good euen to all manner of men or a profitable and beneficiall kindnesse As in Luke 6 35. Tim. What is signified by patience and long sufferance Sil. Patience is that vertue whereby God forbeareth punishment and by long sufferance is meant that whereby God beareth a long time with the wicked long keeping backe and refrayning his wrath before hee punish them notwithstanding they still goe on to heape sin vnto sin Tim. What is meant by the riches of his bounty and patience Sil. The plentifull and large aboundance of these things according to the phrases of Scripture as rich grace for aboundant grace and dwel richly that is aboundantly Col. 3 10. Rom. 9 13. Eph. 1. 7. 2 5. Tim. What is it to despise these things Sil. To make no vse of them for amendment of life for to suffer a thing to ly by vs without any vse argueth a neglect of it that it is not esteemed Tim. What were the lessons gathered from hence Silas Sundry and in order these which follow First that we must be like to God in these properties bountifull patient and long suffering as he is Col. 3 12. Secondly that outward blessings belong to the wicked as well as to the good For his Raine falleth and his Sunne shineth vpon the good and bad Mathew 5 45. Thirdly that the godly are not to fret when they see the vngodly prosper for it is a checking of Gods bountie and patience Fourthly that manic are neuer the better for the benefits that God giueth them but rather the worse being hardened by kindnesse Lastly that it is a dangerous estate to be free from crofses ful of welth for such shall fall into impenitencie and hardnesse of heart Tim. What would Paul haue vs to vnderstand by that speech not knowing Silas Therein he doth both vpbraide and refute the brutishnesse and stupiditie of these sinners that whereas the blessings of God so many so long continued so great ought to haue euen drawne and haled them vnto such a kinde and bounteous giuer so blockish and foolish they were as they were not onely no whit stirred therewith towards God as they did the more neglect nay contemne him and yet did promise to themselues impunity safetie This was sencelesse and beastly ignorance and wickednesse Whence we learn both how out of measure wicked mans heart is being without Gods grace how vnable to moue it selfe to God though God reach out vnto them the hand of his benigoity and also in what perilous condition they doe liue which haue store of good things and are without the spirit of Repentance they are worse then Beasts Tim. In what sence is it saide that the bounty and kindnesse of God leadeth men to repentance Sil. That Gods benefits in all reason should mooue men to amendment and men are to make such an account that Gods kindnesse inuiteth them vnto repentance When he giueth benefits he giueth meanes of repentance but the grace of repentance he bestoweth on his elect Tim. What lesson was giuen heere Silas That euery good blessing of God is as it were a Sermon of repentance also the more benefits wee haue the more cause we haue to loue and please God by doing his will Tim. What doe ye call an hard heart Silas Such a one as will not be softned and mooued by benefits and instructions nor broken with threatnings and corrections the which in Scripture is set forth by the similitude of a stone Ezek 11 19 also of an iron sinew and of a fatte brawny heart Psal. 119. which dulleth all the sences and maketh them vnfit to doe their Offices Mans heart is naturally hard but this hardnes is encreased much by our owne peruersenesse and obstinacy Tim. By what degrees doe men fall into hardnesse of heart Silas First by wicked thoughts and lusts Secondly by yeelding vnto them with consent of the heart Thirdly the putting them or bringing of them into action Fourthly the often practise of sinfull actions Fifthly an obstinacy to continue in euill customes from whence commeth hardnesse of heart Iames 1 14 15. Tim. What be the causes of an hard heart Sil. The first cause is God himselfe as Iudge not as Author God hardened Pharaohs heart Exod. 9 12. Secondly Sathan Sathan entred into Iudas Luke 22 3. Thirdly man himselfe Pharaoh hardned his owne heart Exod. 8 15. Fourthly Impunity or freedome from punishment Fifthly the prosperity of the wicked as meanes and authors this had almost preuailed to harden Dauids heart Psal. 73 13 14 15. Tim. What be the kindes of an hard heart Silas Two First that which is felt and perceiued Secondly the other not felt nor perceiued Tim. What is the hardnesse of heart which is felt and perceiued Sil. When the heart though it feele no present ease yet it is grieued for sinne and desireth to be partaker of ioy and vseth the meanes as in Dauid Psal. 51. Tim. What is the hardnesse which is not perceiued Sil. When men doe eyther carelesly liue in sinne without desire of vsing the meanes to come out as they in the first of the Prouerbs verse 21 hated knowledge and did not chuse the feare of the Lord. Or else when men doe purposely resist the spirit of God in the vse of means as the Iewes Acts 7 51 Yeresist the Holy Ghost Tim. What be the remedies of an hard heart Silas Those which follow First admonition priuate and publike Secondly corrections being blessed which must be asked of God Thirdly meditation of Gods vnspeakeable kindnesse Fourthly prayer and hearty consession of sinne to God and al this done in truth and constantly Tim. What doe these words containe thou heapest and treasurest vnto thy selfe wrath against the day of wrath and of the declaration of the iust iudgement of God Sil. A seuere commination or threatning of a most heauy vengeance at the last vnto such as abuse the great kindnesse and lenity of God and are not bettered but made worse rather by his bounty and patience Tim. How is this vengeance declared and set forth Silas Three wayes First by a similitude taken from humane and earthly affaires of men in this world who hauing plentifull riches doe treasure and lay vp in store that which afterwards they will vse in conuenient time euen so wicked men which in time of Gods patience bearing with them doe increase their vnthankfulnesse and other sinnes though they feele nothing for the present yet afterwards they shall feele it farre more grieuously their vengeance comming vpon them as a Treasure heaped vp in more full measure it being the manner of God to recompence the delay in punishing with the weight of punishment see the like phrase of Treasuring vengeance in Deut 32 34. Tim. What should this teach Sil. That they are in worst case of all others whom God doeth most blesse and beare with except they 〈◊〉 Secondly that all men shoulde feare to abuse and
it the death of the soule by punishing sinne with sinne Secondly other punishments haue with them desire of release so hath not this Thirdly it is an high ready way to that vnpardonable sinne Marke 3 29. Fourthly all other punishments may be and are inflicted though not without paine yet without sinne but in this there is alwaies an addition of sin both of greater corruption and guilt and withall a greater desert of punishment Fiftly it is the peculiar marke and note of the childe of perdition as a broken and contrite spirit is a sure note of the childe of God Rom. 11 5. Ps. 51 19. Sixtly it doth in the end most certainly bring men not onely to temporall destruction but to eternall death Deut. 2 30. Ro. 2 5. 1 Sam. 2 25. Rom. 9 17. Lastly both some of the heathens haue acknowledged the truth of this as Sophocles in Aiax some of the Iewish Rabbins as Rabbi Kimchi for so much Maister Peter Martyr testifieth in his Commentary vpon this Text. Tim. What profit is to be made by the knowledge of this trueth Sil. First it teacheth that all good things turn to the hurt and damnation of the wicked Secondly it sheweth the strange blockishnesse of those wicked men which are vnder such a sharpe and bitter scourge without all sence and dread of it like drunken men which are asleep in the top of the Mast 〈◊〉 the ship is ready to be drowned with a great tempest Moreouer it must mooue the godly to compassion towardes such as they may suspect or see to bee stricken with this iudgement of blindnesse and hardnesse Men pitty such Malefactors as they see drawne vppon hurdles to Tiburne but to see so manie men to be hardned in vnbeleefe and sin deserues much more commiseration Thirdly it admonisheth all Christians to beware of this punishment to feare it long before it come and to shun all such meanes and wayes by which men vse to fall into it as first ignorance of Gods will reuealed ln his word Ephesians 4 18 19. especially where it is ioyned with careles contempt of knowledge Prou. 1. Secondly ordinary and daily disobedience to the word in such things as are knowne to men especially if it grow to a hatred of the Ministers and admonitions by them giuen as in Ahab and Herod toward Elias and Iohn Baptist. Thirdly vnbeleefe or distrust of Gods promises Heb. 3 12 13. Fourthly couetousnesse immoderate desire of riches Math. 13 22. Luke 6 14. Lastly pride of hart which where it raigneth it euer causeth the sinner to resist God as is to be seene in the example of Pharaoh Nabucadnezzar who would not obey the commandement of God because they were high-minded Tim. What profit is to be made of these things Silas First it must serue to warne vs all that as wee tremble at the iudgement of a hard heart so especially we labour against these forenamed sins euen against the very first motion of them beeing greatly humbled that we haue so farre proceeded in them Tim. Let me heare some of those signes by which men may know whether they be neere vnto or within this iudgement of an hardned slumbering minde Silas They arc principally these foure First to be vtterly without feeling or feare of this punishment such as neuer thought of it to feare and shun it are vndoubtedly caught by it their consciences are benummed blinded Secondly to heare the word without sound affections as of feare griefe ioy hope loue according to the matter Thirdly when after plaine often warnings by the word there followes no amendment Pro. 1 21 25. Zach 7 9 10 11. Psal. 50 16 17. 2 Chro. 36 15 16. Lastly when neither Gods seuerity can terrifie nor his kindnesse mollifie the heart being like the foole spoken of by Salomon which though he should be brayed in a Mortar yet will learne no wisedome or like restiue wel-fed iades which spurne against their feeder Deut. 32 15 Tim. How may we apply this to our profite Silas If we be stirred vp by it to enter into a serious examination of our owne hearts whether these tokens belong to vs that we may heartily thanke God if wee finde ourselues free and speedily repent if they haue taken any hold of vs. Tim. You haue told vs what hardnesse of heart is and also what manner of iudgement it is but now declare from whence it comes that the wicked are blinded in vnbeleefe and sinnes Sil. There be three maine causes of hardnesse of heart First the wicked themselues Secondly Sathan Thirdly God The wicked harden themselues as authors by wilfull resistance Sathan hardeneth as a tempter by inspiring vncleane thoughts and God as Iudge by punishing God when he hardens is author of the punishment or iudgment but not of the sinne The Diuell when hee hardens is author of the sinne but not of the punishment but man is author of his owne punishment through his sinne and contempt of the word Tim. How proue ye that the wicked are causes of their owne spirituall blindnesse and obstinacy Sil. First it is expresly saide that Pharaoh hardened his heart Exodus 8 15. When Pharaoh saw that hee had rest be hardened his heart or made it heauy Againe it is written in the Prophet Hosea Chap. 13. verse 9. O Israel thy destruction is of thy selfe which proueth plainely men to bee the proper causes of all the euill that commeth to them eyther in this world or in the next Lastly in Mat. 13 15. and Acts 28 27. The blame of hardening is laide vpon the vngodly them selues who winked with their eyes least they should see hereby giuing vs to vnderstand that those thinges which they saw against their wils they made as though they did not know them they saw and would not see they were wilfully blinded their owne peruersenesse corruption is the cause of their blindnesse in soule and of hardnesse of heart Mat. 23 37. Heereunto accordeth learned Augustine Pharaoh saith hee hardened himselfe by his owne free will And againe in his booke de 〈◊〉 gratia Chap. 4. he saith mans heart being infected from his birth whatsoeuer more hardnesse falleth out after that first corruption he suffereth it righteously and deseruedly And againe whensoeuer wee reade that men were hardened or had their eyes shut or eares made heauy let vs not doubt saith he but that their sinful deseruings were such before as made them worthy of that punishment which followed in his booke de lb. gratia This sheweth this ancient father to haue beene of this iudgement that euill men were themselues the principall and proper cause and procurers of hardening their owne hearts As an hot burning coale or fiery Ouen and Furnace sendeth foorth sparkles so the corrupt heart of man sendeth out those wicked effects in sinfull thoughts and actions which causeth and makes his heart more obstinate and repugnant vnto God Tim. What profite is to be made of this point Sil.
sundry similitudes as of a stone of an Iron sinnew of a brazen forehead of an heart of Adamant Ezek. 11 19. Esay 48 4. Zach. 7 12. Heere in Zacharie as also in that place of Esay there is a plaine description of an hard heart Sec Verses 11 12 of Zachary Tim. How many kindes of an hard heart be there Silas Two one Naturall which all men bring from the wombe called a stonie heart by Ezekiel in chap. 11. verse 19. for all men from their birth are enclined to the disobedience of God being sinners and enemies vngodly and the Children of Gods wrath Secondly there is an habituall hardnesse which is gotten by long custome of sinne which for a time takes away both the feare and feeling of sinne This is common both to elect and reprobate but with great difference For hardnesse of heart in the elect before their conuersion is totall and temporary it wholly possesseth them but it continueth onely vntill their calling after that their hardnesse is partiall mixt with tenderncsse and softnesse of heart as in Dauid and Peter but in the reprobate it is totall and perpetuall so as they remaine wholly obdurate and obstinate till their death as did Cain Esau Pharaoh Iudas and these refused Iewes heere spoken of And this last hardnesse is that which is heere meant in our text which is both of the whole heart and final or for euer For this onely is peculiar to such as be not elected as the nearest iust cause of their destruction which is inflicted vpon them not so much for sinne as for beeing hardened in sinne for their impenitency in sin to the end of their life notwithstanding al means vsed to soften and cause them to relent and turne to God from their sinne Tim. But it should seeme that fewe or no men are whollie hardened because Pharaoh yeelded and desired Moses to pray for him Esau wept Achab put on Sacke-cloath Also of Iudas it is written that hee repented and that Foelix trembled and Balaam wished that hee might dye the death of the righteous Silas These were but sudden motions in the wicked which lasted not like vnto flashings or lightnings Secondly they proceeded not from a soft and brokenhart but from slauish feare and dread or present smart of diuine iudgement Thirdly that beeing once ouer they returne to their former wickednesse and contempte of Gods will as Pharach did and Felix and the reste of them c. Tim. What is the Doctrine out of these words Silas That finall stubbornenesse in sin when a sinner obstinately continueth till his death in one or more knowne sins is a certaine marke of distinction betweene an elect childe of God which shall bee saued and him which shall be for euer condemned as appeareth Rom. 9 17 18. Math. 13 15. Iohn 17 11. 1 Iohn 5 18. The Reasons heere of be because it is neither sinne nor the number nor the long continuance in them that makes the actuall difference For in all these things many of the elect and reprobates are like therefore that which doth it must needes be this vniuersall and finall hardnesse of heart vnto which reprobates are giuen ouer and so are not the elect For whome God elects into their hearts he puts his Spirit which changeth their stony hearts into fleshy being made pliable by his will but the rest as our Text is they are hardned and left in their naturall corruption to persist in it to death and this is the second reason of the doctrine that the elect haue their natural stubbornnesse corrected by the Spirit of sanctification which altereth and reneweth them vnto the obedience of the word 1 Pet. 1 2. 2 Thess. 2 13. Tim. What profit are we to make of the knowledge of this Doctrine Silas It may serue to keepe vs from rash iudgement that wee neuer giue finall sentence vppon any man to brand him for a reprobate for who can tell if a wicked man will so continue vnto the end of his life some haue beene called at the ninth houre of the day some chaunged at the eleauenth and one to wit the Theefe on the crosse conuerted at the twelfe and last houre Secondly heere is a warning to all Christians aboue all thinges in the world to striue against hardnesse of heart and to labour for soft and obedient hearts for as this latter hart to wit when it is mooued and bowed by God to follow his worde is the greatest blessing being the peculiar note of the Childe of God and a speciall fruit of the Couenant so the other to wit a stiffe and vnyeelding heart is the greatest curse beeing the marke of cast-awayes and reiected persons vnto which euery man is so much the nearer the nearer he is vnto hardnes of heart and so much the further off the more softe and contrite his heart is This admonition will be found so much the more needfull if we duely consider with our selues these two things First that we liue in times of exceeding great case plenty and prosperity by which meanes the heartes of men are most vsually hardened and made forgetsull of God as it is written Deut. 32. 