to the Arch-bishop of Canterburie ouer the other Bishops and Ministers in England Now for aunswere to the other part of the obiection touching high Commissioners Iustices of Peace and Quorum I haue referued the next Chapter CHAP. VI. Of civill offices in Ecclesiasticall persons THe authoritie in ciuill matters committed to the ministers of the Church is not made a thing intrinsically incideÌ„t to the ministerie or as a part thereof but it is coÌ„mitted to them by the Prince whom his subiects are not to limit what persons he shall vse in counsell or to whom hee shall commit the execution of his lawes and it is added to their ministerie as profitable and necessarie for the present state and good of the Church Which good to bee procured by that meanes rather then by any other imployment besides it may appeare both by experience and practise By experience for that wee see those Kingdomes Princes and people most blessed of God where learned and godly Bishops haue beene receiued into the Princes Counsell By practise because I haue both heard and read that maister Caluin and maister Beza were admitted to be Counsellours of the seate at Geneua being thought sit men for that place Who doubtlesse would neuer haue yeelded thereunto if they had thought it a thing either vnlawfull in it selfe or incompatible to their function No no it is neither vngodly nor yet vnseemely for a Minister to come from the Pulpit to the correction of vice sinne and wickednesse But contrariwise it is so godly so comely and so necessarie that it euer hath beene vsuall both in the Lawe of nature in the Lawe of Moses and in the Lawe of grace for First in the lawe of nature Melchisedech was both King and Priest So reporteth holy Moses in his booke of Genèsis and Saint Paul to the Hebrewes And Saint Hierome telleth vs that all the eldest sonnes of the holy Patriarches were both Kings and Priests Aiunt hunc esse Sem filium Noe supputantes annos vitae ipsius ostendunt eum ad Isaac vsque vixisse omnesque primogenitos Noe donec sacerdotio fungeretur Aaron fuisse pontifices The Hebrewes saith Saint Hierome affirme this Melchisadech to bee Sem the sonne of Noah and reckoning the yeeres of his life they shewe vs that he liued vntill Isaac and that all the first begotten of Noah vntill Aarons Priest-hood began were Bishops Yea whosoeuer will denie that Noah Abraham Isaac Iacob and others did rule ouer those who were committed to their charge as wel in ecclesiasticall as ciuill causes they may truly be said to knowe nothing in the scriptures Secondly in the Lawe of Moses Moses himselfe was both the ciuill Magistrate and a Priest For Moses iudged the people from morning vnto euen Hee put the Malefactors to death who had committed Idolatry Hee consecrated Aaron and his sonnes and burnt sweet incense on the golden Altar Heli was both the high Priest and iudge of the people for the space of 40 yeares together Samuel likewise was both a Priest and iudge ouer the people for the space of 30. yeares together The good king Iosaphat made the Priests iudges both in ecclesiastical and ciuil causes And after the captiuitie of the Iewes the Machabees were rulers aswel in ciuil as in ecclesiastical causes Read the books of the Machabees Iosephus Egesippus and this truth will soone appeare But what neede many words in a case so cleere and euident God himselfe made a general law that the priests the ciuil magistrate shuld iontly determine iudge and decide all controuersies These are the expresse wordes of the Law if there rise a matter too hard for thee in iudgement betweene boold and blood betweene plea and plea betweene plague and plague in the matters of controuersie within thy gates then shalt thou arise and goe vnto the place which the Lord thy God shall chuse And thou shalt come to the Priestes of the Levites to the iudge that shall be in those dayes and aske and they shall shewe thee the sentence of iudgement These wordes are so plaine as all interpretation may be thought needlesse Thirdly in the Gospell and newe Testament wee haue a pluralitie of examples in this behalfe S. Paul when he made his abode at Corinthus with Aquila and Prescilla whom Claudius the Emperour had driuen from Rome he wrought with his hands being of the same craft with them and made tents as they did S. Augustine thought it a thing so lawfull for a Bishop to be iudge in causes Ecclesiasticall that I wonder how any man hearing or reading his owne words can any longer stand in doubt thereof Thus doth he write Quis plantat vineam de fructu eius non edit Quis pascit gregem de lacte gregis non percipit Tamen Dominum Iesum in cuius nomine securus haec dico testem invoco super animam meam quoniam quantum attinet ad meum coÌ„modum multo mallem per singulos dies certis horis quantum in bene moderatis monasterijs constitutum est aliquid manibus operari caeteras horas babere ad legenduÌ„ orandum aut aliquid de divinis litteris agendum liberas quam tumultuosissimas perplexitates causar uÌ„alienarum patide negotijs secularibus vel iudicando dirimendis vel interveniendo praecidendis quibus nos molestijs idem affixit Apostolus non vtique suo sed eius qui in eo loquâ—batur arbitrio quam tamen ipsum perpessum fuisse non legimus Aliter n. se habebat apostolatus eius discursus Sequitur quem tamen laborem non sine consolatione domini