eodem ¶ The .12 arti of penauÌ„ce or repeÌ„tauÌ„ce fo eod ¶ The .13 article of the vse of the sacramentes Fo. eodem ¶ The .14 article of order ecclesiastike fo eod ¶ The .15 article of rytes or vsages of the churche Fo. eodem ¶ The .16 arti of politike or ciuile mats fo ix ¶ The .17 article of the resurrection Fo. eod ¶ The .18 article of frewyll Fo. eodem ¶ The .19 article of the cause of synne Fo. x. ¶ The .20 article of good workes Fo. eod ¶ The .21 article of honoriÌ„g of saiÌ„tê Fo. xiii ¶ The articles in whiche are rehersed certeine abuses chaunged Fo. xiiii ¶ Of bothe kyndes Fo. eodem ¶ Of the mariage of prestes Fo. xv ¶ Of the Masse Fo. xvi ¶ Of confession Fo. xix ¶ Of diuersities of meates Fo. xx ¶ Of monasticall vowes Fo. xxiii ¶ Of the power of the churche Fo. xxviii ¶ Finis Tabule ⧠Imprynted at London in Fletestrete by me Robert Redman dwellynge at the sygne of the George nexte to saynt Dunstones Churche 1536. CVM PRIVILEGIO REGALI The Apologie that is to say the defense of the confessyon of the Germaynes made by Philip Melancthon and translated by Richard Tauerner at the commaundement of his mayster the ryght honorable mayster Thomas Crumwell chefe secretarie to the kyngê hyghnes CVM PRIVILEGIO ¶ Philip Melancthon to the reder sendeth gretynge AFter that the confessyon of our prynces was in open audience solempnely redde certaine diuines friars prepared a confutation of our wryting whiche whan the Emperours maiestie had caused to be solempnely red in the assemble of the prynces he requyred theÌ„ to assent vnto it But our prynces hearynge that many articles were there disproued whiche to renounce without grudge of conscieÌ„ce they coulde nat demauÌ„ded that a copy of the coÌ„futacion myght be to them exhibited to the entent that they myght bothe see what theyr aduersaries condempned and also refute their reasons And in suche cause whiche apperteyned to chrysten faythe and instruction of the conscience they thought that the aduersaries wolde nat haue made it straunge to exhibite theyr wrytyng But our rulers coulde in nowyse obtayne it onles they wolde haue bouÌ„de them selues to moste perelouse and vnegal coÌ„dicions whiche they coulde nat do excepte they wolde caste them selues into a manifest daunger After this there was publyshed a pacification in whiche appered that our hedes refused no burdayne were it neuer so payneful so that it myght be susteyned without offence of conscience But the aduersaries obstinatly required vs to allowe certaine manifest abuses and errours which thyng whan we myght nat do agayne the emperours maiestie requyred our prynces to assent to the confutacyon whiche to do our prynces vtterly refused For howe shulde they assent in a matter touchinge the faythe to the thynge that they neuer red And they herde that certayne articles were there coÌ„dempned in which thyng they coulde nat allowe the iudgement of the aduersaries without offence There were also certayne other whiche required me to make an Apologie or defense of the coÌ„fessyon in which shulde be expouned vnto themperour the causes why we receyued nat the confutacyon and the thinges soluted whiche the aduersaries obiected For there were certayne of vs whiche when theyr confutacion was red noted the suÌ„me of theyr places and argumentes This Apologie they offered at laste vnto the emperours maiestie to the entent that he myght knowe that most graue hyghe causes letted vs to allowe theyr confutacyon Howe be it the emperour receyued nat the boke that was offered hym After this cam forthe a proclamacion in whiche our aduersaries do triuÌ„phe that they haue confuted by scripture our confessyon Nowe therfore o gentle reader ye se our Apologie in whiche ye shall perceyue aswele the iudgemeÌ„t of our aduersaries for we haue faythfully reported it as theyr condempnacyon of certayne articles agaynst the manyfest scripture of the holy ghoste so farre be they wyde from defetyng our opinions by scriptures But all be it that in the begynnynge I made onely an Apologie yet nowe in my settyng it forthe in prynt I haue added other thynges And for that purpose I haue put to my name bycause they shulde make no cauillacion that the boke was published without any authour certayne This alway hathe bene my custome in suche controuersies that so muche as I myght lawfully do I wolde retayne the fourme of the vsed and accustomed doctryne to the entent that we myght the soner agre together Nor I do nat muche vnlyke at thys tyme all be it I myght iustly wade further in dissuadynge the people from the opinions of our aduersaries But our aduersaries do so haÌ„dle theyr matter that they shewe them selues neyther to seke trouthe nor concorde but to sup vp our blode Doubtles I haue nowe also wrytteÌ„ as soberly and moderately as I can but yet if any thyng shal seme to be spokeÌ„ ouer sharply I here protest that I contende with the diuines frears and nat with Cesar or the prynces whome as my dutie is I haue in hyghe estimacyon and regarde But I sawe lately theyr confutacion whiche I haue marked to be wrytten so capciously and slaunderously that in certaine places they may dysceyue yea the ware and cyrcumspecte readers Natwithstandyng I haue nat medlyd with all theyr cauilacyoÌ„s for that were an infinite worke but I haue comprised the chefe maters to the enteÌ„t that amonge all nacyons a testimonie of vs maye appere that our iudgement is ryght godly of the Euangel of Christe Discorde pleaseth nat vs. Nor our owne priuate peryll dothe nothinge moue vs whiche howe greate it is by reason of the vehemeÌ„t hatredes of our aduersaries kyndled agaynste vs we easely perceyue But we may nat renounce the manifest veritie and necessarie to the edificacion of the churche wherfore we thynke that all incommodities and peryls are to be susteyned and suffered for the glorye of Christe and profite of his churche trusting that God wyll allowe and accepte thys our office endeuour and moreouer we hope that our posteritie and successours shal haue of vs here after a better opinion and a more indifferent iudgement For it can nat be denyed but that many places of Christes doctryne which are moste necessarie to be notified and knowen in the churche be of vs and ours opened and clerely set forthe which here to fore with howe greate and perelouse opinions they were suppressed and hydde through deceitful friars lawyers and sophisticall diuines it lusteth me nat here to recite we haue the open testimonies of many good men which cease nat to rendre thankê to god for this most hyghe benefite that nowe many ryght necessary matters be better opened by vs than they were by our aduersaries here tofore taught or preached wherfore we shal commeÌ„de and coÌ„mytte our cause vnto Christe who shall another day iudge these debates and coÌ„trouersies whom we also humbly beseche to caste his tendre eyes vpon the afflicte
satisfy the laâ—e of god And besydes ther may be done â—orkes of superogation Therfore men maye nat only satisfy and fulfyll the lawe of god but also do more theÌ„ fulfyl it And because Monkes and Freers do more than fulfyl the lawe therfore they haue merites more then they nede them selues And because it is liberalalite to gyue vnto other of that whiche thou haste aboue thyne owne necessitie therfore they may gyue those merites to other men They deuise also a sacrament that is to say a wytnes and a marke of this gyuyng for wheÌ„ men be deade they put about them the habites of theyr relegious men to witnesse that other mens merites be applyed vnto them With suche coaceruatioÌ„s our aduersaries do deface the benefite of Christe and the iustice of faythe ⧠We do nat here rayse vp vayne pratyng about the worde But we stryue about a greate thiÌ„g that is to weâ—e wherof godly myndes ought to conceyue sure and vndoubted hope of saluation whether good workes maye set consciences at peace and quyetnes Whether they ought to thynke that eternall lyfe is so gotteÌ„ if they do set theyr good workes agaynste the iudgement of god orels they ought to thynke that through mercy for Christes sake they be reputed ryghtous do obtayne eternall lyfe These thyngê do come into controuersie whiche onleâ— the coÌ„science do discusse and iudge it can nat haue any stronge and sure consolation But we haue declared euideÌ„tly ynough that good workes do nat satisfie the lawe of god but that they haue nede of mercye that by faythe we be accepted with god for Christê sake also that good workes do nat set the coÌ„science at reste and peace Of all these thyngê it foloweth that we ought to thynke that for Christes sake through mercy and nat for the lawe they that be iustified do obtayne eternal lyfe What shall we say then as touchyng the name of rewarde Fyrste if we shulde say that eternall lyfe is called a rewarde because it is due to them that be iustified by reason of the promyse we shulde nat speake any thynge amysse For these gyftes be ordered among theÌ„ selues as AugustiÌ„ne sayeth Dona sua coronat deus in nobis .i. God crowneth rewardeth hys owne gyftes in vs. But the scripture calleth eternal lyfe a rewarde nat because it is due for our workes but because it dothe recompense the affections and workes albeit yet it is gyuen for another cause Lykewyse as the inheritaunce commeth to the good mans sonne of the howse nat for his owne workes or seruice and yet neuertheles it is a rewarde and recoÌ„pense of the warkes and seruice of the son It is sufficieÌ„t therfore that the name of rewarde dothe for thys cause agre to eternall lyfe be cause eternall lyfe dothe recompence good workes and afflictions Eternall lyfe therfore is nat a rewarde because our workes be sufficient or because it is due for workes but consecutiuely because although it be due for another cause yet neuertheles it dothe recompense good workes and afflictions ⧠Besydes thys we do graunte that workes be in very dede meritorious nat of remission of synnes or of iustificatioÌ„ for workes do nat please but in theÌ„ that be iustified and that because of faythe Neyther be they worthy of eternall lyfe For as iustification commeth by faythe for Christes sake so dothe viuificatioÌ„ but they be meritorious of other rewardê corporall and spiritual whiche are gyuen partly in this lyfe and partly after thê lyfe For god differreth the most parte of hys rewardes vntyll he dothe glorifie sayntes after thys lyfe because he wyl that they be excercised in this lyfe to mortifye the olde man The gospell dothe frely set forth and exhibete the promise of iustification and viuification for Christes sake But in the lawe rewarde is offered and is due nat frely but for workes For asmuche therfore as workê be a certayne fulfyllyng of the lawe they be well called meritorious and it is well sayde that rewarde is due vnto them And this rewarde engendereth degrees of rewardes accordyng to that sayeng of Paule Euery man shall receyue rewarde accordynge to hys owne labour These degrees be rewarde of warkes and of afflictions But our aduersaries do contende and styffly affyrme that eternall lyfe is only due for workes because Paule sayeth He shall rendre to euery man accordynge to hys work In the fyfthe of Iohan. who so euer haue wrought well shall ryse agayne to the resurrection of lâ—fe In the .xxv. of Mathewe I was hungry and ye gaue me meate In all these places in whiche workes be commeÌ„ded and praysed it is necessary to haue recourse to the rule a boâ—â—remembred that is to saye that workes please nat without Christe nor that Christe the mediatour is nat to be excluded Wherfore when the texte sayeth that eternal lyfe is gyuen to warkes It meaneth that it is gyuen to them that be iustified For good workê do nat please god but in them that be iustified that is to say in them whiche thynke them selues accepted to god for Christes sake And they that be iustified do necessarily bryng forthe good workes or good frutes as I was hungry and ye gaue me meate Here when it is sayde that eternall lyfe is giuen to these workes the meanyng is that it is gyuen to ryghtuousnes Therfore he coÌ„prehendeth fayth when he nameth the frutes And the scripture nameth the frutes to shewe that god requyreth nat hypochrisy but iustice whiche is full of efficacitie and workyng and a certayne newe lyfe bryngynge forthe good frutê Neyther do we couet here any vayne or vnfrutful subtilite For they be very wayghty causes for whiche we do dispute these thyngê For if we do graunt to our aduersaries that workes do deserue eternall â–ª lyfe anone they adde these false and inconueniente thynges that workes satisfie the lawe of god that they haue no nede of mercy that we be ryghtuous that is to saye acceptable in the syght of god for our owne workes and nat for Christê sake â–ª that men maye do more then fulfyll the lawe So all the doctrine of the iustice of faythe is quyte ouerthrowne And vndoubtedly it is necessary that the pure doctrine of the iustice of fayth be reserued in the churche Wherfore we be compelled to rebuke the phariseicall opinions of our aduersaries bothe to the entent that we may set forth the glory of Christ and also that we maye set forthe vnto consciences ferme and sure comfortes For howe shall the conscience conceyue certayne hope of saluation whan it shal perceyue that in the iudgement of good workes be vnworthy Onles it knoweth that men be reputed ryghtuous and saued throughe mercy for Christê sake nat for our owne fulfyllyng of the lawe Dyd S. Laurence lyeng on the grydyron thinke that through the worke he satisfyed the laweof god and that he was voyde of syn and neded nat Christ the Mediatour nor the mercy of god No verely he
god And neyther Christe nor Paule do prayse virginitie therfore because it dothe iustifie but because it is lesse combred and hathe fewer cares belonging to it and is lesse letted with domesticall occupations and busynesses in prayeng in teaching in doing seruice to god Therfore sayth Paule The virgine carith for those thinges whiche be the lordes Uirginitie then is praysed for the excercise and study So Christe dothe nat absolutely and generally prayse all them whiche do gelde them selues but he addethe for the kyngdome of heuen that is for to say that they may haue leysure to learne or to teache the gospell For he dothe nat say that virginitie dothe merite remission of sinnes or saluation To the examples of the leuitical prestes we haue aunswered that they proue nat that prestes ought to be bounde to abstayne from mariage all theyr lyfe tyme agayne the leuitical vncleÌ„nesses ought not to be applyed to vs. A custome agaynst the lawe was then vnclennes Nowe suche custome is nat vnclennes for Paule sayeth All thynges be cleane to them that be cleane For the gospell deliuereth vs and maketh vs free froÌ„ these leuitical impurities And if any man dothe defende the lawe of abstaynyng from mariage to the ende to charge lade consciences with those leuiticall obseruaunces that man ought to be resisted in lykewyse as the apostles dyd resyste them whiche required circumcision and whiche went aboute to laye the burdon of Moses lawe vpoÌ„ christeÌ„ meÌ„nes neckes In the meane season yet good men knowe howe to moderate the carnall vse and company of theyr wyues namely when they be busyed with publycke ministeries and offices apperteynynge to the comen weale with whiche good men be often tymes so busied troubled that they do caste the thoughtes cares coÌ„cernyng theyr house out of theyr myndê Good men knowe this also that Paule dothe bydde vs to possesse our vessels in saÌ„ctification They knowe also that somtime they ought to go a sondre to the entente that they may the better gyue theyr mynde to prayer but Paule wyl nat that they shulde kepe in sondre coÌ„tinually Nowe suche maner continencie is easy to them that be good men and occupied But that greate multitude of ydle prestes whiche be in Collegies can nat fulfill so muche as thys leuiticall continencie they lyue in so greate welthe and pleasures as experieÌ„ce sheweth dayly And these verses of the Poete be knowen wel ynough Desidiam puer ille sequi solet odit agentes that is to saye That luste and desyre of bodyly pleasure is wonte to folowe slouthfulnes but it hateth those that he busy and doyng Many heretikê throughe the mysunderstandynge of the forsayd lawe of Moyses haue had contumelious and shamefull opinions of wedlocke And suche were the Encratites of whom we haue spoken before And it is vndoubted and euidently knowen that monkes and freers haue ben wonte to sowe and sprede abrode euerywhere many superstitious sentences concernyng single lyfe whiche sentences haue troubled many godly consciences euen because of the laufull vse of matrimony And it shulde be no harde thynge for vs to reherse and tell examples For albeit they dyd nat vtterly condempne matrimony because of procreation yet they dyd dysprayse it as a kynde of lyuiÌ„g whiche scarcely at any tyme dothe please god or at the leaste wyse shulde nat please god but only because of procreation But single lyfe they dyd extolle and magnifie as an angelical kynde of liuing This they preached to be the moste pleasaunte sacrifice vnto god to merite