those that will be perfect by the workes of the Law God will condemne for vnperfect for not fulfilling the whole Law And for this cause it was that Saint Paul concludeth hereof thus By the workes of the Law shall no flesh be iustified in the sight of God Romans 3. And thus much by proofe of Scripture concerning this point now let vs heare the ancient Fathers 6 Saint Augustine writing against the Pelagian heretikes saith a August in his first Booke against the Pelagians Who will grant you that any man can doe that thing that no man was euer able to doe Againe he saith b Against that 2. Epistle It is impossible that the Law should be fulfilled by flesh Saint Hierome also against the same heretiques wrote thus c Hier. to Cresiphontus against the Pelag. Ye will say Gods Commandements be easie yet you are not able to shew vs any man that euer fulfilled them altogether And these Pelagians Saint Augustine called the new heretiques whereby it seemeth that they were the first Authors of this heresie And notwithstanding their great Doctor Saint Thomas of Aquine proueth it an heresie by saying d Thomas of Aquin 3. Galat. It is impossible for flesh and bloud to fulfill the Law yet commeth their Master Harding and saith e M. Hard. Apolog chap. 19. Diuis 1. We beleeue that God commandeth vs nothing vnpossible to vs otherwise how could he iustly punish for not doing that Commandement which by no meanes we are able to fulfill Wee are sure that God punisheth no man vniustly for there is none iniquity in God To which we answere 7 God is iust and perfect in nature and therefore he gaue a iust and perfect Law and such a one as man might haue kept had he kept himselfe in that perfect estate wherin God created him but if through his owne default hee hath lost the freedome both of power and will so as that he cannot now but breake his Law God is not vniust in punishing him for it And it is most certaine that to the intent man might see what a miserable estate he had brought himselfe into Gal. 3.19 Rom. 3.20 this iust Law was giuen For as Saint Paul saith Galat. 3. It was added because of transgression and Rom. 3. By the Law commeth the knowledge of sinne And this is it which Saint Augustine saith f August in his Preface to the Galathians The Lord gaue a iust Law to vniust men to make manifest their sinnes and not to take them away Againe he saith g Vpon the 118 Psal To this purpose was the Law giuen that of great it might make little that it might shew vnto thee that thou hast no strength of thy selfe to fulfill the Law And so being needy vnworthy and poore might flee vnto grace and cry Haue mercie on me O God for I am weake The Pelagians saith he h In his booke of Grace and Free-will cap. 4. thinke themselues cunning men when they say as we heard right now Master Harding said God would not commaund the thing that he knoweth a man is not able to doe To which Saint Augustine answereth thus h In his booke of Grace and Free-will cap. 4. God commaundeth vs to doe some things that we are not able to doe that we might vnderstand what we ought to craue of him Also their Saint Bernard speaking of that which God in his Law requireth of vs to be performed saith i Bernard vpon the Canticles the 53. Sermon In commaunding impossible things God made not men transgressours but humble that euery mouth might be stopped and all the world in danger vnto God because no flesh shall be iustified in his sight And thus much for the answering that sort of Papists which hold that men are iustified and saued by their good workes Now let vs see what wee can say to the other sort 8 Another sort there are which hold that wee are iustified by faith and workes together And they ground their opinion vpon the words of Saint Iames. chap 2. Iames chap. 2.24 where hee saith Ye see how that of workes a man is iustified and not of faith onely And hereupon they conclude that in the sight of God we are iustified by faith and workes together whereas it is euident by the words doing before Saint Iames had no such meaning and therefore their mis-vnderstanding him hath caused them to erre For they not considering that there be two manners of iustifications the one before God the other before men Mat. 23. Mat. 23. suppose that Saint Iames speaketh there of iustification before God but how can this possibly be seeing as we heard before hee said in the same chap. He that faileth in one point of the Law Iames 2. chap. 10. and 3.2 is guiltie of all And in the chap. following in many things we sinne all Now seeing he saith that in many things wee sinne all and hee that breaketh one point is guilty of all it is cleare he did not meane iustification before God but before men And this appeareth also most euidently from the beginning of the 2 chap. to the 17. verse of the same Where he hauing to deale with the Atheists of his time such as of whom there are too many euery where in whom albeit there appeare no fruit of a true and iustifying faith but the contrarie yet let any well disposed man reproue them for the same streight way they breake forth into these speeches and say I hope I haue as good a faith as you and I hope to be saued as well as the best of you all To such