with our whole Power non do we nor will we permit our Lord the King though he were willing to attempt things so unusual undue and prejudicial to the Royal Dignity and this was Sealed by 104 Earls and Barons in the name of all the Commonalty of England What they affirm touching their Oaths to defend their Laws is an unquestionable truth for besides what hath been noted of this kind allready in the twenty fifth year of this King it was established by Act of Parliament 25. Ed. 1. c. 3. 42. Ed. 3. c. 1. that if any Statute were made contrary to Magna Charta or Charta de Forestis it should be holden for none and the Nobles and the great Officers were sworn to the Observation of them Yea Speed p. 583. by the Royal Command of Henry the Third Oaths were taken to tye all men to the strict Observation of them SECT IV. That we find throughout the History of our Kings that their Election or else their Compact with the People hath generally been conceived a thing proper to strengthen their Title to the Crown or at the least to satisfie their People 4ly IT may be farther worthy of our consideration that we find throughout the History of our Kings that their Election or else their Compact with the people hath generally been looked on as a thing proper to strengthen their Title to the Crown or at the least to satisfie the People For instance First Dunelm p. 195. Hoved. E. 258. Ab omnibus tam Normannorum quam Anglorum Proceribus Rex est electus Gemit de Ducibus Norm l. 6. c. 37. Walsing Hypod. Neust p. 436. Of the Conqueror S. Dunelmensis and Hoveden inform us that Foedus pepigit he made a Covenant with the people Gulielmus Gemiticensis and Walsingham say that he was chosen King by all the Nobles of England and Normandy Secondly Daniel p. 52. Polyd. Virg. Hist l. 10. p. 164. William the Second held the possession of the Crown of England by the Will of the Kingdom the Succession in Right of Primogeniture being none of his Volentibus omnium provincialium animis in Regem acceptus M. Par. p. 10. Chron. Joh. Brompt p. 983 984. The Historians say that the Nobles met in Council at Westminster and after long Consultation made him King that by the willing minds of all he was accepted for their King and the King himself declares quod ipsum in Regem creaverant that they had created him King Thirdly Henry the First was invested in the Crown by the Act of the Kingdom The Historians tell us that a Council of the whole Community rejected Robert Unanimi ascensu suo ipsum refutavêrunt pro Rege omninò recusavêrunt Henricum fratrem in Regem ere êrunt Knyght de Event Angl. p. 2374. In Regem electus est frater ejus Henricus consecratus est Rex Angl. M. Westm Hist. p. 235. In Regem electus est aliquantis tamen controversiis inter Procéres excitatis Sopitis W. Malmsb. l. 5. F. 88. J. Brompt Chron. p. 997. Walsing Hypod. Neust p. 446. Rich. Hagulst p. 310. the eldest Son of the Conqueror and would not have him for their King but with unanimous consent they advanced his Brother Henry to the Kingdom who was by all Elected and Consecrated King at Westminster after the death of William Rufus as being the first born of the Conqueror after he was King of England William of Malmsbury saith he was Consecrated within four days after his Brother's death lest the Rumour of Robert's coming to England should move the Nobles to repent of their Election Sciatis me Dei misericordia communi consilio Baronum Regni Angliae ejusdem Regni Regem esse coronatum M. Paris pag. 38. And in his Charters the King himself writes thus Know you that I was Crowned King of England by the Common Council of the Barons of the Kingdom And 't is observable that his Elder Brother Robert being absent at the Holy Wars they chose Henry King because they were affraid to be long without Government Fourthly Florence of Worcester William of Malmsbury R. Hoveden and R. Hagulstadensis do expressly say that Stephen was chosen King by the Primates of the Kingdom A Primoribus Regni cum favore Cleri Populi electus R. Hagulst p. 312. Flor. Wigorn. p. 665. Hoved. F. 215. Malm sb F. 101. B. with the favour of the Clergy and Laity and that he took upon him the Kingdom with their General consent A scensu Populi Cleri in Regem electus Malmsb Hist Nov. l. 1. F. 101. B. R. Hagulst p. 314. and his own Charters say the same thing as they had reason to do he having no Title at all but as one of the Bloud by mere Election advanced to the Crown Daniel p. 69. Fifthly Radulphus de Diceto Ab omnibus electus p. 529. Saith of Henry the Second That he was Elected by all and annointed by Theobald Arch-Bishop of Canterbury Sixthly And of Richard the First he saith Post tum Cleri Populi Solennem debitam Electionem p. 647. That being to be promoted to be King by right of Succession after the solemn and due Election both of the Clergy