But if any man say unto you this is offered in sacrifice to Idols eat it not for his sake that shewed it and for conscience sake conscience I say not thine own but of others for why is my liberty judged of another mans conscience Yea some grow so far as to alow a liberty upon occasion to be present before an outward Idol without superstition or adoration in the heart because that the true beleevers well informed know that such an Idol is nothing in the world 1 Cor. 8.4 That is say they neither such a God as some out of a superstitious devotion would make it nor such a Divel or defiling thing as others out of their superstitious conceits and feares would have it to be this practise they would justify from Ezekiels presence before Idols Ezek. 8. throughout and Pauls present beholding of Idols and Idolaters at Athens Acts 17 23. And from the answer which Elisha gave to Naamaus quaere and scruple 2 Kings 5.18 19. True it is indeed That the great Idol is the God of this world and next to him our lusts and corrupt desires Col. 3.4 covetousness but any other thing by too much esteem love or fear of it or trust and confidence in it may be made an Idol even our Authors ministers shepherds may be Idolized Zac. 10.2 Zac. 13.2 Your second fail in this first Section as we said is your preposterous placing of the Christian liberties which you recite for you set freedom from the guilt of sin the condemning wrath of God and the curse of the moral Law before deliverance from bondage to sin and Satan which in order of nature must go before as we have proved before Your third fail is in mistakes for the sting of death is sin it self 1 Cor. 15.5 6. which if it cannot be subdued wholy in this life as you affirm then the sting of death cannot be wholy taken away or we freed from it here So likewise the victory which the Apostle there speaks of is not that of the Grave but of Hell which is the inward condemnation of conscience against both which the Apostle triumphs With thanksgiving to God for the victory that is to be had in Christ Jesus for all true beleevers In your second Section you straighten liberty of Conscience as much as you did Christian freedom in the first for though the requiring of an implicite faith be destructive to Liberty of Conscience and the imposing of the doctrines and precepts of men upon us as if they were the commandments of God from which your selves are not free in the next chapter and elsewhere is very injurious likewise yet the Liberty of Conscience may be divers other wayes invaded and infringed As first By violent means to seek to alter conscientious mens judgments and their present perswasions for it is the office of him that is the Lord of Conscience To lighten and change mens mindes when and how he pleaseth Phil. 3.15 Let us therefore as many as be perfect be thus minded and if in any thing you be otherwise minded God shall reveale this unto you Secondly By like forcible means to incite anothe to will and act against his Conscience and much more by imprisonment mulcts terrours or threats Romans 14.15 20 21. For this is to make him destroy his soul verse 20 23. Thirdly we may not disturbe the peace of mens Consciences or make their hearts sad with our invectives or menacing them causelessly with terrours from the Lord Ezekiel 13.32 Because with lies ye have made the hearts of the righteous sad whom I have not made sad c. In your third Section you do deservedly oppose the practice of any sin and the cherishing of any the least sinful lust upon pretence of Christian Liberty But whereas you add ' That this is to destroy the end of Christian Liberty which you there place in two things deliverance from the hands of our enemies and a freedom to serve the Lord without fear in holiness and righteousness before him all the daies of our life you in some sort contradict your selves in calling these the end of our Christian Liberty which you had in the first Section made two main parts of our Christian Liberty as indeed they are In your fourth Section you have set good bounds betwixt the subjects or subordinates and the Governours saying That they who upon pretence of Christian Liberty shall oppose any lawful power or the lawful exercise of it whether it be Civil or Eclesiastical resist the Ordinances of God Wherein your Doctrine is sound and good whatever your practice hath been or may be to the contrary For God is the Author of order and not of confusion and he which hath armed superiors according to their state and degree with authority hath imposed subjection in all lawful things with many other respective duties upon the inferiours and subordinates It is true likewise That no such opinions should be published or practises maintained as are contrary to the light of Nature to the known and received Principles of Christianity in all Ages especially those of the Primitive and purest times whether they concerne Faith Worship or Conversation or are opposite to the power of Godliness But how far the different opinions and judgements of men may by learned men who yet want spiritual eies be judged erroneous prejudicial to the power of Godliness either in their own nature or in the manner of publishing and maintaining them we know not We are as much for modesty and sobriety in men and as far from any thing that is destructive to the external Peace and Order which Christ hath established in the Church or Common Wealth as your selves or any other But we would not have you assume to your selves or attribute unto others a power to lord it over mens Faith and Consciences especially when men walk obediently towards those that are in places of Rule and Authority and live a Godly honest sober peaceable and unblamable life If Men will do wickedly and pretend a liberty in Christ so to do let them be liable to the sword of Justice for so doing But far be it from us so much as by example to draw a weak brother a Saint and fellow servant of the Lord whom no man can accuse but for his different judgement to do any thing against Conscience whereby he should condemn himself as the Apostle speakes Romans 14. How much more ought Governours to be tender and abstemious in the use of violent and coercive meanes to precipitate men into such perilous and destructive courses All Authority is given of God for mens welfare and much more for the Preservation and not the Destruction of the Soul But Brethren you which are so punctual in teaching the Subject his duty to free your selves from flattery temporising or partiallity might have done God and his people yea the Governours themselves no disservice in minding them of their duties also and so setting due limits and boundaries
whereof take these few John 1.13 Which were born not of bloud nor of the will of the flesh nor of the will of man but of God John 3.6 That which is born of the flesh is flesh and that which is born of the spirit is spirit 1 Cor. 2.14 15. For the natural men perceiveth not the things of the spirit of God for they are foolishness unto him Neither can he know them for they are spiritually discerned But the spiritual man discerneth all things but is discerned of none 1 Cor. 15.22 For as in Adam all die so in Christ shall all be made alive and verse 45 46 47 48 49. As it is written the first man was made a living soul but the second Adam was made a quickening spirit Hewbeit that was not first which is spiritual but that which is natural and then that which iâ— spiritual The first man is of the â—â—rth earthy the second mâ—n is the Lord from heaven as is the earthy such are they that are earthy and as is the heavenly such are they that are heavenly and as we have born the image of the earthly so must we bear the image of the heavenly c. More particularly we answer That this one by whom sin entred into the world is not meant our first parent Adam but our own earthy or natural man which is called Adam and Edom from the earth of his foundation For the apostle shews that Adam our progenitor was not the original or first sinner 1 Timothy 2.14 For Adam was not deceived but the woman being deceived was in the transgression according then to your Doctrine the apostle should have said By one Woman sin entred into the world But you hear before how Solomon Eccles 7.29 and the Lord himself Hos 14 1. scribe our fall to our selves This is yet clearer out of the 14. verse here where the apostle speaks of some who sinned after the similitude of Adams transgression but makes mention of none that sinned in him where he had fair occasion to speak of it yea if he had been of your belief he had committed a grievous neglect totally to omit it in silence Secondly here by the world into which sin entered we must understand the world of fallen and corrupt men as our Saviour doth Joâ—n 3.16 17. and John 15.17 18. and not all mankinde as you do c. Thirdly by death is not meant the bodily death which doth not presently ensue upon our fall no more then it did upon our first parents but a death unto righteousness or the life of innocencie with the contrary body of sin and so obnoxiousness to eternal death is hear meant Fourthly these words and death passed upon all men 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 are thus to be rendered in as much or so far forth as all have sinned and as Moses in the 14. verse is not he that was the Lawgiver but the work of the Law drawing us to God so neither is this man the litterall Adam For Paul here saith That death reigned from Adam to Moses which must be understood necessarily thus from the fall of our natural Adam till the work of the Law came For otherwise the extent of the reign of sin should reach from the first man to the last and not to Moses onely Which thing the 13. ver holdeth out more plainly that he meant by Mose the Law For it is there said That until the Law sin was in the world which must be conceived that until the work of the law sin is in the world that is likewise in the faln corrupted men undiscovered which is plain from the latter part of the 13 verse where it is said sin is not reputed nor regarded as the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 signifies and so Coverdel translates it and not imputed when there is no Law for that is false that sin was not imputed when there was no Law extant for it was imputed to Cain Gen. 4. and he was punished So to the old world and they punished Gen. 6 so to Babels builders and they punished Gen. 11.7.8 so it was imputed to Sodom and Gomorrab and they punished Gen. 19. when there was none of Moses law extant but it is a very truth that sin is not reputed not regarded when there is no work of the Law discovering sin unto the man so St. Paul saith of himself Rom. 7.9 that he was alive without the Law and verse v. he saith he had not known lust but by the Law and Rom. 3.20 it is said that by the Law cometh the knowledge of sin Thus you see how death raigned from Adam to Moses yet not from the first individual Adam to Moses the Law-giver but in the 2. part of the 14 ver it is not affirmed that any sinned in the first individual Adam for he saith Some finned not after the similitude of Adams transgression over whom notwithstanding death reigned Now that expression hinteth these two things First Some sinned like Adam not in Adam others sinned not after the similitude of his transgression but some other way as after Esau's transgression Hebr. 18.16 17. or the like according to that Eccles 7.29 Surely if the Apostle had beleeved any such thing as the raigning of death over all men by the first mans sin he would not have omitted that and onely mentioned from Adam to Moses for all may perceive his main designe is from verse 12. to the 15. to set forth the inlet and extent of deaths reigning over sinners therefore he would have used the fullest and plainest expression serving to that purpose but the 19. verse is more plain against universal corruption by the first mans disobedience for there the Apostle useth the word many and saith by one mans disobediene many not all were made sinners Therefore all fell not in the first individual Adam If any yet reply That many in that place is tant ' amount and equivalent to the word all We Answer That then by the same reason the word many in the latter part of the verse must have the same latitude allowed for the Apostle setteth down a full comparison of equals in that verse here the verse must be thus interpreted That as by one mans disobedience all were made sinners so by one mans obedience all are made righteous If any yet reply and say By one mans obedience all that repent and beleeve are made righteous then by the same inter retation By ones mans disobedience all are made sinners that imitate him and sin like him after the similitude of Adam 's transgressions Thus all men may see there is nothing gained by interpreting the word many by a Synecdoche for all are made sinners by one mans disobedience for the latter part of the verse must have the word many so explained which to affirm namely that all are righteous by Christ by an absolute and uniuersal Justification is accounted as detestable an Heresy as it hath been hitherto to deny that
Inâ—rdinate affection evil concupiscence and coveâ—ousness c. This is that Earth which is opposed to be the Heaven of Gods holiness Eccles 5.2 For God is in Heaven and thou upon the Earth For the Lord is present in this outward Earth aswel as we in this Earth all men sin but there are some places in the new Testament also which you oppose us with as first that Luke 17.10 So likewise you when ye have done all these things say ye are â—â—p ofitable servents But this place if well considered makes more against you then for you for our Saviour there implyes that we may do all things which are commanded to wit through his grace yet having so done we are unprofitable servants to God for we have done but our duties and that through grace also and so have added nothing to the Lord. But a second and a grand objection is made out of Rom. 7.14 15 16 17 18 19. c. For the Law saith the Apostle is spiritual But I am carnal sold under sin Answer Although this place is commonly taken as if the Apostle spoke here of his own personal and present estate yet it is certain he did not first because elsewhere speaking of that estate he contradicts what is here spoken by him as 1 Cor. 4.4 For I know nothing by my self but here the person spoken of knowes much evil by himself and Phil. 4.13 I can do all things through Christ which strengtheneth me but he that is here intended though to will is present with him yet findes no means or power to do any good yea that which the Apostle speaks of his present estate chap. 8. of this Epistle to the Romans verse 2. is directly opposite to what is complained of verse 23 of this 7 chapter for in that 23. verse the complaint speaketh thus But I see another law in my members warring against the law of my minde and bringing me into coptivity to the law of sin which is in my members Oh wretched man that I am who shall deliver me from this body of death But Rom. 8.2 Paul saith For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus hath made me free from the law of sin and death what can be more contradictory then this last place is to the former So that of necessity the fist place must be understood of babes in Christ whom Paul here personates instructs and comforts and the latter of his own present condition and victorie as Occumenius and others well observe and what was more usual with the Apostle then to speak of that which concerns others in his own person 1 Cor. 4.6 And these things brethren I have in a figure transferred to my self and Apollos for your sake 1 Cor. 13.11 c. When I was a child I spake as a child c. Thirdly You alledge against us and this truth the words which the Apostle speaks to the Galatians chap. 5. verse 17. For the flesh lusteth against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh and these are contraeâ—y the one to the other so that ye cannot do the things that ye would Here say you the Apostle describes that combat betwixt the flesh and the spirit which must continue while we endure in the body Answer But where do you read that this conflict must last so long The Apostle saith a good space before his death 2 