contrary interpretations to satisfy men of different interests and give them the mutual pleasure of believing their assertions upheld by the autority of the Council And thus the Jesuits and Dominicans were equally contented with the Canons concerning Grace and Justification Each Party drew the autority of the Council to its own side and there has not bin any Writer of these two Orders who in their many Books as opposite one to another as light is to darkness has not alledged these very Canons as invincible proofs against his adversary II. But if any should enquire further and search into that vast multitude of Decrees unknown till then he must needs wonder to find them built upon so sandy Foundations The most general Basis of them is laid in the fourth Session where the Council proposes two objects to our Faith to wit Books which are written and Traditions which are not written And they pretend as a necessary consequence that whatever we oppose against the Church of Rome is of that kind This is the Epitome of all the Council Nevertheless least any one should be offended at the word Tradition and perswade himself that they intend by it to equal mens autority to that of God or humane Ceremonies to the sacred Precepts of the Gospell they give of it a most magnificent character calling it The Word of Christ a Doctrine inspired by the Holy Ghost for the ordering our Faith and manners and preserved in the Catholic Church by a continued succession If that Principle be true there is an end of all Controversies and were the Church of Rome as able to prove it as she is ready to advance it we might hope to see in our daies that blessed Word of Christ accomplish't There shall be one Fold and one Shepherd And indeed there is no Protestant in the World who doth not admit of a Tradition endued with these Qualifications First That it be the Word of Christ 2. Inspired by the Holy Ghost 3. In matter of Faith and Manners 4. Preserved in the Catholic Church by an uninterrupted succession But there is no Protestant in the World that doth not maintain such a Tradition cannot be proved and is nothing else but one of those rich and splendid Idea's as admirable and flattering in their speculation as impossible and deceiving in their practice III. For the perfect evidencing whereof we need but consider the following Proposals First That of all places of the Scriptures whereby the Church of Rome asserts her Tradition there is not so much as one alledged by the Fathers in her sense Secondly That none of the Fathers ever understood Tradition otherwise then for the unanimous consent of the Doctors of the Church grounded upon a word which is written Thirdly That no places in Scripture are express for the authorizing such Tradition but many positive and clear to prove the sufficiency of Scripture Fourthly That among the Traditions of the Church of Rome she proposes many to our belief which do not appertain at all either to Faith or manners IV. The Scripture is most holy most infallible most perfect in it self The Gospel has added what was deficient in the Law And the Apostles Writings supplied the defect of the Gospel There we must stay 'T is no less crime in S. Basil's opinion to add that which is not written then to reject that which is written And 't is a stupendious boldness when God has vouchsafed to reveal his will to men by a certain and infallible word to substitute another neither clear nor undoubtedly received V. That new word which is ascribed to God has properly and by its self relation to those things which cannot be proved by Scripture as one of the Divines present at Trent has taken notice of otherwise it would be a written word But if it be so nothing is more unworthy of Christ and less agreeable to his divine Oracles It is to render his truth suspected or uncertain to expose Christians to infinite errors to give them as many masters as there are persons who will profess themselves the Guardians of that word and to make it the object of all mens scorn since according to the excellent saying of S. Jerome Quod de Scripturis autoritatem non habet eâ—dem facilitate contemnitur qua probatur VI. We find not that Christ in his holy Gospel sends us to Tradition whereby we may come to the knowledg of him Search the Scriptures they are they that testify of me The Apostles speak as their Master We have also a more sure word of Prophecy whereunto you do well that ye take heed as unto a light that shines in a dark place until the day dawn and the day-star arise in your hearts Many saies S. Chrysostom pretend to speak from the Holy Ghost but they do it falsly as long as they speak from themselves as Christ testifies he spoke not from himself but from the Law and the Prophets so if they proffer us any other thing then the Gospel under pretence of its being inspired by the Holy Ghost let us be far from believing it Is there any thing worse saies Pope S. Leo then to have impious sentiments and yet not to be willing to assent to the more learned and wise Those are guilty of this folly who when they are hindred from knowing the truth by any obscurity do not recur to the Prophetical Books the Apostolical Writings and Evangelical autority but to themselves and so become Masters and Teachers of error because they refused to be Disciples of Truth It would have bin very easy for S. Austin in that long and tedious Disputation with the Donatists concerning the Catholic Church to have made an end of it by sending them to Tradition But instead of doing so Let us not hear saies he Haec dico haec dicis but let us hear haec dicit Dominus We have the Lords Books Both of us acknowledg their autority both of us believe them ibi quaeramus Ecclesiam ibi discutiamus causam nostram nolo humanis documentis seâ— divinis Oraculis sanctam Ecclesiam demonstrari We seek as he there adds where the Church is what shall we do in verbis nostris eam quaesituri sumus an in verbis Domini I think it is to be sought in his words who is the TRUTH and knows perfectly her who is his Body Habeo manifestissimam vocem Pastoris mei commendantis mihi sine ullis ambagibus exprimentis Ecclesiam If I suffer my self to be reduced and separated from his flock which is the Church by the words of men I will impute it to my self whereas he advertiz'd me saying My Sheep know my voice 'T is the constant Doctrine of that admirable man in all his Works In his Letter to S. Jerome I confess your Charity saies he I give those Books alone which are termed Canonical that honor as to believe none of their Authors did
of Trent gave it two mortal wounds 1. To declare Bishops in many cases the Popes Delegates 2. To leave the question of their residence and jurisdiction undecided 1. The first of these two things brings Episcopacy unto a strange abatement renders the Pope master of all Bishops Jurisdictions breaks all ancient Canons runs down the interests of all Princes encroaches upon the Rights and Liberties of Churches gives the Bishops a quality unworthy the successors of the Apostles and forces them to receive that as a borrowed and begg'd privilege which belongs naturally to them The second causes Episcopacy to be look'd upon as a meer humane emploiment or Civil Magistracy Such a Bishop could never have the confidence to say with the Apostle 2 Cor. 13. 3. Do you seek a proof of Christs speaking in me Nay he would no more value his sacred character then one of the Kings officers do his and regard the duties of his Divine calling rather as rules instituted for decency then as unchangeable obligations so strictly requir'd from him that without them he has no hope of salvation XXVI Jurisdiction is no less essential to Episcopacy then the power of ordaining Ministers a proposition we could easily demonstrate to be unanswerable would it not render this Discourse too big and had it not bin already done by a learned hand against the infamous Doctrine of â—oth English and French Jesuits For Jesuits are every where the same Ordination and Jurisdiction are so twisted together that they cannot be divided without their â—â—utual destruction Bishops receive both from the same hand and are no less instituted by Christ in the Church to govern 〈◊〉 then to continue the succession of the Governors XXVII Nay may it not be affirm'd that Jurisdiction is both as essential to Episcopacy 〈◊〉 necessary to the Church as Ordination â—or the Church being as St. Paul saies a 〈◊〉 i. e. a society consisting of Rulers and others submitted to them without Jurisdiction it can no more be such a society then without Ordination those rulers can be continued Therefore as noâ— Bishop ordains in the Catholic Church aâ— the Popes or any other Patriarchs delegate but by the fulness of power he receives from Christ so no Bishop exerciseâ— any act of Jurisdiction by any delegation but by that power he is invested with aâ— Bishop successor of the Apostles and Vicar of Christ A Bishop that acts or believes otherwise betraies that dignity intrusted to hiâ— by Christ which he ought to maintain 〈◊〉 the last drop of his blood XXVIII Nor pretend we thereby to say thâ— such a Jurisdiction may be exercis'd in â—â—very place and over all persons the patition of Dioceses shews the extraordâ—â—nary wisdom of Councils and Princeâ— Nor may any one transgress the limiâ— they have put among Bishops without dâ—â—claring himself an enemy to all disciplinâ— Now all the following Propositions aâ— certainly true at least to all admirers 〈◊〉 former times whom I take to be in Eâ—England in a greater number then elsewhere 1. That no man or no part of a Diocess can be substracted from a Bishops Jurisdiction but by the autority of a Prince or Council 2. That no man can be substracted from the Jurisdiction of his Bishop without being put at the same time under another 3. That however a Bishop deals with any man either substracted from his Jurisdiction or added to it 't is alwaies of himself and by the power he receiv'd from Christ 4. That the exemtions of Friars and Monks are a Schism rais'd by the Popes 5. That the name of the Popes Delegates in its most favorable sense given to the Bishops in things which belong to them is plenojure and by all Laws a most shameful injury to the Episcopal order 6. That nemo est qui non perhorrescat to use the words of a Learned Doctor of Sorbon at the speech of the Jesuit Lainez in the Council of Trent That all the power of Jurisdiction hath bin by Christ conferr'd on the Bishop of Rome so that the Jurisdiction of Bishops is not fundamental but deriv'd XXIX Now concerning the divine right of Episcopacy the Fathers of Trent committed two great faults the one to bring it into question and the other to leave it undecided As for the first it had bin receiv'd in the Church for fourteen ages taught by the Fathers embraced by their Disciples and only impugn'd by the Italian Canonists For the second such an indecision is a ground for any man in the Church of Rome to deny doubt of and contradict the institution of Bishops these three things being the nature of all undecided points So a man may maintain there is no government at all in the Church and consequently no Church since it does not appear that Christ hath instituted any other then Episcopacy and certainly to find any other the Scripture must be strain'd in many places the constant universal and never oppos'd practice of fourteen hundred years be impudently contradicted XXX But what is most pleasant in this Indecision is that the Pope has verifi'd the word of the Prophet Psal 35. 