had knowledge as that was which Paul spake of in that place but the place speaks not of faith in Christ onely it would have men to be fully perswaded in their hearts of the lawfullnes of what they doe and likewise to refraine things lawfull in themselves rather then to be a stumbling block to their weak Brother and so much for this Objection Object Christ dyed for all but not intentionally he taking the nature of man upon him his death must needs extend to all of that nature in the sufficiencie of it but neither God in giving Christ nor Christ in giving himself ever intended the benefits of his death remission of sins and eternall life to any but the Elect. Answ First I answer by way of concession that God never intended the benefits of Christs death to any but the Elect if we take Election according to the Scriptures for it is the will of the Father that those and none but those that believe should have eternall life and believers only are the objects and Subjects of Gods Election for Election looks not on men in Adam but in Christ I speak only of such as have the Gospell plainely and powerfully preached to them but seeing most men doe conceive that God doth elect some men to life in unbelief and leaves the rest we shall state the Question thus Whether God did ever really intend that those men which perish and are damned should have believed and so have come to life And to this I answer affirmatively for it was shewed before that God commanded all men to believe in his Son that they might be saved Mark 16.15 16. Ioh 12.36.37 That he threatneth all those which believe not with everlasting destruction from his presence and the glory of his power 2 Thes 1.7 8. and that because they belive not Joh. 3.18 and because they received not the truth in the love thereof that they might besaved but had pleasure in unrighteousnesse as 2 Thes 2.10.12 That hee pittieth those that perish through the abuse of his grace extended towards them Psal 81.8.13 Matth. 23.37 Luke 19.41.42 Therefore it evidently appeares that he intended the benefits of his death viz. remission of sins and eternall life to those who by trusting inlying vanities for sake their own mercies Jonah 2.8 and drawing back to perdition Heb. 10 39. as well as to those who believe to the saving of their souls Heb. 10.39 But yet further consider these Scriptures Joh. 3.17 God sent not his Son into the world to condemne the world but that the world through him might be saved This Scripture which sets forth the act of Gods love in sending his Son into the World declareth also his end and intention therein negatively not to condemne the World affirmatively but that the World through him might be saved Againe Iohn 12.47 If any man heare my words and believe not Iudge him not for I came not into the world to judge the world but to save the World Why will not Christ judge those men that heare his words and believe not because he came to save them Againe Ioh. 5.34.40 Christ speaking to the obstinate Iewes saith unto them these things speak I unto you for what end that yee may be saved And yee will not come to me that yee may have life Neither doth Christ herein expresle his owne desires and intentions of the salvation of those obstinate Iewes but the will and intention of his Father also For he came not downe from Heaven to doe his owne will but the will of the Father which sent him therefore it appeares that as the death of Christ was extended to all so likewise the benefits therof were both by the Father and the Son intended for all Object If God sent his Son and it be his desire to save all men and yet all men are not saved then God misseth his end and is disappointed of his desire which is very unsuiteable to him Answ If God had sent his Sonne with an absolute and peremptory resolution to save all men whether they did receive him or reject him then all must be saved or God disappointed which cannot be for he doth whatsoever he will and if he work in this sence who can hinder but God in sending of his Sonne did intend he should be a sufficient means to save all and so to save them if they did not resist and dispise this grace of his which if they did he resolved to condemne them and not to save them by his Sonne And whereas it is said that God is unwilling that any should perish and that he desires the salvation of all I conceive it is thus to be understood he is not willing that any should perish for want of sufficient means of recovery and he desires the salvation of all as they are in a lost condition unable to helpe themselves but not as they are considered malicious contemnen of all grace and savour means and mercies for that were to set his attributes at variance and divide God in himself the mercy of whose justice is to afford means of help to that which cannot help it self and the justice of whose mercie is to condemne him that refuseth such helpe and to save him that receiveth it so that his mercie cannot desire the salvation of all but his justice must afford the means of accomplishment and when his justice affordeth means his mercie is said to desire for as what men desire they use means to accomplish so what God useth means to accomplish