not alwaies in the same state it laboureth sometimes seeming to decay vnder the Crosse sometimes it flourisheth in the aboundance of much peace sometimes it is gouerned by these who are Nurses of it and sometimes by such whose hands are readiest to pull it downe now where the affection of Princes that gouerne is not all one the condition and state of the Church must needes alter besides euen the chiefe officers erected by our Sauiour of the Apostles Prophets and Euangelistes in that kinde notwithstanding are all ceased for although Apostolicall Iurisdiction doo now continue in Bishops yet no man is ordayned to bee an Apostle that which is aunswered of ordinarie and extraordinarie ouerthroweth the cause for if these bee extraordinarie and all offices that are reckoned vp by the Apostle bee not ordinarie then the Gouernours of the Church ceasing no man can say with reason that forme of the Church gouernment is all one To holde that all that was diuers at diuers times was the same gouernment is to make things continuing and ceasing distinguisht and confounded to bee all one And if wee looke further to that which seemed to bee most solemne the Senedrin and great Councell at Ierusalem is no where extant And if they allow the forme at Geneua they are popular but surely though in this no man could looke for other than difference to arise where trueth hath not laid the foundation of what they holde yet this is most straunge that they are so firme for Doctors to bee distinguisht from Pastors for seuerall Consistories for euerie parish widowes and such like whereas Geneua hath but one Consistorie for diuers Parishes no Doctors distinct from Pastors no widowes and in Fraunce onely Pastors and Elders are thought necessarie yea besides this there were many things commendably in vse in the former times which as the Church hath power to remooue so likewise hath she authoritie to appoint new our Sauiour instituted a Ceremonie which hee inioyned his Disciples to obserue of washing of feete the same continued long in the Church as may appeare by a Treatise attributed to Saint Cyprian but now out of vse and vtterly ceased The Apostles decreed that all should abstaine from bloud and from things strangled the Apostle willeth the Romans to greete one another with a holy kisse yet both these discontinued amongst vs euery man praying or prophecying with his head couered dishonoreth his head a thing at this day not of that strict obseruance but that it may bee done without breach of humility or the Apostles precept That all the lawes and orders in the Church are not durable appeareth by ceasing of the Ceremoniall law and the Iewish pollicie so that the obseruation of the Morall and whatsoeuer hath dependance vpon that is the true rule of discipline for maners other things are but the violent fancies of some weak men who haue abused their Zeale to doe much hurt Neither neede wee stand to prooue much the alteration of this gouernment seeing themselues haue varied in the demanding of it In the yeare 1572. the first admonition which the late most Reuerend Lord Archbishop of Canterbury did after confute was offered to the Parliament as contayning a perfect platforme of the discipline they desired to be established in this Realme Within fewe yeares after they altered it againe In the yeare 1584. an other which seemed to haue receiued as much perfection as they could desire but presently after the Parliament this was found amongst them to haue some thing amisse and the correcting being referred to one who had trauersed the matter a new it came out more perfect in the yeare 1586 an other in the yeare 1588 and it is like as most of these were against Parliaments so some thing now is to bee performed for this if their cause can haue patrons or the patrons can finde hope but I hope by this time our Gouernours are more wise and hee who is able to discerne these plots hath found by experience their desires to bee too proud and in reason not likely to benefit this Church with a better peace so that wee may safely conclude this point That though the Church of all Societies bee fittest to bee Gouerned with an auncient and veriuous discipline yet that discipline is farre differing from the same that they doo require CHAP. III. The Censure of a Booke called the Plea of the Innocent WHere the persons of men haue so neere affinitie with the actions performed by them it will require great moderation and care so to censure the one as that we may not iustly bee suspected to disgrace the other the neglect of this a fault which is too common both in the times before vs and in our age hath turned the confutation of errors to personall reproofes and hath made the defendors weaknes or Indiscretion the greatest aduersary to a good cause and howsoeuer some partiall men are caried with as much loue to all they doo as they are to themselues that doo it and with like disposition are impatient to bee toucht in eyther yet no man of wisedom or vnderstanding can thinke it to bee all one to haue his action or his person censured some Actions I confesse there are of that nature which are the defectes of our ordinary weakenesse and therein though not Excusable yet carry some reason to challenge a fauourable compassion extending either to forgiuenes or to concealments which both doubtlesse are the effects of men that are truly vertuous where as some others as it were by couenant are performed to that end that they rest amongest all men and in all ages lyable to that censure which time shall giue them And they merit Of the first sort are our sinnes in which kinde our profession hath had some euill Confessours of the Latter are Bookes which as they are actes performed with the best of our iudgement voluntarie with deliberation and with a resolution by couenaunt eyther to aunswere or indure what Censures shall light vpon them it cannot bee any breach of Charity or modesty where the opinions misliked are defended to censure the Bookes which are made in defence of them And although euerie man in reason is tyed to bee cerefull of his good name yet seeing that both euerie harde Censure is not a proofe to continue errour nor euerie errour an imputation to a man that deserues well It is not all one to say such a Booke is euill written and to say such a one is not an honest man The first is allowed in the warrantable liberty of all learning but the latter Charitie and Humilitie do both forbid as being but the daungerous effect of too much pride Things that are euill in manners are euill in that they are done and are a iust imputation to the partie in that they are knowne but writings that are Censured carry not euer that sentence among them which some ignorant or partiall opposite shall impose vpon them nor euer doo men censure as
is better than the fat of Rammes Secondly if Ceremonies be contrarie to true holines they were to be omitted for their end was to further deuotion not to hinder it In this respect they were dispensable when eyther by the place or time two violent circumstances of all our actions or for some impediments they could not well be reserued in this respect Circumcision was omitted for those that were borne in the desart as being vnfit to moue immediatly after that wound and being vncertaine to rest seeing they must follow the fire or the cloud when they moued Thus in persecution we are content rather to exercise Religion without Ceremonies than to want it which in peace to neglect or contemne must needs be a great offence Those times being fittest to serue God with greater reuerence and holier solemnities which are compassed about with greater rest and more happie blessings Lastly when Ceremonies are requisite to testifie our faith as doubtlesse they are then when they are through misunderstanding oppugned wee may not in conscience remit any part of them for the refuâ—ing of such can be no small sin where the vsing is blessed with the crowne of martyrdom But seeing as some thinke froÌ„ the particular deuotioÌ„ of the town Cere or as others froÌ„ wanting being a religious restraint they are called Ceremonies we need not to doubt in the beginning eyther that vertuous office which they did or those religious abstinences which they performed ioyned Religion Ceremonies with that nearnesse as that neither was absolutely perfect where both were not This vnkinde separation one of the sower fruits that haue growen in this latter age is a great wound giuen vnto Religion doubtlesse in many for I will not excuse all only froÌ„ the abundance of too much loue Al Ceremonies may be deuided thus Some were for Iustifications such as the law commaÌ„ded whereby the obseruer was made more purified and more holy In place whereof afterward succeeded those that were for ornament and to signifie such vertues as were requisite in those parties that rightly vse them Secondly in respect of the Author some were the ordinances of Nature as to looke vp to heauen to lift vp the hands to bow the knees to knocke the breast and such like when wee pray things vsed in their deuotion by the Heathen themselues others were appointed by God himselfe some by the Apostles and the Bishops that succeed in her place Thirdly some are parts of the immediate worship as sacrifice prayer adoration and such like some onely dispose as fasting austere liuing some are onely instruments as Churches Altars Chalises and all those which religiously being separated serue onely to make the deuotion more solemne and that solemnitie to be more holy Fourthly of these some respect persons sometimes some other concerne places all which concurring in a diuine worship are with Ceremonies by separation made sacred and so fitter to serue vnto holy vses Lastly some are particular some more general vninersal as the faâ—â—ing vpoÌ„ the Sabbath in S. Austins time was obserued at Rome but not at Millan as also the washing of feet after baptisme was obserued at Millane but not at Rome in all which saith the same Father there is no discipline can be better than in these to follow the custom of the place wherunto we come This couÌ„saile gaue Saint Ambrose to Saint Austen that none might offend him nor he might offend any A graue moderation which doubtlesse if it were found in all which desire to bee examples to others of a better life the showes of Religion could not haue wanted so much deuotion nor the sinewes of the Church could haue beene racked with so little pittie For in this kinde the same persons may in contrarie places performe contrarie things both well As Zachaeus receiue Christ into his house with ioy and the Centurion with as much prayse say Lord I am not worthy that thou shouldest enter into my house both honouring their Sauiour by a diuers maner both miserable in their sinnes and both obteyning mercy For in alterations of custome that which may helpe peraduenture with the profit of it doubtlesse with the noueltie of change will do more hurt The best remembrance in this caâ—e wil be this That the end of the commandemeÌ„t is loue out of a pure hart a good conscieÌ„ce of faith vnfeigned froÌ„ the which things some haue erred haue turned vnto vain iangling they would be doctors of the law yet vnderstand not what they speak 〈◊〉 whâ—râ—f thâ—y affirme For loue is the fulfilling of the 〈…〉 therefore whosoeuer thou art saith S. Austen that readest either this or any other so read and so learn that thou thinke this to be truly spoken knowledge puffeth vp but Charity buildeth this suffereth long it is bountifull enuieth not doth not boast it selfe is not puffed vp for preseruatioÌ„ of Vnitie being that whereunto in this kinde all must ayme it is fittest for those who finde Ceremonies in vse not vnlawfull in any Church rather to obserue them keeping the Vnitie of the spirit in the bonde of peace than with the hazard of scisme to striue to annihilate these and to establish those that are much better For in the vse of Ceremonies at this day our Church doth not so farre differ from the endes of the first institution of them that though her reasons be not the same yet shee retaineth nothing that in substance truth is directly opposite The first end of the Iewish Ceremonies was that by them as by certaine elements the people might be retained in the seruice of God as a childe vnder the gouernment and discipline of his father for where men are not restained within some bounds limits for external worship discentions through affectation of singularitie serue as wel by a general contempt to make men prophane as continuall new and vnlimited additions of Ceremonies doe make them superstitious Those rites then to them and â—o in proportion to vs serued as sinewes to hold all and euery seuerall member of the Church in Religious inuocation and worship of the true God A second end was that they might haue a worshipp neither outwardly ouer naked nor apparelled like that which the GeÌ„tiles had a reason doubtlesse to vs not lesse forcible than to them who haue in our eye neere at hand such as are richly attired in this kinde with whom we shall ouer easily fall in loue and dislik our own seruice of God if we haue not some external Ceremonies which we are able to defende both to be as fit for Gods seruice as naturall and comely warranted by Gods word and seruing as wel to that end namely his worship as all the Ceremonies either of Heathens the Iewes or the Church of Roâ—â— doe And surely whilst some honest mindes for profitable ends haue laboured to vnburthen the Church of many Ceremonies they haue done nothing els but vntyle the