remission of synnes to merite garlondes or crownes to brynge forthe the hundreth folde frute and other thinges out of nombre These religions of aungelles Paule dothe greately improue wryting to the Collossians For they do oppresse the knoweledge of Christe when men do thiÌ„ke that they be reputed ryghtuous for suche maner obseruaunces and nat for Christê sake they oppresse also the knowlege of the coÌ„mauddementes of god whan besides the preceptê of god newe ceremonies and seruices be deuised and preferred before the coÌ„maundementes of god Wherfore these superstitious opinions concernynge single lyfe be diligently to be resisted to th entent that both godlye consciences maye knowe what maner honours and seruice god dothe approue But in dede oure aduersaries do not require single lyfe through any suê‘stition For they know that chastitie is not wonte to be kepte But they cloke theyr busynes with superstitious opinions to the entent that they maye begyle the simple and vnlerned ê‘sones They be therfore more worthye of hatered than the Encratites whiche seme to haue fallen in to errour thrughe a certeyne apparaunce of holynes But these voluptuous felowes do purposely abuse the pretence of religion Sixtely though we haue so many causes of disprouynge the lawe of perpetuall abstinence from maryage yet besydê these causes there be many ieopardies of soules and open sâ—launders and occasions of hurte whiche althoughe the lawe were not vnryghtuous yet it ought to feare away good men from the approuynge of suche maner of burden whiche hath destroyed innumerable soules All good men haue complayned longe of this burden as wel for theyr owne cause as for other mennes cause whom they dyd se to be in ieoê‘die But these complaintes no byshops do heare And it is not vnknowen howe greatelye this lawe dothe hurte the comen and publyke maners what vices what vngratious kyndes of lecherye it hath engendred and broughte vp There be yet remayniÌ„g the Romayn satyres In these satyres Rome euen these dayes also dothe knowe and espie her maners touched Thus god auengeth and ponysheth the contempte and despisinge of his gyfte and of his ordenaunce in those persones whiche forbyd wedlocke And sythe in other lawes the custome hath ben to chaunge them if euidente vtilitie haue so required why do they not the same in this lawe in whiche there be so many weyghtye causes rennynge together namely these last dayes why it ought to be chauÌ„ged Nature waxeth olde is made daylye weyker and weyker and vices do encrease wherfore the remedies taughte and gyuen by god were the more to be vsed We see what vice god dothe accuse before the floode what vice he dothe accuse before the brennyng of the fyue Cities Lyke vices haue gone before the destructions of many other cities as of Sybaris of Rome And in these is set forthe an ymage or similitude of the tymes whiche shal be nexte to the worldes ende Therfore principally at this tyme they ought to strengthen to fortifie wedlocke with most sharpe lawes and ensamples to prouoke men to weâ—lock This apperteyneth to the heade officers and rulers whiche oughte to maynteyne good ordre in a comen â—eale In the meane season the preachers and teachers of the gospell let them do both two thynges I meane let them exhorte those that be vncoÌ„tineÌ„t to wedlocke and agayne let them exhorte other that they do not despise the gyfte of continence The byshops of Rome do
but a newe founde halydaye and a straunge sayeng euen in his tyme. So many wycked opinioÌ„s hang in vowes as that they deserue remission of synnes iustification that they be the christian perfection that they kepe the counselles and the coÌ„maundementes that they haue super fluiâ—e of good workes All these thynges syth they be false and coÌ„trary to Christes doctrine make vowes to be vayne and of none effecte Of the power of the churche GReate disputacions haue ben of the power of bisshoppes iÌ„ which many men haue confusely mengled togyther the power of the churche and the power of the swerde Of this confusion great batailles greate vnquietnes haue proceded whiles bysshoppes bâ—arynge themselues bolde vpon the power of the keys nat allouly haue institute and begonne newe honours of god nat only haue burdonned consciences with reseruation of cases and with violente excoÌ„munications and cursynges but also haue translated and remoâ—ed the kyngdomes of the worlde and gon aboute to take awaye thempire from themperours Well disposed and learned men haue reproued these vices in the churche longe sythen Therfore our preachers to thentente to conforte coÌ„sciences were constrayned to shewe the difference of the ecclesiasticall power and of the power of the swerde haue taughte that eyther of them because of goddes coÌ„maundement is to be had in greate reuerence and honoure as hyghe benefites of god vpon earthe And thus our lerned men thynke this is theyr opinion that the power of the keys or the power of bysshoppes accordyng to the gospell is a power or coÌ„maundemeÌ„t of god to preache the gospell to remitte and retayne lose and bynde synnes and to ministre sacramentes For with that coÌ„maundement Christe sendeth forthe his apostles sayeng as my father hathe sente me euen so I sende you Take the holy ghoste whose synnes ye remitte they be remitted whose synnes ye holde styll they be holden styll Also in the gospell of Marke he saythe Go preache the gospell to euery creature cÌ„ This power is put in execution only by teaching or preachyng the gospell and by ministryng the sacramentes eyther to a multitudeê or elles to one man by hym selue accordyng to his vocation and callyng for here be graunted nat corporall thynges but eternal thynges as eternal ryghtuousnes the holy ghoste eternall lyfe These thynges can nat chauÌ„ce or come but by ministration of the worde and of the sacramentes as Paule saythe The gospell is the power of god to saluation vnto all that beleue therfore sythe the power of the churche graunteth eternall thynges and is exercised only by ministration of the worde it lettith nat ciuile administracion Lyke as the crafte of singynge nothyng lettith ciuile or politicall administration for politicall administration gothe about other thynges then dothe the gospell For the gouernour or ruler defendeth nat myndes but bodies and bodely thynges agaynste manifeste iniuries and restreyneth men with the swerde and corporal paynes to thentente to kepe ciuile iustice and peace Therfore the power of the churche the ciuile power may nat be mixed and confounded together The power of the churche hathe his coÌ„maundemente to teache the gospell and to ministre the sacramentes Let it nat breake into anothers office let it nat translaâ—e altere the kyngdomes of the worlde as the byshops of Rome haue done let iâ— nat abrogate and defete lawes of princes let it nat take awaye due and laufull obedience of the subiecte to his prince let it nat interrupte iudgementeâ— of any ciuile ordenaunces or contractes let it nat prescribe ne appointe lawes to gouernours of the fourme and facion of the comon welthe as Christe saythe My kyngdome is nat of this worlde Also in an other place he sayth Quis me constituit iudicem aut diuisorem super vos that is to say Who made me iudge or deuider ouer you And Paule saith to the PhilippiaÌ„s Our policye or coÌ„uersation is in heuen And to the Corinthes The armure or wepons of our cheualry be nat carnall but mighty through god to destroy cogitacioÌ„s and thoughtes cÌ„ After this sorte do our men diuide they offices and dueties of bothe these powers and teache to honour them bothe and do acknowlege that eche of them is a gyfte benefite of god If byshops haue any power of the swerde that power haue they nat as bysshoppes by the coÌ„maundemeÌ„t of the gospel bu by mannes lawe gyuen to them of kynges and emperours to the ciuile ministration of theyr owne goodes So that this is another office thaÌ„ is the ministratioÌ„ of the gospel Therfore when soeuer question is made of the iurisdiction of byshopps the empyre and temporall power ought to be deuided and distincted from the ecclesiastical iurisdiction Undubtedly after the gospell and after goddes lawe no iurisdiction belongeth to byshoppes that is to saye to them to whom is coÌ„mitted the ministration of the worde and of the sacrameÌ„tes saue only this power to remitte and lose siÌ„nes and also to discerne and iudge doctrines and to reiecte a doctrine contrary to the gospel and to exclude and shytte out froÌ„ the coÌ„munion of the church wyckedmen whose wickednes is knowen and this muste be with the worde without mannes violence In these thynges the congregations or churches owe of dutie and be by the law of god bounden to submitte them selues and to shewe obedience accordyng to that sayeng of Christe who hearith you hearith me But when they teache or ordeyne any thynge agaynste the gospell then the congregations haue a coÌ„maundemente of god prohibitynge obedience As this beware of false prophetes and Paule to the Galathians If an aungell from heuen wolde preache or shewe any other gospell accursed be he Also to the Corinthes we can nothynge do agaynste the truthe but for the truthe Also in another place he sayeth Power is gyuen to vs for edification and nat for destruction So also do the canon lawes coÌ„maunde 2. D. 7. cap. Sacerdotes et cap. Oues And. S Austine against the epistle of Petilian sayeth If catholique by shoppes be deceiued any where by chaunce and thynke any thyng agaynst the canonical scriptures of god we ought nat to consent vnto theÌ„ If byshops haue any other power or iurisdictioÌ„ as in cognisauns of plee or in determinynge of certayne causes as of matrimony or of tythes they haue it by mans lawe wherin when the ordinaries fayle to do theyr dueties because eyther they wyll nat or can nat prynces be compelled yea whether they wyll or nat to see the lawe ministred to theyr subiectes for peace to be hodde amongest them Moreouer it is disputed whether byshops or pastours haue ryght and auctorite to ordeyne ceremonies in the churche and to make lawes of meatê of holy dayes and degrees of ministers or orders c. They that ymagin this auctorite to be in byshops alledge and bryng for them this testimonie and auctoritie of scripture Yet
they oughte to come together it apperethe that the Churche dyd appoynte the Sonday whiche daye as it semeth pleased them rather than the Sabbat day euen for this cause that men myght haue an example of christen libertie myght knowe that the kepyng and thobseruation neyther of the saturday nor of any other day is necessary Prodigious monstruous wonderfull disputations are set forthe of the chaungynge of the lawe of the ceremonies of the newe lawe of the chaungynge of the Sabbat daye whiche all haue spronge forth of a false persuation and beleue of men whiche thought that there must nedes be in the churche an honourynge of god lyke to the leuiticall and that Christe coÌ„mitted to thapostles and to bysshops auctoritie to inuente and to fynde oute ceremonies whiche be necessarye to saluation These errours crepte in to the Churche whan the ryghtuousnes of faythe was not clearely ynough taught Some dispute that the kepyng of the Sonday is not merely and fully goddes lawe but in a maner and as it were of the law of god They prescribe of holy days howe far forthe it is laufull to worke Suche maner of disputations what other thynges be they but snares of consciences For although they busy them selues to modefye qualifie and fynde an epikee in theyr tradiditions temperynge the rygour of them with fauourable declarations yet notwithâ—tandynge as longe as the opinion that they are necessary dothe remayne whiche muste nedes remayne where ryghtuousnes of faythe and christen libertie are not knowen this epikee equitie and fauoure can neuer be perceyued ne knowen The Apostles coÌ„maunded to absteyne from bloudde who dothe nowe obserue and kepâ— it And yet they that do not kepe it synne not for vndoubtedly not the apostles them selues wold burden the conscience with suche bondage but they prohited it for a tyme for auoydynge of sclaunder For the perpetuall wyll and mynde of the gospell is to be consydered in a decree Scase any canones are kepte diligentelye and many daylye go oute of vse and memorye yea with them whiche defende traditions moste diligently Neyther can the coÌ„sciences be holpen ne prouided for onles this epikee or equitie be kepte that is to wytte that we knowe that canones and decrees are to be kepte without opinion of necessitie and that consciences are not hurte though traditions be forgotten and vtterly set asyde Certes bysshops myght easely kepe styll lauful obedience if they wolde nat inforce men to kepe traditions whiche can nat be kepte with good conscience They coÌ„maunde prestes to lyue vnmaried they receiue none onles they sweare in effecte that they wyll nat teache the pure doctrine of the gospel The congregations require nat that bysshops shulde repare and make concorde agayne with losse and decaye of theyr honour and yet it shulde become good pastours so to do but they only requyre that they wolde release and pardon vniuste burdones whiche are newe and receiued contrary to the custome of the catholyk churche We wyll nat denye but in the begynnyng some constitutions were grounded vpon reasonable and probable causes Whiche yet are nat nowe agreable ne coÌ„uenient for the tymes ensuyng It appereth also that some were by eâ—rour receyued Wherfore it myght apperteyne to the gentlenes of bysshoppes nowe to mitigate and release them sythe suche mâ—â—ation breaketh nat the vnite of the churche For many mannes traditions in processe of tyme haue ben chauÌ„ged as the caâ—ones them selues do shewe That if it can nat be obteyned that those obseruatioÌ„s shulde be released which can nat be done without synne we muste neades folowe the rule of the apostles whiche coÌ„maunde rather to obey god then men Peter forbiddeth bysshops to be lordes and emperours ouer the churche Nowe it is nat entended by vs to take away iurisdiction from the bysshops but this one thinge is required of them that they wolde suffre the gospell to be purely taught and that they wolde release a fewe certeyne obseruatioÌ„s whiche can not be obserued without synne That if they wyll not remitte ne release any thyng let them loke to theyr charge how they shal make accomptes to god in that they were occasion of this scisme and diuision by reason of theyr obstinacie and styffenes ⧠The conclusion of the boke ⧠THese be the chiefest articles which seme to be in controuersie and debate For al thoughe of moo abuses it myghte haue ben spoken yet because we wolde not be tedious ne longe we medled but with the mooste principall of whiche the rest may easely be iudged Greate compleyntes there were of pardons of pylgrymages of the abuse of excoÌ„munication parochâ—es were many wayes vexed by stationaries Infinite contentions stryfes there were betwyxte curates religious men for the ryght of the paryshe for confessions for buryalles for extraordinarie preachynges and for other thynges innumerable We haue lette these gere passe to th entent that the most principall poyntes of this matter shortely set forth myght be more easelye knowen Neyther is here any thynge sayde or gathered to the reproche sclauÌ„der or hurte of any man Allonly those thynges haue ben rehersed whiche semed necessarye to be spoken to th ende it myght be perceyued that nothyng is receyued in doctrine and ceremonies with vs agaynste scripture or the catholyke Churche For it is manifeste and knowen that we moste diligently take hede leste any newe or wycked opinions shulde creape in to our churches These articles before wryten we thought best to be exhibited and putte forthe accordynge to the coÌ„maundement of Themperours maiestie in whiche myght appere our coÌ„fession and the summe and effecte of theyr doctrine myghte be sene which be teachers preachers amoÌ„ge vs. Nowe if in any thynge this confession shall seme to be not perfecte and sufficient we be redy god wyllyng accordyng to the scriptures to rendre and gyue a larger information ⧠To the imperiall maiestie of Cesar the fyfte his faythfull and true subiectes IohnÌ„ Duke of Saxon elector George Marques of Brandenbrugh Ernest Duke of Lunebrugh Philip Landgraue of Hesse IohnÌ„ Friderike Duke of Saxon. Fraunces Duke of Lunebrugh Uolfgange Prince of Anhalt The Senate and counsell of Nurenberge The Senate of Rentlinge ⧠¶ Finis ⧠¶ The table ¶ The Epistle of the translatour to the ryght honorable mayster Thomas Crumwell â–ª Fo. 2 ¶ The preface to the Emperoure Charles the fyfthe Fo. eodem ¶ The fyrste article of the Trinite Fo. v. ¶ The .ii. article of Originall synne Fo. â—◠¶ The .3 arti of the humanitie of Christ. eod ¶ The .4 article of Iustification Fo. eod ¶ The .5 arti of the obteining of faythe eod ¶ The .6 article of frutes of faythe Fo. vii ¶ The .7 article of the holy churche Fo. eod ¶ The eyght article of the ministers of the churche Fo. eodem ¶ The .9 article of baptysme Fo. eod ¶ The .10 article of the sacrament of the Aulter Fo. viii ¶ The .11 article of confession Fo.
