and feed Mules than men 11 As for strangers preferred to benefices by the Popes there have been alwayes great exclamations by reason of the many evils inconveniences which follow of it which have beene divers times exhibited but to no purpose Marsilius of Padua urgeth this abuse and shewes that many are elected by the Popes who cannot communicate or talke with those who are committed to their charge Wherefore saith he speaking of Iohn the 22 let him answer Christ who against or after elections made or to be made among other monsters which he hath made and doth yet make hee hath created two Bishops his owne countrey men of Languedoc one of Silchester in England the other of Londes in Dacia over those people with whom they cannot have any conference by discourse As for their manners and learning it concernes not me to speake of them Let the Bishop of Rome tell mee say I how that shepheard shall call his own sheep by their name as knowing their conditions by their confessions and reproving them or how can the sheep follow him by hearing the voyce of his preaching and teaching 12 M. Iohn Gerson in his treatise De defectu virorum Ecclesiasticorum wherein he sets downe such things as ought to be reformed in the Church puts this That knowne men and such as are most fitting be elected out of the same Countrey that strangers in manners Language and education bee not sent and set over Churches King Charles the 7 in his Edict the tenth of May 1431 assures us that it is a law established by his Predecessours confirmed by the Ordinance of his deceased Father Charles the 6 intimated to the Councell of Constance and Pope Martin He further treats of the inconveniences and prejudices which follow upon it when they are admitted as that divine service is â—hereby neglected by reason of their non-residence that the Schooles of the Kingdome are unprovided of Students and left desolate that it is a hard case to see the noble and brave Scholars of the Realme unprovided and strangers preferred that by this meanes enemies and adversaries may bee acquainted with the secrets of State and the estate of the Land that strangers reape the profits and get the honours of it 13 Lewes the 11 in an Ordinance made 1464 speaks hereof in this sort Howbeit that by priviledges expresse and Ordinances royall no man can have any elective benefice within our said Kingdome unlesse he be a native and that for the safety of us and our said Kingdome and Dauphine it concernes us much that the Bishopriques Abbeys and other dignities and elective benefices be furnished with able and knowne men such as will comply with us and be firme and sure for us especially such as hold the said benefices and by reason of them divers places and fortresses for which divers duties and services belong unto us from them yet notwithstanding our late pious Father granted the said favours and patents so plentifully and to all manner of persons of what Nation Kingdome or Religion soever they were without distinction that many under shadow and pretence of these licences and patents have insinuated and intruded themselves into the said dignities and elective benefices of our said Kingdome and doe hold them howbeit many of them are strangers unknowne and not to be trusted by us and such as neither can nor ought to performe those duties and services which they are bound to doe unto us by reason of the said benefices 14 And the Court of Parliament in those Remonstrances which they made unto him amongst other inconveniences which they urged would follow upon the abrogation of the Pragmatique Sanction say By this meanes strangers would be prâ—ferred by the Pope and not the natives of the Countrey wherein the benefices lye not of the same qualities and conditions with the Countrey Whereupon would insue questions and controversies betwixt the Churchmen or Seculars to the great hindrance of the salvation of soules and irreverence of the blessed Sacraments 15 Henry the 3 in the fourth Article of the Ordinance of Blois We meanâ— not that from henceforth any shall be preferred to any Archbishopriques Bishopriques Abbeys or to be Generals of Orders neither by death resignation nor otherwise unlesse he be a naturall Frenchman notwithstanding any dispensation or clause derogatory to these presents which they can obtaine from us whereto we will not have any regard to be had The deputies of Paul the 3 touched upon this string in their reformation That no benefices say they in England or Spaine be conferred upon any Italian nor on the contrary Which ought to bee observed aswell in Presentations upon vacancy by death as by resignations wherein regard is only had to the pleasure of the resigner and nothing else Their Counsell did no great good for there was nothing done in the point for all that CHAP. VII Of suits commenced at Rome and of the entrenching upon other Courts of Iustice and jurisdictions GERMANY complained also of suits commenced at Rome concerning benefices which is a very usuall ancient complaint backed with sound reasons seeing that from hence comes the squeazing of Provinces both of their men and money and abundance of other evils and calamities Charles the 6 in the Ordinance of the 18 of February 1406 They insert divers clauses in thâ—ir Buls which are sometimes inextricable they make divers rules beside the law or else quite against law which they revoke at their pleasure insomuch that the most clear-sighted cannot discerne who hath best right amongst divers pretenders Hence arise infinite suits in law which they must goe and prosecute out of the Kingdome with great expence and charges 2 Charles the 7 in the Ordinance made 1422 Divers of our subjects and others by virtue of resignations or Apostolique Buls doe take and receive and endevour to get and obtaine benefices within this Realme and take possession of them and labour to summon or cause to bee summoned our â—â—ige subjects unto the Court of Rome or before some Commissioners or Delegates appointed by our Holy Father which is downright to oppose the rights and liberties of the Church and Clergy Lewes the 11 in an Ordinance of the 16 of August 1471 The most of the benefices in our Kingdome are in suit in the prosecution of which suits a huge masse of money is strangely spent and squandered away nor is it certainly knowne to whom the livings doe of right appertaine or belong Whereupon divine service instruction of the people and administration of the blessed Sacraments are oft-times left off and the revenue of the livings whiâ—h should have beene bestowed upon the reparations of the Churches there is imployed in charges of Law and suits Whereupon some great mischiefs and inconveniences have and doe daily come to passe 3 Nicholas de Clemangiis in his booke De ruinis reparatione Ecclesiâ— after he hath spoken of the Canons and constitutions
Councell holden at Rome under Innocent the third at which were present Primates and Archbishops sixty one Bishops foure hundred and twelve and eight hundred Abbots and Priors In which Councell the said Pope did excommunicate Lewes the King of France his eldest sonne and all the Earles and Barons of England with their complices which conspired and rebelled against the King of England Philip Augustus knowing the excommunication said to Gualo the Popes Legat The Kingdome of England which the Pope pretended to be feudatary to him and thereupon proceeded to that sentence of excommunication never was nor is nor ever will be S. Peters patrimonie in as much as no King or Prince can give away his Kingdome without the consent of his Barons who were bound to defend it And if the Pope intend peremptorily to stand in this errour urged thereto by a desire of enlarging his dominion hee will give a bad president to all Kingdomes Whereupon the nobles of France seconding the words of their Prince begun in an instant to cry out with one voice That they would stand for that article till death And yet all this was against the decision of a solemne generall Councell Boniface the eighth saith Platina having called a generall Councell subjâ—cted Philip the Faire and his Kingdome to the Emperour Albert this was saith the Bishop of Consentia who relates the same story in the yeere 1302. Notwithstanding this decree of the Councell Philip the Faire did revenge himselfe upon Pope Boniface in such sort that if his violent death had not ensued upon it his proceedings had never been blamed nor condemned by any man Platina after he hath delivered the story at large gives him this elogy Thus dyed that Boniface who studyed rather to strike a terrour then religion into all Emperours Kings Princes Nations and people who laboured to give and take away Kingdomes to repulse and recall men at his pleasure insatiably thirsting after an incredible masse of money which he had raked together by hooke and crooke Wherefore let his example be a lesson to all governours religious and secular not to rule their Clergie and people proudly and disdainfully as the man we speake of did but piously and modestly Benedict th' eleventh who succeeded this Boniface being informed of the justice of the cause of our King absolved him from the interdict whereto both himselfe and all his Kingdome were subjected and besides set forth a declaration for the exempting of the Kingdome of France from that power which Boniface by his Decretall did arrogate to himselfe over all Empires and Kingdomes whatsoever and for the preserving of it in the ancient rights and liberties thereof 16 Pope Iohn the twenty second say the German Chronicles having called a Councell at Avinion of Bishops and Cardinals not a fâ—w passed the sentence of excâ—â—munication upon Lewes the Emperour and gave his reasons in his Bâ—ll â—gainst Lewes because he had aided heretiques and schismatiques and had ever been a favourer of rebells And besides he denounced the sentence of excommunication against all those that did not sequester themselves from his company and of deprivation of their benefices and dignities against such Priests as should celebrate divine service in his presence The Author addes one thing very remarkable These proceedings saith he of the See of Rome were in those daies of great efficacy for it was a crime inexpiable to be of another opinion then thâ— Pope of Rome yet were there some notwithstanding who â—ided with Lewes without any regard of the excommunication but these not very many for in an imperiall Diet called afterwards by the Emperour to see if hee could finde any reliefe against that sentence all the world was frozen-hearted and crest-falne All the refuge that poore Emperour had was in a few Lawyers who stoutly defended his right and thereby confirmed most of those who were wavering Lewes had saith the same Chronicle some Doctors both of the Civill and Câ—non Lawe who were of opinion that the Popes sentence was null and invalid which opinion of the Doctors was a meanes why divers did not abandon him See here how the Emperours party notwithstanding his