own Sister Miriam for using some undutiful speeches against him was strucken by God with an exceeding great Leprosie and so odious was the murmuring of Korab Dathan and Abiram and their Confederates as the Lord caused the Earth to open and to swallow some of them quick and the Fire to consume the rest Joshua succeeding Moses the People professed their Subjection and Obedience unto him saying All that thou hast commanded us we will do and whithersoever thou sendest us we will go as we obeyed Moses in all things so will we obey thee Whosoever shall rebel against thy Commandment and will not obey thy Words in all that thou dost command him let him be put to death During the Reign of all the Judges though the People are noted for many great Enormities yet we do not find that they rebelled or shewed any great disobedience against them whom God had set over them to rule them except the particular murmuring and opposition of the Ephramites against Gideon and Jephtha at their first entrance upon conceit they had been contemned which opposition God punished with a great overthrow of them When the People had Kings according to the manner of other Nations to order and govern them their subjection was rather encreas'd than diminished according to Samuel's description of the King's Claim or manner of ruling which should reign over them To command not only over the Persons of his Subjects but also over their Goods which manner of ruling or dealing by any King without a just cause as it was Tyranny so to deny it when the necessity of the King and State did require it according to the Laws of the Kingdom was a great neglect of preserving the publick good and a high degree of disobedience Besides it is generally agreed upon that Obedience to Kings and civil Magistrates is prescribed to all Subjects in the Fifth Commandment where we are enjoyn'd to honour our Parents Whereby it followeth that subjection of Inferiours unto their Kings and Governours is grounded upon the very Law of Nature and consequently that the Sentences of Death awarded by God himself against such as shewed themselves disobedient and incorrigible to their Parents or cursed them or struck them were likewise due unto those who committed any such Offences against their Kings and Rulers being the Heads and Fathers of their Commonwealths and Kingdoms which is not only apparent by way of consequence but likewise by Example Practice and Precept as where Shimei is judged to die for cursing of David the Lord 's Anointed where David himself appointed by God to succeed King Saul would not be induced by any perswasions to lay violent hands upon his Master the King and where it is said Principi populi tui non maledices and again Ne maledicas Regi in corde tuo to which purpose more might be alledged CAN. XVI IF any Man therefore shall affirm that it was lawful in the Old Testament either for Children or Nephews to have been disobedient to their Fathers being their chief Governours from the Creation till Moses's time or afterward for the Children of Israel either under Moses Joshua the Iudges or their Kings to have been disobedient to them in their lawful Commandments or to have murmured or rebelled against them or that it was in those times more lawful unto Subjects for any cause whatsoever either to curse their Princes Kings or civil Governours or to bear Arms against them or to depose them from their Kingdoms or Principalities or to lay violent hands upon their Persons than it was in the said times lawful upon any occasion for Children either to have cursed their Parents or to have rebelled against them when they did reprove or correct them or to have withdrawn themselves from their subjection saying unto them they being private Men We will be no more your Children or you shall be no more our Fathers or bearing civil Authority over them we will depose you from your Government over us and will be no longer ruled by you or to have offered any violence unto them or to have beaten them and much less to have murthered them He doth greatly Erre Placet eis CAP. XVII WHen God appointed Princes Judges and Kings to Reign over his people the manner usually was that they had notice of it thereby to conform themselves to obedience Moses and Aaron acquainted the Israelites with God's pleasure for their deliverance out of Egypt by their service agreeably to his Promise formerly made to Abraham and they chearfully and with great thankfullness submitted themselves to be ruled by them God having appointed Joshua to succeed Moses the same was signified by Moses to the Israelites and they willingly protested their obedience unto him Likewise no sooner did the Lord assign Judges to defend and govern them but presently they followed and obeyed them Upon the people's request Samuel having anointed Saul for their King when the same was made apparent to them either by casting of Lots or by answer from the Lord they shouted when they saw him and said God save the King King David being anointed by Samuel at God's appointment to succeed King Saul and after Saul's Death coming thereupon by God's direction to Hebron the Tribe of Judah presently anointed him again for their King and yielded themselves to be governed by him Seven years after all which time King David had Wars with Ishbosheth Saul's Son the rest of the Tribes came unto David and acknowledged that God had ordained him to be their Governour King David growing old and having appointed by God's direction his Son Solomon to be anointed King in his own Life time when the people knew that Zadok the Priest had so anointed him they forthwith upon the blowing of the Trumpets said all with one Voice God save King Solomon Afterwards also the like course was held upon the Death of every King to make his Successor known to the people Sometimes they were so addicted unto new Kings as they expected no further Circumstance but submitted themselves to their Government and sometimes it was held fit for the young Princes to imitate King David's Example by kind usage and loving words to knit more firmly their Subjects hearts unto them Placet eis CAN. XVII IF any Man therefore shall affirm either that the callings of Moses of Aaron of Joshua of the Iudges of Saul of David of Solomon or of any other of the Kings of Judah elected and named by God himself or coming to their Kingdoms by Succession according as Jacob by the Spirit of Prophecy had foretold did receive any such virtue or strength from the people their said notice presence and applause as that without the same the said callings of God either by Name or by Succession had been insufficient or that if the people had withstood any of them so called by God as is aforesaid they
