all worldly things most deare to us whereas other sinnes spoile the wel-being of our selves or others which so long as life lasteth is recoverable Self-murder is horrible And therefore whatsoever is to be thought of the vile quality and of the damnable deserts of murder in generall is to be conceived to be due and much worse to self-murder in speciall For murder is but the genericall or generall matter and not the speciall and formall nature of Self-murder and therefore if it be horrible to murder another man it is much more odious to kill ones selfe For by naturall reason the more that any Genus or generall matter is restrained and actuated by its superadded formes and specificall differences the more it is intended active and powerfull according to the motion of nature ab imperfectioribus ad perfectiora proceeding toward that perfection wherein it intends to termine and end Now the perfection of a vice if I may so speake consists in the highest exorbitancie of it beyond which none can passe and in murder it is certaine that none can goe beyond self-murder as afterward will fully appeare 4. Things are observable in murder In taking away specially a mans naturall life unjustly and murderously foure things are to be considered 1. That death is undeserved First that the effect done or death of a man in depriving him of his life is without due desert on his part at their hands that put him to death 2. Done without lavvfull authority Secondly that the act it selfe whereby that effect is accomplished is unlawfull on his part that doth it in regard of his want of authority and just calling to do that act and if the sufferer have deserved death and the executioner have a lawfull calling to kill him yet if his manner of doing of it bee contrary to the prescript and rules of his calling and to the minde and disposition requisite for such an agent in that act then the same is murder 3. Done wittingly Thirdly it is considerable in murder that the agent therein both knowes not onely that the nature of his action that he doth tendeth to death but also that morally it is an unlawfull act or thing to be done and also doth voluntarily and wittingly intend the doing of that action without regard of the effect or insuing of death thereupon 4. Death intended Fourthly touching murder it is remarkeable that the agent doe not onely voluntarily and wittingly a lethiferous or mortall act but that he doe also intend and desire to effect the death of a man thereby whom justly he cannot kill otherwise if a man should ignorantly or unwillingly in doing of his lawfull calling be a meanes accidentally to take away the life of a man he is not therefore guilty of murder For for such God provided Cities of refuge for their preservation against the avenger of blood Deut. 19.3 4 5. Iosbua 20.3 by the first of these wee see that an innocent suffers death by the second wee see that the Agent or executioner is such an one as ought not to kill him although he were nocent by the third and fourth it appeare that the act is formaliter murderous in regard of the knowledge and intention of the doer thereof Self-murder is most vile murder in transcendent manner So in Self-murder as it is murder an Innocent never deserving of himselfe that himselfe should kill himselfe is slaine the Actor whereof hath no authority nor calling over himselfe so to doe seeing no man can be both superiour and also inferiour to himselfe and for a man to doe an act upon himselfe which he knowes to be both mortall and unlawfull and yet will doe it with purpose and intent to bereave himselfe of his own life it cannot be denyed to be murder in the highest degree and he a murderer that doth it §. 5. How murder is vile The vilenesse of murder in its effects The vilenesse of murder is not onely seene by its contrariety to Gods Law and the heavie censures and punishments thereof and its incompatibility with humane society but also by the effects thereof upon the sufferer 1. It destroves naturall life For first the act of murder utterly so destroyes the naturall life of man upon the departure of his soule from the body that the same is never againe recovered For naturall life depends not onely upon the presence of the soule informing the body but even upon our state of being in this world insomuch that after the resurrection although soule and body shall be againe united yet as then our bodies shall be spirituall bodies a 1 Cor. 15 44. so shall our lives be So then a murderer takes that life away which he can never give nor restore and destroyes that which he can never build up 2. It destroyes mans persen Secondly the act of murder destroyes the person of man which depends upon mans life For neither is the soule alone nor the body alone the person of man but the whole man consisting of soule and body with their properties hypostatically united So that when the soule is in heaven he cannot say but Synechdochically that the person is in heaven Nor when the body is in the grave can we properly say that the person is in the grave For then either a man must be two persons one in heaven and another in the grave which is absurd or else one created person should be in diverse places at once which is impossible Observe vvhere the person is after death If you say where then is the person after death I answer it is not in actuall being but potentiall in its constitutive principles of soule and body that are to be joyned together at the day of judgment And therefore it is that the soules separate from the bodies thinke not nor worke in that manner as they did organically in the body whereupon the Psalmist saies of Princes that when they die their thoughts perish b Psal 146.4 and therefore neither remember they in that estate things past nor are capable of present under those species and notions as they did here in the body So then he that murders a man destroies a person although his distinct natures doe remaine Thirdly a murderer is injurious to God not onely in breaking his Law but also in destroying his Image which is not properly in the body or in the soule apart but in the whole person of man consisting of both soule and body with their properties personally united man was created in Gods Image now the soule alone or body alone is not the man but both united as is said so it is apparent that wrong is done to heaven and earth by a murderer §. 6. Of the originall of murder Murder whenee 1. From our selves We are to consider whence it comes that man doth monstrously First fall upon his owne kinde to destroy it and then upon himselfe Of murder in
datur regressus but when a man hath killed himselfe he cannot make himselfe alive againe that hee may amend the errors of his course and therefore expedient it is for him to keepe his life as long as hee can when hee hath it 11. It crosses a mans last arme Eleventhly no man is to doe that which may crosse his last aeyme and end which is his salvation but for a man to kill himselfe crosses him in this end and deprives him of attaining the same because thereby he termines and finishes his life with and in an act of most damnable sin and also deprives himselfe of all meanes of reformation and salvation in time to come 12. Self-murder is condemned by similies Twelfthly self murder is condemned by Macrobius and Picolomineus under similies as a servant may not kill himselfe because he is not sui juris his owne 1. So we being Gods servants not only as they say by creation and subordination in place and duty but also by covenant and redemption we may not kill our selves 2. No man may dispose as hee list of other mens goods although he bee usis fructuarius of them for a time having the propertie of them for his profitable use with reservation and preservation of the substance of them we are such and therefore have not such soveraigne and absolute right and authority over our selves that we may kill our selves seeing we are bound as Gods tenants to the upholding and reparations of our selves as much as we can 3. A man committed to prison by lawfull and just authority although unjustly may not make an escape by breaking of ward to prevent punishment because thereby he condemnes and makes himselfe a transgressor and worthy of punishment neither are we to rid our selves out of this life of troubles into which God hath put us untill he shall againe himselfe call us out and free us as Paul and Silas would not come out of prison untill the Magistrates brought them out that had put them in a Act. 16.37 39 4. Plato sayes that as wee may not kill another mans servant in regard that thereby we wrong his Master and as Souldiers may not forsake their stations and places without order from their Commander b Injussa imperatoris deserere stationem so may no man kill himselfe seeing thereby he wrongs God that is his Master and forsakes the place and condition that God his Commander hath set him in there to serve him as a Souldier in this world during his good pleasure a 1 Tim. 1.18 August de C.D. lib. 1. c. 20. Augustine sayes that as he is a false witnesse as well and rather more that wittingly deposes salsely against himselfe so he that kills himselfe is a murderer as much and more then if he killed another man 5. Parricide as to kill Wife Husband or children is odious but self-murder is worse because it is neerest a mans selfe and most against the rule 13. It is the grossest murder Thirteenthly wee are specially bound to shun the most grossa and worst facts and sinnes for that if we do them wee are most inexcusable and culpable and justly damned beeause they are most against conscience they being most within the light of mans understanding whereby the conscience being convinced it inexcusably condemnes the doers of them which also are most within the power of man to resist and against which he hath most helps and therefore the doing of them imports more wilfulnesse than frailty or want of power in those that do the same But self-murder is a sinne of this kind because it is the grossast and most odious sort of murder that can be and therefore most to be shunned 14. It makes a bad exchange Fourteenthly we are advisedly to make no exchange that may be for the worse but a man by killing himselfe makes an exchange for the worse because hee gives his life in exchange for death or at the best for freedome from worldly troubles discontentment which is a price farre above the worth of the purchase and God never allowed of this kinde of truckage nor appointed self-murder to be the means of any good but thereby men cast themselves into greater misery and destruction than otherwise they should ever have beene subject to 15. It puts man into a bad estate to die in Fifteenthly every man should strive to be in such an estate of favour with God and to bee found of him so doing when he dies as may be allowable before God and most comfortable to a mans selfe Blessed is that servant whom his Lord when hee commeth shall finde so doing a Math. 24.46 But a self-murderer in his act of killing of himself can neither have any comfort that hee is in the estate of Gods favour nor that his act is allowable before him whose law thereby hee transgresses with a high hand concluding his last gaspe with an act of horrible sinne having his soule in the passing thereof out of his body filled with disordered passions and perturbations of discontent griefe hatred feare diverted upon unlawfull objects and acts and filled with horror and environed with devils and so by self-murder the soule is most diverted from God and infected when the same should be most neerely converted to God and bee best fitted and perfited for him at death that by the hands of the blessed Angels it may be caryed into heaven and eternall happinesse 16. Man hath not authority to kil himselfe Sixteenthly a man is to do no more than hee hath lawfull right and power to do lest he make himselfe a transgressor but mans power over himselfe is not supreame but as a usu-fructuarie he hath dominium utile profitable dominion of himselfe being bound by God his highest Lord not to commit waste upon himselfe Comparison As mans dominion over the earth is not supreame for the Lord is King the earth may be glad of it but onely to take the profit of it and not to destroy it the creatures he may kill for to enjoy a better use of them But the best use that a man can have of himselfe is by his life and not by his death and therefore he is to avoid self-murder because it deprives a man of that use of himselfe for which God hath given a man to himselfe Comparison As the wife hath not power of her owne body to dispose thereof as she list in regard of that interest and proprietie that her husband hath over her so cannot man do with himselfe what he pleases in regard that we are the members of Christ his body and spouse a Ephes 5.23 24 and therefore are subject to him The object of mans will Man is Lord of his naturall and morall actions because they are the subjects of his will and therefore he is culpable and punishable if they be not well ordered and so to the doing only of that
be used by the tempted privatly and publickly with others against the temptations to self-murder with the grounds of hope of comfortable successe to prevaile against them Page 322 § 4. Of the course that others without or against the wil of the tempted are to use to save him against the temptations and danger of self-murder Page 324 And lastly the conclusion shewing the great benefit of recovery from the temptations and danger of self-murder by the use of the former course Page 326 LIFES PRESERVATIVE AGAINST SELF-KILLING CHAP. 1. The generall description of Self-murder §. 1. Concerning life and death Life and death things of great importance and much to be regarded are not rightly cared for LIfe and Death are two things of the greatest importance in this world both in respect of what they are and whereto they tend that is their Essence and the great consequences that depend upon them and yet there is nothing wherof many men are more regardlesse than of their lives how wretchedly they spend and end them and of their Deaths how desperately they incurre and contract them casting themselves into the danger of it by the hands of others or of themselves although the sinnes in which they die can never afterwards be recovered or eternall destruction be avoided And therefore considering the dangerous and damnable practise of divers persons desperately destroying their owne lives and murdering themselves with so great prejudice to the Honour of God and his truth imbraced amongst us and with so much hurt to themselves and others I have adventured to treat more largely of the point of self-murder than yet I have seene the same done by others Touching which I will first describe in generall what it is §. 2. Self-murder described What it is Self-murder is the voluntary destroying of a mans owne life by himselfe or his owne meanes and procurement 1. In which description we are for the better understanding of it to consider First the object of self-murder and that is the life of man 2. Secondly the act it selfe which is the voluntary taking away of life or unjustly destroying of it which makes it to be murder 3. Thirdly the efficient cause or meanes of the destruction of mans life and that in this case is a mans owne selfe by his owne procurement which specifies the act and makes it to be properly self-murder §. 3. Self-murder is knowne by life Life In explicating these in order I will begin at life as first in nature and more auspicable which is the object of self-murder For self-murder being death and death being onely a privation it cannot be knowne what it is but by the knowledge of life which is its contrarie for no privation can be defined in regard of its want of entitie in it selfe but by its opposite habit as no man that knows not in some measure what light is can know what darknesse is Evill cleaves to good And self-murder being in it selfe evill it cannot be but in and about that thing which of it selfe is good 1. For evill cleaves and adheres to good for two reasons first that it may subsist which extra subjectum bonum without the subject of good cannot be for evill is like to the disease called the woolfe which maintains it self by eating feeding upon the body wherein it is For as non datur summum malum nec datur merum malum per se existens There is nothing absolutely evill neither is there a meere evill subsisting by it selfe but in that which is good 2. Secondly evill adheres to that which is good that it may convert and turne the good subject wherein it is into the quality of it selfe so making it nought and destroying it as loaven that sowreth the whole lump wherein it is the nature of all evill is ever active and destructive of that good that entertaines it or that it is exercised about it being as the worm that destroyes the tree wherein it breeds and harbours Observe All things are subject in this world to contraric passions From whence we may observe that as all created substances are mutable so are they capable of and subject unto contrary passions and qualities in this world and by how much the more excellent any good thing in this world is so much the worse is the contrary evill that attends upon and corrupts it and therefore the better that any created thing is on earth the more danger it is in and needs the greater care and indeavour to be had about it to preserve it against its opposite evill so life being of the nature and number of the best things it is in danger of the worst evils and therefore is with the greater care and circumspection to be watched over for its preservation CHAP. 2. Of the kindes of the life of man THat we may know what life is because there be divers kinds of it which it is that in self murder is destroyed by death we are to consider there are two kinds of the life of man Kinds of life naturall and spirituall the first is naturall the second is spirituall according as he consists of two natures and is an inhabitant of two worlds being made of heaven and earth to inhabit both there is no creature in the world that consists of such various different composition as man nor is indowed with such multiplicity of vitall operations or such variety of properties and qualities fitted for diversity of actions of so many kindes and thereupon is subject to so many and opposite motions and temptations Observ Mans care must be of two lives From the divers kindes of mans life we may observe that mans care must not bee as the brute beasts to live according to the instinct of nature but that he may live by a supernaturall principle and divine direction a spirituall life even here in this naturall life as he expects to arrive and attaine to a more excellent and heavenly end of advancement than other earthly creatures do or shall and there is a taske of more and greater porformances required to be done by him than from any other creature on earth CHAP. 3. Of naturall life in generall §. 1. of divers sorts of life Kindes of naturall life FOr our better understanding of naturall life wee are generally to consider that according to the distinction of earthly living creatures there be three kindes of naturall lives 1. Of vegetation First that which is called the life of vegetation which is the life of trees plants corne and the like whereby they grow and encrease both in their severall kindes and in their individuals 2. Life of sense Secondly the life of sense whereby irrationall and sensitive creatures do besides their life of vegetation common with plants live inlived with sense and motion Now these two kindes of lives considered specifically in the aforesaid severall kindes of creatures fall not under the
