opens and shuts there is such an excellent Image erected like the first part of that in Dan. 2.32 Whose Head was of fine gold his Breast and Arms of silver It was a notable and noble saying of Constantine the Emperour unto the Pastors and Bishops of his time Vos est is in Ecclesia sed ego extra Ecclesiam Episcopus Though he was the great champion of the church and the christians temporal Saviour yet he would not meddle with opening or shutting in Christ's church nor extort the Key of David or Christ's out of their hands to whom Christ left it for what is done by them is done by Christ as by his delegated power what they binde in earth is bound in heaven and what they loose on earth is loosed in heaven Christ will not suffer any to weild his Keys but those to whose hands he hath committed them according to his own method and way of directions who uses them contrary to this they will find them Scorpions in their hands ready to bite and destroy them instead of healing and curing Remember the example of Uzziah and tremble 2 Chron. 26.16 Was it not the downfal to Popery when Spiritual men turned Layicks and Bishops became Princes And on the other side Secular Princes handled the Spiritual Keys opened and shut as they pleased made Laws Edicts and Rules unto the church which was Christs and his churches prerogative only What undid our late Episcopal hierarchy in England but mixing sacred things with profane making Christ's and Caesar's Laws all one The Bishop he was made a temporal Lord to act in the Parliamentary and civil affairs of the Nation and in requital hereof the supreme Magistrate he is made supreme Head of the church to enact what Laws he pleaseth as in reference to the church and to open and shut to whom he wil by his high courts of Delegates and high commission c. such a church such a head a civil church a civil head such a church such laws such officers such keys such pow-Ar all prudentials and all of the present worlds wisdom and fabricating and therefore not strange that the fabrick lasted no longer but fell witâ—in few ages after the first structure thereof And is it not now to be feared that the church amongst us may be lulled asleep as in the lap of Constantine by over-much indulgence and temporal honours cast upon her and her Ministers Though I am not an enemy to their just maintenance and temporal comforts yet I am jealous of them that all is not Lamb-skin that appears so about them but that somwhat if not too much of the Foxes tayl lies undiscovered within What means else the bleatings of the cattle I mean their pressing after preferments extraneous as to their churches as Heads of Universities State-chaplains great Parsonages Commissioners and Tryers c. and so by reason of the want of Christ's own Key do often open to persons against whom Christ hath shut and shut against some to whom Christ hath opened So fallible are men that open with the wooden key of their own Politiques the Lord deliver our Soveraign Magistrate from the snares of these spiritual Machiavilians or Machiavilian Doctors that do teach the Magistrate to lay his Politiques as rules to Christ's church that would have him open where Christ shuts and shut where Christ opens It is equally dangerous unto both Magistrate and Minister to move or act out of their own proper spheres but acting in their own Orbs the one in his Civil Government and State the other in his Spiritual policy and church so both becomes gracious and honourable in their respective governments and dominions Quest. But what Shall not christian Magistrates do nothing in the church or execute no part of their Authority therein which God hath given them for the good of the church I answer First The Magistrate may exercise his authority for the good of the church in several respects First In protecting encouraging and countenancing the church in the service of Christ and defending their liberty therein and so become Nursing Fathers unto the church Secondly As Christ does approve and command obedience from all to Magistrates and their Laws as for God's sake Rom. 13. So Magistrates should approve and command Christ's Laws and Government to be observed of all within their respective boundaries and jurisdictions Thirdly If any proves turbulent seditious or factious in the church under pretence of liberty and so become a peace-breaker in the Commonweal the Magistrate may restrain him by his civil power Fourthly If any church member become a blasphemer an idolater an open delinquent against the first Table or transgressor of the second the Magistrate may chastise him for it over and above the censure of the church not as required thereunto by the church but by vertue of his own civil Laws that equally reaches all persons that transgress them whether Ecclesiastiques or others 2. But secondly in the Negative I answer That Magistrates have nothing to do nor are competent Judges as Magistrates of controversal points opinions doctrines or of things meerly relating to the church Christ never endued the Magistrate with such a power Therefore the argument is very prevalent a Negative That they have no such power The church alone under Christ is endued with that power of trying doctrines suppressing errors in opinions and judgements according to the rule of the Word Now to whom this rule was given the foresaid power was given but the rule was committed to the church only and not to Magistrates Mat. 18. therefore the said power of trying doctrines and suppressing errors was committed only to the church and not to Magistrates Object But may not Magistrates suppress errors and use their authority to that end when they are thereunto well advised by a Learned Assembly of Divines or able Ministers of the church Answ The Ministers of Christ if they be such advisers herein do first betray their trust and calling in their Master's service into the hands of the Magistrate plainly acknowledging that their Lord and Master hath not provided an Armory sufficient in his House and Kingdom to overthrow errors as well as means for their discovery Is not this to run for carnal weapons whilst they lay by those made by God spiritual ones and mighty through God to pull down Powers Principalities and all the works of darkness Secondly If Magistrates act thus upon the advice of others they must not only see with other mens eyes and act upon an implicite faith but do also hereby become but the executioners of their Assemblies Decrees What more doth the Popish Princes when they execute the Edicts of the Romish conclave And what otherwise did Pilate when he became the executioner of the Priests sentence upon Christ in crucifying him A Sea-mark to all to take notice on this account Thirdly Magistrates as Magistrates are not to suppress errours because Christ hath other Laws Ordinances and Ways to suppress them
