their Allegiance What think you of the Popes Nnncio at the head of the Irish Army Sir if you will give your self the freedom impartially to consider the Answers that are made by the Romish Writers to excuse what is charged upon them for these and some other loose Doctrines and practices you will find it no Fable That their defences dwindle into mere evasions I shall now conclude your trouble and my own with a few Animadversions upon the whole matter First That how hot soever your Zeal may grow for the Church of Rome you might have done much better service for the Church Catholick if you had continued in the Communion of that part of it which is established in this Kingdom Secondly To use the word of the Ingenious Author of The Notion of Schisme that for any to desert the Church of England to communicate with that of Rome is such a framick humor as for a man to quit the neatest appartment and exchange for the most sluttish Rooms in the same House Thirdly That you have given a scandal to your Brethren of the Church of England contrary to that Caveat and Admonition of the Apostle 1 Cor. 10.32 Estius ad locum And he that gives offence to his Brother sins against God whose handy-work he destroys Rom. 14.20 He sins also against Christ in destroying him for whom Christ died Rom. 14.15 Fourthly and Lastly That by withdrawing your self from that subjection and obedience which by the Laws of the Catholick Church you owe to your own Bishop Primate or Metropolitan you run desperately into Schisme while you are superstitiously solicitous to avoid it For Schisma est contumax adversus Episcopum rebehio quâ quis ejus communionem deserit c. Schisme is a plain Rebellion against the Bishop whereby a man forsakes his Communion and endures no fellowship with him in Divine matters as Christian Lupus hath it upon Tertullian †Schol. ad cap 6. de praescript Epist 65. And St. Cyprian in an Epistle ad Rogatianum Novensem who had been affronted by his Deacon saith thus Haec sunt initia Haereticorum c. By these means Hereticks are hatched and the endeavours of ill-minded Schismaticks promoted who that they may gratifie their humorsome whymfies do supercilionsly contemn him that is set over them thus men depart from the Church and set up a prophane Altar that is a Conventicle without the Communion of it Thus they make war upon the Peace left by Christ and rebel against Unity and the Ordinance of God And Epist 69. ad Florentium Pupianum writing in reference to himself he saith thus Inde Schismata Haereses abortae sunt oriuntur c. Hence Heresies and Schismes have their rise when as the Bishop who is but one and presides over the Church is most presumptuously contemned and the man dignified with a vocation from God is thought unworthy thereof by men That St. Cyprian writes thus not in reference to the Bishop of Rome but to himself and other Bishops of particular Churches is evinced by Goulartius in his Annotations ad Epist 55. n. 27. against Pamelius With great reason therefore did the Council of Nice decree Can. 6. Antiqui mores serventur c. Let the Ancient customes and priviledges be preserved That the Bishop of Alexandria may have the Junisdiction and power of them who are in Egypt Lybia and Pentapolis for so the Bishop of Rome hath customarily had over his Province Likewise also in Antiochia and other Provinces let their Priviledges be preserved inviolable to their respective Churches The Epitome of which Canon runs thus Super Aegyptum Lybiam Pentapolim Alexandrinus Episcopus potestatem habeat Romanus super Romae subditos Item Antiochenus aliique supêr suos i. e. V. Pandect à Guil. Beverege Edit in 1. Concil Nice Cā 6. Let the Bishop of Alexandria have Authority over Egypt Lybia and Pentapolis and the Bishop of Rome over the Subjects of Rome In like manner the Bishop of Antioch and all other Bishops over their Subjects in their respective Provinces And Alex. Aristenus hath this Gloss upon it Ibid. Unumquemque Patriarcharum c. Every Patriarch ought to be content with his own priviledges and not to usurp upon any other Province which was not heretofore and from the beginning under his power and Jurisdiction for this is the pride of an unjust secular Dominion And in the Second General Council held at Constantinople Can. 2. it is decreed thus The Bishop shall not pass the bounds of their own Diocesses nor confound the priviledges of the Churches but govern themselves according to the Canons And if we observe the Canon prescribed concerning Diocesses it is clear that each Province shall