a Councell in determining of a case after that the Pope had delivered his sentence Card. Cusan Concord Cathol lib. 2. Cap. 17. pag. 737. If the Reader would see this Pillar of Popery That the Pope is not subject to a Nationall or Generall Councell razed and pulled down and that by their own side let him reade Bishop Mort appeale lib. 4. Cap. 2. § 8. p. 451. 452. Wee affirmed before in the conclusion of the fourth Generall Question that these verses speak of private and personall suits and quarrels between man and man Now how this is clearly confirmed and the contrary Objections made by the Separatists fully confuted If the Reader would know and see let him reaâ—e Mr. Bernard against the Separatists pag. 220. 221. § 2. Take with thee one or two Sect. 2 Why must witnesses here be called First Quest that they may convince the offender of his sin if so be he be either ignorant of it or Answ 1 deny it And Secondly that hee may be left without excuse if hee offend again And Answ 2 Thirdly that they may see and know that he which hath suffered the wrong hath done what Argum. 3 became him or belonged unto him to doe Carthus s § 3. Tell the Church Sect. 3 The Separatists object here against us and what wee have said That in these words Tell the Church the word Church cannot be taken for the Iewish Synedrion or the Assembly of Authoritie among the Iewes which was then as well civill as Ecclesiasticall First the word Church in holy Scripture is not alway so strictly taken as men do now use it but is used for the assembly of good or bad Christians or Infidels met together to consult and determine of causes whether civill or Ecclesiasticall Psalme 26.5 Where the Septuagint do translate the word Assembly by the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Church So Prov. 5.4 and Acts 19.32.39.40 in which three verses the word translated Assembly is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the same which is here translated Church Secondly Beza himselfe by the word Church understandeth it as spoken here of the Iews that is the Elders assembled who exercised juâ—gement in those dayes which assembly of Iudges as here they be called the Church so in the old Testament they were called the Congregation which is all one Num. 35.12 24 25. Iosh 20.6 9. And therefore our Exposition is warrantable by the word and this objection is also of no moment against it Sect. 4 § 4. If hee refuse to heare the Church Object 1 The Papists say that Generall Councels may absolutely determine without Scripture and bind all men necessarily to the obedience of their Canons because such a Councell is a representative Church and for the proof hereof they thus urge this place Our Saviour Christ saith If hee refuse to heare the Church let him be unto thee as an Heathen-man and Publican Therefore the Church is absolutely to be obeyed in all things Bell. lib. 1. de Concil cap. 18. Answ 1 First our Saviour in this place speaketh not of the Canons and Decrees of the Church concerning faith but only prescribeth the form of Church discipline for reformation of manners and correction of sin If thy brother trespasse against thee c. verse 15. where Christ saith no more then this That Christians ought to obey the sentence of the Church in censuring of sin and not that they ought to receive new Articles of faith if imposed by the Church though contrary to Scripture Answ 2 Secondly our Saviour speaketh not of every Church absolutely but of a Church guided and ruled by his word and assembled in his name verse 20. For otherwise by the Iesuits collection Christ and his Apostles should have been as Publicans because they obeyed not the Scribes and Pharisees amongst whom the Church was at that time Object 2 The Papists further produce this place to prove that the Church cannot erre but is infallible in her judgement Christ saith If hee will not heare the Church let him be unto thee as an Heathen man and Publican but unlesse her judgement were infallible it were hard yea unequall to hold them for heathen men and Publicans which would not obey her Decrees And therefore the Church that is the Pastors of the Church Bellarm. de verbo Dei lib. 3. Cap. 5. cannot erre but is to bee heard in all things Answ 1 First it followeth not that the Church cannot erre because we are bidden to heare it for so we are commanded to obey Magistrates Rom. 13.1 and yet they may command things unlawfull and in such a case they must not be obeyed Act. 4.19 It was a Law to the Jews that in matters of weight they should repair to the Priests and doe according to that which hee should judge without declining from it Deut. 17.8 and yet the Papists will not say that Vriah and Annas and Caiphas were of infallible judgement Secondly the meaning of this place is That Answ 2 wee must obediently hear the Church and yeeld unto it not simply in all things but conditionally as long as it speaketh things agreeable to the word of God Thirdly the things properly which Christ Answ 3 here mentioneth and wherein hee biddeth us hear the Church are not determinations of faith but Church censures and admonitions wherein it is clear the true Church of Christ may sometimes decline from the right and be admonished by her children notwithstanding this threatning of Christs Thus the Jewes excommunicated him that was borne blind Iohn 9.34 and the East and West Churches censured one another about the keeping of Easter Niceph. lib. 12. Cap 33. If the Reader would see this further cleared and fully proved from some of their own side let him reade Mr. White his way to the true Church pag. 78. Epise Daven de Judice p. 100. Fourthly if the Church may erre in her censures Answ 4 as is proved in the fore-cited Authors notwithstanding these words of Christ then we leave it to the Iesuit to yeeld some sound reason or other why not as well in points of faith Fifthly the judgement of the Church whether Answ 5 in inflicting of censures or defining of opinions concerning faith or determining of differences about Religion is so farre to be regarded as it is warranted by the word For the Scripture neither here nor no where else doth say That the Prelates of the Church can never erre in judging Sixthly this place speaks of a particular Answ 6 Church for not for every offence of one brother against another is a Generall Councell to be called And therefore if there be any weight or truth in the Objection at all it proves that every particular Church hath an infallibility of judgement and cannot erre But this is more then the Papâ—sts affirm But of this more in the next objection Tarmerus in colloquio Ratisbonensi sess 13. produced this Argument to prove That the deciding determining and judging of all controversies of
Iew do injurie against thee which art also a Jew go thou to him and tell him of it between your selvs alone and if hee acknowledge the wrong and doth give thee satisfaction thou art to cease further to call him into question as being reconciled and hee won unto thee by this thy loving carriage but if he doe despise thee as but one to one yet use not extremity but again go to him and take with thee one or two before whom thou maiest manifest the wrong received that they may bear witnesse of it as also of thy charitable proceeding and may be a mean to the same partie for thee to consider of his evils and to make thee recompence for the same but if hee regard not their counsell neither then complain to the authority of the Jewish Synedrion and let them perswade him to deale well with thee and to make satisfaction for the injury done But if hee become so gracelesse and so wickedly obstinate that hee despise it and so no such means as these will do him good then use if thou wilt the utmost remedy and deale with him as if he were no faithfull Iew Bishop Bilson of the perpetual government of Christs Church that is bring him before the Roman power and sue him at Caesars bar as if he were a Publican or Heathen So that this place is meant of private and personall suits and quarrels between man and man Jew and Jew as the state stood then of which our Saviour did speak § If thy brother sinne against thee Sect. 1 The Papists affirm that no Generall Councell is of sufficient authority without the allowance of the Pope and that hee is in such sort above all Councels that hee cannot though hee would submit himself to their sentence Bellarm. de Concil lib. 2. Cap. 11. 14. Now against this an Argument or two may be framed from this place The Scripture here saith Hee that refuseth to Argum. 1 heare the Church let him bee unto thee as an Heathen man and Publican Therefore if the Pope shall refuse the sentence of the Church assembled in generall Councels hee is no better by the voice of Christ then an Heathen Our Saviour saith here If thy brother offend or Argum. 