The Doctrine of the CHURCH of England Concerning the Lord's-Day or Sunday-Sabbath As it is laid down in the Liturgy Catechism and Book of Homilies VINDICATED From the Vulgar Errours of Modern Writers and settled upon the only proper and sure Basis of God's Precept to Adam and Patriarchal Practice VVHERE An Essay is laid down to prove that the Patriarchal Sabbath instituted Gen. 2. 3. celebrated by the Patriarchs before the Mosaick Law and re-inforc'd in the fourth Precept of the Decalogue was the same day of the VVeek viz. Sunday which Christians celebrate in memory of the perfecting of the Creation of the VVorld by the Redemption of Mankind Stand ye in the Ways and see and ask for the old Paths where is the good Way and walk therein and ye shall find rest for your Souls Jer. 6. 16. LONDON Printed for Richard Chiswell at the Rose and Crown in St. Paul's Church-Yard MDCLXXXIII THE PREFACE TO THE Intelligent Readers SAd and deplorable Brethren have been our Sabbatarian Controversies For while one Extream pleads there is no other ground for sanctifying the lord's-Lord's-Day than there is for other Holy-days to wit Ecclesiastical Constitution thinking thereby to oblige Christians to as religious Observation of other Holy-days as of Sunday They aim at an Impossibility seeing in many religious Persons there is imprinted this common Sentiment That the Lord's-Day ought to be discriminated from other Days And this Principle so deeply imprinted as all Attempts to obliterate do furbish it and make the writing more legible Yea the circumjacent Cold of the Devotion of the contrary-minded as by an Antiperistasis enflames the Zeal of Men seriously devout beyond the due Bounds and pusheth them on to the very Brink if not into the Gulf of Judaizing in the manner of celebrating the lord's-Lord's-Day And on the other hand the looser sort observing how some of those that with most Earnestness press the aforesaid Ground of Ecclesiastical Constitution do themselves observe Holy-days think they have fully discharged the Office of good Religious Christians if they sanctify the Lord's-Day as they celebrate other Holy-Days that is by resting from their ordinary Callings frequenting the Morning-Prayer to attend Evensong is a work of Supererogation and trifling away the remainder in pass-times Now what hath or can be the issue of this but Ignorance and Prophaneness and an Incouragement to profane Sundays instead of sanctifying other Holy-days But I love not to be querulous motos praestat componere fluctus I would much rather help towards the calming of this boisterous Sea in order whereunto I shall propound these Preliminaries 1. That the Progress of Men's Devotion for Sundays above other Holy-days into Superstition ought by all means to be prevented and the Jewish Yoke of the strict Ceremonial Rest of their Sabbath as well as their Sabbath-Day it self ought to be taken off the Necks of the Disciples because that Ceremonial Rest being a Shadow of good things to come by Christ the retaining of the Shadow is a denying that Christ the Body is come And bodily Rest as well as bodily Exercise is now under the Gospel unprofitable except it be ordinated to spiritual 2. That yet a due Respect to the lord's-Lord's-Day ought by all means to be incouraged 1. Because this seems to be the common Notion of serious Christians and that argues it to be an Infusion from that one Spirit into which we are all baptized and by which as their Intellectus Agens or common Soul all Christ's living Members are animated 2. Because this is one of the surest Nails fastened by the Masters of Assemblies for the Support of Religion especially in this Age For this Principle is that that not only brings Men to Church to worship God and to be instructed by him in the Ministry of the Gospel but also obligeth them in Conscience to do something extraordinary in their Families on the Lord's-Day towards the educating them in the Nurture and Fear of the Lord beyond what they think themselves bound to do on the Week-Days so that if this were an Errour it would be an happy Errour as being an occasion of bringing Men to the Worship of God and Knowledg of the Truth And truly if I were perswaded that the other Opinion that the Sanctification of the Lord's-Day hath no other Ground than Ecclesiastical Constitution were a Truth I should think it a Truth not necessary to be published For if Men did not apply themselves to the Service of God and promoting the Interest of their Souls with more Seriousness of Devotion on the lord's-Lord's-Day than it is possible to perswade them to in keeping other Holidays the common Practice of most and the Principles of the more Religious considered Ceres and Bacchus would have more Service from Christians than the only true God For how I pray are our very chief Holy-days celebrated such as Christmas Easter Pentecost Sunday excepted but by Carding Dancing Revelling Whitsun-Ales c If God therefore had not better Sacrifices offered to him and Men's Souls better Sustenance administred to them on the Lord's-Day Men would rob God of his Honour and starve their own Souls 3. The first Errour in the Digestion of Men's Thoughts touching this Controversy is the common Hypothesis of all modern Litigants to wit That the Lord's-Day comes in as a Successour in the room of Saturday Upon which sandy Ground it is not so easy to lay any solid Foundation for sanctifying the Lord's-Day For if that Day which God by his Example and Precept first sanctified for the weekly Sabbath be Saturday that Day cannot be unsanctified and another adopted in its room but by an Equal if not a Superiour Authority to that which consecrated Saturday Now a Superiour Authority to the Example and Precept of God cannot be imagined And that which is alledged by either Party for the unsanctifying Saturday falls far short of Equality to it For what argumentative Force can there be in Christ's rising his appearing to his Apostles the Apostles assembling on Sundays for the sanctifying that Day comparable to the express Command of God for sanctifying Saturday much less can the Constitution of the Church counter-ballance it Briefly they proclaim Sunday an usurping Intruder into the Priviledges of Saturday rather than its legal Successour who advance it into the Possession of Saturday's Crown to be the weekly Holy-day upon no better claim than can possibly be deduc'd for it while they make it a younger Brother 4. This Errour in the first Digestion being incurable must either be removed out of the way of Men's Thoughts when they are pitching them upon this Argument or they will be ever learning and yet never come to the Knowledg of the true Ground for the sanctifying of the Lord's-Day but will endlesly draw the Saw of Contention both ways That the abovesaid Errour therefore may be obviated I have laid down this contrary Hypothesis viz. That Sunday-Sabbath is elder Brother to Saturday-Sabbath That being assigned for the weekly
