Linguistic DNA - Concept Modelling Demonstrator

Word A	Word B	Word C	Word D	Occurrence	Frequency Band	MI	MI Band	Prominent
cause_n	great_a	king_n	law_n	4,029	5	4.5431	4	true

ID	Title	Author	Corrected Date of Publication (TCP Date of Publication)	STC	Words	Pages
A05353	A treatise concerning the defence of the honour of the right high, mightie and noble Princesse, Marie Queene of Scotland, and Douager of France with a declaration, as wel of her right, title, and interest, to the succession of the croune of England: as that the regiment of women is conformable to the lawe of God and nature. Made by Morgan Philippes, Bachelar of Diuinitie, An. 1570.; Defence of the honour of the right highe, mightye and noble Princesse Marie Quene of Scotlande and dowager of France	Leslie, John, 1527-1596.	1571 (1571)	STC 15506; ESTC S106704	132,510	314

good reason and lawe to stande at defence and onely to auoide as easely we may their obiections which principally and chiefly are grounded vpon the common lawes and Statutes of this Realme yet for the bettering and strengthening of the same we shal lay forth sundrie great and inuincible reasons coÌ„ioyned with good and sufficient authoritie of the law so approued and confirmed that the Aduersaries shal neuer be able iustly to impugne them And so that we trust after the reading of this Treatise and the effectes of the same wel digested no maner of scruple ought to remaine in any indifferent mans hart concerning her right and Title Whose expectation and conscience allthough we truste fully in this Discourse to satisfie and doubt nothing in the worlde of the righteousnes of our cause yet must we nedes confesse the manner and forme to entreate therof to be ful of difficultie and perplexity For such causes of Princes as they be seldome and rare so is it more rare and strange to finde them discoursed discussed and determined by any lawe or statute albe it nowe and then some statutes tende that waye Neither do our lawes nor the Corps of the Romaine and Ciuil law lightly meddle with the princelie gouernement but with priuate mens causes And yet this notwithstanding for the better iustification of our cause albe it I denie not but that by the coÌ„mon law it muste be knoweÌ„ who ought to haue the Croune and that the common lawe muste discerne the right aswel of the Croune as of subiectes yet I saye that there is a greate difference betwene the Kings right and the right of others And that the Title of the Croune of this Realme is not subiect to the rules and principles of the common lawe of this Realme as to be ruled and tryed after such order and course as the inheritance of priuate persons is by the same For the prous whereof let vs consider what the common lawe of this Realme is and how the rules thereof be grounded and do take place It is very manifeste and plaine that the common lawe of this Realme of England is no law writteÌ„ but grounded only vpon a common and generall custome throughout the whole realme as appeareth by the Treatise of the auncient and famous Writer of the lawes of the realme named Ranulphus de Glanuilla who wrote in the time of the noble King Henrie the second of the law and Custome of the realme of England being then and also in the time of the raigne of King Richarde the firste the chiefe Counsailour and Iustice of the same King and also by the famouse Iustice Fortescue in his booke whiche he wrote being Chauncellour of England De laudibus Legum Angltae And by 33. H. 6.51 and by E. 4.19 Whiche Custome by vsage and continuall practise heretofore had in the Kinges Courts within this Realme is only knowen and mainteined wherein we seeme much agreable to the olde Lacedemonians who many hundred yeres past most politikely and famously gouerned their common Wealth with lawe vnwritten whereas among the Athenians the writen lawes bare al the sway This thing being so true that with any reason or good authoritie it can not be denied then we are farther to consider whether the Kinges Title to the Croune can be examined tried and ordered by this common Custome or no. Yf ye say it may then must ye proue by some recorde that it hath bene so vsed otherwise ye only say it and nothing at all proue it For nothing can be said by lawe to be subiecte to any custome vnlesse the same hath ben vsed accordingly and by force of the same custom I am wel assured that you are not able to proue the vsage and practise thereof by any record in any of the Kings courts Yea I wil farther say vnto you and also proue it that there is no one rule general or special of the common lawe of this Realme which ye â—â—ther haue shewed or can shewe that ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ bene taken by any iuste construction to ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ tende vnto or bind the King or his Crouâ—â—â— I wil not denie but that to declare and see forth the prerogatiue and IurisdictioÌ„ of the King ye may shewe many rules of the lawe but to binde him as I haue sayde ye can shewe none Ye say in your booke that it is a Maxime in our lawe most manifest that who so euer is borne out of England and of father and mother not being of the obedience of the King of England can not be capable to inherite any thing in England Whiche rule being general without any wordes of exception ye also say must nedes extende vnto the Croune What you meane by your law I knowe not But if you meane as I thinke you do the common lawe of England I answere there is no such Maxime in the common lawe of this Realme of Englande as hereafter I shal manifestly proue But if it were for argumentes sake admitted for this time that it be a Maxime or general rule of the coÌ„mon law of England yet to say that it is so general as that no exception can be taken against the same rule ye shewe your selfe either ignorant or els very carelesse of your creditte For it doth plainely appeare by the Statute of 25. E. 3. being a declaration of that rule of the Lawe whiche I suppose ye meane terming it a Maxime that that rule extendeth not vnto the Kinges children Whereby it moste euidently appeareth that it extendeth not generally to al. And if it extende not to binde the Kinges children in respect of any inheritance descended vnto them from any of their Auncestours it is an Argument Ã fortiori that it doth not extende to binde the King or his Croune And for a ful and short answere to your Authorities sette foorth in your marginall Notes as 5. Ed ward 3. tit Ayle 13. Ed war. 3. tit Bref 31. Edw. 3. tit Coson 42. Ed war. 3. fol. 2. 22. Henric. 6. fol. 42.11 Henric. 4. fol. 23. 24. Litleton ca. vilenage it may plainly appeare vnto all that will reade and pervse those Bookes that there is none of them al that doth so much as with a peece of a word or by any colour or shadow seeme to intende that the Title of the Croune is bounde by that your supposed general rule or Maxime For euerie one of the said Cases argued and noted in the said Booke are onely concerning the dishabilitie of an Alien borne and not Denizon to demaunde any landes by the lawes of the Realme by suite and action onely as a subiect vnder the King and nothing touching any dishabilitie to be laied to the King himselfe or to his subiectes Is there any controuersie about the Title of the Croune by reason of any such dishabilitie touched in any of these Bookes No verely not one worlde I dare boldely say As it may most manifestly appeare to them that wil reade and pervse

the Title whiche the Kinges of England haue claimed vnto the Realme of Scotland is not in the possession of the lande and Croune of Scotlande but onely vnto the seruice of homage and fealtie for the same And although the Kinges of Scotland sith the time of King Henry the eight haue intermitted to doe the said homage and fealtie vnto the Kinges of Englande yet for al that the Kinges of Scotland can not by any reason or lawe be called vsurpers And thus may ye see gentle Reader by the opinion of al indifferente men not lead by affection that the Realme of Scotlande hath bene and is yet within the allegeance and dominion of England And so is the Antecedent or first proposition false And yet that maketh no proufe that the Realme of France likewise should nowe be said to be within the allegeance of the Kings of England by reason of the manifest and apparent difference before shewed But what if your Antecedent were true and that we did agree both with the said Queene of Scotland and her subiectes and also with you that Scotland were out of the allegeance of England Yet it is very plaine that your consequent and conclusion can not by any meanes be true And that principally for three causes whereof one is for that neither the King not the Croune not being specially meÌ„tioned in the said rule or pretended Maxime can be intended to be within the meaning of the same Maxime as we haue before sufficiently proued by a great number of other suche like generall rules and Maximes of the lawes An other cause is for that the Croune can not be taken to be within the woordes of the said supposed Maxime and that for twoo respectes one is bycause the rule doth only dishable Aliens to demaunde any heritage within the allegeance of England Whiche rule can not be stretched to the demaunde of the Croune of EnglaÌ„d which is not with in the allegeance of England but is the very allegeance it selfe As for a like example it is true that al the landes within the Kinges dominion are holdeÌ„ of the King either mediatly or immediately and yet it is not true that the Croune by whiche onely the King hath his Dominion can be said to be holdeÌ„ of the King. For without the Croune there can be neither King nor allegeance And so long as the Croune resteth onely in demaund not being vested in any person ther is no allegeaÌ„ce at al. So that the Croune can not be said by any meanes to be within the allegeance of England and therfore not within the wordes of the said rule or Maime The Title of the Croune is also out of the wordes and meaning of the same rule in an other respect and that is bycanse that rule doth only dishable an Alien to demauÌ„d landes by descent as heire For it doth not extende vnto landes purchased by an Alien as we haue before sufficiently proued And then can not that rule extende vnto the Croune being a thing incorporate the right wherof doth not descend according to the common course of priuate inheritance but goeth by successioÌ„ as other corporatioÌ„s do No man doubteth but that a Prior Alien being no denizon might alwaies in time of peace demaund land in the right of his corporatioÌ„ And so likewise a Deane or a Person being Aliens and no deniznos might demaund lande in respecte of their corporations not withstaÌ„ding the said supposed rule or Maxime as may appeare by diuerse booke cases as also by the statute made in the time of King Richard the second And although the Croune hath alwaies gone according to the common course of a Descent yet doth it not properly descende but succede And that is the reason of the lawe that although the Kinge be more fauoured in all his doinges then any common person shal be yet can not the King by lawe auoide his grauntes and Letters Patentes by reason of his Nonage as other infantes may doe but shal alwaies be said to be of ful age in respect of his Croune euen as a Person Vicare or Deane or any other person incorporate shal be Whiche can not by any meanes be said in lawe to be within age in respect of their corporations although the corporation be but one yeare olde Bysides that the King can not by the law auoide the Letters Patentes made by any vsurper of the Croune vnlesse it be by act of Parlament no more then other persons incorporate shal auoide the grauntes made by one that was before wrongfully in their places and romes whereas in Descentes of inheritance the lawe is otherwise For there the heire may auoide al estates made by the disseafour or abatour or any other person whose estate is by lawe defeated Whereby it doth plainely appeare that the King is incorporate vnto the Croune and hath the same properly by succession and not by Descent onely And that is likewise an other reason to proue that the King and the Croune can neither be saide to be within the wordes nor yet with in the meaning of the said general rule or Maxime The third and most prncipall cause of all is for that in the said statute whervpon the said supposed rule or Maxime is gathered the children descendantes and descended of the blood royal by the wordes of Infantes de Roy are expresly excepted out of the said supposed rule or Maxime Whiche wordes the Aduersaries do much abuse in restrainiÌ„g and construing them to extende but to the first degree only whereas the same wordes may very wel beare a more large and ample interpretation And that for three causes and considerations First by the Ciuil lawe this word Liberi which the worde Infantes being the vsuall and original worde of the statute written in the Frenche tongue counteruaileth doth comprehende by proper and peculier signification not only the childreÌ„ of the first degree but other Descendants also in the law saying That he who is manumissed or made free shal not commence any Action against the children of the Patrone or manumissour without licence not onely the first degree but the other also is conteined The like is when the lawe of the twelue Tables saith The first place and roome of succession after the death of the parentes that die intestate is due to the children which successioÌ„ apperteineth as wel to degrees remoued as to the firste Yea in al causes fauourable as ours is this worde son Filius coÌ„teineth the nephew though not by the propertie of the voice or speache yet by interpretation admittable in al such thinges as the law disposeth of As touching this worde Infantes in FreÌ„ch We say that it reacheth to other DescendaÌ„ts as wel as the first degree Wherein I do referre me to suche as be expert in the said tongue We haue no one worde for the barenes of our English toÌ„gue to couÌ„terpaise the said French word Infantes or the Latin word

likewise the statute made in Anno 32. H. 8. geueth auctoritie to dispose landes and Testamentes by last Wil and Testament in writing If a man do demise his lande by his last Wil and Testament nuncupatiue without writing this demise is insufcient in law and not warranted by the said statute We leaue of a number of like cases that we might multiplie in the prouffe of this matter wherein we haue taried the longer by cause th' Aduersaries make so great a couÌ„tenance therevpon and bycause al vnder one it may serue for the answere also touching the Kinges royal assente to be geuen to Parlamentes by his Letters Patentes signed with his hande which is nothing else but a declaration and affirmaÌ„ce of the common lawe and no newe authoritie geuen to him to do that he could not doo before or any forme prescribed to bind him vnto Bysides that in this case there is no feare in the worlde of forging and counterfeyting the Kinges hande whereas in the Testamentarie cause it is farre otherwise as the worlde knoweth and dayly experience teacheth And so withal do we conclude that by reason this surmised Wil was not signed with the Kinges hand it can not any way hurt or hinder the iuste right and claime of the Quene of Scotland to the succession of the Croune of England Now supposing that neither the L. Paget nor Sir Edward Montague and WilliaÌ„ Clarke had testified or published any thing to the infringing annd ouerthrowing of the Aduersaries assertioÌ„ touching the signing of the said Wil yet is not therby the Queene of Scotlandes title altogether hindred For she yet hath her iust and lawfull defence for the oppugning of the said assertion as well against the persons and saying of the witnesses if any shal come foorth as otherwise shee may iustly require the said Wil to be brought forth to light and especially the signing of the same with the Kings hand to be duely and consideratly pondered we yed and conferred She hath her iust defence and exceptions and must haue And it were against al lawes and the lawe of nature it selfe to spoile her of the same And all good reason geueth that the said original Wil standing vppon the triall of the Kinges hande be exhibited that it may be compared with his other certaine and wel knowen hand writing And that other things may be done requisite in this behalfe But yet all this notwithstanding let vs nowe imagine and suppose that the King him selfe whose harte and hande were doubtelesse farre from any suche doinges lette vs yet I say admitte that he had signed the said Will with his owne hande Yet for al that the Aduersaries perchance shal not finde no not in this case that the Queenes iuste Title right and interest doth any thing fayle or quayle Or rather lette vs without any perchance say the iustice and equitie of her cause and the inuincible force of trueth to be such that neither the Stampe nor the Kinges owne hande can beare and beate it downe Which thing we we speake not without good probable and weightie reasons Neither do we at this time minde to debate and discourse what power and autoritie and how farre the Parlament hath it in this and like cases Which perchance some other would here do We wil only intermedle with other thinges that reache not so farre nor so high and seeme in this our present question worthy and necessarie to be considered And first before we enter into other matters we aske this reasonable and necessarie questioÌ„ whether these general words wherby this large and ample autoritie is coÌ„ueied to king Henry must be as generally and as amply taken or be restrained by some maÌ„ner of limitation and restrictioÌ„ agreable to such mind and purpose of the Parlament as must of very necessitie or great likelihod be construed to be the very mind and purpose of the said ParlameÌ„t Ye wil say perchance that the power and autoritie of assignatioÌ„ must be taken generally and absolutely without exception sauing for the outward signing of the Will. Trueth it is there is nothing els expressed but yet was there some thing els principally intended and yet for al that needed not to be specified The outward maner was so specially and precisely appointed and specified to auoyde suspitious dealing to auoide corruption and forgery And yet was the Wil good and effectual without the Kinges hande Yea and the assignatioÌ„ to had ben good had not that restrainte of the Kinges hande bene added by the Parlament But for the qualification of the person to be limited and assigned and so for the necessarie restriction and limitation of the wordes were they neuer so large and ample there is though nothing were spoken thereof an ordinary helpe and remedie Otherwise if the Realme had ben set ouer to a furious or a madde man or to an idiote or to some foraine and Mahometical Prince and to such a one our stories testifie that King Iohn would haue submitted him selfe and his Realme or to any other notorious incapable or vnhable person the generalitie of the wordes seeme to beare it but the good minde and purpose of the Parlament and mans reason doe in no wise beare it If ye graunt that these wordes must nedes haue some good and honest constructioÌ„ and interpretation as reason doth force you to graunt it yet wil I aske farther whether as the King cutte of in this pretensed Wil the whole noble race of the eldest sister and the first issue of the yongest sister so if he had cutte of also al the ofspringes as wel of the said yongest sister as of the remnante of the royal blood and placed some being not of the said blood and perchance otherwise vnable this assignatioÌ„ had bene good and vailable in law as conformable to reason and to the mind and purpose of the Parlament It were surely to great an absurdity to grauÌ„t it There must be therefore in this matter some reasonable moderation and interpretatioÌ„ as wel touching the persons coÌ„preheÌ„ded within this assignation and their qualities and for the persons also hauing right and yet excluded as for the manner of the doing of the Acte and signing the Wil. For the king as King could not dispose the Croune by his Wil and was in this behalfe but an Arbiter and Commissioner Wherefore his doinges must be directed and ruled by the lawe and according to the good minde and meaning of those that gaue the authoritie And what their minde was it wil appeare well inough euen in the statute it selfe It was for the auoiding of all ambiguities doubtes and diuisions touching the Succession They putte theyr whole truste vppon the King as one whom they thought most earnestly to minde the wealth of the Realme as one that woulde and could best and most prudently consider and weigh the matter of the Succession and prouide for the same accordingly If the doinges of the King do not plainely and

