Jerub-baal OR THE Pleader impleaded BEING An Answer to Mr. Croftons lately published Plea for Communion with the Church under her present Corruptions c. Entituled Reformation not Separation By way of humble Remonstrance thereunto SHEWING That Non-Communion with the Church of England in her Liturgy and Common-Prayer in those that yet joyn with her in the substantial Ordinances and instituted Worship of Christ is no Schism and that Such are unjustly called Separatists In a Letter written by T. P. for the private satisfaction of a Friend and by him published for Common benefit In cujus perniciem aliquando convenimus hoc sumus congregati quod et dispersi hoc universi quod et singuli neminem laedentes neminem contristantes Tertul. Apolog. adversus Gent. LONDON Printed in the Yeare 1662. A Letter Written by T. P. for the satisfaction of a Friend in case of Non-Communion with the Church of England in her Liturgy and Common-Prayer Honoured Sir SChism being a dissolution and breach of Vnion 't will not be amisse if for the better understanding of the nature of the Schism in question we make some enquiry into that Church-Vnion whereof it is a breach Now from the distinct notions and acceptions of the Church the nature of Church-Vnion will best appear The Church of Christ even that which is Militant for the Triumphant comes not here to be considered is usually distinguished into 1. Catholick 2. Particular The Catholick Church again into 1. Visible 2. Invisible 1. The Catholick Visible Church is the Vniversality of Persons called by the Word into External Fellowship with Christ and Communion amongst themselves professing the true Religion the Faith Doctrine and Worship of Christ throughout the world called Visible in respect of Outward Administration and Profession 2. The Catholick-Invisible Church is the Collective Body of the truly Faithfull the compleat Quorum of the Elect Gods Chosen ones called out of the whole World of Mankind into an intimate Vnion with Christ and Communion one with another not only externally by the Word but effectually and internally by Gods holy Spirit called Invisible no◠quá Men but quá Elect the Man is seen but not the Christian The Lord only knoweth them that are his 2 Tim. 2.19 The Church-Catholick is under both those considerations called the Mystical Body of Christ viz. 1. By League Outward Profession under the former 2. By true Faith and real Possession under the latter Christ is a Common Head both to the one and to the other 2. A Particular Church is a Society or Societies of Persons called to the participation of and subjected to the Ordinances and instituted worship of Christ under certain external Rules accommodated for Local Joynt-Communion therein in a particular place Such are the English French Dutch Churches and such like including Parochial Distributions and Congregations as the Church Catholick includes them viz. as a totum Integrale or Vniversale so as that nec totum recte de una praedicetur nec una totum sibi vindicare possit saith Junius lib. de Ecclesia though the Papists make a kind of Monopoly of their Romish Church obtruding it for a Catholick yea the only Catholick Church in the World and thus by a cursed Sacriledge impropriate as I may say the Church of Christ This Distinct Notion of the Church ariseth from the diversified Nature of her Members the Constitutive Matter thereof who may be considered either 1. as Professors of the Faith of Christ in obedience to an Externall Call by the Word those constitute the Church catholick-Catholick-Visible or 2. as Possessors of Christ by Faith true Believers in Obedience to an Internall Call by the Spirit those constitute the Church Catholick-Invisible or 3. as Partakers of the same Ordinances and instituted worship of Christ in a particular place in Obedience to a Providential Call and in answer to an Opportunity serving thereunto those constitute a Particular Church so that the same Persons may be Members of the Church under that threefold consideration at once Church-Vnion then must be threefold or considerable under a threefold Notion 1. The First is the Vnion of the Members of the Church Catholick-Invisible with Christ and their Communion amongst themselves wherein they are through the Inhabitation and Indwelling of the same Holy Spirit in all and by vertue of a true Faith joyntly incorporated into Christ and concorporated one with another as Fellow-Members of the same Select Fraternity the Son of God having assumed their Persons into a Mystical as well as their Nature into a Personal Vnion with himself Now Sir This Vnion admits of no breach Christ and his Elect Members the true Branches of that true Vine are inseperably conjoined their Persons as well as their Nature are eternally matched and married to Christ the Mystical Vnion of the one is indissoluble as well as the Personall Vnion of the other with him There is no fear of a divorce here neither can the Body be severed from the Head nor any one Member from the Body the Members may quarrel an Israelite with an Israelite thus we read that Paul and Barnabas did contest and contend so fiercely that their Paroxysme of strife ended in Separation Act. 15.39 Yea they may joyn to their breach of Society a breach of Charity in some degree but neither is the one nor the other a dissolution of that Internal Union whereby the truly Faithfull are coupled together one with another and all of them joyntly with their Common Head Christ The Vinculum Vnionis the Conjugal-Vnion-Knot viz true Faith or the spirit of grace in the Faithfull being altogether inviolable The Holy Ghost is the Fountain-Radical of Faith as of all other Graces and therefore of this Communion One Spirit quickening influencing both Head and Members in the Mystical as one Soul conveys life and sense to all the Members of the Natural Body and hence 't is I conceive that Christ and Beleevers are said to be not One Body onely but One Spirit viz in Esse Mystico 1 Cor. 6.17 Now this same Spirit may suspend his influences viz Comfortable and Augmentative not Vital as in the dark and solitary dayes of soule-desertion and Faith may in such a case be much weakened and impaired viz in its Graduals but True Faith being the Seed of God 1 John 3.9 is in Esse vitali as to its Truth and Nature intrinsecally permanent an irreradicable principle Perseverance and indeficiency being its Genuine property as well as Christs purchase Luke 22.32 there is a kind of Immortality in it So that as there is a weaknesse in the strongest Faith so there is truth in the weakest now this Vnion depends not upon the strength but upon the truth of Faith and not upon the Gradual Communications but upon the Radical Inhabitation of the Spirit Such a suspension then is unfitly termed a seperation David lost Comfort but not the Comforter Psal 51.11 12. or if we grant with some that it is a
be Impregnable and Invincible The Gates of Hell shall not prevaile against her A promise ever made good to the Whole Body of the Catholick-Visible as it is to every Individual Member of the Catholick-Invisible-Church 2. That the Vnion which is between Christ and Particular Visible Professors and Churches parts of the Church Catholick-Visible may be broken and interrupted is a truth that hath been verified in many sad experiences forasmuch as all are not Israel that are called Israel Many Particular Churches and Councels however our Neighbours in the Church of Rome amongst the rest of their Romish strange-fire ascribe an Infallibility and unerring Quality to them yet are known to have so far degenerated as to become instead of Churches of Christ Synagogues of Satan witnesse the Churches of Asia which though once recorded for Golden Candlesticks Rev. 2. yet are at this day the Receptacles of Mahometan Idolatry Judea that degenerate Vine Rome that Adulterate See c. But this is not only Schism but Apostacy being a degeneracy from the true Catholick-Apostolick Faith and a Separation from or not holding of the head from which all the body by joynts and bands having nourishment ministred and knit together increaseth with the increase of God Col. 2.19 which is inconsistent not onely with the Vnity but with the Verity and very Being of a true Church whence those Churches are deservedly called Apostatical as well as Schismatical and Renegadoes or Fugitives from the Faith of Christ such as Parphyrie Julian miserable Spira and such like who have of Visible and Professed Members of the Body become Enemies to the Head some of them turning open Persecutors of that Faith whereof they were once Professors are not barely called Separatists but branded for cursed Apostates 3. The Communion wherein the Members of this great Corporation the Church catholick-Catholick-Visible are by vertue of their Common Profession of the true Religion and Faith of Christ united one with another is subject to a twofold Schism or breach viz 1. A breach in the Church and 2. A breach from the Church The first consists in Intestine Divisions and differences either 1. in point of Judgement and that principally about matters either of Discipline or Worship if the Errour be in a point fundamental or incorrigibly persisted in it is then Heresie which St. Augustine