THE Breach Repaired in God's Worship OR Singing of PSALMS HYMNS and Spiritual Songs proved to be an Holy Ordinance of JESUS CHRIST With an Answer to all Objections AS ALSO An Examination of Mr. ISAAC MARLOW'S two Papers one called A Discourse against Singing c. the other An Appendix Wherein his Arguments and Cavils are detected and refuted BY BENJAMIN KEACH Preacher of God's Word and Pastor of the Church of Christ meeting on Horselydown Southwark Job 6. 25. How forcible are right words but what doth your arguing reprove Isa 52. 8. Thy Watchmen shall lift up the Voice with the Voice together shall they sing London Printed for the Author and sold by John Hancock in Castle-Alley on the West side of the Royal-Exchange and by the Author at his House near Horselydown in Southwark 16â—â— THE EPISTLE DEDICATORY TO ALL THE Baptized Congregations In England and Wales Who are in God the Father and in our Lord Jesus Christ Grace Mercy and Peace be multiplied Particularly to the Church of Christ meeting on Horslydown Holy and Beloved IT cannot but rejoice my Soul when I consider of the exceeding Grace and abounding Goodness of the Holy God towards you his poor and despised Churcâ— and People in respect of that clear Discovery he hath given you of most of the glorious Truths of the Gospel and of the true Apostolical Faith and Practice thereof You have not made Men General Councils nor Synods your Rule but God's Holy Wâ—â—d your Constitution Faith and Discipline is directly according to the Primitive Pattern God hath made you in a most eminent manner to be the Builders of the old Wastes and Raisers up of the former Desolations and Repairers of the waste Cities the Desolations of many Generations Isa 61. 4. You have laboured to sever the Gold from the Dross and to build with proper and fit Gospel-Meterials viz. Spiritual and Lâ—â—â—ing Stones well hewed and squared by the Hammer of God's Word and Spirit and will not take one Stone of Babylon for a Corner you will go forth as far as you have received Light by the Footsteps of the Flock and feed your Kids beside the Shepherds Tents Cant. 1. 8. And God of a small People hath graciously made you a Multitude you have been helped and so born up by everlasting Arms that you have held fast your Holy Profession in the Day of Trial and exposed all that you have had in the World to spoil and loss for the sake of Jesus Christ when many turned their Backs and exposed the Holy Name of God to Reproach and to our further Joy many of you have of late more especially in your General Assemblies shewed your great Zeal for the Name of God and Care of his Church in a more than usual manner and particularly you have endeavoured to revive our hopes for the continuation of a faithful and laborious Ministry for the time to come by striving to promote such Learning and Studies as God's Word directs to and not require like Israel's Task-Masters poor Ministers as I may so say to make Brick and allow them no Straw but you do now more fully see that Gospel-Ministers ought to have a Gospel-Maintenance even such as God hath ordained that so they might not be intangled with the Affairs of thâ—â— Life but wholly give themselves up to that great Work they are called to Go on and prosper Holy and Beloved Let not your Hands be weak nor Satan obstruct or hinder so hopeful a Beginning let it appear you do love Jesus Christ more than Father or Mother more than Son or Daughter and labour to reform what is amiss as to those great Evils that abound too much in the Churches of the Saints tho I hope not so much amongst you as among some others particularly in respect of Pride and Covetousness or that base Worldly and Earthly Spirit that is the Bane of Religion and makes the Lor'd People of so ill a savour in the World let your Lives declare whose you are and to what Countrey you belong and as you have a good Doctrine so labour for a suitable Conversation and then Brethren what can or will be wanting to make you compleat in the whole Will of 〈◊〉 Truly according to my small Light I know not unless it be a restoration of this lost and neglected Ordinance of Singing Psalms Hymns and Spiritual Songs which I fear and partly understand some of you want light in I have therefore made bold to dedicate this small Treatise to you all hoping you will take it from me in good part and well weigh what is here said before you judg and condemn it for an Errour I am afraid of some old Prejudice some of you have taken against this Sacred Truth of the Gospel for so I must call it you can't think you have as yet come to a full attainment or are already perfect in Knowledg Besides I hear you generally own Singing of Psalms c. an Ordinance of God and indeed I cannot see how any who own the Bible and New Tastament of Christ to be their Rule can deny it Why then consider whether you have this Ordinance at all or can be said to sing in any proper Sense Certainly many of you are wholly without it as will I hope appear fully if you read this Treatise quite through impartially Can â—t be thought the Churches should be enjoined by the Holy Ghost to sing Psalms and Hymns and yet there 's no coming at the practise of itâ— without an extraordinary Spirit or miraculous Gifts I have been provoked by our Brother who wrote against Singing to set Pen to Paper and not only by him and his Book but I have been induced by Multitudes for several Months to give him an Answer so that I hope you will not be offended with me in what I have done I have much Peace in the doing of it and truly Brethren the loss of this Ordinance doth I am afraid more obstruct the increase of our Churches than many are aware of What a Multitude are convinced