Moral so far as it concerns you that is in the equity of it He spake indeed more words but not unto your whole Assembly in its present Constitution but as you shall be at the rending of the Vail he would have you hear that which I omit to repeat for that time to come seeing the pressing of you upon that reason to keep that Sabbath-Day God hath commanded you to observe would be a strong Argument against your keeping it SECT III. I could name other differences the Sacred Scripture makes betwixt the Patriarchal and Jewish Sabbath but these already mentioned are sufficient to convince rational Men that the Jewish Saturday-Sabbath was not the Patriarchal Sabbath commanded in the fourth Precept I come now to shew that the Patriarchs celebrated Sunday for their weekly Sabbath Arg. 1. And here first I urge the Premises If Saturday was not the Patriarchal Sabbath either Sunday must be it or it will follow that there have been three several Sabbaths one of the Patriarchs before the Law another of the Jews under the Law and a third of Christians under the Gospel A consequence which a Mahometan may perhaps not disgust but I am sure it will sound harsh in a Christians Ear. Arg. 2. There can no other justifiable account be given of Christians celebrating Sunday but this That the Jewish saturday-Saturday-Sabbath was Ceremonial and Temporary and therefore to give place to that day that was sanctified from the beginning by God's Example and Precept gave place I say to that at the expiration of the Mosaical Law without any new Precept 1. For if Saturday-Sabbath had been the day on which God rested and commanded Adam to rest on and keep holy it could not have been unsanctified but by a Precept as manifest and of as great Authority as that was whereby it was instituted which I am confident can never be made to appear in the translation of the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday And that which is alledged for this comes far short For what Argumentative force can there be in Christ's rising his appearing after his Resurrection and celebrating religious Assemblies with his Apostles ordinarily on Sundays in the Apostles assembling on that day for religious Worship what force I say can there be in all this for the unsanctifying of Saturday and giving its Crown to Sunday comparable to the express Command of God grounded upon his own Example to sanctifie Saturday Nay what are Mens pleading such things as these for the change of the Sabbath upon supposition that Saturday was God's day of rest and commanded by him to be kept but a setting up of their own conceits and miscollected conclusions that because Saturday was instituted in memory of the Creation and Sunday was the day wherein Christ perfected Man's Redemption by his Resurrection c. therefore Saturday must give place to Sunday in direct opposition to God's express precept If Saturday be the day intended in the fourth Precept or Gen. 2. 2. But then I would not have the Saturday-Sabbatarians crow as if I adjudged the victory to them For upon the ground that I have laid the Jewish Saturday-Sabbath being calculated particularly to that Nation and therefore Temporary and Ceremonial must with other Mosaick Ceremonies be abrogated by Christ's Death and give place to the Antient Patriarchal Sabbath on course without any new Precept And here now our Saviour's rising from the dead his frequent appearing to his Disciples on Sundays the practise of the Apostles and primitive Church come in seasonably with their Auxiliary force to support the divine Institution of the Lords-day For though as to the first Consecration thereof their Examples signifie nothing nor are able to stand their ground against the Assaults of God's both Example and Precept yet upon that ground I have laid they are substantial and strenuous Seconds to prove the Restauration of the Ancient Patriarchal Sabbath by the Antiquation of the Judaick What greater influence could our Saviour's rising on Sunday have upon that day to the sanctifying thereof than his suffering on Friday or his Ascension on Thursday could have upon either of those days to sanctifie either of them for the weekly Sabbath 3. But yet Christ chose to rise on Sunday because God had sanctified that day from the beginning And therefore his Resurrection and the Apostles celebrating Church-Assemblies on that day though they are not of Authority sufficient to appoint a new Lord's-Day yet they are safe Guides to point us to that old Patriarchal Lord's-Day whereon the Lord rested and therefore commanded the Patriarchal Church Catholique to sanctifie it in Conformity to and Communion with which Church extending to all Ages and Places save Judea which never was any other but a particular Church God having in all Nations some that feared God and wrought Righteousness and therefore were accepted of him Our Saviour after the rending or the Vail and removal of the Partition-Wall rose upon that Day and upon that Day celebrated Religious Assemblies c. And this was sufficient to revoke the Sabbath to its first beginning to which all things were revoked by Christ saith Tertullian in Monogamia and to intimate that Sunday was the Patriarchal Sabbath It being manifest that the Jewish Sabbath instituted not only four hundred but three thousand years after the institution of the Patriarchal could not make that void any more than the Mosaick Law could vacate the Promise made to Abraham before that Law was given according to the Apostles way of Arguing Gal. 3 17. The Covenant that was before confirmed of God to Abraham the Law which was 430 years after could not disanul that it should make the Promise of none effect And that therefore that Mosaic Law of the Sabbath being made void the Patriarchal must of course take effect without any new Injunction The necessity of which Cousequence will be made more apparent by the next Argument Viz. SECT IV. Arg. 3. That the Patriarchs did celebrate the Sunday-Sabbath before the Institution of Saturday-Sabbath may be proved if not demonstrated from Scripture-Instances It were indeed unreasonable to expect Mathematical Demonstrations in this case seeing Moses his History of the Patriarchal Religion is so exceeding concise as his Narrative thereof for above two thousand years may be in a manner comprised in a Nut-shell Yet if we diligently search I doubt not but we shall find Instances next to Demonstrations in two places viz. Exod. 12. Exod. 16. I will begin with the last because it leads to the change of the Patriarchal Sabbath to the Jewish which seeing we all know to be Saturday by reckoning backward till we come to the day on which that general Church-Assembly mentioned ver 2. was kept we may certainly find on what day of the week it fell Inst 1 The first Instance therefore that I shall give of a Religious weekly Assembly kept on course by the Patriarchs on Sundays is from Exod. 16. 1 c. And they took their Journey
it because that in it God rested from all his Works which he created and made For the understanding whereof and applying it for the support of a weekly Patriarchal Sabbath Let it be observed 1. That the conceit of a Prolepsis in these words of Moses is clearly overthrown by the Premises for if the Patriarchs had stated dayes of Publick Worship so long before Moses that practice of theirs could not possibly be grounded upon any other bottom but God's resting upon the Seventh-day and therefore sanctifying it to be a day of Rest by his Precept to Adam Seeing that their appointing stated dayes for such Worship on their own heads would have been no better than Will-Worship and such as God might justlie have expostulated with them about saying Who hath required this at your hands and so much a greater affront to the divine Majestie as they were further off from all possibilitie of Ignorance of God's resting the Seventh day Nay what presumption had it been in the Patriarchs to have expected God's blessing upon their celebrating other stated Days than God had sanctiâ—â—ed And sure none can imagine but that they waited upon God for his blessing upon their sacred conventions Thus the practice of the Patriarchs is a full Comment on this Text. 2. It being granted that this Text is to be understood according to the plain literal sense then it will cast light upon those Patriarchal Texts that