calls Schisma inveteratum or else 2. in point of Charity and Christian Love The second consists in a degeneracy from the true Religien and a voluntary relinquishing of a Church-state but this is as I have said above of not holding of the Head not Schisme onely but Apostacy a Cat holick and Vniversal Separation for one that thus relinquisheth Christs Body-Catholick separates from it Tanquam Membrum ab Integro as a Member from the Whole now as a Leg or Arm when lost ceaseth to be a member of the body Natural to which it was united even so a Professor thus degenerated ceaseth In statu quo without recovery by repentance to be a Member of this Body Mysticall Whereas many are most justly condemned for Separatists I shall not need to name any who yet while they hold the Head and professedly own the Catholick-Apostolick Faith of Christ cannot be disowned for Members of the Body Branches in the Vine Part of the Mystical Building the Church catholick-Catholick-Visible Church-Communion is distinguishable into 1. Real 2. Pesonal There is a Real Community and a Personal Society now though those Separatists refuse by way of Personal Association to communicate with that Church from which they separate yet they continue a Real Saint-Communion and Fellowship with her in the Enjoyment of the same Objective Ordinances Prayer Word and Sacraments and therefore notwithstanding their Separation from a Particular they cease not to be Members of the Catholick Church Real Community being maintained though Personal Society be unjustly denyed The Third Church-Vnion is that Social-Local-Joynt-Fellowship wherein the Members of a Particular Church are united one with another not only by the Profession of the same Faith and Religion all the Members of the Catholick and Vniversal Church are thus united but in the participation of the same Ordinances Administrations and instituted worship of Christ in a particular place where there is fitting opportunity of executing and yielding due observance to Rules of Joynt-Communion which is not a thing possible for the Vniversal Church now through numerosity and multitude though once it was viz when the whole Catholick-Christian Church consisted of about but 120. Members in all Act. 1.15 Now This Comunion may admit of a twofold breach viz. 1. Schism in the Church 2. Separation from the Church as the breach in the Church Catholick before The first is a breach either 1. in point of Judgement and Opinion or 2. in point of Charity and Christian Affection the too too frequent issue and result of the other 't is chiefely the former I presume that Sr. Augustine calls Dissidium Congregationis Church-dissention the latter he calls Odium Fraternum Brother-hatred and dis-affection both sad Church-Rents What when Lot and Abraham Brethren are at strife when Brethren fall out by the way Separation from the Church is either 1. Partial 2. Total 1. Negative 2. Positive 1. A Partial Separation when we decline Communion with the Church in some Ordinances but joyn with her in others as in Prayer but not in hearing of the Word or in both those but not in the Saerament 2. A Total Separation is an Vniversal declension of Communion with a Church in every Ordinance 1. Negative Separation when we withdraw from Communion with some Church not joyning with any other but continuing in hopes and expectation of the happy amendment of that Church from which we withdraw with a purpose of returning to her when reformed 2 Positive Separation when we do not only decline Communion with a Church but divide into several Parties Combinations and new Conventions as probably 't was amongst the Corinthians One saying I am of Paul another I am of Apollo a third I am of Cephas c. 1 Cor. 1.12 embodying in several Church-wayes setting up Altar against Altar and Threshold against Threshold Separation from the Church may be Culpable or Inculpable Lawful or Vnlawful and that more or lesse according to its Grounds and Causes Now the only lawfull Grounds or Causes of a Total-Positive Separation are usually reckoned three viz. 1. Intolerable Persecution from Persons 2. Damnable Heresie in poynt of Doctrine 3. Grosse Idolatry in poynt of Worship These are the Grounds of our just Departure from the Tyrannical Heretical Idololatrical Church of Rome O happy Divorce may the Lord perpetuate it that we may never say a Confederacy to her again Isa 8.12 but upon Gods own Terms of Accommodation Let them return unto thee but return not thou unto them Jer. 15.19 Again when the Corruptions of a Church are such as that one cannot communicate with her without sin unavoydably That seems to me to be a just
