Truth and Mistery calculated contrived and framed by God with a singular aptnesse and choicenesse of ingredients for the advancement of Godlinesse in the world therefore what particular Doctrine is of the same Spirit tendency and import must needs be a naturall branch thereof and bath perfect accord with it this Proposition then it unquestionable Ans. According to the principles formerly laid downe I have something to say though not to the proposition it selfe § 3. as in the termes it lyeth but only as to the fixednesse and stayednesse of it that it may not be a nose of max to be turned to and fro at every ones pleasure to serve their turnes for what sort of men is there in the world professing the name of Christ that do not lay claime to an intrest in this Proposition for the confirmation of their Opinions It is but as a Common Exordium in Rethoricke a uselesse flourish The Doctrine which is according to Godlinesse that is which the Scripture teacheth to be true and to serve for the promotion of Godlinesse not what Doctrine soever any darke brainesicke Creature doth apprehend so to do in the state and Condition wherein the Saints of God walke with him is a branch of the Gospell I adde in the state and condition wherein we walke with God for in the state of innocency the Doctrine of the Law as a Covenant of Life was of singular aptnesse and usefulnesse to promote Obedience which yet is not therefore any branch or part of the Gospell but opposite to it and destructive of it All the advantage then Mr Goodwin can expect from this Argument to his cause dependeth upon the proofe of the minor Proposition which also must be effected in aswerable proportion to the restrictions and qualifications given to the Major or the whole will be void and of none effect That is he must prove it by the Testimony of God to be according to Godlinesse and not give us in by a pure begging of the thing in Question that it is so in his Apprehesion and according to the principles whereon he doth proceed in the teaching and asserting of Godlinesse Mr Goodwin knowes that there is no lesse difference btween him and us about the nature and causes of Godlinesse then there is aboute the Perseverance of the Saints and therefore his asserting any Doctrine to be suited to the promotion of Godlinesse that Assertion being proportioned to his other Hypothesis of his owne wherein we accord not with him and in particular to his notions of the causes and nature of Godlinesse with which conceptions of his we have no communion it cannot be of any weight with us unlesse he prove his affirmation according to the limitations before expressed Now this he attempteth in the words following What Doctrine saith he can there be more proper and powerfull to promote Godlinesse §. 4. in the hearts and lives of men then that which on the one hand promiseth a crowne of Blessednesse and eternall Glory to those that live Godlily without declining and on the other hand threatneth the vengeance of Hell fire eternally against those that shall turne aside into profanenesse and not returne by repentance whereas the Doctrine which promiseth and that withall possible certainty and assurance all fulnesse of Blessednesse and Glory to those that shall at any time be Godly though they shall the very next day or hour degenerate and turne loose and profane and continue never so long in such a course is most manifestly destructive to Godlinesse and encouraging above measure unto profanenesse Ans. There are two parts of this Discourse the one 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or confirmatory of his owne Thesis §. 5. the other 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or destructive of that which he opposeth For the first it is upon the matter all that he produceth for the confirmation of his Minor Proposition wherein any singular concernement of his opinion doth lye Now that being in a sould sence the common Inheritance of all that professe the Truth under what deceits or mistakes soever the summe of what is here insisted on is that the Doctrine he maintaineth concerning the possibility of the Saints defection promiseth a crowne to them that continue in Obedience and threatneth vengeance of fire to them that turne to profanenesse which taken as a proofe of his former assertion is lyable to some small exceptions As 1. That this doth not at all prove the Doctrine to be a branch or parcell of the Gospell it being is it standeth severally by it selfe the pure tenor of the Covenant of Workes which we confesse to have been of singular importance for the propagation of Godlinesse Holinesse in them to whom it was given or with whom it was made being given and made for that very end and and purpose but that this alone by its selfe is a peculiar branch or parcell of the Gospell or that it is of such singular importance for the carrying on of Gospell-Obedience as so by it selfe proposed that should here have been proved 2. As it is also a part of the Gospell declaring the Faithfulnesse of God and the End and Issue of the proposall of the Gospell unto men and of their receiving or refusing of it so it is altogether forraigne to the Doctrine of Mr Goodwin under contest he might as well have said that the Doctrine of Apostacy is of singular import for the promotion of Holinesse because the Doctrine of Justification by Faith is so for what force of consequence is betwixt these two that God is a rewarder of them that Obey him and a punisher of them that rebell against him is an incentive to Obedience therefore the Doctrine that true Believers united to Jesus Christ may utterly fall out of the Favour of God and turne from their Obedience and be damned for ever there being no Promise of God for their preservation is also an incentive to Holinesse 3. What virtue soever there may be in this truth for the furtherance and promotion of Holinesse in the world our Doctrine laieth as cleare claime to it as yours that is there is not any thing in the least in it inconsistent therewith all we grant God threateneth the vengeance of Hell fire unto those that turne aside from their profession of Holinesse into profanenesse the Gospell it selfe becoming thereby unto them a savour of death unto death the Lord thereby proclaiming to all the world that the wages of sinne and infidelity is death and that he that believeth not shall be damned but that any thing can hence be inferred for the Apostacie of true Believers or how this assertion cometh to be appropriated to that Doctrine we see not The latter part of this Discourse § 6. whereby its Author aimeth to exclude the Doctrine hitherto asserted by us from any claime laid to usefulnesse for the promotion of Godlinesse is either a mistake of it through ignorance of the opinion he hath undertaken to
with a farther opening of his mind as to what he had last spoken of The world the world being vile wretched deceitfull and set upon Opposition against them a man would have thought that the Lord Jesus should have desired that his Saints might be taken out from the midst of this world and set in a quiet place by themselves where they might no more be troubled with the baits and oppositions of it But this is not that which he requests he hath another worke for them to do in the world they are to beare witnesse to him and his Truth by their Faith and Obedience to convince the wicked unbelieving world They are to Glorifie his name by doing and suffering for him so that this is no part of his request I pray not saith he that thou shouldest take them out of the world but that they may not be prevailed on nor conquered by the evill that is in the world That they may be kept and preserved from the power of evill which would separate them from me and my Love This he presseth for and this he is heard in and that not only for his Apostles and present followers but as he tells you v. 20. for all that should believe on him to the end of the world The things prayed for the Reason of his Intercession the opposition against the accomplishment of the things interceded for the distinction put between them for whom he Intercedes and the perishing world all delivered in plaine and expresse termes evidently evince the intendment of Christ in his Intercession evidently to regard the safeguarding of Believers in the Love and Favour of God by their continuance in Believing and preservation from the Power of temptations and oppositions arising against their Perseverance in communion with God The result of what hath been spoken §. 5. as to its influence into the confirmation of the Truth under Demonstration amounts unto thus much That which the Lord Jesus Christ as Mediator requesteth and prayeth for continually of the Father according to his mind in order to the Accomplishment of the Promises made to him and Covenant with him all his desires being bottomed upon his exact perfect performance of the whole will of God both in doing and suffering that shall certainly be accomplisht and brought to passe But thus in this manner upon these accounts doth the Lord Jesus intercede for the Perseverance of Believers and their Preservation in the Love of the Father unto the end therefore they shall undoubtedly be so preserved It is confessed that the Persons Interceded for are Believers all Believers that then were or should be to the end of the World the efficacy of this Intercession having commenced from the foundations thereof the thing prayed for is their Preservation in the state of Union with Christ and one another the motives used for the obtaining this request in their behalfe are taken from the work they have to doe and the opposition they were to meet withall and all the Saints being thus put into the hand of God who shall take them from thence On what account is it that they shall not be preserved To say they shall be thus preserved in case themselves depart not wilfully from God is to say they shall be preserved in case they preserve themselves as will afterwards be farther manifested This Argument is proposed by the Apostle §. 6. in the most triumphant assurance of the Truth and Certainty of the inference contained in it that he any where useth in any case whatsoever Rom 8. 33 34. Who shall lay any thing to the charge of Gods Elect It is God that justifieth Who is he that condemneth It is Christ that died yea rather that is risen againe who is even at the right hand of God who also maketh Intercession for us he laies the immunity of the Elect justified Persons from just crimination or Condemnation on the foundation of the Oblation and Intercession of Christ The first part of this Argument from the Oblation of Christ who shall condemne It is Christ that died asserting the immunity of Believers from Condemnation upon the account of the punishing of all their sinnes in Christ and the perfect satisfaction made by his death for them whence the justice of God in the issue will not have any thing to lay to their charge we have formerly insisted on The other which the Apostle induces emphatically and comparatively though not in respect of procurement and purchase made yet of assurance to be given with 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in respect of his Oblation is that now before us To make the Assurance of Believers plentifull that they may know both the Truth of his first generall Assertion that all things shall work together for good to them and this particular conclusion now laid downe by way of interrogation rejecting all evill opposed to their former enjoyments who shall lay any thing to their charge who shall condemne He gives them a threefold consideration of the state and actings of the Lord Christ after the Expiation of their sinnes by this bloud in reference to them 1. He is Risen 2. He is at the Right hand of God 3. Makeeth Intercession for them the First denoting his Acquitment and theirs in him for he died in their stead from all the sinnes that were charged on him For he was declared to be the Sonne of God accepted with him and justified from all that debt which he undertook in his Resurrection and if he be risen who shall lay any thing to the charge of them whom he died for and for all whose sinnes in their stead he was acquitted The Second is his Exaltation and Power for having purged our sinnes he is sate downe at the right hand of the Majesty on High Heb. 1. 3. receiving thereby a most plenary demonstration of his Fathers good will to him and his in respect of the work that he had undertaken and gone through for them For if he had not made an end of sinne when he was obedient unto death the death of the Crosse he could not expect that God should give him a name above every name with fulnesse of power to give Eternall Life to all that the Father gave him This to assure us that he will doe having power in his own hand the Apostle addes who also Intercedes for us hereby thirdly testifying abundantly his good will and care for our Salvation Upon these considerations the Apostle leads the Faith of the Saints of God to make a conclusion which is to be believed as a Divine Truth that tenders to us the Doctrine we have under Demonstration triumphant against all Objections and oppositions that can be made against it And hence we thus argue Those against whom no Charge can be laid who cannot by any means be separated from the love of God in Christ cannot totally and finally fall away from Faith and fall out of Gods Favour but that this is the condition of all true
them did them no good at all And the reason of this sad successe in the Preaching of the Gospell and Declaration of the Promises he gives you in the same words It is that the word was not mixed with Faith in them that heard it It is the mixing of the Promises with Faith that renders them usefull and profitable Now to what ever Faith is required the more firme strong and stable it is the more effectuall and usefull it is That then which is apt to establish Faith to support and strengthen it to preserve it from staggering Rom. 4. 20. that renders the Promise most usefull and effectuall for the Accomplishment of any worke whereunto it is designed Now Faith in the Promises respects the Accomplishment of the things promised as the Apostle tells us in that commended and never enough imitated Example of the Faith of Abraham Rom 4. 19 20 21. Being not weake in Faith he considered not his own body now dead when he was about an hundred years old neither yet the deadnesse of Sarahs wombe he staggered not at the Promise of God through unbeliefe but was strong in Faith giving glory to God being fully perswaded that what he had promised he was able also to performe Laying aside all considerations that might tend to the impairing of his confidence he firmely believed that it should be to him as God had promised That the Doctrine we insisted on is clearly conducing to the establishing of Faith in the Promises cannot tolerably be called into Question Whatsoever is in those Promises whatsoever Considerations or concernements of him whose they are as his Faithfulnesse Unchangeablenesse Omnipotency that are apt to strengthen Faith in them it preserves entire and exalteth It is a wild Assertion which men scarce search their own hearts if indeed men know what belongs to believing in sincerity when they make that the efficacy of the Promises unto our Obedience should arise from hence that the things promised may not be fulfilled and that the weaknesse of Faith as every such supposall doth at least weaken it yea and tends to its subversion should render the Promise usefull which hath no use at all but as it is mixed with Faith For instance those Promises that God will be an All-sufficient God unto us that he will circumcise our Hearts and write his Law in them that we shall feare him is as was manifested before an usefull Meditation for the ingenerating and quickning of Obedience and Holinesse in us That it may be such a meanes it is required that it be mixt with Faith in them that heare it as was declared According as Faith is strong or weake so will its usefulnesse be I aske then whether this be a way proper to set this Promise on worke for the end proposed namely to perswade them that should believe it that all this may be otherwise God may cease to be their God their hearts may not be circumcised nor the Law mentioned written in them Is this the way to strengthen their Faith and to keepe them from staggering Or rather to subvert and cast downe all their confidence to the ground The Doctrine we have under consideration continually sounds in the eares of Believers 1 Cor. 1. 