8. Let the net that he hath hid catch himself for all these following consequences flow from it 1. That the Holy Father is no Pope by divine right Jure divino for the Popedom being nothing else but an extension of Episcopacy he is no Pope but because he is Bishop No Divine durst yet advance any other opinion But the Episcopacy of the Holy Father is not different from that of other Bishops being in all respects of the same kind Episcopatus unus est And the Italians who are so abundant in novelties when they undertake to raise up the credit of their Master have bin dumb in this matter Therefore if the Popes Episcopacy is not Jure divino his Papacy is not so neither since one is engrafted upon the other and if the Holy Father is not Pope Jure divino what ground can be laid for the ambition and usurpation of the Apostolical See What shall we do with the fine and rare Doctrine of Infallibility 2. The Council has impos'd the belief of its new Decree upon all Christians under pain of eternal damnation but if they are only Ministers from the Church and not from Christ with what eies shall we consider so stupendious a boldness Who hath impowr'd a company of men to make Decrees of divine Faith And how without being authoriz'd by God did they exact an obedience only due to Ministers sent from Heaven 3. 'T is a crime in a Roman Catholic to believe the Council of Trent did not lawfully what it did otherwise such a meeting is a dream and a chimera But who is that Roman Catholic of any sense who can be perswaded of it seeing 't is allow'd in the Church of Rome to deny any of those Bishops had the least autority from God to do what they did XXXI And indeed who will not wonder the Fathers of
Reflexions On the Council of TRENT In Three Discourses I. That the Protestants without any necessity of inquiring into the Decrees of the Council of Trent have sufficient reason to reject it II. That the Doctrine of the Council of Trent is contrary to the antient Doctrine of the Catholic Church III. That the Council of Trent was so far from reforming the disorders which had crept into the Church that it really made the breaches in its Discipline wider and cut off all hopes of correcting the antient abuses A Conclusion of the foregoing Discourses Concerning the State of the Church of England and how she hath bin more successful in the Reformation of her Faith and Manners then the Church of Rome By H. C. de LVZANCY Mr. of Arts of Christ Church in Oxford OXFORD Printed at the Theater And are to be Sold by Moses Pit at the Angel in St. Pauls Church-yard Peter Parker at the Leg and Star in Cornhil William Leak at the Crown in Fleetstreet and Thomas Guy at the Corner Shop of little Lumbard-street and Cornhil 1679. Imprimatur HEN. CLERKE Pro-Cancel Oxon. Martij 17. 1677. TO The right Reverend FATHER in GOD HENRY By Divine Providence LORD BISHOP OF LONDON Dean of his Majesties Chapel-Roial AND One of his Majesties most Honorable PRIVY COUNCIL c. MY LORD I Presume to address to your Lordship a Treatise against the Council of Trent that is against a Conventicle of this last age wherein the ancient Faith was opprest by the establishment of modern errors and Religion crusht by the interests of a politic faction Besides the particular obligations I have to offer to your Lordship the best of my acknowledgments I could not have made a more suitable dedication of this Book then to a branch of that Noble Family which was ever zealous for the Faith once deliver'd to the Saints and to a Bishop of that Church which has alwaies declar'd it self against the unhappy policy of that See which builds its own greatness upon the ruines of the simplicity of the Gospel These two singular qualifications appear so eminently in the conduct of all your Lordships affairs that to them we are to attribute that extraordinary application whereby you answer all the ends of your high calling and content not your self with the advantages and honor but descend to the most laborious and difficult parts of so great a charge that diligent and strict watch whereby you do not only preserve your own Flock but discover all the designs and artifices of its enemies that unblamable conduct which the most violent and partial of your â—dversaries cannot but admire that servent charity which directs to your Lordship as to a sure refuge all them that desire to forsake either vice or error but above all that evenness and steddiness of mind which a Father of the Church calls the Life and Soul of Episcopacy wherewith Almighty God has endu'd your Lordship in so eminent a degree that it may be lookt upon as your peculiar Character My Lord it would be a noble subject to reflect upon a few late instances you have given that you prefer your honor and conscience above all interests whatever that you have no concern but for the welfare both of Church and State and tho the greatness of your quality sufficiently entitles you to the highest honor that either of them can bestow yet you owe your advancement purely to your own merit But My Lord I am prevented by the acclamations of the public and the voice of the whole Nation which by the great things you have already don is making judgment of the yet greater happiness it shall one day derive from your Lordships future undertakings This is become the employment of persons more proportioned to such a work and it is the utmost of my ambition to be admitted amongst the meanest of them who are daily beseeching Almighty God that he would still prosper your Lordship in the accomplishment of those noble designs wherein you are happily engag'd for the good both of Church and State I am with all imaginable respect and duty MY LORD Your Lordships most Humble most obedient and most oblig'd Servant De LUZANCY THE PREFACE THE occasion of these ensuing discourses which are here made public was a Treatise entitl'd Considerations upon the Council of Trent It s author has manag'd his subject with so much dexterity that I could not but judg it agreeable to that love all Christians ought to have for truth and to my own duty in particular to dispel the mist he has attempted to cast before men's eyes To perform this with solidity I thought it not so proper to rely upon any particular historian of that Council there being but four who have treated of it whose testimonies are not free from exception Soavius is suspected by the Romanists as Palaviciny by the Protestants tho with less justice Scipio Henricus is more addicted to his Society then to his Church and more intent to defend the Jesuits then to justifie the proceedings of the Bishops And for Aquilius his Survey De tribus Historicis it is rather a Pamphlet injurious to the Church of Rome it self for its want of sense and learning than a just censure But it appeared much more easie and useful to give a true character of the Council drawn out of its own acts and shew such essential defects in it that all the artifice of its defenders can never satisfie a rational and impartial enquirer There are two things to be consider'd in this Council the manner wherein it was celebrated and those points it determin'd which later either respect articles of Faith or reformation of manners This order I have exactly follow'd by endeavouring in the first discourse to evince that the manner of holding this Council was altogether irregular and that Protestants may lawfully reject it without any further discussion of its decrees in the second that its decisions are contrary to the ancient Canons of the Church and in the third that the reformation which was then pretended to be made was no better then a new violation of Discipline and a perfect illusion of the World In these discourses I avoid the citing any authors but such as for their learning and piety are venerable in the Church of Rome a design which no judicious persons can ever disapprove since it hapens but too often that we combat men whose sentiments their own communion disowns and after a long and tedious disputation we receive no other answer but that the Church of Rome is not bound to make good all the assertions of her privat followers And indeed she would be strangely put to it should she warrant all the dreams of Suarez Vasquez and other Jesuits Since it is easy to demonstrate that they are more contrary to her then to us more pernicious to their mother then to their enemies and as a learned Man of their communion observes fitter to raise new Heresies then to
destroy old ones There being therefore so great a difference between their doctrine and that of their Church I have the justice and honesty not to charge their excesses upon a communion which notwithstanding its many errors cannot cease to be great and venerable but the acts of Trent the Councils of the Catholic Church the writings of the Fathers and the decretal Epistles of the Popes themselves being still extant 't is from thence that the assertors or opposers of that Council must fetch their arguments I make no doubt but that this writing will increase the hatred of my adversaries and I foresee that the blackest colours of calumny will not be dark enough to draw my picture with T is the ordinary way of many Zealots who make it a part of their vertue to slander persons on the account of their Religion and to persecute them to the end either to induce them thereby to turn back to the communion they have left or at least to discredit them in that which they have embraced No Christianly affected man can see such dealings so opposite to God's Spirit without great sentiments of sorrow and compassion nor deplore too much the state of those men who break thro all the laws of charity by a principle of Conscience and certainly a party must needs be strangely weak when its defenders run to Pamphlets and injuries to maintain it The greatest and most signaliz'd revenge I le take of them and of their writings shall be a constant silence As their arguments shall never find me dumb so their reproaches shall for ever make me deaf The living God who understands the language of our hearts shall be the only witness of mine to him alone I will complain and if at any time I pray for the ruine of my persecutors it shall be as St. Austin tells us David did for the destruction of his Enemies He hated them with a perfect hatred he could never be reconcil'd with the sin but nevertheless loved very tenderly the sinner and at the same time he would have suffer'd death to confound the one he would have given his life to save the other REFLEXIONS On the Council of TRENT Discourse I. That the Protestants without any necessity of inquiring into the Decrees of the Council of Trent have sufficient reason to reject it I. THERE are no true Christians whose very being so imprints not in them a profound respect for the Councils of the Church since they consider them as Sacred Conventions wherein that Holy Mother both instructs and reforms her Sons and wherein Bishops speak forth the dictates of that Spirit which proceeds from the supreme Bishop of our souls 1 Pet. 2. 