said Saint Iames Iames chap. 2.18 Thou hast the faith and I haue workes shew me thy faith out of thy workes and I will shew thee my faith by my workes Now in that he saith shew me and I will shew thee it is without all contradiction he speaketh of the outward iustification before men and not that by workes neither by faith and workes together we are iustified before God 9 Againe whereas against those Athiests hee opposed that outward signe of Abrahams faith by offering to sacrifice his sonne Isaac at the commandement of God yet although his faith thereby was manifested to the World to be a true faith hee was neither iustified before God by that worke neither by it and faith together but euen by the faith alone Rom. 4.2.3.4.5.6.7 For as the Apostle Saint Paul saith Rom. 4. If Abraham were iustified by workes he hath wherein to reioyce but not with God For what saith the Scriptures Abraham beleeued God and it was accounted to him for righteousnesse Now to him that worketh the wages is not counted by fauour but by debt but to him that worketh not but beleeueth in him that iustifieth the vngodly his faith is accounted for righteous Euen as Dauid declareth the blessednesse of the man vnto whom God imputeth righteousnesse without workes saying Blessed are they
And when I had opened the fift Seale I saw vnder the Alter the soules of them that were killed for the Word of God and for the testimonie which they maintained And they cried with a loud voyce saying How long Lord holy and true doest thou not iudge and auenge our bloud on them that dwell on the earth and long white robes were giuen to euery one and it was said vnto them that they should rest for a little season vntill their fellow-seruants and their brethren that should be killed euen as they were were fulfilled Loe say they here is a third place euen a place where the soules of the faithful doe rest vntill the latter day To which we answer The Alter vnder which the soules are said to rest The Altar is Christ is Christ as who so will reade the 56. Chapter of Esay and seuenth verse And 60. Chapter 7. verse of the same Prophet and 8. Chapter 3. verse of the Reuelation shall see or that will listen to these testimonies of these three ancient Fathers shall heare to wit Saint Ireneus Saint Augustine and Epyphanius Ireneus saith g Jreneus in his 4. Booke and 34. Chap. Our Alter is not in earth but in heauen Saint Augustine saith h Augustine in his 20. Booke 10. Chap. of the City of God Our Alter is in heauen thither our prayers and oblations are directed Epyphanius saith i Epiphanius in his 2. Booke of Melchisadech Christ is our Sacrifice our Priest and our Alter So that we see euidently that by the Alter is meant Christ and therefore the place in which the soules of the faithfull doe rest till the day of iudgement is vnder the foote-stoole of Christ in Heauen Wherefore those words of Saint Iohn doth not proue a third place Also this is made more manifest by the 15. verse of the 7. Chapter where he speaking of the same soules Reuel 7.15 saith They are in the presence of the Throne of God And therefore whereas the Papists would haue this place of rest Elisius Campus Abrahams bosome or Paradise to be their Elisius Campus a place of pleasure in hell which they say is Paradise or Abrahams Bosome here they are compelled either to say that the Throne of God is in hell or else to grant that the resting place of those soules is in Heauen and then where is their third place yet proued 6 But forasmuch as those words in the 6. Chapter together with the other words in the 7. Chapter doe shew the resting place of the soules of the faithful to be in heauen and a place where they do crie for the time of the perfecting their full ioy and glory it is cleare that vnder the foote-stoole of Christ is the Celestiall Paradise which in the 16. Chapter of Saint Lukes Gospell is called Abrahams Bosome where Lazarus the goâ—d thiefe Paradise is in heauen not in hâ—ll and all the faithfull doe rest with Abraham the Father of the faithfull till they receiue together the full fruition of their faith So that hereby wee see Paradise to be in Heauen and not in hell as they fable And this is yet made more plaine by Saint Paul 2 Cor. 12. where he saith I know a man in Christ about foureteene yeeres agone 2 Cor. 12.2.4 which was taken vp into the third Heauen How that he was taken vp into Paradise By which it is most manifest that Paradise is in the highest Heauen and that therefore their hellish Paradise in which they faine their purified soules of Purgatory doe rest till the last day is fabulous and doth not proue a third place 7 But now I doe expect they will answer thus Be it as you say that Paradise is in Heauen and that therein is the resting place of the soules of the faithfull yet is there at least a third place in which they did rest for a time to wit till they were purified and made fit for Heauen For to the very same effect are these words of Cardinall Allen k Allen in Fulks page 139. By long amending by fire at last they come to that reward Againe speaking of Purgatory fire he saith l Page 130. Through which the good must passe before they come to eternall ioy By which