dispose both the Rebellion of Subjects and the Malice and Greediness of encroaching Kings upon their Neighbours as albeit such their attempts of all sorts were in themselves very wicked and detestable in his sight yet he having the skill to bring Light out of Darkness and to use wicked Instruments and Actions for a good purpose did always frame and apply them to execute his own just Judgments When the Sins of a Nation but principally of his own People were of that Nature Height and Ripeness as his Justice could not fitly be put in execution by any other but by the wicked for example in the overthrowing of Hierusalem God's own City in burning of the Temple that was the place of his Glory and carrying his own People into Captivity though never so much by them deserved no godly King could well have been employed but such a One only as the King of Babylon was In respect of which their Imployment such wicked Instruments to execute God's just Judgments are called sometimes his Servants and the Rods of his Wrath or as Attila termed himself the Scourge of God And when having attained their ungodly desires whether ambitious Kings by bringing any Countrey into their subjection or disloyal Subjects by their rebellious rising against their natural Sovereigns they have established any of the said degenerate Forms of Government amongst their People the Authority either so unjustly gotten or wrung by force from the true and lawful Possessor being always God's Authority and therefore receiving no impeachment by the wickedness of those that have it is ever when any such alterations are throughly setled to be reverenced and obeyed and the People of all sorts as well of the Clergy as of the Laity are to be subject unto it not only for fear but also for conscience sake the Israelites in Egypt after Joseph's death being oppressed very tyrannically many ways did never rebel against any of those Kings but submitted themselves to their Authority though their Burthens were very intolerable both in respect of the impossible works imposed upon them and because also they might not offer Sacrifices to the Lord a special part of God's Worship without apparent danger of stoning to death Besides it may not be omitted when God himself sent Moses to deliver them from that Servitude he would not suffer him to carry them thence till Pharaoh their King gave them licence to depart Afterward also when the Jews being brought into subjection to the Kings of Babylon did by the instigation of false Prophets rebel against them they were in that respect greatly condemned by the Prophet Jeremy and in their Captivity which shortly after followed they lived by the direction of the said Prophet in great subjection and Obedience they prayed not only for their Kings and for their Children that they might live long and prosper but likewise for the State of their Government the good success whereof they were bound to seek and regard as well as any other of the King 's dutiful Subjects And thus they lived in Babylon and other places of that Dominion till the King gave them leave to depart notwithstanding in the mean time they endured many Calamities and were destitute for many years of the publick Service and Worship of God which was tyed to the Temple and might not elsewhere be practised or attempted CAN. XXVIII IF any Man therefore shall affirm either that the Subjects when they shake off the Yoke of their Obedience to their Sovereigns and set up a Form of Government among themselves after their own humours do not therein very wickedly or that it is lawful for any bordering Kings through Ambition and Malice to invade their Neighbours or that the Providence and Goodness of God in using of Rebellions and Oppressions to execute his Iustice against any King or Countrey doth mitigate or qualifie the Offences of any such Rebels or oppressing Kings or that when any such new Forms of Government begun by Rebellion are after throughly settled the Authority in them is not of God or that any who live within the Territories of such new Governments are not bound to be subject to God's Authority which is there executed but may rebel against the same or that the Jews either in Egypt or Babylon might lawfully for any cause have taken Arms against any of those Kings or have offered any violence to their Persons He doth greatly Erre Placet eis CAP. XXIX ALthough the Jews upon their deliverance out of Captivity and restitution to their own Country received many favours from the Persian Kings and had liberty given them to live in a sort according to their own Laws yet they never recover'd their former Estate but liv'd in great subjection and servitude under them whilst that Monarchy endured The Temple and City of Hierusalem were again built but not with the magnificence which they had before Zorobabel first and then Nehemiah were made successively by the said Kings the Rulers and Governours of the Jews so restored but with divers restraints It was not forgotten what mighty Kings had ruled in Hierusalem and therefore the said Rulers were not permitted to govern any more in that Regal sort They were still subject to the direction of those Kings and paid unto them very large Tribute and Customs insomuch as when the Priests gave publick thanks unto God for his restoring unto them the state which they had they said thus withal unto him as bewailing their condition Behold we are Servants this day in the Land which thou gavest our Fathers it yieldeth much fruit unto the Kings whom thou hast set over us because of our sins and they have dominion over our Bodies and over our Cattel at our pleasure and we are in great affliction The extraordinary favour which was shewed to any was principally extended toward the Priests over whom the said Kings had not so jealous an eye as they had over the Princes and the rest of the People Howbeit the same notwithstanding they the said Priests were subject to their own immediate Princes both in Temporal and Ecclesiastical Causes as formerly the Priests had been to the Kings of Judah before the Captivity Their Governours forbad certain who said they were Priests from eating of the most holy things Nehemiah ministred an Oath unto the Priests he reform'd the abuses of the Sabbath and prescrib'd Orders for the better observing thereof He appointed certain of the Priests to oversee the Tithes in the Treasury He commanded the Levites to cleanse themselves and to keep the Gates and to sanctifie the Sabbath Eliasib the High-Priest having defiled the Temple by letting Tobias a Stranger a Chamber in the Court of the House of God where in afore times the Offerings the Incense the Vessels and such other things used in God's Service had been kept Nehemiah the Governour was greatly offended with it and displacing the said Tobias cast forth all his stuff out