consideration of nor are subject to self-murder because the law against murder is not given to them who are not properly capable of the same by meanes of their want of reason neither are they subject to this fact and sin of self-murder which by instinct of nature they abhorre and doe alwaies naturally indeavour their owne preservation 3. Rationall life The third kinde of naturall life is that which is called rationall or of reasonable creatures which is proper to men whereby they live besides the life of vegetation and sense common with other earthly living creatures according to reason or in a rationall manner both for the essentiall forme of their natures whereby they are called rationall creatures and also for their thoughts and actions which for their originall principle whence they flow and for the rule whereby they are ordered are reasonable morall and more divine in all their motions than are other earthly creatures if the same be not perverted by some other exorbitant principles or accidents In and under this rationall life of man both the other lives are comprehended as things inferior and subordinate are contained in their superiour and summary head Note Mans perfection The perfections of all other earthly creatures are in man together with or comprehended in that which is proper to himselfe whereby he transcends them all §. 2. Man only is subject to self-murder Notwithstanding that man indowed with understanding hath the greatest helps against self-murder and hath the greatest reason of all worldly creatures to preserve his life it being so excellent above theirs yet he onely of them all is subject to this fault and mischiefe of self-murder The greatnesse of the sin of self-murder And as all the aforesaid three kinds of lives are comprehended for faculty and vertue in mans reasonable life flowing from his reasonable soule as we see in the ceasing of them all in man at once upon the departure of his soule from the body Note so the killing destroying of mans life is absolutely farre greater than the destroying of the lives of all other earthly creatures because both the lives of them all for kinds and also mans own proper life that farre excells them all in the destruction of mans life are destroyed and also all other creatures were made for man for the comfort of whose life all their lives do serve §. 3. How naturall life is knowne by man in whom it is Touching the knowledge of the naturall life of man a reasonable living creature apprehends the same both by sense and understanding This life is knowne 1. by sense by sense a reasonable creature not onely descernes that it lives but also feeles this life by the effects of it to be a quickning power of inlivening the body inwardly and disposing and inabling it to action outwardly 2. By understanding By understanding a man knowes that this life is an act of the spirit or soule in the body of man or a quickning vertue of it in a continued fluxe by the personall union of the soule and body together §. 4. The soules double act of life in man The soules act of life in man This act of the soule in its union with the body is twofold 1. Making the subiect to live First that which respects the bodie it self or rather mans person in that worke or lively energie which we may in some respect call opus ad intra or a reflexe worke of man upon himselfe upon the personall union of the soule and bodie whereby he becomes a living soule Gen. 2.7 for extension in all his parts and for intensiox in fulnesse of lively power for his subsisting and growth to his appointed period and for use of all his organs and faculties for their proper function being thereby also able to discerne take notice and judge of himselfe his state and actions For not the soule only nor the body onely is to be properly said to live after their union together but the person consisting both of soule and body doth live this life which is not the life of either of the natures or parts of man by themselves considered Man lives or dies personally considered but the life of the person of man consisting of both natures personally united And therefore when one kills a man we say not properly that he hath onely killed an earthly body but we say properly that he hath killed such a person as consists of a soule and a body and therefore it is said in Scripture that there were so many soules slaine a Joshua 10.28 not that the immortall spirit is in it selfe subject to such a death or can be slaine but in regard of its Acting and working in its personall union with the bodie whereby both of them live personally together that life which is the life of the person which is destroyed and ceases upon death which is further apparent by this Reason because the murder of a man is so hainous a crime in regard of the destruction of the Image of God in man which is not onely in the body or onely in the soule but is in the whole person of man so long as the same lives 2 Making the subject to worke The second lively act of the soule in this union with the body personally considered is that whereby it makes the body organically fitly disposed and active to those duties which we call opera ad extra works about objects not it selfe which works are the common outward workes of the person consisting of those two natures and not of either of them apart Observe Upon life depends the subsisting and working of the person Whereupon wee may observe that upon this life depends both the subsisting of the person of man in its being and also all its actions naturall civill and morall so that he that kills a man destroyes his person and abolishes all his personall actions and activity whereby he might be serviceable and usefull to God to himselfe to the Church or Commonwealth And yet we see no thing more passionately and rashly enterprised than killing of men than the which nothing should be more deliberately and upon weightier causes done it being no lesser matter than to dissolve heaven and earth by destruction of a person consisting of an heavenly spirit and of an earthly body to destroy the noblest naturall life and to deprive God and the world of the most glorious and profitable workes Such a thing is this naturall life of man generally considered CHAP. 4. Of mans naturall life more specially §. 1. Wherein the naturall life of man consists Mans naturall life is fraile Phil. 1.22 expounded MAns naturall life consists as in part wee have heard in the Act of the soule united personally with the body by meanes of the animall naturall and vitall spirits which the Apostle calls living in the flesh Philip. 1.22 which is to live neither to the flesh to
wee are cast into the frame and mould of the Gospell untill Christ be formed in us a Gal. 4.19 so that in this worke the spirit is the principall efficient cause as our Saviour tells us Iohn 6.63 it is the spirit that quickneth §. 7. How the Gospell workes life 1. Hovv the Gospell workes not So then the Gospell works not this life in us in a Physicall or naturall manner as having vertue naturally inherent in the words to produce such an effect in those that heare it 1. Not physically For then men should be converted and regenerated in a naturall and not in a divine manner and also then the Gospell would worke alike upon all men that heare it that were alike disposed and did not ponere obicem or lay a barre of their owne to hinder it except God should restraine the naturall power of it in working but so the conversion of man must be within the power of his owne act and God could not be justified in his withholding grace The word is a supernturall instrument of salvation But the conversion of a sinner is wrought by a greater vertue than can naturally and subjectively be in the words and sentences of the Gospell for the word of God is not instrumentum physicum a naturall instrument but a morall or rather metaphysicall instrument of effecting such a supernaturall worke according to the will of the first agent 2. Not Ethically Neither in an Ethicall manner doth the Gospell worke this spirituall life in us onely by morall perswasion as morall Philosophers and Rhetoricians doe affect and draw their hearers by reasons and exhortations stirring up a latent power inherent in us and inclining our wills by rationall motives and objects to be made alive then must it depend upon us that wee are saved and be from a power of our owne exuscitated by the word 2. How God works by the Gospell according to his own will But God works by his word as a more puissant and independent agent that inintends and remits his power in working according to his owne will by the meanes and uses meanes not as necessary for him but that he can doe as much without them in regard that the effect is his owne and man the passive subject of it Mans will is the subject of conversion It is the will of a naturall man that is most dead to God-ward and most averse from him and therefore it is the will that is chiefly to be wrought upon and made alive in conversion whereupon all depends but wee know that nothing can make it selfe alive when it is dead but he that is the fountaine of life the Son of God Rom 1.4 Note Of the heart The illumination of the understanding which is common to the wicked and the godly is presupposed as requisite to fit a man for conversion and therefore in the worke of regeneration the scripture takes notice specially of the heart insomuch that the old Testament uses no other word to expresse the understanding because in Divinity no knowledge without intertainement in the heart and without conformity of the will and practise to the truth is saving action being the end of Theological knowledge in this life words of knowledge in Scripture commonly comprehend affections in them §. 8. Why God uses meanes Although that God could if he pleased convey grace into a sinfull man by immediate influxe or inspiration from which wee cannot utterly exclude all seeing the worke of grace depends absolutely neither upon the nature of the meanes nor upon the abilities and will of the converted and elected whereof many are not by that method of meanes capable but upon God who workes according to the good pleasure of his will yet he uses meanes not to help himselfe as if otherwise he could not doe the worke but in respect of us that are naturall men indowed with senses as well as reason hee appoints meanes Reasons of using of means 1. that by our using thereof we may be active about the worke of our owne salvation and may attaine the same by a way and course within the compasse of our owne power and indeavours as the reward and blessing of God upon our labours to our commendation before God and men 2. Againe meanes are appointed by God for our obtaining of salvation that by using of them our saith in Gods promises and power may be tried in expecting thereby so glorious effects farre above their nature and also our obedience may be proved by doing what God commands us to doe within the reach of our power to get life albeit it doe transcend reason how by this way it can be had as appeares by Naaman the Syrian 2 King 5.13 14. 3. And finally God appoints the use of meanes for our comfort that by our constant conscionable using of the same we may be assured of grace and life as certainly as we are of the use of the meanes appointed to get and by which God hath promised to give it by the working of his holy Spirit §. 9. How the Spirits power is manifested and seene Vse To finde the Spirits power by the meanes in us Now further from the consideration of the excellency of this spirituall life to be wrought in us by meanes our use should be to end eavour to find and feele both the Spirits quickning vertue of regeneration by the meanes powerfully working upon and in us and also to discerne this spirituall life to be in our selves seeing our comfort lyes herein and that the one can never bee without the other Manifest in 4. degrees of operation The vertue of the Spirit in us by the meanes manifests it selfe in foure degrees of operation not to speake of illumination First both in making us see and feele with griefe of heart our owne wretchednesse and sinfull deadnesse 1. Against sinne and also by turning us from our sins and ungodly courses with detestation of them and with resolution and constant indeavours against them it being the worke of the spirit to lust against the slesh because they are contrary the one to the other a Gal 5.17 c. both in nature and effects In which respect the Prophet Hosea tells us that if we will live we must turne Hosea 6.1 for our sinfull courses are the waies of death therefore we should labour to be and find our selves mortified to sinne with some kinde not onely of voluntary indisposition but also of strong antipathie and detestation of committing the same as formerly wee were prone and affected with delight to doe and that at the presence of sinne in its habit or act we may with indignation be displeased and sad having no joy nor contentment in that condition For the motions of sin entertained do worke in our members to bring forth fruit unto death b Rom. 7.5 Which by a contrary life of grace are mortified and subdued but I confesse that
old man There is a lawfull and commanded killing of our selves For understanding whereof it is to be observed that every one of us hath in him a self-old-man of sinfulnesse lively and powerfull in manifold lusts and wicked actions of which the Apostle tells us Rom. 7.5 That when we were in the flesh the motions of sinnes which were by the Law did worke in our members to bring forth fruit unto death when the Commandement came sinne revived the living whereof doth kill us In this case even for our owne preservation it is necessary and lawfull for us to kill our self-old-man with the lusts thereof as the Apostle commands us to mortifie our memhers that the body of sinne might be destroyed we should put off the old man Ephes 4.22 Col. 3.9 so that we should become dead to trespasses and sinnes wherein formerly we were dead The kinds of it This killing of our selves is metaphoricall and morall by which death we are made alive For if we doe not thus die wee cannot live as the sowne corne must first die before it can live and grow Comparison Hovv done 1. In Christ This our self-old-man is slaine by three severall acts or blowes First the same after a sort was crucified in Christ Rom. 6.6 That the body of sinne might be destroyed although not the individuall persons but the common nature of mankind aslumed by Christ did suffer death in him 2. By change of our estate in Justification Secondly our self-old-man is killed by change of our state upon our grafting into Christ by faith so that we are in that respect said to be dead to the Law by the body of Christ Rom. 7.4.6 and that we are dead to the Law that we might live unto God Gal. 2.19 this is done at one entire act or blow in the act of our justification so by this death freeing us from him that hath the power of death even the devill 3. By the Spirit Thirdly our self-old-man and the lusts thereof are killed as touching the dominion and corruption of them by the Spirit of God in the act of sanctification touching which the Apostle tells us Rom. 8.13 That if we through the Spirit doe mortifie the deeds of the body which is the worke of our whole life we shall live How we are actors in it This killing of our self-old-man should be done by our selves being the executioners of it by assistance of divine power from God in three severall acts 1. First by our act of savingly beleeving in Christ whereby our state is changed from death to life 2. Secondly by our constant indeavours to be conformed to Gods Image and will by daily renovation 3. Thirdly by our continuall warfare against our corruptions and temptations touching which the Apostle saies that the flesh lusteth against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh Gal. 5.17 they are so contrary the one to the other that there is no living for either of them but by the death of its opposite neither is there any peace untill one of them be dead Observe The use of our Christian armour Wee should therefore ever use our Christian armour and imploy our utmost indeavours to destroy our self-old-man against which if we doe turne the edge of our spirituall sword to slaughter it with the lusts thereof we shall be diverted not onely from unjustly killing of others but much more from killing our selves in any other respect but when we as Saul doe spare the life of this Agag or self-old-man it causes us by a just hand of God to fall upon our selves to take away that life of our owne which we should both spare and cherish §. 