some according to the original word here 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 correcting disorders and Ordaining Ministers both which plainly argue Episcopal authority for no single Presbyter was ever allowed even by our Antiepiscopal men to manage such a power Now as according to the Apostles word Heb. 7.7 the less is blessed of the better so must the correction of what is amiss and the power of conferring an Ecclesiastical office upon any be in a Superiour also I know well what is usually objected here viz. That Titus was an Evangelist that is say some an Assistant to the Apostle in his peregrinations among the Churches and therefore was endowed with an extraordinary power insomuch that his office was not capable of a Succession My answer hereto is this It is granted that Titus for some time removed from place to place with the Apostle as the exigency of his work required one while at Jerusalem another while at Crete from thence to Nicopolis he is ordered by the Apostle to come unto him after that he is sent to Corinth from whence he is expected at Treas and met with Paul in Macedonia whence he is sent again to Corinth c. as some have traced him in his several Stages Yet nevertheless though he was such a temporary Itinerant with the Apostle and if they will needs have it so though he executed the office of an Evangelist in so doing It followeth not that his first Commission for Crete was thereby revoked But that he did the office of an Evangelist while he attended the Apostle may be granted as he did while he was resident in Crete that is by labouring in the Word and Doctrine For after all that can be said other Evangelist Titus never was nor can he ever be proved to be Add hereunto Neither can it be found that ever Titus had such a peculiar charge given unto him in any of those places where he either accompanied the Apostle or was employed by him as he had in Crete For was he ever appointed to such a work either in Jerusalem or in Corinth or in Macedonia or in Dalmatia or in any place else besides Crete Surely it cannot be imagined but that these places might need the care and vigilancy of a Titus as well as that to which he was consign'd If therefore such an office of Government fixed upon one person in one place over a numerous Clergie was for the advancement of the Gospel of such nacessity in the dayes of the Apostles who were not at all wanting in the discharge of their duty without all contradiction it is at least as necessary now unless we will say that the care of the Churches well-fare was confin'd unto those Primitive Times and not to be extended to after-ages All which considered It is more then probable that the Apostle did devolve a power upon Titus not of an Evangelist in the late upstart sense but that which is indeed Episcopal superiour to that of an ordinary Presbyter and not onely so but that this was to be a president for the Government of the Churches to the end of the world Especially when we look upon the reason which the Apostle annexeth to the seventh verse in these words For a Bishop must be blameless c. Which for my part I conceive to be the ground of the Apostles own act in leaving Titus at Crete for the ends and purposes there premised knowing him to be a fit instrument for such a weighty employment and not at all to shew the qualification of the persons whom he should ordain as it hath been commonly understood Such qualification the Apostle had described in the sixth verse saying If any be blameless that is as a late Writer glosseth upon it approved by the testimony of the Church to be under no scandalous sin The husband of one wife that is One who lives not with a second wife after putting away the first Having faithful children that is such if he have any as have all received the Faith For if he bring not up his own children to be Christian what hope is there that he will be fit to convert others Not accused of riot or unruly that is who live temperately and regularly Meaning that Titus should not ordain any but those that are thus qualified in respect of their own vertuous living the Christian education of their children But now if he should again in the seventh verse repeat the same qualification of unblameableness as referring to the same persons his words would border too much upon an uncomely tautology which was never incident to that spirit by which he wrote As I said therefore before so I say again when the Apostle had declared how the persons should be qualified whom Titus should ordain he proceedeth to give Titus himself a reason implying withal the justification of his own Act why he left him in Crete about such an important business as to correct disorders and to ordain Elders For saith he A Bishop that is one who must be employed in these things must be as I have found thee to be blameless as the steward of God not self-willed c. Otherwise with what face can he lay hands upon any looking for such qualifications as are just and fit for such offices if they be wanting in himself Or how can he correct disorders in others if he himself be blame-worthy Knowing therefore thee to be in all points fitted for this great work I left thee in Crete c. So that the intent of the Apostle here plainly is this partly to satisfie Titus concerning his leaving him there as being for a purpose of an extrordinary concernment but chiefly to shew the qualifications of the persons to be employed in correcting and ordaining upon whom he sets an honourable mark of distinction for his works sake calling him BISHOP whereas the persons or dained he had before distinguished by a title proper to their office calling them Presbyters This is one interpretation of the Apostles meaning which I humbly submit to the judgement of the Church It is clear without any wrest or ambiguity and upon which it plainly follows that Bishop and Presbyter are not one and the same but distinct in their offices and it is hereby as plain likewise that the office of Bishop distinct from that of a Presbyter is of divine inslitution If this sense will not be allowed by our Opponents as for my part I know not why it should be rejected Let them consider a second Whereas the Apostle saith that He left Titus in Crete to ordain Elders in every City shewing in the sixth verse how they should be qualified viz. That they be blameless c. And thereupon alledgeth his reason in the seventh verse For a BISHOP must be blameless c. He implieth the great care that Titus should have in ordaining Elders because from among them BISHOPS were to be chosen for the Government of the Churches whom it concern'd in regard of their power