9. that God is faithfull in all his Promises that he can that he will make them good that his own Excellencies his own Perfections require no lesse at his hands And this it doth not on any Grounds that carry any thing with them that may seeme to incline to the least neglect of God or contempt of any Property Excellency or word of his and so be apt to breed presumption and not Faith But on such only as give him the Glory of all that he hath revealed of himselfe unto us and therefore its genuine tendency must be to beget and increase precious saving Faith in the hearts of men which we conceive to lye in a more direct way of efficacy towards Holinesse and Obedience then the ingenerating of servile feares gendering unto bondage can do This then we have obtained first that the Promises peculiarly insisted on are motives to furtherances of Obedience secondly that the way whereby they become so is by being mixed with Faith and the stronger Faith is the more effectuall will the working of those Promises unto Holinesse be thirdly that the Doctrine of the Perserverance of the Saints and stability of God's Love to them giving him the Glory of all his Excellencies which in his Promises are to be considered is suited to the carrying on of Faith in its growth and increase Indeed that which makes our beliefe of the Promises of Faith divine is the rise it hath and the bottome whereinto it is resolved viz. The Excellencies of him who makes the Promises As that he is True Faithfull Alsufficient the Glory of all which is given him in Believing as the Apostle informes us Rom. 4. 20 21. Yea and all this He must be received to be in reference to the accomplishment of his Promises or we Believe them not with divine supernaturall if that terme may be allowed and saving Faith Surely they must needs think us very easie of beliefe and wholly unexperienced of any Communion with God who shall suppose that we will be perswaded that the Doctrine which eminently asserts and ascribes unto God the Glory of all his Attributes which he would have us to eye in his Promises strengthning Faith on that account doth annihilate the Promises in the Word of the Ministry as to their usefulnesse unto our Obedience Let us deale by instance God hath promised to begin and perfect a good worke in us according as this Promise is mixt with Faith so it will be usefull and profitable to us If there be no Faith it will be of no use if little of little if more of more Let a man now be supposed to be wavering about his mixing this Promise with Faith whereupon the issue of its Efficacy and Fruitfulnesse as was said doth depend And let the Doctrine we teach be called in to speake in this Case and let us trye whether what it saies be prejudiciall to establishment of Faith or whether it be not all that lookes towards its Confirmation It saies then unto the soule of a Believer why art thou so cast downe thou poore soule And why are thy thoughts perplexed within thee It is true thou art weake unstable ready to fall away and to perish thy temptations are many great and prevalent and thou hast no strength to stand against the power and multitude of them But looke a little upon him who hath promised that thou shalt never depart from him who hath promised to finish the good worke begun he is Unchangeable in his Purposes Faithfull in his Promises and will put forth the exceeding greatnesse of his power for the Accomplishment of them so that though thou failest he will cause thee to renue thy strength though thou fallest thou shalt not be cast
it being laid upon the proofe of the Minor Proposition formerly denied here laid downe It will easily be granted that it was incumbent on him to make sure worke here and not to leave any thing liable to any just Exception An errour or a mistake in the foundation is not easily recoverable All that is afterwards heaped up beareth it selfe on a supposition of the Truth of what is here delivered If this faile in the least we may spare our Labour as to any farther consideration of what followeth Now the maine of the proofe here insisted on lieth in the Declaration of that which he calleth the Common Doctrine of Perseverance and concerning this he informeth his Reader 1. That it commandeth all Saints to he fully perswaded and that with the gseatest and most indubitable certainty of Faith that there is an absolute and utter impossibility either of a totall or finall defection of their Faith Ans. 1. What is the intendment of these Aggravating expressions of fully perswaded greatest and most indubitable certainty of Faith I know not Will it please you if it should require them to be perswaded but not fully perswaded Believe it but with little and dubitable cetainty of Faith or uncertainty rather Full perswasion greatest certainty without doubting or staggering are all of their perfections of Faith and of the Saints in believing which without doubt they are in all that they are to Believe to presse after so that all this is no more but that this Doctrine requireth men to believe what it affirmeth God to have promised It requireth men to mixe the Promises of God with Faith Crimen in auditum But though the manner of Believing which it requireth be not blameable yet the thing which it proposeth to be believed is false What is that That there is an Absolute or utter impossibility either of a totall or finall defection of the Faith of true Believers It s requiring this to be Believed is the bottome also corner stone of Mr Goodwin's insuing Argument if it doth not do this he hath nothing in this place to say to it Let him then produce any one that ever wrote in the defence of it that hath in Termes or by just consequence delivered any such thing and on Herbam there shall be an end of this dispute I presume Mr Goodwin knoweth what is meant by an absolute and utter impossibility An absolute Repugnancy unto being in the nature of the things themselves concerning which any Affirmation is and not any externall or forraigne consideration doth entitle any thing to an absolute utter Impossibility did ever any one affirme that in the nature of the thing it selfe the defection of the S t s is absolutely impossible Is it not by them that believe the Perseverance of the S t s constantly affirmed that in themselves they are apt yea prone to fall away and their Faith to decay and dye which in it selfe possibly may be done though Mr Goodw cannot tolerably shew how The whole cerrainty of their continuance in and of the preservation of their Faith depends meerely on supposition of something that is extrinsecall in respect of them and of their state which as to their Condition might or might not be Farther the Perseverance of the Saints is by the same persons constantly affirmed to be carryed on to be perfected in and by the use of meanes It is their keeping by the power of God through Faith unto Salvation And can then an absolute impossibility of their defection be asserted or only that which is so upon supposition viz. of the Purpose of God c. There was no Absolute Impossibility that the bones of Christ should not be broken they being in themselves as lyable to be broken as his flesh to be pierced yet in respect of the event it was impossible they should be so I cannot well imagine that Mr Grodwin is not fully perswaded with the greatest and most indubit able certainty that a Perswasion in things of this kind will admit that the Common Doctrine of Perseverance doth not require Saints to believe that there is an absolute impossibility of their defection but only that God hath promised to Preserve them from that which in themselves and in respect of any thing in them they are obnoxious unto in and by the use of meanes suited and appointed by him to the carrying on of that worke and compassing of the end proposed But yet it pleaseth him here to make shew of a contrary Apprehension and to shew his confidence therein he aggravates it with this annexed supposition and case It doth so saith he though they should fall into 10000 enormous and most abominable sinnes and lye wallowing in them like Swine in the mire yet that they shall remaine all the while in an estate of Grace Ans. Truly this is such an enormous and abominable Calumny §. 11. that I cannot but admire how any sober and Rationall man durst venture upon the owning of it The question now is what Faith the Doctrine insisted on ingenerates in particular persons that should enervate and make void the Exhortations c. of the Ministry Now though the Doctrine should teach this Indefinitely that though men did sinne so and so as is here exprest yet they should be kept in a state of Grace as is mentioned which yet is lowdly and palpably false as hath been declared yet that it doth require particular men to Believe for themselves and in reference to the Guidance of their owne Wayes that they may lye and wallow in their sinne like swine in the mire and yet continue in a state of Grace and Acceptation with God is so notoriously contrary to the whole tenour of the Doctrine the genius and nature of it with all the Arguments whereby it is asserted and maintained that if conscience had but in the least been advised with all in this contest this charge had been without doubt omitted All that is produced for the confirmation of this strange imposition on the perswasion under consideration is his owne Testimony that makes the charge that it is the knowne voice of the common Doctrine of Perseverance and that being said is laid as a Foundation of all that followes The whole Discourse still relating to a supposition that this is the Doctrine which it opposeth from the very next words to the end Nor is there the least farther attempt for the confirmation of this grand Assertion But is this the knowne voice of our Doctrine of Perseverance Who ever heard it but Mr G. and men of the like prejudicate Spirits aganist the Truth The worst that can be charged with looking this way is its asserting the promised efficacy of the Grace of God for the preserving of Believers by the use of meanes from such wallowing in abominable sinnes as is supposed that it affirmes they may be exposed unto In briefe it saies not First That all Believers are certaine of their Perseverance Nor Secondly That
indeed we own and for the discovery of that which is brought forth to contest for Acceptance with it upon the score of Truth and usefullnesse First then §. 30. for the Doctrine of the Saints Perseverance how it stands stated in Mr Goodwins thoughts and what he would have other men apprehend thereof may from sundry places in his Booke especially Cap. 9. be collected and thus summarily presented It is saith he Cap. 9. Sect. 3. a promising unto men and that with height of assurance under what loosnesse or vile practises so ever exemption and freedome from punishment so Sect. 4. It is in vaine to perswade or presse men unto the use of such meanes in any kinde which are in themselves displeasing to them seeing they are ascertained and secured before hand that they shal not fail of the end however whether they use such means or no a lushous Fulsome conceit Sect. 5. intoxicating the flesh with a perswasion that it hath Goods layed up for the daies of Eternity A notion comfortable and betideing peace to the flesh Sect. 15. in administring unto it certaine hope that it shall however escape the wrath and vengeance which is to come yea though it disporteth it selfe in all manner of loosnesse and licentiousnesse in the meane time A presumption it is that men Sect. 18. may or shall injoy the love of God and Salvation it selfe under practises of all manner of sinne and wickednesse Representing God Sect. 20. as a God in whose sight he is Good that doth evill promising his love favour and acceptance as well unto doggs returning to their vomit or to swine wallowing after their washing in the mire that is to Apostates which that believers shall not be is indeed the Doctrine he opposeth as unto Lambs aud sheepe A Doctrine whereby ' t is possible for me certainly to know that how loosly how profanely how debauchedly soever I should behave my selfe yet God will love me as he doth the holdest and most righteous man under Heaven With these and the like Expressions doth Mr Goodwin adorne and Gilde over that Doctrine which he hath chosen to oppose with these Garlands flowers doth he surround the Head of the Sacrifice which he intends instantly to slay that so it may fall an undeplored Victim if not seasonably rescued from the hands of this sacred Officer Neither through his whole Treatise do I find it delivered in any other sence or held out under any other notion to his Reader The Course here he hath taken in this case and the paths he walkes in towards his Adversaries seeme to be no other then that which was traced out by the Bishops at Constance when they caused Divells to be painted upon the Cap they put on the Head of Huss before they cast him into the fire I do somthing doubt though I am not altogether Ignorant how abominably the Tenents and Opinions of those who first opposed the Papacy are represented and given over to posterity by them whose interest it was to have them thought such as they gave them out to be whether ever any man that undertooke to publish his Conceptions to the world about any opinion or parcell of Truth debated amongst Professors of the Gospell of Christ did ever so dismember disfigure defile wrest and pervert that which he opposed as Mr Goodwin hath done the Doctrine of Perseverance which he hath undertaken to destroy Me thinks a man should not be much delighted in casting filth and dung upon his Adversary before he begin to graple with him In one word this being the account he gives us of it if he be able to name one Author ancient or moderne any one sober person of old or of late that ever spent a pen full of Inke or once opened his mouth in the defence of that Perseverance of Saints or rather profane walking of dogs and swine which he hath stated not in the words and termes but so much as to the matter or purpose here intimated by him and it shall be accepted as a just defensative against the Crime which we are inforced to charge in this particular and which otherwise will not easily be warded If this be the Doctrine which with so great an indeavour and a Contribution of so much Paines and Rhetorique he seeks to oppose I know not any that will thinke it worth while to interpose in this fierce contest between him and his man of straw Neither can it with the least colour of Truth be pretended that these are Consequences which he urgeth the Doctrine he opposeth withall and not his Apprehensions of the Doctrine it selfe For neither doth he in any place in his whole Treatise hold it out in any other shape but is uniforme and constant to himselfe in expreffing his notion of it nor doth he indeed almost use any Argument against it but those that suppose this to be the true state of the Cōtroversy which he hath proposed But whether this indeed be the Doctrine of the Perseverance of Saints which Mr Goodwin so importunately cryes out against upon a briefe consideration of some of the particulars mentioned will quickly appeare First then §. 34. doth this Doctrine promise with height of Assurance that under what loosnesse or vile practices soever men doe live they shall have Exemption from punishment wherein I pray in that it promiseth the Saints of God that through his Grace they shall be preserved from such loosenesse and evill practises as would expose them to Eternall punishment Psal. 23. 6. Doth it teach men that it is vain to use the meanes of mortification because Jerem. 31. 33. 1 Cor. 10. 13. they shall certainly attaine the end whether they use the meanes or no Or may you not as well say that the Doctrine you oppose is that all men shall be saved whether they believe or no with those other comfortable and chearing associate doctrines you mention Or is this a Regular Emergency of that Doctrine which teaches 1 Pet. 1. 5. that there is no attaining the End but by the meanes between which there is such a Concatenation by Divine appointment that they shall not be separated Doth it speake peace to the flesh in Assurance of Blessed Immortality though it disport it selfe in all folly in the meane time Doe the Teachers of it expresse any such thing Doth any such Abomination issue from their Arguings in the defence thereof Or doth the Doctrine which teaches Believers Saints who have tasted of the love and pardoning mercy of God and are taught to valew it infinitly above all the world that such is the Love and goodwill of God towards them in the Covenant of mercy in the blood of Christ that having appointed Good works for them to walke in Ephes. 2. 10. 2 Cor. 3. 5. for which of themselves they are insufficient he will graciously continue to them such supplyes of his Spirit and Grace as that they shall never depart from following