promyse that free and the merytes of Chryst as a raunsom and redeÌ„ption Promyse is receiued by fayth this worde fre excludeth our merites signyfyeth that only by mercye is offered the benefyte of Chryst the merytes be the rauÌ„som for there must be some certaine redeÌ„pcion for our siÌ„nes The scripture oft times cryeth for mercy And the holy fathers many tymes say that we be saued by mercy So oft then as mencioÌ„ is made of mercy it is to be knoweÌ„ that fayth is ther requyred which receiueth the ê“mise of mercy And agayn so oft as we speke of faith we wyll that the obiecte be vnderstaÌ„de that is to say the promised mercy For faith doth not therfore iustify or saue because it is of it selfe a worthy worke but only because it receyueth the mercy promysed And thê seruice thêlatria is most highly coÌ„mended in prophetes psalmes wher as the law teacheth not fre remissioÌ„ of sinnes But the fathers knowe the promyse made of Christ that God for Christ wolde remyt synnes wherfore when they vnderstode that Chryst shuld be a pryce and raunsome for our synnes they knewe that our workes were not a raunsome of so great a thyng Therfore they receiued by fayth fre mercy and remissyoÌ„ of siÌ„nes lyke as the holy fathers of the newe testament do Here vnto belong tho oft repetycyons of mercye and faythe in the psalmes and prophetes as here Si iniquitates obseruaueris domine c. Yf thou markest iniquities o lorde lorde who shall susteyne Here he coÌ„fesseth hys synnes and yet he alledgeth not hê merytes He addeth For with the is mercyfulnes Here he lyfteth vp him selfe with the truste of the mercye of God And cytethe the promyse Sustinuit anima mea in verbo eius sperauit anima mea in domino My soule is susteyned in hys worde my soule hathe trusted in the lorde that is to saye because thou haste promysed remyssyon of synnes by thys thy promyse I am susteyned And Paule cyteth the hystorye of Abraham Abraham beleued God and it was recompted vnto hym for ryghtwysnes That is to wytte Abraham perceyued that God was vnto hym mercyful only for hys promyse sake He assented to the promyse of God nor suffered not hym selfe to be plucked away frome it all thoughe he sawe hym selfe vnclene and vnworthye He perceyued that God performeth hys promyse for hê owne truthe and not for our workes or merytes Trulye the affrayed hartes can haue no rest if they shulde thynke that for theyr owne workes or owne loue or fulfylliÌ„ge of the lawe they shulde please God for in the fleshe stycketh synne whiche alwaye accuseth vs. But then the hartes haue rest wheÌ„ in such affrayes they assure them selues that we therfore please God be cause he hathe promysed and that God perfourmeth hys promyse for hys owne truthe and not for our worthynes Thus Abraham herde thys saynge Feare thou not for â–ª I am thy protector Here he raysed vp him selfe and felte God mercyful vnto him not for hys owne deseruynge but because the promyse of god must nedes be iuged true this faythe therfore is imputed to hym for ryghtwysnes that is because he assenteth to the promyse and taketh the offered reconsilement he is nowe truelye iuste and accepted vnto God not for hys owne workes but bycause he taketh the free promyse of god Thys auctoryte of Genyses pleased Paule not without cause we se howe he layth on howe ernestlye he taryeth vpon that poynte because he sawe that the nature of fayth myght in that poynt be easaly espyed He sawe that the recorde of the imputacyon of iustice was added not with out a greate skyll He sawe that the lawde of desernynge iustyfycacyon and of pacyfyenge the conscyence was taken away from workes â–ª when Abraham is therfore pronounced ryght wyse because he assenteth to the promyse and taketh the offered reconcilement he pleadeth not in barre of goddes ire hys owne merytes or workes wherfore thys place dylygently consydered may plenteouslye instructe godlye myndes in thys matter whiche shall so be vnderstonde yf the affrayed myndes haue it before them and assure theÌ„ selue that they ought to assente to the free promyse For otherwyse they can not be quyete onles they presuppose that they haue god theyr good lorde because he hath so promysed and not bycause our nature lyfe and workes be worthye Therfore also the fathers were iustifyed not by the law but by the promyse and fayth And it is a wonderfull thynge that the aduersaryes do make so lytle of faythe syth they se it throughe out al scrypture praysed for the moste hyghe seruyce as in the .49 Psal. Call on me in tyme of trybulacyon and I shal delyuer the. Thus wyll god be knowen thus he wyll be worshyped by receyuynge benefytes of hym and receyuynge them for hys mercyes sake and not for our owne demerytes Thys is the moste ample consolacyon in all afflyctyons And such consolacyons our aduersaryes go about to destroye and putte out of vre in that they make faythe so lytle a seruyce and onlye â—eache men to contende with god by our owne workes and merytes ¶ That the only faythe in Chryst iustyfyeth FYrste leste a man wolde thynke that we speake of the ydle knowledge of the Hystorye we wyll shewe howe faythe cummeth After we wyl shewe that it iustyfyeth and howe thys must be vnderstande then we wyll assoyle thobiections of the aduersaryes Chryste in the last of Luke coÌ„maundeth his dyscyples to preache repentaunce in hys name and remyssyon of synnes For the gospell argueth euery man to be vnder synne and to be gyltye of eternal ire and deth and offereth for Chryst remissyon of sinnes iustificacion which is receyued by fayth Preaching of penauÌ„ce which reproueth vs dothe fray the conscyence with true ernest afrayes In these the hartê ought agayne to conceyue consolacyon which shal be yf they trust to the promyse of Chryst that for hym we haue remyssyon of synnes Thys faythe erectyng and comfortynge vs in those affrayes takethe remyssyon of synnes iustyfyeth and viuifyeth For that consolacion is a newe and a spiritual lyfe These be plaine and open and the godlye maye vnderstande them also the churche haue recorded the same The aduersaryes neuer shewe truly howe the holye gost is gyuen They fayne that the sacramentes gyue the holye gooste ex opere operato sine bono motu accipientis euen of the verye worke it selfe without any good motyon of the receyuer as thoughe the geuynge of the holy goste were an idle thynge But where as we speake of suche faythe whiche is not an idle thought but which deliuereth from dethe and createth a newe lyfe in our hartes and nedeth the holy gost it standeth not with mortall synne but so longe as it is present it bryngeth forthe good frures as we shall say here after what can be spoken of the conuertynge of the vngodly or of the maner of regeneratynge more sympely and more
meriteth only the fyrst grace and that we theÌ„ by our owne fulfyllyng of the lawe do please and deserue euerlastyng lyfe The mediatour Christe taryeth styll and we must alwaies thynke that for him we haue god pacifyed although we be vnworthy as Paule sayeth By hym we haue an entre to god thorugh fayth For our fulfyllyng of the lawe as we sayde is vnclene sythe our nature is horriblely corrupted Therfore the Psalme sayeth Blessed be they whose synnes be forgyuen Wherfore we haue nede of remission of synnes yea euen when we haue good workê But that remission is alwayes purchased by faythe so Christe remayneth a byshop and mediatour g o ergo that fulfyllyng of the lawe pleaseth nat of it selfe But because we coÌ„ceiue Christ by fayth and fele that we haue god pacified nat for the lawe but for Christe Fyfthly If we shulde thynke that after baptisme we ought to be accepted nat by fayth in Christ but for our fulfyllyng of the lawe our conscience shulde neuer be quyete but shulde runne into desperation For the lawe alwayes accuseth syth we neuer satisfy the lawe which thyng the hole churche coÌ„fesseth For Paule sayeth Good that I wolde do I do nat but euyl that I wolde nat do I do He also sayeth In mynde I serue the lawe of god but iÌ„ fleshe I serue the lawe of syn For who sufficiently loueth or sufficiently feareth god who paciently ynough susteyneth tribulacions whiche god putteth vpoÌ„ him who doth nat oft doubt whether humane thynges be ruled by goddes prouidence who doth nat oft doubte whether god heareth his prayer who dothe nat oft disdysdayne and grudge that the wycked haue better fortune than the godly people and that the godly be oppressed of the vngodly who is nat angrie with the iudgemeÌ„t of god whan he semeth to caste vs away who doth satisfy his calliÌ„g who loueth his neyghbour as him selfe who is nat ouerthrowen of his concupisceÌ„ce Of these synnes speaketh the psalme sayeng For this euery saynt shal pray to the. Lo here he sayeth that sayntes or holy men desyre remission of synnes They be more then blynde which se nat that the euil affectioÌ„s iÌ„ the fleshe be nat synnes of whiche Paule sayeth The fleshe lusteth agaynst the spirite the spirit agaynst the fleshe The fleshe distrusteth god trusteth in thinges present seketh humane socours in distresse and affliction yea agaynste the wyll of god it fleeth tribulations whiche by the commaundement of god it oweth to suffre it doubteth of the mercy of god The holy spirite in meÌ„nes tencies of the lawe one solution may be gyueÌ„ that the lawe can nat be done without Chryst if any ciuile workes be done without Christ they please not god Wherfore when the workes be preached it is necessarye to be added that fayth is requyred that for faythe they be preached that they be frutes and testimonies of faythe What thynge can be spoken more symply and syncerely thaÌ„ this doctryne For it is necessarie to the knowledge of the benefytes of Christ to discerne the promyses from the lawe Ambiguouse and perilous causes do engender many and sundry solutions But in good and ferme causes one or two solutions taken out of the fountaynes do answere all that maye be obiected Whiche thynge also appereth in thys our cause For that rule whiche I ryght nowe recyted expounneth all the saynges whiche be recited of the lawe and of the workes For we graunte that the scripture otherwhyles doth teache the lawe otherwhyles the free promyse of remyssyon of synnes for Christe But our aduersaries do vtterly destroy the promyse in sainge that fayth dothe not iustifie but teache that for our loue and workes we receyue remission of synnes reconciliation For yf remissyon of synnes shulde hange of the condicion of our workes so were it very vncertayne For we neuer do sufficient workes Then the promyse shall be put out of yre Wherfore we call agayne good myndes to the coÌ„sideration of the promisses and we teache them of the free remyssyon and reconcilement that is made by the faythe in Christe After thys we adde also the doctrine of the lawe nat that by the lawe we shulde deserue forgyuenes of siÌ„nes or that for the lawe we shulde be compted ryghtwyse and nat for Christ but for thys entent because god requireth good workes For we muste wysely distincte the lawe and the promyses It must be sene what scripture gyueth to the lawe and what to the promyses For it prayseth and commaundeth good workes in such sorte that it taketh not awaye the free promyse nor the benefyte that we haue by Christe For good workes are to be done because God requireth them and therfore they be the effectes of regeneration as Paule teacheth We be his worke made by Christe Iesus to good workes whiche God hathe prepared that we shuld walke in them Wherfore good workes ought to ensue faythe as a geuynge of thankes towarde god also that in them faythe maye be bothe excercised and encrease and be shewed to other that by our confessyon other maye be styrred to deuotyon Therfore sayth Paule that Abraham toke circumcisioÌ„ not that for the very worke he shuld be compted ryghtwise but that he might haue a marke printed in his body wherby he myght be brought in rememberaunce and conceyue styll more faythe and more Also to thentente he shulde confesse hys fayth before other and by hys wytnessynge prouoke other to beleue So Abell by reason of hys faythe offered a more acceptable sacrifice for the sacrifice pleased god not for the very sacrifice but bycause Abel by hys faythe was assured that god was pleased with him because of hê mercie And he dyd that worke only to th ende to excercise his faythe and to prouoke other by hys ensample and confessyon to beleue Syth good workes ought after thys sorte ensue faythe men that can nat beleue and determyne in theyr hartes that they be frely pardoned for Christes sake â–ª do vse workes farre an other way These persons when they see the workes of sayntes and holy persons they iudge after a worldly fashoÌ„ that the sayntes by tho workes haue deserued forgiuenes of synnes and that for tho workes they be accompted ryghtwyse before God Therfore they folowe them and thynke that by lyke workes they deserue remyssion of synnes they go aboute to pacifye the ire of God and truste that for suche workes they shall be accompted ryghtwyse These wycked opinions in workes we damne Fyrst because they obscure the glory of Christ when men do propowne to god these workes as a pryce raunsom Thus the honour due to only Christ is gyuen to our workes Secondly because that notwithstandynge all theyr good workes yet the conscyence fyndeth no peace in them but heapynge workes vpon workes in true trobles at laste dispayreth for when it findeth no worke clene ynoughe the lawe alwayes accuseth and engendreth ire Therdly Such neuer atteyne to the knowledge of god when
is without workê And where he saieth that we be iustified by fayth and workes suerly he meaneth nat that we be renewed or regenerate by workes nor he meaneth nat that partly Christ is our redemer and partly that our workê be our redemption Nor he describeth nat here the maner of iustifycation but he describeth what manner of persones the iuste be after they be ones iustified and renewed And thys worde iustificari i. to be iustifyed signifyeth here nat to be made of the iniust iuste but after an outwarde fashion to be pronounced rightwyse â–ª as it is taken in thys sayeng Factores legis iustificabuntur .i. The doers of the lawe shal be iustifyed Lyke therfore as these wordes haue no incoÌ„uenience the doers of the lawe shal be iustified so thynke we of the wordes of Iames man is iustified nat only by fayth but also by workes for vndoubtedly men be pronounced iuste hauynge fayth and good workes For good workes in holy men and women as we sayde before be iusticies of the lawe whiche be accepted bycause of the faythe and nat bycause they satisfye the lawe Men then be iustified by faythe and workes nat bycause of the workes but by cause of the faythe whiche yet good workes muste nedes folowe For Iames speaketh of tho workes whiche folowe faythe as he wytnesseth when he sayeth fayth helpeth his workes so we muste take The doers of the lawe shall be iustified that is to saye they whiche beleue and haue good frutes be pronounced ryghtwyse For the lawe is satisfied if we beleue and it pleaseth bycause of the faythe and nat bycause the workes do satisfye the lawe Thus we se that in these sentencies is no inconuenience but the aduersaries depraue and corrupt them addyng theyr owne gloses For it is nat sayde that workes deserue remission or that men for theyr workes be accepted and reputed ryghtwyse before god nat for Christ and that the workes do pacify the hartes and ouercum they re of god and that workes nede nat mercie None of all these thynges sayeth saynt Iames whiche yet the aduersaryes asscribe to his wordes ☞ ⧠There be cyted also agaynst vs other sentencies of workes as Daniel 4. Redeme thy synnes with almes dedes And Esay 58. Breke thy bread to the hungrye then pray and god wyll heare the. Luke 6. Forgyue and ye shal be forgyuen Matth. 6. Blessyd be the mercifull for they shall obtayne mercye To these sentencies and semblable of workes fyrste we make thys answere whiche hathe be made before that the lawe is nat trulye wrought without fayth Neyther dothe it please but for faythes sake in Christe accordyng to that sayeng of Christe without me ye can do nothyng Also without faythe it is impossible to please god Also by Christe we haue coÌ„mynge or way to god through faythe Therfore as often tymes as workes be required and praysed the gospell of Christe is to be put vnto Secondarily these textes which I haue a lytle here tofore recited be well nere sermons or preachynges of penaunce for they be made of two partes They haue in the begynnynge preaching of the lawe whiche rebuketh synne and commaundeth good workes Afterwade there is added a promyse But this is moste certein and vndoubted that in preachynge of repentaunce it is nat sufficient to préache the lawe whiche dothe comonly trouble and condeÌ„pne the coscience But it is requysite that preaching of the gospell be added that synnes be frely forgyuen for Christe and that by faythe we obtayne remission of synnes These thynges be so certayne and so clere that if our aduersaries wolde vary from them and exclude Christe and faythe from the preachyng of repentaunce they were worthy to be reiected as persones blasphemous agaynst Christ. Wherfore the sermon of Daniel ought nat onely to be applyed to almose deades but faythe also is to be requyred in it The sermon of Daniel is farre vnlyke the speache of Aristotle who wryttyng vnto his kynge Alexander doth also exhorte hym to liberalite and counseilleth him to vse his power to the comen vtilite and to the welth of al the people and nat to pride For thus he wrytteth to Alexander wherfore assay and endeuour your selfe to vse apply your Empiere and dominion nat to any contumely or pryde but to munificence and liberalite For sothe thys was a very honest sayeng and there coulde nothiÌ„g be sayde better touchiÌ„g the duetie of a greate prynce But Daniell instructeth and teacheth his kyng nat only of his office or calling but also of repentaunce of loue and deuotion towardes god of remission of synnes and of those greate thynges whiche be clene aboue philosophy Nat only therfore almouse deadê be to be requyred here but also faythe And that the texte dothe declare where it sayeth that the kyng was conuerted nat only to gyuing of almouse but muche rather to faythe For there remayneth yet the excellent confession of that kynge and prayse of the god of Israel There is none other god whiche can saue in this wyse So then there be two partes of the sermon of Daniel The one parte is the preachyng of repentauÌ„ce whiche rebuketh synnes and gyueth monition of a newe lyfe sayeng Redeame thy synnes with ritghtuousnes thy wyckednes with benefites towardes yâ— pore For so speaketh Daniell in his owne tongue where it appereth sufficieÌ„tly that he gyueth nat only instruction of almes dedes but of all iustice .i. of the knowlege of god fayth For he sayth Redeme thy sines by rightuousnes Nowe iustice toward god is fayth by whiche we beleue yâ— god forgyueth vs. Afterward Daniel giueth iÌ„struction of benifites towardê pore men whiche is that he shuld nat gouerne proudly nor cruelly but prouide diligeÌ„ly se for the profetê of his subiectê the other parte of his sermoÌ„ promyseth remission of siÌ„nes Lo thy sines shal be healed Hierome here besydes yâ— purpose puttith to a dubitatiue particle forsitaÌ„ muche more vnwysely he disputeth in hys coÌ„mentaries that remission of synnes is vncertayne But let vs remembre that the gospell vndoubtedly promyseth remissioÌ„ of siÌ„nes And he is to be iudged to disannull abrogate the gospell whosoeuer thynketh that remissioÌ„ of siÌ„nes is vncertayn Let vs therfore nat regard Hierome in thys place Nowe for asmuche as here is a promyse euidently put doubtles faythe is required for a ê“myse can nat be receyued but by fayth Howbeit eueÌ„ there also he sheweth yâ— remissioÌ„ might chauÌ„ce wheÌ„ he sayth Redeme thy siÌ„nes And thys promyse of remissioÌ„ of synnes is a verie prophetical and an euangelical sentence which doutles Daniel wold to be receyued by fayth For Daniel knewe that remissioÌ„ of siÌ„nes was promised for the sede that was to come that is to wyt Christ and that nat only to the Israelites but also to al nations For els he coulde nat haue promysed to the kynge remissyon of synnes For it belongeth nat to man namely in the affrayes of
