out Firm. True 't is such dirt has been cast upon that Sacred Order by ignorant and discontented persons such an one was Aerius the first Anti-Episcopal man we read of but this groundless opinion is abundantly confuted by the Testimony of holy Scripture by the practise of the â—niversal Church attested by the general consent of Fathers and Councels as you may see in Dr. Hammond's book against Blondel Dr. Taylor 's treatise of the Divine right of Episcopacy with many others First The Scripture is clean for differrent Orders in the Clergy Our blessed Saviour besides his Seaventy Disciples had his Twelve Apostles which were superior to them as is evident by the chusing of Matthias into the place of Iudas from the example of Timothy and Titus the one a â—ishop of Creet the other of Ephesus by the general consent of Antiquity in those and other Churches In that once famous Church of Rome we have the Catalogue of those Bishops which presided there about Thirty of them suffering Martyrdom for the Testimony of our Lord Jesus What should I mention the Angels of the Seaven Asiatick Churches which by the general consent of the Fâ—thers were the Bishops of those Churches nay St. Hierome himself no good friend to this Order does acknowledg That when Christians began to he divided one being of Paul an other of Cephas to prevent such Schisms there past an vniversal Decree throughout the world Thâ—t Bishops should be setled in every Citty who should govern with the Common Councel of the Bresbyters and that one of the Bresbyters should be elected and set over the rest for taking away the seeds of Schism Dub. I am very well perswaded by what you have said that the Primitive goverment of the Church was by Bishops with the assistance of the Presbyterie who had authority over the Presbyters and were their superiors But I pray you satisfie me in this one thing Why did St. Paul so shâ—rply reprove the Corinthians for not excommunicating the Incestuous Person if they had no authority so to do without a Bishop Firm. This at the first sight seems to be a very smart objection but if we seriously consider the words upon which 't is grounded it has no weight at all The Text that is cited to prove it is 1. Corinth 5.2 Ye are puffed up and have not rather mourned that he that hath done this deed might be taken away from among you Where the Apostle reproves them for want of humiliation for so soul a sin not for the neglect of Excommunication He that had committed that great sin was to be taken away or cut off from the â—hurch but they themselves could not exclude him but this was to be done by the Spirit of St. Paul verse 3 4. in whom the power of Jurisdiction was originally â—eated there being then no Bishop of Corinth for evident it is that in those Churches where there were no Bishops the Apostles kept the power of Jurisdiction in their own hands until Bishops were setled among them as is manifest in the Churches of Ephesus and Creet Neither can it ever be proved that Bresbyters as such had any Jurisdiction belonging to the publick goverment of the Church but by particular Substitution and Delegation from the Apostles and Bishops and noâ— by virtue of their own Order Dub. I am very well satisfied both from Scripture and the general practise of the Church which is the best Comment on the Text That Episcopacy is an Apostolical Institution and I confess I am much confirm'd in this perswasion by Gods blessing upon our English Bishops and Episcopal men such as Cranmer Ridley Iewel Carlton Abbots Morton Andrews Vsher who of English extraction Hall Laud and Sanderson Hooker Cracanthorp Iackson c. whose profound Learning and Piety has given the greatest wounds to the Church of Rome that ever she received â—rom any Protestant writers and their judicious works have been the strongest sence against Popery Heresie Rebellion and Schism that the Christian world can ever boast of Firm. I much rejoyce that you have so good an opinion of our Bishops and Episcopal men I hope the Authority of these renowned Worthies will weigh much with you in our following discourses We will now if you please proceed to your exceptions against Deans and Chapters you shall find all those Learned men before mentioned and many more your opposites in this your second exception as well as in the former Dub. 'T is probable I shall however that I may receive full satisfaction from you give me leave to propose some doubts and scruples which I have against them As 1. They were not from the Beginning but as it were of yesterday 2. They seem to be very useless serving only to maintain the pride and grandure of many idle drones 3. Many poor Parochial Churches are rob'd of their Tiths and Glebs to maintain such lazy Ministers 4. Their Vicars Choral and Singing-men are many of them of no very commendable conversation have little sense or relish of Religion 5. Their Toning of Prayers their Chore service is like a Latine Masse not understood by the people 6. Their Organs and other Musical Instruments are Levitical utterly unlawful under the Gospel Firm. You may think these are such knots which admit of no easy solution