suscipimus prospe vitae aeternae vt fructum seramus cum tolerantia Servi n sumus cius Ecclesiae maxime infirmioribus membris quanta libet in eodem corpore membra sumus Omitto alias innumerabiles ecclesiasticas curas quat for tasse nemo credit nisi qui expertus est Non ergo alligamui onera gravia humeris vestris imponimus quae nos digito non attingimus quandoquidem si officil nostri sarva ratione possemus videt ille qui probat corda nostra mallemus haee agere quae vt agatis hortamur quà m ea quae non agere cogimur Who planteth a vineyard and eateth not of the fruite thereof who seedeth a flocke and receiueth not of the milke of the flocke Yet I call the Lord Iesus to witnesse vpon my soule in whose name I boldly vtter these words that touching mine owne commoditie I had much rather euery day to worke some thing with mine hands as it is appointed in well gouerned Monasteries and to haue the houres free to read and to pray and to doe some exercise in the holy Scriptures then to suffer the tumultuous perplexities of other mens causes touching secular affaires either in determining theÌ„ by iudging or in cutting theÌ„ off by intreating to which molestations the Apostle hath tyed vs not by
regendae ecclesiae rationem varios quoque ordines ministroruÌ„ multiplicaverint quando id eis liberum fuit sicut nobiâ— quando constat id ab illis fuisse factum honestis de causis ad ordinem ad decoruÌ„ ad aedificationem ecclesiae pro eo tempore pertinentibus In the meane while wee blame not the Fathers that for the diuers manner of dispensing the word and gouerning the Church they haue also multiplyed diuers orders of Ministers because they had libertie so to doe as our selues also haue and because it is euident that they did that vpon honest causes which pertained at that time to order comelinesse and edification of the Church Thus writeth the most learned Doctor Maister Zanchius who if I bee iudge was a man of as rare learning and profound iudgement as euer was any in the Church Out of whose words I of serue First that wee should not moue contention in the Church for any rites and Ceremonies in the same Secondly that euery Church hath her libertie therein to appoint what is best for her owne government Thirdly that the Church of olde time did vse so to doe Fourthly that Zanchius approueth S. Austins rule herein as M. Calvin did before him Fiftly that it was lawfull for the auncient Church to appoint sundry orders of ministers and the church this day hath the same authoritie Sixtly that the causes and respects for which the church may ordaine and make lawes in things indifferent are either edification order or decencie as I haue proved already at large The Corollarie of the Chapter FIrst the church may chaunge Christs owne practise and that in Rites and ceremonies pertaining to the holy Sacraments Secondly the church may appoint solemne feastes to be obserued as Salomon did institute the dedication of the Temple for seuen dayes Hester Mordecai the festivitie of their deliuerance Ezra and Nehemias the dedication of the wall at Ierusalem Iudas and his brethren the dedication of the Altar for eight dayes Thirdly the Iewes instituted their Sanhedrim after their returne from their captivitie in Babylon Fourthly the church by S. Austins iudgement may make any Lawes which are neither against faith nor good manners Fiftly the church saith Maister Calvin hath authoritie left her in things indifferent either to make newe lawes or to cassiere and chaunge the old so often as the necessitie of the church doth so require Sixtly the church receiued many vnwritten traditions concerning order and government of the Church Seuenthly the church saith Zanchius hath authoritie to constitute moe orders of Ministers when it is for the good of the Church Eightly the church may make any lawes which are not repugnant to Gods word So saith M. Beza telling vs plainly that we must not so much respect what the Apostles did as what the peace and good of the church requireth Much other like matter the same Beza together with Calvin Martyr and Zanchius haue deliuerd vnto vs as may appeare by this present Chapter I therefore conclude that the authoritie which this our our English church doth this day challenge vnto her in her riâ—es ceremonies ordinances lawes and constitutions is grounded vppon the holy Scriptures the practise of the Catholique Church and the best approued late writers Al obiections that possibly can be made against the lawes and constitutions of our English Church may bee answered with all facilitie by that which is plainly deliuered in this present Chapter whosoeuer shall marke it well will I thinke bee of mine opinion see the ninth Chapter and marke it CHAP. VIII Of things indifferent in particular The first Aphorisme of Chruch-holy dayes THe vulgar people for a great part what through vndiscreet zeale in some and tootoo rash preaching Ne quid gramuâ— dâ—â—a in othersome are so perswaded or rather bewitched blinded that they thinke they serue God better alas for pittie if they be quaffing in the Ale-house or sleeping in their chambers or gazing in the streets then doe their honest neighbours in going to the church on holy dayes there to ioyne with the faithfull in hearing diuine seruice and godly prayers They are not abashed to say for their vnchristian