For the haue in al these their worslipful procedinge against her made suche a hotchepoche suche a minglemangle suche a confuse anâ— disordered Chaos against Iustice and Nature that they them selues were the Accusers they them selues the witnesses they them selues the Iudges and examiners of her cause Is there any honest meaning and gentle natured harte that can once patiently abide and suffer to heare these their taunting and intolerable outragious inueyings and accusations especially of the Earles Murray and MurtoÌ„ the Capiteines ringleaders and chief practitioners thereof against her to whome they are most depely bound aswel for high preferment vndeserued as for diuers pardons of death by manifolde treasons worthely deserued To whom the one of them is by nature and blood albe it base as a brother entierly conioyned And to whome they both ought to be with the rest as to their Irege Ladie most loially subiected Shal they now with the Lord Lindzay be admitted to staine and defile her honour to seeke her harts blood who long sithens had worthely lost ther ingrate chorlishe traiterouse blood if they had not ben preserued by her singuler and incredible clemencie Yet let vs coÌ„sider their precise and most holy forme of Iudgement The Queene was disorderly and rebelliously appreheÌ„ded she was cast in prison not once heard to answer for her selfe most instantly and pitifully crauing audience She was forced and constrained by most vehement and iust feare to geue ouer her Croune and dimisse the regiment to the Earle Murray One great argument of the said constraint and compulsion among other is that she neuer readde such writinges as were offered to her to be by her subscribed nor entred into any couenant or talke for the maintenance of her liuing or safegard of her life Which thing she would neuer by any indifferent mans iudgement haue done if she had freely and voluntarily yelded vp her Regal Dignity Neither can the pretensed ParlameÌ„t be preiudicial to her standing vpoÌ„ no better nor surer grouÌ„d then vpon such as we haue rehearsed and vpon such worshipful letters missiue as are by them I can not tel more falsly or more fondly counterfeited Surely such Traitours as durst laye violent handes vppon their Queene and intrude them selues into the Regal Gouernement will make but smal â–ª curtesie in the faining and forging a letter thereby to worke their purposed mischiefe I would then father demaund of them what authoritie they had to somon and assemble a Parlament And whether this fact of hers supposing she were therein guilty deserueth in her being a Prince and considering how heinously the Lorde Darley had offended her and the Croune of Scotland such extreme punishment to be leuied vpon her for one simple murther especially by them that committed that shameful murther vpon her Secretarie that haue committed so many treasons and daily do committe so many horrible murthers vpoÌ„ the Quenes true louing subiectes How many and how cruel and terrible deathes do such Traitours deserue We haue moreouer to demaund of them whereas they pretende a merueilous and a singuler zeale to religioÌ„ and holy Scripture and to measure al their doinges precisely by Scripture and order thereof what sufficient warrant they haue therein by their priuate authoritie to set violent handes vpon their annointed Prince I find ther that King Dauid was both an adultrer and also a murtherer I finde that God was highly displeased with him therfore Yet find I not that he was therefore by his subiectes deposed And here might I take occasion out of the sacred Scriptures to declaime and discours against your disordered doinges but that it is nedelesse and our matters otherwise growe long But yet consider ye with your selfe you the Earles Murray and Murton with your consociats that euen adiudging the Queene were culpable and in some fault as she is not in this matter whether it had not ben much better and more auaileable to your commoÌ„ wealth and to the state thereof prudently to haue dissembled the matter as your forefathers haue heretofore done in a greater cause then this namely in Duke Robert the Gouernour Kings Roberts brother then to haue permitted your coÌ„mon wealth to haue commen into so miserable and wretched a state as it is now falleÌ„ in and dayly like to be in worse case and worse I suppose it wil be found that it had ben a much better policie to haue reserued the punishment thereof to Gods owne rodde and iustice in this or in an other worlde then to haue taken from him that he hath reserued to his owne only iudgemeÌ„t and to haue geuen to the subiects of other Princes suche a wicked president that if these other subiectes treade fast vppon your steppes there wil shortly fewe Kinges and Princes haue any sure and fast holde of their Sceptre and Roâ—al Dignitie We conclude then against you speake and doe the worste by her that ye can inuent that your proceedinges be not agreable or correspondent to law order and Iustice and therfore to be reuoked and adnulled We say that the common rule of the lawe ought here to take place Spoliatus ante omnia restiâ—uendus est vnlesse where all lawes aswel Gods as mans lawe doe fauour and preferre Princes causes with singuler priuileges and prerogatiues ye haue now espied out a newe law whereby Princes shal haue and enioye lesse benefits and preeminences in their owne defence then other priuate persons We say that for these and many other good and necessary considerations all is voide that ye haue busied your selues about We say that al your dooinges ought to be remoued reuersed and clearly annulled and the Queene wrongfully by you displaced to be restored to her state and former dignitie and honour Then let the whole matter be if there be any iuste cause before competent and meete Iudges to sitte vppon a Prince iustly and orderly heard and determined For as for you especially the Earle Marray and Murton ye are to be charged and chalenged byside al other iust exceptions euen as the principal inuentours mainteiners and workers of this shamefull and cruel murther for the whiche ye haue made al this hurly burly and as I may say stirred heauen and earth against your owne very natural Prince Neither may the Lord Lindzay be heard or suffred to intermedle against her if lawe take place for diuers his demerites among which he standeth charged aswel for that that he was one of the chiefe instrumentes in the slaughter of the Queenes Secretarie Dauid as also in the apprehending and imprisoning of her Grace But I much muse and merueyle how the Bisshoppe of Orkney for shame coulde so presumptuously and heynously inueigh and declaime before the Commissioners of Englande against his Maistresse pretensed mariage with the Earle Bothwell seeinge that he him selfe did celebrate the solemnitie thereof Who also was your onely Bifshop that was present at the Coronation of your newe erected king A man moste apte and ready to serue

and intent of the said law Now in case these two causes and coÌ„siderations wil not satisfie th Aduersarie we wil adioine therevnto a third which he shal neuer by any good and honest shift auoid And that is the vse and practise of the Realme as wel in the time foregoing the said statute as afterward We stand vpon the interpretation of the coÌ„mon law recited and declared by the said statute And how shal we better vnderstand what the law is therein then by the vse and practise of the said lawe For the best interpretation of the lawe is custome But the Realme before the statute admitted to the Croune not only kings children and others of the first degre but also of a farther degre and such as were plainely borne out of the Kings allegeance The soresaid vse and practise appeareth as wel before as sithens the time of the Conquest Among other King Edward the Confessour being destitute of a lawful Heire within the Realme sent into HuÌ„gary for Edward his Nephew surnamed Outlaw son to King EdmuÌ„d called IroÌ„side after many yeres of his exile to returne into EnglaÌ„d to th' intent the said Outlaw should inherite this Realme whiche neuerthelesse came not to effect by reason the said outlaw died before the said king Edward his Vncle. After whose death the said king apointed Eadgar Etheling sonne of the said Outlaw being his next cosen and heire as he was of right to the Croune of EnglaÌ„d And for that the said Eadgar was but of yong and tender yeares and not able to take vpoÌ„ him so great a gouernement the said king coÌ„mitted the protection as wel of the yong Prince as also of the Realm to Harold Earle of Kent vntil suche time as the said Eadgar had obteined perfit age to be hable to weld the state of a King Which Harold neuerthelesse coÌ„trary to the trust supplanted the said yong Prince of the Kingdome and put the Croune vpon his own head By this it is apparent that foraine birth was not accoÌ„pted of before the time of the CoÌ„quest a iust cause to repel and reiect any man being of the next proximitie in blood froÌ„ the Title of the Croune And though the said king Edward the CoÌ„fessors wil and purpose toke no such force and effect as he desired and the law craued yet the like succession toke place effectuously in king Stephen and king HeÌ„ry the secoÌ„d as we haue already declared Neither wil th' Aduersaries shift of foramers borne of father and mother which be not of the kings alegeaÌ„ce help him forasmuch as this clause of the said statut is not to be applied to the kings childreÌ„ but to others as appeareth in the same statute And these two kings StepheÌ„ and Henrie the 2. as they were borne in a forain place so their fathers and mothers wer not of the kings allegeaÌ„ce but mere Aliens and straÌ„gers And how notorious a vaine thing is it that th' Aduersarie would perswade vs that the said K. Henrie the secoÌ„d rather came in by force of a coÌ„position then by the proximitie and nearenes of blood I leaue it to euery man to coÌ„sider that hath any maner of feling in the discours of the stories of this realm The coÌ„positioÌ„ did procure him quietnes and rest for the time with a good and sure hope of quiet and peaceable entrance also after the death of King Stephen and so it followed in deede but ther grew to him nomore right therby then was due to him before For he was the true heir to the Croune as appeareth by Stephen his Aduersaries owne confession Henry the firste maried his daughter Mathildis to Henry the Emperour by whome he had no childreÌ„ And no dout in case she had had any children by th'Emperour they should haue ben heires by succession to the Croune of England After whose death she retourned to her father yet did King Henry cause all the Nobilitie by an expresse othe to embrace her after his death as Queene and after her her children Not long after she was maried to Ieffrey Plantagenet a Frenchman borne Earle of Aniowe who begat of her this Henry the second being in France Whervpon the said King did reuiue and renue the like othe of allegeaÌ„ce aswel to her as to her sonne after her With the like false persuasioÌ„ the Adueruersarie abuseth him selfe and his Reader touching Arthur Duke of Britanie Nephew to King Richard the first As though forsooth he were iustly excluded by Kinge Iohn his vncle by cause he was a forainer borne If he had said that he was excluded by reason the vncle ought to be preferred before the Nephewe though it should haue ben a false allegation and plaine against the rules of the lawes of this Realme as may wel appeare among other thinges by King Richard the second who succeded his graÌ„dfather king Edward the third which Richard had diuerse worthie and noble vncles who neither for lacke of knowledge coulde be ignorant of the right neither for lacke of frendes courage and power be enforced to forbeare to chalenge their title and interest yet should he haue had some countenance of reason and probabilitie bicause many arguments and the authoritie of many learned and notable Ciuilians doo concurre for the vncles right before the Nephewe But to make the place of the natiuitie of an inheritour to a kingdom a sufficieÌ„t barre against the right of his blood it seemeth to haue but a weake and slender holde and grounde And in our case it is a most vnsure and false ground seeing it is moste true that King Richard the first as we haue said declared the said Arthur borne in Britanie and not son of a King but his brother Geffreys sonne Duke of Britanie heire apparent his vncle Iohn yet liuing And for such a one is he taken in al our stories And for such a one did all the worlde take him after the said King Richard his death neither was King Iohn taken for other then for an vsurper by excluding him and afterward for a murtherer for imprisoning him and priuily making him away For the which facte the French King seased vpon al the goodly CouÌ„tries in France belonging to the King of England as forfeited to him being the chiefe Lorde By this outragious deede of King Iohn we lost Normandie withall and our possibilitie to the inheritance of all Britanie the right and Title to the said Britanie being dewe to the said Arthur and his heires by the right of his mother Constance And though the said king Iohn by the practise and ambition of Quene Elenour his mother and by the special procurement of Huberte then Archebishop of Caunterburie and of some other factious persons in EnglaÌ„d preueÌ„ted the said Arthur his nephew as it was easy for him to do hauing gotten into his handes al his brother Richardes treasure by sides many other rentes then in England and the said Arthur being an infante