the place and adds his reason Because they who are Justified may lay barrs in their way from being finally so or being Glorified That is it is not so because it is not so For the Efficacy of the Grace asserted is for the removeall of the barrs intimated or wherein may its efficacy be supposed to consist especially in its Relation to the end designed And so this place is Answered Saith the Holy Ghost those whom God Justifieth he Glorifies perhaps not saith Mr Goodwin some things may fall in or fall out to hinder this Eligite cui credatis Were I not resolved to abstaine from the Consideration of the Judgements of men when they are Autoritatively interposed in the things of God I could easily manifest the fruitlesnesse of the following endeavour to prove the effectuall Calling of Judas by the Testimony of Chrysostome and Peter Martyr for neither hath the first in the place alleadged any such thing least of all is it included in M. G's Marginall Annotation excluding Compulsion Necessity and Violence from Vocation and the latter in the Section pointed to and that following layes downe principles sufficiently destructive to the whole designe whose management M. Goodwin hath undertaken Neither shall I contest about the imposing on us in this dispute the notion of finall justification distinct from Glorification both name and thing being Forraigne to the Scripture and secretly including yea delivering to the advantage of its Author the whole Doctrine under consideration stated to his hand If there be a gospell-Gospell-justification in Sinners or Believers in the blood of Christ not finall or that may be cut off he hath prevailed But Mr Goodwin proceeds to object against himselfe §. 33. Sect 46. But some it may be will farther object against the interpretation given and plead that the Contexture between these two linkes of this Chaine Predestination to a conformity with Christ and Calling is simply and absolutely indissolveable so that whoever is so Predestinated never failes of being called 2. That it is altogether unlikely that in one and the same series of Divine actions there should not be the same fixednesse or certainty of coherence between all the parts The first of these being the bare Thesis which he opposed I know not how it came to be made an Objection I shall only adde to the latter Objection which includes something of Argument that the Efficacy of any one Act of Gods Grace here mentioned as to the end proposed depending wholly on the uninterruptible concatenation of them all and their effectuall prevalency and certainty as to their respective Operation of every one of them being equall to the Accomplishment of the Purpose of God in and by them all and willingly owne it especially finding how little is said and yet how much labour taken to dresse up a pretended Answer unto it Of this there are two parts whereof the first is this I Answer saith he 1. First By a demurre upon the former of these pleas which was that the connexion between the Predestination of God mentioned and his Calling is uninterruptible Somewhat doubtfull to me it is whether a person who by meanes of the Love of God which is in him at present falls under his Decree of Predestination may not possibly before the time appointed by God for his Calling be changed in that his Affection and consequently passe from under that Decree of Predestination and fall under another Decree of God opposite thereunto and so never come to be called Ans. I confesse this demurre outrunnes my understanding Equis albis neither can I by any meanes overtake it to pinne any tollerable sence upon it though I would allow it to be suited only to M. Goodwins principles and calculated for the Meridian of Arminianisme for who I pray are they in any sence in M. Goodwins that doe so love God as to fall under as he speakes that pendulous Decree of Predestination and to whom this promise here is made Are they not Believers Are any others Predestinated in our Authors judgement but those who are actually so is not the Decree of Predestination Gods Decree or Purpose of saving Believers by Jesus Christ Or can any love God to Acceptation without Believing If then they are Believers can they alter that condition before they are Called Wee supposed that Faith had been by hearing and hearing by the word of God Rom. 10. 17. and that it is of necessity in order of nature that Calling should precede Believing What are men called to Is it not to Believe Here is then a new sort of men discovered that believe and fall from Faith Love God and forsake him all antecedently to their Vocation and Calling I am confident that M. Goodwin may be perswaded to withdraw this demurrer or if not that he will be over-ruled in it before the judgement seat of all unprejudiced men It will scarcely as yet passe currantly that men are borne Believers and after such and such a time of their continuance in that estate of beliefe and being Predestinated thereupon God then Calls them Neither doe I understand the meaning of that phrase never come to be called used by Him who maintaines all to be called but this is but a demurrer the Answer followes For the great regard I beare unto the Authors Abilities §. 34. I shall not say that his insuing Discourse doth not deserve to be transcribed and punctually insisted on but this I may say I hope without offence that it is so long tedious so remote from what it pretends unto to wit an Answer to the forementioned Argument that I dare not venture upon the patience of any Reader so farre as to enter into a particular consideration of it The summe of it is that there is no unlikelihood in this that though one part of the Chaine of Divine Graces before mentioned cannot be dissolved nor broken yet another may notwithstanding that a dissolution of any one of them renders the designe of God in them all wholly frustrate and fruitlesse This he proves by proposing a new series of Divine Acts in actuall dependance one upon another some whereof may be uninterruptible but the other not so He that shall but slightly view the Concatenation of Divine Acts here proposed by Mr Goodwin for the illustration of that dependance of them and their Efficacy which we insist upon will quickly finde it lyable to some such small Exceptions as renders it altogether uselesse as to the end proposed As first 1. That the case here proposed and pretended to be parallell to that under our Consideration is a fictitious thing a fained Concatenation of fained Decrees of God being neither in any one place delivered in the Scripture nor to be collected from any or all the Texts in the Bible which course of proceeding if it may be Argumentative in sacred Truths it will be an easie and facile taske to overthrow the most Eminent and clearely delivered Heads of Doctrine in the
to the body of the Jewes returning out of Captivity was before demonstrated The Righteousnesse here mentioned is that which God will and doth exercise in this very Act of Betrothing and not any other act of it which he will make use of to that purpose God engageth to betroth them to himselfe in Righteousnesse using and exercising his Righteousnesse in that very Act of his Love and Grace to them and this is now given in an alluring them to love him by appearing Righteous in bringing them out of Captivity The like interpretation is given of the other expressions following §. 33. Judgement It is saith he by punishing and judging their enemies and destroying them that led them into captivity and held them in bondage and subjection and Loving-kindnesse is his giving them corne wine oyle peace and plenty and Mercy in pardoning of daily sins and insirmities and Faithfulnesse is he knoweth not what This is made the summe of all God by doing them good with outward mercies and pardoing some sins and infirmities will morally try to get their affections to himselfe Virgula Pictoris 1. It is not an Expression of Gods attempting to get their Love but of the establishing and confirming of his own 2. That God should morally try and essay to doe and effect or bring about any thing which yet he doth not will not or cannot compasse and effect is not to be ascribed to him without casting the greatest reproach of Impotency Ignorance Changeablenesse upon him imaginable 3. God promising to Betroth us to himselfe fixing his love on us that we shall know him so fixing our hearts on him to say that this holdeth out only the use of some outward meanes unto us enervateth the whole Covenant of his Grace wrapt up in these Expressions so that all things considered it is not a little strange to me that any sober learned man should ever be tempted so to wrest and corrupt by wrested and forced Gsosses the plaine words of Scripture wherein whatever is pretended he cannot have the least countenance of any Expositor of note that went before him Although we are not to be pressed with the name of Tarnovius a Lutheran a professed Adversary in this cause yet let his Exposition of that place under consideration be consulted with and it will plainely appeare that it abideth not in any compliance with that which is here by our Author imposed on us The Promises we have under consideration §. 34. looking immediately and directly only to one part of that Doctrine whose defence we have undertaken to wit the Constancy and Unchangeablenesse of the Grace of Justification or God's abiding with his Saints as to his free acceptance of them and love unto them unto the end I shall not insist on many more particulars The 10. §. 35. Iohn 27 28 29. closeth this Discourse My sheepe heare my voice and I know them and I give unto them Eternall Life and they shall never perish neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand my Father which gave me them is greater then all and no man is able to pluck them out of my Fathers hand In the verse foregoing our Saviour renders a reason why the Pharisees notwithstanding all his Preaching to them and the Miracles he wrought among them yet believed not when sundry others to whom the same dispensation of outward meanes was afforded did heare his voice and did yeild obedience thereunto and this he telleth us was because they were not of his sheepe such as were given him of his Father and for whom as the good Shepheard he lay'd downe his life v. 14 15. upon the close of this discourse he describeth the present Condition of his Sheepe their Preservation in that Condition from the power of himselfe and his Father engagedthere unto He layeth their abiding him as his Sheepe upon the Omnipotence of God which upon account of the constancie of his Love towards them he will exercise and exert as need shall be in their behalfe There are many emphaticall expressions both of their continuance in the Obedience of Faith and of his undertaking for their Preservation therein The latter I at present only intend Saith he 1. I know them 2. I give them Eternall Life 3. They shall never perish 4. No man shall plucke them out of my hand 5. My Father is Omnipotent and hath a Soveraignty over all and he taketh care of them and none shall take them out of his hand It is not easy to cast these words into any other form of arguing then that wherein they lye without loosing much of that convincing Evidence that is in them this you may take for the summe of their influence into the Truth in hand Those whom Christ so owneth as to take upon him to give them Eternall Life and by his Power and the Power of his Father to preserve them thereunto which power shall not nor possibly can be prevailed against so that the end aimed at to be accomplished therein should not be brought about those shall certainely be kept for ever in the Favour and Love of God they shall never be turned from him Such is the case of all Believers for they are all the Sheep of Christ they all heare his voice and follow him Some few things to wrest this Gracious assurance given Believers of the everlasting good will of God Christ unto them §. 36. by Mr Goodwin Cap. 10. Sect. 37. Page 203. are attempted 1. He granteth that there is an engagement of the mighty power of God for the safegarding of the Saints as such or remaining such against all adverse power what ever But no where for the compelling or necessitating of them to persevere and continue such is there any thing in the Scripture Ans. The sum is if they will continue Saints God will take care that notwithstanding all opposition they shall be Saints still Very well if they will be so they shall be so But that they shall continue to be so that is not promised The termes of Compelling or Necessitating are cast in meerly to throe dirt upon the Truth least the beauty shining forth too brightly there might have bin danger that the very Exceptor himselfe could not have born it We say not that God by his Power compelleth men to persevere that is maketh them doe it whether they will or no. Perseverance being an habitual Grace in their wills it is a grosse contradiction once to imagine that men should be compelled thereunto But this we say that by the Almighty Power of his Spirit and Grace he confirmeth his Saints in a voluntary abiding with him all their dayes Having made them a willing People in the day of the Power of Christ towards them he preserveth them unto the end Neither are they wrapt up by the power of God into such a necessity of Perseverance as should obstruct the liberty of their Obedience The necessity that regardeth them in that Condition respecting