excuse that no power vpon earth can appoint an holy-day and that it is great superstition to obserue the same But certes none that are well studied or read either in the holy ecclesiasticall histories or in generall Councels or in the auncient Fathers or in the best approued late writers can ever without great blushing avouch or defend that vntimely hatched doctrine and vnsoundly conceived opinion Queene Hester and godly Mordecai appointed an holy day for the remembrance of Gods great benefit toward them in deliuering them from Hamans crueltie King Solomon ordained a solemne festivitie for the space of seuen dayes in the dedication of the Temple The Machabees instituted an holy feast to bee kept from yeere to yeere for the space of eight dayes for the dededication of the Altar Which feast Christ vouchsafed to honour with his corporall presence at Hierusalem The Iewes instituted their new Sanhedrim Synedrion or Presbiterie after their returne from their captimitie in Babylon as maister Calvin recordeth in his Harmonie vpon Saint Matthew The reformed churches in Helvetia doe right well allow the feastes or holy dayes of the Nativitie resurrection and such like If I should endevour my selfe to recount all that which may easily be collected out of the auncient councels the holy-fathers for the approbatioÌ„ allowaÌ„ce of holy-daies after the custome at this day of auncient time vsed in this church of England time would sooner faile me then matter whereof to speake I will in regard to brevitie content my selfe onely with one or two testimonies of councels as also of the graue holy auncient most learned father S. Austin then proceed to the testimonie of late writers because in this dispute they whoÌ„ it chiefly concerneth either haue not seene or read the councels and the fathers or else more rashly then wisely contemne their degrees iudgements and without all rime reason preferre their owne opinions before them The councel holden at Granado or Elebertine aboue 1200. yeares ago such is the antiquitie of holy-dayes in the Christian Church reputed the practise of the Church in former ages to be of such force in that behalfe that they deemed them Heritiques that would not obediently yeeld vnto the same These are the expresse words of the Elebertine Councel Pravam institutioneÌ„ emendari placuit iuxta authoritatem scripturarum vt cuncti diem Pentecostes celebremus Quod qui non fecerit quasi novam haresim induxisse notetur We haue decreed that the depraved institution bee amended according to the Scriptures that wee may all keepe the day of Penticost and the feast of Whitsonday Which who soever shall refuse to doe let him bee noted as one that hath brought a new heresie into the Church
is sinne this day as odious in Gods sight as euer it was and remaineth punishable by the law Morall which is the law of Nature more fullie explained in the Law of the Newe Testament but the quantitie kinde of punishment therein omitted by reason of the mutabilitie of times places and persons is wholly referred to the discretion of the wise Godly Magistrate This conclusion containeth in it three parts the expiration of the Mosaicall law Gods wrath and indignation against sinne the quantitie kinde of punishing sinne which is cōmitted to the Magistrate The first part is sufficiently cleered by the context of the former cōclusion The second part may be prooued by manie places of holie writ For as th' Apostle saith Tribulation anguish shal be vpon the soule of euery man that doth euill of the Iew first also of the Graecian Again in another place the wages of sinne is death Again therefore shall her plagues come at one day death and sorrowe and famine and shee shall bee burnt with fire for that God which condemneth her is a strong Lord. And Christ himselfe sheweth his generall hatred against sinne when hee pronounceth life eternall to be prepared for the righteous and euerlasting paine for the wicked The third and last part is proued two waies affirmatiuely and negatiuely Of the former speaketh S. Paul when hee telleth vs That the Magistrate is not to be feared for good workes but for euil Where hee rendreth the reason thereof vz. for that he is Gods Minister to take vengeance on him that doth euill Of the same speaketh Saint Peter when hee affirmeth the magistrate to bee appointed of God for the punishment of euill doers and for the prayse of them that doe well Touching the latter there is no parte in the whole corpse of the new testament or of the old this day in force which determineth eyther the quantitie or kinde of punishment with the which male factors are to bee punished This negatiue assertion is proofe sufficient vntill some instance can bee giuen for the affirmatiue Againe as the Prophets containe nothing but an explication of the Law so the New Testament containeth nothing but a cleare explication of the law and the Prophetes This I haue elsewhere proued at large where hee that listeth may reade the same for all the kindes of punishment expressed in the Mosaicall Law were meere iudiciall and are alreadie expired as is proued in the former conclusion The law Moral which is the law of nature teacheth vs that sinne ought to be punished but for that no one kinde of punishment not quantity in punishing can be meet and agreeable to all nations all times all