all this they make two Objections first 't is against the Justice of God to reprobate Men who have done no evil though Scripture saith clearly it is so to father injustice upon God is certainly a great impity God is most just in every thing he doth though we cannot fathom into the particular causes yet his justice is a general one the consideration whereof ought to stop the mouth of every Creature What shall we say to the case of the Flood which was a great judgment whereby the whole World eight persons excepted perished in the Waters 'T is true the wickedness of Men was raised to an utmost degree but withall it must be owned that there were many Infants new born Babes yea several quick in the Womb who had committed no actual sins yet were involved in that general destruction Death saith Rom. 5.14 Paul reigned from Adam to Moses even over them that had not sinned after the similitude of Adam's transgression Adam's sin was an actual sin eating the fruit of the Forbiden-tree it could not be Original for he was created in Innocency but seeing (a) Chap. 6.23 death is the wages of sin and that those Infants who had committed no actual sin dyed in the Flood we must find another sin not after the similitude of Adam's transgression and that is Original-sin Now I say that as Original-sin was a just cause of the natural Death of those Babes so the same sin when it pleases God to leave them in it is a just cause of Eternal Death in those whom he punisheth with it for Eternal Death as well as Natural is the wages of Original as of Actual-sin And though sin be not the cause to move to pass sentence upon any yet that sentence is passed upon none but what are sinners Hence I conclude that as God was just in inflicting by the Flood Natural Death upon those Children that were unborn or newly born before they had done any evil so this holds for Election as for Reprobation in relation to Faith as to Unbelief according to that famous place of Romans about Jacob and Esau It is to be observed how St. Peter calls (b) Pet. 2.5 the world of the ungodly that world which the Flood drowned without any exception at all of Infants or others What hath been said of the Flood may be spoken to the same purpose of that terrible judgment upon Sodom and Gomorah and the Cities about them where no doubt were also Infants new born Babes and some quick in the Womb which as (c) Jud. 7. St. Jude saith suffered the vengeance of eternal fire and are set forth for an example Yet in all those things no exception against God's justice for he is most just in all his ways For if we must believe David the Lord is righteous in all his ways and holy in all his works Psal 15.17 What shall we say as to the case of Achan his sin was personal he alone had committed it yet that same sin his Sons and Daughters nay the very Beasts as his Oxen Asses Sheep as well as he were by God's immediate command stonned to death and burned with fire Though in the eyes of Men they seemed innocent yet were guilty in the Lords eyes Josh 7.24 25. So in the particular case I before quoted of the Man that was blind from his birth our Saviour saith that neither the Man had sinned nor his Parents but that the works of God should be made manifest in him This was a sufficient answer to the disciples they put no more questions about it But Arminians will impeach God's justice for denying sight to one who had not actually sinned Do not they do so in calling the equity of God's Decrees touching Men into question Can any thing in Scripture be plainer than this (a) Rom. 9.18 22 23. Ephes 1.11 that God hath mercy on whom he will have mercy and whom he will he hardeneth that he hath appointed some to be vessels of mercy to the praise of the glory of his grace and some to be vessels of wrath to make his power to be known and that he maketh all things after the counsel of his own willâ— Yet what more usual than to dispute how this can agree with justice And with what reason God may punish that sin which by vertue of a Decree is unavoidable 'T is strange yet too true how peremptory sawcy and blasphemous speeches some in their Cups and others sometimes upon other occasions break into upon this subject and would reduce God to such terms of reason as they fancied to themselves After such declarations about these things which God hath given in his word were it not better to give him Glory and with David say O Lord thou art just when thou speakest and pure when thou judgest And if they cannot conceive how this should stand with equity rather than to call to question God's justice were it not better to own their weakness And with David say this is my infirmity For wo unto him that striveth with his Maker according to Solomon (b) Eccles 8.4 't is prudence not to controll an earthly King's actions who may say unto him what dost thou And O man who art thou that repliest against God and if in reference to Politicks of Government and Mysteries of State the same (c) Prov. 25.2 Solomon saith the heart of a King is unsearchable there is some secret reasons which many cannot dive into In God's matters as his Decrees and wise dispensation of his Providence much more we must think it to be so for in the same Chapter the wise Man saith it is the glory of God to conceal a thing The second Objection they make and which we already have given a hint to is this if I be reprobate and 't is God's pleasure I should go to Hell it is not in my power to help it so their Damnation they father upon God's pleasure This is too much like our first Parents to lay the fault upon others to excuse themselves Gen. 3.12.13 The woman whom thou givest to be with me she gave me of the tree and I did eat He throws it on the Woman and she upon the Serpent the serpent begiuiled me If God had not given him the Woman then he would not have sinned nor the Woman if God had not created a Serpent so if God had not reprobated us say some we had not been damned But this is no more able to excuse them then the fig-leaves were to cover their nakedness though never so cunningly sewed together The Apostle lays open the case how God directeth and turneth all for his glory even the worst of things For our unrighteousness doth commend the righteousness of God and thorough our lie the truth of God hath more abounded unto his glory Rom. 3.5 6 7. Yet for all this though these evil things are turned to the greatest good that is the glory of God we are nevertheless