25. thereby preserving as well the faith of their people from being undermin'd by the overgrowing malice of Heresie as their manners from being corrupted by the remissness of her discipline The Catholick Church has alwaies judged them of so absolute a necessity that when ever the Devil attempted to disturb her peace so soon she gather'd her Members from all parts of the Earth to oppose him and to learn from the Divine Scriptures how that dreadful Enemy was to be conquer'd So when Arius endeavor'd to deprive us of our Redeemer by the denyal of his Divinity the whole Church thundred upon him in the Nicent Council Macedonius whose blasphemous Tongue inveighed against the Holy Ghost was no better treated in the Constantinopolitan That of Ephesus prov'd no less Enemy to Nestorius A thousand Anathema's were pronounc'd against Eutiches by the Fathers met at Chalcedon And because the Nestorians even after Nestorius his condemnation were resolv'd to maintain his Errors under the name of Theodorus Bishop of Mopsuestia Theodoret Bishop of Cyr and Ibas Bishop of Edessa and did likewise pretend that the first being dead in the Communion of the Church and the two others having been receiv'd in the Chalcedon Council the said Council had approv'd of the Nestorian Heresie the fifth General Synod gather'd at Constantinople condemn'd the three Chapters their Authors and Defenders amongst whom was poor Pope Vigilius reckon'd notwithstanding all his Infallibility It had been the constant desire of Men that the Council of Trent would have taken these first Assemblies for its rule kept both their form and spirit and shew'd in these last Times where Charity is so cold some foot-steps of those where it was so flaming II. There were no reasons wanting to raise in us the most ardent desires that it should have been so There was scarce any Religion to be found in men Superstition had so blinded their minds and fleshly lusts infected their hearts And at the same time that ambition had put Arms into the hands of Princes to disturb the world the bloodless but more pernicious and obstinate quarrels of Divines wasted the face of the Church The immediate fore-going Ages had brought forth Councils that contradicted each other All Europe stood amaz'd at those of Constance Basil Florence and the Lateran The sacred Persons of Kings were become so despâ—cable â—s to be excommunicated and degraded without the least scruple The Divine Authority of Bishops was brought to nothing and it was hard to judg whether ignorance or corruption was more predominant in the Clergy Nay the Popes themselves if you believe their Bulls seem'd to be sensible of so many Exorbitances Pope Pius the Fourth confessed He could not but be struck with horror when he saw how much both Heresie and Schism had prevail'd and how much Christian manners stood in need to be reformed Paul the Third before him had acknowledg'd That Heresie and Schism had vitiated all things But Adrian the Sixth goes further and in his Letter to the German Princes does not think it enough to say That the whole world groans under inveterate and insufferable abominations that he desires earnestly a Reformation but adds That the Church of Rome the Apostolical See is the off-spring â—f so many disorders We know saies he â—here have been many abominations in this â—oly See abuses in Spiritual affairs excesâ—s in the Laws and that all things are perâ—erted and it is no wonder that the disease â—ath flown from the head to the members â—rom the Popes to the inferior Prelates This is also the Confession of those â—rave and learned Doctors who being â—onsulted by Paul the Third about the â—ntended Reformation answered him poâ—â—tively That such an Enterprize would â—rove impossible and useless to the Church unâ—ess it began at the Head III. 'T was requisite therefore to come to that so much expected Reformation recal the ancient Doctrine and manners of the Church and demonstrate by a sudden and efficacious remedy that the Popes were not deaf to the cries and complaints of so many Nations But 't was necessary also to make the humane Grandeur of the Apostolick See agree with the Spiritual necessities that Souls were in exhibit some kind of help which they should be alwaies masters of and like
a contempt of Episcopal dignity XXVI And indeed the most holy Father us'd them all ut creaturas mancipia James of Clodia Fossa saying he could not suffer tradition to be parallel'd with the Scripture was expell'd the Council Peter of Justinianople being but suspected of what they call'd Lutheranism was forbidden to come there and take place amongst the Bishops Another was proclaim'd Schismatical and threatned to be rejected for affirming there had bin many lawful Bishops never call'd or confirm'd by the Pope Nay another was depos'd because he said the Pope should be contented with the title of Holy which God is satisfied with without affecting that of most Holy So that t was not without reason the Cardinal of Lorrain complains the Council was not free since nothing could be propos'd or resolv'd but what was the Legats pleasure nor could they propose any thing but what was the Popes XXVI But to convince all unprejudic'd persons we need but consider the safe conduct granted to Protestants Tho the Fathers of Trent were engaged in honour to blot out the memory of the Constantian Council whose wounds continued still bleeding by testifying to their adversaries all imaginable sincerity and Candour yet they gave them greater occasions then ever to distrust Protestants require nothing but what had bin accorded to the Bohemians by the Fathers at Basil but they are plainly denied They beg at least a safe conduct which they many confide in but t is doubted whether it may be granted them and they are told it shall be given in the Congregation viz. in the Friers meeting and not in the Session viz. in the Council At last after having bin thus baited they oâ—tain safe conduct which has respect only to the Germans worded in such captious terms that thereby the Pope had reserved to himself the power of burning all the English Swedes Danes and French that should come to the Council nay the Germans themselves tho they could blame nothing but their own simplicity Notwithstanding whatever reasons Protestants had of declining such a Council after the example of the Holy Fathers and the judgment of the wisest men then living they trusting the justice of their cause and seeing in that noble and magnificent safe conduct hope was given them of disputing and proposing their difficulties sent their Divines to Trent and exposed them to all dangers without any other defence then the truth which is call'd in the Scriture the shield of the just These Divines thus authoriz'd by their Nation being arriv'd at Trent conceal not themselves They avoid not the sight of men The whole Councill is acquainted with their coming They speak to the Ambassadors make their addresses to the Popes Legats conjure them to pitty the calamities of Germany and after having presented them with the confession of their Faith they beg no other favour from them but to have it read in the Council for its being either approv'd of or condemn'd The Legats do not burden them with Irons or tumble them into Dungeons they are so far from being murdered that their life could not be more secure in the Prince of Saxonies or the Landgraves Chamber But they receive no answer their confession of Faith remains buried the Legats keep it in Petto nor are the most entire submissions and ardent entreaties able to bring it forth Thinking perhaps that the quality of a Priest or of a Divine had no great influence upon an Apostolic Legat they made use of the Emperours Ambassadors That Prince was the Soul of the Pope as the Pope was of the Council But all these endeavours are frustrated there is somwhat unknown and unperceiv'd which strikes dumb their Eminences Who ever heard of any such dealings If Protestants decline the Council grounded upon a thousand unanswerable reasons all the World rises against them nor are the names of Heretics Schismatics nay Atheists sufficient to express their imputed perfidiousness But tho they come and strike Heaven and Earth with their complaints an ignorance is pretended of their being there The Fathers have neither ears nor hearts nor mouths to hear their praiers feel their grievances and answer their proposals and they are forced to beg and expect from God that justice which men deny them XXVII T is evident from so many instances that Protestants did never reject Councils There is no Christian whom the Authority of the Church do's not overcome he deserving to be debar'd from the quality advantages and hopes of a Son who hearkens not unto his Mothers voice The Church has a true jurisdiction a real and effective authority All contrary Doctrines flow from independency and Enthusiasm two blind and furious Monsters every where to be profligated But the very same Protestants so great admirers and defenders of the Church require she should speak in lawful assemblies When they shall be condemned in Councils like that of Nice and Chalcedon then they will receive their sentence with as much joy as respect But when a new and unlawful meeting guilty of essential aver'd and incontestable defects nay acknowledg'd to be such by the most learned and disinterested men of the Roman Communion shall claim the same authority as these Divine assemblies they will be very careful to keep their ancient waies and far from being deterr'd by the threats of that proud and uncharitable Church which excludes from heaven all those she cannot keep blindfold in her bosom they will augment the glorious company of many holy Fathers whom the overpowring number of unjust Councils could never bend to betray the cause of Christ Such an one was St. Athanasius who rejected the Council of Tyre Maximus Patriarch of Jerusalem that of Antioch Cyril that of Syrmium Paulinus that of Milan and Chrysostome an example of Christian constancy that ad quercum In a word they will receive those curses pronounc'd against them as so many blessings and without going any further into the discussion of the Tridentine Councils decrees they will conclude with the words of Cardinal Bellarmine Si legitima Synodus non fuit planum est nullam authoritatem potuisse habere nullius roboris sunt illius Canones REFLEXIONS On the Council of TRENT DISCOURSE II. That the Doctrine of the Council of Trent is contrary to the ancient Doctrine of the Catholic Church I. WHOEVER peruses the Council of Trent cannot but be strangely amazed to find its stile so altogether unlike that of the ancient writings of the Church There is in those I know not what characters of holiness and Christian majesty which command reverence from all but in this we meet with a sort of so unusual and dubious expressions that shew the Authors of it were incomparably better versed in political practices or Books of School-men then in the Works of the Fathers They never intended in many of their Canons to fix a true and uniform sense which all People might rely upon but a double and captious one apt to receive