For Christ rebuketh the pharises whiche thought theÌ„ selues to be made cleane in the syght of god that is to saye to be iustifyed by theyr oft washinges euen as a certayne byshope of Rome sheweth of holy water that it sanctifyeth and clenseth the people And the glose sayth that it cleneth from venial synnes Suche were also the opinions of the Pharisies whiche Christ reprehendeth and he setteth against this fayned purgatyon two maner of clennes the one inwarde the other outwarde he byddeth that they shulde be made cleane inwardly and addeth concernynge outwarde clennes Gyue in almose of your superfluitie and aboundance and so all thynges shal be cleane vnto you Our aduersaryes do not ryghtly applye thys partycle or sygne vnyuersall omnia for Christe addeth thys conclusyon to bothe members Then all thynge shal be cleane to you that is to witte yf ye shall be clane inwardly and shall gyue almose outwardly For he sygnifyeth that outwarde clennes is to be sette in the warkes commaunded by god and not iÌ„ the traditions of men as then were tho ofte wasshinges and nowe a dayes is the dayly sprinclyng of holy water the habites of religious persons as they be called the deuersite choyse of metes and lyke pompes But our aduersaryes do corrupte the sentence with sophistrie translatynge the vniuersall perticle to the one parte alone All thynges shal be cleane to you yf ye gyue almose as yf a man shulde make thê reason S Andrewe is present g o ergo al the Aposteles be present Wherfore in the antecedente both members ought to be ioyned together in thys wyse Beleue and gyue almose so all thynges shall be cleane to you For the scripture sayth in another place that the hartes be purifyed by faythe That if the hartes be clensed and afterwarde almose dedes be put to outwardly that is to saye almanner workes of charite so shall they be cleane al together that is for to saye not onely within but also without And that hole sermone of Christe ought to be ioyned together of which there be many partes wherof certayne do teache of faythe and certayne of warkê And it is no ê“perty of a good reader to pycke out the preceptes of warkes leuynge out the places of faythe There be some also which do interprete it to be an Ironicall locution Gyue ye almose and all thynges be cleaue vnto you For Christe semeth dryly to checke the vayne persuasion of the phariseis whiche whan they had theyr myndes laden with moste lewde affections yet in the meane season because they gaue almose thought theÌ„ selues to be halfe goddes Thys interpretatyon is nat vnmete neyther hath it any thing in it selfe dissonante or contrary to the other scriptures We wolde put to also other places but that we thinke that by these places which we haue rehersed and declared all other lyke may easely be iudged But we shall yet adde this scolastical argumeÌ„t Ryghtuousnes must nedes be in the wyll g o ergo faythe whiche is in the vnderstandyng doth nat iustifye This argument we do therfore reherse that the hole matter myght be made more playne howe fayth doth iustifye and what Paule dothe call iustifycatyon And fyrst because of certayne wayward persons we shall answere artificiously Thê is playne in morall philosophie that iustyce is called obedyence towarde the superiour such as he accepteth and alloweth But faythe is an obedyence towardes the gospell Wherfore faythe is ryghtly called iustyce for obedience towardes the gospell is imputed and rekened for ryghtuousnes in somuche that obedyence towardes the lawe only doth therfore please because we beleue that god is frely gracious and louinge to vs for Christes sake for we do neuer satisfye the lawe Nowe althoughe this faythe be in the wyl for it is to wyl and to receyue the promyse yet neuer theles this obedyence towarde the gospel is not for our clennes imputed for ryghtuousnes but because it receyueth the mercy that is offered and thynketh that we be reputed ryghtuous for Christes sake by mercy and nat for our owne fulfylling of the lawe nor for our owne clennes So the mynde is to be called awaye from gasynge on the lawe vnto the gospell and vnto Christe and we must assure our selues that we be reputed ryghtuous when we do thynke our owne selues to be accepted for Christes sake and nat for our owne loue or for our owne fulfyllynge of the lawe And faythe differeth froÌ„ hope for faythe receyueth at thê present tyme remissyon of synnes recoÌ„ciliation or acceptatyon of our owne selues for Christes sake But hope is busye aboute the good thynges that be to come and aboute delyueraunce to come Secondarely Iustifycation here in thê place signifieth to be reputed rightuous Now god dothe nat repute a man ryghtuous after the maner that a man is reputed ryghtuous in the corte of causes or in philosophi for the iustyce of hys owne warkes whiche maye wele be put in the wyl But he reputeth a maÌ„ ryghtuous by mercy for Christes sake so that a maÌ„ do receyue hym by fayth Wherfore fayth may be called Iustyce for it is that thynge which is imputed to rightuousnes as paule is wont to speake in what so euer parte of man it be put For that dothe nothynge at all let goddes imputatyon howe be it we do put thys faythe in the wyll of man for it is to wyll and to receyue the promyse of Chryste And thys scolasticall argument thus debated because it dryueth the matter to an art the hole cause semeth moche the better to be perceyued By 〈◊〉 these thynges it maye be also perceyued what is to be iudged de merito condigni that is to wyt of the meryte of worthynes of whiche our aduersaryes do fayne that men be ryghtuous in the syght of god for theyr owne loue and fulfyllynge of the lawe Here is no mencion at al made of the iustyce of fayth and in the stede of Christe the mediator is put that we be accepted for our fulfyllynge of the lawe These thynges are in no wyse sufferable but as we sayd before though loue foloweth renouatioÌ„ yet maye nat the glorie of Christ be taken froÌ„ hym and geuen to our fulfyllynge of the lawe but it is to be thought that euen after the renouation also we be accompted iust for Christes sake and that Christ remayneth styl a mediator and mercy stocke and that by the meanes of Christ and for him we haue commynge and entre to the father and that we do nat satysfie the lawe but that we haue alwayes nede of mercy and that we be alwayes compted iust for mercye And thys thynge dothe the hole churche confesse that we be made ryghtwyse and saued throughe mercie as we haue heretofore recyted forthe of Saynt Ierome Our ryghtuousnes is not for our owne meryte but commeth of the mercie of god But so it is that thys mercy is receiued by faith g o ergo cÌ„ But se
was I am sure of the â—ame mynde that the prophete was of which sayed Lorde enter nat into iudgemeÌ„t with thy seruaunt for no lyuing creature shal be iustifyed in thy syght saynt Barnarde confesseth that hys owne workes be nat worthy eternall lyfe whan he sayeth I haue lyued wretchedly But he comforteth hym selfe and gathereth hope of saluation hereof because he perceyueth that for Christes sake through mercy is gyuen remission of synnes and eternall â–ª lyfe as the Psalme teacheth whiche sayeth Blessyd be they whose iniquities be forgiuen And Paule sayeth Dauid callith the man blessed to whom god imputeth ryghtuousnes without workes Paule sayeth that he is blessed to whoÌ„ ryghtuousnes is imputed by fayth in christe although he haue no good workes With suche coÌ„solations be consciences to be comforted and strengthed that is to say that for Christes sake by fathe is goten remission of synnes reputation of iustice eternal lyfe Nowe if in these places of workes fayth after this maner shal be vnderstande they hurte no thyng our sentence or opinion And verely it is necessary alwayes to put to faythe that we do nat exclude the Mediatour Christe And good workes ought to folowe faythe because faythe without good workes is hypochrisye They haue also in the scholes certayne propre and shorte sayengê agreing to our senteÌ„ce of whiche sorte be these that good workes do please god because of grace and fauour Also that we must truste to the grace of god These sayenges they do nat well interprete For the olde wryters dyd meane that we muste truste to grace that is to wete to the mercy of god promysyng that for Christes sake we be accepted But the wryters of later tyme haue traÌ„slated this trust to our owne worke Theyr opinion is that we muste truste to grace that is to wete to the loue where with we loue god This is a false and a corrupte interpretatioÌ„ For we ought nat to truste to our owne loue forasmuch as it is vncleane smal but to the promise of mercy Thys is also a coÌ„men sayeng a monge them that good workes be of strengthe by the vertue of Christes passion it is wel sayd but there ought to haue ben made mention of faythe in these sentencies For the merite of Christes passion is nat coÌ„municate â—o vs onles we do receiue it by faythe and do set it agaynste the terrours of syn and death For Paule sayeth Christe is a propitiatioÌ„ by faythe Also the churche in all prayers or collecâ—es addeth at the ende Per dominum nostrum Iesum Christum that is to say By our lorde Iesus Christ. Here also men are to be monyshed and to be put in remembraunce of fayth For the church meaneth that our workes and our prayers do plese god if we do beleue that god is gracious for Christes sake the hyghe bysshop Let these thynges suffise at thys tyme coÌ„cernyng this place And we do knowe that this sentence and opinion whiche we defend is consonauÌ„te and agreing to the gospell and dothe bringe moste stronge and sure consolations to godly consciences Therfore let nat godly consciences suffer them selues to be led away from this sentence opinion for cause of the vniuste false and sclaunderous iudgementes of our aduersaries For the scripture â—ophecieth that the tyme shulde come whan 〈◊〉 teachers shulde play mastries in the churâ—â—e â–ª whiche oppressing the iustice of faythe in Christe shulde teache to merite remission of synnes by our owne obseruauÌ„ces and workes And the thynges done in Israel be an ymage and figure of the state that shulde afterwardes folowe in the churche Nowe we do se that the prophetes do euerywhere rebuke this persuasion of the people whiche dyd dreame that they dyd merite forgyuenes of synnes by the sacrifices of the lawe and by the reason of thê opinion dyd heape workes vpon workes and sacrifices vpon sacrifices So in the churche there be many persones whiche haue a false persuasion of theyr owne workes and ceremonies But the scripture hathe taught vs that we shulde nat be troubled with the multytude of wickeâ— and vngodly persones and yet it is no mastrie to iudge the spirite of our aduersaries For we do se that in many of theyr articles the manifest and open truthe is condempned by them And let nat this trouble or offeÌ„d any man that they do chalenge and take vpoÌ„ them selues the name of the churche For the churche of Christe is amonge them whiche do teache the gospel truly nat among theÌ„ whiche do defende wronge opinions agaynst the gospell as the lorde sayeth My shepe do heare my voyce ⧠Of the Churche ⧠THe seuenth article of our confession they dampne in whiche we sayde that the churche is a coÌ„gregation of sayntes or holy meÌ„ And they make a longe proces that euyll persons are naâ— to be segregate or deuided froâ— the churche sythe that Iohan Baptist coâ—â—pared the churche to the floure of the Barnâ— in whiche bothe corne and chaffe be layde together on an heape And Christe compared it to a nette in whiche be caught bothe good fysshes and badde Without doubte it is a trewe sayde prouerbe Agaynst the byting of a sycophaunt or sclauÌ„derer there is no remedy Nothyng can be spokeÌ„ so circumspectly but that a captious sclaunderer shal fynde occasion to depraue it We euen for thys very cause dyd adde the eyght article leaste any man shulde thynke that we seuered the euyll persons and hypocrites from the outwarde societie of the churche or plucked away the vertue from the sacramentes whiche be ministred by hypocrites and euyll men Wherfore here nedeth no longe defense agaynste thys sclaunder The eyght article dothe sufficently purge vs. For we graunt that hypocrites and euyll men be in this lyfe mixed in the churche and be membres of the churche as touchyng the outward societie of the signes of the churche that is to wete of the worde profession and sacrameÌ„tes namely if they be nat excoÌ„municate Nor the sacramentes be nat therfore without vertue because euell men minister them or euyll men receyue them For Paule ê“phecieth that the tyme shulde come when Antichrist shuld sytte in the teÌ„ple of god that is to say shulde haue dominion and beare officies in the churche But the churche is nat only a societie of externe thynges and rites as other polecies or ciuile societies be but principally it is a societie of fayth and of the holy ghoste in mens hartes whiche yet natwithstaÌ„dyng hathe outward notes tokyns wherby it may be knoweÌ„ as the syncere and pure teachyng of the gospell and the ministration of the sacramentes agreable to the Euangel of Christe And this churche only is called the bodye of Christe whiche Christ with his spirite reneweth sanctifyeth and gouerneth as testifyeth Paule sayeng And hym he made head aboue al of the churche whiche is his body that is to say an entiertie or the hole congregation of hym whiche worketh all together in all
men Wherfore they in whom Christe dothe nothynge worke be nat membres of Christ. And thys confesse the aduersaries that the euyll persons be deade meÌ„bres of the churche Wherfore we wonder why they rebuked our description which speaketh of the quicke membres Nor it is no newe thiÌ„g that we bryng in Paule defyneth the churche in lyke wyse where as he sayeth that it is purified to the ende it myght be holy And he addeth these outwarde tokyns the worde and the sacramentes For thus he sayeth Christ loued the churche and gaue hym selfe for it to sanctify it purifieng it with the bathe of water by the worde to the ende he myght exhibite it vnto hym selfe a glorious churche nat hauiÌ„g any spotte or wrynkle or any such thynge but that it be holy and inculpate Thys sentence we dyd putte in the confession almoste worde for worde Thus also the article of the Crede dothe defyne the churche whiche hyd vs beleue that there is a catholike churche But the wycked men be nat the holy churche And the article folowyng whiche is Sanctorum communionem the communion of saynctes seme to be added for an exposicion to shewe what the churche is that is to say a congregation of holy persons whiche be felowes and partakers of the same gospell of the same doctrine and of the same holy ghoste whiche reneweth sanctifyeth and gouerneth theyr hartes And thê article is propouned for a necessary cause we se infinite perylles whiche do manasse destruction of the churche Infinite is the multitude of the wycked in the churche whiche oppresse it Wherfore leste we shulde despayre and to the entent we shulde knowe that the churche at leaste wayes shal remayne and because we shulde knowe that be the multitude of the wycked neuer so great yet the churche standeth and Christ perfourmeth his promisses to the churche remitteth sinnes hereth and geueth the holy goste this artycle of the Crede propouneth vnto vs these consolations And it nameth it a catholyk church lest we shulde vnderstaÌ„de the church to be an outwarde congregation of some certayne nation where as it sygnifyeth rather men disparsed through out the worlde which agre in the gospell and haue al one Christe al one holy gost and the same sacramentes whether they haue lyke traditions of man or vnlyke And the glose in the decrees saythe that the Churche largely taken compriseth both good euyll Moreouer that euyll men be of the Churche onely in name and not in dede but the good both in dede and in name In this senteÌ„ce be many thynges red of the fathers For Ierom sayth who therfore is a synner maculate with any spotte can not be sayde of the churche of Christe nor subiecte to Christ. Wherfore although hypocritê and euyll men be felowes of this true churche accordynge to externe rytes yet whan the churche is defined we must nedes define that whiche is the lyuynge bodye of Christe and which is the churche both in name in deâ—e And that for many causes fyrst it is necessary to be knowen what thynge dothe principally make vs membres and lyuishe membres of the Churche But if we shulde onely define the churche to be an externe polecie of good and euyl men shal not vnderstande that the kyngdome of Christ is the iustice of the herte and a gyuynge of the holy ghoste but shall iuge it only to by an outwarde kepiÌ„g of certaine rytê ceremonies Moreouer what diuersitie shall there be betwyxte the people of the lawe the church if the church be an outwarde policie â–ª But Paule doth so discerne the church from the people of the lawe that he calleth the church a spirituall people that is to say distincte not by cyuyle rytes from the geÌ„tyles but the true people of god regenerate by the holy ghoste But in the people of the lawe besyde the promyse made of Christ also the carnal sede had ê“mises of corporal thingê of a kyngdome c. And for these promyses the Iewes were called the people of god not onely the good but also they whiche amoÌ„ge them were euyll For god seuered this carnall sede from the rest of the gentyles by certayn externe ordinaunces and promyses And yet those euyll persones pleased not god But the euangell bryngeth not a shadowe of eternall thingê but the selue thynges whiche be eternal as the holy ghost and ryghtwysenes by whiche we be rightwyse before god Wherfore they only be the people accordyng to the gospel whiche receyue this promyse of the spirite Besyde this the churche is the kyngdome of Christ distincte from the kyngdome of the deuyll But certayne it is that wycked men be in the power of the dyuell and membres of his kyngdome as Paule teacheth sayinge that the deuyll is myghtye in infidelles And Christe sayth to the pharisees whiche without doubte had an externe societe with the churche that is to wyte with the holy persones that were in the people of the lawe for they were rulers they sacrifised and taughte Ye be of your father the deuyll So that the churche which is the true kingdome of Christe is proprely the coÌ„gregation of the godly For the wycked be ruled of the deuyll and be his captiues prisoners they be not ruled by the spirite of Christ. But what nede mo wordê in so manifest a thyng If the churche whiche is truely the kyngdome of Christ is distincte from the kyngdome of the deuyll it ensueth necessarily that wycked men which be in the kyngedome of the deuyll be not the churche Althoughe in this lyfe because the kyngdome of Christe is not yet declared and opened they be myxed with the true churche and beare offices in the churche nor the wycked be not therfore of the kiÌ„gdome of Christ bicause the reuelation openiÌ„g of the matter is not yet made For this is alway the kyngedome of Christ whiche he by his spirite viuifieth be it disclosed or hydde by the crosse Lykewyse as Christ is the selfe same whiche is nowe glorified and whiche was before crucified and afflicte And to this agree the similitudes of Christe whiche clerely sayth that the good sede be yâ— chyldren of the kyngdome but the darnell be the chyldren of the deuyll the felde he calleth yâ— worlde not the churche In likewise IohnÌ„ speaketh of the hole nation of the Iewes and saythe that the tyme shall come yâ— the true Churche shal be seuered from that people So that this place makethe rather agaynst the aduersaries than with them for it sheweth that the true and spiritual people be seuerable from the carnall people And Christe speaketh of the ymage and lykenes of the churche whan he saythe The kyngdome of heuen is lyke to a nette or to .10 virgyns c. And he teacheth that the Churche is hydde with the multitude of euyl men lest yâ— this sclauÌ„dre or offendicle myght offende good men also to thentenâ— that we shulde knowe yâ— the
