Massachusetts Historical Society FROM THE BEQUEST OF GEORGE EDWARD ELLIS Seventh President of the Society Received September 1◠1895. THE Safety of Appearing at the DAY OF Judgement In the Righteousness of Christ Opened and Applied By Solomon Stoddard Pastor to the Church of North-Hampton in New-England Phil. 3.8 9 Yea doubtless and I do count all things but less for the excellency of the knowledge of Christ Jesus my Lord for whom I have suffered the loss of all things and do count them but dung that I may win Christ and be found in him not having mine own righteousness which is of the Law but that 〈…〉 To the Church of Christ in North-Hampton A Main part of the Work which the Lord Jesus has committed to me at present is to be doing service to your Souls and the Souls of your Children to be directing quickening and encouraging of you in the way unto eternal life which work requires the utmost care and diligence not only in respect of the necessity that you stand in of that blessedness which is the design and tendency thereof but also in respect of that difficulty that you will unavoidably meet withal in your pursuit of that blessedness however many men that know not their own hearts and are utterly unexperienced in the way of life may fancy it to be a matter of ease to go to heaven as if there were but a step between them and heaven and upon that account are bold to cast off all care about it at present yet such as have tried it and are walking in that way can upon plentiful experience witness to what Christ has taught us That strait is the Gate and narrow is the Way that leadeth unto Life every thing in corrupt nature is opposite to it and upon this account he requires Ministers to use their utmost industry in their work Luk. 14.23 Compel them to come in I have travelled in this work among you for many years and I may say without ostentation that I have obtained mercy of the Lord to be faithful I have made it my business to gain Souls to Christ and build them up in Faith and holiness principally insisting upon such things as have reached the heart of Religion and I reckon it one of the choicest mercies of the Lord towards me that I have not run in vain nor laboured in vain I have great cause to bow my knee to the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ and bless his Name that he has made me an instrument of bringing many among you into saving acquaintance with himself and I count it worth the while to spend the residue of my dayes in promoting the welfare of your Souls It is in pursuance of this design that this small Treatise is published not that my care is confined to your selves I owe a regard to the prosperity of other places the scope of this Discourse is to clear up the way of Salvation by Christ I meddle not with those false Doctrines that have been invented by men in opposition to this truth the Lord hath been pleased to keep these Churches sound in the Faith and does not yet lay a necessity upon his Ministers here to spend their time in the confutation of such erronions Opinions but I have made it my work to establish your hearts in this Truth to satisfie your Consciences from the Scripture in the safety of your reliance upon Christ vindicating the same from those secret workings of unbelief that are wont to rise up in the hearts of men that you and others may grow up unto all the riches of the full assurance of understanding and the acknowledgment of the misteries of God even of the Father and of Christ That you may be armed against those temptations wherewith your Faith is wont to be assaulted and learn to live in all conditions upon the righteousness of Christ If the Lord please to bless this Discourse together with other endeavours of his Servants in the Countrey both in Preaching and Writing to be a means to bring many Souls to an hearty closing with Jesus Christ that will be the great security of the Countrey against that degeneracy that is begun and against those superstitious practises that are entertained in other professing places the life of Religion takes beginning in the spiritual knowledg of Christ and is maintained by the same as long as we are built upon this Rock the Gates of Hell will not prevail against us The Lord who has watched over you in the time of dayes when you lay open to the fury of the Heathen and that has given special tokens of his Presence with you in his Ordinances both in the dayes of your former Pastor and also in late times continue to own and bless you and enrich you with all the Graces of his Spirit and give you Faith to sit under the shadow of Christ with great delight Which is the Prayer of Him who is Your Servant for Jesus sake Solomon Stoddard The Safety of Appearing in the Righteousness of Jesus Christ CHAP. I. The Introduction shewing the Difficulty of Believing this Truth THere is such Light remaining in the Conscience of fallen Man as has made him inquisitive after a way of acceptance with God and though several particular persons do not ordinarily concern themselves about it yet in all Nations and Ages there have been those that have made it matter of solemn search the abundant evidence that men have of the being purity justice and greatness of God in conjunction with the testimony of their own hearts concerning their guilt has made them restless till they can come at some satisfaction in this point men have been studious in many other points from a thirst after knowledg and to gratifie their curiosity but in this enquiry they have been much influenced