Church of England in her Liturgy or Common-Prayer commonly called Divine Service is Communion with the Church-Visible in Solemn and Publique Worship and then the Conclusion must be Therefore Communion with the Church of England in her Liturgy and Common-Prayer is an Essential part of the sanctification of the Sabbath or Lords day and a positive indispensable duty c. and by consequence Non-Communion c. must be a breach of duty and therefore a sin viz SCHISM REMONS Honoured Friend My Answer to this shall be threefold Viz 1. By way of Concession 2. By way of Distinction 3. By way of Retortion 1. By way of Concession That the Church of England That is the Community of Christians in this Nation concorporated by Baptism professing the true God and Jesus Christ and subjected to the Word and Sacraments c. is a true Church cannot in justice be denyed Her Primitive Constitution being by History Times Index and our best Intelligencer touching Antiquity known to have been Apostolical administers to me no occasion of doubt in the thing But whoever were the Seminary Founders thereof whether Simon Zelotes or Joseph of Arimathea Christs Immediate Emissaries or Aristobolus or Augustine the Monk 't is no matter of Faith only let none despise-his Birth-right as Esau did his O what a happinesse is it that our Native Land should be a thus Consecrated Soil and that we should be by birth in this respect Sons of the Church Visible Church Members The Inroades of Popery into this Iland since the Sun of Righteousnesse first rose herein have been both various and violent and what they may further be God knows but God hath safe-kept his English-Ark in the midst of that Deluge the Rock of Ages hath hitherto been her Ararat By no Antichristian Inundations was she ever as yet totally overwhelmed Popery spoiled her Beauty but did not destroy her Being Mr. Crofton turning Confessor hath acknowledged this Churches present Corruptions as well in Things viz Worship and Ordinances therein administrable by as in Persons both Ministers and People Visible Members the Integral Parts thereof But a True Church is one thing a Pure Church another Here is the New-Creature Hereafter onely the Pure-Creature Now the question is not about Church-purity alas Adulterate Mixtures and Innovations in the Worship of God are a too too plain confutation of this now but Church-Entity the Truth and Being of the Church which our English Donatists Mr. Crofton may know whom I mean having formerly well nigh confounded did like their Progenitors most sacriledgiously monopolize the Church of Christ in this Nation confining the Formality and therefore the Truth and very Essence of a Church within the narrow compasse of their Confederate Members as if it had not been possible for their Ark to contain a Cham or for Tares to grow within their Inclosure God will I hope humble them for it Truth we must needs ascribe to the Church of England while She professedly owns the Faith of Christ and the True Religion For the Truth of Religion proves the Entity or Being as the Power of Religion the Purity of a Church while She owns the Head she must not be disowned for a Part of the Body the Church catholick-Catholick-Visible while She separates not from Christ we have no warrant totally and positively to separate from Her She may be Christs Spouse viz Visibly and Professedly though not a Chast-Virgin-Spouse a Wife though an Adulteresse retaining her Affinity though not her Virginity Corruptions in the Church are either 1. Personal or 2. Real Real again either or 1. Substantial and Intrinsecal 2. Circumstantial and Extrinsecal The latter is Mr. Croftons own distinction though possibly he and I may differ in the application of it Personal Corruptions in Scandalous Professors or Visible Church Members Ministers as well as others the Hophnie's and Phinehas's of our age defile a Church Corruptions Objective and Real though onely Circumstantial and Extrinsecal in Outward Rites and Ceremonies or corrupt Modes and Methods of Administration as the Antiquated Jewish Vestments Crosse in Baptisme Kneeling at the Supper c. adulterate a Church Corruptions Substantial and Intrinsecal which are Church-wasting Corruptions the very Vitals and Intrinsecals of Religion being by them destroyed do ipso facto actually divorce a Church from Christ those are the steps of Church-Apostacy when the Wife becomes a Lewd-Woman Single Fornication in the first Adultery in the second A Bill of Divorce in the last The Church of England is too truly chargeable with the two first but not with the last as is the Church of Rome she having