have been alledged concerning their stated times for sacred Assemblies and clearly discover those Sons of God in Job to have presented themselves before the Lord on that Day which God had sanctified at first to that end Let this at present suffice for the proof of this third Proposition which will be further cleared in the handling the fourth viz. CHAP. IV. These weekly Sabbaths observed before the Mosaical Law were Sundays not Satterdayes SECT I. IN order to the vindication of this point from the charge of Novelty and singularity I shall first shew from the Testimonies of Heathens and Fathers as well as from Reasons deduced from Sacred Writ That the Jewish Saturday-Sabbath was not the Seventh-day Sabbath of the Patriarchs ARGUMENT I. Those Encomiums above quoted which Heathen Poets who were antiently Divines and Philosophers bestow upon the Seventh-day cannot be meant of the Jewish Sabbath partly because those ancient Poets Hesiod Homer Linus had not any acquaintance with the Jewish Affairs as Josephus contra App. lib. 1. observes And therefore those Praises appertain to that weekly Day which that part of the Gentile World that retained the old Tradition observed But especially because when the Jewish Sabbath came under the observation of the Heathens they made a mock thereat they mocked at their Sabbaths Lam. 7. 7. And they who derided them were not the scum but the most intelligent Moralists such as Seneca quoted by St. Aug. de Civ Dei 6. 11. Septimam vitae partem sic perdunt vacando The Jews saith he spend the seventh part of their life in doing nothing With him concur Plutarch de Superst Rutilin in itinerario in diriding the Jewish Sabbath As also Juvenal Sat. 14. Cui septima quaeque fuit lux Ignava et partem vitae non attigit ullam The Jewish Seventh day is a day of Idleness and contributes nothing to any part of life And Persius Sat. 5. At cum Herodis venere dies c. Labra movis tacitus recutitque Sabbata palpes Even whilst thou art celebrating speaking to a Jew Festivals the forethought of the Jewish Sabbath makes thee look pale These seem to deride the Jews for the manner of keeping their Sabbaths for leading thereon a Dog's life of hunger and ease But Agatharcides as Josephus reports cont App. l. 1. styled the Jewish Sabbath it self 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a corrupt or depraved Custom as degenerate from that weekly Holy-day which was anciently and universally observed Arg. 2. This may also be evinc'd by the Testimonies of those Fathers of the primitive Church who were nearest to the Apostles Justine Martyr Dial. cum Triphone Before Moses none of the Righteous observed the Sabbath that is the Jewish Saturday-Sabbath for the Question here discust betwixt him and Triphon the Jew was Whether the Fathers before the Law celebrated the Jewish Sabbath Of which Question the Jew held the Affirmative and Justine the Negative Tertullian contra Judaeos makes this Challenge to the Jews Let them shew that the ancient Patriarchs did Sabbatize that is observe Saturday as their weekly Holiday for that they did celebrate that Sabbath day that God instituted at the beginning Tertullian himself confesseth ad Martionem libr. 4. hoc privilegium donatum Sabbato a primordio c. This priviledge was granted to the Sabbath from the beginning c. Ireneus l. 4. c. 30. all the Patriarchs before Moses were justified without the Sabbath Eusebius hist Eccles l. 1 c. 4. there was no observation of the Sabbath among the Patriarchs as also none amongst us this cannot possibly be meant of any other Sabbath than the Jewish 1. Because Eusebius in praeparat Evang. proveth that the most antient Gentiles had knowledg of and veneration for the seventh day out of Hesiod c. which they could not have from the Jews with whom these NaNations had then no Converse 2. Because of that last clause as also none amongst us which cannot exclude the Lord's day for Christians celebrate that but only the Jewish Saturday Grotius expounds these Testimonies as if they only denied the Patriarchs to have kept the Sabbath after the rigid mode of the Jews grounding that opinion upon Tertullian's Sabbatize but that learned Man should have considered that Tertullians curt Stile and his humour to coin new words renders him the unmeetest of all the Fathers to umpire the sense of others since his own is in very many places past finding out save by the light of other Writers and therefore the other Fathers that writ upon the same Subject ought rather to interpret him than he them But Grotius his haste to wrest these Testimonies out of the hands of the Prolepsarians makes this slip more excuseable than the course that Hamon L'Estrange takes to evade the dint of this Argument by denying the competency of the Witnesses For what humane Authority can be of more weight in the esteem of indifferent Judges than this of these Fathers who were as learned Defenders of the Christian Cause against Jews Gentiles and Hereticks as the Church hath been blest with especially in this case wherein they had to deal with most subtil Adversaries and therefore it is to be presumed that here they did not glance on the Question but examined and discuss'd it throughly neither indeed could these great Defenders of the Christian Cause have stood their Ground in maintaining the Christian Practice of Celebrating Sunday for their weekly Sabbath against the Assaults made from God's Command to the Jews to celebrate Saturday but by denying as our Saviour did
Septuagint which renders it The Seventh Day altho our last Translation of the Bible follows the Hebrew Altho the Puritans as they were called have called long and loud to our Church to rectify the Reading and conform it to the Hebrew as knowing that their opinion of the fourth Precept commandeth a Seventh not the Seventh Day is utterly overthrown by rendring it Wherefore the Lord Blessed the Seventh-day And altho our Church hath gratified their Clamours in conforming the Epistles and Gospels to our last Translation yet in the forenamed versions of the fourth Precept she adheres still to the Septuagint and persisteth in teaching her Children young and old that the Sabbath of the fourth Precept in the plain literal sense of it is the Seventh day wherein God rested and therefore sanctified and separated to be observed by us Christians in obedience to that Precept and in conformity to God's Example Or to give her sense of this Precept thus translated in her own words Homilie of the time and place of Prayer God expresly in the fourth Precept commandeth the observation of the Sabbath which is our Sunday And not only commandeth it but also by his own example doth stir and provoke us to diligent keeping of the same And a little after this Example and Command of God the Godly Christian People began to follow immediately after the Ascension of our Lord Christ It was you see in obedience to this Command urged by this Example that the Christians began to celebrate Sunday in our Churche's Judgment In Obedience I say to this Precept in the plain literal sense of it For sure the Church of England is a more indulgent Mother than to teach her Babes by Tropes and Figures and far-fetch'd Consequences what that holy Will of God is to the keeping whereof their Baptismal Vow obligeth them or to oblige them to say Lord have Mercy upon us and incline our hearts to keep this Law after the pronouncing of the fourth Precept at the Lord's Table if that did not stand intirely in every tittle of it according to its plain and primitive sense in as full force now under the Gospel as any of the rest Moses was faithful in God's House and therefore