by the cryes and disquietness of their own burdened Consciences the fearful apprehensions of Gods anger have spurred them on to discover a way of reconciliation they have not been able so to stupifie their hearts with worldly occasions and carnal delights as to let fall the consideration of this but have been compelled from their own terrors to make that enquiry as they Mich. 6.6 7. Wherewith shall I come before the Lord c. Many men who have busied themselves in this enquiry have not been advantaged to attain a right resolution thereof the Heathen Nations had lost the knowledg of the way of Salvation something in Religion was handed down to them by tradition and something particularly that had a reference unto Jesus Christ especially Sacrifices but the knowledg of the respect they had to him was quite worn out among them and the light of nature is utterly deficient in this particular that light is sufficient to discover to us that God is provoked with us that knowledg flows from our understanding of the nature of God and the experience which we have of our own sinfulness but the way of reconciliation does exceed the
degree we read sometime in Scripture of an Assurance 1 Thess 1.5 of a full Assurance Heb. 9.22 of all riches of the full assurance of understanding Col. 2.2 this assurance in the first closing with Christ what ever degree it is in does not remove the habit and principle of doubting though it does mortifie it in part that it never recovers its strength again yet there will be frequent returnings of this spirit of doubting it will attend a Saint less or more as long as he lives and many times in the first closing with Christ the assurance is not in such a degree but that there will be actual doubting the workings of a spirit of fear are not wholly removed some doubtings and misgivings of heart are consistent with assurance a man may see that it must needs be so that it can't be otherwise and yet immediately have recoylings of spirit but the assurance of the soul so far prevails over all his doubtings that he can venture himself in the arms of Jesus Christ 3. The soul is assured at this time by the Spirit of God that the Gospel is true and the messages of salvation certain The comforter shall convince of righteousness Joh. 16.10 the Spirit works a principle of faith and draws it into act sanctifies the reason and understanding and discovers the glorious excellency of God whereby the heart is assured indeed this assurance cannot arise from any other cause natural reason will not assure men of this for the reason of man is miserably corrupted and cannot see such spiritual things 1 Cor. 2.14 the natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God for they are foolishness unto him neither can he know them because they are spiritually discerned Indeed natural reason from Scripture principles may strongly argue the truth of this way of salvation against the Papist and other Hereticks but natural reason can't satisfie men about those scripture principles yea though natural reason be enlightned by a common work of the Spirit so as to be greatly affected with the Gospel for a time yet it cannot assure a man of the truth of it neither is it possible for Satan to work any such assurance in men men are sometimes afraid whether the discovery they have had were not the delusions of the Devil but though the Devil may comfort false hearts and fill them with joy yet he cannot assure men of the truth of the Gospel for he can only raise those principles that are in men and not put a new principle of faith in them whereby it is that the truth of the Gospel is discerned neither can the Devil give a discovery to the soul of the glorious nature of God or excellency of Christ so as that the heart should trust him love him c. Satan can make no such discoveries to a natural man as a natural mind is uncapable of receiving so that this assurance is the peculiar work of the Spirit From this particular we may conclude the Faith of two sorts of persons to be false on this account that they never have been assured of the truth of the Gospel 1. Such as are perswaded of the truth of the Gospel only from tradition the bottonie of many mens perswasions is the profession and judgment of such men among whom they live this is the doctrine that they have been bred up in the principle that their Parents have taught them they abhor to have any thoughts to the contrary because they have been Educated in this way upon the same ground that a Mahometan and Papist is tenacious of the religion of his Country and as the Heathen were wont to stick to the religion of their Forefathers Jer. 2.11 14. Mic. 5. upon this account many receive the Gospel and this may be a great advantage to men because they are brought under means and are kept from prejudices against the Gospel and so tradition cannot be true faith men cannot be assured of the Gospel upon this foundation this can only be the bottom of a strong opinion and conjecture not of Assurance 2. There is also another sort whose Faith does appear from hence to be unsound namely such who believed that God meant them in the calls of the Gospel because they found some good affections in themselves if their heart had been dead and unsavoury they could not have thought that God called them but the foundation of their believing that they were invited was they found some goodness in themselves but certainly this was built upon conjecture and an opinion of their own and therefore they could not be assured of it