4. Diverse observations from the generall consideration of self-murder Observ 1. Man is in greatest danger From the consideration of self-murder we may observe First that man stands in more danger of destruction than any other creature for no creature is subject to attempts against the life of it by it selfe but onely man who is invironed also with mortall dangers from without but specially of his owne procurement by opening the way for others to invade and hurt him by breaches and armes of his owne making 2. God vvants not executioners of his justice Secondly wee here see that God wants not meanes of execution of his judgements upon man seeing he can leave a man to fall upon himselfe and be his owne executioner Vse Feare God The use hereof is to make us afraid to offend God or to provoke him to be our enemie or to live unreconciled with him destitute of the assurance of his peace and favour Distrust our selves Neither are we over-confidently to trust our selves with our selves of whom wee have so little assurance for security and safety from self-mischiefe and therefore we are carefully to cleave to God for preservation praying him not to give us up to our selves who are mercilesly cruell to our selves when wee fall into our owne hands for the neerer that any are linked and knit together in condition or affection the more desperately opposite they are when they fall into division because of the want of a fit medium or mediatour of reconciliation betweene a mans selfe and himselfe what meane is there either to keepe himselfe from himselfe or to reconcile himselfe to himselfe when himselfe is fallen out into murdercus resolutions against himselfe CHAP. 8. Of spirituall self-murder in speciall §. 1. All perishing soules are self-murdered Soule-murder OF self-murder thus generally defined there are two kinds or specialls to wit spirituall and bodily Although some may be said to be murderers of other mens soules by their scandalous practises or by their corrupt doctrine or by depriving them of the meanes of their salvation and the like yet no soule can perish without the intervening and concurring of the assistance and meanes of him that owes that soule whereby it comes to paffe that all soules that miscarry are in some sort Is also self-murder self-murdered For although it is against nature to desire to bee absolutely miserable and that he should in his last existing in his last principles bee undone or wretched albeit he may affect the dissolution of his personall subsisting upon intention and hope by his change to bee bettered in his future estate subsisting in his remaining principles yet he may wittingly and willingly doe that which may be the destruction of his soule although he doth not intend that effect and so commit not direct but indirect self-soule-murder §. 2. Spirituall self-murder defined What spirituall self-murder is Now that wee may know what it is Spirituall self-murder is the killing of a mans soule or spirituall life by himselfe or his owne meanes That which distinguishes this from bodily self-murder is the subject killed which is the soule or spiritual life not that the soule essextially considered or its naturall life of being and
acting in it selfe can bee destroyed by man whereby it ever lives to be capable of eternall misery or glory For such a death it cannot die without being reduced into nothing and quite extinguished in regard of the spirituall simplicity thereof void of composition and the nature of it is an act but this death is onely of that superadded supernaturall beatificall life of grace and glory whereof a man may misse and come short and be guilty of the losse thereof although he were never personally possessed of it as those that are said 1 Tim. 1.19 to have put away faith and a good conscience §. 3. Of soul-murder by deprivation of life Tvvo degrees of it 1. Of soul-murder there are two degrees the first is deprivation of spirituall life which is poena damni or punishment of losse 2. the second is subjection to misery in positive manner which is called the second death and is poena sensus or punishment of sensible feeling because man was indowed at first as it were habitually with a spirituall life in gracious indowments and communion with God and now by mans owne fault that habit of spirituall life being destroyed it may be truly said that hee himselfe hath killed it in regard that he was radically and implicitely in Adam when he first destroyed and lost the same §. 4. Of mans deficiency to be saved Meanes of mans deprivation of 〈…〉 all life his deficiency The principall meanes of mans deprivation of this spirituall life is his neglect of meanes when himselfe is the immediate cause and procurer thereof by his owne deficiency and that two waies 1. In Adaw First as he is originally confidered in Adam who was the roote of mankind and whose first sinne and effects thereof are equally reckoned to bee all mens in common who then were in him and so thus radically in Adam all men have deprived themselves of spirituall life by their owne act of neglect of eating of the tree of life and of others permitted for their use and by their eating of the forbidden tree of knowledge of good and evill 2. By himselfe personally considered Secondly as he is personally considered by himselfe a man may deprive himselfe of spirituall life and so in that respect be a self-murderer of his soule which is done by his voluntary omission of duties upon which life is promised every man is dead in trespasses and sins a Ephes 2. and thereby subject to death but the Lord hath abundantly provided us of meanes to advance us to life which if we do wilfully neglect or contemne to use there being no other safety of necessiry wee must perish and bee guilty of our owne destruction as were the Iewes by rejecting of the Gospell Act. 28.25 Foure-fold omission Of this degree of self-soule-murder or deprivdtion of life a man may bee guilty by a foure-fold omission of things that ought to be done by him for his salvation 1. Neglect of the outward meanes First when a man willfully neglects the conscionable and diligent use of the outward ordinances of Gods word worship and Sacraments the blessed meanes of life appointed by God without which no man of discretion in the visible Church can be saved the Apostle Rom. 10.13 limits salvation to calling upon the name of the Lord which cannot be without hearing of the word of God This neglect of spirituall meanes is either by not going where they may be had and sincerely used or if hee may have them his neglect may be in not frequenting and carefully using them in conscionable manner nor submitting himselfe to bee wrought upon that he may be moulded in the forme and frame of the word a Rom. 6.17 But doth come to the meanes either with a prejudicate opinion against the truth or with a resolution to continue still in his unregenerated estate and in his sinfull courses as those that with their mouth shewed much love but their hearts went after their covetousnesse Ezek. 33.31 and as those that Ieremie speakes of Ier. 18.12 who said Wee will walke after our owne devices and wee will every one doe the imagination of his evill heart such persons are as guilty of their owne damnation as a man is of self-murder of his body that out of stubbornnesse or sullennesse will not eate but in the midst of plenty starve himselfe to death §. 5. Of mans neglect of the power of the meanes 2. The contempt of the power of the meanes The second omission procuting deprivation of spirituall life and so consequently effecting self-soule-murder in that degree is a mans contempt and regardlesnesse of the spirituall efficacy and power of the meanes for inward change of his spirituall and morall state and condition and for power of enabling him to all holy practise of life and conversation whereby he may be borne againe and be made a new creature a Iob. 3.3 which is a thing most necessary and availeable for salvation Gal. 6.15 Such men are either utterly carelesse and regardlesse of grace and spirituall life from their undervaluing of the worth of it or from their esteeming of the same to be needlesse Or else they harden their hearts as did Pharaoh and set themselves against the power of the Word that it may neither enter into their hearts nor make any divine change in their states or lives as if they had made a league with hell and death What be those Contemners Such are ever learning but never attaine to saving knowledge they are ever sowing but never reape they are ever in the hand of the workeman but are never framed anew they are fairely featured by some outward profession but are without life and sound grace the reason hereof is because such an one rests upon and pleases himselfe in his owne sufficiency using the meanes without consideration of the end why God gave the meanes and why we are couse them and without looking and seeking to God for a blessing upon the meanes that they may be effectuall to his salvation §. 6. Of mans defect in obedience 3. Want of obediencs The third omission whereby a man excludes himselfe from this spiritnall life and so consequently subjects himselfe to spirituall death is wilfull want of obedience to Gods word and that in a double respect 1 Evangelicall First in regard of the Gospell when he doth not savingly beleeve in Christ as the Gospell requires but remaines in privative unbeliefe whereby a man is destitute or deprived of Christ our life and Saviour For we are frequently said to live by faith b Habak 2.4 Heb. 10.38 Rom. 1.17 and therefore without it we are dead and so such as do not savingly beleeve and repent which are the acts of Evangelicall obedience doe deprive themselves of salvation through their owne default which is evident because they are willingly impenitent unbeleevers resisting the motions of the word and Spirit not sorrowing for nor striving against
subjected to manifold sufferings here in this life and is hindered from that ease and advancement that freed out of the body it might have Answer to 1. But touching the first it should make us the more tender over it chary to use it and to consider that by self-murderously destroying our bodies wee do contaminate and defile our soules whereby wee make them far more vile than any carion can be seeing sinne is the onely excrement and morall defilement for which God detests and abhorres men as loathsome Ansvver to 2. For answer to the second it is to be observed that by self-murder of the body a man is so farre from bettering of himselfe that thereby he deprives himselfe of happinesse and subjects himselfe to that wofull misety which otherwise living he might escape and therefore our bodies and naturall lives are to be respected and cherished not onely for their worth but also for their use for which God hath given them to us So that we are not to force a divorce of those things that God hath coupled so neere together nor to thrust away or reject that which God requires us not then and that way to lay downe CHAP. 10. Of the kindes of bodily self-murder §. 1. Direct and indirect self-murder defined 1. Direct self-murder THe kindes of bodily self-murder are two Direct and Indirect Self-murder is not such a generall as in the Schooles is called Genus univocum so predicated of them both as equally communicating it self to both those species or specialls under it but is genus analogum ab uno or commune genus 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for that the same doth properly and primarily belong to direct self-murder Direct bodily self-murder is the killing of a mans bodie or naturall life by himself or his owne meanes advisedly wittingly and willingly intending and effecting his owne death 2. Indirect self-murder Indirect self-murder of the body is when a man advisedly wittingly and willingly intends and doth that which he knowes may be of it self the meanes of the destruction of his naturall life Although he doth not purposely intend to kill himself thereby Or it is the killing of a mans owne body by unlawfull either morall or naturall meanes of his owne using without intending of his death thereby §. 2. Of the differences between direct and indirect self-murder 1. They differ in their ends The proper differences between direct and indirect self-murderers consists specially in three things First in the ends directly and immediately intended by the self-murderers of both kindes in their severall acts the end that is immediately intended in direct self-murder is death it self of their bodies that kill themselves although not for it self but in respect of some benefit conceited to be had thereby which is their ultimate end whereunto death is in the murderers intention subordinate as for a man to kill himself that he may be out of trouble The end that in indirect self-murder is immediately aimed at is the attainment of some good really or apparent in or by the meanes that an indirect self-murderer doth use without any respect or expectation of death thereupon ensuing as in surfeiting by drunkennesse or gluttony 2. In their meanes Secondly they differ in the meanes that are used by them for accomplishing those ends in direct self-murder the meanes abused to that effect and end are not proper of themselves nor by Gods appointment but are perverted by him that kills himself thereby as knives or the like for God never appointed meanes for any man lawfully to use for effecting that which he would never have men to doe a direct self-murderer uses not the meanes for any pleasure he hath in them but for the consequent effects that he intends by them In indirect self-murder the meanes and course used are such as doe properly kill in the end if that they bee persisted in as drunkennesse and the like although they have in them a shew of present good which gives the users of them a kinde of delight and contentment in them whereof they shall be disappointed when in the end they shall in stead thereof finde death which they least expected and most abhorred and would resist the same if it were inferred or offered to them by others 3. In the good aimed at Thirdly direct and indirect self-murder doe differ in the good that is aimed at by them and in the time wherein they looke to enjoy it A direct self-murderer doth fancy his good intended by him in his act of self-murder not to be in the meanes that he uses to kill himself but in or by death in his freedome from evill or enjoying of good the time of his reaping of which benefit he conceives to be after that he is dead and gone An indirect self-murderer conceits the good that hee aymes at by his course to bee and rest in the very meanes themselves that he uses therein expecting the present enjoyment thereof before and not after his death the cogitations and inflicting whereof hee abhorres although he doe prosecute with eager delight the courses that doe hasten and bring his death §. 3. How indirect self-murder is greater in some respects than direct Which of them is the greater sinne It is demanded whether direct or indirect self-murder be the greater sinne Answer In some respects Indirect self-murder I answer if we consider the freenesse of the will with lesse inforcement and with more delight prosecuting those deadly courses of indirect self-murder there can be in that respect lesse said to excuse it than for direct self-murder 1. For freenesse of willing An indirect self-murderer is at last in respect of the mortall meanes he uses and persists in untill the effect be accomplished as sure of death which he abhorres as a direct self-murderer is of the same that he desires and indeavours for and longs after 2. Obstinatenesse Againe an indirect self-murderer is more hardly diverted from his unlawfull dangerous course than at first a direct self-murderer Because this man may be sooner convinced of the vilenesse of his purposed fact in excuse whereof he hath so little to say and also the danger of it is more apparent and ghastfull to the mind that advisedly in cold blood considers of it The other is taken up with looking upon the present contentment in the meanes that he uses not considering death and danger thereupon attending and insuing but self-deceives himselfe with excuses and colourable pretenses and so doth wink as it were that he may not see the blow of death that he is giving himselfe with his owne hands Of direct self murder the cause or occasion is ordinarily from discontentment and sorrow but of Indirect self murder the cause commonly is pleasure and delight Delores serre sacilius est quam â—â—voluptatibus absunere Arist 3 Eth. c. 12. of these two motives pleasure is the strongest and their motion