others brought a great detriment for want of Ability unto them for one of the said Captains having gotten to himself a very strong Kingdom in Syria and another of them in Egypt the Jews dweling betwixt them both were miserably on every side vexed by them Sometimes the Egyptians by Oppression and Force brought them under their Subjection and imposed great Tributes upon them and sometimes the Syrians growing mightier than the Egyptians did likewise very greatly afflict them especially in the Reign of Antiochus Epiphanes whose Invasion and Government was most unjust and Tyrannical He shed innocent Blood on every side of the Sanctuary spoiled the Temple erecting in it the Abomination of the Gentiles and caused it to be named the Temple of Jupiter Olympius The Books of the Law by his Commandment were cut in pieces and burnt and they with whom they were found were put to death A general Commandment was by him published that they should offer no more Sacrifices nor circumcise their Children nor execute any other parts of their own Law in the Service of God but wholly to conform themselves therein to the manner of the Gentiles Whereupon the People by heaps forsook the Lord and offered Sacrifices to Idols and such as refused so to do chusing rather to obey God than Man were most cruelly slain and murthered by thousands until Mattathias moved with the monstrous Cruelty and Tyranny of the said Antiochus made open Resistance the Government of that Tyrant being not then either generally received by submission or setled by continuance It is not pertinent to our purpose to intermeddle with sundry Questions which might here arise Only we observe that Mattathias undertook that charge that he commended the same afterwards to his Sons and that it continued in them and their Posterity until both they and their whole Countrey were vanquished by the Romans CAN. XXXI IF any Man therefore shall affirm either that the Jews generally both Priests and People were not the Subjects of Alexander after his Authority was setled amongst them as they had been before the Subjects of the Kings of Babylon and Persia or that they might lawfully have born Arms against him or that they were not all bound to pray for the long life and prosperity both of Alexander and his Empire as they had been bound before to pray for the life and prosperity of the other said Kings and their Kingdoms whilst they lived under their subjection or consequently that they might lawfully upon any occasion whatsoever have offered violence and destruction either to their Persons or to their Kingdoms for the long continuance and prosperity whereof they were bound to pray or that after the Jews were delivered from their servitude under the Kings of Syria and the Government over them was settled in Mattathias's Posterity it was lawful for the People upon any occasion to have rebelled against them or to have offered violence to their persons He doth greatly Erre Placet eis CAP. XXXII THE afflictions which the Jews endured whilst the Government of the Grecians lasted were much the more grievous unto them by reason of the great disorders which were then amongst their Priests For whereas they should have been a stay and a comfort unto them in their greater miseries their negligence one way and their ambition another way in striving about the High Priesthood did so distract them into parts taking as that thereby great effusion of blood did oftentimes ensue shortly after Jaddus's time this was the general report which for their Wickedness was given out of them The Priests were now no more diligent about the Altar but despised the Temple and regarded not the Sacrifices They did not set by the honour of their Fathers but liked of the glory of the Gentiles most of all The Temple was full of dissoluteness and gluttony of the Gentiles which dallied with Harlots and had to do with Women within the circuit of holy places and brought in such things as were not lawful The Altar also was full of such things as were abominable and forbidden by the Law and two or three of the High Priests applauded thereunto Simon the High-Priest leaving three Sons behind him Onias Jason and Menelaus was not long dead but Jason for three hundred and sixty Talents of Silver procured such assistance of Antiochus King of Syria as he thrust his elder Brother Onias out of the High-Priesthood and not long after had the same measure repay'd unto him again by his younger Brother Menelaus who upon some cunning information and for six hundred and sixty Talents got the place himself Whereupon Jason assembled Forces drove Menelaus into a Castle slew the Citizens without Mercy and in the end being repulsed died abroad as an exile Menelaus afterward caused his Eldest Brother Onias to be Murder'd because he blamed him for stealing certain Vessels of Gold out of the Temple Next Menelaus succeeded Alcimus whereas Onias the Son of Onias before-mentioned should in right have had that dignity Of all which four Persons eminent in their time these things are left for Records unto Posterity Jason to get Antiochus's good will for the High-Priesthood promised him besides his great Bribe to set up a School of Gentilism likewise to build a Brothel-House by the Temple and that the People of Hierusalem should be named Antiochians after the Kings Name He drew his Kinsmen to the Custom of the Gentiles and sent to Tyrus three hundred Drachms of Silver for a Sacrifice to Hercules Menelaus also took the like course or rather a worse for besides that he conform'd himself wholly in effect to the manners of the Grecians it is further thus written of him Antiochus went into the most holy Temple having Menelaus that Traytor to the Laws and to his own Country to be his Guide He thrust himself into the Kings Army against Judas Maccabaeus and the City of Hierusalem hoping thereupon to have attain'd that Government But Lysias the King's Lieutenant crossed his purpose therein and inform'd the King that he the said Menelaus had been the cause of all the mischiefs which had ensued the Wars with the Jews as being the Man who perswaded his Father Antiochus Epiphanes to compel them to forsake the Laws of their Fathers adding thereunto that whilst Menelaus lived the Jews would never be quiet Whereupon the King commanding him to be put to Death he was smother'd in Ashes because he had committed many sins by the Altar whose fire and ashes were holy Alcimus the High-Priest next succeeding was no sooner in his place but he took upon him to be the Captain of all the ungodly Men of Israel and solicited King Demetrius to make War against Judas Maccabaeus complaining that he had killed all the King's Friends The King thus instigated sent an Army against Hierusalem with one Bacchides and Alcimus who pretending that they came in Peace and being thereupon trusted