the said Wil and others for the execution and performance of the same Finally the said Testament was recorded in the Chancerie Wherfore they affirme thaâ— there ought no manner of doubt moue any man to the coÌ„trarie and that either we must graunt this Wil to be signed with his hand or that he made no Wil at al both must be graunted or both denied If any wil deny it in case he be one of the witnesses he shal impugne his owne testimonie if he be one of the executours he shal ouerthrow the foundatioÌ„ of al his doinges in procuring the said Wil to be inrolled and set forth vnder the great Seale And so by their dubblenes they shal make them selues no mete witnesses Nowe a man can not lightly imagine how any other bysides these two kind of witnesses for some of them and of the executors were such as were coÌ„tinually wayting vpon the Kinges person may impugne this Wil and proue that the king did not signe the same But if any such impugne the Wil it would be coÌ„sidered how many they are and what they are and it wil be very harde to proue negatiuam facti But it is euidente say they that there was neuer any such lawful proufe against the said Wil producted For if it had ben it would haue ben published in the Starrechamber preached at Poules Crosse declared by Acte of Parlament proclaimed in euery quarter of the Realme Yea admitting say they that it were proued that the said pretensed Wil lacked the Kinges hande yet neuerthelesse say they the very copies we haue spoken of being written and signed or at least interlined with his owne hande may be saide a sufficient signing with his owne hande For seing the scope and final purpose of the statute was to haue the succession prouided for and ascerteined whiche is sufficiently done in the said Wil and seing his owne hande was required but onely for eschewing euil and sinister dealing whereof there is no suspicion in this Will to be gathered what matter in the worlde or what difference is there when the King fulfilled and accomplisihed this gratiouse Acte that was loked for at his handes whether he signed the Will with his owne hande or no If it be obiected that the King was obliged and bound to a certaine precise order and forme which he could in no wise shift but that the Acte without it muste perish and be of no valewe then say they wee vndoe whole Parlamentes aswel in Queene Maries time as in King Henry the eightes time In Queene Maries time bycause she omitted the Style appointed by Parlamente Anno ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ octauiâ—rice simo quinto In King Henries tyme by reason there was a statute that the Kinges royal assent may be geuen to an Acte of Parlamente by his Letters Patentes signed with his hande though he be not there personally And yet did the saied King supplie full ofte his confente by the stampe only This yet notwithstanding the said Parlamentes for the omission of these formes so exactely and precisely appointed are not destroyed and disannulled After this sorte in effecte haue the Aduersaries replied for the defence of the said pretensed Will. To this we wil make our reioynder and saye Firste that our principall matter is not to ioyne an islewe whether the saide Kinge made and ordeyned any sufficient Will or no. We leaue that to an other time But whether he made any Testament in suche order and forme as the statute requireth Wherefore if it be defectiue in the said forme as we affirme it to be were it otherwise neuer so good and perfect though it were exemplified by the great Seale and recorded in Chancerie and taken commonly for his Wâ—ll and so accomplished it is nothing to the principal question It resteth then for vs to consider the weight of the Aduersaries presumptions whereby they would inforce a probabilitie that the Testament had the foresaide requisite forme Yet first it is to be coÌ„sidered what presumptions and of what force and number do occurre to auoide and frustrate the Aduersaries presumptions and all other like We say then there occurre many likelyhoddes many presumptions many great and weightie reasons to make vs to thinke that as the king neuer had good and iuste cause to minde and enterprise suche an Acte as is pretended so likewise he did enterprise no such Acte in deede I deny not but that theâ— was such authoritie geuen him neither I deâ—y but that he might also in some honorable sort haue practised the same to the honour and wealth of the Realme and to the good coÌ„tentation of the same Realm But that he had either cause or did exercise the said authoritie in suche strange and dishonorable sort as is pretended I plainely denie For being at the time of this pretensed Wil furnished and adorned with issue the late king Edward and the Ladies Marie and Elizabeth their state and succession being also lately by Acte of Parlament established what neede or likelyhod was there for the king then to practise such newe deuises as neuer did I suppose any king in this Realme before and fewe in any other byside And where they were practised commonly had infortunate and lamentable successe What likelyhode was there for him to practise such deuises especially in his later daies when wisdome the loue of God and his Realme should haue bene moste ripe in him that were likely to sturre vppe a greater fier of greeuouse contention and woful destruction in England then euer did the deadly factioÌ„ of the red Rose and the white lately by the incorporation and vnion of the house of Yorke and Lancaster in the person of his father through the mariage of Ladie Elizabeth eldest daughter of king Edwarde the fourth most happily extinguished and buried And though it might be thought or said that there would be no such eause of feare by reason the matter passed by Parlament yet could not he be ignorant that neither Parlamentes made for Henry the fourth or continuance of twoo Descentes whiche toke no place in geuing any Title touching the Croune in King Henry the sixt nor Parlamentes made for King Râ—chard the third nor Parlaments of attainder made against his father could either preiudice his fathers right or releaue other against such as pretended iust right and title And as he could not be ignoraÌ„t therof so it is not to be thought that he would abuse the great confidence put vppon him by the Parlament and disherite without any apparent cause the next royal blood and thinke all thinges sure by the colour of Parlament The litle force whereof against the right inheritour he had to his fathers and his owne so ample benefit so lately and so largely sene and felt And yet if he minded at any time to preiudice the said Lady Marie Queend of Scotland of al times he would not haue done it then when al his care was by al possible meanes to contriue and compasse a mariage

the establishing of the succession and prouiding that the Realme should not be left void of a Gouernour And therefore we must not subuert the statute in cauilling for the defect of the Kings hand forasmuch as the Parlament might haue had authorised his consent only without any hand writing Which as I doe not denie so in these great affaires and so ample a commission in suche absolute authoritie geuen to him it was prouidently and necessarily foresene to binde the Acte to the Kings owne hand for auoyding al sinister and euil dealing the whiche the Aduersaries would haue vs in no case to misdoubt or mistrust in this Wil. Whereas the notoriousnes of the fact and the lameÌ„table euent of things do openly declare the same and pitifully crieth out against it Neither wil we graunt to them that the minde and purpose of the Parlament is satisfied for such causes as we haue and shall hereafter more largely declare And if it were otherwise true yet doth this only defect of the Kinges hand breake and infringe the whole Acte For this is a statute correctorie and derogatorie to the common course of the Lawe as cutting away the successioÌ„ of the lawful and true inheritours It is also as appeareth by the tenour of the same a most greuouse penal Law and therfore we may not shift or alter the wordes of the law Neither may we supply the maÌ„ner and doing of the Acte prescribed by any other Acte equiualent So that albe it in some other thing the Stampe or the Kinges certaine and knowen consente may counterpaise his hande yet as the case standeth here it wil not serue the turne by reason there is a precise order and forme prescribed and appointed Wherfore if by a statute of a Citie there be certaine persons appointed to do a certaine acte and the whole people do the same acte in the presence of the the said persons the acte by the iudgement of learned Ciuilians is vitious and of no valewe yea though the reason of the lawe cease yet must the forme be obserued For it is a rule and a Maxime that wher the law appointeth and prescribeth a certaine plat forme whereby the Acte must be bound and tyed in that case though the reason of the law ceasse yet is the acte voyd and naught And whereas the Aduersaries obiecte against this rule the Parlamentes made by Queene Marie without the vsual style called and somoned this obiection may sone be answered For it may sone appeare to all them that reade and pervse the said statute of Anno 35. Henrici octaui conteining the said style that by any especial wordes therin mentioned it is not there limited and appointed that the forme of the style therin sette foorth should be obserued in euery Writ And therfore not to be coÌ„pared vnto the said statutes of 28. and 35. Henrici octaui wherein by special wordes one expresse forme and order for the limiting of the succession of the Croune by the King is declared and set forth Bysides that the said Writtes being made both according to the auncient forme of the Regester and also by expresse commaundement of the Prince vtterly refusing the said style could neither be derogatorie to the said Queenes Maiestie and her Croune nor meaning of the said statute CoÌ„cerning the said style and for a final and sul answere vnto this matter it is to be noted that the Writts being th'Actes of the Court though they wante the prescript fourme set foorth either by the common lawe or statute yet are not they nor the iudgements subsequeÌ„t thervpon abated or voide but only abatable and voidable by exception of the partie by iudgemente of the Courte For if the partie without any exception doo admitte the forme of the said Writte and pleade vnto the matter whervpon the Court doth procede then doth the Writte and the iudgement therevpon following remaine good and effectual in lawe And therefore admitting that the said statute of 35. H. 8. had by special wordes appointed the said style to be put in euery Writte and that for that cause the said Writtes of Somons were vitious wanting their prescript forme yet when the parties vnto the said Writtes had admitted them for good both by their electioÌ„ and also by their appearence vpon the same the law doth admit the said Writtes and al actes subsequent vpon the same to be good and effectual And yet this maketh no prouffe that therfore the said supposed Wil wanting the prescript order and fourme should likewise be good and effectual in law For as touching specialties estates and coÌ„ueiances or any other external acte to be done or made by any person whose forme and order is prescribed either by the coÌ„mon law or by statute if they want any part of their prescript forme they are accoÌ„pted in law to be of no validitie or effect As for example the law doth appoint euery Specialtie or Deede to be made either in the first person or in the third person Therefore if part of a Deede be made in the first person and the residue in the thirde person that Dede is not effectual but void in the law Bysides that the law hath appointed that in euery Deede mention should be made that the partie hath putto his Seale to the same If therefore any Deede doth want that special clause and mention although the partie in deede hath put his Seale vnto the same yet is that Dede or Specialtie void in law So likewise the law geueth authoritie to the Lorde to distraine vpon the land holden of him for his rentes and seruices dewe for the same And farther doth appoint to carie or driue the same distresse vnto the pound there to remaine as a gage in law for his said rents and seruices If the Lord shal either distraine his TenaÌ„t out of his Fee or Seignory or if he shal labour and occupie the Chatles distrained the distresse so takeÌ„ by him is insurious and wrongful in law forasmuch as he hath not done according to the prescribed order of the law The statute made An. 32. H. 8. geueth authoritie vnto Tenant in taile and to others being seased of land in the right of their wiues or Churches to make leases of the same Wherin also a prescript order and forme for the same is set foorth If any of the said persons shal make any Lease wherin he doth not obserue the same prescribed order in all pointes the same Lease is not warranted in any point by the said statute Likewise the statute made in Anno 27. Henrici octauâ— of Bargaines and sales of land appointeth a forme and order for the same that they must be by writing indeÌ„ted sealed and enrolled within six monethes next after the dates of the same writings If any bargaine and sale of land be made wherein any of the thinges appointed by the said statute are omitted the same is vitious and voide in the lawe So

euidently tende to this ende and scope if a zealous minde to the common Wealth if prudence and wisdome did not rule and measure al these doinges but contrariewise partial affection and displeasure if this arbitrement putteth not away al contentions and striffes if the mind and purpose of the honorable Parlament be not satisfied if there be dishonorable deuises and assignmentes of the Croune in this Wil and Testament if there be a new Succession vnnaturally deuised finally if this be not a Testament and last Wil such as Modestinus defineth Testamentum est tusta voluntatus nostra sententia de eo quod quis post mortem suam fieti velit then though the Kinges hand were put to it the matter goeth not altogether so wel and so smothe But that there is good and great cause farther to consider and debate vpon it whether it be so or no let the indifferent when they haue wel thought vpon it iudge accordingly The Aduersaries them selues can not altogether denie but that this Testament is not correspondent to such expectation as men worthely should haue of it Whiche thing they do plainly confesse For in vrging their presumptions whereof we haue spokeÌ„ and minding to proue that this wil whiche they say is commonly called King Henries Wil was no new Wil deuised in his sicknes but euen the very same wherof as they say were diuers olde copies they inferre these wordes saying thus For if it be a newe Wil then deuised who could thinke that either him selfe would or any man durst haue moued him to put therin so many thinges contrary to his honour Much lesse durst they themselues deuise any new successioÌ„ or moue him to alter it otherwise then they fouÌ„d it when they saw that naturally it could not be otherwise disposed Wherein they say very truely For it is certaine that not only the common lawe of this Realme but nature it selfe telleth vs that the Queene of ScotlaÌ„d after the said Kinges children is the next and rightful Heire of the Croune Wherefore the King if he had excluded her he had done an vnnatural acte Ye wil say he had some cause to doo this by reason she was a forainer and borne out of the Realm Yet this notwithstanding he did very vnnaturally yea vnaduisedly inconsideratly and wrongfully and to the great preiudice and danger of his owne Title to the Croune of France as we haue already declared And moreouer it is wel to be weighed that reason and equitie and Ius Gentium doth require and craue that as the Kings of this Realme would thinke them selues to be iniuriously handled and openly wronged if they mariyng with the heires of Spaine Scotland or any other Countrey where the succession of the Croune deuolueth to the woman were shutte out and barred from theyr said right dewe to them by the wiues as we haue said so likewise they ought to thinke of women of their royal blood that marie in Scotland that they may wel iudge and take them selues much iniured vnnaturally and wrongfully dealt withall to be thruste from the succession of this Croune being thereto called by the nexte proximitie of the royal blood And such deuolutioÌ„s of other Kingdoms to the Croune of England by foraine mariage might by possibilitie often times haue chaunced and was euen nowe in this our time very like to haue chanced for Scotland if the intended mariage with the Queene of Scotland that now is and the late King Edward the sixt with his longer life and some issue had takeÌ„ place But now that she is no suche forainer as is not capable of the Croune we haue at large already discussed Yea I wil now say farther that supposing the Parlament minded to exclude her and might rightfully so doe and that the King by vertue of this statute did exclude her in his supposed Wil yet is she not a plaine forainer and incapable of the Croune For if the lawfull heires of the said Ladie Francis and of the Ladie Elenour should happeÌ„ to faile which seeme now to faile at the least in the Ladie Katherin and her issue for whose title great sturre hath lately ben made by reason of a late sentence definitiue geuen against her pretensed mariage with the Earle of Herford then is there no stay or stoppe either by the Parlament or by the supposed Will but that she the said Queene of Scotlande and her Heires may haue and obteine their iust Title and claime For by the said pretensed Wil it is limited that for default of the lawfull Heyres of the said Ladre Francis and Elenour the Croune shall remaine and come to the next rightful Heires But if she shal be said to be a forainer for the time for the induction of farther argument then what saye the Aduersaries to my Ladie Leneux borne at Herbottel in England and from thirtene yeares of age brought vppe also in England and commonly taken and reputed as well of the King and Nobilitie as of other the lawefully Neece of the said King Yea to turne nowe to the other Sister of the King maried to Charles Brandon Duke of Suffolke and her children the Ladie Francis and the Ladie Elenour why are they also disherited Surely if there be no iust cause neither in the Lady Leneux nor in the other it seemeth the King hath made a plaine Donatiue of the Croune Whiche thinge whether he could doe or whether it be conformable to the expectation of the Parlament or for the Kinges honour or for the honour for the Realme I leaue it to the farther consideration of other Nowe what causes should moue the Kinge to shutte them out by his pretensed Will from the Title of the Croune I minde not nor neede not especially seeing I take no notice of any such Wil touching the limitation of the said Croune here to to prosecute or examine Yet am I not ignorant what impedimentes many doo talke of and some as well by printed as vnprinted Bookes doe write of Wherein I will not take vppon me any asseueration any resolution or iudgement Thus only will I propound as it were by the way of consideration duely and depely to be wayed and thought vpon that is for as muche as the benefitte of this surmised Wil tendeth to the extrusion of the Queene of Scotland and others altogether to the issue of the French Queene whether in case the King had no cause to be offended with his sisters the Frenche Queenes children as the Aduersaries them selues confesse he had not and that there was no lawful impediment in them to take the succession of the Croune it were any thing reasonable or euer was once meant of the Parlament that the King without cause should disherite and exclude them from the Title of the Croune On th' other side if ther were any such impediment whereof this surmised Wil geueth out a great suspicion it is to be considered whether it standeth with reason and iustice with the honour of the King and the