15. of the Israelites when they were full and well fed they forgot the strong God that made them and prooued like the vngratefull Horse that spurneth and kickes at his maister that fedde him Secondly that this iudgement of hardnes of heart hath generally ouerspread most men which nowe professe the Gospell all places being full of wilfull sinners which haue hearts as hard as the flint or the smithes anuell or the adamant such as no meanes faire nor soule either benefits or afflictions thretnings or promises can either breake or somuch as bend them The very word it selfe which should be the meanes of softning them through their owne mallice prooues a greater meanes to harden them Therefore in this generall hardnesse of hearte there is the more cause for all men to take heede to themselues to preuent it in themselues by all good courses as namely besides the constant vse of the publike workes of religion prayer sacraments the word read and preached these foure things following are to be done of all which desire to escape an hardned heart First in time of any affliction to worke their hearts earnestly to feele Gods displeasure in it and their owne sinnes which procured it alwayes begging that euery affliction may be effectually blessed to the humbling of their hearts In time of their prosperity dayly to confesse their knowne sinnes particularly vnto God with great griefe for the offence of God in them all and euery one of them Then to meditate often and earnestly of Gods iudgements against sinne in this worlde and in hell also to meditate of the passion and death of Christ crucified of their owne mortality and death of the day of iudgement Lastly to inure themselues to mourne as well for their small as great sinnes and to auoyde diligently
sake he maketh noble or base Eightly Paul saw no other cause of election but the will of God and it is dangerous to assigne that to bee a cause of election which Paul purposely entreating of this matter saw not this is to make our selues wise and him blockish nay our selues wiser then the Holy-Ghost Ninthly if the cause of election were workes or faith or vnbeleefe cause reprobation what need he say Oh the depth or obiect Is their iniquity with God and therefore it necessarily followeth that election is most free and absolute without any dependance vpon them Yet God did not chuse vs to the end without respect to the meanes for his decree concerneth both meanes and the end This is sufficient to stoppe the clamours of the Lutherans Tim. Doe ye thinke so of reprobation that it is free also without dependance on infidelity or ill workes fore-seene Silas In that some are not chosen to life it is without all respect of their vnbeleefe as a mouing cause but in that they are not onely refused but also appointed vnto destruction this is not without reference to infidelity sinne which as it is the proper cause of damnation so it moued God to ordaine to destruction but not to refuse and cast out from saluation for this was done to Esau ere he had done euill Secondly it is written God hardneth whom he will his will then is the high and first cause why men are not saued Thirdly God as a Potter may make vessels to ignominy for his wils sake Fourthly as we were corrupt in Adam God could see nothing in any man saue vnbeleefe and sinne And therefore if these had moued him not to chuse all had beene reprobated then Paul also should haue said that the purpose might remaine according to merite Lastly there is no vnrighteousnesse to cast off and refuse for sinne all will confesse this to bee iust Tim. What is the end or finall cause of election Sil. The vtmost end is the praise of his free grace Eph. 1. 5. hence elect are called vessels of mercy Rom 9 23. The nerest cause is mans saluation to attain eternal life and the final cause of reprobation is the praise of his iustice and the destruction of sinners Tim. What be the effects of election Silas Two First grace in this life as redemption by Christ vocation faith iustification adoption sanctification repentance good works perseuerance in grace Secondly vnspeakable and endlesse glory in heauen Tim. Are men and women elected to both these Sil. They be so for first Iacob and Isaac were chosen to the grace of the promise verse 8. but this comprehends al. Secondly it were absurd to separate the means from the end or end from the meanes Thirdly Scripture speaketh thus Acts 13 48. So many as were ordained to life beleeued Fourthly hec speaketh of election which is a preparation of the Vessell of mercie to glorie and which is ioyned with loue which is a willing of eternal life to men and all things which bring thither Tim. What vse of this point Silas It confuteth the Papists which say it is to grace and not to glory this they attribute to mans merits Secondly it reprooues such as thinke themselues elect to life they wanting notwithstanding the meanes of effectuall calling and good life Thirdly it comforts such as haue the means that they are sure they be elected to the end for meanes and end be linked together Ti. May they perish whō God hath chosen purposed to saue Sil. No they cannot for the purpose remaines firme Secondly God is vnchangeable and his loue is so too Thirdly then God should not be Almightie if he were not able to saue such as hee was once willing to saue Fourthly there would be no sound comfort to the godly except this foundation of God remaineth sure God knoweth who are his 2 Tim. 2 19. Tim. May such as be elect know themselues to be such Silas They may know it by their calling therefore is election heere ioyned with calling and before Rom. 8 28 30 because the counsel of election being hid before in the counsell of God is manifested in our calling Tim. What should this teach vs Silas First that such as haue but an outwarde calling by the Gospell ought to hope well of their owne election that it cōmeth of his purpose to saue them by saith Secondly because many are called which be not chosen it should stirre vp all sorts of Christians to examine their owne hearts whether they haue obeyed their Calling hauing their hearts changed from vnbeleefe and loue of sinne to faith and loue and practise of righteousnesse Thirdly let such as yet feele not this calling not dispair for who knoweth what may be tomorrow God calleth and turneth at all houres Mat. 20 1 2. Example in Paul and the theefe c. Tim. What are we to thinke of the election of others Silas First let euery man be most careful of his owne to assure it to himselfe by graces of the Spirit 2 Pet. 5 6 7. Secondly in charitie we are to hope well of all which heare the word and outwardly obey it 1 Thess. 1 6. Leaue to God the iudgement of certainty and the searching of hearts DIAL VII Verse 12 13. It was sayde vnto her the elder shall serue the yonger as it is written I haue loued Iacob hated Esau. Tim. VVHat is the end and scope of these words Silas To declare that the difference betweene one man and another touching grace and eternall life depends onely vppon Gods purpose and election and not vpon our worthinesse or vnworthinesse This is declared by two Oracles of God or testimonies of Scripture The first is taken out of Genes 25 23. The latter is taken out of Mal. 1 2. Tim. What is the meaning of the former place of Genesis Sil. That Iacob the younger brother should be Lord and Esau the elder should serue him Tim. This difference might come by chance or by their own deserts Silas Not so for first it was spoken ere they had done good or euill Secondly by another place of Malachy it is shewed that Iacobs dominion came from Gods loue and Esaus bondage from his hatred therefore it is Gods onely purpose which discerned between them and consequently betweene all other men Tim. But doe these words taken out of Genesis fitly belong to proue Gods eternall election to be the soueraigne cause of eternall saluation in heauen Silas Yea they are so or else Paul being ledde by the Spirit of God would not haue alleadged thē so for it were blasphemy against Christ to say that Paul did alleadge the Scriptures false or vnfitly being an Apostle of Christ who in his doctrine was priuiledged from erring as all other Apostles were Tim. Tell vs then how the lordship of Iacob and seruitude of Esau may proue that for which it is cited men may bee poore and lye in prison and be
