and intent of the said law Now in case these two causes and coÌsiderations wil not satisfie th Aduersarie we wil adioine therevnto a third which he shal neuer by any good and honest shift auoid And that is the vse and practise of the Realme as wel in the time foregoing the said statute as afterward We stand vpon the interpretation of the coÌmon law recited and declared by the said statute And how shal we better vnderstand what the law is therein then by the vse and practise of the said lawe For the best interpretation of the lawe is custome But the Realme before the statute admitted to the Croune not only kings children and others of the first degre but also of a farther degre and such as were plainely borne out of the Kings allegeance The soresaid vse and practise appeareth as wel before as sithens the time of the Conquest Among other King Edward the Confessour being destitute of a lawful Heire within the Realme sent into HuÌgary for Edward his Nephew surnamed Outlaw son to King EdmuÌd called IroÌside after many yeres of his exile to returne into EnglaÌd to th' intent the said Outlaw should inherite this Realme whiche neuerthelesse came not to effect by reason the said outlaw died before the said king Edward his Vncle. After whose death the said king apointed Eadgar Etheling sonne of the said Outlaw being his next cosen and heire as he was of right to the Croune of EnglaÌd And for that the said Eadgar was but of yong and tender yeares and not able to take vpoÌ him so great a gouernement the said king coÌmitted the protection as wel of the yong Prince as also of the Realm to Harold Earle of Kent vntil suche time as the said Eadgar had obteined perfit age to be hable to weld the state of a King Which Harold neuerthelesse coÌtrary to the trust supplanted the said yong Prince of the Kingdome and put the Croune vpon his own head By this it is apparent that foraine birth was not accoÌpted of before the time of the CoÌquest a iust cause to repel and reiect any man being of the next proximitie in blood froÌ the Title of the Croune And though the said king Edward the CoÌfessors wil and purpose toke no such force and effect as he desired and the law craued yet the like succession toke place effectuously in king Stephen and king HeÌry the secoÌd as we haue already declared Neither wil th' Aduersaries shift of foramers borne of father and mother which be not of the kings alegeaÌce help him forasmuch as this clause of the said statut is not to be applied to the kings childreÌ but to others as appeareth in the same statute And these two kings StepheÌ and Henrie the 2. as they were borne in a forain place so their fathers and mothers wer not of the kings allegeaÌce but mere Aliens and straÌgers And how notorious a vaine thing is it that th' Aduersarie would perswade vs that the said K. Henrie the secoÌd rather came in by force of a coÌposition then by the proximitie and nearenes of blood I leaue it to euery man to coÌsider that hath any maner of feling in the discours of the stories of this realm The coÌpositioÌ did procure him quietnes and rest for the time with a good and sure hope of quiet and peaceable entrance also after the death of King Stephen and so it followed in deede but ther grew to him nomore right therby then was due to him before For he was the true heir to the Croune as appeareth by Stephen his Aduersaries owne confession Henry the firste maried his daughter Mathildis to Henry the Emperour by whome he had no childreÌ And no dout in case she had had any children by th'Emperour they should haue ben heires by succession to the Croune of England After whose death she retourned to her father yet did King Henry cause all the Nobilitie by an expresse othe to embrace her after his death as Queene and after her her children Not long after she was maried to Ieffrey Plantagenet a Frenchman borne Earle of Aniowe who begat of her this Henry the second being in France Whervpon the said King did reuiue and renue the like othe of allegeaÌce aswel to her as to her sonne after her With the like false persuasioÌ the Adueruersarie abuseth him selfe and his Reader touching Arthur Duke of Britanie Nephew to King Richard the first As though forsooth he were iustly excluded by Kinge Iohn his vncle by cause he was a forainer borne If he had said that he was excluded by reason the vncle ought to be preferred before the Nephewe though it should haue ben a false allegation and plaine against the rules of the lawes of this Realme as may wel appeare among other thinges by King Richard the second who succeded his graÌdfather king Edward the third which Richard had diuerse worthie and noble vncles who neither for lacke of knowledge coulde be ignorant of the right neither for lacke of frendes courage and power be enforced to forbeare to chalenge their title and interest yet should he haue had some countenance of reason and probabilitie bicause many arguments and the authoritie of many learned and notable Ciuilians doo concurre for the vncles right before the Nephewe But to make the place of the natiuitie of an inheritour to a kingdom a sufficieÌt barre against the right of his blood it seemeth to haue but a weake and slender holde and grounde And in our case it is a most vnsure and false ground seeing it is moste true that King Richard the first as we haue said declared the said Arthur borne in Britanie and not son of a King but his brother Geffreys sonne Duke of Britanie heire apparent his vncle Iohn yet liuing And for such a one is he taken in al our stories And for such a one did all the worlde take him after the said King Richard his death neither was King Iohn taken for other then for an vsurper by excluding him and afterward for a murtherer for imprisoning him and priuily making him away For the which facte the French King seased vpon al the goodly CouÌtries in France belonging to the King of England as forfeited to him being the chiefe Lorde By this outragious deede of King Iohn we lost Normandie withall and our possibilitie to the inheritance of all Britanie the right and Title to the said Britanie being dewe to the said Arthur and his heires by the right of his mother Constance And though the said king Iohn by the practise and ambition of Quene Elenour his mother and by the special procurement of Huberte then Archebishop of Caunterburie and of some other factious persons in EnglaÌd preueÌted the said Arthur his nephew as it was easy for him to do hauing gotten into his handes al his brother Richardes treasure by sides many other rentes then in England and the said Arthur being an infante
only Of the like weight is his other coÌsideration imaginiÌg and surmising this statute to be made bicause the King had so many occasioÌs to be so oft ouer the sea with his spouse the Queene As though diuers Kings before him vsed not often to passe ouer the seas As though this were a personal statute made of special purpose and not to be takeÌ as a declaratioÌ of the coÌmon law Which to say is most directly repugnant and contrary to the letter of the said statute Or as though his children also did not very often repaire to outward Countries as Iohn of Gaunt Duke of Lancaster that maried Peters the King of Castiles eldest daughter by whose right he claimed the Croune of Castile as his brother EdmuÌd Erle of Cambridge that maried the yongest daughter as Lionell Duke of Claraunce that maried at Milaine ViolaÌt daughter and heir to Galeatius Duke of Milan But especially Prince Edwarde whiche moste victoriously toke in battaile Iohn the French King and brought him into England his prisoner to the great triumphe and reioysing of the Realme whose eldest sonne Edward that died in short time after was borne beyond the seas in Gascome and his other sonne Richard that succeded his grandfather was borne at Burdeaux as these noble King Edwardes sonnes maried with forainers so did they geue out their daughters in mariage to foraine Princes as the Duke of Lancaster his daughter Philippe to the king of Portingale and his daughter Catherin to the King of Spaine and his Neece Iohan daughter to his sonne Earle of Somerset was ioyned in mariage to the King of Scottes Iohan daughter to his brother Thomas of Wodstocke Duke of Gloucester was Queene of Spaine and his other daughter Marie Duchesse of Britannie Now by this mans interpretation none of the issue of al these noble Women could haue enioyed the Croune of England when it had fallen to them though they had bene of the neerest roial blood after the death of their Auncestours Which surely had bene against the auncient presidentes and examples that we haue declared and against the common Lawe the whiche muste not be thought by this Statute any thing taken away but only declared and against al good reason also For as we would haue thought this Realme greatly iniured if it had ben defrauded of Spaine or any of the foresaid couÌtreies being deuolued to the same by the foresaid Mariages as we thincke our self at this day iniured for the withholding of France so the issue of the foresaide noble womeÌ might and would haue thought them hardly and iniuriously handled yf any such case had happened Neither suche friuolous