he Wee ought to be subject to Parents Magistrates and the servants of all Now not the flesh onely but the whole man and the conscience is subject to the fifth Commandement and to all the ten to obey Parents and Magistrates for otherwise the ten Commandements should no more oblige the conscience of beleevers to obey then the Ceremoniall Law which is blasphemy Therefore by Conscience and Spirit Luther must mean the afflicted conscience under great conflicts and in the midst of challenging and accusing sins So the beleevers conscience is free and feareth none but feareth filially and with a son-ly fear Christ Jesus only and is fully free from the feare of condemnation Antinomians reply that the conscience of beleevers is freed from the ten Commandements as they are a Law and injoyn obedience to the conscience by power or Authority of a Law-giver for so say they no beleever can sin against the Law as the Law either commanding promising or cursing But the beleever may sin against the Law as sin is ungratitude to Christ the Redeemer not as it is a thing offending God the commanding Law-giver or failing against his Authority So Mistris Hutchison and her followers said Art 25. Since we are not bound to the Law as a rule of life it is not transgression against the Law to sin or break it because our sins are inward and spirituall and so are exceeding sinfull and are onely against Christ. Answ. There would be some colour in this Answer if Antinomians did not teach that Beleevers are as free from sin root and branch in the nature and being of it as Christ himselfe then being once justified they cannot so much as sin against Christ nor against the Law as in the hand of Christ therefore I heare that Den maintained before a godly and learned Minister That Christ satisfied for sins onely against the first Covenant and that wee our selves satisfie for sins against the Covenant of grace which is to make us joynt-Saviours with Christ. 2. Sinnes committed by Beleevers once justified are not siâ—s because they are against no Law and involve the trespasser under no guilt curse or wrath for hee is as free as Christ from all danger of wrath 3. These sinnes against the Law in the hand of Christ or against Christ are pardoned and fully removed in their nature and being ere they be committed say Antinomians 4. What Scripture shall warrant us to think that Christ who came not to dissolve the Law in the least Commandement Mat. 5.18 19 20. And who saith To doe to all men is wee would they should doe to us is the whole Law and the Prophets and obligeth us hath freed us from the commanding power of the Law and subjected us to the same Law as given by Christ. CHAP. XIII Of good works according to Luther 11 Conclusion Luther clearely contradicteth Antinomians touching certainty from signes Bona opera placebunt Deo propter fidem in Christum quod non fiunt ad jusâ—â—itam sed ad testimoniâ—m quod grati simus et graâ—â—â— juâ—tificati Spiritus sanctus nunquam oâ—iosus est in piis sed semper agit aliquid quod pertinet ad regnum Dei Si Muncerus Sacramentarii cum audirent nos docere Spiritum rejicere opera hâc doctrina abuti potuerunt neglecto verbo Sacramentis nihil aliud nisi Spiritum sonare idque nobis viventibus docentibus repugnantibus quid futurum est ubi conticuerit nostra Doctrina Post meam mortem multi meos libros proferent in medium inde omnis generis errores deliria sua confirmabunt Sed simul etiam exierunt Anabaptistae Sacramentarii alii fanatici qui de Trinitate incarnatione Christi palam impia tradiderunt non enim fuerunt ex nobis c. Good works shall please God for faith in Christ to their own end because they are not done that we may be righteous but that they may be a testimony that we are accepted and justified freely Luther The Holy Ghost is never idle in the godly but ever doing something that belongs to the Kingdome of God Luther If Muncerus and the Sacramentarians when they heare us preach the Spirit and that wee reject works in the matter of justification only as I have cleared from his owne words can abuse this Doctrine and neglecting word and seales sound nothing but the Spirit as Familists and Antinomians did then and now and that while wee live and teach the contrary and resist them what shall be done when we shall teach no more After my death saith Luther they shall alledge my writings and therewith strengthen errors of all kindes and their own dreames Also there are gone from us Anabaptists Sacramentarians and other fantastick men who have openly taught impious things of the Trinity and Incarnation of Christ but they were not of us It is true Luther falsely chargeth those whom hee calleth Sacramentarians who rejected the dreame of Consubstantiation yet as Calvin observed of the Libertines hey had nothing more frequent in their mouth then the Spirit so Anabaptists Familists Antinomians who all pretend that Luther is theirs alledge nothing more then the Spirit the immediate testimony of the Spirit without the word or any signes or markes of sanctification by which men know that they are in Christ and I appeale to the Reader if they observe any scope or drift in the Sermon preached by Del before the House of Commons but to cry down all Word Scripture Preaching Sacraments Laws lawfull and necessary constitutions of Orthodox Synods against Familists like himself for all these without the Spirit can work but an outward Reformation and hee extolleth so the Spirits inward omnipotent and only working of an inward and heart reformation as that men ministerie preaching can have no more influence in Gospel-reformation then in Christs redeeming of the world and the taking away transgression for saith hee he only that can doe the one can doe the other now in redemption Christ hath no fellows no under Mediators no instruments no with-workers hee alone by himselfe and none with him Hebr. 1. Purged us from our sins and so in all Reformation Familists contend for God is sole Reformer as Jesus Christ is sole and onely Redeemer Antinomians deny any certainty of our being in grace by signes marks and characters of holy walking which Luther is utterly against in all places especially where he extolls good works as the fruites of our justification It is true Luther saith often we must not judge of our spirituall good estate by sense but by faith and so say Antinomians and Eaton most frequently But the word sense is taken two wayes 1. for the enditement of the flesh and unrenewed part opposed to faith and so Luther and we with him teach that in a conflict of conscience when the Law challengeth a beleever especially we are never to look to
which Her lips drop as a honey combe butter and milke are under her tongue and the smell of her garments like the smell of Lybanon her feet beautifull with shooes her two breasts like two Young Roes that are twins c. Sanctification must render the Spouse a societie of Saints even in the eyes of God and not only meerely and declaratively to men-ward as the Yvie-bush is a signe of wine Let Antinomians say Are not the Saints partakers of the Divine nature in the sight of God as well as declaratively in the sight of men 2. If the charity of the Philippians bee an odour of a sweet smell a sacrifice acceptable well-pleasing to God And If to doe good and to communicate be such sacrifices where with God is well pleased though their charity and good works doe not justifie them yet these good works must smell sweetlie to God and bee well-pleasing in his sight and by them God must repute them sanctified though the sanctification be unperfect and not in its measure every way conformable to the spirituall and perfect Law and they are not then meerely declaratively and to men-ward onely Saints by their works of Sanctification 3. The contrary works in the Saints the shutting up their bowels against their indigent brethren their byting and devouring their acts of Adultery and Murther and lying are ill smelling and displeasing in the eyes of God not onely declaratively before men but really and in truth in the sight of God in regard that the Lord 1. is displeased with these sins 2. Forbiddeth them in his Law 3. Rebuketh them 4. Punisheth them 5. Setteth the conscience on against the beleever that doth them that they are grieved for them and mourne 6. Hideth his countenance from them commands us to confesse and crave pardon for them then the Lord must take notice of the contrary acts and command commend and reward them be well-pleased with them and they must be more then naked declarations and signes of Saintship to men-ward The Lord himselfe pronounceth the Saints blessed not onely for Christs imputed righteousnesse which is indeed the first cause fountaine and ground thereof but also for our works of Sanctification as Blessed are the undefiled in their way that feare the Lord and delight in his Commandements that keepe judgement and that doe righteousnesse at all times that doe what Christ commands that doe his Commandements Then God must judge them more then declarations to men-ward because this is the blessing of eternall life in Christ Jesus CHAP. LXXIIII The harmonious compliance of old Libertines Familists and Antinomians WEe doe so much the more hate the Antinomian way as Antichristian and fleshly for there bee other Antichrists then the Pope of Rome and many False Christs risen now in that in the doctrine of sinne sorrow for sinne repentance sanctification c. they doe so comply with the old Libertines in Calvins time and with David Georgius and Henrie Nicolas and the late Familists Parall I. Libertines in Calvins time said The state of innocencie was to know nothing good or ill more then children and Adams first sinne is to know good and ill and regeneration is to be stript naked of the knowledge and sense of either sinne or righteousnesse and therefore the Libertines said to any man troubled in conscience with sinne O Adam dost thou yet know somewhat Is not the old Adam yet crucified If they saw any stricken with the feare of the judgement of God Hast thou yet say they a tast of the old Aple beware that that morsell doe not strangle thee If any man was touched in conscience with remorse of sinne and did sorrow or repent for his transgressions they said sinne raigned in that man hee was sinnes captive Just so the Familists of New England In conversion say they the faculties of the soule and workings thereof are destroyed and in stead of them the holy Ghost comes in And a man must take no notice of sinne nor of his repentance for sinne And frequencie or length of holy duties or trouble of conscience for neglect thereof are all signes of one under a covenant of works that is of one in whom old Adam liveth and raigneth And I know I am Christs not because I crucifie the lusts but because I doe not crucifie them And our late Antinomians say To bee touched with any sense of sinne and for David to confesse his sinne or bee grieved for it was saith M. Towne from want and weakenesse of faith that is from the old man I cannot saith he looke on my selfe my actions sinnefull and my conscience and see my sinnes remaine but I looke to the records of heaven and Gods justice and since the bloud-shed I can find nothing there against me but sinnes as a debt discharged are become a nullitie before the Lord and therefore my peace and happinesse consisteth in the forsaking and not considering my selfe and in my living and abiding in Christ who is in heaven This not considering himselfe and his sinnes is neither to know sorrow mourne for feare or bee humbled for sinne Prâ—testant Divines say when the Lord forgiveth a sinner yet the sinner will never forgive himselfe but know consider feare mourne and be humbled for his sinnes Antinomians say all these are works of the flesh and of unbeliefe and of the Old Adam just as the Libertines said so to feele sinne dwelling in them as Paul did Rom. 7. saith Eaton is an act of the flesh contrary to faith and if saith Saltmarsh A beleever live onely by sense reason and experience of himselfe and as hee lives to men he meaneth dayly sinning by reason of an indwelling corruption he liveth both under the power and feeling of of sinne and under the Law But if hee live by faith he liveth out of the power of all condemnation and unrighteousnesse Then to Antinomians feeling of sin in us and sense reason and experience knowing and discerning sinne in us and our fearing sinne sorrowing or being humbled for it or any acts of repentance are contrary to living by faith and so the works of the old Adam knowing ill and a taste of the soure apple What then is regeneration and the killing of the body of sin and of old Adam It is the abolishing of all conscience knowledge discerning feeling feare sorrow dejection of men for feare of sinne Hence Master Archer D. Crispe and Saltmarsh make Sermons against feare of or trouble for sinne as works of unbeliefe as contrary to the power of God faithfulnesse providence death of Christ free grace a weakening of faith a damping of all religious service And for their not knowing of any good wee doe or acts of Sanctification which is the other branch of the Libertines regeneration Familists say To fetch comfort from experience of grace in our selves is no
are freed from the law how not 5 Chap. VI. How the Command of the law layeth an obliging bond on us 5 6 Proven by six arguments Chap. VII How the Law and the Gospel require the same obedience 7 8 Chap. VIII Of the promissory part of the law the differences betweene the two Covenants mistaken by Antinomians are opened 9 10 Chap. IX of the threatening of the Law and the Gospel 10 11 Chap. X. of Gospel-feare 12 Serving for a reward not mercinary ibid. Chap. XI Law-feare and Gospel-faith are consistent 12 13 Antinomians make the Gospell the very spirit of grace 13 14. And remove all Ordinances 14 Chap. XII Antinomians deny remission of sinnes to the Jewes 14 15 Chap. XIII Of the non-age of the Jewes what it was 15 16 Chap. XIV The old man or the flesh to the Antinomians is under the law the new man freed from all law 16 Chap. XV. Antinomians hold that the justified sinne before men and as touching their conversation not before God as touching their conscience 17 Chap. XVI Antinomians take justification to be an extirpation of sinne root and branch 17 Chap. XVII Christ not intrinsically and formally the sinner 18 Chap. XVIII We are not justified till we beleeve 19 20 Antinomians hold that we are united with Christ before we beleeve 20 Chap. XIX Gods love of goodwill and of good likeing a warrantable distinction 20 21 21 Chap. XX. There is a reall change of our state in justification 22 Chap. XXI We mixe not workes and grace in the matter of justification 23 24 Chap. XXII Antinomians deny sin to be in the justified 24 Chap. XXIII Antinomians say to faith there is no sinne 25 Chap XXIV The Reigne of faith not absolute as Antinomians say 25 26 Chap. XXV God seeth sin in the justified 26 27 Chap. XXVI Confession required in the beleever 27 28 Chap. XXVII The law is to be preached to beleevers 28 29 How duties are to be preached 29 Chap. XXVIII Strict and precise walking a Gospel-duty 30 Chap. XXIX God truely angry at the sinnes of beleevers 31 Chap. XXX The justified countable to God for sinne 32 Chap. XXXI God punisheth sinne in beleevers 32 Chap. XXXII beleevers are to mourne for sin 32 33 Chap. XXXIII Antinomians deny that beleevers should crave pardon for sin or have any sense thereof 34 Chap. XXXIV Men boyling in their lusts without any humiliation foregoing are to beleeve say Antinomians 34 35 Chap. XXXV Spirituall poverty mistaken by Antino 35 36 Chap. XXXVI Repentance mistaken by Antinomians 36 Chap. XXXVII How good workes are necessary 37 38 Chap. XXXVIII The Gospell conditional and how 39 40 Chap. XXXIX Antinomian mortification rejected 43 44 Chap. XL. Antinomians the perfectists of the tyme. 43 Chap. XLI We are compleatly saved in this life say Antinomians 44 Chap. XLII Our happinesse in sanctification as well as in justification 45 46 Chap. XLIII Sanctification crushed by Antinomians 46 47 48 Chap. XLIIII All doubtings inconsistent with faith say Antinomians 49 50 Chap. XLV Antinomians Merit-mongers not we 50 51 Chap. XLVI There is grace inherent in us 52 53 Chap. XLVII We are not meere patients in acts of sanctification 53 54 55 Antinomians abet all reasoning câ—nsequences promises 57 58 59 Chap. XLVIII Beleevers cannot sinne against God but against men say Antinomians 60 61 How the justified are not obliged to eschew sinne according to the Antinomian way 61 Townes vaine objections tending to prove that good workes are not the way to salvation 61 62 63 Good workes are not necessary either by a necessity of meanes or of a command of God to Antinomians 62 63 How sanctification fitteth us for heaven 64 65 Chap. XLVI Antinomians free us from any obligation to Evangelick commands and exhortations to duties and say faith is the only thing commanded in the Gospell 65 66 Chap. L. How we are freed from the law in regard of sanctification as of justification 68 Chap. LI. Antinomians ignorant of Jewish law-service and of Gospel-obedience 69 70 Neither the Jewes under the Law nor we under the Gospell could ever buy the love of God ibid. The errour of the Jewes touching righteousnesse and the state of the Jewes confounded by Antinomians 70 71 Chap. LII That we are not freed from outward ordinances 73 74 Chap. LIII The necessity of outward Ordinances 75 76 Chap. LIV. What peace we may fetch from gracious performances 76 77. Peace with God not the same peace from our selves 77 78. What qualified performances can â—ottome peace 77 78 Antinomians reject all experiences 7â— 80 Antinomians condemne all experiences ibid. Chap. LV. How farre inherent qualifications and actions of grace can prove we are in the state of grace 81 82 Meere â—xternall performances prove nothing 62. To eye the actings of the Spirit and overlooke our selves is the surest arguing of a spirituall state 82 Keeping of the Commandements may prove to our owne Spirits that wee are in Christ. 82 83 Supernaturall acts may reciprocally prove one another 8â— Antinomians conspire with Papists to deny all evidences of our certainty of our being in Christ because all acts or qualifications or workes of sanctification may be called in question 86 87 88 Their certitude of faith being no lesse questionable 88 89 Good workes meanes not pillars of our assurance 90 91 Chap. LVI How duties and delight in them take us not off Christ 91 92. How they may be abused 93 Chap. LVII Of liberty purchased by Christ. 93 94 How we are freed from the Law how not 95 96 Magistrates cannot punish ill doers by the Antino way 100 101 Chap LVIII Antinomians teach that beleevers must not walke in their conversation as in the sight of God but must live by faith with God 101 102 Chap. LIX How justification is one indivisible act not successive as sanctification 104. and sins yet are daily pardoned 105 106 Chap. LX How sinnes are remitted before they be committed 106. Chap. LXI How faith justifieth 107. And Saltmarsh's arguments that Christ is not ours by faith 108 109 110. Answered The order of conversion and of justifying the sinner 111 112 Chap. LXII The Antinomians way and method of a sinners comming to Christ confuted 114 115 116 The abuse of preparations to merit Pelagianisme the abandoning of the practise of humiliation and sin sickenesse before we beleeve is presumptuous Antinomianisme 116 117 Chap. LXIII The law and the spirit subordinate not contrary 117 118 Saltmarsh a Familist 118 Chap. LXIV Antinomians differences betweene the law and the gospell confuted 119 120 Law-obedience did not win God to be our God 119 The authority of God a Law-giver and God a Father not contrary 120. The Gospell commandeth not any thing by the Antinomian way 121 122 The Gospel doth both command and perswade 122. Antinomians call obedience to God a miserable yoake ibid. How Law-rigor and Gospell-sweetnesse doe consist 123 Antinomians reject all arguing and logicall inferences of the Holy Ghost
in scripture and matters of faith 123 124 Though we be regnerate yet we need scripture-teaching 124 The written scripture not given to the flesh 124 125 Chap LXV The Gospel is a rare Covenant in al things 127 128 Chap. LXVI Antinomians errours touching the Covenant of grace 128 129. In the conditions thereof ibid. The time of it 129 130. And in the parties 130 131 Chap. LXVII Of legall and Gospell-conversion 131 How meere commands worke no change 132 133 Naturall men cannot propose a supernaturall end 134 Obedience at set houres not legall 135 136 Whether Covenants Vowes Promises be legall 136 137. What other things are legall 138 139 Chap. LXIX The dead and bastard faith of Antino 140 141 Faith and nothing commanded but only faith in the Gospell how true 140 141 Of Antinomian faith 143 144 Reason for immediate beleeving without all preparations 143 144 145. Taken off Who immediatly invited 144 145 146 Chap. LXX Faith not the onely worke of the Gospel as Antinomians say 148 149 Doing subordinate to sweet Gospell-attractions 149 The way to heaven not so short as Antinomians dreame 149 150 Chap. LXXI The justified obey not God by necessity of nature as the fire burneth 151 152 Chap. LXXII Glorifying of God in sanctification needfull 153 Of our active and passive glorifying of him 153 154 Chap. LXXIII Sanctification concurres as well as justification to make Saints 155 156 Chap. LXXIV The harmonious compliance of old Libertines Familists and Antinomians 157 158. In seventeene paralels to chap. LXXXVI p. 221 Antinomians with Libertines refute all personall mortification 158 159 Chap. LXXV Libertines Familists and Antinomians free us from all law 161 Chap. LXXVI Libertines and Antinomians deny all scripture 163 164. H. Nicholas maketh two words of God 164 165 Antinomians turne Perfectists with Libertines 166 167 The Fathers of old saved as we 167 Chap. LXXVII Antinomians and Libertines foule opinions touching God and the authour of sin 169 170 171 Chap. LXXVIII Libertines and Antinomians take away all sense or remorse of conscience for sin 172 173 Chap. LXXIX Libertines and Antinomians paralel beleevers with Christ incarnate 173 174 Chap. LXXX To follow sense and naturall inclination as a law is our rule say Libertines and Antinomians 174 175 Antinomians sin according to their owne lying sense and declaratively not truely not really and in the Court of God 175 176 Chap. LXXXI Antinomians plead for liberty to popery and to all Religions 177 178 Chap. LXXXII Libertines and Antinomians doubt of the resurrection and of the life to come 178 179. H. Nicholas and New England Familists teach the same 179 180 181 Chap. LXXXIII Familists Libertines Anabaptists go before Antinomians in denying all externall worship and obedience 181 182 183 Chap. LXXXIV M. Del Saltmarsh and Familists deny all outward Reformation scripture seales and ordinances 187 188 Del denies any worke of the spirit or conversion to God in the Old Testament with Socinians· 188 189. Del a Familist 180 181. Del a Libertine 193 194. He denies all lawes 195. Del a disciple of Muncer an Anabaptist 196 197. How ecclesiasticall reformation is spirituall 198 199 Del a Libertine in removing all the working of second causes 199 200 Dels arguments for onely internall reformation against all the Ministery and Ordinances of the Gospell as Swenckfeldians taught 201 202 Beleevers as spirituall as Angels saith Del What need then of preaching to them 204 205. Outward Reforming no more our duty then to redeeme the World 206 207 Del maketh Gods absolute decrees to destroy all the working of second causes 208 209. Del and Familists deny the scripture and contend for an internall enthysiasticall word 210 211 212 213 The middle way between Papists and Enthysiasts 216 217 218 Chap. LXXXV Libertines and Antinomians come neare to other in making God the author of sin 219 220 Chap. LXXXVI Libertines and Antinomians would have us doe nothing â—ecaâ—se God doth all things 221 Chap LXXXâ—II Antinomians refuted in saying that we make the actings of the Spiâ—it like to the acts of morall Philosophy and the differences between these two 222 223 224 225 Chap. LXXXâ—III That wee are tâ—uly righteous in the sight of God and yet sinners in our seâ—ves proved against Antinomians 225 226 227 228 Chap LXXXIX Antinomians are ignorant of faith to dreame that its faith to beleeve against sense that our sins are no sins 230 231 Chap. XC Antinomians free all converted or non-converted from obligation of obedience 233.234 Chap. XCI How and for whom Christ intercedeth for in heaven 234.235 Chap. XCII Antinomians contend for the faith of assurance and reject the faith of dependence 235 236 Chap. XCIII Antinomians deny the Law to be an instrument at all of our sanctification 236 237 Del with Libertines maketh the word and the Spirit all one 238 239 Errata Pag. 14. line penult for the r. that p. 15. l. 18. d p. 17. l. 5. till he made r. till he be made p. 21. l 17. r. from p. 44. l. ult for 4. r. 5. p. 50. l. 14. for and r. an p. 53. l. 37. for they r. there p 64. l. 3. d. in p. 99. l. 7. r. simply p. 101. l. 33. for none r. now p. 123 l. 4. r. claram p. 135. l. 32. r reatu p. 162. l. 25. a castro p. 194. l. 18. but. r. both p. 223. l. 25. for not be r. not to be p. 235. l. 11 forme to Scriptures and ordinances then r forme to Scriptures and ordinances Then p. 254. l. 5 for is r. as at Troas p. 268. in marg will it r. will have it p. 275. l. 3 r. yeelded 290. in mar r. 1 Cor. p. 307. l. 34. r. contrariety p. 316. l. 33 r. because Errata in the II. Part. Pag. 3. l. 12. who ever will have Christ. r. who ever will have Christ and pay not a penny p. 17. l. 18. r. makes p. 65. for Chap. XLVI r. Chap. XLIX p. 65. l. ult r. calleth p. 72. l. 17. r. giveth p. 83. l. 9. for hath r. have p. 96. l. 5. d. and. p. 159. l. 27. for glorification p. 80. l. 28. d. â—hen r. gloriation p. 199 l. 21. d. is 209. l. ult for them r. him p. 223. l. 15. r. in spicitis 236. l. 16. without was r. was without THE DISCENT OF ANTINOMIANS and FAMILISTS PART I. CHAP. I. The Originall of Antinomians and of other unclean Sects who have taught the same things not unlike to their blasphemies THOUGH out of doubt Antinomians have given signification of the first dawning of that Heresie in Paul the Apostles time Shall wee continue in sin that grace may abound Rom. 6.1 and Is the Law sin God forbid Rom. 7.7 and James his arguing against the dead faith voyd of good works Jam. 2. intimateth they were peeping up in his dayes and John hinteth at some denying signes of Justification Yet their Originall seems to be from the old Katharoi called Puritans who rose
For therefore also it is printed that every one who will or can read may peruse it least it should be conceived that it was penned only for your sake Since I am not able to disappoint Satan by any other meanes who still labours by writings to traduce or misconstrue both my person and opinions And truly I wonder exceedingly how it came to be imputed to me that I should reject the Law or ten Commandements there being extant so many of my owne expositions and those of severall sorts upon the Commandements which also are daily expounded and used in our Churches to say nothing of the Confession and Apology and other bookes of ours Adde hereunto the custome we have to sing the Commandements in two different tunes besides the painting printing carving and rehearsing them by children both morning noone and evening So that I know no other way then what we have used but that we doe not alas as we ought really expresse and delineate them in our lives and conversations And I my selfe as old as I am use to recite them dayly as a Child Word for Word so that if any should have mistaken what I had written he might seeing and feeling as it were how vehemently I use to urge these Catechisticall exercises in reason have beene perswaded to call upon me and demand these or the like questions What Good Doctor Luther dâ—'st thou presse so eagerly the ten Commandements and yet teachest withall that they must be rejected Thus they ought to have dealt with me and not secretly vndermine me behinde my backe and then to wait for my death that so they might afterwards make of me what themselves pleased Well I forgive them if they leave these courses Verily I have taught and still teach that sinners must be moved to Repentance by the preaching pondering of the sufferings of Christ that they may see how great the wrath of God is against sinne and that it cannot bee otherwise expiated but by the death of the sonne of God Which is not mine but St Bernards doctrine But why doe I mention St Bernard It is the doctrine of the whole Christian world and which all the Prophets and Apostles have delivered But how doth it hence follow that therefore the law must be taken away I finde no such inference in my Logick and I would gladly see or heare that Logician that would demonstrate the truth of this conclusion When Isaias saith chap. 35 I have smitten him for the sinnes of my people I pray tell me here Christs sufferings are preached that he was smitten for our sinnes Is the Law hereby rejected what is the meaning of these words For the sinnes of my people Is not this the sense of them Because my people have sinned against my law and not kept the same Or can it be imaginable that there should be any sinne where there is noe law Whoesoever abrogates the law must of necessity abrogate sinne allsoe If hee must suffer sinne to bee hee must much more suffer the being of the law For the Apostle saith Rom 5 Where noe law is there is noe sinne If there bee noe sinne then Christ is nothing For why died hee if there were no law nor sinne for which hee ought to die Hence you may see that the Devill intends by this Ghostly Gambold to take away not so much the law as Christ the fulfiller of the law For hee knowes too well that Christ may quickly lightly bee forgotten but the law being engraven in the bottome of the heart it is impossible to raze it out as you may observe in the complaints which are uttered by the blessed Saints of God in the Psalmes that are not able to undergoe the wrath of God which can be nothing else but the lively preaching of the law in their consciences And the Devil also is not ignorant of this that it is impossible the law should be taken out of the hearts of men as the Apostle prooves in his second chap to the Rom. v. 14 15. For when the Gentils which have not the law In the German Copie which received not the law by Moses do by nature the things contained in the Law they having not the Law are a Law to themselves which shew the work of the Law written in their hearts c. His maine plot therefore is to make people secure and to teach them to slight both law sin that when they are once suddainely overtaken either by death or in an evill conscience they might without any remedy sink into hell as having binâ— accustomed to all manner of sensuality and taught nothing else in Christ but a sweet security soe that when terrors of conscience seize on them they take it for a certaine signe that Christ who can be nothing but sweetnesse it selfe had reprobated and forsaken them This the Divell seekes and would faine compasse But it appears to mee that these fanatick spirits are of opinion that all those which attend the preaching of the word must needs be such Christians as are altogether without sinne wheras indeed they are such whose hearts are altogether sorrowfull and pensive such as feare God and feel their sins and therefore they ought to have comfort administred unto them For to such the love of Christ can never be made sweet enough but they still need more and more of it as I have found in experience in a great many to say nothing of my self But these teachers are themselves farre short of such Christians because they are so jocund and secure Much lesse their Auditors who likewise are as fearlesse and foole-hardy There is a godly Virgin an excellent singer who speaks thus in a certain Hymne He hath filled the hungry with good things but the rich he hath sent empty away Hee hath put down the Mighty from their seats and â—xalted them of low degree And his mercy is on them that fear him from generation to generation God cannot but be angry if there be any truth in the Magnificat with such spirits who are secure and dread nothing and such of necessity must those hold Bayards be which take away both law and sin Let mee therefore beseech you Good Mr Doctor to continue as hetherto you have in the pure doctrine and to preach that sinners can and must be drawne to Repentance not only by the sweetnesse of grace that Christ suffered and died for us but alsoe by the terrors of the Law For when they pretend that wee must follow but one kinde of Method in teaching the Doctrine of Repentance to wit that Christ suffered for us lest all Christendome should deviate from the true and onely way this is little to the purpose For it is our duty to improve all manner of means such as are divine Menaces Promises Punishments Blessings and what ever helps we can to bring men to Repentance I mean by all the Presidents in the word to bring them to the
acknowledgement of sin and of the Law Thus doe all the Prophets Apostles and Saint Paul Rom. 2. Knowest thou not that the goodnesse of God leads thee to Repentance But admit I had taught or said that the Law should not bee preached in the Church although the contrary be evident in all my writings and in the constant practise of my Catechising from the beginning why should men so stiffely adhere to me and not rather oppose mee who having ever taught otherwise were now revolted from my self even as I dealt with the Popes Doctrine For I will and may boast of it in truth that there is no Papist now adayes so conscientious and in such good earnest as once I was For those that now professe Popery doe it not for any feare of God as I a poore wretch was given over to doe but they seek somthing else as the world may see and themselves know I was faine to learn by experience what Saint Peter writes Crescite in cognitione Domini Nor doe I finde that any Doctor Councell or Fathers though I should distill their books and extract the quintessence out of them have on a sudden and in their first entrance perfected their Crescite Or that the word Crescite should be as much as perfectum esse For instance Saint Peter himself did learn his Crescite from Saint Paul Gal. 2. and Saint Paul from Christ himself who told him by way of incouragement Sufficit tibi gratia mea c. Good God! will not men endure it when the holy Church acknowledgeth her sins beleeves the remission of sins askes in the Lords Prayer the forgivenesse of sins But how come we to know what sin is if there be no Law nor conscience And where shall we learn what Christ is and what he hath done for us if we could not know what the Law is which he hath fulfilled or what sin is for which he hath satisfied And though we should not stand in need of the law for our part but could pull it out of our hearts which yet is impossible notwithstanding there is a necessity of preaching it in respect of Christ which also is done and must be done that the world may know what he hath either done or suffered for us For who could know what and wherefore Christ hath suffered for us if no body could tell what sin was or the law I conclude therefore that the Law will wee nill we must be preached if we mean to preach Christ though we should not use the word Law For doe what you can the conscience will be terrified by the Law when it is told that Christ was to fulfill the Law for us at so deare a rate Why therefore should any goe about to abolish it when it cannot be abolished Yea when by the abolition of it it is the more firmely established and deeper rooted For the Law terrifies farre more dreadfully when I am told that Christ the Son of God must necessarily satisfie the same for me then if without Christ and such great torments of the Son of God it had been preached to me with bare threatnings For in the Son of God I really see the wrath of God which the Law declareâ— but verbally and with farre lesse operation and efficacy Alasse that my own friends should thus molest me I have enough to doe with Papists I might say almost with Job and Jeremiah O that I never had been born Yea I might almost say O that I had never appeared in Books I did not care but would be content if all of them were already perisht And that the works of such haughty spirits might be sold in all Book-sellers shops which is that indeed they would have that so they might be satiated with their goodly vain-glory Againe I must not count my selfe better then our Lord Jesus Christ the Master of the house who complaines once and againe In vain I have laboured and spent my strength in vain But it is so the devill is lord in the world and I could never be brought to beleeve that the devill was the Master and God of this world till I found by a pretty deale of experience that Princeps Mundi Deus hujus soeculi was also one of the Articles of Faith Howbeit the children of men still remain in their unbeliefe and I my self but weakly beleeve it For every one is in love with his own way and all perswade themselves that the devill sure lives beyond Sea and that they carry God in their pocket But for the godly which desire salvation wee must live preach write doe and suffer all things Otherwise if you regard the devill and false brethren it were better to preach and to write nothing at all but presently to dye and to be buryed For doe what you can they will be still perverting and traducing all things and raise meere Scandals and mischiefes according as the devill doth ride or lead them There is no remedy but we must and will fight and suffer We must not thinke to faire better then the blessed Prophets and Apostles which were used as we are They have invented to themselves a new Method which is that the doctrine of Grace should be preached in the first place afterwards the revelation of wrath that by no means forsooth the word Law might be heard or spoken of This is a curious Crotchet wherein they might please themselves imagining that they can turne and winde the whole Scripture as they list that so they may be Lux mundi But S. Paul must and shal be that light Rom. 1. These men see not how the Apostle teacheth that which is directly opposite to their tenents denouncing first the wrath of God from Heaven and making all the world to be sinners and guilty before God When he hath made them so then he teacheth further how they may obtaine Grace and be justified and this the 3 first Chapters mightily and clearely evince But is it not a singular blindnes folly of theirs to conceit that the manifestation of wrath must be something else beside the law which cannot possibly bee For the manifestation of wrath is nothing else but the Law where it is acknowledged and felt according to that of the Apostle Lex iram operatur And have they not now bravely hit it when in abrogating the Law they teach it againe by teaching the Revelation of wrath But thus they preposterously put the Cart before the Horse teaching the Law after the Gospell and wrath after grace But what foule errors the Devill drives at by those jugling Gypsies I discerne in part well enough but cannot now stand to discusse them And because I hope they will proceed no further it shall not need It hath been a speciall peice of pride and presumption in those men that they would bring something to light that is new and singular that the people might say Heâ—r's a brave fellow indeed Here 's another Paul Have they