great Truth in these words which the Church has so much admired as to make a Canon of them Verily verily I say unto you he that beleives in me hath everlasting life He therefore who has not everlasting life believes not in Christ but he believes in Christ that has Charity for to beleive in Christ est tendere in ipsum amando is to be enclined to him by Love It is to this the remissions of sins hath bin promised huic remissio peccatorum promittitur But if Love cannot be separated from Christian Faith how can he that wants Charity have Christian Faith that is believe in Christ Faith is therefore the Spring of our love and love the Source of our Works What is it to love God continues that holy Doctor but to be inwardly adherent to him to conceive an ardent desire of seeing him an hatred of sin a distast to the World a Charity for our Neighbor whom he has commanded us to love and so strictly to observe in our Charity the rules he has prescribed us in his Law as never to pervert its order But let it be far from Christians to think our Faith or Love come from us If any beleives saies the Council of Orange he can do any good action quod ad salutem pertinet vitae aeternae by the strength of nature and without being enlightned and inspired by the Holy Ghost who poures into our hearts a suavity which makes us assent to and believe the truth that man haeretico fallitur spiritu not attending to what Christ pronounces in his Gospel Without me ye can do nothing Nor to the words of the Apostle We are not sufficient of our selves to think any thing as of our selves but our sufficiency is of God There are in man saies the same Council many good things which man doth not do but in those he doth there are none but what God doth in him No man saies another Canon has of himself but falshood and sin but if any hath truth and righteousness 't is of him Quem debemus sitire in hac eremo ut ex eo quasi quibusdam guttis irrorati non deficiamus in via Good God! how far are the Canons of Trent from the holiness and humility of these how repugnant to the establisht Doctrine of the Church and the sentiments of the Fathers are the proud and Pelagian principles of the Jesuits XI The Anathema's of the seventh Session being no better grounded are not more to be feared the Council cuts off from the Church which is the Body of Christ those who admit of more or less then seven Sacraments It is evident that such a Principle cannot be proved by the Scripture We must then recur to the unwritten Word Sure so important a truth has bin preserved in the Catholic Church and nothing ought to be more obvious in the writings of the Fathers Nevertheless not a word for twelve whole Ages and that so long uninterrupted silence had never bin broken had not the master of the Sentences and other Scholastics brought it into the World Indeed we find every where in the writings of the Fathers that the Adult must give an account of the Faith they professed at their Baptism and receive the imposition of hands from the Bishop We meet every where with Repentance Penance and Confession of Sins We see every where the power of ordaining Priests so committed to the Bishops by Christ that all Ordinations from other hands were esteemed unlawful and sacrilegious But we find no where all these things to be Sacraments And no man can sufficiently wonder how the Fathers at Trent propose as an Article of Faith grounded upon Tradition a thing they are obliged to confess was never spoken of in the Church for twelve hundred years XII The Vnwritten word doth no more favor the Canon which establishes Transubstantiation then the others and we have from the ancient writings so many places against this Doctrine that we cannot conceive how it came into the World Tertullian writing against Marcion who denied that Christ had a real Body tells him Christ made his Body of the Bread he distributed saying This is my Body that is the figure of my Body Figura Corporis mei but it had never bin a Figure Si veritatis corpus non esset had not the Truth Christ had a real Body Christ saies Theodoret honored the Symbols and signs of the Sacrament with the name of his Body and Blood not changing their nature 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 but adding his Grace to their nature S. Jerome is no less positive then Theodoret The Flesh and Blood of Christ saies he are understood two several waies either of that spiritual and divine Flesh of which he saies himself My Flesh is meat indeed and my Blood is drink indeed and Except ye eat the Flesh of the Son of Man and drink his Blood ye have no life in you or my Flesh which was nailed upon the Cross and my Blood which was shed by the Souldiers Spear S. Austin who is justly esteemed the Oracle of the Western Churches adds a pregnant testimony to this Assertion The first heresy saies he in the Disciples of Christ was occasioned by the hardness of his words for when he told them Except ye eat the Flesh of the Son of Man and drink his Blood ye have no life in you they not apprehending him said one to another This is a hard saying who can bear it In saying this is hard they separated themselves from him But he remained with his twelve Disciples and taught them saying It is the spirit that quickneth the flesh profiteth nothing the words I speak unto you they are spirit and they are life Do you understand them in a spiritual manner they are spirit and life do you understand them in a carnal manner they they are no less spirit but not for thee who understandest them not spiritually Spiritually apprehend what I have said Non hoc corpus quod videtur manducaturi estis bibituri sanguinem quem effusuri sunt qui me crucifigent The Sacrament I recommend to you quickneth when it is understood spiritually but the flesh profiteth nothing They answered him according to their apprehension for they understood this flesh as it is used to be sold in a carcass or torn in the shambles Jesus knowing their error said to them What I told you of giving you my Body to eat and my Blood to drink scandalizeth you but what will you say if you see the Son of Man ascending to the place where he was before He resolves here what he had proposed to them he shews them that which they were scandalized by to the end they might apprehend him In this manner they thought he would have given them his Body Ille dixit se ascensurum in coelum utique integrum When you shall see the Son of Man ascending to
the place where he was before then you will know he gives not his Body as you understand it You will then apprehend that his Grace non consumitur morsibus till the end of the World the Lord is above but yet the truth of the Lord is upon Earth with us Corpus enim in quo resurrexit in uno loco esse oportet veritas autem ejus ubique diffusa est That incomparable Doctor speaks after the same manner when he teacheth that all places of the Scripture which seem contrary to truth and good manners are to be understood in a figurative sense If you find saies he a Commandment which forbids a crime or enjoins any good action then its sense is not figurative but it is otherwise when it seems to command a crime and prohibit a good action Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his Blood ye have no life in you saies Christ That word seems to command a crime figura est ergo it is therefore a figure which bids us communicate in the Passion of our Lord and recall into our memories with suavity and utility that his flesh hath bin wounded and nailed upon the Cross for us XIII To what the Church of Rome believes concerning Transubstantiation we may add her practice in taking away the Cup. She is not contented with changing the nature of a Sacrament but thinks it lawfull to tear and divide it All the learned men of her Commumunion assent to the following Propositions First That Christ instituted the Sacrament of his Body and Blood under both kinds of Bread and Wine Secondly That he instituted it thus for all Christians and said drink as he said eat without any distinction of of Priests and Lay-men being the Savior of all Thirdly That at least for twelve hundred years such a practise hath bin faithfully observed in all the Churches in the World and is still in the Eastern Fourthly That its intermission is not grounded upon any invincible reason or irremediable inconveniences For it would be the greatest piece of non-sense in the World to affirm that the Church of Rome in the thirteenth Age hath seen inconveniencies which the Catholic Church could not foresee in twelve hundred years and the Greek is still ignorant of Yet the Council of Trent perseveres in so considerable an innovation stops its ears to the cries of an infinite number of Souls who beseech their Fathers substance might not be so cruelly divided and stiles this a Liberty the Church has alwaies bin Mistress of to dispense Sacraments as she judges it convenient But suppose the Sacrament to be no less compleat under one kind then both and that the Cup is but an addition to it We notwithstanding maintain the Church hath no autority to change any thing Christ hath instituted and prescribes the observation of All reasons in such occasions must be suspected when Christ himself speaks promulgates himself his own Laws and commands them to be put in execution as he hath done here all our pretended inconveniences are then gross errors nor must we affect to be wiser then the eternal Wisdom who foresaw better then we can do the reasons of our scandals Had Christ instituted all the Ceremonies the Church judged necessary for the greater decency of her Worship and commanded the observation of them it would be a dreadful crime to cut off the least But Pope Gelasius speaks not of that division as of the taking