of Christ's true Baptism and yet refuse to have Communion with our Churches when baptized because they say if they â—hould they must lose this Ordinance of â—inging which they have an equal Esteem â—or And how doth it open the Mouths of â—ur Godly Brethren of other Perswasions â—o speak against us for being so zealous for â—ne Gospel-Ordinance and so careless about â—nother that very few Christians who have â—ad the greatest Light Zeal and Piety in â—ny Age of the Church ever doubted of 〈◊〉 grieves me to think there should be a â—reach made in God's Worship among you â—o whom God hath given so much Light in other Cases And O that what is here said might through the Blessing of God prove a Means to repair it In a Word Singing is injoyned Some â—hing it is If we have it not but 't is with â—ou we would willingly know what your Singing is or what you call Singing
For we do say and testify we believe you are wholly without Singing in any proper Sense at all The Lord give us Moderation don't let us be bitter one against another I shall beg a part in your Prayers and intreat you to look over what Weakness you may see in this small Tract for I am you know but a Babe in Christ's School and know but in part And now to you my Beloved Brethren and Sisters who meet on Horselydown whom I hope I may say are my Joy and my Crown whose Souls are most dear to me and whom I can say I truly love and long after it rejoices my Spirit to see how generally you are inlightned into this Gospel-Duty but 't is no small grief to me to see since the Church in such a solemn manner agreed to sing the Praises of God on the Lord's Day to find some of you so much offended I am perswaded 't is for want of Consideration for you have no new thing brought in among you Hath not the Church sung at breaking of Bread always for 16 or 18 Years last past and could not nor would omit it in the time of the late Persecution And have not many of the honest Hearers who have stayed to see that Holy Administration sung with you at that time and yet none of you ever signified the least trouble And have we not for this 12 or 14 Years sung in mixt Assemblies on Days of Thanksgiving and never any offended at it as ever I heard What is done more now 't is only practised oftner and sure if it be God's Ordinance the often practising of it by such who find their Hearts draw out so to do cannot be sinful And on that Solemn Day when the Church would have it put up to see 〈◊〉 the Members stood affected about Singing almost every ones Hand was up for it or to give Liberty to the Church at such times to sing And when put up in the Negative but about 5 or 6 at most as I remember were against it Did any one of you at that time say if we did proceed to sing at such times you could not have Communion with us which if you had I perceive the Church nay every one of us who had born our Burden for many Years would have born it a little longer Besides did not the Church agree to sing only after Sermon and when Prayer was ended And if those few Brethren and Sisters who were not satisfied could not stay whilst we sung they might freely go forth and we would not be offended with them so far was the Church or my self from imposing on the Consciences of any But is it not hard that some of us should so long be laid under a Burden when the Church generally was against Singing at that time and you cannot bear it now it is come to be your Lot I am afraid the noise of these things are misrepresented abroad and therefore I thought it might not be amiss to rectify Mistakes in you or any other Brethren The matter of Difference that is at present between the Church and some few of our dear and beloved Brethren and Sisters is not about Singing it self nor singing with others for that has been all along the practise of the Church for many Years as before I hinted but only about singing on the Lords Day unless it be one Member except the Judgments of any other are lately changed But my Brethren will I hope seriously consider of the Matter and labour after that Christian Love Tenderness and Forbearance the Gospel calls for We are exhorted to bear one anothers Burdens and so to fulfil the Law of Christ For the Lord's sake let us not fall out by the way and lay things grievous on one anothers Spirits for we are not Lords over one anothers Faith but Helpers of each others Joy O my Brethren pray let us all watch against Satan and strive to keep the Vnity of the Spirit in the Bond of Peace I must confess divers of you did much desire me to answer Mr. Marlow's Book before this time but I hope you will excuse my neglect for some of you know the occasion of it â—tis done now and in the fear of God recommended to your perusal And O that the Lord would be pleased to bless it to your Satisfaction then shall I have cause to praise the Lord that I undertook the Work I can â—â—y you lie near my Heart and I would do any thing I am capable of to promote Truth and Peace amongst our selves and in all the Churches of Christ If any of you should say How can we be satisfied to have Communion with the Church when we believe 't is an Innovation that 's a hard word Arâ— you Infallible Is there not ground for you to fear you are mistaken or to think in the least 't is a doubtful case since so much is to be said for it and has been so generally received from the beginning by most enlightned Saints and you your selves with the Church for so long a time been in the Practice of â—t at other times Besides can you find any ground from God's Word that will warrant you to separate your selves from the Church upon this account and also may not the same or like Scruple rise in our Spirits against having