2 sinne against thee c. Tell the Church But the Pope is our brother he being a Christian and one who prayeth or ought to pray Our Father c. And therefore the Pope may bee called to the judgement of the Church and consequently be judged censured and punished by the Church Now the Church doth nothing but by her Prelates and therefore the Pope may bee judged by a Councell consisting of Prelates This Argument was first framed by Gersâ—â— Doctor Parisiensis First hereunto Bellarmine answers Although Gerson said That the Pope ought to acknowledge himself to be subject unto the Church yet we answer that the Pope fulfilleth this Precept when hee reproveth a man in private next by witnesse and after shall himselfe proceed unto publike censure Bellarm. lib. 2. de Concil Cap. 19. § Sed iterum Replie Hereunto as credible a person as the Cardinal is answers Christ said not unto Peter Tell thy selfe but tell the Church which is a Congregation in a Councell Greg. Papa apud Aenaem Sylvium lib. 1. comment de gest Concil Basil Answ 2 Secondly Bellarmine answers again By this word Church is either understood a Bishop as Chrysostome would have it or a company of the faithfull with their head Wherefore in every Bishoprick all offenders are to bee carried unto the Church and Bishop of that place but if that Bishop sin then hee is to bee carried to a higher Church namely to the Arch Bishop or Patriarke under whom hee is if an Arch Bishop or Patriarke offend they are to be carried yet to a higher Church to wit to the Church of Rome or a Generall Councell over whom the Pope is but if the Pope offend he is to bee reserved to the judgement of God for there is no Church unto which he can be carried or before which accused seeing that without him no Church can be found which hath an head Reply 1 First this word Church signifieth either an universall Congregation and Assembly or a Councell consisting of that Assembly but it no where signifies only a Bishop neither doth Chrysostome say Dic Episcopo tell the Bishop but Dic Ecclesiae id est praesultibus ac praesidentibus tell the Church that is the Prelates and Presidents thereof and so also Theophylact 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 And therefore by the Church is alwayes meant some body of men and never a particular person Reply 2 Secondly Christ in these words remits or sends Peter himselfe to the Church as to a superiour Tribunall or judgement yea to a particular Church Now if every or any particular Church have greater authority in judgements then either Peter or any of the Apostles yea or any particular person then much more the Vniversall Church which is represented in a Generall Councell Reply 3 Thirdly the evasion of Bellarmine is idle viz. That when these things were spoken to Peter hee was but a private man and not as yet the Vniversall Bishop and head of the Church and therfore hee did justly then acknowledge himselfe to be inferiour unto the Church For Peter was now an Apostle but an Vniversall Bishop he was never And wee leave it unto them to prove Although I could say that these words were spoken after those Matth. 16.18 Thou art Peter c. when themselvs yea Bellarmine himselfe saith that hee was constituted Head and Vniversall Monarch of the whole Church and therefore it relisheth not well to say that now he is but a private man Reply 4 Fourthly Christ speaks generally If thy brother sin against thee whosoever he is except Bellarmine will say that the Pope is no Brother that is no member of the Church nor no child of God Fifthly the Pope may sin against another as Reply 5 well as another man and therefore Christ sends him to the Church yea many of the Popâ—s have beene Heretikes impure impious abusers of themselvs and of others And therefore by a Councell or Representative Church hee is to be judged and censured Sixthly in the Councell of Basil the case was Reply 6 thus collected out of Saint Hierome and Augustine and the two ancient Popes viz. that it is necessary that the Pope should be subject unto a Councell for if the Church be a Mother then must the Pope acknowledge himself to bee her sonne otherwise how shall he have God for his Father And this our Saviour shewed when hee said unto Peter Tell the Church which authority if the Pope shall contemne hee ought to bee accounted as an Ethnick and Publican Vide Aenaeam Sylvium de gest Concil Basil lib. 1. fol. 5. § Multis yea Cardinall Cusanus doth further prosecute this argument from another sentence of Saint Augustines wherein he requireth the judgement of
Herodians h Epiphan Danaeus The Scribes they were interpreters of the law and hence in this verse Herod called both the Governours of the Sanhedrin the Chiefe-Priests and also those that were skilfull in the law the Scribes that so it might bee a lawfull Councell and yet the end of this Convocation or convocated Councell was for the ruine and overthrowe of Christ teaching us that a true Councell may erre Observ that this was a true Councell appeares thus First it was lawfully called by Herod the King Secondly those that were gathered together in Councell were the lawfull Rectors and Doctors of the people of God the Iewes Thirdly the consultation was about a maine question of Religion the true Messias and yet notwithstanding all this was done for a wrong and a wicked end Hence it may be doubted If a lawfull Councell may erre concerning religion who then Quest 2 must interpret the Scriptures Answer there are three interpreters of the Scriptures First I and thou or every particular man now this is to bee exploded that is when one private mans opinion or exposition shall crosse all that hath beene before it is lightly to bee waved or not much to be weighed and yet there have beene such who have spoken truth as for example Saint Hierome expounding those words The God of this World hath blinded their eyes a 2 Cor. 4.4 by the God of this world he understands the devill which exposition was called inventum Hicronymi Hieronymies phansy or inventiō because they that were before him expounded it of God the Lord and yet we see that his interpretatiō is true and all the other mistooke the place by an unanimous consent of all our now Interpreters I might give instance likewise of Augustines invention as they called it concerning the creation of the Angels but I passe it by concluding that a private and particular mans exposition which thwarts all that hath gone before it as it is not rashly to be beleeved and admitted of so it is not to bee adjudged to the fire nor wholy rejected till it have beene examined by other Scriptures and the analogie of faith Secondly the second interpreter of the Scriptures are the Fathers and Councells of the Church these are venerable highly to bee prized and much esteemed but yet not wholy and absolutely to be adhered unto or admitted without examining of them by Scriptures Thirdly the last and best interpreter of Scriptures is the word of God it selfe and this interpretation is to be admitted accepted and received nil difficile quod non alibi planum b August In fundamentall points absolutely necessary unto salvation that which is obscure in one place is more plaine and easie unto the understanding in another And thus every exposition of holy writ is to be examined whether it doe crosse or contradict any other plaine place of Scripture or no for the whole Scripture is as one truth and therefore that cannot bee the true sense of one place that belies another § 3. Herod demanded of them where Christ Sect. 3 should be borne Quest 1 It may heere bee doubted whether Herod did well in asking counsell of the Chiefe Priests concerning Christ or no First I answer to take counsell of them and Answ 1 advise with them was both according to the custome of the Iewish Church and also was well done because to them were committed the Oracles of God and therefore the Gentiles in these cases were to repaire unto them and all the Proselites were instructed by them Answ 2 Secondly I answer that this was not well done of Herod to advise with them upon an hypocriticall pretexte Teaching us Observ that truth is to be sought in the word and of the Ministers of the word they being appointed by God for this service and worke c Malach. 2.7 that is First to teach men what things are to be beleeved and known Secondly to leade and draw men unto those things that are to bee obeyed and done the Scriptures being given for this end to make a man perfect in knowledge faith and obedience unto salvation d 2 Tim. 3.16 Thirdly to admonish advise perswade and exhort e 1 Tim. 4.13 2. Tim. 2.25 whence wee are called dispensers f Cor. 4.1 that give unto all that are hungry good and wholesome meate and that in due time and therefore although it be blame-worthy to doe as some doe to question with the Ministers of God and desire to bee resolved by them of some scruples for this end that they may entrappe them in their talke or ensnare them as the Iewes did with Christ yet it is according to the ordinance appointment of God that those that are in doubt should have recourse unto his messengers for comfort consolation directiō Hence it may be demāded quomodo quatenus Quest 2 how and how farre we must beleeve the Church and the Ministers thereof First if the holy Citie become an harlot and Answ 1 the watchmen of the citie seeke onely their owne pompe and glory and covetousnesse c. then they are not to be beleeved Answ 2 Secondly if the voyce of the Church and Church-men be not vox Dei the voyce of the Lord we must not then heare nor beleeve them Answ 3 Thirdly wee must heare the Church and chiefe Priests and Scribes as Herod in this verse but then examine by the Scriptures what they teach unto us for this Christ commands g Ioh. 5.39 Search the Scriptures and Paul commends in those noble Bereans h Act. 17.11 that searched the Scriptures daily whether those things were so that were preached unto them And this we see is the present practise of this present Councell holden at Jerusalem the Magi they repaire unto the Church at Jerusalem Herod he repaires to the Priests and they to the Scriptures Vers 11 VERS 5. And they sayd unto him in Bethlehem of Iudea for thus it is written by the Prophet Quest 1 Why doth the Lord suffer Herod to know where Christ was borne seeing he sought his life to prevent which Ioseph was constrained to flye Could not the Lord first have admonished the wisemen not to have come to Jerusalem at all or have blinded the understanding of the Pharisees that they should not know where Christ was born seeing Herod desired not the knowledge of it for good but formischiefe Answ 1 I answer First God would not take away such a cleare testimonie of Christ from Herod the Lord will have him know of the birth of Christ that by his owne experience he may perceive and acknowledge that there is no forcerie against Iacob nor inchantment against Israel yea that all his Fox-like craft and subtiltie cannot availe him but that maugre his malice God will preserve this infant the newes whereof doth so trouble him from his rage tyranny and crueltie Answ 2 Secondly God would not take from his children the participation of the crosse For