higher then outward dispensations when the words expressly mention the Spirit already received Evident it is that the whole Grace Love Kindnesse and Mercy of this eminent Promise and consequently the whole Covenant of Grace is enervated by this corrupting Glosse Doe men think indeed that all the mercy of the Covenant of Grace consists in such tenders and offers as here are intimated that it all lyes in outward endearements and such dealings with men as may seeme to be suited to win upon them and that as to the reall exhibition of it it is wholly suspended upon the unstable uncertaine fraile wills of men The Scripture seemes to hold out something farther of more efficacy Ezek. 11. 19. The designe of these exceptions Jere 31. 32. 32. 40. is indeed to exclude all the effectuall Grace of God promised in Jesus Christ upon the account that the things which he promiseth to work in us thereby are the duties which he requireth of us In summe these are the exceptions which are given into this Testimony of God concerning the abiding of the spirit with them on whom he is bestowed and for whom he is procured to whom he is sent by Jesus Christ. And this is the Interpretation of the words As for mee for my part or as much as in me lieth this is my Covenant I will deale bountifully and gratiously with them the whole Nation of the Jewes my spirit that is in thee that they ought to take care that they entertaine and retaine the Holy Spirit and not walk so extremely unworthily that he should depart frō them the residue of the words wherein the maine Emphasis of them doth lye is left untouched The import then of this Promise is the same with that of the Promises insisted on before with especiall reference to the Holy Spirit procured for us and given unto us by Christ. The stability and establishing Grace of the Covenant is here called the Covenant as sundry other particular mercies of it are also Of the Covenant of Grace in Christ the blessed Spirit to dwell in us and rest upon us is the maine and principall Promise This for our consolation is renewed againe and againe in the Old and New Testoment As a Spirit of sanctification he is given to men to make them believe and as a spirit of Adoplion upon their Believing In either sence God even the Father who takes us into Covenant in Jesus Christ affirmes here that he shall never depart from us which is our first Testimony in the case in hand With whom the Spirit abides and whilest he abides with them they cannot utterly forsake God nor be forsaken of him for they who have the spirit of God are the Children of God sonnes and Heyres But God hath promised that his Spirit shall abide with Believers for ever as hath been clearly evinced from the Text under consideration with a removall of all exceptions put in thereto The second witnesse we have of the constant abode and residence of this spirit bestowed on them §. 26. which Believe for ever is that of the Sonne who assures his Disciples of it Joh. 14. 16. I will saith he pray the Father and he shall give you another Comforter that he may abide with you for ever As our Saviour gives a Rule of Interpretation expressely of his Prayers for Believers that he did in them intend not only the men of that present Generation but all that should believe to the end of the World Ioh. 17. 20. I pray not for these alone but for them also who shall believe on me through their word so is it a Rule equally infallible for the interpretation of the gracious Promises which he made to his Disciples that are not peculiarly appropriated to their season and worke in which yet as to the generall Love Faithfulnesse and Kindnesse manifested and revealed in them the concernements of the Saints in all succeeding ages does lye they are proper to all Believers as such For whom he did equally intercede to them he makes Promises alike They belong no lesse to us on whom in an especiall manner the ends of the World are fallen then to those who first followed him in the Regeneration Let us then attend to the Testimony in this place and as he shall be pleased to increase our Faith mix it therewithall that the Spirit he procureth for us and sends to us shall abide with us for ever and whilest the Spirit of the Lord is with us we are his Doubtlesse it is no easy taske to raise up any pretended plea against the evidence given in by this Witnesse the Amen the great and faithfull witnesse in Heaven He tells us that he will send the Spirit to abide with us for ever and therein speaks to the whole of the case in hand and Question under debate All we say is that the Spirit of God shall abide with Believers for ever Christ saies so too and in the issue what ever becomes of us he will appeare to be one against whom there is no rising up Against this Testimony it is objected by Mr Goodwin §. 27. Cap. 11. Sect. 14. Pag. 234. This Promise saith he concerning the abiding of this other Comforter for ever must be conceived to be made either to the Apostles personally considered or else to the whole body of the Church of which they were principall members If the first of these be admitted then it will not follow that because the Apostles had the perpetuall residence of the spirit with them and in them therefore every particular Believer hath the like no more then it will follow that because the Apostles were infallible in their judgments through the teachings of the spirit in them therefore every Believer is infallible upon the same account also If the latter be admitted neither will it follow that every Believer or every member of the Church must needs have the residence of the spirit with them for ever There are principall priviledges appropriated to Corporations which every particular member of them cannot claime the Church may have the residence of the spirit of God with her for ever and yet every present member thereof loose his interest and part in him yea the abiding of the spirit in the Apostles themselves was not absolutely promised Ioh. 15. 10. 1. The designe of this discourse is to prove Ans. that this Promise is not made to Believers in generall or those who through the word are brought to believe in Christ in all Generations to the end of the World and consequently that they have no Promise of the Spirits abiding with them for that is the thing opposed and this is part of the Doctrine that tends to their Consolation and improvement in Holinesse What thankes they will give to the Authors of such an eminent discovery when it shall be determined that they have deserved well of them and the Truths of God I know not especially when it shall be considered that not
of preserving them from all such unworthinesse as should render them utterly uncapable thereof And this is plainly here asserted in the Assurance given of the perpetuall residence of the Spirit in them with such continuall supplies of Grace from him as shall certainly preserve them from any such state or condition as is imagined Of being necessitated to Believe I have spoken formerly The expression is neither used by us nor proper to the thing it selfe about which it is used nor knowne in the Scripture as to this purpose and therefore we justly reject it as to its signifying any thing of the way and manner whereby we are preserved by the power of God through faith unto Salvation If it denotes only the certainly and infallibility of the event as the phrase or locution is improper so to deny that there is a Promise of our being preserved by the Spirit of God in believing is not to Answer our Argument but to beg the thing in Question yea to deny the positive assertion of the Lord Christ But if there be not such a Promise in the words what then is in them what doe they containe Saith he 2. They are only a Declaration and Assertion made by Christ of the Excellency and desireablenesse of that life which he comes to give unto the World above the life of nature which is common unto all This by comparing the words with those in the former verse is evident whosoever Drinketh of this water shall thirst againe but whosoever Drinketh of the water that I shall give him c. that is the best meanes that can be had and enjoyed to render this present life free from inconveniencies will not effect it but whosoever shall Drinke Injoy Receive and Believe the Doctrine which I shall administer unto him shall hereby be made partaker of such a life which shall within a short time if men be carefull in the interim to preserve it by reason of the nature and perfect condition and constitution of it be exempt from all sorrow trouble and inconvenience whatsoever as being eternall Ans. 1. That these words are only an Assertion of the excellency and desireablenesse of that eternall life which Christ would give above the naturall that the Woman sued to sustaine and that this appears from the Context is said indeed but no more It is true our Saviour doth divert the thoughts of the Woman from the naturall life and care for provision about it with an insinuation of a better life to be attained but is this all he doth or is this the intendment of the words under consideration Doth not the maine of the opposition or difference which at present he speakes unto lye in the supplies that are given for the two kinds of Life whereof he speakes The Water he tells her which she drew from that Well by which he fate for the supply of her naturall life was such that after her drinking of it she should quickly returne to the same Condition of thirst as formerly before she drank of it But that which he gave was such as that who ever drank of it should thirst no more but be certainely preserved in and unto the full fruition of that Life whereof it is the meanes and supply The opposition is not between the lives continued but the meane of consolation and its efficacy 2. It is not the Condition of the Life naturall which is subject to dissolution not capable of perfection that is the Reason why they thirst again againe that have Water naturall for the refreshment thereof But 't is the nature of the meanes it selfe which is supplyed that is not fitted nor suited to permanency abiding usefullnesse as the Water which Christ Promises is that he insists on There is not any thing leades us to suppose that it is the Imperfection of Life and not the Condition of the meanes of naturall life that is primarily intended in the instituted Comparison though the frailty and nothingnesse of that life also be afterwards intimated in the substitution of Eternall life unto the thoughts of the poore woman in the Roome thereof 3. I say that it is not the Doctrine of Christ but his Spirit principally that he is here said to give as Water and that this is not promised to make men partakers of Eternall Life if in the interim they be carefull to preserve it but to preserve them to it and to give them that Care which as a Grace is needfull thereunto The plaine intendment of the Promise is that by the water they drinke they shall be kept and preserved in the Life whereof they are made partakers unto the fulnesse and perfection of it which preservation by the parenthesis if any be carefull in the interim to preserve it is directly taken away from the Spirit that Christ promiseth and assigned to mens owne care even in contradistinction to all the benefits which they receive by him being so bestowed on them The difference then here between Jesus Christ and Mr Goodwin is this Christ saith the Water that he shall give will be a well springing up to Everlasting Life Mr Goodwin That it is the Care of men to preserve themselves that produces that Effect 4. The present exemption which we have by the Waters of Christs giving is not from sorrow and trouble but from thirst that is from what is opposed unto and is destructive of that Life which he also gives as naturall thirst is unto naturall life But of this thirst and our exemption from it I have spoken before It is not then the nature and condition of the Life promised that he points unto no farther then as it is coincident with the meanes of it here spoken of Indeed this meanes of life is our life as to the inchoation of it here below and its daily growing up unto perfection But he adds Sect. 11. 1. That he doth not oppose that Life which accrues unto mē by drinking that Water which he gives thē §. 33. unto the naturall life which they live by other means in respect of the present Condition or Constitution of it or as it is enjoyed by men in this present world is evident from hence because he asserts it free from thirst shall never thirst Now we know that the Saints themselves notwithstanding that life of Grace which is in them by drinking that Water that Christ hath given them are yet subject to both kinds of Thirst as well that which is corporeall or naturall as that which is Spirituall yea the Spirituall Thirst unto which they are now subject though it argues a deficiency of what they would farther have or desire to be and in that respect is troublesome yet is it Argumentative of the goodnesse of their Condition Mat. 5. 6. Ans 1. The summe of this Answer is that the Life here spoken of and promised is not that Spirituall life whereof we are here made partakers but eternall life which is for to come which when
Believers is evident from the Context It is of all that are called according to the Purpose of God sanctifyed and justified the proper description of all and only Believers that the Apostle affirmes these things and to whom he ascribes the condition mentioned Now that this is the state and condition of those persons the Apostle manifesteth from the causes of it viz. the Oblation and Intercession of Christ in their behalfe For those for whom he Died and doth Intercede are on that account exempted from any such charge as might be of prevalency to separate them from God M. Goodwin attempts indeed once more to reinforce the triumphed over Enemies of the Saints §. 7. and to call them once more to make head against the Intercession of Christ but with what ill successe the consideration of what Arguments he useth with them and for them will demonstrate thus then he addresseth himselfe to his taske Ch. 11. Sect 33. pag. 248. I answer It is no where affirmed that Christ Intercedes for the Perseverance of the Saints in their Faith or they who once believed should never cease Believing how sinfull and wicked soever they should prove afterwards But Christ Intercedes for his Saints â—s such and so continuing such that no accusation from any hand whatsoever may be heard against them that no afflictions or sufferings which they meet with in the World may cause any alienation or abatement in the Love of God towards them but that God will protect and preserve them under them and consequently that they may be maintained at an excellent rate of Consolation in every state and condition and against all interposures of any Creature to the contrary This Answer hath long since ceased to be new to us §. 