be governed by the particular Synod of the same Province as it is decreed by the Council of Nice And Leo the Great had so great a veneration and zeal for the Authority and honour of that Synod that in an Epistle to Anatolius Bishop of Constantinople blaming him highly amongst other miscarriages for invading the priviledges of the Churches of Alexandria and Antioch he writes thus I grieve not a little that you are fallen into so great an Error as to attempt the violation of the most sacred Constitutions of the Canons of Nice viz. In attempting to invade after Alexandria and Antioch the dignities and priviledges of all other Metropolitans And blaming him for endeavouring to wheadle the most Christian Emperour and the holy Synod called by his Authority for the extinguishing of Heresie and the Confirmation of the Catholick Faith to serve his ambitious designs he tells him That the Synod of Nice consisting of three hundred and eighteen Bishops was so Sacred and consecrated * Tanto divinitùs privilegio Consecrata with so great a priviledge from God that whatsoever was done by any of their Councils be they never so numerous who assembled in them it should be utterly void and of no Authority Leo Mag. Epist 53. inter opera Paris 1623. if it were differing from what was Ordained by those Holy Fathers †Quicquid abiliorum fuerit Constitutione diversum And in his Epistle to Martianus the Emperour blaming the Ambition of Anatolius as aforesaid he condemns him for this reason Privilegia enim Ecclesiarum c. For the priviledges of the Churches being established by the Canons of the Holy Fathers and fixed by the Decrees of the venerable Synod of Nice Let the Pope of Rome consider well these weighty Letters of his great Predecessors are not to be changed or shaken by any wicked attempts of Novelty but to be preserved inviolable In which business with Christs help it is necessary that I exert my utmost endeavours as one instructed with a Dispensation And it would become my guilt if the Sacred Constitutions of the Fathers established by the Holy Ghost in the Synod of Nice for the Government of the whole Church of God should through my
neglect or connivence ‖ Lud. Bail reads it Te quod absit connivente and so applies it to the Emperour In Sum. Concil Tom. 1. m. p. 141. B. 2. which God forbid be violated or infringed and the gratifying of one Brothers humor should be of more concern to me than the common benefit of the whole Church of God And in an Epistle to Juvenalis Bishop of Jerusalem and the rest of the Bishops assembled in the holy Synod of Chalcedon he writes thus concerning the keeping of the Ordinances of the holy Fathers which are fixed by inviolable Decrees in the Synod of Nice I advise That the rights of the Church may remain as they were ordained by those three hundred and eighteen Fathers divinely inspirēd Let not wicked Ambition covet anothers Right nor let any man seek to augment himself by the lessening of another For by what assentations soever a vain elation may arm it self and think to strengthen its inordinate desires by the name of Councils whatsoever shall be disagreeable to the Canons of the foresaid Fathers shall be void and of no validity Thus Leo the Great And if there were any such thing as Infallibility or Authority either in this Pope Leo the Great or in that first General and most sacred Council of Nice that Canon of theirs concerning the Jurisdiction and Priviledges of the Churches is of full force and ought to be observed inviolably at this day Now to apply this to our own case It is evident out of several Records * See Bedes Histor and the berty of the Brïtannick Ch. by Dr. Basier Lond. printed for John Mileson 1661. That the Britannick Church was ever 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and Independent subject to no foreign Bishop but under her own Metropolitan having her Primacy and Headship with all priviledge Ecclesiastical within her self for six hundred years after Christ till Austin the Monk transgressing that Canon of Nice did by force of Arms subdue and captivate her to the See of Rome The Popes Usurpation began here in blood with the slaughter of Twelve hundred innocent and holy Monks at Bangor and all attempts to reinforce that Usurpation are carried on by methods of the like nature i. e. practices of fraud and violence W. Beverege Anno. ad Can. 6. Concil Nicae p. 58 59. Nevertheless as the Learned Beverege hath observed the unjust violation of that Canon cannot prejudice the high and perpetual Authority of it Wherefore