and Laity he took a Threefold Oath Hoveden adds that he was Consecrated and Crowned King of England F. 374. consilio assensu by the Council and assent of the Arch-Bishops Bishops Counts and Barons Seventhly P. 127. Archiepiscopus dixit quod nullus praevia ratione alij succedere habet Regnum nisi ab universitate Regni unanimiter Spiritus Sancti invocata gratia electus secundùm morum eminentiam praeelectus omnes hoc acceptabant ipsumque Comitem in Regem eligentes assumentes exclamant dicentes Vivat Rex Matth. Paris p. 138. King John received the Crown by way of Election as being chosen by the States saith Daniel Matthew Paris saith That all consented to the Speech of the Arch-Bishop that none ought to Succeed another in the Kingdom unless he were elected by the Community and thereupon they elected the Count and took him for their King Eightly In Regem eligitur p. 474. The History of Croyland saith That after the death of King John Henry his first born was elected King Ninthly Non tam jure haereditario quam unanimi assensu Procerum Magnatum Edward Franc. An. 1602. p. 95. The Succession of Edward the Second saith Walsingam Was not so much by right of Inheritance as by the unanimous consent of the Peers and great Men. Tenthly Edward the Third was elected with the Vniversal consent of the People upon his Father's Resignation Walsing Hist Angl. p. 126. Hypod. Neust p. 508.509 H. de Knyghton p. 2550. The Parliament then met at London declared by common consent That Edward the Second was unworthy of the Crown and for many Causes to be deposed and that his first born Son Edward
should unanimously be chosen King then the Election is publickly declared in Westminster-hall some of both Houses are sent to Edward the Second qui nunciarent Electionem filij sui who should acquaint him with the Election of his Son and require him to resign the Crown Electioni consensit populus universus all the people consented to the Election so did all the Prelates and the Arch-Bishop who made an Oration on those words Vox populi vox Dei and exhorted all to pray for the King Elect. Eleventhly Richard the Second succeeded Edward by right of Succession H. de Knyght p. 2630. ac etiam voto communi singulorum and by the Common suffrage of all Twelfthly Henry the Fourth Fifth and Sixth were only Kings by Act of Parliament Thirteenthly Edward the Fourth at his entrance on the Government makes a solemn Declaration of his Right to the Crown of England challenging it to belong unto him by a double Right the first as Son and Heir to Richard Duke of York Trussel 179. the Rightfull Heir of the same the second as elected by the Authority of the Parliament upon King Henry's forfeit of it Fourteenthly The Parliament Roll published in Speed's Chronicle often saith p. 913 914. That they had chosen Richard the Third for their King and that the Crown belonged to him as well by Election as Succession Fifthteenthly And Henry the Seventh Bacon Hist of Hen. VII p. 12. to all his other Titles by Marriage Conquest and from the House of Lancaster adds that of the Authority of Parliament SECT V. That we find mention in History of divers Acts of Parliament or of the Nobles of the Kingdom continuing the Name and Honour of a King to him who by their own confession had not the immediate Title to the Kingdom and only Proclaiming him who had the Right by Proximity of Bloud Heir Apparent to the Crown 5ly MOreover we read of divers Acts of Parliament or of the Nobles of the Kingdom continuing the Name and Honour of a King to him who by their own Confession had not the just Title and only Proclaiming him who had the Right by proximity of Bloud Heir apparent to the Crown For instance The Contest betwixt Robert the Eldest Son of the Conquerour Ad haec etiam inter se constituerunt ut si comes absque filio legali in Matrimonio genito moreretur haeres ejus esset Rex modoque per omnia simili si Regi contigisset mori haeres illius fieret Comes hanc conventionem 12 ex parte Regis 12 ex parte Comitis Barones Juramento firmaverunt Flor Wigorn. p. 644. and William Rufus his younger Brother ended thus That f Robert dyed without a Lawfull Son King William should be his Heir and if King William dyed without issue Robert should be his Heir and this was Sworn to by twelve Barons of each side In the contest betwixt the same Robert and his younger Brother Henry Principes M. Paris p. 40. Hen. Hunting F. 216. B. Joh. Bromp p. 998. the Princes say some of our Historians the wise men of our Kingdom say others Sapientiores utriusque partis Dunelm p. 226. Flor. Wigorn. p. 650. R. Hoveden F. 268. B. Daniel p. 61. made a Mutual and general League of Concord by their Pious and Wise Council That Henry the First Amiciutriusque foedus inter eos statuerunt sic quod Rex propter manifestum jus quod habuit ad Regnum