all to themselues to be hardened in their sinnes it being his most merciful nature and nothing else which moued him to exempt some from that common misery that being freede from sinne and death by Christ they might partake in his heauenly glory to the glory of his grace DIAL X. Verse 17. For the Scripture saith to Pharaoh for this purpose haue I stirred thee vp that I might shew my power in thee and that my name might be declared throughout all the earth Tim. VVHat is the Apostles drift in these words Silas Hauing cleared God before of iniustice in respect of his electing some out of lost mankinde because hee did it out of the prerogatiue of his absolute and most free mercies as Paul confirmeth by testimony of Scripture so now he like-wise proueth by Scripture that God is not vniust in the matter of reprobation out of Exodus 9 16. Tim. What argument doth Paul take out of this Scripture to proue his purpose Silas From a particular example of Pharaoh whom God did not chuse but reiect very iustly as appeareth two wayes First from the quality of Pharaoh beeing a man hardened by sinne noted in this word raised vp as Paul expounds it in the next verse for seeing Pharaoh was hardened and became obstinate before hee was destroyed therefore God could not be vniust in appointing him vnto destruction for sinners doe perish iustly therefore God is not vniust when he doth appoint them vnto destruction Secondly from the end which hee propoundeth to himselfe of his owne counsell namely the declaration of his owne power and iustice to the praise of his name Now that cannot bee vniust which is done of God to so good an end if withal it be considered that Gods glory is the cheefest good thing and that he hath an absolute right in all his creatures to dispose of them as he thinkes best for his owne glory Tim. But how fitly doth Paul gather a generall doctrine touching all reprobates from this one example Silas Very fitly because the cause and case of all reprobates is one and the same for none of them perish but in regard of their foregoing sinne and God is glorified in the destruction of euery one of them therefore if God dealt iustlye in reprobating Pharaoh vpon these grounds hee is also iust in the reprobating and refusing all other appointed to damnation Tim. What are the parts of this Text Silas Two First a preface and secondly a testimony of Scripture Tim. What is meant by Pharaoh Silas It was a name common to the Kings of Egipt signifieth an auenger as afterwards their Kings were called And the Kings of Gezar Abimelech and the Emperors of Rome Caesar. Tim. What is meant by Scripture Silas Generally euery thing that is written but more especially the holy writings of Moses and yet more particularly the booke of Exodus and therein this one sentence And further by Scripture wee may vnderstand God speaking in the Scripture as appeareth by comparing this place with verse 25. as also by reason for the Scripture is the word of God Tim. What instruction doth arise from hence Silas That euery clause and sentence of holy Scripture must be spoken of and heard and vsed with all religious reuerence firme beleefe The reason heereof is because the most glorious God is the author of it and hath inspired them 2 Tim. 3 16. 2 Pet. 1 21. Tim. What vse is to be made of this point Sil. It reprooues such as faile in excesse of reuerence to the Scriptures ascribing diuine force to the Letters and Syllables pronounced as if God had enclosed his vertue in them which is a meere inchantment and sorcery Secondly such as faile in defect and want of reuerence receiuing Gods words as the worde of a man prophanely denying authority and obedience to them Thirdly it warnes vs in the hearing of the word to remember that we haue to do with God whosoeuer bee the Instruments to deliuer this vnto vs Acts 10 33. Tim. What other doctrine will arise from this Preface Silas That the doctrine of reprobation ought by the Ministers of God to be taught vnto the Church but warily and with circumspection as the mindes of the people be not estranged from God by the rash handling of it For the doctrine of reprobation is a part of the holie Scripture and is reuealed therein therefore it belongeth to vs to take knowledge of it Deut. 29 29. Also this doctrine is profitable and necessary to be knowne for it serueth well to commend Gods mercie toward the elect and to encrease their thankefulnesse finee they know that he freely elected them to life 〈◊〉 they were no lesse corrupt and miserable then those whom he refused Also it teacheth all men to iudge and speak aright of God to wit that he hath absolute power ouer men to appoint them to what ends it pleaseth him without any vnrighteousnesse at all Ti. Is there any other things to be collected out of this Preface Silas Yea two things First that not only the whole Bible but euery particular sentence therein is to be accounted the word of God Lastly it confutes such papists as say that the Scriptures be mute and dumbe for God speaketh in them it is a speaking Iudge Let Christ iudge saith Augustine and the Apostles with him for in them Christ speakes Tim. What are we to learne out of the testimony being the second part of the Text Sil. Three things First that God is the author of reprobation Secondly by what degrees and meanes that counsell is fulfilled Thirdly the vtmost end of this decree of God Tim. How is the first gathered from this Text Sil. Because it is saide I that is I God haue stirred thee vp also that God hated Esau verse 13. and that God prepareth vessels to wrath verse 22. Adde heereunto 1. Thess. 5 10. Tim. What profit of this Sil. First it confutes such as will not haue reprobation depend vpon the will of God but vppon the workes and will of men Secondly such as affirme that there is no decree of reprobation at all Sil. But if God for his wil sake reprobate men is he not herein vniust Silas No because betweene the decree of his reprobation and the execution of it there alwaies goes the sinne of the party as the meritorious cause of theyr destruction Also God refuseth for most holy ends and lastly his will is the rule of righteousnesse Tim. What is meant by the stirring vp of Pharaob Silas It containes those degrees and meanes by the which Gods counsell was performed vpon Pharaoh The degrees be these First that he was created of God iust in Adam but in him suffered to fall Secondly that God had aduanced him to the kingdome Thirdly that amids the great plagues of Egypt he preserued him aliue when others were destroyed Exod. 9 15. Fourthly that GOD withdrew grace from him that hee could not profit by those wonderful
Secondly sencelesse security when such disobedient sinners are neither mooued with the benefits nor correctiōs wherby they are called to repē tance nor yet allured by promises nor terrified by threatnings hauing harts like brawne or an adamant and yron Thirdly desperate obstinacy when after all meanes vsed of God by his worde of iustice and mercy instead of being better and better sinners grow worse and worse more carelesse to please God and keepe his commeandements and more frowarde in their behauiour toward God and man Tim. What is the vse of this doctrine Silas First it affoords comfort to all soft and melting heartes which by the worde and iudgements of God are moued to relent and turne from their sinnes vnto God by true and serious repentance such are no reprobates Secondly it teacheth the miserable condition of all such men as haue stony and brawny hearts they bee in a fearefull condition and had need to looke to it betimes Thirdly it admonisheth all men to beware of and striue against hardnesse of heart whereunto the neerer they are the neerer they are to reprobation and therefore let euery man examine himselfe and with al diligence vse al means to soften their owne hearts See Dialogue on Chap. 2. verse 4 5. DIAL XII Verse 19 20 21. Thou wilt then say vnto me why doth he yet complaine for who hath resisted his will But o man who art thou which pleadest against God Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it why hast thou made me thus c. Tim. VVHat doth this text containe Silas A new obiection against predestination with an answere to it The first obiection was touching Gods vnfaithfulnesse if he did reiect the Iewes to whom hee had promised to be their God The second was of iniustice if hee should elect some and not other some without respect of any worthinesse or vnworthinesse in themselues Now in this our text they charge God with cruelty and extreame rigor For if God harden whom he will and after punish them for that hardnesse this seemes vnto carnall reason to be cruelty This obiection is fortified and backt by two reasons closely coucht in this text The first is this It were cruelty in God to bee reuenged on that hardnesse which himselfe willeth verse 19. But Pharaoh and all wicked men are hardened because God will as before verse 18 therefore he hath no cause to be angry or to punish or if hee doe it seemeth to mans reason to bee all one as if a man should binde his seruant and after beate him because he did not his worke or as if a Magistrate should bid a prisoner breake the Iayle and yet hang him when hee hath done The other reason is this that God must bee accounted cruell if he should punish that which men cannot resist and auoyde but the omnipotent will of God whereby reprobates are hardened cannot bee resisted therefore the hardened without cruelty cannot bee reprehended and punished Tim. What are we to learne for our instruction from this obiection or first part of our Text Silas That the will of God cannot bee withstood and made voyde The reason heereof is because God being himselfe almighty there is nothing to crosse and hinder what he willeth Tim. Yet Steuen accuseth the Iewes Acts 7. that they resisted the will of God so doe the Prophets blame the Iewes of brason