Communion with you who we beâ—ieve lie short of a plain Gospel-Ordinance â—nd so through want of light diminish from God's Word as you say we add thereto by doing of it But far be it from us to have a thought to act that way towards any of you Moreover will not such a practice of a Separation from the Church upon this account justify other Godly Christians who are Members of such Churches who do not sing that are convinced as well as we it is their Duty to separate from those Congregations to joyn with such Churches as are in this practice Doubtless that Door that will let you out of this Church will let others out of those Churches I mentioned before and there are not a few such in this City There is one thing I think good to note here to prevent any mistake that tho I call Preaching a moral Duty yet to preach the Gospel only appertains to such whom God particularly hath gifted for that Work and who have a lawful call to it I shall conclude with the words of the Holy Apostle Finally Brethren farewel be Perfect be of good Comfort be of one Mind live in Love and Peace and the God of Love and Peace shall be with you 2 Cor. 13. 11. Which is the Prayer of him Who is Your unworthy Brother fellow Servant and poor Labourer in God's Harvest B. Keach From my House near Horselydown Southwark April 3d 1691. The Contents of the chief Things contained in the insuing Treatise WHat it is to sing Page 5. That there can be no proper Singing without the Voice pag. 6. 'T is not simple Heart-joy or inward rejoicing without
can or ought to Preach Pray Interpret c. or dispense any one Ordinance of the Gospel c. Nay and 't is not unknown to many there are some have lately made use of this Argument against all Ordinances And this I will say and by the help of God stand by it too That if Singing must be rejected or thrown away by virtue of this Argument viz. Because none have an extraordinary Gift to bring 〈◊〉 forth all Ordinances are gone or must be cast off God deliver poor Christians from the pernicious Arguings of such weak Opposers of Singing of Psalms Hymns and Spiritual Songs Besides 't is evident none of those Duties and Gospel-Administrations were tied up to such who 〈◊〉 those extraordinary Gifts but that others who had but the ordinary Gifts might and ought to attend upon the Administration of the same Duties and Ordinances as well as those so miraculously endowed for the main Business the Apostle strives to do there was not to order the Matter of the Worship of the Gospel but to regulate the Manner how those extraordinary Gifts in the Church should be used to prevent Confusion and that all might be done to edification of the People whilst God saw good to continue them in his Church Doubtless there cannot be a stronger Argument brought to prove and confirm this Ordinance The Holy Ghost inspired the Saints with Miracles Gifts of the Spirit to bring forth a Psalm as well as to bring forth a Doctrine and so witnessed to it and established it as a standing Ordinance in the Church as being of the same Nature and Authority with Prayer and Preaching or any other Gospel-Institution I will close this with one Argument Arg. That Duty or Ordinance which was owned and witnessed to by the Lord in the New Testament with Miracles and the extraordinary Gifts of the Spirit is to abide in the Church as a standing Ordinance But Singing of Psalms c. was thus confirmed owned and witnessed unto Ergo Singing of Psalms c. remains in the Church as a standing Ordinance CHAP. VIII Proving Singing of Psalms Hymns and Spiritual Songs a Gospel-Ordinance to continue in the Church from the practice of the Churches in the succeeding Ages next the Apostles Times particularly in the second and third Centuries with the practice of all the Godly generally in all Ages nay the most strict in Grace and Godliness till this present Age. AS Singing of Psalms Hymns and Spiritual Songs was instituted and given forth by the Holy Ghost in the Gospel and practised by Christ and his Saints in the Primitive Times so we shall shew you from the best and most approved Ecclesiastical Histories it was practised in the Ages next unto the Apostles Days Here I shall give you what Mr. Roberts in his Key to the Holy Bible hath said upon this account pag. 173. And as Singing of Psalms c. saith he was used in the purest Primitive Apostolical Times in the Church-Assemblies so it was continued all along in the successive Churches hitherto though it is too evident that some Corruptions and Vanities by little and little crept into this as into other parts of God's Worship Singing of Psalms c. was used in the second Century to celebrate Christ and his Deity against the Calumny of Theodosiâ—â— Euseb Eccl. Hist Lib. 5. cap. 28. Eusebius tell us that Pliny the Second aboâ—â— Anno 98 wrote an Epistle to Trajan the Emperor that the Christians being gathered together before day were wont to sing Hymns together and praise Christ as God And the same Eusebius affirmeth that Philo-Judaeus did testify the same of this Christian Practice and also assures us that the said Pliny and Traja lived in the Time of the Apostle John who did not die till about 100 Years after Christ This very Passage out of Eusebius I find cited by Mr. â—â—berts Mr. Wells Mr. Cottâ—â— and also by Mr. Sidenham 〈◊〉 others But having the History I need not mention them yet for one Reason I shall add the same over again out of Mr. Sydenham's Treat of Singing p. 209. Eusebius saith he in his Eccles Hist lib. 3. cap. 35. quotes two Epistles of Plinius Secundus to Trajan the Emperor testifying that the Christians were wont to assemble themselves before day to sing Psalms and Hymns together The same doth Philo-Judaeus testify who lived in the Apostles Time as the same Esebius saith Lib. 2. cap. 22. Now in the Time of Plinius and Trajan did the beloved Disciple live saith Zanch on Ephes 5. 