laid home close on the whole church of Thyatira for suffering the woman Jezabel and her prophetique delusions Now if it were alone in the Angels power of Thyatira to deal with these Balaamitish prophets the Spirit of Christ would especially lay the burden and reproof upon them to wit the Superintendents of the church but it is clearly notified unto us that the charge is wholly laid home upon the churches v. 17. Let him that hath an ear hear what the Spirit saith unto the Churches Though I grant the Eldership or Officers may be the mouth of Christ unto the churches and again the churches mouth unto Christ and so they are his Ambassadors agitating in his name and are to precede in many duties in relation to the church yet the charge for admission and entertainment of heterodoxies and corruptions in the churches is not solely laid upon them but upon the whole churches so hence this is clearly evinced that those that are justly charged for the admission and permission of evil had an indubitable power and authority in themselves either not to admit it or being admitted to try it and cut it off by such means as are appointed for such ends but the whole church of Thyatira is justly charged for the admission and permission of corruptions among them therefore the conclusion is evident But this shall suffice herein See more hereon v. 20. following Object But is not this with the Papists to raise the jurisdiction of the church so high as to set it above the soveraignty of the Word I answer negatively for a Soveraign Prince receives no diminution of honour for his subordinate Ministers of State to receive that honour due unto their place neither so doth the Word lose at all of its glory for that the church hath its due honour put upon it also indeed the Word is suprema Lex the Standard the Rule and light by which all doctrines are tryed and discerned and being of Divine Revelation and in its self infallible must needs be above the authority and of a surer testimony then that which is mixed with much fallibility and imperfection as the choicest and purest churches ever were as those of Corinth Ephesus Galatia c. And as a Law of meer humane institution is reputed of so high authority that it binds the Legislators themselves and in that respect is above those that made it but much more the Word of God which is his Law and his revealed mind coming from so infinite and unerrable a Legislator as God is so far transcends the authority of any Judicature on earth as the wisdom of an infinite does a finite creature therefore must needs be binding to all to whom it is made known having such a perfection in it that whosoever is conversant therein it is able by the blessing of the Spirit to make him wise unto salvation and perfect in every good thing and work The Word unto the Church is as the Sun unto the Dial if the Dial be set right to the Sun it will give a right judgment of the time of the day so if the church gives a judgement according to the square and scantling of the Word it will be a righteous judgement but otherwise to make the Word subservient and to conclude unto the churches dictates is an undertaking to rectifie the course of the Sun unto the obliquity of the Dial which will prove Aethiopiam lvvare and most irrational So that church that keeps her self within her own sphere and tries and examines spirits and doctrines that are heterodox and unsound by the sound of the Word which is a most sure light and infallible cynosure doubtless that church will be led and preserved in all truth But if any one so far exalts its self as to conclude for truth its own dictates dissentaneous unto the Word but suiting with self-interest and designe the first may be a golden candlestick both precious and famous for its faith integrity and justice towards God and man but the latter will soon degenerate into an harlot-church if not soon become apostate to the faith The first is Christ's highest Judicature on earth wherein he takes delight to walk in as his Garden enclosed to view their pleasant fruits but the other Christ will look upon as a rotten Tree that cumbers the ground and serves only to be hewen down and cast into the fire Observ 4. Another Observation is That in the purest times and churches there are found great corruptions both in manners and doctrines In this famous church of Ephesus Corinth c. in the Apostles days were found both 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 evil ones and false ones such as pretended they were Apostles but were found liars and deceivers Amongst the twelve there was a Judas In that church in the Ark when the world and church had one and the same extent and boundaries in eight persons only yet one was a Cham and there was also a Cain when it was of a lesser number and but four in the world But here obiter and by the way we must be careful to distinguish between God's Decretive will and his Preceptive Will His Voluntas bene placiti and Voluntas signi as the Schools call it or his will of purpose and his will of good pleasure Not that there are two Wills in God but several and divers acts of one and the same Will as by the same will we love by the same will we hate by the same will we purpose one thing by the same will we command another thing yet they are not two contradictory wills but divers acts of one and the same will Diversa non sunt contraria Now though God may in his providential wisdom ordain false teachers and wicked persons to be found in his church for divers ends known unto God and more especially for the tryal of the faithful and the exaltation of his grace yet they are much mistaken that hence argue either for admission of wicked persons or unsound in the faith into the fellowship of the church or for their toleration therein after a discovery for it is the command of God to the contrary That we admit not such being known into the consortship of the church or being admitted upon discovery we tolerate them not for if they were to be admitted and tolerated quietly within the church then doubtless the church of Ephesus had not received that encomium and well done for their zeal against them nor the church of Thyatira that worthy reproof for the suffering that woman Jezabel amongst them therefore the one church did her duty and obeyed Christ's preceptive will and had the praise and glory for it the other neglected it and therefore had a just check laid upon her So that this question is to be stated de Jure non de Facto I confess de facto there may be evil persons false teachers in the best churches and purest times but de