For in all societies authoritie which cannot be where all are equall must procure vnitie and obedience if vertue will not Now seeing that all men may easily erre that no errors are so daungerous as those which concerne religion the Church should be in a far worse case then the meanest common-wealth nay almost then a den of thieues if it were left destitute of meanes either to conuince heresies or to suppresse them yea though there were neither helpe nor assistance of the christian magistrate without which it were not possible for truth equitie any long time to harbour amongst the sons of men The remedie which in these cases the primitiue Church had when occasion was offered vsed against heresie and iniurie she deriued as well from the promise made by Christs owne words as from the Apostles example in the like case Christ willing them that were grieued by their brethren after the first and second admonition to tell it to the Church And addeth for direction and confirmation of all religious assemblies and conferences where two or three are gathered together in my name there am I in the middest of them and whatsoever you shall binde on earth shall be bound in heauen and whatsoeuer ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heauen Now whatsoeuer is ment here by the name of Church in the reasonable exposition of any to me it is all one to prooue this order that from priuate admonitiō they went to witnesses and from them to assemblies and seeing there must be an end of controuersies amongst men vnlesse we will plucke vp by the rootes all charitie and right when neither priuate perswasion not frendly mediation can appease parties that violently contend what other order could be prescribed but a iudicial hearing and determining of things in question Now because Christ did not set the sword to be the generall and perpetuall rule to gouerne his Church for then without a Prince there could be no Church so consequently there was none either in the Apostles time or three hundred yeeres after though where they beleeue the defence and maintenance of the Church is committed to their charge it must of necessitie follow that either there is no iudge which were the vtter subuersion of all peace when the christian magistrate is wanting or els the pastors and stewards of Christs Church to whom this care is committed must assemble together and with mutuall conference performe those duties to the Church in generall which otherwise they are bound to do to each particular place and person By Gods law what obedieuce and reuerence the father may expect from his owne childe the same or greater must all beleeuers yeeld to the fathers of their faith the one begetteth vs to this life the other to a life that is much better Those then whom Christ hath placed to be watchmen and leaders the light and salt of his Church must not onely warne and guide but also lighten and season in their measure that whole body for when all other failes this onely is left to clense the house of God from vessels of dishonour yea when there were no beleeuing Magistrates to assist the Church this onely was left as the best meanes and after when christian Princes began to protect the truth they neuer had nor can haue safer direction amongst men then by the Synods of wise and godly Bishops Thus a Synod at Antioch about threescore yeeres before the councell of Nice condemned and deposed Paulus Samosatenus for heresie and when he would not yet yeeld to the Church but keepe it by violence vpon complaint to Aurelianus the Emperor though he were a heathen Samosatenus was with extreame shame driuen from the Church by the worldly Prince All countries in all ages haue had the benefit of this not as a thing arbitrarie and left free to those that peraduenture were careles of the Churches welfare but prescribed by sundrie councels as Nice Antioch Constantinople Chalcedon and commaunded by the imperiall lawes in this manner That all the Ecclesiasticall state and sacred rules may with more diligence be obserued we require saith the Emperor euery Archbishop Patriarch and Metropolitan to call vnto him once or twise euery yeere the Bishops that are vnder him in the same prouince and throughly to examine all the causes which Bishops Clarkes or Monkes haue amongst themselues and to determine them so as whatsoeuer is trespassed by any person against the Canons may be reformed So that wee must either cleane reiect Synods a thing doubtles of no small daunger as the times may fall out and make the presbyters in euery parish supreme iudges or else admit some which be no other but the Bishops both to call and to moderate these meetings for in all those Synods which continued in the Church euen when she mas most sharpely pursued by the sworde from the death of the Apostles to the raigne of Constantine they were assembled and gouerned by the Bishops of the chiefe and mother Churches and Cities in euery prouince who by the auncient councels were called Metropolitanes And after when Princes came to imbrace the faith the best meanes they could deuise to procure peace and aduance religion was by their lawes to referre Ecclesiasticall causes to Ecclesiasticall Iudges And least they should be long in strife they charged the Metropolitane to assemble the Bishops of his prouince twise euery yeere there to examine and order what matters of doubt should arise which happely might disturbe the Churches peace Thus the Synode of Rome called by Cornelius against Nouatus consisted of threescore Bishops and many others of the clergie In the councels of Rome vnder Hilarius and Gregorie where foure and thirtie presbyters subscribed after two and twentie Bishops infinit are the examples in this kind which teach vs that neither the Church at any time was or in deed◠can safely be without tempests if Synods want nor Synods can be tightly ordered if the Metropolitans and Bishops should be wanting in them Seeing then they haue this vse if this were all to make that societie able with order to suppresse heresies and redresse wrongs without which doubtles the Church of all assemblies were worst gouerned it ought not to seeme vnreasonable to any that a thing so necessarie and auncient should with honour and reuerence be retained amongst vs. But least the name of Bishops should be offensiue to any as some haue thought it onely the ambitious title of a tyrannous gouernment these that would seeme moderate aduisers to equalitie and humilitie in this case must giue vs leaue to tell them that the name is auncient the office needefull and both so warrantable that they must needes be thought at the least malicious enuiers of the peace and prosperitie of Gods Church who are desirous or can be content that order obserued in the Apostles time and those Churches which were purest and next vnto them should be banished
other speciallitie to that which is sensiblie most eminent in the thing signified and therefore what better title could be giuen to all that wâ—re imployed in this worke then the reuerend name of presbyters or fatherly guides For a presbyter according to the proper meaning of the new testament is he vnto whom our sauiour Christ hath communicated the power of spirituall procreation Out of the twelue patriarchs issued the whole multitude of Israell according to the flesh and according to the ministerie of heauenly birth our Lords Apostles we all acknowledge to be the patriarches of his whole Church S. Iohn therefore beheld sitting about the throne of God in heauen foure and twentie presbyters the one halfe fathers of the old the other of the new Ierusalem in which respect the Apostles likewise gaue themselues the same title albeit that name were not proper but common vnto them with others For of presbiters some were greater some lesse in power and that by our Sauiours owne appointment the greater they which receiued fulnes of spirituall power the lesse they to whom lesse was graunted The Apostles peculiar charge was to publish the Gospell of Christ vnto all nations and to deliuer his ordinances receiued by immediat reuelation from himselfe which preeminence excepted to all other offices and duties incident vnto their order it was in them to ordaine and consecrate whomsoeuer they thought meete euen as our Sauiour did himselfe assigne seuentie disciples of his owne inferior presbyters whose commission notwithstanding to preach and baptise was the same which the Apostles had But when time and obseruation had made a difference in the Church of these two euery Bishop being a presbyter but not euery presbyter a Bishop the Church condemned it as the heresie of Acrius to hold that a presbyter and a Bishop were all one The Bishops as Epiphanius reasoneth begot fathers in the Church but the presbyters onely begot Sonnes For the priests did chose saith Saint Hierâ—â— one amongst themselues whom they placing in a higher degree called a Bishop For vnlesse saith the same father the chiefe authoritie were giuen to one there would be as many schismes as priests So that their collection out of Saint Ambrose and Hierom is so much the more strange who thinke that bishops and presbyters did not differ in the Apostles time It must at least be an imitation of their pride who in former time haue troubled the Church with the like errors Cornelius Bishop and Martyre long before the Councell of Nice reporting to Fabius Bishop of Antioch the originall of Nouatus schisme saith this iolly inquisitor of the Gospell vnderstandeth not that there ought to be but one Bishop in that Catholike Church in which hee knoweth there are fourtie and sixe presbyters Neither haue there wanted rules whereby if it please them they might easily make a difference betwixt these two the presbyters were many in euery Church of whom the presbytery consisted Bishops were alwaies singular one in a citie and noe moe except an intrusion which made a schisme This singularitie descended from the Apostles and their schollers in all the famous Churches of the world by a chare of succession and continueth to this day where abomination or desolation that is heresie or violence haue not broake it off The second signe of Episcopall power was imposition of hands to ordaine presbyters and Bishops for as pastors had some to assist them in their charge which were presbyters so were they to haue others to succeede in their places which were Bishops And this right by imposing of hands to ordaine presbyters and Bishops was deriued at first from the Apostles not vnto presbyters but Bishops onely A thing continuing for this fifteene hundred yeare without example or instance to the contrarie and hath onely found resistance in our age which surely in my opinion cannot be ignorance so much in them as willingnes to oppugne the gouernment of our Church seeing there haue been few Churches of account through all christendome that had not as may be shewed Bishops and presbiters both at the same time But Austin is most plaine who writing to one that was but a presbyter saith Thou shalt be a presbyter as thou art and hereafter when God will thou shall be a Bishop This poynt is learnedly obserued by that reuerend and worthie Bishop whose labored defence may shorten our trauell in this poynt Now besides these many other things were peculiar to Bishops by the authoritie of the Canons and custome of the Church as reconciling of penitents confirmation of infanâ—s dedication of Churches and such like which were as Saint Hierom saith rather to the honor of priesthoode then to the necessitie of any law Now if any man thinke this office superfluous in the Church and of no vse let him well consider before he censure them what it is to see the Church continually stored with sound and able pastours to watch ouer their soules to take care that the flocke of Christ be rightly taught and soberly guided to keepe both presbyters and people from schisme heresie and impietie to direct in times of daunger to determine doubts without troubling the whole prouince and if he shall thinke either these needles to be done or lawfull and fit to be done by any other we could peraduenture thinke it more tollerable thaâ— an ordination so auncient and so much warranted neuer interrupted in the orderly gouernment of any Church since the Apostles time should notwithstanding be remooued as a calling tyrannous and antichristian onely to content the humorous fancies of these men But doubtles that which reasonably they mislike in this case is that men called to the office of the ministerie a function meerely spirituall and ordained to the dispensation of heauenly graces should so farre either forget the vertuous example of our Sauiour or the humilitie of such whom they desire to succeede that swelling with ambition they renew the contention long sincé controuled in the disciples of Christ which should bee the greatest and are content if not to affect yet to accept of those ciuill imployments which belong vnto the Princes counsell whereby not onely they are made idle and hindred from that dutie which the Church requireth but are puft vp with those Lordly titles which are directly vnlawfull and without warrant Now to preuent this we admit Synodes say they and some to gather and gouerne those assemblies but for feare of ambition we would haue that priuiledge to goe round by course to all the pastors of euery prouince Where men are irregular we will not aske them either for reason or example for that they doe but a chiefe man amongst them confesseth that this going round by course to gouerne the Church doth maintaine disorder and faction and ambition is not at all decreased by it and the choosing of one to continew chiefe for his life began at Alexandria from the