they would haue vs to vnderstand that no soule can come into the presence of God in Heauen Soules are in heauen because they haue washed themselues white in the bloud of the Lambe noâ— in the fire of Purgatory but onely such as are purified by the fire of Purgatory and that those that are in Heauen are there because first they were so purified Which how vntrue it is these words in the 14. and 15. verses of the 7. Chapter of the Reuelation will make it most euident which saith They haue washed their long Robes white in the bloud of the Lambe therefore are they in the presence of the Throne of God and serue him in his Temple day and night Now in that the holy Ghost saith Therefore it is as cleare as the Sunne at noone day that all those that are admitted into the presence of God in Heauen are so dignified because by the hands of their faith they haue washed themselues white in the bloud of Christ not in the fire of Purgatory Wherefore as those words before cited did vtterly ouerthrow their hellish Paradise so doth these words vtterly ouerthrow their hellish Purgatorie 8 Thirdly to proue yet that the soules are made perfect by the fire of Purgatorie they cite the words of Saint Paul 1 Cor. 1 Cor. 3.13 3. where he speaking of ignorant Teachers and their doctrine saith Euery mans worke shall be made manifest for the day shall declare it because it shall be reuealed by fire Which words they would make the World to beleeue are meant of the fire of Purgatory that shall as they say purge curious and vaine doctrine and those that haue built it on the foundation Christ whereas the very words themselues doe make it plaine to the contrary for in that it saith the day shall declare it 2 Pet. 1 Chap. 19 verse 2 Thes 2. ch 8. he meant the truth the light whereof Saint Peter calleth The day-starre 2. Epistle 1. Chapter And the power thereof Saint Paul 2 Thessalonians 2. Chapter 8 calleth the Spirit of Gods mouth wherewith he sheweth that Antichrist and all Antichristian Teachers and their doctrine shall be consumed euen as fire consumeth the drosse and fineth the gold and siluer And therefore in that Chapter where hee speaketh of purging by fire that no man should vnderstand him to meane a corporall or materiall fire hee concludeth of that matter thus 1 Cor. 3.8 As it were by the fire That is as it were by fire the vaine doctrine shall be burned and consumed by the fire of Gods truth and the Teacher thereof being tryed thereby to hold the foundation sound the Church shall not condemne him as an heretique
follow Beware saith he left there be any man that spoile you through Philosophie and vaine deceit through the traditions of men according to the rudiments of the World and not after Christ And thus much touching the first Authours of Purgatory and the first place of Scripture that the heretiques brought and Montanus and his Adherents afterwards to confirme the doctrine as also to shew how it tendeth to the vtter confounding of the vertue of Christs death and passion and faith in him and how it did corrupt the Church and confound the iudgements of some ancient writers Now let vs briefly take a view how it hath also confounded the iudgements of the Papists themselues 14 First What confusion the doctrine of Purgatory hath wrought amongst the Papists themselues for the number of hels Sillius saith There beten Aeneas saith but nine Gelasius but seauen Aquines but foure Diuers of the Papists will haue fiue of which Paradise to be one which their Paullinus saith is Abrahams bosome and is in the hell of the damned Secondly touching the place where Purgatory should be Polidore saith It is in Mount Aethne in Cicilie Another saith Saint Patrike placed it in Ireland The Manachies say It is in the Globe of the Sunne Others say It is in the Globe of the Moone Some say It is vnder the South Pole Others say It is vnder the North Pole but some others say It is vnder the City of Romes for there is a deepe hole where Christ went downe with his Crosse on his backe By which we see that hell mouth is in Rome Thirdly touching the degrees of Purgatory Lutzenburge saith Purgatory is the highest of the foure hels Vaâ—â—a saith It is the highest saue one Herolt saith It is the lowest saue one Smith saith It is the lowest of all and Cardinall Allen saith It is in the lower Romes as the best learned iudge Fourthly what Christ did in Purgatory Smith saith Christ did in his soule suffer there for the sinnes of our soules Allen saith It is blasphemie to say that the Diuels had power to torment the soule of Christ Smith saith Christ preached to the soules and brought them all out with him Martion saith Christ did not deliuer all for Abel Enoch Abraham and others durst not come at him lest he would tempt them and punish them Most of the Papists say He deliuered all But Hermes saith They came not all forth till the Apostles descended and preached vnto them also Another saith Christ deliuered the Sodomites and Kaine that reprobate Allen saith Purgatory doth not belong to any but to the faithfull The master of the Sentences saith Iust men goe not into Purgatory at all Allen saith The good must passe there-through before they come to eternall ioy