to overturn all its opposites that asserts That true real Grace or as he calls it a real change of the soul is not pre-requisite as the condition unto Baptism Amongst many other arguments of his against M. Blake's dogmatical faith I shall only make use of his fourth and fifth and eleventh arguments page 96. of his Apologie and refer the Reader to that place for farther satisfaction where there are many more arguments both from Authority and Scriptures levied to this purpose and comporting with this Truth His fourth Argument is They that are to renounce the World Flesh and Divel are to be true Believers to Justification but they that are to be baptized are then to renounce the World Flesh and Divel therefore this abrenunciation hath been practised alwaies in Baptisme since the Apostles times as Antiquity testifies His fifth argument is They that are required to believe sincerely in the Father Son and holy Ghost are required to believe to Justification But such are all as come to Baptism Therefore For the major it requires no more proof but to explain what it is to believe in the Father Son and holy Ghost and our Divines against the Papists have enough proved that the phrase of believing in comprehendeth the act of the will as well as the understanding To believe in God is to take him for our God which is to take him for our soveraign Ruler and chief good This none but a sound believer can truly do His eleventh argument If Baptism be solemnizing of the mystical marriage between Christ and the Baptized then true justifying faith is of God required thereto But the Antecedent is true Therefore Therefore it is said that we are baptized into Christ and into one body and the church hath ever held the Antecedent to be true The consequence is evident in that no man but the sound believer can truly take Christ as a husband and head for so to do is justifying faith These three have I only chosen of M. Baxter's 26. arguments to set as an Antithesis unto M. Morice's positions and as an answer thereunto and if I may speak it pace tanti viri an ill case is much disadvantagious to the most learned man and in this that I have set M. Baxter to answer M. Morice is but to set Socrates to answer Plato And I may add one word that whereas it is objected That Judas and Simon Magus faith which was only dogmatical and formal though rotten in the root gives right of admission I answer First It may be granted in foro Ecclesiae for that may be said to give admission to Baptism c. which so qualifieth the person as the church is bound to admit him as being one that seemeth sound in believing for Judas was always reckoned amongst the twelve before his trayterous betraying act of his Lord and Master and Simon is said to have believed also Acts 8.13 Now the church can but give a judgement of charity and not knowing any thing to the contrary cannot deny admission either to Simon or any other that desires it for charity thinketh no evil and hopeth the best of all and it is an old rule de occultis non judicat Ecclesia But secondly This is not an entituling and having right coram Deo a foedere for that alone is saving faith which God in his covenant makes the condition pre-requisite to such a right of admission which is before asserted and proved and that that gives right coram Deo gives a true title also foro Ecclesiae for according to a charitative judgement they are bound to judge that the profession of faith and wills of such as desire admission are both true real and sanctified or else they would not desire it though oftentimes the sequel manifests that they are deceived therein and hereby it is clearly evinced that the church door is wider then the door of heaven and that the number of the church militant does exceed the tryumphant and is far enlarged beyond the limits of the Elect. And herein this shall suffice Observ 5. That false Teachers are most arrogant and pretend highest to gifts and mission The church of Ephesus found it so in their false Teachers and Corinth also 2 Cor. 13.11 who transformed themselves into the Apostles of Christ and who by their own mouths said they were Apostles they would needs get the honour of men of extraordinary spirits and callings as the Apostles were yet on tryal they were found liars they are of Diotrephes-like spirit that would needs have the precedency and be above John himself and the true Apostles Gaudent preesse non ut prosunt sed quia grande aliquid putant preesse insolentius arrogantius principes in Ecclesia locum appertivisse They are like those in Jer. 8.8 who say We are wise and the Law of the Lord is with us while their hearts are full of lies and vanity and as those in Ezek. 13.6 who saying The Lord saith yet have seen nothing but a vain vision and a lying divination But I should here demand why should those false teachers denominate themselves to be Apostles seeing the number is only limited to twelve I answer Some of the ancient Fathers did denominate the first second and third century after Christ the Apostolical times though the Twelve were dead for the purity of their doctrine and being so near the fountain as Church history manifests And our Bishop Jewel offers to joyn Issue with the Papists so far as the fifth century upon the authority of the Fathers as holding the Apostolical doctrine Secondly I answer This Apostolical office was not so much the peculiar faculty of the Twelve as to debar all others from that denomination and though I grant they were Christ's Apostles catexochen yet that does not hinder but others that are sent for so much the word signifies in the Greek in Christ's Embassies unto the world may appropriate that Title unto themselves as Paul very often in his Epistles hath justly vindicated his right unto it and I know not why might not Barnabas with others that were sent upon the same message with Paul and the rest appropriate the same Title and that justly to themselves also for I am of opinion that those are standing perpetual officers in the church which are described in Eph. 4.11 and are to continue it from one age to another until the whole body of Christ mystical the elect are gathered and compleat for so the words strongly enforce and he gave some Apostles and some Prophets and some Evangelists and some Pastors and Teachers for the perfecting of the Saints for the work of the Ministry for the edifying of the body of Christ till we all come into the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God unto a perfect man unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ Now whereas they object that are contrary minded That some Offices in the church were