they had no assurance that they were called though they might have a strong confidence yet they could not be assured from thence that they were invited 2. In the first closure of the soul with Christ the Soul comes to him meerly upon the incouragement of the call of God in the Gospel God invites sinners in the Gospel to come to Christ and many ways urgeth them so to do and from thence the soul takes its encouragement There were many other things that encouraged them before to wait upon God for converting grace as the power of God Gods converting of others his strivings with him by his Spirit but the thing that is his encouragement to come to Christ is the call of the Gospel he sees his warrant in the call of the Gospel the call of the Gospel is the foundation of his faith that is the reason of his faith that God calls him in his Word The call of God does contain in it sufficient encouragement to believe for therein God shews his readiness to save sinners therein he shews that there is a way of salvation prepared for them therein he binds his faithfulness to them and lays bonds upon himself to save them if they come to Christ and this is the encouragement to them to believe Acts 13 48. they glorified the Word of the Lord and as many for it may be read such as were ordained to eternal life believed For the right understanding of this Consider 1. 1. It is indifferent with this first closing with Christ whether the soul takes notice of the call to believe as Gods call or Christs call some souls in their first closing take notice that Christ calls them others that God calls them and it is no material thing which of these ways it be if either the soul hear God or hear Christ calling him the answer to that call is true faith for there is sufficient warrant for us to come either from the voice of God or the voice of Christ this is an abundant demonstration of it that the call of the Gospel is sometimes propounded to us in Scripture as the call of God Jer. 3.22 Gal. 3.15 2 Tim. 1.9 and sometimes it is propounded unto us as the call of Christ Rev 3.18.20 there is this difference between them that Christ calls us by an authority derived from God God does derive his
manifest at that time that it is his testimony and hereby this differs from the delusions of Satan as the Prophets knew it to be the Lord that revealed things unto them so Saints at the time knew it to be the Spirit of God that witnessed to them they do not need any other help at that time to know it to be the voice of God they do not need a candle to see the Sun though soon after they may have doubts Thus I have cleared up the assumption of the Argument it remains that somewhat be added to evidence the proposition that it must needs be safe appearing in that righteousness upon the account of which God does bestow the beginnings of salvation here And I may evidence that from these two Principles The first Principle is That righteousness which does purchase any part of the good of the covenant does purchase the whole good of the covenant by the righteousness of Christ believers stand already possessed of some part of the good of the covenant and that righteousness that brought them into the possession of that will in due time bring them into the possession of what remains for that which purchases any part of the good of the covenant must needs purchase the whole the condition upon which all the good of the covenant depends was one so that the good of the covenant must be wholy purchased or wholly forfeited it could not be in part purchased in part forfeited the condition of the covenant of works was perfect righteousness if that were performed all the good of the covenant was purchased if that were not performed all the good of the covenant was forfeited an imperfect righteousness would not purchase any one good thing mentioned in the covenant one sin was sufficient to break the whole covenant and expose unto death one sin would make a course of righteousness for many years utterly ineffectual unto the purchase of any good and lay the sinner open unto the curse of the Law Gal. 3.10 Rom. 6.23 whatever was done towards the performance of the condition of the covenant signified nothing except the full was performed that God required so the condition of the covenant of the Mediator was perfect obedience to the law of the Mediator viz. perfect obedience to the commands of the law and perfect bearing of the curse 't is true that the active and passive obedience of Christ have a distinct respect one of them to the possession of good the other to the removal of evil the one is meritorious the other satisfactory one procures the blessings promised the other delivers from the evils threatned but yet Christ being made under such a covenant the success of one depended upon the other and they are joyntly together the purchasing cause of our salvation and one of them would have had no efficacy at all towards our salvation if not accompanied with the other so that this principle stands firm that that righteousness that does not procure all the good of the covenant procures none that righteousness can purchase no good for us that is not sufficient for our compleat salvation that cannot purchase the beginnings of salvation that does not justifie us seeing therefore on the account of Christs righteousness we have already the beginnings of salvation that righteousness is suffieient for our Justification and Salvation The Second Principle is That God in giving the beginnings of salvation in