18 19. Tertullian who flourished near the Apostles Time about 194 saith the Christians were wont to sing out of the Holy Scripture Apol. cap. 1. 9. as their usual custom Athanasius maintains it was practised in his Days Episcop eo locis Cyprian pressed this Duty in his Epistle to Donatus Chrysostom in his Commentary on Psal 41. admonishes all Persons Countrymen Mariners Weavers c. to sing Psalms and Spiritual Songs Estius cries out saith Mr. Wells to take notice of the Custom of the Primitive Christians who did not only sing Psalms and Hymns in their publick Assemblies but in their private Families I might quote Ambrose who zealously pressed this Duty on the Western Churches of singing Psalms and Hymns Lib. 9. Confessionum Mr. Cotton saith that one Samosatenâ—â— the Heretick who denied the Deity of the Lord Jesus was one of the first that within these first 300 Years opposed the Singing he speaks of No marvel if the Saints sung to Christ as unto God that such a Man opposed the practice of Singing such Hymns Basil the Great a most Famous Pious and Learned Man mightily commends the Singing of Psalms as I find him quoted by several worthy Writers I need not go lower Obj. But they Sung with Orrgans or musical Instruments the Ordinance was corrupted and we cannot come at it now c. Answ 1. We find no mention in the least of any other Singing but that of united Voices in Eusebius nor Tertullian c. 2. But pray what Ordinance hath not been corrupted and the purity of it as practised in the Primitive Time lost Now by the same Argument viz. because adulterated and intermixt with foolish Ceremonies we must not Sing So we must not practise Baptism nor the Lord's Supper nor any other â—â—stitution of the Gospel for none have been more abused and corrupted than they have and indeed it is rather an Argument for Singing than against it for here in Satan shewed his Malice and Hatred of it by seeking thus 〈◊〉 add Poison to it But ought not we to labour to restore it 〈◊〉 its primitive Practice as in other Ordinances through Grace we have been helped to do Shall we not have the pure Food of Godâ— Word because Antichrist hath put Poison 〈◊〉 theirs There is one thing I omitted which is worthy to be noted in Eusebius It seems the Christians would not part with this sweet Ordinance of the Gospel though it cost them
Time this Prophecy did refer to which you may soon see if you read the Context How beautiful upon the Mountains are the feet of them that bring good Tydings c. Which the Apostle absolutely applies to the Time of the Gospel and to Gospel-Ministers Rom. 10. 15. And the Prophet doth not only say The Watchmen shall lift up their Voice and with the Voice together sing but also calls upon the desolate and waste places to sing together which can refer to none but the Lord's People who in Gospel-Days shall be made a Praise to him who had been as a poor barren and waste Wilderness For saith the Prophet in the next words The Lord hath made his Arm bare in the Eyes of all Nations and the ends of the Earth shall see the Salvation of God Vers 10. Now this place directly declares the manner how we ought to Sing that is with Voices together And thus I find a most Reverend and Learned Man speak upon the place David's Psalms saith he were Sung together in Heart and Voice by the twenty four Orders of the Musicians who typed out the twenty four Elders which our Annotators and others say signify the Church and Ministers of Christ and so saith this Author viz. All the Members of Christian Churches Rev. 5. 8. who are made Kings and Priests to God to praise him as they did for if there had been any other Order of Singing besides the Body of the People to succeed those formerly used the Lord would doubtless have given directions how or what it was Not Moses only but all Israel sang and the Women as well as the Men also intimateth that that Song John speaks of Rev. 15. 3. which saith he the Protestant Churches getting Victory over the Beast with Harps in their hands and Singing the Song of Moses refers to that Song and manner of Singing Exod. 15. 1 2. And there is no doubt of it but it doth Moreover saith he Isaiah foretells in the days of the New Testament that God's Watchmen and dissolates lost Souls signified by desolate and waste places should with their Voice Sing together Isa 52. 8 9. The Song of the Lamb saith he was with many together Rev. 7. 9 10. And the Apostles expresly command the Singing of Psalms Hymns and spiritual Songs not to any select Christians but to the whole Church Ephes 5. 19. Col. 3. 16. Paul and Silas sang together in Prison Act. 16. 25. and must the Publick hear only one Man Sang I must say it would be a strange sight to see and hear and without any Warrant from God's Word or Practice of any Church of Christ To all these saith he we may add the Practice of the Primitive Churches the testimony of the ancient and holy Basil is instead of many Epist 63. When one of us saith he hath begun a Psalm the rest of us set in to sing with him all of us with one Heart and with one Voice and this saith he is the common practice speaking of Basil of the Churches of Egypt Lybia Thebes Palestina Syria To the same purpose Eusebius gives witness Eccles Hist lib. 2. cap. 17. The Objections saith he made against this do most of them plead against joying to Sing in Heart as well as in Voice as that by this means others out of the Church will sing as also that we are not always in a suitable Estate to the matter Sung and likewise that all cannot Sing with understanding and are not all therefore who have understanding to join in Heart and Voice together Are not all the Creatures in Heaven Earth Seas Men Beasts Fishes Fowles c. commanded to praise the Lord and yet none of these but Men and Godly ly Men too can do it spiritually and with understanding The third Scripture Prophecy is Hos 2. 