Smith saith After Christs resurrection the soules went no more to Purgatory Allen affirmeth that the Apostles went thither Now as touching the element wherewith the soules are purged some say it is onely fire Allen holdeth it to be both fire and water and that they shall be tormented as well with extreame cold as heate Sir Thomas More saith In Purgatory there is no water Ruffensis saith In Purgatory there is good store of water The last question is whether Diuels or Angels be the executioners Ruffensis and Albertus say They be holy Angels but Sir Thomas More saith They be Diuels Therefore Christian Reader I now referre the matter to be iudged by thee whether the Doctrine of Purgatory be such as any in his right wits will thinke he may build his faith thereon or beleeue that there is any such purging place And the rather for that it tendeth to the vtter ouerthrow of the power of all that Christ hath done for mans saluation and whereof that errour of prayers for the dead is an appendix CHAP. XIII The conclusion of the former twelue Chapters Containing an answere vnto two sorts of Papists the one affirming that we are iustified and saued by the workes of of the Law the other that wee are saued by faith and workes together That because no man can fulfill the Law no man can be iustified by the Law That God was not vniust in giuing such a Law as he knew no man was able to fulfill That to seeke to merit saluation is the high way to damnation 1 SO farre and wide Christian Reader as the Romish iurisdiction and Kingdome of Antichrist did extend it selfe this Doctrine of iustification by faith without the workes of the Law was impugned Some teaching that men by their good workes are iustified and for their good workes saued Others that we are iustified and saued by faith and workes together to both which we answere 2 All good workes are said to be the workes of the Law because God commaunded them in his Law for diuers good ends and purposes the iustification by which confisteth of two parts First in not omitting any one thing whatsoeuer the Law hath commanded Secondly in not committing any one thing whatsoeuer the Law hath forbidden which as it is in Leuiticus the eighteenth Chapter Leuit. 18.5 If a man doe he shall liue in them But contrariwise if he doe not obserue and doe all and also doe nothing to the contrary hee is so farre from being iustified by the Law that he is accursed and condemned by it 3 The affirmatiue part is proued in the seauen and twentieth Chapter of Deuteronomie Deut. 27.26 Where it is said Cursed be hee that confirmeth not all the wordes of this Law to doe them and all the people shall say So be it The negatiue part is proued Ezek. 18.11.13 Ezekiel Chap. 18. in these words If he doe any one of these things though he doe not all shall he liue seeing he hath done all these abhominations he shall surely die the death By which it is cleare that whosoeuer omitteth any one thing which the Law requireth or committeth any one thing whatsoeuer the Law prohibiteth hee is culpable of the whole And this is it which the Apostle Saint Iames saith Chapter 2. Whosoeuer shall keepe the whole Law Iames 2.10 and yet faileth in one poynt is guiltie of all Therefore now the question is whether any man can thus absolutely fulfill the Law Wee say no man can Contrariwise the Papists say that a regenerate man may And their Doctor Master Harding will proue it both by the words of Christ and also of the Apostle Saint Iohn * M. Harding in Apol. chap. 19. Diuis 1. The words of Christ Matthew 11. after their Translation be these My yoke is sweete and my burden light And the words of Saint Iohn 1. Epistle 5. Chapter be these His Commandements be not heauy Now the words of Christ that goe before those his words be these Come vnto me all ye that are weary and laden and I will ease you And then it followeth Take my yoke vpon you c. Shewing that if any were afflicted in his conscience and found himselfe
whose iniquities are forgiuen and whose sinnes are couered Blessed is the man to whom the Lord imputeth not sinne So that hereby we see it most manifest that iustification before God consisteth in faith alone without workes euen as he also proueth as apparantly where he absolutely and vtterly excludeth all kinde of workes for being wholly or any part of the cause of iustification in that he saith Rom. 11. If it be of grace it is no more of workes If it be of workes it is no more of grace That is to say it is of the one but not of both And therefore in the third Chapter of the same Booke he closeth vp the doctrine of iustification thus Rom. 3.28 We conclude that a man is iustified by faith without the workes of the Law And thus much by proofe of Scripture touching this point also Now let vs heare the iudgement of the Fathers 10 Saint Augustine saith k August in â—â—s 83. qâ—â—stioâ—s Quest 76. Glossa ordinaria Abrahrns was iustified by faith without works Saint Hilary saith l Hila. 9. Can. Ma. 8. It moued the Scribes that sinnes was forgiuen by man for they onely beheld man in Christ Iesu and that to be forgiuen of him which the Law could not release fides enim sola iustificat for faith onely iustifieth Saint Hierome saith m Hier. 10. cap. Rom. They not knowing that God iustifieth sola fide by faith onely supposed themselues to be iust by the workes of the Law which they neuer obserued Theophilact saith n Theop. 