hauing and following of this law as we haue said vnlesse to omitte other thinges ye would bind our Kinges also to receaue the Deuteronomie at the haÌ„ds of the Leuitical Tribe as that ye say that God gaue here a lawe to the Iewes to make or choose a King and so consequently al your illations out of this place seeme to be of smal force For to say the trueth as God neither gaue them this or any other lawe for choosing of a King nor did bid or will them to choose a King so did the people most greeuously offend God in demanding a King. For though by the iudgement of Aristotle and other Philosophers Monarchie wel and orderly vsed is the best kinde of al other Regiments which God doth also wel like yet would he haue no such magistrate among the Iewes But as he chose them for his propre peculier and selecte people and ruled them as wel in the Desert as in Iudea by a seueral peculier and distinct order and Gouernement from other Nations and after suche wonderful and miraculous sort as the like was neuer harde of in any Regiment by sides so would he also reserue to him selfe only the said Supremacie and Monarchie Neither was he a litle angrie with the Iewes nor they committed any smal fault but as it were renounced and reiected Gods owne Monarchie in crauing a King as holy Scripture plainely and openly testifiet Nonâ—ie inquit reiecerunt sed me ne regnem super eos And the people afterwardes acknowledged their fault Addidimus vniuersis peccatis nostris malum vt peteremus nobu Regem God therefore did not bidde them or wil them to choose a King but forknowing long before by his eternall forsight what they would do though contrarie to his blessed wil and pleasure did in this as in other matters beare with their weakenes and condescended vnto the same and fortold them in the said 17. Chapter that in case they would needes haue a King of what kind and sort he should be And therefore immediatly before the wordes that ye recite thou shalt make him a King ouer them is this texte Cum ingressus fuer is terram quam Dominus Deus dabit tibi possederis illam habâ—â—auerisque in illa dixeris constituam super me Regem sicut habent omnes per circuitum Nationes â—um constitues c. And when thou shalt come into the laÌ„d which the Lord thy God geueth thee and shalt possesse yea and dwel therein if thou say I wil set a King ouer me like as all the Nations that are about me then thou shalt make him King ouer thee whome c. Whiche wordes making for the illustratioÌ„ of this place ye haue omitted Wherfore as this place serueth nothing for any absolute election of a King the second which you seeme especially to regard and ground your selfe vpon so doth it as we haue shewed as litle relieue you to prooue therby your conclusions especially against the ordinarie successioÌ„ either of a strauÌ„ger or of a woman that ye would gather and conclude out of the same Thus haue we sufficiently answered the place of Deuteronomie for this one purpose Th' other two autorities may be much more easely answered The people meant nothing els by their said wordes spoken to Dauid but that they were the seede of Abraham Isaac and Iacob as wel as he and intended with true and sincere hartes vnfainedly to agnise him as their chiefe Lord and Soueraigne For at that time the Tribe of Iuda only whereof King Dauid came by lineal descent did acknowledge him as king Now the residue which before helde with Saules sonne did also incorporate and vnite themselues to the said kingdome If this man looke wel vpon the matter he shal find I trowe that the Queene of Scotland may as wel cal her selfe the bones and fleshe of the Noble Princes of England as this people cal them selues the bones and sheshe of King Dauid But yet the great terrible battering Cannon Athalia is behind She being in possessession of the kingdome seuen yeares was iustly thrust out by cause she was an Alien We may then saith this man iustly denie the Queene of Scotland the right of that which if she had in possession she should not iustly enioy Yet Sir if the Queene of Scotland be no Alien as we haue said then is your Cannon shot more feareful then dangerous We deny not but that Athalia was lawfully deposed but we beseche you to tell vs your Authours name that doth assigne the cause to be suche as you alleage Surely for my part after diligent searche I finde no such Authour Trueth is it that Iosephus writeth as ye doe that she descended by the mothers side of the Tyrians and Sidonians yet neuerthelesse he assigneth no such cause as ye doe And as ye are in this your preatie poisoned pamflet the first I trow of al Christian men I wil not except either Latin or Greke vnlesse it be some fantastical fonde and new vpstart Doctour as M. Knoxe or some the like neither Iew Chaldee nor Arabian that hath thus straungely glosed and deformed this place of holie Scripture against the ordinarie succession of women Princes so are you the first also of all other Diuines or Lawiers throughout the world that hath set forth this new fonde foolishe lawe that the Kings childe must be counted an Alien whose father and mother are not of the same and one CouÌ„trie If the French or Spanish King chaunce to marâ—e an English woman or the King of England to marie a French a Spanish or any other Country woman their Children by this new Lycurgus are Aliens and so consequently in al other Nations al such are haue ben and shal be AlieÌ„s by this your new oracle For what other cause shew you that this Athalia was an Alien but by cause her mother was an Alien genus duceÌ„s say you Ã Tyrijs Sydoâ—iis coming by lineal descent by the mothers side from the Tyrians and Sydonians King Achas maried her mother doughter to Ithobal King of the said Tyrians and Sydonians This Athalia whom Iosephus cal leth Gotholio Achas daughter maried IoraÌ„ King of uda her brother called also Ioram being king of Israel after the decease of his father Achas So then ye see that this Athalia was nomore an Alien among the Iewes then â—â—ing Edbalde Baldus was the sonne of Bertha a FreÌ„ch womaÌ„ and of King Ethelbertus the first Christian King of th' English nation no more then was the noble King Edward the third borne of a French woma â—more then Queene Marie was no more â—en should haue bene the issue of the said Q. Marie in case she had had any by the king â—f Spaine I perceaue that your felowes that â—ould faine make King Stephen King HeÌ„â—e the second and Arthur Neuew to King â—ichard the first Aliens had but rude dul â—nd grosse heades in comparison of

ciuil gouermeÌ„t more or lesse be annexed and vnited to this inheritaÌ„ce as it is not only in Empires and Kingdomes but in many DukedoÌ„s Earldoms yea and Lordships also whether she shal be excluded from the said her inheritance If ye say yea then you say against Scripture If you say that the inheritance must remaine in her and the ciuil gouernment to others then say you against al reason against the vse manner and custom of the whole world it is but your own fond folish glosse WhervpoÌ„ I do inferre that womanly gouernment is admitted not only by these exaÌ„ples but euen by the very wordes rules and decrees of holy Scripture And so I trust you are or haue cause to be fully satisfied aswel touching your allegatioÌ„ that womaÌ„ly RegimeÌ„t is against nature as also touchiÌ„g a brother to be chosen king And therfore I coÌ„clude against you that neither the law of God nor of Nature nor yet reason vpon the which also you ground yourself doe reiect the said Queene Marie from the succession of the Croune of England You reason that where the people erect themself an Head of their owne kinde and Nation there nature assureth the people of natural gouernment and where a stranger carieth opinion of vnnatural tyranny it assureth the ruler of vnnatural subiection To a straunger is murmurre and rebellion threatned But now if this excellent Ladie and Princesse be no straunger and be of our owne kinred and of the auncient and late Roial bloud of this Realme as we haue declared then is your reason also withal auoided which may and doth ofteÌ„times take place in more straungers coÌ„ming in by violent and forceable meanes But here as natural a man as you make your self ye seeme to goe altogether against reason and against nature also If Princes Children were to be counted straÌ„gers and Aliens or to be suspected as enemies and Tyrantes succeding to their owne Progenitours inheritance it was an vnnatural parte and a great folie in the noble Kinges of this and of many other Realmes to geue out their daughters to foreine Princes in mariage And in steade of preferring and aduancing them by their mariage and procuring thereby frindship and amitie with other Princes to disable their said children from ther Auncestours inheritaÌ„ces in those CouÌ„tries from whence they originally proceded And as it seemeth by your kind of reasoning to purchase and procure byside to them thereby an opinion of enmitie and tyrannie This this I say is a frowarde and an vnnatural interpretation Nature moueth and driueth vs to think otherwise and that both a Prince wil fauour loue and cherishe the people from whence he fetcheth his roial blood and by whoÌ„ he must now mainteine keepe and defende his roial estate and that the people likewise wil beare singuler loue and affection to such a one specially of such knoweÌ„ Princely qualities as this noble Ladie is adorned withal Surely it is no more vnnatural to such a Prince descending from the anncient and late roial blood of the Kinges of England to beare rule in EnglaÌ„d and as it were to returne to the head and fouÌ„taine from whence originally she spraÌ„g then it is for al fluddes and riuers which as Homer saith flow out of the great OceaÌ„ sea ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ to reuert returne and reflow againe to the said Ocean This coherence coniunction copulatioÌ„ inclinatioÌ„ and fauour running interchangeably betwixt such a PriÌ„ce and the people is no more straÌ„ge to nature then is the coÌ„iunction of the tree and the rote thereof then of the fountaine and the Riuer issewing froÌ„ thence then of the sonne and of the sonne beames and finally then is the coniunction betwixt the old auncient liuing grandmother and her yong and tendre daughter Neither do I wel know how I may better cal noble England then a liuing grandmother to this good geÌ„tle Ladie whoÌ„ we I doe not doubt if euer God cal her to the Roial state therof shal not only find a louing and gratious Maistresse but a most deare and tendre good doughter For these and other coÌ„sideratioÌ„s the lawes of the Realm do not nor euer did estraÌ„ge such Princes from the successioÌ„ of the Croun of this realm which by reason of the said mutual inclination and beneuoleÌ„ce of th' one to the other standeth with the law of God and nature and with al good reason And therfore your coÌ„clusion is against Gods law Nature and al good reason Wherby you ful vngodly vnnaturally and vnreasonably do coÌ„clude an exclusion of the Q. of ScotlaÌ„d pretending her to be a straÌ„ger to that right that God Nature and reason and the true harts of al good natural English men do cal her vnto The which her said iust right title and interest we trust we haue now fully proued and iustified and sufficieÌ„tly repulsed the sundry obiectioÌ„s of the aduersaries And as this being the principal ought to breede no doubt or scruple in any maÌ„ so many other folish fond and fantastical obiections not worthy of any answere that busie quareliÌ„g heads do cast forth to disable her right or to disgrace her and bleamish either her honour or this happie vnioÌ„ of both Realmes if God shal so dispose of it ought much lesse to moue any maÌ„ An happy vnioÌ„ I cal it bicause it shal not only take away the long mortal enmitie the deadly hatred the most cruel and sharp warres that haue so many hundred yeares ben continewed betwixt our neighbours the Scotsmen and vs but shal so intierly consociate conioine and so honorably set foorth and aduauÌ„ce vs both and the whole Iland of Britanie as neither tonge caÌ„ expresse the greatnes of our felicitie and happines nor hart wish any greater The old enmitie hath trodden downe and kept vs both vnder foot and hath giuen occasion to the common enemie as the Danes and other to spoile vs both It hath caused for these thousand yeares and more so infinite and so ougly slaughters as it wil greeue and pitie any mans hart to remembre and yet neither to the great augmentatioÌ„ of our possessions at this day nor to their much losse they hauing lost nothing of their olde aunciene inheritance sauing Barwike only If this coÌ„iunctioÌ„ once happeÌ„ and if we be once vnited and knit together in one kingdome and dominion in one entier brotherly loue and amitie as we are already knit by neighbourhoode by tongue and almost by all manners fashions and behauiours then will al vnnatural and butcherly slaughter so loÌ„g hitherto practised ceasse then wil rest quiet wealth and prosperitie increase at home then wil al outward Princes our frindes reioice and be comforted our enemies dread vs Then wil the honour fame and Maiestie of the Ilande of Albion daily growe more and more and her power and strength so greatly encrease as to the frinde wil be a good shield and to the enemie an horrible terrour Then shal the vtwarde enemie litle indaÌ„mage vs

CONCERNING THE DEFENCE OF THE HONOVR OF THE RIGHT HIGH MIGHTIE AND NOBLE PRINcesse Marie Queene of Scotland and Douager of France with a Declaration as wel of her Right Title and Interest to the Succession of the Croune of England as that the Regiment of women is conformable to the lawe of God and Nature Made by Morgan Philippes Bachelar of Diuinitie An. 1570. LEODII Apud Gualterum Morberium 1571. A DEFENCE OF THE HONOVR OF THE RIGHT HIGH RIGHT MIGHTIE and Noble Princesse Marie Queene of Scotlande and Douager of France The First Booke IT were to be wished that as God and nature haue most decently ordinately and prouidentely furnished and adorned manne with two eies two eares and but with one mouth and one tongue wonderfully bridled and kept in with the lippes and the teeth so men would consider the cause of it and the great prouidence of God therein and after due coÌ„sideration vse them selues accordingly Then should we sone learne and practise a good lesson to heare and see many thinges and yet not to runne headlong nor rudely and rashly to talke of al we heare and see but to talke within a compasse and to referre al our talke to a temperance and sobrietie and to a knowen tried trueth especially where the said talke may sound to the blemishing and disgracing of any mans good name and estimation But now a daies the more pitie there is nothing almost but that as sone as it is perceaued by the eye or the eare must furthwith be lasshed out againe by the mouth suche a superfluous and curious itching we haue dissolutely and vnaduisely to talke of al matters though they tende to the great hinderance and infamie of many of our bretherne and though we be nothing assured of the certaine trewth of the matter yea without respecte to priuate or publique persons Of such vnbrideled talke no man or woman in our daies hath as I suppose more iuste cause to complaine then the right Excellent Princesse Ladie Marie Queene of Scotland whose honour many haue gone about to blotte and deface in charging her moste falsly and vniustly with the death of her late husbande the Lorde Darley For the defence and mainteining of whose innocencie in this behalfe we intend to lay forth before the gentle Reader the most chief and principal reasons grouÌ„ds and arguments whervpon the Patrones the Inuentors and workers of al these mischieuouse and diuelish driftes grounded themselues and all their outragious doomges And then consequently to infringe and repulse the same For to rehearse answere to and repell all their assertions and obiections it would require a very long tediouse and a superfluouse Discourse in as muche as these iolie gaie oratours measuring their dooinges more by number of false obiections then by true substantial and pitthy matter to make a goodly florish and a trim shewe to face out and countenance their craftie Iuglinges and to couer their disordered dealings therewithal haue raked vp and heaped together one vpon another against their good Maistres and Souereigne Queene no smal number of slanderous Articles But in al this rablement in al this raking and racking what thing els do they but vtter and disclose their owne spiteful malice and malicious spite to the discrediting of their cause and them selues also Euen as the accusers of Aristophanes among the Athenienses did by whome he being ninetie and fiue times greeuously accused was yet euery time by the Iudges cleared and found guiltlesse as I do no whit doubt but that this good innoceÌ„t Ladie wil be by the verdit and sentence of al indifferent men ridde and vnburdened in like maner of al maner of suspicion that these reprocheful men woulde by their malice and ambition bring her into by thier willes with al the worlde For as goodly and as greate a muster as they make two partes of their slaunderous accusation are manifest false and opeÌ„ vntruethes and foule forged lies The residue thereof though in some part they beare trueth and be nothing preiudicial to the Queene in this matter yet they are ful calumniously and meruelous maliciously depraued drawen and wrested to the worst The effect and drifte of the whole tendeth to this that first they would we should beleeue that after her mariage her minde was as it were alienated from her husband Secondly they pretende certaine letters that they surmise and would haue to haue bene written by her Grace wherby they seeke to inferre against her many a presumption as their wily braines imagine But the moste weighty of them al seemeth to them to be her pretensed Mariage whereof we wil lastly entreate And yet though they haue done their worste though they haue cast out al their spite and malice against her they neuer haue bene able by any direct and lawful meanes to prooue any thing at al wherby they may staine her Graces honour in any one of the foresaid points Had they brought forth any such necessarily concluding illation we had not atteÌ„pted this Defence in her behalfe but would haue yelded and geuen place to an open knowen trewth But seeing that the best matter they haue to supporte their doings withal is nothing else but presumptions and surmises which yet are not of the surest and moste probable forte neither suche as are presumptions Iuris de Iureâ— contra quas non admittitur probatio seeing also that we ought alwaies in criminal causes chiefly when a Prince is touched who is Gods annointed to be more procliue and prone to fauour then to hatred to be readier to absolue and release then to deteine and condemne and that it is farre better and a more sure and more indifferent and vpright way to saue the guilties life then to condeÌ„ne and cast away the innoceÌ„t I trust and am in an assured hope that al the indifferent Readers hereof this being the cause and woful aduersity of a PriÌ„ce wheras the like estate of Princes ought and is wont to moue and sturre al honest harted men to commiseration and pitie and to do their indeuour to the redresse and reformation of suche wrong and oppression done wil with indifferencie and without all partialitie weigh and coÌ„sider the allegatioÌ„s of the one and the other side and iudge of the matter as it falleth out accordingly Which is the very thing we most desire And seeing the Aduersaries throughout al their cause wander by ghesses and vncertaine presumptions let vs also as I may say abuse a litle parte of our Defence What â—y I abuse perchance truely if we had no better or they any good matter at al nay rather vse them accordingly for the more ample and better trial and iustification of our cause We as ke theÌ„ then why the better and the stronger presumptions should not frustrate auoide and set backe the weaker and the worse This sexe naturally abhorreth such butcherly practises Surely rare it is to heare such foule practises in women And may we find in our harts