interpretation and gloses as this man nowe frameth and maketh vppon the statute woulde then haue serued nor nowe wil serue But of all other his friuolous and folish ghessing vpon the clause of the statute for Infantes de Roy there is one most fond of al. For he would make vs beleue such is the mans skil that this statute touching Infantes de Roy was made for the great doubte more in them then in other personnes touching their inheritance to their Auncestours For being then a Maxime saieth he in the lawe that none could inherite to his Auncestours being not of father and mother vnder the obedience of the King seing the King him selfe could not be vnder obedience it plainely seemed that the Kinges children were of farre worse condition then others and quite excluded And therefore he saith that this statute was not to geue them any other priuilege but to make them equall with other And that therefore this statute touching the Kinges children is rather in the superficial parte of the worde then in effecte Nowe among other thinges he saieth as we haue shewed before that this word Infantes de Roy in this statute mentioned must be taken for the children of the first degree whiche he seemeth to proue by a note taken out of M. Rastal But to this we answer that this maÌ swetely dreamed when he imagined this fonde and fantasticall exposition And that he shewed him selfe a very infante in law and reason For this was no Maxime or at lest not so certaine before the making of this statute whiche geueth no new right to the Kinges children nor answereth any doubt touching them and their inheritance but saith that the law of the Croune of England is and alwaies hath bene which lawe saith the King say the Lordes say the Commons we allowe and affirme for euer that the Kinges children shal be hable to inherite the Landes of their Auncesters whereâoeuer they be borne Al the doubt was for other persons as appeareth euideÌtly by the tenour of the statute whether by the coÌmon law they being borne out of the allegeance were heritable to their Auncestours And it appeareth that th' Aduersary is driueÌ to the hard wal when he is faine to catch hold vpon a selie poore marginal note of M. Rastal of the Kinges childreÌ and not of the Kings childrens children Which yet nothing at al serueth his purpose touching this statute But he or the Printer or who so euer he be as he draweth out of the text many other notes of the matter therin coÌprised so vpoÌ these FreÌch wordes Les enfants de Roy he noteth in the MargeÌt The Kings childreÌ but how far that word reacheth he saieth neither more nor lesse Neither it is any thing preiudicial to the said Queenes right or Title whether the said wordes Infants ought to be takeÌ strictly for the first degree or farther enlarged For if this statute toucheth only the succession of the Kings children to their Auncestours for other inheritaÌce and not for the Cround as most men take it and as it may be as we haue said very wel takeÌ and allowed then doth this supposed Maxime of forain borne that seemeth to be gathered out of this statute nothing anoy or hinder the Queene of Scotlandes Title to the Croune as not therto apperteining On the other side if by the inheritance of the kings childreÌ the Croune also is meant yet neither may we enforce the rule of foraine borne vpoÌ the kings children which are by theâpresse wordes of the statute excepted neither enforce the word Inâââs to the first degree only for such reasons presidents and examples and other prouffes largely by vs before set forth to the coÌtrarie seing that the right of the Croune falling vpoÌ them they may wel be called the kings ChildreÌ or at the lest the childreÌ of the Croune Ther is also one other cause why though this statute reach to the Croune and may and ought to be expouÌded of the same the said Queene is out of the reach and coÌpasse of the said statute For the said statute can not be vnderstanded of any persons borne in Scotlande or Wales but onely of persons borne beyond the sea out of the allegeance of the King of England that is to wrtte France Flandres and such like For England
one rule as a general Maxime is obiected against her And yet the same rule is so vntruely set forth that I can not wel agree that it is any rule or Maxime of the coÌmon law of this Realm of EnglaÌd Your preteÌsed Maxime is whosoeuer is born out of the realm of EnglaÌd and of father and mother not being vnder the obedieÌce of the King of England cannot be capable to inherite any thing in England Which rule is nothing true but altogether false For euery stranger and Alien is hable to purchace the inheritance of landes within this Realme as it may appeare in 7. 9. of king Edward the fourth and also in 11. 14. of king HeÌrie the fourth And although the same purchace is of some men accounted to be to the vse of the King yet vntil such time as the king be intitled therevnto by matter of Record the inheritance remaineth in the Alien by the opinion of al men And so is a very Alien capable of inheritance within this Realme And then it must nedes fal out very plainly that your general Maxime where vpon you haue talked and bragged so muche is now become no rule of the common law of this Realme And if it be so then haue you vttered very many wordes to smal purpose But yet let vs see fartther whether there be any rule or Maxime in the coÌmon Law that may seeme any thing like to that rule wherevppon any matter may be gathered against the Title of the said Marie Queene of Scotland There is one rule of the coÌmon Lawe in wordes somewhat like vnto that whiche hath ben alleaged by the Aduersaries Which rule is set forth and declared by a statute made anno 25. of King Edward the third Which statute reciting the doubt that then was whether infants borne out of the allegeance of England should be hable to demaund any heritage within the same allegeance or no it was by the same statute ordeined that al infantes inheritours which after that time should be borne out of the allegeance of the King whose father and mother at the time of their birth were of the feaith and allegeaÌce of the King of England should haue and enioy the same benefittes and aduantages to haue and carie heritage within the said allegeance as other heires should Whervpon it is to be gathered by dew and iust construction of the statute and hath bene heretofore coÌmonly taken that the coÌmon law alwaies was and yet is that no person borne out of the allegeaÌce of the King of England whose father and mother were not of the same allegeaÌce should be able to haue or demaund any heritage within the same allegeance as heire to any person Which rule I take to be the same supposed Maxime which the Aduersaries do meane But to stretch it generally to al inheritances as the Aduersaries woulde seeme to do by any reasonable meanes can not be For as I haue said before euery straÌger and Alien borne may haue and take inheritance as a purchaser And if an Alien do marie a woman inheritable the inheritance therby is both in the Alien and also in his wife and the Alien thereby a purchaser Noman doubteth but that a Denizon may purchase landes to his owne vse but to inherit landes as heire to any person within the allegeaÌce of England he can not by any meanes So that it seemeth very plaine that the said rule bindeth also DenyzoÌs and doth only extend to DesceÌtes of inheritance and not to the hauing of any landes by purchase Now wil we then consider whether this rule by any reasonable construction can extende vnto the Lady Marie the Queene of Scotland for and coÌcerning her Title to the Croune of England It hath bene said by the Aduersaries that she was borne in Scotland which realm is out of the allegeaÌce of England her father and mother not being of the same allegeance And therfore by the said rule she is not inheritable to the Croune of this Realm Although I might at the beginning very wel and orderly deny the consequent of your argumeÌt yet for this time we wil first examine the Antecedent whether it be true or no and then consider vpon the consequent That the Queene of Scotland was borne in ScotlaÌd it must nedes be grauÌted but that Scotland is out of the allegeaÌce of EnglaÌd though the said Quene and al her subiects of Scotland wil stourly affirme the same yet ther is a great nuÌber of men in Eng and both lerned and others that be not of that opinioÌ being lead and persuaded therto by diuers histories Registers Recordes and Instruments of Homage remaining in the treasurie of this Realm wherin is metioned that the Kings of Scotland haue acknowledged the King of EnglaÌd to be the superiour Lord ouer the Realme of Scotland and haue done homage and fealtie for the same Which thing being true notwithstanding it be coÌmonly denied by al Scotsmen then by the lawes of this realme ScotlaÌd must nedes be accoÌpted to be within the allegeance of EnglaÌd And although sins the time of King Henry the sixt none of the Kinges of Scotlande haue done the said seruice vnto the Kinges of England yet that is no reason in our lawe to say that therefore the Realme of Scotland at the time of the birth of the said Ladie Marie Queene of Scotlande being in