disalowe very many other errours of the Anabaptistes yet this we condempne in especiall that they dispute the baptisme of chyldren to be vnprofitable For it is vndoubted that the promyse of helthe and saluation apperteyneth also to lytle chyldren But it doth not apperteyn to them whiche be out of the churche of Christ where is neither the worde neither the sacrameÌ„tes For the kyngdome of Christ hath the beinge only with the worde the sacrameÌ„tes Therfore it is necessarie to baptise infauÌ„tes that the promyse of saluation may be applyed to them accordynge to the coÌ„maundement of Christe Baptise ye all people Where lyke wyse as to all meÌ„ is offered saluation so to all men is offered baptisme both to men women chyldren and infantes It foloweth therfore euidently that infauÌ„tes must be baptised because helthe is offered with baptisme Secundarely it is manifest that god doth approue the baptisme of infantes Therfore the opinion of the Anabaptistê is wycked whiche disalowe the baptisyng of infantes And that god dothe allowe the baptisynge of infantes it is declared sufficiently by this the god dothe gyue the holy ghoste to them that be so baptised For if this baptisme were voyde than the holy ghost shulde be gyuen to none at all than shuld none be saued finally there shuld be no churche at all Euen this reason alone is able to confirme and establyshe sufficiently good and godly myndes agaynst the wycked and madde opinions of the Anabaptistes THe .x. article they do approue in which we do coÌ„fesse and knowlege that we do thynke that in the souper of the lorde or sacrameÌ„t of the aultare there is verily and substantially the body also bloud of Christ and that they be verelye exhibited and gyuen with those thynges whiche be sene that is to say breadde and wyne to them whiche do receyue the sacrament This sentence and opinion our preachers haue stedfastly defended and we fynde that not onelye the Romayne churche dothe affirme the bodely presence of Christ but also the Greke churche that nowe is and also in olde tyme hath ben of the same opinion as the canon of the masse witnesseth whiche the Grekê do vse And ther be recordê also of certeyne wryters testifienge the same For Cyrille vpon IohnÌ„ in the .xv. chapitre saythe that Christe is corporallye exhibited vnto vs in the souper of the lorde For thus he sayth Yet we do not denye that by ryght fayth and sincere charite â—e be ioyned to Christ spiritually But that we haue no maner of coniunction with hâ—m as touchyng the flesshe that verely we do vtterly denye And we do saye that it is clene contrarye to the scriptures of god For who hath doubted that Christ also hath ben the vyne and we the braunches whiche do gette lyfe forthe of it to our selues Herken what Paule saythe For al we be one body in Christ. For al be it we be many yet be we all on in hym For al we be partetakers of one bread Doth he thynke happyly that the vertue of the mysticall benediction is vnknowen to vs whiche sythe it is made in vs dothe it not also by the partetakyngâ— of the flesshe of Christ make Christ to dwel corporally in vs And nat loÌ„ge after he sayth wherfore it is to be consydered that Christe is in vs not onely habituallye whiche is perceyued by charite but also by naturall ê‘ticipation â–ª c. These thynges we haue recited not to th entent to begyn a disputation here of this matter for themperours maiestie dothe not disalowe this article but to th entent â–ª that who so euer shall rede these thynges maye perceyue the more clerelye that we do defende the sentence receiued in the hole churche that in the souper of the lorde be truely and substaÌ„cially present the body and bloud of Christe and be verely exhibited and gyuen with those thingê whiche be sene breadde and wyne And we do speake of the presence of the lyuyng Christe For we knowe that dethe shall no more haue power ouer hym THe .xj. article of receiuynge absolution in the churche they do allowe But as concernyng confession they adde a correction that is to witte that the constitution is to be obserued of the chapitre Omnis utriusâ— sexus c. that both confession shulde be made yerely and thoughe all the synnes can not be rekened vp by nombre yet that diligence is to be gyuen to gather them all to mynde those whiche may be brought to remembraunce â–ª to be shewed and rehersed Of this hole article we shall speake hereafter more plentuouslye whan we shall declare our hole sentence touchynge penaunce This is euideÌ„tly knowen that we haue so set forthe declared and garnyshed with prayses the benefite of absolutioÌ„ and the power and auctorite of the keys that many afflicted troubled consciences by the doctrine of our preachers haue taken coÌ„fort after that they haue herde say that it was the coÌ„maundement of god yea moreouer the very voyce of the gospel that we shuld beleue and truste to the absolution and stedfastly decree with our selues that remission of synnes is freely gyuen to vs for Christes sake and that we shulde thynke that by this fayth we be verely reconciled to god This sentence hath lyfte vp and conforted many godly myndes and in the begynnyng brought vnto Martine Luthere very greate coÌ„mendation amoÌ„ge all good men whan he shewed sure stronge consolation to consciences bicause before that tyme the hole power and strength of consolation was oppressed with the doctrines of warkes whan Sophistres and freers dyd teache nothynge at all of faythe and of remission of synnes But as concernyng the tyme doubtles in our churches very many men do often tymes in the yere vse these â—wo sacramentes â–ª absolution and the souper of the lorde And they that teache of the dignite and the frutes of the sacramentes do speake in suche sorte that they do exhorte and prouoke the people to vse the sacrameÌ„tes often tymes For there be many thynges so wryten by oure men concernyng this thynge that our aduersaries if any be good men amoÌ„ge them do vndoubtedly approue and coÌ„mende them There is also denounced excoÌ„munication to wycked ê‘sons and despisers of the sacrameÌ„tê These thyngê thus be done bothe accordyng to the gospell and to the olde canones â—ut no certen tyme is prescribed be cause all men be not a lyke mere at one tyme yea if all men shuld come to gether at one tyme men can not be herde in ordre instructed And the olde canones and fathers do not appoynte any certeyne tyme. Onely the canon saythe thus Yf any do entre in to the church of god and be perceyued neuer to take theyr housyl let them be admonyshed And if they do not then take theyr housyl let them come to penauÌ„ce If they do take theyr housyll let them not alwayes absteyne If they do not let them absteyne Christe
be forgyuen the thy faythe hath made the saufe Go thy way in peace ⧠This is the other parte of penaunce faythe whiche lyfteth vp and conforteth her Of all these thynges it apperethe playnely to godly reders that we do put those ê‘tes of penauÌ„ce whiche be proprely in the conuersion or regeneration remission of synne worthy frutes and punyshementes do folowe regeneration and remission of synne And therfore we haue put these two partes to th entent that fayth myght be the better sene whiche we require in repentaunce And it may be the better ê‘ceyued what the faythe is whiche the Gospell preacheth whan it is set agaynste contrition and mortification ⧠⧠And to thentente that all the worlde maye see howe greate is the ignoraunce of true pietie and godlynes in our controllers and iudges whiche wrote the confutation we wyll adde also the senteÌ„ce of saynt Barnarde who euen in lykewyse knytteth together in repentauÌ„ce these two meÌ„bres coÌ„trition fayth as we do These be his wordê in the thyrde sermone of the AnnuÌ„ciatioÌ„ AuditaÌ„ faâ— mihi mane miÌ„ am tuam quid in te sperdui dnÌ„e Sola nimiruÌ„ spes apud te miserationis locum obtinet nec olcum miÌ„ae nisi in uase fiduâ—iae ponis Sed ost infidelis fiducia solius utique maledictionis capax cum uidelicet in spe peceamus Quanâ— nec fiducia illa dicenda siâ— sed insensibilitas quaedam dissimulaâ—io ê‘niciosa Quae enim fiducia est ei quaÌ„ periculuÌ„ non attenditâ— auâ— quod ibi timoris remedium ubi nec timor sentitur nec materia ipsa timoriâ—â— fiducia solacium est nec eget ille solatio qui laetatur cum male fecerit in pessimis rebus magis exultat Rogemus itaque fratres responderi nobis quaÌ„tas habeamus iniquitates peccata scelera nostra delictaâ— nobis desideremus ostendi Scrutemur uias nostras studia nostra periculaque uniuersa uigili inteÌ„tione pen semus Dicat quisque in pauore suo uadam ad portas in feri ut iam noÌ„ nisi in sola dei miÌ„a respiremê Haec uerâ—â— hominis fiducia est a se deficientê inniteÌ„tis domino suo Haec inquam uer a fiducia est cui misericordia non denegatur propheta testante BeneplacituÌ„ est domino super timentes eum in his qui sperant super misericordia eius Nec parua utiq suppetit nobis in nobis quidem causa timoris in ipso autem causa fiduciae .1 Lorde let me heare thy mercy early in the mornyng because I haue trusted in the. Undoubtedly only hope obteyneth place of mercy with the. Neyther doste thou put the oyle of mercy but in the vessel of hope But that is an vnfaythfull hope and a vessell apte mete to receyue malediction when we do synne in hope Howebeit that ought nat to be called any hope or truste at all but rather a certayne insensibilitie a perelous dissimulation For what truste hathe he whiche regardeth nat the ieoperdye Or what remedy of feare is there where neyther feare is felt neyther the mater it selfe and cause of feare Truste is a comfort but he nedeth no comfort whiche is mery wheÌ„ he hathe done amisse and reioyceth in his vngracious factê Let vs therfore o bretherne pray that answere may be made vnto vs howe greate iniquities and synnes we haue Let vs desyre to haue our synnes and trespasses shewed vnto vs. Let vs serche and ransake our wayes and all our studies and all our ieoperdies let vs consider and ponder with diligent intention Let euery man say in his feare and dreade I shall go to the gates of helle to the ende we may nowe reste and comforte our selues in the only mercy of god This is the true truste of man shrynkyng away froÌ„ him selfe and leanyng to his lorde Thys I say is the trewe truste to whiche mercie is nat denyed wytnessyng the Prophete in the psalme The lorde hathe bene wele plesed with theÌ„ that feare him and in them whiche truste vpon hys mercie And there is verely in vs no lytle cause of feare and in him no lytle cause of truste Thus farre speaketh Bernarde whose sentence and mynde we were therfore the more wyllyng to reporte that the readers myght see perceiue howe we in thê place do take fayth to be meaÌ„t of the hope of mercie whiche lyfteth vp and comforteth affrayed myndes whiche faythe Bernarde calleth ryght wele fiduciam that is to say truste And this may be euidently sene when there is made an antithesis or contention of terrours and of comfortes Lykewyse as Barnarde here wyl that there be in men an acknowlegyng of synnes or contrition or terrours And wyl also that there be added trust whiche may lyfte vp and comforte vs in contrition But because our aduersaries do here principally expressely condempne vs where we saye that men by faythe obteyne remission of synnes we wyll adde a certayne fewe probations by whiche it may be vnderstaÌ„ded that forgyuenes of synnes do chaunce nat by the worke wrought for coÌ„trition but by that especial faythe by whiche euery persone beleueth that he is forgyuen and pardoned of his synnes for Christes sake For this is the principal article about which we do stryue with our aduersaryes and the knowledge wherof we thynke to be moste necessarie to all Christen men But forasmoche as we seme to haue spoken ynoughe of the same thynge before in the title of iustification therfore here we wyll be the shorter For they be placê very moche like as who wolde say nere cosyns the doctrine of repentaunce and the doctrine of iustificacion Our aduersaries when they speake of faythe say that it goeth before repentaunce they meane faythe nat this whiche iustifyeth â–ª but that whiche in a generalitie beleueth that god is and that there be paynes ordeyned for wycked men cÌ„ But we ouer besydes that faythe do require that euery man shuld beleue hys synnes to be forgyuen hym for Christes sake About this speciall faythe we stryue and do set it againste the opinion whiche byddeth to truste nat in the promyse of Christe but in the worke wrought of contrition of confessioÌ„ and of satisfactions cÌ„ This faythe dothe so folowe and ensue the terrours that it dothe ouer come them and setteth the conscience at quietnes and reste This fayth delyuereth vs from terrours and dothe create and engendre peace ioy and a newe lyfe in the harte Thys faythe we do defende to be truly necessary to the remission of synnes Therfore we put it amonge the partes of repentauÌ„ce or of conuersion Neyther dothe the churche of Christe thynke eny otherwyse although our aduersaries do say the contrary And fyrste of all we do aske our aduersaries whether to receiue absolution be a parte of penaunce or repentauÌ„ce or els no Nowe if they do seperate it from coÌ„fession as they be very subtile in distinctioÌ„s we can nat
the lawe not of the gospell whiche doth fayne and imagine that man is fyrste iustified by the lawe before that he be reconciled by Christ to god notwithstandyng that Christe hym selfe saythe Without me â—e can do nothynge Also I am the true vine and ye be the braunches But oure aduersaries do imagine that we be the braunches not of Christ but of Moyses For they wyll fyrst be iustified by the law and offre theyr loue workê vnto god before that they be reconciled to god by Christe before that they be braunces of Christe Paule contrarywyse sayth playnly that the law can not be wroughte nor fulfylled without Christe Therfore the promyse is fyrst to be receyued that by faythe we maye be reconciled to god for Christis sake or that we worke the lawe These thynges we do iudge to be clere euident ynough to godly coÌ„sciences And herof they shall playnely ê‘ceyue the cause why we dyd heretofore holde opinion professe that men be iustified by fayth and not by loue For we muste plede agaynst the wrathe of god not our loue or our workes nor truste in our loue and workes but Christe the mediator and we muste fyrste receyue the promyse of remission of synnes or euer we worke the lawe Finally Whan shall the conscience be set at reste if we do receyue remission of synnes because we loue or worke the lawe For the law wyll always accuse vs bicause we neuer satisfie the lawe of god accordyng to the sayenge of saynte Paule Lex iram operatur The lawe worketh wrathe Chrisostome asketh the question concernyng penaunce wherby we be assured that our synnes be forgyuen vs our aduersaries also in the senteÌ„ces do aske the question concernyng the same thynge This can not be declared neyther consciences can not be made quiete onles they know that it is the coÌ„maundement of god and the very gospell that they shulde be assured that for Christes sake synnes be freely forgyuen and that they shulde not doubte but that they be freely forgyuen vnto them selfes If any manne dothe doubt he as IohnÌ„ sayth accuseth the diuine promyse of a lye This certeyntie and assuraunce of faythe we teache is required in the gospell But oure aduersaries leaue mennes conscieÌ„ces vncertayne and in a doubtfulnes Nowe coÌ„sciences do worke nothyng by fayth whan they do coÌ„tinually doubt whether they haue remission Howe can they in this doubtfulnes call vpon god Howe can they ê‘suade them selues be assured that they be herde Thus all theyr lyfe is without god and without the very true honoure and worshyppynge of god This is it that Paule saythe that what soeuer is not done of faythe is synne And bicause they continue alwayes in this doubtfulnes they neuer haue experieÌ„ce what faythe is So it coÌ„meth to passe at the laste that they fall in to desperation Suche is the doctrine of our aduersaries euen a verye doctrine of the lawe a dissanullyng and an aâ—rogation of the gospell and a doctrine of desperation Nowe we do gladly permitte vnto all good men to gyue iugement of this place concernyng penaunce for it is playne ynoughe without any maner of obscuritie and to pronounce whiche of vs haue taughte the more godly and more holsome doctrine for consciences whether we or our aduersaries Certes these dissensioÌ„s in the churche do nothyng delyte vs wherfore if we had not great and necessarie causes to dissent from our aduersaries we wolde with ryghte good wyll holde our peace Nowe sith it is so that they condempne the manifest and open veritie it standeth not with our profession neither is it laufull for vs to leaue this cause vndefended whiche is not ours but Christê cause and the cause of the churche We haue shewed for what causes we haue put these two partes of penauÌ„ce contrition and faythe And we haue done it so moche the rather bicause there be borne aboute many sayenges concernyng penaunce whiche be alledged of the fathers but maymed and vnperfecte whiche our aduersaries haue detorted wrested to the defacynge of faythe As for example Penaunce is to sorowe bewayle the offeÌ„ces coÌ„mitted and not to coÌ„mitte agayne whiche thou oughteste to bewayle and sorowe Also penaunce is a certeyne punyshement or vengeaunce of the sorower aueÌ„gyng in hym selfe the offence whiche he is sorye that he hath coÌ„mitted In these sayenges is no mention of fayth no not so moche as in the scholes whan they do interprete and declare them is any thyng at all added of faythe Wherfore we to th entent that the doctrine of faythe myght be the better espied haue nombred faythe amonge the partes of penauÌ„ce For those sayenges whiche do require coÌ„trition or good workes and whiche make no mention of faythe that iustifiethe the very thynge it selfe shewethe that they be very perylous And doubtles it may be thoughte and that not without cause that those men lacked a poynt of prudence wysedome whiche haue heaped together these peced and patched rablemeÌ„tes of sentences and decrees For where as the fathers in diuerse other places do speake of the other parte of Penaunce it shulde haue bene profitable to haue pyked out the sentences of both partes â–ª and to haue ioyned them together not only out of one parte For Tertulliane speakethe ercellently of faythe amplifienge the othe of the lorde whiche is in the prophete â–ª Viuo ego dicit dominus nolo mortem peccatoris sed ut conuertatur et uiuat .i. I lyue saythe the lorde I wyll not the deathe of a synner but that he be conuerted lyue For in as moche as the lorde dothe sweare ther he wyll not the deathe of a synner he shewethe and declareth that credence fayth is required by whiche we shuld beleue his othe surely reken with our selues that he dothe forgyue vs. The promyses of god ought to be of greate auctoritie with vs although they be made without any othe put vnto them at all But this ê“myse is also coÌ„fermed and bounde with an othe Wherfore if any man doth not surely reken with hym selfe that he is forgyueÌ„ he denyeth that god hath sworne a true othe whiche is so great a blasphemie that there can none be imagined more haynous For thus saythe Tertulliane He calleth vs to saluation with a reward swearyng also in that he saythe I lyue and couetethe that we gyue credece vnto hym O blessed be they for whose cause god sâ—â—eareth O moste wretched be we if we beleue not the lorde whan he also sweareth And here it is to be knowen that this faythe oughte to thiÌ„ke that god freely forgyueth vs for Christis sake bicause of his owne ê“myse and not because of our workes or contrition confession satisfaction or loue For if faythe shulde leane vnto these workes be grounded vpon them anone it is made vncerteine and doubtfull For the fearefull coÌ„science doth se that these workes be vnworthy Therfore saythe Ambrose very