away of a simple Ceremony We heard saies he that some by I know not what superstition after having received the sacred Body refused the Cup of the precious Blood But for such aut integra Sacramenta percipiant aut ab integris arceantur The reason of that learned Pope is worthy to be weighed because saies he divisio unius ejusdemque mysterii sine grandi sacrilegio non potest pervenire One and the same mystery cannot be divided without a grand sacriledge Pope Gelasius and the Fathers of Trent are wonderfully opposed these say the Sacrament is no less perfect under one kind then under both that such a division is a wise dispensation which cannot be reasonably contradicted the other calls the distribution of the precious Body and Blood one and the same Sacrament and stiles that prudent dispensation a division of two things united by Christ which cannot be done without an horrid sacriledg Which then of the two Gelasius or Paul III. must be supposed to have pronounced ex Cathedra If the Jesuits are chosen Judges between them Gelasius shall be condemned for Salmero and another of his Society were so impious as to say in the midst of the Council that sometimes the Devil transforms himself into an Angell of Light but now appears covered with the Cup of Christs Blood to offer a draught of poyson But as if it had not bin enough to have committed so great an enormity without adding to it an insufferable ignorance these two most holy and learned Fathers as a most holy and learned Jesuit styles them all the members of that Society being ipso facto most holy and learned begged of Cardinal Madruccio That it might be added to the Canons already made that the Sacrament was instituted under both kinds only for the Apostles and Priests XIV The Canons of the fourteenth Session are no less opposite to Antiquity wherein the Council defines Repentance to be a Sacrament a Doctrine unknown till the time of Eugenius IV. The Arch-Bishop of Caesarea tells us in a Book he entitled De Reformatione Scholasticae which he considered as a great step to that of the Church that Eugenius ascribed it to the Florentine Council tho such a Decree had never bin read or seen there 'T is an effect of the Popes usual sincerity So that for twelve hundred years together the Church is silent in this point Now what must a Christian think of a Council that gives to our human satisfactions and poor Sacrifices the power due only to the unspeakable merits of Christ Who without just indignation can hear that our Alms and Fastings expiate our sins and preserve us from eternal Death Did ever any Councils Fathers or Divines run into such excesses nor do we pretend to embrace the other extreme and diswade Christians from that life w ch the Saints term a Cross and a Martyrdom We think that it not only obliges Penitents but Innocents also and we are struck with fear at these words of Christ Except ye repent ye shall all likewise perish But far be it from us to confine our Repentance to some trausient and slight exercices of Piety We require that sinners die continually to themselves that they think no pleasures lawful but such as the miseries of humane life render necessary and unavoidable that they endure rather then enjoy them and bewail the blindness and obdurateness of an infinite number of Souls who being made drunk by the pride and wantonness of the World are
from God Justitiam vero quae ex fide Christi est non esse nisi ex Deo A man may be still sinfull and Gods enemy with such a righteousness Ideo cum in illa quae ex lege est justitia sine querela conversaretur Apostolus fuisse se impium non negat Fourthly they taught That sorrow conceiv'd only out of fear of punishment is a sorrow of Infidels and that if God were satisfied with that there is no man in the World that could chuse but be innocent since no man that has but the least Idea of the life to come but is moved with its apprehension Non enim peccare metuit sed ardere This is a principle the Fathers have with unanimous consent maintained This the Popes in former Ages taught Nay those that sit now in the Apostolical See would do so too if with the modesty and humility of their Predecessors they had not also rejected their doctrine XVI The Council seems in its last Session to gather all its strength against those who reject Purgatory and deprive Saints Images and Reliques of their due honor Yet it appears the Fathers of Trent agreed that all those things Purgatory excepted are not founded upon Scripture but only upon the General Councils and Writings of the Fathers This is collected out of the very words of the Decree the Council there speaking of Ecclesiastical antiquity but not a word of the Scripture A Person of extraordinary merit has undertaken to lay open the mysteries of Purgatory and as he leaves nothing unsaid on that subject so none can take it ill if I refer my Reader to him For those other things Invocation of Saints Images and Reliques 't is easy in a few words to shew how infirm their ground is in the ancient Doctrine of the Church All learned men in the Church of Rome admit of the following Propositions First That nothing in the Scripture authorizes these practices or at least nothing sure fixt cleer and undoubted Secondly That all places taken out of Scripture by modern Writers to prove these things have never bin made use of by the Ancients for that purpose and so are of no autority the ancients being most holy and assured Interpreters of the Scriptures Thirdly That till the seventh pretended General Council that is for eight hundred years there was not any decision made of them Fourthly That to this pretended General Council we oppose others acknowledged General by the Collector of the Councils but as all learned men confess endued with these Qualities 1. More exact in the Discussion of matters as it appears by their Acts. 2. Called by an holy Emperor and peculiar Benefactor to the Church of Rome 3. Free from all Suspicions of oppression which the seventh is guilty of 4. That the consent of the Fathers upon that Doctrine is neither clear nor unanimous and that if in any of later date there be some places tending that way there are in the same and many others a thousand contrary places to invalidate them 5. That if we speak according to the Principles of the Church of Rome it self there can no more then a simple probability be pleaded in this case and that none of the greatest neither but to both parties favorable But there is not a Divine in the World who dares affirm that an Article of Faith can be built upon a simple probability nor declare them impious and blasphemous who have a contrary probability nor excommunicate them and separate them from the Church that is inflict upon them the most dreadful punishment How could the Fathers of Trent therefore do this why did they not fear that threatning of the wise Man Sicut avis in incertum volans quolibet vadens sic maledictum frustrà prolatum venit super eum qui misit illud Nor that of Origen when a man is unjustly put out of the Church he ceaseth not to be within when he that thinks himself within may be really out XVII Saints pray in general for all Christians For tho they triumph in Heaven yet they are her members who strives and combats upon Earth They are indeed united to their Head which is Christ but yet they still preserve the remembrance of the Body which is the Church They are a part of that Spouse who as S. Bernard saies sighs after the Bridegroome and begs a kiss from his mouth wisheth for the end of the World that Christ would hasten his Judgment and manifest that day wherein he will begin to be all in all 'T is in that very sense the Apostle saies The whole Creation groans and travails in pain till now even we our selves groan within our selves waiting for the Adoption to wit the Redemption of our Body 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 So S. Cyprian assures us That the Saints being secure of their immortality are careful of our Salvation S. Jerome argues against Vigilantius in this manner If the Apostles and Martyrs being yet in their Bodies can pray for others much more when they have conquered are crowned and triumph And S. Austin yet more perfectly The Saints in Heaven saies he offering their prayers for the necessity of those that pray God grants to every one all those comforts he judges most suitable to them in the miseries of the present life But there is a vast difference between the Invocation whereby we direct our Prayers to the Saints and the intercession of the Saints for us And none of these things are to be found in the Tradition 1. That the Saints pray for any particular person 2. That they obtain any favors for us by their own merits 3. That it is lawful to honor them with a religious worship XVIII And to discover with how little sincerity the Council of Trent speaks of this custom that it has bin preserved à primaevis Christianae Religionis temporibus it is enough to say that their most learned Men confess it was the sentiment of the Primitive Fathers that the Souls of the Saints should not enjoy the sight of God till the day of Judgement and consequently could neither speak in favor of us no offer to him our praiers S. â—ene Justin S. Clement Tertullian Origen Lactantius S. Ambrose S. Chrysostom S. Augustin Eutimius Theodoret Oecumenius Aretas are said to have bin of that opinion Nay S. Bernard preach't it which shews that this Doctrine continued till the twelfth Age of the Church XIX Indeed we cannot too much honor those holy men who preserve with an undaunted resolution the precious Tresures committed to their charge We must admire them in the powerful effects of Christs Grace who in a corruptible flesh and a sinfull World has preserved them pure and undefiled The constancy of Martyrs the austerity of Penitents the inviolated purity of Virgins who despised all other ambition besides that of being near the Lamb deserve all our Praises Nay a true Christian makes his actions