the thirtie and fourth yeare of the raigne of our late Souereigne Lorde King Henrie the eight was out of the allegeance of the kinges of England For the law of this Realm is very plain that though the Tenant do not his seruice vnto the Lorde yet hath not the Lord thereby lost his Seignorie For the lande still remaineth within his Fee and Seignorie that notwithstanding But peraduenture some wil obiecte and say that by that reason France should likewise be said to be within the allegeance of England forasmuch as the possession of the Croune of France hath bene within a litle more then the space of one hundred yeares now last past laufully vested in the kinges of EnglaÌd whose right and title stil remaineth To that obiectioÌ it may be answered that there is a great difference betwene the right and title which the Kings of EnglaÌd claime to the Realme of Fraunce and the right and title which they claime to the Realme of Scotlande Although it be true that the Kinges of Englande haue bene lawfully possessed of the Croune of France yet during such time as they by vsurpation of others are dispossessed of the saide Realme of France the same Realme by no meanes can be said to be within their allegeance especially considering how that syns the time of vsurpation the people of France haue wholy forsaken their allegeance and subiection which they did owe vnto the Kings of Englande and haue geuen and submitted them selues vnder the obedience and allegeance of the vsurpers But as for the Realme of Scotlande it is otherwise For
Scotland and Wales be al within one Territorie and not diuided by any sea And al old Recordes of the law concerning seruice to be done in those two Countries haue these words Infra quatuor Maria within the fower seas which must nedes be vnderstaÌd in ScotlaÌd and Wales aswel as in EnglaÌd bâcause they be al within one continent coÌpassed with fower seas And likewise be many auncient statutes of this Realm writreÌ in the NormaÌ FreÌch which haue these wordes deins les quatre mers that is within the fower seas Now coÌcerning the statute the title of the same is of those that are born beyond the sea the doubt moued in the corps of the said statut is also of childreÌ born beyond the sea out of the allegeance with diuers other braÌches of the statute teÌding that way Wherby it seemeth that no part of the statute toucheth these that are born in Wales or Scot laÌd And albe it at this time and before in tho reigne of Edward the first Wales was fully reduced annexed and vnited to the propââ Dothinion of England yet was it before subrected to the Croune and King of England as to the Lorde and Sâigniour aswel as Scotland Wherefore if this statute had ãâã made before the time of the said Edwarde the ãâã it seemeth that it could not haue bene stretched to Wales no more then it can now to Scotland I doe not therefore a litle meruaile that euer this man for pure shame could finde in his harte so childishly to wrangle vpon this word Infantes and so openly to detorte depraue and corrupt the common lawe and the Actes of Parlament And thus may you see gentle Reader that nothing can be gathered either out of the said supposed general rule or Maxime or of any other rule or Principle of the lawe that by any good and reasonable construction can seeme to impugne the title of the said Ladie Marie now Queene of Scotland of and to the Croune of this Realme of England as is aforesaid We are therefore now last of al to consider whether there be any statute or Acte of Parlament that doth seeme either to take away or preiudâce the title of the said Lady Marie And bycause touching the foresaid mentioned statute of the 25. yeare of King Edward the thirde being only a declaration of the common law we haue already sufficiently answered we wil passe it ouer and consider vppon the statute of 28. and 36. of King Henry the eight being the only shoteanker of al the Aduersaries whether there be any matter therein conteined or depending vpon the same that can by any meanes destroie or hurt the title of the said Ladie Marie Queene of Scotland to the successioÌ of the Croune of England It doth appeare by the said statute of 28. of King Henry the eight that there was authoritie geuen him by the same to declare limite appoint and assigne the succession of the Croune by his Letters Patentes or by his last Wil signed with his owne hande It appeareth also by the foresaid statute made 35. of the said King that it was by the same enacted that the Croune of this Realme should go and be to the said King and to the heires of his body lawfully begotten that is to say vnto his Highnes first son of his body betwene him and the Ladie Iane then his wife begotten and for default of such issue then vnto the Lady Marie his daughter and to the heires of her body lawfully begotten and for default of such issue then vnto the Ladie Elizabeth his daughter and to the heires of her body laufully begotten and for default of such issue vnto suche person or persons in remainder or reuersion as should please the said King Henry the eight and according to such estate and after such maÌner order and conditioÌ as should be expressed declared named and limited in his Letters Patentes or by his last Wil in writing signed with his owne hande By vertue of whiche said Acte of Parlament the Aduersaries doo alleage that the said late King Henry the eight afterward by his last Wil in writing signed with his owne hand did ordeine and appoint that if it happen the said Prince Edward Ladie Marie and Lady Elizabeth to dye without issue of their bodies lawfully begotten then the Croune of this Realme of Englande should goe and remaine vnto the heires of the bodie of the Ladie Francis his Neece and th' eldest daughter of the FâeÌch Quene And for the defaulte of suche issue to the heires of the body of the Ladie Elenour his Neece seconde daughter to the Frenche Queene lawfully begotten And if it happened the said Ladie Elenor to dye without issue of her body lawfully begotten to remaine and come to the nexte rightfull heires Wherevpon the Aduersaries do inferre that the successioÌ of the Croune ought to go to the childreÌ of the said Ladie FraÌcis and to their heyres according to the said supposed Wil of our late Souereigne Lorde King Henry the eight and not vnto the Ladie Marie Queene of Scotlande that nowe is To this it is on the befalf of the said Lady Marie Queene of Scotland among other things answered that King Henry the eight neuer signed the preteÌsed Wil with his own hand and that therfore the said Wil can not be any whit preiudicial to the said Queene Against which answere for the defence and vpholding of the saide Will it is replied by the Aduersaries first that there were diuers copies of his Wil found signed with his owne hande or at the leastwise enterlined and some for the most part writen with his owne hande out of the whiche it is likely that the original Wil commonly called King Henry the eightes Will was taken and fayer drawen out Then that there be great and vehement presumptions that for the fatherly loue that he bare to the coÌmon wealth and for the auoiding of the vncerteintie of the successioÌ he welliked vpoÌ and accepted the authoritie geuen him by Parlament and signed with his owne hande the said original Wil whiche had the said limitation and assignation of the Croune And these presumptions are the more enforced for that he had no cause why he should beare any affection either to the said Queene of Scotland or to the Lady Leneux and hauing withal no cause to be greaued or offended with his sisters the Frenche Queenes children but to put the matter quite out of al ambiguitie and doubte it appeareth they say that there were eleuen witnesses purposely called by the king who were presente at the signing of the said Wil and subscribed their names to the same Yea the chief Lordes of the CouÌsaile were made and appointed executours of the said Wil and they and other had great Legacies geuen them in the said Wil which were paid and other thinges comprised in the Wil accomplished accordingly There passed also purchases and Letters Patentes betwene King Edwarde and the executors of