right was at first but very weak yet afterwards grew so strong that every one openly rejected the unjust decree of the Councell The Estates assembled at Francford the yeere 1338. did cancell and disanull all these lawlesse proceedings by a faire decree which wee may read at large in Nauclerus Provost of Tubinge wherein are set downe all the authorities and reasons in law against the forementioned sentence and processe with this close By the advise and consent of all the Prelats and Princes of Germany assembled at Francford wee decree that the former processe be void and of no effect and pronounce a nullity upon them all One of our commentators affirmes that even in the Court of Rome where himselfe afterwards was many Prelates and many laiques well skilled in both the Lawes did hold that the Emperour was wronged To bee short there was not one till Pope Benet the twelfth who succeeded Pope Iohn that did not disrelish that processe and yet it was done in a Councell The Councell which was begun at Ferrara 1438 and continued at Florence was never received and approved of in this Realme of France The Bishop of Panormo tells us so The King of France saith he did expresly forbid upon great penalties that any of his dominions should goe to Ferrara to celebrate the Oecunmenicall Councell Charles the seventh telles some Cardinals downright so who were sent Ambassadours from Eugenius and were come to Bruges to get him to accept of it and amongst others to present him with this Article That since such time as it was translated to Ferrara the King should reject the Councell of Basil and receive the Councell of Ferrara with the acts thereof Whereto he made answer after six dayes deliberation with his Prelates and others assembled at Bruges That hee had received the Councell of Basil for a Councell indeed that he sent his Ambassadours thither that many things were there wisely determined concerning faith and mannersâ— and such aâ— hee liked well of But for that of Ferrara hee never did nor never would take it for a Councell 17. These articles and answers are extant in the workes of Nicholas de Clemâ—ngiis And yet for all this Clement the seventh styles this the Eighth Generall Councell For marke how he speakes of it in his Bull of the 22. of Aprill 1527. directed to the Bishop of Farnasia Wee cannot chuse but lâ—nd you our assistâ—â—ce in the impression of the Acts of the eighth Generall Councell held at Florence which you have translated out of Greeke into Latine True it is that Laurence Surius disavowes it when he saith it was not well said to call it the eighth Councell because that 's not it's place He wist not haply that a Pope so saith Bellarmine them to a
consisting of Archbishops Bishops Chapters Abbats Deanes Provosts and other Ecclesiasticall persons together with Doctors of Law both divine and humane and other learned men of the Realme and also of the chiefe Lords of France and others of the Kings Councell about the receiving of the Councels of Constance and Basil. I say Synod for so it is called in the act of Appeal of the University of Paris A while after King Lewes the eleventh assembled a Councell of the Gallicane Church and all the Vniversities in the City of Orleans as well to understand the purport of the Pragmatique Sanction as to give direction for the annates of benefices saith the Author before alledged Before we leave France wee will set downe what an English Historian saith of the Councell of Rhemes holâ—en by Pope Eugenius the third â—â—4â— About that time saith he Eugenius Pope of Rome coming into France out of the affection hee bore to Ecclesiasticall discipline set up a generall Councell aâ— Rhemes where he sitting with a great company of Bishops and Nobles there was a pestilent fellow brought before him who being possest with a devill had seduced a great many by his tricks and juglings 30 Spaine can furnish us also with such like examples and assure uâ— that when it pleased their Kings even Lay men were admitted into theiâ— Councels to have a deliberative voice there and to judge of matters 31 This may be collected from the sixth Councell of Toledo holden under King Chiutillaud and by his authority the yeere 654. where in the thirâ— chapter we reade thus Wherefore we decree and denounce with heart and mouth this sentence pleasing to God conformable to our Kings and do furthermore ordain with the consent and advice of the Grandés and honourable persons of his Kingdome c. To the same effect we finde the eighth Councell of Toledo holden under King Recessuinth and by his command subscribed with the signes of fifteene of his Officers King Eringus caused divers of his Lords and officers of the Court to assist at the twelfth Councell of Toledo holden in the yeere 681â— and ordained them for Iudges together with the Bishops to consult of such things as should bee handled there to all whom hee made this exhortation at the opening of the Councell I doe admonish and conjure you in commune both you holy fathers you right honourable of my royall Court whom we have chosen to assist in this holy Councell by the name of God and as you will answer at the dreadfull day of judgement that without all favour or acceptation of persons without any froward wrangling or â—esire of perverting the truth you treat of such matters as shall be proâ—osed unto you with a sound examination and that you expresse them with a more sound judgement His subscription to the Acts of that Councell have these words Great good will accrue to our Realme and people if these decrees of the Acts of the Synod as they were made by our procurement so they bee confirmed by the oracle of our lasting law To the end that what the reverend Fathers and Lords have ordained by virtue of our command may be defendeâ— by our Edict All his Courtiers and Officers are subsigned to the Acts of that Councell 32 The same forme was observed in England for in the yeere 905. King Edward and Plegmond Archbishop of Canterbury assembled a great Councell of Bishops Abbats and other faithfull people in the southerne parts of Englandâ— saith Matthew Westminster 33 In the yeere 1150. King Stephen having done what hee would at Yorke and the adjoyning shires returned towards the southerne parts about the feast of Saint Michael th' Archangell to keepe a Councell at London together with the Bishops and Nobles of England both for the affaires of the Kingdome and of the Church of Yorke which was then vacant 34 The yeere 1170. at the request of the King of England two Cardinals Albert and Theodinus were sent into France from the See Apostolique who having called a great assembly of Ecclesiasticall persons and Noblemen within the territories of the King of England they solemnly admitted him to purge himselfe of the murther of Thomas Archbishop of Canterbury 35 In the yeere 1190. the Bishop of Ely Chancelour of England and Lieutenant generall of the Realme in the absence of King Richard the second who was then at the warre in the Holy Land called the Bishops and Lords of the Kingdome together And presenting them upon the suddaine with the inâ—strument of his Legation hee openly declared himselfe with a great deale of pompe and insolency to be Legat oâ— the See Apostolique 36 Come we backe to the Emperours there we have the example of Othâ— the first who made up the Councell which he held at Rome for the condemnation of Pope Iohn of Ecclesiastiques and Lay men Of which ranke these are named by Luitprandus Of the Nobles Stephanus filius Iohannes superista Demetrius Meliosi Crescentius Caballi marmorei Iohannes Puisina Stephanus de Musa Theodorus de Rusina Iohannes de Primicerio Leo de Camurzuli Ricardus Petrus de Canaperia Benedictus Bulgaminus his sonne Of the communalty Peter Imperiola with all the Roman army And afterwards by their unanimous advice the Emperour pronounced the sentence of condemnation against Iohn and created Leo in his stead by the same advice 37 We have also the example of Henry the third Who saith Polanus having called a Councell at Worms consisting of foure and twenty Bishops and many of the Nobility he there commanded the decrees of Pope Gregory to bee disanulled 38 We may further alledge the example of Popes For Adrian did summon many Lay men to the Lateran Councell holden by him and Charles the great what time he caused him to bee proclaimed Emperour There was a holy Synod called saith a good Author by Pope Adrian of happy memory at the Palace of Lateran in the Church of St. Saviour which was most solemnly kept by fifty three Ecclesiasticall persons Bishops or Abbats together with â—udges Magistrates and Doctors of Law from all parts and also personâ— of all states and conditions of that City and all the Clergy of the holy Church of Rome Who made enquiry concerning the customes lawes and manners of that Church and Empire consulting also by what meanes heresies and seditions might be rooted oâ—t of the Apostolique See and treating of the dignity of the Senate and Empire of Rome seeing that by reason of these thingâ— a foule errour was spread over the whole world 39 In imitation of him Pope Leo did the like in another Councell at the Lateran under the Emperour Otho the first For as much as your â—umility saith he doth humbly desire our Apostleship that dispatching the holy Synod assembled by your advice at the Patriarchall of the Lateâ—an in the Church of St. Saviour and consisting besides of Iudges and Doctors of