but I shall presently make you understand the contrary First I shall shew you that Cathedrals Deans and Chapters though not under those names were from the beginning of Christianity It is clear from the Acts of the Apostles and the Records of the Church that the Apostles and Disciples of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ those spiritual Fishermen cast in their nets where they were like to make the greatest and most advantegious draughts They usually Preached in the most Populous Citys where they established Churches which anon after were called Mother-Churches to which the Suburbican or those that dwelt in the adjacent Villages were subject and with the Mother-Churches made up the Bishops Diocess which they governed as St. Hirome confesses by the common councel and assistance of Presbiters termed at Rome in after times Cardinals or chief Presbiters and in the time of Charles the great as the Magdeburgenses inform us were incorpated into a Colledge under the name of Dem and Chapter the Dean by the Canon-law being called Arch-Presbiter Before the sounding of Universsitys these Cathedrals were the Schools of the Prophets where young Students were train'd up in the Study of Divinity and other good learning Gerard gives us a tast of their first institution their corruption and how they might be restored to their primitive uses I could wish that some learned Person who has the advantage of Books and well Studyed men to consult with and leisure all which we Country Ministers are deprived of would write in the Vindication of Cathedrals and manifest to this invidious age that the institution of Deans and Chapters is very usefull to the Church and very Antient as I
their lives and conversations very scandalous the greatest Nonconformists of all others not true to our Church and her injunctions in the most weighty matters placing all their Conformity in outward Ceremonies and neglecting what is most necessary for their own salvation and of those poor Souls which are committed to their charge which are in great danger to perish through the ignorance negligence and evil example of such blind guids Dub. But is not the poverty of many of them and the poor pittances allotted for their subsistence as great a cause of their contempt as any Firm. 'T is very true and 't were a work worthy of the Defendor of the Faith and a Religious Parliament to redress this very great grievance by uniting Little Churches by finding out some effectual means for restoring of Impropriate Tithes and Glebs to their respective Ministers which Impropriations are the very dregs of Popery and a grand Sacriledge in any one that shall detain them from the Church Dub. I do a little wonder why you should câ—ll Impropriations Popish seeing many of those who took up arms against King Charles the First diâ— it upon thâ— account of opposing Popery and hindering the groâ—th of iâ— in this â—â—nd and yet some of them are no â—mall Iâ—pâ—opâ—iaâ—ors Firm. Certainly there was never a more manifest peicâ— of hypocrisy in the world for men to be so seemingly zealous against the superstitions of Rome and yet be so deeply in love with her Sacriledge Surâ—ly there is some marvellous sweetness in Tiths and Church lands that prelatical Presbyteâ—ians all parties can swallow down such morsels without any scruple but let them take heed they prove not like that little Book Rev. 10.9 sweet to the palate but bitter in the belly Dub. Indeed I have heard that the Popes of Rome were the first and cheifest Authors of Impropriations and that they did alienate Tiâ—hs and Glebes from their respected Parish Churches for the maintenance of Abbies Priories Nunneries c. Firm. 'T is veâ—y certain that these alienations were made by the Authority of the Bishop of Rome for those uses and at the demolishing of those places those Impropriate Tiths and Church lands were either given or sold to Courtiers and other of the Nobility and Gentry which has proved the ruine of many Antient and flourishing Families and a very great hinderance to the growth of Religion for want of an able Ministry in many poor Parishes where according to the old saying Scandalous livings have made a scandalous Clergy and nothing would be a more effectual redress of this grievance then as was said before the Uniting of litle Parishes the restoring of Impropriate Tiths and Glebes to the Church together with a diligent inspection of the Bishops into the lives and learning of all those whom they shall either Ordain or Institute Dub. I am fully perswaded that the paying of Tiths is no oppression or injury to any man but the Independents and other Sectaries imagine that Tiths are a Levitical maintenance and therefore to be abrogated under the Gospel that Ministers now are to be maintain'd by a voluntary Contribution or at best to have a set stipend Firm. That Tiths received not their beginning from the Levitical Law is evident to any unbyased judgment from the example of Abrahams paying them to Melchisedeck of Iacobs vowing to give the Tenth of all that the Lord should bless him with from the Apostles large discourse about Abraham and