needs be nauseous unacceptable and to no purpose let all that are yet unsatisfied in that point read over and peruse his late Majesties Arguing about it with those Ministers that attended the Commissioners of Parl at the Treaty in the Isle of Wight M. Marshall M. Caryll M. Vines M. Scaman and if they be disposed to a temper of accepting Reason they will finde cause enough to alter their judgement Once those very Ministers were so farre convinced thereby that though they were very shy and unwilling to discover their mindes in a matter of so great and necessary consequence as to give his Majesty satisfaction in those three Quaeries which he propounded unto them concerning Church-Government 1 Whether there be a certain Form of Government left by Christ or his Apostles to be observed by all Christian Churches pretending that the whole volume of Ecclesiastical Polity was contained therein yet they could not but acknowledge the remarkable Learning of his Reply which was clothed as they write with a singular elegancy of stile wishing that such a Pen in the hand of such Abilities might ever be employed in a Subject worthy of it Yet because it will be expected that somewhat be here also said in answer to this part of the before-mentioned objection Let us take into consideration the main Argument that is used against Episcopacy and with a refutation of it put an end to this Controversie That which is chiefly insisted upon by our Anti-episcopal men is the Identity of Denomination which they imagine the Scripture giveth to Bishops and Presbyters 2 Whether it bind perpetually or be upon occasion alterable in whole or in part from whence they will inferre the Identity of Office viz. That Bishop and Presbyter are not distinguishable in any part of their Authority which the Lord hath given them for the edification of the Church A principal instance hereof they alledge out of the Text of the Apostle Tit. 1.5.7 upon which for brevities sake we will onely fix and which being cleared will help us to interpret aright other places of Scripture of the like nature The words are these 3 Whether that certain Form of Government be the Episcopal Preâ—byterian or some other differing from them both Tit. 1 5.7 For this cause left I thee in Crete that thou shouldst set in order the things that are wanting and ordain Elders in every City as I had appointed thee For a Bishop must be blameless c. In which place say they the Apostles reasoning were altogether invalid and inconsequent if Presbyter and Bishop were not the same Office as well as they have the same Name But how justly may it be here said Bernardus non videt omnia These men that pretend to know more of the sense of the holy Ghost in Scripture then others and are apt to censure all that are not of the same judgment with them are not so omniscient but that their brethren who come after them may discern somewhat which they could not see I shall therefore take the boldness to tell them my poor judgment concerning that Scripture hoping that I may make use of my liberty as they do of theirs I know well it is no new Opinion that I am about to encounter with but because our late Writers do with a higher confidence then ordinary seem to abound in their sense concerning this matter I shall endeavour their conviction And first I shall premise a Caution by the way yielding in this Controversie as much as may be consistent with Truth I do not undertake to produce any positive Precept from the holy Ghost in this place for the establishment of Episcopacy in the Church it is enough to shew that a Divine Approbation is given of it in describing the qualification of the persons that are to employed in such an Office distinct from that of a Presbyter together with their superiority over Presbyters and how they are to exercise their power in the several parts thereof viz. Ordination and Jurisdiction Which Divine Approbation if we can here finde as I doubt not we shall I hope it will be acknowledge by all to be Tant-amount to a Divine Institution And though it have not any positive Appointment in Scripture but is onely glanced at in some certain places yet that should not create any scruple in the mindes of any about it no more then some points of Faith which we freely profess are scrupled by us though we finde them not expresly commanded in the written Word Is it meet for any to say unto God What doest thou Who alas among us hath known the minde of the Lord Or who hath been his Counsellour to know fully the reason why he doth in such a manner issue out his Precepts Are not Clouds and thick Darkness set about the Pavilion of God Let not silly man then dare to remove them It would far better become us to keep our distance and to be wise according to sobriety then to arraign the pure word of Truth before the bar of our corrupt reason or to call the holy Spirit of God to account for not giving full satisfaction forsooth to our foolish expectation What if Christ being willing to make his Regal Power the more known to the world would onely give some small intimation of his will concerning this matter as he hath done of sundry other things which we need not here mention to try the spirits of men whether they would thereby be subject unto him or no It is ordinary we know with the Princes of the earth to deal thus with their Subjects by a look or a glance of the eye or by a word of the mouth though uttered in an oblique way to give notice of their further intentions so to search into and finde out the Loyalty and ready affections of those about them And shall Jesus Christ be denyed this liberty This being premised let us now come to inquire out the meaning of the Apostle in the afore-cited place and see whether or no his words will allow of such an Identity between Bishop and Presbyter as hath been commonly conceived or rather try whether by deduction we can prove from thence the Divine Right of Episcopacy which is so much contradicted in these days onely let prejudice be forborn till such time as we have put an end to this controversie First it cannot be denied that the Apostle writeth to Titus as to one with whom he had entrusted the sole inspection of that large and spacious Island an Island containing in it an hundred Cities called therefore Hecatompolis wherein his appointed work was Not to gather a Church by converting the inhabitants thereof from their Paganisme and Judaisme to the faith of the Gospel but the manner of governing a Church which was already gathered was prescribed unto him And this is by the Apostle branched out into two things viz Setting in order things that were amiss or wanting or as it is rendred by
and authority above all others to be blameless as the Stewards of God not self-willed c. From whence I collect that the office of BISHOP and Presbyter are not one and the same Some Objections possibly will be made against this interpretation also but let judicious and sober-minded men judge whether they be of such weight so as to carry the Apostles sense against it I confess great is the confidence that hath been built upon this imaginary Identity from whence hath sprung much trouble to the Church of God and none have exceeded therein so much above measure as those persons who with a strange kinde of affectation called themselves by that Uncouth name of Smectymnuus For they led on with this Errour that BISHOP and Presbyter are one and the same take upon them to tax the Apostles reasoning as inconsequential and his demand as they call it Unjust unless he subscribe to their opinion Which censure they are likewise pleased to stretch out further by a similitude according to their fancy If a Chancellour say they in one of our Vniversities should give order to his Vice-Chancellour to admit none to the degree of a Bachelour in arts but such as were able to preach or keep a Divinity-Act for Bachelours in Divinity must be so what reason or equity were in this So if Paul leaving Titus in Crete should give order to him not to admit any to be an Elder but one thus and thus qualified because a Bishop must be so Had a Bishop been an Order or Calling distinct from or superiour to a Presbyter and not the same this had been no more rational or equal then the former Thus They. But the sense of the Apostle being rendred as before which for ought that I can see may very well be so Their