Christian sort and by a disuse of any other to incapacitate our own and our admirers devotions for the other and make both our selves and them uncharitably censorious of all Forms of Prayer and those who use them that is of the whole Catholick Church except a new and inconsiderable party CHAP. XI The Contents The Proposition That there is nothing in the Liturgy prescribed by the Church of England to which her Lay Communicants may not yield obedience The general Objections against it Answered are 1. That the phrase throughout the several Offices is such as presumes all persons in the Communion of the Church to be regenerate and in an actual state of Grace § 1. The falseness of which suggestion is shewed in ten instances and the phrase of the Liturgy is justified from like expressions of the Holy Scripture ibid. 2. Obj. That the people do not only say Amen but bear a part in the Prayers Answ This is justified from the practice of the Jews and Primitive Christians and the benefit of so doing § 2. 3. That the same Prayers are oft repeated which seems to be the vain Repetition forbidden by Christ Matth. 6.7 8. Answ These Repetitions are justified from Scripture-Examples and the practice of Christ § 3. Objections against several parts or expressions of the Liturgy Answered As 1. That in several parts of the Liturgy all profess to put their trust in God whereas it is to be feared that many in our Congregations do not so § 4. 2. That we all profess to Repent and be heartily sorry for our sins We all say on Sexagesima Sunday that God seeth that we put no trust in any thing that we do after the Communion we all give thanks to God that he hath assured us of his favour and goodness to us And in the Third Collect after Trinity we all profess that God hath given us an hearty desire to pray which professions cannot be thus generally made in truth § 5.3 That we pray that God would give to all Nations Unity Peace and Concord that he would save among the remnant of true Israelites all Jews Turks Infidels and Hereticks that he would have mercy upon all men which petitions cannot be put up in Faith there being no promise of so large extent in Scripture § 6.4 That we pray to God to succour help and comfort all that are in danger necessity and tribulation to preserve all that travail by land or by water all Women labouring of child all Prisoners and Captives and so we pray for Robbers Pyrats Whores c. § 7. Some passages in the Liturgy which seem obscure or Metaphorical explained As 1. There is no health in us 2. Give peace in our time O Lord Because there is no other that fighteth for us but only thou O God 3. Lighten our darkness 4. From Fornication and all other deadly sins 5. From sudden Death Good Lord deliver us 6. By the Mystery of thy Holy Incarnation by thy Holy Nativity and Circumcision and by the coming of the Holy Ghost Good Lord deliver us 7. That our bodies may be made clean by his Body and our souls washed by his most precious blood 8. That God by the Baptism of his Well-beloved Son did sanctifie water to the mystical washing away of Sin 9. The Prayer after the Fourth Commandment Lord have mercy upon us and encline our hearts to keep this Law 10. With this Ring I the Wed with my body I thee worship and with all my worldly Goods I thee endow § 8. The Conclusion THAT there is nothing in the stinted Liturgy prescribed by the Church of England to which her Lay Communicants may not yield obedience or which can render their Communion with her sinful or unlawful to them As will be evident by answering the scruples Dissenters do suggest against the whole or any portion of that Service in which they are obliged to join with us And to begin with the Objections which respect the whole body of the Liturgy § 1 1. It is Objected That in the whole Common Prayer there is not any Petition or Confession which imports any doubt Dr. Chambers paper of unaffected scruples or fear that any of those who join in that Service are in a state of unregeneration or enmity to God whereas there are many in our Congregations of whom the Lord hath cause to complain as of the Jews that they hold fast deceit and refuse to return Jer. 3.5.11.15 To this effect runs the Objection of the Commissioners at the Savoy viz. P. 7. That throughout the several Offices the phrase is such as presumes all persons within the Communion of the Church to be regenerated converted and in an actual state of Grace which had Ecclesiastical discipline been truly and vigorously executed in the exclusion of scandalous and obstinate sinners might be better supposed but there having been and still being a confessed want of that as in the Liturgy is acknowledged it cannot rationally be admitted in the outmost latitude of Charity Answer This plainly seems to be a great mistake or false suggestion against the frame and constitution of our Liturgy For 1. The Sentences of Scripture appointed to be read at the beginning of Morning and Evening Prayer are fitted to the state of unregenerate and wicked persons and call upon them to turn from their wickedness that they have committed Ezek. 18.27 and do that which is lawful and right that they may save their souls alive To rent their hearts Joel 2.13 Dan. 9.9 10. and turn unto the Lord their God To