not as yet I pray God she never may with her degenerated from a Christian Church into an Antichristian See nor her Members with hers from Professors to Persecutors of the Faith not holding the True Head but setting up ANOTHER NAME being in Doctrine damnably Heretical in Worship grossely Idolatrous in both Antichristian The Essentials Constitutive of a True Church are 1. the Head 2. the Body 3. the Vnion that is between them which three concurring in the Church of England Christ being her professed Head she being Christs professed Body and the Catholick-Faith being the Vnion-Bond whereby they are coupled together She cannot in justice be denyed to be a True though the Lord knows far from a Pure Church Vid. Jun. lib. de Ecclesia Herein I agree with Mr. Crofton 2. By way of Distinction Two things are here to be distinguished viz. 1. Communion with the Church-Visible 2. Solemn and Publick Worship 1. There is a twofold Communion viz. One by Profession Another by Participation 1. Church-Communion by way of Common Profession of the same true Religion Faith Doctrine and institured worship of Christ by vertue whereof all the Members of the Church Catholick Visible throughout the World are concorporated and embodyed one with another and all of them with Christ as a Publick Head Catholick Faith being the ground of Catholick Communion the main Ligament of the great Body Mystical is not only a Duty but a Priviledge too indispensably necessary to salvation Extra Ecclesiam nulla salus is a severe Maxim not more known then true no Salvation ordinarily without the Churches Line of Communication The Church is Gods Inclosure Cant. 9.12 his Nursery planted with the Trees of Righteousnesse without whose Pale and Boundaries all that die doe perish Ah my Dear Friend Let me rather be a Myrtle in the Vineyard then a Cedar in the Forrest 'T were better England should be unpeopled then unchurched A Church-lesse People is a Christ-lesse People and if Christ-lesse then Hope-lesse Ephes 2.12 Christ is the Head of the Body the Church Coll. 1.18 No Vnion with this Head without Communion with this Body Christ must be professed or else never possessed no Saint-State without a Church-State no Call by the Spirit without a Call by the Word first so that no Word no Life Rom. 10.13 14. Whosoever shall call upon the Name of the Lord
ground though not of Positive yet of Negative though not of Total yet of Partial Separation and Non-Communion in such a case can be no sin therefore no Schism How can Non-Communion be sin there where one cannot communicate without sin unless men will impose or suffer to be imposed upon themselves a Necessity of sinning that which true Piety abhorrs I am not alone here or without the suffrage of the sober-Learned a sufficient protection against the brand of Novelty who say that if a Church be either no true Church See Dr. Cawdrey in his Treatise Entituled Independency a great Schism or so extreamly corrupted that a good Christian cannot hold Communion with it without sin Separation in that case is no Schism but they are the Schismaticks that give the Cause of that Separation Then let the VVorld Judge who in England may most deservedly be branded for Schismaticks On the Contrary Culpable Faulty and sinful Separation from the Church the Schism in question is as I think it is generally described a Causeless Separation from Communion with and participation of Christs instituted Worship in a true Church Sir This premised we shall easily discover what Church-breach Schism or Separation it is that Mr. Crofton chargeth upon those in the Church of England and amongst those my self who under the present Providence though they joyn with her in the Instituted VVorship and Substantial Ordinances of Jesus Christ therein administred by as Prayer Hearing of che Word Preached Singing of Psalms c. yet do not cannot communicate with her in her Liturgy or Common-Prayer as being guilty of a sinful Practice c. 1. 'T is not a breach of the first Vnion viz. That wherein the Elect Gods Chosen Ones are by a true Faith or the Spirit of Faith un-interruptedly indwelling in them conjoyned one with another and all of them with their Publick Head Christ for this as is declared is an utter Impossibility which none but an Arminian Spirit will deny 2. 'T is not a Breach of Communion with the catholick-Catholick-Visible Church and her Common Head Christ by vertue of Outward Profession which is called a Catholick and Vniversal Separation for this were not only Schism but Apostacy as hath been said not only a Breach of Church-Vnity but a Voluntary forfeiture of a Church-State an Imputation which my Creed will acquit me from while I professedly own the true Catholick Doctrine of Christ and 〈◊〉 Apostles the Orthodox Fathers Councels Confessors Martyrs in all Ages and the Reformed Churches 3. 