most violent and indivertible that are led by it because it moves with nature and not against it and hath will in men more propense that way which by griefe is rather forced than seconded §. 4. How absolutly direct self-murder is the greatest Direct self-murder is the greater sinne and why Notwithstanding Direct self-murder is the farre more grievous sin in three respects 1. End intended First in respect of the direct intention of the will and of its immediate object of murder of a mans selfe whereby it partakes more properly and fully of the nature of self-murder than indirect self-murder doth For what is under a common Genus or generall directly partakes more of the nature of that Genus than that which is under it but by reduction or indirectly So then although direct and indirect self-murder be both self-murder Etiamsiaequè non tamen aequaliter yet they are not equall self-murder but the former is the greater 2. The consequences of their acts Secondly for the consequences of the acts of them both direct self-murder brings more certaine and sudden inevitable destruction than indirect which in this latter may better be prevented by having time of repentance than it can be in the former and death in this is an accidentall effect besides the intention of the agent and nature of the meanes which in the former is perse and of the nature of the action so purposely ordered to that end 3. Company of other sinnes Thirdly direct self-murder hath more and greater sinnes complicated in it than indirect hath both by extension in kindes and number against God others and our selves and also for intension in degrees by reason of circumstances of the party doing the same against the light and reluctancie of nature with direct intention to kill himselfe §. 5. Of the degrees of sinne and how to escape the greatest and its end Vses The uses of this doctrine of the distinction of self-murder into direct and indirect and of the differences betweene them are specially two 1. Degrees of sin First to teach us that there are differences and degrees in the same kindes of sinnes some being more grievous than other some So that although we be not guilty of sinne in the same degree yet we may be in the same kinde as appeares by the Iewes convicted in their consciences of uncleannesse although they were not taken in the act as the Woman was Iohn 8.9 How to escape great sins And therefore to escape falling into the highest degrees of sinne wee should be carefull to avoide and to be free of the same generall kindes of sinne both as they are unformed and confused in originall corruption as in their seminall Chaos and also as they are formed in their distinct habits so improperly called because after the manner of habits they either are in the place of true habits or unite themselves in and with them that they may both brooke one common name and so we should labour to be cleare of sinne both habitually and actually Observe Wee should not bee conceited and blesse our selves so much because we are not fallen into the fowlest degrees of sinne as we should be humble and penitently confesse our guiltinesse in the kindes thereof the difference herein being betweene us and others but in magis and minus in greater and lesser where the least degree makes way and disposes us for the greatest and makes us liable to the same kinde of punishment although not to the same measure of it The same end severall vvaies attained The second use serves to instruct us that men doe come to the same dismall ends as Saul and others did by severall courses being guilty of their owne deaths in diverse manners as men may come into the same prison at and by severall doores Comparison For although a man can draw a right or straight line betwixt the same points but one way yet he may draw crooked lines many waies and they all be terminated in the same points Therefore as a man would beware of any evill end so should he shunne all the courses that may lead or bring him to it For it is no benefit to a man in misery to consider how and by what sinfull course hee came thither so long as he is in that woefull state Wee see many men come and end their daies together upon the same Gallowes but by severall courses and differing crimes some for pettie treason some for wilfull murder some for burglary some for pettie larceny and yet to him that is hanged for the lesser offence it is small ease and comfort because he suffers not for a greater so long as it is for any that he dies CHAP. II. Of Indirect self-murder of the body §. 1. Why Indirect self-murder is first treated of Indirect self-murder is handled first ALthough that by logicall method I should treat first of Direct self-murder because that which is directly under a Genus or generall head should bee handled before that which is but indirectly under it for the neerenesse thereof unto the same and for the light that it may afford for the better understanding of the other yet for all that I will heere begin with indirect self-murder for three causes Reasons 1. Imitation of nature First because I will herein imitate nature which proceeds frō things lesse perfect tothings more perfect because perfectiō is her ultimate end Indirect self-murder is lesse perfect self-murder than direct self-murder because the Genus of self-murder agrees more properly and primarily to direct self-murder than to indirect 2. Precedency in execution Secondly indirect self-murder is ordinarily both the way and the cause of direct self-murder and therefore may be fitly treated of first the rather because direct self-murder never goeth before indirect but this goeth often before and without that 3. End intended Thirdly because my intention is to insist specially upon direct self-murder and by meanes of it onely doe I speake of indirect self-murder therefore I purpose first to dispatch it as an accessary to the other which I principally intend as my last end in this treatise therewithall to conclude the same §. 2. Of Indirect self-murder by omission How indirect self-murder is performed Having shewed what indirect self-murder is and how it is differenced from direct self-murder I will now declare how men doe fall into the same which is done two waies First by omission Secondly by commission 1. By omission By omission a man may indirectly murder himselfe being the deficient cause of the preservation of his life two waies either in a physicall naturall manner or in a morall meritorious course §. 3. Of indirect self-murder by omission physically wrought Wayes how 1. Physically diverse waies First physically and after a naturall manner a man may indirectly murder himselfe divers waies as 1. Neglect of food First a man may indirectly murder himselfe by
unlawfull Ergo. To be more carefull to provide for the safety of their worldly goods than of their soules is wretchednesse and desperate folly which all those doe which by unlawfull meanes would preserve their estates Such mutes are so farre from being worthy of having their estates preserved by this course that therefore they should the rather lose them and themselves be the more cruelly and ignominiously entreated for being guilty of two horrible crimes first that whereof they are indited and for which they refuse to answer to be legally tryed the second is their contumacious rejecting of all just and legall courses of tryall and active obedient subjection to authority requiring their submission Touching their second and third motives of standing mute with respect onely to the matter of their worldly credit the same is meere folly because by this course they doe farre more discredit and make themselves infamous in regard that ipso facto they make themselves guilty of a double crime both of that whereof they are indited and also of contumacy against authority and law and the death of pressing that they suffer is the just reward of their obstinate mutenesse besides all their other demerits it is chiefly the morall manner of dying that is comfortable and honourable wherein such mutes are wanting Their fourth motive which is from feare proud impaciencie of suffering uniustly or inimically by others in the course of ordinary legall triall is most vaine for why should we wrong our selves that we may escape being wronged or insulted over by others this was the practise of Saul to kill himself that he might prevent being insulted over and mocked by the uncircumcised Philistims the matter of the greatest triumph to our enemies over us is to give them a victory by our owne hands both over our bodies and mindes as such mutes doe to their eternall destruction Such mutes are not onely guilty of their owne deaths but also by that course they subiect themselves to everlasting damnation both in soule and body both because they die impenitently and wilfully in a sinfull way of their owne obstinate procurement and choise and also doe cast away their soules in departing this world in uncharitable manner without either confession or clearing of themselves in lawfull manner of the crimes for which they are indited and arraigned and so perish as outlaws against both God and humane authority whose fact is equivalent to direct self-murder by wittingly and willingly doing that unlawfull act which they know will inevitably subiect them to death without hope of escape §. 6. About malefactors arraigned for crimes how they are to answer to the question Guilty or not guilty Question 2. A second question considerable about the foresaid subject is touching malefactors indited and arraigned at the barre of Iustice before a lawfull magistrate to be tryed upon their lives for some capitall crimes that they have done as petty treason burglary murder or the like touching their lives whether when they hold up their hands at the barre and are in legall manner asked the question whether they be guilty or not guilty of such a fact whereof they are indited and which indeed they themselves know they have done whether I say are they bound in conscience and may they answer affirmatively that they are guilty without any danger of being indirectly guilty of self-murder Answer They that confesse themselves to be guilty are indirect self-murderers For resolution of this question I answer that when a man is accused of such a capitall crime and is therefore brought to a legall triall whereunto he is subjected for finding or not finding him to be guilty of that fact upon the verdict of which enquiry Law and Authority is satisfied and determines their proceeding with the party for him upon that question whether he be guilty or not guilty before the triall to confesse himselfe to be guilty so by his owne onely witnesse and verdict casting himselfe upon the losse of his life hee may in a strict construction and in some sort be accompted culpable of indirect self-murder Exception Except it be in case to save innocents from suffering wrongfully for his fault or that it be for greater good of the State of the Church or of his owne Soule when the fact can no otherwise be knowne or proved against him but by his owne confession Touching a voluntary and full confession after conviction and condemnation I know none that is not of opinion that it is necessary for the salvation of the malefactors soule although his body do perish as Achan did Ioshua 7.20 That such an affirmative answer of guilty to that question makes the answerer I say in some sort indirectly guilty of self-murder although they are not the worst men morally considered that doe so I will make it plaine Reasons 1. First a malefactor by such an affirmative answer anticipates and deprives himselfe of that legall triall whereby it were possible for him to have escaped and not to have beene found guilty of that capitall fact for which he is indited and therefore by dying upon his owne onely confession witnesse and verdict which hee needed not to have done he is guilty of indirect self-murder Now for a man that hath in danger of life lawfull choise of two waies the one most certainely mortall the other more doubtfully deadly if hee choose and perish by the former he is indirectly a self murderer because he willingly rejected the latter and safer whereby he might have lived thus it is in this case of answering guilty before the triall 2. Secondly it is a naturall axiome that no man is bound to betray himself Nemo tenetur prodere seipsum quisque tenetur defendere seipsum Vnusquisque praesupponitur esse bonus donec probetur esse malus and that every one is tied to defend himselfe A Traytour saies D. Kellet Miscel li. 1. p. 164. may without sin plead not guilty that is not proved guilty at your barre where every one is presupposed to be good untill he is proved to be bad I am not guilty so farre that I am bound to accuse my selfe and this is saies hee the allowed generall acceptation of that usance For further manifestation hereof it is to be considered that the question and answer is made in a humane civill Court wherein hee is demanded not whether in Conscience but whether in Law he be guilty whereby he is bound to confesse no more against his life than can be legally proved against him specially seeing he answers not upon oath or adjuration which binds the examinate or prisoner at the barre in conscience upon obligation of religion to depose the truth concerning himselfe knowne onely to that deponent and according to whose owne testimony hee is to be acquited or condemned Of answering upon oath about crimes concerning a mans selfe but this being most unreasonable to make a man witnesse Jurie and Judge in his owne cause
Case 4. The fourth Case is of those that trade by Sea who often runne into mortall and desperate adventures out of eagernesse to make their voyages either putting to Sea in such weather and seasons as is like to endanger all or putting for the Port upon desperate hazards of miscarying by stormes sands or rocks or running presumptuously into the danger of Pyrates or other mortall ingagement by Sea either through wilfull negligence or through self confidence of skill or power more than they have so tempting God Observe The true occasion of which miscariages of men by Sea is often given by Merchants upon the Land who praise and respect men for fortunate and valiant according to the successe careat successibus opto Quisquisab eventu facta probanda putat and the event of their courses without respect to the due rules of the managing the same which makes many a man come short home by adventuring to please their Merchants contrary to the rules of art and wisdome Note In this case I would advise men rather to looke to do what they may warrantably justifie and may therein have peace in their consciences although the successe answer not their desire than to endeavour contrary to wisdome and art to please their owners and Merchants by such courses of desperate and unwarrantable adventures as if they or their charge miscary therein will over-cloud them with just blame ignominie and will bereave them of that comfort in their consciences which should cheere and uphold them under their crosses a course of accidentall good successe and a course of direct ill successe are not so to be compared together that for the former a man should venture upon the latter with the guilt of self-murder to be imputed to him if therein he doe perish Concerning Duells Case 5. The fifth Case of desperate adventure is of those that undertake Duells or doe give or accept challenges of single combats upon their owne private motion for private revenge or for supposed maintenance of impeached honour who if they perish in the attempt or by meanes of the conslict are guilty of more than indirect self-murder because that course so unwarrantably and needlefly undertaken is commonly where the wronged may have better redresse with lesse adventure of life Duellers what they b. and those Duellers or single combattants doe by such challenges shew themselves to be lawlesse contemners of authority whose allowance they have not as they ought for such a triall by battle to make the same just but by usurpation they make themselves Kings in contempt and prejudice of lawfull authority in erecting a tribunall for Iustice of their owne making in their own case where themselves alone are Parties Iurie Witnesse Iudge and Sheriffe whereas it is the prerogative of Kings to make warre and peace and independently to execute justice under God It also argueth in them both great folly and impotency of minde so lightly to adventure or give away their lives a price so far exceeding the worth of the purchase that they contend for and which they may have decided farre better without any such desperate danger and also it proclaimes their pusillanimity and weaknesse in that they cannot beare crosses and injuries And finally it makes their cause apparently unjust when they passe by or neglect a peaceable triall by equall justice and reason and doe put it to be decided by bodily strength and chance of warre in a course more beseeming beasts than men It seemes that such men doe account themselves and their lives little worth and that they are weary of living who so rashly expose the same by thrasonicall provocations and darings to be taken away and destroyed in such a manner wherein having abandoned the command of reason they become beasts and becomming slaves to their vilest passions of fury madnesse cruelty and the like whereby they are overcome who would in that course overcome others Duellers degenerate into incarnate devills And while they thus contend to gain or maintaine reputation of Honour and Valour by this most dishonourable and base brutish course of impetuous self-revenge by Duells they justly lose that for which they contend and otherwise might have had Concerning desperate attempts upon daring and wagering Case 6. The sixt case of desperate hazzard and adventure whereby men may indirectly be self-murderers 1. About daring is in the point of provocation by others for proofe of their courage and valour challenging them to dare to attempt the effecting of some deadly enterprise beyond all warrantable calling or lawfull meanes safely and lawfully to accomplish the same as for a man needlesly to conflict with a Lyon to run over rocks to provoke or assault Adversaries too potent for him to resist or offend with safety of his life or upon such daring to doe some capitall act or mischiefe whereby he is most like to perish and not thereby without just imputation to himselfe of guiltinesse of his owne death in regard of the unlawfulnesse of that his course wherein hee cannot warrantably looke for any blessing or protection from God neither doe such unjustifiable daring-practises argue any true fortitude and valour but onely bewraie temerarious audaciousnesse which is in excesse contrary to fortitude because true valour is seene in couragiously undertaking and accomplishing dangerous performances upon advised reason by lawfull courses to just and necessary ends but rash audaciousnesse in daring to doe unwarrantable attempts is manifest by the unreasonablenesse and unnecessarinesse thereof undertaken upon unadvised passion and foole-hardy presumption with arrogancy in the manner of accomplishing and folly in the end of it A truly valorous man manifests his fortitude by his unconquerablenesse upon any provocation of darring to doe any thing that is not fit and warrantable for him to undertake upon good grounds and reason that if he bee crossed or perish in atchieving it hee may have honour and peace and no way be guilty of his owne death So that although daring audaciousnesse exceeds true fortitude in unwarrantably adventuring beyond it yet it comes short of valorous fortitude in the grounds and manner of enterprising and of consequent effects and honour of it A valorous man is his owne master in disposing of himselfe and his actions about dangerous enterprises according to his owne minde sound reason and advised resolution Whereas an audacious man is but as a servant to others by whose will and daring provocations he orders himself and his actions as they list at their pleasure and for their service that he must needs doe whatsoever desperate attempts they will dare him to doe even to the perill of the losse of his life without any lawfull reason and calling 2. Wagering To this case also belongs desperate undertakings with danger of life upon wagers as for a man either upon a naked contract for a certaine summe or upon assumpsit of ten for one or the like to be paid to him when he