perfecte confession In the bokes of doctours of the churche mention is made of coÌ„fession but they do not speake of this rekenynge vp of secrete synnes but of the ceremonies and maner of open penauÌ„ce For bicause that synners and persones of euyll fame were not receyued agayne in to the churche without certeyne satisfaction therfore suche maner persones made confession vnto the preestes to th entent that accordynge to the quantitie of theyr offences satisfactions myght be enioyned vnto them All this matter is no poynte lyke to this rekenynge vp of synnes wherof we nowe speake That confession than was made nat because that without it there could be no remission of synnes before god but because satisfactions coude not be enioyned onles the kynde of the synne were fyrst knowen For accordynge to the diuersitie of synnes sundry canons and constitutions were made And of that vsage maner of open penauÌ„ce we haue nowe onely the name lefte of satisfaction For the holy fathers wold not receiue agayne synners euyll famed persones onles they had fyrst knowen and proued the repentaunce of them so moche as myghte be And of this thiÌ„g there appereth to haue ben many causes For it was a good ensample to cause other to beware to chastise and correcte them that had offended as the glose teachethe in the decrees and it was an vnsemelye thynge and not coÌ„uenient to receyue notorious synners forthwith to the coÌ„munion These maners and customes haue ben laide down many yeres ago Neyther is it requisite to set them vp agayne for they be not necessary to remission of synnes before god Neyther was this the mynde opinion of the fathers that men shulde merite remission of synnes by suche vsages or suche workê How be it those sightê and spectacles of open peniteÌ„tes be rum onte to begyle the vnlerned vnskylled men in that that they thrughe this occasion thynke that by those workê they merite remissioÌ„ of synnes before god But if any man hath so thought he had a Iudaicall and an hethen thoughte For hethen men also had certeyne purgatioÌ„s and satisfactions of synnes by whiche they imagyned them selues to be recoÌ„ciled to god But now the custome and vsage beinge sayde downe and put away the name of satisfaction dothe remayne and a certeyne steppe token of the custome whiche is that in coÌ„fession be enioyned certeyne satisfactions whiche they call define to be workê not of duetie we call them canonicall satisfactions And of thys our opinion is lykewyse as it was of the rehersall of synnes that canonical satisfactioÌ„s be not necessarie by the lawe of god to the remission of synnes no more thaÌ„ these olde spectacles shewes of satisfactions in open penauÌ„ce were necessary by the law of god to the remission of sinnes For that senteÌ„ce concernyng faythe must be reteyned and kepte that by faythe we obteyne remission of synnes for Christis sake and not for any workes of ours eyther goynge before or folowynge And for this cause principally haue we disputed of satisfactions lest they shulde be receiued to the defacynge and obscurynge of the iustice of fayth lest men shulde thynke that for those workes they obteyne remission of synnes And this errour is encresed by many sayengê whiche be comenly vsed in scholes as for example when in the definition of satisfaction they put thys particle clause that it is done to pacifye the wrathe and displeasure of god But yet our aduersaries grauÌ„t that satisfactions do nat auayle or helpe to the remission of the sinne or offence but they ymagine that satisfactions be auaylable to redeme the paynes eyther of Purgatorie or els other For thus they teache that in the remission of syn god forgyueth the offense And yet because it is conuenient to the iustice of god to punyshe syn he chauÌ„geth the payne eternal into payne temporall transitory They adde moreouer that parte of that temporall payne is released by the power of the keyes and the residue is redemed by satisfactioÌ„s And it can nat be perceiued what paynes they be of whiche parte is released by the power of the keyes onles they do say that parte of the paynes of Purgatory be released of whiche thynge it shulde ensue that satisfactions be only paynes redemyng Purgatory and these satisfactioÌ„s they say to be of streÌ„gth also though they be done of them whiche be fallen agayne into deadly synne as who shulde say that the wrathe and displeasure of god might be appeased by them whiche be in deadly syn All this is but a fayned matter lately imagined without auctorite of scripture and of the olde doctours of the churche and nat somuch as Peter Lombard dothe speake after this maner of satisfactioÌ„s The schole men sawe that there were satisfactions in the churche but they perceyued nat that these open shewes and spectacles of penitentes were instituted partely for cause of example and partely to proue and trye them which desyred to be receyued of the churche Brefely they dyd not perceyue that it was a discipline and a matier vtterlye and mere politicall And therfore they superstitiously imagined those satisfactions not to be auaylable to discipline in the syghte of the churche but to be of power and strength to appease the diuine wrathe And likewyse as in other thingê they haue often tymes mengled together spiritual matiers and politike or ciuile matiers euen so the same hath happened also in satisfactions But the gloose in the canon lawes doth other whyles wytnesse that these obseruances ceremonies were iÌ„stituted for cause of discipline good ordre to be had in the church And see I praye you after what maner in the coÌ„futation whiche they haue presumptuously offered vnto the emperours maiestie they ê“ue these theyr fayned imagitioÌ„s They alledge many sayenges of the scriptures to begyle them whiche be vnlerned as thoughe this thynge had his auctoritie by the scriptures whiche in the tyme of Peter Lumbarde was as yet vnknowen They alledge these sentences Worke ye the worthy frutes of penaunce Also Gyue your membres to serue ryghtwysenes Also Christe preacheth penaunce sayenge Do ye penaunce Also Christe byddethe his apostles to preache penaunce And Peter preacheth penauÌ„ce in the seconde chapitre of the actes After this they alledge certayne sayenges of fathers canones And they conclude with these wordes Satisfactions in the churche be not to be put away coÌ„trary to the expresse wordes of the gospell and to the decrees of councels and of the fathers but rather they that be assoyled of the preest ought to ê‘forme and fulfyl theyr penauÌ„ce enioyned folowyng that sayenge of Paule He gaue hym selfe for vs to redeme vs from all iniquitie and that he myghte clense to hym selfe an acceptable people the ensuer and folâ—wâ—r of good workes Howe I â—â—â—eche god to destroy these wycked sophisters whiche so mischeuously do detorte wrest the worde of god vnto theyr most vayne dreames What
shal excuseys to al them that shal come after vs so that it can nat be layde to our charge ne any faute can be put in vs that the auctoritie of bysshoppes is minished and enfebled when men shall reade and heare that we albeit we desyre the bysshoppes nat to vse this vniuste crueltie towardes vs yet can we iÌ„ no wyse obtayne any maner equitie or ryght of them Of mans traditions in the churche IN the .xv. article they receyue the fyrste parte in which we say that those rites and ceremonies in the churche are to be obserued which may be obserued with out any syn and whiche helpe to the keping of tranquilite and good ordre in the churche The seconde parte they vtterly condempne in which we say that mans traditions instituted to appeace god to merite grace and to satisfy for synnes be contrary to the gospell Albeit in our confession coÌ„cernyng the choyse of meares we haue spoken many thynges ynough of traditions yet this natwithstaÌ„ding certayne thingê shal here brefly be repeted For although we thought that our aduersaries wolde for other causes defende the traditions of men yet we dyd nat thynke that euer they wolde haue coÌ„dempned this our article whiche is That we deserue nat forgiuenes of siÌ„nes or grace through the obseruyng of mennes traditions Syth therfore thys article is condempned we haue an easy and a playne cause Now our aduersaries do openly play the Iewes and do openly oppresse the gospell with deuillyshe doctrines For than dothe the scripture call tradicions the doctrines of deuyls wheÌ„ it is taught that they be seruices profitable to deserue remissioÌ„ of synnes and grace For then they endymme the gospel they minishe the benefite of Christ they annulle the iustice of faythe The gospel teacheth vs that we through faythe for Christes sake frely receiue remission of sinnes and be recoÌ„ciled to god Our aduersaries coÌ„trary wyse make another mediatour that is to wete these traditioÌ„s For the traditions sake they wyll obteine remission of sinnes by these they wyll appease the wrathe of god But Christe sayth openly They honour me in vayne with the coÌ„maundementes of men We haue herebefore largely disputed that men be iustified throughe faythe whan they beleue that they haue god pacified not for our workes but frelye for Christe This is vndoubtedly the doctrine of the gospell for Paule sayth playnly to the Ephesians Ye be freely saued through faythe and that not of your selues it is the gyfte of god and coÌ„methe not of men Nowe our aduersaries say that men deserue remission of synnes by these humane obseruaunces What other thyng is this than besides Christ to set vp a nother iustifier a nother mediator Paule saythe to the Galathians Ye be fallen from Christ ye whiche be iustified by the law â–ª that is to saye if ye thynke that by the obseruynge of the lawe ye deserue to be accompted ryghtuous in the syght of god Christe shall nothing auayle you For wherunto nede they Christ which thynke them selues to be ryghtuous by theyr owne obseruynge of the lawe God hath set forthe Christe vnto vs that for this mediatours sake and not for our iustices sake he wyll be mercyfull to vs. But these men thynke that god is pacified and made mercyfull for our traditions sake and not for Christê sake They take therfâ—â—e â—om Christ the honour and prerogatiue of a mediator Neyther is there any difference betwyxte our traditions the ceremonies of Moyses law as concernynge this matter Paule therfore condempneth the ceremonies of the lawe of Moyses lykewyse as he condempneth traditions bicause they were iudged to be workes whiche dyd merite iustice in the syght of god by reason wherof the benefite of Christe and the iustice of faythe were obscured wherfore he putteth awaye the lawe he puttethe awaye traditions and proueth playnlye that not for these workes sake but for Christis sake remission of synnes is freelye promysed so that by faythe we receyue it For asmoche therfore as by faythe ne receyue remission of synnes and syth through faythe we haue god mercyfull and fauourable to vs for Christis sake it is playne errour and heresy to decree that by these obseruauÌ„ces we deserue remission of sinnes If any man do here say that we deserue not by these traditions remission of synnes but that we being alredy iustified do by these traditions deserue grace here agayne Paule cryeth agaynst hym sayeng that Christ shuld be the minister of synne if after iustification it were to be thoughte that afterwardes we be not reputed ryghtuous for Christis sake but that fyrst we ought by other obseruations to deserue to be reputed ryghtuous Also to a testament made by man nothynge ought to be added Ergo to the testament of god whiche promysethe that for Christis sake he wyll be mercyfull vnto vs it oughte not to be added that fyrste by these obseruations we ought to merite to be reputed acceptable ryghtuous Howbeit wherto nedethe any longe disputation No tradition hath ben instituted by the holy fathers for this entent that it shulde merite forgyuenes of synnes but they haue ben instituted for cause of good ordre to be had in the churche and for cause of traÌ„quilitie And though any man wolde institute certeyn workes to deserue remission of synnes or ryghtuousnes howe shall he know that those warkê please god whan he hath no testimonie or witnes of the worde of god Howe shall he make men assured of the wyll of god withoute the coÌ„maundement and worde of god Dothe not god euerywhere in the prophetes forbydde to institute any peculiar maner of honour or seruice without his coÌ„mauÌ„dement In Ezechiel it is wryten thus In the preceptes of your fathers do ye not walke neyther do ye kepe theyr iudgementes ne be ye polluted with the ydoles of them I am your lorde god â–ª walke in my preceptes and kepe my iudgementes and worke ye them If it be laufull for men to institute worshyppyngê or seruice and by the sayde seruices they merite grace â–ª than shall the honourynge seruice of all nations be to be allowed than the honours instituted by Ierohoam other without the lawe shal be to be approued For what difference is there if it hath ben laufull for vs to institute seruices profitable to merite grace or iustice whye was not the same thynge laufull to the gentyles and to the chyldren of Israel But therfore were the honours of the Gentyles and of the Israelites disalowed because they thought them selues by the sayde honours to merite remission of sinnes and iustice and dyd not knowe the iustice of fayth Finally wherby be we made sure that honours or seruices instituted by men without the coÌ„maundement of god do iustifie For of the wyll pleasure of god nothynge can be affermed without the worde of god What if god dothe not accepte ne allowe these seruices Howe than do oure aduersaries afferme that they iustifie sythe this thynge can
