discern the fine-spun threds by which those opinions are sown together I beleeve they would reject them both for their contiguity sake Much lesse doe I by any or all of this invite a secular arm with it's iron mace to crush and subdue the one or the other For my part I shall call for neither Hammer Sword nor Fire against them but the sacred Scripture which is compared to all these Let him cry Murther Jer. 23. 29. Apoc. 2. 1â— Ephes 6. 17. and call for a Constable to keep the peace at a dispute who is impatient of contradiction and accounts his own principles ruined by another mans dissenting from him Meek and innocent truth sufficiently contenteth him in whom it dwels though it meets with opposition from him that knows it not And I would expect to see his flesh come like the flesh of a young childe that is once baptized in the Jordan thereof when he that is seven times dipt in the Pharpar of corporall punishment shall goe away in his errour a leper as white as snow And much more should I rejoyce to rescue one poor soul in gentlenesse and love out of the prison of a corrupt opinion then keep all the hereticks under heaven in the ward where Pharaohs prisoners are bound till their feet are hurt in the stocks and the iron enter into their soul I have but a little to adde concerning him * M. Oates whose Sermon at Terling occasioned this confutation and I have done The small acquaintance I have of him enables me to describe him under this character He is a man of many lovely and desirable parts naturally fitted to do much good but thorow dangerous misapprehensions of the satisfaction which Christ hath made to his Father on the behalf of sinners so desperately corrupted and in a way as smooth as butter and oil able to convey the same to others as he is thereby apt to deceive and delude all the silly souls he meets with and with such together with those that are unstable our County and I fear the Kingdom abounds as the naturall effect of the brooding and warmth of the feathers of implicite faith and blinde obedience scarce yet out of fashion though much pluckt off by the hand of light and truth eminently encouraged by our prosperous and pious Parliament If my love to and pity of wandering souls did not exact from me these expressions so contrary doe I finde them to the constitution of my minde as I should be ashamed to see them under my Name The Apology that I make for my self in this case is That he that would avoid sharp rebuke must learn to be sound in the faith I hope I have wrote out of the eye of envy and disdain unlesse some Pharisee should take offence for whom I take no care because every plant that my heavenly Father hath not planted shall be rooted up I would not willingly tread upon one good flower but I care not how many briers and thorns I walk over so as my feet be but well shod with the preparation of the Gospel of peace Let him that hath an ear hear what the Spirit saith to the Churches And that God would give us understanding in all things is the prayer of Thy Brother and Companion in tribulation and in the patience and Kingdome of Jesus Christ John Maidstone The Contents PART I. Anasceuastique and Polemicall 1. SAmuel Oates A Seminary-seducer p. 1 2. 1. His Interpretation of the mans selling all to buy the field to be Christs parting with all for the Redemption of the whole bulk of mankinde detected and rejected p. 2. 2. His Observations upon the Parable of the Treasure observed as impertinent p. 5. 3. His main Doctrine examin'd and found false p. 6 c. 4. His Reasons so called disproved p. 21. And his Arguments so called disarmed p. 25. 5. Other Passages in his Sermon stopt p. 27. 6. His Uses despoiled and rendred uselesse p. 29. In particular 1. His Consequences tried and cut off Ib. 2. His Comfort to carnall men found a carnall comfort p. 35. 3. His Exhortation examined and condemned 37 2. Antidotes or Counter-poison wrought up with ten Ingredients p. 38. 3. A Doubt whether Christ by his bloud did not purchase the world of creatures and common benefits for all men answered three waies p. 42. And resolved negatively by six Demonstrations p. 44. 4. An Objection about the threatning Gen. 2. 17. not executed answered seven waies p. 45. See more p. 69. 5. That from the simile of the Chaffe bought with the Wheat answered p. 51. 6. Paulus Testardus his darling Tenet related p. 52 And refuted by the discovery of His 1 Inconsistencies 1. With the Scripture in his four shores whereby he would support universall Redemption as 1. Generall Intention of Christs death not the Scripture-intention shewed five waies p. 54. 2. General-Covenant not the Scripture Covenant of grace evidenced 5 ways 58 3. Universall Calling to Christ and grace by the creatures opposed by Scripture and 4 reasons p. 61 62 His Scriptures produced for it answered p. 64. His 7 pleas for its agreement with the call of the Word which I bring in as Objections enervated p. 68. Objection from the calling of men by the Word answered three waies p. 76. 4. Universall grace not the Scripture grace of our Lord Jesus Christ evinced by two main Reasons p. 78. The Result drawn up p. 80. 2. With himself shewed in 8 instances p. 83. 