he is said to desire neither is God disappointed if men neglect this means for the justice of Gods mercie is to render to every man according to his deeds whether good or evill as the mercie of his justice is to provide means of life or salvation so that God is not disappointed in the condemnation of any for his mercie affordeth them means and his justice condemnes them for contempt thereof so that as God cannot worke against himself so therein he is neither crossed nor contradicted but remaineth in his attributes intire and compleat The next thing I shall speak of is the sufficiencie of the means of grace or the sufficiencie of the means which God affords to worke grace or faith in every man That the Gospell was never published to men with plainesse and power but they were thereby enabled to believe and yeeld obedience That God doth enlighten invite perswade and draw all men to himself so farre and so sufficiently that did they improve the Talent and price that God puts into their hands they should certainely come to life and glory It will be needfull before I proceed further to declare what I meane by grace and what I meane by the sufficiency of the meanes of grace Grace I conceive to bee an humble and thankefull apprehension of the free love favour and goodnesse of God and when I speake of the sufficiency of the meanes which God affoords to worke grace in every man I meane
and this appeareth by what is written Iohn 3.16 God so loved the World that he gave his onely begotten Sonne that whosoever beleeved in him should not perish but have everlasting life God so loved the World that is all mankind that hee gave his onely begotten Son that whosoever of them beleeved in him should not perish but live eternally 1 Obj. By World is meant the World of the Elect I Answer that the Elect in their owne sense shall all believe but this word whosoever intimateth that many of this world here meant may not beleeve for if by World here you will understand the Elect onely then this will bee the sense of the words God so loved the world of the Elect that whosoever of this world of the Elect beleeves in him should not perish c. 2 Obj. By World is meant the whole lumpe of mankind but those that are not elect can never beleeve for God will never give them faith and therefore though God doth thus proclaime his love to all yet seeing it is impossible that any other then the elect should beleeve this Text doth not hinder but that the death of Christ may still bee limited to the elect Answ Then the love of God to the greatest part of the world may bee thus expressed such and so great is the love of God towards you that when you doe that which is impossible for you ever to performe viz. believe then you shall obtaine that from him which he cannot in justice bestow upon you viz. remission of sins and eternall life And that I may illustrate the absurdity of this Objection consider what is written in Rom. 3 25 26. whom God hath set forth to be a propitiation through faith in his blood to declare his righteousnesse for the remission of sinnes that are past through the forbearance of God to declare I say at this time his righteousnesse that he might be just and the justifier of those that believe in Jesus in which words we may perceive that God doth proceed in the Gospel in such a way as hee may declare his righteousnesse in justifying of sinners and moreover that that God could not bee just and the justifier of the ungodly but through the death of his Sonne for without blood there is no remission Heb. 9.22 Now if God hath so loved the world that he hath given his Sonne that whosoever believes in him should not perish but have eternall life then the Son must die for all otherwise if those hee did not dye for should believe an hundred times yet must they die in their sinnes yea they are as farre from Salvation as ever they were and so this opinion doth contradict the word of God denying that God hath so loved men or so given Christ that all men may have life through saith for God is able no more nor no further to extend the glad tydings of life peace and remission of sinnes then the death of Christ which is the ground of the Gospell doth extend For he may as well pardon and remit the sins of all Men without relation to the blood and Sacrifice of his Son as he way preach and proffer remission of sins or eternall life to all or any man for whom Christ did not shed his blood but as God will not do that which is unjust so neither will he profer to doe it for in him justice and mercy are inseperable that is he is mercifull justice and just mercy therefore his mercy in proclaiming salvation to all must be just in the execution which could not be if offered not intended to all the justice of his mercie must extend as farre as the mercy of his justice so that he which maketh him mercifull to offer unto all and not as just to give where as he offereth destroies both justice and mercie which is a flat deniall of God Therefore I say that as the Serpent was lifted up in the Wildernes so must the Sonne of man be lifted up in the Ministery of the Gospel as a universall ground and object of faith for all men Ioh. 3.14 Another Text