faces iron sinnewes stiffe-neckt vntamenesse Silas True the will of God is daily resisted to wit his reuealed will his will manifested in his worde and workes But our text speaketh of the secret and hidden wil of God De voluntate bene placiti non signi as Schoolmen write and distinguish Tim. What vse is to be made of this instruction Silas It affoords matter of singular comfort to all the godly who beeing assured by true faith and the fruites thereof of the good will of God from euerlasting may surely resolue that doe Sathan or sinne or the worlde what they can against them yet shall they neuer perish 〈◊〉 Gods will cannot be resisted Tim. What other instruction are wee to draw out of the 19. verse Silas That mans reason corrupted doth draw or gather false conclusions out of true propositions an example heere of we haue in this text For it is true that God hardeneth whom he will and that his will cannot be resisted but heereof it followes not that he may not iustly complaine of and punish obstinate sinners which set and willingly settle themselues in a course of disobedience Againe as it is true that we are freely iustified by faith alone but heereof it will not follow that wee neede not doe good workes as Papists blindly and badly collect Also because in some Churches the Ministry or Leiturgy may be faulty we ought not therefore to conclude that we may not liue in such Churches where such defections be not amended as if any would affirme a body to be no body because it is a lame one or an eye no eye because there is a web and pin in it Tim. But what error is in the conclusion of this obiection Silas First there is a falsity or error heerein that they put the secret will of God for the cause of perishing vnto the reprobate whereas none of them are destroyed but for the contempt of the knowne manifest will of God Secondly though there be a necessity that they be hardened on whome God will shew no mercy yet no reprobate is hardned against his owne will for they are so farre from auoyding the hardnesse of their owne hearts as that they rather contract it by their owne voluntary faults as Pharaoh did and as the obstinate Iewes did also Iohn 8 44. Tim. What vse is to be made of this last instruction Sil. That we must diligently beware how we conferre with mans vnreformed reason in the matter of Gods eternall predestination because thereby we shall bee carried into infinite errors and blasphemies against God Our duty therefore is with meekenesse and reuerence to stoope to that which God reucales in the Scripture admiring with Paul Rom. 11 33. Or with Mary pondering what our dull minds cannot at first conceiue Luke 2 51. Tim. Come we now to the answere of the Apostle to the former obiection and tell vs how he proceedeth Silas First by his Apostolicall authority he beateth downe the malepertnesse of man in disputing with God and this he performes by comparing the exceeding infirmity of man the creature with the high maiesty of God his Creator O man who art thou that pleadst against God Tim. What is meant here by pleading Silas A saucy ouer-bolde questioning with God to call him his decrees and doings vnto our account or examination Tim. What is the instruction out of these words Silas That it is a great impudency for any man to subiect the deepe counselles of God to the blinde poore and beggerly reason of man This is proued first by Deut. 29. 29. where it is written that secret
causes in respect of the reprobate Silas There be three mentioned in this Text. First to shew his wrath against their sinnes Secondly to make knowne his power by breaking them not withstanding their obstinacy against him Thirdly the abuse of his long suffering and lenity Vpon these grounds and for these ends God reiecteth some and is auenged on them Therefore his dealing is not tyrannicall but most iust Tim. Expound the words and first tell vs what is meant here by wrath Silas First Gods iust displeasure conceiued against the reprobate for sinne Secondly the paine or vengeaunce due thereunto Tim. What meaneth this to shew wrath Sil. First to ordaine them to this punishment Secondly in due time to inflict it vpon them most iustly Tim. What doctrine 〈◊〉 from 〈◊〉 Silas That God is most iustly offended with the reprobate for sinne and wil most seuerely reuenge it in them The reason heereof is because sinne is 〈◊〉 to the nature of God Secondly it is the office of diuine iustice to take vengeance on sinne else in vaine were God called the iudge of the world Gen. 18 Rom. 3. Tim. What vse are Christians to make of this doctrine Silas First it strengthens our Faith concerning the righteousnesse of God For sithence he neither punisheth the wicked nor euer meant to doe it but in regard of their sinnes deseruing it we are therefore to beleeue him to bee righteous whatsoeuer corrupt reason obiect against it Secondly it stirreth vp to repentance and to hatred of sinne because God so abhorreth it that he wil eternally plague it euen in his own and most noble creature Act 17 30. Thirdly it should moue all to dread the fearefull iustice of God if Beasts dread the roaring of a Lyon Amos 〈◊〉 4. how much should flesh dread that iust and terrible God Tim. What is the second end or finall cause why God reiecteth and destroyeth some Silas To make his power knowne which is a thing most iust that God should declare and manifest his power to his owne praise and glory Tim. But how is Gods power shewne vpon the Reprobate Silas Heerein that howsoeuer they be many and of great might yet God is mightier then they being able to put them downe and throwe them to destruction which turneth as to the praise of his iustice so of his power treading downe all thinges which resist it as it is written All the Aduer sar es of Iehouah shall perish none shall stand before him when he is angry 1 Sam. 2 10. Psa. 37. And Now is the Axe laide c. Mat. 3 10. Tim. What is the doctrine which ariseth from hence Silas This that the vtmost end of reprobation is the manifestation of Gods power and not simply the destruction of the Reprobate which is the nearest end in respect of the men themselues and is no further respected of God then as it tends to the declaration of his power and Iustice. The reason of this doctrine is because else in vain had God created the world if it had not bin to manifest his glorious properties whereof his power is one Secondly it was his will by this meanes to shewe forth his power and why might he not Tim. What vse of this Doctrine Silas First Gods Children must in the ruine of the reprobate finde cause to magnifie God As Moyses and Mirian did praise God Exod. 15. for the temporall calamity of Pharaoh and his hoast in the redde Sea so the godly must praise him much more for the eternall destruction of the Reprobate in hell insomuch as out of it hee worketh his owne praise Reuel 11 17 18. Secondly God being stronger then man he is more to be feared then all men This reproues the fearefull and iustifyeth Gods iudgements against them and it comforteth the faithfull to consider that they haue such a strong patron to vphold them and put downe their enemies were they as strong as Pharaoh and all Egypt Tim. What is the third cause why God takes vengeance on the Reprobate Silas Because they abuse his suffering and long patience whereby he spared them when hee might strike them dead Tim. What is the Doctrine from hence Silas That God is very patient not onely towardes his Children 2 Pet. 3. but euen towardes his verie enemies Acts 13. Psal. 103. The reason heereof is to giue them space of repentaunce and to take all excuse from them il they be obstinate Rom 2 4 5. Rom. 3. Tim. Shew vs what vse we are to make of this point Sil. Gods Ministers and Children must by the example of their Father learne patience towards those that be euill 2 Tim. 2 24. Col. 3 12. So long as there is any cause to hope that by our sufferance there is any good to bee done vpon them but if they growe more obstinate by our lenity then obey that in Math. 7 7. Tim. What other doctrine from hence Silas It is a fearefull marke of a reprobate alwaies to abuse Gods patience to the hardning of themselues in their euils because none but they do it as none but Gods children can profit by it to amendment of life Tim. What vse of this point Silas It serues for a trial and examination of our selues whether we be our of the ranke of reprobates namely if we finde that we haue profited by the patience and long sufferance of God towards vs to the reformation of our wayes also it serues for terror vnto such as are not made the better by the patience of God towards them And lastly it serues for comfort to such as are bettered by his long-suffering and kindnesse thereby learning more to fear the offending of such a gracious God This is a good token and very comfortable Tim. Shew vs why reprobates are called vessels of wrath Silas Vessels they are called in respect of Gods preordination and creation He fore-appointed and made them to some speciall vse as vessels be euen to the setting foorth of his power and iustice as was saide before Vessels of wrath in regard of their owne sinnes whereby they corrupted and made themselues worthy of his wrath and punishment Tim. What is meant by prepared and by whom are they prepared to destruction Silas To be prepared signifies to be made fit meet before hand and this is done partly by God eternally reiecting them creating them in time permitting them to fall in Adam and iustly hardening them for resisting his will Secondly by Sathan solliciting them to sin and inspiring into them sinne-full motions obdurating them also in sinfull courses Lastly by themselues in regard of their naturall corruption and voluntary deprauation following the lustes of their ignorance with greedinesse Thus in regard of creation and the end to the which they are ordained reprobates are prepared of God as also in regard of sinne as it is a meanes to bring them to that end but respecting sinne as it is sinne which they bring of their owne so