as Popes as infallible as the Oracles of the Holy Ghost as masters both of Men and Angels as judges both of the quick and dead in a word as men of whom according to their own Books 't is not allow'd to enquire Domine cur ita facis IV. That Ambition and Covetousness have bin the two originary sins of the Popes and that to these two Heads may be reduc'd all the rest the very complaints of their own Historians and most famous Authors do evince By the first they made a shift to raise themselves above Spiritual and Temporal Powers to excommunicate and depose Kings to invade the jurisdiction of other Bishops to break thro all ancient and modern Canons and instead of being rul'd by the General Councils of the Catholic Church to exalt themselves above them By the second they made use of all sacred and profane means to enrich themselves reduc'd all Benefices into that state as not to be attain'd but by Simony and sacrific'd all things to the raising of their Families As for the honor of their Dignity the glory of the Gospel and the consideration of the scandal of the Church these could never over-power in them the more strong impressions of Flesh and Blood The invention of Croisados being worn out they had recourse to that of Indulgences set to sale the absolution of sins and whosoever fill'd the Apostolic Treasure tho he were more profligate than the bad Thief became more innocent then the good V. Nor was it enough barely to fall into so many disorders unless they undertook also to Canonize them and thereby bring themselves under that dreadful Curse which God pronounces against those that call evil good 'T was for this purpose that Rome hath bred up such Doctors as flatter the Popes even to Idolatry stiling them Gods upon Earth These gave birth to the monstrous Doctrine of Infallibility never before heard of in the Church for 1400 years These had the face to maintain that if all the World should oppose their Sentiment all the World must be slighted And to sum up in a word all that can be said on that matter they have so far enslav'd themselves to their passion as to decree in one of their Canons that if the Pope should be neglectful of his Brethrens salvation improfitable to the Church dumb in what concerns her good tho he should carry along with him to hell an innumerable number of souls yet no man living can presume to correct him VI. These things are neither exaggerations nor slanders but meer matters of Fact which the best Authors of the Roman Church as Monsieur D'Espences Gerson the Chancellor of Paris Marsilius of Pavia the Cardinal of Cambray the Cardinal Cusan Aeneas Sylvius afterwards Pope do equally complain of And without ever mentioning the impertinencies of Canonists some of whom teach The Pope hath power to excommunicate Angels or the Impieties of some Divines who maintain he can establish any thing against the Law of God and Nature both What can be more amazing then to hear the Popes speak themselves Nicholas the First in his Letter to Michael saies That the Pious Emperor Constantine had call'd the Pope God and that 't is evident God can be judged by no man This piece of madness his successors lik'd so well that they made an express Canon of it Boniface the Eighth defines in a Decretal of his That all humane Creatures are bound necessitate salutis to submit to him as to the King of kings and both Spiritual and Temporal Lord over all the World His successor pretends lawfully to dispense with that which was contrary to the Apostles commands Bene dispensat Dominus Papa contra Apostolum Let all the World know saies Gregory the Seventh out of an excess of modesty and humility That we give and take away all Kingdoms Empires Principalities and all Goods men are capable of possessing VII Nor did these Servants of the Servants of God live any otherwise then they taught There could no Crown in their times be assur'd upon the Head of any Prince whatsoever Right Birth or Election had there established it And indeed we would scarce believe the precedents of Philip Frederic Lewis c. had we not beheld in our own daies what Leo the Tenth Julius the Third and Sextus the Fifth had done The public Records of England Germany and France are fill'd up with their bold enterprises the raising Subjects in rebellion against their natural Princes the absolving them from their Allegiance the putting great Kingdoms into combustion at once undermining them by civil Dissentions and procuring them to be invaded by Foreign Enemies the swearing Friendship with Francis the First and at the same time helping Charles the Fifth to subvert him and again entertaining correspondence with Charles the Fifth whilst he solicited Francis the First to war again are part of the transactions of St. Peters Successors the heads of the Church and Vicars of Christ VIII But for their Convetousness who is able to express it Annats expectative Graces sacred Reservations Preventions Mandats things abominable in all their parts were call'd by them Pious artifices to maintain the Apostolic See That which in its own nature was properly a Crime an Abomination and a Simony was turn'd into an holy action by a Pasce oves meas IX All Friers who grew weary of being govern'd by their Bishops and kept in the hardships of Penance sent mony to Rome where there was not a door in the Conclave but was open to their Gold Great sums to the Datary prevail'd more then all their tears could have done No Canons no Councils no Fathers resisted their bribes They purchas'd Privileges substracted themselves from the Sacred Jurisdiction of their Bishops and tho the very Injunction of their new gain'd liberty was a real Simony a disobedience and an effect of the corruption of their hearts yet the disturbers of it were threatned in their Bulls with St. Peter and St. Pauls indignation X. But that his Holiness not satisfied with the oppression of the Clergy should not spare the Lay-men neither is above all imagination The Records of the Parliament of Paris speak every where of the Popes oppressions Sir Roger Twisden hath writ an excellent account of the insupportable Taxes England groan'd under the natural piety and generosity of the English inviting the Popes to abuse it into an occasion of leaving no limits to their Covetousness For Germany and other Provinces who in the World is unacquainted with their grievances And is there any Roman Catholic who if he consider things impartially confesses not that Leo the Tenth was the cause of greater evils to the Church then Luther XI The Pope himself verified that word of the Prophet The Priests shall eat the sins of the people There was no crime which had not an Asylum at the Penitentiaries The obscene Books of the Jesuits Sanchez and
Hurtado are purity it self compar'd with the Book of the Apostolical Tax All the Casuists together never taught the World so many crimes as this one profligate Book We suppress it because we would not offend the modesty of our Reader There are no tongues or words pregnant enough to express so great an infamy but yet to give some hint of it let us hear the Popes Secretary Our sins saies he are rais'd to such an height that we have scarce any hope of mercy left us 'T were a vain attemt to describe the greatness of the Priests covetousness especially of them that govern How unbounded is their ambition obscenity and luxury How deep is their ignorance both of themselves and Christs doctrine also How full is the little Piety they had left of hypocrisie and dissimulation and how instead of concealing the crimes they commit do they affect rather to make them appear XII This then was the disease of the Roman Church let us now examine whether the Council of Trent has truly reform'd so many abuses whether it hath preserv'd the respect due to Princes render'd the rights of Bishops inviolable taken away the Simonies and Extortions of the Court of Rome and whether Mr. d'Espences complains wrongfully Quod tot annis tot annorum centenariâ—is nil in ea emendatur XIII As for Princes the injuries which the preceding Popes had done them were so far from being repaired that Julius the Third was so bold as to excommunicate the Queen of Navar give her Kingdom over to depredation and confiscate her Goods XIV As for the Holy Father they work out his reformation in a pleasant manner It is consider'd as a Crime to speak of reforming him of searching into his wounds or taking any account of his excesses And when the Cardinals hurried on by the force of truth and the cries of all men are oblig'd out of meer shame to propose the mending any abuse they alwaies add Salva tamen Apostolicae sedis autoritate So when plurality of Benefices is condemn'd it is Salva semper Apostolicae sedis autoritate when that intolerable abuse of Dispensations is cut off 't is salva semper sedis Apostolicae autoritate when any Penance is imposed upon non-resident Bishops 't is salva semper Apostolicae sedis autoritate when Friars are put again under the jurisdiction of their Ordinaries and obedience to their Canons 't is salva semper Apostolicae sedis autoritate that is to say The autority of that Apostolic See which has patroniz'd their first violation of the discipline shal be at liberty to do it a second time They dare condemn no crimes without impowring the Apostolic See to commit them over again A Law however just and necessary in it self cannot be enacted without leaving to the Apostolical See the liberty of infringing it And thus they make of the Apostolical See a sanctuary and retreat for all disorders XV. Nothing is better known at Rome then the lives of a great many Cardinals Heaven and Earth are offended at their Pride Their plurality of Benefices Bishoprics and Abbies is monstrous No secular Princes are attended with greater magnificence Never had the most luxurious Heathens either Palaces so gloriously adorn'd or Tables so delicatly furnished and whatever we read of the Gardens of Lucullus or the pleasures of Tempe is far short of the luxury of their Country Houses Yet they are Clergy-men that is a sort of people who not only vowed in their Baptism to renounce the World but declar'd it also in their Ordination That the Lord was the lot of their inheritance and his Gospel a commandment to die and bury themselves with him Notwithstanding when their Reformation was spoken of in the Council the Legats presently declar'd that the Reformation ought not to extend unto their Eminencies to which a Pious and Learned Bishop more daring then the rest moved to see Sacred Episcopacy so trampled upon by them made answer that the most illustrious Cardinals ought to have a most illustrious Reformation Illustrissimi Cardinales indigent illustrissima reformatione But they are deaf to this voice of Heaven and instead of sincerely advancing the Interest of the Gospel among themselves to the end that the spring it self being purified the stream might be so too 200 Bishops and five Cardinals busie themselves in ordering the subsistence of Franciscans and shaping the habit of Nuns XVI Nothing is so certain as the shameful traffic of the Datary and Chancery none but the wilfully blind can deny it to be a gulph which swallows up the riches of many Kingdoms and sucks the purest Blood of the people But they must first have renounc'd the Gospel and their own reason who confess not that it is a continual commerce of abominable Simony a violating of the most Holy Canons and a pernicious attemt upon the autority of Princes and Bishops What Council in former Ages what custom of the Church what legitimate Title impowers the Popes to give Benefices of other Kingdoms What new Gospel teaches him to raise vast sums upon the account of Spiritual matters What right hath he over those Churches he hath never ministred unto Which of the Fathers or what Authors can he allege to maintain such usurpations Nay who in the latter times â—id not rise against such an execrable abuse and spoke not to him in the words â—f a famous Emperor Cesset altaribus imâ—inere profanus ardor avaritiae sacris â—dytis repellatur piaculare flagitium Yea the Council very well saw all this was in the Diocess of all these Bishops â—hat so intolerable disorders spread their â—ranches The Canons of the Sacred â—ouncils of Nice and Chalcedon are set before their eies as so many eternal Witnesâ—es of the Churches Spirit but instead â—f following their rules they wholly buâ—â—e themselves in cutting off some small â—â—uses reforming of a Country Vicar 〈◊〉 for the rest Salva semper Apostolicae â—â—dis autoritate XVII Of all the different kinds of Simony the Court of Rome is guilty of none is so certain and aver'd as the Annats Boniface the Eighth and John the Twenty second invented them two Popes Baronius stiles Monsters The Council of Basil prohibited them under pain of Excommunication and because the Fathers were inform'd that they came from no other source then the Pope who by a Pasce oves meas Joh. 4. 