Tim. 47. I have fought a good fight I have finished my course I have kept the faith Were not the Galatians Babes in Christ so young and weak that the Apostle had no sooner left them then they were ready to be drawn away from Christ by the false Apostles See Gal. 1.6 with 3.1 2. Now to make their estate the highest pitch growth of a Christian in this life is as if we should take the scantling of a child and conclude that it is the full stature of mankinde and that no man is or can be of a taller groth Fourthly You object what St. James writes chap. 3.2 For in many things we offend all where you imvolue him and his fellow Apostles in that plural number To which we answer That the Apostle can no more be there implyed then in the 9 verse where he saith again and that plurally With the same tongue we bless God even the Father and with the same tongue we curse men which are made after the similitude of God Was James or the Apostles now of the number of those that still cursed men But it is frequent for lenity sake and in a winning way for the Prophets and Apostles of Christ to speak in the plural and sometimes in the singular number those things which concern not themselves but their hearers onely Nebem 5.10 I pray you let us leave of this usury saith the man of God who was no wayes guilty of that sin Isa 59.10 the Prophet speaketh this We groap for the wall like the blind and we groap as if we had no eyes Lastly It is objected out of 1 John 1.8 That the Apostle saith directly If we say that we have no sin we deceive our selves and there is no truth in us Answer The same Apostle implyes ch 4 17. that he and his fellow Apostles were now without sin Herein is our love made perfect that we might have boldness in the day of Judgement because as he is so are we in this present world There is no fear in love but persect love casteth out fear The Apostle therefore speaks the former words to those that were young in Christ and yet imperfect as is evident chap. 2. verse 1. My little children these things write I unto you that ye sin not c. Yea he explains himself so Chap. 1. verse 10. that he may be safely taken into the number If we that say we have not finned we make him a lyar and his word is not in us And thus much of your first erroneous proposition in your 5th and last Section Your other Thesis wherein you affirm That though this corruption remains in the regenerate during life yet it is actually pardoned is false also and contradictory to these ensuing and many other Scriptures Prov. 28 13. Luke 24.47 Acts 8.20 Acts 26.18 or as we shall shall shew at large chap. 11. by Gods assistance Now for a conclusion of this last Section give us leave to propound these Queries unto you First whether those ten unbeleeving spies did not highly displease God and much hinder injure and prejudice the people which hearkened unto them who cryed that there were such Anakiâ— in the way that they could not be subdued by them and Cities so high that they were walled up to Heaven and therefore not 〈◊〉 be scaled Numb 14. Did not the people too slothful and averse before to fight the Lords battail against the Canaanites become therethrough wholy unbeleeving even despairing of victory and altogether indisposed to the fight enjoyned by the Lord Were not both they and those their leaders
the seeking of them Rom. 10.14 15 c. A second let is a depraved judgement Act. 26.9 for I verily thought with my self thâ—t I ought to do many things against the name of Jesus A third impediment is the want of due remembrance and serious consideration of what we know in generall Lam. 1.9 He filthiness is in her skirts she remembred not her latter end A fourth bar is the power of Temptation of which the Apostle complaines 2 Cor. 12.7.8 A filth and a powerful obstacle is habit and custome in sin of which that is verified Qui non est hoâ—iè erà s minùs aptus erat Lastly Gods final desertion one of the heavyest of Judgements is an unremovable obstacle to the willing of good because seconded with Satans power Hence we may take a view how far the faln man can will good convert himself or prepare himself thereunto namely so far forth as men have some light of nature left or new illumination and convincing grace the which of all other is most necessary for the work of a true conversion Jer. 23.24 O Lord I know that the way of man is not in himself it is not in man that walketh to direct his steps Secondly This may be done with the more facility so far as they are chastned by the hand of the Lord and make a good use of it which made the Prophet Jeremy to pray as he doth Jer. 10.24 Correct me O Lord yet in judgement and not in thine angor lest thou bring me to nothing Howbeit in all this the Lord seems to lay no violent hand upon the will but works upon it by understanding judgement and reason with the use of sense and because he is the Author of the new understanding and judgement which leads and drawes the will he is said to work the will also Phil. 2.13 for Causae causae est etiam causa causaei But the main way whereby the man after illuminating or preventing grace can prepare himself to turn his heart or will is by frequent meditation and deep consideration of what he knows by grace or nature In your two last Sections First according to an ordinary distribution you distinguish the condition of converted sinners into a State of Grace and a State of glory but albeit there be different degrees in their new Metamorphosis or change yet their least estate in regeneration is a State of Glory as on the contrary the highest degree of that change and exaltation is a state of Grace For the proof of the first of these consider what the Apostle speaks 2 Cor. 3.18 But we all with open face beholding as in a glass the Glory of the Lord are transformed into the same Image from Glory to Glory as by the spirit of the Lord. 2 Pet. 1.3 Through the knowledge of him who hath called us unto Glory and Vertue And for the evidencing of the latter weigh well what Saint Peter writeth 1 Pet. 1.14 wherefore gird up the loins of your minde be sober and hope to the end for the Grace that is to be brought unto you at the Revelation of Jesus Christ See also 1 Pet. 3.7 as heirs together of the Grace of life But more particulary for your fourth Section As in the beginning of it you attribute too much to the first work or degree of our regeneration so you detract too much from the last and highest period of the same in the end of that Section For first you say but not truely That when God converts a sinner and translates him into the State of Grace he presently freeth him from his natural bondage under sin and by his grace alone enables him to will and to do that which is spiritually good Here brethren you go too far for the Apostle in the behalf of the young Babes or converts complains thus Rom. 7.8 9. For to will is present with me but how to perform that which is good Lâ—nde not for the good that I would I do not and the evil that I would not that do I. How then are they freed when the Apostle saith ver 23 He findes another Law in his members not only warring against the Law of his minde but bringing him captiue to the Law of sin in his members whereupon he cryes out verse 24. O wretched man that I am who shall deliver me from this body of deaâ—h Is a bondage then against your wils no captivity yea it is the most grievous bondage of all others in our sense and feeling though not so perilous to the soul as a willing subjection unto sin Indeed it is true of the young in Christ which the Apostle writs to them of that age 1 John 2.14 I have written unto you young men because ye are strong and the word of God abideth in you and you have overcome the wicked one But the Babe in Christ cannot attain thereunto while he is a chide Now in the close of that Section you flag and fall as much too short saying That this convert at his highest pitch for so you mean by reason of his remaining corruption doth not perfectly nor only will that which is good but willeth that which is evil also The which though it be true of the Infants aforesaid and perhaps may sometimes be verified of the middle ort yet it is not true of the old or aged men in Christ such as the Apostles themselves were as we have proved before In your last Section you do as you are wont wholly transferring the state of Glory in which the will of man is made immutably good out of this world but herein you are some what mistaken if we may give credit to these Scriptures Rev. 3.12 21. C. 1.2.3 4 5 6. CHAP. X. Of effectuall calling ALL those whom God hath predestinated unto life and those onely he is pleased in his appointed and accepted time effectually to call a Rom 8.30 Rom 11.7 Eph 1.10 11. by his Word and Spirit b 2 Thes 2.13 14. 2 Cor 3.6 out of that state of sin and death in which they are by nature to grace and salvation by Jesus Christ c Rom. 8.2 Eph 2.1 2 3 4. 2 Tim. 1.9 10. inlightning their minds spiritually and savingly to understand the things of God d Act 16.18 1 Cor 2.10 12. Eph 1.17 18. taking away their heart of stone and giving unto them an heart of flesh e Ezek 36.26 Eze 11.19 Phil 2.13 Deut. 36.6 Ezek 36.27 renewing their wils and by his Almighty power determing them to that which is good f and effectually drawing them to Jesus Christ g Eph 1.19 John 6.44 45. yet so as that they come most freely being made willing by his grace h Cant. 1.4 Psal 110.3 John 6.37 Rom. â— 16 17 18. II. This effectual call is of Gods free and special grace alone not from any thing at all foreseen in man i 1 Tim 1.9 Tit. 3.4 5. Eph 2.4 5 8 9. Rom â— 11. who is
whom and to whom are all things g Rom. 11.36 and hath most Sveraign Dominion over them to do by them for them and upon them whatsoever himself pleaseth h Re 4.11 1 Tim 6.15 Dan 4.25 35. In his sight all things are open and manifest i Heb 4.13 his knowledge is infinite infallible and independent upon the creature k Rom 11.33 34. Psa 147.5 so as nothing to him is contingent or uncertain l Act 15.18 Ezek 11.5 He is most holy in all his counsels in all his works and in all his commands m Psa 145.17 Rom 7.12 to him is due from Angels and men and every other creature whatsoever worship service or obedience he is pleased to require of them n Revel 5.12 13 14. III. In the unity of the Godhead there be three Persons of one substance power and eternity God the Father God the Son and God the Holy Ghost o 1 Joh 5.7 Mat 3.16.17 Mat 28.19 2 Cor 13.14 The Father is of none neither begotten nor proceeding The Son is eternally begotten of the Father p Joh 1.14.18 The Holy Ghost eternally proceeding from the Father and the Son q Joh 1.15.26 Gal 4.6 CHAP. II. Of God and of the Holy Trinity Examined IN This Chapter yon present us in the first Section with a large description of Gods Essence where we cannot but wonder that you should omit an essential to him and an essence so bright and glorious in the Godhead as the Divine light of God is whereby he manifests himself unto Angels and Men opposeth himself to the Prince of darkness And of which glorious Attribute or Nature of his the word of God maketh so frequent mention There are found in the holy Scripture some short but excellent descriptions of him first Hebr 11.6 That God is that is he onely is of from by and in himself and all other things are by in and for him Secondly God is light 1 John 1.5 that is a lightful bright and glorious being Thirdly God is a Spirit John 4.24 that is a most spiritual being yea that Spirit 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 2 Cor. 3 17. Lastly God is love 1 John 4.16 that is a most holy good gratious kinde patient vertuous and perfect Being for love is the bond of perfection Col. 3.14 see 1 Cor. 13.1 2 to the 13. Now it seems strange unto us that you which are and who would be accounted Seers should not observe the second of these Is not light Gods glorious Robe and Vestment Psal 104.2 Who coverest thy self wiâ—h light as with a garment Is not light Gods habitation Who dwelleth in the light whereunto no man can approach 1 Tim 6.16 Doth not God distinguish himself and his work from Satans and his Kingdom by this very thing 1 John 1.5 6 7. This then is the message which we have received of him and declare unto you that God is light and in him dwelleth no darkness at all c. Is not God the Father called the light of Israel Isa 10.17 And the light of Israel shall be for a fire and his holy one for a flame Is it not said of the Son of God John 1.9 That was the true light which lighteth every man which cometh into the world Is not the Holy Ghost the everlasting light of Gods spiritual Jerusalem Isa 60.20 Thy Sun shall no more go down neither shall thy Moon withdraw it self for the Lord shall be thine everlasting light and the daies of thy mourning shall be ended Is not Gods work in the regenerate light of this light Ephes 5.8 For ye were once darkness but now ye are light in the Lord. Yea Is not our everlasting inheritance a participating of his living and glorious light Psal 36.9 For with thee is the Fountain of life and in thy light we shall set light Col. 1.12 Giving thanks unto God the Father who hath made us meet to be partakers of the inheritance of the Saints in light Brethren what would you think of him who should undertake to give you a description of the Sun and should leave out his glorious splendor and light would you not conclude he had suffered some Ecclipse of his inward and outward senses But we desire to spare you and hope the best of many of you But here we must not omit to shew our great detestation of a late Diabolical Doctrine which turns God into a Devil making him the Author of the evils of sin aswell as the evils of punishment and affirming that he is the worker in deeds of darkness aswel as in the works of light yea maintaining that he is aswell pleased with the one as the other See 1 John 1.5 This then is the Message which we have heard of him and declare unto you that God is light and in him is no darkness at all If we say that we have fellowship with him and walk in darkness we lie and do not the truth So also Jam. 3.11 CHAP. III. Of God's Eternal Decree GOd from all Eternity did by the most wise and holy Councel of his own will freely and unchangable ordain whatsoever comes to pass a Eph 1.11 Ro 11.33 Heb 6.17 Rom 9.15 18. yet so as that neither is God the Author of sin b Jam. 1.13 17. 1 John 1.5 nor is violence offered to the will of the creatures nor is the liberty or contingency of second causes taken away but rather established c Act 2.23 Mat 17.12 Acts 4.27 28. Job 19.11 Pro 16.33 II. Although God knows whatsoever may or can come to pass upon all supposed conditions d Act 15.18 1 Sam 23 12. Mat 11.21 23. yet hath he not decreed any thing because he fore-saw it as future or as that which would come to pass upon such conditions e Rom 9.11 13 16 18. III. By the decree of God for the manifestation of his glory some men and Angels f 1 Tim 5.21 Mat 25.41 are predestinated unto everlasting life and others fore-ordained to everlasting death g Rom 9.22 23. Eph 1.5 6. Pro 16.4 IV. These men and Angels thus predestinated and fore-ordained are particularly and unchangable designed and their number is so certain and definite that it cannot be either increased or diminished h 2 Tim 2.9 Joh 13.18 V. Those of mankinde that are predestinated unto life God before the foundation of the world was laid according to his eternal and immutable purpose and the secret counsel and good pleasure of his will hath chosen in Christ unto everlasting glory i Eph 1.4 9 12. Rom 8.30 2 Tim 1.9 1 Thes 5.9 out of his meer free grace and love without any foresight of faith or good works or preseverance in either of them or any other thing in the creature as conditions or causes moving him thereunto and all to the praise of his glorious grace l Eph 1.6 12. VI. As God hath appointed the Elect unto glory so