reason is because in the Church of GOD there are euer some to whome they are effectually perfourmed howesoeuer the most neglect and refuse them yet there is a remnant which receiue them still and are saued by them Tim. What profit is to be made of this poynt Silas That the great number of vnbeleeuers and wicked men should neuer weaken our account and credit of the promises of the Gospell which being vniuersally reiected yet still take place in the elect to whome they are peculiarly made Tim. Tell vs what is meant by the election of grace Silas The guift of predestination or the grace whereby men are elected or predestinated or by an Hebraisme a gracious and free election The meaning is that such as are kept free from the pollution of Idolatry and other sins they may not thanke themselues as if they were worthy of it for their workes sake but are beholding to the good pleasure of God who hath separated them from others according to his gracious purpose Note that election is not here put and taken actiuely whereby wee chuse grace but passiuely whereby men were chosen of God for hee speaketh of such as were foreknown of God verse second of Gods election of men and not of mens election of God Tim. What is the doctrine from hence Silas That election vnto eternall life proceedeth from the free fauour and grace of God This is the same with that which is written Rom. 9 11 15 Eph. 1 4 5. Ro 15 19. Tim. What profit is to be made of this poynt Silas First it confuteth the Pelagians who affirme that men chuse Gods mercies not that his free mercies chuseth them whereas this text plainly speaketh not of mans electing God but of Gods electing men out of his grace not out of their owne merites Also it ouerthrowes the conceite of Origen and Chrysostome which vpon this place imagine some men which beleeue in Christ to be saued by grace and others which besides faith haue good workes to be saued by the election of grace deuiding things which are conioyned to wit election and grace faith and works as if there could be a iustifying faith without works Secondly it abateth the pride of all flesh to teach that election commeth not from themselues but is wholly of grace Lastly it 〈◊〉 vs vp to great loue and thankefulnesse towards God to praise him for his free loue Tim. What other doctrines will flow from these words Silas That if election be of grace then our iustification sanctification and glorification all be from grace too as it is written 2. Tim. 1 9. Rom. 3 24 28. The reason hereof is 〈◊〉 est causa causae est causa causati quicquid est causa antecedentis est causa consequentis Tim. But be grace and works at such vartance as that these blessings and things cannot proceed from both Silas Yes verily they are as contrary as can be when the cause of election and saluation is to be searched out there is no coniunction of grace and workes no more then of light and darkenesse as the text speaketh If it be of faith then not of works The reason hereof is because merite of works being once put and granted grace is destroyed as it is heere written then were grace no grace Tim. What is the cause of this consequence that therefore grace is destroyed if works be admitted as a partner in the cause of election and saluation Sil. The reason is because grace giueth eternall life and whatsoeuer belongs to it as a thing not due but merite of workes craues them all as a debt therefore if election calling iustification c. should not bee wholly from grace but in part also from workes then grace should not remaine free and therefore shoulde not bee grace see Rom. 4 4 〈◊〉 Gal. 3 18. Tim. What profite of this point Silas It refuteth such as in the mystery of election iustification c. doe mingle grace and merite of workes together ascribing some-what to grace some-what to workes foreseene in matter of election past or present in matter of iustification whereas these thinges by God himselfe are pronounced asystata which haue no agreement at all together Secondly we are taught that it is impossible that the Church of God should faile upon earth because it doth springe out of the election and grace of God which cannot at any time vtterly faile Thirdly it conuicteth them of error which heere vnderstand by grace infused grace the habite of iustice powred into mans heart by the Spirite whereas the Apostle speaketh heere of grace as it is in God subiectiue as in a subiect and doth oppose it as a thing contrary to the works of righteousnesse which be in men as to a contrary and tels vs what he meanes by grace to wit the election of God Lastly this must prouoke all beleeuers to ioyfull thankefulnesse seeing God when he could not saue them by works which they had not did by his franke grace chuse and saue them which deserues at our hands al possible praise both in word and deed in life and death Such as bee often mindefull of such a free mercy to glorifie God for it it is a good signe that they be vnder this grace and are euen the chosen children of God DIAL V. Verses 6 7. And if it be of grace it is no more of workes or else were grace no more grace but if it be of works it is no more grace or else were works no more works What then Israel hath not obtained that he sought but the election hath obtained it and the rest haue beene hardened Tim. VVHat doth this text containe Silas These two thinges hauing set downe grace to be the efficient cause of election and of effectuall calling now he excludeth workes or denieth them to be any cause thereof Secondly he concludeth the first part of this Chapter touching the casting away of the Iewes in the seauenth verse That all which were freely elect amongst them were certainely saued none perished but the reprobates and that through their owne default because they were hardened in their sinnes and namely in their disobediēce of the Gospel of Christ which they obstinately and rebelliously refused beeing graciouslie and first tendred to them Tim. What signifies Grace Silas Grace signifies Gods free fauour or his euerlasting gracious loue and mercy and workes doe signifie merite of workes or meritorious workes for these bee contrary to grace and not woorkes simply considered as duties Tim. By what argument doeth Paul shut out workes from being any cause of election or vocation or how proueth hee that these come not from merit of workes Silas The argument is taken from the opposition or repugnancy of flat contraries such as in no wise can stand and consist together being immediate contraries The argument may thus bee framed If election and calling bee of meritorious works then it is not of grace but they both come of grace therefore not of
aduersarics of Gods grace Further we are taught heereby that the Romish Synagogue cannot be the true Church of Christ because most obstinately impudently they persist to ascribe mans iustification and saluation partly to grace partly to merite of works and thereby doe ouerthrow the doctrine of grace which is the very soule and life of a true Church for take away the doctrine of free election iustification and saluation and presently the very foundation of all religion is shaken to pieces so farre it is off that they can bee the true Church hauing cast downe the groundworke whereon it resteth Lastly it conuicteth such of error as vnderstand this text to bee meant of grace infused into mans heart whereas grace being set against workes therefore as workes doe sticke in men as in their proper subiect so grace heere spoken of hath no other subiect but God Tim. What doctrine doth arise out of the seauenth verse Silas First that in the Church of God there are sundry which seeke for righteousnesse and saluation and neuer obtaine it as Rom. 9 31. Tim. How comes this to passe seeing it is promised to such as seeke that they shall finde Silas The reason is because they seeke amisse and not as they ought whereas that promise is made to such as seeke aright Vnto which two things are to be considered First the manner that we seeke these things by faith and secondly that we intend Gods glorye as the end of our seeking see Rom. 9 30. Many Israelites failed in both these for they sought righteousnes and life by their owne