a way of believing in Christs righteousness for salvation does own that to be the way of salvation God does in this way give such mercies as are evidences of his favour and such as do accompany salvation he subdues sin quickens the heart in holiness reveals his loving kindness c. And herein God does plainly testifie that this is the way to salvation and that the righteousness of Christ was the procuring cause of salvation if the righteousness of Christ were not sufficient for our salvation God would be angry with us for believing in Christs righteousness we might expect frowns and judgments in this way but Gods giving the beginnings of salvation in this way does eminently own it to be the way of life when did God in such a way own men in a way of depending upon their own righteousness or external priviledges they have some common mercies but none of the beginnings of salvation but the beginings of salvation being bestowed in this way are an evident sign of divine approbation of it God bore witness to the Apostles preaching this doctrine by many wonderful signs Heb. 2.4 and he bears witness to those that by saith receive this doctrine by wonderful gracious effects in them he gives the earnest of heavenly glory which evidently shews the efficacy of this righteousness which they trust in to accomplish their salvation Eph. 1 13 14. in whom after that ye believed ye were sealed with that holy spirit of promise which is the earnest of our inheritance until the redemption of the purchased possession unto the praise of his glory CHAP. VII The ninth Argument From the Sacraments of the New-Testament Two Objections against this Doctrine Answered Argument IX IT is safe appearing before God in that righteousness the efficacy whereof unto salvation we are taught in the Sacraments of the New-Testament But in the Sacraments of the New-Testament we are taught the efficacy of Christs righteousness unto salvation God in these Sacraments is by sensible signs teaching of us this truth so that in the Sacraments there is a divine testimony to this doctrine 1. We are taught the efficacy of Christs righteousness unto salvation by the ordinance of Baptism as 't is said of circumcision that it was a seal of the righteousness of Faith so is baptism the washing of water signifies our washing in the blood of Christ as the legal washings had a respect unto the cleansing away of sin by Christs blood so has our baptismal washing this ordinance practised first by John and afterwards appointed by Christ to be a perpetual ordinance in the gospel church is appointed on this design to strengthen our Faith in this Doctrine 1. This appears because by baptism is held forth our fellowship with Christ in his sufferings that is signified thereby that we have an interest in the vertue of his sufferings that his sufferings are made over unto us that we do participate in the good and benefit of them Rom. 6 3. so many of us as were baptized into Jesus Christ were baptized into his death there was sealed up unto us the vertue and efficacy of his death therefore verse 4. we are said to be buried with him by baptism into death the like expression you have Col. 2.12 we are thereby partakers of his sufferings as if we our selves had suffered and if this be held forth then our justification and reconciliation is held forth for that is procured by the sufferings of Christ Rom. 5.10 we were reconciled to God by the death of his Son. 2. Baptism is
that presents it self for his relief is the reformation of his sins and diligent applying himself unto the duties of Religion and they are travelling this way after peace sometimes many years with a neglect of Christ men ought indeed to seek their peace with reformation but not by their reformations but men are mightily wedded to this way of seeking salvation by their own duties this is one of those things that make the work of conversion so exceeding difficult it is a difficult thing to bring men to be earnestly seeking salvation and when they are brought unto that it is very difficult to bring them to seek it in the right way they sought it not by faith but as it were by the works of the Law Rom. 9.32 but men have no ground at all for this it is safe appearing before God in the righteousness of Christ but it is no ways safe for men to trust in their own righteousness when men make their own righteousness the ground of their confidence they do but flatter themselves and please themselves in a vain delusion their own works can never procure their acceptance with God. In prosecuting this Vse let us consider 1. Who they are that seek salvation by their own Righteousness 2. What righteousness they do attain unto 3. What are their temptations to seek their salvation in this way 4. What confidence they have in their own righteousness 5. How they do to hide it from themselves that they trust in their own righteousness 6. The vanity of mens trusting to their own righteousness The first thing to be considered is Who they are that seek salvation by their own righteousness But before I give you their characters it will be needful to premise two things 1. They that seek salvation by their own Righteousness do not expect salvation from the covenant of works as it requires perfect obedience in order unto life they dare not adventure their souls on the strictness of the Law though they had need to do so if they seek life by their own works but they do not thus they look upon their righteousness as that which will allay the Anger of God and be an