8. It is that indeed which is the shield behinde which Mr Goodwin lyes to avoide the force of all manner of Arguments pointed against himselfe though it be the most weake and frivolous that ever I suppose was used in so weighty a matter It is here cast as he hath many moulds and shapes to cast it in into a denyall of the Assumption of our Syllogisme and a Reason of that deniall First he denies that Christ intercedes for Believers that they may Persevere in their Faith he prayes not for their Perseverance 2. His Reason of this is two fold 1. A supposall that they may prove so wicked as not to continue Believing 2. A description of what Christ Intercedes for in the behalfe of Believers viz. that they may continue in Gods Love if they doe continue to Believe notwithstanding all their affictions Homo homini quid interest Whether men will or no these must passe for Oracular Dictates 1. First for the first Let what hath been spoken already be weighed and see if there be not yet hope left for poore soules that Christ prayes for them that their Faith faile not And by the way who will not embrace this comfortable Doctrine that will assure him in his Agonies Temptations and Failings that all help and supplies are made out to him from and by the Lord Jesus in whom is all his hope and that he receives of his Father upon his Intercession all the fruits of his Death and Bloudshedding in his behalfe But that he should Believe or being tempted should be preserved in Believing of that Christ takes no thought nor did ever intercede with his Father for any such end or purpose Such consolation might befit Jobs friends miserable Comforters Physitians of no value But of this before 2. For that supposall of his of their proving wicked afterwards to an inconsistency with believing it hath often been corrected for a sturdy Begger and sent away grumbling and hungry and were it not for pure necessity would never once be owned any more by its Master Christ Intercedes not for Believers that they may Persevere in the Faith upon such foolish supposalls whose opposite is Continuance in the Faith and so is coincident with the thing it selfe interceded for To Intercede that they may continue Believing is to Intercede that they may never be so wicked as Mr Goodwin supposeth they may be The end of Christs Intercession for the Saints asserted is that they may never wickedly depart from God Doth Mr Goodwin indeed take this to be the tenor of the Doctrine he opposeth and of the Argument which he undertakes to Answer viz. That the Faith of Believers and the continuance of that is interceded for without any reference to the worke of Faith in Gospell Obedience and communion with God in Christ Or if he thinks not so why doth he so often insist on this calumnious evasion 3. In giving the aime of Christ in his Intercession for believers we have this new cogent Argument against our Position Christ Intercedes for the things here by me mentioned therefore he doth not Intercede for the Perseverance of the Saints But why so Is there any inconsistency in these things any repugnancy in termes or contrariety of the things themselves Christ Intercedes that Believers may enjoy the Love of God therefore he doth not Intercede that they may be established in Believing 2. The summe of all that is here ascribed to the Intercession of Christ at the best is that God will confirme and ratify that everlasting Law that Believers continuing so to the end shall be saved which whether it be the summe of Christs Intercession for his Church or no that Church will judge If there be any thing farther or of more importance to them in what is assigned to it by M. Goodwin it is wrapt up in the knot of c. which I am not able to untye 3. Those words of the Apostle who shall lay any thing to the charge of Gods Elect do not denote this is that the Intercession of Christ for them that no accusation be admitted against theÌ„ whilst they belive which is no more but the confirmation of that generall Proposition of the Gospell before mentioned But it is the Conclusion which they make upon the Account of the Intercession of Christ in the Application of the Promise of the Gospell to their owne soules Neither is there any more weight in that which followes that there be no abatement or alienation of the Love of God from them upon the account of their sufferings and afflictions which for the most part are for his sake what Saints of God were almost so much as once tempted with a conceit that Gods Love should be abated or alienated from them because they suffered for him And this is the Foundation of that excellent rate of Consolation at which the Saints upon the account of the Intercession of Christ may be maintained Into Afflictions Temptations Tryalls they may fall but if they continue in Faith and Love they shall not be rejected No Creature shall be heard against them that Christ takes care for But for the worst enemies they have their owne Lusts Corruptions and Unbeliefe the fiery Darts of Sathan
are suited to the cherishing of that Principle of the new or inner man in the heart to the nourishing and strengthning of the new creature such as are apt to ingenerate Faith and Love in the heart unto God such as reveale and discover those things in his nature mind and will as are apt to endeare and draw out the heart to him in Communion discouraging perplexing Doctrines doe but ill manure the soyle from whence the fruits of Obedience are to spring and grow Look then I say whatsoever Gospell Truth is of eminent usefulnesse to warme foment stirre up and quicken the Principle of Grace in the heart to draw out increase and cherish Faith and Love that Doctrine lies in a direct immediate tendency to the promotion of Holinesse Godlinesse and Gospell Obedience Yea and whereas to the carrying on of that course of Obedience it is necessary that the contrary Principle unto it which we mentioned before be daily subdued brought under crucified and mortified there are no Doctrines whatsoever that are of such and so direct and eminent a serviceablenesse to that end and purpose as those which inwrappe such discoveries of God and his good will in Christ as are fitted for the improvement also of the principle of Grace in us Hence the worke of Mortification in the Scripture Rom. 6. 2 3 4 5 6. is every where assigned peculiarly to the Crosse and death of Christ Rom. 8. 13. his Love manifested therein and his Spirit flowing therefrom Rom. 7. 7. The Doctrine of the Law indeed humbles the soule for Christ Gal. 3. 23. but it is the Doctrine of the Gospell that humbles the soule in Christ It is the Grace of God that hath appeared 2 Cor. 5. 15. that teaches us effectually to deny all ungodlinesse and worldly lusts to live soberly and righteously and Godly in this present world Tit. 2. 12. He that will but with a little heed read Cap. 6. to the Romans will know from whence Mortification flowes which truly by the way makes me admire at the extreame darknesse and blindnesse of some poore men who have of late undertaken to give directions for Devotion and walking with God who indeed sutably to the most of the rest of their discourses all manifesting an Ignorance of the Righteousnesse of God Rom. 10. 4. and a zealous endeavour to establish their owne coming to propose waies and meanes for the mortifying of any sinne or Lust tell you stories of biting the tongue thrusting needles under the nailes with such like Trash as might have befited Popish devotions five hundred years agoe Were not men utterly ignorant what it is to know the Lord Jesus Christ Phil. 3. 10. and the power of his Resurrection and the fellowship of his sufferings Gal. 6. 14. and being made conformable to his death they could never feed on such huskes themselves nor make provision of them for those whose good they pretend to seeke Unto what hath been spoken adde 4. Fourthly §. 8. who are the Persons that are to be provoked to Holinesse and Godlinesse by the Doctrine insisted on Now they are such as doe believe it and are concerned in it We say the Truth under consideration is of an excellent usefulnesse to farther Gospell Obedience in the hearts of Believers and Saints of God who are taught of God not to turne the Doctrine of Grace into wantonnesse What use or abuse rather men of corrupt mindes and carnall principles who stumble at Jesus Christ and abuse the whole Doctrine of the Gospell by their prejudices and presumptions will make of it we know not nor are sollicitous 2 Cor. 4. 3 4. If the Gospell be hid it is hid to them that perish it is sufficient that the food be good and wholsome for them for whom it is provided If some will come and steale it 2 Cor. 2. 16 27. that have no right to it and it prove through their own distempers gravell in their mouthes or poyson in their bowells they must blame themselves and their own wormewood Lusts and not the Doctrine which they doe receive It is provided for them that feare God and love the Lord Jesus Christ in sincerity not for doggs swine unbelievers we shall not marvaile if they trample on this pearle and rend them that bring it To such as these then I say the Doctrine of the Perseverance of the Saints or the stability or unchangeablenesse of the Love of God unto Believers and of their continuation in Faith and Obedience is full of exceeding effectuall motives and provocations unto Holinesse in all manner of Gospell Obedience and holy conversation exceedingly advantaging the soules of men in a course thereof Now the influence it hath into the Obedience of the Saints floweth from it upon a twofold account 1. By removing all discouragements whatsoever §. 9. that are apt either to turne them aside from their Obedience or to render their Obedience servile slavish or unacceptable to God it setts them through Christ at perfect liberty thereunto 2. By putting unconquerable and indissoluble Obligations upon them to live unto God and the praise of his glorious Grace and evidently drawes them forth unto the Obedience required 1. It removeth and taketh out of the way all discouragements whatsoever all things which are apt to enterpose to the weakning of their Faith in God or their Love to God which as hath been said are at the bottome of all Obedience and Holinesse that is acceptable to God in Christ Now these may all be referred unto two heads 1. Of perplexing anxious fears §. 10. which are apt to impaire and weaken the Faith of the Saints 2. Of hard thoughts of God which assault and shake their Love That slavish perplexing troublesome feares are contrary to the free and ingenuous state of Children whereunto the Saints are admitted and however sometimes yea oftentimes they are at the bottome and the occasion of burthen some servile and superstitious Obedience Impairers of their Faith I suppose I need not labour to prove That kind of Feare whereof we speake of which more afterwards is the greatest Traytor that lurkes in the soule To feare the Lord and his Goodnesse Hos. 3. 5. is the soules Keeper but this servile perplexing feare is the Betrayer of it in all its waies and that which sowres all its duties A thing which the Lord sets himselfe against in rebukes reproofes dehortations as much as any failing and miscarriage in his Saints whatever It is the opposite of Faith hence the fearefull and unbelieving are put together in their exclusion from the new Jerusalem Rev 20. 8. it is that which is direct contrary to that which the Apostle adviseth the Saints unto Heb 10. 19 20 21 22. it is that which mixeth Faith with staggering Rom 4. 20. Prayer with wavering making it ineffectuall Iames 1. 6. 7. Let us now suppose a man to have attained some assurance of the Love of God
downe He hath undertaken to worke and who shall let him The Councell of his heart as to the fulfilling of it doth not depend on any thing in us what sinne thou art overtaken withall he will pardon and will effectually supply thee with his Spirit thatâ— thou shalt not fall into or continue in such sinnes as would cut off thy Communion with him And doth not this mixe the forementioned Promises with Faith and so render it effectuall to the carrying on of the worke of Love and Obedience as was mentioned And as this Doctrine is suited to the establishment of the soule in Believing and to the stirring of men up to mixe the the Promises with Faith so there is not any thing that is or canbe thought more effectuall to the weakening impairing and shattering of the Faith of the Saints then that which is contrary thereunto as shall afterwards be more fully manifested Tell a soule that God will write his Law in him and put his feare in his inward partes that he shall never depart from him what can ye pitch upon possibly to unsettle him as to a perswasion of the Accomplishment of this Promise and that it shall be so indeed as God hath spoken but only this according as thou behavest thy selfe which is left unto thee so shall this be made good or come short of accomplishment If thou continue to walke with God which that thou shalt do he doth not promise but upon Condition thou walke with him it shall be well and if thou turne aside which thou mayst do notwithstanding any thing here spoken or intimated then the word spoken shall be of none effect the Promise shall not be fulfilled towards thee I know not what the most malicious Devill in Hell if they have degrees of malice can invent more suitable to weaken the Faith of men as to the accomplishment of Gods Promise then by affirming that it doth not depend upon his Truth and Faithfulnesse but solely on their good behaviour which he doth not effectually provide that it shall be such as is required thereunto God himselfe hath long since determined this difference might he be attended unto What hath been spoken of the Promises of the first sort might also be manifested concerning those of the second And the like might also be cleared up in reference to those other weapons of Ministers warfare in casting downe the strong holds of sinne in the hearts of men to wit Exhortations and Threatnings But because Mr Goodwin hath taken great paines both in the generall to prove the unsuitablenesse of our Doctrine to the promotion of Obedience and an Holy Conversation and in particular its inconsistency with the Exhortations and Threatnings of the Word managed by the Ordinances of the Ministry What is needfull farther to be added to the purpose in hand will fall in with our vindication rescuing of the Truth from the false criminations wherewith it is assaulted and reproached as to this particular And therefore I shall immediately addresse myselfe to the Consideration of his long Indictment and charge against the Doctrine of the Perseverance of the Saints as to this very thing CAP. XI 1. The Entrance into an Answer to Mr G's Arguments against the Doctrine of the Saints Perseverance His sixt Argument about the usefulnesse of the Doctrine under consideration to the worke of the Ministry proposed 2. His prâ—ofe of the minor Proposition 3. Considered and Answered Many pretenders to promote Godlinesse by false Doctrines M. G.'s common interest in this Argument 4. His proofes of the usefulnesse of his Doctrine unto the promotion of Godlinesse 5. Considered and Answered The inconsequence of his Arguing discovered 6. The Doctrine by him opposed mistaken ignorantly or wilfully 7. Objections proposed by Mr G. to himselfe to be Answered 8. The Objection as proposed disowned Certainty of the Love of God in what sence a motive to Obedience 9. The Doctrine of Apostasy denies the unchangeablenesse of Gods Love to Believers placeth Qualifications in the Roome of persons 10. How the Doctrine of Perseverance promiseth the continuance of the Love of God to Believers 11. Certainty of Reward incouraging to regular Actions Promises made to Persons qualified not suspended upon those Qualifications Meanes appointed of God for the accomplishment of a determined end certaine 12. Meanes not alwaies conditions 13 M. G's strange inference concerning the Scripture 14. Considered The word of God by him undervalued and subjected to the judgement of vaine men as to its Truth and Authority 15. The pretended reason of the former proceeding discussed The Scripture the sole judge of what is to be ascribed to God and believed concerning him 16. The Doctrine of the Saints Perseverance falsely imposed on and vindicated 17. Mr G's next Objection made to himselfe against his Doctrine its unseasonablenesse as to the Argument in hand demonstrated 18. No Assurance of the Love of God not Peace left the Saints by the Doctrine of Apostasy The ground of Peace and Assurance by it taken away 19. Ground of Pauls Consolation 1 Cor. 9. 27. the meaning of the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 20. Another Plea against the Doctrine attempted to be proved by M. G. That attempt considered Not the weaknesse of the Flesh naturally but the strength of Lust spiritually pretended 21. The cause of Sinne in the Saints farther discussed 22. The Power ascribed by M. G. to men for the strengthning and making willing the Spirit in them considered 23. The Aptnesse of the Saints to performe what and whence The opposition they have in them thereunto 24. Gospell Obedience how easy 25. The Conclusion 26. Answer to Chap. 13. of his Book proposed THE Argument §. 1. wherein Mr Goodwin exposeth the Doctrine under contest to the triall concerning its usefulnesse as to the promotion of Godlinesse in the hearts and wayes of them by whom it is received he thus proposeth Cap. 13. Sect. 32. Pag. 333. That Doctrine which is according to Godlinesse and whose naturall and proper tendencie is to promote Godlinesse in the hearts and lives of men is Evangelicall and of unquestionable comportance with the Truth such is the Doctrine which teacheth the possibility of the Saints declining both totally and finally Ergo Of this Argument he goeth about to establish the respective propositions §. 2. so as to make them serviceable to the enforcement of the Conclusion he aimeth at for the exaltation of the Helena whereon he is enamored and for the major Proposition about which rightly understood we are remote from contesting with him or any else and will willingly and cheerefully at any time drive the cause in difference to Issue upon the singular Testimony of the Truth wrapped up in it he thus conâ—irmeth it The Reason of the major Proposition though the truth of it needeth no light but its owne to be seen by is because the Gospell it selfe is a Doctrine which is according unto Godlinesse a ministry of Godlinesse is a Doctrine