Melchisedeck Heb. 7. By all which 't is evident that Tiths had not their Original from the Levitical â—aw and were not at first affixt to the Arâ—nical but to the Melchisedechian Priesthood As to that of Stipend and Voluntary Contribution 't is a meer plot of the Devil and Popish Emissaries to render Ministers contemptible by â—aking them Stipendiaries or Eleemosynaries directly contrary to what St. Paul has laid down The Elders that rule well are worthy of double honor which sufficiently evinceth that they ought to have an honorable maintainance and not to depend upon the cold and frozen Charity of the people I am sure St. Paul found his Corinthians very backward to supply the Ministers necessity in better times then these we live in like so many Stipendaries or Alms-men by which they will be forceâ— to Preach placentia or starve and suit their Doctrine to the humor of every Mechanick What a strange piece of non-sense is it that amongst our Congregational men the Minister should be the only poor Dependent 'T is most certain and evident to all that can make use of their reason that Gods way for the Ministers maintenance is the best which both before and under the Law given by Moses was by Tiths at least by God's approving of Abâ—aham's paying them to Melchisedeck ' â—was strongly insinuated that the great Lord of Heaven and Earth would in after times order and appoint that Tiths should be the maintenance for the Priest and Levite which has continued for many hundreds of years under the Gospel and there are many fair proofs from holy Scripture that they are due by Divine Right they are established by Civil and Ecclesiastical Laws are the most convenient and rational way for the Ministers support who by this meanes when the earth brings forth plenâ—ifully shares with the people in that blessing when less fruitfully as in times of scarcity suffers with them in this Calamity and thus partaking with them in blessings and affliâ—â—ions will be the fitter to Stir them up thankfulneâ—sâ— for the one and to press upon them the great duties of Patience and Humiliation under the other Dub. I did not doubt of the lawfulness and reasonableness of Tiths before we entred upon this discourse but now there is not the least scruple in me concerning them Firm. Therefore let us now proceed to another gross error maintaind by the Independents and other Sectaries about the electing of gifted Brethren into the office of Ministers Dub. That any gifted Brother any one that perswades himself that he has the Spirit and through a strong imagination conceives himself fit to Speak in the Congregation may without any farther tryal or lawfull call take upon him the office of Publick Preaching and Ministring in the Congregation which is the most sacred and weighty of of all other This is nothing less then a presumptuous usruping of the Priests office This I know to be the Opinion and practise of Independents and other Sectareis let me have your judgment of it Firm. That you shall most willingly And herein my judgment is that this is one of the most wild and Fanatick opinions that ever entred into the minds of men that it opens a wide gap to all Schisms and Heresies a certain cause of all manner of disorder and confusions in the Church upon this account Priests and Jesuits and all manner of Sectaries have had so fair an oppâ—rtunity to vent their poysonous Tenents in theâ—â— Independent Congregations Dub. I am fully
before intimâ—ted although under other names and I do somwhat wonder that neither Bishop Dean or Ganon so far as I know has hitherto vindicated these Churches from those reproaches which have been cast upon them by ignorant spitefull sacrilegious persons Dub. But do not we see that Bishops Deans and Canons do not joyn together in the goverment of the Church but rather are at variance and oppose one another are mostly Non-resident keep not that Hospitality which their Predecessors usually did and therefore they being thus useless 't were fit their lands were sold and imployed to better purposes Firm. This was your second exception against Cathedrals but a very frivelous one drawn from the worst Topick from personal abuses to take a way the true use of the thing it selfe This is meer Clowns Logick and makes as much against Parish Churcheâ— Schools Universities and all Courts of Justice as against Cathedrals The abuses ought to be taken away I am as much for a reformation as any man but not for an extirpation If Bishops Deans and Chapters do not joyn together in the Goverment of the Church 't is the fault of their Persons not of their Institution Deans and Canons ought to be of Councel to the Bishop in a subordinate way not to have cordinate power and Authority with him If they are too much guilty of non-residence as it cannot be denyed but that many of them are this ought to be reformd by Mulcts and Punishments but especially by those that have the power of collating those dignities that they do not confer them upon any person that lives out of the Diocess or at too great a distance from the Cathedral which is a very great abuse and wants Reformation As for the