inducement unto God to save them that which will win the good-will of God and draw the heart of God to them yea they look upon their righteousness as that which will bring God in their debt that God is beholden to them for their service yet they do not lay claim to blessedness by the strictness of the Law for they know and confess themselves to be sinners they pray for forgiveness which things are inconsistent with justification by their own works the Jews did not stand upon a strict covenant of works Rom. 9.31 32 they sought it as it were by the works of the Law but these men do make such a mixture of the covenant of works with the covenant of grace wherein the covenant of works is predominant they make some profession of the Gospel and yet adhere to a covenant of works therefore the Apostle tells them that if they be circumcised Christ shall profit them nothing Gal. 5.2 they made account to have some benefit by Christ so they made account to have some benefit by grace therefore the Apostle tells them that whoever of them are justified by the Law are fallen from grace they did not pretend to the strictness of the Law but took in Gospel Principles into their way of justification and yet were legal all the while this makes the Apostle dispute in that manner against them Rom. 6.11 if it be grace it is no more of works otherwise grace is no more grace but if it be of works then is is no more grace otherwise work is no more works they mingled grace and works together they made their own works the foundation of their hopes and yet took in the plea of Gods grace and Christs Righteousness they thought their own works did contribute something and the grace of God through Christ would make up their defects 2. The Saints of God have a great deal of a self-righteous spirit remaining in them and men must not conclude because they find such workings in their hearts that they are self-righteous no doubt many of the Galatians that were tainted with the doctrine of the Legallists were really converted Gal. 4.14 there was somewhat of this spirit in Peter Mat. 19.29 we have forsaken all what shall we have therefore as the people of God are not compleatly delivered from other corruptions so not from carnal confidence there is such a spirit working and sometimes prevailing in them but there is also in the Saints an evangelical spirit Phil. 3.3 we rejoyce in Christ Jesus and have no confidence in the flesh they allow not themselves to have any confidence in the Flesh These things premised take these characters of those men that seek salvation by their own righteousness 1. Such men as magnifie themselves by their duties and frames they count highly of themselves because of what they do pride is the very spirit of self-righteousness The self-righteous man sets a great price upon what he does he loves to be thinking upon what he has done how his heart melted in such a duty how his affections were drawn out and enlarged in such a prayer what he has done and suffered in the cause of God he loves to chew over duties again as things that do commend him to God while another man is magnifying free-grace and the Righteousness of Christ the self-righteous man is idolizing his own services falls in love with his own beauty is taken with his own carriage and thinks that God and man should be taken with him he thinks his works do ingratiate him with God and draw the heart of God towards him so the Pharisee Luke 18.12 I fast twice in the week and give tithes of all that I possess he minds God of it what a choice man he was and thinks that God has not many such servants as himself he counts his own righteousness his riches Rev 3 17. he is rich in prayers rich in mournings rich in duties of Religion and of charity he is not brought to be poor in spirit he don't see himself without money and without price but has a considerable estate of his own to live upon he thinks that by his duties he gains somthing towards the paying for salvation Phil. 3.7 he places his confidence in those things and glories in them as a rich man boasts of his wealth so he boasts of his righteousness and despises other men as the Pharisee Luk. 18 11. I am not as other men or like this Publican whereas the spirit of a Saint is to glory in the righteousness and sufferings of Christ Gal. 6.14 God forbid that I should glory save in the Cross of Jesus Christ 2. Such men make their duties their refuge in time of danger such men are oftentimes scared from a remembrance of their former courses and sence of present
the Lord to make him hate him there is nothing in man that can byas the will of God either way to love him or hate him but God herein acts from his meer pleasure 2. Hence it follows that this or that particular man is as capable of being loved of God as any other in the World God has manifested special love unto thousands of men and women and you are as capable an object of divine sove as any of them you are as capable as Abrahum Moses David Paul or any other it is true you are as capable of Gods hatred also as any other the meer pleasure of God does decide it who shall be the objects of his love and his hatred you have no reason to be discouraged because you can find no reason in your self of Gods love those that God did set his love upon could find no reason in themselves of Gods love though you be mean and despicable yet you are as capable to be an object of Gods love as any other I do not say that one man is under as great likelihood as another they that God brings under means are