officers now at present authorized in the churches meerly as such officers then surely there are some officers wanting unto the churches by which it may be rightly dispensed But the major being formerly cleared the consequence I believe none will deny that looks upon the preaching of the word as an act of authority and office therefore the conclusion is evident And therefore to shut up this discourse I am very much of opinion that all primitive offices and officers which were of positive institutions in the Apostles times are moral positive laws and still constringent and perpetual unless you can show their repeals See Cawdry on the Sabbath part 1. cap. 2. hereon and therefore binding unto the church in all ages Confer hereunto that of Eph. 4.11 12 13. All which indeed the church doth virtually and implicitely maintain though they have laid by the names thereof so necessary do they find the acts of the said offices though the offices themselves nominally are thrust out of doors When we send Preachers to our American plantations for the discipling the poor Indians are they not tantamount as Apostles When Eusebius the centurists and later Church Historiographers do historifie the acts and occurrences of the church are they not in a qualified sense Evangelists when persons do interpret and enucleate dark or prophetical Scriptures do they not look like Prophets When by the faith and prayers of the faithful corruptions are vanquished the will 's reformed health restored and Satanical dispossessions accomplished do they not carry the face of miracles And why then should we not entertain the offices and gifts themselves nominally as well as operatively and virtually though with some mark of distinction as by a crescent as unto younger brothers acknowledging always and that justly a pre-eminence of gifts and spirit in those of the first age and nearest unto the fountain of life and verity but far thereby from concluding that their offices were buried with the first founders together with their most excellent gifts in one arme but still kept alive and preserved for the good of the Church and the perfecting of the Saints for the work of the Ministry for the edifying of the body of Christ till we all come to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God unto a perfect man unto the measure of the station of the fulness of Christ And that none may judge me rash or presumptory in this opinion I submit it to the tryal of Christ's churches and add Adhuc sub Judice lis est Try all things hold fast that which is good Let every one be perswaded fully in his own mind and in the mean to walk in that measure of light that he hath attained unto In the next place the question may be seasonably set how shall we know or try false Apostles from true Christ's ministers from antichrist's or the pseudo-prophets from the Orthodox Seeing the false ones can transform themselves into the Apostles of Christ and say they are Apostles and Ministers of Christ as well as true ones 2 Cor. 11.13 Rev. 2.2 This question indeed is worthy the discussion useful both for the rectifying of the private judgement of discretion as well as of the publique authoritative judgement of the church in this particular for indeed it is no new thing nor strange to the purest churches of God to have false Prophets and false Apostles in them In the days of Ahab 1 Kings 18.19 the prophets of Baal were four hundred and fifty and of the Groves four hundred but the true ones hid by Obadiah were but one hundred Ezekiel Jeremiah met them too in Babylon Jer. 28 29 chap. and Ezek. 12.2 3. The Apostolique primitive churches were much troubled and vexed with false Apostles false prophets and false teachers also witness 2 Cor. 11.13 2 Pet. 2.1 Gal. 5.12 Matth. 24.11 and those churches of Ephesus Pergamus Sardis c. had their share also in this trouble by the doctrine of Balaam Nicolaitans Jezabel c. and this God often suffers with the sad consequences thereof in and upon his churches to make the Truth more clear and precious to try the godly and discover hypocrites and to shew his power and wisdom that can produce good out of evil and preserve his undefiled in the midst of contagions but the wisdom of the Saints is to try them and discover them that so they may be avoided with all their malignant influences and pernicious doctrines Now a false Apostle or Prophet may be discovered two ways First Either from his false doctrine or prophesie Or secondly From his false call or mission The ancient Prophets of God were called Seers from the clear divine revelations and irradiations they had of the mind of God 2 Kings 17.13 and this was called the Gift of Prophesie Next They had a clear call to exercise that Gift But the false Prophets they prophesied out of their own hearts and follow their own spirits and have seen nothing as in Ezek. 12.2 3. that is They are Prophets because they will be Prophets it is their own motion that makes them prophesie they thrust themselves upon it and make their own wills the highest original of their call and therefore in the next place the things they prophesie are their own what their fancies lusts private interests affections and carnal reason suggest unto them so their prophesies come by the will of man not of God as that of 2 Pet. 1.21 and therefore however esteemed and magnified by men is worthless in God's account because it only proceeds from their own spirits and not from God's Spirit the true Spirit of prophesie Now I would not here be mistaken as if I pressed for enthusiastique prophesies but to keep close to that Spirit of prophesie in the Word of God which will not close with man's base interests and motions but is according to the will of God in all things and this is the true spirit of prophesie and therefore what comes from the will of man and private Spirits are in the Scriptures variously branded under the Titles of lies dreams vain divinations perverse things the commandments of men Mark 7.7 wisdom of this world 1 Cor. 2.6 another Jesus another Spirit another Gospel 2 Cor. 11 4. Therefore Paul durst not preach any other thing but Christ Jesus the Lord and what he had from him by his Spirit that he preached unto them 2 Cor. 4.5 Therefore we may plainly judge a false Prophet or Apostle when he comes with doctrines and prophesies of his own motions and own Spirit and own designs being opposite and destructive to the Spirits doctrine of faith and godliness within the Gospel Object But will not some say that all heretiques false apostles and false Teachers will come with verbum Domini in their mouth and pretend highly that their doctrines are concordant and agreeable to the word of God or else in vain to broach and attest them And who more high then