similitude or somewhat alike unto it may be retorted upon them in this manner If a Chancellour in one of our Universities should give order to his Vice-Chancellour to admit none to the degree of a Bachelour in Divinity but such as were learned in the Scriptures of good report and of a grave and sober conversation for Doctours in Divinity who are to be taken out of that lower degree must be so there would be both reason and equity in such a Command so when the Apostle gives order to Titus not to admit any to be a Presbyter but one that is blameless because a BISHOP who is to be chosen out of the Presbytery must be so I hope the Divine spirit of this Doctor gentium may pass without control and not have an imputation of irrationality any more put upon him though it be affirmed as the truth is that the office of a BISHOP is here distinguished by him from that of a Presbyter and made Superiour unto it Let none now think of me that because of this my free manner of writing I have design'd thereby to make way for a Polemical dispute with some persons of note that are contrary minded in this case they would mistake me much that should judge so of me I am not willing to be reckoned among the disputers of this world And I do confess my self the unfittest of many upon sundry accounts for such an undertaking besides there hath been too much wrangling already among us Animosities have encreased to the great decay of brotherly-Love in the management of this controversy occasioned chiefly by this pretended Identity Jam. 1.20 But the wrath of man saith the Apostle worketh not the Righteousness of God And what have all the Jehu-like sallies and furious heats of the adversaries of Episcopacy at length produced What I say whereby Gods name may be honoured or his Church edified Is not the shame of their nakedness made bare to the view of all men Oh that God would now give repentance unto all those that are conscious to themselves of a guilt herein Even those very persons that I mentioned before who were the Ring leaders in this difference have reason sadly to lay it to heart if they be yet living who had they but followed that Counsel themselves which they gave unto that Reverend BISHOP with whom they did contend their offense had not been so great viz. To have written more cautiously and to have given less scope to their luxuriant pen for as they did let it run into causeless aggravations it did certainly bring too great a scandal upon Religion and made good their adversaries charge against them But since things that are past cannot be wholly recalled Oh that they would give glory to God in confessing their Errour and endeavour to repair again those breaches which their inadvertency hath made by a publick retractation They are men that pretend much to tenderness of Conscience and therefore I presume are not of that proud Cardinal's spirit who confessed there was need enough to reform the abuses of the Romish-Church but he could not endure that Luther a poor beggarly Friar as he call'd him should give the first Onset unto it I hope better things of these men as to this case in their capacity and that they will not disdain for this once to receive a word of Exhortation from one that is least esteemed in the Church because they know well that the more inconsiderable the person is as to his outward estate that gives them an advice of such concernment as this they may the more magnifie God's name in a ready consenting thereunto But to return to our purpose I have here offered my conceptions in the expounding of this Scripture which hath been so much controverted of late humbly presenting them to the judgment of the Church not knowing that ever yet any expositour Antient or Modern hath rendred the sense of it so before If the glory of God may hereby be advanced and the Churches peace promoted I have my aime and it shall be the Crown of my rejoycing to my dying day But as to the Objection that hath thus let out my thoughts so far towards this subject I will be confident that either of these interpretations that are here given will sooner be received by those that are wise and moderate then our adversaries wrest which hath hitherto created so much trouble unto us The result will be this Episcopal Government is warranted by the word of God therefore it is no superstition to have it reestablished in our Church nor no transgression of the Law of Christ to yield subjection unto it And now to finish this matter whereas there hath been a Cry made Away with Superstition and Away with Idolatry Away made Away with Superstition and Away with Idolatry Away with Liturgy and Away with Bishops we may clearly see by what is here written that this clamour is altogether causeless Poor people that are thus wosully deluded the Lord pitie them and the Lord forgive them for they know not what they say Much more reason surely is there to cry out with a shout Blessed be God for Liturgy and Episcopacy whereby we
time of the Old Testament with all the legal Ordinances attending upon it is a day that is set and expired being yesterday and therefore not to be brought into our account neither are we to walk in the light of it p. 118. Proved by sundry instances ibid. Whereupon followeth The conviction of those who in this day will grope after the obscure light of yesterday these are First the Jews p. 121. Secondly they that seek to be justified by the works of the law p. 126. Thirdly the Papists p. 128. Fourthly they that now-a-days pretend to Oracles and wait for Miracles p. 129. Where is to be seen What we are to judge of the pretended Visions and Revelations of these times ibid. And what Miracles are now to be regarded in the time of the Gospel p. 132. A second Doctrine propounded viz. Jesus Christ was the Saviour of his Church in the time of the Old Testament even as nâ—w in the time of the New p. 134. Proved ibid. A Question resolved How Christ could be a Saviour before he was in a capacity to suffer death by taking our nature upon him for the expiation of sin p. 135. Jesus Christ was a Prophet from the beginning p. 136. Jesus Christ was a King from the beginning p. 138. Jesus Christ was a Priest from the beginning p. 149. A difference observed in respect of the dispensation and manifestation of Christ to the Fathers and us p. 155. Examples of sundry of the Fathers believing in Christ Adam Abraham Job Daniel c. p. 156. Moses's intercourse with Jesus Christ upon the Mount p. 159. Whereupon followeth 1. An exhortation to the Jews to look unto Jesus p. 164. 2. A warning to take heed of despising the ages before us p 166. 3. Our religion proved to be the onely true Religion p. 169. 4. The Limbus Patrum of the Church of Rome proved to be an absurd forgery p. 170. 5. To hold that the object of the faith of the Patriarchs of old was not Jesus Christ is a gross errour p. 175. 6. And as gross is it to maintain that we are not now justified by the Object but by the Act of Faith p. 176. Of the second course or computation of time viz. To day Wherein first this Doctrine is propounded viz. The time of the Gospel is a time of light p. 180. It is a true light p. 181. It is a great light ibid. It is a marvellous light ibid. It is an invincible light p. 182. Whereupon follow The duties of those who are the children of this day 1. To rejoyce and be glad in it p. 184. An Objection But this day is a day of trouble of rebuke and blasphemy p. 186. Answered ibid. 2. To let the light of this day shine in upon their souls p. 188. A Question put viz. What is this light p. 189. Answered 1. It is the light of Life ibid. 2. It is the light of the glorious Gospel of Jesus Christ p. 190. 