'T is not a Breach in the Church either 1. in poynt of Judgment and Opinion nor 2. in poynt of Charity and Affection 1. Not in poynt of Judgment and Opinion for as for Erroneous Principles according to that light God hath given me I abhor them Church-rending Divisions I shall not willingly or wittingly be accessory to never forgeting what Luther said of Caspar Schwenckfield that Church-Incendiaries may kindle a fire here which may burn themselves to all eternity hereafter But if a Dissent in Judgment about matters of Worship or Discipline yea and perchance in Doctrinal poynts too at least Non-Fundamentals from our present Church-Pilots be a Schism I shall not busie my self about either Vindication or Excuse under the Censure but sure I am either Mr. Crofton himself is in this sense a Schismatick or else justly may he be branded for an Apostate 2. Nor in poynt of Charity and Christian Affection Mr. Crofton is no competent Arbitrator in that case God himself is best able to judge who at this day walks charitably who not for my own part I have Charity for all Church-Members understand their Persons not their Corruptions The Law of Piety and the Law of Charity God himself hath married together and whom God hath joyned let no man separate 4. The Breach or Schism then charged must be a Separation from the Church of England not 1 Total since I communicate with her in those Parts of Christs instituted Worship and Ordinances Prayer Hearing c. Nor 2. Positive whilst I turn not Conventicler and embody not into a Party or Convention set up against her Altar against Altar Threshold against Threshold c. But 1. Partial and 2. Negative viz meer Non-Communion with her in her Liturgy or stinted and Set-Forms of Common-Prayer This is the Schism and Separation charged This is the Crime and great Article of Endictment What and is Mr. Crofton turned Accuser of the Brethren Sir Two Things I equally dislike Separation on the one hand and Superstition on the other and what sober Christian will not they being destructive the one to the Vnity the other to the Purity of the Church and the latter not more than the former understand I pray you sinfull Separaiotn Schism in the Church is a Rent and Wound in Christs Body a Crucifying afresh of the Son of God The Schismatical Rendings of the Church by Anabaptists and such like Fanaticks in Germany cost Zealous Luther no little grief and lamentation God forgive those who are known to have been too too guilty of such Sectarian-Cruelty here at home 1 Cor. 1.13 Zech. 13.6 Is Christ divided was a sad Interrogatory What Christ wounded in the house of his friends that 's sad The Voluntary Rending of Christ-Mystical is a sin nothing inferiour in my mind to that of the Jews Crucifying of Christ Personal forasmuch as that it reacheth both Head and Members That then which inclineth me to this attempt is not Consciousnesse to my self of any Schism or sinfull Separation though I perceive you are ready to espouse mine Acculers quarrel in case of non-satisfaction to your enforced request but the prevalent sense as well of your importunity as of mine own innocency This Epistle possibly may seem to be with the City of Myndus lyable to upbraiding the Porch being too big but neither is the premised Introduction larger nor the subsequent discourse more brief than I judged expedient Mr. Croftons Grounds and Reasons urged for Communion with the Church of England in all Acts of worship and consequently in Common-Prayer therein administred by and against Separation or withdrawment from the same are all reduced to four Positions or Argumentative Propositions from which Premises he infers partly the Lawfulness partly the Expediency and partly the indispensable Necessity of the former as the sinfulnesse and unwarrantablenesse the Schism of the latter And those Positions he calls CONSIDERATIONS which come now to be considered CONSID. 1. Page 4. Communion with the Church-Visible in all the Acts I had rather say Parts of Solemn Publique Worship is an Essential part of the sanctification of the Sabbath or Lords day and positive indispensable duty of every particular soul called by the name of God to be onely superseded by a reall inevitable necessity with assurance to any that God will have mercy and not sacrifice This is the Major-Proposition of Mr. Croftons great Doom-Argument The Assumption must be this But Communion with the