A Modest and reasonable examination of some things in vse in the Church of England sundrie times heretofore misliked and now lately in a Booke called the Plea of the Innocent and an Assertion for true and Christian Church policy made for a full satisfaction to all those that are of iudgement and not possessed with a preiudice against this present Church Gouernment wherein the principall poynts are fully and peaceably aunswered which seeme to bee offensiue in the Ecclesiasticall State of this Kingdome The Contentes whereof are set downe in the Page following By William Couell Doctor of Diuinitie Eccles. Chap. 3.1 The children of wisedome are the Church of the righteous and their ofspring is obedience and loue AT LONDON Printed by Humfrey Lownes for Clement Knight and are to be solde at his shop at the Signe of the holy Lambe in Saint Paules Churchyard 1604. The Contents of this Booke Chap. 1 KIngs and Princes haue authoritie and ought to haue care for the Church gouernment page 1 2 The Church visible of all other Societies is fittest to haue a Discipline but neuer the same that some men desire page 13 3 The Censure of a booke called The Plea of the Innocent pa. 25 4 The proceeding of the Reformers wholly vnlawfull pag. 32 5 Of Contention pag. 46 6 Of Ceremonies pag. 55 7 Of Subscription pag. 75 8 Of Discipline pag. 94 9 Of Archbishops and Bishops pag. 103 10 Of Ministers their Office and learning pag. 124 11 Of the maintenance of Ministers and of Tithes pag. 142 12 Of Non Residencie Pluralities and Dispensations pag. 159 13 Of publike prayer and of the defectes supposed to be in the Liturgie of the Church of England pag. 174 14 Of Tolleration of diuers Religions and how farre dissenting opinions from the true Christian faith may and ought to bee permitted in one and the same Kingdome pag. 196 15 An humble conclusion to his sacred Maiestie and the Right Honorable Lords of his Highnesse priuie Councill together with the rest whom it may concerne to defend this Church page 206 Deo omnis Potestas Gloria To the Right Honourable and most Reuerend father in God c. my verie good Lord the Lord Bishop of LONDON ⸫ THe word Right honorable is in great trauell with much euill when she shall be deliuered he onely knoweth who measureth al times with his hand and before whose eye lieth open that bottomlesse aeternitie it selfe The faces of Kingdomes and States according to the prosperitie and aduersitie of the Church amongest them sometimes looke heauily and sometimes chearfully as refreshed with more good Man whose Reason and Religion serueth to number these things feeleth in himselfe a true diuinitie manifested by that pure ambition of being greater than hee yet can bee whilest notwithstanding in the sence and feare of these things hee stoopeth as to a burthen that is too heauâ—e Religious and mature wisedome the safest builders of true greatnesse assureth men in prouidence to preuent the worst things or at least by foresight growing familiar with theÌ„ teacheth how to beare them with much patience fewe Kingdomes there are which haue not eyther more scarres in the Church not fully cured or else greater signes of greater insuing euils than our owne I am loth to be thought to flatter a fault whereunto I am not vsually subiect and a thing needlesse being the greatest hatred from the greatest loue which euerie beareth to himselfe but I may say truly and I doubt not but what I say the world thinketh the greatest part of this good next our dread Souereigne is now without enuie bee it spoken your owne The consideration whereof hath made me out of that infinite loue and duty which I owe to his Grace being dead and your Honour yet aliue to dedicate these labours to you both in the defence of that Church which truth experience her aduersaries haue proued for gouernment the most absolute since the Apostles time That it is vndertaken by me is the greatest disaduantage to this cause that it is continued and daily receiueth strength from authority is amongst infinite blessings the greatest and most vnspeakable of this Church I haue dealt as your Honour well knoweth in this cause with a threefolde disaduantage one that it hath so fully beene handled by so many of great learning heretofore so that at this time a defence was rather requisite to tell those that hope for alteration that our Church is still of the same iudgement and spake not heretofore onely to please that State a second is that the things disliked are not differences of any great learning seeing wee deale with aduersaries whose chiefest hope dependeth vpon the allowance of vnlearned followers so that Demonstrations of reason are more requisite than proofes from authoritie Last of all they are a generation apt and skilfull to speake euill I haue carefully and according to my naturall disposition auoided all occasion that might prouoke them to it yet I looke for no other neither by the grace of God so that this paines may benefit the Church do I much care the strongest tyrant of things and men is fancy the truest gouernour Religion hallowed follies when they are vnmasked are but at the best the weake opinions of simple men of whom notwithstanding if they had learned humilitie and obedience this Church might haue much vse your Lordship is besides that particular duty and thankefulnesse which I owe vnto you executor of his Testament and Inheritour of his vertues that was the true owner and possessor of these labours which if it please your Honour to accept with their vnworthie Author into your more priuate and inward affection It shall bee my happinesse to be your seruant and their credit by your Lordships meanes to doe seruice to this Church Thus in the assurance of this hope crauing pardon for my boldnesse I humbly take my leaue desiring God to blesse you with all Graces fit for so high a place and with contentment and long life to my singular comfort and the especiall benefit of this Church May 27. 1604. Your Lordships in all dutie WILLIAM COVELL To the Christian Reader IF the immoderate desire of reformation in some men had not extended it selfe further than eyther Religion or reason would wel permit and especially at that time when thankfulnesse exacted from vs all something like a Sabbath for that blessed Rest continued to this Church by the meanes of our dread Souereigne this cause and some others not yet published had with their vnworthy authors slept in a long and a charitable silence and whereas the miraculous blessings bestowed and continued vpon this land could no otherwise rightly be vnderstood than the true effectes of that Church which was planted in it seeing as S. Ambrose saith That is Charitie to be expected that is Charitie greater than the Empire if that faith bee inuiolate which preserueth the Empire I thought it vnfit to let these men vnderstand that
this Consistoriall Gouernment may take place the benefit whereof as they magnifie little weighing those yet vnexperienced Euils which must needes follow so the harmes of it are at large set downe by diuers others who with learning and iudgment haue labored in this point There is doublesse no Societie deerer vnto God than his Church in the gouernment whereof he hath made choice of two sorts of men to be imployed vnder him The first are Ministers of his word and Sacraments whose calling is perpetuall and necessary in the Church for so long as the Church is in this world it caÌ„not possible be coÌ„tinued without these of wihch we shall more fitly speake heereafter The other are Kings and Magistrats whom to the happy estate of the Church we hold with all reuerence of such vse that those are worst that mislike their gouernment that Church in all reason like to be most happy which God in his mercy hath blessed with the best King This appeareth in the Kings of Iuda who being vertuous Religion that was decaied was restored and what the Idolatry of others had corrupted the vprightnes of some which followed did purifie againe God in his loue performing that promise vnto his Church that Kings should be her Nursings-fathers and Queenes her Nursing-mothers In this respect more specially than others they are called Gods seruants not only because they serue him in the gouernmeÌ„t of the coÌ„monwealth a thing common with them and the worst Princes but because he vouchsafeth to vse their meanes as the fittest Instruments to aduance his Church vpoÌ„ earth And surely a double seruice God expecteth from them the one Common with all Christians the other peculiar to serue him in that place as Kings Princes To haue performed the first is an action of praise and may giue great hope but to faile in the second is staynd with reproch vsually accompained with much daunger Euill Princes seruing oftentimes to Act but the ruines of that Kingdome by the fall of the Church in whose misery theselues for the most part doe perish In the first dutie as Christians they are not priuiledged aboue other men they are tyed to same obedience bound to as many vertues nay moe for exaÌ„ple must in the end being called to the same account be iudged with as much seuerite as the meanest subiect Be wise now therfore O ye Kings be learned ye that are Iudges of the Earth Serue the lord with feare reioyce vnto him with Reuerence In the latter the seruice of Princes hath two parts the one concerning the Commonwealth the other Religion and the Church to the first they are tyed as Kings to the latter they are bound as they are vertuous and Religious Kings The first in dooing mercy and iudgment in defending the fatherlesse and poore in seeing that such as be in neede and necessitie haue right in bestowing duely punishment and reward and in all those other polliticke vertues they are happy Instruments to make a prosperous and flourishing Commonwealth The second concerneth his Religion a duty as it lyeth vpon all for all ought to be Religious so especielly vpon the Prince who must not only be but be the meanes to make all other to become Religious a thing though not euer true vnder vertuous Kings whose holy examples sometimes preuaile no farther but to make Hypocrits but seldome or neuer to be expected where the Princes theÌ„selues delight to seeme opeÌ„ly prophane If man had no other light but the light of Nature would not so willingly beleeue what were done with as without the Scripture yet euen this point will appeare to be most true being the practise of those men who had no other guide for their Actions than the vnchangeable directions of the light of Nature for whatsoeuer the Religion was as in most it was nothing but Idolatrous Superstition yet the transgression thereof was esteemed worthy to receaue punishment and the appointment of this punishment was thought to be peculiar to those who had principall authoritie to gouern the Comonwealth Thus the Athenian tooke vpon theÌ„ the power to condeÌ„ne Socrates a man peraduenture wiser thaÌ„ any of the rest but faulty as they thought in ReligioÌ„ therefore to be censured by the Authoritie which they al had The like we read of the RomaÌ„s Tyberius would make Christ a God without the authority of the Senat wher though the Act was needles to Christ little honor yet it sheweth that both the care of Religion belonged to the Roman Emperor that men euen Heatheâ—s were not hastily carried to performe any actioÌ„ of that nature without the aduice of others iudgmeÌ„t neither euer the Apostles or Prophets repreheÌ„d this care in the Rulers in any age It was easie to erre what ReligioÌ„ was but all men saw to whom the care did principally belong neither should any maÌ„ deserue coÌ„mendation for performing that which were wholy exempted from the limits of his owne calling But al Antiquitiâ— hath giueÌ„ in this kind honorable Testimony to CoÌ„stantine and Theodosius two Emperors of much vertue Nay Religiâ—n it selfe which giueth the best Rules to preserue Religion being contained in the Two Tables expresly commandeth who ought to be the ouerseer the keeper and preseruer of both Inwardly the strongest moÌ„tiue is Religion and they are most for the most part Religious who are Religious for conscience but there is a feare from the hand of the Maiestrate able to restraine those at least from outwarde being euill whom neither Conscience nor Religion could make honest Christian Emperours haue with their Zeale gained much honor for this in the eye and Iudgement of Gods Church This made them when contentions arose to call Councells as that of Nice Constantinople Ephesus Chalcedon to purge the Temples both from Heathenish Idolatry and Christian superstition to make lawes the better to keepe men in obedience towardes God the irreligious contempt of whose worshippe though in the Subiects themselues haue brough a iust ruine euen for not forbidding both vpon the Prince and the Commonwealth Reason then which tyeth Princes to procure the prosperitie of that land ouer which they gouerne exacteth froÌ„ them a principall care of the Church and of Religion the decay and the contempt whereof are the originall causes of pestilence dearthes wares and such like For where humors are infected a little it is like that the maners are first distempered a great deale the most of the Fathers are plentifull in this point This made Saint Austine learnedly to confute the Donatists whose Haerecy was like the error of some in our days holding that Princes ought to permit euery man to enioy what Religion he likes and to persecute no man for Religion at all this serueth to confute the two great Errors of our time the one of the Anabaptists the other of the Church of Rome The first holding it vnlawfull for a Christian to be a Magistrate much lesse to vse his