though the Bishop of Rome ever since he sent the aforesaid Austin hither hath exercised the chief Authority in this Nation yet at last having shaken off his Tyrannical yoak our Church through Gods blessing doth most deservedly enjoy her Ancient priviledges by that most worthy Ordinance and Canon prescribed by the Universal Church in this matter It is manifest then that the Bishop of Rome can afford you no good Sanctuary against the Authority of that Bishop and Metropolitan whose Communion you have forsaken What therefore St. Hierome saith against John of Jerusalem I may fitly apply to the Pope of Rome Tu qui regulas quaeris Ecclesiasticas Nicaeni Concilii Canonibus uteris alienos Clericos cum suis Episcopis commorantes tibi niteris usurpare Responde mihi Ad Alexandrinum Episcopum Palestinam quid pertinet Thou who seekest for Ecclesiastical Canons and usest the Constitutions of the Council of Nice and notwithstanding pretendest to usurp the Government over the Clergy of other Bishops tell me what hath the Bishop of Rome to do with Great Britain Sir from what hath been suggested it is evident that the Bishop and Church of Rome have shamefully prevaricated both the Doctrine and Government of the Catholick Church as it was declared and fix'd by the most Ancient and sacred General Councils The Doctrine as well in matters of Faith as Manners And the Government by usurping the Jurisdiction and priviledges of other Churches And if as you profess you have not changed your Loyalty I am very apt to believe the wicked Plot now under Examination with many of the like nature may be sufficient to make you abhor the Communion of that Church whose Morals can hatch such Monsters and whose Governours do make it their business to Lowbel their pliant Creatures into designs of Treason and Assassination by the help of false Lights Bulls and Dispensations and encourage them in the attempts by the fond applause of Merit and a Crown of Red Letters In short the scandal hereof is so foul it may very well become your ingenuity and without doubt it will tend much to your reputation and inward peace to take your leave of such Company with good old Jacobs imprecation Gen. 49.6 O my Soul come not thou into their secret unto their assembly my Honour be not thou united And this is the Advice which proceeds though but from the common prudence yet from the highest Charity of SIR Your most affectionate Friend and faithful Servant L. W. FINIS
form of sound words 2 Tim. 1.13 And it is undoubtedly St. Judes Faith we contend for which as Beza very well notes upon the place was once and at once so delivered to the Saints that it ought never to be changed That Faith which the Fathers of the Council of Nice professed we do very heartily embrace we keep this Faith whole and undefiled But from receiving any other we are deterred by the Sentence of the Synod of Ephesus forementioned Qui aliam fidem audent componere c. Whosoever shall dare to compose alledge or introduce any other Faith if he be a Bishop or Clergy-man he shall be degraded if a Lay-man excommucated If the Faith thus delivered were sufficient for their salvation in genere fidei why not for ours And herein without all doubt we are no less Infallible than the Church of Rome And to the Ancient Fathers in the most Sacred Councils this was their †Lud. Bail Sum. Concil Tom. 1. in decreto de Symbolo Sess 3. m. pa. 522. Shield against all Heresies Quo solo c. Through whose attractive power alone they have in times past drawn unbelievers to the Faith resisted and rooted out Hereticks and confirm'd the Faithful as the Fathers of the Council of Trent do acknowledge If there be any other points of Faith needful to salvation our ignorance thereof after a long and diligent search is both involuntary and invincible and that will totally excuse us For that superfatation of Articles by Pope Pius the Fourth we were never Baptized into them nor can we answer for them The truth is the Faith of the Church of England the Romanists can never justly reprehend being more pure more Primitive and more Catholick than their own and was professed intirely by all Christian Churches before some Articles of the present Church of Rome were ever known to have had a being And for part of this we have a pregnant acknowledgment in the Council of Trent where they set down this Symbolum fidei totidem verbis quibus in omnibus Ecclesiis legitur Lud. Bail ubi supra In the same words in which it is read in all Churches And this they set down as that principle wherein all that do