the death of the Lorde Darley before the Counsaile of EnglaÌd The causes vvhy the Earle Murray vvent about asvvel to make avvay the L. Darley as to depose the Queene The Earle Murray de clared the day before that the L Darley should be slaine Diuers assembles of the Earle Murray aÌd his adherents to consult vpon the slaughter of the L. Darley Indentures made and subscribed for the execution of the said purpose Diuers excuted in Scotland for the said murther vvhereof none could charge the Queene The Q. in a maÌner miraculously deliuered out of Lochleuen prison The Commissioners appointed in EnglaÌd to heare the Quene of ScotlaÌd her maters vvel liked of her faid innocency and of her title to the succession of the Cioune An exhortation to the Earles Murray aÌd Murton aÌd others to reconcile theÌselues to the Q. The Q. of ScotlaÌd ful of mercy The ende of Rebels euer vnhappy Other Princes vvil not suffer the Quene of Scotland to be iniuried by her subiectes Man only hath the pierogatiue of vvit and reason among al earthlye creatures Men are most bouÌd to the preseruation of their CouÌtrey A great coÌmoditie to the coÌmoÌ vvealth to knovv the heire appa rente Why all the vvorld almost doth enbrace succession of Princes rather then election Flores histor anno 1057. Richardus Canonicus sanctae Trinit Lond. Flor. histo anno 1190. Polid li. 14 Polid li. 20 The Quene of Scottes is right heire apparent to the Croune of Englande Inst de iust iure §. fin The common lavve of this Realme is rather grounded vpon a general custom then any lavve vvritten In Prologo suo eiusdem li. fo 1. et 2. De dict Ra nulpho GlaÌuilla uide Giraldum Cambren in topogra de Wallia Fortescue de lau Leg. Angl. c. 17. â E. 4.19.33 H. 6.51 Pinsons printe Inst de iure natura geÌt ciuil §. ex non script 25. E. 3. The adueâ sacies case pettineth to subiects only No Maxime of the lavve bindeth the Croune vnles the Croune specially be named Of the Tenante by the curtesy Nor that the landes shal be diuided among the daughters Not the vvife shall haue the third part 5. E. 3. Tit. praerog 21. E. 3.9 28. H. 6. Nor the rule oâ Possessio fratris c. Nor that the executour shall haue the goods and Chattles of the resâatour 7. H. 4. sol 42. Nor that a traitour i vnable to take landes by discente and vvithout pardoÌ An ansvvere to the Aduersary making a difference be tvvene Attainder aÌd the birth out of the allegeaÌce 22. H. 6. fol. 43. The suppo sed Maxime of the Aduersaries touching not Kinges borne beyond the sea as appeareth by King Stephen and King H. 2. The Aduersaries obiection touching King H. 2. auoided As touching Arthur King Richardes nephevve Vt autem pax ista summa dilectio taÌ multiplici quaÌ arctiori uin culo connectatur praedictis curiae uestrae Magnatibus id ex parte uâ stra tractaÌtibus Domino disponente coÌdiximus inter Arthurum egregiuÌ Dâ cem BritaÌniae nepoteÌ nostrum haeredem si forte sine prole obirâ nos contigâ rit filiaÌ uestraÌ matrimonium contrahendum c. In tractatu paciâ inter Richa 1. TancreduÌ Regem Si ciliae Vide Reg. Houeden RicharduÌ Canonicum S. Trinitatis Londin A false Maxime set forth by the Aduersarie 7. E. 4. fo 28.9 E. 4. fo 5.11 H. 4 fo 25.14 H. 4. fo 10. the statute of Edvv. 3. An. 25. to â cheth inâe ritaÌce not purchase â H. 4. fo 25. Scotland is vvithin the allegeance of EnglaÌd The Lorde loseth not his seignorie though the tenaÌte doth not his seruice The causes vvhy the Croune caÌ not be coÌprised vvithin the pretended Maxime Without the croune there can neither be King nor allegeance 40. E. 3. fol. 10. 13. E. 3. Tit. Bref 264.16 E. 3. iurans desait 166.17 E. 3. tit scire fac 7. A Deane a Person a Priour being an Alien may demande lande in the right of his corporation An 3. R. 2.6 C. 3. fo 21. tit droit 26. lib. Ass p. 54.12 li. Ass tit enfant 13. H â fol. 14.7 E. 4. fol. 10.16 E. 3. iurans defait 9. H. 6. fol. 33.35 H. 6. so 35.5 E. 4 fol. 70.49 li. Ass A. 8â 22. H. 6. fo 31.13 H. â so 14. The King is alvvaies at ful age in respecte of his Croune The Kings children are expresly excepted from the surmised Maxime â LiberoruÌ ff de uerbo ruÌ signific L. Sed si de in ius uo caÌdo instit de haere ab intest L. Lucius ff de baered instit L. Iusta L. NâtoruÌ L. Liberorum de uerb signif L. 2. § sâ mater ad S. C. Tertul L. Filius de S. C. Maced L. Senatus de ritu nugâ L quod sâ nepotes ff test cuÌ notatis ibid. Infantes in Frenche couÌteruaileth this vvorde liberi in lat The grand fathers cal their nephues sonnes L. Gallââ § InstitueÌs ff de liber Eâ post l. ff C. de impub. Alâis substan c 1. q. 4 Father and son coÌpted in person aÌd flesh in maner one Great absurditie in excluding the true aÌd right successour for the place of his birth only An euasion auoided preteÌding the priuilege of the KiÌgs children not to be in respect of the Croune but of other laÌdes The royall blood beareth his honour vvith it vvhereso euer it be Vide Anto. Corsetum de potest et excell regi q. 106. CoÌquerors glad to ioinevvith the ioyall blood Henry the first L. â ff de legious Commonvse and pââctise the best interpretation of the lavv Eodâ anno Rex cuÌ in diebus suis processisset AeldredaÌ Vigornen sem Episco pum ad Regem Hunga riae trans mittens reuocauit inde filium fratris sui Edmundi Eduardum cuÌ tota fa milia sua ut uel ipse uel filij eius sibi succedereÌt in regnum Flor. histor 1057. Flor histo â066 Aelredus Regioual lens de reg Anglorum ad Regem Henr. 2. King Stephen and King H. â The aduer saries fond imagination that King H. 2. should come to the croune by composition not by proximitie of blood Rex Stepha nus omni haerede ui duatus prae ter solummo do Ducem Henricum recognouit in conuentu EpiscoporuÌ aliorum de regno Optimatum quod Dux HeÌr ius hae reditariuÌ in regnuÌ Angliae habebat Et Dux benigne concessit ut Rex Stepha nus tota uita sua suuÌ regnuÌ pacifice possideret Ita tamen confirmatum est pactuÌ quod ipse Rex ipsttuÌe praesentes cum caeteris regni optimatibus iurareÌt quod Dux Henr. post morteÌ Regu si illum superuiueret regnum sine aliqua contradictione obtincret Flor. histo An 1153. The like fond imagination touching King Richardes nephevv Diuersitie of opinioÌs touching the vncle aÌd nephue vvhether of them ought to be preferred in the royall gouernement
to beleue that it is now at length found and practised by such a Ladie and Princesse froÌ whose person her noble birth her honorable state and priÌcely educatioÌ and the whole trade of al her godly and vertuous life past do farre repel and driue away al such suspicion and coÌiectural presumptioÌs And whom al Christian Princes haue had in high estimation and worthy price for her great prudeÌcie and many other Princely qualities the which ful goodly do adorne and beautifie the grace and comlines of her Roial personage Doth any man or woman fal to extreme lewdnes al at ones No verily We doo both rise and fall by degrees aswel to all singuler vertues as to al extreme naughtines Let them shew me then if they can any euil doinges in al her former life wherevpon to make a sinister diuination to fasten vpoÌ her their treacherous accusations What vnsemely outragiouse and vnprincely parte hath she hitherto played Lette the noble Realme of France testifie of her demeanour and behauiour Let her owne subiects that be not her opeÌ enemies and her duble duble traitours accuse her hardly and spare her not But yet let them wel thinke withal at their better leisure and when they shal be better aduised whether there be any indifferent person who wil not both detest and vtterly abhorre the peruers and naughty nature of such vngrate traitours Or that wil not thinke it farre vnlike that this noble Queene who hath so gratiously pardoned them duble and treble treasons would euer finde in her harte so to vse her owne deare husbande This is vnlikely this is incredible and the more al circumstaÌces coÌsidered For if she had bene desirous to haue ben ridde of him as they falsly and maliciously imagin and report her to haue ben she had good and lawful meanes to serue her turne Albe it he was her head in wedlocke yet was he otherwise but a member of her commoÌ Weale subiect to her as to his principal and supreme Gouernesse and to her lawes By the due and ordinary processe and course whereof he might iustly haue bene conuicted condemned and executed aswel for the murther committed vpon Dauid her Secretarie in whose body his dagger was found stabbed as for the imprisoning of the Queene and for the attempting to remoue her from Ciuil gouernment to intrude him selfe thereto and for diuers other the like pageants by him plaid Who can nowe reasonably thinke that where she by lawe and iustice might haue fully satisfied this her falsely surmised will and desire that she would not take the opportunities in this sort offered but omitting them al seeke vnlawful meanes to his destruction This vehement presumption of her innoceÌcy is much holpen for that she would not consent to a diuorse betwene her and the Lord Darley as we shal hereafter declare though she were moued therto by a great numbre of her Nobilitie and by such as be now her greatest Aduersaries I adde thereto as a great and an vrgent presumption and token of her innocencie and pure conscience that she voluntarily came into England refusing the offers of diuers of her owne subiectes who besought her Grace to repaire into their quarters profering to preserue her Grace safe therein wher she knew right wel were both the father and mother of the said Lord Darley a Noble Princesse that would not see the blood of her nere Cosen vnreuenged and a worthy sort of men of Nobilitie also who would neither suffer suche a facte to passe and escape vnpunished nor so vertuouse and giltlesse a Queene to remaine without ayde helpe and succour being with Rebelles and Traitours shamefully oppressed and bereaued of her Royal dignitie The worthy saying also of the wise Cassiue is here to be remembred Cui bono Wherby he did signifie that in suche doubtful coniecturall cases a man may make a great ayme and coÌiecture against the personne appeached if by the facte dooing he should enioye any speciall profitte emolument or commoditie If the Queene had after his fatal and final