word The execution whereof ensued as rigorous as ever For one Mr. Otho who was sent as Legat upon that occasion did not spare excommunications causing besides certaine great summes of money to be levyed for the defraying of his charges because as he said in this commission hee was not bound to make war at his owne charges Mean while the Legat not forgetting himselfe did not neglect to extort both money and meanes for himselfe for compelling every one to pay him procurations he sent certaine rigorous injunctions to the Bishops and Archdeacons to this effect He afterwards demanded the fifth part of all the goods and spirituall revenues of the Clergy men aliens who had any preferments in England whereof there were then good store and from them hee proceeded to the rest and all to make warre against the Emperour Frederick And whereas divers were marked out for that beyond-sea voyage hee dispatched a pretty commission to his Legat to absolve them of their vow and to exact of them certaine great sums of money All these evils were occasioned mainly by the softnesse of King Henry the third who when it was asked by his subjects Why he would suffer England considering the large priviledges thereof like a Vineyard without a wallâ— to ly open to the prey and desolation of passengers He replyed â— neither will nor dare contradict the Pope in any thing 28 Nor is here an end For about that time saith the same Authour there came into England a new way of exaction most execrable and unheard of in any age For our holy Father the Popeâ— sent a certaine exacter into England Peter Rubeus by name who was instructed to wipe the poore English of an infinite masse of money by a new invented mouse-trap trick For hee came into the Chapters of the Religious cozening and compelling them first to promise and then to pay after the example of other Prelates whom he lyingly affirmed to have payed already For he said Such and such a Bishop such and such an Abbat have already freely contributed why doe you slowbacks delay so long that you may loose your thanks with your courtesie Besides this cheater caused them to sweare not to reveal the manner of this exaction to any till halfe a yeere after like robbers who compell those they rob to promise that they will not speake of it But though men should be silent the very stones out of the Churches would cry out against such rake-hells This fit of the fever descended like an hereditary disease upon his successours Innocent the fourth knew well enough how to husband such a fertile field but so as he made all England cry out of him who brought their complaints as far as the Councell at Lyons in the yeere 1245 then and there demanding for justice and reliefe against these tyrannicall exactions and that even before the Popes nose who was there in person who as the Historians say casting his eyes downe for shame durst not say mum And for the Councell which regarded nothing but the Popes pleasure it was deafe on that eare The same complaint was afterwards put up in a Parliament in England by King Henry himselfe who begun to meane himselfe where these Articles were exhibited amongst others The Kingdome of England is grieved inasmuch as the Lord Pope is not content with the subsidy of Peter pence but doth extort a grievous contribution of the whole Clergy of Englandâ— and intends to extort far greater yet and this he doth without the assent or consent of the King against the ancient customesâ— liberties and lawes of the Kingdome and against the appeall and protestation made by the Proctours of the King and Kingdome in the generall Councell 29 This Parliament used so much respect to the Pope as to content themselves with sending some soothing letters to him thinking to soften his heart with the relation of their miseries but this was all in vaine for the grievance grew daily greater and greater and indeed you may observe a new kind of extortion whereof complaint was made to King Henry There were lately brought certaine letters from the See Apostolique containing no little prejudice against the King and Kingdome to witâ— that the Bishops should maintaine some ten men of war well provided of horse and armour some five some fifteene to send over to the Pope for the service of the Church for the space of one whole yeere to be paid by the Bishops of England and imployed where the Pope should thinke expedient which Knights service is not due save only to the King and Princes of the Realme c. A little after The Pope taking courage to trample under-feet the poor English as the same Historian cals them and in trampling to impoverish them commanded the Bishops of England with more imperiousnesse than was usuall that all the beneficed men in England should contribute unto him to wit such as were resident the third part of their goods and the rest halfe adding withall some very hard conditions He sent to one M. Iohn his Legat that if any Bishop should make dainty of paying the subsidies which he demanded under colour of exemption that he should sesse them deeper Another English Historian speaks thus of this matter By reason of these and such like oppressions there was a great murmuring both amongst the Clergy and people insomuch that whatsoever was contributed was given with imprecations or to speake more properly and not conceall the truth with down-right cursings putting the Pope in minde of their grievances with a complaint proceeding from the bottome of their hearts and setting before him their insupportable oppressions And he afterwards addes these grievances The Church of England is intolerably vexed with infinite charges in the tenth of all their goods in the hastening of reliefes in the money levied for Souldiers in the subsidies divers times exacted by Otho the Legat in the paying of 6000 Marks in the twentieth part of their three yeeres revenues in the subsidie of the Roman Empire in the subsidie granted freely 30 Matthew Paris sets downe an infinite company of other barbarous exactions saying The charges were marvelously increased with a great deal of overplus and flowed day by day from the Court of Rome over the miserable Kingdome of England besides the burthen and unwonted slavery insomuch that the Bishops were debarred from the bestowing of their benefices till they had discharged these exactions and yet the pusillanimity of the King never contradicted it Horrible burthens and unheard of oppressions did spring up daily Wee have thought fit to insert in this booke not all the charges for that would be a very hard thing nay altogether impossible to set downe but onely some few to the end that such as read them may bee sorry for them and pray to God that we may be one day freed from them We should spend too much paper in setting downe all which is
delivered by him at large concerning this point it shall suffice us to recount the proverbiall speech of that Pope England said he is indeed the garden of our pleasures an exhaustible pit and where there is abundance out of much much may bee taken This proverb was received with all honour and reverence by his successour Alexander the fourth who sent one M. Rustand into England who rifled the purses of the poore Clergy-men soundly with the aid and assistance of the Bishop of Hereford who was licensed by the Pope to borrow money in the name of the Abbeys and Monasteries and to pawne their goods for the payment thereof Which he so effected that the money went to the Pope but the bond laid upon the Abbats and Priours which they were compelled to pay together with the costs and damages and interests The pretence was that that money should be imployed to the use of the Abbeys and Monasteries But for feare least the jugling should bee discovered he tooke a course to hinder the thing from ever comming to tryall by any meanes whatsoever An English Historian after he hath delivered this relation addes these words These things and others like detestable O shame O griefe did spring at that time from the sulphureous fountaine of the Church of Rome The same M. Rustand had commission to levie the tenth of the goods in England Scotland and Ireland and to raise some other great and intolerable exactions with injust actions and contumelious speeches heare what the â—ame Authour sayes of it At that time Rustand called all the Bishops of England together at London by virtue of the Popes authority to heare his commission where being met after the faculties of the said Rustand were read he brake with them requiring of them all an infinite summe of money by virtue of certaine writings full of injury and injustice which might have deeply wounded the hearts of the most patient men if that sum had beene levied the Church of England yea the whole kingdome should have undergone a most base servitude and beene throwne into an irrecoverable poverty Afterwards he commanded his debts to be discharged by the English Clergy writing to this or that Bishop by name to pay such a sum excommunicating such as were refractory There are an infinite examples of the like nature recorded by Historians from age to age which witnesse unto us that this is not a fault personall but perpetuall and Papall 31 Nor hath England only made these complaints France also hath divers times groaned and appeared to bee in a kinde inslaved Nicholas de Clemangiis a French Devine makes a long and ample description of the taxes and subsidies of the Popes amongst which he ranks the imposition of tenths divers other tributes What shall I say of the spoyling of Prelates of the too too usuall tenths and of other taxations And a little after What should I doe setting down particularly an infinite company of other tributary impositions which are dayly exacted of the most infortunate Clergy The Pragmatique of S. Lewes is very observable concerning this point Item we will not in any wise that there bee any levie or collections made of the charges and exactions of moneys imposed by the Court of Rome upon the Churches of our Realme by meanes whereof our said Realme hath beene impoverished Nor is it lesse considerable which Matthew Paris relates to have happened under that Prince About the same time saith hee the Pope sent his authentique letters to all the Bishops in France in particular by his solemne Nuncioes to the Predicants and Minorites intreating them that every one of them according to his ability would furnish him with a certaine summe of money which hee would undoubtedly repay so soone as he begun to get breath This comming to the Kings eare who suspected the avarice of the Court of Rome hee sent out prohibitions that no Prelate of his Realme should impoverish his countrey in that kinde upon paine of forfeiting all his goods And so those sophisticall Legats of the Pope upon whose shoulders this charge was laid returned out of the Realme emptâ—-handed with hissings and mockings He means Innocent the 4 in whose time King Lewes raigned the yeer 1247 what time this was done This was the Pope who so soone as he was come to Lyons to hold his Councell wherein he excommunicated the Emperour Frederick made such a pitifull complaint of his poverty and the great summes of money which hee ought that our French Prelats shifted themselves to their very shirts to exercise their charity towards him without sparing either gold silver moveables apparell vessels horses or other things whereby hee got an inestimable treasure 32 But the story of the Abbat of S. Dennis is memorable who having extorted great summes of money out of his Abbey to present unto the Pope as others did in hopes to be made one day an Archbishop S. Lewes the King as Patron of that Abbey compelled him to repay the said summe out of his owne purse Charles the 6 in a Decree made February the 18 1406 They take occasion to reserve the first-fruits in the vacancies and to extort great summes of moneyâ— wherby the kingdome is exhausted and to thrust themselves upon the Popedome for to enrich and preferre both them and theirs And in another Decree made the same yeere he accounts this amongst other extortions Imposing tenths and other subsidies at their pleasure without ever consulting with the rest of the Bishops about it in the raising whereof there is no meane observed either of justice or equity And in another made in March 1418. That an infinite deale of gold and silver and rents were transported out of the Kingdome and the Province of Dauphiny to the prejudice of the ancient customes and the undoing of the Realme to the irreparable losse and damage of the Common-wealth and the miserable desolation of the Churches aswell such as were of royall foundation as others We will here relate what Marsilius saith of tenths So that this Bishop speaking of the Pope seeking to get this jurisdiction over earthly Princes although wrongfully by such a kind of distribution or donation of such like temporall matters of benefices and tenths which when I looke upon all Kingdomes at once doe amount to an inestimable deal hee may stir up a great deal of sedition and indeed hath ever hithertowards so done and doth yet more especially in the Catholique Empire of the Romans 33 The Popes do likewise claim unto themselves the spoyles and inheritance of the rest of the Clergy therefore have denyed them so much power as to make their wils and dispose of their owne goods Concerning which wee have already heard the testimony of Nicholas Clemangius let us now heare what Marsilius of Padua saith Adde hereunto saith he a new branch of that root how that the Bishop of Rome by virtue of that plenitude of power hath