Peter or Paul themselves The Prince of Anhault tearmed the Scriptures the swathling bands wherein Christ was wrapped that is the containers and includers of truth it selfe Therefore we must never forsake them Fourthly there is nothing more profitable Answ 4 either for the unregenerate or for the regenerate and therefore to bee adhered unto by all because under those two all are included First it is profitable for those that are not regenerated and as yet borne anew unto God and that in these regards First the word of God breakes the hard heart Is not my word saith the Lord like a hammer that breaketh the Rocke in pieces i Ier. 23.29 Secondly the word of God gives sight to the blind eyes k Psa 19.8 Behold saith God unto Paul I have sent thee to open their eyes and to turne them from darknesse unto light l Acts 26.28 Thirdly it is profitable for such to bring them from the power of Satan unto God m Act. 26.18 Fourthly it is profitable unto them for the pardon of their sinnes and spiritual adoption into the fellowship of sonnes n Act. 26.18 Fiftly it is profitable to convince them of their sinnes o 1 Cor. 14.24 Secondly it is profitable for those that are regenerated in these respects First the Scriptures protect and defend them against the temptations of Satan they are a shield unto them that put their trust in God p Pro. 30.5 yea they are the spirituall sword which serves both for offence and defence q Ephes 6.17 Secondly by the Scripture the understanding of Gods children is more and more enlightned r Psal 19.8 9. Thirdly their affections are thereby more and more enflamed Did not our hearts burne within us said the two Disciples while he opened unto us the Scriptures ſ Luk. 24.52 Fourthly the word of God doth purge us from our guylt Now ye are cleane through the word that I have spoken unto you t Ioh. 15.3 Fiftly the Scriptures are profitable unto the righteous to arm them against afflictions to comfort them in sorrow u Rom. 15 4. Sixtly they strengthen them unto patience in all crosses whatsoever x Rom. 15 4. Answ 5 Fiftly the word of God is the guid convoy and directer of the soule and therefore cannot be forsaken without inevitable danger of erring the word of the Lod is right y Psa 19.8 that is regula recti the rule of truth and uprightnesse yea thereby the servants of God are forewarned that is advised preadmonished and forearmed against the assaults of Satan z Psal 19.11 The word of God is a light unto our feete and a lampe unto our pathes a Psa 119 105. And therefore we must not seeke unto them that have familiar spirits but seeke the Lord in the law and in his testimonies b Isa 8.19 20. And therefore seeing the word of God is the conducter of the soule wee must take heed that we never forsake or let goe out of our hands this weapon of the Scriptures Quest 5 It is here demanded what word of God it is that is the directer of the soule for it is controverted both by the Papists and Anabaptists who like Sampsons Foxes c Iudg. 15 4. meet in the tailes both of them opposing us and the truth but their heads are diametrally opposite one to the other as appeares by a double quaere Quest 6 First what word of God is the rule to walke by Answ 1 To this first they both answer not the Scripture alone Answ 2 Secondly the Papists say besides the Scriptures there are 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 traditions which are the rule of the life also Answ 3 Thirdly the Anabaptists cry downe their traditions and advance 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 their enthusiasmes and revelations which we are rather to be regulated by then by the written word of God Answ 4 Fourthly we say that it is the written word onely that is the rule of the life and directer of the soule and neither unwritten traditions nor unwarranted revelations If wee believe not Moses and the Prophets wee will believe nothing saith our Saviour d Luk. 16 29. because the Scriptures were written that we might believe and believing bee saved e 1 Ioh. 20.31 and therefore saving faith is built upon the Scriptures only and neither upon traditions nor enthusiames yea it is onely the Scriptures that are truely profitable for all sorts of men as was shewed in the former question answer 4. yea they are able to make us wise unto salvation and perfect men in Christ Jesus f 2 Tim. 3 15 and therefore are the onely loadstone of our Quest 7 life Secondly who shall expound the word of God which is the soules conduct First here they both answer that the Scriptures Answ 1 must not expound themselves they must not be both a Judge and a Partie Answ 2 Secondly the Papists say the Church must interpret the Scriptures that is that Church which is built in the Popes brest infallibility lying and residing onely in him Answ 3 Thirdly the Anabaptists say the Holy Spirit in them is the interpreter of the word that is their revelations are all divine truthes and to be obeyed and admitted as oracles from heaven Answ 4 Fourthly we say the holy Scriptures interpret themselves quod in uno difficile aliàs aptius that which is more difficult in one place is easier in another a Austen And therefore I conclude that the holy Scripture is that Lucifer or day starre that directs the soule unto Christ for the Father sends us unto the Sonne commanding us to heare him the Sonne sends us unto the word bidding us search that diligently b Ioh. 5.39 the scripture is able to make us perfect the Apostles taught the whole Counsell of God c Acts 20.20.27 and yet they teach nothing besides Moses and the Scriptures And therfore how injurious unto the soules of Men are Papists that robbe the people of this light and debarre them from the Scriptures These are builders 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of Babell indeede they speake a tongue which the people cannot understand for they must not enjoy it or bee suffered to reade it in the vulgar tongue These make the Scriptures like the Shew bread which none were to touch but the Priests alone These are like the spyes Obiect 2 sent to Canaan they bring evill reports of the word of God telling the people the beauty of it but withall the difficulty to bee such as they can never overcome and therefore it boots them not reade them To this I answer First Chrysostome opposes Answ 1 the Apostles to the Philosophers and Rhetoritians because these were very obscure and hard to be understood but the Scriptures are plaine and may be conceived at least the precepts and instructions thereof by the diligent reading of them Chrysost hom 3. de Lazaro Secondly if the divine
must needs bee visible Touching the visibilitie of the Church I lay downe this proposition There shall be alwayes a Church truly visible so long as this mortall world shall last Here that I may be the better understood let me adde these explanations to wit First the most visible Church shall not alwayes bee truest for the weeds of errour and chaffe of hypocrisie and superstition shall sometimes over-grow the come of true religion d Aug. brev coll col 3. as Arianisme did the truth in Hilary his dayes e Hyl. cont Auxen teste M. Cano Yea this is confessed Major pars vincit aliquando meliorem the greater part oftentimes overcomes the better Bellarm. de Concil 3.9 Secondly errours over-growing the truth peradventure the Church shall at some time bee visible onely ad intra not ad extra that is knowne among themselves though not observed of the world I say peradventure because many of our worthy Divines hold that it shall be visible alwayes not onely in some scattered persons but in an orderly Ministery and use of the Sacraments f D. Field de Eccles 1.10 Thirdly this Church shall not alwayes be resplendent and glorious in the worlds eye as the Papists sometime perswade the ignorant but after Saint Augustines comparison like the Moone ever being but sometimes in the wane scarce seene shining at all Obscurari potest multitudine scandalorum saith Bellarmine g Bell. de eccles milit 3.16 in answer to Hylary out of Saint Augustine epistol 48. Fourthly this visible Church hath no warrant of not erring in the usuall sense to wit in part this being the greatest imposture that the Papists gull the world withall as shall be shewed in another place Sect. 5 § 5. A City set upon a hill Here wee have two things to consider of first what this Citie is Secondly what this Mountaine is Quest 1 First what this City is which is set upon a Mountaine Answ 1 First some say the Apostles are this Citie but this cannot be except onely by a Metonymie as we take mundus pro mundanis the world for worldlings And therefore our Saviour doth not say Yee are the City set on an hill Secondly others say the Church is this City Answ 2 because it is as a City deare and consecrated unto God yea elsewhere called the City of God Psal 46.4 the joy of the whole earth the Citie of the great King Psal 48 2. and of righteousnesse Esa 1.26 yea it is termed Mount Sion the City of the living God the heavenly Ierusalem the Church of the first borne h Heb. 12.22 How deare and pretious this Citie is in Gods sight may appeare by these things observed by some in the metaphore I. The City is the Church thus David Glorious things are spoken of thee oh Citie of God i Psa 87.3 II. The Mountaine whereupon the City stands is Christ according to that of the Prophet David The stone became a great Mountaine and filled the whole earth k Da. 2.35 III. The Citizens of this Citie are the Saints thus saith Saint Paul Yee are fellow-citizens with the Saints and of the houshold of God l Eph. 2.19 IV. The Towers of this City were the Prophets who were most eminent in the Church V. The Gates of this Citie were the Apostles by whose Ministery men were brought into the Church VI. The Walls of this City are the Ministers of the Word and the Apostles successours who are as rampers to defend the Church against the assaults of sin superstition and errour m Chrys inperf op s Thirdly the true City is not in this life for Answ 3 here we have no continuing City but we seeke one to come Hebr. 13.14 to wit that new Jerusalem which is above Revel 21.2 10. Quest 2 If the City expected and longed for by the faithfull be not in this life then how is the Church called a City both in this verse and in other places as was shewed before Answ The Militant Church of Christ may be called a City partly Analogicè because it something resembles the heavenly Hierusalem and triumphant Church partly Synechdochicè because it is a part of that Citie which is above What is to be expected or may be looked for Quest. 