3. It is the light of the knowledge of the glory of God ibid. 3. To walk in this light p. 191. A two-fold walk 1. Walk in the Commandments of the Lord ibid. Motives hereunto 1. It is the great design of Almighty God this day to save his people from their sins p. 192. 2. We are to walk worthy of our calling p. 194. 3. Consider the length of our way p. 195. 4. This day will have an end p. 196. 2. Walk in the Ordinances of the Lord p. 199. Let then the world be awakened that lyeth asleep in the darkness of sin and ignorance p. 202. Let the Ignorant be roused p. 202. Let the profance be alarum'd p. 203. A Question put viz. How cometh it to passe that wo and misery falls so inevitably upon profane people this day p. 207. Answered 1. The sin of such persons is found out by the light of this day ibid. 2. Their sin doth finde out them p. 208. Application p. 209. Another Doctrine propounded viz. Jesus Christ is the Same to his Church now in the time of the Gospel which he was before under the Law p. 212. Proved by Scripture p. 213. An Objection But we see there is a change to day from what was yesterday in the form of Divine worship How then can Jesus Christ be the Same p. 215. Answered ibid. Inferences thereupon First the Imputations of Novelty upon those Churches which adhere to this foundation charged on them by the Church of Rome cannot be just p. 217. The said Imputations justly retoried upon the Romish Church ibid. Secondly an Exhortation to let the same minde be in us which was in Christ Jesus that is to be the Same in things pertaining to God p. 220. An Application hereof to us of this nation with a free and plain discovery of our late inconstancy p. 222. An Objection Shall we then be the Same which we have been in profaneness and superstition p. 227. Answer God forbid ibid. 1. The bad Old Cause did not preserve us from either p. 228. 2. The League and Covenant though contrived to strengthen the said Cause yet as it was illegal in it self so was it treacherously carried on p. 229. It is objected But is there not a return to Superstition when the Lyturgie Ceremonies and Episcopacy are restored p. 233. It is answered ibid. Where 1. The Lyturgie and Ceremonies are vindicated p. 234. Particularly 1. Our bowing at the name of Jesus p. 235. 2. Our bowing at our entrance into and departure from the Congregation p. 236. 3. Our Lyturgie and Ceremonies are acknowledged to be a will-worship which is plainly manifested to be in some respects lawful p. 238. But that they are extracted from Romish Missals is a slanderous untruth p. 242. 2. Episcopacy is clearly proved by the Scripture to be of Divine Right Sensu Primario p. 248. An Exhortation to the Jews p. 262. Matter of rejoycing to the Gentiles p. 268. An Application hereof to our own Nation p. 270. A serious Expostulation with Anabaptists ibid. Of the third course or computation of Time viz. For ever p. 273. A Doctrine propounded In the midst of the various changes and chances that may come upon the Church to the end of the world Jesus Christ will be unto it still the Same Ibid. Proved by Scripture p 274. Inferences from hence 1. Assurance may be had of the Churches perpetuity p. 275. 2. A remedy to cure the sad distempers of our Church about Order and Church-Government p. 276. 3. An Exhortation and Christian Advice given to those who pretend they cannot for conscience sake submit to Church-Government by Bishops p. 277. 4. Comfort to all who live goldy in Christ Jesus both in respect of themselves and their posterity p. 281. Another Doctrine propounded viz. Jesus Christ will be the Same unto his Church in her Triumphant and Glorious estate in heaven unto all Eternity p. 282. Wherein first The full sense is given of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 p. 283. Secondly how
as if he could not have been perfect without his Creatures for he was from all Eternity ' 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 sufficiently pleased with his own Perfection but willing he was that other things might have a Being to the end he might communicate his Goodness unto them And as he began this Work for that end so he continued still the same for his Goodness extended over all the World He is good unto all saith David and his tender mercies are ever all his works Ps 145.9 Psal 145. His Power in like manner was the same from first to last without Diminution or Augmentation without weariness or fainting he rested not that is He ceased not till he had finished all and then pleased himself upon the Sabbath-day rejoycing in all the Works that he had made And now to sum up this whole matter Jesus Christ we see is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the same in the work of Creation First The same with the Father in that eternal Counsel and Decree from whence all things had their first Rise and Original Secondly The same with the Father in the execution of that Decree framing and fashioning every Creature in his Rank placing them all in their several Stations exactly according to the primary Pattern and Tenour of that Decree Thirdly The same without any Coadjutour in the mighty Work that he undertook his own and only Omnipotent Fiat gave a Being to the World and all the parts of it without which they had never been Finally The same from first to last without any variableness or shadow of turning exercising his Divine Wisdom Goodness and Power throughout the whole Creation Many are the Inferences that might be derived from this Consideration but we shall not extend our Discourse beyond the due boundary of the Text Only somewhat we will observe that may be for further edification First then this Doctrine may lead us to a further knowledge of our Lord and great Redeemer JESUS CHRIST for saith the Apostle Rom. 1.20 The invisible things of him from the Creation of the World are clearly seen being understood by the things that are made even his eternal Power and Godhead Walk we therefore about this Creation go round about it tell the parts thereof mark well the beauty of the Frame the admirable Order of this great and goodly Fabrick consider the several Palaces that are set therein for Angels for Men and the various lustre which the Lights do transmit there being one glory of the Sun another of the Moon and another glory of the Stars that we may know it for our selves and tell it to the Generations following that Great is the Lord and greatly to be praised his Greatness is unsearchable Ps 145.3 It is indeed unto all the faithful people of God whose hearts are raised up to a spiritual elevation a most pleasing kind of Geography as a reverend Bishop of our Church calls it in this large Map of the created World Bishop of Chi. in the Celestial and Terrestrial Globe to contemplate the Creatour for the works of the Lord are great saith the Psalmist sought out by all them that have pleasure therein Ps 111.2 But when in their search they happen to light upon the soot-steps of the Creatour by the whisperings of his Spirit which is very frequent and common unto them O what an incomparable pleasure is it then to pursue the Tract Hos 6.3 and to follow on to know the Lord So doth the Psalmist in the fore-cited place His work saith he is honourable and glorious Ps 111.3 and then followeth His righteousness endureth for ever Which way of Divine Speculation through