathers plainly against all these Practices With what face then can it be said That the Church of Rome hath made a constant Visible Profession of the same Faith and Practice in all Ages from the time of Christ and his Apostles Or would the primitive Church of Rome if it should now visit the Earth again own the present Church of Rome to be the same in all Matters of Faith and practice that it was when they left it And whereas they demand of Us to shew a Visible Church from the time of Christ and his Apostles that hath always opposed the Church of Rome in those points of Doctrine and Practice which we Object to them what can be more impertinent than this Demand When they know that in all these Points we charge them with Innovations in Matters of Faith and Practice and say that those things came in by degrees several Ages after the Apostles time some sooner some later as we are able to make good and have done it And would they have us shew them a Visible Church that opposed these Errors and Corruptions in their Church before ever they appeared This we do not pretend to shew And supposing they had not been at all opposed when they appeared nor a long time after not till the Reformation yet if they be Errors and Corruptions of the Christian Doctrine and contrary to the Holy Scriptures and to the Faith and Practice of the Primitive Church there is no Prescription against Truth 'T is never too late for any Church to reject those Errors and Corruptions and to reform it self from them The bottom of all this Matter is they would have us to shew them a Society of Christians that in all Ages hath preserved it self free from all such Errors and Corruptions as we charge them withall or else we deny the Perpetual Visibility of the Catholick Church No such matter We say the Church of Christ hath always been Visible in every Age since Christ's time and that the several Societies of Christians professing the Christian Doctrine and Laws of Christ have made up the Catholick Church some parts whereof have in several Ages fallen into great Errors and Corruptions and no part of the Catholick into more and greater than the Church of Rome So that it requires the utmost of our Charity to think that they are a true tho a very unsound and corrupt Part of the Catholick Church of Christ. We acknowledge likewise that We were once involved in the like Degeneracy but by the mercy of God and pious care and prudence of those that were in Authority are happily rescued out of it and tho' we were not out of the Catholick Church before yet since our Reformation from the Errors and Corruptions of the Church of Rome we are in it upon better Terms and are a much sounder Part of it and I hope by the Mercy and Goodness of God we shall for ever continue so So that to the Perpetual Visibility of Christ's Church it is not necessary that the whole Christian Church or indeed that any Part of it should be free from all Errors and Corruptions Even the Churches planted by the Apostles in the Primitive Times were not so St. Paul reproves several Doctrines and Practices in the Church of Corinth and of Colosse and of Galatia and the Spirit of God several Things in the Seven Churches of Asia and yet all these were true Parts and Members of the Catholick Church of Christ notwithstanding these Faults and Errors because they all agreed in the Main and Essential Doctrines of Christianity And when more and greater Corruptions grew upon the Church or any part of it the greater reason and need there was of a Reformation And as every particular Person hath a right to reform any thing that he finds amiss in himself so far as concerns himself so much more every National Church hath a Power within it self to reform it self from all Errors and Corruptions and by the Sanction of the Catholick Authority to confirm that Reformation which is our Case here in England And whatever part of the Church how great and eminent soever excludes from her Communion such a National Church for reforming her self from plain Errors and Corruptions clearly condemned by the Word of God and by the Doctrine and Practice of the Primitive Christian Church is undoubtedly Guilty of Schism And this is the Truth of the Case between us and the Church of Rome And no blind talk about a Perpetual Visible Church can render Us guilty of Schism for making a Real Reformation or acquit Them of it for casting us out of their Communion for that Cause 7. And Lastly to mention no more they pretend that we delude the People by laying too much stress upon Scripture and making it the only Rule of Faith and Manners whereas Scripture and Tradition together make up the entire Rule of Faith and not Scripture Interpreted by every Mans private Fancy but by Tradition carefully preserved in the Church So that it ought to be no wonder if several of their Doctrines and Practices cannot be so clearly made out by