possidendum Roberto singulis Annis tria millia Marcarum Argenti daret ab Anglia quis eorum diutius viveret Haeres esset alterius si absque filio moreretur M. Westm p. 236. Henr. Huntingd. Hist l. 7. F. 216. B. M. Par. p. 40. being invested with the Crown by Act of the Kingdom should enjoy the same during life and that by reason of the manifest Right which Robert had to the Kingdom Henry should pay him 3000 Marks yearly and that the longest liver should be Heir to the other if he died without a Son by which Acts if William Rufus or Henry had Sons they were to Reign though the manifest Right was in Robert and his Heirs And here it is observable Maxima pars Nobiliorum Normannorum favebat Roberto cupiens hunc sibi asciscere in Regem fratremque aut fratri tradere vivum aut Regno privare peremptum hujus execrandae rei principes extitêre Odo c. hoc execrabile factum clam tractaverunt in quadragesima Florent p. 642. Dunelm A. D. 1088. Hoved. par 1. F. 264 Radulph de Diceto p. 489. Proditores vocat H. Huntingd. Hist l. 7. F. 213. Perfides W. Malmsb. Hist l. 4. F. 68. Conjurationis perfidiae Socios Florent p. 643. Perjurij Reos Matth. Paris p. 10. that though the greatest part of the Nobles did upon some dislike to Rufus to whom they had sworn Allegiance favour his Brother Robert desiring to advance him to the Kingdom and to destroy William or deliver him alive to his Brother yet do all our Historians declare that they who sided with William were faithfull to their Earthly Lord and the other party were Traiterous Perfidious and Perjured Persons and that the thing it self was an excrable fact And in like manner they who stood for Henry against the same Robert L. 5. de Henr. primo F. 88. who had manifest right are said by W. of Malmsbury justas partes fovere to be of the right side and they who fought against him to be fidei Regi juratoe transfugoe violaters of their Oath and yet this Henry was advanced to the Throne not because he had Right during the life of his Elder Brother but because Robert being gone to the Wars at Jerusalem Quia ignorabant quid actum esset de Roberto fratre primogenito timuerunt diu sine Regimine vacillare Matth. Paris p. 38. they knew not what was become of him and were affraid to be long without Government But to proceed to other instances of this Nature from History In the contest between King Stephen and Henry Duke of Normandy the Son of the Empress Maud and the Right Heir of the Crown Theobald Arch-bishop of Canterbury and Henry Bishop of Winton Rich. Hagulst p. 330. H. Huntind l. 8. F. 228. Joh. Brompt Chron. p. 1037. Gervas Chron. p. 1375. Chron. de Mailros p. 167. made peace betwixt them upon these conditions That King Stephen from that time should entirely enjoy the Kingdom as lawfull Prince with the Glory and Honour of it and Henry should succeed him in the Kingdom as lawfull Heir This peace was thus made by the Counsel of the Wise Men and the intervention of the Nobles and Friends of both parties and was declar'd to be honest and profitable R. Stephanus Ducem Hen. cognovit in conventu Episcoporum aliorum Regni Optimatum quod jus Hereditarium in Regnum Angliae habebat Dux benignè concessit ut R. Stephanus tota vita
of that Establishment by our succeeding Kings Hist Nov. F. 186. A. 25 H. 8. c. 21. such as Malmsbury stiles our Patriae Leges and the Statute of Henry the Eighth the accustomed and ancient Laws of this Realm originally established Add to this then that Rule of Grotius Successio non est titulus Imperii qui Imperio formam assignat sed veteris continuatio jus enim ab electione coeptum familiae succedendo continuatur quare quantum prima electio tribuit tantum defert successio De jure Bell Pac. l. 1. c. 3. Sect. 10. That Succession is not a Title of Empire which gives the form to it but is only a continuation of the old Title The Right begun by the Election of the Family being continued by Succession And thence with him we may reasonably infer that Succession only brings down to Kings what the first Election gave and makes them only Kings according to the Compact and with the Conditions agreed on at the first admission of their Progenitors to the exercise of the Royal Authority SECT II. That they thought it absolutely necessary that whosoever would be their King should make this Compact with them and be as much obliged by Oath to grant these Priviledges to them as they were to swear Allegiance to him 2dly OUR Kings well knowing what a Reverence the Community had for their Laws found no better means to gain or to secure to themselves the Crown and to pacifie the discontented Parties than by fair Promises and Engagements to maintain or grant to them their Laws Cum Regni fastigia fratri suo Roberto praeriperet coepit tam per se quam per omnes quos poterat fide sacramentoque Lanfranco promittere