acknowledge that they have rebelled against the Lord their God And have not obeyed the voice of the Lord to walk in his ways which he set before them Luke 15 18 19. And that they have sinned against their heavenly Father so as to be no more worthy to be called his servants 2. The Exhortation calls upon them to confess their manifold sins and wickednesses and not to dissemble or cloak them but confess them with an humble lowly penitent and obedient heart to the end that they may obtain forgiveness of the same through Gods infinite goodness and mercy and so it manifestly doth suppose that many of them who are thus exhorted have not yet obtained forgiveness of their sins 3. The General Confession doth acknowledge that we are miserable offenders and that there is no health in us and prays that God would restore them that are penitent according to his promises declared to mankind in Christ Jesus our Lord and so suggests that they have need of Repentance to interest them in those promises 4. The Absolution begins with a declaration that God desires not the death of a sinner but rather that he may turn from his wickedness and live adding that God will pardon and absolve all those that truly repent and therefore calls upon us to beseech him to grant us true repentance and his Holy Spirit and doth suppose that many present want
Because these kinds of Death are more uncomfortable to our surviving Friends who in these cases have no time allowed by their consideration to wean themselves from our enjoyment and do receive no benefit from our latter ends as from our dying counsels and meditations they might do 3. Because they who dye thus want their viaticum which is provided by the word of God and the compassion of the Church to fit them for their journey to the great Tribunal and doubtless it is no small comfort to the dying Christian to enjoy an opportunity to confess his sins unburthen his Soul of them to hear the Prayers and to receive the absolution of the Ambassadors of Christ and to partake of that most comfortable Sacrament which sealeth the love of God unto him and doth assure him who faithfully doth eat this Bread and drink this Blood of Christ that he will raise him up at the last day 4. No man is so prepared to appear at Gods Tribunal but he both may and ought to be prepared better and therefore may desire to have time for further preparation O spare me a little before I go hence saith the man after Gods own heart and who will not joyn with him in that Prayer we ought indeed to be always prepared for death and 't is our wisdom so to be but who is so well fitted as he ought or he desires to be and who cannot be better fitted by a more leisurely summons for his change If we observe how ardently the dying person prays how humbly he confesseth his forepast offences how heartily he doth bewail his former sins what resolutions he doth make of living more unto the glory of God if providence shall raise him up again we cannot reasonably doubt but that it is desireable to have these opportunities vouchsafed of doing good to our own souls before we go hence and be no more seen Q. 6 What is the meaning of those words in the Litany by the mystery of thy holy Incarnation by thy holy Nativity and Circumcision by thy Baptism Fasting and Temptation by thy Agony and bloody Sweat by thy Cross and Passion by thy pretious Death and Burial by thy glorious Resurrection and Ascension and by the coming of the Holy Ghost Good Lord deliver us Do not you seem to conjure here These expressions may have two very plain and obvious meanings 1. By applying them so as to make them a request that by means of all these meritorious or beneficial acts of our Lord Jesus we may be delivered from all the aforesaid miseries Temporal Spiritual and Eternal that he who took our nature on him Heb. 2.14 18.4.15 11. that he might be in all things like us and so a more compassionate High Priest to us under our natural infirmities and that by death he might destroy him who had the power of death viz. the Devil that he who came into the world that we might live through him he who was circumcised and became obedient to the Law to save us from the curse of it that he who was baptized Gal. 3.13 Matt. 3.15 that by his own example he might teach us to fulfil all righteousness and who was tempted that he might be a merciful High Priest to succour us when tempted that he who suffered such Agonies for our iniquities as caused in him a bloody sweat and a most ignominious Death upon the Cross for our Redemption that he who was raised again for our justification Rom. 4.25 and is ascended to the right hand of God Heb. 7.25 there to intercede for ever for us and being thus ascended sent his Holy Spirit to be our comforter and sanctifyer that he would by the merit efficacy and beneficial influences of all these gracious acts deliver us 〈◊〉 all those dreadful evils mentioned in the foregoing words 2. All these considerations may be here urged as so many motives to our dear Redeemer taken from the consideration of his former goodness and loving kindness to us to work deliverance for us now and so the import of them will be this by the endearing love which thou hast shewed unto us in all these gracious dispensations we beseech thee