6. makes all crimes lawful they add those so remarkable words That if the Bishop of Rome who more then any other ought to observe and execute the Canons of the Councils comes to scandalize the Church attempting any thing against such a prohibition let him be proceeded against by a General Council The most considerable Authors of the Church of Rome both for Learning and Piety complain most bitterly of this The Faculty of Sorbon calls it not only a Crime but an Heresy Paul the Third his Counsellors who had bin first oblig'd under pain of Excommunication to declare
man most deeply engag'd in the love of the World most buried in all its pleasures the most taken with its glory one that is a public sinner guilty of all the excesses which libertinism or atheism are able to inspire such an one as this must be excus'd from too much troubling himself The bearing of a Medal bowing to a Saint walking to such a Church or the like will wash him whither then snow and presently render him as innocent in the eyes of God as the best of them who think it worth their while to work out their salvation with fear and trembling Phil. 2. 12. who are at the trouble of mortifying in themselves the body of sin by an incredible perseverance by continual Fasting Praiers and Alms that they may present their bodies a living sacrifice holy and acceptable unto God Rom. 10. 1. XXII Thus the power of Dispensing opens the door to infinite scandals But the Pope was impowr'd to do what he would the Council granting him that which he could never hope for viz. the affertion of his infallibility and pre-eminence above general Councils two Opinions that had never bin heard of for 14 Ages and were scarce brought forth into the World but all learned and pious Men opposed them the 400 Bishops at Basil and the famous Sorbon stiling them pernicious Heresies but the Fathers of Trent being afraid to contradict openly so considerable an autority and yet desirous to have their intent dealt after a most pleasant manner they take away these two words Infallibility and Superiority but preserve carefully the thing 1. The Council declares the Church of Rome is Mother and Mistress of all Churches 2. The Council affects to stick at many matters and remits their decision to the Popes judgment Now what man of sense is there who would not draw these two Consequences 1. The Church of Rome being Mother of all Churches in the World and a general Council being compos'd but of particular Churches the Pope being Bishop of Rome is therefore Father and Master of all Bishops Councils 2. There is Infallibility in the Church this must either be in the Pope or in the Council not in the last since the Council cannot and dares not give their Opinion in many and weighty matters therefore in the first whose Church is Mistress and Mother of all Christian Churches in the World and whose sentence an oecumenical Council submits unto as to an Oracle which must fix its uncertainty But the same man should with their good leave to these consequences add a third which is 3. That the faculty of Sorbon is Heretical The Learned Gerson Chancellor of Paris is an Heretic The 400 Bishops at Basil are Heretics Pope Pius the Second an Heretic Martin the Fifth an Heretic And generally all the Learned Men of the Church for these 200 years are Heretics for they all call that Doctrine of Infallibility and Superiority a pernicious Heresie XXIII These two Points Infallibility and Superiority being once stated what reformation could be expected in the Church If the Pope be infallible What an insolent boldness is it to subject him to other rules then his own And if the Church of Rome be Mistress and Mother of all Churches What right have these Churches to give Laws instead of receiving them from her And therefore I cannot sufficiently admire how the author of the Considerations upon the Council of Trent durst assert That the Pope had bin ill us'd at Trent and nothing was said of his Supremacy We leave it to all persons to judg of the truth of this Assertion we can only say That the Authors who had written till then with the greatest ardor to promote the Apostolical Grandeur had never given her the ambitious qualifications of Mother and Mistress nay they were so far from raising the Pope above Councils that they call such a Doctrine a Schism and an Heresie XXIV But as if Infallibility and Superiority were not enough the Council adds a third a Vow of true obedience The word true obedience is no less pleasant then the trae pardon of sins The Court of Rome is so us'd to equivocations and ambiguities that her fears appear in her own Decrees All Christians therefore whether Clergy or Laity are tied up or rather sacrificed to the Pope by a solemn Oath so as let him be as much Arian as Liberius as much a Monothelite as Honorius as unlearned as Celestine the Fourth as Simoniacal as John the Twenty second as unclean as Alexander the Sixth let him be as insolent towards Kings as Hildebrand to Frederic Boniface to Philip August Innocent to John King of England Leo the Tenth to Henry the Eighth Julius the Third to the Queen of Navar yet he cannot be resisted 't is not lawful to disobey the Father and Master of all Churches to believe him in the wrong whose judgment is above all Councils and to oppose him to whom you are sworn upon the four Gospels XXV These reasons occasion'd the doleful complaint of Monsieur d' Espences then present at the Council who saies openly That the Church is in a more desperate condition then before and that by reason of the Italian Bishops whom he calls the Helena which triumph'd at Trent there is no hope to cure her wounds Gentianus Hervaeus Doctor in Sorbon also and present at the Council speaks after the same rate and differs only from the others in that he ascribes all the miscarriages of the Council to Lainez and Salmero both Jesuits Julius Sanelius being return'd from Trent whether he had bin brought by the Cardinal of Lorrain gave an account of that Assembly in these terms That in the Council of the Apostles it had bin said Visum est spiritui sancto nobis it seem'd good to the Holy Ghost and to us but in that of Trent Plus nobis quam Spiritui Sancto more to us then to the Holy Ghost It appears therefore that the pretended Reformation of the Pope and Court of Rome is a meer Chimera nor is it an harder matter to evidence that the Reformation of the Church is a meer disorder It may be said and very truly that the sins which Lay-men lie under have no other source then the bad examples of the Clergy and we may learn both from profane Writings and Divine from Historians as well as Prophets that the good or bad life of Priests hath ever had an unspeakable influence on mankind But 't is another truth no less certain that if the sins of the people come from the Priests those of the Priests spring from the Bishops this being a daily experiment that as the Clergy is holy when it is govern'd by Saints so it becomes abominable to God when the life of its head does not answer the duties and excellency of his dignity The shortest way therefore to reform the Church was seriously to reform the Bishops But instead of reforming the Episcopal Order the Fathers
looks on the praises which the Saints have given him in their Epistles as titles and privileges from Christ the Church of England opposes it with as much constancy as justice and not being able to cure the wounds of that Bishop she leaves him to the judgment of our great God XII The pride of the Pope has caus'd the separation of the Greek Church and made a breach between East and West which will never be made up It has also bin the occasion of the one part of the West being divided from the other And it is not ten years since in the affair of the four French Bishops it had like to raise a Schism and a division in the rest XIII But supposing the submission of all the rest to Rome should be lawful yet that is nothing to the Church of England which was never any part of it It plainly appears she receiv'd the Faith almost as soon as Christ brought it to the world but altho the time be uncertain yet none can think that she was ever instructed by the Church of Rome Her manner of observing Easter as in the East and her Ceremonies very different from those used in the Church of Rome shew that she receiv'd the Gospel from thence St. Gregory having sent hither Austin the Monk and that Holy Saint requiring the Clergy to submit to the Popes autority the Abbot of Bangor in the name of all the rest answer'd in such terms as shew'd the purity and simplicity of the former times We submit our selves saies he to the Church of God to the Pope of Rome and to every good Christian and love each of them with such a degree of charity as is due to them to assist them both in our works and Councils to become sons of God we know no other respect due to him whom you stile Father of Fathers XIV It is therefore certain for six hundred years at least that the Church of England hath in no manner bin subject to that of Rome her Councils and promotions of Bishops and generally all that belongs to Religion has bin transacted without the Church of Rome being at all concerned in them It would be much against the honor of the Pope if those means should be made known by which he hath endeavor'd to establish himself for the succeeding ages The public Acts of this Kingdom of a far greater autority then all their legends are â—ully charg'd with his Oppressions What pains did the Kings take to put a stop to them with what constancy did the Clergy oppose it till the time of Henry the Eighth That history was writ with as much impartiality as truth by the Learned Sir