2. Conspiracy with Arminius in three main heterodoxies against the truth p. 91 7. The close of the controversall part with a few positive Arguments Demonstrating 1. That the Decree of Election is in order of nature before the decree of Redemption 93 2. That Redemption by the death of Christ is solely and only of and for the elect as a fruit of their Election p. 94. PART II. Catasceuastique and Practicall 1. The true Scope and Orthodox sense of the two Parables of the Treasure and the Pearl p. 98. 2. The Doctrines raised according to the scope opened also confirmed and applied are seven Doct. 1. Christ and his Gospel-grace is a precious hidden Treasure p. 104. Doct. 2. Even Gods elect as others for a time they wander after some or other imaginary mediums and waies of soul-enrichment and contentment p. 117 Doct. 3. In Gods good time his elect prevented with his love and light are drawn te beleeve the certain attainablenesse of Christ and his grace for themselves p. 123. Doct 4. The true beleever having found Christ in a promise doth in a gracious manner hide him and lay him up p. 132. Doct. 5. The true Christian hath some joy yea the conceptions of great joy in his finding of the Lord Jesus Christ p. 141. Doct. 6. The joy of a true beleever worketh him to utmost self-denial p. 149. Doct. 7. Thorow self-denial brings forth such diligence as whereby the true Christian groweth up to a firm assurance and clear evidence
founded in him but in the seed of the woman the Lord Jesus nor is Adams enmity with Satan and reconciliation with God there mentioned but only the womans and her seed partly exprest partly implied 3. All died as they sinned in Adam before this promise but the promise is not made of or to all mankinde who died vertually in him only of and to the woman is it spoken and her seed the principall whereof should be the redeemer and the rest of her seed the redeemed ones of the Lord between whom and the old Serpent Satan and his seed there should be irreconcilable enmity 4. If you would know who and who only and what number they are for whom if you speak of the certain individuals the Lamb was a ransome from the beginning you must wait till the Lambs book of life be opened of which we read Revel 13. 8. and 17. 8. where plainly you may learn That 1. He was not slain for any first or last but for such whose names are in his book 2. Comparing those Texts with Rev. 13. 3. there are a world of people whose names are not written in his book therefore not slain in the Arminian sense for all the world nor must this last place in Timothy nor any of the former be so understood We have now done with the Scriptures alleadged and abused by him and vindicated by us which I desire you to hold fast in the true sense not in a perverted interpretation these were his out-works which we have taken and possesse we them for the Truth Come we at length to batter down the enemies Forts and strong-holds of his carnall-reasonings and confident arguments Two Reasons and two Arguments were brought to prove his Doctrine That Christ gave himself for the whole world Now such as have studied Logick or artificiall reasoning know no difference between Reasons and Arguments for it they be Reasons and do not argue they are irrationall Reasons and if they be Arguments without reason they are unreasonable Arguments But to follow him in his own method and to deal with him at his own weapon If we have taken the Scriptures out of his mouth we shall not doubt but to take his weaponâ— of Reason and Argument out of his hand or leave him a bare Sceleton of reason without flesh or substance much lesse having any soul or life of faith or divine truth in his assertions And first of the two Reasons Reason 1. Reasons disproved The whole harmony of the Scriptures such as he had proved his point withall are they not enough and do they not sound all one way Answ 1. Call to minde every of those Scriptures but remember their sense as well as their sound He is a foolish man who thinkes as the bell tinks Nor yet do the Scriptures give an uncertain sound but in opening and examining of them with the context and scope and with other Scriptures you hear with one consent they speak not absolutely of Christs dying for all but of and for such an all and such a world as is the all and the whole world of believers elect Gods people his true Israel some of all sorts of people out of all Nations some 2. Search and consult with other Scriptures which neither he nor I have yet mention'd and you will be more fully convinc't that we have the truth with us and that this Doctrine of Christs dying for the whole bulk of men is another Gospel from that which Christ and his Apostles or we from them have ever preached I shall instance but in three places the first in Joh. 15. 10. Greater love hath no man then this that a man lay down his life for his friends and presently to shew whom he laid down his life for he addeth v. 11. Ye are my friends c. It is most true what the Apostle saith Rom. 5. 10. When we were enemies we were reconciled to God by the death of his Sonne But 1. What We meaneth he there Not all men but such as are justified by faith and have peace with God by faith v. 1. 