as much as may bee to mitigate the euils that when the best things are not possible the best may bee made of those that are Wisedome will rather tollerate some euill in A forme of gouernment that is tryed Than in a Gouernment vntryed to stand to the hazard of a farre greater It is the honour of all Kings that which is the Title of the Princes of this Land to bee as they are called Defendours of the Faith and this not onely in regard of Enemies abroad but in respect of those also which desire alteration at home oftentimes A hope of ease giueth men that iustly suffer occasion to complaine whose discontentments how lamentably soeuer diplayed are not alwaies the euidences of true griefe nor euer the argumentes of a iust wrong For doubtlesse let a Church bee as well gouerned as euer was any eyther in or before the Apostles time Let Moses and Aaron both labour to make it Excellent Let Dauid and all his Counsellours aduise for the good of it yet she shal neuer want those within the bosome of her who eyther wearie with that which is auncient or in loue with some newe deuise of their owne are readie to depraue that Gouernment which they ought for to reuerence as being the Orders of that Societie wherevnto in all dutie they doo owe obedience There will euer bee some Corah Dathan and Abiram to tell Moses and Aaron that they take too much vpon them Such is the frailtie of humane nature and so great our vnwillingnesse to liue in subiection to the gouernment of other men That wee will rather hazard an opposition to God himselfe than haue our Zeale to bee guided by the limits of any Lawes doubtlesse those that are thus proud may iustly suspect that GOD hath not placed them as workmen in the reformation of the External gouernment of that Kingdome whose foundation was first laid with so much humilitie This if the first authors of these troubles had well considered they would not in a matter of so great Consequent haue allotted the power and authoritie of alteration vnto the violent and vnlimited passions of the rude multitude a thing in it selfe as without warrant so incredible almost to haue proceeded from men that were furnished but with common sence Could any thing sound more pleasing to the lowest and worst parts of a Kingdome Could any thing moue sooner to rebellion than to tell them that Reformation of Religion belongeth to the Communaltie that the Communaltie may lawfully require of their King to haue true Preachers and if he be negligent they iustly may themselues prouide them maintaine them defend them against all that persecute them and may detaine the profit of the Church-liuings from the other sorte If these strange opinions which must needes sound harshly in the eares of all Kinges had not dispersed themselues like a poyson into the veynes of this Kingdome the Authors might haue slept in silence and their hallowed treasons haue remained vntouched But seeing those who were sollicitours abroad are now so neere that they be daungerous perswaders at home it is a consideration not of small importance as well to looke at the Authors and the meanes with what pretences soeuer they are ouershadowed as at the thing it selfe neither much needfull nor verie safe And howsoeuer in humane reason we haue now lesse cause than euer to feare the daunger of this euill yet seeing no harme in a religious Kingdome with a vertuous Prince findeth as little resistance as that which is couered with the name of Zeale all men haue cause both to pray aduise and assist that the misteries of this euill the iust punishment for the contempt of his truth light not vpō vs in our dayes nor in the dayes of our Children that shall succeede after There is not any fancie grounded vpon so little truth that hath so speedely growne to that greatnes as the discipline of Geneua hath It is like in our Kingdome yet fit inough peraduenture for them vnto the Gourd that shadowed Ionas but of a small continuance and yet some great Prophets are content to rest vnder the shadowe of it wee shall easily forgett the Author of greater benefits vnlesse some Worme in mercie be sent for to eate it downe at the first in the Auncient Disputations against the Papists and Anabaptistes both in Fraunce and Geneua there could bee found but two essentiall notes of the Church The true preaching of the word and the right administration of the Sacraments but when some of ours were returned from Geneua they were not affraied to tell vs a strange opinion to be publisht by learned wise men That Maister Beza helde the Geneua Discipline the third note of the Church and of as much necessitie as the Sacramentes or the worde it selfe which thing if it were as soundly proued as it seemes it is constantly beleeued by them all men had reason to acknowledge them the Authors of much good and to aduenture themselues farre in the defence of it Out of this stronge opinion haue proceeded these vnreuerend speeches against our Land Englande with an Impudent forehead hath said I will not come neere the Holy one wee are neuer the better for her Maiesties reformation seeing the Walls of Sion lye euen with the Ground Rome is come into our gates Antichrist reigneth amongst vs Infinite are the speeches collected out of their owne writings by others in this kinde and yet for all this they would seeme both to flatter the Prince if so worthie a Prince could bee flattered and highly to commend her happie gouernment so many waies profitable both to the Church and the Common-wealth but whilst we charge them with Innouation a thing whereunto wise Gouernors must haue good regard One commeth forth with great boldnesse yet one of the weakest that hath laboured in this cause and saith wee craue no alteration in Religion but only that the things which are standing as they doe may be brought to the order of the Apostles vse and to the Canon of Gods holy word in those circumstāces which remain yet vnreformed Do you speake cōsideratly in this plea were all things that are desired by you and others vsed in the Apostles time Are they all warranted by the Canon of Gods word Doubtlesse if you had perused with any indifferency all the learned discourses of those that haue laboured in this you should easily haue found that most things demaunded and so much desired are new and that wee are not now absolutely tied to all these things that were in vse in the Apostles time It shall not be amisse howsoeuer it hath beene alreadie most learnedly performed by others to let them Vnderstand that the orders of the Church haue beene at times diuers Whereof some haue beene added some ceased and that wee are not absolutely tied to imitate the times that haue beene before in euerie particular the Church as it is Militant heere on earth liueth
and Zeale is thought to bee farre lesse But we will hope much better of these men than that sufferance hath made them proud and their pride more contentious than heretofore And therefore me thinkes it is most straung that any man should haue so little vnderstanding as one of them hath who make vs beleeue that the Countenaunce of the Bishops were more estraunged from them now than euer before for doubtlesse if the great moderation of those persons whom our late Souereigne of blessed memorie thought fit to be aduansed to that place to be called Bishoppes had not with more than fatherly care â—estrained it selfe in compassion towards them from seuere execution of Iust lawes their occasions of complaint peraduenture would haue beene farre greater though not more reasonable but surely the Vnitie of the Church had beene much more There is nothing so daungerous as lenitie in that case where patience giueth occation for insolent contention to be more proud a thing as vnsufferable in it owne nature at all times so then especially most destitute of all excuse when inferiour persons are aptest to prouoke and the things in question in their owne iudgment are of no great momeÌ„t as those then haue don euill offices who haue renued the memorie of almost outworne errors so are they lesse tollerable in this that hauing poysoned the world with so euill opinions they seeme notwithstanding earnestly and humbly desirous to liue in peace assuring themselues that what difference soeuer prosperitie breedes doubtlesse persecution would make vs to be all one but euer reseruing this priuiledge to themselues that the Bishops in submission as offendours must first yeeld But if a man rightly consider the originall of this sinne of contention and what affections they are which giue strength vnto it hee can hardely in reason expect quietnesse to be found in the patrons of this cause pride enuie and vaine Glorie are the originall fountaies of this euill for where inferiour persons both for place and Iudgment haue ouerualued their owne fancies by their owne conceit it is no more like that in humilitie they should once yeeld thaÌ„ it is possible for obedient humilitie to become proude The distance being equall in both only in this the disaduantage greater that wee haue all of vs an aptnesse to doe euill but without grace no possible meanes in our selues to become good Hereunto if we add the second that as out of pride we loue our selues so out of enuie wee hate others no man can maruell if men that are proude vaine glorious and enuious easely also bee founde contentious for that which in different opinions maketh contenâ—iâ—â—s to cease is when men are perswaded of their betters that they are not easily deceiued and of themselues that they may and doe easely erre but all contentions are not of the same nature for some neede no excuse when we resist as we are bound for the defence of a good cause for other a small excuse may serue in that being without order yet they are not scandalous but that which is common with these men is highly sinfull without all colourable show of excuse when they are more vnreuerently bitter than is beseeming the grauitie of the persons with whom they striue and more vehement than is aunswerable to the cause that they would defend For the seruant of the Lord must not striue but must be gentle towards all men apt to teach suffering the euill men patiently so that if any man had these defects that were an aduersarie in this cause We must instruct them with meekenesse that are contrarie minded proouing if at any time God will giue them repentance that they may knowe the truth If any man teach otherwise hee is puft vp and knoweth nothing but doteth about questions and striffe of words whereof commeth enuy strife raylings euill surmisings all which are to no profit but to peruert the hearers And surely as the Apostle telleth vs Where enuie and strifes is there is sedition and all manner of euill workes But if after so much patience so many fould cleare and modest defences of a iust cause any man lust to be contentious we haue noe such custome neither the Churches of God Thus Coutention through the corruption of our nature being seldome limited in the end becommeth Inordinate and a foule sinne and so consequently without warrant when either we contend about that which is so true or so trifling that we ought not or whether we contend in that maner that doth not become vs or in that place or last of all with those persons that are vnbefitting The error in the first is that of the disciples which should be the greatest which exaÌ„ple saith Beda is willingly reade of many that desire fâ—oÌ„ the Scripture to findâ— example to warrant them to the like coÌ„tention but saith S. Ambrose if the Apostles contend it is not made a pretence of excuse for vs but set downe for a Caueat In the second the fault in those clamorous rayling and vuciuill speaches by aduersaries of all sides wherein if some in our Church had not beene too forward to aunswere their aduersaries in the same kind the best causes had beene handled with better praise and the worst had beene performed with lesse blame hence commeth it that hee who for learning hath not deserued least for the defence of our Church for modestie of writing onely excepted hath deserued best The place and the persons are ordinary circumstances to make our contentions to bee more faultie but seldome though the Scholeman say otherwise doe I finde any reason for men of the Church for to warant either ForÌ„whereas there is amongst vs Enuying strife and diuisions are we not Carnall and walke as men For saith Salomon it is a mans honor to cease from strife but euerie foole will be medling And doubtlesse if in this cause of the Church gouernment many whose conditions and learning might Iustly haue inioyned them silence had not beene medling Moderation with Grauitie might haue determined that cause which stoode only supported with a hott Zeale And seeing the best warrant of our actions must be the sincere Testimonie of our conscience from a true feare I wonder how some Inferiour and meane men could thinke it lawfull for them to vndertake a matter of that moment nay to receiue it being almost deade when men of farre greater learning and dwiseome did remaine silent some excuse peraduenture I could allowe him if others farre more worthie had not had as much Zeale and had not beene as farre better able to defend the cause but it may be he taketh his labour to be well imployed hauing made in his opinion for the good of the Church a benifit of that small Talent which God hath giuen him Other ends for which the world hath censured him hardly I dare not accâ—â—â— him of for who am I that I should condemne