bewraieth you and your whole cause withal Is it to be thought that either the Earle would send to the said Sir Iames who had before assisted the faction against the Quene with the force and streÌ„gth of Edenborough Castle and driuen from thence the very Earle him selfe or that the said Sir Iames would send any such thing to the Earle Is it likely Is it credible Had the forger and inuentour of this tale by seemely conueiance parted and diuided the distinction of his times Howe say ye Whereas nowe it is in no case to be supposed or coniectured that suche a wise vertuous Ladie would sende any suche letters yet putting the case that she had sent them it is not to be thought that either the receauer thereof or that she her selfe whome ye conceaue to haue sent them would haue suffred them for the hasarding of her estimation and honour to remaine vndefaced namely seeing there was a special mention made and warning geuen forthwith to burn them and make them away Neuerthelesse when you haue takeÌ„ your best aduantage you can of them such kinde of letters missiue and Epistles especially not conteining any expresse commaundement of any vnlawful acte or deede to be committed and perpetrated not ratifiyng or specifiyng the accomplishment of any such facte already past but by vnsure and vncerteine ghesses aymes and coniecturall supposinges are not able in any wise to make a lawful presumption much lesse any good and substantial proufe not only against your Soueraigne and Prince but not so muche as against the poorest woman or simplest wretched creature in al Scotland Surely the Ciuil lawe willeth that in criminal matters for such are these the accusers alleage and bring foorth nothing but that they may be able to approue and iustifie by the testimonie of good and lawefull witnesses or by some other most manifest cleare and euident proufe or presumptions Sciant cuncti accusatores eam se rem deferre in publicam notionem debere quae munita sit idoneis testibus vel instructa apertissimis documentis vel indiciis ad probationem indubit atis luce clarioribus expedita This rule ought to be obserued and kept in the simplest and seeliest poore mans cause that is and thinke you nowe you moste vngrate and vnthankefull subiectes that ye maye lawefullye take armes against your Maistresse and your moste benigne Queene that ye maye caste her into vile prison and spoyle her of her Croune and whiche is more of her good and honourable name fame and estimation and then bleare mennes eies and face the world out with the shew of these letters as it were with a carde of ten But yet say you they are her letters She denieth them and we denie them to There is neither subscription of the writer nor superscriptioÌ„ vnto whom they were directed they are neither sealed nor signed there appeareth neither date wherein they were dated neither day nor moneth There is no mention made of the bearer who is as it may be supposed for any name he beareth the man in the Moone He was neuer yet knowen nor herd of that did either receaue or deliuer them For as for him that ye surmise was the bearer of them and whome you haue executed of late for the said murther he at the time of his said execution tooke it vpon his death as he should answere before God that he neuer caried any such letters nor that the Queene was participant nor of couÌ„sayle in the cause Think ye that wise and expert meÌ„ are ignorant how perilous and dangerous a matter it is to fasten any good proufe vpon illation of letters and how easy it is to some men to imitate and counterfeat any character The which a Knight lately deceased in England could so liuely and subtilely doe that he who wrote moste crabbedly and vnleageably could hardly discerne his owne hande writing from the Knights counterfeiting hande But who conferred these letters I pray you with your Queenes owne hande writing Dare you to warrant them in this so perilous and weighty a cause to haue bene so exquisitely and so exactly vewed and conferred with al suche dewe circumstances as the Ciuil law doth require were it but a Ciuil or a money matter You wil peraduenture answere that there was dew collation by you made O perfecte and worthy collation O meete and apt men for suche a purpose As though it is not notoriously knowen throughout the worlde that ye are her most mortal enemies as though these counterfeit letters were not the vnderpropped postes and vpholders of your whole treachery and vsurped kingdome as though that many in Scotlande could not expresse and resemble and counterfeit in their writinges the Queenes very character and as though there were not among your selues some singuler artificer in this haÌ„dycraft and that hath sent letters also in her very name aswel into Englande as to other places bysides without either her commaundement or knowledge How can I chose then but say that this deede is your shamefull handy-craft and not her hand writing Yea surely al this is your owne fained forging and most vile counterfeiting If ye be angry with me for thus saying by you I hope you wil be sone colde with me againe seeing that I wil not bring out any dead witnesses as ye craftily do contrary to reason and lawe Quia testibus non testimonijs credendum est nor suche like but good sufficient and lawful witnesses suche as ye can not by any iust exception or tergiuersation auoyde or elude And these are none other but euen your owne selues For either you must bring foorth good and apparent witnesses to prooue it her hande or some suche as were priuie to the meaning of the sayd letters whiche ye neyther yet haue done nor are likely euer to doo Or ye must graunte that you were priuie to them your selues with the Queene or at least with the said Earle whom ye surmise to haue receaued these letters or that al this is by you maliciously driuen and concluded If ye graunt vs that ye were priuie of the saied letters we truste then you wil be good to the Queene and if it were but for your owne honesties sake If ye denie that and withal that you were the contriuers thereof your selues we pray you to tel vs and blush not how you could so readily and so directly hit the interpretation of these wordes our affaires and what these wordes should meane there being so many affaires as ye pretende in these your fayned false letters betwene the Queene and the Earle That only thing that by these wordes ye surmise pretende and coniecture I suppose that if you were wel examined of this point vpon the sodaine and were vrged and vehemently pressed by any indifferent and vpright Iudge you woulde be somewhat to feeke And yet take at your leasure as good aduisement and as long consultatioÌ„ with your selues as ye can and may thinke meete

and defende him against al men that would then after challenge or pursue him as guiltie of the said crime The wihch their doings the Queene considering and fearing dangers imminent and withal calling to mind the sundry and diuers vprours and seditioÌ„s already made against her the wretched and most cruel murther of her Secretarie in her own presence the late straÌ„ge and miserable murther of her husbaÌ„d the distresse the discomforte and desolation wherein she was presently bewrapped the Earles actiuitie in Martial feates and the good and faithful seruice done by him to her mother and to her self fearing some new and fresh sturre and calamitie if she should refuse her Nobilities request though very circuÌ„spect and naturally prudent in al her other doinges yet neuerthelesse a woman and especially neuer to that houre ones admonished either opeÌ„ly or priuately after the Earles acquital that he was guiltie of the said fact nor suspecting any thing therof yelded to that to the whiche these craftie colluding seditious heads and the necessitie of the time as then to her seemed did in a maner enforce her Let them now lay on lode let them now rage and raue against this acquital and mariage let them lie to their owne shame vpoÌ„ their owne deuifes and doinges thereby to defame their Queene Let them lie that the Erle of Huntley was restored to his fathers patrimonie to procure his sisters consent to the diuorse betwene th' Erle and her which restitution was made not for that coÌ„sideratioÌ„ but by cause the Queene thought in her coÌ„science his father wrongfully coÌ„demned Let them crie out vpoÌ„ th' Earle Bothwel for that the senteÌ„ce of diuorse was promulged partly by force partly without the iust and vsual order of the law and without sufficieÌ„t proufs Let them cry out vpoÌ„ him for his violeÌ„t taking and deteining the Queene Yet if they caÌ„ not precisely proue the Quenes consent to any of his vnlawful actes as hitherto they were neuer able to do then can they not get or gather any iust occasion which is the thing they only seeke for to suspect the Queene of this greuous acte On th' other side it is wel knoweÌ„ and easy to be proued that this faction did chiefly procure as we haue said aswel the acquital as the supposed mariage and therfore by likelihod was priuie of all other consequent deuises and practises Wherefore they do nothing but blow out and blase to the worlde with their owne foule filthy mouthes their own shame and doe fare like a man that doth thrust a sworde through both his owne sides to pricke a litle and raise but the outward skinne only of his enemie Ye may now wel perceaue geÌ„tle Reader that hitherto they haue produced litle matter of credit against their Quene and yet as it appeareth very good matter against them selues and for their owne discredit Nowe may ye therefore easely coniecture and by these their chiefe and principal matters and groundes easely perceaue what accompt is to be made of al the residue of their lewde slanders and what smal force and strength al their whole sayinges do beare They see it they see it wel inough themselues good Reader whereby they wel perceaue and fully vnderstand that they altogether are vnable to beare out and mainteine by reason iustice or law these their outragious and seditious procedinges And therefore they set vpon them the best colour and countenance they can Wherein you shal nowe heare what they did alleage being in England for them selues They say that no man can charge them or the residue of their Nobilitie that they haue gone as much as one onely step from the office and dutie of good subiectes in taking armes against the outragious enormities already committed and to preuent the great daÌ„gers immineÌ„t to the persons of their Queene and her dere sonne to their Nobilitie and to the whole state of their weale publike And that it was no smal harts grief to them to heare what vilanie al Nations thought and openly spake of them for suffering such a Tragical matter to scape vnpunished which thing ingendreth of vs say they among strangers and al forain Nations an ill and sinister opinion of some common consent thereto made by our whole Nobilitie Yea to see also the very Executour thereof him selfe by violent force to take deteine and kepe his and their Souereigne and with mariyng with her to disteine her honour Wherfore to set her Maiestie at freedom out of his bondage to preserue her honour and the personne of her sonne and by due punishment of suche a malefactour to recouer their good name and estimation with the rest and quietnes of their CoÌ„trey when they had but in vaine attempted aswel al other meanes as by the offring to the Earle singuler battail they were driuen to gather force to resist them who came to the fielde against them with a strong army But he refusing either to wage singuler battail which was then offered to him or to ioyne in battail with their caÌ„pe escaped by flight The Queene in the meanewhile rendred herself into the Nobilities hands there assembled and by them was conueied to EdeÌ„borough but afterward they were of very necessitie compelled to sequester her vntil such time as some remedie might be found for these maters into LochleueÌ„ Wher she hauiÌ„g now aduised with her self and fully perceued her owne disabilitie to susteme the weight of so great a roome frely and voluÌ„tarily by their saying gaue ouer the Croune to her sonne appointing the Earle Murray being at that time out of the Realme to be RegeÌ„t therof during her sonnes minoritie Th' Earle Bothwel not long after being by them pursued fled the Realme to escape their handes Now this said resignation by the Queene ones made to her sonne he was forthwith by them solemnly crouned and he as King the Earle Murray as Regent obeyd and the state of both these RegimeÌ„ts was by Acte of ParlameÌ„t established WhervpoÌ„ quietnes began to encrease and iustice more and more daily to take place which yet some persons sai thei much enuiyng at to the disturbaÌ„ce of the same and of the kings authoritie first practised contrary to the said their Acte of Parlament the Queenes deliuerance out of Lochleuen and then shewed them selues in armes But as their atteÌ„pt say they was vnlauful so the victory fel against them on our the righteous side Whereby God him self semeth to haue geueÌ„ senteÌ„ce for the equitie of our whole cause against our Aduersaries These are the principal allegations that these good men haue proposed for the iustification of their proceedinges against the Quene before the CoÌ„missioners of EnglaÌ„d Finally they say that the moste parte of them selues are for particuler benefits priuately so muche beholding to their said Quene that a number of them could be coÌ„teÌ„ted and wel willing if they might preserue Scotland in the state of a Kingdome preseruing also the professioÌ„ of true religion with the Kinges person