denied the instrumentality of his Spirit be sure that in stead of a Zion such will erect a Babel and being ignorant where the green pastures of the Gospel lies they will like idle Shepherds either starve the sheep of their flocks or at least poyson them with unwholsome herbage And these I account as sufficient rules to try and examine false Apostles and Teachers by and to find them liars Object But an Objection may here arise from him that hath the first call of abilities from God That if I count it so necessary for him to denominate him Orthodox in his call to have the additional call of the church also But then saith he to what church shall I repair to receive this call seeing there are so many that are pretenders to be the true and right churches of Christ and that the alone ordaining authority is in them and not in others This is indeed locus lubricus a slippery question and I should be loth to deal with it lest I should offend the contrary minded by ventilating my judgement herein but I profess ingeniously it was neither men nor parties self interests nor by-affections that did lead me first to this undertaking but only the general good of christians unto which the Lord moved my heart with much singleness of Spirit being clearly unbyassed and not so over-much engaged to any of the new parties of these times but that I can reserve my judgement free to close with truth wheresoever I can find it And therefore I think it not amiss but to prosecute my first intendment in the singleness of heart to endeavour to clear up truth according to the scantle of my judgement not as walking in the clouds but in plainness and perspicuity though for my reward I may have his hire that traced truth so near at the heels that had his teeth dashed out for his pains but if I be a fool herein yet being reputed a fool for the promotion of truth it will be some comfort and if I suffer loss herein yet this consideration will consolate Magnis tamen excidit Ausis First then to the business Understand that the word Church in Scripture is ordinarily taken to avoid all criticizing upon the word to be the company of the faithful gathered out of all Nations by the ministry of the Word and Spirit and this I conceive to be the genuine definition of the church which may abundantly be made good both by good authority and Scripture Now this church is either more improperly first called the invisible church or secondly more properly the visible church The invisible church comprehends only the elect and seeing their number to us are unknown therefore they are denominated invisible But secondly The visible church is either to be taken for the visible universal catholique church or secondly for a visible particular political church Now the question is concerning the church in this last notion for 't is apparent the invisible church as invisible hath not to do in visible and outward ordinances Neither secondly the visible universal church can by themselves or others their representatives convene for the institution of Officers for how can it stand with conveniency or with the least shew of reasonableness that all the churches of Christ dispersed and planted in the various and far distant corners and Ilands of the world should either by themselves or their representing Officers meet together in one catholique assembly for the disposing and conferring of all mediate calls and Offices And therefore Christ hath ordained that All wise order and gubernation in and over his mystical body the church that every part of this universal body I mean every particular christian assembly of the church catholique for every particular is part of the whole should have within their own limits and jurisdiction a full power to exercise all the offices and ordinances which Christ hath given and instituted for the good and edification of his church unto the end of the world Neither is the church to be called catholique in respect of any her Officers for we know no such office since the first Apostles that were so extraordinary gifted as to have the denomination of Catholique authority over the universal church though they may be accounted to have Jus ad rem fit to be officers of any parts of the catholique church and so to have a potential right thereunto yet actual they have not before their particular calls does invest them into Jus in re as well as their gifts and abilities does to Jus ad rem But the profession of that catholique universal faith which is one and the same in all churches over the whole world that gives denomination to the universal or catholique church therefore the results and conclusions of combined Churches Provincial or National may be only admitted as prudentially binding and obliging as Ecclesiastical Laws and Canons but not as having a divine authority stamped upon them though agreeable to the divine truth it self so that such constitutions are to be received and embraced not solely virtute authoritatis convocation is sed virtute veritatis propositae which if the same conclusions were enjoyned by a particular christian political church were to be received by all of that church not only for the truths sake therein but in submission to the divine authority of the church that commands and institutes them Such is the difference between prudential Ecclesiastique Edicts and Ecclesiastique divine Institutions the one is humane and binding only prudentially the other is divine and obligeth conscienciously These considerations being cleared I come to answer the question to what particular visible church must a candidate apply himself for a mediate authoritative call and mission to receive it rightly and according to the mind of God and satisfaction of a good Conscience I answer and take leave here first to distinguish and take notice between the bene esse and the esse of a call There may be particular churches which I cannot deny but to be truly churches of Christ but not true ones that is they may have being in Christ by faith as branches in the Vine yet mixed with much rottenness and unsoundness and as a leprous person is a man yet a sorry one so a church holding the faith which is as the soul and life thereof yet entertaining much corruption and errour may be truly called a christian church but a sad one So the Ministerial call does answer the constitution of the churches from whence they proceed It s observable that the off-springs constitution do follow the parents temperature strong issues are not to be expected of sickly parents Fortes creantur fortibus as Seneca so in politique bodies of particular churches if they are found and healthy in the faith their off springs are strong and healthy also then their officers and ordinances will be lively efficacious and virtual If ootherwise be with them they will lose much of their vigour life and vertue and