Scripture or perhaps seem contrary to it as it may be expounded by a private Spirit but not as Interpreted by the Tradition of the Church which can only give the true Sense of Scripture And therefore they are to understand that several of those Doctrines and Practices which we Object against are most clearly proved by the Tradition of their Church which is of equal Authority with Scripture In this Objection of theirs which they design for the Cover of all their Errors and Corruptions there are several things distinctly to be considered which I shall do as briefly as I can First Whereas it is suggested That We delude the People by laying too much stress upon the Scriptures which certainly we cannot well do if it be the Word of God it ought to be considered whether They do not delude and abuse them infinitely more in keeping the Scriptures from them and not suffering them to see That which they cannot deny to be at least a considerable Part of the Rule of Christian Doctrine and Practice Doth it not by this dealing of theirs appear very suspicious that they are extreamly afraid that the People should examine their Doctrine and Practice by this Rule For what other Reason can they have to conceal it from them Secondly Whereas they affirm that Scripture alone is not the Rule of Christian Faith and Practice but that Scripture and Oral Tradition preserved in the Church and delivered down from hand to hand makes up the entire Rule I would fain know whence they learn'd this new Doctrine
plain then that there is no Reason nor Necessity to extend this Precept of our Saviour concerning self-denyal to every thing that may properly enough be called by that name and therefore this Precept must be limited by the plain scope and intendment of our Saviour's Discourse and no Man can argue thus such a thing is self-denyal therefore our Saviour requires it of his Disciples For our Saviour doth not here require all kinds of self-denyal but limits it by his Discourse to one certain kind beyond which self-denyal is no Duty by virtue of this Text and therefore for our clearer understanding of this Precept of self-denyal I shall do these two things 1. Remove some sorts of self-denyal which are instanced in by some as intended in this Precept 2. I shall shew what kind of self-denyal that is which our Saviour here intends 1. There are several things brought under this Precept of self-denyal which were never intended by our Saviour I shall instance in Two or Three things which are most frequently insisted upon and some of them by very devout and well-meaning Men as that in matters of Faith We should deny and renounce our own Senses and our Reason nay that we should be content to renounce our own Eternal Happiness and be willing to be damned for the Glory of God and the Good of our Brethren But all these are so apparently and grosly unreasonable that it is a Wonder that any one should ever take them for Instances of that self-denyal which our Saviour requires especially considering that in all his Discourse of self-denyal he does not so much as glance at any of these Instances or any thing like to them 1. Some comprehend under self-denyal the denying and renouncing our own Senses in matters of Faith and if this could be made out to be intended by our Saviour in this Precept we needed not dispute any of the other Instances For he that renounceth the certainty of Sense so as not to believe what he sees may after this renounce and deny any thing For the Evidence of Sense is more clear and unquestionable than that of Faith as the Scripture frequently intimates as John 20. 29. where our Saviour reproves Thomas for refusing to believe his Resurrection upon any less Evidence than that of Sense Because thou hast seen thou hast believed Blessed are they wich have not seen and yet have believed Which plainly supposeth the Evidence of Sense to be the highest and clearest degree of Evidence So likewise that of St. Paul 2 Cor. 5. 7. We walk by Faith and not by Sight Where the Evidence of Faith as that which is more imperfect and obscure is opposed to that of Sight as more clear and certain So that to believe any Article of Faith in contradiction to the clear Evidence of Sense is contrary to the very Nature of Assent which always yields to the greatest and clearest Evidence Besides that our Belief of Religion is at last resolved into the certainty of Sense so that by renouncing that we destroy and undermine the very Foundation of our Faith One of the plainest and principal Proofs of the Being of God which is the first and Fundamental Article of all Religion relies upon the certainty of Sense namely the Frame of this visible World by the Contemplation whereof we are led to the acknowledgment of the invisible Author of it So St. Paul tells us Rom. 1. 