to Gregory the Seventh's days also a huge Heap of the Pope's Bulls from the said Gregory's time to Pius Quintus and lastly no short summ of Papal Constitutions set forth a little before the said 7th Book of the Decretals So as all these Volumes being put together they exceed as far the Body of the Civil Law as the usurped Dignity of the Papacy exceedeth the mean Estate of the Empire Placet eis John Overall CAP. XII WE have in the former Chapter made mention of the new and later sort of Decretals Bulls and Constitutions not knowing what Credit the Popes will bestow upon them hereafter and therefore leaving them to their Chance we have thought it expedient to return to the ancient Canon-Law revived and approved not long since by Gregory the Thirteenth where we find a new Ocean of Questions Disputations Quarrels and Brabblements For as it happen'd with the Civil-Law that it no sooner was again renew'd and restor'd by Lotharius but sundry great Doctors began to write many Books and Commentaries upon it to explain it and to discuss the Difficulties which did arise in it So fell it out with the Canon-Law the number being almost infinite of Glossographers that made short Notes upon it and of Canonists who set forth large Discourses for the salving of Contradictions and many other Absurdities Amongst all which Lawyers Doctors Glossographers and Canonists assisted as every Man's Fancy led him with many Schoolmen and sundry Divines such as they were there did shortly after grow many great Controversies and endless Oppositions The Civilians of Italy perceiving by the body of the Civil Law how far the Empire was dejected from that Royal Estate and Majesty which once it enjoyed and finding also that many of the best Reasons in their Judgments which the Popes the Canon-Law the Glossographers the Canonists the Schoolmen and many more had brought to prove that the Pope ought to have Jurisdiction over all the Churches in the World as that Bees had a Captain that Beasts a Leader that One is fit to end Controversies that a Monarchy is the best Form of Government and that One must he over All to receive Appeals to give Direction unto All to punish all rebellious persons and many such like were fully as forcible and strong to prove that there ought to be one Emperour over all the World they did very stifly and resolutely insist upon that Point and went so roundly to work in it by force of the said Reasons and with many other Arguments that some of them would needs have it Heresie for any man to hold the contrary alledging a Text for their purpose where it is said That in those days there came a Commandment from Augustus Caesar that all the World should be taxed Against those Italian Civilians Vltramontane the Civilians on this side the Alpes Frenchmen Spaniards and of other Countries opposed themselves with all their force not in any dislike of the Honour due to the Emperours but because otherwise their Masters the Kings of France of Spain and of divers other Kingdoms who had freed themselves long before from the Empire should be brought again de jure at the least by the foresaid Reasons to be subject unto it Whereupon in Confutation of them and to strengthen their own Assertion they alledged that one Bee was never the Captain over all Bees nor one Crane the General of all Cranes nor one Beast the Leader of all Beasts that it was against the Law of God the Law of Nature and the Law of Nations that there was never any Monarchs so great but there were in the World many Kings who were never subject unto them that the place of Scripture is to be understood of all places in the World that were then under the Romans and ought to be extended no further That a Monarchy is then best when it is contain'd within such limits as it may well be govern'd that all Monarchies hitherto had ever their bounds which were well known That it is impossible for all men to fetch Justice from one place or to receive thence any benefit by their Appeals and so after many other such Arguments they do conclude that to think that the Emperour ought to have the Government of all the World is a vain an absurd and an untrue conceit Now we are to consider how in all these troubled Disputations and Oppositions the Glossographers Canonists School-men and Parasitical Divines that were sworn to the Pope behaved themselves As soon as the Civil Law began to flourish as being read by the Emperour's Commandment in sundry Universities Gregory the Ninth began to smell what was like to come of it and therefore did afterward forbid it to be read in Paris being the especial Place then as it seemeth where it was most esteemed But as touching the Point so controverted when these Champions of the Popes saw how the Matter went That either they must hold that there ought to be but one Emperour over all the Kingdoms in the World or else be forced to confess that there ought not to be One Pope over all the Churches in the World the same Reason being as pregnant for the one as for the other they joyned with the Italian Civilians that there ought to be but one Emperour Marry how Forsooth remembring Gregory the Seventh Adrian the Fourth Innocentius the Third and that great Augustus Caesar Boniface the Eighth and divers other Popes how Emperour-like they had demeaned themselves and what great Authority they challenged the said Pontifical Champions fell to this Issue That the Pope being Christ's Vicar who was Lord of lords and King of kings it must needs follow that the Pope was likewise that One Emperour who was to govern all the World in Temporal Causes as he did all the Churches in the World in Ecclesiastical Causes And thereupon they reasoned in this sort Christ is Lord of all the World but the Pope is Christ's Vicar on Earth therefore the Pope is Lord of all the World Again The Emperour is the Pope's Vicar and his Successour in all Temporal Causes therefore the Emperour is Lord of all the World all Temporal Jurisdiction being habitually in the Pope and from him derived to the Emperour And many of the Italian Lawyers especially such as mixed their Studies with the Canon-Law were well enough content that so as the Emperour might be Lord of all how and whence he had it whether from God or from the Pope they stood indifferent But for all this the French and Spanish Lawyers stuck to their tackling and were peremptory That neither the Pope nor the Emperour had any such Universal Dominion over all the World And divers likewise of the said Italian Doctours that were not too much addicted to the Canon-Law were not afraid to hold and maintain That the Emperour held as well from God the Authority which he had as the Pope did his Papacy Howbeit such was the