congregations be compelled openly to enstructe and to here chyldhod And this ceremonie briÌ„geth forth verye good frutes Amonge our aduersaries in many countreys throughout the hole yere be made no sermones at all sauing only in the lente and yet seldome than But the cheife honour of god is to teache the gospel And wheÌ„ our aduersaries do preache they speake of humayne traditions of the honouryng of sayntes and of suche lyke trifles which the people be wery of and nat without good cause And therfore the people departe and go from them forthwith in the begynnyng after that they haue rehersed the texte of the gospell A certeyne fewe better men do nowe begin to speke of good workes but of the iustice of faythe in Christe of the consolation and comforte of consciences they speake nothynge at all Yea moreouer they do rayle vpon thys moste holsome parte of the gospel Contrariwise in our churches all the sermones be spente in these comen places of the feare of god of faythe in Christe of the iustice of faythe of the consolation of consciences through faythe of the exercises of faythe of prayer what maner one it ought to be that we ought surely to beleue that it is effectuall and that it is herde of the crosse of dignitie of prynces and theyr officers and of the ciuile ordinatioÌ„s of the diuersitie of the kyngdome of Christe or of the spirituall kyngdome of polityke or ciuile thynges of wedlocke of the bryngyng vp and information of chyldren of chastitie of all the offices or workes of charitie By thys estate of churches it may be iudged that we do diligently obserue the ecclesiasticall discipline godly ceremonies and good customes of the churche And coÌ„cernyng mortification of the fleshe and discipline of the body thus we teache as our confession dothe shewe that true vnfayned mortificatioÌ„ is done by the crosse and by suche afflictions wherwith god dothe exercise and try vs. In these we must obey the wyl pleasure of god as Paule sayeth Gyue your bodyes an holt or sacrifice cÌ„ And these be the spiritual exercises of feare and faythe But besydes this mortificatioÌ„ which is done by the crosse there is also a certaine voluÌ„tary kynde of exercise necessary whereof Christe dothe saye Beware that your hartes be nat made heuy through superfâ—uitie of meate and drynke And Paule sayeth I do chastise my body and do brynge it into bondage â–ª cÌ„ And these exercises be to be taken vpon vs nat for that they be honours or seruices iustifieÌ„g vs but to th entent that they may kepe the flesshe vnder leaste fulnes do oppresse vs do make vs recheles and without feare of whiche thiÌ„g it coÌ„meth to passe that men do folowe obey the affectioÌ„s and desyres of the flesshe This diligence ought to be continuall because it hathe a coÌ„tynual coÌ„maundement of god And that precyse forme and maner of certayne meates and tymes prescribed and coÌ„maunded helpeth nothyng at all to the kepyng vnder and subduing of the flesshe For it is more delicate and more costly then be other dyners and suppers And nat so muche as our aduersaries them selues do obserue the forme and maner whiche is taught in the Canones This place of traditioÌ„s hathe many and that harde disputations and we haue proued and founde by very experience â–ª that tradicions ar very snares of the consciences When they be requyred as necessarye they do meruaylously tormente and vexe consciences that forget or leaue eny obseruaunce or ceremony vndone Agayne the abrogation of theÌ„ hathe certayne incoÌ„modities and certayne questions belongyng vnto it But we haue a playne an easy cause because our aduersaryes do condempne vs for that we do teach that traditions of meÌ„ do nat meryte remissyon of synnes Also they do require general or vniuersal traditions as they call them as necessary to iustifycation Here we haue a bolde and a stedfaste defeÌ„der we meane Paule which euery where affermeth that these obseruaunces do neyther iustifye nether be necessary aboue and besydes the iustifycation of faythe And yet neuertheles we do shewe that the vse of libertie in thies thinges is in such wyse to be moderated and measured that vnlearned men be not offended ne for the abuse of the libertie made lesse fauorable vnto the true doctrine of the gospell and that without reasonable and probable cause nothinge be chaunged in the accustomed and vsuall ceremonies but that the auncient custumes be obserued and kepte for the norishment of concorde namely such as may be kept with out synne or without any great hurt or incommoditie And euen in this same present assemble or perliameÌ„t we haue shewed and protested that we wyll for charities sake with good wyl obserue indifferent thynges with other men although they had some incoÌ„moditie in them For the publyk and coÌ„men concorde as far forthe as maye be done without offendyng of consciences we haue iudged to be preferred before all other coÌ„modities or profetes But of thys hole mater we shall speake also nat longe here after when we shall dispute of vowes and of the ecclesiasticall power ⧠Of thynges politike ⧠THe .xvj. article our aduersaries do receiue without any exception in whiche we dyd confesse that it is laufull for a christen man to beare office to excercise iudgemeÌ„tes accordiÌ„g to the lawes of emperours or kynges or according to other pÌ„sent lawes to set appoynte ponishementes by the lawe to kepe warre ryghtfully to make bargaynes by the lawe to kepe somwhat as propre or seuerall to take an othe when it is required of the rulers and gouernours to coÌ„tracte matrimonye finally that laufull ciuile ordinaunces be good creatures of god and the ordinauÌ„ces of god whiche a christen man may saffely vse This hole place of the diuersitie of the kyngdome of Christe and of the ciuile kyngdome hathe bene profitably set forth to lyght by the wrytinges of our learned men that the kyngdome of Christe is spirituall that is to wete begynnynge to worke in thâ— harte knowledge of god feare of god faythe eternall iustice eternall lyfe And in the meane season it doth suffre vs outwardly to vse the ciuile ordinaunces that be lawefull of whatsoeuer nations they be amonge whom we do liue lykewyse as it sufferith vs to vse phisike carpeÌ„ters crafte meate drynke the ayer Nether dothe the gospell make newe lawes of the ciuile state but it commaundeth that we obey the present lawes whether they haue bene made by hethen nat christeined men or els by other and with thys obedience it byddeth vs to excercise charitie For Carolostadius was madde which dyd lay vpon vs the Iudiciall lawes of Moyses Of these thynges our men haue therfore wrytten the more pleÌ„tuously because monkes freers haue sparcled many pestileÌ„t opinioÌ„s in to the churche They called it the euangelicall policie or gouernaunce to haue all thynges in coÌ„mune they sayde that these be counsayles nat to kepe
worke it may holde her handes from murdre from adulterie from thefte Sythe there is lefte in the nature of man reason and iudgement of thynges sensible there is lefte also a choyse of these thynges and a libertie and power to worke ciuile iustice For yâ— doth the scripture cal the iustice of the flesshe whiche iustice carnal nature that is to say reason dothe worke by her owne selfe withoute the holy ghooste howbeit the strength of concupiscence is so greate that men do more often obeye and folowe lewde affections than the ryght iudgement And the deuyll who hath greate power ouer wycked persones as saynt Paule saythe dothe not ceasse to styrre and prouoke this weyke nature vnto diuerse and sondry synnes These be the causes wherfore euen ciuile iustice also is so seldome a thynge amonge men that as â—e do see not the philosophers them selues haue attayned it whiche seme to haue greately desyred it But this is a false sayeng to say that man doth not synne whiche dothe the workes of the coÌ„maundementê out of grace And they adde also more that remission of synnes and iustification is due of necessitie to suche maner workes For the hertes of men without the holy ghoste be without feare of god without trust towardes god they do not beleue that they be herde of god that theyr synnes be forgyuen that they be holpen and saued of god Therfore they be wycked But so it is that an euyll tree can not brynge forthe good frutes And without faythe it is impossible to please god Wherfore although we graunt vnto frewyll libertie and power to worke the outwarde workes of the lawe yet we graunt not to frewyll power to worke spirituall workes that is to witte to drede god truelye to beleue and truste in god truelye to decree with it selfe truelye and to thynke that god dothe loke vpon vs doth heare vs dothe forgyue vs. c. These be the verye workes of the fyrst table whiche maÌ„nes herte can not worke without the holye ghooste as Paule saythe The naturall man that is to saye man vsynge onely his naturall powers dothe not perceyue those thynges whiche be of god And this may be iudged if men consydre howe the hertes do thynke of the wyll of god whether they do verelye decree with them selues that they be fauoured and herde of god This fayth it is an herde thyng euen for holy men also to kepe and holde fast ergo moche lesse it is in wycked men and it is receyued as we sayd before whan hertê thrughly made affrayde do heare the gospell and do take consolation and conforte This distribution therfore or diuision is profitable in whiche ciuile iustice is assigned and gyuen to frewyll spirituall iustice to the gouernauÌ„ce of the holy hhoste in them that be regenerate and borne agayne in Christe For so is kepte and reteyned good ordre and discipline For all men ought to knowe bothe that god dothe require that ciuile iustice and that we be able after a certeine maner to ê‘fourme fulfyll it And yet neuertheles there is shewed the diuersitie betwyxte ciuile iustice and spirituall iustice betwyxte philosophicall iustice and the doctrine of the holy ghoste and it may be ê‘ceiued where we haue nede of the holy ghoste Neyther is this diuision fyrst inuented by vs â–ª but the scripture dothe moste euideÌ„tly teache it Augustine also treateth of the same and of late dayes it was very well handeled of Wyllyam of Parrhise but it is vngraciously and wyckedly troden vnder foote and oppressed by them whiche haue dreamed that men may obeye the lawe of god without the holy ghoste And that the holye ghoost is gyuen there where is respecte of merites ⧠Of the cause of synne THe .xix. article our aduersaries receyue in whiche we confesse that althoughe one god alone hath created made all nature and doth conserue and kepe all thingê that be yet that notwithstandynge the cause of synne is in the deuyll and men a wyll turnynge it selfe awaye from god accordynge to the sayenge of Christe of the deuyll Cum loquitur mendacium ex propriâ—s loquitur Whan he speaketh a lye he speaketh of his owne ⧠Of workes IN the .xx. article they put these wordê expressely that they do reiecte and disalowe our sayenge that men do not merite forgyuenes of synnes by good workes This article they do saye openly and playnly that they do reiecte disalowe What is to be sayd in a matter so manifest Here the workmaysters of the confutation do openly shewe and declare with what spirite they be moued and ledde For what is more certein vndoubted in the churche thaÌ„ that forgyuenes of sinnes coÌ„meth freely for Christê sake that Christe is the mercy stocke for our synnes not oure workes as Peter sayth To hym all the prophetê beare witnesse that in his name al they that beleue in hym do receyue remission of synnes To this churche of the prophetes let vs assente and agree rather than to these vngratious writers of the coÌ„futation whiche so boldely without shame blaspheme Christe For although there haue ben certein writers whiche haue thought that after the remission of synnes men be ryghtuouse in the syghte of god not by fayth but by the selfe workes yet dyd they neuer thinke this that the remission of synnes doth come for our workes sake and not freelye for Christis sake Therfore this blasphemye is not to be suffred that the honoure of Christe be gyuen translated to our workê These diuines be ashamed of nothiÌ„g if they dare pronounce suche maner sentence in the Churche And we do not doubte but that the Emperours maiestie and the mooste parte of the princis wolde in no wyse leaue this place remaynynge in the confutation if they were admonyshed ⧠⧠We coulde in this place recite infinite authorities and testimonies of the scripture and of the fathers but we haue sayd many thynges alredye of this matter heretofore And there is no nede to reherse many testimonies vnto hym whiche knowethe wherfore Christe was gyuen vnto vs and whiche knoweth that Christ is the mercy stocke for our synnes Esaie sayth The lorde hath layde on hym the iniquities of vs. Our aduersaries do teache the coÌ„trary that god dothe laye our iniquities not on Christe but on our owne workes Neyther it lustethe me here to tell what maner workê they teache We do se an horrible decree to be made agaiÌ„st vs whiche shulde feare vs a greate dele more if we dyd stryue aboute doubtfull or tryflynge matters But nowe for asmoche as our consciences do vnderstande and knowe that oure aduersaries condempne the manifeste truthe the defence wherof is necessarye to the hole churche and dothe amplifie and set forth the glorie of Christ we easyly despise al terrours and punyshementes of the worlde and with a bolde mynde we shall abyde and suffre if any thyng is to be suffred for the glorie of Christ and for
prayed vnto her shulde dye with out housell Another of them sayd ouer the hole psalter dayly standyng on the one foote Some wyse man paynted a Christofore that is to say a bearer of Christ whiche wolde signifie by an allegorie that there had nede to be greate streÌ„gth of mynde in theÌ„ whiche shulde beare Christe that is to saye whiche shulde teache the gospel or confesse and acknowlege Christ because that suche one muste nedes abyde great ieopardies Afterwardes folyshe freers taught amonge the people to call and pray to Christofore as though there had ben ones suche a Polypheme that is for to saye suche a greate gyauÌ„t in very dede And where as sayntê in dede haue done very greate thinges eyther profitable to the comon weale or els conteynynge priuate examples the rehersall wherof shulde be very profitable bothe to establyshe the faythe and also to ê“uoke other to folowe theyr actê no man sought out these thynges out of the true histories Undoubtedly it is profitable to heare howe holy men dyd administre comen weales what chauÌ„ces what ieoperdies they put them selues in how holy men dyd helpe kynges in greate ieopardies howe they taughte the gospell what disputations and batayles they had with heretikes The examples also of mercy be profitable as when we see that Peter was ê‘doned the denieng of his maister that Cyprian was forgyuen that he was a negromancer whan we se Augustine in his syckenes prouinge the strengthe of faythe to afferme stedfastlye that god dothe in dede heare the prayers of them that do beleue Suche maner exaÌ„ples which do conteyne eyther faythe or feare or administration gouernaunce of the comen weale it were profitable to be recited But certayn hypocrites or stage players not indued with any knowlege eyther of faythe or of gouernynge of comen weales haue imagined tales countrefaytynge the workes of poetes in whiche be nothyng els but only superstitious exaÌ„ples of certeyn prayers of certeyn fastes and there be added also certeyne thinges makyng for lucre As for example the fayned miracles of the Rosaries and lyke ceremonies Neither is it nede to reherse heare any examples For there be legendê as they cal them glasses of examples and Rosaries in whiche there be many thynges not vnlyke to the true narrations of Luciane in whiche is neuer a true worde These wonderfull and wycked tales byshoppes diuines religious men do fauour and allowe because they make for the belye But vs they may not abyde which to th entent that the honour benefite of Christ myght the more be sene do not require inuocation of sayntes and do rebuke the abuses in the honouryng of sayntes And notwithstandyng that all good men euerywhere do desire either the auctoritie of the byshops or the diligence of the preachers in the redressyng of these abuses yet our aduersaries in the confutation do vtterly dissemble and wyll not be a knowen euen of those vices which be manifest and open as thoughe if the confutation were receyued they wolde compelle vs to allowe euen the most knowen euident abuses So disceytfully is the confutation made not onely in this place but almoste euerywhere There is no place in which they do discerne the manifest abuses from their decrees and opinions And yet amonge them selues if any be wyser than other they do graunte that many false persuations do stycke in the doctrine of schole men canonistes and besydes this that many abuses haue cropen in to the churche throughe the greate ignoraunce and negligence of pastors and curates For Luther was not the fyrste whiche complayned of open abuses Many ryghte connynge and excellent men haue longe before these dayes sorowed and bewayled the abuses of the masse the truste in the obseruaunces of monkes and freers the gaynfull worshyppynge of sayntê the confuse darkenes of the doctrine of penaunce whiche ought to be euen most playne and open of all other in the churche We our selues haue herde excellent diuines saye that there waÌ„teth measure in the doctrine of scole men wherin is conteyned moche more philosophicall braullyng than godlynes And yet amonge these the olde men be more nere to the scripture than the wryters of late tyme. So the diuinitie of them hath thus gone out of kynde more and more Neyther was there any other cause to many good men whiche beganne to loue Luther at the begynnyng then that they sawe hym to rydde and delyuer the myndes of men from those endeles mases of mooste confuse and enuegeled disputations whiche be amonge the schole diuines and canonistes and to teache thynges profitable to true vertuous lyuynge Wherfore our aduersaries dyd very maliciouslye that whan they wolde haue vs agree to the confutation they dyd dissemble and speake no worde of the abuses And if they wolde the welthe and profite of the Churche they ought speciallye in this place in this occasion to exhort the Emperours maiestie that he wolde take counsell coÌ„cernyng the redresse of these abuses whom we perceyued very euidently to be most desyrous of well orderynge and healynge of the churche But our aduersaries go not aboute to helpe and further the most honeste and holy entente and purpose of themperoure but that they maye oppresse vs by all maner meanes Many euidente tokens shewe that for the churche they take lytle thoughte They gyue no diligence that the people maye haue amonge them some certeyn fourme of decrees and opinions in the churche Manifest abuses they defende with a newe straunge crueltie They suffre no worthye teachers in the churche What they entende by these thyngê good men maye easelye iudge But by this waye they neyther ê“uyde well for theyr owne kyngdome neyther yet for the churche For whaÌ„ the good teachers be burned and slayne and the true doctrine is oppressed afterward there shall ryse madde and frantike persones whom our aduersaries shall not be able to represse whiche shall trouble the churche with wycked opinions and shall ouerthrowe the hole ordre of the Churche whiche we desyre very greately to conserue and kepe Wherfore we beseche praye you moste noble emperour Charles for the glorie of Christe which we do not doubte but your maiestie desyreth to garnyshe set forthe and encrease that ye wyll not assente to the violente counsayles of oure aduersaries but that ye wyll seke other honest wayes of makyng concorde and peace in suche wyse that godly consciences be not ouercharged ne any crueltie be exercised vpon innoceÌ„t men so as we haue sene vsed yet hytherto nor the holsome and true doctrine in the churche be oppressed This seruice ye mooste speciallye owe vnto god to conserue I meane the ryght and holsome doctrine and to prouyde that it maye come to them which shall folowe after your tyme and to defende them that teache the ryghte and true doctrine For this thyng god requireth whan he garnyshethe kynges with his owne name and callethe them goddes sayenge I sayde ye be goddes that is