3 cap. Gal. Because no man is iustified by the Law c. Now he doth plainly shew that fidem ipsam vel solâ—m faith it selfe yea euen alone hath power to iustifie Saint Chrisostome saith o Christost 4. Hom vpon the 1. to Tim. chap. 1. Who could hardly beleeue that enemies that sinners that such as were not iustified in the Law nor by workes that they by and by haue ex sola fide by faith onely obtayned the chiefe merite It seemed to the Iewes said heâ— an incredible thing that a man that had spent all his former life vainely and disorderly hauing passed the same in wicked workes that afterwards hee should be said to be saued sola fide by faith onely Againe he saith thus of them p In his Hom. vpon th 3. chap. to the Gala. They said who so stayeth himselfe sola fide by faith onely is accursed Contrariwise Saint Paul proueth who so stayeth sota fide by faith onely is blessed Moreouer he saith q Vpon the 4. chap. to the Rom. the 8. Ser. That a man destitute of workes should be iustified by faith that peraduenture may seeme to be well but that a man beautified with vertue and good workes should neuerthelesse by them not be iustified sed sola fide but by faith onely truely this is wonderfull And hereof it is that their Doctor Maister Harding is compelled thus to confesse r D. Har. in his booke A detection of sundry foule errours liâ—s c. in fol. 357. Wee are iustified freely without workes that may deserue the grace that God giueth To conclude Saint Origen saith Å¿ Origen 3. Bâ—â—â—ke 3. chap. Rom. Rom. 4 5. If we require an example who was iustified sola fide by faith onely without workes I suppose that the same theefe doth suffice And indeed this iâ— that remedyâ— whereby God doth saue his elect which hee calleth at the last houre whether on their death bedde or on the gallows-tree And this it is which Saint Paul saith Rom. Rom. 4.5 4. By faith God doth iustifie the vngodly And as hee sheweth that faith is the onely meanes whereby God doth saue the vngodly Gal. 3.11 Hab. 2.4 whom he vouchsafeth to call so Galla. 3. aluding to these words of the Prophet Habakkuk chapter 2. The iust shall liue by his faith hee proueth that the most righteous shall be saued by their faith onely or else they shall neuer be saued And thus much for the answering the other sort of Papists also which will haue men to be saued by faith and workes together 11 But now Christian Reader what shall wee say shal we conclude that we are iustified by such a faith as the Papists charge vs with which is generall with all the wicked which not onely is without the fruits of a true and liuely faith but hath the contrary God forbid But wee say that we are iustified by faith that is by such a faith as Saint Paul saith 2. Thess 3.2 1 Cor. 13. chap. All men haue not 2 Thess 3. Yea by that faith which hee saith worketh by loue and which Saint Iames saith James 3.17 Is full of mercie and good fruits chapter 3. Euen by the same faith which is manifested vnto men and approued of God to be a true faith which at the day of iudgement shall be tried by the fruits thereof and all iudged thereby at which time euery one that is found to haue had it shall as the Apostle Saint Peter saith 1. Ep. 1. chap. Receiue the end of his faith euen the saluation of his soule The rest that had not this fruitfull faith shall be damned as appeareth in the 25. Chapter of Saint Matthew 12 True it is that the generall sort because they beleeue Christ to be the Sauiour of the world and haue their names deriued from him to be called Christians thinke verily they shall all be saued Yea though many of them liue worse then the very Infidells But what reason haue they so to delude themselues seeing that not a few but many which preach Christ and the Christian faith shall be damned because howsoeuer they preach well and teach the truth their liues are not correspondent Our Sauiour Christ speaking of Christians and the time of triall who be true Christians indeed Matth. 7. saith Matth. 7.22.23 Not euery one that saith vnto mee Lord. Lord shall outer into the Kingdome of heauen but he that doth my fathers will which is in heauen Many will say vnto mee in that day Lord Lord haue we not by thy name prophecied and by thy name cast out Deuills and by thy name done many great workes and then saith Christ I will professe vnto them I neuer knew you Depart from mee yee that worke iniquitie And here wee see those miracle-mongers the Papists specially included who as we proued in our second Chapter worke their miracles in the name of Christ to draw men to Antichrist And as touching their conuersation of life their Saint Bridgit bringeth Christ thus reproaching them for the vilenesse thereof saying t Bridgit in her sixt Booke of Reuelation 15. chap. Their conuersation and life stinketh like a Where in my sight So that as she saith in another place v In her first Booke chap. 50. The simple sort by their bad example they hurle downe headlongs 13 But now haply they will obiect and say are wee singular