marvell that one man endeavours the ruine and destruction of another when we see how desperately and eagerly they doe the same against themselves For who can expect better respect and usage from any man than he gives to himselfe or is in him to performe Some difference there is in the affection and intention of betternesse to himselfe but his reall performances are to himselfe worst Thus having declared what indirect self-murder is and how it is diversly procured and committed now I will shew certaine exempt cases which although in the materiality of the facts they differ not from indirect self-murder yet in the formality of their acting are much discrepant §. 15. Of certaine exempt Cases Exempt cases Three cases there are wherein men are warrantably to expose their bodies to the apparent danger of death without perill of self-murder or just blame of guiltinesse of their owne deaths 1. By calling First when a man hath a lawfull calling generall or particular which without danger of losse of his life in discharging thereof he cannot execute then is he to adventure his life that he may doe his duty which otherwise cannot be performed committing himselfe to Gods protection and disposall As Peter did in comming downe out of the Ship to walke upon the Sea when Christ commanded him a Mat. 14.29 and as Sampson in execution of his office of Iudge against his enemies pulled downe the house whereby hee with them did perish b Judges 16. Pacchtarius ad Januarium In fine obitus sui sub Martyrii passione David a Mauden in praeceptum 6. discurs decim and is commended among the faithfull Heb. 11.32 whom Bacchiarius an ancient Author calls a Martyr of which David a Mauden gives the reason quia illae quae ad Martyrium requiruntur conditiones in ipso reperiuntur the things requisite for Martyrdome were found in him being a person reconciled to God and dying for Gods glory and in defence of the truth and by a warrantable calling of divine instinct and supernaturall ability And we see that when God did call Moses to come up into the mount there to die he obeyed and went willingly and wittingly unto his owne death Deut. 34. By this rule souldiers and servants taking wages or otherwise bound to fight for their lives or at the command of their superiours are bound as Mauden sayes ex justitia by the law of justice to expose their lives to death in discharge of their duty to obey and protect their superiours Reasons of incouragement The reasons of incouragement to undertake such mortall adventures are specially two First our knowledge and assurance that God whom herein wee are to respect and obey originally or secondarily commanding us will either protect us in our wayes and undertakings or will so dispose of us as shall be best for us with comfort and honour in and after our death Knowledge in which respect both Plato pro Socrate and also Aristotle affirme that honest a mors turpi vitae est praeferenda An honourable death is to be preferred before a shamefull life 2. Benefit of death Secondly the feare of the losse of our lives should bee no remora or hinderance to our dutifull performances because our deaths in this manner may be the medium or meanes to the end that is better than our lives Wee see that if a thing destinated to a certaine end doe at any time crosse or hinder the attaining of that end in that respect it is to be deemed evill and to be rejected as our Saviour commands that if our eye cause us to offend then pull it out and in like case to cut off our hand or foote Mat. 5.30 which is done by mortification and grace making them as uselesse to any scandalous courses as if they were cut off in semblable manner as men throw away their armour to save their lives by slight in a hot pursuit of their enemies and as men at Sea throw their goods into the water to save themselves §. 16. A particular question about souldiers flying resolved Abâ—ut souldiers a case of conscience Question A question may be here moved whether it be in conscience lawfull for any souldier out of feare of death upon his owne apprehensions to flee and runne away to save his life before a signall command or example bee given him by his Commander so to doe Answer Souldiers are to stand I answer for the fact it is true nothing is more frequently done in warre than so to runne away in disorderly manner because feare bereaves men of their use and command of reason and also self-love makes every man more carefull of his owne particular than of the publike things that are neerest doe most affect extremities of dangers convert all a mans thoughts to thinke how then to preserve himselfe But for the morall lawfulnesse of that course it appeares not to me yea rather I conceive that although present death stood ready before them to swallow them up they are not to turne their backs to leave their stations and runne away without due crder signall or example of their Commanders Because such desertion of their Commanders and fellowes in distresse is a betraying of them into their enemies hands Againe the greatest destruction and ruine of an Army comes by disorderly flight wherein every man is objected to the enemies execution Whereas by resolution and couragious resisting to death many victories are gotten with the preservation of the body of an Army Finally if the publike doe miscary our particular cannot bee safe but those that escape may in regard of their after-miseries wish that they had fallen in the army by the sword of their enemies We are bound to attribute so much to the wisdome and valour of our Commanders that they will not cast away the lives of their men but upon apparent possibilities of victory or preservation by opposition although we see it not Helps so to do 1. Faith The helps to enable us to this high courage of performing of duty are two First Faith both for the goodnesse of our estate in Christ to Godward wherby we may be assured of everlasting life and glory when we die and also for the lawfulnesse of our calling and imployment in that service wherein death attaches us that we may as comfortably there end our dayes as if we dyed upon our beds being perswaded of our future happy condition and that our death in that manner is more usefull to men and more acceptable to God than our lives 2. Resolution Secondly undaunted resolution to be obedient in doing our duties considering that obedience is better than sacrifice although in doing thereof wee doe perish For for to enjoy vertue and union with God which confists in obedience to Gods will is better than life without them §. 17. The second exempt case about venturing of life which is upon urgent necessity The second Case Necessity in three
Coate let him have thy Cloake also and whosoever shall compell thee to goe a mile goe with him twaine a Mat. 5.38 39 40.41 For no man is so farre bound to contend for justice in his owne particular but that he may upon good reasons forbeare or dispense with his owne right whereby he incurres onely an evill of damage and not of sin 3. Of yeelding to suffer Thirdly this yeelding is not a making of the innocent sufferer to be guilty nor of the nocent wrong doer to be just or more obstinately to persist in his unjust courses no more than the not applying of medicines to the disease called No li me tangere doth foment it when the medling with it would inrage it and make it worse This course of yeelding to suffer wrongs makes way and place for passive obedience and for God the great and righteous Iudge of the world to do justice even upon the highest and to worke his owne glorious works with redresse of all such evills as neither by right nor might can bee by man reformed in which course of suffering wrong wee have the Martyrs for examples to follow §. 21. Touching the voluntary appearance of Felons at liberty upon baile to free their baile Third question Touching the voluntary appearing of Fellons to receive justice A third question reducible to this point is whether a man that for some capitall crime is under bond of his owne promise or upon some penall summe of money or upon bond of a friend for him of body for body for his personall appearing at the Assizes ought thereupon to appeare when he certainely foresees that there he shall be cast and die as put the case it be for battery or wounding of a man mortally who dies thereupon after such bond given Answer When they ought I answer if the bond for his appearance bee his owne promise hee ought in conscience to appeare because Gods Word and Law bindes us to keepe our promises if the same be not to doe sin although the same may bee damageable to us a Psal 15. but if so bee that his bond for appearance be a penall summe of money onely by sureties then all that a man hath he will give for his life so that in this case I see not that he is bound in conscience to appeare where he foresees his owne death when the Magistrate hath accepted a penall summe for fiduciary caution in stead of his personall imprisonment or other assurance for his appearance and so may shift himselfe for his safety to some place as a City of refuge to keep himselfe from the hands of the avenger of blood When againe they ought But if hee bee at liberty upon his friends bond of body for body for appearance then ought hee in conscience to appeare although hee certainely foresee that there hee shall die that he may free his friend by his meanès and for his sake so ingaged both in respect of the Law of friendship and in regard of the cause that is not his friends but his owne that by his meanes and for him an innocent man do not perish which were his grievous sinne §. 22. What a guilty person ought to do to free the innocent Fourth question Concerning an innocent mans suffering by misprision or error in stead of the nocent and what the guilty ought in that case to doe A fourth question that belongeth to this point may be this if a burglary or a murder be committed and an innocent man be attached arraigned found guilty and upon presumptions be condemned for it to die the true fellon not being knowne as it fell out where a certaine young man a Suiter to a Maid was taken cast and condemned to death and suffered for the murder and death of that maide with whom he was late in company after the rest of the family were in bed and she the next morning found murdered which fact was done by a Villaine that was hid about the house and not by the young man-suiter as the Fellon afterward confessed Whether is not the true actor of such a fact bound in conscience to discover himselfe and confesse that hee may save the life of an innocent that for his sinne he may not die Answer The nocent ought to discover himselfe I answer that hee is bound in conscience so to doe for otherwise he is guilty both by his fact and silence of the death of such an innocent man so suffering whom he might and ought to rescue now it is certaine that no man is to doe or omit that which by the doing or omission thereof either multiplies or aggravates his sin to his owne worse and eternall condemnation And how againe he is bound not to suffer other men to sinne either by rashnesse or malice in the witnesses or jurie when it is in his power to prevent it by true information as in this case he may yet I thinke he is to do it with as great circumspection for safety of his owne life as he can being sure that he leave not the truth undiscovered nor suffer the innocent to perish through his feare or neglect §. 23. About a mans voluntary revealing to the Magistrate his own secret capitall crimes Fift question A fift question hitherto belonging to bee resolved is if a man have committed a capitall crime as murder Polygamy or the like which was done so long agoe or so farre off or so secretly that none knowes or will accuse him thereof About secret capitall crimes and is so troubled in conscience about it that upon his private confession to Divines thereof and their counsell and consolations ministred to him he hath no rest nor comfort but in revenge upon himselfe is strongly tempted to destroy himselfe by his owne hands and cannot prevaile against his resolutions of doing it whether then is he to accuse himselfe of the crime and to put himselfe into the hands of Iustice to suffer for it Answer When and how the delinquent is to reveale his crimes that are capitall In this case I think such an one ought so to do both for the easing of his conscience that no otherwise can have rest that thereupon others may be affraid to venture upon sinne with presumption of secrecy when they shall see the force of conscience compelling men to blaze their owne crimes and shame And also for preventing of self-murder by submission to the sword of Iustice and to the mercy of the Magistrate who perhaps will hardly in such a case condemne a man upon his owne inditement and witnesse where there is no other that doth the same and when the act seemes to be unreasonable that any man should seeke his death where none accuseth and if he were in this case condemned it is most like that the supreme Magistrate would save such a one by pardon or replevin for the usefulnesse of his life in time to come for the sword
man than death A blessing may become a judgment Thus the greatest earthly blessing may become in mans sense and opinion a grievous judgement For God can make a man a terror to himself and to all his friends so that in that respect he may brooke the name of Magor Missabib as did Pashur Ier. 20.3 4. when a man leaves God or is left of him who is the blessed object and fountaine of all true contentment and solid comfort Observe The misery of the damned in hell Whereby wee may see in part the miserable state of the damned in hell whose living there is a second death farre exceeding the first in misery there is a death of dissolution and a death of torment the former brings the subject to an end the latter brings the subject of it to all miseries they that are in this latter shall wish for the former and shall not finde it whereby we may in some sort see two things 1. For measure First the measure of hells misery upon a man in it being even as if a man in his perfect strength and senses were struggling and in the very pinch and agonie of the last and fiercest act of death labouring under the unspeakeable horror and unsupportable and untolerable paine of it and in kinde and degree much more as a man in that death of hell shall bee made more capable and spiritually sensible of misery than he is here and whereas here a man can die but by one mortall paine there shall the damned be under all paines and mortall miseries in their extremities to the utmost measure and degree that those damned wretches are capable of with exact spirituall sense and feeling of the same besides their woe for want of that infinite happinesse in heaven whereof they are deprived 2. The durance of v. Secondly wee may see here the everlastingnesse and endlesse continuance of that death in hell which shall be as long as the damned shall have being which shall be ever that they may be capable of suffering to the utmost of their capacity so that their being gives neither ease nor comfort but they shall ever be in the same extremity of death for evermore without any relaxation or abatement which fills them with utter desperation and unexpressible woe Note For they have all that can make any creature miserable viz. in hell they have both life and death by their living there they are capable of and doe suffer the punishment of sensible misery and by that death they have punishment of damage in deprivation of all comfortable good and so whatsoever wee can be in the absence of good and in presence of evill they have the same §. 3. Concerning the wills object and faultinesse Object of the will is good That we may surther understand how a man can will his owne death wee are to observe that the will never chooses to doe a thing sub ratione mali as it is evill but wills a thing that is either in itselfe good or apparently such in our apprehension or else it chooses a thing that in itselfe is evill but is comparatively good in respect of another evill which in our judgement or sense is greater or worser and so no man chooses death for it selfe but in respect of some conceited good imagined to be had by it and not otherwise or to have a lesser evill for a greater by that exchange as Saul who that hee might escape the mocking of the heathen killed himself a 1 Sam. 31.4 so that no man is absolutely willing in the act of self-murder but conditionally because he uses it not for itself but as a meanes for a further end and good The kinds of good Will hath ever good for the object of it but of this good there is a double triplicity First bonum animi corporis fortune Good of the minde of the body and of wealth and preferment Secondly there is Bonum utile jucundum honestum Good profitable pleasant and honest Of these goods the will doth not ever respect bonum honestum or morale vertuous or morall good but often makes choise of profit or pleasure as the greater good before the other and still bonum or good is the object of the will Note From hence it is evident that the error of the will is not all nor ever from the mis-information of the judgement but that the will is in it selfe very fanlty in three respects Wils faultines 1. It obeyes not the sound understanding First in that it doth not ever listen unto nor obey the true and good directions of the understanding but rejects them or inclines against them according to that old saying Video meliora proboque Deteriora sequor I see and approve better things but follow the worser the bounds of the understanding and will are not of equall extent 2. It submns to the affections Secondly the fault of the will is that it submits it selfe to receive information and direction from the affections passions and senses following the same without reasons precedent triall and approbation whereby it inverts the course of nature rebells against its Soveraigne and subjects its selfe to her servants and labours so to enthrall the understanding to the same 3. Corrupted by innated pravity Thridly will is corrupted by innated pravity whereby it is more inclinable to erroneous directions than to true readier to move to vice than to vertue and by meanes of that pravity either inbred in it selfe or acquired by impressions from inferiour faculties and senses it labours to deceive and corrupt the minde and understanding that the same may determine and give direction according to wills owne disposition whereby it comes to passe that the will ever followes the last determination of the practicall understanding and yet is not therefore blamelesse For sinne is vitium suppositi the vice of the person and therefore is in all the parts and faculties of the same especially in the will which is the primus motor the first mover in all practicall actions which are sinfull but as they are voluntary The motions of mans will are very diverse and often contrary Will variable For although will in man is answerable to instinct in irrationall creatures and to naturall inclinations in insensibles yet it moves much more variously both as man is compounded of many more various things whereof every one conferres to his motion naturall and morall according to its nature and also as man and his will is passively affected and wrought upon by motives within and without and as his reason directs and perswades variously according to occasions whereupon it followes Note that man is the most uncertaine and unstable creature in the world most restlesse and tossed as the Sea with tempests and stormes in his will distracting him in his resolutions and performances una eurusque notusque ruunt creberque procellis Affricus as the East the