15. which clearly alludes to the Gospel-days 〈◊〉 Expositors shew viz. when God should make a New Covenant with his People and betrâ—â—â— them to himself for ever vers 19. I will allâ—â—â— her and bring her into the Wilderness and speak comfortably unto ber Vers 14. And 〈◊〉 give her Vineyards from thence and the Valey of Achor for a Door of Hope and she shalâ— sing as in the days of her Youth and as in the day when she came up out of the Land of Egypt which is clear has respect to that of Exod. 15. see our Annotators on this Text for it fully confirms Singing under the Gospel and such a Singing as was of Old I shall close this with what Dr. Roberts saith in his Key to the Holy Bible pag. 175. Finally that passage in the Prophet Thy Watchmen shall lift up the Voice with the Voice together shall they Sing is saith he prophetically spoken of the Times when the Feet of the Messengers of glad-tidings shall be beautiful who shall say unto Sion Thy God reigneth This is interpreted by the Apostle Paul of the Gospel-times under the New Testament I rather chuse to give my Understanding of this glorious Truth in the words of other Men such worthy and renouned Men as these than in my own thinking some may more readily incline to receive the Truth from them than from such a poor Nothing-creature as I am yet did not I verily believe as they did in this matter I should not have cited a word from their Pens Besides some of their Works â—ie in great Folio's that very few may meet â—ith and what they say which they prove from God's Word we ought carefully to receive though in some things they differ from us Therefore if any Answer me they must also answer them in what I have cited out of their Writings or I shall conclude I have no Answer at all CHAP. XII Proving 'tis our Duty to sing the Praises of God with united Voices from the great Noise such are said to make when they sing THis appears by that in Exod. 32. 17 18. And when Joshua heard the noise of the People as they shouted he said to Moses There is War in the Camp vers 17. And he said It is not the Voice of them that shout for mastery neither is it the Voice of them that cry for being overcome but the noise of them that sing do I hear vers 18. Certainly one Man's Voice could not have made such a Noise nothing can be more clear but that they sung with united Voices together Obj. But here it is objected This was in praise of the Golden Calf and so no rule Answ 'T is no matter to whom they sung it was their Sin and horrid Wickedness to give that Divine Worship and Praise to a moltenâ—mage that belonged to God only but there is no question but they sung now to this false God as they had done cap. 15. to the true God of Heaven and Earth and therein lay part of their wicked and horrid Deed. The second Scripture is Psal 81. 1 2. Sing aloud unto God make a joyful Noise which cannot be apply'd to
should and ought to sing And as we are not tied up by the Lord in Preaching to do no more than barely read the Scripture or quote one Scripture after another which would be rather Reading than Preaching but may use other Words to edify the Church provided they agree with or are congruous to the Word of Christ or the Sacred Scripture and yet we call that the Word of God which is preached and so indeed it is so when that which we sing is taken out of God's Word or is Scripture absolutely congruous truly and exactly agreeing thereunto it may as truly be called the Word of Christ as our Sermons are and may be so called Obj. But you add words to your Hymns that are not in the Text you refer to So we do in Preaching but if those words agree with the Text 't is still the same Word and may be opened thereby the better to the understandings of the People Besides let it be considered that we have not the Holy Scriptures in those words in which they were written by the Pen-Men of the Scripture for they wrote the Old Testament in Hebrew words and the New-Testament in Greek words Also the Translators differ much in words in giving the true sense of the Original so that this Objection is a mere contentious Cavâ—â— Moreover there are in our Bibles all Learned Men know a multitude of Suppliments or words added to make good the sense the Originals being too short to express it in our Language Now you may as well nay if not with more colour of reason say part of the Scripture is Human and not Divine as to call our Sacred Hymns so And so you may by the same Argument call our Sermons likewise 'T is evident as Mr. Barton observes in his Epistle to his Book of Hymns That Justin Martyr Tertullian and many others have signified the Primitive Church used not only David's Psalms but other Portions of Scripture to put in Songs for edification Hymns may as he saith be plainer than Psalms and more suitable to Gospel-occasions such in which Christians may truly say they do teach and admonish one another in such saith he as inculcate our Duties and reprove our Vices out of most piercing Passages of Holy-Scripture and such as may answer or suit with all Sermons and accommodate all Occurrences and are no Innovations but reduction to primitive Use and Order Remarkable is that passage in Eusebius concerning the Christians practice in singing of Hymns to Christ as to God Plinius Secundus to clear the Christians to Trajan adds this viz. Only that