profess the Faith of Christ do necessarily agree and as that firm and only foundation against which the gates of Hell shall never be able to prevail This Faith I say we do keep whole and undefiled but it seems it was a foundation too narrow to bear up the Popish superstructures of Hay and Stubble but yet being the only foundation as they confess and so firm that the gates of Hell shall never prevail against it we do stedfastly rest upon it building our selves thereon as St. Epist Jude v. 20 21. Jude directs us in expectation of the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ to Eternal life Towards the accomplishment whereof our Charity is so much more Catholick than theirs that with some craft and sophistry though with little reason they take an Argument from thence to delude the weak and make them Proselytes to their party For our Agenda or matters of Practice we have a Liturgy that is full solemn and intelligible we have all Sacraments and Sacramentals that are generally necessary or of any efficacy to salvation And besides all publick Offices for private devotion and use we have Institutions and forms of Christian piety no part of the Christian Church better Our Priesthood and Government you cannot with any truth or reason deny to be Apostolical and if our Discipline be in some instances collapsed from the severity which it obtained in the practice of the Ancients that of the Church of Rome is so likewise And if we reflect upon the many disadvantages and perils which are in Their Communion they will warrant the security in ours to be far the greater Amongst the disadvantages on that side I reckon their half Sacraments against the express letter of our Saviours Institution * Mat. 26.26 1 Cor. 11.23 c. and their Service in an unknown Tongue contrary to the express discourse of the Apostle †1. Cor. 14. Amongst the perils I must account 1 That of Idolatry in the adoration of the Host 2 The veneration of Images 3 And the invocation of Saints Secondly Such as arise from the abuses in the matter of Confession and Penances of Indulgence and Dispensation with many delusions under pretence of Revelations Thirdly Such as arise from several of their Doctrines viz. That the Sacrament does conferr Grace ex opere operato from the Act performed without any worthy or moral disposition in the Receiver That Attrition for fear of Hell is sufficient without Charity to obtain Grace and pardon in the Sacrament of Penance That in a case of Conscience I may follow a probable opinion which is more benign and gentle and reject that which is more safe if it be more severe and rigid That a man is not obliged to decline and avoid Proximam occasionem peccandi the immediate danger of sinning though he has had sad experience of his own frailty and recidivation That the precept of Repentance does not bind presently but only in the time of sickness or at the point of death These Doctrines are taught and practised without any the least check of his Infallible Holiness Nor is the danger small which ariseth from the perswasion of their Infallibility For from thence proceeds a belief that whatsoever they take upon them to define is as true as Gospel And what sad work this hath made in the Church of God we may observe from that single instance about the Sacrament In a Council at Rome under Nicholas the Second An. Dom. 1059. Berengarius was enjoyned a form of Recautation wherein he professed and swore that the Bread and Wine which are set upon the Altar after Consecration are not only a Sacrament but also the true Body and Blood of our Lord Jesus Christ And that the said Body is not in Sacrament only but in truth N. B Sensualiter manibus Sacerdotum tractari frangi fidelium dentibus atteri i. e. sensually handled by the Priest broken and torn by the teeth of the Faithful Expressions so gross to unfold an inexplicable mystery that the Author of the Gloss upon Gratian gives his Reader this sober warning of them De confect dist 2. c. 42. ego Bereng Haec verba nisi sane intelligas in majorem incides Haeresin quam ipse Berengarius habuit i. e. Unless you understand these words in a sound sense you will fall into a greater Heresie than Berengarius was guilty of And upon the account of this pretended Infallibility I might add some Reflections upon those horrid Murthers Treasons and Rebellions which have been encouraged and carried on out of a belief of the Popes Supremacy and Power over Princes at least in ordine ad Spiritualia in order to Church-matters which must needs make a great flaw in