South and West windes of contrary thoughts making their incursions at once upon him whereby he is sometime driven and cast away upon the deadly rock of direct self-murder with the furious impetuosity of his owne self-perverted judgement will and affections §. 4. Observations from the knowledge of direct self-murder Vses The uses of this knowledge of direct bodily-self-murder what it is are specially three 1. Information or judgement First it serves to informe our understanding in two points 1. Horriblenesse of self-murder Degrees of it First touching the execrable horriblenesse of the fact of this self-murder which is seene in three degrees 1. First in that it is an unjust taking away of the life of a man contrary to Gods Commandement Gen. 9.5 and to the sixt Commandement of the Law which makes it to be murder 2. Secondly in that it is the so taking away of a mans owne life which is most neere and deare to him which makes the fact to be self-murder and is directly opposite to the Law of nature 3. Thirdly in that it is a fact done by a mans selfe upon himselfe advisedly wittingly and willingly which makes it to be direct self-murder intended to the highest degree of that kinde being complicated with and compounded of many pernicious ingredients raising it to the highest pitch of poysonfull disposition The greatnesse of self-murder which both aggravates the sinne of self-murder to a transcendency of wretched badnesse and also shewes the horrible malice and cunning of Satan that was a murderer from the beginning a Ioh. 8.44 in indeavouring mans destruction by mans selfe in such a damnable manner and degree of finning as the devill himselfe without mans owne help cannot possibly effect both to the destruction of Gods Image in him and also to the certaine damnation of the self murderers soule which by that fact the devill labours to gaine to himselfe to make man partner with him in his torments and out of malice against God to disgraoe and deface his Image 2. Mans perversnesse The second point wherein the former doctrine serves to informe our understanding is concerning the perversnesse of the nature of man and the excessive exorbitancy of his courses whereby he is subject and breakes out to kill himselfe which practise of self-murder all other creatures doe abhorre by the instinct of nature and so we see that the most noble creatures are obnoxious and subject to commit the greatest errors by their abuse of their most eminent parts wher oby they doe abase and deject themselves into a miserable estate as farre beneath other creatures by violating the Law of nature as ever God had advanced them above them as is apparent by the fall of the devils for the grievousnesse of sin is to be measured not onely by the matter and act of it but also by the quality of the doers of it and by the circumstances of doing thereof Vse 2. How to behave our selves to our selves The second use is to admonish us that we are not onely to be carefull how we behave our selves in things concerning God and our neighbours but also how we behave our selves towards our selves and in our owne affaires and goods because our love to our selves is the rule of our love to our neighbours whom we are to love as our selves a Levit. 19.18 and to whom wee are to doe as we would be done to by them b Mat. 7.12 and therefore it behooves the rule to bee straight otherwise all things measured by it must be crooked and so from him that carelesly failes towards himselfe no right performances can be done by him to any other qui sibi ne quam cui bonus to whom can he be good that is nought to himselfe Vse 3. A man is to feare and watch himself And therefore seeing wee often prove our owne greatest enemies and doe as much evill to our selves as the devill himselfe can desire and more than he by himselfe or by any other meanes is able to effect or bring to passe upon us it is requisite and needfull that wee bee affraid of our selves and that we neither trust our selves nor trust to ourselves but that we be carefull and doe watch over ourselves neither giving way to our owne opinions nor purposes before wee doe examine them and finde them conformable to the truth all things are to be suspected that come from an Enemy Timeo Danaos dona ferentes and a man hath no such dangerous enemie to himselfe as himself because of his neerenesse to himselfe of his advantages of prevailing against himselfe and of his deceitfull cunning to beguile himselfe so exercising all hostilitie and mischiefe upon himself under pretence and colour of love and friendship to himselfe he is self-betrayed and self-destroyed Vse 3. To discerne things that differ The third use of the former doctrine of self-murder is that thereby wee may discriminate and know diverse cases that are very like this self-murder and yet properly are not direct self-murder nor the doers thereof thereby perishing self-murderers the which exempt cases are of foure sorts §. 5. Of certaine exempt cases Exempt cases 1. Men without reason are not self-murderers The first is when a man destitute of understanding or of the use of reason kills himselfe as a child without discretion a naturall foole a mad man in his mad fits one in his sleepe or in such sits or sicknesse as is accompanied with a delirium or phrensey as in a calenture the same is not in them properly self-murder Reasons why because understanding in them is desicient or passively depraved and not actively and wilfully done by themselves so that they cannot judge morally nor sometimes naturally of their owne actions neither are able rightly to direct them in a state of that impotency of understanding neither is such an act in such persons to be deemed willing or an act of the will so long as reason is wanting without which it is not possible for a mans will rationally to move And therefore in such prancks and mad acts the will whereby they are done is but brutus impetus abrute motion or violence which motion is not from the understanding so much as from accidents making a man not to be himselfe and such a man in doing such an act whereby he kills himselfe intends not the same upon knowledge to the end to kill himselfe and therefore neither in the Courts of earth nor heaven are such persons condemned as self murderers for killing themselves because they are not properly so much agents as sufferers both in the act doing and also in the effect or death thereupon ensuing Case 2. About self-killing ignorantly The second exempt case herein is when a man kills himselfe ignorantly not knowing what he doth or not knowing the mortall nature of the meanes whereby he doth it As he that eates poyson the nature
whereof he knowes not or when a man doth kill himselfe out of a rash precipitancy and sudden unpremeditate pang and fit of forcible passion or temptation tempestuously raised by others making violent impressions upon him suppressing reason and captivating the will to doe that which otherwise hee abhorres and for which in the Court of heaven he is not properly a direct self-murderer because such a fact before God is but a kinde of chance-medly when it proceeds not out of advised judgement and will but that the doer thereof is therein quoad principium motus for the originall of his motion in that act more passive than active Comparison as a Ship that may be overset in a storme and as persons possessed by uncleane spirits that by their meanes did cast themselves into the fire and water a Marke 9.22 wherein if they had perished they had not beene self-murderers when they were not in their owne power nor was it an act of their owne free judgement and will Case 3. Killing by mischance The third case is when a man kills himselfe by mischance or misadventure in his doing of an act of lawfull imployment without any intent to take away his owne life As a man in his attempt to save another out of the fire or water is by his act drowned or burnt to death himselfe or if a man be killed by the breaking of a peece of his owne shooting off at another marke or the like This is an act of God in his speciall providence taking away the life of a man Exod. 21.13 and is not an act of self-murder because the actors end and intention is not to kill himselfe but to doe a lawfull duty neither doth that act of his in regard of that mortall effect of it proceed from his judgement and will but to him is meerely casuall and contrary to his expectation and desire and so in that respect he is meerely passive and so formaliter and in truth not a self-murderer Case 4. Self-killing in discharge of ones calling The fourth exempt case is when a man in discharge of his calling doth wittingly and willingly such an act whereby hee knowes hee must die as did Samson of whom Augustine sayes that Spiritus latenter hoc jusserat the spirit did secretly command it in this case such an one is not a direct self-murderer because hee intends not primarily his owne death but the discharge of his necessary duty otherwise not feasable And this death is not from an act of his owne meere judgement and will but from Gods in obedience whereunto he layes downe his life Case 5. About phrenticks The fift exempt case is of phrentick persons of whom when it shall happen any to kill himselfe in his fit of phrensie he cannot justly be said to be a direct self-murderer nor yet an indirect self-murderer where his phrensie is not contracted by his own fault because of his defect of the use of his understanding in his act of self-killing whereof then he knowes not the morall nature neither properly can he be said to be a voluntary agent therein because then he hath not a will determined by any act of the practicall understanding but doth it only by a bruit passion or unreasonable internall impulsion equivalent to inforcement from negation or their faultlesse defect of power of sufficient opposition which is evident by that which they are habitually to the contrary manifested when they have any Lucide intervalls or when they were or are in their sound mindes alwayes abhorring such a fact Of this see more Cap. 15. § 22. and Cap. 18. § 2. CHAP. 13. Of direct self-murderers §. 1. Practise and habit gives denomination One act of self-murder gives denomination to those that do it and why A Self-murderer hath denomination from his fact of self-murder whereby it staines him with an ill and odious name although a man properly is not to be named from one single act but from an habituall disposition and continued practise yet here one act gives the name because it proceeds from that which is in a man by way of habit and is an act that in regard of the extinguishment of its subject can be done but once by one body but if they should live againe in the same state yet upon the same motives and disposition would againe and againe doe the same as we see by the practise of those that after restraint or disappointment of effecting their purpose therein doe not cease still to attempt the same untill it be done and therefore such a fact is equivalent to a constant practise if any body be impatient and ashamed of the imputation of the name of any notorious vice then should he be most carefull to avoide the thing in respect whereof the same is due unto him Observe He that hath the principall must have the appurtenances the name of any crime must goe with the thing to which it belongs the odious repute of the name shewes the vilenesse of the vice which is farre more to be abhorred than the nickname of or from it Comparison But men are commonly like witlesse children more affraid of shadowes than substance as children are gastered with mentioning of Goblins and bugheares so many men are startled with the disgracefull names of vice imputed unto them who are not at all affraid of the vices which they entertaine and for which the names of the same are due to them who doe deserve to brooke the name of the master whom they serve and of the trade which they practise Why should any man serve such a master or exercise such a trade whereof he is ashamed and would not brooke their names That some men doe murder themselves is apparent §. 2. How it is by Scripture apparent that many men doe murder themselves That many do murder and destroy themselves by their acting of that horrible unnaturall fact and sin upon their owne bodies is apparent three wayes 1. By the Scriptures First by the Scriptures of the old and new Testament in the old Testament we reade of Saul and of his armour-bearer that they killed themselves 1 Sam. 31. Of Abimelech that did the same by his owne command Iudges 9.54 Also of Ahitophel that he hanged himselfe 2 Sam. 17.23 Of Zimri that hee burnt himselfe to death 1 King 16.18 In the new Testament we reade of Iudas that though he were one of Christs disciples hanged himselfe Mat. 27.5 Which intimates That the Scripture witnesseth so much it intimates to us three things 1. The certainty of such facts First it evidences to us the certainty of such facts because the Scripture is infallibly true aswell in matter of history as of doctrine It records them not for imitation but for condemnation which is plaine if wee consider how ungratious the persons were that did it the manner of the Scriptures propounding and relating of the same with dislike of it and
furniture and power of hell and what their owne wit can invent or abuse for that end Observ It is hard to do good easie to doe evill From hence wee may observe First that whereas when wee are to do good wee are hardly drawne to it and do excuse our backwardnesse by pretence of disability and want of meanes and by alledging of impediments and letts as Moses did a Exod. 4.10 13. the sluggard pretends that a Lion is in the way b Prov. 26.13 But when wee are about to do evill we make no such objections but finde abundance of helps with opportunities and great frowardnesse and readinesse to doe the same Causes 1. Mans disposition The causes hereof are specially two First internall in mans owne will and disposition far more prone to evill than to good where will and inclination are to a thing they will find meanes Causes 2. The devill and evils easinesse Secondly there is an externall cause hereof to witt the devill who doth powerfully instigate and help to do mischiefe according to mens tempers and the outward occasion and the work of doing evill is farre more easie than of doing good because of the entitie that is in goodnesse and the non entity that is in evill goodnesse is an effect of power and evill is more properly an effect of impotency to pull downe is more easie than to build up to erre than to go aright Observe 2. Self-murderers are guilty of abuse of Gods Creatures Secondly we may here observe that he that is a self-murderer is guilty not onely of the vile act of self-murder but also of the abuse of Gods good creatures and of his owne abilities in perverting the same to that unnaturall end contrary to Gods ordination whereby they are in this respect subject to vanity c Rom. 8.20 so that a self-murderer erects a counterwork of creation and use of things against God while he gives being to self-murder against both nature and religion so setting up his owne works of evill against Gods that are good and disposing of Gods good works to his owne vile ends contrary to Gods will and ordination Note whereby it is apparent that such wicked persons are factiously-rebellious against God and disturbers of the peace and tranquillity of all the frame of nature and grace contrary to the Lawes and ordinances of God Sinne is in the world as pestilentiall humors in the body which disorder and indanger all where they are §. 