of sticking to the Rule and Word of God To such we may put St. Paul's question (e) Rom. 11.34 35. Who hath known the mind of the Lord or who hath been his counsellour Hast thou known his mind or hast thou been his Counsellour Or who hath first given to him hast thou then it shall be recompensed to thee again Thou hast chosen him to be thy God before he predestinated thee to the adoption of Children thou hast believed in him before he elected thee to believe in Christ since thou makest God as accomptable to thee be sure if he owes any thing he will pay it but one should know that (a) Job 33.13 there is no striving against God and that he giveth not account of any of his matters For (b) Prov. 21 30. there is no wisdom nor understanding nor counsel against the Lord. As to the question whether or not the decree of Election be absolute I say 't is not in some respect and in some other it is 't is not absolute in relation to the means conducing to the obtaining of Salvation which are included in the decree whereof the merits of Christ and Faith are the chief though I must say that the Use and Application of those means is the work of grace God saith Job (c) Job 23 1â— performeth the thing that is appointed for me And St. Paul by the grace of God I am what I am ... Yet not I but the grace of God that was with me 1 Cor. 15.10 And I can do all things through Christ which strengtheneth me Philip. 4.13 It is absolute in relation to any impulsive or instrumental cause or any condition which the decree should depend upon which is the question between Arminians and us In the execution of the decree Faith is the instrument and hand whereby we receive and apply Christ's merits unto us but it is under no such Notion in the making of the decree What I said before I repeat here that there are not two decrees one for the end another for the means but one and the same for both because God willeth together end and means where one can do two are superfluous Now God doth nothing in vain Let us now speak of the matter of Election or who are those whom God elected unto eternal life They are Men fallen in Adam and for sin in the sight of God guilty of eternal death yet God hath not chosen all men sinners but only some few of every sort especially of those which are low and contemptible in this world As to the first they are Men fallen in Adam We think this to be the order of God's decrees about Men First to Create Man for the glory of his Name Secondly to permit they should fall from the integrity wherein they were created and so become guilty of eternal death Thirdly Out of that whole lost lump of mankind to restore some to everlasting life thereby to shew his mercy and leave the rest in the state of Perdition and Damnation for their sins to manifest his Justice Our reasons why God hath chosen men in that state are First Because he hath (a) Ephes 1.4 elected us that we should be holy and without blame Therefore he lookt upon such as unholy and sinners Secondly Scripture calleth Election (b) Rom. 9.15.23 a will to shew mercy and a little lower the Elect are called vessels of mercy therefore considered as in misery for misery is the Object of Pity and Mercy We say in the second place all men are not elected only some out of all sorts on which Scripture is positive (c) Matth. 20.16 few are chosen Neither doth God give eternal life to all for some are Damned therefore he decreed not to do 't for God doth nothing in time but what from eternity he decreed to be done God hath not mercy upon all but (d) Rom. 9.18 he hardneth some neither doth he give the means of Salvation as calling by the word Faith in Christ Repentance Justification by Faith to all but only to some so that we may say they who are not elected to the means are not elected to the end for God will not bestow the end but through the means the very name of Election signifieth a choice of some out of many he cannot be said to chuse who taketh all promiscuously The Adversaries we are now disputing against to prove that God decreed from eternity with an antecedent will to save in time all and every Man do argue thus (e) 1 Tim. 2.4 God will have all men to be saved therefore he decreed to save them all but the consequence is not good for in the Text the Apostle doth not mean every particular Man but men of all sorts as Princes and Subjects which is the scope of the place For there he exhorteth to have prayers made for all men for Kings and all in authority Rich and Poor Old and Young Men and Women great Men and of low degree that is of all Ages Sexes Quality Nation and People c. The particle all is distributive as School-men say into the genders of singulars not into the singulars of genders we do not our selves give that sence but 't is Scripture interpretation The four Beasts and twenty four Elders said to the Lamb (a) Rev. 5.9 chap. 7.9 and chap. 11.9 chap. 13.6 chap. 14.6 chap. 19.18 Thou wast slain and hast redeemed us to God by thy blood out of every kindred and tongue and people and nation Which is repeated in several other places of the same book as are quoted in the Margin to shew this is the true meaning of the Spirit of God And the Reader may peruse them with that of Colos 3.4 Again they object (b) 2 Pet. 3.9 God will have none to perish but all that should come to repentance But there the Apostle speaketh not indifferently of all Men but only of the Elect as appeareth in the same verse God is patient or long suffering to us ward so he is not willing that any of us should perish and who those are whom he speaks to they are the same he writes his Epistle to and them he nameth in the first verse of the first Chap. To them that have obtained like precious faith with us thorough the righteousness of God and our Saviour Jesus Christ He will have none of these to perish but that they all come to repentance and certainly they will Thus the word all is taken for the Elect in the two following places (c) 1 Tim. 2.6 Christ gave himself a ransome for all and (d) 2 Cor. 5.15 Christ died for all and not for every Man whether Believer or Reprobate as it will be proved in its place by the grace of God What St. Paul saith that (e) Rom. 11.32 God hath concluded them all in unbelief that he might have mercy upon all is not to be understood of every particular Man but