3 in this Citie Foure things to wit first 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Order Answ God the King of this City not being the author of confusion but of peace 1 Cor. 14.33 and therefore all things are to be done decently and in order vers 40. avoiding contention because it becomes not the Church of Christ n 1 Cor. 11.16 And therefore those who will not be subject to the godly decent and lawfull injunctions and orders of the Church are no true members thereof or at least are to be esteemed as stubborne children whether they be 1. Fanatici the Anabaptists who understand all truths as they list themselves measuring all Doctrines by their owne revelations Or 2. Furiosi the Brownists who will tolerate no rites or customes at all although all who know any thing agree that in all Churches there have beene some Or 3. Pertinaces those that are headstrong perverse obstinate and rebellious whose will is a Law and will make any thing lawfull that they please not subjecting themselves to any government or command though never so lawfull Of all these we may say with the Apostle If any seeme to be thus contentious we have no such custome wee nor the Church of God o 1 Cor. 11.16 Secondly the second thing to be expected in this City is Unitie there is but one governement one King one head and one body and therefore we expect unitie in this City reade Ephes 4.5.16 and Rom. 12.5 and 1 Corinth 10.17 it being necessary that the Citizens should be of one minde and of one judgement having but one rule to walke by and one way which all must walke in who hope to be saved p Phil. 3.16 There is one light whereby we are enlightned one truth whereby we are directed one law of obedience unto all one faith in Christ unto salvation one profession of faith and obedience and whatsoever differs from this is an error We may differ in outward and adiaphorall things and yet be of the same religion and body of Christ as we may see Protestant Churches that although they vary in circumstances yet they hold one and the same substance and fundamentall truths entire Thirdly as we may expect in this City unitie betweene the subjects and Soveraigne the body and the head so wee may also betweene the fellow-members of this body because I. they are concives fellow-Citizens q Ephes 2.19 II. They are brethen Psal 133.1 III. because they are members of one mysticall body Romanes 12.5 and 1 Corinth 10.17 Ephes 4.16 and 5.27 Fourthly in this City there is splendour villages are more vile but Cities are more splendidious and sumptuous this splendour and glory which is in that
Teaching us that errours in religion often proceede from the Priests and Pastors of the Church Observ Hence the Lord complaines that the prophets Prophesie lies and the Priests take bribes Ierim 5.31 yea both Priest and Prophet have erred through wine Isay 28.7 and by coveteousnesse Ier. 6.13 and 8.10 Why are the shepheards so often the causes Quest 2 of the sheepes going astray First because they are enemies often unto reformation Answ 1 although the Church stand in neede thereof Here are two things to be distinguished or particularly observed namely First that the Church stands in neede of Reformation which appeares thus I. The whole truth is not revealed unto the Church at once but by little and little for there is nothing altogether perfect II. There daily arise new blemishes and staines in the Church by the corrupt lives of some therein III. Reformation is like Sysiphus stone alwaies relapsing and falling backe either unto the former errours or unto worse And therefore every particular nationall Church ever and anone stands in neede of Reformation Secondly the leaders and Rectors of the Church are often the greatest enemies unto this reformation hee that desires to see a true and cleare illustration of this let him reade the Historie of the Councell of Trent where hee shall see amply proved that the reformation which was so carefully instantly and necessarily desired by many and for a long time was still opposed withstood by the Court of Rome the Clergie Thus the Pharisees were enemies unto Justification by faith in Christ because it was contrary to their estimation and credit Answ 2 Secondly private spirits by some evill spirit have beene still conjured up in the Church amongst the Doctours Teachers who either by private jarres displeasures dissensions ambition coveteousnesse and pride have disturbed the peace of the Church We have many examples hereof in all ages I. Wee reade how the sonnes of Eli troubled vexed and disquieted the Church o 1 Sam. 2.12 II. How the Priests in Ieremias time seduced the people and opposed the Prophets p Ierem. 1. â—8 and 20.1 and 28.1 and 26.11 III. How the Pharisees opposed Christ Iohn 7.47 c. and withstood his Apostles Acts 4.1 and 5.17 and 7.51 IV. How great a combustion did Arrius kindle in the Church because he obtained not a Bishopricke such a fire as made the whole world weepe before it could be quenched V. What shall we say of the ringleaders of the Brownists and Separatists who have withdrawne many subjects from their true Christian obedience not suffering them to pray heare or communicate with us VI. God no sooner sowes Wheate but the devill sowes tares The Lord had no sooner raised up Luther and Zwinglius but the devill conjured up Zwenkfelduâ— Servetus Osiander David-Georgius and divers others VII If wee looke upon the Papists wee shall behold a Mappe of misery in this kinde For first their Priests seduce the people unto Idolatry making them say to a stocke thou art my father and to a stone thou hast brought me forth q Ier. 2.27 Secondly they will not bee reformed in what is amisse holding this opinion that nothing must be changed or altered in their Church or Religion lest they should seeme formerly to have erred grounding this their infallibilitie upon that of the Prophet The law shall not depart from the Priest Ier. 18.18 and that speech of our Saviour unto Peter The gates of hell shall never prevaile against my Church but how falsely they ground this opinion upon these places we shall see God willing in their proper places Thirdly such enemies are the Papists unto Reformation that they persecute those who are reformed In Jerusalem the blood of the just was shed by the Priests and Prophets r Lament 4.13 and so also in the Popes jurisdiction how great was their rage against Luther Zwinglius and all those who were by their Ministry reformed both in opinion and practise Fourthly their principall care is to seduce people and to leade them into errors As Christ said of the Pharisees so wee may say justly of the Popish Clergie They compasse heaven and earth to pervert and divert a soule from the waies of truth such zealots and zealous factors are they for the devill what nation is there where true religion is professed but some of their Jesuites and Sâ—minaries or Secular Priests are sent thither privately to seduce and corrupt simple soules bringing them from light unto darkenesse How our land hath long groaned under these soule-devouring locusts is well knowne who creepe into mens houses polluting and defiling both the bodies and soules of poore credulous and ignorant women The Prophet Hosea threatnes the Priests that God will power vengeance upon them Hose 5.1 Because they were a snare on Mizpah and a net spread upon Tabor And therefore let the seducing Priests of the Romish Church consider how by this their wickednesse they provoke God unto anger who will require the blood of all those whom they have corrupted at their hands If errours and heresies begin so often at the Quest 3 Priests and Pastors of the Church then how may or can the people be preserved from erring and being mis-lead They must not be tossed to and fro with every Answ 1 blast of doctrine Ephes 4.14 like the waves of the sea Iam. 1.6 but walke wisely and circumspectly according to these ensuing rules First labour for a sure foundation that is Rule 1 first hearken unto the pure unspotted and infallible word and truth of God that thereby yee may grow up 1 Pet. 2..2 in grace strength and knowledge that thereby you may be made perfect 2 Tim. 3.16 that being the true light by which we must walke 2 Pet. 1.20 Secondly adde nothing unto the word of God neither 1. the chaffe of superstition with the Papists Å¿ Ierem. 23.28 for what hath the chaffe to doe with the corne neither 2. new opinions as the Sectaries who daily beget and breed new Minervaes in their owne braine but remember God and Dagon will not dwell together and therefore adde nothing unto the true and pure word of God Secondly take heede of all seducings that is Rule 2 First love not to heare Invectives novelties and strange doctrines for although this be pleasing to our corrupt nature and delightfull to itching eares yet it is not profitable for the edifying of our soules wherefore Saint Paul exhorts holy Timothy to bee instant in Preaching the pure word of God for the time will come when men will not endure sound doctrine but having itching eares will turne away their eares from the truth unto fables Å¿ 2 Tim. 4.2.3 Secondly never embrace wrested constrained and forced interpretations of the word which will not agree with the proportion of faith or good manners or the scope of the place Thirdly let us love and labour for the peace Rule 3 of Syon that is first let us esteeme the Church to