2. Though the elect of God are enemies as considered in themselves and in their naturall estate yet being loved of God from eternity with the love of good pleasure they have a price laid down for them by Christs death to bring them under the love of friendship and when they do actually believe they are actually reconciled and of enemies are made friends so that Christ laid down his life for such as were in Gods choice and love his friends and by Christs death and the fruits of it brought into a state of actuall friendship A second follows John 10. 15. And I lay down my life for the sheep whom in the verse precedent he had called his sheep See here I beseech you ye that love the truth and love not to be seduced though that is a weak property of sheep to wander yet if you be Christs sheep hear the voice of the good shepherd and not of strangers for whom doth Christ himself say that he died he best knows and is only able to resolve this doubt why if you will believe him who is truth it self I lay down my life for my sheep he doth not say for goats at all but for the sheep behold and hearken after the harmony 'tween this and the fore-alleadged Scriptures certainly where Christ or his Apostles speak in larger tearms of all and world and whole world must not these tearms be limited to Christs sheep It was a subtill counsel your new Lecturer gave you that other Scriptures which he cited in the second place as but favouring his opinion should be expounded by the positive Scriptures but be you as wise as he was subtle and learn to reduce all his positive Scriptures which yet had Synecdoches in them of the whole for a part or of the generall for the speciall to and by this main Position of our Lord a fundamentall truth Let this be first laid down I lay down my life for my sheep and whosoever shall after so plain a foundation laid by Christ himself in his Word and by his Spirit in your hearts teach universall Redemption or Christs dying for the bulk of mankinde tell him he doth nothing else but build hay and stubble upon the foundation nay he doth yet more wickedly even lay another foundation with Christ or besides his purpose A third and last is in these words Ioh. 17. 19. For their sakes I sanctifie my self Christs sanctifying himself is his preparation for death setting himself apart to die for whom for their sakes his eleven Apostles not Iudas v. 12. and for those which should and shall believe on him through the Apostles doctrine this is not for the sake of all men that he so much as prepares to die much lesse that he died for them for whom he fitted not himself to die in their behalf So as you see to make up the harmony and consent
and ineffectually called but as called and that effectually and according to purpose And so this Heretick is forc't being 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 convinc't and condemn'd in himself as I gather by this Use to apply his comfort to the elect alone and to that end quoted the 2. of Col. 2. The Apostles praier for them that they might have the full assurance of understanding which he interpreted to be That they might see their particular assurance of life in a generall promise and not their generall assurance in a particular promise for we desire no more then a particular and personall assurance in and from a generall promise such as Pauls 1. Tim. 1. 15. and yet this generall is not so universall as that Christ died for all the world of men But not hurting us in all this Use of Comfort hitherto at last he thought he would strike home and wound us deeply with this blow A man may preach seven years of particular Redemption and not comfort a distressed conscience to which I say two things 1. What means he by a distressed conscience a childe of light walking in darknesse or a childe of darknesse blowing up the sparks of his own fire-sticks but almost smothered and stifled with the smoke thereof 2. We preach a choice and speciall Redemption in a generall offer to what sinner soever that is distressed and will be directed As Paul Believe and thou shalt be saved and Act. 16. immediately the Jailor is comforted he staied not seven years for it His third Use was To teach us abundance of love to Examination of his third Uâ—e Christ Answ I demand whom he means by us if the people of God and the elect and believers how is this a direct inference from Christs buying the whole world if all men be meant by us how shall they love who doe not believe but if he understood Gods peculiar people because he mention'd the Spouse afterwards no wonder her love is so carried after her espoused husband Christ let him know that the hearts of the Saints are touched and taken with the speciall love of Christ it is that which constrains them to love him in a speciall manner and that the more abundantly because they know in part and shall yet further know Christ died for them not only out of a generall love which he bears to mans nature but out of a speciall and singular love which he bears to their persons and to theirs onely Thus have we followed his Counsell to search the Scriptures and we finde them of weight for speciall Redemption and love but weighing the man and his Doctrine and Uses too of universall Redemption we have found them too light Let me but adde a few Arguments as Antidotes against the poyson which some of you may have suck't in of late and preservatives from the infection