ende purchased to her selfe the matching in mariage with any great and mighty Prince for her great aduancement or any other encrease of her honour or aduantage whatsoeuer there had ben some colour and shew whereby one might haue an apparent presumption Againe she was not ignorant but that his death either proceding from such naughtie meanes or otherwise naturally was likely to be a merueilous great let and impediment to her great affaires Among other things the testimonie and coÌfession of diuers guyltie as they be reported and executed in Scotland for the said offence which they opeÌly made at the time of their death doth tende much to the aduancing and approbation of her innocencie These men yet peraduenture wil replie and say that these are but slender presumptions And yet were it so that they were of force sufficient they must yeelde to an approued trueth It remaineth now then that we consider how sure and substantial their proufe is Concerning therefore the first parte we wil not altogether denie but that she was somewhat estranged from him and therfore they might haue spared a great sort of then needelesse and friuolous arguments and yet flat and plaine lies withal to prooue the same But fie vpon the crueltie of these accusers who were the very authours them selues and themselues the only workers and bringers to passe of al this discorde training this seely yong Gentleman by ther guilefull and wily circuÌuentions wretchedly to conspire with them against his owne deare wife and dradde Souereigne to the most cruell and detestable slaughter of her trustie Secretarie Dauid and to the imprisonnement of the royal person of the very Queene her selfe These and many other like pranks and practises as the reuocation of th' Earle Murray and of other traitours of your allie and affinitie without the Queenes knowledge by the Lorde Darleyes youthful rash and remerariouse deuice to departe the Realme with many other like practises purposes and attemptes for his princely person very vnmete and farre vnsemely ye craftily suppresse and speake no word of for feare of burning your owne clothes I say therefore fie and dubble fie vpon âe impudencie of these mischieuous traiâârs now to lay to the Quenes charge and reprochefully to obiect to her the changing âher minde toward her husbande which rose and began vpon causes for the which they had bene long earst trised vp if they had not fortuned vpon and met with so gratiouse a Mastresse as I knowe and they though vndeseruing it do wel feele that the whole worlde hath very few her like And yet al this your pretensed alienation of her accustomed fauour from him not withstanding her very motherly care for bysides al other respectes though they were not farre different in yeares she was to him not only a loyal Prince a louing and deare wife but a moste careful and tender mother withal was neuer a deale lessed or minished
like aduise Now at the last cometh the Lorde Lindzay sent in CommissioÌ from their CouÌsaile to present and offer vnto her the writinges who most greuously with feareful wordes and very cruel and sterne couÌtenance threâned her that vnlesse she would therto subscribe she should lose her life But cal you this voluntarie yelding ouâ and Resignation of the Croune A voluntary assignation of the regiment to you Earle Murray yea surely as free and voluntary aâ a man with his owne hands casteth into the sea his goods in a maine and raging tempest freely and voluntarily sauing that peradueÌture ye may replie and say that there is so much wil in him that he had rather bide the âduenture of his goodes and riches then of his life being contented to redeeme the âafegard of his life with the losse of his goodes And yet as voluntary as ye make it free and voluntary ye shal no more make it then ye shal be able to prooue that the peoples good wil was alienated from her as ye surmise For the procuring whereof ye haue by your craftie slaunderous leasinges and wretched practises done all the endeuour that your malitious and spitefull braines could inuent and serch out But surely your dooinges haue bene so gratious that if she had bene deadly hated before they might haue procured and gotten her a wonderful loue and fauour of the people againe And whereas she was euen as she wel deserued most entierly and tenderly beloued before now ye haue by these your so Tragical and TyraÌnical procedings purchased to her such an augmentation and encrease of the same specially wheÌ that the people amoÌg whom for a while some ye haue through your cou lorable craftie conueiances made to misdeme and haue somwhat the worse liking of her shal throughly and perfectly vnderstand and knowe your said wily policies as more and more daily they doe that she shalbâ much beholding to you but no God hauâ mercy to you therefore But now to procede and go forward with your louing loyal procedings towarde her ye neuer ceassed nor staied vntil ye had procured and obteined a coulorable ParlameÌt whereby ye gotte your vsurped and vnnatural kingdome ratified and confirmed and not onely al your wicked practises already past but euen what mischiefe soeuer yâ wold should afterward passe also against her quietnes and safetie And thus behold how these humble obedient and louing subiectes haue purchased and procured a Commissâo long before hande the like whereof as â suppose was neuer in the world heard of a fore in any whatsoeuer rude sauage and barbarous Nation or Countrey to slay kill and murther their owne Souereigne Queene and a most innocent Ladie at their owne willes and pleasure The which their saied Commission they had in this wise executed long ere this as it is credibly thought if God had not wonderfully eluded and miraculously frustrated this their mischeiuous malitious purpose and intent And yet is there one iniurie more that doth greeue and molest this good guiltlesse Ladie more then al these foretold villanous praÌks plaied of them against her And surely not without iust cause of griefe For in dede it farre passeth and excedeth them al. And that is their shameful and most traiterous diffaming her being altogether innocent therein with the death of her husbande as though that she had suborned the Earle Bothwel therto and rewarded him therfore with the mariage of her owne body Here perchance they will say Mary this is our chief quarel in dede this was the marke we principally shotte at The great loue and zeale we beare to Iustice and the earnest desire we haue to purge and rid the Realme of the slander and infamie that ariseth therto by this horrible facte moueth and stirreth vs vp to seke by al meanes we can the punishing of the said Earle who was the coÌmitter and chief perpetrator thereof If it so be surely there is vppon the sodaine commen vpon you a meruelous deuotion For why Were not ye and your band and AdhereÌts the chief and principaââ authours assisters fautours aiders and abetters for the clearing and iustifiyng of the said Bothwel accused and indited as gilty of the said murther what is it that maketh you now so hot that then were so cold By like the world and wether is anew changed and altered of late Yet tel vs we pray you in good earnest was your principal scope and zeale to apprehend th' Erle Bothwel Tel vs then a good cause why ye did dismisse him when you might haue had him at your pleasure Did not the forsaid Grange comming to the Queene from you speake to him also Did he not take him by the hand and wil him to depart assuring and telling him that no man should folow or pursue him Did not th' Erle remaine in the Countrey at hand many monethes after vntil the returning home of the Earle Murray And then for a face and couÌtenance ther were made out to the seas certaine ships to apprehend him it being of you pretended that he was now become an arrant Pirate and Rouer vpon the sea Nay nay it was not he you so long sought after It was an other bird and her ye had fast in the cage and therefore ye permitted the Earle to flee whether he would But yee you say in your Accusation put vp to the Commissioners of England that as he was the chief executor of the said Lord Darleys death so she was of the foreknowledge and counsel yea and the mainteiner therof also And therefore she both stopped the inquisition of the facte and punishment of him and also matched her selfe in mariage with him I aske then as before of you why through the special sute and procurement of your faction he was acquited and set on cleare bord Why did you with a great number of the Nobilitie moue further and worke the said mariage as most metee and necessary for your Quene Why did you as by your hand writing it wilappeare proffer and promisse to him your faithful seruice and to her your loyal obeisance Why did none of all your factioÌ nor any other els either openly or priuately declare and detect this matter to your Queene before the pretended mariage Was there no time occasion and opportunitie to geue her warning thereof but by the terrible and feareful blast and souÌd of the Martial trumpet For she good innocent Ladie hath vpoÌ her honour protested and plainly declared the which her protestatioÌ also the disorderly ambitious and Tragical doinges of these rebellious and traiterous subiects do much helpe and confirme that afore her taking and inprisonmeÌt she neuer knew who were either principal or accessarie or by any meanes culpable and blame worthy concerning the said murther Touching the third point it is not worthy the coÌfuting For these men knew right wel that the Queene had put her sonne safe and sure inough in the guarde and custodie of the Earle of Murray