faculties as appeares by the passage which we have urged elsewhere speaking of the penitentiary taxes of the Church of Rome 19 This power was never more than imaginary in France for Legates were never permitted to exercise this faculty there as being contrary to the Lawes of the Land and indeed heark what the Collection of the liberties of the Gallican Church saith concerning this point The Pope cannot legitimate bastards and illegitimate persons so as to make them capable of succeeding or being succeeded by others nor to beare office and purchase temporall estates in this Kingdome 20 Many other abuses might be here alledged which are committed in these faculties as they call them that in particular which is so ordinary that it can never be forgotten To derogate from all Decrees of Councels and dispense with them or as others terme it to put a dorre or obstacle before the Councell and other Constitutions derogatory to them Of which abuse Gerson speakes thus It is not lawfull for the Pope to make so much adoe about these obstats which are ordain'd in Generall Councels Cardinall Cusan in his booke De Concordiâ Catholicâ makes a large Chapter of this But we should have enough to doe if we would seeke out all the abuses and usurpations of the Court of Rome CHAP. IX Of the Popes usurpation of Lordships and Kingdomes 1 THey have laboured hard to usurpe Lordships Kingdomes and Empires insomuch that they quite forgot the care of Spirituals Two maine causes have moved them hereunto Avarice and Ambition We shall here prosecute onely so much as concernes the first or at least as belongs jointly to both Marsilius of Padua Not content with those Temporalls which were bestowed upon them by Princes by reason of their insatiable appetite they have seized upon many temporall things that of right belong to the Empire as the Cities of Romandiola Ferrara and Bononia with divers other possessions and many lands and Lordships then especially when the Empire was vacant 2 Langius reporteth a passage out of the Chronicles of Engelbert Westerâ—itz a Clerke of Brandenburg where as much is said of the City of Rome The keyes whereof saith he were presented by the Citizens to Innocent the seventh with branches of Palme trees and the temporall dominion thereof granted unto him but with little equity and commendation forasmuch as the abundance of temporall things are no little impediment to spirituall and the Pope who is Saint Peters successor ought not to take this dangerous temporall dominion upon him for we never reade that in former times even after the donation of Constantine in which our curious Canonists doe greatly hugge themselves that any Pope did administer the temporall dominion of the City of Rome but in these latter daies and within our memorie some Popes have ventur'd to meddle with it thereby heaping upon themselves both cares and troubles howbeit from all antiquity Rome was ever the royall and imperiall City else he that should be lawfully preferred to the Empire by the Electors deputed whosoever he were should be vainly and idlely called the King of the Romanes as commonly hee is by the ancient Historians 3 There is nothing here but very true and yet our Popes beside the donation of Constantine have forged us another made by Lewes the Gentle who bestowed upon them the City of Rome in expresse termes howbeit the ancient Historians speake not a word of it and it is plaine they never enioyed that right till within this little while to wit after the time of Boniface the ninth who being intreated by the Romanâ—s to remove his seat from Avinion to Rome for the great gaines which they presaged they should reape by the approching yeere of Iubilee he being arrived there seized upon the Cittadell of the Castle of S. Angelo and made himselfe master and commander of the City for him and his successors But let us heare the testimonie of Guicciardine concerning this 4 Being returned to Rome upon these conditions while the Romanes were busie about the gaines that yeere 1400 the Pope having got the command of the City fortified the Castle of St. Angelo and bestowed a garrison in it whose successors till Eugenius although they were troubled with divers difficulties yet having fully established their government for the future the succeeding Popes have ruled the roast at Rome at their pleasure without any contradiction 5 But we shall speake more at large of such usurpations as these hereafter we will onely observe that the Popes were ever so crafty in the managing of Empires and Kingdomes under the pretence of spiritualty as to pick out something alwaies for their owne advantage So Boniface to take up the quarrell which was betwixt the King of England and Scotland whom the other King pretended to be his vassall came in play as to assist the Scotch Affirming how that Kingdome belong'd of right to the Church of Rome and that it was in his power onely to give it or take it from whom he pleased which he affirmed so as that hee would needs bee the Iudge himselfe but hee met with a people that would not beleeve him 6 A certaine King of Poland called Casimire being turned Monke and enâ—red into the Abbey of Cluny in France was dispensed with for his vow by Pope Bennet at the request of the Polanders repenting themselves of their fault so as he had licence both to reigne and to marry but for the pot of wine It was ordained by the Pope that the Polanders should pay a yeerly pension to S. Peters Church in Rome for maintaining of candles which is called in Polonish Snatro Petre that is S. Peters Saint 7 Charles of Anjou brother to S. Lewes the King was by Clement the 4 who prosecuted the designe of his predecessour Vrban the 4 Declared King of Ierusalem and Sicily with this condition that he should pay fourty thousand crowns yeerly to the Church of Rome by way of fee. Wherein two usurpations are remarkableâ— one in the manner of the fee which Peter Anaclete the anti-Pope had formerly laid upon Sicily the other in the tribute which Clement the fourth added de â—ovo 8 But there is nothing so memorable as the usurping upon the Kingdome of England where excommunication was openly profaned King Iohn of England being at enmity with the Lords of the Land by reason of certaine injuries pretended to be done unto them by him was excommunicated by Innocent the third the yeere 1513. This excommunication was carried from Rome by Stephen Archbishop of Canterbury William Bishop of London and Peter Bishop of Ely who thundred it out in France where that King had then certaine Earledomes and Dukâ—domeâ— after they had acquainted King Philip Augustus with the whole businesse Whom those Bishops commanded as also all others for the remission of their sinnes that invading England in hostile manner they should depose King Iohn from his crowne
observed and practised which plainly proves our exposition to be true 18 Our Lawyers tell us that when there is any controversie about the sense and meaning of a law speciall regard ought to be had of that sense which practice hath put upon it Let us observe this rule in the exposition of our Canon The question is Whether the Pope ought to call Councels or no we finde by practice that the Popes did not call them but the Emperours and that they did so constantly the Popes seeing and knowing as much that they themselves have beene petitioners to the Emperours to get them called that they have appeared at the Councels upon command from them therefore we may well conclude they have no right at all by this Canon to call Councels 19 We will adde furthermore that the Popes never complained of the Emperours for taking upon them that power of Convocation which doubtlesse they would have done if it had belonged to them of right for they have alwayes observed that rule to a haire De vigilantibus non dorâ—ientibus So as to say the truth no man can accuse them of negligence in preserving St. Peters patrimony which they have husbanded so well that their successors for the future need make no scruple of receiving it without an inventary 20 We say moreover that it is but a little while agoe since they usurped this authoritie for we doe not finde that ever they used it till the yeare 1123â— what time the first Councell of Lateran was holden Calixt the second being Pope and Henry the fifth Emperour Platina saith that Pope held a Councell of nine hundred Bishops to consult about the sending of succours into the holy Land Howsoever we must observe that this usurpation which they continued from thence forwards was not without all interruption for the Emperors alwayes kept a hanke of their right though it was but extrema quasi lacinia They called divers Councels after that time as that of Pavy which was assembled by the Emperour Fredericke the first to determine the schisme betweene Victor and Alexander the third about the yeare 1163 or 64 but it is not amisse to heare what language he useth in his letters of Convocation 21 And for the prescribing of a remedy pleasing to God and proper for this disease we have resolved upon the advice of certaine godly and religious men to hold a generall Councellâ— which we appoint to be at Pavie The author that relates these letters speakes thus of them The Emperour supposing that the authority of calling a Councell appertained unto him after the example of Iustinian Theodosius and Charles and that the controversie could not be determined by any lawfull judgement unlesse both parties were summâ—ned thereunto sent Bishops both to the one and the other to summon them The same Emperour useth the same termes in his speech made at the opening of the Councell He was also the man that called the Councell of Dijon about 1165. It is true that Pope Alexander the third would not be seene there Because saith Platina he did not call it himselfe But he raised that quarrell too soone considering that his right was not yet well caulked 22 So likewise the Councels of Pisa and Constance were called by the Emperours Now if the possession was afterwards lost by the negligence of the Emperours yet this is sufficient to bring a writ of Right and make an entry for which triall the Emperours are better furnished of evidence than the Popes and besides they who should breathe nought but justice and honestie will voluntarily surrender unto Cesâ—r what of right belongs unto him 23 What we here speake is concerning Generall Councels for as for Provinciall we deny not but the Popes have hâ—d authoritie to call them within the bounds of their owne territories as have also other Patriarchs and Metropolitans And yet those bounds are but very narrow for wee doe not finde that they were extended over all the West and what Balsamon saith that the Bishop of Rome is the president of the Westerne provinces must be restrained unto Italy And for matter of fact the Pope was neither seene nor heard in person nor by proxie at the Councell of Cullen which consisted of the French and German Bishops and was assembled by the authoritie of the Emperour Charles the third Anno Dom. 887. 