Roger Twisden It appears by all public Acts that the Pope hath wonderfully endeavor'd to make use of all conjunctures of times to get footing into this great Isle He hath bin enrich'd by the liberality of her Kings by Factions which he sow'd in the heart of the Kingdom and by the Wars which he brought upon it from abroad XV. Henry the Eighth whom all the Popes have so cry'd out upon went not further then his Predecessors and the title of supreme Governor in these his Realms well understood is no less due to him then to any other Prince in the World This King or any of his Successors pretend to no more autority over the Church then Constantine Justinian or Charles the Great They have neither power to administer the Sacraments nor to Preach the word of God They meddle not at all with any thing which belongs to faith or manners and leave to their Bishops all the power in those matters which Christ himself has given them They make no Canons tho they add Sanctions to them and declare the knowledge of Spiritual affairs is not a right of their Crowns They only take care of the outward administration of the Church to see Canons executed and hinder foreign autority under pretence of piety from disturbing the quiet of their people Upon this account the Bull of no Pope is receiv'd in France without the Kings consent all privileged men are daily restor'd to the jurisdiction of the Ordinaries and when any thing does endanger the liberties of the Gallican Church or the Laws of the Land the Pasce oves meas is of no force and the Kings autority stops the attemts of the Holy Father In Spain the King has the disposal of all things belonging to the outward Government of the Church The Inquisitors condemn in the Kings name and when the Council of Trent was there receiv'd 't was by the command he gave his Subjects to do it nor do the Kings of England claim any more XVI 'T was not the title of Supreme Governor which did most of all distast the Pope He could easily bear with that in all Kings for it is but what naturally belongs to them he knew that every King has such autority over the Church but he fear'd the consequences of it which indeed are very terrible to a Pope Henry the Eighth by that did suppress the Bulls which came from Rome and retain'd in his own Realms those vast sums which before were yearly carried out of them This was transacted in the sight of two great Kingdoms inclin'd enough to do the like The Pope therefore thought that in prudence he ought to cry out on that Prince but because a man cries in â—ain when things are represented in their â—rue and lively colours he gave his defenders liberty of forming Chimera's to the end they might work upon the people such an effect in this point as he desired XVII The Church of England need not recuâ— to an extraordinary mission nor to those arguments so far distant from reason to prove her self a Church She hath not confounded the order of things and assum'd a Government lately sprung up Since she hath receiv'd the Faith which was according to Nicephorus in the firsâ— age and to St. Beda some small time after we see the succession of Bishops hath continu'd without the least interruption or change XVIII The Usurpations of Popes the comâ—merce of Italians and most of all the ignorance wherewith God for some timâ— permitted the West to be blinded madâ— them fall into the errors of Rome But when God looked upon the Church in hâ—â— mercy and had opened her eies she laâ—bored to reform her self but not in a tuâ—multuous manner and spilling of bloodâ— She was not left to the conduct of the blind People which will suffer nothing but what pleaseth them best and which is delighted only with extreams The King calls a Council of the whole Kingdom stored with wise and holy Bishops as appears both in their lives and works This Council form'd the articles of a reformation which being seconded by the law of their Prince according to the custome of all Monarchs were by that great Kingdom receiv'd with a general respect XIX These holy Prelats in the Reformation had nothing carried on either
by heat or violence an extraordinary and unusual prudence appears in all their Canons they busy not themselves in calling the Pope Antichrist and Rome Babylon but render them the same respect they had ever done They judg themselves without judging others and are content to pray for other Societies without pronouncing either their Salvation or condemnation XX. As they do separate themselves only from the errours of the Church of Rome so they do pretiously preserve what doth not bear that name otherwise 't would not have bin the work of a pious zeal but of a wicked madness None can deny that there are many great and holy rites in the Church of Rome They therefore by a judicious distinction have thrown out those practises which were evil and retain'd the good XXI Having therefore two businesses in hand to wit the reformation of Doctrine and ordering of manners they have made use of the shortest and easiest means They compar'd all to the Scriptures and customes of the first Ages There is no point of their Faith which may not be proved by Scripture nothing in their Discipline which is not conformed to the ceremonies of the first 500 years XXII The Church of England therefore hath the comfort of having her Doctrine founded on the Scriptures so believed by the holy Saints as she beleiv'd it her Canons conformable to the antient Canons her Liturgy like the first Liturgies When she goes about to interpret the Scriptures she exacts not of her Children a blind obedience as doth the Church of Rome She thinks not to make any volume Canonical which was never really so but she follows the tracts of the Saints and of the Councils and hath learnt from the primitive Church which books in the Holy Bible are the grounds of our Faith and which only the object of our Piety XXIII We may say the same thing of all those points which raise the difference betwixt us and the Church of Rome The most considerable one is that of the Eucharist She treats that incomprehensible mystery with the respect due to it She neither presumes nor pretends to comprehend more of it then Christ hath bin pleased to reveal to them and the antient Church understood It is manifest first that Christ instituted the Sacrament of his body and blood Secondly that he is really present in it Thirdly that he abundantly communicates his grace and his holy Spirit to those who before they receive it seriously try themselves as the Apostle speaks and who not only forsake Sin but the very appetite of sinning and labour to order their life by his example But the manner of his being present is uncertain Christ saies nothing of it it appears noâ— that the primitive Church hath known how That of England receives with thanksgiving what he hath bin pleased to reveal to her and adores with a submissive silence what he hath not bin pleased to let her know We understand nothing of the Lord's Supper but by the Scriptures and the practice of the primitive times and when we limit our selves to that without going any further the manner of expounding it is not difficult The Infinite love of God towards us in that Sacrament destroies not the order which his wisdom hath put in things We leave to Faith all the latitude of it without contradicting the principles of reason But when men pretend to make Evangelists speak as Scholastics or Scholastics as Evangelists and look for Transubstantiation concomitancy and existence of the accidents without their subject c. all seems obscurity and darkness We sacrifice not our reason to faith but we throw aside both of them in saying that God explains himself after a manner conâ—rary to those principles which he hath established The Church of England is therefore in 〈◊〉 right of supposing as receiv'd what she beleives and the Church of Rome is obâ—â—ged to prove what she advances The former supposes the miracle which Christ â—ath wrought adding nothing new or â—npossible the other proposeth a thousand things to our beleif of which Christ â—ath said nothing and which are in â—hemselves greater miracles then that about which the two parties differ besides that they draw idolatrous practices XXIV The Church of Eng. doth not only think her self bound to beleive what Christ saies of the sacrament but she administers it â—s he hath given it us She orders the Sacrament under both kinds according â—o the command of Christ and to the praâ—tice of the Catholic Church and the whole World know the unchristian grounds upon which an Italian Bishop in the Council of Trent thought it was not to be granted for fear of making an argument against the pretended Infallibility of the Church of Rome XXV It is unreasonable that she do's not permit service to be read in the vulgar tongue and the Bible to be â—ranslated She knows nothing was ever grounded upon a less foundation then that and without looking on the orders of St. Paul which are so exact thereupon is there any thing in the World so contrary to reason as to pray to God in an unknown Tongue which exposeth the Praiers to the scorn and irreverence of those that offer them The Eastern Church did alwaies pray in Greek or in languages used by her divers Nations Whilst the Latin was the language of the West it was fitting that the service should be read in it but by the distraction of the Empire the incursions of Barbarians and the various revolutions we find in history that language having lost its life and given place to the various Idiomes of all Nations it was fitting men should pray in such languages as may be understood but it being more for the interest of the Pope to keep people ignorant he hath opposed so necessary a practice St. Jerome translated the Bible into Dalmatian the language of his own Country there are also to be â—ound manuscripts of the Bible in most languages of the World The more universal and dangerous heresies were the more the holy Saints exhorted the People to look in the Scriptures for those remedies which God hath granted against them XXVI The Church of England hath therefore turn'd the Liturgy into her Mother tongue The Priests and the Congregation there present send the same Praiers to Heaven and to take away all marks of Enthusiasm or novelty she hath composed the admirable Book of common Praier It is nothing but a collection of the most pathetical and instructive places of Scripture That which she hath not from thence are the very words of the Fathers or antient collects which by tradition were receiv'd from the primitive Church All is sound all is holy we address our selves to God in God's own language and we speak to him as he hath spoke to us 'T is a happy obligation for a Christian to pray after such a manner wherein a vain imagination bears no part his mind is enlivened his heart softned by that he can preach to himself and