keeping of Hospitality the cavil is just the same which the Egiptyans had against the Isralits for not fulfilling their tale of Brick when they denyed them straw to make it Sacrilegious hands have Robbed Cathedrals of many of their rich Mannors and how should it be possible for Deans and Prebends to maintain that Hospitality which their Predecessors heretofore have kept I know a Canon of one of the most Auntient Cathedrals in England that his necessary expences in his Residence journeys being deducted did not receive de claro five pounds yearly for seven years in twelve Now according to the law of God and nature Families Wives and Children must be provided for and how can such necessary provision and any considerable Hospitality stand together out of an Hundred Marks or an Hundred Pounds of yeary Income which is more then some Cathedral Residentaries do receive to my knowledge I wish that those of the Gentry who have their Thousands of yearly Revenues would forbear their squandring away of their Rich Patrymonies in vanities and very sinful courses that they would keep Hospitality and Residence upon their own Rich Mannors amongst their poor Tenants and Neighbours who eat the Bread of carefulness and then they might with greater confidence câ—vil at the non-residence and wâ—nt of Hospitality in the â—lergy The best way to pull out the Moth which they discover in the Churches eye is first of â—ll to cast out the Beam which is in their own eye Second Whereas you object that Cathedral dignities are made subservient to the pride and luxury of the Idle and lazy Ministers my reply shall be very short If any such be â—rept into such places I shall not be their advocate but be ready to throw the first Stone at them But I pray you do not cast such dirt upon those who have laboured in the word and doctrine but esteem them worthy of double honor however the infirmities of old age have now seized upon them dimness of sight weakness of memory an hoarse voice and feeble lungs If these Cathedral perferments be great encouragements to younger men which none but Fools and Sacrilegious persons will deny VVhy may not such places be as so many Ecclesiastical Hospitals for these Milites emiriti old souldiers of Jesus Christ who have war'd a good warfare and though now they are less able to teach in the Pulpit yet may they instruct out of it by their grave and exemplary lives and sage councels 1. Tim. 5.17 Let the Elders that rule well 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 not 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 be worthy of double honor Dub. I beg your pardon for those hasty words that dropt from me against Cathedrals I clearly understand they are not so useless as the ignorance envy and malice of some men would render them Let me hear from you how you can vindicate them from defrauding Parochial Churches of their Tithes and Glebs by appropriating them to themselves Firm. This exception cannot totally be avoided yet Cathedrals are not so much in fault as the Supream power of the land which took away their rich Mannors and gave them in their stead lean and scandalous Impropriations which as some say was done in policy to prevent their total abolition which fate Abbies and Priories had lately sufferred under for those rich Mannors being exchanged for poor Impropriations Cathedrals were not now so sweet and lushious morsels to sacrilegious palates Dub. But is there no meanes to augment the maintenance of those Churches whose Tithes are Impropriate to Cathedrals Firm. At his Majesties happy Restauration there was a fair opportunity which offerred it self the like we cannot expect How easie had it been then to have setled a competent maintenance upon most Churches in the Nation Some augmentations by his Majesties appointment were then made I wish there had been more I know no other way to redress this grievance but by annexing some Prebends unto the Vicaridges of these Impropriated Churches which might be done in Cathedrals of the old Foundation where there are minor Prebendaries distinct from Residentiaries mean while those Parochial Churches are supplyed mostly by the Vicars Choral whose maintenance from their Colledge and privy Tithes received from those Churches where they serve is not contemptible I wish 't were better and that some of them by their industry and conscientious diligence in their Ministry did deserve a better subsistance at which wish no man can take exceptions but he that is guilty of ignorance or negligence in the duty of his calling which is his fault in being so and not mine in wishing it should be otherwise Dub. I perceive by your discourse that 't is rather the unhappiness then the fault of Cathedrals that Parochial Tithes are appropriated unto them but certainly iâ— Canons Residentiaries were Beneficed in or near the Citties where Cathedrals are scituate and a competent maintenance allowed them from the respective Cittizens the Vicars Choral those of them who are not Preachers might assist as Curates for Baptizings Burials and other inferiour Offices and so by the continual residence of the Bishops Deanes Canons and Vicars Choral the Chore service Preaching Catechizing Church discipline and Goverment might be much better performed then