by the Maccabees themselves because he was a Priest of the Seed of Aaron did traiterously notwithstanding and treacherously Murder sundry of the Jews and held the Government of that Country till Judas Maccabaeus put him to flight Howbeit accusing the Maccabees again of wicked things he urged afterward the said King to send a new Army against them and was himself as it seemeth in the Host when Judas Maccabaeus was slain Besides it is also reported of him how he commanded that the Walls of the Inner-Court of the Sanctuary should be destroy'd and how he pulled down the Monuments of the Prophets and how in that his so wicked and profane an attempt he was stricken with the Palsey and died with great torment Now concerning Onias who if he had been of lawful Age and might have had his right ought to have been High-Priest before both his Uncles Jason and Menelaus when he perceiv'd that Alcimus had gotten that place and saw no probability how he might get it from him he fled into Egypt and there procured a Temple to be built like unto that in Hierusalem whereof he was made the principal Ruler So greedy was he of the High-Priesthood that seeing he might not be High-Priest in Hierusalem he would needs be a High-Priest in Egypt against God's Command But perhaps the High-Priesthood amongst the Jews was better bestow'd afterwards Indeed now it came into the hands of the Maccabees but how they used it there is little mention It is probable that being so distracted as they were and so continually in a manner vexed with Wars they had no time to execute that office in such sort as otherwise divers of them no doubt would have done But it cannot be denied that some of that rank were greatly puffed up with that Authority and did thereby much forget themselves and the holy Duties appertaining to the High-Priesthood Else would not Aristobulus have so unnaturally famished his own Mother nor have suffer'd the cruel Murther of his Innocent Brother Antigonus nor would Alexander succeeding Aristobulus have committed the like Murther upon his younger Brother nor would afterward the two Sons of the said Alexander viz. Hircanus and Aristobulus have grown through their ambitious desires to such mortal hatred For Aristobulus thrusting his eldest Brother Hircanus from the High Priesthood and he the said Hircanus continuing still his claim they never ceased their Hostility till Pompey having subdued them both brought both them and the whole Country under the subjection of the Romans We omit what great sums of money they bestowed on either side to procure Pompey's favour to whom they had committed the deciding of their Causes and also how Hircanus assisted Pompey in his attempt against Hierusalem partly in hope thereby to get the High Priesthood and partly in malice against his Brother who as long as he could defended that City the Issue of all which strife was this Pompey subdued the City slew twelve thousand Men Aristobulus is put from the High Priesthood the civil Government is separated again from the High-Priesthood the High Priesthood is bestowed upon Hircanus for his Service and the civil Government thenceforth translated to strangers the Temple was spoiled and Hierusalem was made Tributary to the People of Rome Of all which Calamities falling in this sort upon the Jews the dissention betwixt Hircanus and Aristobulus was held in those days to have been the cause to the great blemish of their credits professing themselves to be God's High-Priests Besides while Jason Menelaus Alcimus and the Maccabees were busied in their said Un-Priestly Contentions and Greekish profanations divers Sects of Religion arose and encreased among the Jews especially that of the Pharisees a crafty and an arrogant kind of Men seditiously bent against their Kings and impugners without fear of their Authority In which course they were the rather animated because they found through their Hypocrisy that Women were generally addicted to them and that the People did so admire them as they believed in effect whatsoever they told them against any although it were never so false or maliciously devised by them And thus Religion went in those days when the Priests had gotten the Reins into their own hands although we doubt not but that there were some few notwithstanding both of the Priests and of the People who disliking of all their said hypocritical ambitious profane and wicked Practices cover'd sometimes with a pretence of Zeal and sometimes with the glorious name of the High Priesthood did truly from their hearts both fear and serve the Lord. CAN. XXXII IF any Man therefore because in the Law of God there was great obedience to the High-Priest prescribed and required or that it is said by the Prophet That the Priests Lips should preserve knowledge and that the People should seek the law of his mouth whereas the meaning of the Holy Ghost in those and such like places only is that the High-Priests were to be obeyed when they commanded that which was not repugnant to the law of God and that the Lips of the Priests ought to preserve knowledge shall affirm either that it was not wickedly done by their Priests to thrust the People into many imminent dangers for the maintenance of their lewd quarrels and factions or that they did not grievously offend God when they forsook his true worship and brought heathenish and profane Sacrifices into his Temple or that the People were bound to obey when they requir'd them to conform themselves to the Idolatrous worship of the Heathen or that it was lawful for any of the said High-Priests by injury bribery or cruelty to seek the High Priesthood or that the Priests and People that joined with them did not wickedly who assisted Pompey to invade Hierusalem and to bring their own Countrey in Bondage to the Romans or that any such Pharisaical Sects never ordained by God were lawfully then permitted to seduce the simpler sort of the People leading them into Factions and Dislike of their Superiours He doth greatly Erre Placet eis CAP. XXXIII THE Jews being subdued by the Romans and brought under their subjection about sixty years before the coming of Christ were used by them very kindly and with great respect They had liberty granted them to live according to their own Laws so as they paid their Tributes and framed their Behaviour to Quietness and Obedience Hircanus the High-Priest placed by Pompey lived long after in great Authority But nothing would satisfie them till in the end it came to pass that as the Ambition and Strife betwixt Hircanus and Aristobulus brought Pompey upon them so now their own Wickedness and rebellious Hearts were the cause of their greater Servitude Afflictions and Miseries The remnant of the Maccabees Aristobulus and his two Sons Alexander and Antigonus would never desist from their rebellious Attempts until they were all cut off Antipater the first Governour or Procurator appointed