and the whole state froÌ„ danger to liue willingly in perpetual exile and bannishment God be thanked that after these seditious and trayterous subiectes haue bene so stout and storming in the rekoning vp and accumulating of faults and offenses of their innoceÌ„t Maistresse and Quene they are yet at the leÌ„gth forced to answere for theÌ„selues and for their excessiue outragious rebellious dooings Their glorious and glittering excuses may perhaps at the first shew seme to some of the Readers to haue a ioly face of much probabilitie great trueth and feruent zeale to the weale publike But may it please them aduisedly and depely to ponder and weigh aswel what we haue said as what we farther shal say in supplement of ful answere and then to iudge and deme of the mater none otherwise then reason equitie and law do craue they shalat length fynde out and throughly perceaue and know these mennes dealinges and doinges who as yet couer their foule filthy lying detestable practises and trayterouse enormities with suche a visarde of counterfeit fained holines and suche exceding greate shew of zeale to the Queenes honour in punishing malefactors and to the preseruation of the state of the Realme as though al the worlde would fal and go to ruine if it were not vpholden and vnderpropped by the strength of their shoulders They shal see how they wil appeare in their owne natural likenes so ougly that al good harts wil vtterly detest them and thinke them moste worthie for example sake to al the worlde hereafter of extreme punishment We affirme then first that as they haue produced nothing in the worlde touching the principal points as of the Lorde Darleyes death the acquital of the Earle Bothwel and the Queenes mariage with him iustly to charge her withal so are they them selues aswel for the said acquital and mariage as for their damnable and rebellious attempts against their Souereigne and for many other enormous crimes so farre and so depely charged so foule stained and so shamefully marked and noted that neuer shal they with al their hypocritical fine fetches be able to rubbe out the dirty blottes thereof from their skirts which thing wilbâ— easely perceaued of them that wil vouchesafe aduisedly to consider the friuolous and contradictorie excuses they make in their defence At the beginning their open surmised quarel whereby they went about to drawe the peoples hartes to them selues and to streÌ„gthen their owne faction stood in three points as appeareth by their excuses and by their pretensed Proclamations The first was to deliuer the Quene from the Earle Bothwel who violently deteined her and to preuent daungers imminent to her person The second to reuenge the Kings death vpon the said Bothwel whom they knew as they pretended to haue ben the principal doer in the execution of the said murther The thirde was to preserue the yonge Prince the Queenes sonne This is their ioly and holy pretense Nowe let vs see how conformable their worthy procedinges are to these their colourable cloked holy collusions The first gentle and humble admonition that these good louing subiectes gaue her to refourme these surmised enormities was in â—attail array at Bortwike Castle which they thought vpon the sodaine to haue possessed with the Queenes person Wherevpon they being disapointed therof gat into the Town and Fortresse of Edenboroug by the treason of Balfoure the Captaine thereof and of Cragmiler the Prouost of the Citie whereby they being the more animated to follow and prosecute their wicked enterprise begaÌ„ now to be strong in the field The Queene hauing also a good stroÌ„g army and thinking her self wel able therby to encounter with th' enemie and to represse their furious outrage yet notwithstaÌ„ding for the great loue and pitie she had to them though rebellious subiects willing as muche as in her lay to kepe and preserue their blood from sheding offred them faire of her owne free motion that if they would vse her as their Queene she would peaceably come to them and take due and conuenient order for the redresse of al suche thinges as might appeare by law and reason mete to be refourmed Wherevpon the Lorde Grange was sent by the Lordes to her who in al their names moste humbly vppon his knees assured her of al dewe obedience of securitie anâ— safetie of both her life and honour And ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ the good Ladie her conscience bearing heâ— witnes of al her iust and vpright dealingeâ— and therfore nothing mistrusting dismissing her army yelded her self to the Lordes whâ— conueyed her to Edenborough and there set her at suche a meruelous libertie and ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ suche securitie and safetie that al good meâ— to the worlds ende wil wonder at their exceding good loyaltie First they keping her owne Palaice seâ— and placed her in a merchants house and vsed her otherwise very homely She now considering and perceauing to what ende these matters tended most pitifully cried and called vpon them to remember their late promisse or at the least that she might be brought before the Counsaile offering to stande to the order and direction of the States of the realme But God knoweth al in vaine For now had they the pray whereon they inteÌ„ded to whet their bluddy teeth ere they did dismisse or forgoe her as the euent doth declare Wherefore in the night priuily she was conueyed and with haste in disguised apparel to the strong Forte of Lochleuen and after a few daies being stripâ—ed out and spoyled of al her princely atâ—rement was clothed with a course broune â—assoke After this these good loial subiects praâ—ising and encreasing more and more daily â—he performance of their saied promised â—bedience neuer ceassed vntil they had vsurped the ful authoritie and Regiment of the whole Into the which though they had intruded themselues yet seing as blinde as they were by disordinate vnseemely and vnmeasurable ambition that the Queene remained and was stil Queene and that there was no iust cause by the ordinarie course of the lawe or for any her demerits and deserts to bring her forth to her trial that she might be conuicted and deposed went like good honest plaine men and wel meaning subiects bluntly to worke and coÌ„sulted and determined to dispatche and rid her out of her life vnlesse she would yelde to them and subscribe suche writinges as they would send to her concerning the dimission of her Croune to her sonne and the Regiment of the Realme to the Earle of Murray Wherevpon th' Earle of Athele Secretâ—rie Ledington with other principals of theiâ— factious band sent Robert Miluen to Lochâ—leuen to wil her in any ease if she sought the safegard of her life to coÌ„descend to such demaundes and set her hand to al such writinges as should be proposed and broughâ— to her Whiche as they said to doe neuâ— could be preiudicial to her being by forâ—â— and violence extorted Sir Nicolas Throgmorton also being then Ambassadour theâ—â— from England gaue her the

the couÌ„tenance and maintenance of a Kingdom is mere vaine and altogether nedelesse For why should you thus feare hauing such a noble Queene lineally descending froÌ„ the Roial race of the noble Kinges of ScotlaÌ„d and inheriting the Croune therof of right she hauing bisides God be thaÌ„ked therfore so goodly a noble Impe when the time and law calleth him therto to succede his mother vnlesse that you be M. Knoxes owne good scholers and such of his affinitie that haue set vp and erected a ioly new schole as we haue declared teaching that it is not lauful for a woman Prince to haue Ciuil Gouernment These and many the like thinges would this good and gratious Impe reasonably and like a good natural louing childe tel and reproue you of if he were of discretioÌ„ and intelligeÌ„ce to weigh and coÌ„sider your strange procedings and diuellish dealinges against his most deare and tender mother Yea he would tel you that his mothers inestimable and vnmeasurable benefits were wel and worthely employed and bestowed vppon suche a wicked and vngrate generation He would also say and tel you that you should purchase your selues smal renoune and litle reward of God or of the world for this your false fained patieÌ„ce in heariÌ„g your selues called and that ful worthely traitors and Rebelles No more surely then if ye had hard as now ye must for this dainty dish we haue reserued for you to the last course and so proued withal the deuisers and procurers of the shameful vile vilanous murther of the noble yonge Lorde the Lorde Darley your owne Mastresse and Queenes most dere husband Whose tender hart neuer any worldily thing so nigh and so depely pearced as did this mischieuous note Ye triumph and vaunt of your glorious victorie and of the vnmerciful slaughter that you haue made vpon the Queenes most louing loyal and faithful subiects Ye valew measure and rule thereby the goodnes and equitie of your quarel and cause But this rule doth not alwaies holde as neuer hauing exception and instance The Israelites quarel against the Tribe of Beniamin rising vppon a trueth and horrible facte perpetrated and commited by the Gabaonits whome the Beniamits did defende and not vpon false fayned doinges and outragious ambition as yours doth against your Souereigne was a thousand times better and more iust then is this your pretensed quarel and seditious vprore And yet the Beniamits gaue them a sore greeuous and pitiful ouerthrow And surely it were no il counsayle for â—ou to remember withal the olde saying â—spice finem take good hede what may fal â—â—t at the ende Ye do litle weigh and conâ—ider the greate prouidence of almighty God in this facte whereby he seemeth to â—une prouided suche an indifferent way â—nd so free from al sinister suspition for the â—rouf and iustification of the Queenes inâ—ocencie and integritie and for the mainteâ—â—nce and preseruation of her name and â—onour the which she estemeth and preferreth afore al earthly thinges and for your â—tter confusion and shame the like wherof could not by man be found What shal I then say to you How shal I beginne or wherein to accuse you Surely I may wel cry out O heaueÌ„ Ã´ earth Ã´ God Ã´ man Hearken hearkeÌ„ to such a heighnous diuelish deuice and drift as doubtlesse neither Tragedy nor any record of Antiquitie can lightly report a more heinous HearkeÌ„ I say to this detestable and abhominable facte Hearken of subiectes that haue consented vnto and caused their owne Princes Husband to be slaine and not contented to enioye their owne impunitie of so horrible and greeuouse a crime haue sought and inueÌ„ted meanes and waies willingly and wâ—â— tingly to haue slandered therewithal theâ— most innocent Maistresse and Souereignâ— and haue most wrongfully and ful iniuriouâ—ly cast her in prison and spoiled her of aâ— her Princely estate being in a readines eueâ— ry howre to haue bereaued her of her liâ— and al and as they haue of them selues reâ— ported haue bene of nothing more repeâ— tant and sorie then that they haue not fullâ— executed their purposed mischiefe We say then no lesse boldly then truely First that the Queene for this facte is far frâ— al fault We say next that ye Murray anâ— your companions are the very deuisers and coÌ„triuers of the murther of this noble geÌ„tle man your selues But to disclose and opeâ— these matters at the ful it requireth a very large scope and discourse Yet wil we aâ— briefly as the cause wil suffer prosecute the same For the first part that may suffice that we haue already declared and shal here after declare for her innocencie Now before we procede to the seconde for the more euident and open condeÌ„nation of these men let vs imagine that to be done that neuer was thought of her parte to be â—one Let vs imagine and suppose that the Quene was therin guilty as these men most â—lsely and slanderously report yet are all â—hese their procedings of no validitie or â—orce and she remaineth stil their Queene â—nd in her fulauthoritie by good reason and â—awe The zeale to punnish greate crimes is â—oÌ„mendable so it be measured by order and â—â—we For as Aristotle saith It is not inough ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ do ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ a good dede vnlesse it be ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ wel done also The one whereof respecteth â—he fact the other the forme manner and faâ—hion the qualitie meanes and order of the â—oing thereof Quia forma datesse rei This â—orme and fasshioÌ„ of wel doing hath not ben obserued in your procedings For it can not â—e wel done that is vnlawfully and disorâ—erly done If it had ben but a pore priuate mans cause for the lacke of dew and conueâ—ient forme in the treating and handling thereof the whole procedinges had ben of none effecte or purpose The lawes of wel ordered coÌ„mon wealthes especially the Ciâ—il lawe the Principal and Mastresse of all other Ciuil policies and ordinances do reâ—uire in aliudgements to be geueÌ„ against the â—efendaÌ„t three seueral and distinct persons the Iudge the Accuser and the witnesseâ— The defendant hath the benefit of iust anâ— lawful exceptions aswel against the Iudgeâ— as against the Accusers and witnesses Echâ— of whom may be reiected for open enimâ—â— toward the Defendant and for diuers otheâ— causes Accusers may be repulsed some â—â— that they haue receaued a singuler benesâ— of the partie defendant as a bondeman mâ— numitted and made free in case he wil aâ— cuse his patrone and manumisser or if a maâ— wil accuse his educatour and bringer vppâ—â— Some for nearnes in blood and consanguâ— nitie as the brother Some for naughtâ— and infamous behauiour and some for otheâ— respectes Shal these vngrateful Traitours then thaâ— iustly neither can be Iudge nor accuser noâ— asmuche as witnesse against their Souâ— reigne and to them a most gratious Quene by any reason or lawe play them selues aâ— the three parts in the Tragedie

sufficiently serue him for the aduauncement of his coÌ„mendation and praise and for the significatioÌ„ of his fine politike head and inuentioÌ„ I meane for that before his departure out of Scotland into France with his Matchiauels practises he had so conningly coÌ„triued the whole matter with his faction that they should procure not only the Earle Bothwel to be acquited of the murther but for his good seruice to be rewarded with the Quenes espousalles intending by this mischieuous policie the vtter vndoing and ouerthrow aswel of him the Earle Bothwel as of the Q. her self also There neuer lacked good wil in them aâ— it wel appeareth by their vngratious doing to haue long before ouerthrowen their faâ—â— Maistresse but there euer lacked apparent matter to blinde mens eyes withal and to make her odiouse with the people Now these wily men wel knew that if they mighâ— once compasse and bring this mariage to passe with the Earle whome they intended then as fast to blase abrode for the murther by him committed as they did suppresse the same before from their good Ladie and Queene vntil they had brought her to the baite it would seeme very probable not only to the eyes and iudgemeÌ„t of the rude and coÌ„mon people but also of many sage graue wise and learned men that she was priuie oâ— her husbands death Whereby they might pretende one execrable acte against her that al men would detest and abhorre to colour and cloke their rebellious treacheries Lucifer him self could not haue fetched a finer and a more mischieuous and diuelish fetche then herein these men haue done As for the Earle Murraies absence it doth nothing releaue or excuse him yea it is â—ingulerly to be noted and marked that his â—ery iourneyes lacke not their fine fetches â—o serue his turne Through his first iorney â—nto France he wan and purchased the high â—ue and fauour of his benigne Maistresse â—e returneth out of England at the very point seruing two turnes at once by th' one thereof to circumuent his good innocent â—adie thinkiÌ„g to make her beleue by reason of his absenc ethat he was farre from the societie of that conspiracie by the other to â—ssist the better with his presence the conâ—ederates and sodenly to ioyne with them as he did I graunt that he was absent bodyly at the facte doing but yet nothing was done the whiche was not by his counsel or agrement concluded The which his deuise was so horrible that it caused the murther of his Souereignes Secretarie her imprisonment by her owne husbande that the Queene being greate with childe was put in suche a feare as might haue tended to the present danger of her life and of her childe Yea the very scope of this diuelish drift was euen to haue ouerthroweÌ„ him also whome they made their vnhappie and vnlucky instrument to ouerthrowe and depose his owne louing wife and moste dread Souereigne These mysteries ful stuffed with such mischieuous purposes lo wrought this Earle in this time of his absence Now it is to be considered that about sixtene houres before the Lorde Darley was slayne the better to colour the matter he departed from the court About twoo monethes after he toke his iourney into France leauing the Earle Bothwel as his most entier and trusty frinde recommending al his causes and affaires to him before al other At his second returne from France he intrudeth himselfe into the Scepter Roial vnder the name and shadowe of the yonge Prince The which thing was so imagined inuented and deuised long ere that he departed and in his absence by his trustie frinds remaining in Scotland accordingly accomplished and executed The Queene was afterward apprehended and cast into prison at LochleueÌ„ where his mother and brother dwelleth vnto the which Fortresse she should haue ben sent as we haue said at the first coÌ„spiracie of the said Murray if their malitious mind and intent had not ben disapointed by the prouidence of God. Now what searche when and after what sorte it was made for the said Earle Bothwel we haue already declared If ye alleage farther and say that no man can denie but that the said Earle Murray made also long diligent and narrow search for the murtherers and did seuerely punish them to this we replie and say that he needed not to trauaile muche or farre for the sewing out of this matter For he might at al times haue found the heades of the conspiratours vpon the Earle Murtons and his owne shoulders We say farther that as it is a strange and new kind of deuotion in the Earle Murray so to quarel for lacke of soleÌ„nitie at the burial of him for whose said burial he longed and loked for so long so we say likewise that it seemeth wonderful to loue him so tenderly being deceased and dead whome he so depely hated liuing And to seke so seriously and seuerely to punish the murtherers of him whome he would so oft haue murthered him selfe This geare seemeth to vs poore simple and slender witted men vnlikely incredible and halfe repugnant to nature And whatsoeuer the cause be we be of that minde that it is not likely to procede of any feruent zeale or greate affection he beareth to the partie or to the execution of Iustice Ye are good Reader desirous peraduenture to learne what other cause there might be of so strange dealing Wel as strange as it is we lacke not examples of the like craftie and subtile policie as well in holy Scripture and in the monumentes of Antiquitie of diuers other Countries as of Englande and especially of Scotlande it selfe We finde then in Holy Scripture that there was one Onias at Hierusalem the High Priest a man of singuler vertue and perfection and one that meruelousely tendered Gods honour and the honour and wealth of his Countrey There was also at the same time one Simon a very euil disposed and wicked creature whiche went about certaine naughty and wicked deuises But seeing that he could not atchiue his mischieuous purpose by reason this blessed man Onias stayed stopped and preuented him he practiseth this wicked deuise He causeth Kinge Seleucus to be infourâ—ed of the great and inestimable treasure remaining and reposed in the Temple at Hierusalem Wherevpon the King sent Heliodorus to fetch away by force the said treasure But afterward when this purpose chaunted to be frustrated and voide by reason that this Heliodorus being wonderfully plagued of God was constreined to forbeare and relinquish this enterprise and the people also wonderfully offended and in a great rage to see such a heinous sacrilege attempted what doth now thinke ye this good and honest man Simon Surely he plaieth the same parte that the Earle Murray hath played with his most gratious Queene opeÌ„ly charging the good innocent Onias with his owne shamefull acte and saying that he solicited and incensed the King to robbe and spoile the Temple We find in the Chronicles of our Realme that albe