24 Nor was hee at that of Aquileia called by the Emperours Valentinian and Theodosius consisting of the Bishops of France Africke and other Provinces at which Saint Ambrose Bishop of Milan was present 25 The like may be said of such as have beene holden in France Spaine and other Kingdomes or Provinces of the West the calling whereof bâ—longed either to the Primates and Metropolitanes or to the Kings and Princes 26 So Maximus Patriarch of Ierusalem assembled the Bishops of Syria and Palestine to receive Athanasius into the communion of the Church and restore him to his former dignitie So Athanasius himselfe after hee was called home out of exile by Iovinian the Emperour assembled a Councell of Bishops But it would be tedious to heare all the examples which are extant about this subject As for the calling by Kings and Princes we shall speake of that anon 27 For the present we must answer an absurditie which Bellarmine presseth that in these dayes it would be impossible for any one to call a Generall Councell but the Pope for as for the Emperour to whom wee said it of right belongeth he cannot doe it saith he because he hath no authoritie over Kings and Princes but on the other side the Pope hath over all Christendome Bellarmine is deceived for the Pope in that respect hath scarce any more authoritie at this day than the Emperour Let him cast up his count of those Kingdomes and Provinces which have withdrawne their obedience from him and he will finde that he hath misreckoned himselfe All that Bellarmine can infer is this that we must talke no morâ— of Generall Councels in these dayes seeing there is no man to call them with convenience and authoritie Wee answer that he that should now undertake of his owne absolute power to call any should much deceive himselfe even the Pope not excepted But that every one out of courtesie would be willing to hearken unto it There is not a Prince in Christendome but yeelds the first degree of honour to the Emperour and would take in good part any gentle and kinde summons which should come from him for the holding of a Councell The Emperour Fredâ—ricke the first found a way to assemble that of Pavy whereunto he summoned the Archbishops Bishops Abbats and other Ecclesiasticall persons as well in all his Empire as in other kingdomes to wit of England France Hungary Denmarke And it is probable that when he made this convocation he writ of it in particular to those Christian Princes which were no subjects to the Empire
presided there 3 We read in an old French Historian that Rhabanus Archbishop of Mentz presided in two severall Councels holden in that Citie by the command of Lewes the Gentle But the same authour tels us plainely that it was the same Emperours pleasure and in his absence seeing that in the Acts of those Councels at least of the first for the rest wee have not the same Rhabanus and all the Synod speake continually of the Emperour with a great deal of humility even referring all to his judgement But heark what the forecited author saith of it Orgarius Bishop of Mentz dyed in the yeer 847 and Rhabanus succeeded in his place who by command from King Lewes held a Synod at Mentz the same yeere The title of that Synod imports that Rhabanus presided in it whence it follows that it was by virtue of the Emperours command The same author saith In the yeer 852 there was a Councell holden at Mentz the Metropolitan Citie of Germany by the will and command of the said most renowned Prince Rhabanus Archbishop of that Citie being President of it A litle after he addes further that at the same time while they treated of Ecclesiasticall matters the King was imployed in publique affaires and that they sent their Decrees unto him to bee confirmed a certaine testimony that the presidence was conferr'd upon Rhabanus by the Prince 4 King Charles the Bald was present at the Councell â—olden at Piâ—tis upon Sein in the yeer 863. Hee is named first the Decrees are conceived in his name whence it follows that hee presided there Wee may make the like inference of all those other Councels which run in the name of our Kings or to speake more properly where our Kings speak and decree such things as are proposed with the advice of the Clergy of which kind we find good store for without doubt either they themselves presided in them or others for them 5 King Arnold after he had called the Councell of Triburâ— in the yeer 895. presided there himselfe as may be collected from that epistle which contâ—ines the Preface which is likewise avouched in plaine termes at the end In this holy Councell the devout Prince and most renowned King Arnold being President and imploying himself about it the holy fathers and Reverend Pastors of the Church which came thither were all seated 6 Philip Augustus call'd a Councel at Paris ann 1â—84 at which he presided as is collected from the words of the author who speaks thus of it He commanded a Generall Councell to bee called at Paris of all the Archbishops Bishops and Princes of his Realme which he having kept with them by common advice by his authority royall hee enjoyned the Archbishops Bishops and all the rest of the Ecclesiasticall Prelats by their frequent Sermons and exhortations to perswade the people committed to their charge to goe to Ierusalem to defend the Christian faith against the enemies of the crosse of Christ. 7 When King Lewes the father of St. Lewes reigned in France saith Iohn le Maire and Gregory sixâ— Romanus the said Popes Legat came into France by the will of the King there was a Councell of the Gallicane Church assembled whereat the King and the said Legat did preside 8 In the yeer 1286 there was a Councell holden consisting of all the Prelates and Barons of France Against Pope Boniface the eighth where King Philip was present in person and presided at it reckoning up all the outrages and injuries which hee had received from that Pope Boniface saith the same authour 9 The Ordinance of Charles the sixt in the yeer 1408 makes mention of certaine Presidents by him established at a Councell holden at Paris Not long agoe saith hee it was proposed and demanded by our Atturney Generall at a Councell holden at Paris consisting of the Bishops and Clergy of the Churches within our Kingdome and Dauphiny where our cousen Lewes King of Sicily our eldest sonne Duke of Aquitain and Viennois the Duke of Bourges our unkle by the fathers side the Duke of Burgundy our cousen and the Duke of Bourbon our unkle by the mothers side did preside for us that the Popes exactions and other grievances formerly rehearsed might be utterly abolished 10 King Lewes the eleventh caused a Councell Of the Gallicane Church and all the Vniversites to bee assembled in the Citie of Orleans to bee more fully informed in the businesse of the Pragmatique Sanction at which Peter Duke of Bourbon Lord of Beavieu presided in steed of the King 11 There are Presidents in store for England too William the first presided in a Councell holden at Roan in the yeer 1073. It was judged saith an English authour at a Councell holden in that Citie where William King of England was President that the Monkes which were guilty of the cryme should bee kept in close prison during the Bishops pleasure The same King presided also at another holden before that at Silchester in the yeere 1070 whereof we have spoken elsewhere In the year 1102 or as others have it 1070 Anselm Archbishop of Canterbury called a Generall Councell of the Churches of England to London and presided at it but it was with the consent and good will of Henry the first where some Ecclesiasticall affaires of great importance were treated of 12 Wee could also produce some examples for Spaine for hee that shall read the Councels holden in that Countrey â—ill easily acknowledge that the Kings had all the authoritie in them whensoever they were pleased to use it 13 All the discourse which wee have made upon this point is in a manner superfluous for having proved by so many examples that Kings and Princes called Councels it follows that they had also authority to preside in them which yet they did not alwayes use being for the most part more apt to weild the sword than to manage an Ecclesiasticall action to give their opinions or cause others to opine in spiritual matters to pronounce the sentence of judgement and such like For this reason ofttimes they left all to the Clergy without intermedling themselves but when they were pleased to interpose they were so farre from being censured for taking too much upon them that on the contrary they were highly extoll'd and commended for it And what was spoken to the Emperour by an Archbishop of Bulgaria is applyable to all Princes within their owne Realmes and Dominions The Emperour saith hee as the common-skilfull Monarch of the Churches is President of the Decrees of Councels and makes them bee in force he ordaineth Ecclesiasticall orders hee sets lawes to the life and policy of those that serve at the Altar c. CHAP. XIV Of the approbation and authorisation of Councels 1 IT remaines now that we speak of the authorising of Councels which the Popes in their books arrogate unto themselves exclusively to all others which is also