hath he by the eternal and most free purpose of his will foreordained all the means thereunto m 1 Pe 1.2 Eph 1.4 5. Eph 2.10 2 Thes 2.13 Wherefore they who are elected being fallen in Adam are redeemed by Christ n 1 Thes 5.9 10. Tit 2.14 are effectually called unto Faith in Christ by his Spirit working in due season are justified adopted sanctified o RoÌ„ 8.30 Eph. 1.5 2 Thes 2.13 and kept by his power through Faith unto salvation p 1 Pet 1.5 Neither are any other redeemed by Christ effectually called justified adopted sanctified and saved but the Elect onely q Joh. 17.9 RoÌ„ 8.28 to the end Joh 6.64 65. Joh 10.26 Joh 8.46 1 Joh 2.19 VII The rest of mankinde God was pleased according to the unsearchable councel of his own will whereby he extendeth or withholdeth mercy as he pleaseth for the glory of his Soveraign Power over his creatures to pass by and to ordain them to dishonor and wrath for their sin to the praise of his glorious justice r Mat 11.25 26. Rom 9.17 18 21 21. 2 Tim 2.19 20. Judg 5.4 1 Pet 4.8 VIII The Doctrine of this high Mystery of Predestination is to be handled with special prudence and care Å¿ Rom 9.20 RoÌ„ 11.32 Dâ—u 29.29 that men attending the will of God revealed in his word and yeelding obedience thereunto may from the certainly of their effectual vocation be assured of their eternal Election t 2 Pet 1.19 k Rom 9.11 13 16. Eph 1.4 9. So that this Doctrine affords matter of praise reverence and admiration of God u Eph 1.6 Ro 11.33 and of humility diligence and abundant consolation to all that sincerely obey the Gospel w Rom 1â— 5.6.20 2 Pet 1. â—0 Rom 8.33 Luk 10.10 CHAP. III. Of God's Eternal Decree examined IN this Chapter you begin well in the first Section and end not much worse in the last if you had added a word or two more and had observed the advice therein given but in the rest you fail much Here then we must crave your patience as elsewhere that you will suffer your failings to be represented your errors detected and those objections which have been so many stumbling blocks to you and many others and may prove works of offence hereafter also if not timely removed to be answered and cleared Your failings are here specially two First you forget your selves and contradict what you have spoken before in your describing of Gods holy nature and Secondly you distinguish not things but differ very much as First Betwixt Gods general knowledge whereby he sees and knows all persons and things before-hand Acts 15.18 known unto God are all his works and his special foreknowledge of some mens wayes and courses and these either evil and disapproved in themselves as was the obstinacy and envy of the Jews into whose hands Christ was delivered by the determinate counsel and foreknowledge of God Act. 2.23 and Acts 4.28 or else foreseen and allowed as the faith obedience and perseverance of the Saints Rom. 8.29 For whom he did foreknow those he did predestinate to be made conformable to the Image of his Son Secondly Betwixt Gods predestination from everlasting and his destination in time Thirdly Betwixt a predestination of things and those either good such as are good works which God hath ordained that we should walk in them Ephes 2.10 or evil to wit the evil of punishment as Tophet was ordained of old Jsai 30.33 and betwixt the predestination of persons and those either to some office estate or condition here as Jeremiah was ordained of God to be a Prophet Jer. 1.4 Paul an Apostle 1 Tim. 2.7 or to an eternal estate hereafter of life or death Fourthly Betwixt an absolute predestination either unto life and so onely is Christ ordained or unto death and so is the spiritual Antichrist and that great son of perdition appointed to death and betwixt a conditional predestination either to life or death under which not onely Angels fall but men also as Rom. 8.13 For if we live after the flesh we shall die but if through the Spirit ye shall mortifie the deeds of the flesh ye shall live Fifthly Betwixt a general Election unto life which is alwayes conditional as first of the Angels in case they should persevere in obedience and so retain their first estate And then secondly of men and that in a twofold estate For in the state of Innocency they were ordained to life in case of perseverance in obedience and the retention of God's Image in which they were created And secondly after their fall in case they imbrace the grace that shall be offered and fulfil the conditions or requiring of the same And betwixt God's special Election of some persons both Angels and men out of foreseen perseverance c. Sixtly Betwixt the special Election of God which is from eternity out of foreseen Faith Love Obedience Perseverance c. or that which is made in time actually and that is either conditional as of those which by regeneration are called out of the sinful estate wherein other men are yet captived and so all called ones are said to be chosen John 15.16 19. and Election in this notion is all one with calling 2 Pet. 1.10 Wherefore the rather Brethren give all diligence to make your calling and election sure Which persons are chosen or called to life conditionally that they persevere in Faith and Obedience c. Rom. 11.22 Behold therefore the goodness and severity of God towards them that fell severity but towards thee goodness if thou continue in his goodness therwise thou also shalt be cut off Or else the Election of God in time is absolute such was the Election and choice of the blessed Angels after their perseverance in the fear and love of God when others had fallen therefrom And such is the Election of men spoken of by the Lord Isai 48.10 Behold I have chosen thee in the furnace of affliction These have fulfilled the conditions aforesaid of peseverance in Faith Obedience and Mortification And therefore were absolutely and finally chosen to eternal life These are the Elect that cannot be deceived Matth. 24. and who shall never fall Seventhly Betwixt some that were onely typically Elected or passed by in God's providence as figures and representatives of those which should be saved or perish as Isaac and Ishmael the two sons of Abrabâ—â— were Gen. 17.16 and Rom. 9.6 7. without any prejudice to the salvation of either And those which are really elected or rejected For as Moses and Aaroâ— were debarred entrance into the land of promise for their doubting or unbelief for a warning to all unbeleevers Heb 4.1.11 Revel 21.8 yet without any peril of their own exclusion from eternal life none that we know of making the least doubt of their salvation so it was not prejudicial to the salvation of Ishmael his father Abraham having obtained life for him
by his prayer to God Gen. 17 20 21. that he carried the type of those who should not be heirs of life Gal. 4.22 c. and peradventure the like may be said of the person of Esau who at the meeting of his brother Jacob was turned into another man Gen. 23.4 and did ever after sweetly accord with him although Hebr. 12.16 he carries the type of a spiritual fornicator and profane person that sels his eternal birthright for a morsel of meat here in this world and of him that losing his first grace or blessing obtaines not a second But here we would not be misunderstood for though we brought Isaac as an instance of a typical or representative seed which he was in opposition to Ishmael Rom. 9.6 7. yet we do not deny but that he was one really elected out of Gods special foreknowledge nor do we doubt but Ishmael might be so likewise howsoever he was generally and conditionally elected as was also Cain Gen. 4.6 7. where the Lord saith unto him Why art thou wroth And why is thy countenance fallen If thou doest well shalt thou not be accepted c. Eighthly Betwixt these that are unchangeably designed to life or death out of foreseen faith or unbelief perseverance or Apostacy and those that are absolutely and peremptorily without any condition or respect to standing or falling rising again through grace or lieing still retaining or losing grace received For after this last manner none are irrevocably designed either to life or death from all eternity among Angels or men Ninthly Betwixt a soveraign power invested in a most wise just gratious loving and merciful Prince which may be used to his greater glory and the same placed in a rigourous and cruel Tyrant which last to affix upon God is no small degree of blasphemy Tenthly Betwixt an absolute preterition of some from eternity before they have done or thought good or evil yea had any being which is not found in God towards any of his future rational creatures and a passing over of some in time for their personal ingratitude and contumacy against him as the fallen Angels are declined after their fall and some men after grace often refused and others after grace abused are lest to walk in their own wayes Eleventhly Betwixt the not extending of grace at all after a needless and wilful Apostacy as the Lord dealt with the proud and presumptuous Angels which fell and the withholding of mercy from some persons which were not so strongly and well situated in grace and which fell through the temptation of others and thus God withholds not his first grace which iâ— also a sufficient grace from any of the sons of men though they are fallen in Adam Twelfthly Betwixt the withholding the first or converting grace from fallen men which is not kept back for any till they resist it and the withdrawing of his second or subsequent grace from such as have wilfully cast off the first in the just requiring of it and so do despite of the Spirit of Grace These few necessary distinctions being first premised we proceed Now for your errors and mistakes in your several Sections First we say that your assertion in the second Section is very false and erroneous where you say That Although God knows whatsoever may or can come to pass upon all supposed conditions yet hath he not decreed any thing because he foresaw it as future or as that which should come to pass upon such conditions For did not the Lord foresee that if he created the Angels free Agents some would fall and others stand still in their integrity That if he created our first parents with liberty of will that they would fall That if he offered fallen men his grace to help them up again some would embrace it and some refuse it That his offered grace being conditional some which received it would persevere and fulfil those conditions and some would fail in the performance after they had begun well That Judas being returned to his former covetousness would betray his Master for gain That the Jews out of obstinacy and envy would condemn and deliver Christ to the Gentiles That Pilate out of favour to men would yeeld him up to be scourged and crucified All which and a thousand things more the Lord foresaw would conditionally or supposedly come to pass and did thereupon decree or determine that they should so do because he could turn them to his glory yet do we not say that the Lord was necessitated so to do alwayes but when he foresaw that the effects and productions arising out of such supposed conditions were not conducible to his wise and holy ends he both could and in time did put a stop thereunto at his pleasure Thus he foresaw that the men of Keilah out of their wicked and ingrateful disposition being left to themselves would deliver and betray David into the hands of Saul and therefore he did both decree not to permit it and did actually hinder it by advertifing David of it that he might timely escape In your third Section there is truth and error to be found accordingly as your words are taken for you speak generally and ambiguously saying By God's Decree for the manifestation of his glory some men and Angels are predestinated unto eternal life and others fore-ordained to everlasting death To which we answer thus First That men and Angels are not in all things and every way disposed of alike in God's eternal Decree For though no fallen Angels are ordained to life yet by your own confession many fallen men are appointed to salvation in Jesus Christ Secondly We say that all both men and Angels are first predestinated to eternal life in case they should continue in their first created estate by answerable obedience The truth whereof appears sufficiently in the confirmation and blessing of those holy Angels which persisted in their allegiance who are therefore called the Elect Angels Thirdly We affirm that all men though fallen are appointed to restauration and life by grace conditionally that they beleeve on that grace and obey its requiring Ezek. 18.23 have I any pleasure at all that the wicked should die saith the Lord and that not he should return and live Ezek. 33.11 Say unto them as I live saith the Lord I desire not the death of the wicked 1 Tim. 2.3 4. For this is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Saviour who would have all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth Whereunto add that of Tit. 2.11 12. which holds forth both the universality of grace it self and its condition For the grace of God that bringeth salvation hath appeared to all men Teaching us that denying ungodliness and worldly lusts we should live soberly righteously and godly in this present world But lastly we grant notwithstanding that some both Angels and men were appointed for destruction yet conditionally through their own default and disobedience as
the Apostles shew both of the one and of the other and first of the Angels 2 Pet. 2.4 God spared not the Angels that sinned but cast them down into Hell Jude 6. And the Angels which kept not their first estate but left their own habitation he hath reserved in everlasting chaines under darkness to the judgement of the great day And secondly concerning men 2 Thes 2.12 That all might be damned who beleeve not the truth but had pleasure in unrighteousness Now these and some other Scriptures by us alledged do not speak immediately of Gods eternal Decree yet we know that God works all things in time according to the counsel of his own will from eternity Ephes 1.11 In your fourth Section you declare your selves more fully in this point of Predestination saying These Angels and men thus Predestinated and fore ordained are particularly and unchangeably designed and their number is so certain and definite that it cannot be either encreased or diminished Which words of yours we will grant to be true First of the Angels after some had stood fast in obedience and others had fallen but this was a destination in time not a predestination from eternity Secondly Of Angels and men out of the special fore-knowledge of God whereby he certainly foresaw the perseverance of the good Angels in obedience when the wicked spirits fell as also the persistance of the Saints in faith and obedience towards grace which should be exhibited on the one hand with the Apostacy of the lapsed Angels and the obstinacy of the impenitent men and backsliding temporaries on the other hand and so accordingly determined that the one part should be saved and the other perish But that Gods decree in the general toward Angels and men was onely conditional and did no wayes necessitate either to sin and damnation or to obedience and salvation it is evident out of these ensuing texts and many more As for the Apostate Angels the fault of their Apastacy is wholly and clearly ascribed to themselves 2 Pet. 2.4 Jude 6. as before And as for men it is said Luke 7.30 the Pharisees and Lawyers did frustrate the counsel of God against themselves 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which things would not possibly be done unless God's counsel was conditional add 2 Pet. 3.9 But God is long-suffering to us ward not willing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance which is spoken aswel of singula generum as of genera singulorum and you had before God's oath Ezek. 33.11 As I live saith the Lord I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked To confirm his affirmation Ezek 18.23 Have I any pleasure at all that the wicked should die And as there is no enforcing necessity from Gods decree to dispose Angels and men to obedience or disobedience life or death so neither was there any necessity of nature that is want of liberty in their wills or inability to obey before their fall whatsoever there is left afterwards in mankinde But if you mean by this particular and unchangeable designing men and Angels an absolute irrespective and peremtorie or inevitable dispose of some Angels and men to life and of others to destruction and that from eternity you do not onely make God a respecter of persons in those that are