house that the Rafters the Beames the maine timber might with the violence of tempests more speedily perish The third end was to make knowne vnto men by an externall worship that holinesse which in hart they professed vnto him that man hauing two parts and he the Author of both it might not be his fault to be defectiue in either of them Yet as wholy to depend vpon outward Ceremonies is but Hypocrisie so altogether to neglect them vnder pretence to worshippe him in spirit is but to sinne with more libertie vnpunished and vncontrouled Lastly the comlinesse of order and the preseruation of humane Societie are not the contemptiblest ends for the vse of Ceremonies For seeing order is the ornament of all Societies and seeing the Church of all Societies is most excellent it must needes follow that those things which Ciuilie done doe adorne others vnciuilly neglected or continued doe disgrace the Church And I am sorrie that in the earnest contention for Church gouernment men are so backeward in the allowance of Church Ceremonies seeing wise men of found iudgment haue made them a part of the Church discipline Yet Ceremonies are not all of like nature some being absolutely necessarie and common to all others not so necessary and to some it is fitte that for all men in the furtherance of Gods worshippe there should bee a sanctification of persons times and places which if either they were not done at all or done without Ceremonie the corruption of mans nature would easily esteeme them to be vnholy For although God be to be worshipped at all times and that as Christ saith the Kingdome of Heauen commeth not by obseruation either of time or place yet because whole Churches must assemble which cannot be done without these nor these rightly be thus seuered without Ceremonies all antiquitie hath allowed the distinction of these and the vse of sober and moderate Ceremonies in the separation of them that being rightly to be tearmed Religious which for the holines we leaue to imploy vnto common vses And howsoeuer it may be not altogether vnfit at least it ought not to be offensiue that Churches though all reformed are in this different for so in the obseruation of Easter the East and the Weast were diuers Africa and Italie Rome and Millaine in which our Rule must be with humilitie and loue to be all things to all yet it is many waies conuenient to haue an vnitie if it were possible of Ceremonies for the whole Church First that all may abstaine from that worshippe which is Heathenish Secondly not to inuent a peculiar worship of our owne a thing neither safe to be done nor easily without better directions to be left vndone Thirdly to remoue offence for weakenesse not able to discerne that the meanes often are diuers where the end is but one from the differing in Ceremonies haue thought a contrarietie and difference to be in Religion it selfe Lastly to let vs know that God will be worshipped externally and with order this being the best witnesse and nourishing of that worshipp which is within And doublesse the Ceremoniall worship in generall is from the lawe of nature although some specials doe proceede from the lawe positiue so that both respecting the vse which is manifolde the practise both before the lawe vnder the law and since for the Church of God vpon earth did neuer want Ceremonies it must needes seeme strange that the peeuishnesse of some few and they none of the greatest vnderstanding should preuaile so far that things of more necessarie vse as the word of Sacraments should be amongst the people distasted only for the obseruation of some few Ceremonies and yet these neither many nor the fancies of priuate men as if the obedience of inferiours with humilitie in this case were like the sinne of the sonnes of Elie for which men abhorred the offerings of the Lord. All men confesse that the Ceremonies of the Iewes prefiguring are to be remoued but not those in the Church which established by Authoritie serue onely for order and the better worship Yet all men of sound iudgment must needs graunt that for their vertue they are all inferior to the word and the Sacraments for their number they ought to be so limited that with their vnseasonable multitude they ouerwhelme not that worshippe which with their order and comlinesse they ought to further For as husbandmen are content the Branches of the Vine so long to growe and spread vntill thereby they procure the grapes to become fewer so in the Church the admission and retaining of Ceremonies are so farre lawfull vntill by their error and defect either in substance or number religion and deuotion become colder And if the opinion of them who hold the Church may ordaine Ceremonies for instructions ornament and order had extended it selfe likewise to account them a bond of diuine worshipp so farre as positiue lawes may serue to increase deuotion their assertion doubtlesse had beene much sounder and the people had excercised religion with greater holinesse and more peace but in this we haue dealt as in our religious seruice where few things can be rightly ordered that are carried with a doubtfull and headlong course The originall of this euill is as a wise man noteth That wee haue numbred the opinions of others but not weighed them a sweete error seruing but to make vs to loue that wherein at length wee must needs perish But if any man thinke as surely it is the opinion of some that those Ceremonies ordained by Christ or his Apostles are fit inought to be retained in the Church but the rest as being made without warrant haue no warrant to remaine still we answere that of all which Christiā Churches how much soeuer corrupted doe or shal vse there is by vs noe defence vndertaken for them yet wee doubt not that euery particular Church may our Church hath lawfully ordained some Ceremonies which ought religiously to be obserued more also if the church so thought fit not hereby to iustifie any to make him righteous but for ends that are spiritual and many waies behouefull to Gods worship First for ornamēt a thing which I wōder in al other cases should be accounted a vertue in religion only should be esteemed a vice Herein whilst we haue shūned iustly the glorious vanity of superstitious worship we haue familiarly fallen to despise the persons the place the times and almost that dutie which we would honor and all onely through the neglect of some due Ceremonies Secondly to stirr vp deuotiō a thing apt inough through our vanities to become small vnlesse some externall helps may be added for to make it greater Neither can the accesse of Coremonie in the consecration of new times or new places be otherwise vnderstood than the faithfull acknowledgment of special new extraordinary fauours that we haue receiued Neither ought the memorie of the resurrection
haue no Church this being as essentiall as either the word or the sacraments where this is wanting wee haue great cause both to examine the practises of these men and to consider that discipline which they tender vnto vs for that which we now haue and what benefit by this exchange is likely to redownd vnto Gods Church And surely if both our Disciplines had the like warrant that they were the lawfull â—rdinations of men for the well gouerning of the Church not repugnant to the word of God yet it is like the aduantage would be far greater on our side being auncient not the inuention of our selues found to be safe by experience and duly proportioned with the greatnes riches freedoms glory and gouernment of this kingdome whereas theirs in their owne opinions if they were not ouer partially addicted to it is new the inuention of late time dangerous by experience in a kingdome and no way proportioned but to the limits and bounds of some priuate Citie we haue knowne the aduocates of this discipline to haue much grace for which I do honor them in exhortation and prayer but to be either inuentors or aduisors of lawes and ordinations fit for a Church discipline their manner of liuing doth not allowe them that wisdome so that wee holde it much safer to retaine our owne reforming such parts as the boldnes of sinne maketh vs to thinke now to bee too remisse rather than to aduenture an exchange euen for that which by so many titles they commend vnto vs. For surely no man is lesse fit to lend his tongue to giue praise to a worke than he or they who haue lent their heads and their hands to be authors of it both because all of vs naturally loue what we doe our selues and seldome haue wee so much vnderstanding that we doe aâ—â—isse when we had no more vnderstanding but to faile in the doing of it But where their owne weakenes or want of experience might faile as not affoording them so much wisdome to make lawes if there they will vrge vs with expresse commaundement of holy Scripture then it must not seeme strange vnto them if that for which they pretend scripture without warrant of scripture be not admitted by vs wherein if they faile the Church at their hands receiueth a double wrong first a contention to disturbe her peace and secondly the false pretence of an euerlasting truth to giue authority and warrant to the late unwise inconsiderate and vnholy inuentions of silly men Dealing in this but peraduenture with lesse malice as Satan and all heretikes haue done to couller temptations and heresies with Gods word For seeing that with man especially in the Church nothing is or ought to be of that account as the scriptuâ—es are all men are dâ—sirous for that which they are willing to maintaine to alledge that proofe which hauing gâ—eatest authoritie must with men of reason finde least resistance For in all other things let reason be neuer so apparant with some men they are as easily contemned as they are alledged this onely conteyned in the two testaments both in admonishing is vpright in promising is heauenly and in threatning is fearefull All other writings as the assurance is but weake which they can affoord so their proofes are but the opinions or iudgements of mortall men and where the hearer is of the same nature with him that perswadeth reason oftentimes doth belâ—â—ue that he hath not much reason to be perswaded But in the scriptures as Hugo saith whatsoeuer is taught is truth whatsoeuer is commaunded is goodnes and whatsoeuer is promised is happines and therefore these men haue proceeded aright if they be able to proue what they vndertake in making the plaine scripture to be the commaunder of all parts of that discipline which doubtlesse whithout scripture reason hath little warrant to thinke that lawfull we understand then by discipline in this chapter which notwithstanding few of the patrones haue defined vnto vs that eternal gouernment of the church and of euery member thereof in respect they are of the Church whereby manners are reformed the peace of the Church maintained God glorified and order and decency procured this whether in substance it be such that nothing is to be added altered or diminished is the principall contention betwixt them and vs our Church holding that it hath this libertie to prescribe orders for the whole assemblie to giue direction for the goods of the Church and the maintenance of the clergie for the proceeding in matters of Church gouernment making lawes and ordâ—rs iudiciall notice censures election of offices and such like and this not without the authoritie of him who hath the supremacie in all causes all these we hold changeablâ— according to times and places whereas those who will needes be our aduersaries in this cause will haue all such as concerne the substance of discipline to be appointed by God and to be alwaies firme and immutable and the Eldership to haue the execution of them and to this end in euery parish or precinct there must be a presbyterie of doctors pastors elders and deacons and of diuers presbiteries conferences and synodes all which say they are precisely required in Gods word But seeing remonstrance hath been made both of the errors of them all and the infinit dissentions amongst themselues we can be content to let that discipline fall which stronger then they if they were willing could hardly haue strength for to hold vp This discipline of the Church ought to see the execution of those lawes and ordinances which God by his Apostles in their time and daily since by the Church maketh neither doe we thinke that any in the bosome of the Church after so long a time of knowledge can now doubt but that God hath left vnto his Church an authoritie to make lawes the execution whereof in reason is committed to those who succeed in place and authoritie the Apostles of Christ that did plant the Church whose dominion notwithstanding we make not so absolute that like tyrants at their pleasure they may rule ouer Christs flocke yet the power that the rulers of the Church haue in matters of a lower nature are lesse limited by farre hauing warrant to ordaine and appoint things indifferent which serue for order comlines and the edification of Christs Church By this authoritie the Apostles ordained many things in the Church whereof from Christ they had no expresse mention by this power S. Paul ordained that gatherings should be made at Corinth vpon the Lords day that the man should pray bare headed and the woman couered Such authoâ—itie at this day a particular Church hath as of England France end Scotland or any other that the clergie with the allowance of the prince and the rest whom it may concerne for to make lawes may ordaine and appoint â—uch ordinances as seruing for edification order and comlines in the Church are so long in force vntill they