of this hereticall tenet of Christs buying the world of men and dying for them all and we have done with the Anasceuastique part of our discourse which tends to the weakning ruine and destruction Antidotes or Counter poison of so grand an errour First Gods Attributes are hereby wronged and scandalized as 1. Gods power is called into Question as if a generall benefit were merited by Christ which by reason of mans wickednesse he cannot apply 2. His wisdome is eclipsed for it puts upon him such an intention as yet by proper and direct means he attains not unto 3. His justice is rendered unjust for he receiveth a full satisfaction of his Sonne for all men and yet neither first nor last receiveth them into the favour of communion and friendship 4. His highest love is undervalued for it holds forth Gods love to give his Sonne but not so as to give them faith for whom he gave his Sonne and it speaks of Christs sweating and dying for them whom yet he lets die and perish in their sins Secondly If he died for all then he died in their stead and as their surety he discharged the whole debt and so it is not only unjust but impossible that any should perish here the Remonstrants Arminians so calling themselves at the Hague conference had a subtle distinction of Christs dying Non loco vice omnium not in the room and stead of all sed bono tantum but for their good only whereas the Scriptures which own not such a distinction hold out Christ as dying in the room and stead of sinners that they might not die eternally but live for ever so is a 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Rom. 5. 6. b 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 where 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is as much as 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and so rendered Philem. v. 13 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that in tâ—y stead in another case and about the Question in hand the word in 1 Tim. 2. 6 is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a ransome in the room and stead of all or pro onnis ordinis electis which compared with Mat 20 28. is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for many and but for many indivduals or in stead of many singulars chosen of God one choice-singular-Jesus suffered 1 Pet. 3. 18. and other places to be understood Christ died for the wicked that is in their stead The just in the room of the unjust The good the all or any of the benefits that comes from Christs death floweth from this that he suffered in the room of those who have that good and benefit by his death and if as themselves acknowledge he died not in the room and stead of all they weave but a spiders web to say it was for their good how can the surety do the debtour any good if he neither be bound in his stead nor paies the debt in his room Thirdly If he died for all he rose again for all ascended sits at Gods right-hand and makes intercession for all for the Scriptures joyn his death and resurrection together Rom. 4. ult and his death ascension sitting interceding with the Father all together Rom. 8. 34. and more particularly with his intercession 1 Joh. 2. 1 2. and if so that he riseth ascendeth sits and pleads for all he is either heard or not heard for all if heard for all then all must be saved if not heard for all then Christ intercedeth in vain and the Father doth not hear him alwaies crosse to Scripture Joh. 11. 42. Fourthly This loose opinion puts all that hold it upon such distinctions as have no ground from Scripture but are contrary to it as 1. That but even now named or refuted of loco and bono not in stead of all but for the good of all 2. That of impetration and application which the Gospel holds forth as inseparable acts of Christs mediation to whom Christs death is or shall be applied for them he obtained remission of sinnes and for whom he did impetrate to them he applieth Isa 53. 11. Joh. 10. 15 28. Heb. 9. 12 15. Yea the Apostle inferreth
Christ The o 1 Cor. 2. 14. naturall man 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is not capable of them 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 nor is he able to know the things of the Gospel and of the Spirit because as the Apostle saith They are spiritually discerned 2. Not commonly known or but known of a few in every age that are Gods elect at what time God makes out the discovery in the Gospel insomuch as the Prophet admireth their paucity and complaineth of their slender company p Isa 53. 1. Lord who hath beleeved our report and to whom is the arm of the Lord revealed 3. Never known of reprobates Gospel-treasure is ever hid to them though Apostles open and unfold it q 2 Cor. 4. 3. If grant it our Gospel be hid it is hid to them that are lost 4. Known of the elect Preachers and beleevers but r 1 Cor. 13 9. in part though their knowledge is a growing knowledge yet as something is more made known something is ever hidden 5. Known but in a * 1 Cor. 2. 7. 1 Cor 13. 12. mystery while here and through a Glasse and in a Riddle in comparison of what shall be seen face to face and understood plainly as speech is when it is uttered in proper and plain expressions Then shall the riches of Christ be told over cast and summed up and we shall know the perfect value that it amounts unto but here while we preach and you hear of this riches all is Å¿ Ephes 3. 8. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 unsearchable beyond the search and reach of all humane learning naturall wit or spirituall understanding to trace or finde out Christ and Gospel-treasure is hid in the Scripture-field or 2 Where hid in that part of the Word which is called the Gospel or the Covenant of grace and the many great and precious promises which are as a field 1. For the large and spatious ground the Gospel t Tit. 1. 2 3. 2 Pet. 1. 4. promises are capacious and carty in the womb of them all the excellency and worth of Christ all the precious pardons and graces all the hopes comforts and assurances of a Christians heaven upon earth and in heaven 2. For the limiting hedge and boundary the promises were first made to Christ and all of them are Gal. 3. 16. 2 Cor. 1. 20. yea and Amen in him to them that are Christs and are in Christ Christ and all his grace is wrapt up in promises a promise cannot be had without Christ nor Christ out of a promise Now Christ and all his worth is hid in the Gospel-promises in a two-fold consideration 1. Till they be opened therefore x Luk. 24. 27. the Lord began at Moses and all the Prophets and expounded to the two Disciples in all the Scriptures the things concerning himself And the Apostle y Rom. 16. 25 26. tels the Romans and us that mystery was kept secret in the Scriptures of the Prophets which now by the preaching of Jesus Christ is made manifest for the obedience of faith 2. Till our understandings be opened which our Lord z Luk. 14. 45 46. did for the Disciples many of them together Then opened he their understandings saith the Text that they might understand the Scriptures The Scriptures about Christ may be opened long enough and clear enough and yet he lieth there unseen till mens eyes be opened and cleared but there he is and precious is that field of Scripture-promises which hideth and holdeth such a treasure Let this Doctrine of the full Treasure and fair Pearl of rich price hid and wrapt up in full and precious promises 1 Use of instruction and conviction serve for the full conviction of those who question the fulnesse of Christ and Gospel-grace or when they are told of it prize it not and slight the Word and Ministery where it is to be found Three sorts are here to be informed and convinced about the weaknesse of their judgements and affections and oÌ„ that they might be cured as discovered First Such who doubt of the all-sufficiency of Christ and Gospel-grace for their poorsouls they acknowledge not nay they see not enough in that which is preached and offered to them for their justification and pardon or for their sanctification and qualification for heaven Now what is that you have heard of in these Parables was it not of a treasure and a treasure that hath all the fulnesse of God and of his Spirit above measure in him and is not here enough for thee and the filling up of thy empty soul 1. In the want of a justifying righteousnesse to take off thy guilt and fears of death be convinced there is more righteousnesse in one Lord Jesus Christ then guilt in all the sinfull sons of Adam if thou hadst sinned from Adam to this day above 5500. years sinning for length of time and besides the guilt of that first sinne hadst the guilt of the greatest sins upon thee that ever were committed and in every act of sin hadst come near the sin against the holy Ghost that sin excepted which yet thou art not fallen into there is fulnesse of righteousnesse and forgivenesse for thee or any sinner that doth or shall beleeve which cannot but overcome and break an heart full of unbelief for and from it were it seriously weighed and considered 2. In the want of sanctification and good frame of heart and life All treasures of wisdome holinesse strength are in this one Treasure to supply thy emptinesse and enrich thy poverty Yea there is that in Christ which will enable thee to sell all thou hast to buy himself the pearl and Gospel-treasure with Christ will put money in thy purse if thou wilt accept him and it to make sure of him for thine for he is the Authour and finisher of faith and of all that appertain to faith not beleeving therefore of Christs sufficiency will be inexcusable Secondly Such as do not prize this Gospel-treasure and Pearl of great price I beleeve let Arminians old and new â—eâ—ch what they will by a policy and stratagem of Satan to draw off mens eyes from looking upon Christ our treasure in this Text yet so brightly hath the light shined by the true Application of it unto Christ and his grace that even many a naturall conscience is enlightned and convinc't that it is meant of him as the treasure of treasures and the pearl of pearls but here now is the sin of these persons that their wils and affections are not carried after Christ nay something yet in their judgements is better then Christ for them and prefer'd before him in their fancies Is it not so with many here and every where As the a Rom. 1. Gentiles of old withheld the light of nature and truths of God in unrighteousnesse imprison'd and â—nother'd it and did not glorifie God according to the knowledge they had of him So the Gentiles or