appointed to life from which the Scripture vindicates the Lord frequently Acts 10.34 Rom 2.11 Deut. 10.17 1 Pet. 1.17 But this contradicts what you speak concerning God Chapter the second where you describe him to be most wise most holy most loving most gratious most merciful and most righteous c. When you ascribe to him such a peremtory and irrevocable Decree of condemning thousands of Angels and men everlastingly and that before they had done or purposed any evil against him or yet had any being Consider this we pray you could any of you which is a father and scarce hath one drop of love mercy and goodness compared with God's ocean appoint one or more of your little babes which yet never offended you to be burned to death How far then must it be from the gratious disposition of him that is love it self and whose bowels of Compassion are infinite inevitably to designe so many millions of Angels his children by creation to endless and insufferable flames of fire before they had any existence in nature or capacity of offending In your Fifth Section you say that those of mankinde that are predestinated unto life are chosen by God before the foundation of the world was laid according to his eternal and immutable purpose and the secret counsel and good pleasure of his will in Christ unto everlasting glory out of his meer free grace and love All which is true both of Gods general and special election But whereas you add these words in conclusion without any foresight of Faith or good works or perseverance in either of them as conditions or causes moving him thereunto It is a most dangerous error and falsehood For was not that counsel of God which Paul declared to the Churches Acts 20.27 briefly comprehended in that Doctrine whereby as he himself saith he testified bâ—th to the Jewes and also to the Gentiles repentance towards God and faith towards our Lord Jesus Christ Act. 20.20.21 Doth not the same Apostle tell us Rom. 8.29 That those whom God foreknew he did predestinate to be made conformable to the Image of his Son Doth not Saint Peter tell the believing Jews that they were elect according to the foreknowledge of God through sanctification of the Spirit to obedience and the sprinkling of the blood of Jesus Christ 1 Peâ— 1.2 Doth not Saint Paul declare the counsel or will of God to be conditional when he saith 1 Tim. 2.3 4. For this is good and acceptable before God who will have all men to be saved and to that end to come to the knowledge of the truth Are not the words of Saint Peter clear also to that effect 2. Pet. 3.9 Who willeth not that any man should perish but that all men should come to repentance Is not the saving grace of God which hath appeared to all men conditional by the Apostles own testimony Tit. 2.11 12. For the Grace of God which bringeth salvation to all men bath appeared teaching us that denying ungodliness and worldly lusts we should live soberly righteously and godly in this present world Is not the Gospel it self which is a declaration of the whole counsel of God to be published conditionally Mat. 18.19 20. Mark 16.15.16 Go yee into all the world and preach the Gospel to every creature he that believeth and is baptized shall be saved but he that believeth not shall be damned Doth not God best know what his own will and counsel is and was from eternity when he tels us Ezâ—k 18. and 33 and almost every where else in the old Testament that the obstinate sinner shall die but such as convert to him shall live Yea the finall and
monitions commandements and requirings you seem to lay some default upon God himself saying That he withholdeth that grace from them whereby their hearts that is their wils and affections might have been wrought upon which both derogates from Gods mercy and is inconsistent which innumerable Scriptures testifying the contrary as Esai 5.4 What could I have done more for my vineyard that I have not done Mat. 23.37 How often would I have gathered thy children as a ben gathereth her chickens under her wings but see would not Acts 7.51 Ye stifnecked and uncircumcised in heart and eares ye do alwayes resist the holy Ghost as did your Fathers so do yee CHAP. VI. Of the fall of man of Sin and of the punishment thereof OVR First Parents being seduced by the subtilty and temptation of Satan sinned in eating the forbidden fruit a Gen 3.13 2 Cor 11.3 this their sin God was pleased according to his wise and holy counsel to permit having purposed to order it to his own glory b Ro 11.32 II. By this sin they fell from their original righteousnesse and communion with God c Gen 3.6 7 8. Eccl 7.29 Ro 3.23 and so became dead in sin d Gen 2.17 Eph 2.1 and wholy defiled in all the faculties and parts of soul and body e Tit 1.15 Gen 6.5 Jer 17.9 Ro 3.10 to 19. III. They being the root of all mankinde the guilt of sin was imputed f Ge 1.27 28. and Gen. 2.16 17. and Act 17.13 with Ro 5.12 15 16 17 18 19. and 1 Cor 15.21 22 25. and the same death in sin and corrupted nature conveyed to all their posterity descending from them by ordinary generation g Psa 51.5 Gen 5.3 Job 14.4 Job 15.14 IV. From this original corruption whereby we are utterly indisposed disabled and made opposite to all good h Ro 5.6 Rom 8.7 Rom 7.18 Col 1.21 and wholly inclined to all evil i Gen 6.5 Gen 8.21 Rom 3.10 11 12 do proceed all actual transgressions k Jam 1.12 15. Eph 2.2 3. Mat 15.19 V. This corruption of nature during this life doth remain in those that are regenerated l 1 Joh 1.8 to Rom v. 14.17 18 23. Jam 3.2 Pro 20.9 Eccl 7.20 and althoug it be through Christ pardoned and mortified yet both it self and all the motions thereof are truely and properly sin m Ro 7.5 7 8 25. Gal 5.17 VI. Every sin both original and actual being a transgression of the righteous Law of God and contrary thereunto n Joh 3.4 doth in its own nature bring guilt upon the sinner o Rom 3.9 19. whereby he is bound over to the wrath of God p Eph 2.3 and curse of the Law q Gal. 3.10 and so made subject to death r Ro. 6.23 with all miseries spiritual Å¿ Eph. 4.18 temporal t Rom. 8.20 Jam. 3 39. and eternal u Matth. 25.41 2 Thess 1.9 CHAP. VI. Of the fall of man of Sin and of the Punishment thereof examined IN this Chapter of mans fall you have given sufficient evidence of it for except the first and last Sections all parts of it are a resemblance of the depraved man you spake of sufficiently corrupted In the second Section these are your words By this sin they that is our first parents fell from their original righteousness and communion with God and so became dead in sin and wholly defiled in all the faculties of soul and body In which words we finde the fruits of the forbidden tree evil as well as good error as well as truth That they fell from their former communion with God from some degree of original righteousness and that they became dead that is liable to eternal death we grant you but that they fell wholly from original righteousness at the first Act of their Apostacy or that they presently became so wholly defiled as you speak are great mistakes As to the first of these did not the Image of God in which they were created consist in holiness and righteousness Now you know habits are not lost by one act or two Again the thing that God threatned was a gradual punishment as well as a certain In dying ye shall die Furthermore those that fall away from inchoated grace and that renued Image of God which is not at first so strong and vigorous as Gods similitude was in the first man though they die and being in a great decree of languishing are said to be dead yet they die but gradually after great debilities and decay may be kept alive and recovered Rev. 3.1 2. I know thy works that thou hast a name that thou livest and art dead Be watchful and strengthen the things which remain that are ready to die for I have not found thy works perfect before me Now as for the second that they became wholly defiled in all parts and faculties no Scripture speaks it nor could it be till the whole Image of God was extinguished by contrary corruptions True it is that if the Lord had wholly left them to themselves as he did the rebellious and backsliding Angels it would have fared no better with them in the end then you speak of but the father of mercies was pleased to appear unto them in the cool and declination of the day before it was dark night with them and by his covenant of grace to help them up again In the third Section you say They being the root of all mankinde the guilt of the sin was imputed and the same death in sin and corrupted nature corveyed to all posterity descending from them by ordinary generation where that they were the root of all mankinde is undoubtedly true but all the rest of that Section may be justly questioned And first that passage where you tacitely exempt Christ from the imputation of this sin made unto him for doubtless that with all other sins of ours were laid upon him But secondly it may be upon good ground hoped that it neither was nor shall be imputed to any of their posterity who are not the imitators of the same in actual rebellion for that just Lord doth not onely forbid the punishing of the children for the iniquity of their parents even with temporal death Deut 24.18 but he swears also by his own life that he will not do that thing Ezek 18.1 20. Then what you there affirm in the second place is more improbable then the other to wit That the same death in sin and corrupt nature is conveyed to all their posterity descending from them by ordinary generation is yet more improbable For first that some men are sanctified from the womb as Jeremiah and John the Baptist were and the Virgin Mary might possibly be none will deny And secondly that all others are still created innocent in some measure of Gods image there are not a few Scriptures which seem to testifie it of which Genesis the 9.6 is one where the
the unbeleeving guids shut out of Canaan And are not these things writen for our instuction See Heb. 4.12 Let us therefore fear least a promise being left us of entering into his rest any of you should seem to come short of it for to us was the Gospel preached as well as unto them but the word preached profited them not being not mixed with faith in them that heard it CHAP. VII Of God's Covenant with Man THE Distance between God and the Creature is so great that although reasonable Creatures do owe obedience unto him as their Creator yet they could never have any fruition of him as their blessedness and reward but by some voluntary condescention on Gods part which he hath been pleased to express by way of Govenant a Isa 40.13 14 15 16 17. Job 9.32 33. 1 Sam. 2.13 Psal 113.5 6. Psal 100.2 3. Job 22.2 3. Job 35.7 8. Luke 17.10 Act. 17.24 25. II. The first Covenant made with man was a Covenant of works b Gal. 3.12 wherein life was promised to Adam and in him to his posterity c Ro. 10.5 Rom. 5 1â— to 20. upon condition of perfect and personal obedience d Gen. 2.17 Gal. 3.10 III. Man by his fall having made himself uncapable of life by that Covâ—â—ant the Lord was pleased to make a second e Gal. 3.21 Ro 3.20 21. Gen. 3.15 Isa 42.6 commonly called the Covenant of Grace Wherein he freely offereth unto sinners Life and Salvation by Jesus Christ requiring of them faith in him that they may be saved f Mark 16.15 16. John 3.16 Ro. 10.6 9 Gal. 3.11 and promising to give unto all those that are ordained unto life his holy Spirit to make them willing and able to beleeve g Ezek. 3.6 26.27 John 6.44 45. IV. This Covenant of Grace is frequently set forth in Scripture by the name of a testament in reference to the death of Jesus Christ the Testator and to the everlasting inheritance with all things be longing to it therein bequeathed h Heb. 9.25 16 17. Heb. 7.22 Luk. 22.20 1 Cor. 11.15 2 Cor. 3.6 7 8 9. V. This Covenant was differently administred in the time of the Law and in the time of the Gospel i Vnder the Law it was administred by promises prophesies sacrifices circumcision the Paschal Lamb and other types and ordinances delivered to the people of the Jews all fore-signifying Christ to come k Heb 8.9 10. Chapters Rom 4.11 Col 2.11 12. 1 Cor 5.7 which were for that time sufficient and efficacious through the operation of the Spirit to instruct and build up the Elect in Faith in the promised Messiah l 1 Cor 10.1 2 3 4. Heb. 11.13 John 8.16 by whom they had full remission of sins and eternal salvation called The Old Testament m Gal 3.7 8 9 14. VI. Vnder the Gospel when Christ the substance n Col. 2.17 was exhibited the ordinances in which this Covenant is dispensed are the preaching of the Word and the administration of the Sacraments of Baptism and the Lords supper o Ma 28.19 20. 1 Cor 14.23 24 15. Which though fewer in number and administred with more simplicity and lesse outward glory yet in them it is held forth in more fulness evidence and spiritual efficacy p Heb 12.22 to 28. Jer 31.33 34. to all nations both Jewes and Gentels q Mat 28.19 Eph 2.15 16 c. and is called the new Testament r Luke 22 20. There are not therefore Two Covenants of grace differing in substance but one and the same under various dispensations Å¿ Gal 3.16 17. Rom 1.21 22 23 â—0 Psal 3â— 1 with Rom. 4.3 6 16 17 23 24 Beb 13 8. Acts 15.21 CHAP. VII Of Gods Covenant with man examined WE will not say that you have made a Covenant with death or an agreement with hell but in this tract of the Covenant you do not alwayes keep league with truth for though you beging plausibly in the first Section yet both there and elswhere you affirm many things untruly As first when you say That the distance between God and the creature is so great that though all reasonable creatures do owe obedience unto him as their Creator yet they never could have any fruition of him as their blessedness and reward but by some voluntary condescension on Gods part which he hath been pleased to express by way of Covenant For do not the elect Angels from their first creation by their first constitution see God in his own light and participate of his blessedness in wisdom holiness power life peace and glory And if the Lord did not create our first parents in so ful a fruition of blessedness yet he could have so beatified them if he had pleased without a precedent covenant And was not the humanity of Christ in his inward man placed in that communion and fruition of God from the beginning of his incarnation though his outward man was subject to mortality and misery Yet you make us some peece of amends in your second section saying That the Lord made a Covenant of works with mankinde at the first wherein liâ—e was promised to Adam and in him to his posterity upon condition of personal and perfect obedience Where by the way you tacitly grant two truths by your selves denyed and by us asserted Chapter the third so powerful is truth in it self that oft times it breaks forth from men de improviso though they have gain said it before the which two truths are these First that all men in Adam were appointed or ordained to life if the Covenant of life was made to him and all his posterity For God works all things in time according to the eternal counsel of his will as we said before out of Ephes 1.11 And secondly That this decree was conditional also for so you confess the first Covenant to have been and so are all subsequent Covenants likewise or the far greatest part of them which are given by God himself to mankinde In your third Section you are more defective and erroneous for though you say truly in the beginning of it That man by his fall having made himself uncapable of life by the Covenant of works the Lord was pleased to make a second Covenant commonly called the Covenant of grace wherein be freely offereth unto sinners life and salvation by Jesus Christ Yet herein you faile in that you do not set forth that this Covenant was universal for all sinners as indeed it was For it was made with all mankinde in our first parents and as all that fell had need of the same and were by creation alike related to God so he had compassion upon all impartially being no accepter of persons and appointed one mediator alike neer to all men betwixt him and us even the man Christ as we shewed before out of Rom. 3.22 23 24 c. Rom 10.11 12 Rom. 11.32 Gal. 3.22 â—8 1 Timo.