as Antichristian from amongst vs only because it is the pleasure of those men to admit no superiors For if the name of Archbishop be not to be found in scripture considering the thing it selfe is of necessarie vse in Gods Church they haue as little reason to except against it as if Homonsion were not warrantable because Arius gaue occasion that the Nicen councell did first inuent it Many names are inuented since the Apostles time and yet both lawfully and necessarily vsed for these men haue been told long since that the authoritie and the thing whereof the Archbishop hath his name was in Saint Paules time and therefore the name lawfull and if it were not yet both might bee lawfull seeing they appertaine to the externall pollicie and regiment of the Church which according to time place persons and other circumstances is not tyed of necessitie to be alwaies one And surely those that mislike this ouer proude title as they tearme it haue least cause seeing they of the Discipline challenge as great iurisdiction ouer their Parishes and as lofty dominion ouer Prince and Nobles as euer any Pope did ouer the whole Church And if Clement whom Polydore alledgeth to that end said that Peter in euery Prouince appoynted one Archbishop whom all other Bishops of the same Prouince should obey I see no reason why any man for that should so farre forget both modestie and charitie as some haue done to call him a hell hound a naturall sonne of Satan surely naturall he was not and the sworne souldier of Antichrist I wish these to remember that the slaunder of authors is no good answere when better reasons can be alledged then onely to say that they say it But if they thinke the title vnlawfull as some of them write because the Scripture doth appropriate it to our Sauiour Christ I wish them to remember that if Archshepheard and Archbishop be all one then the name is to bee found in Scriptures and that names proper vnto God as Shepheard light of the world and such like may be in a diuers sence and are often communicated with other men Hereunto we may adde that the famous Councell of Nice which by all men of wisdome is reuerenced esteemed and imbraced as the soundest and best testimony next the Scriptures doth not onely allowe of the name but also of the office of Metropolitane and Archbishop determining him to be no Bishop which is made without the consent of the Metropolitane and to shew that this name and office was more auncient than that famous Councell the Canon saith Let that olde custome be obserued alluding peraduenture to those Canons which passe vnder the Apostles names Neither was this name or title so strange imediatly after the Apostles time that Volusianus was affeard to say that Diomysius Areopagita was by S. Paul made Archbishop of Athens or Erasmus to call Titus Archbishop of Crete and Eusebius giueth the authoritie to Iohn the Euangelist whose suruiuing the rest brought this benefit vnto the Church that for consecrating of Bishops and other vses he was as Archbishop or Metropolitane to the whole Church For in Saint Cyprians iudgement heresies and schismes haue risen from no other occasion then from this that the Priest of God is not obeyed neither one Priest for the time in the Church and one Iudge for the time in stead of Christ thought vpon to whom if the whole brotherhoode would be obedient according to Gods teaching no man would moue any thing against the Colledge of Priests This speech of that auncient Father was to comfort Cornelius shewing that faintnes in that case was to betray the Church and that sects and schismes must needes arise where the authoritie of Bishops is despised For this place was not to confirme the authoritie of the Church of Rome but as the best expounde him that hee would haue an Archbishop in euery Prouince to beare rule ouer the rest of the Cleargy For hee that attempteth any thing in the Church without the Bishop breaketh peace and confoundeth good order and Cyprian being Bishop of Carthage had the charge and ouersight of all the Churches in Africke in Numidia and in both the Mauritanes and not only these but as Gregorie Nazianzene saith the whole East parts for the which cause Illiricus doth call him Metropolitane So that if herein wise men had onely inuented what was fit and not followed what was before them their action had not been without warrant seeing in the outward pollicie of gouerning the Church where precepts and examples are wanting it is not forbidden for those that come after as well to be examples to others as to follow the examples of such as haue gone before them But if in the first planters of the Church which both in comparison of the rest were fewe and blessed with graces farre more excellent than any in our time inequalitie was allowed and that allowance without fault it must needes in all reason follow that the authoritie of Archbishop was not thought so dangerous as now to the gouerning of Christs Church wherein if either their maintenance bee greater or their outward honor more in these Christian times of peace then could be expected amongst Pagans and they tyrants no man can in reason or ought with out blame to oppugne these who will not be thought an enemie to the former seeing the times and names being diuers the authoritie notwithstanding is all one But it is the vnnaturall fault of this age through the sides of those whom peraduenture in some priuate respects we mislike to wound euen our fathers in religion whom we ought to honor But seeing these men doubtles are much wiser who take vpon them to be the reformers of our Church then that they should be offended with the names where the things are lawfull it is surely to be thought in all reason that the superioritie of Bishops is not by them accounted so great a fault as that any amongst the clergie whose office and ministerie is all one should by a speciall name aboue the rest of theirbrethren be called Bishops As if to ouer see that flocke committed to their charge were a dutie belonging and by our Sauiour imposed vpon them onely But because the names of things haue so many artificers by whom they wore first made but moe who after haue vsed them to an other sence it shall not so much concerne vs to inquire what in the beginning was the difference betwixt Bishop and presbyter as to learne afterward what the Church ment when these names expressed those persons which for office and ministerie of word and sacraments not for order and iurisdiction were all one The clergie of the Gospell were at the first after the Apostles time either Presbyters or Deacons for those who aduisedly at the first did impose names vnto things had either regarde vnto that which naturally was most proper or if peraduenture to some
Euangelist Saint Marke sixe yeeres before Peter and Paul were martyred sixe and thirtie before the death of Saint Iohn in the which there is nothing that can or ought to be misliked This as it is true so it is warranted with much reason for vnlesse we suppose a thing surely not likely if possible all in a presbytery to be men without fault a power to doe harme vnto Christs Church must by this curcular reuolution fall into their hands whom wisedome of election would hardly haue called to that place Besides what men shall worthily suffer whilest they are inferiors there is some likelyhoode they will offer the like when they doe commaund Neither is this to quench ambition as they thinke but to kindle a farre greater in the whole clergie For what we giue vnto one experienced of yeeres tried in gouernment freed for the most part from the passions of young men these without difference propound to all And thus they cure this feuer of ambition by infecting many as if diseases were therefore lesse because moe were sicke For what cannot be inioyed without pride is not easily expected without sinne fruition and expectation of one and the same thing are so neere that neither can be vertuâ—â—s where both are not Neither doe we giue vnto Archbisâ—ops or bishops power or honor by Gods law but what their people must needes yeeld vnto their pastors and presbyters if they will haue any We are not to limit Princes whom they shall vse in councell or to whom they shall commit the execution of their lawes especially such as are made for the Churches good seeing we finde that God hath blest those Princes and kingdomes most where vertuous Bishops haue been admitted to the Princes Councell wherein surely they haue brought a farre greater benefit to the peace and prosperitie of the Church then in reason they could by any other imployment besides Neither was it a meanes for to be idle either in Caluin or Beza both of them fit men for that place that they were both admitted as councellors of that state It cannot chuse but bee great intemperancie in them who haue so dishonorably laboured to deface that dignitie so auncient and of such vse in the Church of God as also to wound euen the best and the worthyest in that place with tearmes farre vnbeseeming as if their vngouerned humors had fully resolued to belch out poyson against all that were thought excellent It pleaseth one of them to censure them all thus Archbishops and Bishops are vnlawfull vnnaturall false and basterdly gouernors of the Church and the ordinances of the diuell Another saith they are in respect of their places enemies to God Much hath the vnwise and immodest dealings of sundrie in our Church labored to dishonor so honorable and so great an office experience hath taught vs the good of them and to these we onely make this answere that wee are sorrie to see them so skilfull and so willing to speake euill But doubtles it is loue to our present state which hath made them so zealous in this cause for saith one If we be sworne to her maiesties most lawfull supremacie ouer all persons and espie in our Church a lordly prelacie a thing brought into the Church by humane inuention by meanes weereof it is apparant that the Pope of Rome hath climed about all states both Ecclesiasticall and ciuill if now our desire extend it selfe that our lordly dignities and power of our Bishops might be examined by holy scripture and brought backe a degree or twaine neerer to the apostolike practise and Christs institution that so all occasions might be cut off hereafter that this climing vsurpation might neuer take holde vpon England any more are we troublers of the state Doubtles we are If it were not a thing possible to make a difference betwixt the clyming vsurpation of the Church of Rome and the lawfull prelacie how lordly so euer established in our Church I doubt not but all our Bishops would cast themselues at his Maiesties feete and intreate his highnes to vnburthen them of all that honour which hetherto they haue held iniurious to his supremacie and contrarie to the scriptures and the Apostles practise To men of vnderstanding things could not bee thus odiously compared that are moste vnlike The Pope challengeth authoritie ouer all christendome so doe not our Archbishops the Pope exalteth himselfe aboue Kings and Princes but our Archbishops with reuerence and humilitie acknowledg their subiection and more dutifully I doubt not then those who thus carefully are fearefull of their clyming The Pope saith that to bee subiect vnto him is of necessitie to saluation our Archbishops acknowledge no such thing and as their limits of gouernment are farre vnlike so the manner of their gonernment is farre more lawfull the one being an vsurpation which ambition sought out superstition and pollicie haue holden vp the other a necessarie authoritie which schismes and dissentions in the Church inuented the Apostles vsed all antiquitie followed and the peace of the Church did impose vpon them So that one of the most modest and most learned that seemeth to fauour the cause of discipline maketh it a principall point of the Ecclesiasticall gouernment that the inferior clergie in things honest bee obedient to the Bishop and the Bishop to the Metropolitan expressing the vse of that which others vehemently mislike and acknowledging the names and subordination of both But as it is an imputation in their opinion to the Archbishops that their place and authoritie is like the Popes so it is a blemish to our Bishops in the iudgement of these men that for learning and vertue they are not like vnto those holy fathers of the Church that haue gone before them We dare not take vpon vs to thinke that our times are better and more fruitefull in vertue then other were or that the Bishops of our land a thing to be wished are all of them without fault but seeing it pleaseth some to compare them thus I hope it shall neither be dishonour to the vertuous memories of those that are dead nor bee thought a flattery towards those that doe liue if we say considering we may say it with much truth that for soundnesse of doctrine honestie of life and the moderate vse of externall things they are not inferiour to the most reuerend of those Bishops that haue been before them For doctrine wee are loth to rippe vp the errors that the anncient Bishops were infected with Papias Bishop of Ierusalem who liued in Ignatius and Policarpus time held the error of a thousand yeere after the resurection wherein the kingdome of Christ should here remaine vpon earth Most of the auncient fathers were infected with this opinion Saint Cyprian that same clere fountaine as Saint Hierom calles him failed in the opinion of rebaptisation diuers both of the Greeke and Latin Church were spotted with the errors about freewill merits inuocation of