20. That the invisible things of God from the Creation of the World are clearly seen being understood by the things which are made even his eternal Power and Godhead And the great external Evidence of the Christian Religion I mean Miracles is at last resolved into the certainty of Sense without which we can have no assurance that any Miracle was wrought for the confirmation of it And the knowledge likewise of the Christian Faith is conveyed to us by our Senses the Evidence whereof if it be uncertain takes away all certainty of Faith How shall they believe saith St. Paul Rom. 10. 14. How shall they believe in him of whom they have not Heard And ver 17. So then Faith cometh by hearing and hearing by the word of God So that to deny and renounce our Senses in matters of Faith is to take away the main Pillar and Foundation of it 2. Others almost with equal absurdity would comprehend under our Saviour's Precept of Self-denial the denying and renouncing of our Reason in matters of Faith and this is Self-denial with a witness for a Man to deny his own reason for it is to deny himself to be a Man This surely is a very great mistake and tho the ground of it may be innocent yet the consequence of it and the Discourses upon it are very absurd The Ground of the mistake is this Men think they deny their own Reason when they assent to the Revelation of God in such things as their own Reason could neither have discovered nor is able to give the reason of whereas in this case a Man is so far from denying his own Reason that he does that which is most agreeable to it For what more reasonable than to believe whatever we are sufficiently assur'd is revealed to us by God who can neither be deceived himself nor deceive us But tho' the Ground of this mistake may be innocent yet the Consequences of it are most absurd and dangerous For if we are to renounce our Reason in matters of Faith then are we bound to believe without Reason which no Man can do or if he could then Faith would be unreasonable and Infidelity reasonable So that this Instance likewise of Self-denial to renounce and deny our own Reason as it is no where exprest so it cannot reasonably be thought to be intended by our Saviour in this Precept 3. Nor doth this Precept of Self-denial require Men to be content to renounce their own Eternal Happiness and to be willing to be Damned for the Glory of God and the good of their Brethren If this were the meaning of this Precept we might justly say as the Disciples did to our Saviour in another Case This is a hard saying and who can hear it The very thought of this is enough to make Humane Nature to tremble at its very foundation For the deepest Principle that God hath planted in our Nature is the desire of our own Preservation and Happiness and into this the Force of all Laws and the Reason of all our Duty is at last resolved From whence it plainly follows that it can be no Man's Duty in any case to renounce his own Happiness and to be content to be for Ever Miserable because if once this be made a Duty there will be no Argument left to perswade any Man to it For the most powerful Arguments that God ever used to perswade Men to any thing are the Promise of Eternal Happiness and the Terrour of Everlasting Torments But if this were a Man's Duty to be content to
another World yet according to a right Estimate of things and to those who walk by Faith and not by Sight this which we call Self-denyal is in truth and reality but a more commendable sort of Self-love because we do herein most effectually consult and secure and advance our own Happiness 4. And Lastly Since God hath been pleased for so long a time to excuse us from this hardest part of Self-denyal let us not grudge to deny our selves in lesser Matters for the sake of his Truth and Religion to miss a good Place or to quit it upon that account much less let us think much to renounce our Vices and to thwart our evil Inclinations for his sake As Naaman's Servant said to him concerning the means prescribed by the Prophet for his Cure If he had bid thee do some Great thing wouldest thou not have done it How much more when he hath only said Wash and be clean So since God imposeth no harder Terms upon us than Repentance and Reformation of our Lives we should gladly and thankfully submit to them This I know is difficult to some to mortifie their earthly Members to crucifie the flesh with the affections and lusts of it 't is like cutting off a right Hand and plucking out a right Eye Some are so strongly addicted to their Lusts and Vices that they could with more ease despise Life in many cases than thus Deny themselves But in Truth there is no more of Self-denyal in it than a Man denies himself when he is mortally Sick and Wounded in being content to be Cured and willing to be Well This is not at all to our Temporal Prejudice and Inconvenience and it directly conduceth to our Eternal Happiness for there is no Man that lives a holy and virtuous