for this purpose is 1 Cor. 15.3 where the Apostle speaking to the Corinthians saith For I delivered unto you first of all that which I also received how that Christ dyed for our sins according to the Scriptures In which words consider first what it was that he delivered to these Corinthians and that is that Christ dyed for their sins And secondly when he delivered this unto them and that was first of all Now if Christ had not died for all Paul could not have concluded that Christ had dyed for them for they were at that time Gentiles carried away with dumb Idolls 1 Cor. 12.2 Fornicators Adulterers Theeves Drunkards and the like 1 Cor. 6.9.10.11 And Paul spake not from any speciall Revelation of God concerning these men in particular but he spake according to the Scriptures which foretold the death of Iesus Christ Now if it be objected that Paul doth not say for your sins but for our sins joining himself with the rest who were believers at that time or with the Elect I answer First that this could be no glad tydings to the Corinthians that Christ dyed for Paul and others if they were not included if Paul were not able to prove by the Scriptures that Christ dyed for them whilest they were sinners then they could not receive it nor stand in it nor be saved by it as the former verses expresse for faith comes by hearing hearing by the Word of God for wee cannot believe that of which wee have not heard Againe 2 Cor. 5.4 It is said that if one dyed for all then were all dead Paul with the rest that sent that Epistle having in the former Verses spoken of being besides themselves towards God and sober for the Corinthians cause tells them that the love of Christ did constrain them and why so because they did judge that they were dead and how do they prove that they were dead they tell them that all were dead and therefore they were dead and that all were dead appeares in that Christ dyed for all and this I conceive to be the meaning of these words If one dyed for all then were all dead 1 Tim. 2.1 Wee are exhorted to make Prayers and supplication for all men the reason is declared in vers 4. God would have all to be saved that his desire is that all should be saved he hath fully manifested in giving Christ a ransome for all Vers 6. Now it is not the will of God that any should be saved for whom Christ did not die and our Praiers must be made according to the will of God therefore if Christ dyed not for all we cannot pray in faith for any much lesse for all If we have a ground in the Scriptures to pray for the Salvation of all men then if we do pray in faith for all or any man they or
themselves and so their faith is stronger or weaker as they appeare to themselves better or worse men Must be pressed to repentance love and holinesse from the love and grace of God towards them as sinners they must not first beleeve because they are good but they must be good because they believe Paul the chiefe of sinners obtained mercy and so became a patterne of the large extent of the love of God that no man might exclude himselfe from his grace and mercy in Christ and Christ conversed with Publicans and Harlots therby to shew his desire of the good and Salvation of Sinners and to reprove the error of the Pharisees that thought that Christ should save and respect such onely as were Pharisaically holy and reformed whereas Christ tells them that he comming to save sinners the more sinfull men were the more proper it was for him to apply himselfe to recover reform and save them by his grace Secondly all men are called upon to believe that they may have life Acts 17.30 now God would not call upon all to believe if there was not a Christ crucisied for all to believe in Thirdly Unbelievers are threatned with eternall death and ruine for their unbelief Joh. 3.18.36 Matth. 10.14.15 2 Thes 1.8 9. now if Christ died not for all those for whom he did not die should rather be threatened with condemnation for believing then for unbeliefe yea certainly in whatsoever God condemnes them he would justifie them in this that they did not believe that Christ dyed for their sins for to have believed that if Christ did not dye for them had been to believe a lie then which nothing can bee no more contrary to the God of Truth Fourthly those men which perish are chargedwith neglect of salvation Heb. 2.3 and putting from them the word of eternall life Acts 13.46 and for not receiving the truth in the love thereof that they might be saved 2 Thessa 2.10 and for not comming to Christ that they may have life John 5.40 These and the like expressions are used concerning such as neglect and reject the Gopell by which it evidently appeares that there was life and salvation in the Gospell for them for they could not put that from them which was never there for them Christ would not blame them for not comming to him that they might have Life if there had been no life in him for them if they had come and there is life in him for none for whom hee did not die the receiving of no truth whatsoever would save them if Christ had not shed his blood for them seeing without blood there is no Remission therefore it is cleare that Christ hath given himselfe to