justitiam aequitatem misericordiam se per totum Regnum si Rex foret observaturum pacem libertatem securitatem Ecclesiarum contra omnes defensurum p. 13. Eadmerus informs us concerning W. Rufus that desiring to forestall his elder Brother Robert in getting the Kingdom he pawned his Faith and Oath that if they would make him King he would in all things observe Justice Equity and Mercy throughout his Kingdom and defend the Peace Liberty and Security of the Church against all Men. When his Brother Robert was come into England to claim his right and he had many of the Nobility who favoured him and sided with him W. Rufus calls the Normans and English Nobility to London leges statuens Pag. 642. and there stablishing the Laws he marched with them against his Brother saith Florence of Worcester He bound them to him saith M. Paris faciles leges promittendo Pag. 10. by promising them easie Laws as those of King Edward were by them stiled and accounted He sweetned them saith John Brompton Pag. 984. by promising that he would establish meliores leges quas sibi vellent eligere those more acceptable Laws which they would chuse Now those we know by their request in his Fathers days were the Laws of Edward and they with the emendations of his Father were the Laws then established These Promises he very little regarded after his agreement made with his Brother Robert but falling sick at the suggestion of his Barons he again promised to God saith Radulphus de Diceto Pag. 490 491. Rectas leges statuere to stablish right Laws Henry the first his Successor in the beginning of his Reign saith * Ipfe in principio Regni sui leges justas libertates populo dedit chartâ consirmavit sigillo corroboravit p. 310. R. Hagulstadensis gave to the People their just Laws and Liberties confirming them with his Charter and his Seal Dunelmensis R. Hoveden Florence of Worcester W. of Malmesbury M. Paris and Henry of Knyghton say that on the very day of his †Qui consecrationis suae die legem Regis Edvardi omnibus in commune reddidit cum illis emendationibus quibus pater suus illam emendavit Dunelm p. 225 226. Hoveden p 1. F. 268. B. Flor. Wigorn. p. 650. W. Malmsbur F. 88. M. Paris p. 38. H. de Knyghton p. 2374. Consecration he granted to all his People the Laws of Edward with the emendations which his Father had made of them * Pag. 216. B. Chron. p. 997. Henry of Huntington and John Brompton say that having promised a desirable melioration of the Laws and Customs he was consecrated by Maurice Bishop of London M. Paris saith most expresly that †Henricus congregato Londoniis clero Angliae populo universo promisit emendationem legum quibus oppressa fuerat Anglia tempore patris sui fratris nuper defuncti ut animos omnium in sui promotionem accenderet amorem ut illum susciperent in Regem Patronum Ad haec clero respondente Magnatibus cunctis quod si animo volente ipsis vellet concedere chartâ suâ communire illas libertates consuetudines antiquas quae floruerunt in Regno tempore Sancti Regis Edwardi in ipsum consentirent in Regem unanimiter consecrarent Henrico autem hoc libenter annuente se id facturum cum juramento affirmante consecratus est in Regem apud Westmonasterium p. 38. Henry having assembled the Clergy and all the People of England that he might dispose their minds to the love and the promotion of him and the taking him for their King and Patron promised them the emendation of the Laws by which England had been oppressed in the time of his Brother and that all the Clergy and Nobility answered That if he would freely grant to them and confirm by his Charter those Liberties and ancient Customs which flourished in the time of King Edward they would unanimously consent to receive him for their King and that upon his Consent and Oath to do so he was created King at Westminster And when his Brother Robert came to challenge the Crown as his by right of Succession and the Concord made betwixt him and his Brother Rufus to animate his Subjects to stand by him he speaks thus to them * Ego vero Rex humilis pacificus vos in pace in antiquis vestris libertatibus prout crebrius jurejurando promisi gestio confovere omnia videlicet quae sanctus Rex Edvardus Deo inspirante providè sancivit inviolabiliter jubeo observari Ibid. p. 42. I your mild King am desirous to preserve you in your Ancient Liberties as I have often promised upon Oath And command all things to be inviolably observed which holy King Edward by the Inspiration of God advisedly established Steven succeeded him and he to get the Kingdom Meliorationem legum promisit juxta voluntatem arbitrium singulorum M. Paris p. 51. R. Hagulstad p. 314 315. Chron. Jo. Brompt p. 1024. Bonas leges antiquas justas consuetudines in Hundris Placitis aliis Causis observabo Rich. Hagulstad p. 314. Confirmavit Pacta quae Deo populo