deliberation hath chosen the welbeloved sonne of the Church Thomas for supreme Bishop calling him by the name which hee is now called Nicholas the fift This was done in the yeare 1449. In the same Act it is said that the Kings of England France Sicily and the Dolphin did much further that union 17 Bellarmine urgeth Leo the tenth against us also and the Councell of Lateran which was continued and ended under him after it was begun by Iulius the second For the better judging of the validity of this Councell wee must know the cause of it as Onuphrius a witnesse beyond exception doth deliver it The French being puffed up with the good successe of their affaires summoned Pope Iulius the second to a Councell which should be holden at Pisa the first of September as it was agreed upon betwixt them and the Emperor and the Cardinals that were revolted from the Pope who having laboured to make peace with the King of France Lewes the twelfth upon condition of recovering Bonony and dismissing this Councell of Pisa seeing that hee was growne insolent after his victory and that he obstinately refused to hearken unto him by the advice of Anthony de Monte he called the Generall Councell of Lateran to Rome to defeat the Conventicle of Pisa. And besides he excommunicated the King of France the Florentines who had received the Councell into the City of Pisa and all those that were assembled thither He deprived five Cardinals of all their honours and dignities who had beene the authors of that Councell He labours to sleight the authority of this Councell by setting downe the small number of Cardinals yea by minishing of them contrary to truth For by the Acts thereof it appeares that there were other five besides those whose names hee rehearseth The author of the Dialogue upon the death of Iulius reckons nine Nine Cardinals saith Iulius who is the speaker revolt from me proclaime a Councell invite me to come to it desire me to preside at it when they cannot obtaine that they call it themselves and summon all the world unto it with the authority of Maximilian as Emperour and Lewes the twelfth King of France But let him make the number as little as he will it may suffice our other Frenchmen yea all good Christians that this reverend Councell of Lateran was not called out of any zeale to religion but onely to breake that of Pisa and to hinder the reformation which they would have made of the head and the members But it is fitting to shew thoroughly the validity of that of Pisa and the nullity of the Lateranâ— to the honour of our Kings and the shame of the Popes 18 The world had a long time gaped after that so much desired reformation of the Head and the members â—ivers Councels had bin holden for that end but still in vaine by reason of the Popes craftinesse I will say nothing without good warrant that is a thing must bee looked to nowadayes Give eare therefore to the instructions which the Cardinals that called the Councell of Pisa gave to Ioannes Baptista de Theodorico and Francis de Treio whom they sent to Rome Having not had any Generall Councels say they for so many years and howâ—ver some few were assembled as wee finde that there have beene five within these hundred years last past viz. that of Pisa Constance Siena Basil and Florence yet for all that the Church hath not beene reform'd effectually by reason of those impediments and quarrels which have intervened and the Lords field in the meane time is overgrowne with briers and thornes that must of necessity bee purged by a Councell Vpon this occasion also it was religiously ordain'd by the Councels of Constance and Basil that Synods should bee held every ten yeers 19 But this being neglected by the Popes after the Councels of Lausanne and Florence at last the See comming to be void in the yeare 1503 the Cardinals before they went to a new election bound themselves by an oath that hee amongst them upon whom the election should light should bee bound to call a Councell within two years after and they drew an instrument hereof whose inscription runnes thus The things underwritten are the publique chapters ordained betwixt the supreme Bishop that shall bee and the right reverend Cardinals unanimously and with common consent for the defence of the libertie of the faith and the reformation of the Church in the Head and members Then follows the text We all and every one of the Cardinals of the holy Church of Rome here underwritten do swear and vow to God Almighty to the holy Apostles Peter and Paul and promise to all the saints of holy Churchâ— that if any of us be chosen Pope presently after the solemnity of his election he shall sweare and vow purely and in all simplicity and good truth to keep and cause to be effectually fulfilled and kept all and singular the Chapters here underwritten and to require all notaries to send out publique Buls of the same 20 First of all hee shall swear and promise that in case of necessity of assisting faithfull Christians c. There are yet some more Chapters and then it is said Item forasmuch as it is very important to call a Generall Councell with all speed for the peace of Christians the reformation of the Church the abolishing of many exactionsâ— as also for an expedition against the infidels hee shall promise swear and vow to call it within two yeares after his creation and to begin it effectually in some place of freedome and safety which shall bee chosen by him and two parts of the right reverend Lord Cardinals by balots The oath and vow made by the Cardinals concerning the things aforesaid 21 Wee all and every one of us the Cardinals of the holy Roman Churchâ— assembled together at Rome in the Palace Apostolique for the election of a future Pope of Rome conâ—irming the Chapters aforesaid agreed upon amongst us with consent and concord for defence of the Catholique faithâ— Ecclesiasticall liberty reformation of the Church in the Head and members and for the band of charity and peace betwixt the supreme Bishop and the Cardinals of the Church of Rome his brethren do vow to God to the glorious Virgin Mary his mother to the blessed Apostles and to all the Court of heaven swearing upon the holy Gospels corporally touched one to another and also to the publique notaries here undeâ—written as legall persons covenanting in the name of the holy mother Church and of our sacred Colledge and of all others that have any interest therein that whosoever amongst us shall bee chosen Pope hee shall fulfill and keep all and singular the things contained in the said Chapters without all coven fraud and treachâ—ry and without using any exception that hee shall not countermandâ—ny of them directly or indirectly openly or privatly that after his election or before the publication of it hee
are forbidden to grant Bishopriques after Canonicall election For wee read that some Popes of good fame have become intercessours to Kings for those who had been elected unto Churches to get them to give them the Bishopriques and that others have deferred the consecration because they had not yet received the Princes consent I would have set downe the examples hereof were it not that I desire to avoid prolixitie in my letter So Pope Vrban as we understand excludes Kings only from the corporall investiture but not from the election for asmuch as they are heads of the people or of the grant although the eight Synod forbids them onely to assist at the election but not at the deliverie which whether it bee done by the hand or by seale or by word of mouth or by the rod what matters it Seeing Kings doe not pretend to conferre any thing that is spirituall in it but only to consent unto the will of those that require them or to grant unto them Ecclesiasticall possessions and other externall goods which Churches hold by the liberalitie of Kings As for the Sacrament of which he hath spoken now twice there was no question of that seeing that by former Councels the investiture was granted to Emperors and the consecration to Bishops 24 What can be alleadged more in defence of these later Councels If any man will say that the Emperour Henry was justly deprived of this right because he had violated the holy See and had put Pope Paschal in prison Wee will give two or three very pat answers to this objection One that hee did no more but repell the injury which was done unto himselfe For even in the Church and while he received the Eucharist from the Popes hands hee was like to have beene traiterously killed Heare what the German Chronicles say of it While the Emperour received the Sacrament from the Popes hands behold one of the principall of the Clergy who was offended with that purpose which the Emperour had put on that he would maintaine the constitutions of his Predecessors stirred up a sedition and tumult in the temple beat off the guard of the Emperours body and went about to seaze upon him who with much adoe saved himselfe repelling the force with his owne hands And speaking of the same Emperour hee afterwards addes Hee got him presently into the Citie killed a great multitude of citizens and Clergy-men tooke the Pope prisoner Elsewhere the Pope and Emperour were very good friends by meanes of the agreement made betwixt them of which wee have spoken already yea in such sort that the Pope sealed it by delivering the body of Christ unto the Emperour By giving unto him saith Sigebert the body and bloud of our Lord Iesus Christ in the celebration of the masse Wee give you this body said hee O Emperour in confirmation of the true peace betwixt me you And for a third answer his personal and particular fault could not prejudice the Empire and his Successours But we have said enough of this point It only remaines that some that can well manage it enter upon this inheritance There will want no right if hee want no forces CHAP. X. Of elections nominations and Investitures belonging to other Kings and Princes 1 WE come now to other Princedomes reserving France to bee spoken of in the last place The twelfth Councel of Toledo grants election of Bishops to the King of Spaine which our Popes have registred in their books It was decreed by all the Bishops of Spaine and Gallicia that without any prejudice to the priviledges of every particular Province it shall be lawful hereafter for the Bishop of Toledo to receive and consecrate all such Bishops as the Royall power shall elect and that every such Bishop shall bee approved by his judgement Which as Lancelot Conrad witnesseth is observed and kept even at this day 2 As for the Kings of England though they have often quarrelled with the Popes and the Clergy of the Kingdome about this point yet so it is that from age to age we alwaies finde them possessed of this right For to goe no higher about the yeare one thousand King Etheldred created one Robert Aâ—chbiâ—shop of London and one Edmund Bishop of Luiddifarne otherwise called Holyland at the entreaty of the Monks of that Bishoprique King Edward made one Robert first Bishop of London c. and afterwards Archbishop of Canterbury whose successour he made one William He gave also the Bishoprique of Shyrburne to one Herman In the year one thousand one hundundred seventie King William the first of that name bestowed the Archbishoprique of Yorke upon a Canon called Thomas In the yeare one thousand seventie eight hee bestowed three Bishopriques upon three of his Chaplaines and many others upon divers Ecclesiastiques 3 In the year one thousand ninety two King William the second bestowed the Bishoprique of Lincolne upon Robert Blunt his Chancelour he bestowed also that of Worcester upon a Canon called Sampson One of the two bestowed also the Bishoprique of Silchester upon Lanfranke 4 The yeare one thousand one hundred and one King Henrie the first bestowed the Bishoprique