oppose or a wilfull perverting of it contrary to his owne science conscience Is that the Doctrine you oppose Is it so proposed by those who through Grace have laboured to explaine vindicate it Doth not the maine weight of the doctrine turne on this hinge that God hath promised to his Saints true Believers such supplies of the Spirit and Grace as that they shall never degenerate unto such loose and profane courses as are destructive to Godlinesse Doubtlesse that Doctrine is of a most spotlesse untainted innocency which its Adversaries dare not venture to strangle before they have violently treacherously defloured it And thus Mr Goodwin leaveth his Arguments in the dust like the Estriches egges under the feet of men to be trampled on with ease The residue of this Discourse onwards to the next Argument §. 7. beingspent in the answering of pretended Objections put in against himselfe in the behalfe of the Doctrine of Perseverance not at all called out by the import of his present Arguments Discourses I might passe them over but in as much as that which is spoken thereunto tendeth to the further clearing of what formerly hath been evidenced concerning the suitablenesse of the Doctrine contended for unto the promotion of Holinesse I shall farther consider what he draweth forth on this occasion Sect. 33. he giveth us an Objection and a foure fold answer theruuto pag. 333 334 335. That which he calleth an Objection he laieth downe in these words If it be objected and said yea but Assurance of the Unchangeablenesse of God's Love towards him that is Godly is both a more effectuall perswading motive unto Godlinesse and more encouraging to a persevering in Godlinesse then a doubtfulnesse or uncertainty whether God will be constant in his Affection to such a man or no Certainty of reward is more encouraging unto action then uncertainty Ans. If any one hath been so weake §. 8. as to make use of this plea in behalfe of that Doctrine it seemeth to defend which I scarcely believe it will I doubt not be an easie taske to undertake that he shall be no more admitted or entertained as an Advocate in this cause The assurance of the Unchangeablenes of Gods Love to them that are Godly is but one part of the Doctrine in hand that such as may perhaps be cōmon to it with that W ch is brought into competition W th it It is the Assurance of the Unchangeablenes of Gods Love to a man to keepe him up to Godlines to preserve him in that state Condition of Holines to the end of the certainty of the continuance of the Love of God unto him on that account in that way that is that great Gospell motive to Obedience wherein as its peculiar our Doctrine glorieth as hath formerly been manifested Perhaps Mr Goodwin doth not think that any man is bound to lay more blocks in his owne way then he judgeth himselfe well able to remove and therefore he framed that Objection so that he might be sure to returne at least a specious answer thereunto and this he attempteth accordingly and telleth us in his first Paragraph three things 1. That the Doctrine teaching the Saints defection §. 9. doth also maintaine the Vnchangeablenesse of the Love of God to them that are Godly Ans. But what Love I pray you is that which when it might prevent it will yet suffer those Godly ones to become such ungodly Villaines and wretches as that it shall be utterly impossible for the Lord to continue his Love to them Is the Love you mention indeed a Love to their Persons or only an Approbation of their Duties and Qualifications If the First whence is it that God ceaseth at any time to love them Doth he change and alter his Love like the Sonnes of Men Why they change therefore he changeth also That God changeth not and therefore we who are subject to change are yet preserved from being consumed we have heard But that upon the change that is in men God also should change we are yet to be instructed and the Immutability of God hath taken greater hold upon our understandings and in our hearts then that we should easily receive any thing so diametrically opposite thereunto If the Love mentioned be only an Approbation of the Qualifications that are in them and of the Duties that they doe performe then is it no more a Love to them or to their persons then it is to the persons of the most profligate wretches that live The object is Duty solely where ever it may be found and not any person at all for it is an Act of Gods approving not purposing or determining Will. This is not our sence of the continuance of the Love of God to them that are Godly so that there is no comparison betwixt the Doctrines under contest as to the Asserting of the Love of God to Believers or to them that are Godly Wherefore he saith 2. That the Doctrine he opposeth §. 10. Promiseth Gods Love and the unchangeable continuance of it unto men though they change to Prophanenesse Though this is said over and over an hundred times yet I cannot believe it because the Doctrine openly affirmeth the continuance of the Love of God to them that are Godly to be effectually and eventually preventive of any such prophanenesse as is inconsistent therewithall and therefore much more vaine is that which he affirmeth in the third place 3. Namely that the Doctrine of the Perseverance of the Saints doth not so much absolutely promise the Love of God to them that are Godly as it promiseth it conditionally to them that are prophane in case they have been Godly that is it teacheth that God promiseth the certain continuance of his Love to him that is Godly on condition he cease to be so and turne prophane Claudite jam rivos pueri we have enough of this already 2 ly He addeth yet §. 11. Neither is certainty of reward in every sence or kind more encouraging unto Action then uncertainely in some kind to promise with all possible Assurance the same reward or prize to him that shall not runne in the race which is promised to him that shall runne is not more encouraging unto men thus to runne then to promise it conditionally upon their running which is a promising of it with uncertainty in this respect because it is uncertaine whether men will runne in the said race or no and consequently whether they shall receive the said prize or no upon such a promise Vncertainty of reward is then and in such cases more encouraging unto action then certainly When the certainty of obtaining or receiving it is suspended upon the Act not when it is assured unto men whether they Act or no. Ans. 1. Perswade your servants your labourers if you can of that great encouragement that lyes in the the uncertainty of a reward above that which may be had from an Assurance
we see all things unpartially weighed and debated to and fro that the Doctrine which supposeth a possibility of the Saints declining is the Doctrine which is according to Godlinesse and the corrivall of it an enemy thereto Ans. We have here an Assertion an Inference and a Conclusion The Assertion is that there is no such aptnesse and pronenesse to sinne in Believers as is intimated and that because there is such a strong propensity in them to Righteousnesse which that they have is proved from sundry places of Scripture That is because the Spirit is in Believers the flesh is not in them Because they have a new man in them they have not an old because they have a principle of Life they have not a body of death That is where the Spirit lusteth against the flesh the flesh lusteth not against the Spirit We thought the Doctrine of Paul Rom. 7. Gal. 5. and in innumerable other places with the experience off all the Saints in the World had laine against this piece of Sophistry It is true their propension unto Righteousnesse raigneth in them but it is as true their propension unto sinne rebelleth in them Though the Land be conquered for Christ yet the Canaanites will dwell in it if the Saints leave of but one day the worke of killing crucifying and mortifying they will quickly finde an actuall rebellion in them not easie to be suppressed They have indeed a propension to Holinesse ruling in them but also a propension unto sinne dwelling in them so that when they would do good â—vell is present with them and the good they would do they cannot But when Mr Goodwin can prove this consequence that Saints have strong inclinations to Righteousnesse therefore they have not so to sinne for my part I will forbeare for ever disputing with him If he can beat us not only from Scripture but all our Spirituall sence and experience doubtlesse it is to no purpose to contend any longer with him Hence then 2. He inferreth §. 24. that to abstaine from sinning that is sinning customarily against conscience so as to endanger the losse of the Favour of God is no such great mastery no such matter of difficulty to such men This abstaining from such sinnes on the one hand is the whole course of our Gospell Obedience which it seemeth however it be compared to running in a race striving for masteries called resisting unto blood wrestling with principallities and powers requiring for its carrying on the exceeding greatnesse of the power of God with suitable help in time of need from Jesus Christ who is sensible of the weight of it as no small matter knowing what it is to serve God in Temptations yet is it indeed but a trifling thing a matter of no great difficulty or mastery Doe men Watch Pray Contend Fight Wrestle with God and Satan doth the Lord put forth his Power and the Lord Jesus Christ continually intercede for the preservation of the Saints Ad quid perditio haec to what end is all this toile and labour about a thing of little or no weight Egregiam vero laudem We know indeed the Yoke of Christ is easy and his Commandement not grievous that we can doe all things through him that inableth us but to make Gospell obedience so slight a thing that it is no great mastery or matter of no great commendation to hold out in it to the end this we were to learn till now and are as yet slow of heart to receive it The Conclusion is Io §. 25. Pâ—an vicimus all things unpartially weighed the case is ours and Godlinesse exceedingly promoted by the Doctrine of the possibility of the Saints defection 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and the corrivall of it an enemy to it to prove which not one word in the Argument hath been spoken nor to free the other from a charge of a direct contrary importance one word to the purpose and of Mr Goodwins sixth Argument for his Doctrine of the Apostasy of Saints this is the end But this is not all he hath to say in this case §. 26. in hand Indeed the maine designe of his whole 13. Chap. consisting of 41. Sections and about so many pages in his Book and containing all which in an Argumentative way he insisteth on in the case in hand looketh this way and therefore having already pluckt away one of the maine propps of that discourse I shall apply my selfe to take away those which doe remaine that the whole may justly fall to the ground and therefore shall as briefely as I can consider the whole of that discourse containing nine Arguments against the Perseverance of Saints for the possibility of their totall and finall defection CAP. XII 1. M. G. entrance and preface to his Arguments from the Apostasy of the Saints considered 2. The weaknesse of his first Argument The import of it 3. Answer to that first Argument Doctrine may pretend to give God the glory of being no accepter of Persons and yet be false Justification by workes of that rank and order 4. Acceptation of Persons what and wherein it consisteth No place for it with God contrary to distributive Justice 5. The Doctrine of the Saints Perseverance charged with rendring God an accepter of Persons 6. Unjustly what it saies looking this way 7. The summe of the charge against it considered and removed 8. M. G. second Argument and the weight by him hanged thereon the originall of this Argument by whom somewhat insisted on 9. The Argument it selfe in his words proposed of the use and end of the Ministry whether weakned by the Doctrine of Perseverance 10. Entrance unto an Answer to that Argument The foundation laid of it false and when it falsely imposeth on the Doctrine of Perseverance sundry things by it disclaimed the first considered 11. The iniquiry of those impositions farther discovered 12. The true state of the difference as to this Argument declared 13. The Argument satisfied 14. The reinforcement of the Minor attempted and considered 15. The manner of Gods operations with and in naturall and voluntary Agents compared Efficacy of Grace and liberty in man consistent 16. An Objection to himselfe framed by M. G. that Objection rectified Perseverance how absolutely and simply necessary how not 17. The removall of the pretended Objection farther insisted on by M. G. 18. That discourse discussed and manifested to be weake and sophisticall The consistency of Exhortations and Promises farther cleared 19. The manner of the operation of Grace in and upon the wills of men considered 20. The inconsistency of exhortations with the efficacy of Grace disputed by M. G. 21. That discourse removed and the use of Exhortations farther cleared Obedience to them twofold Habituall Actuall of the Physicall operation of Grace and meanes of the word their compliance and use How the one and the other affect the will 22. Inclination to Persevere when wrought in Believers 23. Of the manner of Gods operation