cross by him to reconcile all things unto himself by him I say whether they be things in Earth or things in Heaven And you that were sometimes alienated and enemies in your mind by wicked works yet now hath he reconciled in the body of his flesh to present you holy and unblameable and unreprovable in his fight Where you may take these things into consideration First Whom he reconcileth All the members of the Church who are regenerate Secondly From what from the enmity in their minds whereby they are set upon wicked works Thirdly Where through the spiritual blood of the Covenant or the spirit of grace which is called the blood of his cross because it is then sent unto us and poured down upon us when we are upon the cross with him and suffer with him not yeelding unto temptations Fourthly That Christ is said to be still doing of that work 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Lastly In what way as a precedent for us he hath done it to wit in the body of his flesh through death as these ensuing Scriptures shew 2 Tim. 2.11 12. 'T is a faithful saying for if we be dead with him we shall also live with him if we suffer wiâ—h him we shall also raign with him see Rom. 6.8 But that it is unpossible to have reconcilement and communion with God unless it be in such a way the Apostle witnesses likewise 1 John 1.5 6 7. This then is the message we have heard of him and declare unto you that God is light and in him is no darkness at all If we say that we have fellowship with him and walk in darknesâ— we lye and haue not the truth But if we walk in the light as he is in the light we have fellowship one with another and the blood of Jesus Christ his Son cleanseth us from all Sin Thus far of Christ's spiritual and true reconciling us unto God which is then perfected and consummate when besides the slaying of the enmity aforesaid he hath made us in all things of one spirit with the Father For which unity and reconcilement he prayeth John 17.21 That they all may be one as thou Father art in me and I in thee that they also may be one in us Now for the purchasing of an everlasting inheritance for us eternal life is the free gift of God through Jesus Christ our Lord Rom. 8.23 And as the Father hath it in his hand to bestow so it is in the Sons gift likewise and consequently as it seems to us he needs not to purchase it But if you will call the fulfilling of that way and process whereby the faln man must attain it the way race of obedience aforesaid a purchasing of it it is by the inward and spiritual obedience of Christ especially that we attain Heb. 10.36 For ye have need of patience that after ye have done the will of God ye may receive the promise Howbeit his outward passive obedience was requisite thereunto without which as we could not be delivered from the curse so neither could we come to inherit life By this you see we stand in need of an inward and spiritual mediation from Christ aswel as that outward of which alone you here speak Nor can we partake of the benefit of the outward till qualified and prepared first thereunto by the work of the inward In your Sixth Section you proclaim your great ignorance or small regard of our great and most necessary redemption from the power of sin and Satan saying That the work of redemption was not actually wrought till after Christs incarnation For were not the fathers before and after the flood with the Prophets and other holy Saints in the Old Testament in their respective times spiritually saved and redeemed by Christ And much more doth that great secret of the Father's sparing and forbearing us along time for his Sons sake who in patience and meekness hath been led as a lamb to the slaughter and the end of whose long sufferance in us is salvation as St. Peter speaks Epist 2 3. Chap. 15. seem to be hidden from you Yet here you grant some truths at unawares as that Christ is the promised enmity against sin who must break the Serpents head and consequenly that his power and Kingdom must be within us where Satan is to be trodden down Rom. 16.20 You grant also that he is the Lamb slain from the beginning of the world But whereas you add for a proof thereof out of Hebr. 13.9 That Christ is the same yesterday and to day and for ever That speakes of his immutable Deity and not of his humanity though now made unchangeable Yet this we say brethren ere we leave this Section that you hold forth a very lame and imperfect redeemer which which hath indeed redeemed us by his death from the curse of the Law when our iniquities are put away from us but who must redeem us from all our corruptionsâ— who must save and deliver us out of the hand of all our enemies who must inable us to keep and fulfil the Law of God who must renew the Image of God in us Is not the true Christ made of God unto us wisdom righteousness and sanctification as well as redemption 1 Cor 1.30 In your Seventh Section As we grant it to be true that Christ in the entire office of a Mediator acteth according to both natures joyntly or severally as occasion requires doing by each that which is proper to its self so perhaps it may be granted that sometimes in the Scriptures by reason of the unity of the person that which is proper to one nature is attributed to the person denominated by the other Howbeit the places to which you refer us do not prove so much for that of Acts the 20.28 It s true First of Christ in the Godhead that he hath purchased his Church with his own blood having redeemed it from the power of Satan by his Spirit Secondly To that of John 3.13 it may be said that as Christ is spiritually born in us he is the Son of man which comes from Heaven and is or dwells in the heavenly being Finally To 1 John 3.16 It may be truly answered that Christ the Son of God hath laid down his life for us while he died in us to keep off the deserved wrath of God from us and to preserve us from the death threatned in the Law as also to set us an example how we may in following him overcome sin and recover life again we seeking his grace and help thereunto In your eighth and last Section being like checquer-work you have black as well as white errour as well as truth where your first affirmation That Christ doth certainly and effectually apply and communicate his redemption to all those for whom he hath purchased it will prove false in what sense soever it be taken For first If we here understand Christ's outward redemption as you undoubtedly do that being made for
place in which the Lord speakes of a child shortly to be born unto the Prophet and to be called Immanuel as some most learned expositors affirm Isa 7.14 15 16. Therefore the Lord himself shall give you a signe Behold a Virgin or a young woman for the word signifies both shall conceive and bear a son and shall call his name Immanuel Butter and hony shall he eate that he may know to refuse the evil and chuse the good for before the child shall know to refuse the evil and chuse the good the land that thou abhorrest shall be forsaken of both her Kings Here you may please to observe these things with us First That though this place be commonly understood of our Saviour yet it is a great mistake for his proper name was Jesus and not Immanuel Secondly This child was to be born shortly after this prophecy and is given to the Jewes as a sign and token of a sudden deliverance from Rezin and Remaliah before the child should be of age and knowledge to refuse the evil and chuse the good And thirdly The prophet in the next Chap. triumphing against the enemies of the Church alludes to this very name as if the child were then in being Isa 8.10 saying Take counsel together and it shall come to nough speak the word and it shall not stand for God is with us Where it is in the original Immanuel The second thing to be observed is that this child even from iâ—s insancy according to the common state of mankind should have the knowledge and ability to refuse the evil and chuse the good a faculty spoken of in two verses together as before But to come to your third Section where our main contest begins Besides a mistake in the very first entrance Man that is fallen into sin being by you taken for all mankinde no smal mistake as we have proved before You are first defective in that you distinguish not of the different states of sin And secondly to maintain that which is true in it self viz. that the faln man cannot without preventing grace by his own strength convert himself or haply prepare himself thereunto you lay such grounds as are either false or at leastwise improper of which anon But first you speak of a state of sin into which man is faln as though there were but one such whereas there is a manifold state in sin one against God the Father another against the Son and a third against the holy Ghost Mat. 12.32 There is a state of sin before regeneration and another under grace Rom. 7.9 14. there is a state of sin before mans first conversion and another after their final falling away 2 Pet. 2.21 22. as there is a threefold degree of righteousness and grace wherein some are Babes some youngmen and some old men so there is a threefold state or age in sin So the Lord saith to Abraham Gen. 15.16 That the iniquity of the Amorites is not yet full and complaines Jer. 9.3 That the sinners proceeded from evil to worse finally there is a sin unto death and a sin which is not unto death 1 John 5.16 Now the false grounds aforesaid which you lay for the establishing of a truth are these That the faln man hath lost all ability of wil to any spiritual good accompanying salvation That a natural man is altogether averse from from any such good The ground that you here improperly apply is That the man is dead in sin For the first of these t is a rash and ungrounded asseveration for you will not deny That to become a Christian to have our wicked thoughts forgiven us to hear the word preached to eat and drink at Christs table to keep the commandements of the second Table as they are commonly called and finally to dye the death of the righteous are all of them spiritual good things and such as accompany salvation But we finde all these things wished for and desired by those which you count unregerate for King Agrippa hearing Saint Pauls defence had more then a velleity some good measure of inclination to become a Christian Act. 26.28 Simon Meâ—us entreated the Apostles to pray for him that his wicked thoughts might be pardoned and that none of the evils they had spoken of might happen unto him to hinder his salvation Act. 8.24 Our Saviour tels us Luk. 13.26 That many will plead before him at the latter day that they had heard him teaching in their streets and had eaten and drunke at his table The young man who enquired of our Saviour what good thing he should do to inherit eternal life had from his youth kept the precepts of the second table aforesaid Mat. 19.20 Yea our Saviour looked upon him and loved him on that behalf Mar. 10.21 Finaily Balaam desired to dye the death of the righteous and that his latter end might be like his Num. 23.10 For the second ground that the natural man is altogether averse from any thing that is good it is alike erroneous with the former whether we take a natural man for the earthly man as he is still created of God in innocency or for the faln man in his unregenerate estate as you mean For in the first notion the natural man can both will and act according to his first integrity till he disables and corrupts himself by falling as Esau or Edom a type of this man did seek to please and observe his father And you may remember that the Apostle would have us in malice and naughtiness to be like children 1 Cor. 14.20 But many natural men taken in your own sense are not utterly averse from all good things even Herod himself heard John the Baptist gladly and not only willed but did many things according to his Doctrine and precepts Mark 6.20 And Moses having set before all Israel life and blessing with death and cursing Deut 30.19 he there expresly commands them to chuse life That both they and their seed might liâ—â— Isa chap. 1.19 20 elicites and excites this freewilling faculty saying If ye be willing and obedient ye shall eat the good of the land but if ye refuse and rebel ye shall be devonred by the sword for the mouth of the Lord hath spoken it Yea the very name of freewill offerings so oft mentioned in the Scriptures argues some competent remainder of that faculty unless ye would subjectum tollere but consider we pray you these two things which we have partly touched before First That all faln men are not alike extensively corrupted that is they are not all alike enclined to all fins but some to voluptuousness and prodigality more then to covetousness or the like And though David a King prayeth thus against covetousness Encline my heart to thy Testimo nies and not to covetousness Psal 119.36 Yet Luther saith That he was never tempted to that sin Whence it will necessarily follow that such a man is not equally averse to all good but to
some vertues more then to others The Pharisees though inclined to pride and covetousness were not so propense to sensuality and uncleaness as some of the Publicans were Luke 18.11 12. and consequently they did not so much abhor sobriety temperance and chastity as the others did nor did the other so much aversate sincerity liberality and humility as the Pharisees did Secondly You may take notice that all faln men are not alike intensively depraved sinners do gradually sinks into sin by custome and continuance therein so the Lord saith Ezek. 16.46 47. That Jerusalem had more deeply corrupted her self then her elder sister Samaria or her younger sister Sodom and by consequence she was more averse to good then either of them both And our Saviour affirms that Corazin and Bethsadia were more averse from repentance and amendment then Tyre and Sidon Luk. 10.13 And though it fares thus with the divel and his Angels yea and with all those men who through pride malice and desperation are incorporated into him yet we hope that the case or state for the present is not so evil or desperate with any other as you here would make it with lapsed men For to be utterly averse from all good is a most forlorn and deplorable condition and their very incorrigible state of whom the Lord complaines Jer. 13.23 Can the Ethiopian change his skin or the Leopaâ—d his spots then may ye also do good who are accustomed to do evil Now for your ground improperly and impertinently applyed That because man since his fall is dead in trespass and sins Eph. 2.2 5. he cannot therefore by his own strength convert himself or at all prepare himself thereunto To this we say It is neither a lively nor a forcible kind of arguing for it must be considered to what kind of life men by their fall become dead not to their natural life surely for the Apostle speaking of her that liveth in pleasures saith that she is dead whilst she liveth 1 Tim. 5.6 Here then as he chargeth her with a spiritual death so he grants her a natural life still remaining It is then to the former light of Christ or life of righteousness that we are dead by our fall as it is written Act. 8.33 That the life of Christ is taken from the earth and Isa 58.8 That he was cut off from the land of the living Agreeably hereunto the Apostle tels the Ephesians that