places and al persons it leaueth the quantitie and kinde of punishment to bee determined by the godly and prudent Magistrate as shall bee thought most fit and commodious for the peaceable gouernement of the common weale the circumstances of times places and persons euer dulie considered this is euident by the practise of all nations for as M. Caluin writeth truely where Gods law the law of nature forbiddeth to steale the ancient lawes of the gentiles punished theft with double others condemned theues with exile and bannishment others adiudged them to be whipped others to be put to death False witnes was punished in som places onely with infamie in other places with hanging All lawes doe reuenge murder with blood but yet with diuers kinds of death In some places there are grieuouser paines appointed for adulterers in other places those that are more easie yet wee see how they all by this diuersitie of punishment tend to one and the same end For they all with one consent giue sentence of punishment against those offences which are condemned by the eternall lawe of god to wit murder theft adulterie false witnes but they agree not all in the manner of the punishment neithe truely is it necessarie or expedient that they should agree therein Their is a countrey which should out of hand be destroied with theues and slaughter if it did not with horible example deale verie sharpely with murderers There is also some time which requireth the enlarging of the sharpnes of punishment and some people verie prone to some certaine sinne vnlesse they be with great rigour kept in awe he is then very euill affected and enuieth the publike commoditie that is offended with this diuersitie which is most meete to retaine the obseruatiō of the law of God Thus writeth M. Caluin adding much more to the like effect which I omit in regard of breuitie referring the reader to the place out of whose words I note first that all nations who haue as S. Paule recordeth the law of nature ingrafted in their harts did not agree in the kind of punishing sin but vsed some one kind some another Secondly that theft murder false witnesse adulterie and such like haue not one and the same kinde of punishment in euerie people natiō Thirdly that addultery is punished in some places sharply in other som places more gentlie Fourthly that his diuersitie of the kinds of punishment is not onely godly and lawfull but also expedient and necessarie And so I conclude that the law morall which onely law is now in force doth leaue the quantitie and kinde of punishment to be determined by the ciuill Magistrate The third Conclusion Emperours and Empresses Kinges and Queenes absolute Princes and independant Magistrats may lawfully in certaine causes vpon good and godlie considerations either tolerate sinne vnpunished or pardon male factors For the exact handling of this conclusion because it is a matter of great importāce very necessary for many respects I deem it operapretiū agreable to the time in which we liue to lay down some strōg foundations in that behalfe First this is a constant Axiome approued by vniform assent of al learned diuines Cess inte fine legis cessat lex ipsa When the finall cause or end for which the law was made ceaseth then doth the law of necessitie also cease This foundation is grounded vpon the holy scripture where by the flat decree and setled law of the apostles wee are bounde to abstaine frō blood strangled meates This notwithstanding no man hath this day anie scruple of conscience to eate the same yet hereof no other sound reason can be yeelded saue onely that the end for which that law was made did lōg sithēce cease For euē at that time was no precise necessitie to abstaine from blood and strangled meates But this law was onely made in respect of the state of that time that the Gentiles and the Iewes might liue more peaceably together there by avoid all occasion of contention and quarreling And I therefor so soone as that end ceased the law also ceased with it and so we are this day freede from the same yea this Axiome is euident lumine
they did not loue for that such light diuorcement was onely permitted but neyther by God not by Moses approued I will demonstrate by these important and insolluble reasons First because these are Christes owne wordes Moses because of the hardenesse of your heartes suffered you to put away your wiues but froÌ„ the beginning it was not so Secondly because the mariage was indeed after suchlight diuource vnlawfull by the law For thus writeth Saint Paul know yee not Brethren for I speak to them that know the Law that the law hath dominioÌ„ ouer the maÌ„ as long as he liueth for the womaÌ„ which is in subiection to a maÌ„ is bound by the Law to the MaÌ„ while hee liueth but if the man be di ade shee is deliuered from the law of the man So then if while the man liueth shee take an other maÌ„ she shal be called an adulteresse Out of these words I note first that marriage cannot bee dissolued during the life of the former husband I note secondly that this was so euen in Moses law because Saint Paul saith hee speaketh to them that knew the law I note thirdly that to be married after diuorce for a light cause during the life of the former husband is plaine flat adulterie I therefore conclude that to tollerate sinne vnpunished vpon good