the Law were condemned in this verse Therfore all unwritten Traditions must now be abolished To this Bellarmine answers two things namely Answ 1 First Christ condemneth not the ancient Traditions of Moses but those which were newly and lately invented Answ 2 Secondly Christ taxeth and findeth fault onely with wicked and impious Traditions To his first answer we answer two things viz. Replie 1 First the Scripture maketh no mention of any such Traditions of Moses Christ biddeth them search the Scriptures and not run unto Traditions Secondly these which our Saviour here speaks Replie 2 of seemed to be ancient Traditions bearing the name of Elders Traditions and they were in great authority among the Iewes most like because of some long continuance To his second Answer we answer likewise two things to wit First their Traditions were not openly and Replie 3 plainly evill and pernicious but had some shew of holinesse as the washing of pots and Tables and beds yea the Traditions of the Papists come nearer to open impietie and blasphemie then the Jewish Traditions did Secondly Christ in opposing the Scripture against Replie 4 Traditions therein condemneth all Traditions not written which were urged as necessary besides the Scripture What may wee safely hold concerning the Quest 1 Traditions of the Church First that besides the written word of God Answ 1 there are profitable and necessary constitutions and Eâ—clesiasticall Traditions to wit of those things which respect the outward decencie and comelinesse of the Church and service of God Secondly the efficient cause of all true Traditions Answ 2 is the Holy Spirit which directs the Bishops and Ministers assembled together in Councell or Convocation for the determining of such orders and Constitutions according to the word of God and doth also direct the Churches in the approving and receiving of such Traditions Thirdly no Tradition of the Church can constitute Answ 3 or ratifie a Doctrine contrary to the written word of God neither any rite or ceremony for both Constitutions and Doctrines ought to be agreeable at least not contrary to the written word And as all Civill Lawes ought to have their beginning from the Law of nature so all Ecclesiasticall Traditions from the word of God Rom. 14.23 and 1. Corinth 14.26 40. Fourthly although Ecclesiasticall Traditions Answ 4 may be derived from the word yet they are not of equall authority with the word How may the true Traditions of the Church Quest 2 be known or discerned from humane and superstitious Ordinances By these foure notes and marks to wit Answ First true Traditions are founded upon the word and consentaneous unto the word and deduced derived and taken from the word Secondly true Traditions are profitable for the conserving and promoting both of piety and externall and internall worship Thirdly true Traditions make for the order decorum and edification of the Church And Fourthly are not greevous and intollerable as the Traditions of the Pharisees were and the Papists are Matth. 23.4 VERS 4 5 6. For God commanded saying Honour thy Father and Mother Verse 4.5 6. and he that curseth Father or Mother let him die the death But ye say whosoever shall say to his Father or his Mother It is a gift by whatsoever thou mightest be profited by me And honour not his Father or his Mother he shall be free Thus have yee made the Commandement of God of none effect by your Tradition Sect. 1 § 1. Honour thy Father and thy Mother Quest 1 Whether is the Father or Mother more to be honoured and loved Answ 1 First Children can never honour and love parents that is either Father or Mother enough because we are imperfect in our Obedience to every precept Answ 2 Secondly I conceive that a vertous Father is more to be honoured and loved then a vitious Mother and contrarily a vertuous Mother more then a vitious Father because there is Tantundem aliquid amplius a naturall Relation to both but a spirituall Relation onely to the vertuous and godly We are commanded principally to love our heavenly Father best and caeteris paribus to love those best next him that are neerest unto him in love and most like unto him in purity Answ 3 Thirdly if we speake properly positively and without any Relation to any thing understanding the Question thus Whether the Father In quantum est pater as hee is the Father or the Mother as she is the Mother be more to be honoured and loved then with the Schoolemen I answer that the Father is more to be loved and honoured then the Mother And the reason hereof is this because when we love our Father and Mother Qua tales as they are our Father and Mother then wee love them as certaine principles of our naturall beginning and being Now the Father hath the more excellent cause of beginning then the Mother because the Father is Principium per medum Agentis Mater autem magis per modum Patientis materiae And thus if wee looke upon Father and Mother Secundum rationem generationis then we must confesse that the Father is the more Noble cause of the Child then the Mother is If the learned Reader would see this prosecuted let him read Thomas 2.2 q. 26. Art 10. And Arist etheâ— lib. 8. And Anton. part 4. tit 6. Cap. 4. § 8. And Aurtum opus pag. 60 b. Answ 4 Fourthly if we speake of that love and honour which is due unto parents according to their love towards Children then we answer that the Mother is more to be beloved then the Father and that for these reasons viz. I. The Philosopher saith because the Mother is more certaine that the Child is hers then the Father is that is his he beleeves it is his Child but she is sure that it is hers II. Because hence the Mother loves the Child better then the Father doth Arist lib 9. ethic III. Because the Mother hath the greater part in the body of the Child it having the body and matter from her and but only the quickning vertue from the Father h Arist de gen animal lib. 1. IV. Because the Mother is more afflicted for the death of the childe than the Father is and doth more lament the adversity thereof than his Father doth Solomon saith Prov. 10. A wise Son rejoyceth his Father but a foolish Son is a heavinesse to his Mother From whence some say that Fathers in regard of their naturall constitution of body which naturally is hot and dry do more rejoyce when their children are promoted unto honour than the Mothers do but Mothers in regard of their naturall constitution which naturally is cold and moist do more mourn and lament for the losses and crosses of their children than the Father doth But I will neither trouble my self to prove this nor perswade my Reader to beleeve it but leave it to the Philosophers and Schoolmen to be decided and discussed V. Because the mothers part is more laborious
Church and not the Scribes and Pharisees as Bellarmine himself confesseth Tom. 1. 1272. B. Quest 6 Can there be a Visible Church of Christ ad intra without a visible ad extra Answ The Visibility of the Church of Christ may be in two or three for although the whole Synagogue of the Jewes should have failed yet the Church should not have fallen because besides that people there were Melchisedech Iob Cornelius the Centurion and the Eunuch as is confessed by Bellarmine himself de Eccles milit li. 3. Cap. 16. Sect. Ad Tertium Yea at the time of Christs death when the Apostles failed and shrunk away for fear the profession of the faith and truth remained in the Blessed Virgin only August Epist 48. Quest 7 What is meant here by the Church of Christ or what doth our Saviour mean by this word Church Answ 1 First it signifies sometimes the place which is set apart and consecrated for the service of God and the celebration of Prayer Preaching and the Sacraments but not so here Answ 2 Secondly sometimes it is taken for some particular and nationall Church but neither so here Answ 3 Thirdly sometimes for that part of the Church which is Triumphant in Heaven Answ 4 Fourthly sometimes for all those who professe the name of Christ and who are called Christians But it is not taken in this sense here by our Saviour Answ 5 Fifthly sometimes for a particular assembly of Christians The Church which is in thy house salute Answ 6 Sixthly sometimes Church is taken for that part therof which is Militant or for all the faithfull flock of Christ And thus it is principally taken in this place By what markes or signes may this Church of Christ be knowne Quest 8 The markes of the true Church are these viz. First the word of God as it is revealed Answ and commended unto us by Christ and this is the chiefe and principall marke because it is given for the rule of the Church and is that whereby the Church is begotten and unto which she must cleave constantly and immovably Reade for the confirming of this note Matth. 7.24 and 10.7 and 13.23 and 17.5 and 28.20 Marke 13.10 and 16.15 Luke 24.47 Now by these and the likâ— places it is evident that the pure word of God not adulterated with the traditions and inventions of men is a notable marke of the Church of Christ Secondly a true and lawfull use of the Sacraments and Keyes according to the institution of Christ Matth. 28.19 Baptize them in the name of the Father Sonne and Holy Ghost Luke 22. Doe this in remembrance of me Iohn 20. Whose sinnes yee remit they are remitted c. Thirdly confession of the truth constancie and perseverance in the profession thereof and purity of life and conversation Matth. 5.16 10.32 So Peter in the â—ame of the other Apostles having confâ—ssed Christ to be the Son of the living God he in this verse presently addes Vpon this Rocke will I build my Church Fourthly obedience to the Ministerie in those things which Christ hath taught and ordained as Luke 10. Hee that heares not you heares not me c. Iohn 8. Hee that is of God heares Gods word And Matth. 