the death for all and is become a compleat meanes of life to all Object Christ would not pray for the world much lesse would hee die for the same Joh. 17.9 For Answer to this Objection consider these two particulars First who they were that Christ prayed for Secondly what it was that Christ prayed for The persons for whom Christ prayed were those whom God had given him out of the world vers the 6. such as had received the word of God and did know and believe that he was sent of God ver the 8. such as the world did hate verse the 14. such as Christ sent out into the world vers the 18. whereby it appeares that the persons prayed for were such as did at that time be-believe and so were given to Christ for the World loved them aswell as others whil'st they were in unbeliefe and were of the World And it further appeares that it were the Disciples of Christ only which were there said to be given and prayed for if you consider the 12. Verse Those that thou hast given me have I kept and none of them is lost but the Son of Perdition compared with the 20. Vers where it is said Neither pray I for these alone but for them also which shall beleeve on me through their word Now Christ needs not to inlarge his prayer for those that should afterwards believe if they had beene included in the former words those which thou hast given me for that would have been a vaine repetition Secondly consider what Christ prayed for viz that they might be one and that they might bee kept from the evill of the World now Christ did not desire nor endeavour to make unity betweene believers and unbelievers but the contrary and there was no need of Christs prayer that Unbelievers though elect should be kept from the evill of the World for the World could not discern any thing in the Elect during their unbelief which should cause them to have an evill eye towards them and if by evill wee understand the corruption of the World then they were of those that made the times corrupt and so Christ would have prayed his Father to have delivered them out of the evill or wickednesse of the world rather then to keepe them from it and so the reason is evident by what hath been said why Christ excluded the unbelieving World out of his prayer seeing he tooke occasion from the enmity of the world against his people to make this prayer unto his Father which prayer was in no sense proper for the unbelieving World And moreover hee excepted the world in no other respect but as they were considered opposing their owne Salvation not that he would not have all to bee saved but that the World might not prevaile against his worke in hand the divulging of the Gospel which was to be done by his Disciples therefore is he so earnest for them that the evill of the world might not prevaile over them in their Ministery in his absence that thereby the world might know that he was sent of God vers 21. therefore their Salvation was more implyed in these words I pray not for the World then their condemnation Obj Many men were in Hell that very time that Christ did die and therefore it is a foolish thing to thinke that Christ dyed for them First I Answer that no man is yet in Hel neither shall any be there untill the Judgement for God doth not hang first and judge after and therefore wee see the Scriptures referreth the punishment of men untill the last day so Paul writes to the Thessalouians seeing saith he it is a righteous thing with God to recompence tribulation to them that trouble you and to you that are troubled rest with us when the Lord Jesus shall bee revealed from Heaven with his mighty Angels in flaming fire taking vengeance on them that know not God and on them that obey not the Gospell of our Lord Jesus Christ who shall be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his power when hee shall come to be glorified in his Saints and to bee admired in all them that believe 2 Thess 1.6 7 8 9 10. vers so Matth. 25. when the
Now that we were not to have perished in Hell fire in relation to Adams sinne or the Law Consider we all dyed in Adam and Christ to redeeme nor to prevent us from death suffered death he hung on a Tree and so was made a curse for us and delivered us from the curse of the Law Gal. 3.13 Deut. 21 23. That we through him might receive the blessing Gal. 3.14 And if wee had bin to suffer in Hell in relation to Adam or the Law then Christ also should have suffered in Hell for us to have redeemed us from thence which hee did not The resurrection of the dead comes by Christ 1 Cor. 15.21 22. who by death overcame him that had the power of death Heb. 2.14 So that we should for ever have perished in the grave had not Christ dyed and rose againe and never have risen from the dead to receive the sentence of a second death And this may serve for answer to this Objection about our inability and Gods requiring of us to keep the Law Againe if the most of men where the Gospel came were unable to believe then the Gospel or Christ crucified could not be a Gospel of grace bringing salvation to all men Tit. 2.11 and 3 4. nor glad tydings of great joy to all people Luk. 2.10 11. For if men could have no benefit by Christ unlesse they came to him and