princeâ— qualities resplendent in her with maâ— whereof she is much adorned and singuleâ—ly endued that they haue in most earneâ— wise solicited and entreated that she mighâ— be restored againe to her honour anâ— Croune They haue moued the said Quenâ— of Scotland also that it may please her to accept and like of the most noblest man of all England betwene whome and her there might be a mariage concluded to the quieting and comforte of both the Realmes of England and Scotland Finally the noblemen of this our Realme acknowledge and accept her for the very true and right heire apparent of this Realm of England being fully minded and alwaies ready when God shal so dispose to receaue and serue her as their vndoubted Queene Maistresse and Souereigne whereby it may easely appeare howe wel they like of her cause that had the hearing and trial of the same although they neuer as yet came in her presence These things now and many other which for the eschuing of prolixitie we forbeare to enlarge our Treatise with may be alleaged for the defence of the Queenes integritie and for the vprightnes of her cause the whiche I would wishe you the Earles Murray and Murton with your allied confederats before al other most depely and bytimes to weigh and consider accordingly as thâ— weight and greatnes of the cause as your owne safety with the welth and honor of your owne natiue Countrey do require I am not ignorant that the matter is gone very farre with you and that many impedimentes doe concurre to withdraw you to seeke that remedy for reformation of things past which is the best and the only remedy But surely when ye haue fully weighed al thinges on euery side accordingly ye shall finde no sure and sound remedie but in making a true a sincere and an vnfained huÌ„ble submission to your gratious Queene whom ye haue so greeuously offended and molested Let not the greatnes or number of your treasons wrought against both your Quene and CouÌ„trey let not any vaine false imagined opinioÌ„ either of the shame of the world or of your vtter ouerthrowe by reason of suche fond presumption of your present high estate of your great power force and strength let no vaine expectation of external succours stay or stop you from so necessarie a duetie and so commendable before God and the worlde Ye best knowe that among al the Princely ornamentes and vertues of your Queene her mercy and clemeÌ„cy are singuler and peerlesse She seemeth well to haue learned that lesson of the Gospel If thy brother doe offend thee forgeue him not onely seauen times but seanenty times seauen times She will not onely forgeue but forget also She neither is ignorant in what state her Realme standeth in nor that extreme seueritie from the which she naturally abhorreth is not of al other times now against suche as wil imbrace mercie offered to them to be shewed and practised She wil rather like the lawe of ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ ã€ˆâ—Šã€‰ obliuion and forgetfulnes so much of the Writers commended The great benefite wherof ye haue so often and so abundantly receaued at her handes And therfore ye neede the lesse to feare the discontinuance of your high and honourable estate and condition As for shame it standeth in the euil doing it self and not in the amending and reforming of il deedes which amendement and reformation if ye earnestly and truely mind it wil be to the great contentation of your most gratious Queene and of al her louing subiects And in so doing you shal both highly auaunce your honourable estate and estimation and make her a good amends for that which is past and can not be reuoked But on the other side if ye geue ouer and refuse this occasion now present and go forward with your rebellious enterprises and attempts minding to abide and trie the vttermoste ye must wilfully cut away and exclude from your selfe al good hope of mercie and pardoÌ„ and take a wrong way for your owne saftie and preseruation For your cause is naught and so ye well know it to be And therfore can ye not loke to haue and obteine a good prosperous successe and ende thereof Wel ye may as hitherto ye haue done tosse turmoile and tumble al thinges vpside dounewards for a while but be ye assured that Gods hande wil fal and light the heuier and with a greater paise vpon you at the length therefore It is easy to be seen by the course of all times aswel by your owne very Stories at home as by the Chronicles of all other Nations abrode to what ende commonly such seditious conspiracies and treasons do come to that is to the vtter ouerthrow and confusion for euer of those persons that worke attempt practise and mainteine the same They seeme for a while to beare great sway and al the world for a while to runne with them but in the ende they faile and are cleane geuen ouer What meruaile were it if a house should not long continue that is builded but vpon a yelding sandy grounde Ye haue builded and founded al your doinges vpon vntrue and lying slauÌ„ders and treacherous treasons against your dread Souereigne The sincere veritie whereof we haue herein truely declared The which being once throughly detected and euidently knowen to such as ye haue in Scotland craftily abused and shamefully circumuented as surely it daily bursteth out more and more ye shal see your selues sodenly leaft naked and quite forsaken euen of those who haue bene your greatest assisters aiders and furtherers For as the old prouerbe is Trueth is the daughter of time And as ye shal be leaft alone at home so can ye not looke for maintenance and vpbearing of foraine Prinâ—es They wil not defile them selues and their honourable vocation with helping so foule a cause and so dangerous and perilous a matter that may tende to the molestation and hurt not only of their owne state but of the states of all Kinges Christened Nay ye must rather thinke that otheâ— Princes wil iudge and take it to touch theâ— to nigh to suffer such a vilanie to passe anâ— escape vnreuenged and so good a Ladie tâ— be left destitute and desolate The Emperouâ— wil not beare it France wil not beare iâ— Spaine wil not beare it And especially England with her worthy Nobilitie wil noâ— beare or suffer such outragious dealinges against their next louiÌ„g neighbour yea againâ—â— the heire appareÌ„t of this most noble Realmeâ— albe it that ye with your surmised lyes the better to mainteine your vsurped and new erected Kingdome put others in feare oâ— their owne state in case the said innocent Queene should be restored to her Croune againe FINIS the teares of an english hart And his soden arryuall here with all the maner and circumstances thereof would yeelde nevve argumeÌ„ts of an other much loÌ„ger discourse For first his coÌ„ming hither as it vver in a maske bewraies a strange melancholik

bereaue vs of the present Gouernour the hartes and iudgementes of men being no better nor more firmely setled and fixed towards the expectation of a certaine succession then they seme now to be then wo and alas it yrketh my verie harte euen onse to thincke vpon the imminente and almost the ineuitable daunger of this our noble Realme beinge like to be ouerwhelmed with the raging and roring waues of mutual discorde and to be consumed with the terrible fier of ciuil disceÌ„tion The feare whereof is the more by reason already in these later yeares some flames thereof haue sparkled and flusshed abrode and some parte of the rage of the sayd fluddes haue already beaten vpoÌ„ the bankes I meane the hot contention that hath bene therein in so many places and among so many persons of bookes also that haue bene spread abrode and daily are spread being framed affectionately and sounding according to the sinister opinion of euery mans priuate appetite Seing therefore that there is iust cause of feare and of great danger likely to happen by this varietie of mens iudgementes so diuersely affected as wel of meane men as of greate personages I take it the parte of euery true Englishman to labour ad trauaile eche man for his possibilitie and for suche talente as God hath geuen him to helpe in conuenient tyme for the preuenting of the imminent daunger We knowe what wit what policie what paines what charges menne imploie to prouide that the Temmes or sea doo not ouerflowe such places as be moste subiecte to daunger We knowe what politike prouision is made in many good Cities and townes both to foresee that by negligence there ryse no dangerouse fiers and yf they chaunce with al diligence to represse the rage thereof Wherein among other his prudente dooinges Augustus the Emperour is commended for appointing at Rome seuen companies ordinarily to watche the Citie for the purpose aforesaide Wherevnto he was enduced by reason the Citie was in one daye in seuen seuerall places sette on fier And shal not we euery man for his his parte and vocation haue a vigilant care and respecte to the extinguishement of this fier already sprong out that may if the matter be not wisely foreseen destroie subuert and consume not one Citie onely but importe an vniuersall calamitie and destruction Which to represse one ready and good way seemeth vnto me if men may knowe and be throughly persuaded in what person the right of the succession of the Croune of this our Realme doth stande and remaine For now many men through ignorance of the said Right and Title and also the same being depraued by certaine sinister persuasions in some bookes wherevnto they haue to lightly geuen creditte be caried away from the right opinion and good hart that they otherwise would and should haue The whiche kind of men I doo hartely wishe from their said corrupte iudgemente to be reuoked and shal in this Treatise doo my beste indeuour to remoue not presuming vpon my self that I am any thing better able then others this to do for I knowe my owne infirmitie but being glad and willing to impart vnto others such motiues as vpon the reading of such bookes which of late haue ben set forth by the Aduersaries and after the diligent weying of diuers argumentes to the contrarie seeme vnto me sufficient to satisfie any honest and indifferent man that is not obstinately bent to his owne wilfull affections or to some other sinister meaning and dealing We say then and affirme that the right Heire and Successour apparent vnto the Croune of this Realme of England is at this time such a one as for the excellent giftes of God and nature in her most princely appearing is worthie to inherit either this noble Realm or any other be it of much more dignitie and worthines But nowe I claime nothing for the worthines of the person whiche God forbid should be any thing preiudiciall to the iuste title of others Yf most open and manifeste right iustice and title do not concurre with the worthines of the person then let the praise and worthines remaine where it is and the right where God and the lawe hath placed it But seing God Nature and the law doth call the person to this expectation whose interest and claime I do now prosequute I meane the right excelleÌ„t Ladie Ladie Marie Queene of Scotlande I hope that when her right and iuste title shal be throughly heard and coÌ„sidered by the indifferent Reader if he be persuaded already for her right he shal be more firmely setled in his true and good opinion and that the other parties being of a contrarie minde shall finde good causes and groundes to remoue them from the fame and to geue ouer and yelde to the truthe Her Graces Title then as it is moste open and euidente so it is moste conformable to the lawe of God of Nature and of this Realme And coÌ„sequently in a manner of all other Realmes in the worlde as growing by the nearest proximitie of the Roial blood She is a Kinges and a Queenes daughter her selfe a Queene daughter to the late King Iames of Scotlande sonne to Ladie Margarete the eldest Syster to our late Soueraigne Kyng Henrie the Eight Whose daughter also the Ladie Lenoux is but by a later husbande the Ladie Frauncis late wife to Henrie Marques Dorsette afterwarde Duke of Suffolke and the Ladie Elenour late wife to the Earle of Cumberlande and their Progenie proceedeth from the Ladie Marie Dowager of France yongest Sister of the said King Henrie late wife to Charles Brandon Duke of Suffolke I might here fetche foorth olde farne dayes I might reache backe to the noble and worthie Kinges long before the Conquest of whose Roial blood she is descended Whiche is no parte of our purpose neither doth enforce her Title more then to prooue her no stranger within this Realme But the Argumentes and prouffes which we meane to alleage and bring forth for the confirmation of her right and Title in Succession as Heire apparent to the Croune of England are gathered and grouÌ„ded vpon the lawes of God and nature and not only receaued in the Ciuill policies of other nations but also in the olde lawes and Customes of our owne Countrey by reason approued and by vsage and long continuance of time obserued from the first constitution of this Realme in politicall order vnto this present day And yet for al that hath it bene and yet is by some men attempted artificially to obiecte and caste many mystie darke cloudes before mennes eyes to kepe from them if it may be the cleare light of the said iust title the which they would extinguish or at the least blemish with some obscure shadow of lawe but in deede against the lawe and with the shadowe of Parlamentes but in deede against the true meaning of the Parlamentes And albe it it were inough for vs our cause being so firmely and suerly establisshed vppon al