2. Of the application of the meanes of self-killing 2. Application For application of the aforesaid meanes to the wicked act of self-murder there are three things considerable In it 3. things considerable 1. Predestination and determination of the end First the self-murderers premeditation and determination of the end which is his owne death to be effected by himselfe so setting limits to his owne daies as if he were his owne absolute Master and that he were so unhappy that his life were worse than death which death all other creatures do abhorre and that he were so desperate and forlorne for want of present mercy or future hope and that he were so forsaken of all that he can finde none to rid him out of his life and misery but that he must kill himselfe so hastening himselfe by a most wofull exchange into a farre greater misery by so doing than ever it was possible for him to suffer in this world by living although that therein he should live for ever under the most exquisite torments that here he can be capable of 2. Election of meanes The second thing considerable in the application of the meanes to the acting of self-murder is the election and choise of the particular meanes to effect the same all self-murderers do not choose to die by the same meanes For then the way of so dying would be unvariably one and the same in them all Wherein a self-murderer observes three things In election of meanes to kill himselfe a self-murderer observes specially three things 1. Such as best agree with his temper First he is carefull to make choise of such meanes as do best fit and agree with his naturall temper and sexe and are least formidable and terrible to his fancie or sense in the execution such as are familiar to him by daily use or such as in his judgement or sense are least horrible or painfull as Cleopatra that chose to kill her selfe by Aspes making her die sleeping 2. Such as be readiest Secondly a self-murderer makes choise of such meanes to kill himselfe that are readiest at hand and easiest for him to have according to his sexe calling occasions or imployment 3. Most certaine to effect death Thirdly he chooses to use those meanes which in his opinion are most certaine to effect that end most easily speedily and unperceivedly from the knowledge of others that he may not be crost of his designe and aime nor be long in paine Observe 1. It is easie to do evill Here we may observe that there is variety and choise of meanes to doe any one evill or sinne which shewes with what facility and ease we may sinne and perish and with what difficulty and hardnesse wee may doe good and bee saved which cannot bee done by such multiplicity of meanes and waies a right line can bee drawne but one way and the truth is simple and not manifold 2. The folly and madnesse of self-murderers Secondly here appeares the folly and madnesse of those that are so circumspect and carefull about choise of the meanes whereby they would die and are so regardlesse of the morall maner how they die and of their consequent condition that will follow upon such a death Observe every grosse and notorious sin is ever committed with a spice of madnesse accompanying the same because it is done against the dictat of sound reason and of true religion and therefore such men are so frequently in the Proverbs called fooles in respect not onely of the thing they doe but also in regard both of the reasons of their proceedings and also of the fruit and end of their courses touching whom it may be said that they have sowne the wind and they shall reap the whirle winde as sayes the Prophet a Hosea 8.7 §. 3. Of the method of self-murderers The method and maner of execution of self-murder The method and manner that a self-murderer observes in execution of self-murder consists in three branches 1. He observes opportunities First he watches and hunts after all opportunities and affects retired solitarinesse that he may without hinderance kill himselfe 2. Secrecy Secondly hee affects secrecie and expedition to accomplish that vile act upon performing whereof all his indeavours and power being bent and being deserted and left of God and his good Angels and the devill instigating and helping him and all meanes fitly concurring for that execution the
and the people of Israel were gathered together for to doe whatsoever thy hand and thy Counsell determined before to be done a Acts 4.27 28. Will any man therefore say that neither Iudas nor any of those were blameable for betraying and putting our blessed Saviour so cruelly and spitefully to death If Gods decrees were sufficient to warrant men to doe evill then either there could bee no sinne in the world whatsoever men doe or else God must be the author of sinne and the onely sinner which is a thing most blasphemous to thinke 2. Ignorance The second reason that manifests the error of those who thinke themselves warranted to doe whatsoever God hath decreed is both their ignorance of what God hath decreed which for the most part he keepes so seeret that it is not certainly known but by the event and effect what it is and in this case the Scripture sayes that the secret things belong unto the Lord our God Deut. 29.29 but those things which are revealed belong unto us and to our children for ever that we may do all the words of this Law Gods secret will is the rule of his owne actions And also it is their ignorance of the use of Gods decree which is properly his owne will whereby and according to which he in wise and in soveraigne manner orders all things according to his owne good pleasure But it is not that which he would have alwayes to bee our will and according to which we should order our wills and practise for which he hath given us his revealed word and law which is to be in all practicall things the measure of our wills and wayes Gods revealed will is the rule of our actions And therefore so long as Gods word forbids self-murder we are not to dare upon pretence of destiny or Gods decree to entertaine thoughts to attempt it Gods secret decrees containe no formall commandements to us what we should doe nor put any reall influxe to incline us to sin nor subject us to compulsory necessity of sinning contrary to our owne wills or to the meanes and Commandements that we have against the same Observe So then it is certaine that our fulfilling of the secret will and decree of God by our wretched courses and the accidentall good that may come to others thereby cannot excuse us from damnation for running a course contrary to the revealed wil of Gods Commandements and to the meanes whereby we are to order our practise in obedience to God No man is saved for fulfilling the will of Gods decree which no man can overthrow It is not in the power of the most wretched and malicious men in the world to crosse but must fulfill the secret decree of God neither is any man commended or saved for fulfilling that decree which no man can disappoint But all men are commended or condemned for those courses and meanes which they use according as the same is commanded or forbidden in the Word whereby the severall decrees of God for mans salvation or destruction are voluntarily accomplished by men themselves Note Mans care should be to live well Mans only care in all estates should be to live well in conformity to Gods revealed will and word not being solicitous so much for our deaths which after a good life can never be ill We serve not such a master as will not be carefull of our good in which regard worthy is that speech of dying S. Ambrose recorded by Paulinus in his life Non ita inter vos vixi ut pudcat me vivere nec timco mori quoniam Dominum benum habenus I have not so lived in the world that I am ashamed to live neither am I affraid to die because wee have a good Lord. Where wee have no commandement we should be passive about our deaths Although that God is active and workes in all things about us and that we are to cooperate with him in all things where hee gives us a commandement to worke yet in those workes of God where wee have no commandement of his to worke with him as in and about our deaths there we are only to be passive Observe Three things we are to observe from this point of deceit of the judgement 1. Men are strong to beleeve errors First we may here see that people that are weakest in faith and most diffident to beleeve Gods word and saving truth upon the credit and authority of God himselfe are often strongest and most consident in beliefe of errors upon any seeming ground as Solomon saith The simple beleeveth every word a Prov. 14.15 The reason hereof is plaine because such persons are overswayed by prejudices and strength of passion so farre that they rather suspect and reject Gods sacred and infallible truth than their owne fancies and Satans suggestions Note When men leave the truth they become both superstitious and vainely credulous They therefore that beleeve God and in God are freed from many errours and much needlesse feare 2. Disobedients to God are forward to obey the devill Secondly we may from hence observe that many persons that are most disobedient to Gods lawes by keeping whereof they might live are most forward to obey Satan and their owne lusts to their owne destruction For a man cannot serve both these contrary masters at once b Mat. 6.24 Such people like well to have God to be their friend but they care not for having him to be their master but would live as they list but when they forsake him they are unhappy in their choise when they can serve none other but to their owne ruine 3. Men to excuse themselves blame God Thirdly from hence we may see that many men are willing to doe evill but are loth to beare the burden of the blame thereof and therefore they turne it upon God and would make him a party with them against himself in breaking of his owne lawes Men that would not have their courses framed by the right rule of Gods truth labour to frame all reason and divinity by their owne crooked fancies and courses whereby they doe as farre as they can deturb and cast downe God from his throne and advance themselves unto the same by their perverting the order established by him and by making themselves gods to live by their owne wills as the supreme rule of all their actions Which shewes to us how needfull it is for us to labour for self-deniall and that wee may resignē our selves wholly to God to bee ordered and disposed wholly by him in all things as he pleases which is the onely meanes of our preservation from sin and damnation §. 6. Of conceited good by self-murder perverting the judgement The fourth ground of error in judgement is conceit of benefit The fourth and last ground of a mistaken understanding which causes or occasions self-murder is both the conceit of good that
that are godly and wise both about what they are to do and also upon what grounds and reasons that they may not be deceived Note But this is remarkable that ever the worse the thing is that is to be done and the weaker the reasons of doing of the same are the lother the doers thereof are to reveale the same lest they should bee crossed of their purpose or shamed for their weaknesse and enterprise so disclosed §. 7. Concerning afflictions upon the body occasioning self-murder Second generall motive of self-murder Calamities The second generall motive occasioning self-murder is immoderate affectation of freedome from evill of punishment that sinfull man is liable unto for bearing of which he hath neither comfort nor strength as he apprehends The sorts of them These evills are either reall and true or but fancied and conceited and are either present or feared and are such as a self-murderer despaires either to be able of himselfe to beare or that God will uphold him in them or will deliver him from them and therefore hee resolves not to endure them but out of obstinacy of minde and will purposes to remove himselfe by self-murder from that which hee cannot remove from himselfe As wee see in part by the pettish humour of Ionah Ion. 4.8 Three sorts of them These evills whereby men take occasion to kill themselves are of three sorts 1. Vpon the body First they are those that are upon their bodies which doe also much affect their soules because of their neere union together whereby they doe make one person and doe so sympathise together that what is proper to the one nature in matter of action or passion is deemed to bee common to the other in regard of the unity of the person consisting of them both Whereupon it is that the sufferings of the body doe drive the soule into strange passions and undertakings on the bodies behalfe Evills upon the body are threefold These evills upon the body occasioning self-murder are of three kindes 1. Inbred diseases First they are inbred diseases and torments of continuall grievous painfulnesse being in the judgement of sense importable both for intensive greatnesse and also for extensive multitude Non est vivere sed valere vita or unintermitted continuance as may be the gout stone strangury racking aches furious fevers incurable gangreenes and the like desperately raging or noysome diseases Better eye out than alwayes aking from which to be rid as from an irksome long and painfull death many doe make choise to kill themselves dispatching that by a voluntary short death which they see will otherwise cost them a tedious and long death As did Pomponius Atticus Tullius Marcellinus and other like starve themselves to death thereby to cure such desperate griefes 2. Inflicted torments Secondly the evills upon the body that often occasion self-murder are either sense of inflicted torments or of ignominy by man greater and more shamefull than they can or will endure Or else they are such as they horribly feare shall be inflicted upon them if they doe live and are strongly perswaded that they shall not be able to endure the fame but that they shall if they live disgrace both themselves and their cause by their sinking under the burden or by their unseemly manner of behaviour in their troubles and therefore divers to prevent the latter and to be delivered out of the former have murderously killed themselves As Iosephus reports of Eleazar and his companions Joseph de bello Judaico lib. 7. cap. 28. who killed themselves that they might not bee punished by the Romanes but might escape from their tyranny that their wives might die undefiled and their children not taste of servile captivity Alleadging but unjustly that it was misery to live and not to die because death freeth our soules from prison unto their most pure and proper place where never after they shall be touched with calamities Vpon which motive it was that the Stoick Seneca said that for our readie dispatch every veine of our body is a way to liberty a Quarr cunque venam nostri corporis esse viam ad libertatem meaning by bleeding to death and upon this reason it was that Saul killed himselfe b 1 Sam. 31.4 and whereupon also the Iaylor would have done the like c Acts 16 27. so farre doth the forerunners and feare of death prevaile with some that the same makes them to cast themselves headlong into that which they would most shun Note 3. Want of necessaries for the body Thirdly the evils on the body whereupon some people doe precipitate themselves into the jawes of self-murder are want of necessaries of livelyhood being without meanes or hope of supply thereof whereby they and theirs depending upon them are pinched with famishing hunger starved with piercing cold vexed with intolerable oppression and neglect that makes a wise man mad Eccles 7.7 Which fills them with painfull smart for their owne particular oppresses them with sorrow and griefe to behold the miseries and to heare the ruefull complaints and lamentations of those they dearely love as of their Wives Children and neerest friends walking as living and forlorne ghosts upon the earth which possesses them with comfortlesse and hopelesse desperation especially when they consider what plenty they have had and what others their inferiours still have whose bowells of compassion they finde shut up against them and theirs An image of which estate we may see in the Lamentations of Ieremie d Iam. 2 11 14. Mine eyes do faile with teares my bowels are troubled my liver is powred upon the earth for the destruction of the daughter of my people because the children and the sucklings swouned in the streets of the City they say to their Mothers where is corne and wine When they swouned as the wounded in the streets of the City when their soule was powred out in their mothers bosome the tongue of the sucking child cleaving to the roofe of his mouth for thirst the young children aske bread and no man breaketh it unto them b Chap. 2.20 By which necessity it came to passe that women did eate their fruit and children of a span long the hands of the pitifull women have sodden their owne children they were their meate in the destruction of the daughter of my people c Cap. 4.10 according both to the threatnings of the breach of the Law d Deut. 28.53 and also to practise in besieged townes e 2 King 6.29 In which regard it is said that they that be slaine with the sword are better than they that be slaine with hunger f Lam. 4.9 Therefore diverse persons that they may prevent what they or theirs may uncomfortably doe or suffer in such felt or feared distresse doe with their owne hands kill their Wives or Children and then themselves that they may not feele or behold a greater