workes and therefore obtained it not as it is written Rom. 9 31 32. and 10 3. And they robbed God of the glory of his grace Tim. What vse is to be made of this doctrine Sil. It warneth vs that it is not enough for vs to seeke to be iustified and saued vnlesse we take the right course prescribed in the worde for many pray and neuer obtaine because they pray amisse and many striue to enter and neuer enter because they striue not aright so many seeke and neuer finde because they seeke God not for himselfe but themselues and for their owne benefites and not for loue of his goodnesse that they may praise his grace and set foorth his glory Tim. What other Doctrine from this 7. Verse Sil. That in the bosome of the Church of God there haue alwayes liued two kinds of people some elect and called some Reprobate and hardened This diuision beganne in Adams family in Caine and Abell whence did spring two Cities as Augustine obserueth one of God another of the world it was continued in the family of Abraham in Isaac and Ismael the one of them beeing the childe of the Flesh and the other the Childe of the promise Also in the house of Isaac in Esau and Iacob and Christ saith That at his comming two shall bee in the fielde the one taken and the other refused Luke 17 34. And lastly Paul writeth that of the same lumpe of mankinde there are made some vesselles of mercie to honour others vessels of wrath to destruction The high and soueraigne cause heereof is the wil of God shewing mercy to whom he will and hardening whom hee will Rom. 9 17. The subordinate cause and second reason is that there are two beginnings of mankinde the seed of the woman Christ Iesus the heade of the elect and the Serpent Satan the Prince of this world which begetteth children of differing and contrary dispositions and qualities 1 Iohn 3 8 9. and Iohn 15 19. Tim. What vse are Christians to make of this truth Silas It reprooues both such as beleeue all men are elect and shall be saued and such as liue so securely as if none should perish and warns vs not to stumble though we see many wicked to be in the world Tim. What is the next Doctrine from this verse Silas That all the elect shall certainly bee saued for they attaine what they seeke for to wit Christ and his faluation as it is not possible for the Reprobate to bee saued so it is impossible that any of the elect should perish The reasons heereof be First the election of GOD which is vnchangeable Secondly the promises of God which are vndeceiueable Thirdly the Prayers of Christ which can neuer be denied Lastly the power of Christ to whose keeping they are committed which is vnresistable Tim. What Vse of this point Silas First they are from hence confuted which say the elect may vtterly and for euer fall from Gods fauour and faith in Christ. Secondly heere is great comforte to such as haue the true markes of their owne election to assure vnto them their standing in grace vnto saluation in despight of Satan sinne themselues and the whole world For they are by grace of election kept from beeing hardned to destruction DIAL VI. Verse 7 8. The rest were hardned as it is written GOD hath giuen them the Spirit of slumber eyes that they shoulde not see c. Tim. VVHat is the sum of this Text Silas That the rest of the Iewes whō God had not elected were hardned by the iust iudgement of God as he proueth by a testimony oracle of holy Scripture Tim. What be the parts of this Text Silas Two First a proposition The rest were hardned namely so many as not being freely chosen of God did not obtain Christ and his righteousnesse vnto saluation all the rest besides these were blinded Secondly a proof out of holye Scipture to confirme the hardening of the Iewes it proueth two things not only that many Iewes were hardned because the Scripture had foretold it but whence this hardnesse came or what was the maine and highest cause of the blindnesse and hardnesse of this Iewish people to wit the singular or speciall iudgement of God so appointing so foretelling yea and so working it in time also it sheweth what this hardnesse is to wit a spirituall slumber or sencelesse sleepe of the soule or a shutting of eyes and eares that seeing and hearing they should neyther see nor heare vnto their conuersion Lastly how long this hardnesse did continue vppon the Iewes namely euen from Esay his time vnto the present time wherein the Apostle wrote vnto this day which must be referred vnto the end of verse 7. the rest cited out of Esay being enclosed in a Parenthesis Tim. What signifies the rest Silas The other Iewes which did not belong to the election of Grace but were reprobates and reiected of God Tim. What is meant by hardning Silas It signifies properly the thicke skinne of ones hands or feete with trauell or worke which is so barked or stifned as if it were pierced or pinched yet it is not felt but by translation from the body to the soule it signifies the stubbornnesse or obstinacie of mans heart resisting in his wit and will the word of God This stubbornnesse is noted in Scripture by
First it cleares Gods iustice against such as fasten the blame of their destruction vpon Gods seuerity because hee hardeneth and destroyeth none but such as by their owne malice haue deserued it Secondly it prooueth the Papists slanderers and false accusers for they are not ashamed to write of the Ministers of the Gospel that wee teach God to bee the chiefe author and proper cause of hardnesse euen as it is a sinne whereas with one consent we all doe teach the proper cause of vnbeleefe and sinne as it is a sinne to lurke in our owne nature and doe wholly discharge God of this God neyther willeth approueth nor worketh sinne saith Philip Melancton vpon the first Chapter to the Romanes Euery one sinneth willingly saith Peter Martyr and no man is compelled of God to sinne vpon the 9. Chapter of Iudges The originall of sinne is not in God saith Caluine vpon Iames 1 13. Wee hold him for impious and blasphemous faith Beza contra Castil which saith there is iniquity with God yet both Dureus the Iesuite and the Rhemish Priestes doe charge vs that we doe make God the proper authour and worker of hardnesse of heart and the actiue cause of sinne Yea hereupon Stapleton the Diuinity reader at Doway inferreth that the God of the Catholikes and the God of the Protestants is not one For saith hee the Catholikes God is not the cause of sinne but the God of the Protestants is so which is a wicked calumniation may be iustly retorted thus The true God allows no Masse Transubstantiation Purgatory prayer to or for the dead merites c. Tim. But you sayd that spirituall blindnes and hardnes proceedeth from Sathan how proue you that Silas First from the text which maketh the slumber or sencelesnesse of the Soule in heauenly matters to be an effect of the euill spirite sent by God into the wicked to make them more blinde and obstinate then they were afore Also it is written 2. Cor. 4 4. that Sathan doth blind the mindes of the wicked and 1. Kings 22 22. Sathan is sent of God with authority to leade into error and blindnes that wicked King Ahab Tim. But how is Sathan the cause of hardnes of heart Sil. As a tempter and instigator and inspirer to breathe and droppe in vngodly and vnrighteous cogitations into wicked mens hearts as liquor is distilled and dropped into a vessell Hence hee is sayed to woorke in the children of disobedience Ephesians 2 2. and to bee effectuall in the wicked strongly to delude them 2. Thes. 2. 9. and to haue entred into Iudas by his suggestion to encrease his malice against Christ. Tim. Is this power giuen to Sathan ouer any which are born of God Silas No ouer none of them but ouer the reprobate only for it is written that that wicked one toucheth them not 1. Iohn 〈◊〉 8. also by watchfulnesse and prayer they are kept from falling into his snares though they bee sore and often tempted Mat. 6 13. and 26. 41. His tyranny is exercised onely vppon and ouer them which are addicted and wholly giuen to disobedience ouer the reprobate in whome hee raigneth and worketh euen at his pleasure 2. Thes. 2. 10. Thereason here of is because wicked men are worthily committed to Sathan to be gouerned by him because they want only and wilfully shake off the regiment of God and will not bee ledde by his worde and Spirite Psalme 2 3. That which Pharaoh spake with his mouth the same all wicked men thinke in their harts and say in their soules Who is the Lorde that wee should obey him And therefore they haue an euill Spirite sette ouer them as it did happen vnto Saul who resisted the good Spirite of GOD and had therefore an euill Spirite sent to rule and vexe him Tim. What is the profit to be made hereof Silas It should teach all Christians willingly to obey God labouring to keepe his worde and suffering it to gouern their wayes lest after their deseruings he do put them into the hands and power of Sathan to be by him carried along vnto destruction for there is no remedy such as cast off the yoke and gouernment of Christ must be put vnder Sathans rule and dominion Tim. Why did you affirme that God was the cause of a blind and hardned heart Sil. Because the Scriptures both in this Text and in innumerable other places doe attribute it to God in Esay 6. 