of Hereford upon Kemelin and gave him the investiture of it The same King gave the bishoprique of Winchester to a Canon called Thuilphus and afterwards to the Chaplaine of Queene Adalida 5 The yeare one thousand one hundred and two Anselme Archbishop of Canterburie would have made the Councell of Lateran to bee received in England holden against Henrie the fifth about the point of Investitures And in obedience thereto he made a difficultie of consecrating certaine Bishops who had beene invested by Henrie the first who was much incensed against him upon that occasion And forasmuch saith Matthew Westminster as hee would not consecrate certaine Bishops who had been instituted by the King obeying his pleasure nor so much as communicate with them the King was thereupon moved with choler against him 6 The yeare one thousand one hundred and seven there was a Councell holden at London where it was ordained That from thence forward no man should be invested in England by the King or any other Lay man into any Bishoprique or Abbey by the donation of the Pastorall staffe or ring alwayes reserving the homage due to the King But Henrie the first did not forbeare to use his right for all that which this Councell could not take from him And indeed in the yeare one thousand one hundred and nine he erected the Abbey of Ely into an Episcopall See and caused one Herveus to be ordained over it and having assembled divers Bishops at London in the same yeare hee made them consecrate one Thomas who had beene chosen Bishop of Yorke In the yeare one thousand one hundred and thirteen The same King Henry bestowed the Archbishoprique of Canterburie upon Richard Bishop of London and invested him in it by giving him the crosier
staffe and ring In the yeare one thousand one hundred twentie five hee bestowed foure Bishopriques more 7 William of Newburie both Doctour of Divinitie and an Historian proves in like manner of King Richard the sonne of Henry the second who raigned about the yeare one thousand one hundred eightie nine First of all saith he this new King was so affected that by his meanes many Churches which were vacant of England were provided of Pastours Richard of Ely the Kings treasurer was preferred to the See of Lincolne Godfrey Lucy to the chaire of Silchester William Longchampe the Kings Chancelour to the Bishoprique of Ely Hubert Deane of Yorke to the Church of Salisbury hee bestowed also the Metropolitan See of Yorke upon his brother Ieffrey 8 The yeare one thousand two hundred and seven Pope Innocent the third would have perswaded the Monkes of Canterburie to chuse one Stephen Langton for their Bishop but they replyed that it was not lawfull for them to doe so without the Kings consent But the Pope having injoyned them under the paine of Anathema they were compell'd to consent unto him so and so though with a great deale of murmuring Which being done the Pope writ unto King Iohn a soothing letter to get him to approve of it But he being offended thereat Commanded that all the Monks should bee drawne out of the Monasterie of Canterburie as guiltie of high treason yea and that they should be chased out of his Kingdome 9 In the yeare one thousand two hundred fortie and five Henrie the third King of England Having received a foule injurie done as he thought both to him and his forasmuch as many Bishops were created in England without his consent hee sent Mr. Lawrence de St. Martins his Proctour to the Court of Rome to make complaint of it and plead the right which hee had thereunto from all antiquitie 10 One Mr. Richard de Witz having beene elected Bishop of Chichester by Innocent the fourth who was then at Lyons To the intent that such an injurie done to the King might not passe unpunished saith an English Historian hee was justly deprived of a Baronrie which belonged to the Bishoprique 'T is true it was restored a long time after by meanes of the earnest intercessions which were made thereupon There are infinit examples of this nature both in these authors from whence wee have taken the former and divers others 11 Wee will here observe that our Popes have elsewhere testified in their owne books how the right of bestowing benefices and Prebends which belongs unto the Kings of England in capite during the vacancie of the Bishoprique This wee read in a Decretall of Alexander the third in these words The said Bishop being deceased and the revenues of the Bishoprique being come unto the Exchequer a certaine Prebend chancing to bee void our wel-beloved sonne in Christ Henrie the illustrious King of England hath bestowed upon Thomas his Clerk This Decretall was extant in the title De jure Patronatus after the chapter Praeterea in the third booke of the Decretals as I have seene in an ancient Manuscript which is in my custodie One of our Doctours witnesseth also that it was anciently there and afterward expunged A learned Spanish Bishop publisht it since by adventure without ever thinking upon it for he had no intention to harme the Pope 12 Our Doctour of the Civil law beare witnesse of the rings of England affirmingâ— that this eight belongs unto them and determining also that it is a thing which may bee done They say as much for the King of Hungary the King of Apulia and also for the King of France See here the verie words of Alexander in his counsels Baldus said well in the law descripta de precib imperat offerend that Kings and secular Princes who by ancient custome time out of minde have power to conferre Prebends and Benefices within their dominions may doe it because such a custome gives them a priviledge And he sets downe a president of the King of Hungarie and the King of England The King of Apulia might be added also according to that remarkable glosse in the summarie of the seventh Quaestion causa 16. Another might be urged of the King of France as saith Iohn the Monke upon the first chapter De Praebendis in sexto 13 See here many authorities together whereunto wee will adde that of Lancelot Conrade Lawyer of Millaine and the King of Spaine his subject who will furnish us with some others So some Kings and Princes saith he may conferre the benefices of their Kingdome when they have got this right either by custome time out of mind or by Apostolicall priviledge as Alexander hath counselled in his 74. Counsel num 8. volum 4. Baldus in the law Rescript C. de precibus imperat offerend Martin Lawrence de Privil Rescript Quaest. 2. Following Alexander he urgeth the examples of the Kings of France England Hungary and Apulia and addâ—s also the King of Spaine hee saith â—urther that the King of France seemes herein to have a greater power and a larger right than the Emperour 14 A German Bishop who writ in the yeare one thousand one hundred and nine addes also the King of Scotland and proves the same of him which hath beene said of the rest We reade saith he of the Bishops of Spaine Scotland England and Hungarie that by ancient institution till this upstart novelty came in were put into their Bishopriques by the Kings with purity and integrity and with peace and quietnesse for temporall matters Afterwards hee speakes of our Kings of France on this manner A long time before the decree of Adrian and his successors the annointed Kings and the Maiors of the Palace invested Bishops Dagobert Sigebert Theodorick Hilderick Pepin Maior of the Palace and Theodoret who established Remachus Andomarus Amandus Antpertus Eligiuâ— Lampertus and other Bishops of most holy life 15 Let us now see what this right of France is It is certaine that from the verie infancie of this Realme our Kings have begunne and continued through all their three lines to elect Churchmen to bestow Bishopriques Abbeyes and other Ecclesiasticall dignities upon them to give these elections to such as they thought good alwaies reserving unto themselves their consent or approbation and to proceed therein such other waies as they thought fit The examples hereof are so plentifull that wee should bee afraid to tyre the reader by reciting them and therefore we will content our selves with quoting them in the margent especially considering that there are so manie other waies to prove it that we care for nothing but curtailing our discourse 16 Whosoever shall seriously consider these examples hee shall finde that our Kings have alwaies dealt herein as they pleased that sometimes they have made elections and nominations themselves sometimes they have given leave to the Clergie to make them either alone or with
whereat the said Archbishop was highly offended in so much that he with other Bishops at the Synod of Estampes were upon the point of revoking the said consecration made by the Pope as prejudiciall to the authoritie Royal. See here what the same Bishop saith of it in a letter to Pope Vrban Moreover I give your Holinesse to wit that the Archbishop of Sens being infatuated by the counsell of the Bishop of Paris having summoned the said Bishop of Paris and two others of the same humor to wit he of Meaux and he of Troyes did very indiscreetly accuse me this present year because of the consecration which I had received from you saying that I had offended against the Kings Majesty by attempting to receive my consecration from the See Apostolique We have heard before what this same Bishop said of Investitures speaking of the King of France 26 We may now conclude that elections nominations and approbations in point of benefices have alwaies belonged unto our Kings and have beene at their free disposall By their last ordinances they have beene pleas'd as well to disburthen themselves of that charge as also to prevent the enterprises of the Popes to decree that elective dignities should bee conferr'd by elections and benefices which were not elective by the collations and presentations of the Collators and Patrons And this according to the Councell of Basilâ— which hath tied the Popes hands in this respect and the Pragmatique Sanctions of St. Lewes and Charles the seventh Yet this was still with two conditions one that the Kings Congé d'elire should bee requir'd by way of preamble at least in respect of Bishopriques and Abbeyes otherwise the election should be accounted a nullitie Which is verified by the letters of our Kings as farre as King Lewes the eleventh containing the said licence which may yet be found in the treasurie of Chartres in a great box quoted xxv Which right was declared to belong to King Philip the Faire when the question was about Saint Maglairs Abbey as some report 27 The other that the said Prelates before they could be called such should be bound to take the oath of allegiance according to the ancient custome as it was determin'd by the Arrests of the Parliament of Paris against the Archbishop of Anx and the Bishop of Mantes Which was observed in the time of Philip the first according to the testimonie of the Bishop of Chartres who in his epistles addressed to Pope Paschal speaking of the Archbishop of Rhemes who had beene depriv'd of his dignitie