cause is no sin at all This mine assertion of diuorcement is not onely grounded vpon the Scriptures but also confirmed by the holy fathers and best approued writers of this our age The 4. Reason We haue many examples in the holy scriptures of blessed meÌ„ that often pardoned Malefactors to this day were neuer reproued for the same King Dauid pardoned wicked Nabal at the peticion of his vertuous wife Abigal The same king Dauid pardoÌ„ed Abner who rebelled against him for the house of Saul The self same king tolerated Ioab in his naughtie dealings albeit he was more then a little offended with his manners The same king tolerated cursed Shemei thogh he coÌ„manded his son Salomon to do execution on theÌ„ both after that him selfe was dead The holy Patriarch Iacob did not punnish his sonnes Simcon and Leuie with death for their cruell murder done vpon the Sechemites though he had plaine regall and supreame authoritie ouer theÌ„ S. Austen did verie often intreate the Emperours most earnestly and humbly not onely to pardon heretickes but also the Circumcellions most naughtie people and cruell murderers The blessed virgin Mary was found to bee with child by the holy Ghost befor S. Ioseph shee came together Whereupon Ioseph because he was a iust man and would not put her to open shame was minded to put her away priuily thus reporteth holy writ Out of which wordes I note first that Ioseph knew the holy virgin to be with childe Secondly that he knew him selfe not to be the father of the childe Thirdly that Ioseph knew no other but that Mary his wife was an adultresse Fourthly that he thoght to haue put her a way secretly so to keepe her from shame punishment Fiftly that Ioseph was euen then deemed iust when the sought and thought to keepe her from shame although in his iudgement she deserued death by the law Yea S. Paul him selfe made intercession to Philemon for his seruant One simus though he had beene a vagabond and theuish fellow The first obiection No inferiour hath power to alter the law of his superiour and consequently man cannot pardon or tolerate malefactors whoÌ„ god appointeth to be punished The answer I answer first that precepts deliuered to vs in holy writ are of two sorts Some affirmatiue other some negatiue The negatiue bind vs at all times euery houre and in euery place but the affirmatiue thogh they be very apt to bind yet doe they not actually bind vs saue then onely when the due circumstances of times places and persons occurre hereupon it commeth that it is neuer lawfull to steale neuer lawful to commit addultery neuer lawfull to beare false witnes neither at any time nor in anie place the reason hereof is this because these precepts be negatiue This notwithstanding it is sometime lawfull to omit the precepts affirmatiue For exaÌ„ple it is necessary vnto saluatioÌ„ to mak confession of our faith and yet we doe and may often omit the same for that it is an affirmatiue precept And therfore Christ willeth vs not to giue that which is holy to dogs neither to cast our pearles before swine leaste they trâ—ad theÌ„ vnder their feete and turne againe al to rentus But wee are then bound to confesse our faith when either it tendeth to the glorie of God or to the good of our neighbour so that if such confession were not then made either god should be dishonoured or our neighbour scandalized So it is Gods coÌ„mandemeÌ„t to giue him thy cloake that will sue the at the law and take away thy caate yet maiest thou at sundry times for sundry respects denie him both thy coate and thy cloake So it is Gods commaundement to go with him myles twaine that will compell the to goe one and yet maiest thou sundrie times denie lawfully to goe with him either more or lesse so it is Gods commaundement neuer to turne away froÌ„ him that would borrow money of the or any other goods and yet maiest thou sundry times for sundry respects denie to lend either thy mony or other things All which and other the like haue this onely ground and foundation vz. That they are precepts affirmatiue which neither bind at all times nor yet in all places For precepts affirmatiue to vse schoole-tearmes obligant semper sed non ad semper Secondly that the ciuill magistrate had authoritie to mitigate many punishmeÌ„ts ordained for malefactors euen in the time of the old testameÌ„t For thogh he were appointed to punish them that vsed false weights and measures yet was that punishment to be determined according to the quantitie and qualitie of his trespasse The partie that was worthy to be beaten receiued many or few stripes at the descretioÌ„ of the magistrate M. Caluin a most zealous patron of pure religion hath these expresse words Impunè quidem vt liceat statui potest sicut in arbitio Principis est panas remittere Verum vt vitiosum non sit quod vitiosum esse natura dictat nullus legislator efficiet A law may be made that he which doth it shall not be punished euen as it is in the princes pleasure to pardon and releasse the punishment But that that be not sinfull which nature it selfe sheweth to be sinfull no law maker can effect or bring to passe Thus writeth this learned man granting freely as we see that the magistrate may sometime vpon good causes tolerate those sinnes vnpunished which gods law doth sharply reproue and speake against where the reader must obserue