10.14 15. § 6. And the gates of hell shall not prevaile against Sect. 6 it What is here meant by the gates of hell First for answer hereunto we must observe Quest that amongst the Jewes there was a greater Answ 1 Consistory and a lesser which differed in divers things and amongst the rest in place For I. The greater Consistory sate only at Ierusalem within the Court of the Temple in a certaine house called Lischath hagazith The paved Chamber because of the cuâ—ious cut stones wherwith it was paved by the Greekes it was called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The pavement as Iohn 19.13 Pilate sate downe in the judgement seat in a place called the pavement II. The lesser Consistory sate in the gates of the Cities Now because the gates of the Citie are the strength thereof and in their gates their Iudges sate therefore it is said here The gates of hell shall not prevaile against it that is neither the strength nor policie of Satan Iewish Antiq. Godwyn pag. 234. Secondly our Saviour saith That the gates of Answ 2 hell shall not prevaile against this faith this Rock and those who confesse Christ with as good a faith as Peter did and the Metaphor is taken from the gates wherein the Jewes and Gentiles exercised their judgements as appeareth by Moses Gen. 22.17 and Iob 32.21 And because wicked Judges did there give false sentences as absolving the offenders and condemning the innocents therefore false judgement and tyrannicall Iudges and injurious Magistrates are called hell gates that is the gates of death or the judgement seats of death Wherefore 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the gates of hell may be translated the gates of death or the gates of the grave The gates of Hades saith Christ shall not prevaile against or overcome the Church nor utterly destroy the faithfull neither at length have the victory for they may kill the bodies but they cannot hurt or touch the soules Now these gates are false Iudges malicious Magistrates and cruell Tyrants which sitting in judgement condemne the innocents and justifie the Malefactors and consequently may injure and wrong the bodies of the righteous but not their soules at all Peter not at Rome pag. 33. Answ 3 Thirdly by the gates of hell some understand vices sinnes and the corruptions of mans nature which shall neither raigne in their mortall bodies nor finally or totally prevaile against them Origen Ambros s It is questioned betweene us and Rome whether the Church of Rome may erre or not and wee affirme that it may that is any particular Church or visible Congregation and confirme it thus Argu ∣ ment 1 If any Christian Church hath this infallibility of judging so that it cannot erre then it must have it from some divine promise But there is no such thing promised to any Church Therefore no Church is exempt from errour If this place bee objected as it is by the Papists That Christ hath promised Object that the gates of hell shall not prevaile agaâ—nst his Church We answer First Christ speakes not here of any particular Answ or nationall Church and consequently not of the Church of Rome Sect. 7 § 7. And I will give to thee the keyes of the kingdome of heaven Mason de Min. Ang. l. â— cap 3. The Papists to prove the absolute and boundlesse power of the Pope alleage this place To thee will I give the keyes of heaven Marke say they Christ did not promise unto Saint Peter Clavem one key but Claves two keyes to wit First Scientiae the keyes of knowledge and with this key hee doth open the doore of the Scripture absolving all mysteries and resolving all controversies Secondly Potestatis the Key of power and with this Key he doth open the
Religion belongeth onely unto the Church that is to the chief Pastors and Bishops only of the Church He argues thus If all controversies be to be decided by the Church and referred unto the Church then it will follow that the Church is the Iudge of all controversies But the Antecedent is true that all controversies are to be decided by the Church and are referred unto the Church Therefore also the Consequent That the Church is the Iudge of all controversies Now he proves the Antecedent from these words Tell the Church and if hee will not hear the Church c. Therefore the Bishops and chief Pastors must expound the doubts in Scripture Bellarm. lib. 3. de Script Cap. 3 arguâ—s thus Our Saviour speaks here of private injuries but the place is to be understood also of publike injuries such as Schisme and Heresie are Now by this word Church is not meant the whole body of the faithfull but only the Pastors and Bishops and theâ—efore Heretikes and Schismaticks are not to be referred or turned over to the Congregation of the faithfull to judge and censure but to the Prelates of the Church because as a man hears and speaks by his head so the Church doth by her Prelates and consequently from the judgement of the Pastors there is no appeale their sentence and determination being the last and utmost judgement Answ 1 First Hunnius in eodem Colloquio Ratisbonensi did rightly distinguish this word Iudge for there is a double Iudge namely I. A Iudge who hath absolute authority of judging now if the Argument understand Iudge in this sense wee deny the Consequent for although it be certain that all controversies which arise amongst Christians may bee referred unto the Church that they may have her judgement yet it is most false that the Church is a Iudge which is absolute from all Law and may pronounce after her own will and so in effect be the chief and principall Iudge that is the very Rule of Religion and controversies II. There is a Iudge whose power is limited and restrained unto the Law and if the Argument speak of this Judge wee have nothing to say against it for wee deny not but that some yea all controversies may bee referred unto the Church to be examined and judged Answ 2 Secondly wee deny that the last and utmost judgement of controversies belong unto the Church her judgement being only Ministeriall Thirdly we must give care to the Church but Answ 3 with a double condition namely I. Wee must be sure that it be the Church of God as our Saviour himselfe expoundeth it ver 20. Where two or three are gathered together in my name c. So that every Congregation is not the Church but that which is assembled in the name and authority of Christ And therefore it is necessary that we know that Church which wee hear to be the Church of Christ and that by the Scriptures for otherwise wee cannot know the true Church but by the word except it be the true Church we ought not to hear it at all II. Wee must not hear the Church although it be a true Church contrary to the Scriptures but only so long as shee teacheth the doctrine of Christ for otherwise an Angel from heaven is not to be heard Gal. 1.8 If the Pastors Prelates and Presidents of the Church shal prescribe those things which are approved or prescribed by Christ wee must hear them otherwise not for there have been many Bishops and Councels which have refuted â—iver Heretiks and yet have erred themselvs in many other things Wherefore the Church is not simply to bee heard in whatsoever she saith or teacheth or to be beleeved and obeyed in all her decrees opinions tenents and commands but only then when shee speaketh and teacheth the truth of Christ For we are not to beleeve or credit the Church but for Christ and his words sake I find this answer given by Dr. Willet Synops 46. initio Whitak de sacra Script pag 31.7 Fourthly if the judgement of the Pastors and Answ 4 Bishops in a Councell bee the last and utmost judgement then not the Popes judgement only which the most of the Iesuits labour for Fifthly our Saviour speaks not here of the Answ 5 chief Iudge of all controversies or of the chiefe Interpreter of Scripture but only of brotherly correction and admonition which wâ—o contemnes are referred to the Church and if they will not heare the Church thâ—y are to be excommunicated For the interpretation of Sâ—ripture dependeth not upon the will and fantasie of the Pope Cardinals or Popish Councâ—ls but must be tried by the Scripturâ—s themselvs Now the reason why wee deny that the Evangelist speaks here of the supream Iudge or Rule of controversiâ—s is because that which is meant and understood in this place to bee told to the Church doth belong unto all Churches viz. of Constantinople Ierusalem Smyrna Rome and the rest not unto all together but every one severally Now the Papists themselvs do not contend that every particular Church is the rule of all controversies Now that the place is to be understood of brotherly admonition and reproof appears thus namely I. Because the speech is of private offences between brethren as is plain from verse 15. If thy brother shall sinne against thee But private offences injuries and jars are not to be referred either to a Nationall or Generall Councell but unto the Ecclesiasticall society or jurisdiction of every place by whom the reasons on both sides may be weighed and known and judgement accordingly pronounced II. Because this is the first degree of publike or Ecclesiasticall judgment for the former degrees here named by our Saviour verse 15 16. are private to wit when the wronged Brother doth privatly alone admonish him that did the wrong or before some few Witnesses But it was scarsly ever heard of or at least done that either private offences or even publike and those which belong unto the Church should presently at the very first be referred unto the Church universall scattered through the whole world III. Because our Saviour speaks here of Excommunication as some are of opinion let him be as a Heathen c. But Excommunication and every kinde of Ecclesiasticall censure doth belong also to every particular Church Concil Nicen can 5. And therefore in this place by Church are to be undeâ—stood the Jurisdictions of particular Churches and not such a Judge as is absolute free and exâ—mpt from all Law having his own will onely for a rule I conclude this Objection with a double Argument If every Church which who so hears not be Argu. 2 to be accounted for a Heathen man or publican be the absolute Judge of all Controversies then it will follow that every particular Church is the absolute Judge of all Controversies but the consequent is absurâ—ly false therefore also the antecedent Cham. t. 1. p. 26. Argu. 3 An obstinate sinner must be referred to