they held early Assemblies in Singing of Hymns to Christ as unto God Euseb lib. 3. cap. 33. Doubtless they were compiled by some among them out of the New-Testament as the Spirit of God might enable them in the same manner as they did and we do compile our Sermons and I see no other objection lies here against our Hymns than lies or may be made against our Doctrine Thus as to the general Direction the Holy Ghost has given about what we should sing viz. the Word of Christ But then Secondly we have particular Directions as to the Matter we ought to sing expressed in the Texts viz. Psalms and Hymns and Spiritual Songs I know some do conclude that all these three allude to the Book of Psalms because these three are the Titles they say of Davids Psalms Though that were granted that some of David's Psalms are called Hymns and Songs yet I see no reason that all other spiritual Hymns and Songs should be excluded 1. Because we often find in the New-Testament the Psalms of David or Book of Psalms mentioned as comprehending all those Hymns and Songs contained therein without calling them the Psalms Hymns and Spiritual Songs of David see Luk. 20. 42. 24. 44. Act. 1. 20. Moreover this seems to exclude other Scripture-Songs that they themselves own may be sung as Moses's Deborah's Isaiah's Habakkâ—k's Simeon's Zachariah's Mary's c. However by Psalms we are assured is intended the Book of Psalms or those called the Psalmes of David because we read not in all the Scripture of any called Psalms but them only so that the Form of these are contained in God's Word I hope these will not be called Humanâ— The Holy Ghost hath enjoined the Singing of Psalms particularly and many of the Psalms of David are 't is evident pure Gospel i. e. Prophecies and Promises that relate or refer wholly unto Gospel-times and divers excellent Psalms there are that be filled full of the High Praises of God for Christ and the Blessings and Priviledges Christians receive by him tho I do not judg all the Psalms of David are so sutable to our days nor can be so properly sung as some others to the Edification of the Church But I do not find any Man giving any convincing Argument that no Hymns that are made out of God's Word or putting other Scripture-Songs as the Canticles c. into Verse or proper Measure to be sung are excluded in those words Psalms and Hymns and Spiritual Songs I am of the same Mind with those Learned Men that Mr. Wilson in his Dictionary and others speak of that Psalms Hymns and Spiritual Songs comprehend all kinds of Spiritual Songs whereby the Faithful sing to the Glory of God and the Edification of the Church provided they are taken out of the Word of Christ Moreover I have met with a Piece written by a very Learned Man who after he hath given the Sense of some Men about the Titles of the Psalms and various Acceptation of the words Psalms Hymns and spiritual Songs speaks thus Yet I must tell you by the way that these words in the Hebrew do not make such a precise difference For Tehillim is the general Title of all the Psalms Mismor the particular Title of most Psalms as well as of the Psalms of Degrees Nor do the Greek Words make such a distinguishing difference for a Psalm is of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to sing and a Hymn of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to sing Praise And 〈◊〉 Odo called a spiritual Ode or Song by 〈◊〉 Translators is of the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 so that it seems to me saith he that the Apostle useth many words to signify that all 〈◊〉 Singing should be of Divine Things and not vain things to glorify God and not to please our foolish Fancies But whether we distinguish the one way or the other 〈◊〉 see saith he the Apostles press the Duty of spiritual Singing whether of this kind or that viz. whether Psalms of David 〈◊〉 other spiritual Hymns whether called of Men of this Name or that Name in which Injunctions the Apostles are so clear that very few since the coming of Christ that I know of have made scruple of the thing and if any have of late they never mention these places as if either they did not remember them or could not answer them And to close this
because we have not those Gifts must we not be found in this Ordinance viz. to sing which is required in the New Testament we by the same Argument must lay all others aside likewise as the None-Churches have done from such a way of arguing as you use here the Lord deliver us But what you speak on this occasion doth not concern them that sing David's Psalms therefore if composed Hymns were not justified by God's Word as comprehended in Hymns and spiritual Songs Col. â— 16. then the Book of Psalms as our Brethren say are wholly intended and then they must be sung and them only but we see no reason so to believe Eusebiw speaks of the Christians singing of Hymns to Christ as to God in the first Century which shews it was the Practice of the Church in the Primitive Times to sing other Hymns besides those in the Book of Psalms As to Forms of Prayer the Lord hath left us a Form by which we are directed how to pray and so he has left us his Word and the Psalms of David that we may know how to compile our Hymns as well as our Sermons by the help and assistance of his Spirit there is no more a Form of Preaching left than there is a Form of Hymns and what tho Christians differ in their singing they also differ in their method or form of Preaching as much and your Argument say you what you will 〈◊〉 alike against the one as against the other But is it unlawful to premeditate what we design to ask of God in Prayer Have not some in Prayer and Fasting-days in Churches drawn 〈◊〉 