nature in himself who delights to make all his iourneis in such sulleÌ solitary sort therfore belike an ill companion to liue withall in any felovvship Then yt shewes his extreeme want of abilitie to defray the expence of woeng in a bountiful shew sitting such a prince as coÌmeth to obtein out Queen This his secrete comming departing discouers a mistrustfulnes in him towards our people and therefore no loue which must needs come froÌ his own ill consci ence of fearing french measure in England for on our part the Lord be thanked we haue not committed such villenies all men deeme him vnworthy to speed who comes in a net as though he were loath to auow his errand Some men may think he is ashamed to shevv his face but I think verely that he meanes not sincerely who loues not light wil not com abroade The last noble princely gentlemaÌ that went out of EnglaÌd to vvin a Queen in france gaue trial shew of vvisdome manhod behauiour and personage by open coÌuersatioÌ performing al maner of knightly excercises which makes vs in England to find very strange this vnmanlike vnprincelike secrete fearful suspitious disdainful needy french kind of woeng in Monsieur we can not chuse but by the same stil as by all the other former demonstratife remonstraÌces conclude that thys french mariage is the streightest line that can be dravvne froÌ Rome to the vtter ruine of our church the very rightest perpendicular downfal that can be imagined froÌ the point france to our English state fetching in vvithin one circle of lamentable fall the royal estate of our noble Queen of hir person nobility and commons vvhose Christian honorable healthful ioyful peaceful and long souereigne raigne without all superior ouerruling commander especially french namely Monsieur the king of kings hold on to his glory and hyr assurance of true glory in that other kingdom of heauen Amen Amen Amen A TREATISE TOVCHING THE RIGHT TITLE AND INTEREST OF the mightie and noble Princesse Marie Queene of Scotland to the succession of the Croune of England Made by Morgan Philippes Bachelar of Diuinitie assisted vvith the aduise of Antonie Broune Knight one of the Iustices of the Common Place An. 1567. LEODII Apud Gualterum Morberium 1571. A TREATISE TOVCHING THE RIGHT TITLE AND INTEREST OF the mightie and noble Princesse Marie Queene of Scotland to the succession of the Croune of England The Second Booke THE great prouidence good Reader of the eternal God who of nothing created all thinges did not only create the same by his ineffable power but by the same power gaue a special gifte and grace also to euery liuing thing to continue to renewe and to preserue eche his owne kinde But in this consideration the condition of man among and aboue al earthly thinges hath his pearelesse prerogatiue of wit and reason wherewith he only is of God gratiously endewed and adorned by the which he doth prouide not only for his presente necessitie and sauegard as do also naturally after their sorte al beastes and al other liuing thinges voide of reason but also by the pregnancie of wit and reasonable discourse doth long afore forsee the dangerous perils that many yeres after may happen either to himself or to his Countrey and then by diligence and careful prouision doth inuent apte and mete remedies for the eschewing of suche mischieffes as might outragiously afterwarde occurre And the greater the feare is of greater mischief the greater the deper and the speedier care is wont to be taken to preuent and cut of the the same It is also most certaine by the confession of al the world that this care is principally dew by eche man that hath opportunitie to do good therin to his Prince his Countrey and to the common Weale and good quiet of the Countrey for the continuance and happie preseruation of the same To the preseruation whereof as there are many partes and branches belonging so one principal part is for Subiectes louingly and reuerently to honour dreade and obediently to serue their Souereigne that chaunceth presently to rule and gouerne The next to foreknow to whome they should beare their allegeance after the deceasse of their foresaid Prince and Gouernour Which being once certaine and assuredly knowen as it procureth when the time requireth readie and seruiceable obedience with the great comfort and vniuersal reast and quietnes of the Subiectes so where for the said Successour there is among them discord and diuersitie of iudgementes the matter groweth to faction and from faction to plaine hostilitie and from hostilitie to the daunger of many mens liues and many times to the vtter subuersion of the whole state For the better auoiding of suche and the like inconueniences albeit at the beginninge Princes reigned not by descente of blood and succession but by choyce and election of the worthieste the worlde was for the moste parte constrained to repudiate election and so often times for the better and the worthier to take a certain issue and ofspringe of some one onely persone though otherwise perchaunce not so mete Which defecte is so supplied partely by the great benefit of the vniuersal rest and quietnes that the people enioy thereby and partly by the graue and sage Counsaylours to Princes that the whole worlde in a manner these many thousand yeares hath embraced succession by blood rather then election And politike Princes whiche haue had no children of their owne to succede them haue had euer a special care and foresight thereof for auoiding of ciuil discention So that the people might alwaies knowe the true and certaine Heire apparent chiefly where there appeared any likelyhod of varietie of opinions or faction to ensewe about the true and lawful succession in gouernement This care and foresight doth manifestly appeare to haue bene not onely in many Princes of foraine Countreies but also of this Realme as wel before the tyme of the Conqueste as also after namely in Kinge Edwarde the Confessour in declaring and appointing Eadgare Atheling his nephewes sonne his heire as also in King Richard the first who before he interprised his Iourney to Hierusalem where for his chiualrie he atchiued high honour declared by consent of his Nobilitie and CoÌmous Arthur sonne of his brother Duke of Britaine his next heire in succession of the Crowne Of the whiche Arthur as also of the said Eadgare Atheling we wil speake more hereafter This care also had King Richard the second what time by authoritie of Parlament he declared the Lorde Edmond Mortymer that maried Philippe dawghter and heire to his Vncle Leonel Duke of Clarence heire apparente And to descende to later times our late Noble Souereigne King Henry the eyght shewed as it is knowen his prudente and zealous care in this behalf before his last noble voiage into Fraunce And now if God should as we be al as wel Princes as others subiect to mortall chaunces once
and remaining beyond the sea in the custody of the said Constance yet of this fact being against al Iustice aswel the said Archbishop as also many of th' other did after most earnestly repent considering the cruel and the vniust putting to death of the said Arthur procured and after some Authours committed by the said Iohn himself Which most foul aÌd shamful act the said Iohn neded not to haue committed if by foraine birth the said Arthur had beÌ barred to inherit the Croune of England And much lesse to haue imprisoned that most innocent Ladie Elenor sister to the said Arthur in Bristow Castle wher she miserably ended her life if that gay Maxime would haue serued to haue excluded these two childreÌ bicause thei wer straÌgers borne in the partes beyond the seas Yea it appeareth in other doings also of the said time and by the storie of the said Iohn that the birth out of the legeaÌce of England by father aÌd mother foram was not takeÌ for a sufficieÌt repulse and reiectioÌ to the right and title of the Croune For the BaroÌs of EnglaÌd being then at dissension with the said King Iohn and renouÌcing their allegeance to him receaued Lewis the eldest sonne of Philip the FreÌch king to be their King in the right of Blanch his wife whiche was a stranger borne albe it the lawful Neece of the said Richard and daughter to Alphonse king of Caâtil begotten on the bodie of Elenour his wife one of the daughters of king Henrie the second and sister to the said king Richard and king Iohn Which storie I alleage only to this purpose thereby to gather the opinion of the time that foraine birth was then thought no barre in the Title of the Croune For otherwise how could Lewis of FraÌce preteÌd title to the Croune in the right of the said Bblach his wife borne in Spaine These examples are sufficient I suppose to satisfie and content any man that is not obstinatly wedded to his own