with Rods. I was once stoned I suffered thrice Shipwrack Night and day have I been in the deep Sea In Journying I was often in perils of Water in perils of Robbers in perils of mine own Nation in perils amongst the Gentiles in perils in the Wilderness in perils in the Sea in perils amongst false Brethren In weariness and painfulness in watching often in hunger and thirst in fastings often in cold and nakedness Besides these things which are outward I am cumber'd daily and have the care of all the Churches Much is not written of St. Peter by the Evangelist St. Luke but it is not to be doubted that his Case was as bad as any of his Fellows When he began to Preach he was call'd in question with great eagerness and vehemently threatned Also with some other of the Apostles he was cast into Prison and beaten Likewise when James was killed by Herod's Commandment Peter was again Imprisoned and loaden with Irons and had assuredly in all likelyhood escaped hardly with his Life but that the Angel of the Lord delivered him In a word after many Afflictions Injuries Calamities and Miseries endured by the Apostles whilst they lived in this World they were in the end as well St. Peter as almost all the rest most spitefully and cruelly by the Enemies of Christ and of their own Salvation put to Death During the course of whose lives in so great dangers and manifold distresses out of question they would greatly have marvelled their hard Estates consider'd but especially St. Peter if he had known himself to be the sole Monarch under Christ over all the World and that the Emperour and all other Kings had been at that time his Vassals and that likewise they the rest of the Apostles had been under St. Peter so many Soveraign and Temporal Princes to have commanded and ruled amongst them throughout the whole World Neither do we see any true cause that might have moved St. Peter to have concealed that his so eminent temporal Power and Authority if he had thought it to have been the Ordinance of God or at least if he for modesty would have been silent why the rest of the Apostles should not have published it that the civil and temporal States in those times who knew no such Ordination made by Christ might have been left inexcusable Besides the concealing of a truth of so great importance was an injury offered to all the faithful in those days who had they been truly taught in these Mens conceits ought to have left their Obedience to the Emperour in all temporal Causes and for the dignity of the Gospel to have adher'd unto St. Peter to have been directed in them by him their temporal Monarch The consideration of all which inconveniences and consequents doth perswade us to think that none of the Apostles ever dreamed of any such temporal Soveraignty notwithstanding that they knew well the Scriptures how Christ told them That All Power in Heaven and Earth was given unto him how St. Peter had two Swords and how Ananias and Sapphira for lying to the Holy Ghost were stricken suddenly from Heaven with Death Touching the two first of which places the same being notoriously abused and wrested by the Canonists and their Adherents to prove the Popes temporal Monarchy the said Cardinal doth very resolutely reject the Arguments which are thence by them deduced And to the first he answereth Potestatem de quâ hic loquitur Dominus non esse potestatem temporalem ut Regnum terrenorum sed vel tantùm spiritualem ut B. Hieronymus B. Anselmus exponunt qui hunc esse volunt sensum eorum verborum Data est mihi omnis potestas in coelo in terrâ i.e. ut sicut in coelo Rex sum Angelorum ità per fidem regnem in cordibus hominum vel ut addit Theophylactus esse potestatem quandam summam in omnes creaturas non temporalem sed divinam vel divinae simillimam quae non potest communicari homini mortali That the Power whereof the Lord here speaketh is not a temporal Power like the Power of terrene Kings but it is either a spiritual Power as St. Hierom and St. Anselm do expound the said place who will have this to be the sense of those words All Power is given me in Heaven and Earth which is to say that as in Heaven I am King of Angels so by Faith I do reign in the hearts of Men or as Theophylact addeth it is a certain supream Power not temporal but divine or most like to the Divine Power which cannot be communicated to any mortal Man And for the second Argument drawn from St. Peter 's two Swords the same is set down by our said Cardinal in these words Secundò objiciunt Scripturam Luc. 22. Vbi Dominus duos gladios Petro concedit Cùm enim Discipuli dicerent Ecce duo gladii hic Dominus non ait nimis est sed satis est Quare B. Bernardus 4. 4. de Consid Bonifacius octavus in Extravag Vnam sanctam de Majoritate Obedientiâ ex hoc loco deducunt Pontisicem duos gladios ex Christi institutione habere that is Secondly they object the Scriptures Luc. 22. Where the Lord doth grant two Swords to Peter For when the Disciples said Behold here are two Swords the Lord answered not they are too many but they are sufficient Therefore St. Bernard and Boniface the eighth do hence deduce that the Bishop of Rome by Christ's Institution hath two Swords Unto which objection our Cardinal saith thus Respondeo ad Literam nullam fieri mentionem in eo loco Evangelii de gladio spirituali vel temporali Pontificis sed solum Dominum illis verbis monere voluisse Discipulos tempore Passionis suae in iis angustiis metu ipsos futuros fuisse in quibus esse solent qui tunicam vendunt ut emant gladium ut ex Theophylacto aliisque Patribus colligitur I answer that according to the Letter there is no mention made in that place of the Gospel either of the spiritual or temporal Sword of the Bishop of Rome but that Christ meant only in those words to admonish his Disciples how they should be in the time of his Passion in those straights and fear wherein Men are accustomed to be who sell their Coat to buy them a Sword as it is to be collected out of Theophylact and other Fathers And for Bernard and Boniface he saith They did expound the said place mystically and meant not to have their words so far extended as the Objector would have them Which answer it is likely Bernard if he were now alive would take in good part but assuredly if any Cardinal in Bonifacius 's days had made it he would have smarted for it and might perhaps have tried the depth of Tiber. Neither do we suppose that the now Pope will give him any great thanks for it nor