and for whose reestablishment the said Bishop had interceded to the Kings Councell The Princes Court saith he inclining to the contrary we could not obtaine an entire peace unlesse the said Metropolitan would make unto the King such an oath of allegiance as other Archbishops of Rhemes together with all the rest of the Bishops of this Realme of France how holy and religious soever they were made to the Kings his predecessors Divers authors beare witnesse of this oath of allegiance made by Bishops to their kings and princes both in England and France and other places some of them set downe the very forme 28 Since this time our kings have beene compell'd to divide their rights with the Popes to give them content and be at peace with them by taking away elections and reserving unto themselves in stead thereof the nominations and allowing unto Popes the confirmations By the ordinance of Orleans King Charles would have taken the Clergie and people in to his share by decreeing that when Bishopriques fell void the Archbishop and Bishops of the Province and the Canons of the Cathedral Church should meet togther with twelve gentlemen chosen by the Nobilitie of the Dioces twelve Bâ—rgesses chosen in the Guildhal of the Archiepiscopal or Episcopal Citie to make he a nomination of three persons of which the King should chuse one whom he pleased to name Which notwithstanding we never yet saw observed 29 Wee will say for conclusion that it is no small advantage to the Pope to have the confirmation of the Bishops of France which was granted him by the Concordat but it will bee farre greater yet if he keepe that authoritie which is given him by this Councel For by it hee will quickly bring all these Concordats to nothing and wil resume the extravagancies of his predecessors who had got all the elections and collations of the Bishopriques and benefices of this Kingdome into their Churches to the utter ruine and destruction of it draining the Realme of moneyes and filling it with strangers and bringing it to an extreame miserie as we say else where 30 We shall only here observe the particular interest of Kings and Princes for as much as concernes their power and authoritie whereof they ought to be very jealous if they marke it There is nothing which fortifies it so much as that right which they have to chuse and elect Churchmen nor which weakneth it so much as when the Pope hath an hand in it either in whole or in part Ivo Pishop of Chartres although hee had received his Investiture from Philip the first yet in asmuch as he had got his confirmation from Pope Vrban he was alwaies affectionate to him and the See Apostolique even to the prejudice of the King and Kingdome to whom he did sometimes very ill offices as wee collect from some of his epistles On the contrarie because Lupus had got the Abbey of Saint Peter de Ferriers in the Dioces of Sens by the donation of Charles the Bald he was alwaies loyall and he even brags of it in one of his Epistles 31 An English Historian though hee bee a Monke yet hee knew well how to set out this interest of Princes For speaking of the consecration of certaine Bishops of England made by Innocent the fourth when he was at Lions hee saith They were consecrated by the Pope not without great damage and danger to the Realme of England For the Pope having so ingaged the Bishops unto him they found themselves more obliged unto him and despising the King they were more inclined to doe mischiefe to the Kingdome 32 The Bishop of Chartres continuing his devotion to Pope Vrban gave him notice of this point upon the election of an Archbishop of Rhemes who he assured the Pope was very zealous for the See Apostolique adding afterwards Now how necessarie it is for the Church of Rome to place in that See a minister which is devout and affectionate unto her it is not for me to informe your wisedome which knowes very well that this See weares the Royall Diademe and serves for a patterne almost to all other Churches of France either of ruine or Resurrection 33 Not without cause did Pope Nicholas the first stomach at Lotharius because he would not suffer any Bishop to bee chosen in his Kingdome unlesse hee were faithfull and well inclined to
him King William the first of England in the beginning of his reigne which was about the yeare 1070 knowing this very well deposed some part of the Bishops and Abbats from their dignities and Prelacies and put others in their places whose fidelitie was known unto him 34 Another Monke and English Historian saith the Popes upon this occasion invented another way to oblige such Prelats unto them as held their dignities from Kings and Princes Which was by making them renounce them and resigne them into their hands as faultie and nullities and taking them with one hand they gave them againe with the other Ivo toucheth upon this tricke in his epistles For amongst other reasons to prove that investiture is no heresie hee puts this If Investiture were an heresie hee that renounceth it could not be restor'd without blemish to himselfe Now wee see many honest men both in Germany and Franceâ— give up their Pastorall staffes to wash away that staine by some shew of satisfaction and resume those Investitures which they had renounced from the Apostolique hand So did Thomas the Archbishop of Canterburie who put Henry the second King of England to so much trouble For being at the Councel of Tours Hee secretlie resigned that Archbishoprique into the Popes hands which he had received from the Kings hand and it was afterwards restor'd him againe at the same instant from the Popes hand It was Alexander the third who held this Councell at Tours in the year 1163. A REVIEW OF THE COVNCELL OF TRENT BOOKE VI. CHAP. I. Of things attributed to the Pope by this Councell in matter of justice And first of criminall causes of Bishops 1 WEE will treat in this Booke of Iustice and Iurisdiction and wil make it clearly appear that this Councel hath as far as it was able robb'd Kings Princes and other Clergie men of them to bestow them upon the Pope It is a most true Maxime that all Iurisdictions do spring from secular Princes that the source and fountaine of them is hereditarie to them whence the rivulets are derived upon their officers and upon Ecclesiasticall persons and others whom they thinke good Clergie men from the greatest to the least have no coactive jurisdictions but such as spring from thence Kings and Emperours have parted with it and have honoured them with it but in such sort as some of them both did and doe abuse it daily They are come so farre as to contest with their officers to attempt against them to make laws for extending the traine of their robes further yea even to subdue unto themselves those from whom they received that power and by a most unsufferable ingratitude to declare and pretend them subject to their jurisdiction All this is proved by us elsewhere Wee will onely say here that this Councell â—â—â—h gone about as it were to lay at the Popes feet all the spoiles and conquests which all other Bishops have got from those victories obtained by them â—t divers times over the temporall Iurisdiction and over those to whom it belongs and to paire also that which is left unto them making it almonst unserviceable and invalid at least for as much as concernes the Pope and his Clergie whom it totally exempts from their Iurisdiction 2 We shall make it appeare plainly that this Councell hath dealt very liberally with the Pope in this respect and that it hath strain'd it selfe to confirme his usurpations yea even to augment them without sparing any thing First of all it attributes to the Pope the cognizance and judgement of all criminall causes of Bishops except pettie ones That the Pope onely have the cognizance and decision of all criminall causes which are more hainoâ—s objected against Bishops and even of heresie which God forbid But if the cause be such as it must necessarily be tried out of the Court of Rome let it not bee committed to any persons excepting such Metropolitans or Bishops as the Pope shall chuse That this commission be in speciall and sealed with the Popes hand and that hee never give them any greater power but onely to receive the bare instruction for matter of fact and to make the processe which they shall forthwith send to the Pope the definitive sentence being alwayes reserv'd unto the Pope 3 In another decree it is ordained That the causes of Bishops when by reason of the quality of the crime which is objected unto them they ought to make appearance be brought before our holy Father the Pope and be determined by him It is also decreed against Bishops that keepe concubines That if they doe not abstaine from that crime after they have beene admonished by the Provinciall Councell they shall bee complained of to the Pope by the same Councell who shall punish them according to the quality of their offence even by deprivation if need require So that a Provinciall Councell hath no power to condemne a Bishop for criminall matters save onely for Peccadillo's such as we may say for playing at ball for getting up late in a morning and such like things 4 Now wee say on the contrarie that the cognizance of such crimes belongs to Emperors and Kings That they themselves ofttimes have proceeded to judgement That they have assembled Councels for that end and have assisted and presided there That sometimes they have committed the same judgement to the said Councels or their Iudges That Popes themselves have become petitioners unto them yea plaintives before them and which is more have themselves beene judged by them 5 The Bishops of the Nicenâ— Councel acknowledge Constantine for their Iudge when they presented their Libels unto him wherein they accused one another hee blush'd at that in their behalfe and would have covered their shame by suppressing such Investitures using this honest shiâ—t to them that they could not be judged by any man In which the Pope alone tooke him at his word although hee were absent and hath made good use of it afterwards Now that Constantine said this by way of complement and to suppresse those dishonorable quarrels appears from hence that upon other occasions hee either tooke the judgement upon himselfe in the causes of Bishops or committed it to his Officers Hee made the Bishops of the Synod of Tyre to come unto him to render a reason of their â—act in the condemnation of Athanasius And after hee had heard them confirmed their sentence being moved so to doe by the testimony of false witnesses which were subborn'd and sent Athanasius unto banishments into Tryer a citie in Gallia Belgica 6 The same Emperour after hee had twice ordain'd Ecclesiasticall judges to determine the cause of Cecilianus an Orthodox Bishop at last he himselfe tooke it into his cognizance and gave the finall sentence So say the Clergy of Hippo in Africa in that epistle which St. Augustine made upon the same occasion and sent to Ianuarius Being so stricken in age as you