by interposing an intervening necessity and clear obstacle thereunto and therein God loves obedience better then sacrifice Secondly I answer That the first Ministerial Reformers never maintained a personal succession of Ministery and Officers from the Apostles lineally through the loyns of Antichrist but only a succession of doctrine which in all ages was by the invisible church maintained and asserted somtimes with more perspicuity and visibility then other for if we should grant a personal succession of officers and Ministery from the Apostles days we must needs also grant a perpetual and necessary visibility of a church and consequentially a truth of Ministery and Ordinances of Christ in the Antichristian state and how a true christian Ministery and Ordinances can be found in that Antichristian state in that man of sin that mistery of iniquity that whore of Babylon as I formerly said I know not or how the same state can be both meerly antichristian and christian a Whore of Babylon and a Spouse of Jesus Christ a Ministery of God and a mysterie of iniquity a Temple of God and oâ— Idols I leave it to the Judicious to consider In the next place in the affirmative I hold That a true and Justifiable call respecting the essence thereof may be received in any the churches of Christ holding the foundation aright of godliness towards God and faith towards our Lord Jesus Christ though otherwise differing among themselves in many circumstantial points yet de bene esse it may more comfortably be received from one church then another as formerly was evinced the more pure spiritual and sound the churches are the more sound spiritual and edifying their Ministerial functions are the more loose unsound and corrupted the churches are the more corrupt and loose their Ministerial call will be Therefore the godliest churches and soundest in the faith are in the first place for missions Ministerial calls and offices to be sought and repaired unto But if any one should ask me what I thought then of the present Ministery of England as now constituted who as Presbyters ordain one another to their Ministerial offices who were first ordained themselves by the late Bishops and so holding their ordination from them as from true Presbyters I answer and I think it not meet but contrary to the simplicity of the Gospel to cloud my judgement in any thing If the English Presbyterie as the Helvetian and Genevan hath done to their perpetual glory had declared to the world that the Romish church was the antichristian whore and so publiquely renounced all ministerial calls as derived from her then I grant such ministery and Presbyters to be true Ministers and Presbyters as unto the essence and being thereof though collating of offices meerly as officers or Presbyters without the just assent and assistance of their churches is not so justifiable as hereafter I may have occasion to evince but if they maintained their calls from the Bishops to be good as by succession of Presbyters they have utterly nullified and undone their case and their call too in my judgment and my reason is for what was not good and justifiable in the fountain and first origen cannot be made justifiable by succession in the streams and branches a polluted fountain cannot send forth sweet wholsome streams causa causae causa causati If that Episcopacy was antichristian as most of them grant though both name and office are warrantable in a Gospel regulated sense from whom they had their first mission and calls how then comes their calls more warrantable then that of their first Authors and Founders If Bishops in their ministery were orthodox and sound how came they to supplant them and pull them down Christ's ministery is not for the work of desolating and dethroning Brethren in the same holy function but rather for consolidating and confirming therefore surely there was somwhat amiss all was not right or else they might have stood to this day Witness the National Covenant against Antichristian Prelacy c. But the truth is Episcopacy as it was then constituted in England was of the off spring and brood of Babylon they always held their call good as ministerial Bishops having their personal calls from such successively as first received it from the church of Rome and so could never be made good or justifiable in the succession neither will it suffice as some say to salve it that Christ had always a church of invisible Saints under antichrist because they must prove themselves then to succeed that very church or those very invisible Saints and not only that but that those very Saints were ministerial officers or Presbyters or else all will be in vain according to their own concessions for men may be Saints but not ministerially Saints sent or Presbyters who according to them hath the alone power of ordination and therefore in want of such true ministerial Presbyters in the succession of the Ministery must either unavoidably acknowledge according to their own principles their ministerial offices void and null or otherwise plainly concede that they have it derivatively from the church of Rome and what a sorry call that is if at least so to be called I have formerly evinced And it is a maxime in Law that quod initio vitiosum est non porest tractu temporis convalescere See more hereon Du Plessis Treat Of the Church p. 3624. and Bishop Jewel Defen Apolog. part 2. page 131. who are witnesses without exception manifesting the vanity of such a claim But I proceed to the next verse Verse 3. And hast born and hast patience and for my names sake hast laboured and hast not fainted Observe from this Observ That false Teachers and false Apostles are great persecuters of the faithful ones of Christ The church of Ephesus had suffered much from such false Teachers for Christ's sake and his truth The false Prophets of old were alwaies against the true ones and caused them often to be smitten and afflicted as Micaiah was jeared by Zedekiah Which way went the Spirit from me to thee 1 Kings 22. 2 4. and that not all but was smitten disgracefully on the check also Shemaiah stirred up the authority against Jeremiah the Lord's Prophet and would have cast him in the prison Ier. 29.24 Yea saith Ezekiel 22.25 There is a conspiracy of her Prophets in the midst thereof not only like Foxes but even like Lions ravening the prey These false Teachers have been always very pernicious to Gods true church What great persecuters Arrius and his followers were to Athanasius and the Orthodox They were the Priests and false Prophets of old that shed the blood of Christ and his Apostles though not by their own hands yet by incensing the authority to do it How willingly would Pilate release Christ if it were not for the out-cry of the Priests and their followers false prophets still exclaim and fastigate the Magistrate and tells them that they shall do God good service in