Saints many things might bee alleadged in this kinde if it were any vertue to rippe vp their faults whom we ought to honor where as I hope the aduersaries to our Bishops will confesse that neuer any companie of Bishops since the Apostles time taught and held such sound doctrine in all points as the Bishops of England at this day For the second which is honestie of life euery age hath some imperfections amongst all conditions the most worthie are not free from the slanderers tongue In the councell of Nice in the presence of the Emperor the Bishops libeld one against another contentions ouer eager bitter were betwixt Epiphanius and Chrisostome both very worthy and very reuerend Bishops betwixt S. Austin and S. Hierom whereas doubtles if some zealous for discipline had held their peace the Church of England had beene as Hierusalem a Citie built at vnitie in it selfe Now for the last which is the moderate Imployment of externall things vve recken it amongst the greatest felicityes of our time that when the expectation of greedy cormorants was big with hope of the deuouring the riches and reuenews that the Church had that euen then the conscionable zeale of the prince by vertuous and wise lawes manacled their hands whose desires were vnsatiat and their harts vnhallowed and left vnto the church a rich and honorable patrimony for Indowment whereby worthy rulers may not want double honor labour may haue her merit and religion may bee able to releeue the poore Heerein if any couetously doe retaine or riotously mispend what vertuous authority confirmed vnto better vses a thing which I hope no man can accuse in the Bishops of our church let them amend their faults and not their offence be made a cloke to those monsters that thirst with desire for to robbe the church More perticulerly amongst the rest of him who being the worthiest amongst the clergie and worthylie in the highest place is by an vntemperate spirit with vnholy sacriledge said of all the Bishops in the sea of Canterburie to haue done most harme and that none had so ambitious and aspiring a minde as hee no not Cardinall Wolsey none so proud as he no not Stephen Gardiner none so Tyrannicall as hee no not Bonner I may say truely of him that if the church gouernment of this land which he defended with great Iudgement with his pen hee had not with as great authority protected for the space of this twenty yeres in the place of an Archbishop which God graunt for the good of his church may continew still doubtles Contention Ignorance and Atheisme long since had ouer-runne the Church Of whom because it is neither honour to him to bee commended by mee nor disgrace to bee reproched by them I will say considering his iustice in gouernment his care in prouiding for the Clergie his wisedome in Counselling his Integritie in preferring his Diligence in Preaching his grauitie in behauiour his humilitie in conuersing his care to the Church his zeale to religion his courage to the truth as Theodosius spake of S. Ambrose I know onelie Ambrose who is most worthy to beâ— called a Bishop But not to labour any further in this cause which hath had so many of singuler worthy men abâ—e to defend it much better wee say this calling so much misliked serueth to a greater perfection to a fitnes in action and to a singuler ornament in gouerning the Church For the first the fulnes of grace which is in the heads of the Church distilleth as by seuerall wayes to the singuler benefit of all parts whilst hee hath giuen some to be Apostles some to bee Prophets some to bee Euangelists some to bee Pastors and Doctors for the consummation and Perfection of his Church for the fitnes in action the Church hauing diuers Imployments as well for gouernment as doctrine requireth and alloweth seuerall ordinations to serue these Let no man therefore presume to vnderstand aboue that which is meete to vnderstand but that he vnderstand according to sobrietie as God hath delt to euery man the measure of faith For as wee haue many members in one bodie and all members haue not one office so wee being many are one bodie in Christ and euery one anothers members Last of all for Ornament that Atheists vnbeleeuers may wonder and bee in loue with the comely and beautifull gouernment of Christs Church as the Queene of Saba was with the order of Salomons house for in a great house are not onely vessels of gold and â—f siluer but of wood and earth some for honour and some vnto dishonor vnitie and varietie are the ornaments of the church of Christ Vnitie of Faith Charitie and Peace Varietie of Offices and degrees and these saith the Apostle for the repairing of the Saints for the work of the Ministrie for the edification of the body of Christ for if the whole body were ancare wher were the seeing if the whole were an eie where were the heating but now hath God disposed the members euery one of them in the body at his owne pleasure for if they were all one member where were the body And who are these that they should mislike what Example Authoritie and Experience haue found sufficient CHAP. X. Of Ministers their office and learning IF the passage from earth to heauen were either not needefull at all or possible to bee performed ordinarilie by any other meanes then a vertuous meditation betwixt God and man then peraduenture Instruments of best vse for the defects of this life were wholly to bee regarded and the vtter want of the Clergies seruice were as lawfull in the best kingdomes as the contempt of their persons is vsuall and common with the worst subiects But seeing vniuersall Corruption is the truest inscription of mankinde and holinesse to the Lord is the great title that God hath that man by that power may bee made like vnto him that did first make him hee hath appointed for the performance of this worke holy times holy places holy things and holy persons all chiefely to this end that as hee is himselfe so man likewise by these might bee made holie As if the same puritie which could not endure those blessed spirits once stained to continew in a place of blisse but cast them down did lesse reasonablie allow that creature whose greatest happines peraduenture was but vpon earth to be carried vp to heauen into those ioyes vnles redeemed by his Son and sanctified by his holy spirit and by both these by the seruice and ministerie of men and not Angels darkenesse were made light rebellion obedience the children of wrath the sonnes of an infinit loue enmitie reconsiled and made peace and lastly sinfull men were become holy So that the summe of their dutie whose labours are imployed in this kinde is onely to honour God and to saue mâ—n And their difference from all the world besides is principally this that being
are worthie men enough why doth he complaine of the silencing of some as a great wrong to the Church which in this great scarsitie of good and lawfull Ministers did much want their seruice Secondly that the Apostle described the qualities required in men of this calling doth not say that if none can bee found or not a sufficient man in whome all these qualities concur that then the Church shal rather be destitute of Ministers then haue such For there were in the Apostles time that swarued froÌ„ this rule and yet he was glad that they preached the Gospell Heerein we differ not from the confession of the Heluetian church which it is like our aduersaries in this cause doe more reuerence then they doe our owne who say wee condemne all vnmeet Ministers not indued with guifts necessarie for a shepheard that should feed his flock how bee it wee acknowledge that the harmlesse simplicitie of some shepheards in the ould Church did sometime more profit the Church then the great exquisit but a little to proude learning of some others Wherefore we reiect not now a daies the good simplicities of certaine so that they bee not altogether vnskilfull of God and his word and yet for all this let no man think but there are as many learned godlie graue and worthy Ministers of the word in this Church of England at this day bee it spoken without pride to Gods honour and the ioy of our whole land as in any one realme or perticuler Church in all Christendome that either is now or hath beene before vs. But for the scarsetie not of our owne in comparison of others but rather in respect of the multitude of our parish Churches I hope they will giue vs leaue to render them better and truer reasons then as yet wee haue receiued at their hands who onely with out cause to make it the Bishops fault are willing to tell the world that if these vrging of order and obedience which it pleaseth them to teaâ—â—â—e beggerlie trifle of mans deuise were not that then learning and religion would not bee of so little account and estimation amongst vs. But I hope all men see that the defect of prouision in this kind and yet I wish that most reformed Churches were but so well furnished is neither from religion professed nor from the gouernment that is vsed nor from the gouernours of the Church but the crueltie of the times past wherein numbers of meete Ministers haue beene consumed the vnwillingnesse of manie at this present who seeing the contentions amongst our selues and by reason of these the contempt of the Clergie are vnwilling to enter into this calling the schismes and deuisions which haue made a number renounce this office others worthilie to bee suspended and depriued from all which the Church which ought to haue had the vse of the labour and learning of men of abilitie is forced to craue a supply at their hands who are not altogether so sufficient to performe that charge But the greatest occasion of this euill is where law and reason haue giuen authoritie to some to be patrons to present their consciences haue beene corrupt and they haue failed of that trust which former times haue iustlie reposed in them Wherein if the people complaine that their authoritie to choose is defeated by this meanes surely it is but vnthankfulnesse in them to mislike a thing begun with so great reason for their good continued now more then a thousand yeeres warranted by lawes and practised with the liking of all nations the beeginning of patronages is not expreslie mentioned in the lawes of this land Aduocations Presentations are remembred in Magna Charta as currant by the lawes before that time the plea of Quare Impedit when Bishops refuse the patrons clarke is mentioned long since for this custome was most vsuall that the patron might not place a Clarke without the Bishop nor the Bishop refuse the Clarke of the patron if hee were such as were alowable by the Canons of the Church In Spaine before that time the councell of Toledo made this Canon wee decree that so long as the founders of Churches remaine in this life they shall bee suffered to haue the chiefe and continuall care of the said place and themselues shall offer meete Rectors vnto the Bishop to bee ordained in those Churches and if the Bishop neglecting the founders shall presume to place any other let him know that this admission shal bee voide and to his shame others shal be placed in their steads euen such as the founders shall choose beeing not vnworthy Long before this the like was determined by the Roman lawes strictlie to bee obserueÌ„d through the Roman Empire If any build a Church or house of praier and would haue Clarks to bee placed there hee or his heires if hee alow maintenance for those Clarks and name such as are worthy let them bee ordained vpon his nomination but if such as they choose bee prohibited by the Canons as vnworthy then let the Bishop take care to promote some whom hee thinketh to bee more worthy It seemeth this law had two reasons for the patronage which doubtlesse are not the least ground of that intrest which they now haue The first the building of the Church a work which while the world was in loue with religion gaind greatest reuerence to those of whom it could point and say these are the men that haue built vs Sinagogs Heerein if any fraudulentlie discharge that vertuous trust which through many discents is deriued vnto them I hope God will looke vpon them in mercie to amendment as the carefull Phisition vpon sick persons in the meane time I must tell them what I heare that the church by their meanes is like the body of the Amalekite sicke and vnlesse it bee refreshed like spedily to die for famine For whilst meaner men content with lesse alowance hauing beene important suters for places in the Church obtaine them the Patrons haue deuided the maintenance of the Clergie and the small alowance hath depriued them peraduenture of a better teacher And howsoeuer good lawes haue beene made to auoide the corruptions of Patrons in this kinde yet the couetous desires of such as hardly satisfied are able to finde meanes to escape the danger and yet falselie notwithstanding to defraud the Church For humane lawes how vertuous or religious soeuer where the vprightnesse of conscience is wanting serueth for the most part not to make the sinne to bee lesse common but the sinner in the fact to bee more secret seeing betwixt God and man this is the difference that the law of man what it seeth doth account sinne but God punisheth as a fault what no man can reueale sauing onely the conscience of him that sinneth In the one Confession is a way to obtaine pardon but in the other a meanes to procure punishment They onely are vertuous who without all respects