of our mind that he will omit how the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven were given to St. Peter and so to the Roman Bishops his Successors and not to the Bishops of Constantinople and we likewise following his Example as a thing impertinent to our purpose will here omit the same Only we do observe that the contention betwixt the Bishop of Rome and the Bishop of Constantinople was de Primatu and that the Bishop of Rome obtain'd that place by Phocas his means which the Bishop of Constantinople did challenge to himself Whereupon we offer to Mens Considerations these two Arguments Whosoever taketh upon him that Primacy or place in the Church which John Bishop of Constantinople did challenge to himself is the forerunner of Antichrist but the Bishops of Rome do take upon them that Primacy and place Ergo. Again Those Priests which do adhere unto him that taketh upon him that place and Primacy which John the Bishop of Constantinople did challenge to himself are an Host prepared for the King of Pride but all the Priests that do adhere to the Bishop of Rome do adhere unto him that taketh upon him that Primacy and place which John the Bishop of Constantinople did challenge to himself Ergo. But our purpose is not to dispute only this we add that till this time that the Bishop of Rome had prevailed so far with Phocas as is aforementioned his Predecessors notwithstanding their great Authority after Constantine's Reign and favour with the Emperours succeeding they behaved themselves dutifully toward them and acknowledged them to be their Lords and Masters But afterward in short time they left those Phrases and began to call the Emperours their Sons To which alteration a very worthy Man taking exception he is answered by another of many good parts it must be confessed after this sort St. Gregory might call Mauricius his Lord either of Courtesie or of Custom and yet our holy Father Pius the Fourth shall not be bound to do the like in consideration that the Custom hath long since been discontinued Placet eis Jo. Overall CAP. V. ALthough when the Bishops of Rome after much opposition had obtain'd their desires for their Primacy beforementioned they might well enough as we suppose have been contented Yet forasmuch as still they remain'd in greater subjection to the Emperours than they thought was agreeable with their greatness their aspiring mind rested not there but began shortly after to cast about how they might in their places be independent and absolute For the compassing whereof they took hold of every occasion that might serve or be wrested and drawn to that purpose At the first receiving of the Gospel Men are ever for the most part very zealous and great Favourers of the Ministry In the Apostles times they sold their lands and possessions and laid the price of them at the Apostles feet St. Paul was received by the Galatians as an Angel of God yea as Jesus Christ and such was their love toward him that to have done him good they would have plucked out their Eyes and given them unto him When the Emperours of Rome became Christians they did exceed in this behalf especially towards the Bishops of that See bestowing upon them very great riches and ample possessions Of all which zealous Dispositions benefits and favours they ever made above all other Bishops their greatest advantage by imploying the same to the advancement of their greatness Wherein they were furthermore very much helped and further'd by the Authority which the Emperours gave unto them in temporal Causes holding them for their Gravity Learning and Discretion very meet and sit Persons in their own absence from Rome to do them that way very great service Besides if we shall deal sincerely and truly as we hold our selves always bound and more strictly in a cause of this Importance we must needs confess that it hath been the manner of Divines from the Apostles times almost to magnify and extol the worthiness and excellency of their own calling which was a very commendable and necessary course in many the ordinary contempt of the Ministry consider'd and had been so in all of them if they had not therewith depressed too much the Dignity and preheminence of Kings and Princes Comparisons in such Cases were ever worthily held to be odious Bishops and Priests might without any just reprehension have been resembled to Gold to the Sun and to what else is excellent without comparing the highest Magistrates under God in respect of themselves to the Moon to Lead and to some other things of such like base Estimation And we doubt not but that they would have refrain'd from such Comparisons if they could have foreseen how the Bishops of Rome would to the disgrace and dishonour of civil Authority have wrested and perverted them notwithstanding that their Inferences thereupon have ever had more shew and probability than substance and truth except we shall say that the Callings of Schoolmasters and Physicians are in Dignity to be preferr'd before all other Temporal Callings because the end of the one is the instructing of Mens understandings and of the other Health which either are or ought to be both of them in their kinds of greater Estimation than any other things whatsoever We shall not need to trouble our selves with the citing of any Authorities to prove how eagerly the Bishops of Rome especially after Boniface the Third had obtained of Phocas the said Supremacy have pressed the same Comparisons It is so evident both in their own Writings and likewise generally in all their Treatises who from time to time have laboured with all their force and might to advance above all other Authority upon Earth the Soveraignty of that See Placet eis John Overall CAP. VI. ALbeit the former occasions as they were handled and particularly the device last before specified wrought very much in the hearts of the simpler sort to the debasing of the Imperial and Regal Authority in respect of the Spiritual and that it was therefore prosecuted and amplified with all the skill and rhetorick that could be Yet there was another matter which troubled the Bishops of Rome exceedingly and never gave them rest until they had prevailed in it as if without it they had gained little by their Primacy It seemeth that Constantine the Great when he left Rome notwithstanding his especial benefits and favours to the Bishops of that See did in his wisdom think it fit that none should be advanced to that Bishoprick without the Emperour's consent For the better manifestation whereof it is to be observed that whilst the Bishops of Rome were labouring so earnestly for their Supremacy till Phocas's time the City of Rome had been four times surprised by divers barbarous Nations An. 413. by Alaricus the second King of the Goths Innocentius the First being then Bishop An. 457. by Gensericus the Leader of the Vandalls Leo the First being then Bishop An.