in their unbelief they were at thee time without Christ Eph 2.12 and consequently without power to do good till we receive that again by grace But what is that to the willing and nilling faculty which is a natural and essentiall property to the soul Must that be dead in the man also and he become a meer passive block or a dead trunk as you would have him we have proved before that even the faln man can both will and act some kinds of righteousness at leastwise towards man witness that young man in the Gospel before spoken of But here to disintangle you and others we will first breifly â—istinguish concerning the use and exercise of that faculty and then secondly shew some causes why men do not ordinarily choose the good and nil the evil even then when it is in their power so to do For the first of these we must distinguish between freedome of will and coaction the latter of which may befal man but not the will of man Secondly betwixt a will that willeth or nilleth with full consent and a mixt will wherein the one party is predominant Phil. 1.23 For I am in a strait between two desiring to depart and to be with Christ which is best of all Thirdly Betwixt an indifferency of will or aequilibriuâ— to good or bad and a will enclined more to that which is good then to the evil This we take to have been the state of will in or first parents if not of all men yet before they fall Fourthly Betwixt a will more enclined to the evil then to the good and a will inflexible The former of these may be found after our fall gradually in men according to their inchoated or more perfect habits in evil The latter of these is found in no man till he be wholly incorporated in the pride and malice or desperation of the divel That the will of man after the fall is not wholly inflexible till such a diabolical incorporation we prove by these few instances instead of many First Pharoah that proud and obstinate Tyrant although at the first he was most averse to obey Gods voice and let Israel go yet he was brought to it by degrees untill he fully consented by Gods Judgements upon him and his people together with their perswasions Secondly Those six hundred thousand Israelites brought out of Egypt who harkening to their unbelieving spies or searchers of the good land refused to go up fight against their enemies afterwards being made sensible of Gods displeasure against them did of their own accord go up and fight against the Amalekites in the mountain even then when Moses forbad them and threatned them with capital danger Numb 14. A most evident example of the vertibility of mans will Judas himself though he would not be warned by our Saviours discovery of his treason aforehand nor by his threatning of the ensuing danger Mar. 14.18 19 20 21. Yet afterwards his will turned and he brought the money again which had corrupted him truely confessing his great wickedness Wisdome it self or Christs declareth Prov. 1.20 30. though many will not turn to him at his calling or reproof yet when it is too late the door of mercy being shut against them in the time of their great calamity this will turn to him and seek him early that is diligently So that mans will is never finally obstinate till it be wholly indevilled But from these last instances we should be warned to seek the Lord while he will be found Isa 55.6 Where the Psalmist concluds thus Psal 32.6 For this shall every one that is godly pray unto thee in the time when thou maist be found Surely in the great waterfloods of Gods destroying calamities they that is the wicked shall not come nigh him But to go on in our distinctions we must in the fifth place distinguish betwixt freewill and power voluntatem arbitrium for the one may be had where the other is wanting Rom. 7.18 Lastly Between a free will or agency and some strong inclination of nature to this or that object both which may stand together As first in God who is strongly inclined to the good and Sathan who propends wholly to the evil yet doth act freely without compulsion though not without some necessity or strong influence of nature Now in the second place the causes why the faln man doth not will the good which he might are these among others The first is the ignorance of that good ignoti nulla cupido Thus the ignorance of things promised hinders
they proceed from themselves are defiled and mixed with much weakness and imperfection and that they cannot endure the severity of Gods judgements for doth the Lord any where require more of his Saints then to love him with all their heart and with all their souls and so much we finde promised to all that truly return unto God if they have faith and will to seek it Deut. 30.6 And the Lord thy God will circumcise thine heart and the heart of thy seed to love the Lord thy God with all thy heart and with all thy soul that thou mayest live Yea doth not the Apostle expressely tell us 1 John 4.17 That herein is our love made perfect that we may have boldness in the day of Judgment because as he is so are we in this world Defend the honour of God then according to the truth and take not from the glorious works of Christ whereby the Father is glorified upon pretence of giving glory to the Father Remember what Job saith Chapter 13.7 Will ye speak wickedly for God Will ye talk deceitfully for him In your sixth Sextion as you speak comfortably to the young beleevers in Christ who are constant in their good willing indeavours that their good works are acceptable to God in Christ though for the present they are not wholy unblamable and do truely affirm That the Lord is pleased to reward also that which is sincere in them though accompanied with many weaknesses and imperfections yet your sayings in that Section are so accompanied also First In that you speak that the works of beleevers are accepted for their persons the contrary whereof may be truly asserted that the persons are accepted for their works wrought in them by Christ Revelations 3.8 I know thy works behold I have set before thee an open door and no man shall shut it for thou hast a little strength and hast kept my word and hast not denyed my name And verse 10. Because thou hast kept my word I will also keep thee from the hour of temptation which shall come upon all the world to try then that dwell upon Earth Secondly In that you say That the workes of the best grown Saints in this life are not wholy unblameable and unreproveable in the sight of God Thirdly In your affirmation That the unperfect workes of the Saints are accepted in Christ though they remain such all our life long which is not true of those who have both time and means to aime at perfection it self Hebrews 5.12 13 14. with Hebrews 6.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 c. 2 Peter 1.8 9. Lastly Whereas you imply That bare sincerity will carry out the Saints though they remain imperfect in their obedience all their life long it is a great mistake for the Lord requires growth answerable unto the grace means and space offered unto men even of them who are sincere already 1 Peter 1.22 Seeing you have purified your soules in obeying the truth under the obedience of Love saith the old Latine Translation to the unfeined love of the Brethren see that ye love one another with a pure heart fervently But as you have here and elsewhere weakened the hands of the regenerate in the work of perfecting their obedience and good workes so you have animated the unregenerate in their way of working that which is good in your seventh and last Section where you say and that truely That the neglect of what they can do in this kinde is more sinful and displeasing to God then the doing of such things which for matter are commanded in the word where by the way you hint what are the requisite things which should concur to the making up of a good work viz. That they have the word for their rule faith for their efficient a purified heart for their fountain the Glory of God for their end where onely your main efficient is wanting the spirit and power of God Yet thus much we must advertise you of that many of those whom you account to be moral men and Heathens do act out of Conscience enlightened and the grace of regeneration also as Abimilech seems to have done Genesis 20.1.6 Job Rabah the widow of Sarepta and others did CHAP. XVII Of the Perseverance of the Saints THEY whom God hath accepted in his beloved effectually called and sanctified by his Spirit neither totally nor finally can fall away from the state of Grace but shall certainly persevere therein unto the end and be eternally saved a Phil 1 6. 2 Pet 1.10 John 10.28 29. 1 Joh 3.9 1 Pet 1.5 II. This perseverance of the Saints depends not upon their own free-will but upon the immutability of the Decree of Election flowing from the free and unchangeable love of God the Father b 2 Tim 2.18 19. Jer 31.3 upon the efficacy of the merit and intercession of Jesus Christ c Heb 10.10 14. Heb 13.20 21. Heb 9.12 13 14 15. Rom 8.23 to the end John 17.11 14. Luke 22.32 Heb 7.25 the abiding of the spirit and of the seed of God within them d John 14.16 17. John 2.27 1 John 3. â— and the nature of the covenant of grace e Jer 32.40 from all which ariseth also the certainty and infallibility thereof f John 10.28 III. Nevertheless they may through the temptations of Satan and the World the prevalency of corruption remaining in them and the neglect of the means of their preservation fall into grievous sins g Mat 26.70 72 74. and for a time continue therein h Psalm 51 title and verse 14. whereby they incur Gods displeasure i Isa 64.5 7 9. 2 Sam 11.27 and grieve his holy Spirit k Eph 4.30 come to be deprived of some measure of their graces and comforts l Psal 51.8 10 12. Revel 2.4 Cant 5 2.3 4 5. have their hearts hardned m Isa 63.17 Marke 6.52 Marke 16.14 their consciences wounded n Psalm 32.3 4. Psalm 51.8 hurt and scandalize others o 2 Sam 12.14 and bring temporal judgements upon themselves p Psalm 89.31 32. 1 Cor 11.30.32 CHAP. XVII Of the perseverance of the Saints examined PErseverance follows good works here in due order for it is in them that the Saints must persevere howbeit we finde in you a constancy which we cannot commend for you persist in doctrine tending to security In your third chapter of Gods eternal decree you make some presume and others to despair teaching that Gods decree of life and death is both particular and absolute In your ninth and tenth chapters you make men stupid by denying us al use of our wils and setting forth Gods work to be irresistable in our first conversion and here you sow pillows under mens arm-holes in saying That true converts cannot possibly fall away from grace We grant indeed that this controversie about the perseverance of the Saints without greater light then for a long time appeared in the world was
afterwards being taken in due time may be recovered and revived by the respective means which you here set forth Yea whatsoever you here surmise to the contrary as we have proved it may be finally and irrecoverably lost by security presumptuous rebellions finall and total Apostacy See 2 Joh. 8. Look to your selves that we lose not those things which we have wrought Rev. 3.11 Hold that fast which thou hast that no man take thy crown But the absolute and final assurance of which we speak is neither subject to shaking nor any diminution and much less to a total and finall amission as the place before cited proves For when a man attaines to that estate his seed remaineth in him and can never be lost as we said before 1 John 3.9 See Revelations 3.12 Him that overcometh will I make a pillar in the temple of my God and he shall go no more out c. And I will write upon him the name of my God and the name of the City of my God which is new Jerusalem that cometh down out of heaven from my God and I will write upon him my new name and verse 8.10 of that Chapter Jeremy 32.40 John 14.16 23. Hebrews 17.28 Revelation 7.14 15 16 17. Revelation 21.3 4 5 6. Wherefore we ought as you say in your former Section to give all diligence to make our calling and Election sure 2 Pet. 1.10 as neither of which is sure or absolute at the first And this we must do not by searching out certain markes and tokens which proves us to be in some estate of grace but by adding vertue to vertue and a spiritual progress even to the end 2 Peter 15 6 7 8 9. Wherefore adde unto your faith vertue and to vertue knowledge and to knowledge temperance and to temperance patience and to patienece godliness and to godliness brotherly kindnesss and to brotherly kindness love where the Apostle sets forth seven steps of spiritual progress beyond saith which you take to be the highest estate of grace in this life and then addes this encouragement upon our respective proceeding verse 12. For so an entrance shall he abundantly Ministred unto you into the everlasting Kingdom of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ CHAP. XIX Of the Law of God GOD gave to Adam a Law as a covenant of works by which he bound him and all his posterity to personal entire exact and perpetual obedience promised life upon the fulfilling and threatned death upon the breach of it a Gen 1.26 27. with Gen 2.17 Ro 2.14 15. Rom 10.5 Gal 3.10 11. Eccl 7. â—9 Act 2â— 28 II. This Law after his fall continued to be a perfect rule of righteousness and as such was delivered by God upon mount Sinai in ten commandements and written in two Tables b Jam 1.25 Jam 2.8 10 11 12. Ro 13.8 9. Deut 5.32 Deut 10.8 Exo 34.1 The four first commandments containing our duty toward God and the other six our duly toward man c Mat 22.37 38 39 40. III. Besides this Law Commonly called morall God was pleased to give to the people of Israel as a Church under age ceremonial Laws containing several Typical ordinances partly of worship prefiguring Christ his graces actions sufferings and benefits d Heb 9. c. Heb 10.1 Col 2.17 Ga 4.1 2 3. and partly holding forth many instructions of moral duties e 1 Cor 5.7 2 Cor 6.17 Jud. v. 23. all which ceremoniall Laws are now abrogated under the New Testament f Col. 2.14 15 16. Dan 9.27 Eph 2.15 16. IV. To them also as a body Politicke he gave sundry Judicial Laws which expired together with the state of that people not obliging any other now further then the general equity thereof may require g Exod 21. ch Ex 22.1 to 29. Gen 9.10 with 1 Pet 2 13 14. Mat 5.17 with v. 38 39 1 Cor 9.8 9 10. V. The moral Law doth for ever binde all as well Justified persons as others to the obedience thereof h Ro 13.8 9 10. Ep 6.2 1 Joh 2.3 4 5 6. and that not only in regard of the matter contained in it but also in respect of the authority of God the Creator who gave it i Jam 2.10 11. neither doth Christ in the Gospel any way dissolve but much strengthen this obligation k Mat 517 18.19 Jam 2.8 Rom 3.31 VI. Although true believers be not under the Law as a Covenant of works to be thereby justified or condemned l Ro 6.14 Gal 2.16 Gal 3.13 Gal 4.4 5. Act 13.39 Rom 8.1 yet it is of great use to them as well as to others in that as a rule of life informing them of the will of God and their duty it directs and binds them to walk accordingly m Ro 7.12 22 25. Psa 119.4 5 6. 1 Cor 7.19 Gal 5 14 16 18 19 20 21 21. discovering also the sinful pollutions of their natures hearts and lives n Ro 7.7 Ro 3.20 so that examining themselves thereby they may come to further conviction of humiliation for and hatred against sin o Jam 1.23 24 25. Ro 7 9 14 23. together with a clearer sight of the need they have of Christ and the perfection of his obedience p Gal 3 24. Rom 7.24 25. Rom 1.3 4. It is likewise of use to the regenerate to restrain their corruptions q Jam 2.11 Psal 119.101 104 128 in that it forbids sin and the threatning of it serve to shew what even their sins deserve and what afflictions in this life they may expect for them although freed from the curse thereof threatned in the Law r Ezra 9.13 14. Psa 89.30 31 32 33 34. The promises of it in like manner shew them Gods approbation of obedience and what blessings they may expect upon the performance thereof Å¿ Lev 36.1 to 15 with 2 Chr 6.16 Eph 6 2 3. Psa 37.11 Although not as due to them by the Law as a Covenant of works t Gal 2.16 Luk 17.19 So as a man doing good and refraining from evil because the Law encourageth to the one and deterreth from the other is no evidence of his being under the Law and not under grace u Rom 6.12 14. 1 Pet 3.8 9 10 11 12 with Psal 34 12 13 14 15 16. Heb 12.28 29. VII Neither are the forementioned uses of the Law contrary to the Grace of the Gospel but do sweetly comply with it w Gal. 3.21 the spirit of Christ subduing and inabling the will of man to do that freely and cheerfully which the will of God revealed in the Law requireth to be done x Exek 36.27 Heb 8.10 with Jer 31.33 CHAP. XIX Of the Law of God examined TRuth it self hath no such cause to wage Law with you here as elswhere most of those things which you have here set forth especially concerning the moral law being legal just and true though herein you