unclean lusts whatsoever This is the most sad condition when God does unchurch a people for their sins witness the habitation of these seven Asian churches wherein the Synagogue of Satan in Mahumatism and Heathenism is set up in the room of Christ's holy Doctrine and Ordinances and all for their impenitency and obstinacy in their loud crying abominations and therefore I cannot too often recognize this verse to backslidden souls Remember from whence thou art fallen and repent and do thy first works or else I will come against thee shortly and will remove thy Candlestick out of his place except thou repent Verse 6. But this thou hast that thou hatest the works of the Nicolaitans which I also hate Christ goes on and tells the church of Ephesus that though she was justly faulty for her defection in her first love yet she had this commendable point in her to be added unto her other commendable graces That she abhorred the abominations of the Nicolaitans both in judgment and practise which also was most hateful and abominable unto Christ himself Now the Sect of the Nicolaitans as all Ecclesiastique history testifies took the denomination from Nicholas a Deacon of Antioch but whether he was their leader himself or whether they falsly pretended him the first founder of their heresie is disputable Indeed Ireneus Tertullian and Epiphanius are of opinion that he himself was their leader yet Clemens Alexandrinus and Eusebius lib. 3. do say That the Nicolaitans had falsly pretended the name of Nicholas to their heresie as M. Baxter asserts in his book of Infidelity p. 132. However we see their heresies were abominable for Christ hated them and their heretical practises and opinions consisted as Antiquity testifies under the name of christians to hold and practise all manner of corporal obscenities and adulteries lawful and all manner of spiritual fornication and idolatries also and which they grounded on this wicked principle That there was no difference in good or evil but only in opinion and therefore took liberty to all sorts of wickednesses And that these were chief heads of their heresies is somwhat evident from verse 14 15. of this chapter where the doctrine of Balaam and Nicolaitans are joyned and compared Now we know that Balaam's wicked doctrine was To lay a stumbling block before the children of Israel to entice them to offend God both in corporal and spiritual whoredom in the business of Baal Peor that so by offending him they might perish Numb 25. compared to 31.16 The Nicolaitans were this false Prophet's true disciples and were true branches of the Gnosticks of old who pretended strange and unknown high mysteries and discoveries of light which plain and orthodox christians never heard of as many of the same spirit now a days pretend unto on purpose to amuse the simple and to draw them into the snare of Satan and how well these filthy dreamers amongst us do correspond with their elder Brethren the Nicholaitans compare the heresies and blasphemies of some of these times with that description of the Nicholaitans made by M. Baxter out of historical Antiquity page 129. of his said book of Infidelity speaking of the Nicholaitans whose inhumane filthiness saith he was such and their divelish conceits so many and vile that I will forbear to mention them only this They made themselves like Christ and some of them to be equal to him and some the same with him That good and evil differed not in deed but in mens opinions they worshipped Images they lived in such horrid ways in lust and filthiness as is not to be named Epiphanius himself unhappily fell in amongst them and knew their ways from their own mouths and actions but happily escaped when they would have drawn him to their lusts They have multitudes of amazing words and notions like our Behmenists that would bring a man into a suspition of witchcraft to read them They used witchcrafts and several sorts of inchantments and kept divels in familiarity with them that by their means they might encrease their knowledge and power Thus far M. Baxter And he professes afterward that it is not one nor two but all church histories of those times that makes mention of them do say the same things and if they will read Epiphanius himself who once fell in amongst them they will see much more Having thus far described the Nicholaitans and their heresies in the next place take this Note Observ That the more pure sound and undefiled the church is the divel is most solicitous to raise heresies and schisms in it How busie the divel was in those Asian churches in the Apostles times to bring in the foul heresies of the Nicolaitans the doctrines of Balaam and Jezabel if possibly he could so to entice them to sin against their God that he might have his purpose on them but when the church became more corrupted tyrannical and antichristianized under the headship of the Bishop of Rome their heresies were less and their schismes fewer then in the primitive purer times for Satan would rather hereticate and poyson the whole then a part and indeed the divel has his designe accomplished when he sees a church rushing onward to their own destruction by the multitude of their corruptions and amongst such he hath no need to lay any of his stratagems of heresies and schisms but only to let them in peace and security and they will hasten on fast enough unto their own destruction Therefore hence unto me it is a good argument that we have true and faithful churches of Christ amongst us and that the true doctrine of the Gospel is sincerely preached and taught amongst our churches or else Satan the envious one would not be so ready to sow also his tares of heresies and errour as he does at present amongst us to overthrow if he may our hopes and harvest It seems to me but a sad saying when some Ministers affirm they give thanks to God that their churches are not troubled with the heresies of the times though I confess heresies are great evils and to be fervently deprecated from all Christ's flocks yet when they say they are all at peace it is much to be feared that there is another strong man keeping the house besides Christ for be sure when Christ comes to bruise Satan's head he will bite Christ's heel and no sooner is the man-child Christ born in the souls of his faithful ones but the Dragon will presently send forth floods of water of heresies errours and persecutions if possibly to destroy both it and them Rev. 12.15 and this proceeds from that everlasting enmity set between the seed of the woman and the seed of the Serpent even from the beginning Gen. 3.15 and will continue until he be bound up in everlasting chains of darkness and therefore the purer the church is the busier will Satan be to undermine them if he may Observ 2. Another Note is That all heresie is defiling and abominable