and who is for ever Qâ—i venturus est in soecula And what we now say of our selves in this point the same also our Progenitors were forced to say according as the Psalmes and other Scriptures testify Yea our posterity will even experiment the same and must sing with us and the whole Church the 124 Psalme If God were not with us now may Israel say c. O! What a lamentable thing is it that we should have so many dreadfull examples before us of such men who were so highly conceited of themselves as if they had been the only pillars to support the Church and as if the Church had been founded upon them and yet see to what a shamefull end they were brought at last Yet these terrible judgements of God cannot abate our pride and daring nor make us lowly and humble What is befalne Muncer in our time to say nothing of Elder and former ages who was perswaded that the Church could not subsist without him but that hee might beare and rule her And of late the Anabaptists have warned us with a vengeance to remember how puissant and neerely advancing that specious Devill is and how perilous it is to have such gallant thoughts of our selves Let us be wise at last and learne when we enterprize any thing first to look according to the counsell of Isaiah into our hand whether it be God or an Idoll whether it be gold or clay But all this availes not for we still remain secure without feare or care We can put the devill farre from us and beleeve not that there is such a body of flesh in us as Saint Paul complaines Rom. 7. That he could not doe that which he would and that he was led captive For we forsooth are those Heroick Champions that need not feare our flesh and thoughts but we are all Spirit and have wholly captivated both flesh and devill so that whatsoever we think or is cast into our mindes that must be a certain truth and infallibly the Holy Ghost How can it be otherwise Therefore what other fine Catastrophe could be lookt for at last but that both horse and rider must break their necks But enough of those lamentations The Lord Christ be and remain our Lord Christ blessed for ever Amen I conceive without failing against charity I may say that Eislebius after the death of Luther returned to his vomit and recanted his recantation upon these reasons First because I think we may credit Osiander his testimony who saith in his old age he turned Epicure An vero ante mortem ad meliorem mentem redierit affirmare nequeo Audivi tamen eum etiam in provecta admodum aetate homini Epicuraeo quà m pio Theologo fuisse similiorem Lucas Osiander Epit. hist. Ecclesiast â—entur 16. l. 3. p. 802. Deâ—to Agric Eislebi Printed at Wittingburgh by Joseph Klug an 1539. that is Whether or no Eislebius before his death repented of his heresie I dare not affirm but I heard by report in his old age that he lived more like a voluptuous Epicure then a Godly Divine 2 The Divines of Eisleben in their large confession published an 1560 say that after Luthers death he againe defended his error in his publicke writings So Schlusserburg Catalo heretick l. 4. pag. 36 37. 3 he declined to publish in writing his owne recantation as Luther desired him but shifted the businesse and layd it upon Luther to do it though he was a learned man and able to doe it himselfe How ever Osiander is so farre from thinking that Luther favoured the Antinomian way that he saith he believes that there was not any that held the opinion of Antinomians and though Luther have hard phrases in his Comment on Galathians yet Osiander saith Cent 16. l. 2. c. 29. pag. 314. That a sinner broken in Spirit should not heare the Law condemning sinnes but should turne his eyes to Christ who healteh the broken in heart Luther was a man much exercised in conscience and writes much from his owne experience especially in his Commentary on the Epistle to the Galatians Therefore I purpose God willing further to vindicate Luther in all his writings from the Antinomian error when I have further from Schlusselburgius Sleidan and Osiander cleared the errors of Eislebius and his that the Reader may see that they are the very errors of present Antinomians and Familists 1 The Law is not worthy to be called the Word of God 2 When thou art in the midst of sin only beleeve and thou art in the midst of salvation 3 The Law of God belongeth to the Cours or Benches of Civil Iudges to men-ward not to the pulpit or conscience to God-ward 4 Men are not to be prepared for the Gospel or conversion by the preaching of the Law 5 Who ever have to doe with Moses goe straight to the Devill 6 In the Gospell nothing now should be spoken of violating of a Law But onely of the offending of the sonne of God 7 To heare the word and thinke of it in the heart is the proper consequence of the Gospel 8 Peter understood not Christian liberty 9 To make our Calling and Election sure by good workes is needlesse 10 If you think the Church should be so governed as men must be sober holy good chast now yee have erred from the Gospell 11 The Law teacheth not good workes nor is the Law to be preached that wee may doe good workes but only the Gospell 12 The Law and Moses cannot shew us the true God 13 Christians are not to be rebuked by the Law 14 Our faith and New-Testament-religion was unknowne to Moses 15 Good workes profit nothing to salvation Ill workes tend not to damnation 16 Christians with all their good workes belong to the Devill 20 The Holy Ghost converteth by himselfe not by the Law nor convinceth he the conscience of sin 21 A beleever is above all law and all obedience 22 The Legall Preachings of the Prophets belong nothing to us 23 We should not use these phrases A Christian conversation a christian obedience good workes of christians 24 The law good workes new obedience belong not to the Kingdome of Christ but to the world as Moses and the Popes supremacy belongs thereunto So Saltmarsh Christ is our new obedience and our mortification by imputation 25 We should so live as Iewes Anabaptists and others should see no good workes in us 26 The law onely without the Gospell reveales not sin in its greatnesse and deformity 27 The Gospell only argueth the contempt of a mediator 28 Paulus Crellius the Antinomian prop. 85 Negant nostra ecclesiae 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 vocabulum evangelij se generaliter in hac disputatione pro corpore doctrinae accipere tam legem quam evangelium It is true the Law in its rigour condemning and cursing and denying righteousnesse or justification to a sinner is no part of the Gospel as the Gospel is the pure doctrine of free
justification in Christs alone imputed righteousnesse nor can the law as it curseth and condemneth justifie or convert the soule but sure what ever Antinomians say on the contrary The Law of the Lord converteth the soule Psal. 19.7 that is the law in the hand of Christ and spiritualized with a Gospell-Spirit converteth which is not to be taken as M. Towne dreameth asser pag. 42. The Law is established in our sanctification but that is in the inward Spirit not in the outward letter for he and Antinomians imagine that we fulfill and obey the law because the Spirit immediately and irresistibly draws us and acts on us as on blocks and that we are not to obey God and abstain from sin out of conscience to the written Law Thou shalt not kill but so all we doe must be will-service wanting all warrant of one letter of the word contrary to Rom. 14.23 These Antinomians descended to a more subtle and finer way of the Laws use they said it was no question but the just man or beleever having received the Holy Ghost doth every thing of the Law and lawfully useth the Law to discipline and represse those that were politically or in a Theologicall consideration unjust or unregenerate or to terrifie and punish their owne flesh or unrenewed part which Towne with them sayes is under the Law and is no better said they then the flesh of the unjust for none on earth keeps the Law but the beleever by the Spirit of Christ for he by faith establisheth the Law In this the old Antinomians are not so grosse as new Antinomians for I make it good in this Treatise that whereas old Antinomians said caro justorum non est melior carne injustorum the flesh and unrenewed part of beleevers is no better then the flesh of unbeleevers and so the Adulteries and murthers of the one are sins as well as the murthers of the other Our Antinomians as Saltmarsh say the Scripture calleth us ungodly and sinners and children of wrath not that we are so but seem so or not so in Gods account but in the worlds then by good Logick the flesh the sins the murthers of the beleever are but seeming sins and sins in the worlds false account not in Gods just and true account Yea they are as clean saith Eaton from sin as Jesus Christ and as Saltmarsh saith as the glorified in heaven and they are sins saith Deâ— to men ward and in the conversation but not to Godward or in the conscience that is right downe they are no sins at all The question is said the old Antinomians whether or no there be a law given to the just man or the new man that is whether or no doth the Law teach the new man or the unrenewed part to doe good works and require them of him or doth it teach him that he must doe good works as a meere patient or doth he without the Law urging teaching commanding doe the Law being created in Jesus Christ to good works or more shortly whether is the Law a meere patient toward a just man or is it active in teaching ruling regulating of him in doing of good works for to teach rule exact require command doe all import some activity or is the law proposed as a teacher and commander onely to the flesh or to the unrenewed part of a beleever this is the cardo hinge of the controversie say they Saltmarsh saith We being once justified have no need of one beam of light from the Law to teach us no more then the world has need of the first dayes light of the creation or of a candle when the Sun is risen and Towne saith the Law in teaching ruling or commanding is a meere patient that is the Morall Law is as close abolished in teaching us what we shall doe as the Ceremoniall Law now if the Spirit should teach us to be circumcised and to keep the Ceremoniall Law that Spirit should be judged to be Enthysiasticall and not of God for the Apostle saith the contrary Gal. 5.1 and calleth it a falling from Christ if then the Spirit teach us to honour our Parents not to kill whereas the Law teacheth us no more that we should doe such a duty then the Law teacheth us to be circumcised or then if a Candle-light should show us what is black we are to beleeve it is so and the light of the sun show the contrary we were to beleeve that black is not black so if the Spirit teach the Mother to kill her childe and offer it in a sacrifice to God because it was baptized as an Anabaptist mother in Dover lately hath done the mother is to beleeve and follow the light of that spirit contrary to the expresse law and the law is by this way a meere patient and the beleever freed from the direction of the sixt Commandement Thou shalt not murther for the teaching ruling commanding thereof are activities and yet is the Law a meere patient to the regenerate part so the womans regenerate part killed the child and sinned not in so doing for the regenerate part say they is under no Law and the Antinomians who did chide with the Minister because he convinced the Mother of sinning against the sixt Command in killing her own childe said right Why speak yee to the beleeving Mother of the Law the Law doth not rule nor teach the regenerate part and she hath killed the childe according to the Spirits dailight and the regenerate part not according to the Laws star-light and the flâ—sh speak say they to her of free grace So Michael Neander a grosse Antinomian wrote in an Epistle to a friend in his time To the just man there is no Law given in any use or office as he is just and liveth in the Spirit as he is one with Christ and converseth in heaven where there is no law that acts in a just man the just dialect of the English Antinomian Towne pag. 129. asser of grace Being Iustified by faith we are admitted to the favour and presence of God there to live and abide for ever here by sense and light in the kingdome of glory c. and Saltmarsh speaketh in the same Grammer as if the beleever were at the right hand of God and the old Antinomians said in the words of Towne read his words the justified man as Schusselburgius relateth their minde is holy just neither male nor female but one with Christ flesh of his flâ—sh and bone of his bone and the same by grace faith and imputation that Christ is by nature in whom Christ liveth speaketh worketh all things for all the workes of the just man are the workes of Christ and he is the meere passive matter of these workes Therefore all the doctrine of love good workes and new obedience which Christ and the Apostles give after the doctrine of justification is given only for the unjust man
be sweetly handled and ought not to be terrified with examples of Gods wrath but Paul teacheth another thing 2 Tim. 2.3 when he saith The Scripture is profitable to rebuke to correction So Saltmarsh Crisp Den Del Town Randel preach a honey Gospel and a short cut to heaven and exclude all gall and vinegar from the law Let 's not fall to the madnes of Antinomians who remove the law out of the Church as if they were all holy that are in the Church the world loves such teachers and say preach to us pleasant things Antinomians teach that all sinnes are simple taken away and are not to be rebuked and that because they are pardoned and damnation is removed and sin is nothing so Honey-combe c. 3. p. 23. Saltm free grace 140. Towne asser gr 71.72 Beleevers are as cleane from all sinnes as Christ or the glorified Saints pardoned sin is no sin God cannot see adulteries to be sinnes in them 2 Conclusion Luther saith for justification the law is unpossible but it s given to show sin to worke wrath and to make the conscience guilty But lay aside the matter of justification saith he no man can too highly commend good workes commanded of God and Its necessary that Godly teachers presse as diligently the doctrine of good workes as of faith Satan is angry at both and resisteth with all his strength both k Faith onely is not sufficient and yet only faith justifieth for if it be true faith it obtaineth the spirit of love This Spirit fullfilleth the law and obtaineth the kingdome of heaven Except faith be without the least good workes it justifieth not yea it is not faith it is impossible that faith can be without assiduous and great good workes Faith justifieth not as our worke but as a worke of God for the promise is a worke of God not our worke in which we doe or give something to God but in which we receave something from God and that through his mercy Thou holdest in thine hand seeds of divers kinde but I aske not what seeds are conjoyned with these or these seeds but what is the proper vertue of every seed in this case shew plainly what faith it 's alone doth in justification but not with what other vertues it is conjoyned faith it alone apprehendeth the promise beleeveth God promising and puts to its hand and receaveth something that God promiseth this is the proper worke of faith only Love hope patience have objects about the which they worke and other bonds within which they consist for they embrace not the promise but fulfill the commandements So Luther in the matter of justification putteth reproach on good workes just as Paul Phil. 3. maketh all his priviledges and his very workes of righteousnesse that he doth by the grace of Christ dung and losse in the comparison of imputed righteousnesse Workes saith he cannot be taught except yee hurt faith seeing faith and workes in the matter of justification are extreamely contrary so that the doctrine of works must necessarily be a doctrin of Devils and a departure from faith Pernitiosi Doctores sunt qui hodie nescio quibus occasionibus adducti contendunt legem in ecclesiâ non praedicandam Tu legem non doceres ubi verus legis populus est scilicet avari supeâ—bi adulteri usurarii Idololatrae In Antinomorum dogmate erat haec propositio sigâ—is esset adulter tantum ut crederet se habitu rum Deum propitium Sed qualis quaeso Ecclesia in quâ tam horribilis vox sonat faciendum discrimen erat docendum quod adulteri sâ—u peccatores duplices sunt quidam qui agnoscunt adulterium seâ— pâ—ccatum suum alii securè indulgent Quomodo predicatio legis potest as debet ex Ecclesiâ ejici nonne simul excludis timorem Dei maximam partem operum Dei Luth. tom 2. in Ge. Antinomi novi isti prophetae contendunt homines tractandos suaviter nec terrendos irae divinae exâ—mplis sed diversum Paulus dicet 2 Tim. 2.3 Vbi dicet scripturam utilem ad objurgandum ad castigandum Ne in Antinomorum insaniam inâ—idamus qui legem ex Ecclesia tollunt quasi vero in ecclesia ommes siâ—t sancti mundus quidem tales doctores amat sicut apud Hierem. dicunt loquerâ— nobiâ— placentia Antino docent omnia peccata sublata nec arguenda esse nec homines terrendos lege pescatum esseremissum nibil damnationis igitur peccatum est nihil et prorsus sublatum Lex non tantum non est necessaria ad justificationem sed plane inutilis et impossibilis sed data est ut peccatum ostendat iram operetur hoc est conscientiam ream faâ—it Extra causam iustificationis nemo potest bona opera a Deo praecepta satis magnifice praedicare Aeque necessarium est ut pij doctores tam diligenter urgeant doctrinam de bonis operibus quám doctrinam de fide Satan enim utrique sensus est et acerrimé resistit Non sufficit sola fides et tamen sola fides iustificat quia si vera est impetrat spiritum charitatis sic legem implet et regnum Dei consequitur fides nisi sit sine ullis etiam mini mis operibus non iustificat impossibile est fidem esse sine assiduis et magnis operibus Fides justificat non tanquam opus nostrum sed tanquam Dei opus promissio enim non est nostrum opus cum nos Deo facimus aut damus aliquid sed accipimus aliquid a Deo idque tamen per ipsius miserecordiam Texes manu varia semina non autem quero ergo quae cum quibus conjuncta sint sed quae cuiusque propria virtus hic aperâ—e die quid faciat sola fides non cum quibus virtutibus conjuncta fit sola enim fides apprehendit promissionem credit promittenti Deo Deo porrigenti aliquid manum â—â—mâ—vet et id accipit hoc proprium solius fidei opus est charitaâ— â—pes patientia habent alias materias circa quas versaâ—tur habent alios limites intra quos consistant non enim amplectuntur promissionem sed mandata exequuntur Opus non potest doceri nisi laedas fidem cum fides opera in re justificationis extreme adversantur ita a fit ut doctrina operum necessario sit doctrina daemoniorum et discessio a fide Luther speaketh so of Good workes only in the matter of justification But our Antinomians speake so of the whole course of sanctification in order to heaven and as they are the way to the Kingdome not the cause of the crowne as both they follow the person already justified and as they goe before him who is yet to be justified for Crispe saith vol 1. ser. 4 pag. 89. But withall I must tell you that all
this sanctification of life is not a jot the way of that justified person to heaven I perswade my selfe Luther had an eye to Antinomians when he said 〈◊〉 feared after his death that the doctrine of the true office of the law should be obscured Luther to 3. fol. 102 admoneo pietatiâ— amatores praecipue qui aliquando sunt futuri doctores ut diligentèr ex Paulo disâ—â—â—t intelligere verum et proprium usum legis qui ut timeo post tâ—mpora nostra interim obscurabitur et prorsus obruetuâ— to 4.106 timeo quod ista doctrina de vero legis usu nobis extinctiâ—â—bscurabitur 3 Conclusion Luther saith the New man needeth no law it s the flesh the old man the body of sin that is under the Law The law in a Christian ought not to exceed his bounds and ought onely to have dominion over the flesh which is subject to it and remaineth under it but oh law wilt thou invade the conscience and exercise dominion there and accuse the conscience of a justified beleever none terrified of sin and take away the joy of heart thou dost this beyond thy office When I behold Christ I am all holy and pure knowing nothing of the Law as it curseth and condemneth the beleever but if I behold my flesh I finde avarice lust wrath pride feare of death sadnes horror hatred murmuring and impatience against God in so farre as these are present Christ is absent or if he be present he is weakely present here there is need yet of a paedagogoe who should exercise and vex this strong asse the flesh that by this paedagogue sinnes may bee diminished and a way prepared for Christ. Luther Lex in Christiano non debet excedere limites suos sed tantum dominum habere in carnem quae et ei subiecta sit et sub ea maneat hoc ubi fit lex consistit intra suos limites lex si tu vis ascendere in regnum conscientiae et ibi dominari loquitur de conscientia hominis justificati sub tentationibus terrefacta et eam arguere peccati et gaudiâ—m cordis tollere hoc praeter officium tuum facis Si Christum inspicio totus sanctuâ— et purus sum nihil plane sciens de lege Si vero meam carnem inspicio sentio avaritiam libidinem iram superbiam timorem mortis tristitiam pavorem odium murmurationem et impatientiam contra Deum quatenus ista adsunt catenus abest Christus aut si adest infirme adest hic opus est adhuc paedagogo qui fortem asinum carnem exerceat et vexet ut hac paedagogia minuantur peccatâ— et Christo via paretur I grant the Antinomians now as Town Saltmarsh Den and the old Antinomians in Luthers time spoke after the same Grammer and stile and so did the Libertines in Calvins time say non ego pecco sed Aâ—inus meus It s not I that transgresse the law and am under the law but my asse But they have a farre other minde then Luther for the Antinomians as Schlusfelburgius saith cato heriti l 3. p. 53 54. taught that the flesh only and the unrenewed man was under the law but the renewed and justified man was under no law more then if it had beene never given to him and the law was no rule of life and obedience to a beleever Luther cryeth against this as most false and Luther saith those that beleeve in Christ must be daily mortified by daily Law-rebukes and arguenda sunt peccata et proponenda ira dei propter incredulos qui in ecclâ—sia sunt imo etiam propter credentes ne adhaerescenti peccato et innatae imbicillitati indulgeant lex manet inquit ante evangelium et justificationem in justificatione et post justificationem Luther verum tunc amplius non sunt opera legis sed Christi in nobis per fidem operantiâ— et viventis per omnia ideo non possunt sunt Mogis omitti quam ipsa fides nâ—c sunt minus necessaria quam ipsa fides Caeterum opera legalitâ—r perfecta quae verè sunt legis ficta et falsa sunt Good workes saith Luther are not any more the workes of the law compelling under the paine of damnation for he saith in the same place libere et gratis facienda sunt but workes of Christ working in us by faith and every way living in us therefore they can no more be omittted then faith it selfe and are no lesse necessary then faith it selfe Observe this in reading Luthers works that he taketh the law as opposed to justifieing grace and as it may condemne or justifie and so as an instrument of the Covenant of works exacting perfect obedience in a legall sence otherwise neither Luther nor any of our Divines will say good works absolutely perfect and in all things conforme to the Law are necessary to salvation for it is false all beleevers are saved by faith in Christ without any such good workes or perfect legall obedience Then we must hold this to be Luthers minde that if good workes be commanded to the renewed man in the law as well as faith and be as necessary as faith then the renewed part is under the law commanding good workes as well as it is under the command of faith but Luther saith the former Antinomi say nothing sins but the flesh nothing is under the law but the flesh so nothing is under a command and an obleiging rule of law or Gospell to doe good workes and beleeve but the flesh a senselesse untruth For it is the new man by the Spirit of Christ saith Luther from the word of truth that doth good workes and beleeveth So Luther to 4. fol. 499 in Psal. 130. 2 and excellently saith Luther to 1 fol. 436 Christiana lâ—bertas est quando non â—utata legâ— mâ—taâ—tur homines ut lâ—x eadem quae prius libero arbitrio odiosaâ—uit iam defusa per spiritus saâ—ctâ— charitatem cordibus nostris iucunda fiat Hence Luther saith two things that contradicts the Antinomians 1. The Law is not changed when the sinner is changed but that which was hatefull to free will before is the same law but now sweet and pleasant to the heart then if the law be not so much as changed it is not abolished to the beleever it s made of hatefull pleasant 2. That Law that is pleasant to the heart and sweet it is not given to the flesh and unrenewed part but especially to the renewed part 3 The renewed part in the beleever doth either do good workes by the grace of Christ and so keepe the law though unperfectly or not doe good workes at all If the latter be said the renewed part is not renewed but dead and is the very old man which is a contradiction but if thâ— former be said that it is the new man or renewed part that
doth good works in the believer then the new man either doth thâ—se good works contrary to the law which is non-sense for to be mercifull sober just true chast are agreable not contrary to the law or the new man doth good workes without the law and so without the word of either Law or Gospell this is will-service to God and separateth the Spirit from the word and is a high way to legittimate murther adulteries paricides under the veil of the Spirits working and leading without the word if the new man worke according to the law then is the law a rule and what the new man doth according to a ruling law he doth it ex debito out of obligation then must the new man be under this law and obligation as a rule nor can it be said that the flesh doth good workes for Paul saith in his flesh there dwelleth no good nor can it be said the new man worketh not according to the law but according to the Gospel because the Gospel as distinguished from the Law sheweth us credâ—nda non facâ—â—nda what we should beleeve not what we should doe 4 the new man worketh by love the flesh worketh not by love but love is the fulfilling of the law Ro. 1â— 8 9. Ga. 5.14.18.19 24. Ga. 6.2 thâ—n must the new man be under the debt of love and so under the law as an obleiged rule and to this Luther â—eâ—reth witnesse Sponte faciunt quod lex requirit fide enim Spiritum receperunt qui non siâ—it eoâ— esse otiosos si caro resistit Spiritu ambulent Sic Christianus implet legem fide Christus enim perfectio legis est ad salutem omni credenti fâ—ris operibus et remissione peccatorum intus But our Antinomians meane that there is no indwelling sinne in beleevers they are as cleane as Christ from all sinne as the glorified in heaven that God can see no sin in beleevers because there is no sin in them he cannot be displeased with them for sinne because it is not forgiven sinne is no sin it hath no being before God it s but a seeming sin not really and to faith 3 But Antinomians as Towne asser pag 77 78. Salt free grace pag. 140 44 45. Eaton Hony-com c. 11.322 teach that all the naturall civill and religious workes of beleevers as well as their persones are made perfect and conforme to Gods law then Christ cannot bee absent in any measure nor weakely present as Luther saith nor have they need of the paedagogie of the law to make way to Christ. Beleevers of their own accord doe what the Law râ—quireth for by faith they have receaved the Spirit that suffereth them not to be idle if the flesh resist they walke in the Spirit so a Christian fulfilleth the Law of God by faith for Christ is the end of the Law for salvation to every one that beleeveth he fulfilleth the law without by good works and remission of sins within 2 Luther Meaneth that the flesh the asse in beleevers truly sinneth and violateth the Law and bringeth the beleever under condemnation if God would enter into judgement with them so as God seeth sinne adultery in David to be sinne denying of Christ in Peter to be sinne and hateth it and is displeased with it and beleevers have carnem peccatricem a sinning sinne in them Luther Tom. 2. c. 18. fol. 119 pride avarice murmuring against God and in so farre as they have these in them Christ is not in them To 4. fo 114. 3 Luther in these words expresly saith the justified man is not perfect nor are his workes perfect because the sinne of them is pardoned quatenus ista avaritia libido superbia c. adsunt Christus abest aut si adest iâ—firme adest hic opus est adhuc paedagogo qui fortem asinum carnem excerceat et vexet in so farre as there is sinne in the beleever Christ is absent or if he be present he is weakely present c. and hath need of the paedagogie of the law 3 Conclusion Taking the Law simply as the Law and an instrument of the covenant of workes exacting by Law-compulsion perfect obedience without a Mediator and that under the strictest penalty of eternall wrath for the least breach as it is opposed to the Gospell which is a milder King and taking the conscience not in its latitude as it is in both the beleever and the unbeleever but as it is in the beleever renewed and withall troubled and terrifyed with the sense of sinne so the Law as Luther saith is abrogated and hath no dominion over the renewed man or the renewed conscience to condemne it but only over the old man and the sinning and lusting flesh to chase the beleever to a more strict closing with Christ and arguing and convincing him of too reall and true sinning not of seeming and imaginary offending against a Law as Antinomians dream so is Luther to be taken Lex justo non est posita sie enim vivit ut nullà lege opus habeat quae eum admoneat urgeat â—ogat â—ed sine ullà coactione legis sponte facit quae lex exigit Idâ—o lex non potest accusare reos agere credentes in Christum nec enim conscientias perturbare terret quidem accusat sed Christus fide apprehensus aâ—igit â—am cum suis terroribus minis Itaque lex iis simpliciter abrogata est non igitur habet jus accusandi eos Sponte enim faciunt quod lex requirit Luther ingrediendum est igitur Regia vià ut neque legem plaâ—e rejiciamus neque plus ei tribuamus quam â—portet Luther Ante Christum lex est sancta post Christum est mors Ideo ubi Christus venit justificans impium nihil simpliciter scire debemus de lege nisi quatenus imperium habet in carnem quam coercet premit Luther lex etiam dedecalogi sine fide in Christum est mortifera non quod lex mala sit sed quod justificare non possit quia plâ—â—e contrarium habet effectum Luther Legis câ—geâ—tia condâ—mnantis proprium officium est nos reos facere humiliare occidere adinferâ—um dâ—ducere omnia nobis auferre sed illo fine ut justificemur non ergo simpliciter occidit sed ud vitam occidit Luther Dominetur saâ—e lex in corpus veterèm hominem is sit sub legâ— hâ—ic praescribat lex quid facere quid perferre debet cubile enim in quo Christus sâ—lus quiescere dâ—rmire debet non contaminet id est novum hominem nullo suo usu aut officio perturbet Luther Fatemur justis non esse pâ—sitam legem quatenâ—â— justâ— sunt spiritu vivunt sed quatenus in câ—rne sunt corpus peccati habent esse sub lege facere
prorsus cogitare nosse debet nisi unicum Christum acsummis viribus adnitatur ut tum legem quam longissime è conflâ—ctu abjiciat Extra locum justificationis debemus cum Paulo reverenter sentire de lege eam summis laudibus evehere appellare sanctam bonam justam spiritualem divinam â—ebemus extra conscientiam facere ex ea Deum in conscientia verò est verè Diabolus A man a beleever terrified in conscience and under the despairing apprehensions of wrath doth never sin more horribly then in that article of time when he beginneth to feele and understand the Law in its condemning power It s unpossible that Christ and the Law can dwell together in one soule for either must the Law or Christ yeeld the one to the other Luther Let us learne to distinguish these two righteousnesses that we may know how far we are to obey the Law for we said that the Law ought not to exceed its limits but only have dominion over the flesh of a Christian to shew that he is a sinner Saltmarsh saith free gr 145. he is but a seeming sinner say thou to the law stay within thy limits and exercise dominion over the flesh but come not neare my conscience to condemne me otherwise to obliege as a rule of obedience it doth where there is no Law It s the great skill and wisdome of Christians to be ignorant of the Law and workes and of all active righteousnesse especially when the conscience wrestleth with the justice of God as without the Church of God it is the great wisdome of God to know consider and presse the law works and active righteousnes To the Divell accusing thou art a sinner and therefore damned we may answer because thou callest me a sinner therefore I shall be just and saved yea thou shall de damned no for I flye to Christ who gave himselfe for my sinnes When the concience is terrified with the Law and wrestleth with the justice of God consult neither with naturall reason nor with the Law but lean only to free grace and the word of consolation and theâ—e thou mayest behave thy self as if thou hadst never heard any thing of the Law of God there thou mayest enter in darknesse where there shineth neither law nor reason but only the mirror of faith which may save thee without and beyond the Law the Law is also to be heard in the own time and place Luther A Christian hath nothing at all to doe especially under a temptation with the Law and sin in so far as he is a Christian he is above the Law and sin for he hath Christ the Lord of the Law inclosed in his heart as a ring hath a pearle indented in it therefore when the Law accuseth him and sin terrifieth him he beholdeth Christ who when he is apprehended by faith he hath with him the conquerour of the law sin death and hell who commandeth these that they hurt him not Extenuations of the Law are referred to the conflict of conscience Nor can we vilely and hatefully enough speake of the Law in this argument therefore the conscience in a true conflict ought to thinke of or know nothing but only Christ and with all its might endeavour to remove the Law as far as can be from the conflict Setting aside the case of justification we ought with Paul to thinke reverently of the Law and extoll it with great praises as holy good just spirituall divine and when the Law is out of the conscience we are to make a God of it but in the conscience it s the Devill Now Antinomians not only in the case of Justification debase the Law but they cry it downe as a rule of life they have nothing to doe with Moses and his Law or strict walking And where as Antinomians tell us the sinnes of beleevers are but sinnes to our sense and feeling or before men or sinnes in our conversation not really not before God not in our conscience not to faith they never learned this from Luther who expoundeth sense and faith a far other way For so Luther speaketh in a conflict of conscience we know by experience sense of sin wrath hell death hath dominion then we must say to the tempted Brother thou wouldst have a sensitive righteousnesse that is thou desirest to hâ—ve such a sense of righteousnesse as thou hast of sinne that shall not be but thy righteousnesse must goe beyond the sense of sinne and beleeve thou art righteous before God that that is thy righteousnesse is not visible or sensible but there is hope it shall bee revealed in its owne time Luther In certamiâ—e conscientiae experientiâ— doctiscimus fortitor dominatur sensus peccati irae dei mortis inferni-Ibi tum dicendum est tentato Tu frater vis habere iustititam sensitivam id est cupis ita sentire iustitiam ut peccatum sentis hoc non fiet Sed tua iustitia debet transcendere sensum peccati sperare te coram Deo justum esse hoc est â—ustitia tua non est visibilis non sensibilis sed speratur suo tempore revelanda Luther never denyed the sinnes of beleevers to be reall sins and that there was â—o more originall sinne dwelling in a beleever then in Christ as our grosse libertines doe But he forbiddeth the tempted to measure their owne condition as forlorne and hopelesse from sense because they feel sinne wrath hell death terrours of conscience but contrary to the sense of all this the weake soule must beleeve an invisible and spirituall righteousnesse and seek no sensitive righteousnesse as most men doe in conflicts of conscience Luther hath divers comfortable grounds of beleeving when the Law in its condemning power breakes in upon the conscience In cruce aliud peccatum invenio contra meum peccatum quod me accusat devorat peccatum scilicet aliud in carne Christi qui tollit peccatum mundi omnipotens est damnat devorat peccatum meum l Fateor me peccâsse sed peccatum meum quod peccavi damnatum est in Christo qui est peccatum damnans est autem peccatum illud damnans fortius damnato 2 Luther Sicut tutissimum est canem latrantem contemnere praeterire ita una vincendi ratio est contemnere rationes Satanae neque cum iis disputare diutius Textatus à Satana cum nullum evadendi modum sent is simpliciter claude oculos nihil responde commenda causam Deo Luther Sathan nihil minus ferre potest quam sui contemptum Hi sunt amplexus ejus quibus amplectitur sponsam prae impatientia amoris Luth. Non enim feram te O lex Tyrannum durum crudelem exactorem in conscientia mea regnare siquidem ea sedes est templum Christi filii Dei Qui possum esse sanctus cum habeam
of it selfe it hath not strength to bring righteousnes and newtraâ—ly its infirmity and poverty it selfe Luther Our merit by doing the Law is just nothing What can a cursed sinner ignorant of God dead in sinnes lyable to the judgement and wrath of God deserve therefore that is the only way of eschewing the curse to beleeve in God Thou O Christ art my sin and my curse or rather I am thy sin and thy curse thy death thy wrath of God thy hell on the contrary thou art righteousnesse blessing life the grace of God my heaven for the text saith clearly Christ was made a curse for us then wee are the cause why hee was made a curse yea wee are his curse Good workes are not to bee drawne to the article of justification as Monks doe s Wee grant wee must teach of good works and charity but in the owne time and place When the question is without the lists of this Article of Justification We say with Paul by Faith in Christ onely not by the workes of the law or charity we are jâ—st not that we reject works and charity as our adversaries say When then we are in this common place of justification wee reject and condemn works wee simply reject all laws and works of the Law Tota ratio justificandi quoad nos passiva est Active Lex est elementum infirmum egenum quia reddit homines infirmiores egentiores passive quia ipsa per se non habet vim opes justitiae donandae afferendae neutraliter est infirmitas paupertas ipsa Ergo meritum nostrum plane nullum est Quid enim mirerer maledictus peccator ignorans Dei mortuus in peccatis obnoxius irae judicio Dei Quare illa unica via est evadendi maledictionem credere certâ fiduciâ dicere Tu Christe es peccatum maledictum meum seu potius ego sum peccatum tuum maledictum tuum mors tua ira Dei tua infernus tuus Tu contra es justitia benedictio vita gratia Dei coelum meum Quare textus clarè dicit Christus factus est pro nobis maledictum Itaque nos sumus causa quod factus sit maledictum imo nos ipsius maledictum sumus Luther non sunt trahenda bona opera in articulum justificationis ut Monachi fecerunt s Concedimus docendum quoque de bonis operibus charitate sed suo loco tempore quando scilicet questio est de operibus extra hunc capitalem articulum Respondemus cum Paulo sola fide in Christum nos pronuntiari justos non operibus legis aut charitate non quod opera aut charitatem rejiciamus ut adversarii nos accusant Cum versamur in communi loco de justificatione rejicimus damnamus bona opera Our Antinomians point blanck to this in all the way to heaven condemne them so Crisp Saltmarsh say the onely work of the Gospel is faith Therefore the law is passive onely in the article of Justification in which article it condemneth compelleth curseth and so is just nothing and is passive in justifying but in binding the New man to obey and in laying on him a rule of life it is active We can then easily expone Luther The just man ought not to live well in regard of any compulsion of a legall curse that the law from which in Christ hee is delivered can inflict on him Neither standeth hee in need of the Law to teach him in a compulsory legall way to live well for hee liveth not well because the Law forcing and cursing and not furnishing Grace as the Gospel doth requireth that hee live well Justus non debet bene vivere sed bene vivit hoc est non obligatur compulsione legali vi condemnatoriâ legis quia nulla condemnatio iis qui sunt in Christo ibid. Nec indiget lege quae docet eum bene vivere Injustus autem debet nexu legalis condemnationis bene vivere quia non bene vivit quod lex requirit hoc totum urget ne ex lege opâ—ribus justifieri presumant c Luth. l. 1.451 In this regard Luther doubteth not to say that the Law is simply and absolutely abolished to a just man 2. That the law is not the law if it bee not a condemning law But hee taketh the law strictly as a covenant of Workes and as opposite to Grace as Paul doth Rom. 7. Yee are not under the Law but under Grace Then the law is absolutely abolished to a just man it hath no power to accuse them for they doe willingly what the law requireth The law is not given for this end to justifie but to discover sin terrifie accuse and condemne This is the fruite of the law when it is alone without the Gospel and the knowledge of grace that it leadeth men to despaire and finall impenitence The law without Christ and the Gospel is omnipotent Yea it s invincible omnipotency the conscience compared to it most weake and poore for its a tender thing so that except it bee strengthened it is terrified waxeth paile and despaireth for the least sin therfore the law in its proper use hath more strength and might then heaven and earth can comprehend so that one tittle or iota of the law can destroy whole mankinde By the law we have no helpe but the revealing and warning of our misery Luther Itaque lex eis simpliciter est abrogata non habet igitur jus accusandi eos Sponte enim faciunt quod lex requirit Luther non data est lex ut justificet sed ut ostendat peccatum terreat accuset condemuet Hic legis effectus est quando sola est sine evangelio cognitione gratiae ut adducat in desperationem finalem impaenitentiam Lex in suo usu est omnipotens imo est invinbilis omnipotentia ad quaÌ„ collata conscientia est infirmissima et pauperrima et enim tam tenera res ut propter leviss mum peccatum ita pavefiâ—t pallescat ut disperet nisi rursus erigatur Quare lex in proprio suo usu plus virium opum habet quam coelum terra comprehendere potest ita ut etiam unus apex unum iota legis totum genus humanum occidere possit Per legem non adiutorium sed nostri mali indicium monitorium habemus All this is true of the Law as a Covenant of works without Christ and the Gospel as Luther saith quando est sola siâ—e evangelio Tom. 1. in Gen. c. 3. f. 57. Then Luther thinketh that the Law conjoyned with the Gospel and as it is in the hand of Christ hath the beeing of the law and not such terrible effects 2. Luther acknowledgeth that the law as it condemneth is to be preached to beleevers that they may crucifie