Indifferent Men Women Babes Children Youths Old Men of all Languages of all Dispositions of all Trades of all Professions and according to their divers inclinations innumerable ways diversified I am not used to quote Authorities of the Fathers though I could easily shew that the Orthodox Men amongst them do about all these controverted points speak as we do but besides that those Quotations would fill too much Paper we must give them no farther credit than as they agree with the infallible rule the word of God therefore we keep close to it only this passage is so much to our purpose that I thought fit to set it down However we shall hereafter have occasion to make use of such Authorities The same answer may be returned to this God will have all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth that is Men of all sorts and qualities and that the Apostle meaneth it so in this place it appears out of the scope very clearly for St. Paul exhorteth (b) 1 Tim. 2.1 2 3 4. prayers supplications c. to be made for all men He proceedeth to the distinction when he saith for Kings and all that are in authority and giveth the reason That we may lead a quiet life in all godliness under their Government for this is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Saviour who will have all men to be Saved that is of the several states and conditions whether they be Kings or any in Authority as well as those that live under them The Adversaries themselves must own how restrictions must be made of those general terms as in the last Text God will have all men to be saved they will not deny that 's expressed under condition of Faith and Repentance and yet the Text doth not explain it self so the like we may say of other places which tend to the same effect if men could but part with prejudice which they are prepossessed of and seek after truth for truth's sake there would sooner be an agreement They Object farther (a) 1 Cor. 15.22 As in Adam all die so in Christ shall all be made alive therefore by his death he hath obtained life for all we deny the Consequence the scope of the place is not to shew the extent by way of parallel of the number of those that were dead or alive but the ground of death or life for the sense of the place is and St. Austin explains it so as all those who die die in Adam So all those that are made alive are made alive in Christ out of him there being no Salvation (b) Acts. 9.12 Neither is there salvation in any other for there is none other name under heaven given amongst men whereby we must be saved It is most clear out of Scriptures how all dead in Adam are not quickned by Christ but some are left in the state of death for (c) Math. 7.14 few find the way to life This very comparison between Christ and Adam was by Pelagius urged against Austin But say they if Adam hath more destroyed than Christ hath restored then Adam had more power than Christ which is a gross mistake for the restoring to life one dead Man requireth a greater power than to kill a Million Another place of Scripture they bring (d) 1 Tim. 4.10 God is the Saviour of all men but there St. Paul doth not speak of deliverance by way of Salvation but of Preservation and of God's Providence in this world extended upon mankind and to shew it is so 't is added in the same verse specially of those that believe in matter of redemption there is no speciality God takes care of preserving all men in general but Believers in a special manner They make use of another place (e) Rom. 14.15 Destroy not him with thy meet for whom Christ died Therefore Christ died for those who may be damned but the Apostle doth not say that he may be damned for whom Christ died but his scope is to forbid giving offence or matter of scandal to a weak Brother with eating things which he thinks to be unlawful and unclean neither is one destroyed upon any occasion of offence though his Conscience be thereby wounded for the hand of God doth uphold those whom his Son hath redeemed Of this same nature is another place they bring against us (a) 2 Pet. 2.1 Some deny the Lord that bought them and bring upon themselves swift destruction But this Text is not about true redemption from eternal death but only a deliverance of the error and ignorance of the times by the means of the light of the Gospel which happeneth sometimes to the false Prophets which the Apostle speaks of not that they were so in truth but only in appearance they lived in the Church with them that were truly redeemed whose number they seemed to be of but were not really so I now come to the last Objection which is that all to whom Christ's death is preached are bound to believe Christ died for them or else they would be bound to believe a lye but as many Reprobates are hearers of the Word so they ought to believe that Christ died for them But 't is not true that all those whom the word is preached to ought absolutely to believe Christ died effectually for their sins but only in a qualified and restrictive sence if God enableth them by his grace to repent and believe not that repentance should be the cause of that death of his but a most certain and infallible sign of it Scripture doth indeed bind all the Faithful and Elect to believe that Christ effectually died for them because it is so but for those who are yet out of Christ there is no such Precept they must first really be ingrafted in Christ and then believe it not first believe it and then be ingrafted else they should believe a lye in believing their sins are actually purged because a Man must be first in Christ before his iniquity can actually be washed away Then Scriptures enjoyn no reprobate and unregenerate Man to believe at first that Christ effectually died for his sins only as I said upon condition of Repentance and Faith which the reprobate shall never have and the unregenerate who is Elect is not absolutely bound to believe it till the time of his conversion be come And suppose every private Man were obliged to believe Christ effectually died for his sins yet it doth not follow therefore that Christ died effectually for all Men because knowing nothing to the contrary every Man may be bound particularly to believe for himself but not for all besides 't is not well argued to say every Man must particularly believe he is Elected therefore he must believe all are Elected or he must believe particularly he shall be saved therefore he must believe all shall be saved this Argument from the individual to the species doth not hold The revealed