stands little in stead unto the Papists and their champion Bellarmine in his book of Grace and Free will cap. 1. to maintain from hence their Pelagian doctrine The power of mans Free-will before conversion unto Faith and amendment For Bellarmine therein triumphantly interrogates were not he foolish that would knock at his neighbours door if he knew for certain that there were no man within that could open It is true it were so but Bellarmine for all his great learning herein is much mistaken Christ here knocks at a door where there was one within that was able to open the party was only asleep he was not dead or quite departed from his house and therefore he knocks and calls unto him to awake and open unto him like the Spouse in the Canticles 5.2 She was asleep when her beloved came and knocked saying Open to me my Sister my Love my Dove my Undefiled So Christ comes to the church of Sardis vers 2. and bids her to awake and strengthen the things that remain and commands Laodicea to open unto him who had a power and ability to open though it was grown weak and remiss and therefore had need of a knocking a vigorous call to rouse her up unto her duty And therefore Bellarmine is quite mistaken when from hence he asserts That Christ bids the reprobate and unregenerate to open to him it is only a believing church a backslidden luke-warm believing church that he bids to rise up and open to him it is not one altogether dead but a sleepy careless luke-warm church that he stirs up to this duty of opening to him Secondly I answer Though it were granted Bellarmine that Christ somtimes knocks at the doors of Reprobates and unregenerate persons and calls to open to him though they neither will or can open to him yet Christ may do this as often he does without any impeachment to his wisdom he hereby shows what their duty is and requires it from them and justly he may though they are not in a possibility to perform it they having forfeited and lost their ability by their own fault not only in their common parent the first Adam but also by walking in the same steps of disobedience with him and Christ is not bound by any Law to restore it again unto them And therefore Christ in the last place does often call to open to him upon the very reprobate themselves as in a judiciary way for the aggravation of their condemnation upon their refusal according to that of John 15.22 If I had not come and spoken to them they had no sin but now they have no cloak for their sin Thus much in answer to Bellarmine and his doctrine of Free-will and the power of the meerly natural man in the works of grace and faith which are in the first place to be wrought by the Spirit to be nourished by the Spirit to be consummated and perfected by the same Spirit But to proceed If any man hear my voice and open the door I will come in to him and will sup with him and he with me As if Christ had said If any man will be obedient to the word of my mouth opening the door of their hearts yeilding obedience to my many and earnest solicitations I will then come and dwell in that soul and impart my self unto him and sup with him that is communicate and have mutual fellowship with him and he with me Note hence Observ 1. That it is the Saints highest priviledge to have fellowship with Christ and he with them Where there are those heavenly intercourses there is a heaven upon earth or earth ascending into heaven and heaven coming down upon earth persons hereby do become the Temples of the holy Spirit I will come in to him saith Christ that is Christ will dwell in him spiritually really operatively by his grace and he shall dwell in me that is by faith and so such become and are made the sons of God Luke 19.5 and are made partakers of his holy nature Is it not a great shame to our christian churches to deny themselves this great priviledge in not hearkning to the voice of Christ or opening the door unto him It is true we are ready to hearken to the voice of Christ so far as stands with our interest that we may not be accounted heathens abroad in the world and indeed that is all if it will amount so far for the ordinance of preaching is no distinguishing Ordinance Go Teach all Nations and the Ordinances of Prayer and Praise are but natural duties which all persons in the world are bound unto as well as christians but where is the opening the door to Christ in his especial distinguishing Ordinances Where is the mutual feasting supping and communicating between Christ and his churches in his holy Ordinances of the Supper tasting and feeding on the several and various gifts of the Spirit of Christ in his members Where is the improving of his Discipline Where are his Gardens enclosed Are not all like a Forrest or Wilderness without any culture or hedge about them 'T is true there are some few gardens whose savoury spices and precious ointment does cast a sweet smelling savour abroad but their tender Grapes are but weak and it is to be feared if God's mercy prevent not that either the little Foxes will undermine them or the wild Boar root them out I speak it according to my judgement and conscience that our contentation and sitting satisfied under a formal and luke-warm preaching and some other natural duties only will be a means to provoke God to spew us out of his mouth for our half way Religion the one ought to be done and the other not left undone we ought to have a respect to the whole will of God not so far only as our carnal wisdom thinks sufficient and no farther It was once and not long since a just complaint That common Prayer and other church Discipline and Episcopal Ruling had thrust out of doors a true preaching and divers other holy Ordinances of Christ But observe the change now it is to be feared that preaching will silence and invalidate many other of the Ordinances of Christ and render them useless to us Therefore we are to hearken to the voice of God the whole voice of God and open to it if we expect Christ to come in and to sup with us and we with him We are first to hearken to his Word open the door to him of our hearts in the preaching thereof then we are to proceed and not sit still as those silly ones that are ever learning and never coming to the knowledge or practise of the truth we are to go on to the work of perfection that is to walk in all the Ways and Ordinances of Christ which will build up our souls unto the measure of a perfect man in Christ and make us wise indeed unto salvation Lastly I conceive there is more in these words I