their condemnation were aggravated for not comming and God gave them not where with all to come the case I say being so with the most of them the love of God towards them in the Gospel was no other then such as the charity which Iames speaks of Iam. 2.15 16. If a Brother or a Sister be naked and destitute of daily food and one of you say unto them depart in peace be yee warmed and filled notwithstanding yee give them not those things that are needfull to the body what doth it profit Now if God injoined them to love in deed and in truth and not in word and in tongue 1 Joh 3.18 It is farre from God himself so to doe if he would not have us to bid a man be cloathed and warmed and not give him wherewithall how much lesse will he in the gospel of his love and grace to the Sons of Men bid them to repent and believe that they may be saved and give them not wherewithall Yea further where it is said God so loved the World Joh. 3.16 It were then more proper to say God so hated the world and whereas God proclaimes himself in the gospel to be love to be gracious and mercifull to lost men this Doctrine proclaimes him to be wrath hatred anger c. to the Sons of men for if salvation were not to be had by Christ but through faith and condemnation came upon them through unbelief and the condition of men were such that they could not believe and God afforded them no power then the eternall ruine and damnation of the most part of them was an inevitable effect of the death of Christ so that this Doctrine tends to the subversion of the free grace of God in the gospel Againe God sent his Son and the Sonne in obedience to the Father came to save men even those which perish Ioh. 3.17.12.47 Act. 3 26. now it were absurd to thinke that Christ was sent and came to doe that which being come he used not meanes sufficient to accomplish for that were to deny the wisdome of God which alwayes maketh choice and use of meanes sufficient to effect the ends proposed by it yet this must needs be concluded if men could not beleeve the gospel when it was preached and published to them by Christ for faith is held as absolutely necessary to salvation as the blood of Christ seeing God requires those that heare the gospel to beleeve it upon pain of condemnation in hell fire now if Christ hath given himselfe for any to whom he hath not given meanes sufficient to beget faith their condition is as desperate as if he had never given himselfe for them according to the old Proverbe As good nothing as never the nearer for if I know two things equally and individually absolute by me to be performed to effect one and the same end if I doe the one and leave the other undone it is as impossible the thing should be effected as if I had done nothing at all but when ever God propounds meanes to effect an end the meanes is sufficient to accomplish the same But God did propound meanes to save those which notwithstanding did perish Therefore the means used was sufficient to accomplish their salvation though they perished through the wilfull neglect of it Ioh. 5.34.40 2 Thess 2.10 but if all the means used with those that perish were insufficient to save them then the end of God in using the meanes could not be to save them as the Scriptures plainly declare it was for that end which the means cannot possibly produce cannot be the end of God in the meanes and seeing God having sent his Son requires all men unto whom he is preached with power to beleeve upon pain of damnation in hell it being unpossible for the most of those that heare him preached to beleeve hell-fire must needs follow the giving of Christ as hath been already declared and therefore the ruine and destruction of the most of men may be more truly and properly said to be Gods end in giving Christ unto them according to this doctrine then the salvation of them as the Scriptures evidently demonstrate Againe men are charged with the neglect of salvation now how can that bee neglected which was impossible to bee obtained Againe those that reject the gospel or meanes of grace are said to be guilty of the blood of their soules Act. 18.6 whereas if the meanes used with them were not every way sufficient to bring them to life their rejecting of it could not make them guilty of their owne death and ruine Again God bemoanes and laments men that perish because they did not make use of the means which he affoorded them for their recovery O that my people had hearkened unto me and that Israel had walked in my wayes but my people would not hearken unto me and Israel would none of me Psal 81. O Ierusalem wilt thou not be made cleane when shall it once be Jer. 13.27 O that thou hadst knowne in this thy day the things that belong to thy peace how often would I have gathered thy children as a hen gathereth her chickens and ye would not Luke 19.41 42. Matth. 23.37 These things have I spoken unto you that ye might be saved and ye will not come unto me that ye may have life Joh. 5.34.40 yea moreover God protests and sweares that he hath no pleasure in the death of the wicked Ezech. 33.11 in the death of him that dyeth Ezech. 18.32 Now what can uphold the sincerity of God which were blasphemy to question in these