come we by faith in Christ come suffering glorified Luther saith tom 1. p. 529. Non facta sed fidem patrum imitemur let us follow not the deeds but the faith of the Fathers Luther burnt offerings were not for justification but a sacrificed Oxe was a witnesse of grace and to speak so a working voyce of thankfulnesse or an handy or manuall gratitude by which the hand powred out thankfulnesse by reall words They beleeved in Christ to come we know he is come and gone to the father to prepare dwelling places for us Luther Abraham saw Christs day in faith and the spirit onely Luther the same Christ the same faith from Abâ—l to the end of the world and did reigne in divers ages of the world Antinomians as Den Crisp Saltmarsh Del deny any heart-Reformation true conversion to God actuall remission of sins and of all sins or free justification by free grace in a Gospel-way to the Jews under Moses as we are justified and saved under the Messiah and make the promises and covenant of grace with Papists and Sâ—â—inians to differ in substance and nature from our Gospel-promises and free covenant as if their law tutory Gal. 4. had varied the way of Justification and salvation to them and to us CHAP. XII Of Christian Liberty and of sense true and false 10 Conclusion Antinomians have not Luther for them in the Doctrine of Christian Liberty Luther Vnusquisque Christianus sciat sâ— per Christum constitutum esse in conscientia dominum legis peccati mortis contra scâ—at quoque hanc servitutem externam corpori suo impositam ut per charitatem serviat pâ—oprio Qui autem aliter intelligunt libertatem c. Luther Omnia sunt libera nobis per fidâ—m omnia serva per charitatem ut simul stet servitus libertatis et libertas servitutis Libertas Evangelii non tollit res corpora debitâ— nominum sed conscientias liberat a vinculis spiritualibus Luther Christianus in conscientia debet esse medicus in externis moribus debet esse asinus Per fidem Christi non sumus liberi ab operibus sed ab opinionibus operum id est a stultâ praesumptione justitiae per opera quesitae Let every Christian know that by Christ he is made in his conscience as he beleeveth in Christ the Lord of law sin death so that these have no power over him On the contrary let him know that this externall servitude is laid on the outward man that by love he is to serve his neighbour Those who otherwise understand Christian liberty as Antinomians who think they owe no obedience to the Law they enjoy the gaine of the Gospel to their owne destruction and are worse Idolators under the name of Christians then they were in Popery All things are free to us by Faith yet all things are under obligation of Law in regard of charity that so the servitude of liberty and the liberty of servitude might stand together The liberty of the Gospel takes not away things bodies nor duties of men but freeth the consciences from spirituall bands of wicked opinions Thâ— Christian in his conscience should be a physitian but without in externall conversation an Asse to beare the burthen of Brethren Luther meaneth in things indifferent that are without the case of scandall as hee exponeth himself Tom. 1 472.528 and clearly To. 1. In Christum credentibus omnia munda indifferentia licita sunt quaecunque vel praecipiuntur vel prohibentur externis ceremoniis c. and Tom. 2.154 155 156 158. Through faith in Christ wee are not free from works but from opinions of works that is from a foolish presumption of righteousnesse to come by works Now by opinion of good works Luther meaneth conscience and the resting of the conscience on good works as our righteousnesse hence so often saith Luther the Law hath nothing to doe with the conscience the Law hath no power over the conscience the Law ought not to reigne over the conscience And so 2. he placeth our Christian liberty not only in freedom from the Judiciall Law Tom. 4 on 1 Pet. 2. Rom. 13. and from the Ceremonies of the Law of Moses Tom. 4. fol. 145. But also from the condemnation of the Morall Law As is clear Luther That Christian liberty which Christ hath purchased is not so easily beleeved as spoken if it could be apprehended by a sure and firme faith no fury nor terror of the world of law sin death and the devill could be so great which would not be swallowed up as a little spark of fire by the great sea Libertas illa quam nobis Christus peperit non tam cito creditur quam nominatur Si certa ac firmâ fide apprehendi posset nullus furor aut terror mundi legis peccati mortis et diaboli tam maguâ— esse posset qui non 〈◊〉 seu scintilla a mari ab ea absorberetur Then Luther evidently thinketh our Christian Liberty is not from duties commanded in the Law but from the terrors accusation and condemning power of the Law after wee have sinned against the Law Luther Verba illa libertas ab ira Dei lege peccato morte c. Dictu facilia sunt sed Magnitu dinem hujus libertatis sentire fructum ejus in certamine in agone conscientiae applicare hoc plus quaÌ„ dici potest difficile est Luther In carne nulla debet esse libertas Debemus enim subjecti esse parentibus Magistratibus in summâ omnium servi esse sed in Spiritu conscientiâ Liberrimi ab omni servitute ibi nulli credimus nulli confidimus nullum timemus nisi solum Christum qui regnat inter medias afflictiones cum gaudio laetitia inter media peccata cum virtute fortitudine These words Liberty from the wrath of God law sin death c. are soon said but to finde the greatnesse of this liberty and the fruite thereof in a conflict and agony of conscience and apply it practically is more hard then can be spoken So he expresly clearely this Liberty in the flesh that is in sinning there ought to be no liberty for we ought to be subject to Parents Magistrates and finally the servants of all but in the spirit and conscience we are most free from all servitude for there we beleeve none trust in none feare none but onely Christ who reignes in the midst of afflictions with joy and gladnesse in the midst of sins with strength and courage It s clear by the flesh Luther cannot mean as Antinomians and Papists with Libertines doe the sensitive part which they call the Asse contradistinguished from the minde will and conscience as if the renewed man in whole sinned not with will affection reason conscience for the reason that Luther giveth is contrary to that for saith
to his Saviour as the word saith 3. Christ converteth not sinners as sinners so as their sinnefull condition should be the ratio formalis the formall reason why they are converted for then should Christ convert all sinners all Pharisees all Americans Indians Tartarians hee healeth none but sicke sinners but neither as sinners nor as sicke sinners a gracious Physitian who healeth the sicke without money healeth none but such as are sicke for that were a contradiction Yet their sicknesse is not the formall â—eason why he healeth them for so he should heale all So Christ cureth sicke sinners and these onely but not because they are sinners nor because they are sicke but because and as they are freely chosen of God Joh. 17.6 Thine they were and thou gavest them me here the cause and the reduplication for which he saith they have kept thy word But this suiteth with Familists who will have no new creature at all no grace inherent in a beleever as we shall heare and so no reall change made but onely a putative or relative change CHAP. IV. How we teach a desire of grace to be grace WEe never taught that a desire of the grace of conversion in the unconverted is conversion or that a desire in them to pray and beleeve is prayer or beliefe as Antinomians charge us But in the converted a reall unfaigned supernaturall desire of grace goeth for grace 1. In that its virtually the seed and of the very nature of grace the same Spirit that worketh the will worketh the deed 2. It s grace in Gods acceptation Abrahams aime to offer Isaak is in the Lords bookes an offering of him Because thou hast done this thing c. 3. Where ever a desire of grace is concomitantly there is grace With my soule I have desired thee in the night this desire is blessed of God as saving grace judge then of Familists who say t is a vaine and delusive Doctrine that God passeth by our dayly infirmities acccepting our wils for our performances But they contend for a perfection here in this life CHAP. V. How we are freed from the Law how not THree things are to bee considered in the Law 1. The commanding 2. The promising 3. The threatning power of the Law Now as for the mandatory power of the Law we are to consider 1. The motives bands and helps of obedience to this command of the Law 2. The quantitie of it The Law as steeled and clothed with constraining love and lovely authority of thankefulnes to God-Redeemer and as due debt to the Lord-Ransomer Jesus Christ and this is a morall motive and as it commeth from the grace of Christ bindeth us to obedience not onely in regard of the matter but also of the authority of the Law-giver though Towne say We are freed from the Law in its dominion offices and effects and another the sonnes of God are not subject to the Law that is they are not to be taught what they should doe or leave undone seeing the Spirit teacheth them they need looke for no Law Command or precept but are above all ordinances Reading hearing c. as Christ was and another The Spirit of Christ setteth a beleever as free from hell the law and bondage here on earth as if hee were in heaven nor wants he any thing to make him so but to make him beleeve he is so CHAP. VI. How the command of the Law layeth an obleiging â—and on us BUt 1. we say not that the morall Law bindeth under that reduplication as given by Moses for then all Ceremonials should bind us also who are Christians But that God intended by these ten words delivered by Moses to obleige all Christians to the worlds end to perpetuall obedience is cleare 1. Christ and his Apostles presse the morall Law upon the Gentiles Paul commandeth the Romans the fulfilling of the Law in love the Ephesians the first Commandement given by Moses Exod. 20. with promise James his hearers the fulfilling of the royall Law according to the Scripture no Scriptures but the writing of Moses and the Prophets and that not for the matter only for so a Sabbath day could not obleige the Gentiles if the Law-giver did not command it but from the authority of the Law-giver for vers 11. Hee that said this is the authority of the Law-giver Doe not commit adultery said also Doe not kill and There is one Law-giver so the Apostles adde in their Epistles these very things that Moses commanded to the doctrine of faith shewing that they are Christs ten Commandements rather then Moses 2. Notwithstanding that all Law Thou shalt not kill Thou shalt not steale should expire in regard of any binding they have from God just as this thou shalt be circumcised when Christ dyed and rose againe yet there is Scripture for removing of shadowes Act. 15. Gal. 5. Col. 2. but none for removing the love of God and our neighbour except in the case of justification Rom. 3. Gal. 3. Act. 15. 3. Paul expressely resolveth the Antinomian question Doe wee then make void the Law through faith God forbid Yea we establish the law And Rom. 6.1 What shall we say then shall we continue in sinne that is in a breach of the Law that grace may abound that is that the riches of pardoning grace in justification may flow largely God forbid and Rom. 7.7 is the Law sinne because it irritateth our corrupt nature God forbid For what ever is a sinne to the beleever argueth subjection to the Law as Adultery in a beleever argueth that he is under a commanding Law to say its a sinne against Christ the Redeemer maketh all the ten but one love Christ and no sinne in the world but unthankefulnesse but this should be no sinne to a Tartarian to murther why he never heard of Christ. Joh. 15.22 and so can be guilty of no unkindnesse to Christ and for sinne against the morrall Law if it be abrogated in Christ as the ceremoniall Law is Murthering his brother is no more sinne then if this Tartarian be not circumcised it can be his sinne to be so 4. The law of Nature bindeth perpetually and bindeth the Gentiles then must also the Morall law bind for the authority of the Law-giver for the law of Nature hath all its obligation from God who wrot it in the heart When the Heathen were charged by their consciences for great sinnes they naturally feared vengeance from a Law-giver who had written these lawes in their hearts now the Morall law hath all its obliging power from the Law-giver also 5. The Law by the operation of the Spirit is a meane of our conversion Psa. 19.7 as all the obleiging power that the rest of the Word of God even the Gospell is usefull for doctrine for reproofe for correction for instruction in righteousnesse to make us perfect to salvation and the Gospell
have the Old man in beleevers shut up under the Law and the New man above all Law or subject to none at all as Familists and Libertines when they sinned said Non ego pecco sed asinus meus not I but the flesh doth sinne or sense reason the Old man doth sinne because the Old man onely is under the Law not the New man 2. Guiltinesse and sinne is a thing that falleth on the person not on a part of man 3. The command is given to the person the person is the subject of punishment and condemnation not his sense only 4. Thus Denne and Saltmarsh say Faith righteousnesse light joy and peace is in conscience in the sense fâ—â—sh conversation is sinne yet nothing that can condemne because the conscience is washed in justification but sinne is in the conversation saith Denne and in the sense reason or flesh saith Saltmarsh so here originall sinne shall be no sinne CHAP. XV. Antinomians hold the justified to sinne before men and as touching their conversation not before God and as touching their conscience SO Antinomians say the justified have no sinne in their conscience nor can God see any sinne in their conscience yet there is sinne in their conversation and flesh But 1. sin Originall and the flesh lusting against the Spirit dwelleth inherently in its essence being a blot in the conscience and whole man though guilt and actuall condemnation bee removed so was Paul a wretched man onely for sinne in mind will conscience affection no ill but the ill of sinne could make him cry out of his wretched condition 2. The justified must be as perfect as Angels if no sinne dwell in them and they need not pray for pardon wanting all sin 3. Sin in conversation as murther in the hands oppressing of men blasphemy in the tongue are against the Law of God and must be sinnes in the conscience else they are against no Law of God which make the sinnes of the justified and their doing golden graces CHAP. XVI Justification is close mistaken by Antinomians when they judge it to be an extirpation of sinne Root and branch as Papists fancie venials to remaine onely in the justified IUstification to us is not as Antinomians dreame an utter extirpation of sinne in its essence root and branch for Papists conceive of justification so as nothing that is sinne remaineth in the justified but some gentle venials which we can satisfie for our selves but we judge justification to be a judiciall and law-removall of the guilt or obligation to eternall punishment 1. It is a judiciall and forinsecall Law-declaration that is opposed to condemnation but this removeth Law-guiltinesse to die not the intrinsecall inherent blot of sinne as if the sinner had never sinned and were now no sinner 2. By it the sinner is not as Antinomians say as righteous as Christ because Christ could say in truth I have no sinne but wee even being justified are lyars if we say we have no sinne 3. Sin dwelleth not in Christ at all nor was there in him flesh and concupiscence lusting against the Spirit as in us For it is cleare from the Scriptue that sinne dwelleth in the justified CHAP. XVII Christ not formally the sinner as Antinomians dreame NOr was Christ so made sinne as the intrinsecall guilt of sin was laid on him as Crispe saith Christ was onely the Adulterer the Idolater the sinner imputatively not inherently and formally in that he did beare the satisfactory punishment of wrath and hell due to our sinne 1. Christ was so made sinne not in the imagination but really suffering in our person yet so as sinne physically and inherently in its blot remaines in us and after wee are justified wee have sinne We are sold under sinne and carnall in many things wee offend all Now its blasphemy to say that Christ was so sinfull as we are 2. Nor is the surety the principall any way save onely legally penally imputatively the debtor there is no injustice in the surety as in the principall in borrowing money and profusely wasting it and wronging his brother nor can the surety bee called formally the unjust man the waster though he be legally the debtor and holden in justice and really not in imagination to pay the summe so was Christ never inherently and formally the sinner as the snow is formally white because Christ in himselfe in his physicall person and natures was innocent holy harmelesse undefiled separated from sinners even while he was a surety for sinners 3. Scripture expoundeth Christs bearing of our sinnes not as if the essence forme and intrinsecall fundamentall and essentiall guilt of sinne had been on him then he should have been a sinner as we are and so not a sinlesse sacrifice for sinne but in bearing the punishment due to us in his owne body on the tree in being wounded for our transgressions but it s the Antinomianâ— way to confound Sanctification and Justification and to make us as inherently and intrinsecally in our very persons holy sinnelesse righteous free of the indwelling of Originall sinne and the old man and the flesh as Christ himselfe and this is the Familâ—sts principle That Christ hath Goded and Christed a Saint and Christ is incarnate and maned in the beleever so that the beleever is God manifested in the flesh and dwelling personally in us all the sinnes that a beleever commits are no more sinnes then the actions of Christ for all our sinnes were swallowed up and annihilated in Christ He that is borne of God say they cannot sinne and M. Towne telleth us that justification is regeneration and to faith there is no sinne CHAP. XVIII That we are not justified untill we beleeve WEe hold against Antinomians that we are never justified till we beleeve They say from eternity we were justified or from the time that the Messiah dyed all sins were finished and wee justified or from our birrh But justification in Gods decree and purpose from eternity is no more justification then Creation sanctification glorification the crucifying of Christ and all things that fall out in time for all these were in the eternall purpose of God 2. In justification our sinnes are in their guilt fully done away as a thick cloud cast in the bottome of the sea remembred no more sought for and not found if all this was done from eternity beleevers were never sinners never children of wrath really as Paul saith never dead in sinnes never enemies to God or ungodly they were onely such in a mentall consideration 3. It is true God loved his chosen ones from eternitie to salvation and from that love sent his Sonne to die to wash justifie and sanctifie them but this is not their justification but a fruit of justification in time When our time is the time of love and wee are dying in our owne
beleever But the beleever is not and shall not be till his dying day as free of sinne and spotlesse in the sight of God as Christ himselfe and whosoever feareth sinne and beleeveth not that God seeth no sinne in him being once justified robbeth God of his glory and is undoubtedly damned say they for its unpossible God can see sinne where there is none at all say they nor is this our freedome to be freed from the Law that is from the servile feare of eternall wrath or mercenary hope of reward as if the Law of God could command such slavish feare and hireling hope as Towne saith For the Law never did never could command sinne but so to feare or serve God as to seeke him earely when his rod is on us and when he slayeth us when the heart is like a deceitfull bow as Pharaoh did is slavish feare and to serve the Almighty for hire or gaine is sinne to feare the punishment and love the reward more then God is slavish and mercenary Gods holy Law can command no feare no obedience but what is free liberall ingenuous sinlesse sonnely filiall and holy for the Law is spirituall it is holy just and good 6. Christian liberty is not in freedome from subjection and obedience to Magistrates Masters Kings Parliaments for this Peter saith is to use our liberty as a cloake of maliciousnesse and that opened the mouthes of ignorant and foolish heathen who objected this to some peeping-up Antinomians in these daies who said their Christian liberty freed them from that yoake of subjection to lawfull Authority Kings Governours Masters now beside that Antinomians teach that Saints should not serve nor obey those that are not Saints nor beleevers as if Dominion and Civill power were founded on grace as Papists teach They doe not speake out but when they teach that Murthers Adulteries or any thing done against our brethren or to the disturbance of the peace of humane Societies committed by beleevers are no sinnes before God and that there is no more sinne in the children of God then in Christ himselfe and upon this ground God in justice cannot punish yea nor rebuke them for sinne Then say I these Adulteries and Murthers committed by beleevers if they bee no sinnes against God nor his Law they can bee no sinnes before man neither For the Magistrate beareth the sword to take vengeance on evil doers if these bee not sinnes against God even because they are sinnes against our neighbour then the Magistrate doth unjustly punish them 1. The Magistrate is the Vicegerent of God not judging for man but for the Lord and so should not punish but for these ill deeds for the which the Lord himselfe would punish But the Lord judgeth them neither sinnes against his Law nor can in justice punish them say Antinomians Ergo neither can the Lords Vicegerent judge them sinnes for they are against no Law of God nor can he punish them upon the same reason 2. The Law commandeth to Love our neighbour as our selves no lesse then to love God and he that loveth not his brother loveth not God and then who ever sinneth not as an evill doer against God cannot sinne against his brother and the peace of humane Societies and so the Magistrate ought not to draw his sword against him I grant Gods not punishing sinne is not a ground nor rule to the Magistrate not to punish sinne but sure Gods not punishing sinne and his none-displeasure against any thing as no sinne as having lost the nature and being of sinne as being against no Law as all the Adulteries Murtherings Cousonings Cheatings Robbing Stealing false-Witnesse-bearing of beleevers are supposed to bee in regard they are no more sinnes against a Law of God then any thing that Christ doth must be a rule to the Civill Magistrate who may no more strick the innocent who faileth against no Law of God nor he may kill robbe and oppresse Antinomians make a found escape from this they say The Adulteries Murthers lyings of beleevers are sinnes before men not before God or sinnes to their sense and feeling not to their faith and before God or sinnes in conversation not in conscience or sinnes in the flesh not in the Spirit So Towne Saltmarsh Denne Eaton So the Magistrates doe punish men for seeming Adulteries and Murthers fancied to be murthers but are not so indeed nor before God onely the unbeleeving weake conscience and erring sense or flesh taketh them to bee sinnes but they are not any reall injuries to God nor contrary to any Law of God 2. The Magistrate in conscience cannot judge that to bee violence to the life of a brother nor worthy of death which no Law of God can condemne as a sinne nor can hee in justice for imaginary Murther inflict reall death 3. Adultery and Murther must be then true and reall innocencies CHAP. LVIII Antinomians teach beleevers must not walke in their conversation as in the sight of God but must live by faith with God ANtinomians from their mis-understood justification of which they be utterly ignorant with Familists inferre That justified persons must not walke and live blamelesly with men and by sense but must live and have their dayly conversation in the sight and presence of God and so they abandon all sinceritie of holy walking before men and must live by faith up with God without sinne Dr. Tayler strongly proveth the Law to be in force to beleevers because the same sins are forbidden after faith and before faith and so the same holy and sincere doing of the Law by personall strength of free grace is given to us in Christ and Towne answereth him Keepe the Law and works here below on earth and as Enoch converse in spirit and walke with God in the alone righteousnesse of Christ and though justification be one individuall action and not by succession and degrees as inherent holynesse yet the vertue and efficacie of it is to cleare the coast of the conscience from all sinne to keep the unbeleever in everlasting favour peace securitie happinesse though the Jebusite must be in the Land and the prick in the flesh uncessantly forcing us to sinne more or lesse inwardly or outwardly yet Faith banisheth all the vapours that arise from our earthly members The same Saltmarsh hath But this is a subtile way of fleshly living 1. The word requireth sincerity as in the sight of God in our walking and conversing here on earth below with men Servants saith Paul obey in all things your masters according to the flesh not with eye-service as men-pleasers but in singlenesse of heart fearing God Then servants are to serve as beleeving they are under the eye and sight of God and childrens obeying their parents is well-pleasing to God then doth God see and judge our works and Enoches walking with God
the Angel and prevailed he wept and made supplication to him Gen. 32.24 25 26. nor is this an old Testament-Spirit the parable of the unjust Judge and the Widdow is in scope a doctrine of prevailing with God by importunitie of prayer Iames bringeth the example of Elias for the prevailing of prayer and Christ This kinde of devill is not cast out but by fasting and prayer and so the Spirit of adoption worketh freely Object 2. Saltmarsh The Spirit worketh not freely when wee take in Christ but by the way and rest not wholy on him Answ. They looke on Christ by the by who take in their good works as fellow-causes with Christ thinking to be heard for them Christ is but a by-Mediator if he bee not whole Mediator it s a practicall error naturally in us to improve the the sufficiencie and incomparable weight of Christ to little purpose and dote more upon done duties then on Christ yet this is not our Doctrine but our sinne that we are to be humbled for Obj. 3. Saltmarsh When we are in bondage to some outward worship of circumstances as time place person the Spirit works not freely Answ. It may be Saltmarsh thinketh the Lords day under the New Testament legall men of his gang doe it 2. And not to pray but at such houres as the Spirit moves him because the Spirit onely and the Spirit acting and ravishing is the only obliging Law and command under the New Testament the Letter or written Scripture to pray continually in all things to give thanks to bee abundant in the worke of the Lord to be rich in good works and to make our selves friends with the Mammon of unrighteousnesse at any time ere we bee put out of our stewardship except when the Spirits wind bloweth faire that so they may receive us into the everlasting habitations is a law bondage yea to abstaine from adulterie murther swearing except the Spirits acting which is our onely obliging Law now is a legall not a Gospel-service nor can a beleever sin when he commits adultery murther for hee doth nothing against the only obliging New Testament Law the acting of the Spirit when the Spirit actually doth not act him and stirre him to duties of charitie and love of the brethren and doth not actually deterre and pull him back by his immediate impulsions and breathings from adulterie and murther I desire an answer intimating a difference between sins of Adultery and Murther and so sinfull omission of duties of Chastity and saving the life of innocent brethren for a Moneth which must involve a sinnefull not-loving our brother for a Moneth and the not praying to God for thirty dayes as the heathen Kings Law was upon supposition that the Spirit act not and stirre not up to prayer for thirty dayes and if so it is a question if Adultery be sinne and if abstinencie from Adultery upon the conscience of the seventh Command be not an impeaching of the free working of the Spirit of Adoption and a spece of legall bondage As for Saltmarsh his fourth ground of bondage to wit that to doe any thing from the power of an outward commandement or precept of the Word that it brings forth but finer hypocrisie and his seventh To take any outward thing to move them rather then apply Christ for strength life and Spirit is meere bondage I have answered alreadie it is an Enthusiasticall opposing of the working of word works and well grounded experiences of the Saints to the actings of the Spirit and a looseing of us from beleeving and obeying Scriptures from trembling at the Word and a most wicked way of Enthusiasme Object 5. Saltmarsh when they doe because of some vow or covenant they have made c. It is more properly the service of the Old Testament and part of their bondage for wanting the power and fulnesse of the Spirit of adoption to worke them to obedience freely from within they were under the power of outward principles to put them on from without Answ. 1. If nothing move men to doe but the Letter of the Covenant Vow or Promise not the Spirit of grace then can the Spirit never be said to worke Legally or not freely because the Spirit works not at all nor can this bee called properly the service of the Old Testament except Antinomians say the Spirit of grace wrought none at all in the Old Testament but onely the Letter contrary to all the heavenly Psalmes made by the Holy Ghost and the acts of faith in Moses David Job Jeremiah which every Page of Old Testament refuteth and we must say meere nature and the dead Letter without the Spirit acted them So Hebr. 11. Psal. 51.10 and infinite other places on the contrary 2. Nor can yee say by the same reason that a naturall conscience a desire of a name lest they should be reputed covenant-breakers moved these in the Old Testament to act for so none could have been tearmed men according to Gods heart nor perfect and upright men as David Job Ezechiah Noah because upon this Antinomian ground they were all but fine hypocrites If I mistake not Saltmarsh condemneth all who have taken the Covenant in the three Kingdomes and are moved for feare of the oath of God to stand to it as Legalists and Old Testament Spirits The Covenant that Asa Josiah caused the people to stand too was a Law-bondage that we are not now obliged to and upon the same grounds to keepe faith and promise upon lawfull contracts and oathes between King and people or made to God to keepe Marriage-covenants contracts legues and bargaines betweene man and man which we conceive to be of the Law of Nature must all be the proper service of the Old Testament and contrary to the Gospel to keepe my lawfull promise made to a man to pay my debt because I promised when I borrowed money To keepe the Covenant of God made in Marriage because it is an outward covenant is to doe because of some Covenant and to be in Law-bondage and to doe as being under the power of outward principles and Paul must writ to Philemon as under the bondage of the Old Testament If Onesymus hath wronged thee or oweth thee ought put it on my count if he should pay Philemon seeing he became his debter by an outward promise and covenant he did not pay him by the Spirit of adoption working freely but by a Legall Spirit as being under the Law not under grace by this learning A Jesuiticall way to loose men from all covenants promises bargaines in buying and selling treatise and Indentures betweene persons Nation and Nation to loose us from all the bonds of the Law of Nature and Nations and free us from that which is the Law and the Prophets Whatsoever yee would men should doe to you the same doe ye to them Then shall nothing bind us under the New Testament Doth the Spirit of
way of grace And its poverty of Spirit when we see we have no grace and Saltmarsh Denne Crispe Eaton Towne and the Antinomians reject all comforts assurance or rejoycing from acts of Sanctification and works in the regenerate and say that its a seeking of righteousnesse in our selves and sure then it must bee a worke of the flesh to exercise our knowledge that way to discerne our selves to be sonnes because wee walke in love and after the Spirit Paral. II. Libertines said All sinne was but an opinion that we sinne and under opinion they comprehend conscience scruples remorse sense of judgement That Christs worke of Redemption was to destroy opinion and sense of sinne and then are men new creatures And there is no Devill no sinne no world that are our spirituall enemies David Georgius placed the spirituall life of his in committing Adulteries without sense of sinne and that publickely without shame and that faith in Jesus Christ was the way to abolish this shame in acting this filthinesse which shame was the fruit of the first Adams disobedience And that they should confesse all their sins to their shame again and again in the publike assembly till all pride and glorification of the flesh bee crucified that grace and mercy may be seene to be more glorious And they must goe in this selfe-denyall while they be deaden or to the opinion of any propriety of goods or possessions or wives or Marriages and then they come naked to the new Kingdome of David Georgius where they are to live above all lawes of marriage c. or consanguinity or the like Antinomans doe well neere border with this way onely that which Libertines doe call opinion or discerning of sinne Saltmarsh Eaton and Den call sense Towne calleth it sense or unbeliefe all call it sinning not before God but before men and in the conversation So they say the Adulteries Murthers committed by the justified are seeming sinnes sinnes in mens account saith Saltmarsh but not so before God and to the eye of Faith Now to live by faith is Antinomian Sanctification or Mortification or these sinnes saith Towne before God are no sinnes to faith they are meere nullities but to our sense and flesh they are sinnes So Saltmarsh and Eaton to sense reason experience or to unbeliefe that can but lye and deceive they are sinnes to faith and before God who seeth no sinne in us they are no sinnes Or as Master Denne saith They are sinnes in the conversation before men not in the conscience and before God and all come from this the Justified are under no Law of God and so cannot sinne if then they thinke their adulteries to be sinne that is sense unbeliefe ignorance of their Christian liberty and the erronious opinion of the old Adam Faith beleeveth Adultery to bee no sinne at all It s true to the beleever it is no condemning sinne no sinne such as actually bindeth them over to eternall wrath say we but not a nullity for that not for that an exorbitancie against no Law of God as the Libertine and his brother Antinomian say Then no sense of sinne no trouble of minde for sinne as good Saltmarsh saith can be in beleevers because where there is no transgression there is no Law and no trouble of minde for a breach of the Law This is an opinion of faith that Christ hath purchased a power to beleeve sinne to be no sinne and this is with David Georgius not to thinke shame of sinne but to be deadned to all sense of sinne and so Faith pulleth the conscience out of the justified man hee may sinne with ease CHAP. LXXV Libertines Familists and Antinomians free us from all Law and that we neither sinne nor are to be rebuked for sinne Paral. III. LIbertines said Wee were freed from all Law either directing commanding or condemning And so did David Georgius and so teach the Libertines of New England These that are in Christ are under no Law and Antinomians as Towne Saltmarsh Crisp Denne say We are freed from all the Law of God in all its offices to direct give light rule binde oblige or command as well as to threaten and condemne Paral. IV. Libertines taught That when we are once regenerate we can sinne no more but are as Angels So Libertines of New England and Antinomians say A beleever is as free from Hell Law and bondage on earth as if he were in heaven nor wants he any thing to make him so but to beleeve he is so And Hee that beleeveth saith Eaton that Christ hath taken away his sinnes is as cleane from sinne as Christ himselfe And to Faith there is no sinne and the beleevers person and works are perfect before God and free of sinne and sinfull imperfections Paral. V. When Libertines were rebuked for sin they said It s not I that sinne but my Asse or sinne dwelling in me and they cited that text 1 Joh. 3. He that is born of God sinneth not It s true Paul saith Rom. 7. Not I but sin dwelling in me but his meaning was it s not I as regenerate who sinne because I make not sinne my taske and worke nor doe I evill with the whole bensell of my soule the whole strength of my mind affections and will in regard the unrenewed part protesteth against sinne but I as unrenewed and as fleshly in part as halfe a sufferer I sinne being as a captive sighing in my fetters and complaining that I am wretched through necessitie of sinning I doe the evill I would not doe Rom. 7.17.18.22.23 But the Antinomians conspire with Libertines in the same sense for Towne saith That the old Adam and all his works are shut up under the Law and wrath of God So it is but the Old Adam the flesh the Law of the members that doth sin but it was never the Apostles minde to deny that a beleever once justified can sinne any more For in many things we sinne all Jam. 3.2 And if wee say we have not sinne we are lyars 1 Joh. 1. But Antinomians deny that beleevers can more sin then Christ himselfe or then the gloryfied in heaven and to a beleever there is no sinne God can see no sinne in them Now sure Libertines who said the state of the regenerate was an Angelike puritie did thinke sinnes acted by their Asse the flesh were no sinnes as Antinomians deny Adulteries and cousening and robbing done by the justified to be sinnes but seeming sinnes as Saltmarsh and no sinnes before God as Eaton saith CHAP. LXXVI Libertines and Antinomians destroy Scripture and make the Spirit all and some Paral. VI. LIbertines saith Calvin are so spirituall in their owne fancie that they count no more of the sacred word of God then of Fables except when it serves their turnes The places of Scripture