Liberi Therefore doo we supply it as wel as we may by this worde children The Spaniardes also vse this worde Infantes in this ample sorte when they call the nexte heire to the heire appareÌ„t Infant of Spaine euen as the late deceased Lorde Charles of Austrich was called his father and grandfather then liuing Yf then the original word of the statute declaring the said rule may naturally and properly apperteine to al the Descendants why should we straine and binde it to the first degree only otherwise then the nature of the worde or reason wil beare For I suppose verely that it wil be very harde for the Aduersarie to geue any good and substantial reason why to make a diuersitie in the cases But touching the contrarie there are good and probable consideratioÌ„s which shall serue vs for the seconde cause As for that the graÌ„dfathers cal their nephewes as by a more pleasant plausible name not only their children but their sonnes also and for that the sonne being deceased the graÌ„dfather suruiuing not only the graÌ„dfathers affection but also such right title and interest as the sonne hath by the lawe and by proximitie of blood growe and drawe al to the nephew who representeth and supplieth the fathers place the father and the sonne being compted in person and in flesh in maner but as one Why shal then the bare and naked consideration of the external and accidental place of the birth only seuer and sunder suche an entier inwarde and natural coniunction Adde therevnto the many and great absurdities that may hereof spring and ensue Diuerse of the Kinges of this Realme as wel before the time of King Edwarde the third in whose time this statute was made as after him gaue their daughters out to foraine and sometimes to meane Princes in mariage Which they would neuer so often times haue done if they had thought that whyle they wente about to set forth and aduance their issue their doinges should haue tended to the disheriting of them from so great large and noble a Realme as this is which might haue chanced if the daughter hauing a sonne or daughter had died her father liuing For there should this supposed Maxime haue ben a barre to the children to succede their grandfather This absurditie would haue bene more notable if it had chanced about the time of King Henry the secoÌ„d or this king Edward or king Henry the firste and sixte when the possessions of the Croune of this Realme were so amply enlarged in other Countries beyond the seas And yet neuer so notable as it might haue bene hereafter in our fresh memorie and remeÌ„brance if any such thing had chanced as by possibilitie it might haue chanced by the late mariage of King Philippe and Queene Marie For admitting their daughter maried to a foraine Prince should haue dyed before them she leauing a sonne suruiuing his father and grandmother they hauing none other issue so nigh in degree then would this late framed Maxime haue excluded the same sonne lameÌ„tably and vnnaturally from the succession of the Croune of Englande and also the same Croune from the inheritance of the Realmes of Spain of both Sicilies with their appurtenaÌ„ces of the DukedoÌ„ of Milan and other landes and DominioÌ„s in Lumbardy and Italie as also from the Dukedomes of Brabant LuxeÌ„burg Geldres Zutphan Burgundie Friseland from the Countreies of Flandres Artois Holland ZealaÌ„d and Namurs and from the new found lands parcel of the said Kingdome of Spaine* Which are vnlesse I be deceued more ample by dubble or treble then al the Countreies now rehearsed Al the which Countreies by the foresaid Mariage should haue bene by al right deuolued to the said sonne if any such child had bene borne If either the same by the force of this iolye newe found Maxime had bene excluded from the Croune of England or the saide Croune from the inheritance of the foresaid Countreies were there any reason to be yelded for the maintenance of this supposed rule or Maxime in that case Or might there possibly rise any commodity to the Realme by obseruing therein this rigorous pretensed rule that should by one hundred part counteruaile this importable losse and spoile of the Croune and of the lawful inheritour of the same But perchance for the auoiding of this exception limited vnto the blood roial some wil say that the same was but a priuilege graunted to the Kinges children not in respect of the succession of the Croune but of other landes descending to them from their Auncestours Whiche although we might very wel admit and allow yet can it not be denied but that the same priuilege was grauÌ„ted vnto the Kinges children and other descendantes of the Blood roial by reason of the dignity and worthines of the Croune which the King their father did enioy and the great reuerence which the law geueth of dewtie therevnto And therefore if ye would go about to restraine and withdraw from the Croune that priuilege whiche the lawe geueth to the Kinges children for the Crounes sake ye should doo therein contrarie to al reason and against the rules of the Arte of Reasoning which saith that Propter quod vnumquodque illud magis Byside that I would faine knowe by what reason might a man saye that they of the Kinges Bloodde borne out of the allegeaunce of Englande maye inherite landes within this Realme as heires vnto their Ancestours not being able to inherite the Croune Truly in mine opinion it were against al reason But on the contrarie side the very force of reason muste driue vs to graunt the like Yea more great and ample priuilege and benefit of the law in the succession of the Croune For the Roial blood where so euer it be found wil be taken as a pretious and singuler Iewel and wil carie with it his worthie estimation and honour with the people and where it is dew his right withal By the Ciuil law the right of the inheritance of priuate persons is hemmed and inched within the bandes of the tenth degre The Blood roial runneth a farther race and so farre as it may be found wherewith the great and mightie Conquerors are glad and faine to ioine withal euer fearing the weaknes of their blooddie sworde in respect of the greate force and strength of the same For this cause was Henrie the firste called for his learning and wisedome Beauclerke glad to consociate and couple him self with the auncient Roial blood of the Saxons which coÌ„tinuing in the Princely SuccessioÌ„ from worthie king Alured was cutte of by the death of the good king Edward and by the mariyng of Mathildis being in the fourth degree in lineal descent to the said king Edward was reuiued and revnited From this Edward the Queene of ScotlaÌ„d as we haue before shewed taketh her noble auncieht Petigrue These then and diuers other reasons and causes mo may be alleaged for the waying and setting foorth of the true meaning

and remaining beyond the sea in the custody of the said Constance yet of this fact being against al Iustice aswel the said Archbishop as also many of th' other did after most earnestly repent considering the cruel and the vniust putting to death of the said Arthur procured and after some Authours committed by the said Iohn himself Which most foul aÌ„d shamful act the said Iohn neded not to haue committed if by foraine birth the said Arthur had beÌ„ barred to inherit the Croune of England And much lesse to haue imprisoned that most innocent Ladie Elenor sister to the said Arthur in Bristow Castle wher she miserably ended her life if that gay Maxime would haue serued to haue excluded these two childreÌ„ bicause thei wer straÌ„gers borne in the partes beyond the seas Yea it appeareth in other doings also of the said time and by the storie of the said Iohn that the birth out of the legeaÌ„ce of England by father aÌ„d mother foram was not takeÌ„ for a sufficieÌ„t repulse and reiectioÌ„ to the right and title of the Croune For the BaroÌ„s of EnglaÌ„d being then at dissension with the said King Iohn and renouÌ„cing their allegeance to him receaued Lewis the eldest sonne of Philip the FreÌ„ch king to be their King in the right of Blanch his wife whiche was a stranger borne albe it the lawful Neece of the said Richard and daughter to Alphonse king of Caâ—til begotten on the bodie of Elenour his wife one of the daughters of king Henrie the second and sister to the said king Richard and king Iohn Which storie I alleage only to this purpose thereby to gather the opinion of the time that foraine birth was then thought no barre in the Title of the Croune For otherwise how could Lewis of FraÌ„ce preteÌ„d title to the Croune in the right of the said Bblach his wife borne in Spaine These examples are sufficient I suppose to satisfie and content any man that is not obstinatly wedded to his own fond fantasies and froward friuolous imaginatioÌ„s or otherwise worse depraued for a good sure and substantial interpretation of the coÌ„mon law And it were not altogether from the purpose here to consider and weigh with what and how greuous plagues this Realme hath bene oft afflicted and scourged by reason of wrongful and vsurped titles I wil not reuiue by odious rehearsal the greatenes and number of the same plagues as wel otherwise as especially by the contention of the noble houses and families of York and Lancaster seeing it is so fortunately and almost within mans remeÌ„brance extinct and buried I wil now put the gentle Reader in remembrance of those only with whose vsurping Titles we are nowe presently in hand And to begyn with the most auncieÌ„t what became I pray you of Harold that by briberie and helpe of his kinred vsurped the Croune against the foresaid yong Eadgar who as I haue said and as the old monumeÌ„ts of our Historiographers do plainly testifie was the true and lawful Heire Could he thinke you enioy his ambitious and naughty vsurping one whole entier yere No surely ere the first yeare of his vsurped reigne turned about he was spoiled and turned out both of Croune and his life withal Yea his vsurpation occasioned the conquest of the whole realme by WilliaÌ„ Duke of NormaÌ„die bastard sonne to Robert the sixt Duke of the same And may we thinke al safe and sound now from like danger if we should tread the said wrong steppes with Harolde forsaking the right and high way of law and iustice What shal I now speake of the cruel ciuil warres betwene King Stephen and King Henry the second whiche warres rose by reason of the said Henry was vniustly kept froÌ„ the Croune dew to his mother Maude and to him afterwardes The pitiful reigne of the said Iohn who doth not lament with the lamentable losse of Normandie Aquitaine and the possibilitie of the Dukedome of Britanie and with the losse of our other goodly possessions in France whereof the Croune of England was robbed and spoiled by the vnlawful vsurping of him against his nephew Arthur Wel let vs leaue these greuouse and lothsome remembrances and let vs yet seeke if we may finde any later interpretation either of the said statute or rather of the coÌ„mon law for our purpose And lo the great goodnes and prouidence of God who hath if the foresaid exaÌ„ples would not serue prouided a later but so good so sure so apt and mete interpretatioÌ„ for our cause as any reasonable hart may desire The interpretatioÌ„ directly toucheth our case which I meane by the mariage of the Lady Margaret eldest daughter to King HeÌ„ry the vij vnto Iames the fourth KiÌ„g of ScotlaÌ„d and by the opinioÌ„ of the said most prudeÌ„t Prince in bestowing his said daughter into ScotlaÌ„d a ma ter sufficient inough to ouerthrow al those cauilling inueÌ„tioÌ„s of the aduersarie For what time King Iames the fourth sent his ambassadour to king HeÌ„ry the seueÌ„th to obteine his good wil to espouse the said Lady Margaret there were of his Counsaile not ignorant of the lawes and Customes of the Realme that did not wel like vpon the said Mariage saying it might so fal out that the right and Title of the Croune might be deuolued to the Lady Margaret and her childreÌ„ and the Realm therby might be subiect to ScotlaÌ„d To the whiche the prudent and wise King answered that in case any such deuolution should happen it would be nothing preiudicial to England For England as the chief and principal and worthiest part of the I le should drawe Scotland to it as it did Normandie from the time of the Conqueste Which answere was wonderfully wel liked of al the Counsaile And so consequâ—tly the mariage toke effect as appereth by Polydor the Historiographer of this Realm and such a one as wrote the Actes of the time by the instruction of the King him selfe I say then the worthy wise Salomon foreseeing that such deuolution might happen was an interpretour with his prudente and sage Counsaile for our cause For els they neaded not to reason of any such subiection to Scotlande if the children of the Ladie Margaret might not lawfully inherite the Croune of England For as to her husband we could not be subiect hauing him selfe no right by this mariage to the Title of the Croune of this Realme Wherevpon I may wel inferre that the said newe Maxime of these men whereby they would rule and ouer rule the succession of Princes was not knowen to the said wise King neither to any of his Counsaile Or if it were yet was it taken not to reache to his blood royall borne in Scotlande And so on euery side the Title of Quene Marie is assured So that now by this that we haue said it may easely be seen by what light and slender consideration the Aduersarie hath gone about to strayne the wordes Infantes or children to the first degree

oportet sed ad sinceram testimoniorum fidem testimonia quibus potius lux veritatis assistit It hath not lightly bene heard or sene that men of suche state and vocation in so great and weightie a cause would incurre first the displeasure of God then of their Prince and of some other of the best sorte if their depositions were vntrue and would purchase them selues dishonour slaunder and infamie yea disclose their owne shame to their owne no manner of way hoped coÌ„moditie nor to the commoditie of other their frendes or discommoditie and hurte of their enemies This sufficiently doth purge them I wil not say of their fact and fault from al sinister suspicion for this their deposition and testimonie their deposition proceding as it plainly seemeth from no affection corruption or partialitie but from a zeale to the trueth and to the honour of the Realme And though perchance if they had bene thereof iudicially conuicted and condemned and had not by dew penance themselues reformed some exceptioÌ„s might haue bene layed against them by any partie iudicially coÌ„uented for his better aduantage yet as the case standeth nowe there is no cause in the worlde to discredit their testimonie yea and by the way of accusation also such persons as be otherwise dishabled are in treason and other publike matters touching the state enhabled both to accuse and testifie As for the eleuen witnesses the beste of of them Sir Iohn Gates we know by what meanes he is departed out of this life One other the said William Clarke is so gone from them that he geueth good cause to misdeeme and mistrust the whole matter Howe many of the residue liue I know not To whom perchaunce some thing might be said if we once knowe what them selues say Which seeing it doth not by authentical recorde appeare bare names of dumme witnesses can in no wise hinder and deface so solemne a testimonie of the foresaid L. Paget and Sir Edwarde Mountague Neither is the difficultie so great as the Aduersaries pretend in prouing Negatiuam facti Which as we graunt it to be true when it standeth within the limites of a mere negatiue so being restrained and referred to time and place may be as wel proued as the affirmatiue It appeareth now then by the premisses that the Aduersaries argumentes whereby they would weaken and discredit the testimonie either of the witnesses or of the executours that haue or may come in against the said pretensed Wil are but of smal force and strength And especially their slender exaggeration by a superficial Rhetorike enforced Whereby they would abvse the ignorance of the people and make them beleue that there was no good and substantial prouffe brought foorth against the forgerie of this supposed Wil by cause the vntrueth of the same was not preached at Poules Crosse and declared in al open places and assembles through the Realme when they knowe wel inough that there was no necessitie so to doe And that it was notoriously knowen by reason it was disclosed by the saide Lorde Paget as wel to the Counsaile as to the higher and lower house of the Parlament And the foresaid forged Recorde in the Chancerie therevpon worthely defaced and abolished The disclosing whereof seing it came foorth by such and in such sort and order as we haue specified as it doth nothing deface or blemish the testimonie geuen against the said supposed Wil whether it were of any of the witnesses or executours so is ther no nede at al why any other witnesses bysides those that haue already impugned the same should be now farther producted I denie not but that if any such witnesse or Exeoutour had vpon his othe before a lawful Iudge deposed of his owne certaine notice and knoweledge that the said Wil was signed with the Kinges owne hande in case he should afterward contrarie and reuoke this his solemne deposition it ought not lightly to be discredited for any suche contradiction afterward happening But as I haue said suche authentical and ordinarie examinations and depositions we find not nor yet heare of any such so passed Now contrariwise if any of the said witnesses or executours haue or shal before a competeÌ„t Iudge especially not producted of any partie or against any partie for any priuate suite commenced but as I haue said moued of conscience only and of a zeale to truth and to the honour of God and the Realme freely and voluntarie discouer and detecte such forgerie although perchance it toucheth them selues for some thing done or said of them to the contrary or being called by the said coÌ„petent Iudge haue or shal declare and testifie any thing against the same this later testimonie may be wel credited by good reason and law Whereas they would nowe inferre that either this pretenfed Will was King Henries Wil or that he made none at al I doo not as I haue said entende nor neede not curiously to examine and discusse this thing as a mater not apperteining to our principal purpose And wel it may be that he made a Wil conteining the whole tenour of this pretensed Wil sauing for the limitation of the Croune and that these supposed witnesses were present either when he subscribed the same with his owne hand or when by his coÌ„maundment the Stampe of which and of his owne hand the common sort of men make no difference as in dede in diuers other cases there is no difference whiche these witnesses might take to be as it were his owne hand was set to the Wil. This I say might after some sort so be And yet this notwithstaÌ„ding there might be as there was in deede an other Wil touching the preteÌ„sed limitation of the Croune by the Kinges owne hande counterfeyted and suborned after his death falsly and coulorably bearing the couÌ„tenance of his owne hand and of the pretensed witnesses names How so euer it be it is but to smal purpose to goe about any full and exquisite answere touching this point seeing that neither the original surmised Wil whereof these witnesses are supposed to be priuy is extant nor their depositions any where appeare nor yet that it appeareth that euer they were as we haue said iudicially examined Seeing nowe then that if it so falleth out that the principal Wil and that that was by the great Seale exemplified and in the ChaÌ„cery recorded had not at least touching the clause of limitation and assignment of the Croune the Kings hand to it we neede not nor wil not tarie about certain scrolles and copies of the said Wil that the Aduersaries pretend to haue ben either writte or signed with his hand A kingdom is to heauy to be so easely caried away by suche scrolles and copies When al this faileth the Aduersaries haue yet one shift left for the last cast They vrge the equitie of the matter and the mind of the Parlament Which is they say accomplished and satisfied by making this assignation for

Selected quad for the lemma: cause_n

Text snippets containing the quad