now it is and those scandals and reproaches which are so frequently cast upon Cathedrals more rationally be confuted Firm. I much approve of what you say for the Non-residency of Bishops Deans and Canons and the remote Vicaridges of Vicars Choral from their respective Cathedrals is the just occasion that the service of God is very perfunctorily performed to the great scandal of the Goverment of the Church which we can look upon as a grieveance but 't is only in the power of King and Parliament to redress Dub. The Lord put it into their hearts to undertake so good and pious a work â—et me now hear what you can answer to what is objected against the Lives aâ—e Conversations of Vicars Choral Petty Canons Singing-men as they are setled in some Cathedrals Eiruâ— My answer is That the charge is too general and favours of want of Charity That some of them may be such whose conversation is not so commendable as it should be or that they have not that sense and relish of â—eligion which ought to be in men of that Place and Calling I fear may too justly be charged upon them but much of this dirt might be wiped off by the constant Residence grave Example and strict Discipline of those to whom the goverment of the Church belongs 'T is confessed that through the corruption of our natures the best duties frequently perform'd are apt to degenerate into cold and airy formalities 'T is the great happiness of those Christians which dwel near Cathedrals that they may meet Three tâ—mes a day Evening Morning and Noon to offer up prayer and praises to the High and Holy God but 't is very much to be lamented that Cittizens and others not hindred by necessarie occasions should be so frequently absent from these solemn Assemblies as usually they are It is yet more to be lamented that those whose duty it is to officiate at those solemn services should look upon them as a pâ—nsum a task a burden as naughty boyes at school do their lessons how far are such stupid souls from holy David's zeal and piety One thing saith that good King Psal. 22.4 have I desired of the Lord which I shall seek after that I may dwel in the house of the Lord all the daies of my life to behold the beauty of the Lord and to enquire in his Temple Want of sense zeal at holy Offices is not the fault of Chore or Quire service but of those that Officiate who if they will seriously fix their hearts upon those holy duties when they sing and give praise as David did attending to the matter of their heavenly and ravishing Anthems as well as to the Musick they would not look â—pon the service as a burden but as a blessed opportunity thus to praise Almighty God in the beauty of Holyness Dub. Happily it might be so to those who understood those Anthems but I have heard some say that the singing in Chores is to them much like a Latine service they knowing not what is sung Firm. This is your Fift Exception and 't is indeed a very weak one there being none who frequent this service but know very well what is sung unless it be the full Anthem let those that make this objection frequent this service and then they will be ashamed of so frivelous a Cavile and easily perceive the fault to have been in themselves and not in the service Dub. There is one exception yet behind against your Chore service as the use of Musicall Instruments in the performance of a great part of it which are said to be Levitical and therefore unlawful under the Gospel as we have seen in the Geneva Notes upon the last Psalm as also in Aquinas Quest. 22.9 19. and divers other Learned Men. Firm. This is a very gross mistake for Musical Instruments are not part of the Levitical law never instituted by Moses who was so faithful a servant in his trust that he would not have omitted to enjoyn them had they been given him in Charge by Allmighty God They were in use long before Moses presently after the Creation of the world for Gen. 4. we read that the rare gift of playing on Musical Instruments was given to Iubal Can we imagine that such a gift was bestowed on him to Stir up wantonness and lust by the more artificial singing of unsavory Sonnets Or is it not more rational to conceive that this skil in Musick was given to men to Sing forth the Praises of our great Creator in a more excellent manner When we Glorify the Lord we ought to exalt him as much as we can Ecclesiasticus 43.30 And surely if Musick has a natural influence upon our affections to Stir up and quicken them in wantoness and daliance certainly it may work the same effect upon them to quicken and enliven them in a more devout and intensive Praising of Almighty God in all those that have a Religious tendency and a serious disposition to his worship and service besides seing 't is a moral and perpetual duty to shew forth the Praises of God all rational men will consent that this ought to be performed after the best manner and consequently with such skil and are that has the greatest influence upon our affections rather then after such a manner which