all your owne errors if they be errors to be vailed with meere weaknesse measure out to us some scruples and graines of charity if you would have pounds and talents of meeknesse and forbearance weighed out to your selves You will not buy and take in with a little weight and sell and give out with a great measure Double weights are abomination to the Lord. Give us but quarter measure and charge us not with persecution and slaughtering of the Saints because we judge a toleration to all even to such as will not come up to the unity of one faith and confession thereof that is Socinians Anabaptists fleshly Familists Antinomians Arrians Arminians Antiscripturians Enthusiasts Seekers and the like to be right downe Atheisme we conceive the godly Magistrate does not persecute the Saints if he draw the sword against adulteries murtherers rapts robberies even in Saints and we hope you at least some of you are of the same minde with us now spirituall whoredome perverting of the right wayes of the Lord Socinianisme professed and taught to others even in Saints to us is worse and more deserves the sword then adulteries for false teachers are evill doers and so to be punished with the sword Rom. 13.3 4. and called evill workers Phil. 3.2 such as rub the pest of their evill deeds upon others and therefore not to be received into any Christian society house or Army 2 Joh. 10. such as the Holy Ghost said under the Kingdome of the Messiah when the Spirit was to bee powred on the family of David and the fountaine opened should bee thrust through wounded and killed because they prophesie lies in the name of the Lord Zach. 13.1 2 3 4 5 6. c. 12.10 all the godly thinke of Antitoleration as a truth of God they are perswaded of in conscience must stand when the hay and stubble of Liberty of conscience Antinomianisme and the like shall be consumed with fire so doe the godly in the Churches of N. England thinke with us refute this opinion of ours and of these whom you esteem to be Saint-murtherers with reasonings and not railing nicknaming us Antichristians Babylonish Lords over the conscience to shame us out of this opinion which is the truth of Christ with the odious and bloody charge of persecuters of the Saints sonnes of Babel Tyrants over the consciences of the godly this is the heaviest club-club-law on the conscience and the saddest tongue-persecution we know else the sharpe arrows of the mighty and coals and firebrands of Juniper with which M. Burtons writings are salted against his sometimes dear brethren the Presbyterians the sometime Saviours and Redeemers of the oppressed and crushâ—d Saints are not persecution contrary to Psal 52.1 2 3 4. Ps. 120.2 3 4. Jobs friends persecuted him Job 19.20 sure they lifted neither sword nor speare against him whether our Brethren did counsell in private and publicke to send an Army against their brethren of Scotland to destroy them who in the sincerity of their hearts did sacrifice their lives for their safety peace liberties and Religion or no I leave to their owne consciences As for the forcing of our opinions upon the consciences of any It is a calumny refuted by our practise and whole deportment since wee came hither Our witnesse is in heaven it was not in our thoughts or intentions to obtrude by the sword and force of Armes and Church-government at all on our brethren in England but wee conceive that Master Burton and the renowned Kingdome of England are engaged by the oath of God to receive such a Government as is most agreeable to the word of God and the example of the best reformed Churches and are obliged sincerely really and constantly through the grace of God to endeavour in their severall places and callings the preservation of the Reformed Religion in the Church of Scotland in doctrine worship discipline and government against our common enemy Now if M. Burton have sworne the covenant he hath ingaged himselfe in the first Article thereof really sincerely and constantly to endeavour in his calling the preservation of the like supremacy which the Pope himselfe claimeth over Kings Princes States Kingdomes commonwealâ—hs the preservation of infallible Generall Assemblies on earth of that spirit of Antichristian pride and tyranny of Rebellion and Treason in lifting up a Papall throne above Kings and Kesars above Kingdomes and Commonwealths to the enslaving of the whole Nation of England in their soules bodies and estates whereby the fundamentall Laws priviledges and power of Parliaments liberties and freedome of all true bred English subjects are brought under perpetuall bondage worse then that either of Egipt or Babylon Now I desire Burton to awake and all our brethren of the way of Liberty of conscience in England who I suppose have sworn the Covenant sincerely and really if a Preacher of the Gospel and Saints who preach cry print that the government of the Church of Scotland and of all the Reformed Churches is Antichristian Tyrannicall rebellious treasonable destructive to the liberties laws and freedome of the English subjects worse then that of Egipt and Babylon doe in their callings of preaching the Gospell professing the truth sincerely really and constantly indeavour the preservation of the government and discipline of the Church of Scotland O but they doe endeavour its preservation onely in their callings against the common enemy What is this but they sweare to defend Antichrist in the Presbyterial government against Prelates that is against Antichrist in Prelacie and yet blacke it as Antichristian and how in your severall callings now M. Burton and our brethrens calling is to preach and write for the truth then must their calling bear them to preach and print to the Prelaticall party and to Cavaliers that the government of the Church of Scotland is lawfull Apostolicke and of Divine right otherwise they cannot in their severall callings defend it against the common enemie for it is not Pastors calling nor I suppose a lawfull calling in our brethrens minde to defend it with the sword and must the preaching and printing to Antinomians Socinians Arminians to Saints hold forth an Antichristian a worse then Egiptian and Babylonish government exclame against it as undefendable and yet defend it against the common enemy the Prelates But whether our Brethren did sweare the Covenant with a purpose to keep it or no and whether they have not endeavoured not to preserve but to destroy and extirpate the Reformâ—d Religion doctrine worship discipline and government in Scotland and persecuted us because we assert it or if more can be done then the proposalls of the Army and the Parliament hitherto have done if they doe no more to promove all heresies and errors contrary to sound doctrine wee must remit in silence to the only finall determination of the most High They are stronger then we but I am confident the earth shall not cover the blood that is shed in Scotland but it shall
it please you this is Gods mind if not Sir you are where you was â—e a Sceptick to Christ's second comming and change your faith every New Moone wee have nothing to say but fare ye well are the Antichrists in this not we Nor dare wee conceale our feare of the â—ad â—udgements of God and his highest displeasure for the breach of the Covenant of God in this Land And that First since so many victoriâ—s and great deliverances bring forth no other fruit but persecution of the Godly and faithfull Ministers of Christ and more virulent hating of and railing against the Church and Kingdome of Scotland these that are most zealous for Reformation and most conscientious and sincere for the Covenant and settling of Religion Above and beyond all that Prelates or those of their way ever attempted Yea and the crushing and ruining of these that have wrought a greater salvation for the Kingdome than all the sectaries in England when such are persecuted impeached imprisoned cast out of the Parliament and Kingdome for no cause if the bottome of the businesse were examined but for their adhering to the Presbyteriall Government Covenant of God their brethren of Scotland opposing as the Covenant of God obleigeth them the Heresies and Blasphemies abounding in this Land when vile and naughty men because they side with sectaries such as blaspheme God deny the deity of the holy Ghost not onely goe free but Familists Antinomians Libertines who joyne in these blasphemies Arminians Socinians the old Courteours and darlings of the late Prelats and popish affected Seekers Anabaptists Seperatists and Independents of another stampe then these of New England Covenant breakers and the like are not onely connived at against the Covenant but sit in Parliament are advanced to highest places in the State and Army and such Familists as Mr. Del and Saltmarsh are alowed and authorized to be ordinary preachers to the Army But know I beseech you that the Lord will discerne betweene him that feareth an oath and feareth not an oath 2 God must reckon with the Land because the Ambassadors of Jesus Christ are dispised hated and persecuted 3. The City that have borne the weight and burden of the charge of the War is badly requited to say no more 4. When cursed Pamphlets uncharitable railings against the Covenant Reformation Reformed Religion the godliest in the Parliament the Church and Kingdome of Scotland the Assembly of Divines the razing of the foundation stones and principles of the Gospel passe Presse and Pulpit uncontroled whereas even Papists as Calvin said against Libertines have not dared in terminis to remove such march-stones of Christ Jesus as doe disterminate Christian Religion from Judaisme Paganisme Turcisme may not the Lord say to England and to the Parliament that which he said to the people of old Jerem. 2.9 Therefore I will yet plead with you saith the Lord and with your childrens children will I plead 10. For passe over the Isles of Chittim and see and send to Kedar and consider diligently and see if there be such a thing 11. Hath a Nation changed their Gods which are yet no Gods But my people have changed their glory for that which doth not profit 12. Bee astonished O yee heavens at this and be horribly afraid be ye very desolate And Esa. 29.21 They make a man an offender for a word and lay a snare for him that reproveth in the gate and turne aside the just for a thing of nought 5. And what can wee answer to all the Sister-Churches in Christendome who have heard of so many Declarations Letters Ordinances Remonstrances promises before God the world and the elect Angells that we came to this Reverend Assembly as willing to joyne with the professed desires and invitation of the honourable Houses of Parliament to remove not only government by Archbishops but likewise to settle such a government as is most agreeable to the word of God most apt to procure and preserve the peace of the Church at home and a happy union with the Church of Scotland and other Reformed Churches abroad in doctrine worship government and one forme of Catechisme and to establish the same by Law To oppose heresies errors schismes injoyne the Nationall Covenant by Ordinance of Parliament to bee taken by all when now indulgence and more is yeelded to all heresies blasphemies and sects and an army pleading for Liberty of conscience to all Religions Popery not excepted is owned and authorised by the Houses whereas other humble and modest petitioners for a government according to the word of God against the Erastian and unwarrantable government set up but in quarters and peeces of which the Lord may say Offer it now to your Governour will he be pleased with it and accept your persons have beene checked and dismissed without an answer till his day yea and censured as guilty of breach of priviledge of Parliament as it faired with the Reverend Assembly of Divines for a submissive and humble supplication for the Royall Prerogative of Jesus Christ in his own free Courts and Assemblies 6. Shall not the Reformed Churches abroad who have hitherto prayed for the sad calamities of the Church of England when they heare as they must heare in languages knowne to them that the Parliaments of both Kingdomes have made their humble addresse to the Kings Majesty and the Ambassadors of Christ and the godly have laine at the footstoole of the throne of Grace soliciting the Lord in whose hands is the heart of the King that he would graciously incline his spirit to take the National Covenant for the extirpation of Popery Prelacy superstition heresie schisme prophanenesse and whatsoever shall be found contrary to sound doctrine Wonder and bee astonished when it is reported that the Parliament of England joyned in the same Covenant with us have not only not pressed the same on the Subjects which they desire of their Prince but suffer satyres raylings reproaches to be cast upon the Covenant of God in Presse and Pulpit highly promote those that are greatest enemies thereof and countenance an Army who labour with all their power to render the heart of the Prince averse to the Covenant and the sincere promoters thereof and doe require the open toleration not the extirpation of all heresies blasphemies yea of the Kingdome and throne of Antichrist against which we Covenanted and to take off all Laws for pressing the Covenant that so it may be buried in England though many of the Army and Independents Antinomians Socinians and others did solemnly with their hands lifted up to the most High ingage themselves to the Lord never to suffer themselves directly or indirectly to bee divided and withdrawne from that blessed union and conjunction So that what the Kingdome and Church of Scotland and the most faithfull adherers to the Covenant labour to build in publicke with this underhand dealing is destroyed and casten downe I doe not say this of all I am confident there
Recantation of the Antinomian errour in an Epistle of D. Luther to Mr. D. Guthel containing the minde of Luther touching Antinomians as a Sect that had their rise from the Devill 69 70 71 72 73 74 Luther is for the Law 70 71 That none is perfect in this life and we are to sorrow for sin 73 74 Islebius recanted his Recantation and returned to spread Antinomianisme after Luthers death 80 81 The tenets of Islebius Antinomians in Luthers time 81 82 The Antinomian way of Paulus Crellius in Luthers time 182 183 184 How Antinomians stated the question of old 83 How the Law is a patient to beleevers 84 Of the Antinomianisme of Michael Neander 84 85 Divers distinctions touching the use of and freedome from the law tending to cleare Luthers mind 86 87 Three speciall uses of the law according to Luther Ibid. Luther refuteth Antinomians in terminis and is most contrary to them 86 87 89 How faith only justifieth as Luther saith 100 How faith and works are contrary 101 How according to Luthers minde the Law hath power over the flesh and not over the renewed conscience 102 103 How Good workes conforme to the law are not necessary 103 The law the same now and under the covenant of works Ibid The law is given properly to the new man not to the flesh 103 104 How the terrified conscience is freed from the law 105 106 How the law condemneth and terrifieth how not 106 107 How the law is given to the New man how not 108 109 Excellent replyes of a beleever to the accusing law 109 110 The tempted beleever freed from challenges of the law 110 111 How a tempted beleever is to comfort himselfe against law-temptations in the conscience 112 113 Luther is for conditions in the Covenant and for preparations before conversion 114 115 Sundry excellent answers to Satan and the law what a sinner is at the brink of dispaire 115 116 117 118 How we are patients in justification how not 118 119 How the law is weak 119 How good workes are naught 120 121 How the law is abolished how not 121 122 That the law is to be preached to all 119 120 Of the union betweene Christ and a beleever opposite to the phancied union of Familists and Antinomians who say that a beleever is Godded and Christed 123 124 125 Of our legall union our union by faith our union by marriage by nature and the intervening of interests and conditions with Christ and a sinner 125 126 127 Luther makes sin to dwell in the justified contrary to Antinomians 129 130 How it is in them and how removed pardoned sinne is essentially sin 131 132 133 134 How we are under the law and under grace in regard of the flesh and the Spirit 134 135 The divers respects of Law and Gospel 138 How the law is a dead Letter 139 Of the Letter and the Spirit 139 140 Luther detesteth allegories 139 How the beleever needeth not the Law in the Letter 142 143 None are perfect in this life as Luther saith contrary to Antinomians 143 144 We must then have patience 144 145 Sin in the beleever rageth to their feeling and yet is made lesse sin 145 146 Luther taught that the Jewes were Justified and actually pardoned by faith as we are contrary to Antinomians 146 147 148 Ch. IX Of Christian liberty and of true false sense 148 149 c. Luther in the point of Christian liberty is against the Antinomians 148 149 How the Law hath nothing to doe with the conscience according to Luther 149 150 151 152 Antinomians distinction that we sinne not against the Law but against Christ removed 151 Luther unduly chargeth these he calleth Sacramentarians with making the Spirit without the word their rule it being the doctrine of Antinomians in his time 153 154 How wee are to judge of our spirituall estate by sense how not 153 154 Luthers minde of freewill and contrary to Antinomians therein 155 156 How the will is a patient rather then an agent in good 157 158 Of the subjective and active power of freewill 158 159 Thirteen considerations of the Author touching freewill 160 161 162 163 An absolute independent power in the will to doe without the predeterminating grace of God neither peculiar to the Covenant of workes before the fall nor to the Covenant of grace after the fall 160 161 Chap. XIV Of the piece called Theologia Germanica and of the Bright starre 163 164 c. Libertines sprang from the Gnosticks Familists from Libertines Antinomians from both 163 164 165 Of John Waldesso who hath sundry principles of Familisme and Antinomianisme in his booke 164 165 God is the creature saith Theologia Germanica 165 To ascribe any thing to the creature is sinne the new man is Christ. 165 166 How creatures are under-causes of their owne working 166 The hell and heaven of Familists 167 The Familists acknowledge no Christ but a metaphoricall Christ. 167 168 So Theol. Germanica and the piece called the Bright-star The workes of H. Nicholas 168 Familists of England dissemble their grossest points Their Petition to King James 168 Vent their malice in the Petition against Puritans were tollerated by Prelates because they railed against non-conformists 169 The contents of the Petition of the Familists in England to King James 168 169 170 Chap. XV. Of the Familists and Antinomians in New England 171 Their rise ib. Their tenets 171 172 173 The Saints suffering are God manifested in the flesh as Saltmarsh and Familists say 172 173 174 Saltmarsh Chaplaine to the Generall Sir Tho. Fairfax goes along with the Familists of N. England ibid. Ordinances of preaching reading hearing Sacraments are not to be seperated from the Spirit nor the Spirit from them 175 Chap. XVI Of the first Authors of Antinomianisme and Familisme in N. England as Mistresse Hutchison M. Wheelwrit their preaching seditious railing and foule tenets 176 177 178 Mrs. Hutchison bold maintained she might preach to a Congregation and alledged the example of Priscilla 178 Her abominable tenets in which she denied the immortality of the soule the resurrection Christ heaven sanctification asserted revelations beside and without the word of God 178 179 A Generall Assembly at Cambridge in N. England confuted and condemned M. Hutchison M. Wheelwright and others 180 M. Hutchison bare thirty formed monsters 181 Was excommunicated banished to the Road-Iland killed by the Indians she and all her house 181 182. as is reported Mrs. Dyer a Familist the wife of William Dyer a prime Familist brought forth a terrible monster 181 182 Chap. XVII Of the late Familists banished out of N. England in Massachusets and now inhabitants of Shaw-omet otherwise called Providence 188 The blasphemous tenets of Sam. Gortyn a wicked Familist who preacheth openly in and about London 183 184 185 Gortyn and these Familists deny God incarnate and say every suffering Saint is Christ and there is not another Christ. 184 185 186 So doth M. Beacon
spoken it Micha 4.4 The mouth of the Lord of Hoasts hath spoken Deut. 30 8. Obey the voyce of the Lord. How often is it said the Lord hath said Esa. 29. Because they have not heard my words saith the Lord which J spake to them by my servants the prophets rising and sending them c. 1 Thes. 2.13 For this cause also thanke we God without ceasing because when yee received the word of God which yee heard of us yee received iâ— not as the word of men but as it is indeed the word of God which also worketh effectually in you that beleeve Heb. 13 7. Remember them which have the rule over you and have spoken to you the word of God all which and many other places can carry no other sense then the word externall written and preached which God rendreth effectuall by his Spirit is an instrument of conversion 11 Err. Faith and conversion to Christ commeth not mediately by the preaching of the word but immediately from the inspirations of the holy spirit and from heaven His arguments are not a whit different from the reasons of Mr. Del in which Del proveth laws synods ministery are all externall carnall literall things so Del. ser. pag. 6 7 8 9. c. Gospel reformation is internall Spirituall and the law written in the heart as Ier. 31.33 the word vocall externall or written reformes by halfes not constantly and intermits and againe lyes still as dead as a stone because men can doe it But Gospel-reformation is as proper to God as to redeeme the world and to take away sin and bring in everlasting righteousnesse if all the Angels in heaven should undertake the work of reformation they should sink under it how much more the powers of the world Del. ser. 10 11 12 13. Iust so argues Swenckefeld Epistola ad quendam Ecclesiasten excussa Basil. an 1527 his 1 argu which is Dels also ser. pag. 6 7. is this iustifying faith is of the nature of internall and spirituall things for it is of God yea faith is the gift of the Holy Ghost then it hath not its originall from things bodily the word and hearing but comes from the internall word for the naturall man perceaves not the things of God 2 Saith Swenckefeld what ever is not of faith is sin then outward hearing of the word without faith is sin 3 All preaching is in vaine except the man have eares to heare Mat. 13. since the word cannot be received but by an enlightened minde and the light of faith and the grace of God the soule being fore-disposed by Iesus Christ though you should heare the word a thousand times in thy unbelieving eares they shall receive no more but a sound they shall reciâ—ve no more but a carnall affâ—ction of a fanzied and counterfeit faith from free will which shall not indure long so read Del. serm pag. 4.5 and as if Swenckefeldius had spitted him out at his mouth so he speakes 4. The Ministers saith Swenckfeld should be someâ—what 5. Then Paul and Apollos should give increase 6. Then the word of God should be tyed to Elements and sounds and and all that heare the word should beleeve 7 But saith hee hee that is of God heares the word of God thâ—n must Grace prevening prepare us before wee can heare the externall word with fruit 8 Their is one Maister Christ the cheif corner stone and he teacheth the externall man not by externalls but by his Spirit when God teachâ—s as he doth Ephe. 3.5 he needeth no perishing and vanishing thing to helpe him to save us Conspice hic inquit Swnckefeld epist 16. verum doctorem veram doctrinam veritatem ipsam â—ternam quae nullo Caduco sive transitorio in adminiculum sui egeaâ— ut nos salvet 9. If the vocal word did necessarily goe before justiâ—ieing faith then justification should be the work of our hands or not without our helpe But Abraham beleeved God not the word preached 10. Then should man not God lay the first stone in our Iustification and experience teacheth us what a building it is we have an historicall faith and a certaine apprehension and assent of naturall reason form the letter of the word so Saltmarch the Antinomian 146 fr. g. the law is now in the Spirit and in the Gospel for a believer to walke by Now the Spirit and the Gospel is all one to the Antinomian to the Enthusiast Libertines and Swenckfeldians so Saltmarch sayeth Nor is the holinesse and sanctification now such as is fashioned by the law of outward commandement Swenckefeld calleth it verbum vocale but by the preaching of faith by which the Spirit is given which renewes and sanctifies a beleever and makes him the very law of commandement himself what this Antinomian calles the preaching of faith Swenckefeld calleth verbum substantiale Christ himself not any created thing so doe the Familists teach Rise Reigne er 9. The whole letter of the Scripture say they holdeth for a covenant of works so er 7. er 8. Know that it is most false that sanctification is not now fashioned by the Law of outward Commandement that is by the word externally preached as by an instrument subordinate to the working of the Spirit for his conscience knowes we never ascribe more to the word for more is contrary to the word Rom. 10.17 Faith commeth by hearing that is the word of the Gospell externally preached 1 Cor. 1 24 we preach Christ to the Jewes a stumbling block but to the called Christ the power of God and the wisedome of God this preaching of Christ is the preaching of faith but not in the Antinomian sense this is the effectuall working oâ— the Spirit for so Saltmarsh meaneth as his exposition evidenceth for the effectuall working of the Spirit can never be a stumbling to the Iewes then this preaching of Christ and of faith must be outward and externall preaching of the Gospell which instrumentally giveth the Spirit For Gal. 3.2 Paul opposeth the hearing of faith that is the externall hearing of the letter of the Gospell that giveth the spirit instrumentally to the workes of the law or the externall doctrine of the Law that can neither promise to give nor give the Spirit instrumentally for if by the hearing of faith he meane the inward hearing and effectuall working of the Spirit then he saith as much as yee receaved the Spirit by the effectuall receiving of the Spâ—rit and also he must meane that all that heares externally the doctrine of the Gospell as the Galatians did must receive the Spirit whereas Paul clearely makes an opposition between the externall preaching of the Gospell and of the Law otherwise by the externall preaching of the law accompanied by the Spirit we also receive the spirit But let Saltmarsh answer if either now or under the Old Testament true holinesse and sanctificattion was fashioned by the law of outward Commandement without the Spirit in some measure or degree 2 If
higher Spirit then that which speaketh in the letter of the Law it 's true it s the same infinite Spirit The Lord that speaketh in all Scripture but in the Law he saith nothing but either perfectly doe all or die eternally But in the Law as handed by the Prophets Christ and the Apostles the Lord condemneth and convinceth that we may flee to the suretie of a better Covenant Heb. 7.22 Now in this sense Law and Gospell called the word of God is not a dead letter in it selfe for Psa. 19.7 The Law of the Lord converteth the soule c. Rom. 1.16 The Gospell is the power of God to salvation to every one that beleeveth both to worke faith Rom. 10.17 and to give salvation Rom. 15.4 For whatsoever things were written aforetime were written for our learning that we through patience and comforâ— of the Scriptures might have hope this must be the written scriptures 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 1 Cor. 1.21 For after in the wisedome of God the world by wisdome naturall knew not God It pleased God by the foolishnesse of preaching to save them that beleeve then is the word preached a mean to save the beleevers Act. 13.26 To you is this word of salvation sent Yet the Jews to whom it was sent Blasphemed and judged themselves unworthy of eternall life ver 46 Act. 20.32 I commend you to the word of his grace which is able to build you up 2 Cor. 10.4 For the weapons of our warefare are not carnall but mighty through God to the pulling downe of strong holds casting downe imaginations and every bâ—ight that exalteth it selfe against the knowledge of God That which is the strong weapons by which men fight word and discipline and is mighty through God is not a dead letter though these weapons be mighty through God so is the word a hammer and a sire and the people wood and the sword of the Spirit and sharper then a two edged sword to discerne the thoughts and intentions of the heart Ier. 5.14 Eph. 6.17 Heb. 4.12 Re. 1.16 Ps 45.3 The Rod of Christs lips by which he smites the earth Esa. 11.4 The Sceptor of his Kingdome all which evince that the word externally preached hath power in it selfe to destroy and being accompanied by the Spirit hath power to coÌ„vert and so is an instrument of the Spirit both wayes 3 Conclusion The Lord hath made and sanctified a ministery and ministers to be fathers of the second birth and instruments to save themselves and others 1 Cor. 4.17 1 Tim. 4.16 2 Cor. 3.2 Yee are our Epistle written in our hearts read of all men 4 Forasmuch as yee are manifestly declared to be the Epistle of Christ ministered by us written not with inke but with the Spirit of the living God not in tables of stone but in the fleshy tables of the heart 1 Thes. 2.19 For what is our hope or ioy or crowne of rejoycing are not even yee in the presence of our Lord Iesus Christ at his comming 20. For yee are our glory and crowne Swenckfield denyeth that he destroyeth Scripture or the ministery or preaching but saith he Epist. An. 1529 In a Christian there be two things 1 The new and internall man 2 The old or externall man called the flesh God dealeth with the Christian man internally by the word of Spirit and life he meaneth the substantiall word in whcih he reveales himselfe through Christ by the various riches of heavenly blessings but externally he dealeth with the flesh of man by the word of the letter and by preaching and by signes and seales So Saltm as if brought up at his feet saith free grace pag. 150. And this Gospell fits man who is made up both of flesh and Spirit and so hath need of a law without and in the letter aswell as in the heart and Spirit The law is spirituall but we are carnall Rom. 7 nor can such a state of flesh and Spirit be ordered by a law onely without for the word of the law and Spirit meerely is for a spirituall condition or state of glorie as Angels who onely liue by a law spirituall and word of revelation then both agree in this that the law is given to the outward man the flesh the body and the law of the Spirit of life to the inner man the soule and Spirit hence these foule consequences 1 The law belongs not to a beleever but to civill courts as Islâ—bius said 2 The word of God can lay no tye no band on the inner man to know God beleeve in Christ love God intend his glory long for heaven and Christs second appearance for the law is given to the flesh and the outward man nor can the letter of the Gospell bind him to any Gospell or heart obedience absurd 3 There can be no sinnes in spirit or soule or inner man because no law and so no obedience most absurd 4. All Ministry scripture is not to rayse an inward spirituall conformity between the Soule and the Gospel nor to make us lowly and meek in spirit as Christ is but to put on us an outside of externall conformitie between the flesh or outward man and the law how then is the law spirituall I should rather think that the spirituall law and commandements of the Gospel were given first and principally and most kindly to our spirits and thoughts and intentions and rather secondarily to the body and outward man so farre as the acts of the outward man fall under the dominion and command of the will and faculties of the inwardman 5. The spirit without the word is the law and only rule that regulateth man in all his inward and most spirituall actions and not the scripture and so the more spirituall the more lawlesse loose and carnall And Mr. Del goeth farther on with Swenckfeld for he will have the accomplishing of Gospel reformation that is the justification of a sinner and his conversion to Christ to be done by the spirit only without all power of man and so it is not visible nor ecclesiastick ser. pag. 4. It stands not in making lawes to consciences add Mr. Del contrary to the word of God act 15.22 23 28 c. by the sacred power or clergie by the messengers of Christ and of the Churches for externall conformity only and meerly externall its false wee aime at more in outward dueties worship and government and to have these confirmed by civill sanction To have Artaxerxes and Kings to ratifie and command under penalties the building of the house of God and to have Kings and Queenes nursefathers and mothers to the Church is lawfull and should be our aime and prayer to God 1 Tim. 2.1.2 3. and that the Kings of the earth bring their glory and honour to the New Jerusalem Revel 21.24 wee heartily desire though the Lord can build Jerusalem without the sword of sectaries and the arme of the Magistrate And Del sayth this Gospel reformation
doth not much busie it selfe about outward formes and externall conformitie but only minds the reforming of the heart and when the heart is right with God the outward forme cannot be amisse and therefore saith Christ touching the worship of the New Testament God is a Spirit and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and truth but speaks not one word of any outward forme So that God in the Gospel-reformation aimes at nothing but the heart p. 6. Swenckfeld ascribeth something more to the ministrie of the word God sayeth he deales externally with the flesh and outward man by the letter of the word or by preaching or by signes or seales But Del is so much for this spirit that he will have the gospel to mind only the reforming of the heart and to aime at nothing but the heart So these foule consequences must follow hence 1 The Gospel cares nothing for outward duties or outward worship all externalls must be left free and indifferent to bow to Idols or not to bow to murther or not to murther which is the false charge that the Councell of Trent puts on us the falsest calumnie the Devill can devise that in the Gospell except faith all other things are indifferent and neither commanded nor forbidden 2 Conseq The Apostles and Elders Act. 15. in forbidding fornication and uncleannesse minded no Gospell reformation such as Del pleaded for 3 Conseq Davids heart was right and Peters also in the maine when the one committed adultery and treacherous murther and the other denyed his Lord then shall murther and denyall of Christ before men be things indifferent for Gospell-reformation mindes onely the reforming of the heart and when the heart is right with God as was Davids whose heart was according to the heart of God long ere he fell in these sinnes 1 Sam. 13.14 and Peters heart Mat. 16.17 the outward forme cannot be amisse then outward practises of adultery and treacherous murther and denying of Christ with oathes were not amisse Old Anabaptists called Fratres liberi and Nicodemites come and learn at M. Del to keepe the heart right and violate all the ten Commandements your false worships your lying whoring couzening c. cannot be amisse your Gospel needs not busie it selfe with these formes For saith he What Christ speakes not one word of in the N. Testament worship Ioh. 4 that hath nothing to doe with Gospel-reformation I Assume But Christ speakes not one word of formes of right externall worship not adding Idoll worship bowing to Baal not one word of speaking or preaching as the Oracles of God as it is 1 Pet. 4.11 nor of consenting to the wholesome words even the words of our Lord Jesus Christ and to the doctrine that is according to Godlinesse 1 Tim. 6.3 nor speaketh Christ one word Io. 4. to hold fast the forme of sound words 2 Tim. 1.13 Nor to obey from the heart that forme of sound doctrine once delivered Rom. 6.17 yea many say Christ speaks in that place Ioh. 4. not one word of faith love feare hope of preaching hearing praying praysing or of any worship either externall or internall but onely of the manner and sincerity of worship then by Dels arguing there should be no externall worship under the Gospell yea more Reformation in worship is but the halfe of reformation Christ there speakes not one word of the other halfe of reformation of the duties of the second table of love mercy righteousnesse sobriety not killing not whoring not couzening and oppressing the widdow the Orphan as Antinomians doe then Gospel-reformation aiming onely at the heart cares nothing for any of these 4 The power wisedome and righteousnesse of men have no place in Gospel reformation because saith M. Del it is the hautinesse and loftinesse of men that must be layd in the dust in the day of reformation pag. 12 13. Now the power of preaching the Gospell and the Keyes of the Kingdome to shut and open to proclaime ministerially the remitting and reteining of sinnes are the onely meanes on mans part to reforme the Church the word preached by sinfull men is the cheife meanes now these are not pride and hautinesse because Christ giveth these to men Mat. 16 18 19. Ioh. 20 21. 2 Cor. 5.18 19. 2 Cor. 10.5 2 Cor. 4.7 Ephes. 4.11 12. 1 Cor. 12.28 But hee giveth not pride and hautinesse nor infuseth he these into any they are from that evill one Satan 5 It is true M. Del in words saith it is the word that onely reformes not the power of the world nor the sword But he knoweth in his conscience we plead not for the sword to reforme The sword was never sanctified of God to turne a soule to Christ but when an Elimas perverts â—oules and the Gospell we hold the sword should be drawen against him that he pervert no more But this word that workes Gospel-reformation is yet the internall and substantiall word of Swenckfeld of all the Eâ—thysiasts for he saith page 17.1 This word is not the Law but the Gospell so say all the Enthysiasts now if Enthysiasts meane that onely the Law is made by us the meanes of conversion excluding the Gospell their conscience beare them witnesse that that is a calumnie the Law it alone makes none perfect and converts not any nor speakes it one word of Christ But if they meane that the Law is wholly excluded from the worke of conversion at all as they teach Then 1 The Law ought not to be taught at all in the Church But Christ and his Apostles taught the law and the Gospell both But what use hath the teaching of that at all that hath no influence in the conversion of sinners 2 That by which is the knowledge of sinne and our sicknesse and is a paedagogne to lead us to Christ is not wholly excluded from being a meanes of our comming to the Physitian but such is the Law Rom. 3.20 Gal. 3.23 24. 3 That which lets us see our condemnation and that we have ground of selfe dispaire and stoppeth our mouthes as guilty before God that which lets us see our debts and that we are drowned and broken for this end that we may flee to Christ our rich surety that which closeth us under sinne that God may shew mercy that is a meanes of our conversion But such is the Law Rom. 3.19 Rom. 8.2 3. Rom. 11.32 Gal. 3 22. 2 Del and his Antinomians meane no other thing by the word but what Swenckefeld meanes to wit the internall and substantiall Word heare him then speake with the mouth and tongue of Swenckefeld ser pag. 18. So that the word whereby Christ reformes is not the word without us as the word of the law is but the word within us as it is written the word is nigh theâ— c. if thou live under the word many yeares if it come not to thy heart it will never change thee nor reforme thee 2 he adde pag. 19.