limited the words As I. Stella in hunc locum saith They sit in Moses Chaire Cum bona docebant c. when they taught good things such as Moses prescribed II. Iansenius Concord in Matth. 23.2 Cap. 120. saith Non est illis obediendum c. They must not be obeyed when they teach any thing contrary to that Chaire III. Emanuel Sa in hunc locum saith Non tenemur hoc loco c. This place bindeth us not to obey them if they teach that which is evill for that is to teach against the Chaire IV. Maldonate in locum saith de doctrina legis et Mosis loquitur He speaketh onely of the Doctrine of the Law and of Moses V. Carthusian in hunc locum saith Hoc non est absolutè et universalitèr intelligendum c. When our Saviour saith Doe whatsoever they bid you we must not understand it universally and absolutely but of their lessons and doctrines which are not contrary to the Law of Moses VI. Erasmus s Matth. 23.3 saith Cathedrâ Mosis c. Christ did not understand by Moses chaire the doctrine of the Priests but the Law of Moses neither were they to be obeyed further then they taught according to that Law VII Ferus Lib. 3. in Matth. 23. saith Praeceptum Christi quaecunque dixerius vobis servate et facite ctc. That CHRISTS Commandement Observe and doe whatsoever they bid you bound them not to observe all the Decrees of the Pharisees but so farre forth as they agreed with the Law c. VIII Let the Reader if he desires more Expositors read Gloss in Matth. 23.2 and Nicol. Gorr ibid. and Ariat Montan. elucid ibid. Aquinas 2. 2. qu. 104. Artic. 5. et August Tract 46. in Iohan. Where he shall heare them with one mouth and mind say Sedere super cathedram Mosis c. To sit in Moses chaire is to teach according to the Doctrine and rule of Moses Law and to command things agreeable thereunto that is to say true doctrine and the same that Moses taught wherein onely they might be followed and no further Secondly because if the Pharisees be not to be heard beleeved and obeyed in all things but in some onely then of necessity we must have another rule whereby we may be directed in our hearing for else how can we tell wherein we must follow our teachers and wherein we must not And therefore there must be a Judge in Religion and the matters of faith above the interpretation of the Prelates of the Church Thirdly the Pharisees taught many errors and blasphemies and that I. Both against the Law of Moses Matth. 5.20 and 15.3 and 25.13 And also II. Against the divinity of Christ Marke 14.64 Iohn 7.48 and 8.13 and 9.22 24. and 19.7 15. And in this regard our Saviour bad his Disciples Matth. 16.6 12. to beware of the leaven of the Pharisees which was their Doctrine Wherein he had gaine-said himselfe if by Moses chaire he had meant any thing but the prescript of the Law or by those words had commanded us in all points to doe according to the Prelates doctrine for then the Jewes must not have honoured Parents nor loved their Enemies nor beleeved in Christ because the Pharisees taught against these things I enlarge not this here because both in the fore-going question something hath beene said and in the following answer of this objection something shall be said of the errours of the Pharisees Fourthly Moses himselfe did preadmonish us not alwayes to heare all who sate in his chaire Deuter. 18 19 30 21. And therefore the Prelates are not to be obeyed in all things which they teach Answ 4 Fourthly we answer to Latomus his Argument CHRIST saith Whatsoever they bid you doe that observe and doe therefore the authority of Ministers is necessarily to be obeyed in all that they teach We deny the consequent and that for these reasons viz. I. Because when the authority of the Ministers is named in the conclusion either it is to be understood First of all Ministers together in generall now if he thus understand it he declines wholly from the true sense of the place for when CHRIST named the Scribes and Pharisees he understood not every one as appeares by that which followes They love the uppermost roomes at Feasts verse 6. And they say and doe not verse 3. And doe not after their workes verse 3. All which cannot be understood but of particular persons and almost all the Fathers have applied this Doe not after their workes unto particular Pastors as if our Savior would say according to the Aphorisme Vivimus legibus non exemplis People must frame and direct their lives according to the Pastors Doctrine out of the word and not according to their lives and conversations Or Secondly by the authority of Ministers is to be understood every particular Minister whatsoever now if he thus understand it then I. He doth not touch the question which is concerning the authority of the Church in judging of matters of Faith for the Church is not in every particular Minister And II. The Papists themselves will not say That every one that sits in Cathedra or to whom is given Ecclesiasticall authority is an absolute Judge of all controversies II. Because if the authority of the Ministers of the Church be absolute and that it is necessary to obey them in all they teach then it is necessary that such authority should have beene given unto the Scribes and Pharisees and such an infallibility in them For if the Papists will goe about from hence to prove the absolute authority of the Church in judging of all matters of faith and doctrine then they must needs grant such a power and authority to have beene in the Scribes and Pharisees and therefore seeing theirs was not absolute and supreme no more is the Ministers now That the authority of the Scribes and Pharisees was not absolute appeares both by the severall expositions of the Interpreters of this text mentioned in the former answer and also by this Medium If their authority had beene absolute and that it was necessary to have obeyed them in all things then we should never have departed from them but this is false for Matth. 16.6 CHRIST saith Take heed of the leaven of the Pharisees which the Evangelist expounds to be meant of their Doctrine Whence we see plainly that somethings were to be avoided which they maintained and taught therefore these words of CHRISTS The Chaire of Moses doe not signifie absolute authority III. Because if the authority of the Scribes and Pharisees had beene such as that it was necessary to obey them in all things then they should have beene the rule of truth but this is false for the rule is alwayes like it selfe and never declines a Rectitudine from truth and rectitude but the Pharisees were not alwayes like themselves that is as those that sit in Moses Chaire and very often did depart from the
fol. 19 a. 20 a. 120 b. 101 b. 113 b c. 187 b and pt 1. folio 488 b. pt 2. fol. 32 b. 104 b c. 106. 122 b c. 154 a. 263 b c. 277. 373 a. Divers questions concerning Christs Miracles miraculous cures and workes and vertue and power pt 1. fol. 128 b. 129 130 b. 131 a. 132 a. and pt 1. folio 466 b. and 489 a. 499 b c. 507 a. pt 2. folio 63 64. 81. 119 a. 132 a. 386. and pt 1. fol. 513 b. 516 a. 518 a. 523 b. 524 a. Questions concerning the manifestation of Christ pt 1. fol. 23 a. 54 a. 78 b. Questions directing us how to come unto Christ pt 1. fol. 24 b. 25 a. 49 a. 55. 63 b. 78 b. 85. 135. 443 a. 468 a. 473 b. 488 b. 497 b. and pt 2. f. 119 b. 194 a. Divers necessary questions concerning the arraignment examination accusations opposition persecution passion and death of Christ Pt. 1. folio 49 b. 84 a. 88 b. and pt 2. f. 131 a. 132. 261 b. 298. 337 a. 358 b. 361 362. 370 b. 372. 374. 376. 377. 379. b. 380 b. Questions concerning Christs love unto us pt 1. folio 51. 495 b. and pt 2. folio 78 a. 244 b. 308 b. Questions concerning the joy felicity benefits and comfort we have by Christ pt 1. folio 116 b. 117. and pt 2. fol. 32 b. 55 b. 56 a. 97 b. 100 b c. 102. Why Christ fasted pt 1. folio 89. What gesture he used in prayer pt 2. folio 154 a. Questions concerning the speeches of Christ pt 2. folio 277. 306 a. and pt 1. folio 492 a. Questions concerning the preaching of Christ Pt. 1. folio 118. 124 125 126 341. 346. Christ was neither temporall King nor Beggar pt 1. folio 25 b. 139 b. 468 b. Questions concerning Christs comming pt 2. folio 3â—2 314 a. 319 b. 321 322 c. 325. 327 b. 331 b. and pt 1. folio 500 b. Questions concerning Christs subjection unto the Law pt 1. folio 180 184. 193 194. The Geanealogie of Christ See Genealogie Whether Adoration were rightly given to the Humane body of Christ pt 2. folio 385 a. How many wayes the name Christ is taken in Scripture part 2. folio 309 a. He is the Head Husband and Foundation of the Church See Church Divers apparitions of Christ after his Resurrection pt 2. folio 384 a. 385. Christ was no seducer pt 2. fol. 381. Christ seeth the secrets of the inward man pt 1. folio 467 a. How Christ is our Father and Brother pt 1. folio 487 a. Christians They must be Nazarites and wherein and lights and a holy City unto God and why pt 1. fol. 53. 171 b. 242 a. The difference betweene Christ and all Christians pt 1. fol. 132 a. The sinnes of Christians are worse then the sinnes of Heathens and why pt 2. folio 83 b. 84 a. The happinesse of Christians both here and hereafter pt 1. folio 456 457. Church Questions concerning the authority of the Church and how farre she is to be beleeved part 1. folio 30 b. and pt 2. folio 218 219 220. 292 293. Questions coÌ„cerning the nature notes universality infallibility continuance purity visibility excellency members afflictions portion Foundation and Head of the Church pt 1. fol. 35 b. 76 a. 77 a. 78 a. 102. 