the Creatures whereby we may ascend in our Meditations above every name that is named Ps 83.19 to the knowledge of him whose Name alone is Jehovah hath God himself caught us As when he instructed Job and would convince him of his rashness and folly in his peremptory Argutations making him also sensible of his own Almighty Power he brings the work of his Creation into remembrance before him Job 38 39 40 41. viz. Things in Heaven things in Earth and things in the Deep When we shall now therefore consider the Heavens not only this lower Heaven which in some sense may be called our Heaven wherein we and other poor mortal Creatures do breath which we may feel with our hands and wherein the Arm of the most High is many times stretched forth in mighty Winds and roaring Thunders and blazing Comets able to make the very Pillars of the World to tremble yea and to cool the courage and daunt the Spirits of all Atheistical Caligula's But those above especially which we see with our eyes at a greater distance so great that it is a wonder saith a Contemplative Divine we can look up to so admirable a height Bishop Hall and that the very eye is not tired in the way ascribed unto God by David as his Peculiar with this distinguishing term of Appropriation Ps 8.3 Thy Heavens Psal 8.3 Those which are the curious and exquisite Master-pieces of God's fingers Amos 9.6 for there saith the Prophet hath he built his Stories that is his Spheres or Ascentions from the Moon which is the lowest to the Stars which is the highest that can be discerned by men on Earth in which regard it may be though it be commonly taken for David's Night-meditation these two are only mentioned Ps 8.3 comprizing all the rest When we consider further the wonders of God in the Deep wherein saith the Psalmist Ps 104 25 26. are things creeping innumerable both small and great Beasts There go the Ships those moving Islands which bring the several Nations of the World into acquaintance one with another which suck the abundance of the Seas Deut. 33.19 Es 23.3 and Treasures hid in the Sand which reap the Harvest of the Water far surpassing the harvest of the Ground the artificiallest Wonder that ever was framed There goeth that Leviathan the wonder of that Nature the King over all the children of Pride made to play therein Job 41. whose wonderful parts and comely proportion is admirably described by the Tongue of the Learned Bishop King upon Jonas even the learnedst Tongue that the Holy Ghost had as one skilful in Scripture-learning sweetly expresseth it Yea there are the goings of the great God himself whose Name is Wonderful for the Sea is his and he made it Ps 95.5 and his Spirit still moveth upon these waters as it did formerly For as a King he sitteth upon the Water-floods saith the Psalm his power and providence walking constantly in state upon the Surface of them Ps 29.10 And though the proud Waves do rage that the very Mountains shake at the swelling thereof because they are stinted in their Current Job 38.10 11. Ps 104.9 and cannot with a full carrere turn again to cover the Earth yet he still keeps them under
we have been such strangers unto it by giving entertainment to Errour in the most ugly appearances thereof that we might well have asked as he did what is Truth True it is there was a certain Covenant made whether according to truth and righteousness somewhat may be said hereafter but made I say for the extirpation of Heresie and Errour c. But it is as true which was once freely spoken at a Monethly-fast in Saint Margarets Westminster If we had sworn to the utmost of our power to have advanced Errour and Heresy Feb. 24. 1646. they could not well have grown and encreased more then they did when we swore against them There was a time also when we took sweet Counsel together under the peaceful Government of a Religious King and the vigilant inspection of Grave and Orthodox Bishops walking to the house of God in company where we had full Congregations the office of the Ministery Honoured the Word faithfully preached Sacraments duely administred c. And have not Sacraments of late been laid aside as useless and unnecessary The Ministery cryed down as AntiChristian Congregations scattered Churches put to profane and sordid uses to the shame of Religion and the scorn of our Adversaries round about us The Word indeed was preached and we do with all due thankfulness acknowledge it to God's glory for though some did preach Christ of envy and contention not sincerely yet some did it of good will and therefore seeing Christ was preached whether in pretence or in Truth Phil. 1.18 therein with St. Paul we did rejoyce yea and will rejoyce Notwithstanding it was both our sin and our shame that that Holy and Divine Ordinance was I say not with impunity but with publick approbation so much profaned when the pulpit was too often made a Tub for Mechanick praters to pour out their Blasphemies or turned into a Theatre by others to promote carnal interests and to strengthen the Schisme that was the set up And if any honest Orthodox Ministers durst be so bold according to their commission given them of Christ to manifest their zeal in preaching against these impostours and their abettours as some there were who could not forbear It was not their Gravity Learning Piety Fidelity to their Countrey nor ability to promote the glory of the Gospel that could be a sufficient safeguard unto them But they must be branded with the odious mark of Malignancy and even in the very execution of their office affronted interrupted contradicted yea sometimes laughed to scorn I instance not in particular persons His Majesties gracious Act of indulgence forbidding it But hence it was that many faithful Ministers were so much despised throughout the Nation sometimes called Legalists otherwhiles Formalists yea reviled with the most opprobrious terms that Malice it self could invent To some they were too plain to others they were too eloquent one while tax'd for not preaching Christ another while for not holding forth the Doctrine of Free-grace But if in their Sermons they happened to make mention of those Holy Antients whom the Church hath honoured with the Name of Fathers they were presently by some temerarious Head or other censured for Bablers or at the best but low-spirited Men that would be padling in the shallows of Antiquity not fit forsooth to be named with the profound knowledge of these dayes So imperious were people grown in their superintendency over their Teachers yea though they were illiterate Mechanicks yet being the Darlings of the Schisme they would presume as being allowed to be Dictatours to the most grave and learned Ministers that were not of their Faction not considering what the Apostle saith that The spirits of the prophets are subject to the Prophets implying doubtless that it is the Ecclesiastical Senate that should take cognisance of Preachers Doctrines so as to regulate whatsoever may be found amiss in them not the Company of spear-men or calves of the people as the Prophet calleth the rude malitude But such was the impiety of those times that the poor Ministers of Christ though by the Holy Ghost accounted the Prime Masters of the Assemblies did commonly stand in their Pulpits like Prisoners at the Bar when their Hearers Ec. 12.11 how ignorant soever sat like so many Judges round about them Again As preaching was prophaned so in like manner was prayer too much perverted and depraved Whereas in our approaches to