fond fantasies and froward friuolous imaginatioÌs or otherwise worse depraued for a good sure and substantial interpretation of the coÌmon law And it were not altogether from the purpose here to consider and weigh with what and how greuous plagues this Realme hath bene oft afflicted and scourged by reason of wrongful and vsurped titles I wil not reuiue by odious rehearsal the greatenes and number of the same plagues as wel otherwise as especially by the contention of the noble houses and families of York and Lancaster seeing it is so fortunately and almost within mans remeÌbrance extinct and buried I wil now put the gentle Reader in remembrance of those only with whose vsurping Titles we are nowe presently in hand And to begyn with the most auncieÌt what became I pray you of Harold that by briberie and helpe of his kinred vsurped the Croune against the foresaid yong Eadgar who as I haue said and as the old monumeÌts of our Historiographers do plainly testifie was the true and lawful Heire Could he thinke you enioy his ambitious and naughty vsurping one whole entier yere No surely ere the first yeare of his vsurped reigne turned about he was spoiled and turned out both of Croune and his life withal Yea his vsurpation occasioned the conquest of the whole realme by WilliaÌ Duke of NormaÌdie bastard sonne to Robert the sixt Duke of the same And may we thinke al safe and sound now from like danger if we should tread the said wrong steppes with Harolde forsaking the right and high way of law and iustice What shal I now speake of the cruel ciuil warres betwene King Stephen and King Henry the second whiche warres rose by reason of the said Henry was vniustly kept froÌ the Croune dew to his mother Maude and to him afterwardes The pitiful reigne of the said Iohn who doth not lament with the lamentable losse of Normandie Aquitaine and the possibilitie of the Dukedome of Britanie and with the losse of our other goodly possessions in France whereof the Croune of England was robbed and spoiled by the vnlawful vsurping of him against his nephew Arthur Wel let vs leaue these greuouse and lothsome remembrances and let vs yet seeke if we may finde any later interpretation either of the said statute or rather of the coÌmon law for our purpose And lo the great goodnes and prouidence of God who hath if the foresaid exaÌples would not serue prouided a later but so good so sure so apt and mete interpretatioÌ for our cause as any reasonable hart may desire The interpretatioÌ directly toucheth our case which I meane by the mariage of the Lady Margaret eldest daughter to King HeÌry the vij vnto Iames the fourth KiÌg of ScotlaÌd and by the opinioÌ of the said most prudeÌt Prince in bestowing his said daughter into ScotlaÌd a ma ter sufficient inough to ouerthrow al those cauilling inueÌtioÌs of the aduersarie For what time King Iames the fourth sent his ambassadour to king HeÌry the seueÌth to obteine his good wil to espouse the said Lady Margaret there were of his Counsaile not ignorant of the lawes and Customes of the Realme that did not wel like vpon the said Mariage saying it might so fal out that the right and Title of the Croune might be deuolued to the Lady Margaret and her childreÌ and the Realm therby might be subiect to ScotlaÌd To the whiche the prudent and wise King answered that in case any such deuolution should happen it would be nothing preiudicial to England For England as the chief and principal and worthiest part of the I le should drawe Scotland to it as it did Normandie from the time of the Conqueste Which answere was wonderfully wel liked of al the Counsaile And so consequâtly the mariage toke effect as appereth by Polydor the Historiographer of this Realm and such a one as wrote the Actes of the time by the instruction of the King him selfe I say then the worthy wise Salomon foreseeing that such deuolution might happen was an interpretour with his prudente and sage Counsaile for our cause For els they neaded not to reason of any such subiection to Scotlande if the children of the Ladie Margaret might not lawfully inherite the Croune of England For as to her husband we could not be subiect hauing him selfe no right by this mariage to the Title of the Croune of this Realme Wherevpon I may wel inferre that the said newe Maxime of these men whereby they would rule and ouer rule the succession of Princes was not knowen to the said wise King neither to any of his Counsaile Or if it were yet was it taken not to reache to his blood royall borne in Scotlande And so on euery side the Title of Quene Marie is assured So that now by this that we haue said it may easely be seen by what light and slender consideration the Aduersarie hath gone about to strayne the wordes Infantes or children to the first degree
then shal we with our children after vs reape the pleasant fruites of this noble coÌiunctioÌ wrought thus to our haÌdes by Gods good and gratious prouidence without expense force or slaughter which hitherto a numbre of our courageous wise and mightie Princes haue this thousand yeares and vpward sought for but in vaine as yet with so excessiue charges with so great paines and with so many and maine Armies and with the blood of so many of their subiectes Then shal we most fortunately see and most gloriously inioye a perfect and entier Monarchy of this I le of Britanie or Albion vnited and incorporated after a most merueilous sort and in the worthie and excelleÌt person of a Prince mete and capable of such a monarchie As in whose person by side her worthy noble and princely qualities not only the roial and vnspotted blood of the auncient and noble Kings of ScotlaÌd but of the Normans and of th' English Kings withal as wel long before as sitheÌce the CoÌquest yea and of the Britaine 's also the most auncient inhabitants and Lords of this Iland do woÌderfully and as it were euen for such a notable purpose by the great prouidence of God most happily concurre The euident trueth whereof the said Queenes petigrue doth most plainly and openly set foorth to euery mans sight and eye Then I say may this noble Realme and Iland be called not Albion only but rather Olbion that is fortunate happy and blessed Which happy and blessed coniunction when it chauÌceth if we vnthankfully refuse we refuse our health and welfare and Gods good blessing vpon vs we refuse our dewty to God who sendeth our dewty to the partie whom he sendeth and our dewty to our natiue CouÌtrey to whom he sendeth such a person to be our Maistresse And such commodities and honour withal comming therby as I haue said to whole AlbioÌ as a greater we cannot wishe And finally we shal procure and purchase as much as in vs lieth such disturbance of the common-wealth such vexatioÌs troubles and warres as may tende to the vtter subuersion of this Realme from which dangers God of his great and vnspeakable mercie defend and pre serue vs. FINIS Hos tres libros à viris Catholicis ijsque eruditissimis lectos examinatos intellecto ab ijsdem librorum argumento vnà cum editionis necessarijs causis iudicaui meritò edendos esse Actum Louanij 6. Martij 1571. Thomas Gozaeus à Bellomonte sacrae Theologiae Professor authoritate Pontificis librorum approbator Errata Libri secundi Fol. Pa. Lin. Errata Correction 4 2 16 Ad And 10 1 18 vvorlde vvorde 11 2 14 good goodes 28 2 17 Bblach Blanch. 32 1 3 in Chauncerie In the Chauncerie 53 2 16 landes and testamentes laÌdes and tenemeÌtes 58 2 24 laufully neece laufull neece 64 2 5 unto heires unto the heires 66 2 27 be produced be procured 67 1 17 put out vvrongfully Errata Libri tertij 9 1 2 Salomon Salmon 9 1 5 fasly safely 15 2 22 father Constantinus father Constantius MeÌ should be rather prone to absolue then to coÌdemne It is nothing like that the Queene vvould haue sought the destruction of the Lord Darley by these meanes vvhen she might haue opeÌly put him to death by Iustice The Q. contrary to minde of her Nobles came into England The Q. enemies lay to her discord vvith the Lorde Darley vvhereof they vvere the authours The Q. vvas fully reconciled to the L. Darley before his death The adueriaties charge the Q vvith their ovvne vvicked deuises The Q. moued by them to make a diuorse vvith the L. Darley The accusation touching letters lent by her to the Earle Bothevvel The vnlikely tale of the Earle Both vvelles letters surmised to be sent to Master Balfoure In case the suâmised letters vvere sent by the Q they can make no good prouf against her L. sin e dâ Probat What exquisite proufes be re quired in criminal causes The surmi sed letters neither haue superscriptioÌ of the vvriter nor subscription neitherany date neither signed nor sealed and the beater neuer knovveÌ He that vvas the surmised bearer at his death denied the same An easy thing to couÌterfeit a mans hande These letters vvere fained and contriued by the Queenes Aduersaries An ansvver to the Aduersaries obiectioÌs that the Queene did not mourne the death of the L. Darley L. Liberor ff de his qui notantur inf The consideration mouing ⪠or rather forcing the Quene to this pretensed mâ riage The Aduersaries declaratioÌ before the Commissioners of England The causes that the Rebelles pretended