172 b. 173. 175. b. 276 a. â—05 b. 422 a. 440. 459 a. and Pt. 2. folio 8 a. 142 c. 145 a. 181 b. 182 183 184. 186 b. 187. 188 a. 218. 222. 256. 260 a. 296 b. 325 a. 388 a. 394. The Church of Christ is like unto a Field a City a House a Ship and the Kingdome of Heaven and wherein Pt. 1. fol. 77 c. 173 a. 174 b c. and folio 458 b. and pt 2. folio 73. 154. 169 b. 170 a. Questions concerning disobedient Churches and the enemies of the true Church pt 1. folio 297 298. and Pt. 2. f. 6 a b. 7 a. 277 a. 291. Questions concerning separation from the Church pt 2. folio 8. 143 a. Objections for Church-treasure answered pt 1. fol. 188 a. and pt 2. folio 326 a. That Church which is lead by blind or blemished Teachers is miserable pt 2. fol. 167 a. At whom the Church began Pt. 2. folio 306 b c. The happinesse of those within the Church and their duty in regard of those who are without Part 1. folio 30 b. a. and pt 2. fol. 198 b. 199. 394. Circumspection Warinesse Watches Watchfulnesse The night was anciently divided into foure Watches and the life of man into three Pt. 2. fol. 155 a. 305 b. We must beware of others and why pt 1. fol. 421 b. Circumstances See Adiaphorall things City We should be a holy City unto God pt 1. fol. 242 a. Cleansing Purging Washing Divers questions concerning spiritual Washing purging and cleansing pt 1. fol. 77 78 a. 129 b. 326 b. and pt 2. fol 67 b c. 301 302 303. c. There were amongst the Iewes divers sorts of washings pt 2. folio 373 b. Collections Conclusions false Collections and Conclusions often drawne from true propositions pt 1. fol. 97 b. 103. Collegies Schooles There were Collegies and Schooles of learning under the Law pt 2. fol. 78 b. Comfort Consolation Divers comfortable questions concerning the sweet comforts consolations which are given to the godly pt 1. f. 143 144 145 pt 2. f. 98. 100. b. 101 a. 102. Commandements Law Questions coÌ„cerning the differences between the Law and Gospell pt 1. fol. 55 a. 183. and Pt. 2. fol. 241 a. Profitable questioÌ„s concerning the impossibility obedience excellency coÌ„tents abrogation destruction division consummation exposition scope end and use of the Law pt 1. fol. 80. b. 181 182 183 184 b. 185 a. 192. 215. 301. 404 405 406. 500 b. and pt 2. f. 75. 179. b. 241 b. 242 a. 287 a. 299. b. Humane Lawes are often opposite to divine Pt. 1. fol. 248 b. and pt 2. fol. 27 a. Christ was no enemy unto the Law pt 1. fol. 180. 193 194. 404 b. Divers errors concerning the Law pt 1. folio 181 182. The Preaching of the Law is never acceptable to sinners although it be necessary Pt. 2. fol. 76 b. 77 a. 78. a b. Commet Starre Divers questions concerning the Starre or Commet which was seene by the Wise-men part 1. folio 24 b. 26 b. 27. 34 b. There are divers sorts of Starres and commets part 2. folio 24 b. 25. a. 27. a. Common wealth The meanes whereby a Common wealth may flourish Pt. 2. fol. 87. a. Company Companions Society There are divers sorts of societies and associates Pt. 1. fol. 51 b. and Pt. 2. fol. 18. Questions coÌ„cerning society with wicked men pt 2. fol. 17 18 19. and Pt. 1. f. 481 a. 49â— b. 496 a. What is required of those who keepe company and converse with Saints pt 2. folio 329 b. Compunction Contrition Humiliation Godly Sorrow Contrition is a part of repentance and belongs unto
Rules concerning going to Law pt 1. folio 45 b. 246 247. Swearing See Forswearing Sword What is meant by Sword Matthew 10.34 I came to send a Sword pt 2. folio 50 a. Synagogues What the Iewish Synagogues were and why Christ preached in them Part 1. folio 124 b. 125 126. 522 b. 523 a. Synode See Councell Syria Divers questions concerning Syria pt 1. folio 130 b. T. TAbernacles What the Tabernacles were made of wherein the people remained in the Feast of Tabernacles pt 2. folio 270 a. Taxes See Subsidies Teaching See Preaching Temple Concerning the excessive cost of beautifying Churches pt 2. folio 160 a. Temporall things See Covetousnesse Temptation To Tempt Questions concerning Christs being tempted pt 1. folio 35 b. 86 87. 95 b. Questions concerning the significations of this word Temptation and which temptations are the strongest Pt. 1. folio 86 b. 96 a. 102 b. 108 a. 315 b. When we are most sharply tempted and how we may be â—est supported under temptation pt 1. folio 84 b. 85 a. 86 a. Questions concerning those who are tempted of Sathan and those who are not tempted and the author and sorts of temptation and remedies against it pt 1. folio 86 a. 88 89 a. 110 b. 112 b. 113 b. 315 316 b. 317. Questions concerning Gods tempting of Man and mans tempting of God and mans tempting of man pt 1. folio 88 b. 108 109 110 111 112. 315 b. 316. and pt 2. folio 329 a. Questions whether temptation may be without sinne and how Christs temptations and ours differ pt 1. folio 86 87. Testament Why the second Volume of holy writ is called a Testament and why the New Testament pt 1. folio 5 b. Thankesgiving Why we give thankes before and after meat pt 1. folio 307 a. Theeves Questions concerning theevs in generall and the good Thiefe in particular pt 1. folio 328 b. and pt 2. folio 375. Theology Humane learning necessary unto Theology pt 1. fol. 48. b. Things All things depend upon God pt 1. folio 101 b. Things are called three manner of wayes pt 1. folio 168 a. Thirst See Hunger Thoughts How many sorts of thoughts there are pt 2. folio 168. And the evill of evill thoughts pt 1. folio 490 b. 491 a. Threatnings Why and how all the threatnings of God shall be accomplished pt 1. folio 46. b c. Tongue See Mouth Touching Touching was alwayes of great esteeme pt 1. folio 516 b. Traditions Divers questions concerning humane Traditions pt 1. folio 11 a. 42 a. 103 a. and pt 2. f. 1. â—7 Translation The word may lawfully â— translated into the vulgar 〈◊〉 mother tongue pt 2. folio 34. b. The Vulgar Translation is not the truest pt 1. folio 483 b. Transmigration Questions concerning the Transmigration of the soule and the absurdity of that tenet pt 2. folio 151. 179 b c. Transubstantiation Controverted questions concerning Transubstantiation pt 2. folio 155 a. 195 245 b c. 338 a. 342 c. 357 b. 383 a. Trees Divers sort of Trees in generall and of evill Trees in particular pt 1. folio 428. Tribute See Subsidies Trinity The Trinity may not be painted pt 1. folio 81. The Trinity in Vnity proved pt 2. folio 391 a. Trouble See Danger Truth We must enquire after Truth at the Ministers hands pt 1. folio 30 b. The whole Truth must be taught and why pt 1. folio 234 235 a. The Truth must be maintained even unto death Pt. 2. folio 297. How manifold Truth is pt 2. folio 282. Tyre Who the Tyrians were pt 2. folio 83 a. V. VEngeance See Revenge Viper The nature of the Viper pt 1. folio 70 b. and pt 2. folio 128 b. Virgina See Maides Vision of God Or beatificall Vision Divers questions concerning this beautificall Vision pt 1. folio 164 165. Visitation Why the sicke are to be visited pt 2. folio 333. Ulcers Three sorts of Ulcers pt 1. folio 505 b. Unbeleevers See Gentiles Uncleannesse See Adultery Unity See Agreement Unworty Worthy Unworthinesse Worthinesse How many sorts of Unworthy persons there are and why we must not converse with such pt 2. folio 17. Divers questions concerning Worthinesse viz. How manifold it is what is meant by this word worthy and who are worthy and why we must live worthily and wherein true worthinesse consists pt 1. folio 72 b. and Pt. 2 folio 16. 20. Vocation See Calling Vowes Questions concerning Vowes viz. How many sorts of Vowes there are and what a Vow is and whether single life be to be vowed See Monkes and pt 1. folio 234. 399 a. and pt 2. folio 234 236. Usury Divers questions concerning Usury pt 1. folio 21â— 249. 250. and pt 2. folio 331 a. W. VVArinesse See Circumspection Warre Warfare See Souldiers Washing See Cleansing Watches Watchfulnesse See Circumspection Water See Raine Wayes See Paths Weapons See Armour Wickednesse See Prophanenesse Will. Divers necessary questions concerning the will of God and the will of man pt 1. f. 301 302. 303 519 a b. and pt 2. folio 359 360. Wildernesse Why John preached in the Wildernesse pt 1. folio 55 b. Wine The nature kinds and use of Wine and wherein it is like unto Grace pt 1. fol. 503 b. 504 505. Wisedome See Prudence Wisemen See Magi. Word See Scripture Workes See Actions World See Covetousnesse Worship Images are not to be worshipped pt 1. folio 114 b. God onely is to be worshipped pt 1. folio 114 b. Why the publike worship of God is not to be neglected pt 1. folio 125 a. All Religions in the world enjoine some worship and have some publike places for worship pt 1. folio 125 a. Religious worship is not to be left for some circumstances which are amisse pt 1. folio 126 b. Religious worship is not pleasing unto God except it be accompanied with faith and love pt 2. folio 114 b. 115 a. Worrhinesse See Vnworthy Wounds Three sorts of wounds pt 1. folio 505 b. Wrongs See Injuries Y. YOke Divers necessary and profitable questions concerning the sorts and kinds of Yokes in generall and of Christs Yoke in particular pt 2. f. 104. 107 108 c. to f. 13. Youth We must serve God in our youth pt 2. folio 305 b c. Z. ZEale Divers questions concerning good Zeale both in regard of God and our brethren and our selves pt 1. f. 149 a. and pt 2 fol. 74. 301 b. The end of the Table CHRISTIAN READER although I hope thou shalt meet with no willing Errors yet thou 〈◊〉 J am sure 〈◊〉 with soâ—e unwilling Errataes especially in the Nine first 〈◊〉 of the second Part. Now the faults which J first light upon and met withall both in those sheetes and the 〈◊〉 of the Booke and which were committed by the oversight of the Printers J intreat thee thus to amend In the first Part or Time thou readest thus FOl. 7 b. Second Fol. 14. a. For the avoyding of Fornication which are c. Fol. 14 b. § 2. Place Fol. 15 b. Either by