at his repeating of the Decalogue and applying it to the Israelites he lets them know that they were not concerned in that Reason for sanctifying of that Sabbath which God published on the Mount to wit because God rested on the Seventh-day but urgeth the keeping of their Sabbath by another Reason peculiar to themselves to wit their resting from Egyptian Bondage Deut. 5. which very Reason is an Argument that their Saturday-Sabbath was not the day on which God rested but local and temporary And God's urging the sanctifying of the Sabbath of the fourth Precept from his own Example argues the day therein commanded to be the day whereon God rested and to concern all Ages and Nations The reason of it being common to all and therefore to be our Sunday And this speaks the faithfulness of our Church viz. her informing her Children that the whole and intire both Precept and Reason appertains to us Christians and therefore we are bound to beg pardon for the breach thereof and Grace to observe it I had never much Artificial yet have so much Natural Logick as to think this a very strange Inference God rested the Seventh-day that is Saturday wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day that is Sunday and the common Opinion to be void of Reason viz. That the day commanded in this Precept is gon but the Precept remains seeing all that 's commanded is the sanctifying of the day whereon God rested It may with every whit as much reason be said the honouring of Father and Mother is gone but the Law commanding that Honour is still in force as that the day whereon the Command bids us rest is gone but the Precept commanding that Day of Rest remains as if that day injoyned belonged to the Jews and the Precept enjoyning to us My resentment of such horrible absurdities unavoidably issuing from the common Opinion that Saturday is the Day whereon God rested and that Day which he commanded the Jews to sanctifie in the fourth Precept And yet that the Precept is still in force to us Christians obliging us to sanctifie another day Sunday in Conjunction with the reverence I bear to the sounder Doctrine of the Church of England viz. That the fourth Precept commands us to celebrate Sunday upon the Account of God's resting on that day first put me upon that enquiry whereof my Treatise of the Sabbath is the result viz. whether that Hypothesis could be proved from Scripture and Reason and if proved whether it would secure unto us our Sunday-Sabbath without any new Institution by Christ's Precept upon better grounds than can be laid by the vulgar opinion and such as free our Necks from the yoak of those carnal austerities which attend the Jewish Temporary and Ceremonial Saturday-Sabbath This Design I confess affronts the whole World of private modern Writers but I have standing on my side the Church of England which carried on the Reformation of Christian Religion from Papal Innovations more pecately regularly cautiously and with a greater respect to Catholick Antiquity than any other Reformed Church did And that which inclined me the rather to follow her Conduct through my whole Tract of the Sabbath was this because I observed that the Writers upon the fourth Precept have fallen into inextricable perplexities meerly through this one mistake That the Sabbath injoyned in that Precept is Saturday and not as our Church teacheth Sunday And that if they had followed our Churches Clew they would have found the way out of those Labyrinths wherein they have lost themselves For if Sunday be the Day whereon God rested and therefore commanded in that Precept to be sanctified after God's Example and unless it be that day wereon God rested that Precept does not command the sanctification of it how naturally will these Consequences follow 1. That Adam and the Patriarchs could not be ignorant of that Example of God which was laid down in the Precept as the Reason why we are to sanctifie it for if that reason oblige us who only hear it It must much more oblige Adam who after a sort saw it 2. That the Law of the Saturday-Sabbath is not expresly commanded in that Precept but only reducible to it in regard of its equity and proportion of time viz. one of seven And therefore Saturday-Sabbath may depart and the Precept continue in full force Nay that Sabbath together with the Ceremonial Precepts concerning it must as the rest of Mosaick Ceremonies depart at the rending of the Vail and give way to the Sunday-Sabbath And thus the Christian Church is disburdened of those Austerities about which there hath been so much wrangling amongst Modern Writers 3. That there was no need of a new Gospel-Precept for the first Institution of Sunday-Sabbath and that
understood but that the Signification thereof might easily be found out if Men could digest it as Platonism Latinism Graecism signifies the pure natural and genuine Imitation of Plato of the Latine or Greek Tongue so Sabbatism is nothing else but the genuine Imitation of the Sabbath and according to the Tenor of the Apostle's Discourse of that complacential Rest which God took on the seventh Day It remains therefore that the Christian or lord's-day-Lord's-day-Sabbath is the most natural and genuine Copy of God's Rest But it is beyond my Intention to make a just Comment I intended these short Notes as Instances only to shew how Men's disgusting the Notion of a Christian-Sabbath makes them cast up from their nauceating Stomacks the Apostle's Arguments undigested 2. The next Bugbear that frights Men out of the plain way of Truth is a Conceit that when they hear the sound of a seventh-day Sabbath they think they hear the Man-drakes Voice of the Jewish Sabbath I need not here give Instances of this for they occur every-where in all Men's Writings concerning the Sabbath And it is too too common an Opinion that the Jewish Sabbath is the seventh Day in the order of the Creation and our Christian Sabbath the First de Die autem primo Mundi constat inter omnes illum fuisse Diem Dominicum Gregor de Valentia Tom. 1. Disp 5. Quest 3. Pun. 1. Quando quidem Dies septimus ab eo fuit Dies Sabbati Concerning the First Day of the World it is agreed amongst all Men that it was the Lord's-day seeing the Seventh from that was the day of the Sabbath yea his Conceit is that it was called Sunday from the beginning because the Light created on the first Day was the Light of the Sun not yet endowed with its proper Motion North and South which it received the fourth Day but only with that of the Primum mobile from East and West But I have sufficiently proved the contrary to wit that the Jewish Sabbath was not the seventh but sixth Day in order of the Creation but only of gathering Quails and Mannah And that our Lord's-day tho according to the Jewish Idiom it be called the First Day the first Day of their Week after that God had appointed them to observe another beginning of their Work as well as Year then was in use before yet it is in reality the Seventh Day of the Week commencing that Account from the Creation and the same Day of the Week whereon God rested 3. The last thing I shall name here is as a remora to Mens arrival at the true meaning of the Apostle's Discourse is a Tincture with that Spirit which Luther's Aerij Daemones were of or with that wherein they in the Corinthian Church were immerst who would be of Christ in opposition to Paul and Apollos These Men's high-flown Minds will not stoop to the Contemplation of any Sabbath-Day to be celebrated under the Gospel in the visible Communion of Saints but hang hovering in the Clouds about a Day of Rest purely spiritual nor of any Rest but everlasting and in this humour so spiritualize the Apostle's Arguments as they leave nothing in them after their Chymical Operations but thin etherial Vehicles or flitting Elizian Shades But can a certain Day limited to the seventh be an individuum vagum or a limited Day be the eternal Sabbath What ever mean Thoughts such Men may have of the Christian or Lord's-Day-Sabbath the divinely inspired Pen-man had such an high Esteem of it as he thought it a Subject worthy to be treated on as being a very sovereign means to prevent Apostacy and to hold Christians to their Profession For that 's the mark he aimed at and concludes his Discourse of the Sabbath with the mention of that as his aim Chap. 4. 