on the wills of men M. G. discourse and judgement 24. Considered 25. Effects follow as to their kind their next causes 26. The same Act of the will Physicall and Morall upon severall accounts Those accounts considered 27. God by the reall efficacy of the Spirit produceth in us Acts of the will morally good that confirmed from Scripture 28. Conclusion from thence 29. Of the termes Physicall Morall and necessary and their use in things of the nature under consideration Morall causes of Physicall effects 30. The concurrence of Physicall and Morall causes for producing the same effect the efficacy of Grace and exhortations 31. Physicall and necessary how distinguished Morall and not necessary Confounded by M. G. 32. M. G. farther progresse considered 33. What operation of God on the will of man he allowes All Physicall operation by him excluded 34. M. G's sence of the difference between the working of God and a Minister on the will that it is but graduall 35. Considered and removed All working of God on the will by him confined to perswasion perswasion gives no strength or ability to the person perswaded 36. All immediate acting of God to good in men by M G. utterly excluded 37. Wherein Gods perswading men doth consist according to M. G. 1 Cor. 3. 9. considered 38. Of the concurrence of diverse Agents to the production of the same effect 39. The summe of the 7 Section of Gh. 13. The will how necessitated how free 40. In what seuce M. G. allowes Gods perswasions to be irresistible 41. The dealings of God and men ill compared 42. Pauls exhortation to the use of meanes where the end was certaine Acts 24. câ—dfâ—dered God deals with men as men exhorting them and as corrupted men assisting them 43. Of Promises of Temporall things whether all conditionall 44. What condition in the Promise made to Paul Act. 27. 45. Farther of that Promise its infallibility and meanes of Accomplishment 46. The same considerations farther prosecuted 47. 48. Of Promises of Perseveranâ—e and what relations to performe in conjuction 49. M. G. opposition hereunto 50. Promises and protestations in conjunction 1 Cor. 10. 12 13. discussed An absolute Promise of Perseverance therein evinced 51. Phil. 1. 12 13. to the same purpose considered M. G. Interpretation of that place proposed removed 52. Heb. 6. 4 5 9. to the same purpose insisted on 53. Of the consistency oâ— Threatnings with the Promises of Perseverance 54. M. G. opposition hereunto 55. Considered and removed What Promises of Perseverance are asserted how absolute and infrustable Feare of Hell and punishment twofold The feare intended to be ingenerated by threatnings not inconsistent with the Assurance given by promises 56. Five Considerations about the use of Threatnings the first c. 57. Hipocrites how threatned for Apostasy of the End and Aime of God in Threatnings 58. Of the proper End and Efficacy of Threatnings with reference unto true Believers 59. Feare of Hell and punishment how farre a principle of Obedience in the Saints 60. Of Noahs feare Heb. 11. 7. 61. M. G's farther arguings for the Efficacy of the feare of Hell unto Obedience in the Saints proposed considered removed 62. 1 Ioh. 4. 18. consâ—dered 63. Of the Obedience of Saints to their heavenly Father compared to the obedience of Children to their naturall Parents M. G's monstrous conception about this thing 64. How Feare or Love and in what sence are principles of Obedience That which is done from Feare not done willingly not chearfully 65. How Feare and what feare hath torment 66. Of the nature and use of Promises Close of the Answer to this Argument IT will be needlesse to use many words unto the Discourse of the first Section §. 1. seeing it will not in the least prejudice our Cause in hand to leave Mr Godwin in full possession of all the Glory of the Rethoricke thereof For although I cannot close with him in the Exposition given of that expression 1 Tim. 6. 16. God inhabiteth Light inaccessible some thing in my weake apprehension much more glorious divine being comprised therein then what it is here turned aside unto Neither am I in the least convinced of the truth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of the former Discourse in the close of the whole asserting a deliverance to be obtained from our thoughts of the Doctrine of the defection of the Saints which he intimateth to be that it is anti-evangelicall tormenting and bringing soules under bondage by a narrow and unprejudicate search into it finding my selfe every day more and more confirmed in thoughts of that kind concerning it by my engagement into such an enquiry which hath been observed in this present Discourse as farre as my weakenesse will permit yet it being not in the least Argumentative but for the whole frame and intendment of it Commune exordium and that which any man of any opinion in the world might make use of I shall not insist upon it His second Section containeth his first Argument §. 2. drawne forth in the defence of his Doctrine of the possibility as he calleth it but indeed what it is we have heard of the defection of Believers Of this I presume he intended no more use but as a forlorne to begin a light Skirmish with his Adversaries ordering it to retreat to his maine Body advancing after or desperately casting it away to abate the Edge of his Combatants Weapons it is so weake and feeble and therefore I shall be very briefe in the consideration of it thus then he proposeth it That Doctrine which rendreth God free from the unrighteousnesse which the Scripture calleth the respecting of persons of men is a Doctrine of perfect consistence with the Scripture and the truth The Doctrine which teacheth the possibility of the Saints declining and this unto death is a Doctrine of this import Ergo. Ans. 1. §. 3. The first proposition must be supposed Vniversall of else the whole will quickly be manifested to be unconclusive If it be only Indefinite and so equivalent as it lieth to a particular the conclusion is from all particulars and of no force as Mr Goodwin well knoweth Take it universally and I say it is evidently false and might easily be disproved by innumerable Instances Not that any errour or falsehood can indeed give God the Glory of any one of his Attributes but that they may be fitted and suited for such a service were not their throates cut and their mouthes stopt by the Lies that are in them which Mr Goodwin's Doctrine is no lesse lyable to then any other and not at all exempted from that Condition by its seeming subserviency unto Gods Aprosopolepsia Doth not the Doctrine of Justification by Workes even in the most rigid sence of it according to the tenor of the old Covenant absolutely render God free from the Unrighteousnesse of Accepting of Persens And yet for all that it hath not one jot the more of Truth in it nor is it the
we are disenabled from persuing the Comparison instituted The one part being not to be considered or at least not being considerable The time when first Head was made against the Truth we professe and Criminations like those managed by Mr Goodwin hatched and contrived to Assault it withall was when it had been eminently delivered to the Saints of this Nation and all the Churches of Christ by Reinolds Whitakers Greenham and others like to them their fellow labourers in the Lords Vineyard The poore weake Wormes of this present Generation who imbrace the same Doctrine with these men of name are thought to be free some of them at least from being destroyed by the poysonous and pernicious embracing of it by their owne weakenesse and disability to discerne the naturall genuine Consequences and Tendency in the progresse of that which in the Roote and Foundation they imbrace Their ignorance of their owne Doctrine in its compas Extent is the Mother of that Devotion which in them is nourished thereby So our great Masters tell us against whose Kingly Authority in these things there is no rising up For the Persons formerly named the like reliefe cannot be supposed He that shall provide an Apology for them Affirming that they understood not the state nature consequences and tendences of the Doctrines they received defended preached contended for will scarce be able by any following defensative to vindicate his owne credit for so doing In the lives then and the Ministry of those men and such as those if any where are the fruits of this Doctrine to be seene If it corrupted not their lives nor weakned their Ministry if it turned not them aside from the pathes of Gospell Obedience nor weakened their hands in the Dispensation of the Word in the Promises Threatnings and Exhortations thereof to the Conversion of soules and building up of those who by their Ministry were called in their most holy Faith it cannot but be a strong presumption that there is no such venomous infectious quality in this Doctrine as of late some Chimicall Divines pretend themselves to be able to extract out of it Now what I pray were these men What were their Lives What was their Ministry All those who now oppose Mr Goodwin's Doctrine do it either out of Ignorance or to Comply with Greatnesse and men in Authority thereby to make up themselves in their Ambitious and worldly aymes and to prevaile themselves upon the opinion of men for what cause else in the world can be imagined why they should so ingage what though they really believed the whole fabricke of his Doctrine wherein he hath departed from the Faith he once as they say professed to be a lye A lye of dangerous and pernitious Consequence to the soules of men a lye derogatory to the Glory of God the efficacy of Grace the merit of the Death of Christ and the honour of the Gospell and full of disconsolation to poore soule◠being in and under Temptation What though they suppose it secretly to undermine the maine fundamentals of the Covenant of Grace and covertly to substitute another Covenant in the Roome thereof what though they have observed that the Doctrine they have received was Imbraced Preached prized by all those great and blessed soules which in the last Generation God magnified with the conversion of so many thousands in this Nation given into their Ministry whilst they spent their dayes under continuall Aflictions persecutions what though they have the generall known consent of all the Reformed Churches beyond the Seas with them in their zeale for the Doctrine under consideration What though under these the like apprehensions they profes in the presence of God his holy Angels and men that the eternall Interest of the precious soules of men is more valuable to them ten thousand times than their owne lives and that that is the sole Reason of their opposition to M. 〈◊〉 in his attempts against the Doctrine they have so received and imbraced yet it is meet for us to Judge and for all to whom evill surmises are not esteemed to be among the workes of the flesh that all their opposition is nothing but a cōplyance with and pursuit of those worldly low and wretched aimes that they are filled withall But as to those Persons before mentioned what shall we say Their Piety Literature Zeale Diligence Industry Labour with successe in the worke of the Ministry and that under manifold discouragements are so renowned in the world that how or wherewith they shall be shifted of from being considerable in their Testimony I cannot imagine If ever Persons in these latter Ages had written upon their breasts Holynesse to the Lord If ever any bare about a conformity to the Death and resurrection of our Lord Jesus Christ they may put in for an eminent esteeme and name among them will doubtlesse be found at last to be of the thirty if they attaine not to the first Ranke of the Worthyes of Christ in these ends of the world How is it that they were not retarded in the course of their Gospell Obedience by their entertainement of this wretched Doctrine of the Saints Perseverance But what though they kept themselves Personally from the pollution of it yet possibly their Ministry was defiled and rendered uselesse by it And who I pray is it that in this Generation can so support himselfe with successe in the Ministry as to rise up with this accusation against them Many thousands who were their Crowne their Glory and Rejoycing in Christ are fallen a sleepe and some Continue to this day Of the Reasons given by Mr Goodwin why all the Zealous Fruitfull Faithfull Preachers of former dayes imbraced this Doctrine we shall instantly undertake the Consideration In the meane time this seems strange that God should magnify and make famous the Ministry of so many throughout the world and give in that visible blessing to their Labours therein which hath filled this Island with such an increase of Children to Sion as that she hath not lengthned the cords of her Tabernacle to such an extent and compasse in any proportionable spot of earth under Heaven if any one eminent part of their Doctrine and that whereon they lay'd great weight in their Ministry which they pressed with as much fervency and contention of Spirit as any head of the like importance should indeed be so apparently destructive of Holinesse and of such a direct and irresistible efficiency to render uselesse that great Ordinance of the Ministry committed to them as this is clamoured to be What will be the successe of them in their Ministry who shall undertake to deny and oppose it I hope the People of God in this Nation will not have many Instances to Judge by The best conjecture we can for the present make of what will be hereafter must be taken from what hath already come to passe and the best guesse of what events will be are to be raised from
of mankind not at all to any of those whereby they are distingunished as such This they professed to have a powerfull Efficacy to prevaile with them for that exactnesse in walking with God which by his Grace they attained unto And why they should not be believed herein as farre a sany men whatever bearing the like Testimony to any Doctrine whatever I know not Besides the intendment of this instance of the Persons and their Piety who formerly Believed and spake forth this Doctrine was to manifest by an eminent experiment that there was not in it nor is any tendency to a contrary frame unto Piety Holines which it is injuriously charged withall if by the consideration thereof we do not obtaine that it hath a proper and direct serviceablenesse to the promotion of Godlinesse yet at least we have a convincing demonstration that it is no way obstructive to it Nextly §. 15. Sect. 26. Mr Goodwin entreth upon his defensative to the charge against his Doctrine whose Foundation is laid in the unworthinesse of its Authors in this Nation before it fell upon his hand These he confesseth to be the worst of our late Bishops with such as Romanized â—yrannized among them with their Clergie creatures favorites Persons many of theÌ„ of superstition loosenes much profanenes Of the Apologie shaped for the clearing of the Doctrine he maintaineth from aparticipation with them in their unworthinesse there are three parts In the 1. whereof he denieth that this Doctrine did any way induce them to the loosenesse that was found upon them In the other two giveth as many Reasons of their receiving of it and cleaving to it As for the first part I shall willingly assent to him that the Holinesse or unholinesse of Professors is not to be charged on the Religion they professe I meane appearing Holinesse in the profession of it unlesse there be an evidence of a connexion betwixt their principles practises which in this case to us our apprehension of them who charge this Doctrine with the miscarriages of those men there is At least we may insist on this that there is a suitablenesse in the whole Systeme of the Doctrine whereof the Apostacy of the Saints is an eminent parcell to that frame of Spirit which is in men of loose and superstitious wayes enemies of the Grace of God and power of Godlinesse Neither can there any other reason be tollerably assigned or alledged for the embracement of that Doctrine by those Persons formerly mentioned but only their ignorance of envy to the great Misteryes of the Gospell the Covenant of Grace with union communion and close walking with God A designe was upon them written with the beames of the Sunne to cry up a barren outside light and loose profession with a vaine superstitious selfe-invented Worship of God instead of the Power of a Gospell-conversation and Ordinances of Christ according to his appointment Seeking after a Righeousnesse as it were by the workes of the Law and being ignorant of the Righteousnesse of Christ they found the whole Doctrine whose defence M. G. hath lately undertaken suited to their principles and aimes and therefore with greedinesse drunke it downe like water untill they were swelled with the Dropsy of Pride and selfe conceit beyond what they could beare whatever be now pretended it was little disputed then and in those dayes which Mr Goodwin pointeth unto but that loosenesse of Life inclination to Popery enmity to the power of Godlinesse were at the bottome of the entertainement of the Arminian Principles by that generation of men But Mr G. proceedeth to alleviate this charge §. 16. informes us thus That if the soundnes rottennes of Opinions should be esteemed by the goodnes or badnes of the Lives of any parcell or number of Persons professing the same as well the Opinion of Atheisme which denyeth the being of any God as the opinion of Polytheisme which affirmeth a plurality of Gods must be esteemed better and more sound than that which maintaineth the being of one God and of one only for certaine it is that there have been many Heathens Professours some of the one some of the other of those Opinions who have quitted themselves upon fairer tearmes of honour and approbation in their lives than many Christians professing of the last opinion have done I am not willing to wring this Nose too farre least bloud should follow The lives of many Atheists and Pagans are preferred before the lives of many professing Christianity By Professors of Christianity Mr Goodwin intendeth those who are so indeed and seasoned with the Power of the Principles of that Religion or such only as making an outward profession of it are indeed acted with Principles quite of another nature which notwithstanding all their Profession rendreth them in the truth of the thing it selfe enemies of the crosse of Christ their God being their belly their glory being in their shame and their end being destruction Philip. 