God we were wont to fall down upon our knees adoring the Divine Majesty with the humbling of our bodies to the very dust according to the religious example of the devout servants of God in Scripture Luk. 22.41 Mar. 14.35 Mat. 26.39 yea of the Son of God himself of whom Saint Luke saith that He kneeled and prayed Saint Mark that he fell to the ground and prayed Saint Matthew that he fell upon his face and prayed What an Unreverend insolency hath the late times produced when this humble gesture was in many places wholly neglected as being forsooth below the Saintship of our Upstart Reformers who possibly might pretend to have more familiaritie with the God of Heaven then those could be allowed to have that had been before them And therefore they might now serve him without fear though the truth is they did it not in righteousness nor true holiness Was not the spiritualness of prayer confined to the suddenness of conception and volubility of utterance qualities not incompossible with a spirit of opposition to all that is good and holy which also were accompanied too frequently it is to be feared with a vain ostentation of mens abilities for invention and with such expressions many times that no honest heart God knoweth could say Amen unto them When a Set-form though compiled according to the warrant and pattern that Christ hath given us and used with a pious and sincere devotion was contrary to the rules of Christian Charity contrary to the judgement of the best Divines both Antient and Modern forein and domestick yea contrary to the general practice of the Reformed Churches condemned and rejected as unsutable to the spirit of Adoption and unacceptable to the God of Heaven as if the Almighty were more to be taken with the variety of words then with the groans of the spirit which may assoon ascend up into his ears in the Religious use of a form as in the uttering of the best conceived prayer in the World But it is no marvel that set-forms of prayer were so much decryed when the Lords prayer it self was sleighted yea so despised that if according to the good antient Custome among us prayers were concluded with a rehearsal of it Such was the horrible profaness of some who yet pretended to a Seraphical strain of Holiness above others that they would thereupon most unreverendly in the face of the Congregation put their hats on their heads that they might thereby throw contempt upon that prayer and those that used it Which disdainful posture if they did
Church of Rome If then that Cause so much pleaded for had such ill Consequents attending upon it may we not well say Sublatâ Causâ tollitur Effectus When the Cause is taken away the Effect will follow At least as I said before there is great hope it shall follow especially now when God hath in Mercy set over us a Man of Understanding and Knowledge Pro. 28.2 to lengthen out the State and Tranquillity of our Countrey when for the Transgressions of it it was by the Intrusion of Usurpers neer unto utter ruine A Man I say after his own heart Tutour'd and Bred up by him like David in the school of affliction Whose Heart is also fixed upon God to serve him in Righteousness and true Holiness A Prince so pious that he makes it his work and accounts it his glory to have true Religion established amongst his people in the Power and Purity of it See his Majesties Proclamation May 30. 1660. Witness his extreme dislike of Profaness which he hasted to publish the very next day after his happy Return unto us Commanding it to be read in all Churches monethly for six moneths after But well worthy indeed to be set up in them as a perpetual Monument of Piety to all Generations Wherein he declares the Purpose and Resolution of his Religious Heart in these words We will not exercise just Severity against any Malefactours sooner then against men of Dissolute Debauched and Prophane lives with what parts soever they may be otherwise qualified and endowed Requiring all Majors Sheriffs and Justices of the Peace to be very vigilant and strict in the Discovery and Prosecution of all Dissolute and Profane Persons such as blaspheme the Name of God by profane swearing and cursing or revile and disturb Ministers and despise the publick worship of God Witness also the Declaration which his Majesty set forth Octob. 25 immediately following concerning Ecclesiastical Affairs wherein he hath made known to God and the world That his Resolution is and shall be to promote the Power of Godliness to encourage the Exercises of Religion both publick and private and to take care that the Lords Day be applied to Holy Exercises without unnecessary divertisements and that Insufficient Negligent and Scandalous Ministers be not permitted in the Church Which being so What is it but a profane slander of the footsteps of Gods Anointed both of Christ himself and his Vicegerent over us to amuse the world with false reports of a return to profaness as if the Times were now become so loose that Wickedness should be established by a Law Whereas there was never more likelihood then now if the Devil through the turbulent spirits of factious Schismaticks did not hinder it for Religion to prosper and Holiness to flourish Away then with Profaness and let Superstition pack together with it for what entertainment is it like here to finde When King Charls the Sufferer L. Bishop of Winton the sonne of King Charls the Martyr as a Reverend Father of our Church hath worthily proclaimed him is new by the Divine Power and Goodness settled upon his Throne to be the Defender of that Faith for which he suffered That Faith I say which the Church of England professeth in opposition to the Church of Rome From which as it was observed by that Loyal and Peace-making Parliament that first so happily brought the Nation under his Majesties Government neither the Temptation of Allurements Perswasions and Promises from seducing Papists on the one hand nor the Persecution and hard Vsage from some seduced and mis-guided Professours of the Protestant Religion on the other hand could at all prevail upon him to make him swerve in the least Degree But chose rather still to suffer Afflictions though never so grievous as Moses did then to enjoy the pleasures of sin for a season by so doing For which his Name shall be sweet and his Memorial precious in all the Churches of Christ to the end of the World I say then again Is it like that Superstition in any kinde should be Tolerated much less shall it be Established under the Government of so famous a Sufferer for the Protestant Profession yea and so active a Defender of it who hath made it manifest that his Care and Study is for the propagation thereof And who hath solemnly professed that nothing shall be proposed to testifie his Zeal and Affection for it to which he will not readily consent It will be objected What do we hear Words when we see Deeds Is there not an Actual return to Superstition in this Land now when the Ceremonies which were cast out are brought in again and the Liturgie restored And what are these but either the Issues of Will-worship which the Holy Scripture doth condemn or the Bratts of Babylon which should be taken not to be cherisht but to be dasht against the stones Besides Is not the Government also by Bishops set up again in its former Height which is not warranted by the word of God If we then should consent to these things How shall we like unto Jesus Christ our Pattern in the Text continue faithful with God in our Conformity to