our consciences in well-doing and be our selves taken up about heavenly things and holy imployments then is it not in the hand of any creature to make us miserable or weary of our lives the comfort whereof depends not upon any earthly wight our repudiating desertion and wrong by those here on earth that should least faile us should make us cleave the more close to God and to live here as possessing none of these things 1 Cor. 7.29 30 31. that for our want of them or suffering by them we may care the lesse considering what little assurance we have of them at any time which at all times are accompanied with dislikes §. 16. Of afflictions unwarrantablenesse to kill ones selfe Insufficiency of this motive of crosses for a man to kill himselfe 1. Afflictions are not simply evill The insufficiency of this ground of affliction to warrant any man to murder himselfe is apparent by foure things First by the consideration of the nature of the things that men by self-murder would rid themselves from which are afflictions and therefore in that respect not properly evill much lesse so bad as self-murder which is the course men take to free themselves from the former It is certainely madnesse for any body wittingly and willingly to cast themselves into a greater evill that they may free themselves from a lesser For a man to get out of trouble by making a stollen escape Non enim poena vitatur furtiva discessiene sed crescit he encreases his deserved punishment wee must not breake prison but wait Gods leisure 2. Death is worse than afflictioÌ„s Secondly if a man consider what hee parts from namely his life to bee freed from troubles he may see the folly of such a course of self-murder upon this motive For the goods of nature and of the world Donum vilae majus est ijs ommbus Filli. are farre inferiour to a mans selfe and to the worth of his life because in them consists not a mans chiefe happinesse and therefore for the same should not a man kill himself The Philosopher sayes that Poverty is not horrible or to bee feared neither death neither any thing at all besides sinne a Arist asserit nec paupertatem esse horribilem aut pertinvescendam nec mortem nec omn no quicquam praeter culpam Therefore why should a man kill himselfe for that whereof he should not be afraid and why should hee make so bad an exchange in giving away his life for ease from that which cannot by its presence make miserable and for to precipitate himselfe into endlesse misery 3. A self-murderer is deceived Thirdly if a self-murderer did consider how he is deceived in his expectation of being eased or delivered from troubles by killing himselfe VltimuÌ„ malorum hujus vitae maxime terriâ—ile est mors et iccireo inferre sibi morteÌ„ ad alias hujus vitae misertas evadendas est majus malum assumere ad minoris mass vitaâ—ienem Tho. 2.2 q. 64. Art 5. when thereby he casts himselfe into infinite greater miseries hee might see what little force this motive hath in it to worke and justifie this effect Seeing life is more proper and effectuall than such a death to procure happinesse Although that self-murder be a quick way of dispatch and of putting out all feeling of bodily paine it is not therefore better when the exchange is for the worse ease and expedition in doing self-murder is no argument of commendation seeing evill of sin is most easily performed as the Apostle shewes Rom. 7.21 Heb. 12.1 Because it is not an act of power but of impotency Peter Martyr wonders at the Stoicks that place happy life in vertue and doe hold that adversity is not evill that they should to free themselves from troubles kill themselves and sayes What kind of happinesse is that which death doth perfit if life be happie then should wee labour to abide therein what happinesse is that which may be overcome by those things that are not evill a Quaenam est foelicitas quae morte est perficienda Si vita est beata in ea est manendum quae est faelicitas quaevinci potest ab ijs quae non sunt mala For persecution our Saviour bids us flee from it or patiently to endure it and no where allowes that we should kill ourselves to prevent or escape it our blessed Saviour although he were to lay downe his life yet would not kill himselfe for accomplishment of that worke that necessarily was to be done Ludovicus Vives cites out of Plutarch and he out of Menander That it is not the part of a good and valiant man to say I will not suffer this but to say I will not doe this b Non est boni et fortis viri dicere hee non patiar sed hoc nonfaciaÌ„ 4. He resists Gods will Fourthly he that kills himselfe for to free himselfe thereby out of troubles and afflictions resists the will of God by shaking off that burden which God hath laid upon him to beare during his good pleasure to which all are subject And thereunto the Son of God submitted himselfe when he said to Peter The cup that my Father hath given me shall I not drinke it c Iohn 18.11 And therefore we are bound in this case to fulfill the will of God by passive obedience when we cannot doe the contrary without offending God neither did the Saints of God use self-murder to free themselves out of troubles whereof we have neither precept nor commendable example §. 17. Of certaine uses about afflicted persons Observe The uses or observations observable from this motive generally considered are two Afflicted persons are doubly burdened First we are here to observe that persons in trouble and adversity are under a double burden both of their afflictions which they suffer and also of strong temptations wherby thereupon Satan assaults them both which the persons in distresse doe commonly aggravate so making their estates more tedious and unsupportable than otherwise they would be Note in which condition men should beware of hard uncharitable conclusions against themselves Beware of censuring either in censuring themselves to be reprobates forsaken of God or the like or in determining rashly of or against themselves what they will doe with themselves or to themselves in that case otherwise than they have warrant from God Beware of concealement Againe in that estate they should take heed of over-close concealement of their troubles from those that may advise and help them to beare their burdens concealed griefe is most dangerous to sink a man but vent gives ease and procures help Finally of persons in adversity others are to be observant how they doe and to be helpfull to them by their countenance counsell and aide of assistance from themselves and by their intercession from others that so that may be easily borne that
under their generall Againe Gen. 9.5 God saies That at the hand of man he will require mans blood even at a mans owne hand that is a mans owne blood at his owne hand if he kill himselfe as Peter Martyr interprets it And if by the Word of God it had beene lawfull for a man to kill himselfe then would not the Apostle Paul have cryed out to the Iaylor that was about to kill himselfe That he should doe himselfe no harme a Act. 16.28 for why should he have letted him from doing a lawfull thing or have called it a doing of himselfe harme in any morall consideration Self-murder is against love the summe of the Law Furthermore self-murder is an odious fact contrary to the generall summe of the Law which is love and justice it is against that love that we owe to God in respect whereof wee are to keep his Law and to affect to enjoy him and it is against that love wherewith wee ought to love our selves and whereby we should endeavour our owne wel-fare and happinesse and according to which we should love our neighbours Who can expect better measure at a mans hand than he performes to himselfe if the rule be not straight all that is measured by it must be crooked the Apostle delivers it as an axiome no man yet ever hated his owne flesh Ephes 5.29 and againe he condemnes those that under pretence of wil-worship did not spare their owne bodies b 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Col. 2.23 Self-murder is also contrary to the love that we owe to our neighbours by depriving them thereby both of our selves and of all the good and comfort that they might have by our lives Self-murder is against the generall justice of the Law It is likewise against the generall justice of the Law which requires that wee should give to every man his due For self-murder deprives God our neighbours and our selves of their rights God of obedience and glory c Rom. 13.7 by our lives and our neighbours and our selves of that benefit that both should have by our living Question About Superiours Here a question may be moved whether a Magistrate that hath no superiour over him on earth and is guilty of a capitall crime or crimes may justly in punishment of himselfe therefore put himselfe to death or cause others to do it and whether a capitall malefactor whose hainous offence falls not under mans cognizance or being knowne is neglected to be punished as privy murder or blasphemy in the highest degree against God may not in this case or where he is a subject to none other man kill himselfe or cause another to do it in execution of justice Answer I answer to the first branch of the question with Thomas Aquinas negatively because he cannot be his owne capitall Iudge in his owne cause a Sccūdasccuda q. 64. Art 5. Nullus est Judex sui ipsius and so Magistrates that have no earthly superiour over them are lyable to be punished onely by God either immediatly as was Herod b Act. 12.23 or mediatly by extraordinary meanes of Gods raysing up as was Belthazzar by Darius c Dan. 5.30 31. A Magistrate may not kill himselfe nor may be slaine by his people 2 Sam. 11. 12. Magistrates are under the same morall Lawes in equall strictnesse and extent as any other men for before God there is no respect of persons and therefore a Magistrate can no more lawfully kill himselfe than a private man can kill himselfe as wee see in King David who neither did put himselfe nor was put to death by others for his adultery and murder Reasons 1. Finally for no crime can a Magistrate in any case kill himselfe because he is not his owne but the Common-wealths and therefore cannot dispose of himselfe in that respect as he list 2. neither hath the body punitive power of jurisdiction over its head 3. neither is hee to bee valued and esteemed simply as an individuall man who as David was may be worth thousands and therefore for crimes punishable in their particular subjects by death is not to be put to death by his people nor yet to kill himselfe whose losse that way may bring farre more damage than such an execution of Iustice upon him can do good in such a tomerarious manner Magistrates neglect and secret capitall crimes belong not to any to redresse by death upon themselves For answer to the second branch I referre the reader to that which is said before touching insufficiency of the third generall motive to self-murder And further adde that things secret belong to God and the Magistrates omissions and aberrations belong to God and not to private men from private motion in authoritative manner to amend Such a man if to punish himselfe he kill himselfe cannot do it but either as a Magistrate or as a private man then in neither respects can he do it as we have heard and therefore he cannot lawfully do it at all A Case About persons condemned to death what they may do to prevent or hasten it I would here further determine a case which is this Suppose a man be condemned ignominiously to die may he poyson or famish or bleed himselfe to death may hee stab himselfe hang himselfe cut his owne throat break his neck or cast himselfe off the ladder leap into the water or fire either to hasten his death that he is adjudged to or to prevent it specially when it is undeserved Answer They may not kill themselves although commanded to do it although the Iudge should command him to do the same hee ought not to doe it I answer that much lesse may he doe it of his owne accord Reasons 1. because it is against the Law of God and of nature for one to kill himselfe 2. and is an act of self-condemnation as if in his owne opinion he were neither worthy nor fit to live nor yet to die in a warrantable manner by the hand of justice 3. the lengthning of life is a blessing to be imbraced for the good that thereby we may do or get 4. to prevent justice in the execution thereof doth wrong it by invading and usurping the right thereof with injury to the Common-wealth by a self-willed cutting off the members therof in such a disorderly course as opens a way to overthrow the same death is an act of suffering and not of agency of him that is to die 5. self-murder is a more shamefull and uncomfortable death than any other that a man can suffer 6. and it is not the death inflicted by others but the cause thereof in our selves that makes it honourable or disgracefull according to the deserts of our lives If a man be undeservedly condemned to die it is the more honourable and comfortable for him to suffer a 1 Pet. 3.14 17. c. 4. v. 15 16.
accidentally to kill himselfe but in all the aforesaid respects he was wholly bent to destroy his enemies the Philistims which he could not doe but with and by the death of himselfe which is apparent by the story Iudg. 16.28 2. Secondly he was a Iudge of the people of Israel to free and avenge them of their enemies the Philistims and therefore by vertue of his office was warranted to destroy them as he should be able in which execution although he perished through his owne voluntary act according to his owne certaine foreknowledge he could not be a self-murderer from which sinne his office and calling of God to that work freed him 3. Thirdly for that act and last worke of Sampson whereby himselfe died God called him to it that then and there he might so do it both by his providence giving him such an opportunitie against his enemies so assembled as he could never have the like againe and also by the extraordinary supernaturall assistance of the Spirit of God that came upon him Spiritus latenter hoc jusserat Decreti secunda pars causa 23. c. 9. si non licet and strengthned him to do the deed which it never doth for any wicked act which is rather the work of the devill Whereby it is manifest that Sampsons act was not self-murder 4. That Sampsons act was warrantable and no fact of self-murder is evident by his intending and going about it in subordination to God and his will manifested by his Spirits assistance and obtained by lawfull and pious prayer which no self-murderer doth who preferre their owne wills above Gods in satisfying whereof they cannot comfortably pray for Gods assistance to doe the deed which in their owne consciences they know is unlawfull and wicked and therefore were horrible to entreat him to be an actor of the same with them 5. Fiftly this last act of Sampson is spoken of in the history of it Iudg. 16.30 with commendation when it is said that the dead which he slew at his death were more than they which he slew in his life and Heb. 11.32 himselfe is honoured among the faithfull as being one of them whereas the facts of self-murder and the persons of self-murderers are never spoken of but with aspersion of blame and disgrace and therefore Sampson is no self-murderer 6. Sixtly things may be done lawfully in a type of figure upon divine instinct or ordination which otherwise were unlawfull to be done as a Certaine man of the sonnes of the Prophets said unto his neighbour in the word of the Lord smite me I pray thee and the man refused to smite him then said he unto him because thou hast not obeyed the voice of the Lord behold assoone as thou art departed from me a Lyon shall slay thee and assoone as he was departed from him a Lyon found him and slew him Then he found another man and said smite me I pray thee and the man smote him so that in smiting he wounded him 1 King 20.35 36 37. Which act otherwise had beene unlawfull that here done upon divine command and for a type or figure was good Sampsons manner of so dying was a type or figure of Christ who by his death slew more than in his life and therefore in this respect it was lawfull and he no self-murderer 2. About Pelagia and others not self-murderers Secondly I answer touching Pelagia and others in the Primitive Church who killed themselves to avoid either doing of sin themselves or suffering sin to be done upon them that they were charitably thought of and favourably censured because of their precedent pious godly life and of their good intention although the act were wicked and are excused 1. By allegation of their ignorance of the morall nature and of the danger of the fact to their soules 2. And by the suddaine invasion and surprisall of them by violence of their unadvised passions which can be no president for ordinary practise either to warrant the fact to be lawfull or to comfort the persons doing it with expectation of the like event and safety But of this see more cap. 12 § 5. and cap. 15. § 23. and cap. 17. § 7. argument 17. supra § 4. Whereby it appeares evidently that those and such persons were not proper self-murderers and so not of that number and ranck of self-killers that are certainely and finally excluded from salvation And so this objection is of no force against the former conclusion of the damnation of all proper and transcendent self-murderers because the instances given are insufficient and impertinent to make proofe or to give any comfort and hope of salvation to any proper self-murderer in regard that the same are of another kinde for although by falling by their owne hands or meanes they were self-killers yet they were not proper and direct self-murderers seeing these two are not alwaies convertible and of equall extent as hath beene shewed §. 11. About antecedent Prayer and repentance for pardon of sinnes to come 3. Object From mens preparation to God-ward before they murder themselves The third objection that may be alledged in favour of the salvation of self-murderers is that a self-murderer purposing and resolved to murder himselfe may before the fact make his peace with God by humiliation and repentance for all his sinnes past and in particular for his hainous sin of self murder to come praying instantly to God to forgive him both the guiltinesse and punishment of that vile fact that he is bent suddainely to do and beseeching him through Christ and his merits to receive him into mercy and to save his soule for the same casting himselfe upon and beleeving in Christ And so thereupon dispatches and murders himselfe by his owne meanes or hands hoping and expecting to be saved whereby and in which case such an one seemes to die in a good minde in peace with God and in charity with all the world and in an estare sure enough of heaven for his soule and of perfection of salvation for both at the resurrection and great day of Judgement Answer A self-murderer cannot make peace with God To this objection I answer that no man can make or be at peace with God when and so long as he wilfully intends and persists in such a sinfull course or practise as offends enrages and makes God his implacable enemie in that case such is the state of an indivertibly-resolved self-murderer and therefore it is impossible that so long as he is in that minde to murder himselfe he can make or be at peace with God whom by his vile sin he inrages against him so that he cannot die that way but in vengeance from God both thereby punishing his former sinnes and also thus dispatching him away to hell Antecedent prayer and repentance for self-murder is uneffectuall Neither can any man truly repent before hand for that grosse sinne which he is purposed and fully