renders the service of God mean and contemptible as 't is rendred in many of our Parochial Churches Dub. You have fully satisfied me that Musical Instruments in the service of God are not Levitical but are natural means to Stir up the affections in these sacred Hyms and Anthems Nevertheless I have heard that many who are much taken with Chore Anthems are much offended at the manner of reading of Prayers in Cathedrals when they pray for the Sick they use the ordinary tone which is used in Parish Churches at other times they pronounce their Prayers in a middle way between Reading and Singing Which seems to be not so grave and sutable to the Solemnity of Prayer Firm. I confess this is a common objection and some that are no enimies to Cathedral service have in this much desired a reformation but this must be left to the prudence of those that set at the Serne mean while we ought not to condemn the Quireservice for this seeming indecency well knowing that the stress of Religious duties does not consist in the toning and modulation of the voice but in the Musick of the heart and affections in a serious and devout fixing of the mind upon the things that are Read or Sung the want of which in those who Read Prayers or Sing Anthems is no little sin and one main reason why some of our Singing-men are not so seriously devout as they ought to be really those that are frequently present officiating in holy duties unpreparedly carelessly formally and irreverently by Gods just judgment may be given up to a senceless stupidity for their prophanation of the holy ordinances of God Dub. 'T
in the Bible Firm. I believe you yet you will not say that the best Sermon that ever was made by man is to be preferâ— before a portion of sacred Scripture The explication or application of the word mixt with much of mans conceptions before the pure word it self and esteem the hearing of it read useless and unlawful Dub. God forbid I should Firm. You see by this one instance how fallible your own phantiful experience has been and how it has lead you against Scripture against the general practise of the Church against all sober reason so dangerous a thing it is for men of short discourse that are not masters of reason but are guided to phansies over powred by passions engaged in parties to meddle with controversies which are too high and hard for them Dub. I confesse that 't was no great wonder that so mean a man as I should be mistaken but 't is very strange that so many grave and learned men as were in the late Assembly should be so much against the Common Prayer Book of the Church of England which I have heard learned men affirme to be the best Liturgie in the world Firm. 'T was very strange that so many learned men should be overborn by some leading men that had more zeal than judgmâ—nt and happily more of interest and designe then of learning and piety but as there have been Parliament-drivers so there have been Assembly-drivers and Convocation-drivers before you or I were born and will be after we are in our graves And I am confident thaâ— disgâ—ised Priests and Jesuits have had more then one finger in animating the Presbiterians against the Church of England as well as to my knowledge they have had in somenting Anabaptisme and Quaquerisme soâ— 't is their Maxime divide impera divide the Hereticks and wâ—e shall Reign I have more charity then to believe that the Assembly the greatest part of them were of opinion that set Forms of Prayer were either useless or unlawful though they cannot be excused from too much compliance I fear against their own judgments They could not be ignorant that the vote against the Book of Common-Prayer was contrary to the sentiments of the most learned men in all the Reformed Churches beyond Sea of very sober men in this Nation known heretofore by the name of Puritans the most discreet and moderate of that Party were never against set forms of the Reverend Bishops of the Church of England many of which sacred order have beeâ— as famous in their generation both for learning and piety as former ages ever knew yea since His Majesties happy Restauration the chiefest of the Presbiterian perswasion have acknowledged set forms of Prayer in publick to be lawful they plainly confess in their Conference with the Bishops they are not against them but every daies experience will make it evident they must be for them as well as not against them unlesâ— the late Assembly could have as easily voted and made all Ministers of the Church of England Discreet Judicious Orthodox and of a ready Elocution as they did rashly and inconsiderately vote down the Liturgie Besides the Congregation especially the weaker sort those tâ—at are ignorant and cannot read may better joyn in prayer when the Forms of iâ— are known and common then they can in strange â—nd extemporary expressions with which they are â—ltogether unacqainted which being the practise in the late tiâ—es of confusion has taught the people only to hear prayers as if they were so many Sermons wherein they were not at all concerned to joyn with their hearts and tongues and to say Amen or as if the ear were