or the flesh and old man in every man So say the English Antinomians that the precepts of a Christian conversation doe onely obleige the hypocrites under the law that are mixed with true beleevers so doth Towne all the duties Mat. 5. Blessed are the meeke c. are performed by the beleever in Christ and Christ presseth not these â—uties as obleiging the beleever but that he may destroy all vaine boasting and confidence in mans owne righteousnesse of workes bred by the Scribes and Pharisies which is an abominable doctrine for then there was no beleever on earth blessed through personall meekenesse spirituall poverty hungring for Christ and the Apostles and beleevers were not blessed nor had any reward to looke for in heaven in that they were persecuted and killed for Christs sake the contrary is cleare in scripture The putting on of the new mâ—n said they and walking in newnesse of life is nothing but externall discipline and hath nothing common with the Spirit So Eaton Crispe Den Saltmarsh it s but to walke according to the outward conversation honestly as in the sight of men not as in the sight of God yea walking contrary to new obedience and after the lusts of the old man in beleevers is no sinne which God can see in beleevers say Eaton Towne Saltmarsh in Luthers time Christopherus Petzelius wrote a bitter peece for Antinomianisme against Ioannes Wigandus Crellius in spoâ—gia contra Ioâ—n Vigandum and others as Petrus Paladius in catalo aliquot haereseor relateth Antinomians now as of olâ— pretended that Luther is of their mind and alleadge diverse testimonies out of Luther But Luther instituted six publicke disputations at Wittingburg against the Antinomians but the style of Luther was according to his Spirit and zeale hot hyperbolicke vehement against justification by works and therefore these distinctions are to bee observed to cleare Luthers minde 1 Luther speaketh one way of the Law and the workes of the law in the matter of justification and a far otherway of the Law and workes simply as they obleige all 2 To Luther the law teaching squaring commanding is one thing the law in strict terms commanding perfection under highest eternal paine compelling terrefying cursing condemning is another thing 3 The Law compelling legally and condemning that it may condemne is one thing and the Law compelling and condemning materially not that it may destroy and condemne but condemning to the end it may chase the sinner to Christ and save intentionally is a farre other thing 4 The conscience simply is one thing and the conscience terrifyed crushed shaken with dispaire a far other thing Luther constantly â—aught that the law obligeth the conscience of believers as well as unbelievers and yet that the law ought to exercise no dominion over the terrified affrighted conscience of a believer to presse him to despair 5 The Law according to Luther hath three speciall uses 1 That it may reveale sinne and wrath and by this be a paedagogue 〈◊〉 lead the sinner to Christ. 2 To be a rule of a holy life 3 To discipline and compesce with the fury and feare of wrath hypocrites and wicked men that they may be disciplined externally and not goe with loose raines after their lusts 6 The Law in its rigour as it sounds out of the mouth of Moses and is violated and presseth us to absolute obedience out of our owne strength without a Mediator or a Mediators free grace is to the beleever a rough and bloody enemy and preacheth bloody tragedies and craveth and exacteth hard things but the Law as pacified with the blood of a surety and as it is the sweet â—reathing of the love of Christ through the Spirit and as it saith walke in love through the strength of him that hath loved you to death it is a sweet warme kindly lovely freind and leadeth us being willing 7 The law is eternall the law condemning forceing cursing a believer is not eternall but ceaseth to the believer in that bloody office through the satisfaction of Christ. 8 Luther highly magnifieth good works in themselves but as the agent resteth on them with confidence he abaseth them 9 The law without the Spirit is a poore thin liueles hopeles useles dead letter the law animated with the Spirit and tempered with some ounces of Gospel-breathings of free grace concurreth instrumentally to convert quicken revive us and to promote salvation 10 The law as it teacheth directeth commandeth obligeth bindeth to duties for the authority of the law-giver and is ever an active rule to the believer and never a passive thing But as it condemneth and â—urseth it is to a believer a meere passive and a naked stander by and hath no activity nor can it act in that power upon any in Christ as the law of Spaine is meerly passive in condemning a free borne man dwelling in Scotland 11 The binding authority in the law laying on the sinner an obligation to doe and act is different from the binding power of the law to suffer punishment for transgressing of the law The former agreeth to the Law simply as it is a Law the latter agreeth to the Law aâ— it is violated and disobeyed 2 The former is eternall urgeth the believer unbeliever before the fall after the fall in the life to come the latter is removed in Christ to all those that are in Christ for the law fully satisfied neither condemneth nor can it condemne to eternall suffering for Christs passive obedience removeth all possibility of our passive obedience for sin in a satisfactory way 12 The Law admonishâ—th but helpeth not Hence these conclusions for the clearing of the truth and of the minde of Luther more fully 1 Conclusion Luther expresly declared himselfe against Antinomians by that title and name They are saith Luther pernitious teachers who in our time moved by ways I know not what contend that the law should not be preached in the Church wouldest thou not preach the Law where there is truely a people for Law to wit men greedy proud unclean usurers Idolaters In the Antinomian sect saith Luther this is a peculiar proposion if any was an adulterer a murtherer c. let him only believe that God is gratious to him and that 's enough but what a Church is this in which so horrible a voice doth sound But we must teach that there be two sort of sinners some who acknowledge their sin some who securely please themselves therein I intreat Saltmarsh Eaton Crispe Den Towne Del Randel Simson who are so much against all preparations for Christ and for sole beleeving and cry out so much against strict walking with God to consider this How can the preaching of the Law bee excluded out â—f the Church doe ye not also exclude the fear of God and a great part of the works of God The Antinomians these new prophets contend that men should
legis opera id est non esse justos nec facere bona opera The Law is not given to a just man who so liveth that hee hath no need in his terrified and quaking conscience of the Law as compelling and forcing with curses and as condemning of a Law which should admonish presse and compell him but without any compulsion of the Law of his owne accord hee doth what the Law requireth therefore the Law cannot accuse and impleade beleevers as guilty nor can it trouble their conscience it terrifieth and accuseth but Christ apprehended by faith chaseth it away with the terrours and threatnings thereof therefore the law to them is simply abrogated nor hath it authority to accuse them for they doe willingly what the law requireth We must then walk saith Luther in the Kings way that we may neither utterly reject the Law nor ascribe more to it then is due Before Christ the Law as it rigidly commands and condemnes is holy after Christ justifieth it is death Therefore when Christ commeth being apprehended by faith we should know or acknowledge in the renewed conscience nothing of the compelling and condemning Law nothing simply of the Law but in so farre as it hath dominion over the flesh which it oweth and presseth So the Law saith Luther of the ten Commandements without faith in Christ bringeth death not that the Law is evill but because it cannot justifie but hath the plaine contrary effect The proper office of the Law as the Law without a Mediator is to make us guilty to humble kill bring to hell take all from us but for this end as it is the hand of the Mediator that we may be justified and then it killeth not simply but killeth to salvation Therefore Luther the Law hath dominion indeed over the body and the old man let this man be under the Law let the Law prescribe what he ought to doe what he ought to suffer let it not pollute the chamber in which Christ only ought to rest and sleep that is let it not trouble the new man with its use and office Wee grant saith Luther there is no Law given to the just as they are just and live in the Spirit but as they are in the flesh and have in them a body of sin and are under the Law and doe the workes of the Law for that is not to be just nor to doe the workes But the Antinomians in Luthers time and in our dayes doe wickedly inferre then these and the like commandements Walke in my Laws put â—n the new man who is created according to God serve one another in love doe not belong to the new man but only to the flesh and to those that are under the law for what need is there said the old Antinomians to bid a man put on his coat when his coat is already on him therefore wee say this to a man that hath not put on his coat that is to a man under the Law and to the old man in the beleever not to the new man for it is true these precepts as they are meerly legall and to be obeyed without the grace of the Mediator and as they exact perfect Law obedience in a compulsive way under the paine of death eternall are not given to the new man nor to the beleever at all that is most true But that these commands Evangelically considered and as they urge obedience unperfect and by the grace of God are not given to the new man but to the old only is a most palpable untruth for Christ biddeth the beleever and the new man put on his coat though he have put it already on but imperfectly there is a sleeve or a shoulder of his new wedding coat not on yet it is not perfectly buttoned in this life though the coat of imputed righteousnesse be perfect and if sanctification be sincere yet it is not every way so sewed and pinned on us but the very new man hath need in regard that his faith is in the growing hand of that command Put yee on the Lord Jesus The just as just should have no need of a compelling Law if they were perfectly just both in person and works as Antinomians say they are And it is most false that the Law is givâ—n formally to the flesh as if sinfull flesh were commanded to beleeve and put on Christ or were capable of righteousnesse as before is cleared 4. Conclusion Luther saith the conscience of a beleever weake and tender terrified challenged accused hath nothing to doe with the Law Luth. Nunquam pâ—câ—at homo horribilius quam in eo articulo in quo incipit legeÌ„ sentire sâ—u intelligere Impossibile est Christum legem simul habitare in corde aut enim legem aut Christum cedere oportet Discamus igitur diligentissimè hanc artem distinguendi inter has duas justitias ut sciamus quatenus legi parere debeamus diximus autem suprà quod lex in Christiano non debet excedâ—re limites sâ—os seâ— tantum hâ—bere dominium in carnem Christiani Dicas legi consiste intra limites tuos exerce dominium in carnem conscientiam autem nâ— attingas mihi ubi nulla lex est Summaâ—â—rs sapientia Christianorum est nescire legem ignorare opera totam justitiam activam presertim cum conscientia luctatur cum judicio Dei sicut extra populum Dei summa sapientia est noscere inspicere urgere legem opera activam justitiam Luther Diabolo accusanti tues peccator ergo damnatus respondere possumus quia tu me peccatorem dicis ideo volâ— esse justus salvus imo damnaberis non confugio enim ad Christum qui sem tipsum tradidit pro peccatis meis Cum conscientia perterrefit lege nec ratio nem nec legem consulas sed sola gratiâ ac consolationis verbo nitarâ—â— ibi omnino sic te geras quasi nunquam de lege Dei quicquam audieras sedâ—scendas in tenebras ubi nec lex nec ratio lucet sed solum aenigma fidei quae certo statuit te salvari extrà ultrà legem est lex audienda sed suo loco tempore Luth. Christiano nihil prorsus negoâ—ii esse debet praesertim in tentatione cuÌ„ lege peccatâ— quatenus est Christiâ—nus est supra legem peccatum habet enim in corde praesenâ—em inclusum ut 〈◊〉 gemmam Christum dâ—mâ—num legis itaque cum lex cum accusat peccatum perterre facit intâ—â—tur Christum quo fide apprehenso habet â—â—cum victorem legis peccati â—ortiâ— diaboli qui illis omnibus imperat ne noâ—ere possint Luther Extenâ—â—tiones legis referendâ— sunt ad certamen conscientiae Nequâ— satis viliter odiose cum in hoc argumento versamur de ea loqui possumuâ— ideo conscientia in vero agone nihil
sentiam peccatum quod sentis agnoscis peccatum bonum est gratias age Deo ne despera Est gradus ad sanitatem cum aegrotus agnoscit fatetur morbum suum Sâ—d quomodo liberabor à peccato accurre ad medicum mactatâ ratione crede in eum Disce credere Christum non pro fictis aut pictis sed veris non pro parvis sed maximis non pro uno atque altâ—ro Sed pro omnibus non pro devictis nullus etiam Argelus velmi nimum peccatum vincere pâ—test sed pro invictis peccatis traditum esse nisi inveniaris in numero eorum qui dicuntur nostri hoc est qui haâ—c fidei doctrinam habent â—â—cent aâ—diunt discunt ei credunt tum plane de saluâ—â— tuâ actum est As 1. Luther When I finde remorse of conscience for my sinne I looke up to the brazen Serpent Christ on the crosse and there I finde another sin against my sin that other sinne in the flesh of Christ which taketh away the sinne of the world is an omnipotent sinne and condemns and swallows up my sin And l I confesse I have sinned but my sinne is condemned in Christ who is made a condemning sinne and the condemning sin is stronger then the condemned 2. As its most safe to contemne and passe by a barking Dogge so the only way of overcomming is to despise Sathans casting in thoughts and dispute no longer with him And when there is no escaping close thy eyes and answer nothing and commend the cause to God he giveth a reason Sathan cannot indure to be a contemned enemy 3. Luther Tentations are the throngings or embracings of the bridegrome to the bride from impatience of love 4. Luther The tempted is to say I cannot endure thee O Law a rigorous Tyrant and a cruell exacter to reign in my conscience for it is the seat and temple of Christ the Sonne of God 5. Luther It s true the tempted saith how can I be holy when I have and fâ—el sin that thou feelest and acknowledgest sin its good give thanks to God despaire not it s a degree to health to feele sicknesse But how shall I bee freed from sin flye to the Physitian follow not reason beleeve and sacrifice reason Antinomians comfort us thus the sin of beleevers is seeming sin Luther saith it s too reall and must be cured by Christ. 6. Luther Christ dyed not for the painted and phancied but for true sinners and the chiefe sinners not for one or two but for all not for conquered but for unconquered sins and if thou be of the number of these that beleeve its good Luther here would have the weake ones that finde hearing learning loving of his doctrine 〈◊〉 beleeving that is such as have qualifications and conditions in them to know Christ dyed not for phancied men but for them Antinomians reject all qualifications and conditions Yea. Luther comforts only these against the Law who have this condition of Christ inclosed in their heart as a pearle set in a ring Luther tom 4. f. 46. Yea though Luther be against all preparations of merits yet is he cleare for preparations of order against the Antinomians Legis proprium officium est nos reos facere humiliare occidere â—o fiâ—e ut justificemur w Lex non facit filios Dei atqui praeparat ad novam nativitatem qua fit per fidem Luther Malleus lex opprimit pertinacem best aÌ„ presumptionem ut ista contusione homo in nihilum redactus desperat de suiâ— viribus justitiam â—itiat misericordiam remissiâ—nem peccatorum Luth. to 1.472 Per fidem Christi non sumus liberi ab operibus sed ad opinionibus opeâ—uÌ„ id est à stultâ praesumptione justificationis per opera quaesitae fides enim conscientias nostras redimit rectificat servat quâ cognoscimus justitiam esse non in operibus licet opera abesse neque possint neque debeant Luther Sentiens terrores minas tuas O Lex immergo conscientiam meam in vulnera sanguinem mortem c. Christi Venit in mentem Christum velle expostulare nobiscum velle rationem à nobis exigere transactae vitae c. Luther Cor dictat Deum adversum verbum Dei sequi debeo non sensum meum Luther Est diabolus persuasor mirificus Verbum pingit Christum non accusatorem non durum exactorem Luther Quanquam caro non nihil murmuret tamen Spiritus gemit ad Deum potius intentatione perpetuo manere perire cupit quam ad impietatem à Deo recidere Hic canon est quod in omnibus tentationibus nos ipsi alium fingimus Deum esse quam sit putamus enim Deum tunc non esse Deum sed phantasma id est horrible spectrum Luther Peccator es igitur te odit Deus Haec consequentia vera est in naturâ in jure civili ad tribunal Christi hoc sequitur peccator es ergo confide Luther Cum Sathan vexat conscientiam per legem â—tile est opponere Satanae Quid ad te tamen non peccavi tibi sed Deo meo Non enim sum tuus peccator Quid igitur juris est in mâ— non peccavi tibi non legi non conscientiae nulli homini Angelo nulli sed soli Deo It is proper to the Law to make men guilty to humble kill bring downe to hell and take all from us for this end that we may be justified w The Law maketh not men sons of God but it prepareth us for the new birth The Law is a fire and a hammer breaking the rocks to suppresse that pertinacious beast presumption that a man may be brought to nothing and despaire of his owne strength and righteousnesse and being terrified may thirst for mercy and pardon More of this yee may see in Luther to 1. fol. 11. p. 286.412 to 4. f. 5. f. 296. to 1.53 Luther never ment that wee are freed from the Law as a rule of good workes Luther to 1.472 by the faith of Christ we are not freed from workes but from the opinion of workes that is from a foolish presumption of justification by workes Luther Finding thy terrours and threatnings O Law I dip my conscience in the wounds death blood resurrection of Christ beside these I will see nothing heare nothing For we think Christ will quarrell with us and seeke a reckoning of our ill â—ed life and will accuse and condemne us In tentations though sense say that God is an enemy I follow the Word that sayeth the contrary The divell is an admirable perswader to cause us thinke a little sin a hainous crime But the word pointeth Christ sweet meeke 10. Luther The flesh murmureth but the Spirit sighes to God and had rather dye in the tentation then depart to wickednesse
11. Luther This is a rule in all temptations we fancie another God and beleeve God not to bee God but a phancie a Ghost 12. This consequence thou art a sinner therefore God hateth thee is true in the Civill Law or Court but in Christs Tribunall its true thou art a sinner therefore beleeve 13. Luther When Sathan vexeth the conscience with the Law it s fit to say to Sathan what is that to thee yet I have not sinned against thee but against my God for I am not thy sinner what Law then hast thou in me I have not sinned to thee not to the law not to conscience to no man to no Angell but only to God Luthers meaning is that he hath not sinned to the Law or so against it that he should be therefore condemned because he is pardoned in Christ. Luther Nulla alia re potest sanari hoc vulnus conscientiae quam verbo divinae promissionis Luther Si es calamus contritus noli te amplius conterere aut Satana conterendum dare sed da te Christo qui est 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 amat conquassâ—tos contritus Spiritu Luther Desperatus non orat dum desperatio durat sed cum remittitur paroxysmus tum primum incipit clamor plurimus adjuvatur animus cum audit fratrem commodè tractantem verbum Dei cum ad hunc modum siducia in Deum animo anxio inculcatur tum surgit sciâ—tilla fidei gemitus cordis O si possem sequitur tandem sensus gaudii neque potest Deus hos gemitus negligere Luther Deus mammam gratiae etiam justificatis nonnunquâ—m subtrahit ut discamus Quid nostra ipsorum justitia soleat facere nempe quod solet opprimere desperatione Luther Cum Satan objicit ecce es peccatoâ— non sic credis non sic orâ—s sicut requirit verbum tu contra dic quid me vexas his visibilibus bene sentio ista nec opus est ut tu me doceas illud opus est ut verbum sequar transferam me ad invisibilia Luther Maxima pars fallitur quod non credunt has cogitationes esse tentationes Satanae Luth. Docemur in hoc certamine appreheÌ„dendaÌ„ promissionem in baptismo factam quae certa clara est sed hoc cum fit non statim cessat Sathan sed reclamat in corde tuo te non esse dignum istâ promissione est autem opus ardenti oratione ne extorqueatur nobiâ— promissio Dic scio promissam mihi propter filium Dei gratiam Haec promissio non mentietur etiamsi in exteriores tenebras abjiciar 14. Luther This wound of conscience cannot otherwise bee healed but by the word of God If thou be a broken reed doe not breake thy selfe any more or give thy selfe to Sathan to be broken but give thy selfe to Christ who is a man-lover and loveth the broken and bruised in Spirit 16. The despairing soule prayes not while the despaire continueth but when the feaver turneth to a cool the cry begins he is much helped when he heareth a brother rightly handling the word of promise when faith in God is thus inculcated in a sad heart then glimmereth up a sparcle of faith and a sigh of heart O if I could then followeth sense of joy God cannot despise these sighes 17. God withdraweth the paps and 〈◊〉 of Grace from the justified that we may learne to know what our owne righteousnes useth to doe even to presse us with despaire 18. when sathan objecteth behold thou art a sinner thou dost not so beleeve thou dost noâ— so love as the word requireth say thou againe why vexest thou me with those visible things I feel these well there is no need that thou teach me there is need I follow the word and turne to invisible things 19 Luther The greatest part of men are beguiled that they know not that the thoughts of their utter casting out from God is a tentation of Sathan 20. Luther In a conflict of despaire we must hold the promise made in baptisme if Sathan cease not but cry in thy heart thou art not worthy of that promise wee must ardently pray that the promise be not throwne out of our hand Say I know there is a promise of grace for the Son of Gods sake made to me this promise shall not lie though I were cast in utter darknesse I have stayed the longer on these because possibly every Reader cannot have Luthers works at hand 4. Conclusion Luther and our Divines say that we are patients in the businesse of justification which tendeth not to favour the Antinomian dreame that we are justified without faith and before we beleeve or that we are â—locks and dead passive creatures in the act of beleeving or in other supernaturall acts The Antinomians of old as now t Towne and others teach that the Law hath no activity over the new man by teaching ruling commanding requiring exacting or demanding obedience of him because the Christian man is Lord of the Law and the Sabbath and doth all without a Law teaching or commanding for the new man as new doth good workes by nature as the fire casteth heat then not by law or teaching or command But Luther will have justification to be passive and the Law in justification a patient in a farre other sense 1. Because the broken debtor is free in Court for nothing he doth himselfe but because the rich surety did all and paid his debt 2. Because the Law and the fulfilling thereof in the person of the justified is utterly unpossible and he is justified freely in Christs rich grace without Law or workes and the Law makes him no helpe for justification at all but is a meere patient 3. Because Christ that justifieth the ungodly and is the head of the justified oweth nothing at all to the Law and needed not to be teached what to doe by the Law and did and over-did and out-suffered more abundantly by grace then the compelling cursing and threatning Law can teach or command had wee suffered for the breach of one Law and done all the rest of the Law most perfectly and exactly yet could we never have given such glory to God nor such exact payment and satisfaction to the Law both by doing and suffering as Christ did we should have payed to the Lord and his Law but copper and brasse Christ payed our Law-debts in fine and pretious gold And what our new obedience wants in quantity for we cannot by Grace keep the Law exactly nor thereby be justified it hath in quality being wrought by Grace and perfumed with the glorious merits of Christ in these respects saith Luther The whole nature of justifying us in regard of us is passive Actively the Law is a weake and poore â—lement the letter of neither Law nor Gospell can give strength to obey and its weake passively because
of these three and it is that the sinlesse creature should yeeld its beeing lust will and desires rather to be trampled on dispised or turned to nothing before God be dishonoured All the essentiall attributes of goodnesse holinesse wisdome grace justice power soveraignty c. that are all infinite in God proclaime that there is an infinite distance between the Creature and the Creator but if we speak of a borrowed beeing and a borrowed working at the second hand and by loane then it is no sin for creatures to say they are creatures for the Holy Ghost saith it and biddeth man say that he is clay and a living soule nor is it sin to the Creature to ascribe doing of good to it self as the Church saith I have sought thee O Lord Isa. 26. and David I love thee O Lord and Paul I have laboured more abundantly then they all though it was a labouring borrowed from grace and sure the Creature acts sin and against a law and not in subordination to God as Law-giver acting him against a Law 4. Error Obedience is to deny selfe The creature is all good in the Creator and to value and esteem all beeing and all good God himselfe Theol. Ger. c 13. 5. All creatures the body and soule of man were hid potentially in God and shall returne to silence and to nothing after This is cleare against the immortallity of the soule that Scripture saith seeth God injoyeth his face goeth to Paradise or torment after death 6 Hell standeth in these 1. when a man seeth himselfe worthy of all ill 2. Perpetually damned and lost 3. Neither wils nor conceives comfort from any â—â—eature 4. Yet he waiteth for deliverance 5. Beares nothing waywardly but sin 6. And when he cannot think ever to be delivered or comforted He is in heaven when he regards nothing desires nothing but the eternall good so this becomes his he may often in one day passe from heaven to hell and from hell to heaven and is safe in both This is a hell and a heaven unknown to Scripture 1. They are within the bounds of this life hell and heaven are after death and buriall Luk. 16. 2 There is a marcet way between this heaven and this hell But Luk. 16. there is a gulf and no passage between the right-heaven and Scripture hell Luk. 16. 3. These may end the true hell and heaven are eternall Mat. 25. last Psal. 16.11 7. When God alone works in man and leaves undone in him without any I to mee or mine there is true Christ and no where else Theol. Germ. c. 22. Christ crucified in Mount Calvary is but an imagination to suffer with Christ is Christ crucified Our sufferings and Christs are one by union of will and Spirits Bright star c. 18 â—89 190 191. c. 200. Then is Christ not true man 2. nor dyed he really but only Spiritually in us when we suffer with the like meeknesse and patience as he dyed and suffered and yet he is but an Allegorick or phancied man to the Familist The like Familists say of his Resurrection Ascention and judging the world It s but to doe what is already done to open these rotten graves any farther These two pieces so fleshly and abominable agree well with the Tenents of H. Nicholas and are now set out An. 1646. by the Familist Randel to the insnaring of the soules of many thousands in London In the yeare 1â—75 the Familists of England published a confession before King James came to the Crowne of England but laxe and generall I know not what for H. Nicholas wrote bookes of sundrie sorts As his exhortation 1 c. 6. § 5.7 8 9. His instructions of the upright and Christian baptisme his crying voyce his first exhortation and these saith hee may bee confessâ—d among the adulterous and sinnefull generation and the false hearts of the scripture learned for so hee called all the godly in England and all that are not of his way But for his love-secrets hee saith yee shall not talke of your secrets either yet utter your mysterâ—â—â— openly or nakedly in the heaâ—ing of your young children or disciples but spare them not in the â—ares of your Elâ—â—rs which can understand the same or are able to beare or away with the sound thereof But they have their private Traditions and unwritten verities saith H. Nichol. in his Elidad § 5. By which they grow up in love according to the requiring of her service where all things needfull to bee knowen or declared are alwayes according to the capacity of their understanding brought and declared to them to the § 17 young or new borne children according to their youngnesse to the weak according to their weakenesse and to the eldâ—râ— according to their driednesse or old age where § 18 neither some heare all nor all heare some private mysteries but the confession might have a sound meaning Though as they ment there is nothing sound in it About the yeare 1604. the Familists of England presented with this fraudulent confession a supplication to King James which was printed at Cambridge anno 1606. And answered by one of the Universitie in the supplication they hid their soul tenets and say Wee doe beseech your Princely Majesty to understand that the people of the Familie of love or God doe utterly disclame all obsurd and selfe-conceited opinions and disobedient and erroneous Sects of the Anabaptists Browne Penry Puritans and all other proud-minded Sects and Heresies whatsoever protesting upon pain of our lives that we are not of consent nor agreeing with any such brain-sick Preachers nor their rebellioâ—s or disobedient Sects whatsoever but have beene and ever will be truely obedient to your highnesse and your Laws to the effusion of our blood and in this part of their supplication the Reader may see the bloody persecuting minds of Familists for they exhort King James to persecute all the truely godly that were non-conforme to Prelates and went under the name of Puritans and tacitly praise King James for executing the Laws against such as in conscience durst not bow to the then Prelaticall Baal and the Familists principles carry them to esteem any Religion indifferent yet half an eye may see how desirous they are the Sword should be drawn against the godly whom they all Puritans and therfore judge if Antinomians and Familists now in England who cry out against the use of the Sword for matters of Religion and plead for a Catholick licence and tolleration to all Religions that themselves may be tollerated also if they had the Sword and Power if they would not be most bloody Dragons in cutting the flesh and drinking the blood of those they call Presbyterians and Puritans for thinke not their doctrine is different from that doctrine of their fathers So here they quit the Protestant Doctrine maintained by those that are called but unjustly Puritans and promise to conforme to all Popish Ceremonies to Arminianisme
29. nor was Christ for that under any absence of the Spirit 1 Tim. 4.14 15 16. and Revel 1.3 compared with Rev. 2.7 whereas he sayth The Ministery that is to destroy Antichrist is more glorious then Arts and Tongues and this is Jesus Christ himselfe 1. Libertines said the Gospel or Word was the Spirit himselfe Saltmarsh here sayth the Ministry destroying Antichrist is Christ which is most false The Ministery is but 1. an Instrument 2. a created Ordinance Christ is God Man and Mediator 2. The Ministery that destroyeth him is the Word preached as an instrument and Christ the principall cause But the principall cause removes not the Instrument as Familists imagine but the Ministery of Familists shall never do it Whereas former Antinomians made two contrary administrations one under the Law in the old Testament another undâ—r grace or the Gospâ—l in the new Testament Onely John Baptist was pinned in as halfe a Legalist between both Saltmarsh p. 68. after he with the Familists hath made a greater number of spheres and circles of Administrations following the spirit in his fulnesse and variety he foldeth them up in three of Law Gospel and Spirit or of Letter Graces and God or of the First Second and third Heavens After the cut of David Georgâ— who said the first Ministration was the law of death and the letter the second was under Christ and the Apostles but not very spirituall but fleshly literall carnall but the last under David George the true Messiah was spirituall purely spirituall beyond that of Christ and the Apostles and so spirituall that to have conscience or sense of uncleannesse or sinne was a work of the flesh And Saltmarsh saith it is fleshly and literall that a pardoned man should confesse sin p. 69 70 a Christian saith hee passeth throâ—gh severall ages even as Christ was under the Law circumcision Supper of the Lord Baptisme and then hee crucified all that flâ—sh hee walked in under these dispensations and entered unto glory Answ. Then he crucified Baptisme the Lords supper preaching of the Gospel the Ministery the visible Church and every outward letter of conference praying for Saltmarsh now turned Seeker denies all these and hee must have crucifyed all his preaching tongues writing of books 2. What tongue or Science of the Holy Ghost taught Saltmarsh to call the Ordinances of the New Testament flesh or fleshly Ordinances for I doubt he meaneth not that Christ true man dyed for our sins for 185 186. he saith It is a discovery of the highest attainment of Protestants generally that we are born in sin And that the way of salvation was by Jesus Christ the Sonne of God born of a Virgin in the fulnesse of time made under the Law bearing our sinnes crucified dead buried and risen and ascended and entred into glory c. but pag. 190 191. he forsaking this as legall doctrine tels us of a further discovery as to free grace as if the Protestant Doctrine were merits of men not the free grace of God And he setteth downe that of the Antinomians and not a word of Christ God-man crucified and dead for our sins And the confession of Faith made in this Assembly at Westminster yea all the Reformation now is onely in some outward ordinances saith he not any purer or more glorious discoveries of God or the Spirit or Jesus Christ or our union with the Spirit or glory as to spirituall things or Christ risen but as to Christ in the flesh or under the Law of which these Ordinances were a signe And p. 198 199 200 201. which he calleth the last highest and most glorious discoverie of God by love and grace for to the Familists there is no Article of the Protestant faith that savours of truth for to them all our Doctrine is a dead Letter Nor did Christ die for our sins and rise for our righteousnesse but onely the dying of Christ is a meere figure insinuating that he dyed not in our nature as true man but as Gortyn saith the sufferings of every Saint who is the figure and image of Christ is all the Christ crucified the Scripture knows There is nothing in all the books or writings of Familists discovered touching the controversies between Protestants and their Adversaries Papists Arminians Socinians Arrians Antitrinitarians Sabellians Libertines Swenckefeldians Anabaptists c. Concerning Election Reprobation the power of free-will the supremacy of the Pope Idol-worship the consubstantiality of the Son of God Christs manhood his dying satisfaction merit buriall resurrection ascension the last judgement heaven hell the resurrection of the body in all which they are unsound and ought to give a confession of their faith as Anabaptists have done 12 The Jewish Church saith Saltmarsh p 70. or dispensation that was according to Moses and the Letter in which they were led out in carnall and more fleshly courses as in proceeding against the Nations by warre and fighting with all their other legall Rites and Rudiments were a clear figure of the Christian under age or under tutors and Governours and worldly Rudiments Here lawfull Warres and the use of the Sword are made legall rites and figures War saith he with all other legall Rites then Warre is no more lawfull to us under the New Testament then Circumcision and all the Law of Ceremonies Saltmarsh then would no more goe as a Priest to the Campe to preach to the Generall then he would be Circumcised except with H. Nicholas he thought all Moses Law indifferent and that the spirit without scripture led him to be accessorie to unlawfull bloodâ—shed and the spirit is his rule not the word of God 2 If the ceremonies of Moses be the figure of a Christian under Tutors and worldly rudiments such as hearing of the Gospel baptisme prayer confession reading then all these must bee abolished in this life to the Christian and if Christ have crucified all these as fleshly ordinances to Pray heare must be as unlawfull as to be circumcised which Paul saith Gal. 5. is to fall from Christ. See if these men mind God 13 The Disciples of Châ—ist saith p 70 71. according to Johns ministerie were a type and figure of such as are under Tutors as Gal. 4.1 and as carnall and Babes in Christ 1 Cor. 3.1 2. Answ. These under non-age Gal. 4.1 are under the Law of Moses and yet Heirs of the promise The Disciples were under Christs ministerie and beleeved in Christ as come and were blessed in that the Father revealed Christ to them not flesh and blood Matth. 16.16 17. The Baptists ministery and his Doctrine and baptisme were all one with the ministerie and baptisme of Christ and the Apostles as our Divines prove against Papists for both preached Christ the Saviour that taketh away the sins of the World justification by free grace faith repentance to life sanctification c. Corinthians are called carnall not because they prayed and heard and beleeved but because though Babes
have nothing but inward spirituall worship and say now it was unlawfull to take â—he Covenant and the deepest Familists say it was at that time dangerous to refuse the Covenâ—nt and they might lawfully take it and keepe their heart to God for H. N. Epistle to the Daughters of Warwick so teacheth Now councels as sermons and preaching and the written word are but formes to these men Anoynting is the work of the alone Holy Ghost 1 John 2.27 and no worke of men and they are all carnall â—en or such as H. Nicholas speaketh are wise with Worldly Antichristian false and fleshly wisdome 2 He tels us the New Testament worship consisteth in faith hope love and citeth John 4.23 and Paul preached at Troas and administred the Lords Supper till breake of day all that beleeved were together and continued daily in the Temple and did breake bread from house to house here was union but not a word of externall Vniformitie Answ. Here was all the Uniformity we crave for that which Peter preached in one house Matthew or another Apostle preached not the same very words and in the same forme of Grammer but all the twelve preached the same thing in Doctrine prayed for the same thing all administred received the Supper of the Lord according to the Institution of Christ all did sit at table all did take break and eate all did drink after the elements were blessed this Uniformity or unity cal it as you will we seeke and an union in the externall acts and ordinances but this unity is not among Presbyterians Familists Antinomians Arrians neither Doctrine nor praying nor beleeving of these same fundamentals are one as the letter would say for if all have love and all give faith and beleife to the dictats of their Conscience and a Spirit leading without scripture This unity sufficeth not though Familists beleeve Christ is not God incarnate yet we beleeve he is God incarnate though Antinomians beleive a justified man cannot sin needs not coÌ„fesse nor sorrow for sin yet we beleive the just contrary here is neither unity say we nor uniformity we have unity of faith hope love say Familists but no uniformity because there is an indifferency in what ye beleeve if yee beleeve what Conscience or an Enthysiasticall spirit speake to you it is all one you have true faith and true love By the way of these men The Unâ—formity that Familists cry downe is the tying of the spirit and his various working to one form and way of working for this were to rule order inlarge and straighten the spirit of God by the spirit of man saith Del. But we judge Familists to be ignorant of the state of the question For the preaching and worshipping of God in spirit and truth is not the thing in question but how the outward Ordinances whither the spirit concurre with them or concurre not ought to be ordered we say God hath not left men at freedome to follow the dictates of Conscience at will which often is conceit not Conscience the word regulateth us sufficiently that we looke to the rules of edification charity prudency order decency and especially the word of God But the mystery is this all outward things are indifferent and we are to please one another in them and the spirit without the word is a rule to us in the ordering of externals We heare Saltmarsh and M. Beacon say we must please one another in love in outward things so H. Nicholas saith paterne of the pres Temp. The Services and Ceremonies he meanes all the Idolatrous service of the Church of Rome shall not save any one without the good nature of Jesus Christ and of his service of love nor yet condemne any one in that good nature of Jesus Christ nor in the service of love I see not then how Becold sinned in taking fifteen wives at once for to follow the word and figures of the Law thou shalt not commit Adultery is as Del and Familists tell us the spirit of man that inlargeth straitens the spirit of God which would have some colour if preaching of the word sacraments hearing were to be ordered by the wisdome of mere men and if Orthodox Doctrines of councels in their matter were mens devises and not Gods word and if the spirit of God did not agree to goe along with his owne Ordinance In Vniformity every Christian will doe for peace sake as far as Conscience will permit But shall the Christian doe nothing for truths sake and for the commanding law of God in Uniformity or in unity or onenesse in externall worship In external worship then we have no law but please one another in love and the law of peace or if Conscience have any acting therein it is Conscience acted by the Spirit without the word so in all externals if we keepe faith and love in the heart we may live as we list A good loose world there is an Uniformity in wars in marrying in whoring in invading the rights of the Subjects their power liberty goods possessions wee have no law in these but peace pleasing one another in love And what may we not doe then If we keepe Familistical love in our heart which is the Godly being and the Godding of man with God a permitting Conscience no word of God is our rule But the onely rule say they is Conscience Led with peace that is with a desire to please one another in love in all externals in cursing or no cursing murthering or no murthering whoring no whoring lying blaspheming railing no lying no blaspheming no railing For the written word and law of God the Old and New Testament to Antinomians and Familists is a forme a letter and some certaine figures which yet are not the Christian mans obliging rule Saltm sparkles of glory p. 238 239. for p. 216 217. The whore is adorned saith he with gold and pearle which are those excellencyes of nature and formes of worship and Scriptures with which shee decks her self as a counterfit Spouse of Christ pag. 243.245 So the Uniformity of having the same Old New Testament and the same Law and Gospell preached is here covertly condemned and the having the same outward Ordinances is contrary to inward and spirituall unity in the Godly being of love and faith as if we had no word of God for to read Scripture partake of Ordinances but all externals were free In things of the mind wee looke for no compulsion but of light and reason The Authour means in Religion and faith which cannot be compelled we looke for no compulsion This was as much As we looke not from the Parliament for any Laws or use of the Sword to punish us then if one should deny there is a God as many fools doe if any should blaspheme and raile against the Godhead wee looke the Parliament should not take notice of it 2 all Religion here comes in under the name of things of the minde