14. as he had begun that Discourse with an Exhortation of the same Tendency viz. To hold fast their Profession Yea it is the main Scope of the whole Epistle to disswade the Hebrew Christians from forsaking Church-Assemblies as some had done and drawn back to the Perdition of their Souls and to perswade them to a firm adhering to Christian-Fellowship in the Administration of Sabbath-Ordinances On which Days also he strictly chargeth the Ministers to be instant in preaching calling that a Preaching in Season and with the same Breath stiling Preaching in the Synagogues of the Jews on their Saturday-Sabbath Preaching out of season 2 Tim. 4. 2. That I do not by this Exposition of them pervert the Apostle's Words will be manifest if 1. We consider that the Precept for Preaching presupposeth an Audience of Men. I think none will imagine that Timothy was bound by this Injunction to preach to Stones as they say Venerable Bede did once nor to Sheep Hogs and Birds as that goodly Saint of the Pope's making Anthony is fabled to have done frequently 2. That a publick Audience could not be had but upon stated Days of meeting either upon a civil account as in Markets c. or upon a religious account as in the Jewish Synagogues every of their Sabbath-Days and in Christian Churches on the Lord's-Day the first Day of the Week in the Jewish Reckoning 3. That the Apostles took all Occasions of such publick Assemblies to preach the Gospel besides their teaching from House to House 4. That their Attendance upon the Administration of Gospel-Ordinances to the Church would not permit them on the Lord's-Days to preach to Forreign Assembles either of Jews or Gentiles and therefore preaching to them was out of season being performed on Week-Days Days that were not then appointed of God to be Seasons for sacred Solemnities for even the Jewish Sabbath though it had been appointed to that Nation for a time to be their weekly Sabbath yet not it's grown out of Season and the Patriarchal Sunday-Sabbath came into season whence Preaching on that day is stiled Preaching in Season How much Light this Observation casts upon the Apostle's Discourse and what Darkness the vulgar Opinion viz. that the Apostle speaks of a spiritual and eternal Rest hath drawn-over the Hearts of Men in their reading this part even of the New Testament is apparent from this one Instance vers 10. For he that is entred into his Rest hath ceased from his own Works as God did from his Learned Men are puzled how to give such a Sence of this Clause as is coherent with the Context But understand the Apostle to speak here of the Christian Lord's-Day-Sabbath and the sence is as clear as the Sun at Noon-day and that sence admirably consonant with what precedes and follows thus It remains therefore that the Church in sanctifying the Lord's-Day doth most properly imitate God's seventh Day Rest For he that is entred 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 into the Rest of that same People of God to whom the Sabbatism appertains for 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 not 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is the Antecedent to 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 he also hath ceased
Sabbath at the beginning by God's Precept to Adam and in him to his whole Posterity to the end of the World and therefore extending to all Ages and all Mankind And this being assigned to the Jews only for that short time wherein the Law-giver was pleased to dispense with that Nation as to this Law given to all Nations and that for Reasons sufficiently palpable 5. This Hypothesis enervates the Arguments brought against the Divine Institution of the Lord's-Day and furnisheth Conscience with a solid ground of bearing a due religious Respect to it without danger of Judaizing in the manner of the Celebration thereof 1. To instance in their Herculean Argument drawn from the Gloss they put upon that Text Gen. 2. 3. as being spoke by Moses by way of Anticipation If that Day that God rested on was not Saturday but Sunday his sanctifying the Day he rested on could not have respect to the after-Institution of another Day for what Consequence can be in this because God at first rested on Sunday therefore he appointed Moses above two thousand Years after the Creation to command Saturday to be sanctified comparable to what is in this because God rested on Sunday the Seventh Day in the order of the Creation he therefore blessed it and sanctified it that is separated it by his Precept to Adam to be the weekly Sabbath Indeed the dream of a Prolepsis in this Text chargeth Moses with most gross Equivocation in the use of these words and God blessed except we fancy an Anticipation in those other Places of his Text where these words occur as Gen. 1. 22. where speaking of Fish and Fowl he saith And God blessed them saying be fruitful and multiply and vers 28. speaking of Adam and Eve he saith And God blessed them saying be fruitful and multiply 2. That this Hypothesis yields a solid Ground for the consciencious observing the Lord's-Day so as there needs not any new Constitution be made by Christ or his Apostles for the observing of it is manifest of it self For if Sunday be the Day that God separated at first to be the weekly Sabbath to the Patriarchs and was accordingly celebrated by them before the giving of the Law by Moses the standing part of the Fourth Command obliging all Mankind must necessarily refer to that and that there is a standing part of that Precept for the Breach whereof we are taught to say Lord have Mercy upon us and for the better observing whereof we are taught to pray Incline our Hearts to keep this Law is the declared Judgment of our Church And then the Temporary and Ceremonial Part both as to the Day and Mode of keeping it peculiar to the Jews being part of those carnal Ordinances that were imposed upon them until the time of Reformation Heb. 9. 