5.1 Act 15.10 11. and in greater boldness of access to the Throne of Grace h Heb 4.14 16. Heb 10.19 20 21 22. and in fuller communications of the Spirit of God then believers under the Law did ordinarily pertake of i Joh 7.38 39. 2 Cor 3 13 17 19 II. God alone is Lord of the conscience k Jam 4.12 Ro 14.4 and hath left it free from the Doctrines and commandments of men which are in any thing contrary to his word or beside it in matters of faith or of worship l Act 4.19 Act 5.29 1 Cor 7.23 Mat 23.8 9 10. 2 Cor 1.24 Mat 15.9 so that to believe such doctrines or to obey such commands out of conscience is to betray our liberty of conscience m Col. 2.20 22 23 Gal 1.10 Gal 2.4 5. Gal 5.1 and the requiring of an implicit faith and an absolute and blinde obedience is to destroy liberty of conscience and reason also n Rom 10 17. Ro 14.23 Isa 8.20 Act 17.11 Joh 4.22 Hos 5.11 Rev 13.12 16 17 Jer 8.9 III. They who upon pretence of Christian liberty do practise any sin or cherish any lust do thereby destroy the end of Christian liberty which is that being delivered out of the hands of our enemies we might serve the Lord without fear in holiness and righteousness before him all the dayes of our life o Gal 5.11 1 Pet 2.16 2 Pet 2.19 Joh 8.34 Luk 1.74 75. IV. And because the powers which God hath ordained and the liberty which God hath purchased are not intended by God to destroy but mutually to uphold and preserve one another they who upon pretence of Christian liberty shall oppose any lawful power or the lawful exercise of it whether it be civil or Ecclesiastical resist the ordinance of God p Mat 11.25 1 Pet. ◠13 14 16. Ro 13.1 to 8. Heb 13.17 and for their publishing of such opinions or maintaining of such practises as they contrary to the light of nature or to the known principles of Christianity whither concerning faith worship or conversation or to the power of godliness or such erroneous opinions or practice as either in their own nature or in the manner of publishing or maintaining them are destructive to the external peace and order which Christ hath established in his Church they may lawfully be called to account and proceeded against by the censures of the Church q Rom 〈◊〉 32 with 〈◊〉 Cor 5.1 5 11 13 2 Jo 10.11 2 Thes 3.14 1 Tim 6.3 4 5. Tit 1.10 11 13. Titus 3.10 with 18 15 16 17. 1 Tim 19 20. Revel 2.2 14 15 20. Revel 3.9 and by the power of the civill Magistrate r Deut 13.6 to 12. Rom 13.3 4. with 2 Jo 10.11 Ezra 7.23 25 26 27 28. Revel 17.12 16 17. Nehem 13.15 17 21 22 25 30. 2 Kings 23.5 6 9 20 21. 2 Chron 34.33 2 Chron 15.12 13 16. Dan 3.29 1 Tim 2.2 Isa 49.23 Zach 13.23 CHAP. XX. Of Christian liberty and liberty of Conscience examined THis head of liberty is not now unseasonable when liberty hath got such head that almost every one affects that freedom which Tully describes Potestas vivendi ut velis but if we may use that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which we would both give and take you have too much restrained your Christian freedom in your first Section and liberty of consciences in your second contradicted your selves in your third and perhaps set the Governors too far at liberty in you fourth and last In your first Section you faile in three things first in that your enumeration of Christian liberties and freedoms is to defective secondly in that you reckon them up preposterously and thirdly in that you mistake some of them you name For the first of those you have first left out our freedom from the bondage and bewitchment of carnal wisdom and holiness Gal. 3.1 Who hath bewitched you that ye should not obey the truth 1 Pet. 1 18 19. Forasmuch as ye know that ye were not redeemed with corruptible things as silver and gold from your vain conversation received by tradition from your fathers See Gal. 5.1 Col. 2.20 21. Secondly The exemption from the great bondage of fear wherein some are held all their life long justly expecting wrath and vengeance is by you omitted Heb. 2.15 And deliver them who through fear of death were all their life time subject to bondage Thirdly Freedom for Christian Subjects from the judicial Law as well as from the ceremonial by your own confession in the last chapter especially where other Laws not contrary to the word of God are imposed upon them 1 Pet. 2.12 13 14 15 16. Fourthly A liberty to observe and omit some ceremonial Laws for the edifying of others and our own peace and indempnity of which liberty in Christ the Apostle speaks expresly Gal. 2.3 4. And as he used it himself at Cenchrea Acts 18.18 and in circumcising Timothy there Acts 16.1 2 3. and that he did the like also with the advise of all the Apostles Acts 21.22 23 24. So he chargeth that we should let no man condemn us for such things but either do them or omit them as it is required or expected at our hands by the people with whom we are to converse Col. 2.16 17. Let no man judge you in meat or in drink or in respect of an holy day or new moon or the Sabbath which are the shadow of things to come but the body is of Christ Fourthly You leave out our freedom from sorrow pain c. Revel 21.4 7 17. Lastly you have omitted the great freedom of the Spirit when he in fulness is poured upon the Saints or when the Jerusalem which is from above descends upon them which yet is not a freedom to sin but an immunity from fin to walke with freedom yea with delight in all the wayes of righteousness Gal. 4 26. But Jerusalem which is from above is free which is the mother of us all 2 Cor. 3.7 Now the Lord is that Spirit and where the Spirit of the Lord is there is liberty To which liberties some add two more one is a license to observe any outward thing not forbidden in the word of God which shall be enjoyned by Ecclesiastical or civil powers because the things that are without us defile us not Thus say they Paul became all things to all men that he might win the more To the Jews he became a Jew to them that were under the Law as if he were still under it to them that were without Law as without Law also being always under a Law to Christ 1 Cor. 9.19 20 21. And 2dly a liberty to eat of things that had bin offred to Idols when it offends not others 1 Cor. 10.27 28 29. If any of them that beleeve not bid you to a feast and ye be disposed to goe whatsoever is set before you eat asking no question for conscience sake
of his spiritual ordinances epecially and these are first the commandments of the morall Law and then his other precepâ— subservient thereunto as the Scripture every where cals them Gods ordinances 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Exod. 18.20 2 Kings 11.37 but not of the preaching of mans doctrine the administring the Sacraments not without ignorance perhaps some superstition and confusion as you often do and which you account to be the main if not the only ordinances of God Thus we fear that will finde you guilty of which the Prophet complaines Isa 24.5 The earth is defiled under the inhabitants thereof because they have transgressed the Laws changed the orâ—iâ—ancâ—â— broken the everlasting Covenant c. For what ordinances do you speak of to the people but of your way of preaching and administring the Sacraments c. In your Directory for worship you have omitted the ten Commandements Gods principal ordinances but highly magnified your kinde of preaching which hath more of art then of the spiritual gift of Prophecy in it your keeping of an outward day in every week holy with your self chosen worship and other meer humane â—rdinances Is not this to change the ordinances as Isaiah speakes In your fourth which is your last Section You first set out the respective duties of Subjects to Magistrates well and truly Secondly you rightly affirm That neither difference in religion no nor Infidelity it self do make void the Magistrates just and legal authority nor free the people from their due obedience to him If Infidelity it self cannot do this what other thing can Yet it must be granted that when Magistrates are esective and chosen conditionally the breaking of a fundamental condition may disanull his place and claim Thirdly you say here That Ecclesiastical persons are not exempted from their obedience which is but true in part in regard of civil honor obedience and all needful assistance especially where the Magistrate is no more but civil But in matters of faith salvation and damnation the consciences not only of Ecclesiastical persons as you call them but of laicks themselves are exempted from his tyranny and force therein they are only the subjects of Christ Yea in these things some persons may have authority over the Magistrate himself in the Lord though that Magistrate be a Christian also to wit such persons as are inspired and sent of God to be his mouth as Naâ—han and Gâ—d were to David and John Baptist was to Herod and diverse other Prophets were to their respective Princes and Governors Lastly you justly shut out the Pope and his jurisdiction from us as those which have taken the oath of supremacy but here you are too general in your affirmatives for want of due distinction or limitation for in some parts of Italy which are the Popes inheritance he hath power and authority over his subordinate officers and the people as other Princes have and may justly deprive those that are under him of dominions and lives when they break such capital Laws as deserve death confiscation and disinheriting but he may not do this to forraign Princes and States nor to their people who are not under his lawful jurisdiction whether upon the pretence of heresie or any other like pretext Yet some Papists are confident of this that now you have deprived the Pope of his deprivative authority over Princes you will assume it to your selvs or bestow it upon your friends when and where you think good to serve your own turns CHAP. XXIV Of Marriage and Divorce MArriage is to be between one man and one woman neither is it lawful for any man to have more then one wife nor for any woman to have more then one husband at the same time a Gen 2.24 Mat 1.19 56. Prov 2.17 II. Marriage was ordained for the mutual help of husband and wife b Gen 2.18 for the increase of mankind with a legimiate issue and of the Church with an holy seed c Mal 2.15 and for preventing of uncleanness d 1 Cor 7.2 9. III. It is lawful for all sorts of people to marry who are able with judgement to give their consent e Heb. 13.4 1 Tim 4.3 1 Cor 7.36 37. Ge 24.57 58. yet it is the duty of Christians to marry only in the Lord f 1 Cor 7.39 and therefore such as profess the true reformed Religion should not marry with Infidels Papists or other Idolaters neither should such as are godly be unequally yoked by marrying with such as be notoriously wicked in their life or maintaine damnable heresies g Gen 34 14. Exod 34.16 Deu. 7.3 14. 1 Kin 11.4 Neh 13.25 26 27. Mal 2 11 12. 2 Cor 6.14 IV. Marriage ought not to be within the degrees of consanguinity or affinity forbidden in the word h Lev 18 c. 1 Cor 5.2 Am 2.7 nor can such incestuous marriages ever he made lawful by any law of man or consent of parties so as those persons may live together as man and wife i Mar 6.28 Levit 18.23 25 26 27 28. The man may not marry any of his wives kindred nearer in blood then he may of his own nor the woman of her husbands kindred â—eerer in blood then of her own k Lev 20.19 20 21. V. Adultery or fornication committed after a contract being detected before marriage giveth just occasion to the innocent party to dissolve that contract l Mat â— 18 19 20. in the case of adultery after marriage it is lawful for the innocent party to sue out a divorce m Mat 5.31 32 and after the divorce to marry another as if the offending party was dead n Mat 19.9 Rom 7.2 3 VI. Although the corruption of man be such as is apt to study arguments unduely to put asunder those whom God hath joyned together in marriage yet nothing but adultery or such wilful desertion as can no way be remedied by the Church or civil Magistrate is cause sufficient of dissolving the bond of marriage o Mat 19 8 9 1 Cor 7 15 Mat 19 6 wherein a publike and orderly course of proceeding is to be observed and the persons concerned in it not left to their own wils and discretion in their own tase p Deu 14 1 2 3 4 CHAP. XXIV Of Marriage and Divorce examined IN this tract of marriage and divorce the path is so trite that it is no wonder if you deviate not as you have done hitherto yet are you sufficiently deficient in many things and in some other mistaken here also Your defects are these among others First since those that marry shall have trouble in the flesh as Saint Paul speaketh 1 Cor. 7.28 and marrying brings with it of necessity many avocations lets and distractions from attending upon Gods service and the seeking of his kingdom 1 Cor. 7.32 33 34. you might very seasonably in these calamitous times wherein the people like the generation before the flood are mad upon