or the Spirit which is not the doctrine that Paul and Iohn received from the Lord Gal. 1.8 2 Ioh. v. 10. 1 Cor. 11.23 But Familists will have the Scriptures to beare witnesse to us of and to reveale the Father and the Son but for the holy Spirit he must be revealed without the testimony of Prophets and Apostles though Christ our dying friend hath left us his will in his last testament confirmed by the death of the Testator and forbids us to expect any farther revelation Heb. 1.1.9.16.17.27.28 Rev. 22.12.18.19 Is it not safer to beleeve the Prophets and Apostles upon whose word and doctrine we are builded as living stones and a habitation to God Eph. 2.20 21 22. then to relye upon the word of such seducers as H. Nicholas Del Saltmarsh and the like who come in their owne name and bring neither word nor workes to witnesse their doctrine not so much as Simon Magus and the Antichrist who bring wonders and living miracles to evidence that they are sent from God Familists have no escape but to say that their new discoveries are revealed to them by the Spirit to be contained in the spirituall and allegoricke sense of the Scripture Now undeniably the Scripture hath a literall sense and here it hath a mysticall and spirituall sense and so many senses as the Papists teach So Bellermine de verb. dei l 3. c. 3. Thomas p. 1. art 10. So Cajetanus ibid. Alpâ—onsus a Castro l. 1. adver her Lyra in 2. Reg. 7 Bucanus in Theolog. Scolastic part 2. c. 3. q. 5. 11. The same Gospell-truths in the manner of preaching and delivering of them may be spiritually by some and literally and dryly published by others and nothing is thereby either added or taken away from the substance of truth But duties commanded in the Law are then pressed upon the consciences of the hearers in a legal way when they are forced upon the consciences of the people upon legal motives Law-obligations threatnings of curses sad judgements but they are then spiritually preached when they are pressed upon the hearers in a terrible Law-way but for that end discovered to them that they may be chased into Jesus as to the Gospel-sanctuary and City of refuge to such as runne themselves out of breath to be in the bosome of our Saviour 2. They would be pressed so spiritually as there may bee still a pointing at a pardoning ransome and a healing and curing spirit so that all obedience must be new from new principles of the Mediators grace and upon Gospell motives only not from Hagar and the covenant tending to bondage Nor 3. upon the same necessity and account they were to be performed by vertue of a Covenant of workes What I before said toucheth the question whether the formall and last object of our faith be the word of God or the anointing strength saving grace and eye-salve of the Spirit as some Schoolmen Granado and others affirme the latter but the word is the formall object of faith the saving grace or anointing the efficient by which we are anointed inabled and quickned to beleeve the word now the eye-salve or anointing is not that which we see and beleeve that which we see is the saving Gospel-truths we beleeve Saltmarsh with Familists denying the Scripture to bee the word of God will have the inward supernaturall grace and anointing to be the only obliging rule of faith otherwise saith he it s in vaine to write bookes one against another for we then but set letter to letter argument to argument reason to reason but all in vaine without the Spirit as if Christ in proving the resurrection against Saduces Paul in proving justification by faith without works against such as turn the grace of God into wantonnes had not set letter to letter argument to argument and all in vaine for they remained still blinde yet Christ and Paul convinced and silenced these obstinate wranglers by the word of God without powring the Spirit on them without whose power they remained unconverted and hardened against the truth the formall object is that into which our faith is resolved when we give a reason of our faith as thus for what cause or formall motive doe you see with the eye of faith and believe that Maries son is the Messiah only Saviour ye do answer because so saith the Lord in the Old and N. Testament and that is the true object but yee doe not give an account of your faith when yee answer I beleeve it because I have eyes within inlightned because that is not to answer what is the true object of your faith if any aske you upon what morall grounds goe you to Rome yea give no reason if yee answer I goe to Rome because I have a will and a locomotive power in the nerves and muscicles of my body to move for now you answer by the efficient cause when the question is made of the formall objective cause If any aske why doe you see colours in day-light yee doe not answer because I have eyes and a seeing faculty but to the former you say I goe to Rome for such businesse to the lâ—tter I see colours in day-light because they are seeable and colours cloathed with light before my eyes so 1 Ioh. 5.10 He that beleeveth on the Sonne of God hath the witnessâ— within him that is the beleever hath objectively the the truth stamped in his heart but the anointing by which he was inabled to receive the testimony and truth is not for that the object or the thing beleeved or received but the saving helpe by which wee are strengthened to beleeve and receive the testimony the inward speaking of God to the heart as Augustine saith lib. 11. confess c. 3. sine strepitu syllabarum without noise of words is the saving apprehending of Christ and Gospell-truths but it is not the thing or object savingly apprehended the day-starre in the heart is not the Gospell-truth that wee see and receive but the light of Christ inabling and the Spirit strengthning the soule to beleeve and receive these Gospell-truths for without the day-starre and Spirit no man can see these truths 12. Upon the principles of Antinomians and Familists these and the like Gospell-promises I will give you a new heart and a new spirit Behold I make all things new a bruised reed shall hee not breake Come to me all yee that are weary and heavy laden and I will ease you Him that commeth I will in no wise cast away but will raise him up at the last day Yee that have no mony come buy and eat c. are as literall and legall being written and preached and as carnall for they value them to be but outward ordinances as this Cursed be every one that abides not in all that is written in the Law of God to do it or as the very Law and Covenant of workes which promiseth not any new heart but presseth the Law in its
that the dead which are fallen asleep in the Lord rise up in this day of his judgement and appeare unto us in godly glory which shall henceforth live in us everlastingly with Christ and reign upon the earth is a detestabl hereticke But H.N. teacheth so Evangel c 37. sect 9. Whosoever teacheth that to bee borne of the Virgin Mary out of the seed of David after the flesh is to bee exponed of the pure doctrine out of the seed of love is a detestable hereticke But H.N. teacheth so Document sent c. 3. sect 5. Whosoever teacheth that Jesus Christ is come againe unto us according to his promise to the end that they all which love God and his righteousnesse and Christ and perfect being might presently enter into the true rest which God hath prepared from the beginning for his elect and inherit the everlasting life is a detestable hereticke But H.N. Evan. c. 1. sect 1. teacheth so c. Having examined these reasons with the books of H.N. we doe finde that in truth he holdeth these heresies and we think in our hearts and of our own knowledge affirm that H.N. is in these heresies a detestable heretick promising faithfully befor God and your honours never hereafter to have any dealing with his bookes and doctrin nor to go about to bring any to the love liking or reading of them and that we now speak is the true meaning of our heart as we look for mercy at his hands which searcheth the heart It shall never be well with England till the like abjuration of the doctrine of H.N. of Wil. Del Joh. Saltmarsh of Town Eaton Den Crispe and the scandalous Antinomians be tendered to most of the Army of Sir Thomas Fairfax and all the Sectaries in England but the Arme of the Lord must still bee stretched out against the land in fury and indignation till it be destroyed and till he throughly avenge the quarrell of the Covenant with so high a hand and so presumptuously broken by the Kingdome of England A MODEST SVRVEY of the secrets of Antinomianisme with a briefe refutation of them from the word of truth CHAP. I. Antinomians unjustly aceuse us IT cannot be judged either a wounding of the weake who side with Familists for a bastard love with Antinomians for a dead and rotten faith with Libertines the enemies of holy walking with God to answer those that aske a reason of our hope especially when we are nick-named Legalists Antifidians Pharisees Antichristian teachers enemies to free Grace because we stand for a rule of righteousnesse in the Law repentance from dead workes strict and close walking with God against all which that is to me a wall of brasse As deceivers and yet true as unknowne and yet well knowne Yet I give a briefe account of those saving and innocent Doctrines of the hoast of Protestant Divines if possibly truth may pierce through their eye-lids who winke because they will not see Of old the Albigenses were called Hereticks but saith an indifferent man genus haereseos nunquam nominant So now neither the heresie nor the Protestant Divine can be named that teach that the Law and Gospel are mixt in the matter of justifitation or that teares of repentance wash us from our sinnes that the covenant of grace is a covenant of works that we are to seeke righteousnesse in our selves CHAP. II. Antinomians are Pelagians WEe are farre from Pelagian grace that an unconverted man can leave sinne because sinne hath an earnest desire of soule-saving comfort cannot speak nor doe but in feare of sinne that an hypocrite under the Law can in good earnest and down-rightnesse of heart yeeld himselfe wholly to the law of God as a wife to her husband to bee instructed and ordered in all things inwardly and outwardly after the minde of God in the Law So Saltmarsh telleth us of a Legally-Gospel-way of conversion in which Christ in truth is received Much like to that of Familists of New England that a Legalist for truth may attaine the same righteousnesse that Adam had in innocency before the fall and a living faith that hath living fruits may grow from the living law We judge that an unconvert is so farre from a conformity to the Law that his conscience is burnt with a hot iron and he never saw his keepers face hee being under the law a captive in thick darkenesse and therefore all his faire vertues are white sinnes 2. Hee is an ill tree that cannot bring forth good fruit 3. True mortification is wrought by the Gospel-spirit 4. The law cannot give life 5. An hypocrites faith who is under the Law is dead CHAP. III. We hold no morall preparations with Pelagians Papists and Arminians going before conversion WEe teach not that which Saltmarsh falsely chargeth us that Vowes and undertakings never ascending to Christ fit us for conversion nor doe we too much burne or bear the wine of Gospel-grace with the Law-fire of workes and conditions For 1. we deny against Antinomians and Arminians any such Gospel-promise he that doth this and this and is so and so fitted with such conditions quallifications as money and hire in hand shall be converted as a reward of his worke The question touching preparations is not whether an humbled soule because humbled hath a good warrant to beleeve and receive Christ. We conceive the bottome of no mans faith is within himselfe but the common ground and Royall charter warranting all to beleeve is the free and money lesse offer of a precious Saviour who ever will have Christ and pay not a penny of condition or law worke for him take him freely But the question is of Christs order of bringing us to beleeve and close with Christ and the question is whether a damned Pharesee on his high horse of merits and law-righteousnesse an undaunted Heifer a Simon Magus a despitefull Atheist Elymas a Witch never broken nor convinced by the law must in that distance to Christ and the Gospel be charged to beleeve an everlasting love of election toward himselfe and without more adoe be led into the Kings chamber of wine to the slowings of soule-redeeming bloud or must he first bee humbled convinced of sinne burdened with everlasting burning due to him and so led to Christ. Antinomians say Sinners as sinners belong to Christ and have Christ offered to them as sinners and none can beleeve too hastily in Christ but sure they can beleeve or presume too misorderly and arrogate Christ to themselves as you teach them while they know no sinne-sicknesse for Christ. For 1. some too hastily will bee Christs Disciples before they make their reckoning what it will cost them 2. The Lords order is to cast downe and then convert first he draweth away some of the ill bloud and rancke humours and pricketh the heart and then bringeth the sicke to the Physitian the trembing Publicane
spirit and that it is no sinne in a beleever not to see his grace Which is all one as not to know try and prove himselfe whether he be in Christ or no. And so wee may contravene a command of God and not sin and to sin against one of the offices of the Spirit which is to make us know the things that are freely given us of God is no sinâ— And in Calvins time Libertines say to know good or ill was the old Adam to know and want the feeling of grace of holinesse or of sinne was mortification and a dead conscience not to bee moved nor touched with sorrow or feeling of sinne nor to feare it in justified persons is faith and and true mortification so the New England Libertines CHAP. XLIV Antinomians say all doubtings is inconsistent with Faith THe Justified say the Antinomians are to doubt no more freedome and libertie purchased in Christ frees you from all bondage as if you were in heaven and gives assurance without all wavering feare or doubting Wee are not to feare our sinnes nor any thing else Which keepeth good harmony with New Englands Libertines who say that doubting in any sort is inconsistent with true assurance especially after the revelation of the Spirit which some call the broad Sealâ— and to doubt upon the commission of some haynous sinne whether God be my Father argueth the party doubting to bee under a covenant of works No question doubting in justified persons is a sinne Christ rebuketh it Why doubt yee 2. Christ requireth faith without doubting 3. Hee forbiddeth it 4. It s contrary to faith 5. And punished But it is in the truely justified Faith and fainting are almost woven thorow either in the same prayer in David Psal. 31.22 I said in my hast I am cut off from before thine eyes this is great fainting yet there is fire under ashes faith bordering with fainting neverthelesse thou hardst the voice of my supplication So is it with Jonah Ezechiah Iob. Dregges in the bottom when the wine is jumbled appeare in the Prophets complaint an ague of madnesse starts up beside reason and above faith even after Asaph and Jeremiah both had received the broad seale of the revealing Spirit when Faith sickens it dyeth not Will the Lord cast us off for ever and will he be favourable no more is his mercy cleane gone for ever doth his promise faile for evermore And wilt thou be altogether to me as a lyar and as waters that faile 2. This goeth on another false ground that being freed from the curse of the Law wee are freed from all fits of the old agues of the Spirit of bondage and that all trouble of conscience argue a Law-state of works but that old guest upon sense of sinne and apprehension of wrath can make a new plea betweene the soule and Christ and there will arise new stormes of love-jealousies and complaints against the beloved surmises of unbeliefe because sinne dwelleth in the justified 3. Davids bones were broken for sinne and for his sinnes the arrowes of God sticke in his flesh and his moisture is turned into the drought of summer 4. There can be no neerer way to despaire and shake the very foundations of a beleevers faith then comfort him so miserably as say if ever he doubt he is under the Law and under the curse since it argueth the strong man to be cast out when he throweth in fire-brands of doubtings in at the windowes to see if he can regaine his place CHAP. XLV Antinomians not Protestants Merit-mongers ANtinomians say that wee teach the same with Merit-mongers who say the reward is given ex pacto by covenant as due debt because of the fidelity of God and not that our works in strictnesse of justice deserve such a reward to which we answer 1. None of us say the crowne is given either for faith or for good works as if they should determine the Lord to give a reward or lay bands on him for the intrinsecall dignitie and meritorious vertue that Christs merit hath put on our works we utterly deny any such vertue either in our good works considered in their owne nature or as they borrow some perfume of Christs meriting vertue Paul Rom. 3. argueth that none are justified by works because saith hee all have sinned vers 9. both Jew and Gentile every mouth vers 19.20 stopped and all the world is become guilty if then our works were thus perfect that they were void of sinne they should have a power to justifie But Towne asser 77.78 Eaton Honey combâ— cap 16.459.460.461 say Christ giveth perfection to our works and maketh them free of inherent sin this is as much as Papists say Christs bloud conferreth a power of meriting on good works 2. They say we fulfill the Law in Christ when he makes our works perfect and sinnelesse then we also justifie our selves by our good works in Christ. But we know that Antinomians give more then a meriting power to good workes while they make them perfect as Christ and free from sinne as his actions are Why but then should they not justifie us before God if they be perfect and render us before God perfect as M. Towne saith and Eaton saith Justification is meritorious of all the favour and blessings of God Sanctification of it selfe merits nothing at all This is more horrid merit then ever a Papist taught For Justification if it merit all the favor and blessings of God then must it merit the favour of eternall election to glory of effectuall calling of Christs comming in the flesh of free Redemption of the sending of the Gospel of grace to this nation rather then to this whereas all these goe before justification and flow from a more ancient and eternall free grace then Justification even from eternall election and everlasting love 2. But Sanctification saith he of it selfe merits nothing nor doe Merit-mongers say their best works of themselves merit any thing but as dipt in Christs bloud from whose grace they borrow a meriting power and of justice besides a free promise and paction God oweth a crowne of glory to these works say Papists and this meriting power say they though it be borrowed from Christ yet our workes have from the grace of Christ the formall principle of them a meriting power beside before and without all free paction and promise of reward that God maketh to our works and here we part waies with all Merit-mongers and shall never we hope meet But that God hath made a promise of his free grace to reward our works and hath tyed himselfe to himself not to us is cleare For God is not unrighteous to forget your worke saith the Scripture and labour of love and it is a righteous thing with God to recompence tribulation to them that trouble
1. That they would have the Gospel a body and susteme of non-senses and foolish dreames and all Logick banished that the Gospel may be a fardell of phancies under the vaile of spirituall and supernaturall knowledge for the perfect like that piece called the Bright Starre and Theologiâ— Germanica and the Power of Love and the Tree of knowledge of good and evill 2. All reasonings and use of Logick which the Prophets and Apostles make a heavenly and spirituall use of in the Scripture to them are Legall and smell too much of the dead Letter the sowre and killing Law yea the Letter of written Gospel because written and because preached and opened in spirituall discourses to Cornwell and others is a humane thing and begets but a humane faith so that Faith commeth by hearing is to Saltmarsh not vocall Preaching but the very Spirit of grace working faith as I observed before 3. All expounding of Scripture by consequence is expounding of Scripture in the Letter saith Saltmarsh in the Letter to Towne is in a Law-way to Cornewell is in a humane not a Divine way Then Christ Matth. 22. must bee a Legall Preacher and must argue after a Law-way or a humane not a Divine and Gospel-way and must much darken the glory of the Gospel for he proveth the resurrection of the dead onely by a consequence I am the God of Abraham c. Ergo the dead shall rise and he sharply rebuketh the Sadduces as ignorant both of the Scripture and the power of God because they did not thus argue in the Letter and in the consequence to the darkening of the glory of the Gospel Libertines said also to reason against committing of Adultery as Joseph doth Shall I doe this and sinne against God Is a worke of Old Adam discerning good and evill as wee shall heare if the Lord will And Saltmarsh saith Exhortations perswasions conditionall promises and Gospel-commandements are natural and so conveyances carnall Legall and of the Letter Which to me is a foule aspesâ—ron laid on the Gospel and a mixing of Law and Gospel Works and Faith according to the Antinomians way and a rendering of the preaching of the Gospel which is the power of God and the wisdome of God as odious as the Jewes and Greeks made it of old that is to make it a meere naturall and humane thing But reasoning from Scripture is as Divine as to convince silence rebuke convert and open the heart though the Spirit bee the principall agent in these 4. If wee be meere patients and act nothing by any obligation but as the Spirit acteth on us and in us then not onely the morall Law but the very Law of nature and the dictats of a naturall conscience shall not of themselves oblige us as to honour our Parents to love our brethren to doe to all as we would that men should doe to us except the Spirit act us to these duties and then must either the Holy Ghost attend the suggestions and dictats of the law of nature to blow with and concurre with them and with the Word read and preached which were a fettering of the Holy Ghost to attend the inclinations and motions of our heart or then no man could sinne at all against either the Law of nature or written Scripture save onely these heathen and others who resisted the Spirit not to say that grace were not grace nor every way free if the will of the creature should be master and exercise a dominion over grace to command at its nod the spirations and breathings of the Holy Ghost then should it be in the power of free will to dispose of desertions absence and the ebbings of the joyfull out-goings and manifestations of the Holy Ghost so should wee command the North and South winde of the Spirit to blow upon the garden that the Spices may flow out and command the out-flowings of the river and the tyde that gladneth the soule Which sure we cannot admit or then our doubtings complaints love-jealousies should be free of all unbeliefe and disquieting doubts contrary to Scripture and experience yea and all our sinnes and darknesse and false apprehensions under sad desertions should bee counted on the Holy Ghosts score as his sin who did not act us to the declining of these sinnes and the performing the contrary duties and not be imputable to us for all sinne must bee contrary to some Law-obligation 5 We hence clearely see Antinomians must come fully up to New England Libertines that In the saving conversion of a sinner the faculties and workings of the soule in things pertaining to God are destroyed and made to cease and the holy Ghost commeth in place of them as the faculties of the humane nature of Christ whereas grace purgeth away the oare but destroyeth not the gold and doth not remove nor substantially change the soule and heart but maketh it new sanctifieth it reneweth the Spirit purgeth the conscienâ—e bringeth all things to our memory When Christ casteth the old heart in his furnace or putteth it on a new frame it loseth no substance but receiveth a new mould 6. It fomenteth the presumption of the Libertine who saith If Christ will let me sinne let him looke to it upon the perill of his honour bee it Which may have this good sense as to be a word of boldnesse of faith holding forth as much as it highly concerneth the honor of Christ his faithfulnesse and unchangeable grace who is intrusted with all the flocke young and old to suffer none to fall in such sinnes as may tend to or be a finall falling from Christ but that upon the perill of his glory He will lose none but raise them up at the last day but as Libertines sense carrieth the matter the justified cannot sinne Christs Spirit is ingaged to enact immediatly and to preserve the ransomed man from all sinne if the man fall Christs Spirit not inacting him to stand is the Author and cause of his fall Whereas we are commanded to keepe our selves in the love of God David kept himselfe from his iniquitie CHAP. XLVIII Antinomians hold that the beleever cannot sinne against God but against men in his conversation WEe beleeve that the Law or Commandement of Christ respecteth our salvation with God as well as our conversation with men contrary to Antinomians who will have us as compleatly saved being once justified as sinnlesse and perfectly holy as the glorified in heaven Yea wee have not so much as the blot of Papists venials or Protestants sinnes of infirmity or originall sinne dwelling in us So as I judge the man that said to a learned opposer of the Anninomians spoke right in the Antinomian way Sinne is nothing how then can Christ hate nothing If from eternity it was so pardoned and remitted before it was committed I see not how to Antinomians it must not bee meere nothing as concupiscence
marrow of Antinomianisme that there is no sinne condemned in the Gospel but unbeliefe so there is no command of holy walking and sanctification in the Gospel but onely Faith therefore Saltmarsh saith All these Scriptures that set forth to us sanctification and mortification Christ is made to us sanctification I live not but Christ liveth in me But yee are sanctified but yee are justified we are his workmanship created unto good works I can doe all things through Christ that strengthneth me c. All these Scriptures set forth Christ the sanctification and the fulnesse of his the All in All. Christ hath beleeved perfectly hee hath repented perfectly hee hath sorrowed for sinne perfectly hee hath obeyed perfectly hee hath mortified sinne perfectly and all is ours and wee are Christs and Christ is Gods And so wee are to beleeve our repentance true in Christ who hath repented for us our Mortifying sinne true in him through whom we are more then corquerours our new obedience true in him who hath obeyed for us who is the ende of the Law to every one that beleeveth our change of the whole man true in him who is righeousnesse and true holynesse and thus without faith it is unpossible to please God And this is the divinity of Denne That mortification and vivification are but the living by or through faith and beleeving in him that justifieth the sinner And that learned Divine M r Tho. Gataker saith of one Heyden a follower of Eaton That in a Sermon on 1 Joh. 3.7 He that doth righteousnesse is righteous he expounded that place of our doing righteousnesse in Christ who hath done righteousnesse for us so hee expounded the doing of our heavenly Fathers will the putting on of the New man which is created in righteousnesse and holynesse abounding in the worke of the Lord to be the beleeving of Christs imputed righteousnesse to bee ours So doe Saltmarsh and his fellowes teach us to expound all the Gospel-precepts and exhortations to holynesse to walke in Christ to be aboundant in the worke of the Lord to walke in love to love one another to honour our father and our mother to obey Magistrats and Masters to deale justly with servants to abstaine from fleshly lusts to mortifie our members not to defraud one another not to lye c. to be nothing but beleeve Christ hath done all these for us So as the grace of God and the Gospel layeth on us no tye or obligation in our persons to deny our selves to live holyly justly and soberly in this present world to love one another by vertue of a Commandement for that is Legall saith Saltmarsh and Jewish so as Christ Jesus is made the same very way our imputed sanctification as he is our imputed righteousnesse and so personall holynesse should no more be added by any obligation of command to Christ our sanctification then to Christ our righteousnesse CHAP. L. How we are freed from the Law in regard of Sanctification as of Justification NOr doe wee deny as Antinomians would charge us But we are from under the Law in regard of Sanctification as well as of Justification thus farre that the Apostle saith As many as are Christs are led by the Spirit of Christ and so not under the Law and if yee be led of the Spirit yee are not under the Law But this onely beareth so much that our voluntary free sweet and loving obedience commeth not from the feare of cursings Rom. 8.15 or the Spirit of bondage but yet from the binding and obliging authority of the Law-giver nor is this obliging rule and government of the Law contrary to the sweet cords of Gospel-love by which the Spirit kindly draweth and gently leadeth the Saints in the way of Sanctification these two are made friends in Christ and jarre not as contraries which is the cardinall and first principle of grosse mistaking in the Antinomian while hee grosely conceiveth there is no awe of love in the Law which commandeth all gracious acts of feare though not from Law-principles for the Law is terrible and causeth Moses feare and quake but it is because it acteth and breatheth out curses on Moses as a sinner and a broken man to chase him in to his surety and the sweet sanctuary of a terrified conscience but the Law demandeth the same awe and feare of love of sinne as sinne and as done against a Father in a covenant of grace It is true when the man is once under sin he cannot pay the debt of lovely awe out of his owne unbroken and sinnelesse nature Yet the Law still craveth as the Law and it craveth the same debt if the broken man pay it out of money borrowed from his suretie that is from the sanctifying Spirit of Christ the Law is the same craver the summe is the same debt now payed in gold though clipped and wanting many graines because of the sinnefulnesse of flesh out of the Kings treasure the fulnesse of Christ and his Spirit of grace the sinner is the same debter that is obliged to the same creditor and Lawgiver onely the bond and the tenor of it is changed grace is in the bond and it is payed now not as Law-debt this doe and live by Law-right and a covenant of works which pre-supposeth neither a bankrupt nor a breach in the debter nor an offence to the creditor nor a surety or Mediator to bee baile for the broken man but it s payed with the same obligation and Law-power and commanding authority but also now from a new principall the summe is better money and in one respect is choiser it is the coyne of a new King and stamped with a new Image of Gospel-grace in another respect it is worse because tainted with sinne Whereas obedience under the covenant of works was to be perfect and sinnelesse or not at all CHAP. LI. Antinomians ignorant of Jewish Law-service and of Gospel-obedience ANtinomians speake evill of that they know not Saltmarsh saith All Gospel-ordinances are onely wayes and meanes for God to reveale his love and grace by the Spirit of adoption not any wayes or meanes of ours for getting some love from God which Christ himselfe hath not gotten for us So there is not now saith he Gospel-teaching and obeying but men now runne in a Legall straine and would worke God downe into his old and former way of revealing himselfe as under the Law when he seemed to be onely in the way to reconciliation and peace rather then pacified and thus in prayer and fasting and other acts of obedience they deale with God as under the Old Testament not considering the glorious love revealed in Christ crucified We cannot but complaine to God of these men who slander our Doctrine and cease not to pervert the right wayes of God For if Saltmarsh meane that we thinke by fasting praying and acts of Evangelick Sanctification to buy the love
follow that the Law bee urged in tenour of a meere covenant of works yea or as hedged with ceremoniall and bloudy sacrifices that are Heraulds of our guiltinesse and hand-writings of condemnation is accidentall to the Law not essentiall though the Law have its denomination from this sad office Rom. 7. Rom. 8. Yee are dead to the Law yee are not under the Law so that under the Gospel the Law is substantially and formally the same saith Luther as death is essentially the same before the fall under Moses and under Christ Luth. tom 1. fol. 56. Relativè non formaliter aut substantialiter est peccatum sublatum Lex abolita mors distructa then the Law in its essence and obliging power is eternall never abolished But Antinomians will have the Gospel-grace to loose a man from all commanding Lawes because he is pardoned and because he getteth a pardon for Adultery and murther and such like they conceive this pardon giveth a dispensation that though he commit Adultery and Murther being once a pardoned David he sinneth now against no Law henee beleeve and be pardoned saith the Antinomian and sinne if you can The most ingenious Antinomian I know is M. Randall who as M. Gataker saith Preached that it s as possible for Christ himselfe to sin as for a child of God to sinne And M. Simson That if a man know himselfe by the Spirit to be in the state of grace though he be drunk or commit murther God seeth no sinne in him And when Abraham denied his wife and lyed even then truly all his thoughts words and deeds were perfectly holy and righteous from all spot of sinne in the sight of God And Randall Its blasphemy for a child of God to crave pardon for sinne And it cannot bee avoided the Adultery of a beleever is but seeming Adultery and he is an Adulterer and a sinner so saith Saltmarsh to the eyes of the world and else-where to sense and feeling not truely and before God or in his account for to Faith saith Towne there is no sinne And even that same Text That not a tittle of the Law can perish proveth the same for Matth. 5.19 Whosoever beleever or unbeleever shall breake one of these least Commandements and shall teach men so as Antinomians doe shall bee called the least in the kingdome of heaven and whosoever shall doe and teach the same shall be called great in the kingdome of heaven Now 1. that Christ speaketh of the Law there as ordinarily it was taken for a binding and obliging rule is cleare vers 17 Think not I am come to destroy the Law and the Prophets for hee speaks of that which he came to fulfill but hee came to fulfill the Law by doing and suffering 2. That which may be broken in a sinnefull way is a binding and obliging rule but the Law Christ speaketh of there may be broken for hee saith Whosoever therefore shall breake c. 2. That he intendeth that the Law stand as a rule binding to personall obedience and not to imputative obedience onely in the Mediator is cleare For 1. he saith Whosoever shall breake the least of these it must bee understood of personall breaking not imputative for hee that breaketh the Law in Christ his breach being imputed to Christ shall not be the least man but a chiefe man in the kingdome of heaven even a heire of heaven 2. If the binding and obliging Law bee not understood Christ came in the Antinomian sense to free beleevers both from the cursing and obliging and commanding Law Now sure Christ came to destroy the Law as it curseth and condemneth beleevers for he exhausted the curse and dyed the cursed death for us but he came not to take away the binding power because he both threatneth the breaker and the Antinomian teacher of breaches with being the least of the kingdome of heaven that is with being excluded out of heaven by a meiosis for it is opposed to be great in the Kingdome and also he promiseth a reward to the doer he shall bee great in the kingdome Now that Law which is hedged with threatning and reward is a binding Law 2. The beleever can neither breake the Law in order to punishment nor keepe and doe the Law in order to reward by the Antinomian way because they are freed from all binding and obliging Law say the Antinomians as well as from all cursing and condemning Law so Christ could doe no more if he intended to come in the flesh to destroy the Law then if he should take away the whole nature and being of the Law for he removeth say the Antinomians all the binding and commanding all the threatning and minatory power and the rewarding and promissory power of the Law from beleevers What then leaveth hee of the Law to any man who beleeveth Just nothiâ—g Antinomians say Christ came to fulfill the Law by doing and suffering and so came not to destroy it Anâ—w That cannot be his meaning here for the Argument of our Saviour should so conclude nothing and it is this If whosoever breaketh the least Commandement of the Law and teacheth others to doe so bee debarred out of heaven and who so doth and teacheth men to doe the Law be great in heaven then I the Saviour of man came not to destroy but to fulfill the Law But the former is true Ergo so is the latter The major proposition hath no truth for by the Antinomian way beleevers according to the Antinomian Gospel are neither excluded heaven in breaking the Law nor admitted to heaven in doing the Law but Christ doth all for them and they are not excluded heaven for breaking a Law they are freed from all binding commanding and obliging power of the Law and who can breake a Law who is under no Law Where there is no Law there is no transgression saith Saltmarsh applying it wickedly to this case and to all trouble of conscience for sinne when we are once justified 5. The Antinomians place liberty from the Law in the free loose and wide walking without any feare of sinning against a Law which to them is a shaddow a fancie and nothing and in being compelled for feare of wrath and eternall vengeance to love and serve God as if the Law of God did command us to serve God for feare of wrath and hire or hope of reward But the holy Law of God biddeth us feare sinne before and after it is committed For the Law commandeth the whole feare of God and the offending of his Majesty by sinne And happy is the man that feareth alway this fearing of sin is contrary to hardnesse of heart he is happy who feareth an oath lest he be insnared Now fearing sinne as sinne is contrary to a law is bondage and floweth from the Spirit of bondage say Antinomians Yea it is unbeliefe and a making God a lyar because say they there is no spot of sinne in the