to deliver us from all the forementioned evils both of sin and punishment Q. 7 What mean you by those words in the Communion Service viz. that our bodies may be made clean by Christs body and our souls washed by his most precious blood do you not hereby seem to ascribe a greater efficacy to the blood than to the body of Christ and to restrain the virtue of the latter only unto the cleansing of the Body Answ 1 That the words used at the delivery of the Elements the body of our Lord Jesus Christ which was given for to preserve thy body and soul to everlasting life and the like concerning his blood are a manifest evidence that the Church intended no such thing but that we heartily believe that the benefits both of the body and blood of Christ do redound to the Salvation and consequently to the Sanctification both of our Souls and Bodies He who desires to see more to this effect may consult Dr. Womacks Letter from p. 66. to p. 74. Q. 8 Why do you say That God by the Baptism of his Well-beloved Son in the River Jordan did sanctifie water to the Mystical washing away of sin was not this rather done by Gods own institution of that ordinance to such an end than by the Baptism of his Son who knew no Sin and therefore upon whom Baptism could have no such effect Answer I Answer this is an expression frequently used by the Antient Fathers Tertullian 1 Adv. Jud. c. 8. 2 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 p. 153. 3 Orat. 38 39. Epiphanius Nazianzen St. Jerom and allowed by the Assemblys Annotations * Iu. Matt. 3. where one end of Christs Baptism is assigned to be this viz. To sanctifie the flood Jordan and all other waters to the mystical washing away of sin Now for explication of the phrase consider that to sanctfie in Scripture signifies first to declare any thing to be holy to own and to acknowledge it as such Sanctificetur nomen tuum hallowed be thy name that is say Interpreters Sanctum declaretur Sancte praedicetur let it be declared and agnized as holy So when God saith 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 I will sanctifie my Great name Ezek. 36.23 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 I will be sanctified before the Heathens Ezek. 38.23.39 27. the meaning is He will declare his Holy Name to them and they shall acknowledge it And in this sense God by ordering the Baptism of his Son in the River Jordan that so he might fulfill all righteousness submit as well unto the Christians Baptism as to the Circumcision of the Jews declared that Baptism was sacred or set apart by him unto this use and Christ by his submission to it owned it as sacred and whereas if a thing be sanctified already or set
which must therefore be unlawful according to this Argument because prescribed by no Apostle in the Holy Scriptures This is a business which if it were necessary would be equally necessary to all Ages Ob. 2. Ibid. and parts of the Catholick Church and therefore it cannot be necessary but it must be the matter of an universal law now God hath made no such law in Scripture and so Scripture sufficiency as the Catholick Rule of faith and universal obedience is utterly overthrown Answer The Answers given to the first objection do also manifestly shew the vanity of this for may it not as well be said of the Festivities of the Apostles and first Martyrs of the Church as of the feast of Christmas the Ascension of our Lord c. That If they are necessary to be observed they must be necessary to all Ages that God in Scripture hath made no law concerning them c. May it not as well be said that if Publick Assemblies are necessary to be set apart now that if any unprescribed forms of Prayer are necessary to be used now or any words in Scripture not prescribed in consecration or celebration of the Sacraments that if standing on the Lords day in time of Prayer if Stationary days if the Penitential Discipline observed in the Primitive Church were necessary in any Age or part of the Church they must be necessary in all Ages and parts of the Catholick Church and that God hath in Scripture made no laws concerning them and so Scripture sufficiency is and was by the observation of them overthrown 2ly Tho we do judge the observation of these Festivals expedient yet we by no means hold it necessary not by necessity of precept for we pretend not to any precept of this kind not as a necessary means for we acknowledge God may be duly praised and Worshipped and magnified for the mercies we then celebrate on other days and therefore we confess that * Non putandum Ecclesiam Christianam aliquancessitate astringi ad obser vationem immotam festorum dierum sed statuendum dies hosee humanâ authoritateconstitutos eddem posse tolli mutari c. Dav. in Coloss 2. v. 16. if the Church thinks fit she may leave all men to their liberty in the observing or not observing of these days only we add that sure the General Rule of doing all things for edification will warrant her appointment of them for the forementioned ends as well as the appointment of a Lecture-day or of a Sermon before the Assizes God himself hath appointed a day for the same purposes as these are pretended for Ob. 3. Ibid. for the Lords day is to commemorate the Resurrection as the great triumphant act of the Redeemer