unto us a spiritual verticum wereby we may be inabled to keep a spiritual Passover with him from death to life and become the more strengthened to follow him in his like sufferings and death and so to be better armed and fortified against all encounters of the enemy Thus was the sacrifices of the Old Testament accompanied with a meat offering and drink offering to shew that we must be furnished with the body and blood of Christ to help us in the sacrificing and offering up our spiritual sacrifice of sin Thus Melchizedek met Abraham when he was weary and faint with his late fight and brought him bread and wine to revive and strengthen him Thus furnished we ought to remember and shew forth the Lords death till his comming to us in the spirit 1 Cor. 11.23 26. and by eating of this one bread we also become one bread or flesh or bread with Christ and each other as St. Paul speaks 1 Cor. 10.16 and so this Sacrament without all controversie was ordained as you speak afterwards to oblige us unto duty and to further our communion with Christ and with each other that we may be made one bread and one body with him and in him yet not in your sens or way but as St Paul speaks 1 Cor 10.16 17. by being all made pertakers of one bread to wit his word and 1 Coâ— 12.13 by being all made to drink into one spirit as before it was shewed at large In your second Section you truely say That in this Sacrament Christ is not offered up to his Father as a sacrifice for the quick and the dead but Christ here offereth himself in his Mystical flesh and blood as a true meat offering and drink offering to his true beleevers and followers nor is it advisedly said of you there That at or in this Sacrament there is no real sacrifice at all made beside the commemoration of his own offering of himself with all possible praise to God for the same for in the right celebration of this Supper we ought to offer up both the sacrifices of a broken and contrite heart Psal 51.17 and to sacrifice the remainder of our sins as our daily offering in the holy of Gods Tabernacle in true conformity to Christ and through the help of his spiritual flesh and blood 1 Pet. 4.1 2. yet it is Christ himself and not his sacrifice that is the alone propitiation for all men John 12.1.2 In your third Section you set forth some of the duties of the person who is to administer this Sacrament truly but you have omitted the many parts of his office which are to declare the time and ends of its institution with the holy mysteries which it signifies and to stir up the people to lay hold of these benefits and to follow Christ unto the death with sutable prayers and thanksgivings In your fourth Section you truly affirm That the Priest or Minister should not observe or take this Sacrament alone and that he should communicate in both kindes to the true beleevers and followers of Christ and you do not without cause deny pompous elevations of and processions with the host for adoration sake and other superstitious reservations and abuses of the bread or host In your fifth you mistake much saying That the Elements in their signification have relation to Christ crucified as we have shewed before Yet it is true that the names of the Elements are attributed to the body and blood of Christ which they are designed to represent but the predication is Sacramental as you speak and lies in the verbe substantive 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which is as much as doth signifie est for significat as Gen. 41.25 26 27. and Gen. 50.12 18. It is likewise true which you there affirm That the Elements even after consecration remain for nature and substance bread and wine still In your sixth Section you justly tax and refute the Doctrine of Popish transubstantiation and might have reproved the consubstantiation of the Lutherans also upon good grounds but if that those terms or phrases were used to teach us that we must be spiritually consubstantiated with Christs body and blood aforesaid or transubstantiated into the same it might pass in a good sense of spiritual conformity In your seventh Section you comfort your selves and your worthy receivers with vain words and hopes concerning the presence not real only but spiritual also of that body and blood of Christ which were never signified by this Sacrament so that herein the Papists Lutherans and Calvinists do litigate de lanâ— Caprina and do not once discern which are the spiâ—itual flesh and blood of Christ there intended In your last Section you say That in this Sacrament persons ignorant of the mystery though made pertakers of the outward Elements yet they receive not the things therby signified wherein you speak truly though the speech laies hold on your selves among others but it is a question whether all that come ignorantly to this Sacrament be guilty of the body and blood of Christ we for our parts hope many are not neither doth it seem consonant to reason that all wicked or unworthy receivers that are pertakers of the Elements though they sin in coming uncalled or unprepared to this ordinance should at that time be guilty of the true body and blood of Christ which perhaps they never understood but all they that esteem not aright of the body and blood of Christ when truly offered unto them and rightly understood are guilty of the profaining of the same and much more if they by Apostacy turn therefrom as we heard before Hebr. 10.29 CHAP. XXX Of Church censures THE Lord Jesus as King and Head of his Church hath therein appointed a Government in the hand of Church Officers distinct from the Civil Magistrate a Isa 9.6 7. 1 Tim 5 17. acts 20 27 28. Heb 13.7 17 24 1 cor 12.18 Mat 28 18 19 20. II. To these Officers the keyes of the Kingdom of Heaven are committed by vertue whereof they have power respectively to retain and remit sins to shut that Kingdom against the impenitent both by the word and censures and to open it unto the penitent sinners by the mystery of the Gospel and by absolution from censures as occasion shall require b Mat. 16.19 Mat 18 17 18. Ioh 20 20 21 22 23. 2 cor 1.6 7 8. III. Church censures are necessary for the reclaiming and gaining of offending brethren for deterring of others from the like offences for purging out of that leaven which might infect the whole lump for vindicating the honour of Christ and the holy profession of the Gospel and for preventing the wrath of God which might justly fall upon the Church if they should suffer his Covenant and the seals thereof to be profaned by notorious and obstinate offenders c 1 Cor 5. chapter 1 Tim 5.20 Mat 7.6 1 Tim. 1 20 1 Cor 11.27
then for you to have pressed the necessity of the first resurrection for all fallen and corrupted men Revel 20.6 Blessed and holy is he that hath his part in the first resurrection on such the second death hath no power CHAP. XXXIII Of the last Judgment GOD hath appointed a day wherein he will judge the world in righteousness by Jesus Christ a Acts 17.30 to whom all power and judgement is given of the Father b Joh 5.22 27. In which day not only the Apostate Angels shall be judged c 1 Cor 6.3 Jude 6. 2 Pet 1.4 but likewise all persons that have lived upon earth shall appear before the tribunal of Christ to give an account of their thoughts words and deeds and to receive according to what they have done in the body whether good or evil d 2 Cor 5.10 Ec 12.14 Rom 2.16 Ro 14.10 12. Mat 12.36 37. II. The end of Gods appointing this day is for the manifestation of the glory of his mercy in the eternal salvation of the elect of his justice in the damnation of the Reprobate who are wicked and disobedient For then the righteous go into everlasting life and receive the fulness of joy and refreshing which shall come from the presence of the Lord but the wicked that know not God and obey not the Gospel of Jesus Christ shall be cast into eternal torments and be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his power e Mat. 25.31 to the end Rom 2.5 6. Rom 9.22 23. Mat 25 2â— Acts 5.19 2 Thes 1.7 8 6 10. III. As Christ would have us to be certainly perswaded That there shall be a day of judgement both to deter all from sin and for the greater consolation of the godly in their adversity f 2 Pet 3.11.14 2 Cor 5.10 11. 2 Thes 1.5 6 7. Luke 21.27 28. Rom 8.23 24 25. so will he have that day unknown to men that they may shake off all carnal security and be always watchful because they know not at what hour the Lord will come and may be ever prepared to say Come Lord Jesus come quickly g Matth 24 36 42 43 44. Mark 13.35 36 37. Luke 1â— 35 36. Rev 22 20. Amen CHAP. XXXIII Of the last Judgement Examined THis argument de rebus novissimis is a good subiect for you and us to close with but as you want some light in the beginning so we cannot commend your discerning or Judgement in your end You by your Scriptures to which you referr us confounding so many kinds and times of Judgment very different in themselves First you might have observed that Christs office of Judicature is twofold the one in the Saints and the other outward over all persons of Angels and men The former of these his inward and spiritual office Christ executes two wayes at two distant times yea in two several degrees The first is when he judgeth betwixt them and their spiritual enemies and not only delivers his servants from them but guideth and ruleth them according to his Lawes and Will Thus as types of Christ Othnicl Gedion Jephtha and the Judges of old were said to judge Israel and sutably hereunto David speaks thus of Christ Psal 72.4 He shall judge the poor of his people he shall save the children of the needy and break in peices the oppressors and Christ himself saith John 12.31 Now is the judgement of this world now is the Prince of this world cast out Christs second way of judging in his Saints is when he riseth up in them in fulness of light and power after they are dead with him in which day and coming of his he manifests unto them truth and errour light and darkness life and death yea every Councel of their own hearts even as the light of the Sun laies all open to the eye 1 Cor. 4.5 Therefore judge nothing before the time until the Lord come who both will bring to light the hidden things of darkness and will make manifest the counsels of the heart and then shall every man have praise of God for this very cause the Apostle would have all men forbear judging till that time but not until the general day of judgment now the outward judging of Christ is either in this life or the other in this life he judgeth and punisheth persons nations yea and sometimes the whole earth as he did in the daies of Noah After this life he first judgeth every man at his death Heb. 8.27 It is appointed unto all men once to die and after that cometh the judgement and then as you have here set it forth all men and Angels at or in the last day Thus then is a manifold day or time of Christs coming to judgement spoken of Matth. 24. and 25. Chapters and elsewhere First His particular coming to every man at his death Matth. 24. Secondly His coming to judge and punish the nation of the Jews Matth. 24.23 which came to pass about 38 yeers after his death Thirdly His coming to punish the fals proud and Apostate Jerusalem of the Gentiles a work now in hand Matth. 24.3 20 36 37. Fourthly Christs inward and spiritual coming promised to his Apostles and Disciples John 14.19 20. and spoken of 1 Corinth 1.7 Heb. 10.36 37. Jam. 5.7 which spiritual coming of his was after a time to cease in the Church by reason of mens Apostacy and the departure away from the true faith Luke 17.12 The daies will come when ye shall desire to see one of the daies of the Son of man and shall not see them Fifthly There is Christs second coming and his spiritual entrance into his Church in the same kinde called also the day of the Lord of which 2 Thes 2.2 in which the man of sin the son of perdition that mystery of iniquity should be revealed yea and destroyed by the brightness of his coming which coming of his brings the Gospel with it that was to be preached unto all Nations Matth. 24.30 And then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in Heaven and then shall all the Tribes of the earth mourn and they shall see the Son of man coming in the Clouds of Heaven with power and great glory and he shal send his Angels with a great sound of a Trumpet the Gospel aforesaid and they shall gather together his Elect from the four winds which time is by Zachariah described to be a gracious time chap. 12.10 11.12 and wished and longed for by St John Revel 1.7 22. This seems to be that blessed time wherein Christ shall come in the spirit but not in the body as many Chiliasts dream to errect a Kingdom throughout the earth in the hand of his Saints Dan. 7.13 14 27 28. which kingdom shall continue a thousand years Rev. 3.4 5 6. yea some are so bold as to say that this comming of Christ is the great day of judgment spoken of Acts 17.30 and elsewhere wherein Christ cometh spiritually with all his Saints to give a true and upright sentence concerning all spiritual things good and evil for which purpose they alledge that text 1 Thes 3.13 But St. John describes another judgement which shall follow after the thousand years are ended Rev. 20.7 8.15 which seem to be that very judgement which you aim at in this chapter And so sixthly and lastly There is Christs day or time of his last coming to keep a great and general Assizes Thus much in reference to your first Section especially In your second Section we admit your reasons produced to shew why there should be such a judgement with the proceedings then and the several events by you set forth and the rather because you there in the manifestation of the glory of Gods justice against there probates seem to lay their own condemnation upon their own disobedience and demerit and no way ascribe it to Gods absolute preterition or soveraignty to the want of means or sufficient grace for their effectual calling as you have done heretofore Lastly For a peaceable and friendly conclusion we grant you that which you assume in your third and last Section namly that Christ would have us certainly perswaded of a general judgement to deter all men from sin and for the greater consolation of the godly yet would he have us as well assured of our personal and particular going to judgement for the same ends so he would not have us ignorant of his spiritual coming but hope thereupon prepare our selvs thereunto 1 Thes 5.23 and though to take away security make us watchful he would have the day and hour both of our particular and his general judgment unknown unto us yet by such foregoing tokens and Characters as he hath set forth in his word we should learn to know his approaching judgements and commings and order our selves accordingly Matth. 24.32 33. Now learn a Parable of the Fig tree when its branches are yet tender and pntteth forth leaves you know that summer is nigh so likewise you when ye shall see all these things know that it is neer even at the door Against your 15. Article by you revised and here published we have not much to say but what hath been spoken upon those heads and should have had the less if you had left them all standing in statu quo prius And therefore we will here exhibite no articles against them as being more Orthodox then your selves though you hold them not for oracles We have here endeavoured to follow the Councel of St. Jude verse 3. Earnestly to contend for the faith which was once given to the Saints If any will be contentious against the truth we have no such custome nor the Church of God 1 Cor 11.16 But beloved building up your selves in your most holy faith praying in the holy Ghost keep your selves in the love of God looking for the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ unto eternal life Now unto him that is able to keep you from falling and to present you faultless before the presence of his glory with exceeding joy To the onely Wise God our Saviour be Glory and Majesty Dominion and Power Now and ever Amen Jude 20 21 24 25. FINIS