10. vanish of themselves as being antiquated by Christ's Cross and give way to the Antient Patriarchal Sabbath And here now our Saviour's Rising from the Dead his frequent Appearing to his Disciples on Sunday the Practice of the Apostles and Primitive Church come in seasonably with their Auxiliary Force to strengthen my Hypothesis and to support the Divine Institution of the Lord's-Day For though as to the first Consecration therof these Examples signify nothing nor are able to stand upon that old Ground against the joynt Assaults of God's express Precept and Example for sanctifying Saturday Yet upon the Ground that I have laid they are substantial and strenuous Seconds to prove the Restauration of the antient Patriarchal Sunday-Sabbath by the Antiquation of the Jewish Ceremonial Saturday-Sabbath though they are not of Authority to appoint a new Lord's-Day yet they are safe Guides to point us to that old Patriarchal Lord's-Day whereon the Lord rested and therefore commanded the Patriarchal Church-Catholick to sanctify it as their weekly Sabbath in Conformity to and in Communion with which Church extending to all Places and Ages Our Saviour after the rending of the Vail rose upon that Day and upon that Day celebrated religious weekly Assemblies with his Apostles and taught them to do the like during those forty Days wherein he convers'd with them betwixt his Resurrection and Ascension speaking to them of the things appertaining to the Kingdom of God 3. Lastly this secures us from falling into Jewish Superstition in the manner of celebrating our Christian Sabbath for with the Jewish Day the Jewish manner of keeping that Day vanisheth So that the Christian Church is not obliged to sanctify the Lord's-Day in those strict Formalities of bodily Rest and other carnal Observances imposed upon the Jews but in the more generous and man-becoming Exercises of contemplating the Glory of God in the Creation compleated by the new Creation of believing acquiescing and triumphing in God through Christ of attending on Gospel-Ordinances publick private and secret of visiting the Sick relieving the Indigent and eating our Bread with Gladness of Heart on that day above others that being the Christian weekly Festival and the Day which God hath made for us to be glad and rejoyce in neither need we macerate our selves with studying when to begin when to end the Christian Sabbath at Even Midnight or Morning For he who having set his Secular Affairs in such order as they give no Interruption to his Sunday-Devotion goes to bed with God on Saturday-Night and riseth with God on Sunday-Morning and spends the Day in such like Exercises as have been mentioned may after he has commended himself and his Family if he have one to God go to his Rest on Sunday Night without danger of prophaning the Sabbath at his usual time Briefly the usefulness of this Hypothesis is so great and apparent both as to putting an end to all Strife even amongst the most Litigious and setling inward Peace in the truly Consciencious as I was something jealous lest the prospect thereof might make the Arguments I bring for proof of the Hypothesis seem to have more weight than indeed they have till I had communicated my Papers to several Persons of more quick Understanding in the fear of the Lord with this humble Request That they would weigh their Contents in the Ballance of their impartial Judgments which I heartily thank them they did and thereby gave me occasion to rectify some Passages and Encouragement to commit this Tract as it now stands corrected to publick view If it shall please the divine Goodness to make use of so mean a Person as my self towards the setling the Consciences of Christians upon a safe Ground and the binding up of those Wounds which the Church hath received in the House of her Friends as the poor tattard Captive Democedes cured Darius after that the Egyptian Physicians had for seven Days and Nights by violent handling of his dis-joynted Foot kept him without Sleep Let God have the Praise who chooseth the weak and foolish things of this World to confound the mighty and wise And let him have your Prayers Christian Reader whose utmost
Latitude with the beginning Heb. 1. 10. and Heb. 4. 3. Though the Works were finished from the Foundation of the World that is in the sixth day distinguished from the seventh day vers 4. For he spake of the seventh day on this wise and God rested the seventh day from all his Works so that the time specified by from the Foundation of the World vers 3. concludes with the sixth day before the seventh whereon God rested Now Christ cannot be said to be slain then actually for so he was not slain till the fulness of Time till the Hour appointed of the Father nor in the divine Decree for so he was slain before the Foundation of the World but only in respect of the Promise then made to Adam In which Promise he was exhibited as God-man as Man in regard of the Serpent's brusing his Heel as God in regard of his breaking the Serpent's Head This leads me into a Flowry Field of Meditation wherein I must crave leave to expatiate and refresh my self after my tedious Walk through dark and controverted Texts in the pursuit of Truth I shall therefore offer here these things to Consideration 1. When things are once put into a divine Promise they are then in Scripture Language said to be for tho they attain not to actual Existence till long after yet the Promise gives them a real being or metaphysical Essence as rosa in Hieme Hence God saith to Abraham Gen. 17. 15. I have made thee a Father of many Nations when as yet Isaac through whom he was to be the Father of many Nations was not yet conceived in the Womb nor in human probability ever like to be conceived in Sarah's Womb. From which Instance the Apostle draws this Inference that God calls things that be not as to actual Existence as if they were in real Essence because he that promised was able to perform it and was then engaged to perform it upon the honour of his Veracity Rom. 4. 17. so that it was as impossible that it could miscarry or prove abortive as that God can lye From which Promise we have a thousand times greater Assurance to say the Lamb was then slain then we have to say while the Fruit is only in the Root and not brought forth this is a Pippin this a Pearmain c. For this latter is grounded on a Lie upon the immutability of God's Covenant with Day and Night c. which though we cannot yet God can break yea hath broke as when he made the Sun stand still in the days of Joshua go back at Hezekiah's Prayer and suspended its Light at our Saviour's Passion as the Fire did also its burning property in the Case of the three Children but the former is grounded on the Immutability of God's Promise by Oath and the most sacred Oath even by Himself than whom he hath not a greater to swear by In respect of this Immutability the Hebrew Doctors upon Gen. 15. 18. have this Observation He saith not I will give but I have given and yet Abraham had now begotten no Children because the Word of the holy blessed God is a Deed therefore he so speaketh Ainsworth Thus the Son of God was tendered to fallen Man as the Lamb slain he was in this Promise as manifestly held out to Adam as crucified as making an Atonement for Sinners by the Oblation of his Blood as he was after his actual Crucifixion and Ascention held out to the Galatians Chap. 3. 1. 2. The Son of God in the Virtue of this his future Oblation of himself and Mediation by Merit entred upon the Exercise of his Mediatory Office by Intercession immediately upon Adam's Fall he did not suffer the mortal Wound to fester but applied the healing Balm flowing from his bruised Heel to it while it was green as soon as ever he saw Adam naked and in his Blood he poured clean Water upon him cast his Garment over him and entred into a Covenant with him and said unto him Live No sooner had Man made a League with the Serpent and proclaimed War against God but God was in Christ reconciling the World to himself In the Cool of the day that is in the Evening of that Day whereon he fell Adam heard the Voice of the Lord God that is the Word or Son of God as both Christians and Jews expound that place Gen. 3. 8. See Dr. Owen's Exercit. 10. 2. calling him to Repentance by Arraignment to Faith by the Promise of the Woman's Seed yea to Glory by presenting himself in the Form of an human Body and that glorious Body such as he shewed himself in at the Transfiguration and hath now at the Right-hand of the Father Dr. More Append. to Mystery of Iniquity As when Job had wish't Chap. 9. 