9. God commands Esay to goe and make their hearts fatte and Esay 29. 10. the Lorde is sayed to couer them with the Spirite of slumber and to shut their eyes and Esay 19 14. the Lord mingled amongst them the Spirite of errour and often in Exodus it is affirmed of God that he hardned Pharaohs heart of Sihon King of Hesbon that the Lord God hardned his Spirite and made his heart obstinate Deut. 2. 31. also Rom. 1 24. that God deliuered vp to vile affections c. and 2. Thes. 2 11. that God sent strong delusions that they should beleeue lyes and Iohn 12 40. God hath blinded their eies and hardned their hearts These and many other texts shew that God hath a hand and a worke in the hardning of sinners else wee should deny the word of God and take from God more then halfe the gouernment of the world if wee should deny him to haue an operation in the sinfull workes of the wicked whose soules and bodies are subiect to God who made them and are to be disposed by him Tim. Will not this bring in God to be the author and cause of sin seeing hardnes of heart and blindnes of minde is a sinne and if it be of God then God doth worke sinne Silas No not so this will not follow hee is the author of the iudgement but not of the sinne There bee two things to be considered in hardnesse of heart The first is apostasia the repugnancy or aberration from the will of God this God neither willeth approueth nor worketh but abhorreth and punisheth it as comming from Sathan and from the corruption of mens harts and being contrary to his image and worde The other is antimisthia Rom. 1 27. the recompence or iudgement which is executed when a sinner that was blinde and obstinate before is further indurate and blinded as a reward due to his contempt of God Of this punishment and due recompence God is the authour and cause for it is a iust thing with God to punish sin with sinne lesser with greater former with latter sinnes All punishment being an act of iustice is good Therefore sinne as it is a punishment commeth from God and not as it is a transgression for so it proceeds from Sathan and the wicked Thus Augustine teacheth Pharaoh sayeth he hardneth himselfe libero arbitrio and God hardened him iusto suo indicie againe God hardeneth not as an euill auth our but as a righteous iudge who though hee doeth not instill any sinne into the creature
Good Deut 4 8 5. Acts 9. 2 3 4. The Law would free vs from death Thence called a quickening Spirite In respect of Author Of manner Of obedience Of the end to teach vs the worship of God who is a pure Spirit Lex ordinat hominem ad spiritualem obedientiam Indeed wee should be spirituall and free from death it we would do the Law Law is a rule of spirituall holinesse A transition to the third part of the Chapter Paul now speakes no more in time past I haue but I am * Vocibus Apostoli sunt gemitus sanctorum pugnantium contra carnales concupiscentias August Paul was partly spirituall partly carnal euen after new birth Agnascit et dcplozat potentes peccati inse habitantis reliquias Paraeus As Salomon and before him his Father Dauid did Psal. 〈◊〉 Paulus de se loquitur in proescnti absque fictione vcl prosopopoeia scd ingenue ex sensu infirmitatis suoe Sighes cōplaints of trobled sinners can hardly be brought in order yet Paul is not without Method Id est 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Aug. Psal 10 12. 130 3. Phil. 3 17. If I doe what I would not then I consent to the Law that it is good but the former is nue therefore the latter Mark 20 6. Non loquitur de carne Physice sed I 〈◊〉 ogice 〈◊〉 3. Part. Voluntas bonum eligit care bonum eligit intercipit Paraeus Psalme 119. Tutus siattonitus securus si cantus Tertull. A Maior in Canterbury beheaded for comforting Rebels Edward 4. In the north many vndone for fauouring the two Earles 2. Part. 1. Part. 2. Part. 3. Part. 4. Part. Heb. 2 15. 16. Christ had not saued vs from sin being himselfe a sinner Heb. 7. 25. See this in the story of Pbaraoh Exod 1 2 c Also of Nebuchad 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 in Daniell Ier. 9 23. 1 Cor. 3 18. 19 20. Confutation Instruction Humiliation Consolation Psal. 33 6. Esay 59. 21. Rom. 8 16. The Spirit of Adoption is peculiar vnto Children Galath 4 6. It leadeth the willing it haleth not vnwilling The will cannot be compelled but willeth all freely which it wisheth Children of Gods purpose 2. and actuall children being called 2 Cor. 2 1 Proposition 2 Assumption 3 Conclusion Abba Pater Why we must labour for certainty of our adoption As in Martine Marbecke that fained himselfe to be Edward 6. 2 Proposition 2. Assumption 3. Conclusion The truth po wer mercy of God the promiser cause me to be of good hope Bernard Ephes. 1 13. 1 Proposition 2 Assumption 3 Conclusion 2. Heires 3. Heires of God 1 Pet. 1 4. The ends and vses of the Crosse. 〈◊〉 Rom. 5 3 4. 〈◊〉 posuere dy 〈◊〉 laborem virtutis via 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 angusta porta Quality Quantity 4 Doctrine Reasons 5 Vse Drift Summe Part. Interpretatiō Doctrine Reason Vse 2. Doctrine Vse 3. Doctrine Reason Vse A righteous man regards the life of his beast saith Saloman 〈◊〉 Doctrine Reasons Vses Doctrine Reasons Suprema regula iustitiae 〈◊〉 Dci 〈◊〉 Drift Parts Interpretatiō Doctrine Reasons What differēce between faith Hope Faith is before hope as the cause before the effect Vse 2. Part. Vse Ospes fallaces meritis considere nostris Doctrine Reasons Vses I will be with thee saith god to Moses Exod. 3. God and Moses will be strōg enough euen against Pharaoh The Godly faile in their prayers for lack of knowledge Facit nos postulare quae Dco placet Quiasunt de re incnarrabil's sci vita aeterna Facit gemere plus quam dici potest Drift Summe Order or me thod Interpretation The word know is set against opinion or doubting 1. Doctrine Similitude Vse Inter hoec omnia etiam eaquoe nibil sunt numerantur Bernard 〈◊〉 humiliores reddunt doctiores Aug. Cooperantur nō per se operātur sed concurrant cum causa operante Paroeus 2. Doctrine Reason What it is to loue God aright The fountain of our loue to God is Gods loue to vs. Augustine referreth this to the purpose not of the elect but of God They which be predestinate doe not perish because Gods predestination is not deceiueable August Parts Interpretation It is not a prescience of merites and truth which is the cause of election Doctrine Vse Destinare est rem ad certum sinem ordinare Praedestinare est proeordinare antcquam ad fi nem mittas Vse Scmen aut igniculi Fidel in insantibus How faith doeth iustisie not iustify See 3. Chap. Sanctificatio est gloria inchoata Glorificatio cst sanct ficatio consummata Election not vniuersall Predestination free 1 Tim. 6. 17. Mauritius who dyed most miserably Non 〈◊〉 tradid t sed occisions 〈◊〉 1 5. Hebr. 13 5. 1 Cor. 3 22 23 Iohn 6 17. The question hath heere the force of a negotiation and stronger deniall A Maxime logicall Who shall dis allow whome God allow eth Gods iudgement seat is highest saith 〈◊〉 A speech borrowed from Kings who set at their right hand their chiefe and greatest Officers and fauourites as Salomon vsed Bath sheba 1. Kings 2 19. For Christ to make intercession and to pray is not to bee taken properly but to shewe the good will of the Sonne to vs as Chrysostome noteth Seeing Christ suffered for euill seruants why should not we suffer for a good Lord we had profit by his sufferings he can haue no profit by our passions Ambrose They are slaine without any resistance Duplex persuasio vna fidei altera charitatis haec aliquādo sallitur illa nunquam Lutherus An Oath a part of Gods worship Deut. 6. Dolor est morbus excrucians animum ex malo vel imminent vel presente oritur Cicero A thing vnheard of that for Christs sake one should wish to be separated from Christ. Hierom Like to that of Christ Father if it be possible So ought Moses prayer to be vnderstood Exod. Blot me out c. This was a priuate condition next is publike The chosen people of God his flocke his sheep his lot his inheritāce consecrated to the true God not as Athens I elos Sicilia were dedicate to false Gods which yet they reckned their honors Ephe. 1. 4 5. All these ren thinges they be not virtues of the 〈◊〉 but guiftes of God to keepe them from pride Chrysust Chrysost vnder standeth it of Christ the Sonne If beside Christ they cannot find any other person to whom these words may be referred let them leaue this glory Ambr. A child of so many prayers and teares cannot be lost as one said concerning Augustine the sonne of Monica Coherence Method Summe Interpretation Doctrine Reasons A doubt A solution A 2. doubt Vses Interpretation Doctrine Reasons Vses Scope Method Interpretation Summe Doctrine Reason Vse 2. Doctrine Interpretation A doubt A solution As Sarahs wombe being barren was not cause of procreation so water in Baptisme is a thing cold dry vnable to regenerate Doctrine Reason Vse 2. Doctrine Reason Vse Oracles of Apollo at Delphos were