implying all the Rest of his works so that tho it be principally for the resurrection above any single work of Christ yet also for all the work of Redemption and the whole is on that day to be commemorated with Holy joy and praise now when God himself hath set apart one day in every week to commemorate the whole work of Redemption it seems an accusing of his Institutions of insufficiency to come after him to mend them and say we must have an Anniversary day for this or that part of the work Answer 1. That God did institute the Lords day for the particular Commemoration of the whole work of the Redemption is Gratis dictum what Scripture or what declaration of Any Father of the Church saith so 2ly This Argument makes it unlawful to set up a lecture upon any day but the Lords day for that day being appointed for publick reading and hearing of Gods Holy word for men to set up another day for that end is to accuse his institutions of insufficiency 3ly This Argument condemns the universal Church of Christ from the Apostles days for they did then observe the feast of Easter and so tho God had set apart a weekly Commemoration of the resurrection of our Lord they did come after him and observe an Anniversary day for the same thing and so according to this way of Arguing did more apparently accuse his institutions of insufficiency 4ly This objection seems to accuse the wisdom of Gods own institutions for tho the Jewish Sabbath was instituted with a peculiar respect to their deliverance out of Aegypt Deut. 5.15 yet for that mercy which was far inferior to those which Christians do enjoy by our Lords Birth his Death his Resurrection and Ascension he required other solemnities to be observed yearly viz. The great feast of the Passover why therefore may not the wisdom of the Church in imitation of this pattern besides the Lords day weekly set apart for celebrating the work of our Redemption require other solemnities to be observed yearly for a peculiar Commemoration of the most Signal parts of that Redemption Obj. 4 The fourth Commandment being one of the Decalogue seems to be of so High a nature that man must not presume to make the like Ibid. but it seems a doing the same or of like nature to what God hath done in the fourth Commandment if any man will make a necessary stated Holy day to the universal Church Answer 1. Who goes about to make a Necessary stated Holy day to the Universal Church sure none besides the Church of Rome pretendeth to give laws unto her But what the Universal Church hath thought fit to observe I hope our Church may prudently comply with and call upon her Children so to do 2ly Is not this done as much by the stated Festivals which you allow of as by those you do condemn was it not done as much by appointing the feast of Purim to be observed yearly and by ordaining that these days should be remembred and kept throughout every Generation Esth 9.27 28. every Family every Province and every City and that these days of Purim should not fail from among the Jews nor the memorial of them perish from their seed was it not done as much by the whole Congregation of Israel when they ordained that the days of the Dedication of the Altar should be observed from year to year by the space of eight days And yet neither our Lord 1 Macc. 4.59 nor any of the Prophets charged them with violation of the 4th Commandment on that account or with presuming to do the like to that which God had done in the institution of it Object 5 Where there is no law sure we are there is no transgression but there is no law of God Commanding Christmas or other Holy-days therefore there is no trangression in not keeping them But then it is not sure that there is no transgression in keeping them therefore the surer side is to be taken Answer 1. That this Argument plainly destroys his former grant of the expedience of observing and enjoyning other Holy-days for which no law of God commanding them can be produced 2ly That this Argument may be retorted thus
or at the least we understand not how they can be said with any certainty of truth And Q 1 What say they is the meaning of that Metaphor in the Confession There is no health in us Answer The meaning is That we have no power to help or save our selves out of the misery which by our sins we have deserved that there is nothing in our selves which can preserve us from perishing under the guilt of our iniquities this is the frequent import of the word health in Scripture So Psal 42.11.43.1 God is the health of my countenance i. e. the help of my countenance Psal 42.5 Salvation is far from the wicked Psal 119.155 N. Transl Health is far from them saith the Old And again Trust not in Princes or in any sons of men for there is no help in them Psal 146.3 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 there is no health or no Salvation in them say the Seventy Q 2 What is the meaning or at least the appositeness of that Respons Give Peace in our time O Lord. Resp Because there is none other that fighteth for us but only thou O God Answer To lay the foundation of a perspicuous Answer to this Question consider 1. Vide Comber part 1. p. 363 364. 1 Chron. 