34. Let him take his Rod away from me and let not his Fear terrifie me Then would I speak and not fear him Elihu according to Job's wish makes him this Offer Behold I am in God's stead I also am formed out of the Clay Behold my Terror shall not make thee afraid neither shall my Hand be heavy upon thee If thou canst answer me set thy words in order before me stand up c. Job 33. 5 6 7. So the Lord pleaded with Adam by his Son in the Form of God manifest in the Flesh I doubt not but the Son of God in human shape was all this seventh Day busied in most holy Colloquies with Adam but that he fully revealed himself to him and Eve shewed him how and in what order he created all things wish'd him to meditate upon these Works and in them to praise and acknowledg the true God his Creator and taught him that after his Example every seventh Day all Labour set aside he should spend in the Exercise of Piety Zanchy de Creatione Hom. l. 1. Fuller upon these words They heard the Voice of the Lord God walking in the Garden Gen. 3. 8. hath this Observation By this Voice I understand certain Words which God spake with himself walking Christ appearing to them in human shape 3. This his mediating to reconcile Man to God argues he had upon the instant of Adam's Fall so far reconciled God to Man by becoming his Surety by giving Bond to make Satisfaction pay Man's Ransome at the day appointed at the fulness of Time as the Father upon Consideration thereof would not take the Forefeiture but delegated the Son to treat with his Rebels and offer them Pardon and a better State than that they were fallen from on the Condition of their accepting the Covenant of Grace For Christ did not take this Honour of the Melchisedochian Priest-hood upon himself but was called of God an High-Priest after this order Heb. 5. 10. and made a Priest by Oath by him that said unto him The Lord sware and will not repent thou art a Priest for ever c. Heb. 7. 21. He was sworn to this Office of Mediation and sent to manage it by
they heard Christ discourse they cried out Lord evermore give us of this Bread Not so much as the Type of that Bread which can give Satisfaction and Rest to the Soul was communicated on their Sabbath and that was a plain enough Indication that their Sabbath was not the true Rest 3. In the very form of its first Institution Exod. 16. 23. the Imposition of the Name bewrays the nature of the thing is the Rest of the Sabbath Sabbathon Sabbath the Sabbatism the Sabbath holy to the Lord so Ainsworth reads it But he is exceeding wide of the sense of the Hebrew Word Sabbathon in translating it Sabbatism except he takes Sabbatism for a Diminitive for Schindler in his Penteglot and P. Fagius on the Chaldee Paraphrase Exod. 31. 15. affirm that Sabbathon hath the form of a Diminitive which saith he the Hebrews form by adding on to the end of the Primitive as Isch viz. Ishcon virunculus so of Sabbath comes Sabbathon Sabbatulum And Fagius observes that the Hebrew Doctors do thus distinguish these two words that Sabbath signifies the whole day from beginning to end Sabbathon that part of the Eve before the just beginning of the Sabbath which was taken from the prophane and added to the sacred Time by such as chose rather to over-do than to come short The Name therefore given Saturday-Sabbath at first was the Puny Sabbath the demy-Rest or the Eve-rest of the true Sabbath A Diminitive Rest for Children under Age preparative to that holy Rest suitable to Men which was to succeed 4. David speaking of another day of Rest than that which Moses had instituted the Celebration of and of another Rest than that which Joshua brought them into the Possession of made so clear a Comment upon the Precept of the Sabbath as well as of their Rest in Canaan as from thence the Jews might have collected that both were but shadows of a better Rest and better Day of Rest approaching by the same way of Ratiocination that the Apostle useth in the 3d and 4th Chapters to the Hebrews Touching the Rest of Canaan it is not material to my Business and therefore I shall not speak of that but occasionally But what the Author of that Epistle argueth from David's speaking of another day so long a time after the giving of the Precept touching Saturday-Sabbath is of such moment towards the right Perception of the Strenuousness of his Arguments for both and of so great Concernment towards the Illustration of that Point I am now handling as I shall for the clearing of the Apostle's Discourse on that Subject commit to the Censure of the pious and learned these Annotations 1. The Rest of Joshua and the Sabbath of Moses as reflected on by David are that Yoke of Heifers wherewith the Apostle plows to find out the Riddle of the Lord's-day-Sabbath and the not making them to draw equally is the main reason why Commentators make no better Work of St. Paul's Arguments touching another Day and why they make a balk or a bungle of the Christian Sabbath though all the Texts alledged not only in their own most natural Tendency but in the Apostle's express Application of them look directly thitherward I will begin with that which Beza confesses to be a most obscure place Heb. 4. 3. For we which have believed do enter 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 into that Rest as he said as I have sworn in my Wrath if they shall enter into my Rest although the Works were finished from the Foundation of the World It is the Mis-translation of this last Clause makes this Text unintelligible but if Men did not shut their Eyes for fear of seeing the Light of the Christian-Sabbath dart in upon them from hence or cast the Vail of their own Pre-occupations upon the face of it there would be no Obscurity at all in it for take it as the Apostle gave it if it were writ by him in Greek and it is as light as Day 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 If they shall enter into my Rest 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 equidem scilicet nempe I mean or that is to say or to wit in the Works when they were finished from the Foundation of the World i. e. They shall not enter into that Rest I took on the seventh Day when I saw all things that I had made and lo it was very good For he speaks in a certain place of the seventh Day on this wise And God did rest the seventh Day from all his Works as it immediately follows vers 4. by which Quotation of what is said Gen. 2. 2. the Apostle proves that he hath given a right Explanation of David's Words when he saith the Rest of God there meant is God's resting in the Contemplation of the Perfections of his Works on the seventh Day upon the account whereof he blessed the seventh Day because it is there said of the seventh Day that God rested from all his Works And that he had rightly concluded from God's swearing Unbelievers out of his Rest that Believers that is Christians had entred into it seeing the only Bar put in against entering is Unbelief he proves vers 5. from that place of David which the Apostle had taken for his Text Chap. 3. and in this place again that is he speaks again of the seventh Day on this wise If they shall enter into my Rest The reason of which Consequence the Apostle gives vers 6. Seeing then some must enter in for to what purpose else serves the Promise of entring and they to whom it was first preached entred not in because of Vnbelief The Consequence is so plain that it needs not be repeated to wit that therefore they that have believed are entred And again or furthermore vers 7. He limiteth a certain day 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 saying to David to day after so long a time it is said To day if you will hear my Voice That is the Day that David speaks of cannot be the Jewish Saturday-Sabbath for the Jews were very zealous in keeping that carnal Commandment insomuch as he that did but gather a few Sticks was stoned to death and in recompence thereof had bodily Rest given them by Joshua in Canaan but it was many hundreds of Years after that that David spake of another Day and another Rest which he would not have done if that had been God's seventh Day 's Rest conducting them to the true Rest For if Jesus i. e. Joshua had given them Rest then would he not afterwards have spoken of another Day vers 8. From all which Premises the Apostle draws this Conclusion There remaineth therefore a Rest to the People of God ver 9. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. therefore the Sabbatism remains or is left or falls to the share of the People of God i.e. to the Christian Church according to that Rom. 9. 25. I will call them my People that were not my People And now Sabbatism is not so hard to be