several things as a Form of those Cases 〈◊〉 they agreed together to spread before the Lord and is this Form sinful think you But 〈◊〉 of this hereafter IV. Of Womens Singing Object You say Women ought not to sing in the Church because not suffered to speak in the Church and also because singing is teaching By the way then it appears the bare Melody in the Heart where you say is the Essence of Singing that is not Singing by your own Assertion Thus you destroy what you would build Answ But if Women may not speak nor â—â—ach in no sense in the Church they must not be admitted to give an account of their Conversion in the Church or how God was pleased to work upon their Souls for that Practice is full of Teaching and Instruction and has been blessed to the Conversion of some other Persons that have been by But I will be at the pains to transcribe what worthy Mr. Cotton hath said to this Objection it appears others have brought it before you The second scruple about Singers is saith he whether Women may sing as well as Men for in this Point there be some deal with us as Pharaoh dealt with the Isrâ—â—litesâ— who tho he was at first utterly unwilling that any of them should go to sacrifice 〈◊〉 the Lord in the Wilderness yet being 〈◊〉 length convinced that they must go then 〈◊〉 was content the Men should go but not 〈◊〉 Women Exod. 10. 11. So here some that were altogether against singing of Psalmâ—â— at all with lively Voices yet being convinced that it is a Moral Worship of God warranted in Scripture then if there must be a singing one alone must sing not all 〈◊〉 if all the Men only and not the Women He then mentions your Objection to which he replies 1. One Answer saith he may at once remove both Scruples and withal clear the Truth it is apparent by the Scope and Context of both these Scriptures that a Woman is not permitted to speak in the Church 1. By way of teaching whether in expounding or applying Scripture for this the Apostle accounteth an Act of Authority which is unlawful for a Woman to usurp over the Man 1 Tim. 2. 13. And besides the Woman is more subject to Error than the Man ver 14. and therefore might sooner prove a Seducer if she became a Teacher 2. Yet nevertheless in two cases it is clear a Woman may speak in the Church â— In way of Subjection when she is to give account of her Offence thus Peter questioned Sapphira before the Church touching the price of Land sold by her and her Husband c. and she accordingly spake in the Church to give her Answer to the Question Acts 5. 8. 2. In way of singing forth the Praises of God together with the rest of the Congregation for 't is evident the Apostle layeth no greater restraint upon Women for silence in the Church than the Law put upon them before for so himself speaketh in the place alledged 1 Cor. 14. 34. it is not permited to a Woman to speak but to be under Subjection 〈◊〉 also saith the Law 2. The Apostle then requireth the same Subjection in the Woman which the Law put upon them Now it is certain the Law yea the Law-giver Moses did permit Miriam and the Women in the Song of Thansgiving to sing the Praises of God Sing ye to the Lord for he hath triumphed gloriously the Horse and his Rider hath he thrown into the Sea which may be a ground sufficient to justify the lawfulness of Womens singing together with the Men the Praises of the Lord and accordingly in the Primitive Churches it was the ancient Practice of Women to sing the publick Praises of the Lord we read recorded in the Ecclesiastical History Socrates Chap. 18 Greek Copy and Chap. 16. of the Latin Theodoret's third Book Chap. 17. Obj. But say you there is no Institution for Womens Singing Answ No need 't is a Moral Duty You may ask whether they are to praise God as well and demand a word of Institution for their Breaking of Bread with the Church for you know some demand a Proof for that V. Of the Order of Singing What need you talk of Order about Singing or of Womens Singing when the Essence of it being in the Heart is sufficient though the Act or Thing it self be never done But to proceed This you say we have plainly and clearly delivered to us 1 Cor. 14. 20 to 34. How is it then Brethren when ye come together every one of you hath a Psalm hath a Doctrine hath a Tongue hath an Interpretation let all things be done to edifying That which you infer from hence is that this is the Rule for our Practice viz. one by one or one after another must speak and exercise their Gifts and not all together and so he that has the Gift of a Psalm he is singly or alone by himself to sing as in Prayer and Preaching Answ The Apostle directs that Church in the exercise of extraordinary Gifts There was 't is clear confusion about the exercises of those Gifts in the Church of Corinth it seems this was their practice some times viz. Every one of them who had a Doctrine and that had a Psalm and so of the rest would come forth with them together May be many