the only member to be imployed in that holy duty Again Set and prescribed Forms consisting of Scriptural phrases and expressions unaffected and â—â—tted to the understanding of the meanest câ—pacitie are soonest received into the heart and aptest to excite and carry along with them judicious and steady â—ffections as King Charles the Firâ—â— haâ— observed in his most excellent Book Hereunto may be added That out of well composed Forms the weaker Christians may be furnished with a stock of wholesome expressions composed by the advice joynt sistance of the cheif Pastors and Ministers of thâ— Church for their help and direction in their private Devotions which iâ— imposible to bâ— done by the suddain various uncertain expressions of divers particular Ministers Besides Set Forms are necessary for uniformity in the publick worship and upon this account learned and sober men have wished there were but one publick Liturgie in all Christian Churches in the world which if it were possible would be a great means of peace and unity amongst Christians by preventing the spreading of Schisms and Heresies that may be as well prayed up as preached up as also undecent unscriptural expressions tautologies vain-repetitions phantastical affected words and phrases utterly abhorrent from the sobriety and gravity of Divine Oratory which is quite another thing from that of the Stage or Desk Lastly Should we deal with an understanding Recusant endeavouring to perswade him to forsake his superstitious worship and to joyn himself to our Assemblies how could we assure him if we have no publick established Liturgie that our way and manner of worship is and shall continue Scripture-proof sound and innocent without errours and indecencies Do we think that any wise man would leave his Popish blind way of worship to be guided by our dark Lanthorn not being rationaly assured after what way we do worship the God of our Fathers which we cannot satisfie him in if we have no set Liturgie Dub. I very much approve of your reasons for Publick Set Forms of Prayer as also of your â—nswer to that argument drawn from Experience which appears so great and mighty to some mens vain imaginations but is indeed very weak and fallacious Firm. You must give me leave to adde Two things more in answer to that argument drawn from Experience and then we will discourse of those exceptions against our Common-Player in particular 1. I will oppose experience to experience those that reproâ—ch our Common-prayer for a cold and dry Service extolling extemporary conceptions so much beyond it let these men make this easie experiment to themselves Let them take some of thâ— best of extemporary prayers verbatim which your Short-hand-writers can exactly do let these prayers be read or repeated memoriter with all the advantages of pleasing tones bodily gesticulations lively pronunciations and assure your self they will at length appear to be as dull dry and cold as any part of our Liturgie 2. I would have you seriously consider what the most judiceous Hooker sayes concerning Sermons and Reading of Scripture why the former are so highly esteem'd and the other so much slighted the truth is they please more then Lessons and Chapters by reason of those outward advantages which a Sermon well delivered has above thâ— Scripture barely read besides the singular attention and affection which
tender consciences and the occasions of many shâ—rp contentions amongst Christians agreeing in the substantials of Religion and seing that Conformists themselves confess them not to be in their own nature necessary but only expedient for order and decency were it not better they were laid aside then continued is they are the perpetual causes of discord and dissention amongst us Firm. And are order decency and uniformity without which there wiâ—l be neither â—ove Peace or Unity suâ—h inconsiderable nothings that a few innocent Ceâ—emonies must be utterly abollished to gratifie the dogmatizing humors of those men who esteem things in themselves indifferent to be sinful and unlawful which is sâ—â—t Superstition 'T is indeed much to be lamented that we should quarrel about Mint and Cummin to the prejudice of more weighty and material duties and the scandal of our Religion But by reason of our innâ—te and acquited corruptions 't is necessary that offences should come yet wo be unto that man by whom they come I know weakness and renderness of conscience is much pretended and we ought to take heed how we offend any of Christs little ones but how can these men be reckon'd in the number of weak or little ones who seem to themselves so great so strong and able in the things of Religion and for their tendernesse of conscienâ—e we appeal to their bloody civil Warrs 't is well known by whom and how they were began and carryâ—d on till at length they came up to the death of the King tho I believe very much against the intentions and designs of the most grave and sober men of that Party Dub. But really Sir were it not more beseeming Christian prudence so far to condescend to our dissenting Brethren who agree with us in the Doctrine of our Church