Life and in Obedience to the Laws of God that can lightly receive any Prejudice by it in this World Since God doth not call us to Suffer we should Do so much the more for him Since he doth not put us to testifie our Love to him by laying down our Lives for him we should shew it by a greater Care to keep his Commandments God was pleased to exercise the first Christians with great Sufferings and to try their Love and Constancy to him and his Truth in a very Extraordinary manner by Severity and Contempt by the spoiling of their Goods and the loss of all things by bonds and imprisonments by cruel mockings and scourgings by the extremity of torments and by resisting even unto blood by being kill'd for his sake all the day long and appointed as Sheep for the slaughter God was pleased to make their way to Heaven very sharp and painful and to hedge it in as it were with thorns on every side so that they could not but through many tribulations enter into the Kingdom of Heaven Thus we ought all to be in a Readiness and Resolution to submit to this Duty if God should think fit at any time of our Lives to call us to it But if he be pleased to excuse us from it and to let this Cup pass from us which may lawfully be our earnest Prayer to God since we have so good a Pattern for it there will be another Duty incumbent upon us which will take up the whole Man and the whole time of our Life and that is to serve him without fear in holiness and righteousness before him all the days of our lives A SERMON PREACHED At Whitehall before the Family Nov. 1. 1686. HEB. XI 13. And confessed that they were Strangers and Pilgrims on the Earth The whole Verse runs thus These all died in Faith not having received the Promises but having seen them afar off and were persuaded of them and embraced them and confessed that they were Strangers and Pilgrims on the Earth THE Apostle having declared at the latter end of the foregoing Chapter that Faith is the great Principle whereby Good Men are acted and whereby they are supported under all the Evils and Sufferings of this Life Verse 38. Now the Just shall live by Faith In this Chapter he makes it his main business to set forth to us at large the Force and Power of Faith and to this Purpose he first tells us what kind of Faith he means viz. a firm Persuasion of things not Present and Visible to Sense but Invisible and Future Ver. 1. Now Faith saith he is the confident expectation of things hoped for and the evidence of things not seen Faith represents to us the Reality of things which are Invisible to Sense as the Existence of God and his Providence and of things which are at a great distance from us as the Future State of Rewards and Punishments in another World And then he proceeds to shew by particular and famous Instances that the firm Belief and Persuasion of these things was the great Principle of the Piety and Virtue of the Saints and and Good Men in all Ages of the World by this Abel and Enoch and Noah Abraham Isaac and Jacob Joseph and Moses and all the Famous Heroes of the Old Testament obtained a good Report and pleased God and did all those eminent Acts of Obedience and Self-denyal which are recorded of them They believed the Being of God and that he is a Rewarder of them that diligently seek him They dreaded his Threatnings and relyed upon his Promises of Future and Invisible Good things They lived and died in a full Persuasion and Confidence of the Truth of them tho they did not live to see them actually fulfilled and accomplisht All these saith he speaking of those Eminent Saints which he had instanced in before All these died in Faith not having received the Promises but having seen them afar off and were persuaded of them and embraced them This is spoken with a more particular regard to Abraham Isaac and Jacob to whom the Promises of the Conquest and Possession of a Fruitful Land were made and of a Numerous Offspring among whom should be the Messias in whom all the Nations of the Earth should be blessed These Promises they did not live to see accomplisht and made good in their Days but they heartily believed them and rejoiced in the Hope and Expectation of them as if they had embraced them in their Arms and been put into the actual Possession of them And they confessed that they were Pilgrims and Strangers in the Earth This Saying and Acknowledgment more particularly and immediately refers to those Sayings of the Patriarchs Abraham and Jacob which we find recorded Gen. 23. 4. where Abraham says to the Sons of Heth I am a Stranger and a Sojourner with you And Gen. 47. 9. where Jacob says to Pharaoh The days of the years of my Pilgrimage are an hundred and thirty years few and evil have the days of the years of my Life been These Good Men were Strangers and Sojourners in a Land which was promised to be theirs afterwards They dwelt in it themselves as Strangers but