own gift laying hold on the righteousnesse of Christ freely and of onely pure grace imputed to us 5. Cornewell and other Antinomians make arguing obedidience and perswading comforts by inferences and consequences works of man not able to produce assurance and Saltmarsh thinketh discoursing and reasoning not enough to produce assurance of faith and he thinks it a Legall bondage to support the soule from marks and such things as cannot give evidence but by inferences yet all the superstructures of faith in Gospel-obedience as binding upon perswading arguing reasoning All other assurances saith Saltmarsh beside the assurance of the light of faith such as are from marks and love to the brethren that come by way of reasoning and arguing are rotten conclusions from the Word and such things as true legall teachers have invented not understanding the mystery of the kingdome of Christ then all Scripture and Gospel-arguing are vaine janglings by this 6. Nor doth the Gospel command by patterne rather then precept as if the examples of the cloud of Witnesses who running their race with patience inherit the promise of free salvation Hebr. 12.1 2 3. should destroy commands or as if patternes without Law or any otherwise but in so farre as they are warrantted by the Law of God did tye and oblige us to obedience and imitation for if patternes as patternes did tye us then should we be obliged to follow the Fathers and Christ in their extraordinary works and miracles which neither Law nor Gospel commands us to doe 7. But the truth is outward commandements written or preached by Antinomians are given to us in the Gospel onely by accident and because we are carnall and sinnefull but were we as spirituall as we should be wee should need no Law but that which is spirituall and written in the heart no more then Angels need a written and outward Law Now that Antinomians meane this is cleere by Saltmarsh his Divinity Commands saith hee are for obedience as well as tydings of forgivenesse this kind of Gospel fits both God and man and God the Father may be seen in commanding holinesse and the Spirit in forming the holynesse commanded and the Sonne in redeeming us to holynesse even to the will both of the Father and the Spirit And this Gospel fits man who is made up both of flesh and Spirit and so hath need of a Law wâ—thout and in the Letter as well as in the heart and Spirit the Law is spirituall but we are carnall Rom. 7. Nor can a state oâ— flesh and Spirit bee ordered onely by a Law within for the word and Law of the Spirit meerely is for a spirituall condition or estate of glory as Angels who live by a Law spirituall and state of revelation Answ. 1. Here be strange conceits of old libertinisme Gospel commands are as well saith he for obedience as tydings of forgivenesse But why for obedience Any disobedience to them is no sinne in a beleever as is proved then they are not to a beleever for obedience 2. I know not how man because hee is flesh hath need of a Law without and the letter of an outward command then because he is spirit or as he is spirituall he hath need of no Law nor letter of an externall command Timothy then hath no need as he is a renewed man to give himselfe to meditation and reading and doctrine nor to continue in the things that he had knowne from the Scriptures which are given by divine inspiration to save his owne soule and others and to make him perfect to every good worke Nor have the Saints at Colosse need that the word of Christ dwell richly in them Nor the called of Iesus Christ at Rome as they are called and sanctified any need of learning from the Scriptures that they through patience and comfort of the Scriptures might have hope Onely the flesh and the old man possibly hath need of the Scriptures and the letter of the command then it was not Davids inward man that esteemed the testimonies of God and his promises sweeter then the honey and the honey combe and as his heritage and more then thousands of silver and gold Nor did Peter or the Saints as regenerated to a lively hope 1 Pet. 1.3 and as they obtained the like precious faith relish the promises as great and precious but onely their flesh found sweetnesse in Gods word And Mary not as renewed but according to the flesh and corruption sate at Christs feete and heard his word and choosed the better part that could not bee taken from her And this sorts well with the old Anabaptists who said that the unregenerate onely needed outward ordinances as the Word preached by men and hearing reading Sacraments but for the regenerate there is no need that any teach his neighbour because we are all taught of God and the annoynting teach-them all And the Sonnes of God are not subject to the Law that is they are not to bee taught what they should doe or leave undone seeing the Spirit of God which is their instructor will teach them sufficiently neither is any thing to bee commanded or injoyned them as to doe good or eschew evill or the like The same Spirit I say doth command or injoyn them likewise to retaine the best and quit the contrary and obey them accordingly And so speake the Libertines of N. England These that bee in Christ are not under the Law or commands of the Word as the rule of life 3. If man because he is flesh hath need of a Law without and in the Letter by flesh is either understood a body and sensitive soule but then the meaning must be that the Law of Word and Gospel is given to the outward man to regulate him in his animal and vitall actions as eating sleeping walking seeing hearing and other senses as if no Law were imposed on the Spirit heart understanding conscience and will a carnall dreame that many put upon the Pharisies or by the flesh must be understood the unrenewed and sinnefull corruption This must be the sense of Saltmarsh for hee citeth Rom. 7.14 The Law is spirituall that is just and holy as vers 12. Wherefore the Law is holy and the commandement is holy and just and good but I am carnall that is sinfull flesh unholy and sold under sinne Now thus Law and Gospel commands threatnings Gospel-promises sweet invitations of free grace that loaden sinners would come to Christ and bee refreshed eased saved are all given to man because he is sinnefull and no outward Commandement would be laid on man if he had not sinned which is a conjecture and fancie Divines say the Tree of life and of knowledge of good and ill were Sacraments to innocent Adam the Sabbath was ordained for Adams worshipping of God an outward Law was laid on him If thou eate thou shalt die when as yet Adam was not
first make our selves by some preparing grace his married Spouse For sure this is a Marriage-covenant we must first make our selves his people and then for shame he must be our God as if Marriage-love bred first in our breast and stood upon this poore legge the grace of man to God not the grace of God to lost man 2. We teach that faith in Christ is both a condition of grace on our part but not Antecedent and preparatory to the Covenant and also a grace promised when the new heart is articled to us so that Christ bringeth into the covenant himselfe his righteousnesse his free grace and the condition of Faith that receives him just as if the heire of a King should offer to marry a Maid of low birth upon condition she weare about her necke on the Marriage day a gold chaine having in it a rich Diamond of the Crowne and withall should oblige himselfe under his hand and seale in the Marriage-contract both to bestow this chaine on her freely and to infuse a Spirit of grace and love to close in her heart with such a lover and to yeeld consent to the match and to adorne her selfe with this chaine Just so doth the Prince of life here and its a vaine thing to parallel this covenant of grace with other covenants 3. Nor did ever any man before Saltmarsh dreame that Law-obedience was an Antecedent condition of the Covenant of works with Adam nor were Adam and Eve in their state of sinlesse innocencie The people of God before God was first their God for then never man Adam nor any other were under the Law or Covenant of works till first they absolved and kept to the end a course of perfect obedience Yea so there was never on earth such a thing as a covenant of works except made with Christ nor can we say that God made a Covenant of works with Adam for his perfect obedience yet sure perfect obedience was a condition of the Covenant of works Antinomians have a second great mistake of the covenant of grace while they make it as old as election to glory and the Lambe slaine from the foundation of the world it s an everlasting covenant indeed but that is not because it is not made in time Christ is an eternall Mediator and an eternall Priest and the Lambe slaine from eternity but that was onely in Gods decree and eternall purpose as touching the beginning of his Mediatorship and Priesthood and so the creation of the World is eternall but sure Christ in the fulnesse of time was made of a woman entred by a calling of God in time to bee Mediator and Priest and dyed not for sinners till the raigne of Tyberius Cesar as he was borne in the raigne of Augustus nor were we justified pardoned and redeemed from eternity more then we were effectually called sanctified and gloryfied from eternity But Antinomians will have our sinnes pardoned from eternity before we beleeve And when were we then borne in sinne and the heires of wrath by nature and under condemnation by the second Adam Never really When were we sometimes dead in sinnes and trespasses and in time past walking according to the course of this world according to the Prince of the power of the aire And sometimes foolish disobedient serving divers lusts and pleasures lyving in malice and envie hatefull hating one another Not when we were justified if we were justified from eternity and when wee were chosen to glory before the World was But so must all our sinnes before conversion be but sinnes in conversation not in conscience and our Murthers cousening stealing persecuting whoredomes if we be chosen and so justified and washed when wee are chosen are seeming and fancied not reall sinnes nor such in themselves nor to the light of faith or in Gods sight by this Antinomian dreame Their third great mistake in the covenant of grace is in the parties Saltmarsh tells us that the new covenant is no covenant properly with us but with Christ for us It s true Christ standeth for us as principall undertaker who articles as the second Adam for us yea for all his seed to worke the conditions in us he is the Mediator surety witnesse Messenger or Angel of the Covenant for us But Antinomians will have him so for us as the Covenant shall oblige us to no dutie or condition of beleeving to bee performed by us and the Gospel shall tye us to no holy walking Why Wee are saith Saltmarsh to beleeve that our beleeving repenting new obedience mortification are all true in Christ who beleeved repented obeyed for us It is true wee are to beleeve our repenting obeying beleeving are true in Christ. 1. As in the meritorious cause who hath satisfied justice for all our sinnes and for the sinfull defects in our believing repenting obeying 2. We are to beleeve they are true in Christ as the author and principall cause who works in us to will and to doe by his effectuall grace But Antinomians will not have us to beleeve they are true in us as personally and in our selves though by Christs strength acting them or doing or performing the duties of beleeving repenting mortifying our lusts by any obligation of the Law or Gospel commandement CHAP. LXVII Of Legall and Evangelicall conversion WEe deny not but there is a Legall conversion and Gospel terrours and Gospel-hell fire and condemnation and the worme that never dyes and that nature may propose ends to it selfe in turning to God outwardly and that as incident to Antinomians as to any generation of people For it is knowne that many Antinomians are deluded not converted by a worke of the Law storming and quelling the conscience with the smoake and fire-slaughts of everlasting burning especially where the conscience neighbours wich a Melancholike complexion and when the party comes to such a Physitian as M. Saltmarsh though there be no inward change in the heart no evidences either to him or the deluded soule of a new and inward worke but the party still in the gall of bitternesse no sense of sinne but a dumbe beastly feeling of the flashes of hell fire a Pharaoh-like disposition the counterfeit white Angel saith to the perplexed soule Beleeve everlasting love and read Pharaoh and Simon Magus and your own names in the Lambes Booke of life beleeve and apply immediately without care conscience or sense of sinne or humiliation all these are reprobate money to buy grace away with them to come to the bloud of attonement come though yee be neither wearie nor laden nor pricked in heart with sinne and be yee assuredly perswaded that that bloud was shed for you that yee are as cleane from sin 160. agoe as Christ himselfe Honey combe cap. 3. pag. 25. Mourne no more be not humbled doe nothing at all but rest upon what Christ hath done for you rejoyce evermore sorrowing for sinne is Legall unbeliefe severe and
without cause and Marrying another and in robbing the Widdow and Orphane and taking the Oxe away from the fatherlesse and so followeth his calling 2. Sinning according to sense and the flesh as lying and whoring are not sinnes according to Faith and before God sense is unbeliefe and a blind judge and reputeth that to be sin which is not sinne saith Eaton For Faith seeth them above sense to be utterly abolished 3. The beleever following his sense in Adultery rapine lying is under no law Ergo his following of his sense his being present at a Masse his robbing his brother cannot be a sinne then it must either be in it selfe lawfull and a following of his calling as the Libertine said or it is unlawfull The Antinomian must speake condictions to call that unlawfull which is against no Law 2. Randell a Familist setting forth a peece of Cusanus Intituled The Vision of God hath a Familists conscience to picture God himselfe and Clouds encircling him expressely forbidden in the second Command but it is no Command to him Master Denne Doctrine of John Baptist 65. retaineth the destinction of Clergy and Laicks condemned by all Protestant Divines and Pag. 66. hee saith Hee will condemne the removall of Images Idols Crucifixes of Wood Glasse of Stone but he mentions no command of God to justifie it for we are commanded no worship externall in the New Testament but Faith that is no sinne as sinne is forbidden but unbeliefe to this Towne assert grace pag. 94. cannot answer one word So H. Nicholas in his joyfull message of the Kingdome cap. 31.33.34 highly extolleth the Romish Church Pope Cardinals Bishops Priests c. Service Ceremonies till hot contention arose about them 3. We know Antinomians thinke nothing of Idolatry adding to the worship of God and that some of them speake their conscience when deterred from Adultery Murther Rapine they have said What Adultery God seeth no sinne in beleevers One of them in Scotland said hee would take the Lords Supper on the crowne of his head if Authority should command him Another said once dipping or ten times were indifferent Most of them are for libertie of all blasphemous religions and their saying is Beleeve in Christ and sin against the Law if thou canst This is to make sense that which Libertines call naturall inclination Yea all outward Commandements to Towne and Saltmarsh are but shaddowes the Spirit is all the beleevers obliging rule No externall Command can oblige a Beleever under perill of sinning against God in his court in foro Dei and wee know how broad and large their consciences bee in the matter of Marriage and Divorce CHAP. LXXXI Sundry Antinomians say Irish Papists ought to have liberty of conscience and to injoy their religion Parall XIII LIbertines said they knew that their soules were immortall and live for ever in heaven but Christ by his death hath taken away that opinion and hath restored life to us in that now wee know wee shall not die Antinomians cannot deny but wee die but they will have no death to be the execution of the righteous Lords sentence for sinne to the godly but that they returne to dust beleeving and neither feeling nor fearing sinne or punishment for sin for that is against the power faithfulnesse providence free grace sufferings of Christ faith all religion and Archer Saltmarsh Crispe upon the same grounds that the beleever committeth Adultery to his owne sense but his Adultery really and to his faith is no sinne so they are not to feare or feele any afflictions or death but to beleeve them to be shaddowes Now the removall of feare and the opinion of dying is imputed to Christs death so as Saltmarsh saith The Spirit of Christ sets a beleever as free from hell the Law and bondage here on earth as if hee were in heaven nor wants he any thing to make him so but to make him beleeve he is so for Sathan sinne sinnefull flesh and the Law are all so neere him that he cannot so walke by sight and in the cleare apprehension of it but the just doe live by Faith and Faith is the evidence of things not seene Then beside that it s his happinesse not his bondage that the Law is is so neere him that is it written in his inner parts and heart it must bee his sinne and feeling contrary to Faith which was one opinion and sense that hee knoweth and beleeveth hee must lay downe this tabernacle of clay And Towne saith Faith banisheth all the mists and vapours arising from these earthly members out of Gods sight and presence Thus I am a sinner and no sinner dayly I fall in my selfe and stand in Christ for ever But Towne lyeth in saying Hee is a sinner in himselfe and no sinner in Christ. For sinne in himselfe or to his flesh or sense is no sinne at all and against no Law his sense lyeth and deceiveth Faith by which he should walke doth truly say he is in himselfe and really no more a sinner then Christ is a sinner in himselfe and upon the same grounds sense of death and sicknesse and paine and feare are but deceiving opinions and errors contrary to faith and Christ came to dye and remove from us feare feeling opinion of all affliction and paine as contrary to faith Now it s a sinne not to walke by Faith then must the feeling of paine and death bee a sinne and Christ came to give us a sense dedolency and dulnesse of apprehending either sinne or ill of affliction and so say Libertines CHAP. LXXXII Libertines and Antinomians doubt of the Resurrection and life to come Paral. XIV LIbertines denyed the Resurrection and said with Hymeneus and Philetus That it was already done and in this life they mocked salvation in hope of the comming of the Lord they said To walke in newnesse of life was the Resurrection with Christ and all the resurrection wee are to looke for David Georgius saith As there was a revelation under Moses and the Prophets and a more cleare one under Christ and the Apostles So under himselfe the true David the Lyon of the tribe of Judah the stone hewed out of the Mountaine without hands there was now a farre more glorious revelation and most spirituall that he exceeded so farre Christ according to the flesh and the Apostles as that all Ordinances and externall worship and seales should cease when he comes because of the efficacie and spiritualnesse of his doctrine above Christ in the flesh and all the Apostles as the Spirit is above the flesh And the clouds in the which Christ was to come to judge the quicke and the dead must bee Allegorically expounded of the mindes of the Saints The Archangell that shall sound the Trumpet is the Doctrine and discipline of this David the Christ. And that the place of happinesse was in this earth not
pag. 145. Nemo negare potest sub V. T. nec vitam aeternam promissam fuisse à Deo nec modum illam consequendi fuisse patefactum Ostorodius Inst. lib. 1. cap. 5. pag. 21. Promissiones veteris Testamenti tantum corporales fuerunt spiritualibus in N. T. promulgatis Non autem spirituales eternae fuerunt consequenter non accidentale tantum sed substantiale discrimen inter Vetus Novum Testamentum si res promissas spectes statuendum est Smalcius de Divin I. C. pag. 25. â— 6 Fatentur omnes Judaei hodie nullum vitae aeternae apertum extare in ipsorum lege ut ut apertius loquar in faedere quod Deus cum iis per Mosem pepigit promissum M. Del boldly saith They are all Antichristian that are not Antichristianly Popish and of the Socinian way with him to teach there was no conversion no inward reformation no promise of salvation and life eternall nor the same covenant of grace in the old Testament that is now under the New Testament and that there was no saving grace nor operation of the Spirit accompanying the Sacraments of the old Testament but onely temporall things promised them He hath Arminians also on his side as Episcopius Disp. 11. th 5. The promises of the Law were touching temporall felicity of the Gospel concerning the everlasting inheritance â—h 7. The doctrine of the Old Testament was known by nature as agreeable to right reason the doctrine of the Gospel was unknown to the Princes of this world it is evident there is no precept say the Belgick Remonstrants Apol. cap. 22. cap. 24. clearely delivered in the Old Testament for beleeving in Christ nor in terminis any promise of life eternall It s sure Arminians are limbs of Antichrist and enemies to free grace Yet Antinomians with Del joyne hands with them against Protestants who all teach to this day the same Saviour the same promises of life eternall the same free grace of imputed righteousnesse the same covenant of grace was revealed darkely in shaddowes and types to the Jewes and more sparingly and to us more clearely and abundantly in the New Testament and that Abraham was saved as we who now are Antichistian whether Del and his Antinomians or wee These that teach the same with Antichrist and contend for perfection and freedome from all sinne in this life are not the men who must fight the battels of the Lambe But 1. was there then no Spirit and life in the Patriachs Prophets Moses David till Christ came in the flesh and reformed them inwardly What became then of the soules of those that dyed in peace and entred into their rest before Christ came in the flesh Esa. 57.1 2 3. Dyed they under the curse and severity of the second death as never inwardly converted Hee belyeth the Old Testament who saith so and doth the Letter of the Gospel without the Spirit save and inwardly reâ—orme and justifie before God more then the Letter of the Law I thinke Judas and the people whose hearts were fatted and heardned and yet heard Christ in the flesh and the Apostles preach Gospel were as farre from inward heart-reformation as uncircumcised Jewes and Heathen Mat. 13.14.15 16. Act. 28.26 27. 1 Pet. 2.7 8. Rom. 11.8 9. Joh. 8.21 Joh. 9.41 Job 5.40 Then Del must meane by the spirit some other thing then the Gospel as opposed to the condemning Law For the Gospel is a condemning Gospel to thousands who stumble at the stone laid on Zion as well as the Law 3. Del saith No outward Law of Synods Councels of men can make men perfect as pertaining to the conscience more then Leviticall Lawes could doe and so the Gospel abolisheth all such outward Lawes imposed on conscience as well now as heretofore under Moses Gospel-reformation saith he is the mortifying destroying and utter abolishing out of the faithfull and elect all that sinne corruption lust evill that did flow in upon them through the fall of Adam Or it is the taking away and destroying the body of sinne out of the faithfull and elect by the presence and operation of the righteousnesse of God dwelling in their hearts by faith This is true Gospel-reformation and beside this I know no other Esai 1.27 Zion shall be redeemed with judgement and her converts with righteousnesse Againe Christ as hee makes us righteous with his owne righteousnesse and makes us the righteousnesse of God in him so hee is called our righteousnesse not in himselfe onely but in us And therefore you see how grossely they are mistaken who take Gospel-reformation â—o bee the making of certaine Lawes and constitution by the sacred power or Clergie for externall conformity in outward duties of outward worship and government and to have these confirmed by civill Sanction and inforced upon men by secular power when in the meane time all that inward corruption and sinne they have brought with them into the world remaines in their hearts and natures as before so the old Prelats reformed His reasons are 1. All things belonging to Christ a Spirituall King having a spirituall Kingdome are spirituall a carnall Reformation is not sutable to a spirituall Kingdome The reformation of the Civill and Ecclesiasticall state is but carnall wrought by the power of flesh and bloud and stands but in outward things 2. Gospel-reformation is inward layes hold on the heart soule and inner man and changes and renewes that dâ—th not much busie it selfe about outward formes or externall conformitie but onely mindes the conformity of the heart for when the heart is right with God the outward formes cannot bee amisse Christ saith touching the worship of the New Testament God is a Spirit and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and truth hee speakes not one word of any outward formes So that God in his Gospel-reformation aymes at nothing but the heart according to Jer. 31.33 I will put my Law in their inward parts c. So that they shall not onely have the word of the Letter in their bookes but the living word of God in their hearts But now Civill Ecclesiasticall reformation is outward and so industrious and elaborate about outward formes outward orders outward governing outward confession outward practises like the Reformation of Scribes and Pharisees notorious hypocrites who made cleane onely the outside of the cup or platter leaving them all filthy and uncleane within So Civill Ecclesiasticall reformation makes a man cleane outwardly with an outward confession of Faith when inwardly he is all filthy thorow unbeliefe and whites him over with new handsome formes of worship Object But is there no change of outward things in the Gospel Ans. Yes an outward change that flowes from an inward but not an outward change to inferre an inward c. Answ. 1. Master Del must lay downe a ground that outward Lawes were imposed on the conscience and forced on them with violence of Magistrates and Synods
without any foregoing teaching under paine of corporall punishments to the Jewes as he and his saith Presbyterians doe now urge consciences how shall Del prove that 2. Hee must say that outward and meerely litterall observing of Lawes and Synodicall Decrees according to the Word of God for any others beside or against the Word the Presbyterians know none without Faith in Christ doe make men perfect as pertaining to conscience which is Dels dreame not our doctrine 3. Hee and his condemne all Lawes of the Civill Magistrate yea all the written Scripture Law and Gospel and say an Arbitrary and Enthysiasticall Spirit in the Christian Magistrate without all Civill Lawes inacted or written should conclude of the heads and lives of Christians without the Law Morall or Gospel and so condemnes all Acts of Parliaments Answ. 2. You could not have heard more if Henry Nicholas or Anton. Pocquius or David Georgius had beene preaching to the Honourable House for Del followâ—s them at the heeles For Henry Nicholas if you but change Dels word of Reformation into the word regeneration or begetting in the same Spirit debaseth Christ in the Scriptures and all outward worship as if there were one Christ in the Scripture and another contrary Christ in the Spirit and inward working for sure hypocriticall and meere externall reformation and the inward reformation are by Protestants made two contrary reformations the one from God the other not from flesh and blood onely but from the Devill So Henry Nicholas If I could give all my goods to the poore c. If I had not love it were not any thing to me that is whosoever hath not Christ he is without God and without righteousnesse in this world I meane the being like Christ which is received through the power of the Holy Ghost and not any Ceremoniall Christ which one man speaketh to another or promiseth to another through the Ceremoniall service Dels Grammar is Pag. 6. through the word of the letter in their bookes in outward formes outward worship outward confession which he out of his prudencie according to his fleshly minde hath set up ô no the worke or begetting or procreating of the children of God commeth not so slenderly to passe as men now at this time teach each other out of their unregenerate Spirit Del out of a Spirit not inwardly reformed the bodie of sinne not being destroyed no reformation can come Henry Nicholas condemning all Scripture as a Literall and carnall thing and an Elementish Ceremoniall and fleshly service yea and confession with the mouth as carnall outward hypocriticall and Pharisaicall and doth expressely reject all the teaching of men or by the ministery of men which the Apostle asserteth Ephes. 4.11 1 Cor. 4.2 2 Cor. 4.7 And the Lord Jesus the great Apostle of our profession Math. 28.19 20. Act. 1.6 8. and pronounceth the Ministery of one man teaching another to be fleshly prudence and not such a way by which the begetting or procreating of the children of God commeth to passe Now that Monster of men knew Protestants whom hee refuteth in this taught against Pelagians and the Pope whom he denieth to be the Antichrist and Papists that we utterly deny that the Scriptures of themselves yea that the Man Christs teaching in the flesh or Paul or the Apostles Preaching or any mans externall instructing of another man most soundly according to the Scriptures can without the hearing and learning of the Father Joh. 6.45 and his omnipotent drawing of men to the Sonne Joh. 6.44 and the inward teaching of the Spirit inwardly reforme or beget men over againe to God So his condemning of one mans teaching of another as Fleshly Ceremoniall Elementish is a simple rejecting of the Scriptures and all outward and externall worship And just as David Georgius rejected the Literall Christ and asserted himselfe to bee the Spirituall Christ and true David In the same manner M. Del speaking of inward Reformation that is conversion of a sinner to God that onely being his Gospel-reformation hee knoweth well Presbyterians and the Assâ—mbly of Divines who are if they shall condemne his Gospel for the substance of it the enemies of the truth of Christ and the last prop of Antichrist in the Kingdome doe teach that inward reformation or destroying of the body of sinne is not wrought by the onely Letter of the Word and the teaching of men or Lawes or Constitutions of Synods but that wee conjoine with all outward meanes the inward and omnipotent power of the Holy Ghost without whose grace all other meanes are nothing yea Pauls planting and Apollo his watering are nothing effectuall to an inward reformation M. Del argueth against the Holy Ghost and Paul who Preached the Gospel to the blaspeming Jewes and scoffing Athenians Act. 13 Act. 17. for all he could say to them was but outward and litterall preaching the Apostles were but men and not Lords of the heart and therefore could but worke outward conformity to outward duties when the heart remained corrupt Nor is it much that Dell saith there is neede of an outward change in the Gospel which indeed is a belying of himselfe for an outward change is an outward reformation and hee saith Pag. 4.5 Gospel-reformation is a destroying of the body of sinne in the faithfull and elect by the presence and operation of the righteousnesse of God dwelling in their heart by Faith besides this I know no other An outward change is an outward reformation besides this But this is nothing Del acknowledgeth neither Ministery outward worship or outward ordinances as Familists did before him For the Author of that blasphemous Peece called Theologia Germanica saith Just men have neede of no law are led by the Spirit and are not to bee taught by any Law what they should doe or leave undone seeing the Spirit of God which is their instructer will teach them sufficiently neither is any thing to be commanded or injoyned them as to doe good to shunne evill or the like but Pag. 72. Yet hee saith more then Del doth to wit That both the life of Christ as also all Commandements Lawes Ordinances and the like ought not to be laid aside and cast off and to be neglected contemned and derided And Henry Nicholas saith The Lord speaketh in the Scripture but he saith withall that the Spirit is the Word not the Letter So Del maketh an opposition betweene the Letter in the bookes and the living Word of God in the heart 3. Del speaketh exclusively Other reformation beside this of the heart saith he I know none 2. Gospel-reformation saith hee onely mindes the reformation of the heart If only then it minds not externall reformation 3. Christ speaking touching the worship of the New Testament saith saith he Not one word of any outward forme So that God in his Gospel-reformation aymes at nothing but the heart Then hee aymes at no outward change nor any externall worship
the heart spoken of Jer. 31.33 is the very new heart and the Spirit or the heart of flesh Ezech. 36.26 27. the circumcised heart Deut. 30.6 the new creature the Lord Jesus formed in the heart by Faith Gal. 4.19 Ephes. 3.17 it is not any meanes or cause or author of the new heart but it is the new heart it selfe formed by the Holy Ghost as the Author and Father of the second birth by the Word written conveyed by preaching to the soule Now except Del would say Christ onely worketh inward reformation by inward reformation onely for this inward word is inward reformation he cannot make sense of this inward word excluding the Law and outward Word both of Law and Gospel as he doth For nothing can bee more false then that the Word whereby Christ reformes is not the Word without us as the Word of the Law is but the Word within us For I find great ignorance if not worse in Familists and Antinomians in this Saltmarsh saith The Spirit worketh Legally and not freely when men doe things as meerely commanded from the power of an outward Commandement or precept in the Word he meaneth in the written Scripture For saith hee that bringeth forth but a Legall or at best but a mixt obedience and service and a finer hypocrisie and when they doe because of some vow or covenant when they take any outward thing to move them rather then apply Christ for strength life and Spirit For it is the outward Word onely in its kind that is the sole and onely objective cause as wee see colours onely because they are colours and the Light of the day-light-Sun onely because it is light and nothing else can be the object of the sense of seeing but light and colours and we onely heare sounds meerely because they are sounds and smell things odoriferous and smellable because they cast a smell and onely taste meats meerely and formally because they are sweet sowre bitter sharpe or some way good or ill to the taste Now life or the faculty of seeing hearing smelling tasting are in no sort the object of seeing hearing smelling tasting Just so when wee doe meerely for the Word in the Prophets and Psalmes without us and but of conscience and meerely as commanded from the power of an outward Commandement or Precept I adde or a Gospel-promise written in the Word then we obey God in a free filiall Gospel-way out of meere conscience to an outward Command as the onely objective ground warrant and rule of our obedience what ever Papists on the one extremity say for an unwritten Word of God and Enthysiasts on the other hand for a Word within or a Spirit acting and obliging as their onely rule excluding the Law and Gospel because they are Letters and written and Scripture and a Word without as the onely objective ground and warrant of Divine Faith was in the Prophets time Thus saith the Lord. And in Christ and the Apostles time According as it is written in the Prophets in the Scriptures So Christ Luk. 24.26 Ought not Christ to have suffered these things and to enter into his glory Vers. 27. And beginning at Moses and all the Prophets hee expounded unto them all the Scriptures the things concerning himselfe Vers. 45. Then opened he their understanding that they might understand the Scriptures and said unto them thus it is written and thus it behoved Christ to suffer and rise from the dead the third day and remission of sinnes should be preached in his name among the Nations Then Christ would have beleeving and repentance Preached and commanded for no warrant and objective ground but because the Word without the Commandement or Precept in the Word commandeth it and this Satan cannot call finener hypocrisie So Revel 2.11 Hee that hath an eare to heare an inward and renewed a circumcised eare and heart Let him heare what the Spirit saith to the Churches this Spirit speaking to the Churches is not an inward word or a regenerating Spirit in the heart of beleevers in these seven Churches Antinomians pervert the Word of God so But it is the Holy Ghost speaking in the Word without the written preached and externall Epistles that the Spirit sent to these seven Churches and so the onely meane of Abrahams obedience to sacrifice his onely sonne Isaak and the onely warrant for his faith was the Commandement of God and a Word without Goe now take thy sonne thy onely sonne Isaak and offer him to me Many other things naturall reason a seeming contrary word that he should be the sonne of Promise seeme to command the contrary but Abrahams faith appeared in this that he closed his eyes at all Commandements and carnall inhibitions of nature on the contrary and meerely for an externall command of God as the sole and onely objective warrant and formall object of his faith and of his obedience without because God so commanded he obeyed and so are wee to obey and beleeve upon no objective cause warrant or ground but the written or preached Precept or promise of the Gospel or Covenant of grace that is a word without us and the onely meane of faith and inward reformation and this Word is written as the Law is in the Scriptures and layeth an authoritative binding power on our conscience to obey God for his onely Word as the Law doth But it is not the onely Word that is the efficient and effectually working cause of our obedience if the Spirit of grace doe not concurre with both the written and preached Law and written and preached Gospel and covenant of grace wee cannot obey Antinomians make obedience for the outward written command as the onely objective cause and warrant of our faith and obedience through the effectuall working of the Spirit two contrary obediences imagining that the former is Literall Legall and finer hypocrisie and the latter the onely true obedience A grosse mistake 1. Because none can sincerely obey meerly from the power of an outward command or precept in the Word but the man whose eares the Lord circumciseth Deut. 30.6 Revel 2.11 and whose understanding Christ openeth to understand the Word without Luk. 24.45 and therefore the Word without is the onely meanes of inward reformation 2. The Letter of the Covenant of grace holdeth forth the inward grace signified and cannot bee contrary to the inward Word in the heart for the Holy Ghost as the principall efficient causeth us to obey for conscience of the command written and preached in the Gospel which is belâ—eve in the Lord Jesus or the written promise he that beleeveth shall be pardoned and saved And to say they are contrary is as good sense as to say light and colours because they are without us they are therefore contrary to life and the visive faculty of seeing within us or that sounds or sweet smelling flowers without because they are without must be contrary to the naturall faculty and sense of hearing and smelling