in taking away at least some of those Ceremonies which are more liable to exception then to comply with the Superstitious Papists in the use of them Firm. I confess some moderate men have thought so especially since we are frustrated of of one main end for which our first reformers retained them which was to draw over the Papists into the Communion of our Church which they did adhere unto for the Ten first years of Queen Elizabeth until they were interdicted by the Popes bull But seeing we are deprived of all hopes of that much desired issue and that by the cunning of Priests and Jesuits stirring up and animating the Conformists and Non-conformists against each other about these Ceremonies Our differences amongst our selves do daily increase and multiply some wise and peaceable men have desired that the use of certain of those Ceremonies might be forborn at least for a time which not withstanding they are still continued These peaceable men abhor the great sin of Separation do continue their conformity to the rites of our Church daily begging at the throne of Grace that the God of truth and peace would for his mercy â—ake so assist those powers which he has ordained that they may be instrumental for the establishing of truth and peace amongst us Dub. I like well of the temper of these men and wish that their moderation were not only known unto but practised by all men for certainly if the Spirit of love peace and meekness did rule more in our peevish and froward hearts we should enjoy a greater measure of Peace Love and Christian Charity then these angry times have hither to been happy with I return you my hearty thanks for that satisâ—action which you have given me in those scruples which have much troubled me about the Goverment Liturgie and Ceremonies of the Church of England there is yet one thing behind at which I have somwhat been scandalliz'd 't is this Your Church does receive persons who are notoriously proâ—hâ—ne in their lives and grossly ignorant in the principls of Religion to the Holy Sacrament of the body and blood of Christ besides she tollerates at least Ministers that are scandalous in their conveâ—sâ—tion frequenters of Alâ—-houses not at all serious in Religion shew little sence of it in their discourses Preaching or practises men of little conscience and of as little learning Firm. This accusation is most fals whether it springs from spite or malice or extream ignorance I know not sure I am our Church orders that no suâ—h persons be admitted to the Holy Sacrament thâ—t no such Ministers be permitted to officiate that they are to be suspended once and again and if they do no not reform they are to be deprived for the first you may see the Rubrick before the Communion and the 26. Canon For the Second see Artic 26. and Canon the 74. and 75. and Canon 10. made 1640. which are so clear against the admitting of profane persons to to the Communion or tollerating of scandalous Ministers without due Punishment that whosoever chargeth these abuses upon our Church must be grosly ignorant or very malitious Dub. Yet we see that such prophane persons are admitted to the Sacrament as members of your Church and such unworthy Minsters are allowed to officiate Firm. Such persons are no members of out Church but rather the Synagoge of Satan and that Minister who does admit such persons natoriously prophane to the Holy Sacrament is a greater Non-conâ—ormist to the orders of the Church then he that scruples at a Surplice and those Church-wardens who neglect to present them are guilty of Perjury and ought to be debar'd themselves from the Communion Can. 26. Dub. 'T is evident that such Ministers are not Punished either by Admonition Suspensition or Deprivation Firm. This is not true in all places to my knowledge where such Ministers or people escape unpunished 't is mostly by the fault of the Church-wardens and Sides-men in not presenting them for what Judge either Ecclesiastical or Civil can punish offences that are not brought before him Dub. But many times offences and scandalâ— have been presented and the offender not punisâ—â—d yea your Ecclesiastical Judges are more severe against those who are Non-conformists to the laws oâ— the Church â—hen agâ—inst those that are Non-conformists to the laws of God as profane irreligeous wretches Firm. No mâ—n câ—n excuse the personal abuses that are committed in any Court Civil or Ecclesiastical all Court Officers never yet were nor ever will be men of integrity â—nd of unbias'd judgments no question that many abuses which are committed by the Officers of Ecclesiastical Courts might be prevented if the Bishops would be somtimes personally present in their respective consistoâ—ies as was intimated they ought to be Canon 11. made 1640. If we must seperate from a Church that enjoyns no Intollerable conditions for Communion with her because of some personal â—aulâ—s of those who are entrusted with her Goverment we must turn Seekers for where shall we find a Church whose Officers are alwaies all of them impartially just and upright Dub. I confess there is no good reason we should seperate from a Church