3. 18 19. If the former be intended as the Assertion is most false the Gospell only effectually teaching men to deny all ungodlinesse and to live soberly righteously and Godly in this present world so it tendeth directly to the highest derogation from the honour of our Lord Jesus Christ and of his glorious Gospell He that would be throughly acquainted with the notorious untruth of this insinuation let him a little consult Tertullian Arnobius Lactantius Austin others handling the Lives Conversations of the best of the Polytheists and Heathens before in their dayes if he be not contented to take a shorter course and rest in the Authority of the Apostle or rather of the Holy Ghost describing them and their conversations to the Life as they lay under the just hardening Judgements of God Rom. 1. 18. to the end If the latter sort of men called Christians be intended the comparison instituted between them and Atheists is to no purpose they themselves being disclaimed and disowned by Christ his Gospell and reckoned among them with whom they are compared So that upon the matter this is but the comparing one sort of Atheists with an other and giving in a Judgement that of all those are worst whose practises are so and yet pacifie their owne Consciences and deceive the world with a pretence flowrish of a glorious profession I shall not now enter upon any long enquiry what influence the ungodly and profane lives of any ought to have upon the Judgements of men in discovering and discerning of the Doctrines that they bring especially if such as consent in any Doctrine do also concurre in a dissolutenesse of conversation That it will be of no small consideration the experience of all Ages hath evinced The Athenians refused a virtuous Law because the Person was vicious who proposed it and it is generally esteemed that there is a correspondency betwixt the principles practices of those men who earnestly
from you so that you also having my Law written in your hearts shall never utterly and wickedly depart from me And for such sinnes and follies as you shall be overtaken withall I will graciously heale your backslidings and receive you freely This is the Language of the Doctrine we maintaine which is not we full well know obnoxious to any Exceptions or Consequences what ever but such as bold and prejudiced men for the countenance of their vaine conceits and opinions will venture at any time to impose and fasten on the most pretious Truths of the Gospell That God should say to Believers as is imposed on him fall into what sinnes they will or abominations they can yet he will have them believe that by an irresistible hand he will necessitate them to Persevere that is in and under their Apostacy which is evidently implyed in their falling into sinnes and abominations in the manner insisted on is a ridiculous fiction to the imagination whereof the least colour is not supplied by the Doctrine intended to be â—raduced thereby Secondly §. 4. for the ensuing Exhortations Promises and Threatnings as farre as they are really Evangelicall whose use and tendency is argued to be inconsistent with the Doctrine before proposed I have formerly manifested What is their proper use and efficacy in respect of Believers and their consistency with the truth we maintaine apprehended as it is indeed and not visarded with ugly and dreadfull appearances will I presume scarcely be called in question by any who having received a Kingdome that cannot he shaken doe know what it is to serve God acceptably with reverence and Godly feare It is true they are made unto and have their use in reference unto them that Believe and shall Persevere therein but they are not given unto them as men assured of their Perseverance but as men called to the use of meanes for the establishing of their soules in the wayes of obedience They are not in the method of the Gospell irrationally happed on such intimations of unchangeable Love or proposed under such wild Conditionalls and Suppositions as here by our Author but annexed to the Appointment of those wayes of Grace and Peace which God calls his Saints unto being suited to worke upon the new nature wherewith they are indued as spreading it selfe over all the facultyes of their Rationall Soules wherein are Principles fit to be excited to Operation by Exhortations and Promises Thirdly §. 5. all that is indeed Argumentative in this Discourse is built on this Foundation that a Spirituall Assurance of attaining the end by the use of meanes is discouraging and disswasive to the use of those meanes A Proposition so uncouth in it selfe so contradictory to the experience of all the Saints of God so derogatory to the Glory and Honour of Jesus Christ himselfe who in all his Obedience had doubtles an Assurance of the end of it all as any thing that can well fall into the imaginations of the Hearts of men Might not the Devill have thus replyed upon our Saviour when he tempted him to turne Stones into Bread cast himselfe from a pinacle of the Temple received Answer that man lives not by Bread alone but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God but alas thou Jesus the Sonne of the Living God that art perswaded thou art so and that God will preserve thee whether thou usest any meanes or no that thou shalt never be starved for want of Bread nor hurt thy selfe by any fall whatever thou clost the Angells having charge that no evill shall come nigh thee nor thy foot be hurt against a stone thou maist now cast thy selfe headlong from the Temple to manifest thy Assurance of the Love and Faithfullnesse of God with his Promises to thee If our Saviour thought it sufficient to stop the mouth of the Devill to manifest from Scripture that notwithstanding the Assurance from God that any one hath of the end yet he is to use the meanes tending thereunto a neglect whereof is a sinfull tempting of God we shall not need to goe farther for an Answer to the same kind of Objections in the mouth of any Adversary whatever His 19 th Section containeth his fourth Argument §. 6. in these words If there be no possibility of the Saints falling away finally then is their Persevering uncapable of reward from God But their finall Perseverance is not uncapable of reward from God Ergo The minor Proposition I presume containes nothing but what is the sence of those who deny the conclusion or how ever it containes nothing but what is the expresse sence of the Lord Christ where he saith that he that endureth to the end the same shall be saved Therefore I suppose we shall bee excused from farther proofe of this without any prejudice to the cause in hand Ans. I grant Eternall Life may be called the Reward of Perseverance in the sence that the Scripture useth that word applyed to the matter in hand It is afterward neither procured by properly and Morally as the deserving cause nor proportioned unto the obedience of them by whom it is attained a Reward it is that withall is the free gift of God and an Inheritance purchased by Jesus Christ a Reward of Bounty and not of Iustice in respect of them upon whom it is bestowed but only of faithfulnesse in reference to the promise of it A Reward by being a gratious incouragement as the end of our obedience not as the procurement or desert of it so we grant it a Reward of Perseverance though those words of our Saviour he that endureth to the end the same shall be saved expressed a consequence of things only and not a connexion of causality of the one upon the other of the foundation of this discourse concerning a possibility of declining immediate consideration shall be had He proceeds then The consequence of the Major Proposition §. 7. stands firme upon this foundation No act of the Creature whereunto it is necessitated or which it cannot possibly decline or but doe is by any Law of God or rule of Iustice rewardable therefore if the Saints be necessitated by God to Persevere finally so that he leaves unto them no possibility of declining finally their finall Perseverance is not according to any Law of God or man nor indeed to any principles of Reason or Equity capable of reward no whit more than actions meerely naturall are Nay of the two there seems be more reason why acts meerely naturall as for example Eating Drinking Breathing Sleeping should be rewarded in as much as these flow in a way of necessity yet from an inward principle and connaturall to the Agent than such actions whereunto the agent is constrain'd necessitated determined by a principle of power from without and which is not intrinsecall to it And this is the strength of the Argument which will quickly appeare to be very weakenesse For First the efficacy of
is this Because such a signification of it would render the sence altogether inconsistent with the scope of the Apostle which is to exhort Christians unto righteousnesse and Love of the brethren now it is contrary to common sence its selfe to signify unto those whom we perswade to any duty any such thing which imports an absolute certainty or necessity of their doing it whether they take care or use any meanes for the doing of it or no and a cleare case it is that the certainty of a perpetuall remaining of the seed of God in those that are borne of him importeth a like certainty of their perpetuall performance of that duty whereunto they are exhorted Ans. If this be all it might have been spared The Argument consisteth of two parts 1. An aspersion of the infinite wisdome of God with a procedure contrary to all Reason and common sence 2. A begging of the thing in question betwixt its Author and its Adversaries That there is any thing at all in the Text even according to our Interpretation of it that importeth an absolute necessity of mens doing any thing whether they take care to use the meanes of doing it or no the Reader must judge The abiding of the Seed is that we say which shall effectually cause them in whom it is to use the meanes of not sinning that eventually they may not doe so and that a certainty of the use of meanes is imported is no Argument to prove that their necessity of Persevering is proved whether they use meanes yea or no. To take care to use meanes is amongst the meanes appointed to be used and this they shall doe upon the account of the abiding seed That indeed which is opposed is that God cannot promise to worke effectually in us by the use of meanes for the accomplishment of an appointed end but that withall rendreth uselesse and vaine all his exhortations to us to use those meanes This is M. Goodwins Argument from the place it selfe to inforce that improper Acceptation of the word remaineth in us What remaineth of M. Goodwins long discourse upon this Text of Scripture §. 72. is but a fencing with himselfe and raising of Objections and Answering them suitably to his owne principles wherein we are not in the least concerned There is not any thing from the beginning to the end of it that tendeth to impeach our Interpretation of the place or impede the progresse of our Argument but only a flourish set upon his own Exposition which if he were desired to give in briefely and in termes of a plaine downeright significancy I am verily perswaded he would be hardly put to it to let us know what his mind and conceptions of this place of Scripture are But of this subject and in Answer to his Fifth Argument with this Chapter this is the issue CAP. XVI 1. M. G's seaventh Argument about the tendency of the Doctrine of the Saints Aposlas◠as to their consolation proposed 2. Considered what that doctrine offereth for the consolation of the Saints offered the impossibility of its affording the least true consolation manifested 3. The influence of the Doctrine of the Saints Perseverance into their consolation 4. The medium whereby M. G. confirmes his Argument examined what kind of Nurse for the Peace and consolation of the Saints the Doctrine of Apostasy is whether their obedience be farthered by it what are the causes and springs of true consolation 5. M. G. Eight Argument proposed to consideration 6. Answer thereunto the minor Proposition considered the Holy Ghost not afraid of the Saints miscarriages 7. The confirmation of his Minor Proposition proposed and considered 8. The Discourse assigned to the Holy Ghost by M. G. according to our principles 9. Considered 10. Exceptions against it the First 11. The Second 12. The Third 13. The Fourth 14. The Fifth 15. The Sixth 16. The Seaventh 17. The foundation of M.G. Pageant everted 18. The proceedings of the Holy Ghost in exhortations according to our principles 19. Sophismes in the former discourse farther discovered 20. His farther plea in this case proposed 21. Considered 22. The instance of Christ and his obedience considered and vindicated as to the application of it to the businesse in hand 23. M.G. last Argument proposed 24. Examined 25. 1 Ioh 2. 19. explained 26. Vindicated 27. Argument from thence for the Perseverance of the Saints 28. M.G. exceptions thereunto 29. Considered and 30. Removed 31 32 33 34 35 36 37. The same words farther perused 38. M.G. Consent with the Remonstrants manifested by his trascriptions from their Synodalia 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47. Our Argument from 1 Ioh. 2. 19. fully cleared 48. The conclusion of the examination of M. G. Arguments for the Apostasy of the Saints THE seaventh Argument which Mr Goodwin insisteth upon §. 1. in the 36. Section of his 13. Chapter containes one of the greatest Rarities he hath to shew in the whole packe concerning the influence of the Doctrine of the Saints Apostacy into their Consolation in their walking with God an undertaking so uncapable of any Logicall Confirmation as that though Mr Goodwin interweave his Discourse concerning it with a Sillogisme yet he quickly leaves that thorney path and pursues it only with a Rhetoricall flourish of words found out and set in order to deceive At the head then of his Discourse he placeth this Argument as it is called That Doctrine whose genuine and proper tendency is to advance the peace and joy of the Saints in Believing is of a naturall sympathy with the Gospell and upon this account a truth such is the Doctrine which informeth the Saints of a possibility of their totall and finall falling away Ergo. The Proposition of this syllogisme he supposes we will grant §. 2. and not to trouble the Reader with the Qualifications and limitations formerly annexed to that which proposed the furtherance of the obedience of the Saints as a proofe of the truth of any Doctrine for my part I do For the proofe of the Assumption wherein alone Mr Goodwin's interest in this Argument doth lye He referrs us to his 9. Chapter where as he tells us if we may believe him he hath undenyably demonstrated the truth of it But we have considered whatever looks that way in that Chapter and have found it all as Chaffe and stubble before the breath of the Spirit of the Lord in the Word That which lyes upon his shoulders to support A burthen too heavy for him to beare whose demonstration he hath undertaken is that it tends to the Peace Joy Consolation of the Saints of God in their walking with him which arises from and solely depends upon that assurance they have of their eternall fruition of him through Christ to be instructed that indeed they are in themselves weake unable to do any thing as they ought that they have no strength to continue in the Mercy of God but carry about with them