from his own Works as God did from his For as God rested on the seventh Day from his proper Works as Creator that being the proper Work of God the Father who made me and all the World though as to other kind of Works the Father worketh hitherto Even so he that is entred into the Rest of the People of God the Christian-Sabbath doth therein most genuinely imitate God in that he also hath ceased from his Works that is the Works of the Law of Moses that being the proper Notion of Works in St. Paul's Sence whensoever he makes Comparison betwixt the Law and the Gospel And the Works of the Law being the proper Works of the Hebrews to whom this Epistle was directed as differencing them from all other Nations He hath cast off that Yoak of Ceremonies which neither we nor our Fathers could bear and hath taken the easy Yoke of Christ upon him that he may find rest to his Soul And what an apt Introduction is this to what is immediately subjoyned vers 11. Let us therefore strive to enter into this same Rest lest any Man fall after the same Example of Vnbelief Let me therefore perswade you to imitate God in his Seventh-Day's Rest lest you imitate your fore-Fathers in Unbelief and be excluded from eternal Rest From which fearful State the best way to be secured is to attend upon Christian Lord's-Day's Assemblies and Administrations where you shall hear Moses in the Newness of his Spirit not in the Oldness of the Letter you will see that Vail that Moses put upon his Face done away if you will turn unto the Lord and will find the Word of God as a sharp two-edged Sword drawn out of the Scabbard of Types and Ceremonies wherein it could not do any Execution upon the Soul and so weilded as it shall pierce even to the dividing asunder of the Soul and Spirit which is the plain Importance of vers 12. For the Word of God is quick c. that is as it is dispenc'd in Christian-Assembles into which if an Unbeliever should come while they are prophesying 1 Cor. 14. 24. that is applying Old-Testament Prophesies unto Christ and proving thence that Jesus is the Christ he is judg'd convinc'd of all convinc'd of the Sin of Unbelief Joh. 16. 8. convinc'd and judg'd of all that is all that prophesy one by one 1 Cor. 14. 31. not only by the prophesying of such as like Apollos are mighty in the Scriptures Act. 18. 28. but is so mightily convinc'd that Jesus is the Christ even of the weakest of them that have the Gift of Prophesying that is of applying the Old-Testament for proof of the truth of the Gospel he is I say by this powerful Word so convinc'd as the Secrets of his Heart are made manifest and so falling down on his Face he glorifieth God and confesseth that God is in you of a Truth 1 Cor. 14. 25. By the Premises it appears that the Apostle's scope in his Discourse of the Sabbath is to withdraw the Jews from the Celebration of their Fruitless Sabbath to the Observation of the Christian-Sabbath As also how well God provided for the Settlement of publick-stated Assemblies in the Church when the Jewish Sabbaths were antiquated by letting the Apostles see that though the Law for that was out of date Col. 2. 16. yet there remained a Sabbath to the People of God viz. That which was instituted from the beginning and commanded in the Decalogue Had the Apostle indeed only decried that and not establish'd this it might have been thought that the Church had been left to her choice what Day of the Week to have celebrated as Calvin and the Prolepsarians conceive But as if the holy Ghost had purposely intended to obviate that Errour the admitting whereof would unavoidably bring Confusion into the Christian World he was pleased to direct the same Apostle whose Pen had cancel'd the Jewish to write in Vindication of the Christian-Sabbath and to inform him that seeing the Partition-wall was taken down there was a plain and open way made for the Restauration of the Patriarchal Sunday-Sabbath that Sabbath in the sanctifying whereof the greatest part of those Worthies mentioned Heb. 11. had received Grace to offer acceptable Sacrifices to God by Faith in the promised Seed to walk with God to be upright before him in the most general Apostacies to obey his Call unreservedly though they knew not whither To exert such Heroick Acts of Faith Patience Contempt of the World Dependance on God c. as made them the Wonders of that World which was unworthy of them and Paterns to the best of Christians That Sabbath in the Celebration whereof the Christian-Church forsook the Jewish Synagogue then became the Synagogue of Satan and betook themselves to the Communion of the General-Assembly and Church of the First-born consisting of all those who from the Publication of the Promise of Christ to Adam had been begotten again of the immortal Seed of that ever-induring Word administred to the Patriarchs and all that adhere to the Patriarchal Religion in all Nations and Ages and administred without those carnal Ordinances and unprofitable bodily Exercises wherewith the Jews Sabbath was incumbred if not wholly taken up therewith For the Jews that out-went the Ox and Ass in keeping the Mosaical Sabbath as such did not go beyond them in the Strength of the Services thereof which could not perfect them that frequented them as touching Conscience but in the strength of the Ordinances of the Patriarchal Sabbath so that it was their doing Sunday's Work on their Saturdays that sanctified the Jews as to Conscience Their own Sabbath's Rest from Work sanctifying them only by the external visible separating of them from other Nations to the end that our Saviour's Descent from Abraham might be more conspicuous And therefore as their fore-Fathers sell short through their looking no further than Canaan so those then Moderate Jews to whom he writes would also fall short of Eternal Rest if they did not look forward beyond their Sabbath-Day to Sunday or the Lord's-Day-Sabbath in the Ordinances whereof Saving Grace is so plentifully dispenc'd as the Eunuch shall have no cause to say I am a dry Tree nor the Sun of the Stranger to complain I am utterly cut off from God's People If they take hold of God's Covenant and keep his Sabbaths now under the Gospel tho they were excluded from the Congregation of the Lord under the Mosaical Sabbath Isa 56. 4 c. but their Sacrifices shall be accepted upon his Altar and he will make them joyful in his House of Prayer To this God of all Grace who deals thus bountifully with us Gentiles even to the Father Son and Holy-Ghost be given all Praises and Adoration now and for ever Amen FINIS Books printed for and sold by RICHARD CHISWELL FOLIO Dr. Cave's Lives of the Primitive Fathers in 2 Vol. Dr. Cary's Chronological Account of Ancient Time Wilson's Compleat Christian