with them There be other diuersities betwixt the ordre of prestes and the state of the people but it is easy to se what is theyr entente and why they do defende this diuersitie or difference so greatly But we leaste we myghte seme to minishe the true dignitie of the ordre wyll speake nomore at this tyme of this theyr craftye and subtyle purpose They alledge also the peryll and ieoperdie of spyllyng and certayne lyke thynges whiche haue nat so greate strengthe as to chauÌ„ge the ordenaunce of Christ. And let vs put the case that it were free eyther to vse the one parte or bothe Howe can yet the prohibition be defended Howbeit the churche dothe nat take this libertie vnto her that she may make of Christê ordenauÌ„ces thinges indifferent We verely do excuse the church which hathe susteined this iniury and wronge because they myght nat be suffred to haue bothe partes but the auctours and causers whiche do defende that it is wel done to prohibite the vse of the hole sacrament and which nat only do prohibite the vse but also do excommunicate and persecute with violence them that do vse the hole sacramente these persones I saye we can nat excuse Let theÌ„ loke to theyr owne charge howe they wyll make aunswere to god what cause they wyll shewe of these theyr purposes and ententê Neyther is it to be iudged forthwith that the churche dothe ordeyne or approue what soeuer thynges the bysshopes of Rome do ordeyne namely sythe the scripture dothe prophesie of bysshopes and curates that they shulde so do as Ezechiel sayeth Peribit lex a sacerdote The lawe shall begyn to peryshe at the preste ⧠Of the wedlocke of preestes ⧠NOtwithstandyng the greate infamy which goeth abrode of the filthie single lyfe of prestes yet neuertheles or aduersaries dare â—at only defende the bysshop of Romes lawe vnder the wycked cloke and false pretence of the name of god but also they dare exhorte the emperour and the princes that in nowyse they shulde suffre the wedlockes of prestes to the greate shame and infamy of the Romayne empire for so they speake What more vnshamefastnes hathe euer ben redde in any hystorye then is this of our aduersaries For the argumentes whiche they vse we shall reherse afterwardes Nowe let the wyse reader considre what shame these vile wretches haue whiche say that wedlocke dothe engendre shame and infamy to the empire as who shulde saye that the churche is greatly garnyshed and renoumed by the open infamy of those vngratious and prodigious kyndes of lechery whiche do brenne amoÌ„ge these holy fathers whiche outwardly do couÌ„terfet and pretende the sadnes and vertue of Curius but in corners liue most viciously and voluptuously Yea and a greate parte of those thyngê may nat be so moche as named with honestie whiche these men ceasse nat to do with great boldnes And these theyr prodigious voluptuousnes and lustes they desyre to haue defended with your moste chaste ryght hande moste noble Emperour whome euen certayne olde ê“phecies do call the kyng with the chaste face For it apperith very well that this was spoken of you pudicus facie regnâ— bit ubique The chaste in face shall raygne euery where They desyre that contrary to the lawe of god contrary to the lawe of all nations coÌ„trary to the canones of the couÌ„cels ye shulde pul in sundre and breake matrimonies that ye shulde ordeyne greuous sore punyshmentes agaynst innocente men for cause of wedlocke that ye shulde kyll prestes whoÌ„ euen the Barbarianes do reuerently and religiously spare that ye shulde dryue women fatherles chyldren into exile as persons outlawed and banished Suche sort of lawes they offre vnto you moste good and moste chaste Cesar whiche no barbarous nation beit neuer so cruell and beastly coulde fynde in theyr harte to heare But for asmoche as in these your gratious maners there can be no filthynes or crueltie we hope that ye wyll in this cause deale gentely with vs namely after that ye shall knowe that we haue mooste wayghtye causes for the mayntenauÌ„ce of our sentence opinion taken out of the worde of god agaynst whiche oure aduersaries do set moste tryfelynge and most vayne persuations And yet they do not defende single lyfe earnestely For they knowe howe fewe of them do kepe chastitie but they cloke their kyngdome with a colour and semblaunce of religion to the whiche kyngdome of theyrs they do reken single lyfe to be very profitable so that now we may perceyue that Peter gaue warnynge very well that in tyme to come false prophetes shulde deceyue men with fayned wordes For our aduersaries nothynge say nothyng wryte nothyng do in all this hole cause truely simply playnly charitablye but in verye dede they stryue aboute theyr lordeshyp and kyngedome whiche they do falsely suppose to be in ieopardie and this they go aboute to fortifie and maynteyne vnder the wycked pretence and colour of vertue and holynes But we in no wyse can approue this lawe of lyuynge single without wyues which our aduersaries do so greatly defende because it is repugnaunte to the lawe of god to the lawe of nature and disagreinge from the very canones of the councaylles And vndoubted it is also that it is superstitious and perylous For it engendreth infinite sclaunders synnes and corruptynge of the publyke maners Other of our coÌ„trouersies do require some disputation of lerned men In this matter the thynge is so manifest on bothe sydes that it nedeth no disputation at all onely it requireth a iudge that is a good man whiche feareth god And notwithstandyng that we defende the manifeste veritie yet our aduersaries haue deuised certeyne cauillations to mocke out our argumentes Fyrste of all the booke of Genesis teacheth that men were created that they shulde be frutefull that the man shulde desyre the company of the woman and contrarywyse by ryght reason For we speake not of concupiscence whiche is synne but of that appetite which shuld haue ben in nature vncorrupted whiche they call naturall appetite And this appetite is verely goddes ordenaunce of the one kynde or sexe to the other Nowe sythe this ordenauÌ„ce of god can not be taken away without the siÌ„guler and special worke of god it folowethe that the lawe of contractynge of matrimonie can not be taken awaye with statutes or vowes Our aduersaries do make here a cauillation and say that at the begynnynge of the worlde it was coÌ„maunded that the earthe shulde be fylled but now the earth beinge full they say that wedlocke is not coÌ„maunded Se howe wysely they iudge The nature of man is formed and created thrughe that worde of god that it shulde be frutefull not only in the begynnyng of creation but so loÌ„ge as this nature of the bodies shal be euen likewise as the earthe is made fruteful by vertue of thê worde Germinet terra herbam uirentem Let the earth briÌ„g forth grene grasse By thê
also do dissolue breake those whiche were alredye contracted And this appereth euidently to be contrary to the coÌ„maundemente of Christe whiche saythe Whom god hath ioyned let no man departe in sondre Our aduersaries cry out in the confutation that to lyue single without wyues is coÌ„maunded by the councelles We do not accuse the the decrees of the councelles For these decrees vnder a certeyne condition do permitte wedlocke but we do accuse the lawes whiche the byshoppes of Rome haue made syns the olde generall couÌ„cels contrary to the auctoritie of the sayde councelles Thus do thÌ„e byshoppes of Rome despise the auctorities of the couÌ„cels whiche they wyll that other men shulde thynke to be mooste holy inuiolable This lawe therfore of perpetuall absteynyng from mariage is onely the lawe of this newe domination of the pope And that not without a cause For Daniel gyuethe this marke and token to the kyngedome of Antichriste that they shall contemne women Fyftelye althoughe oure aduersaries do not defende the lawe because of superstition forasmoche as they se that it is not wonte to be obserued yet neuertheles they sowe superstitious opinions whyles they pretende religion holynes They saye that they require the single lyfe and absteynyng from mariage because it is puritie clennes as who shulde say that mariage were vnclennes and synne or as though single lyfe dyd merite remission of synnes and reconciliation and wedlocke dyd not so And to this purpose they alledge the ceremonies of Moyses lawe that syth in the lawe durynge the tyme of theyr ministration the preestes were seperated from theyr wyues moche more in the newe testameÌ„t the preeste forasmoche as he oughte alwayes to pray ought always to conteine lyue chaste This folyshe vnmete similitude is alledged as it were a demonstration and a most stronge and euident proffe that preestes ought neuer to mary And yet in the similitude it selfe wedlocke is permitted and graunted onelye the vse of the wyfe is forbidden duryng the tyme of theyr ministerie And they be two sundrye thynges to praye and to ministre The holy men dyd praye euen than also whan they dyd not exercise any publike or open ministerie or office Neyther dyd the companyenge with theyr wyues let them that they myghte not praye But we wyll answere in ordre to these fayned tryfles and figmentes Fyrste our aduersaries muste nedes graunte this that wedlocke is pure clene in them that do beleue because it is saÌ„ctified with the worde of god that is to saye it is a thynge laufull approued by the worde of god as the scripture copiously doth recorde For Christ calleth wedlocke goddes ioynyng or couplyng together whan he saythe whom god hath ioyned together And Paule sayth of wedlocke of meatê and lyke thyngê They be sanctified by worde and prayer that is by the word wherwith the coÌ„science is made sure and out of doubt that god dothe approue and allowe it by prayer that is for to saye by faythe whiche vsethe it with gyuyng of thankes as the gyfte of god Also in the fyrste epistle to the Corinthianes he saythe The vnchristen husbande is sanctified by the christen wyfe c. that is to say the vse and companyeng of them together is laufull holy because of the fayth in Christ as it is laufull to vse meate and drynke c. Also to Timothe he wryteth The woman is saued by generation and by bryngyng forthe of chyldren c. If oure aduersaries coulde brynge forthe suche a place of scripture for single lyfe thaÌ„ wolde they make merueylous triumphes Paule saythe that the woman is saued by generation and bryngynge forthe of chyldren What coulde be sayde more honorable agaiÌ„st the hypocrisie of single lyfe than that a womaÌ„ is saued by workê of matrimonie by vse companye coniugale of the one with the other by bryngynge forthe chyldren and by other workes apê‘teinyng to the orderyng of an house And what is Paules mynde Let the reder obserue and marke faythe to be added and not the offices or workes of orderynge an house to be praysed without faythe if they abyde sayth Paule in the fayth For he speaketh generallye of the holle kynde of mothers Therfore he dothe principallye require faythe by whiche the woman receyueth remission of synnes and iustification Afterwardes he addeth a certain worke of callyng Lykewyse as in euery man there ought to folowe after faythe the good worke of a certein vocation This worke pleaseth god because of fayth So the workes of the woman please god because of fayth and the christen woman is saued whiche in suche sorte of workê of her callyng dothe godly seruise These auctorities testimonies do teache that wedlocke is a lauful thyng If thaÌ„ this worde cleÌ„nes betoken that thyng whiche is laufull and approued before god than be wedlockes clene because they be apê“ued by the worde of god And Paule saythe of laufull thynges Omnia munda mundis i. All thynges be cleane to them that he clene that is to saye to them whiche beleue Christe and be ryghtuous by faythe Therfore as virginitie in wycked men is vnclene so wedlocke in godlye men is cleane because of the worde of god and faythe But if this worde cleÌ„nes be taken as a thyng contrary to concupiscence so wedlocke betokeneth clennes of harte that is for to saye a mortified concupiscence because the lawe doth not forbyd wedlocke but coÌ„cupiscence adulterie fornication wherfore single lyfe is not clennes For there maye be more clennes of the herte in a maryed man as in Abraham or Iacob than in very many of those yea whiche be truely continente Finally if in suche sorte they vnderstaÌ„de single lyfe to be cleÌ„nes because it doth merite iustification more then â—edlocke we than playnly with open voyce say agaynst them For we be iustified neyther for cause of virginitie neyther for cause of wedlocke but freelye for Christis sake whan â—e beleue that for his sake we haue god good and gracious to vs. Here peraduenture our aduersaries shal crye out that after the maner of Iouiniane wedlocke is of vs made egall to virginitie But we wyll nat for these rebukes and reuiling wordê caste away the truthe of the ryghtousnes of fayth whiche we haue before declared And yet we do nat make virginitie egall to matrimonye For lykewyse as one gyfte is better then another as prophecy is better then eloquence eloquence is better then carpenters crafte so virginitie is a more excellent gyfte then wedlocke And yet as an Oratour is nat more rightuous before god for cause of hê eloqueÌ„ce then a carpenter because of his carpentrie so lykewyse a virgine meriteth nomore iustification with her virginitie then a wyfe doth with the workes apperteinyng to a wyfe but euery one in theyr gyfte ought to serue faythefully â–ª and to thynke that by fathe for Christes sake they obtayne remission of siÌ„nes and by fayth be reputed ryghtuous before
called Aerius whom they saye was condempned because he dyd deny that in the masse oblation was made bothe for quicke and deade This colour they vse often tymes they alledge olde heresies with them they falsely compare our cause to the entent that with suche comparison they myght make vs more hated Epiphanius witnessith that the opinion of Aerius was that prayers for deade men be vnprofitable This opinion Epiphanius reproueth Neyther do we defende Aerius but we stryue with you which wyckedly defende an heresy manifestly contrary to the sayeng of the prophetes apostles and holy fathers that is to wete that the masse by the vertue of the worke wroughte dothe iustifie and that it dothe merite remission of synnes as they call it a pena et culpa euen also to vnrightuous men for whom it is applied if they make no stoppe or impediment of theyr owne parte These poysoned errours we disalowe whiche minishe the glorye of the passion of Christ and vtterly oppresse the doctrine of the iustice of faythe Suche lyke persuasion hadde the wycked Iewes in the lawe that they merited remission of sinnes by theyr sacrifices throughe the vertue of the worke wrought dyd nat receiue it frely by faythe Therfore they encreaced those ceremonies and sacrifices they ordeyned the honouryng of Baal in Israel in Iurie also they made sacrifice in the halowed woodes Wherfore the prophetes condempnyng this persuasion dyd warre nat onely with those worshyppers of Baal but also with other prestê whiche made the sacrifices ordeined by god with that wycked opinion But this persuasion cleauith in the worlde and shall cleaue alwayes I meane that ceremonies and sacrifices be redemptioÌ„s of synnes Carnall men do nat suffre this honoure to be gyuen onely to the sacrifice of Christ that it is the very raunsome and propitiation because they perceiue nat the iustice of faythe but gyue egall honour to other seruices and sacrifices Therfore lykewyse as in Iurye there stycked a false persuasion among the wycked bysshops concernyng sacrifices and lykewyse as in Israell there coÌ„tinued the worshipping of Baal and other lyke And yet neuertheles was the churche of god amonge them whiche dyd dysalowe and rebuke those wycked sacrifices and seruices So lykewyse in the kyngdome of the pope there remaineth the worshyppyng of Baal that is to saye the abuse of the masse whiche they applye to the ende that they may by it merite to vnrightuous men remission of synne and of punyshmeÌ„t for siÌ„ne And this worshyppyng of Baal with the Popes kyngdome is lykely to coÌ„tinue vntyll Christe shal come to iudge and vntyl the tyme that the glorie of his commyng shall destroye the kyngedome of Antichriste In the meane season all that truly beleue the gospell ought to improue and rebuke those wicked seruices and worshyppinges deuised agaynst the coÌ„maundement of god to obscure and dymme the glory of Christe and the iustice of faythe These thynges we haue spoken breffly coÌ„cerning the masse to the entent that al good men in what couÌ„trey soeuer they dwel may knowe and vnderstande that we with greate affectioÌ„ and diligence defeÌ„de the dignitie of the masse and shewe the right vse of it and that we haue moste rightuous causes to dissent and disagre from our aduersaries And here we wolde that all good men toke admonition and counsayle that they do nat helpe our aduersaries which defende the prophanation and abusyng of the masse leaste they charge them selues with the feloushyp of other mennes synne This is no tryflynge matter but a wayghty cause and a greate busynes yea no lesse then that busines of Elie the prophete whiche did improue and vehemently rebuke the honourynge of Baal Yet we haue set forthe this so greate a matter myldely and coldely and we haue nowe made answere without raylyng or euyll wordes But if our aduersaries do prouoke vs to gather together all kyndes of theyr abusynges of the masse the matier shall nat be so myldly handeled ⧠Of abbey vowes ⧠WIth vs in a certayne towne of Turingia called IsenacuÌ„ more thaÌ„ thyrty yeres ago there was a certayn freer of saynt FrauÌ„cê ordre IohnÌ„ Hilten by name whiche of his owne companye was caste into pryson bycause that he had rebuked certayne very notorious abuses For we haue sene the workes whiche he wrote by whiche it may be wel ynough perceyued what maner doctrine it was that he taught And they whiche knewe hym reporte of him that he was a gentle olde man sadde without any waywardnes This IohnÌ„ shewed before many thyngê whiche partly haue come to passe al redy and partly seme to be nere at hande whiche thyngê we wyl nat recite leaste any man wolde interprete them to be rehersed eyther of displeasure and euille wyl towardes some persone or elles of fauour and for the pleasure of some man But in coÌ„clusion when eyther by reason of age or of fylthynes of the prysoÌ„ he was fallen into disease and sickenes he sent for the wardeyn of the place to come vnto him that he myght gyue him knowledge of his infirmitie and sycknes When the wardeyn enflamed with pharisaical harred agaiÌ„st hym had begonne to chyde with hym and to rebuke hym sharpely for his doctrine whiche semed to be agaynst the proffettes of the ketchyn than this IohnÌ„ leauynge the mention of his infirmitie and beinge inwardlye sorye and syghynge sayde that he was ryghte well coÌ„tentid to suffre al those iniuries for Christê sake For he had neyther wryten nor taughte any thynge that myghte appayre or hurte the state of religious men he onelye rebuked he sayde certayne abuses notoriouslye knowen But there shall another come sayd he in the yere of our lorde god M.D.xvj. whiche shall destroye you neyther ye shall be able 〈◊〉 resiste hym This sentence concernyng the decaye of the kyngedome of religious men and the nuÌ„bre also of the yeres his frendê afterwardê dyd fynde also wryten in his workes amonge the annotatioÌ„s whiche he had lefte vpon certeyne places of Daniel And thoughe howe moche this sayeng is to be regarded the ê“ffe of the thyng shall declare yet be there other signes and tokens as sure and as vndoubted as the gospell is whiche threaten a chaunge to come vnto the kyngdome of freers other religious ê‘sones For it is euidently knowen howe moch hipocrisy there is in abbeys how greate ambition howe greate couetousnes howe moche blyndenes and ignoraunce and how moche crueltie of euery vnlerned foole howe greate vanitie in sermones how greate crafte in imaginyng often tymes newe wayes to get money And there be other vices also besydes these whiche I lyst not at this tyme â—o reherse And where as in old tyme abbeys were the scholes of Christis doctrine nowe they be growen out of kynde as it were from a golden kynde to an yirnye kynde bryngyng nothynge els but myschiefe and destruction The rychest monasteries onely fynde and norysshe an ydle multitude whiche there vnder false