his Rule which he hath set us I answer First we may be still the same in a constant Adherency to the Foundation though we may as Divine Providence leads us whether it be in Judgment or in Mercy vary sometimes from that which is Circumstantial of which nature are those things that are here objected unto us and our fidelity to the former wil certainly entitle us to a faithful Imitation of Jesus Christ notwithstanding our change in the latter Nay is it not a great weakning of the Foundation and an injurious imputation put upon the Master-Builder to lay so much weight upon Circumstantials as to make them Unchangeable when they are not of his particular appointment though allowed by him to be annexed to his Building It is Superstition doubtless so to set up External Rites in competition with the Everlasting Rule of the Gospel as if they were not upon any Emergency whatsoever to be altered or removed And it is as ranck Superstition on the other side after they have been removed and restored again Superstitio ex super stando qua significatur nimium ese Sen. Epist 123. pertinaciously to stand in opposition against them especially when Experience hath made it manifest that the removal of them hath introduced much disorder and profaness in the service of God But we may appeal unto Christ himself to Judge in this Case Whether or no when a Christian Magistrate that truly feareth God taking notice of a great decay of Religion which by a wild and lawless Liberty hath been brought amongst his Subjects shall for the improvement of Piety recommend unto them a Form of Divine Service accompanied with such Rites and Ceremonies as are in force by Law and in the observing whereof True Religion hath formerly flourished Whether I say
command yet allowed by God and accepted and therefore not to be accounted as superstitious So those Ceremonies c. which have been and are again in use amongst us I mean such as are established by law may indeed be said to be a Will-worship wherein we in this time of the Gospel should rather excell those before us under the Law then to come short of them But to say that they are therefore Superstitious that is Anti-Christian and Idolatrous as some are apt most profanely to traduce them is a Soloecisme proper for those that are enemies unto reason Nevertheless though our Form of Divine Service and Ceremonies be a Will-worship yet we shall ever deny that they sprung out of Babylon that is according to the sense of these quarrelsome people that we received them from Rome It is the Lot it seemes of this poor Church of Christ to have this Cross laid upon her viz. to be on all sides upbraided still with Rome Papists on the one hand checking us that the first Plantation of the Gospel here came from thence and that therefore we are unnatural Children to separate our selves as we do from our Mother that gave us our being Schismaticks on the other hand charging us that we have not as we pretend separated from that Idolatrous Church but to this very day do hold too servile a compliancy with it crying out against us with open mouth as is the Mother so is the Daughter Rome like a false Strumpet hath devised a Superstitious Form of Religious Worship and England like a true Chip of the old Block doth follow her example therein But as Venerable Bede once gave the sense of those four famous and solemne Letters S. P. Q. R. So may we in this case Stultus Populus Quaerit Romam Senatus populusque Romanus foolish people cry out Rome not understanding what they say nor whereof they affirm As to the first of these reproaches if it were not out of our way we might reply that supposing not granting it to be true The people of this Nation received the Christian Faith from Rome We hold not our selves obliged thereby to follow Rome any otherwise then she followeth Christ for we have learned it from the mouth of our Lord himself that who so loveth Father or Mother more then him is not worthy of him But what Logick is this The Planters of the Faith here came from Rome Ergo the people of this Nation were ever after in the worshipping of God to keep the Order of Rome If this argument would hold saith Bishop Jewel then would I reason thus The Church of Rome was first planted by them that came from Graecia or from Jerusalem Ergo Rome is to keep the Order of Graecia or of Jerusalem which consequence I dare say will not down with her that takes upon her to be perpetual Dictatrix to all the Churches of the world But we shall let this pass as impertinent to our purpose neither is there need at any time to insist much upon it for it is sufficiently witnessed saith Bishop Godwin by many Histories without exception that our Island of Britain received the Faith of Christ even in the first infancy of the Church from Jerusalem That which is now before us is to make manifest the folly of these Schismatical Objectours who accuse us of Superstition in our Church-Service because as they say we received it from Rome It would be too large a digression here to undertake a Vindication of our Church in every particular that concerns this matter enough hath been written thereof already by sundry persons both Learned and Godly whose works praise them in the gates yet requisite it is that somewhat be here added to wipe off that aspersion before premised which may be reduced to this Argument Whatsoever Church hath received her forme of Divine-Service from Rome is therein guilty of gross Superistition But the Church of England hath received her form of Divine-Service from Rome therefore is the Church of England in the form of Divine-Service guilty of gross Superstition We will not meddle with the proposition of this argument Let Rome plead for her self against it But as for the assumption we shall by clear and plain demonstration prove that to be utterly false both in respect of the times of old as also of the later since the Protestant Reformation And first We may here by the way upon very good warrant affirm that Non fuit sic ab initio It was not wont to be thus with England in the times of old viz. To follow Rome in the forme of Divine Service The reason of our confidence herein we have from that venerable Authour our Country-man before mentioned who is by all parties acknowledged to be a faithful Witness worthy of an high esteem in the Church Hee I say in his Ecclesiastical History informes us Beda lib. 3 cap. 25. that the Church of this Island of Britain well near until seven hundred years after Christ in the keeping of Easter-day and manner of Baptising followed the order of the Greek Church without any regard therein had to the Church of Rome And when Austin that imperious Monk was sent hither from Rome And when Austin that imperious Monk was sent hither from Rome here were saith Bede at that time one Arch-Bishop seven Bishops Lib. 2. cap. 2. and one and twenty hundred holy and religious Monks about Bangor who lived by the labour of their own hands the Countrey being for the most part Heathenish and as he further avoucheth plures viri doctissimi many moe great learned men that utterly refused to receive any Roman orders or customes from the said Austin in the Service of God though he urged them thereunto by many terrible threats Again Sain Gregory being then Bishop of Rome of whom it is said none of all his successours were for Holiness and Learning worthy to be compared with him when he had sent this Austin hither to preach the Gospel he gave him his instructions in this manner Where you finde any thing that seemeth ☞ better to the Service of God then is in the Church of Rome Choose you the same and do your endeavour to bring into the English Church the best and choicest things Choose out of many Churches for things are not to be loved for the place sake but the place is to be loved for the things that are good By these instances it may appear that this Church in those dayes did not in their publick service of God conform to the order of the Church of Rome neither did that Church impose any such order upon us In process of time indeed it came to pass that there were sundry Orders came here into use especially that of Sarum compiled by Osmund Earl of Dorset and Bishop of Salisbury which continued for above five hundred years till the reign of Edward the sixth In all which time the Romish Superstitions in Divine worship were too