at the beginning Ansvvere to the first The Lord Grange promised vpoÌ his knees obedience in al the Rebelles names The Q. imprisoned at LochleueÌ The Q. thretned to be âid avvay if she vvould not renouÌce her Croune The ansvvere to the secoÌd The Quenes ene mies dimissed the Earle Both vvel vvheÌ thei might haue takeÌ him The Quenes enemies bouÌd by their haud vvriting to obey the Eâle Bothvvel if he matied the Q. An ansvvere to the third The PriÌce if he vvere at age vvold not like the enâmies doinges against his mother He vvas vnlavvfully crouned Why the confirmation of the Rebelles doinges made by an acte of Parlament is nothing vvorth The incoÌstancy of the Queenes enemies first preteÌding before the Counsaile of EnglaÌd her voluntary dimission of the Croune and after vvard that she vvas deposed A strange doctrine of Maister knoxe against vvo mans Gouernment The Quenes enemies fondly triumph of their victory against her true subiectes In case the Queene vvere culpable yet are her enemies procedigs vnlavvful It is not inough to do a good thing vnlesse it be vvel done The lavv geueth exceptions to the Defendant against the Iudges the Accusers and vvitnesses C. Qui accusat non po L. Iniquum l. fin L. qui accusat ff de accusa A good argument that the Queene by coÌpulsion dimissed the Croune The Duke Robert of Scotland ExceptioÌs most iust against the Queenes accusers ãâ¦ã ly against the Earle of Murray The great benefits emploied by the Q. vpon the said Earle He vvent about to entaile the Croune of the Realm to him self and the Stevvardes His tebellââ against the Qâene His coÌspiracy vvith them that slevve the Secretatie Dauid A charged pistilet set to the Queenes belly The Q. by her industrie coÌueied her selfe avvay vvith the L. Darley The cause vvhy the Earle Murray hated the Lorde Darley The cause vvhy the Enemies did impute the slaughter to the Q. The vvorking of Murray in the time of his absence Murray and MortoÌ the heades of the coÌspiracy against the L. Darley 2. Machab. 3. 4. Hect Boet. Lib. 11. The Earle of Murray resembled to Dunvvaldus that procured the slaughter of King Duffus in Scotland Idem li. 16. The like paâte plaid by Duke Robert in Scotland The Earle Murray aÌd his felovves being driuen froÌ al other shiftes at leÌgth laied to their Quene
and the whole state froÌ danger to liue willingly in perpetual exile and bannishment God be thanked that after these seditious and trayterous subiectes haue bene so stout and storming in the rekoning vp and accumulating of faults and offenses of their innoceÌt Maistresse and Quene they are yet at the leÌgth forced to answere for theÌselues and for their excessiue outragious rebellious dooings Their glorious and glittering excuses may perhaps at the first shew seme to some of the Readers to haue a ioly face of much probabilitie great trueth and feruent zeale to the weale publike But may it please them aduisedly and depely to ponder and weigh aswel what we haue said as what we farther shal say in supplement of ful answere and then to iudge and deme of the mater none otherwise then reason equitie and law do craue they shalat length fynde out and throughly perceaue and know these mennes dealinges and doinges who as yet couer their foule filthy lying detestable practises and trayterouse enormities with suche a visarde of counterfeit fained holines and suche exceding greate shew of zeale to the Queenes honour in punishing malefactors and to the preseruation of the state of the Realme as though al the worlde would fal and go to ruine if it were not vpholden and vnderpropped by the strength of their shoulders They shal see how they wil appeare in their owne natural likenes so ougly that al good harts wil vtterly detest them and thinke them moste worthie for example sake to al the worlde hereafter of extreme punishment We affirme then first that as they haue produced nothing in the worlde touching the principal points as of the Lorde Darleyes death the acquital of the Earle Bothwel and the Queenes mariage with him iustly to charge her withal so are they them selues aswel for the said acquital and mariage as for their damnable and rebellious attempts against their Souereigne and for many other enormous crimes so farre and so depely charged so foule stained and so shamefully marked and noted that neuer shal they with al their hypocritical fine fetches be able to rubbe out the dirty blottes thereof from their skirts which thing wilbâ easely perceaued of them that wil vouchesafe aduisedly to consider the friuolous and contradictorie excuses they make in their defence At the beginning their open surmised quarel whereby they went about to drawe the peoples hartes to them selues and to streÌgthen their owne faction stood in three points as appeareth by their excuses and by their pretensed Proclamations The first was to deliuer the Quene from the Earle Bothwel who violently deteined her and to preuent daungers imminent to her person The second to reuenge the Kings death vpon the said Bothwel whom they knew as they pretended to haue ben the principal doer in the execution of the said murther The thirde was to preserue the yonge Prince the Queenes sonne This is their ioly and holy pretense Nowe let vs see how conformable their worthy procedinges are to these their colourable cloked holy collusions The first gentle and humble admonition that these good louing subiectes gaue her to refourme these surmised enormities was in âattail array at Bortwike Castle which they thought vpon the sodaine to haue possessed with the Queenes person Wherevpon they being disapointed therof gat into the Town and Fortresse of Edenboroug by the treason of Balfoure the Captaine thereof and of Cragmiler the Prouost of the Citie whereby they being the more animated to follow and prosecute their wicked enterprise begaÌ now to be strong in the field The Queene hauing also a good stroÌg army and thinking her self wel able therby to encounter with th' enemie and to represse their furious outrage yet notwithstaÌding for the great loue and pitie she had to them though rebellious subiects willing as muche as in her lay to kepe and preserue their blood from sheding offred them faire of her owne free motion that if they would vse her as their Queene she would peaceably come to them and take due and conuenient order for the redresse of al suche thinges as might appeare by law and reason mete to be refourmed Wherevpon the Lorde Grange was sent by the Lordes to her who in al their names moste humbly vppon his knees assured her of al dewe obedience of securitie anâ safetie of both her life and honour And ãâã the good Ladie her conscience bearing heâ witnes of al her iust and vpright dealingeâ and therfore nothing mistrusting dismissing her army yelded her self to the Lordes whâ conueyed her to Edenborough and there set her at suche a meruelous libertie and ãâã suche securitie and safetie that al good meâ to the worlds ende wil wonder at their exceding good loyaltie First they keping her owne Palaice seâ and placed her in a merchants house and vsed her otherwise very homely She now considering and perceauing to what ende these matters tended most pitifully cried and called vpon them to remember their late promisse or at the least that she might be brought before the Counsaile offering to stande to the order and direction of the States of the realme But God knoweth al in vaine For now had they the pray whereon they inteÌded to whet their bluddy teeth ere they did dismisse or forgoe her as the euent doth declare Wherefore in the night priuily she was conueyed and with haste in disguised apparel to the strong Forte of Lochleuen and after a few daies being stripâed out and spoyled of al her princely atârement was clothed with a course broune âassoke After this these good loial subiects praâising and encreasing more and more daily âhe performance of their saied promised âbedience neuer ceassed vntil they had vsurped the ful authoritie and Regiment of the whole Into the which though they had intruded themselues yet seing as blinde as they were by disordinate vnseemely and vnmeasurable ambition that the Queene remained and was stil Queene and that there was no iust cause by the ordinarie course of the lawe or for any her demerits and deserts to bring her forth to her trial that she might be conuicted and deposed went like good honest plaine men and wel meaning subiects bluntly to worke and coÌsulted and determined to dispatche and rid her out of her life vnlesse she would yelde to them and subscribe suche writinges as they would send to her concerning the dimission of her Croune to her sonne and the Regiment of the Realme to the Earle of Murray Wherevpon th' Earle of Athele Secretârie Ledington with other principals of theiâ factious band sent Robert Miluen to Lochâleuen to wil her in any ease if she sought the safegard of her life to coÌdescend to such demaundes and set her hand to al such writinges as should be proposed and broughâ to her Whiche as they said to doe neuâ could be preiudicial to her being by forââ and violence extorted Sir Nicolas Throgmorton also being then Ambassadour theââ from England gaue her the