the children of godly Parents that God is striving with by his Spirit are more likely than others but one is as capable as the other for the free will of God is the only thing that does determine it and therefore you have sufficient ground of encouragement to accept the offer of salvation 3. If God have wrought a spirit of Faith and Holiness in you that is a manifestation that God has set his love upon you though you can find no reason why God should love you can't tell why God should have any respect unto you yet it is certain he does love you if you have a gracious change wrought in you though he has cast away thousands of greater natural and acquired endowments than you and of greater external enjoyments than you yet you are one of those that he has chosen and has set his heart upon 2 Tim. 1.9 Who hath loved us and called us with an holy calling not according to our works but according to his purpose and grace given us in Christ Jesus before the World began Discouragement 4. They find things since their coming to Christ much contrary to their expectation they thought that they should have had more expressions of the love of God more quicknings of the Spirit more help against corruption more visible answers of prayer they thought that if they came to Christ they should have had little trouble or temptation but have lived a sweet easie and pleasant life but things are far otherwise things run very low in their souls they have a great deal of darkness and temptation they find very evil workings of heart and therefore they fear whether God has accepted of them or be willing to accept of them and to bestow salvation upon them did they walk in the light of the Lord and enjoy such communion with God as they expected and feel such evident fruits of the love of God as they promised themselves they should not be so backward to believe but since it is otherwise it begets a trembling and fearfulness in them it puts them to a great stand hence the calls of God take less impression on them especially because they think it is not so with others that come to Christ others do enjoy more manifest tokens of divine acceptance but they are both in inward and outward respects under tokens of divine displeasure and this is an hindrance unto their believing Job 9 16 17. If I had called and he had answered yet would I not believe that he had bearkened to my voice for he breaketh me with a tempest and multiplieth my wounds without cause For the removal of this Discouragement Consider 1. That many sad and sorrowful dispensations are consistent with the favour of God men are ready to think that if God delighted in them he could not find in his heart to exercise them in such a manner his compassion would work so towards them that they should not experience such sorrows but men greatly mistake it is true that all the wayes of God are mercy to them that fear him but yet many times his wayes are in appearance contrary unto love it is common with God to bring those that he has rejected into a prosperous condition they are under very smiling providences and on the other hand God frequently frowns upon his own children not only in external dispensations but also by inward darkness leaving them to conflict with sore temptations the love of God to his people is not an affection as love in men is but it is a design to make them happy not to bestow all those degrees of blessedness upon them that he can but it is with subserviency to a greater design even the glory of his Name and therefore he leads them to happiness in such a way as is conducible to the manifestation of the glory of his pardoning grace his holiness and soveraignty and it is frequent with God to lay very heavy afflictions upon his dearest children Psal 73.14 all the day long I have been plagued and chastened every morning and God leaves his sometimes to a great deal of inward darkness Psal 88.15 while I suffer thy terrors I am distracted men that fear the Lord may be in darkness and have no light Isai 50.10 the dispensations of God unto Job and the issue of the controversie between him and his friends stand upon record to satisfie the hearts of Gods people in all ages in this particular 2. God does sometimes withdraw from his own children the sensible quicknings of his spirit God never takes away wholly his sanctifying presence from his people God is present with them to uphold the being of grace there is a divine manutenency whereby God does preserve the life of grace at all times but the sensible quicknings of his spirit may be often withheld God may often so far withdraw that they may not perceive any special gracious operation of the spirit upon their hearts and that as at other times so in duties of worship they may be left many times under great dulness and senslesness left much to the stoniness of their own hearts without any special impressions made on them by the spirit of God there are times when God makes their hearts burn within them but there are times when they are left unto a benummed frame of spirit as if they had no spiritual senses they have great cause of joy but their hearts do not rejoyce therein great cause of sorrow but unaffected with it great cause of fear but fearless their senses are bound up and spiritual truths that they think of or hear of don't sink into them Mat. 25.5 They all slumbred and slept 3. The people of God ought not to count it a frown that they have not the immediate light of Gods countenance frequently we must have a care that we do not complain