they were all of such venerable Antiquity Howsoever the matter of them being sound and Catholick and because it is not to be imagined that one Osmund though an Earl and a Bishop should be generally owned for Os mundi the Speaker to the whole Church in the Liturgy of it we may safely affirm that the said Collects are of the same pure primitive Original with the rest of our Church-Service The form of Letany in the next place which is most cavill'd at was ordered by Saint Gregory Lib. 9. Indict 4. Epi. 45. while Rome continued in the state of innocency to be used in the Church of Sicily without intermission upon the fourth and sixth dayes of every week which our Liturgy in a conformity thereunto enjoyneth to be said or sung upon the same dayes viz. Wednesdayes and Fridayes Lib 1. De vocatione Gentium And Saint Ambrose who was above two hundred years before him saith That this form of publick devotion in the Church for the substance of it was so generally observed Vt nulla pars mundi sit in qua hujusmodi orationes non celebrentur à populis Christianis That there was no part of the world where these Prayers were not used in Christian Assemblies Non solum pro Sanctis in Christo regeneratis sed etiam pro omnibus infidelibus inimicis crucis Christi pro omnibus Idolorum cultoribus pro haereticis schismaticis c. Even as we do at this day in our Letany not onely praying that God would be pleased to bless and keep all his people but that he would bring into the way of Truth all such as have erred and are deceived Our Versicles and Responds we oftentimes meet with in Primitive Liturgies E. g The Lord be with you And with thy Spirit Lord have mercy upon us Christ have mercy upon us c. Lift up your hearts We lift them up unto the Lord. Let us give thanks unto the Lord It is meet and right so to do c. Thus saith Saint Chrysostome The Priest in the holy Ministration speaks unto the people In 2. ad Cor. Hom. 18. and the people unto the Priest to quicken their devotion and to testifie their unanimity in the Service of God Neither is our Alternate singing though it be not enjoyned in our Liturgy without good warrant from that Antiquity which we ought to reverence Lib. 2 cap. 24. Theodoret writeth that Davids Psalms were sung in the Church of Antioch by the Quire of Singers one side answering the other in their singing Act. 11.26 Which order it seems beginning there as the Appellative title of Christian did Ad fines orbis terrarum tandem pervenit saith he was at length spread over the world And this saith Sozomen wrought marvellously upon Theodosius Lib. 7. cap. 23. diverting him from his intended purpose of destroying the Citizens of Antioch because of some contempts which they had put upon him For as the said Historian relates it they fearing the Emperours displeasure repented them of what they had done against him much bewailing their near approaching ruine and having prevailed with Flavianus their Bishop to intercede for them took this course according to his directions Some of them when the Emperour sat at his table came into his presence singing Psalms after the manner of Antioch that is Antiphonicws one answering the other wherewith the Emperour being a religious Prince was so taken that he let go his anger was reconciled to their City Phialam quam manu tenebat lachrymis obortis irrigavit The Cup which he held in his hand he watered with his tears and so mingled his drink with weeping In fine Lib. 6. cap. 8. This manner of Antiphone in the Church was saith Socrates occasioned first by a vision of Angels which Ignatius Bishop of Antioch that faithful servant of Jesus Christ who had been conversant with the Apostles had presented unto him whom he heard lauding the blessed Trinity with Responsory Hymns the Pattern whereof he commended to that Church to be ever after observed and practised by them Vnde ad omnes Ecclesias ista traditio promanavit saith the Historian From whence also that order of singing went among all the Churches Many more Instances might be produced to witness that our Liturgy is not of such an upstart Original as to derive its Extraction from Rome since by her Apostatizing she hath chang'd her name into Babylon But we must not extra oleas vagari and these few may suffice to convince gain-sayers of their false and uncharitable accusation of our Church-Service as that it is Superstitious and Idolatrous because Popish and Babylonish which is so unjust a calumniation that as it hath been observed There is not any one Protestant Divine of any note or eminency even among the Reformers of Religion who did ever condemn our Service-Book of the least point of Popery but rather many among them did highly commend it Yea and Sir Edward Cook that Oracle of the Law of England unto whom we have reason for his Gravity Courage and integrity in his place and calling notwithstanding all the oblatrations of Popish Rabshekah's against him to give some heed more then ordinary Such was P.R. in his reckonings with Bp. Morton about Equivocation The like is also a. vouched by D. Ben. Carrier in hit letter to K. James pag. 126. He I say affirmeth with much confidence That Pope Pius Quintus wrote unto Queen Elizabeth a letter about the tenth year of her Reign offering to allow and ratifie the English Service-Book if she would accept it as from him which she refusing to do he did excommunicate her and by his Bull roared out an Inhibition to all his party called Roman Catholicks that they should not from thenceforth go to any of our Churches while the said Service-Book was read though to the hearing of our Sermons a Toleration was granted unto them To conclude Since the Primitive Pattern is thought fit next to the holy Scriptures to be a Standard for Church-Orders in the Service of God throughout the Christian world let our adversaries and friends too but conform unto it in such a manner as we have done since we separated from Rome and I dare boldly say we shall have no just cause in the sight of God to charge one another with Superstition And now that Imputation of Superstition upon the account of our Liturgy being with as much brevity as the matter could well bear yet sufficiently if not satisfactorily to our irrefragable opponents removed We should undertake the vindication likewise of Episcopal Government for that also is by our Objectours brought under the same Censure But concerning this neither need there much be said it being abundantly cleared of late against those that have openly professed themselves enemies to that Government We shall not here repeat the Arguments that have been used in the behalf of Episcopacy such an unsipid crambe must