speak 〈◊〉 other times which they are allowed to do In Sect. 6. You speak of those prophetical places of the Psalms c. urged by us for Singing under the Gospel-days where all the Earth is exhorted to sing unto the Lord Psal 96. 1. Psal 95. 1 2. Psal 100. 1 c. 1. This you would have refer to the preaching of the Gospel i. e. as the Apostles sound went â—orth into all the Earth Rom. 10. 18. confounding Preaching and Singing together one time and Prayer and Singing at another 2. You would have it chiefly to refer to the seventh thousand Years of the World or Reigâ— of Christ hinting in your first Part as if then there shall be a Singing besides the Essence of it in their Spirits but if that thousand Years you speak of shall be before the end of the World or Gospel-Dispensation pray where lie those Precepts that will authorize them in those days to sing and yet do not authorize or warrant us to sing now Shall they have a new Bible for those Times But if the Precepts for Singing then are contained in our holy Scripture and yet do not belong to us 't is good for us to consider whether other Precepts written therein do not wholly refer to those Times too nay all Ordinances till the Spirit comes down in an extraordinary manner and so now we must throw off all Gospel-Administrations and turn Seekers I am sorry to see such Stuff as this published to the World But what I have said or cited from the Writings of other Godly Men in respect of those Prophetical Psalms and other places of Scripture that enjoin the Gentile-Churches to sing the Praises of the Lord I would have you and others consider well of before you write again In Sect. 7. you heap up a company of confused words to no purpose about premeditated Matter for Prayer to oppose premeditated Hymns c. Append. pag. 38 39 40 41 42 43 c. Answ 1. The Form of Prayer Christ hath left us is a Rule for us in Prayer and we may premeditate what we intend to lay before the Lord it appears from thence and so is the Word of Christ our general Rule by which we must premeditate and precompose our Spiritual Hymns and Songs 2. But Prayer and Singing differ the one from the other we may use other words in Prayer than what we premeditated as the Spirit of God may help us But we are limited by God's Word to sing David's Psalms or else Hymns and Spiritual Songs composed out of the Word of God Now let them be either they must be so many words and no more or else none can sing with him that has the Hymn Now we say the extraordinary â—nfluences for Singing Preaching Interpreting c. are gone therefore every Ordinance must be performed by the ordinary Gifts and Influences of the Spirit or else we must have none at all Was Singing or any other Ordinance performed in the Gospel-Days by an extraordinary Spirit not performed then also and afterwards as well and as acceptable to God by the ordinary Gifts Shew if you can that other Ordinances which had such special Gifts then to attend them as well as Singing do notwithstanding remain Ordinances and yet Singing of Psalms and Hymns doth not so continue If therefore a Man should premeditate every word of his Sermon by the Assistance of the Spirit who dares to say he speaks not by the Help of the Holy Ghost or that his Sermon is not part of Spiritual Worship 'T is no matter whether we have our Sermons or our Hymns mediately or immediately composed and brought forth provided they be Spiritual and done by the help of the Spirit But to close all Are not David's Psalms part of Spiritual Worship and are not the Churches exhorted to sing them In Sect. 8. Appendix pag. 43 44 c. in answer to what we say That our Psalms and Hymns are Spiritual though precomposed you say 1. That such Forms are not Spiritual Worship because Singinâ— in the Primitive Gospel-Times was from the special Gift of the Spirit 2. Though say you the Matter of precomposed Forms of Singing be Spiritual yet the Heart must be Spiritual too or Grace and Melody must be in exercise in performing of them The Grace of Joy must be raised in the Soul to the heighth of Melody and so break forth Or to that purpose you speak pag. 44 45. Answ 1. We need no more the special Gift in Singing to render our Singing Spiritual than those special Gifts in Preaching to render our Sermons Spiritual 2. As to have Grace in our Hearts not only in the Habit but also in the Exercise in Singing we acknowledg it is necessary to a right performance of it And so 't is in Prayer Preaching and all other Spiritual Duties of Religion And let me tell you we need no greater assistance of the Spirit in Singing than in Praying or Rejoicing therefore what signifies that which you say pag. 45. Viz. The least exercise of true Grace in our Hearts in Prayer gives Essence or Being to Prayer so the least exercise of gracious melodious Joy gives Essence to inward Singing And say you as we ought not vocally to pray in the Publick Worship of God in the Church without a sufficient Gift of the Spirit so also we ought not vocally to sing in the Church unless it be by a sufficient Gift of the Spirit And seeing we have not such a Gift we are not capable of vocal Spiritual Singing 〈…〉 we must be contented as you intimate in pag. 46. with the Essence of it in our Spirits only Answ By this way of arguing you may lay Godly Christians under Temptations about Prayer especially in the Church because they may plead they have not the Gift whereas the Grace of Prayer viz. a broken Heart is that which God chiefly looks at and so should we too This makes no more against Singing than it doth against Praying And thus I must argue upon you If I have not the Special Gift of Singing I must content my self with the Essence of it in my Heart and yet as I have shewed the essence of it is not in the heart as it is in the Voice and so since if I have not the special Gift of Prayer I must be contented with the Essence of Prayer only Heart-Prayer and not pray vocally at all But you intimate that none ought to sing but such who are in the full assurance of the Love of God But you might as well say none ought to rejoice in the Lord nor to praise him but such only as well as to say what you do here against their Singing who want that assurance But you hint in pag. 46. as if we must be satisfied with your Essence of Singing viz. inward joy in the Heart till we come to the primitive perfection of Divine Worship c. Answ We doubt not through Grace but we are come to such perfection of