in respect of Conscience are onely vertuous To conclude then this point we say our lawes our tongues desire that our Ministrie may be learned through the whole land that the hinderance of this is not wholy in the gouernours of the Church that a lesse portion of learning may serue then some men exact in all vntill better supply may be had we Reuerence Vse and Esteeme the meanest of these as the Ministers of Iesus Christ. CHAP. XI Of the maintenance of the Ministers and of Tythes AS it is of all vertuous considerations to a Prince not one of the lest moment if both for the safetie of his subiects for remouing of scandall and the discharge of his owne conscience in the day of account it bee not the greatest to prouide for a learned Ministerie in all parts of his kingdome so it is not either of least difficultie or least vse to ordaine a conuenient and bountifull allowance for them neither can this how wisely soeuer gouernd bee a perpetuall maintenance if it shall depend vpon the voluntary contribution of rich men or to be thought an allowance fit and conuenient for them if it be not So that the wisdome of deuout men in times past from their religion were as carefull to haue alotted a perpetuitie of liuing to them whose continuall successors could not dye and were not lykely to be very euill as naturall parents for that race which proceeding out of their owne bodies more subiect both to ende and miscarry are notwithstanding desirous that they may be richly furnished and plentifully maintained for a long tyme. Vertue working as strongly and prouidently in the one as nature and affection in the other So that what care those that were beefore vs vertuously imployed in this kinde by indowing both Churches and other places both to furnish and giue rest to the Clergie with honorable perpetuall alowance to this end serueth both to make the labour now far easier to prouide maintenance for a learned Ministrie the greatest part whereof their religious deuotion hath performed vnto vs as also to make vs so holily to esteeme of those things which their wisedome did consecrate to this end that pollicie cannot thinke alterations or diminutions in this kind to bee safe euen where vnhallowed Prophane and cruell Sacriledge were accounted to bee no sinne For seeing the Chruch peraduenture doth now want what authoritie thought fit to take from her because Superstition had made her too rich and Alterations onely might haue giuen some hope that time would haue brought those religious houses and lands into their possessions againe whose erronious blindnesse deserueth an euerlasting banishment it is wisedome rather to tollerate some things for the maintenance of the Clergie which a few wandring person made rich by contributions whilst a great number zealously blind are made poore to maintaine them think and write against with great bitternesse as the meanes of idlenesse and a superfluous pompe then stirred vp by the inconsiderate enuie of these men being vpon the Church such vnnecessarie want that if the deuotion of the Apostles time wherein they sould their possessions and laid the price at their feete faile as no doubt they doe the Church must either bee desperately poore or beg her reliefe from those kingdomes that are next vnto her Wherein besides the iniurie to God which is no lesse then a boulde prophanation of holy things the Church receiueth at their hands a double wrong First an apparant discouragement from entring into that calling wherein how faithfully soeuer they imploy themselues with how great sinceritie soeuer it be vndertaken by them yet few or none doubtles wil be willing to vndergoe either the labour or the contempt wher so slender recompence so small rewards are alotted to them Both which of necessity must be seeing almes seldom when it is no matter of extraordinarie zeale floweth with so great a streame from worldly men that it hath or can haue any possibility to effect either the other is the intollerable burden of the poore which now lieth vpon the shoulders of the laitie in former times whilst the church was rich beeing chiefely the humble almes-men of religious houses and now because both the charity and the meanes faile the Clergie who for the most part are fitter to receiue then to giue reliefe haue referred this waight to the laitie which neither they can well beare nor easely put off And yet an extremitie in this kind hath bene the originall of good lawes for the redresse of it Now surelie all this must of necessitie bee more desperatlie euill if either our owne couetousnesse or the clamorous zeale of some inconsiderat men cause vs to make a diuision as of pray whatsoeuer our pretences are of that last and least portion of the Churches wealth Now because the first groūd of that plentifull alowance which the Church had was the religious consecrating of a portion of our goods to his seruice who had reserued a part of our time meerelie to that end and seeing our liberall dealing with God was the best and most thankfull acknowledgment of his bountifull and liberall dealing with vs holy men did confesse as well in the one as in the other that in mercy they did receiue both their time and their riches from his hand so that by a part and that small in comparison of what wee allot vnto other vses we confesse his absolute dominion by whose fatherlie goodnesse wee receiue the whole Wherein through couetousnesse or any other sinister occasion to bee defectiue were to denie vnto God that which belongs vnto him seeing neuer any nation in the world did honour him and not account it a speciall part of their dutie to doe him honor with their verie goods A part doubtlesse in christianitie of our Morall dutie seeing for the sway riches carrie in the world and for that inclination which mens minds haue to cleaue fast vnto these things wee are naturallie more apt to honor our riches as God then to honour as wee ought God with our riches So that vnlesse this tribute as it were daylie put vs in minde whose subiects we bee wee are apt to make our selues Kings and the world to bee our owne free and independant inheritance Now seeing what wee offer vnto God serueth vs well for the perpetuitie of religion which cannot possiblie continue without a conuenient alowance for such as are necessarilie to bee imployed in the Ministerie thereof as it doth to expresse our thankfull acknowledgement of his mercie from whence wee receiue all that wee haue in all ages both the gift hath beene refused and the giuers reproued whensoeuer the coldnesse and want of deuotion in the people made their oblations to bee sparing and little worth for there ought to be some proportion both betwixt him whom wee desire and hope that he will accept our oblations as likewise betwixt the principalest end and the things themselues wherein whatsoeuer either
so that from hence was vnderstoode by the name of a Benefice A pastorall cure of soules ouer the people of some parish whereas formerly it signified some standing Ecclesiasticall reuenue taken out of the treasure of God and alotted to a spirituall person to the end hee may vse the same and inioy it as his owne for tearme of life vnlesse his default cause depriuation And wee know that the Clergie for manie yeeres after Christ had no other Benefices but onely their Canonicall portions or monethlie Diuidends allowed vnto them according to their seuerall degrees and qualities out of the common stock of such guifts oblations and Tythes as the feruor of christian pietie did then yeeld In the Apostles time Churches were onelie in the cities in regard whereof those that liued in villages beeing without instruction were called Pagans which after by the example of others both intertaining and giuing allowance for the maintenance of the same truth those to whom principall care was committed in this kind appointed meaner men of lesse learning and lower qualitie to vndertake the instruction of those places who were desirous and willing to yeelde after the example of others oblations and tithes for maintenance of those that were placed ouer them Now to say that either seuerall parishes thus distinguished might by no permission bee allotted to the care and instruction of one man or that it were not lawfull for any reason how beneficiall soeuer to Gods Church to bee absent from that particuler care committed to him were in the former to denie all better trust and reward to men of more worth and greater abilities and desert and in the latter to bee ouer Tirannous in considering and allowing the cause of absence and peraduenture in a true construction ouer rigorouslie seuere in both But seing all men know which wee doubt but our aduersaries in this cause will conffesse that this limitation of particuler parishes was meerlie positiue and the inuentions of men thought and found better for the better performance of the Clergies dutie it cannot bee the absolute transgression of a deuine ordination in that sence as if either to haue moe parishes then one or from one to be absent at somtime were a direct vnexcusable breach of the morall law For the duties commanded not to bee done in them are by no meanes not for a moment euer allowed to be done at all which thraldome if in seueritie they bring vpon Gods church let them take heede what dangers they fall into themselues that by this meanes the church receiue not a greater harme whilst peraduenture in this case their remedie is worse then the disease is Now to allow absence vpon reason without appointing those causes and such as must iudge which are reasonable were to make all men to think that they had reason that were willing neither is there any great force from the nature of Relatiues if that were all why one may not as well haue diuers parishes as one parish haue diuers Pastors And howsoeuer wee hold not the reason good that beecause Tymothie Titus had manie congregations committed to their charge therefore others may yet the reason in their opinion from this example ought not to want strength who think a Bishop and a Minister is all one In this first distribution for the best discharge of their calling and the greatest benefit to the church of Christ if some vnder the Bishops aboue their bretheren which had moe and more distant parishes then any in our church all termed by one name though some were Suffraganes to Bishops it ought not to seeme a matter of vnreasonable fauour and vnlawfull to commit seuerall churches to the instruction and gouernment of some men whose learning discretion care is more eminent and that these may whilst their labours are vsed for the benefit of Christs flock lawfully bee absent and haue inferiour men of the Clergie for a tyme to supply and to execute their roomes so that doubtlesse a zeale in these reprouers did carrie them to far when alledging those extrauagant reasons against Pluralities they yeeld them to tend to couetousnesse that one man had the stipend of many that they make non Residents that it maintaines Ambition that it is the occasion of a gadding and roaguing ministerie no small cause why others want and lastly a taking away of that recompence which belongs to others these reasons in their opinion of some force howsoeuer they haue alreadie bene profoundly answered with much iudgement yet beecause they still please themselues in the rehearsall of them we can bee content both with patience to giue them hearing and withall to hope for this fauour at their hands that they will yeeld thus much to vs that many things may occasionally bee the accidentall procurers of much euill which are originally no causes nor iustly can suffer a reproofe as vnlawfull things Neither are these onely the occasions of the euills which they lay vpon them seeing either all or most are commonly to bee found amongst thē who notwithstāding would seeme to be furthest from this sin But seeing whatsoeuer in our Church is practised in either of these two Pluralities or non Residencie is not the corruption of some priuate man but the approbation and allowance of the Court of Parliament wherein what soeuer is established all men in the eie and construction of the law are thought and deemed to haue consented we cannot but thinke it vnreasonable and vnreuerend for these men to disanull or make question of an Act of their owne making and withall wee hope it both hath and shall appeare to the world that as it is not lawfull without dispensation to haue or to doe either so that authoritie to dispence in both is most agreeable to reason and Gods truth For seeing the disposition and limitation of priuate parishes extendeth no further but to be the wise Positiue inuention and ordination of those who formerlie haue gouerned in Gods Church and that all humane lawes are dispensable by supreame authoritie a dispensation being but the relaxation of a common right made vpon knowledge of the cause by him that hath right to dispence wee hope that likewise these may and that the lawes forbidding non Residencie Pluralities are in force still notwithstanding by Priuiledge some particulers are and are fit to bee exempted from the common right Doubtlesse neuer meere human law was either made with that wisedome or was in execution of so necessarie vse but that sometimes it was fitter to receiue Dispensation then to stand in force for seeing the best lawes of men are but the euidences of Humane reason which wee finde by experience groweth from a weakenesse to bee more strong and from imperfection to bee more absolute wee cannot in reason without inthralling our selues in too great a bondage deny Abrogation and Dispensation to humane lawes which are not to bee like those of the