Noluit enim c. For he would not endure it as One saith that his Consent should be required in the Election of the Bishop of Rome nor that the Emperour according to his will should have the bestowing of the Bishopricks that were included within the limits of the Empire Surely it might have pleased him to have endur'd both the one and the other as sundry Popes his Equals had done before him And howsoever this Attempt of Gregory is eagerly maintain'd in these days and held to be Apostolical yet then it seem'd very strange to many Therefore an ancient Historiographer writeth in this sort Lego relego Romanorum Regum Imperatorum Gesta c. I read over and over again the Acts of the Roman Kings and Emperours but can find in no place that any of them before Henry the Fourth was excommunicated by the Bishop of Rome or deprived of his Kingdom And again the Empire was the more vehemently moved with Indignation through the Novelty of this Attempt because such a Sentence against the Emperour of Rome was never heard of before those times And another more ancient than the former and almost of 500. Years standing doth not only term the said Fact of the Pope a Novelty but saith in Effect that it was an Heresy These are his words Surely this Novelty I will not call it Heresy was never before heard of in the World viz. That Priests should teach the People that they owe no Subjection unto Evil Kings and that notwithstanding they have taken an Oath of Fidelity unto them yet they owe them no Fidelity nor are to be acounted perjur'd that violate the said Oath Nay that if any obey their King in that Case he shall be held for an excommunicate Person and he that attempteth any thing against such a King shall be absolved both from the Offence of Injustice and of Perjury To this Heretical Novelty and most insolent Attempt which since hath had many false Colours cast over it to cover the Lewdness and Deformity of it we might add the said Pope's very admirable Pride in permitting the said Emperour when he came unto him to be absolved from the said Excommunication to stand bare-footed in the Frost and Snow Three days at his Gates But that which ensued this Novelty or Heresie this Unpriestly and Inhumane dealing with so great a Person is most remarkable above all the rest viz. How he wound himself like a cunning Serpent into the Interest of the Empire and upon a sleight Occasion The said Rebels of Germany in their Fury against the Emperour having suggested unto him That the Empire was a Benefit belonging to the City of Rome to be bestowed where she thought fit although they added therewith that the same was to be done by the Bishop and by the People of Rome with the Consent of other Princes Yet he finding what would serve his turn and was most available to his own Designment did afterward of himself and by his own Authority take upon him to dispose of the Empire as being void by Virtue of a second Excommunication and did accordingly send a Crown of Gold to Rodulphus Duke of Suevia now also grown a Traytour with this Inscription Petra dedit Petro Petrus Diadema Rodulpho Christ gave St. Peter Authority to make Emperours and I his Successor do thereupon send you this Crown and by my Authority from St. Peter do give you the Empire It is plain and evident that many Emperours in former Ages bestowed the Papacy and sometimes took it from one and gave it to another but that ever Pope there before this Man did so dispose of the Empire we do not find it in any approved Author Neither can we conceive or easily believe that Christ ever gave St. Peter any such Authority as is here dreamed of Only we observe by the Report of One no Protestant That Gregory to justifie and colour his said Presumption bragged above measure that the West Empire was his that he was both Bishop and Emperour Christ having imposed upon him those two Persons that he had no Equal and much less any Superiour that he might take all Right and Honour from other Men and transfer the same unto himself and do much more than here we will mention But touching any Proof for all these great Prerogatives we find none Except this will serve his turn That St. Peter received power to bind and loose which we hold insufficient notwithstanding that the Papists now-a-days do allow them all and admire him for it It hath been a usual Custom for the Pope's Friends to extol those Bishops of Rome most who shewed themselves whilst they lived the greatest Practitioners and Traytors against the Emperours Agreeably whereunto One saith of him That he was a Man worthy of the Pontificalship because he depressed the Insolency of Politicks terrified Monarchs with the Glory of his Name and Zeal and delivered the Church from the Captivity and Servitude which it endured under Princes and that of all the Bishops of Rome he was One of chief Zeal and Authority and a Man verè Apostolicus truly Apostolical and most to be praised Proceres Populum sacramento praestito sanctè solvit ut Rodolpho adhaereant sanctius imperat he did godly absolve the Noblemen and People from their Oath of Allegiance to the Emperour and did more holily command them not to obey him What was thought long since of these so Godly and Holy Practices we have above touched and we must also of necessity confess that to be true which this Authour and his Fellows do write of Gregory's Greatness For it is further recorded of him that he did first erect Imperium Pontificium the Papal Empire But touching his Vertues if an ancient Cardinal that wrote his Life did know him there is no cause why any Man should be in love with them And as concerning this new and before unheard of Pontifical Empire if we may believe another of their own Authors it brought with it into the West Empire Wars Bloodshed Homicide Parricide Hatred Whoredome Theft Sacriledge Dissention and Sedition both Civil and Domestical Corruption of the Scriptures false and sycophantical Interpretations with many more Mischiefs there by him mentioned and yet saith he Gregory's Successours did uphold it by the space of 450. Years invito Mundo invitis Imperatoribus in spite of the World and of the Emperours and thereby drew both Heaven and Hell into their Subjecti on and Servitude Again In former times God as a most indulgent Father did often chastise the Western Christians by Saxons Hunns Normans Venetians Lombards and Hungarians Men differing from us in Religion but now as if God were become an angry Father towards us and we were neglected and dis-inherited by him we have for above 400. Years tyranniz'd amongst our selves worse than Turks We deceive we circumvent we kill we turn our