in our selves but that the justified must be as free of all indwelling sinne as Christ Jesus or as the glorified in heaven and so absolutely perfect in our person and our works maketh all sanctification no sanctification before God and that inherent holynesse rendreth us not a whit lovely and acceptable to God more then if wee were wallowing in our lusts and serving the Devill contrary to the Scripture that saith That our sanctification is the will of God that our service is holy living and acceptable that God is well-pleased with our sacrifices of almes in Christ Jesus And that a holy and sincere profession and walking doth take the love and ravish the heart of Christ yea by this way we sinne onely in dishonouring Christ and in not walking in him contrary to the end of Redemption which calleth us to sanctification not in the sight of God but meerely declaratively for Eaton tells us that if any more be ascribed to Sanctification but a meere declaration to the eyes of men that we are healed we goe on with Papists and Bellarmine to make sanctification the onely formall cause why we are justified But the man is farre out Bellarmine and Papists say that God so farre accepteth works of inherent holynesse that without Christs imputed righteousnesse we are justified for these works we acknowledge that God for Christ loveth and accepteth works of sanctification and obligeth us to them by a command to doe them except we would sinne in omitting them but that God loveth and accepteth them as the cause of our righteousnesse in part or in whole in the matter of our justification wee utterly deny Antinomians would have all acts of sanctification meerely arbitrary and of courtesie and to come from no obligation of a command or Law and so that these acts being omitted are no sinne before God and being omitted they are but arbitrary no declarations we are not healed or discourtesies to Christ no sinnes against a Law and being performed God loveth them no more then he doth Adulteries or Murthers acted by justified persons Master Eaton ignorantly objecteth That God by justification shall place us in two contrary states of salvation and damnation to bee the members of Christ and of the Devill that God shall come short of his end of Redemption if wee be sinners in our selves then cannot the bloud of Christ clense us from all sin divers other things that are Characters of weakenesse and poore Divinity he objecteth as all his gang doth Answ. Sinners are taken two wayes in Scripture 1. For wicked men servants of sinne sinne having a dominion and Lordship over the party as in many Scriptures is cleare So we say not that we are both righteous before God and sinners in our selves we should then be both sanctified and not sanctified members both of Christ and of Sathan as hee objecteth But we take sinners in this for these that are sinnefull and have sinne dwelling in them and for such as If they say they have no sinne they are lyars and so the Scripture also taketh sinners Now Antinomians deny the justified to sin at all or to have any sinne dwelling in them because Christ hath washed away all sinne But ignorant men they should know that justification is a forinsecall and judiciall freeing us from all sinne that is from the Law-guilt and condemnation of all sinne and so all our sinnes are removed as a cloud are taken away as if they were cast into the bottome of the Sea but justification is not a Physicall washing away and expulsion of all indwelling and inhabitation of sinne and an introduction of the contrary habit as when heat commeth in the same subiect in the place of coldnesse light in the place of darkenesse whitenesse in the subject in which blacknesse did reside as Antinomians with Papists fondly conceit this is sanctification which is imperfect and graduall in this life not justification and so it followeth not that one and the same person because sinne dwelleth in him after justification but subdued and having lost his dominion is now both under the dominion of Sathan and also a member of Christ. 2. Christ obtaineth his end in Redemption which is to free the sinner from sinnes condemnation in justification fully and in sanctification by degrees not fully while we be perfected in glory Christ can well dwell in the heart by faith where sinne dwelleth as an underling but not where it dwelleth as a King and Tyrant in its full dominion which dominion is not removed formally by justification though the state of justification and the full dominion of sinne cannot stand together in the same person but properly and formally by sanctification It s true God seeth sinne pardoned and the sinner freed from the guilt but he seeth it dwelling in us not to our condemnation for the Lord imputeth it not and therefore it followeth not that the Lord both seeth us righteous in Christ and not righteous in Christ but onely hee seeth us righteous in Christ by imputation of grace and freed from condemnation and sinnefull in our selves by the inherencie and in-dwelling of sinne pardoned and subdued which is the doctrine of Prophets and Apostles delivered in the Scripture CHAP. LXXXIX Antinomians are ignorant of Faith to dreame that its Faith to beleeve against sense that our sinnes are no sinnes IT is the true nature and essence of Faith say Antinomians To beleeve cleane contrary to that which we see and beleeve in our selves if God hath spoken the contrary as if God were not able to abolish that sinne which wee dayly feele dwelling in us out of his owne sight above our reason sense and feeling The Mystery is this as for the Adulteries Oppressions treacherous Covenant-breach Lying that justified Antinomians commit Faith is to beleeve they are no sinnes before God against no Law but meere nullities in the Lords Law-court as Towne saith though Lying and deceiving reason beleeveth them to be sins for its true faith To beleeve the contrary of what sense and reason apprehendeth because God so saith and giveth his Sonnes bloud to cleanse us from all sin and sweareth the same But this is a dead false lying faith of Antinomians 1. Because the light of faith discovereth the sinnes of a justified person to bee hainous provocations of the majestie of God so David I acknowledge my transgression and my sinne is ever before me And the Church For our transgressions are with us and as for our iniquities we know them And Paul in the New Testament I know that in me that is in my flesh dwelleth no good And I find then a Law that when I would doe good evill is present with me And I see another Law in my members rebelling against the Law of my minde and bringing me into captivity to the Law of sinne which is in my members these three words 〈◊〉
〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 I know I find I see rebellion and sinne in me were words that came from the light of Faith not from lying sense And Faith and a sight of God can discover more corruption to Esaiah Job to Paul to the woman that washed Christs feet with teares then reason can reveale to them 2. Faith doth not stupifie the conscience to blot out all sense of sinne out of it its true the Libertine Pocquius spake in the stile of Eaton◠now we are quickned in the second Adam Christ through seeing sinne in our selves no more because it is dead But the second Adam commeth in the soule with a candle to make us see and know and feele by the light of Faith sinne which was hidden before 3. The Antinomian dead faith is against confession of sin because we must know and beleeve we have sinne if we confesse it this was Gods challenge to a heardned people Yet thou sayest because I am innocent surely his anger shall turne from me Behold I will plead with thee because thou saist I have not sinned This is that which the Lord commandeth onely acknowledge thine iniquity Antinomians say lying sense and corrupt reason knoweth iniquity but Faith is as blind as a Mole and seeth no sinne in the beleever 4 This faith of Antinomians is repugnant to the godly shame confusion and selfe-indignation that the justified man in Scripture beareth against himselfe for sinne The want whereof is the Whores forehead that cannot blush and therefore must Faith see and know sinnes that are the cause of shame 5. This lying faith is to beleeve that Adultery and Lying to come as well as the past sinnes are pardoned and abolished and so that they are no sinnes before ever they bee committed what feare then what holy care what challenges of conscience can be required to an Antinomian lying faith to eschew and feare these sinnes ere they be committed For its the act of lying sense say Antinomians to apprehend them as sinnes then sure they cannot lawfully be apprehended as ills to bee feared and eschewed if it bee a lying apprehension to thinke that that is a snare to my feet which is no snare at all but a boggle to affright a childe it must be a lying apprehension to conceive that a fancied snare to be an evill to bee shunned and declined If the Whore be no Whore the Antinomian needs not eschew the going neere her house for feare the house fall on him as Salomon intimateth Prov. chap. 5. And surely the justified Antinomian may goe on in Adulteries and blouds before he act them and feed his lusts without feare for if he conceive these to be sinnes it is his lying sense and deceiving reason for faith is to beleeve the just contrary that they are no sinnes and so not to bee eschewed as sinnes because an antedated pardon doth no lesse abolish their being and nature before they bee committed in which case they are remitted and so nullities and shaddowes before God then a pardon doth utterly abolish their being when they are committed in the Antinomian way CHAP. XC Antinomians free all converted or non-converted from obligation of obedience or practise of Christian duties ANtinomians cry out against Preaching of duties as a Legall way and destructive to Gospel-preaching of Christ and Faith 1. Because there bee no acts of Sanctification commanded in the Gospel so as the beleever sinneth either in omitting these duties or in doing contrary to them I appeale to all their writings for any such Commands either of Law or Gospel 2. They cry out against Preaching of duties as Legall preaching without any limitation wee cry out as much as they against this Preaching in an unjust way 1. If duties be preached without Christ and not issuing from the grace of Christ. 2. If they bee more Preached then Gospel-grace and free Redemption in Christ. 3. If duties as conditions of the Covenant of Works as parts conditions or causes of our justification are fellow-saviours with Christ be pressed 3. It will be found they free the unconverted from all doing or eschewing of sinne because they can doe nothing out of faith and out of saving principles of grace So Saltmarsh adviseth the troubled in spirit onely to beleeve immediatly everlasting love without any foregoing humiliation desire of the Physitian sense of sinne or setting on any duties Much like the Familists of New England who say that the Spirit acts most in the Saints when they indeavour least as if our doings desire sense of sinne going before conversion did so much the more hinder conversion 2 Nor can our impotency to doe good without the grace of God loose us from an obligation of doing our dutie seeing the omitting of these duties in the substance of their acts is a greater sinne then the doing of them for so the unconverted should not sinne in not giving to the poore because they cannot give it for God nor in abstaining from murther because they cannot abstain out of sonly feare or in not praying because they cannot pray in faith whereas Peter Act. 8. commandeth Simon Magus to pray though being in the gall of bitternesse hee could not pray in faith 3. The converted so should be under no obligation to pray heare beleeve but when the Spirit wrought actually in them to will and to doe for without such an actuall influence they can doe nothing CHAP. XCI How and for whom Christ intercedeth in Heaven ANtinomians hold that Christ advocateth at the right hand of God for the unbeleeving and unconverted elect as well as for beleevers onely Christ intercedeth not say they for the manifestation of the purchased Redemption to the elect not converted It s true the purchased Redemption and bloud-shed of Christ is for the elect as well not converted as converted But Antinomians goe on another ground that sinners are justified and pardoned before they be converted and beleeve But the Scripture knoweth not any intercession of Christ but for applycation of the purchased Redemption 1. Because Christ liveth againe that hee may bestow the blessings of his Testament actually upon his friends Christ confirmeth his owne Testament which no other dead friend doth and the goods of his Testament are peace Joh. 14.27 The sprinkling of the Conscience from dead works to serve the living God Heb. 9.14 15 16 17 18 19 20. As Moses sprinkled the booke and the people the Tabernacle the vessels 19.20 So that Christ as our high priest is entred into heaven as a sprinkler Now he is no sprinkler to the unconverted 2. The thing he prayeth for as intercessor is the not failing of the faith of the Saints and he liveth to save the commers to God through him that is the beleevers and is touched with our infirmities and that we should hold fast our profession and by him as intercessor We have boldnesse
c. 18. fol 18. b Luther writeth against the Antinomianâ— by name Luther â—o 2. in Gen c. 18 f. 119. Luthâ—r â—â—fuâ—eth the Antâ—nomians under the name of Antinomians is enemies to the law of God c Luther to 2. in Gen. c. 18. fo 119. d 19. fo 118. e Luther to 2. in Gen. c. 19. f. 132 f Luther tom 2 in Gen c 2. fol 132. g Luther tom 1. pa 555. Luther extolleth good works against all Antinomians h Luther tom 3. fol. 109. I Luth. ttm. 3 fâ—l 165 l Luth tom 1 fol 449. m Luth tom 1 fol 522. n Luther to 2 in Gen. c. 15. fol. 57. (o) Luther to 2 in Gen. Luther teachâ—eth that only faith justifieth and yet faith is not alone with out good workes Luther tom 2 fol. 517. How faith and workes are contrary to Luther q Luther to 4 fol. 6. r Luth. tom 4 f 114. r Luth tom 4. fol 114. How according to Luther his mind the law hath power ouer the flesh and not over the renewed conscience q Luther to 4 fol. 6. r Luth. tom 4 f 114. r Luth tom 4. fol 114. How according to Luther his mind the law hath power ouer the flesh and not over the renewed conscience s Towne ass p. 35.73 t Salt free grace 154.152 w Den. ser. man of sin p. 9.10 x Schluss cat heret l. 3. p. 53.54 55. y Cal. adv lib. c. 18 452 a Luther tom 2 in Ge. c. 18. fol. 119. b c. 19 f. 132. c Luther contra Anti. disp 3. propos 27. dis 4 pro. 33. d Luther tom 2. fal 5â—9 d Luther tom 2. fal 5â—9 How good workes conforme to the Law are not necessary The new man is under the same law as a rule of life which was in the covenant of workes and though we be changed the law is the same The Law is given to the new man 〈…〉 of lifâ— and not properâ—y to the flesh but as a sinne condemning law (e) Luther to 4.178 Eaton (f) Hony-com c. 3. pag. 25. (g) Saltm free gracâ— pag. 140. (h) Hony-com ch 5 73 74. Crispe vol. 2. ser. 4.136 137 138 152 153 154 157. (i) Hony-com c. 71 72. (k) Hony-com c. 7.134 (l) Saltm free grace 145. (e) Luther to 4.178 Eaton (f) Hony-com c. 3. pag. 25. (g) Saltm free gracâ— pag. 140. Crispe vol. 2. ser. 4.136 137 138 152 153 154 157. (i) Hony-com c. 71 72. (h) Hony-com ch 5 73 74. (k) Hony-com c. 7.134 (l) Saltm free grace 145. How Luther according to Scripture saith the new man and terrified conscience in the beleever is simply freed from the law and the Law is abrogated to him and hath only power over his flesh m Luther tom 4. fo 178. n Luther tom 4. p. 112. o Luther tom 4.119 How the law condemneth terrifieth and how not p Luther tom 4. fo 47. q Luther to â— p. 112. r Luther to 1 128. How the renewed man iâ— freed from the Law s Luther tom 1. fo 546. n Luther tom 4. p. 112. o Luther tom 4.119 How the law condemneth terrifieth and how not p Luther tom 4. fo 47. q Luther to â— p. 112. r Luther to 1 128. How the renewed man iâ— freed from the Law s Luther tom 1. to 546. t Schlusselburgiuâ—â—at hereticâ— l. 3. p. 53. w Towne ass grace p. 35. p. 3. How the Law is given to the new man and how not Luther tom 1. f. 541. Luther tom 2. l. 253. a Luther tom â— f. 5â— The guiltâ— conscience 〈◊〉 beleever noâ— under the 〈◊〉 b Luâ—her tom 4 f 5. Excellent replyes of a beleever to the accusing Law c Luther tom 4. fo 15. d Luther to 4 fo 40. e Luther to 4. f. 46. A tempted beleâ—ver freed from the chalinges of the condemning Law Luth tom 4.117 g Luth tom 4. f. 11â— h Luther tom â— f. 118. Luther tom 1. f. 541. Luther tom 2. â— 253. a Luther tom â— f. 5â— The guiltâ— conscience 〈◊〉 beleever noâ— under the 〈◊〉 b Luâ—her tom 4 f 5. Excellent replyes of a beleever to the accusing Law c Luther tom 4. fo 15. d Luther to 4 fo 40. e Luther to 4. f. 46. A tempted beleâ—ver freed from the chalinges of the condemning Law Luth tom 4.117 g Luth tom 4. f. 11â— h Luther tom â— f. 118. i Luthâ—r tom â— f 154.55 A tempted sâ—nner is 〈◊〉 from a sensitive 〈…〉 impâ—ted rigâ—teousnesse i Luthâ—r tom â— f 154.55 A tempted sâ—nner is 〈◊〉 from a sensitive 〈…〉 impâ—ted rigâ—teousnesse k Luther tom 4.54 Christ on the crosse is to bee eâ—ed to comfort the weake beleever against his own sin m Luther tom 3 f. 376. The wayes of overcomming Law temptations n Luther tom 3 f. 396. o Luther tom 3 376. p Luther tom 3. fo 489. q Luther tom 4 f. 6. r Luther tom 4 f. 76. s Luther tom 4. f. 14. k Luther tom 4.54 Christ on the crosse is to bee eâ—ed to comfort the weake beleever against his own sin m Luther tom 3 f. 376. The wayes of overcomming Law temptations n Luther tom 3 f. 396. o Luther tom 3 376. p Luther tom 3. fo 489. q Luther tom 4 f. 6. r Luther tom 4. f. 76. s Luther tom 4. f. 14. Luther is for conditions in the Covenant of grace and for preparations before conversion Antinomians deny both t Luther tom 4 f. 112. x Luther to 4 10â— z Luther tom 4 f. 156. a Luth. 9. tom 4. f. 289. b Luther to 4. f. 289. Temtations and how they are resisted in the conscience c Luther tom 4 f. 147. d Luther tom 4 f. 387. e Luther to 4.391 t Luther tom 4 f. 112. x Luther to 4 10â— z Luther tom 4 f. 156. a Luth. 9. tom 4. f. 289. b Luther to 4. f. 289. Temtations and how they are resisted in the conscience c Luther tom 4 f. 147. d Luther tom 4 f. 387. e Luther to 4.391 f Luther to 4 f. 400. g Luther tom 4. fo 413. h Luther tom 4 â— â—92 i Luther tom 4 f. 502. k Luther tom 4 758. in Ps. 2. l Luther ex ad Cus. Aquilam an 1528. f. 393 m Luther to 2. in Gen. c. 21. f. 188. f Luther to 4 f. 400. g Luther tom 4. fo 413. h Luther tom 4 â—â—92 i Luther tom 4 f. 502. k Luther tom 4 758. in Ps. 2. l Luther ex ad Cus. Aquilam an 1528. f. 393 m Luther to 2. in Gen. c. 21. f. 188. How we are patients in justification how not n Schlusselburgius iâ— Caâ—â—logo heretico l. 3. p 49. Towne ass 3.9 10. o Luther tom 4 f. 399. p Luther to 4.130.131 q Luther â—â— â— 95. r Luther tom â— f. 52. o Luther tom 4 f. 399. p Luther to 4.130.131 q Luther â—â— â— 95. r Luther tom â— f. 52. s Luther tom 4. f. 451. How the law is abolished and how not s Luther tom 4. f.
bene vivit nec indiget lege quae doceat cum bene vivere In justus autem debet bene vivere quia non bene vivit quod lex requirit hoc toâ—um urget ne ex lege et operibus justi fieri praesumant sed per fidem accipiant Spiritum sine lege operibus quo legi satisfaciant How the beleever needeth not the Law in the letter neither is under it a Towne all 7â— 77 78. b Saltmarsh free grace 140. c Eaton honey combe â— 11.322.323.324 c. d Randel Preface to the Bright-star Luâ—her never dreamed beleevers to bee perfect as Antinomians think e Luth. tom 1. f. 65. f Luth tom 4. f. 343. g Luther to 3. in Gen. f. 2. in c. 25. Patience required that sin dwell in us e Luth. tom 1. f. 65. f Luth tom 4. f. 343. g Luther to 3. in Gen. f. 2. in c. 25. Patience required that sin dwell in us h Saltm â—re grace 140. I Towne asser gr 15â— 157 158.159 k Luther tom 4 f. 63. m Luther tom 2. f. 432. Sin rageth more in the godly then in the wicked n Luth. tom 2 f. 434. How sin pardoned is no sin k Luther tom 4 f. 63. m Luther tom 2. f. 432. Sin rageth more in the godly then in the wicked n Luth. tom 2 f. 434. How sin pardoned is no sin o Luther to 4. f 173. p Luth. tom r. in Gen. c. 3. f 57 q Luther to 4. f 404· r Luther to 4. in Gen. c. 42. f. 96. o Luther to 4. f 173. p Luth. tom r. in Gen. c. 3. f 57 q Luther to 4. f 404· r Luther to 4. in Gen. c. 42. f. 96. Luther taught that the Jewes were iustified by faith as wee are the Antinomians say the contrary s Luth. tom 2 â—5 t Luther to â— 397. w Luther to â— 413. y Luther tom â— in Gen. c. 13 f. 35. z Luther â— â— 523. s Luth. tom 2 â—5 t Luther to â— 397. w Luther to â— 413. y Luther tom â— in Gen. c. 13 f. 35. z Luther â— â— 523. a Luth. tom 4.164 Luther in the point of Christian Liberty against the Antinomians * Luther to 2. â— 78. b Luther tom 1 â— â—31 c Luther to 3.394 d Luther tom 1 473. a Luth. tom 4.164 Luther in the point of Christian Liberty against the Antinomians * Luther to 2. â— 78. b Luther tom 1 â— â—31 c Luther to 3.394 d Luther tom 1 473. How the Law hath nothing to doe with the conscience in Luthers meaning e Luther tom 4 150. e Luther tom 4 150. f Luth tom 4.149 g Luth. tom 3. f. 421. f Luth tom 4.149 g Luth. tom 3. f. 421. How the conscience is free according to the minde of Luther That distinction of Antinom that We cannot sin against God as a commanding lawgiver but against God Redeemer only removed Rise reigne ruine of Antinomiaâ—s in New England p. 60 61. art 2â— h Luth. tom 4. f. 410. i Luth tom 4.403 k Luth. to 1. in Gen. c. 24. f. 23â— l Luther tom 3 in Gen. f. 38. m Luther tom 4. in Gen. 41. â— 84. h Luth. tom 4. f. 410. i Luth. tom 4.403 k Luth. to 1. in Gen. c. 24. f. 23â— l Luther tom 3 in Gen. f. 38. m Luther tom 4. in Gen. 41. â— 84. o Del ser. 12.13 15. to judge of our spiritual condition by sense hath a two fold meaning Luther in the matter of free-will against Antiâ—omians Familists a Luth. tom 1. f. 9. 1 Luth. tom 1. f. 9. b Luther to 1. f. 11. c Luth. tom 1. f. 27. f Luth. tom 1.306 b Luther to 1. f. 11. c Luth. tom 1. f. 27. f Luth. tom 1.306 g Luther to 1.46 g Luther to 1.46 Tom. 3. f. 82. h Luther to 4. f 174. Tom. 3. f. 82. h Luther to 4. f 174. Of the subjective and active power of free-will Luth. tom 2. f. â—06 k Luther to 3.200 l Luth. tom 3.457 Luth. tom 2. f. â—06 k Luther to 3.200 l Luth. tom 3.457 m Luther to 2.215 n Luth. tom 3.218 m Luther to 2.215 n Luth. tom 3.218 o Luth. tom 1. f. 46.138 p Luther tom â— 140. o Luth. tom 1. f. 46.138 p Luther tom â— 140. Note an absolute independent power to doe what ever God commandeth peculiar neither to the covenant of workes before the fall nor to the law or Gospel after the fall but iâ— ever was common to all States to the creature to act dependently upon Gods predetermination Libertines sprang from the Gnosticks Familists from Libertines Antinomians from both a Theol. Ger. â— 2â— p. 53. b Bright stare c. 8 p. 11. The wild stuffe that is in Theologia Germani and the Brightst Theol. Germ. c. 14. vetus homo est Adamus inobediemia ipseitas egoitas â—t â—imilia ut novâ—s homo est Christus obedientia How creatures are under-causes of their own working and yet in beâ—ing and working depend on God The heaven hell of Familists included within the lists of this life The Familists acknowledge no Christ but a Metaphoricall Chriâ—t Of the Familists in England in reigne of K Jâ—mes and the contents of a supplication they â—râ—sented to the King Familists dissemble and cover theâ—â— foulest and grossest poynts of doctrine from the simple prelats patrons of Familists The rise of the late Familists in N. England Of Mistris Hutchison and her tenets Of M. Wheelwright a preacher in N. England a prime Familist The tenets of the laâ—tâ—r familists called Gortenianss Gortine and the latter Familists of New England deny the incarnation or that Christ was true man and dyed for us Del ser p. 19. M. Beacon turneth Christ over in a metaphâ—ricall Saviour as all Familisâ—â— doe John Waldesso so much extolled by M. Beacon is an Enthysiast and rejecteth the scriptures Seaven headed policy p. 111. Of other Antinomians now in England 〈◊〉 would câ—eare how he said 〈◊〉 hath perfectly beleeved repented and mortified 〈◊〉 for us but 〈◊〉 no purpose Sparkles of glory p. 3. Familists deny the first Adam to be a true man but a figure only and Christ to be man only figuratively in regard of his mysticall body the saints in whom he dyes and suffereth Familists acknowledge no visible buâ— only invisible Church Familists teach that Christ is not ascended to heaven in our flesh and nature Sparkles of glory p. 49. What is Antichrist to Familiâ—â—s not the Pope but the Protesta 〈◊〉 whome they fasly call legall teachers Saltmarsh maketh the Antichrist to come in with arts tongues yet flowers the Margine of his book with bits of broken Greek such as he can Familists with Saltmar make three admâ—nistrations of Law Gospel and all Spirit Antinomians two Law and Gospel as they expone them Wars under the New Testament for any religious causâ— not lawfull to Familists who yet practise them not a little The Baptists
a trance Prophets not ever under actuall vision as Prophets when they preach their visions to men and in a far other case then when they are in a â—rance aâ—d actuâ—â—ly see the visions of God Prophets see not really the things themselves present offered to them in the visions of God but only the speces or images therof in the decree of God or some other way The Spirit opposed to that which is bodily and to that which is externall How externall Ordinances are contrary to the Spirits acting and how not Three wayes of unâ—â—n between the word and the Spirit How the word remaineth in the new birth and how it passeth away We are to wait on God in the use of outward Ordinances though the Spirit worke not ever with the word nor upon our hearts Divers wayes of the Spirits concurring with the word How the Spirit is opposite to the letteâ— and to externals The spirit contrary to human eloquence 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 To speake drying and coldly is not to speake in the Spirit That which is most spirituall excludeth most of us yet not alwayes our discoursing and arguing part The Spirit is contrary to wilde and carnall logicke The expressions of the spirituall estate The Spirit determineth the actions of the spirituall man according to their specification or nature and kinde How obliging Law and a free Spirit consisteth together How morall compulsion of the Law is exhausted by the freenesse of a Gospel-spirit of love Threatning had influence on the will of the first Adam not of the second or of confirmed Angels The place 2 Pet. 1. untill the day-starre arise vindicated as making nothing for a naked light of the Spirit without the Scriptures How the Spirit is called the day-star how true that is to be taken the more of the letter the lesse of the Spirit and what truth is in it How we are changed into the same spiritualnesse contained in the Gospel Jer. 31. We know none of the Familists new discoveries of the Spirit that are not warranted by the word Act 9.23 Act 26 23. Luk 4 20 21 22 23. How duâ—ies are 〈…〉 in the Gâ—spel Aâ—l the Gospell to Antinomians a mâ—ere killing letter as the Law is The word spirituall beyond figures and letters in every consideration The Spirit determineth the actions of the spirituall man according to the exercise of them The order of acting in supernatural actions often from the spirit· The assumption of a syllogisme of our reflect acts of knowledge of our spiritull state is at lengh proven only by sense and the testimony of the spirit without discoursing How far the Saints are to leave room for new light Many new deductions from ancient truths may be known which were knowne before only implicitly and in the an eâ—edent not distinctly Preaching of duties or of externall worship not contrary to the teaching of the Spirit as Antinomians dreame What the Law of the Spirit of life â—s Characters of a spirituall condition Other characters of a spirituall disâ—osition Sparkles of glory p. 271. The written word to Familists is as a type or shadow of the ceremonial law that perisheth but wee hold the word written and preached to be the everlasting Gospel Ordinances of the written word and preaching are to continue to the end Sparkles of glory 314 315. Divers wayes and formes of worshipping of God and of leaving these formes and ascending higher and higher from natuâ—â—ll to civill and morall Religion frâ—m thence to Law then to Johns baptism then to Christ in the flesh then to pure Gospel then to poore and all-Spirit or Familists phancies How mortification is a signe of a spirituall condition a There is nothing in this Petition the smels of Christs ointments nothing that looks with any face like the anointing that teacheth all things nothing to heighten Christ much to flatter K Iames all to lift that abominable impostor H. Nichoâ—as up above Christ the stile and words full of gall against Puritans and the truly godly in England thâ—e words base earthly low devilish hereticall temporizing a Basilicon Doron wâ—itten to Prince Henry b Their fleshly and abominable doctrine as especially that the Familists may wallow in adulteries blood rebellion perjury and if the Spirit helpe them not against these sinnes they are as innocent as the maid forced in the field who did cry and there was none to helpe and so by no Law can be guilty See their tenets as H. Nicholas taught b Their foule opinions may here be read in this Treatise and in H. Nicholas writings c King Iames was misinformed in that for Familists and the godly unjustly called Puritans are as contrary as light and darknesse d The unjustly so called Puritans did never owne Browne nor Penry who set on foot the old doctrine of the Anabaptâ—sts in England and Enthusiasticall revelations beside the word of God e It is not unlike that such fleshly teachers who crave Libertâ— of conâ—cience to themselves will petition the Prince that the tyrannous laws of Prelates be executed against the truely godly and that liberty be denied to all save to themselves only a proper character of Hereticks and Schismaticks e The Familists and Antinomians because Purirans are esteemed the godly party now call themselves but most unjustly the true successors of the Puritans and all the godly opposite 〈◊〉 their way who strive to walke with God they call Legalists Pharisâ—es literall Doctors but because they change all colours with the court and wind oft times they are enemies to old non-conformists calâ—ed sometime Puritans in that 1. against Puritans they make all externalls indifferent 2. They reject Scripture and imbrace revelations 3. They contemne close walking with God as pharaisme and law-living f But I noted before that Familists will have no Magistrates over them and we may see it to be their practise this day g The Familists subjection of their consciences to the spirituall Popish lawes of Prelates prove them to bee men of more wide consciences then Puritans they need not feare to bee called Puritans g Deceivers as Simon Magus and others take godly titles to themselves for H. N. saith fidelitas docl c. 4. sect 11. beside Gods service of love there is not another in heaven or in earth here they call themselves the family of God h They knew well that Prelates imbittered the mind of K. James against Puritans his faithfullest subjects i They say it to the praise of their Mr. Henry Nicholas that he names no mans name but here they name both sects and names k Protestants know Puritans to be godly and sound in the faith Familists turne their backe then on the Protestants and the soundest of them l Reader iudge how the Familists and Antinomians now in England shall deale with Puritans and the truly godly what a bloody heart they beare toward them since their fathers the old Familists do persecute them with so bloody a tongue before their
Prince m Obedience to the Kings laws to the effusion of their blood can have no orher sense but they will raise bloody wars against Puritans if the K which I hope shall not be command them I pray God it be not fulfilled in their children this day in England they promise they have been and ever will be obedient to the Kings laws which respecteth the time to comâ— so as if the King and Parliament should againe establish Popery they say for all time to come they shall be ever truly obedient and adde no limitation condition of obedience in the Lord. You may see the consciences of Familists that as after ye shall heare they prostitute themselves to avouch or deny take or leave all Religions as the times and mens lawes shall 〈◊〉 prove them or not n What Pharisees bee these doth not Paul judge himselfe the chiefe of sinners is not Elias a man compassed with infirmities No wonder it bee hâ—rd to prove any wickâ—d doctâ—ine or practise for H. Nichoâ—as in his Epistle to the two daughters of Warwicke would prove men may bely and dissemble and deny their Religion and Christ before men so the heart be good o Shall wee then beleeve that Familists now in England will not be deadly persecuters of Puritans p Puritans are against all religious ceremonies of mens devisings so that tything of mint is unjustly ascribed to to them q To Familists all outward worship and ordinances are traditions they live only upon love within and are swine without and yet sinne not q There is to Familists no judgement and mercy but that which is inward let men as touching the outward man be swine for filthinesse Lions for blood and rapine they may have inward righteousnesse and that is all and enough r Then Puritans only none or few of the prelaticall way or other Sectaries refuted Familists s Familists count all Religions popery or any thing as they come out to the view of men neither up nor downe t But the Saints of love say Familists are above and beyond all laws and Rulers Magistracie is but for fleshly men t Familists by their principles may professe or deny any Religion as the Market goes t This is no little exception in which they swerve from the Religion of England in that they are Familiâ—ts and of a sect destructive to all Christian religion to Châ—ist his person office righteousnesse imputed faith repentance Scriptures heaven hell judgement resurrection c. w He that doth evill hates the light H.N. was once thought to be homo novus But H. Nicholas was a fleshly abominable seducer and false prophet a Mercer in Amsterdam x Neithâ—r Calvin nor Luther knew any thing of God but only H Nicholas is the Catholick Apostle of the world and cannot erre y Nothing here of Christ by whose name only we are saved Act. 4.11.12 dutifull obedience to God and Magistrates and to love â—ur neighbour are such Law-â—ighteousnesse as pagans doe diefie as highest devotion in all this petition nothing smelleth of Christ his Spirit eternity nothâ—ng of Scripturall or spirituall communion with God in Christ Jesus z All hereticks make the Scripture their rule and only judge but not simply but as they understand them which is to make their owne understanding only umpire and judge in the matters of God a They afterward tempt the King to forsake the Protestant Religion and to turne Familist b It s a pure commendation that H Nicholas wrote much the more the worse since he writeth against the Prophets and Apâ—stles c Christ and his Apostles name false teachers Saduces Hymeneus Philetus Simon Magus Elimas c. but though hee name neither Calvin nor Luther yet their doctrine he calleth often carnall fleshly false ceremoniall wisdome the letter the flesh the devill hypocrisie d Thâ—se men that cry out aâ—gainst Scripture-wisdome as carnaâ—l ceremoniall â—evilish selfie as H. Nicholas and his cannot speake hâ—nourably of the perfection of Scriptuâ—e d The family of love have no heads or Kings that are borne oâ— the flesh and blâ—od of sin spirit lauâ— c 4. sect 8. they themselves reigne as only Kings on earth everlastingly fideâ—itâ—s decl c. 4. sect 18. e Of all the meanes by which men are saved through Christ they speake only of the works of the Law of inherent righteousnesse and repentance not one word of free grace faith in Christ and the impuâ—ed righteousnesse of Christ. Familists then are the legall Pelagians not we no reformation is knowne to Familists but inward that of the heart f Not more said then truth can beare for H Nicholas his doctrine is a seâ—tina a pumpe dunghill and a sea of many fleshly errors and heresies f The due fruits of repentance and newnesse of life are here made antecedent meanes and wayes going before our saving in Christ or our free redemption that is in Christ Jesus so as we must be justified by workes otherwise let any man make sense of these words g Our Saviour saith yee shall know thâ—m by their workes h The foulest of the bookes of H. Nicholas containing the mystery of Familisme and fleshly loosenesse are only to be seene by the wise and experienced Eldeâ—s who can digest them â— It is hard to prove any thing against them who profâ—sse it lawfull to deny their Religion before men H.N. Epist to the daughters of Warwicke h It is not likâ— but Q. Elizabeth heard of these bookes and saw them since many of her and K James his Court favoured them i Ioh. Knewstuâ— M Microniâ—s H. Amswâ—rth wrote against thâ—se filthy errors and set downe their own words to the world k The Prelates the Popish Magistrates never troubled these licentious men because they tooke part with them agâ—iâ—st the Puritans only some godly Magistrates nick-named Puâ—itans cast some of them in prison l Neither by oath or any other way could they be brought to make confession of the secrets of unpure Familisme l They say they will take or leave their Religion of love as the Laws thinke fit but they lie fâ—r here being cast in prison by the inferiour Magistrate they persist then the infeâ—iouâ— Magistraâ—e to them is no Magâ—strate the Law is no Law m All heretickes and impure sectarâ—es say they dâ—e wilfully maintaine no heresie and therefore plead for liberty of conscience and a toleration of all religions The Familists defame the doctrine of the Apostlâ—s and Scriptures and have nothing to doe with the martyrs of the primitive Church for H. N. as I observe taught that Christ never had any man lay down his life for him or his truth his meaning was only allegorically to renounce his lusts for Christ otherwise Christ rejoyceth not said he in our death or blood o The Puâ—itans refusing the Popish ceremonies and the Romish denomination of Prelates are branded by those men as disobedient to Magistrates p They desire the Popish Laws against hereticks to be used against
them by which any man that denies his heresie and â—aiâ—h he beleeveth as the Church beleeveth is absolved which Familists do q Faith and a good conscience then are not the two chiefest jewells that God hath gâ—ven to men r The Prelates and prophane courtieâ—s and the multitude were their friends as they are to all licentious religions t Divers of the court of Queen Elizabeth and of K. James and some nobles were Familists I would these who now rule all by violence and force were not of that abominable way for enemies they had few or none except Puritans they lived under the shadow of Prelacie and court when many thousands of pretious Christians for nâ—n-conformity were silenced banished prisoned wasted w If the way of H. Nicholas beâ— thâ— only true way of salvation as here they say fidelitas decl c. 4 sect 11. the King should bee petitioned without delay to take it to his consideration as a matter to be preferred to all his most important Kingly affaires but they petition for a delaying triall because every one that doth evill hateth the light x Then they allow a share of the grace of Christ on all rulers for they except none though heathens and persecuters and on all mankinde on the universall earth x Grosse flattery y Then they can settle upon no Religion till K. Iames find leasure to try and read the hereticall and fleshly writings of H. Nicholas a In this they professe their zâ—ale to have K. Iames an illuminated Elder of the family of love as it would be their joy this day to have K. Charles of their way that so hee might compell all others to that way for they talke much of liberty of conscience to themselves but we finde when they have the sword they straine and squeeze to the blood the consciences of all contrary to their way b They conceive King Iames and all not of their way that are but Scripture-learned with the fleshly wisdome as they speak of the letter to be the very Antichrist and all lyes that the ungodded or unilluminated men out of the imagination or riches of their owne knowledge and of the learnednesse of the Scriptures bring forth Institute preach or teach See Evan. ch 32. ch 33.34 and H.N. Exhor c. 14. Sect. 9. c They doubt if there be any of their way and family in Germany which evidenceth that it is a notoâ—ions lie that H.N. saith Evan ch 34. that he is godded to publish the joyful messâ—ge in all the world And H.N. Exhor 12. sect 40. and Exhor 14. sect 9. that all the Kingdomes of the world should assemble them to this one Kingdome of peace and love and this same love service shall breake in among all Nations and let it selfe be heard over all lands but here they doubt if in one corner of Germany one man of this way can be had c All heretickes as Calvin noted of libertines delight to speake in uncouth language beside the Scripture that they may be the only spirituall men whom none can understand but spiritualists of their owne way d They clearly professe they will not suffer for familisme nor that which to them is the only true Religion and make K Iames the absolute and peremptory judge that if he find them hereticall they shall submit faith conscience and salvation to the King to leave or take the writings of Henry Nicholas as his Majesties Laws shall appoint them this is a Religion for the times and the flesh This well agreeth with the Familists of our time Del Saltmarsh Bâ—con Râ—ndel and others to whom profession of truth and of Christ before men is an externall and a forme in Religion and who cry out against formes and uniformity and teach that we should please one another in love in all these externalls we may doe or leave undone Sabbaâ—h preaching hearing Sacraments let them be inrolled in the Kallender of the late indifferent ceremonies since they are Jewish câ—â—nall literall fleshly and perish with the using and let the Service-booke bowing to altars the name of Jesus Episcopacy Socinianisme professed Acianisme be recalled these belong nothing say â—hey to Refoâ—mation or Religion Reformation is only in the heart Religion is 〈◊〉 of the minde The Kingdome of Christ is neither promoved nor hindered by these Familisticall love in the heart is all then surely the Nicodemites in Calvinâ— time these that buy a religion with every new-moon erre not e Then the Scriptures and H. Nicho. bids us follow the Kings religion what ever it be and denying of obedience to the King and his Lawes if they forbid a Religion that is the holy service of the love of God as they say is resisting and undutifull disobedience to the Law so must we obey men rather then God f They seek not the truth and cause of Christ to be cleared for the present but only present ease to the flesh and inlargement under baâ—le g They are willing to submit their câ—uâ—e to the Câ—ergy that is to the godly Prelâ—â—es who would be 〈◊〉 to 〈◊〉 them because they take the Puritans off from thinking upon their lordly domination and will-worship and the more enemies and persecuters the Puritans have the more ease and lesse contradicting of the Prelaticall cause as this day the Prelaticall party declare themselves willing to compâ—und wiâ—h Arrians Socinians Famâ—lists Antinomians Anabaptists Seekers Separatists and all so the Presbyterians that stand for the Covenant of God and reformation may fall h In all â—ges 〈◊〉 and Sectaries have called punishing of seducers or not receiving them in our house as being evil doers 2 Ioh. 10 and so â—ustly punishable Rom. 13 4 5. with the name of persecution i Yet they pâ—stered twelve Counâ—ies in England and would God they were few in number this day k Yet may Familists live in all sort of fleshlinesse and Idolatry murthers lying whoring c and if the Spirit help them not they are no more guilty then the maid forced in the field that did cry and there was none to helpe and so by Law she was innocent Document sent 6. c. 10. they cannot bring forth any thing but all good and love Document sent c. 2. sect 1. in many places H.N. extolls his disciples as Gods habitation the seale of Gods Majesty the holy City of peace the new Ierusalem one with God God one with them c. And whereas John maketh the love of the brethren a marke of these that are translated from death to life 1 Ioh 3.14 Yee may know Familists by their workes they are malitious haters as is evident in this petition of the truly godly in England whom they call their enemies these twenty five yeares l The Puritanes are the proud ones that King James is to subdue all others the Antichristian sect and the Familists only the house of God of love of the godly being c. m Twice they pray God for the King and his son that they may have long