22.9 Isai 39.8 That it was one of Gods gracious Promises to his pious Servants of old that he would give peace in their days and so this is fit matter of our Prayer 2. Consider That God is in the Scripture stiled the God of Peace that it is He who makes peace in our borders and by his providence preserveth peace among Nations Psal 46.9 breaking the Bow and knapping the Spear asunder Consider 3. That this God is our only sure defence against our Enemies and that our Armies and Navies will be unsuccessful to defend us without his good providence or to procure peace for us And therefore it behoves us to apply our selves unto him for these mercies Conlider 4. That the end of all just War is Peace men therefore sighting in their own defence that they may oblige their neighbours to live peaceably by them This being so what is more proper than this Prayer Give peace in our time O Lord thou God of Peace either by keeping us from War or rendring our Arms so happy and successful that they may procure us a lasting peace This do we beg of thee because there is none other who can keep us from War or save us in it or make our fighting tend unto our lasting future peace but only thou O Lord. Q 3 What is the meaning of that Metaphor Lighten our darkness O Lord Answ I Answer It is a Scripture phrase used Psal 18.28 Job 29.3 importing our desire that by the goodness of our God we may be kept in a joyful comfortable prosperous state which state in Scripture is usually signified by the word light being preserved still from all calamities and miseries if we at present are free from them or else delivered from them by his power and mercy if we labour under any kinds or degrees of them and the ensuing clause is but an explication and application of it to the then present night Q. 4 What mean you by your Prayer for deliverance from Fornication and all other deadly sins Do you not by it seem to approve that Popish Doctrine which holds that some sins in their nature are venial that is do not deserve Eternal Death Answer This cannot rationally be suspected of that Church whose Doctrine it is That all sin is in its own nature deadly though all in the event do not and according to the tenor of the Covenant of Grace will not prove deadly to the Christian. For that New Covenant declares God will accept of our sincere obedience that is of such obedience as is consistent with sins of ignorance and weakness and that such sins will not exclude us from Gods favour but will be pardoned upon our general Repentance and our desire to be cleansed from our secret sins The import therefore of this phrase is this That God would graciously deliver us from-all those sins which are therefore deadly 1. Because they do declare him who commits them to be unregenerate or dead in trespasses and sins And thus it is declared concerning Fornicators Eph. 5.5 For no Fornicator hath any inheritance in the Kingdom of Christ but is a son of disobedience vers 6. He is yoked with the prophane Heb. 12.16 and doth commit that sin which is contrary to his cleaving to Christ and which permiteth not his body to be the Temple of the Holy Ghost And 2. 1 Cor. 6.16 19. Because they leave us under the sentence of death so that whosoever dies without particular Repentance for and reformation of them will be obnoxious to Eternal Death they being sins for which the wrath of God comes upon the Children of disobedience So is it said of Fornication Coloss 3.6 and to all Fornicators it is threatned That they shall have their portion in the lake of fire and brimstone which is the second death Rev. 21.8 and St Paul plainly saith Fornicators and Adulterers God will damn Heb. 13.4 And 3. Because they usually end in death few ever escaping from them or being renewed to Repentance such is too frequently the fate of him who goeth to the Harlots House For none that goeth to her house saith Solomon Prov. 2.19 returns again or takes hold of the paths of life The mouth of a strange Woman being a deep pit Prov. 22.14 into which he that is abhorred of the Lord doth fall Now these sins being too many to be named particularly and being difficult to be exactly stated and enumerated are comprehended under this general appellation To humble the bold committers of them by minding them that if they be not speedily repented of which is but rarely done they will end in their Damnation or Eternal Death Q. 5 Why pray you for deliverance from sudden death which if it happen to the prepared Christian seems to be no evil Answer Though some 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Euchol p. 776. who it seems think that they are always sit to dye do inconsiderately blame this petition of our Liturgy as unbecoming Christians and thereby blame the Church of God which for a long time hath made use of this petition yet I suppose that none of them would wish or if they well considered be as much contented to dye by the immediate suddain hand of God as to have time to recollect themselves before death to dye as did Jobs children or they on whom the Tower of Siloam fell but rather would conceive it were a mercy worthy of their thanks to be delivered from such a death And that 1. Comber part 2. p. 61 62. Because this suddain death affords no time to settle our Estates but leaves our temporal concerns entangled and involves our Relations in Law-suits and contests 2.