but would seeke to merit their fauour by gratefull offices It was extraordinary in this woman firmly to belieue as shee told the messengers but resting so perswaded a worke of no perfection to make her peace with the Israelites â—ad shee doubted whether their title vnto the land of Canaan had been iust or suspected Gods donation of it vnto Abraham to haue been forged by his successors as Constantines is by the baser Roman cleargy shee might without any iust imputation for want of loue or other good works haue aduentured her life amongst her neighbours in defence of her country Or had she vpon the Israelites misdemeanours distrusted their successe she might at last in worldly policy haue rather hazarded their future displeasure then incurred present danger of death or torture of her Citizens for harbouring spies But whiles she firmly belieues both that the Israelites donation was from God that they would certainly preuaile against her people though her entertainment and concealement of them were acts of kindnesse prudence and humanity yet their omission had been properly not of faith because impulsiuely they were from faith nor could they haue been omitted but through vnbeliefe or distrust vnto Gods promises Worldlings would haue condemned her not for vvant of charitie but for excesse folly rather had shee not done as shee was perswaded By faith then those workes become righteous which without it had been traiterous And if we respect not the cause of our knowledge but the thing knowne faith did perfect the workes the workes only made the perfection of faith knowne to men In this sense it is most true of faith what some misapply to iustification of mens persons workes iustifie and perfect faith not in the nature of the thing but in the sight of man to whom they witnesse the liuelihood and perfection of faith noâ— as causes but effects and signes of our iustifiattion they are not onely signes but conditions concomitant or precedent In the same sense are these other words of the Apostle to be vnderstood As the body without the spirit is dead so faith vvithout vvorkes is dead also For if a humane bodie want spirit breath or motion we rightly gather it wants life yet are breath and motion rather effects then causes of life But the schoole-men dreaming the holy Ghost had been scholler to Aquinas or some chiefe masters of their profession take the sprit in this place for actus primus as the soule by which wee liue and breath and hence they conceiued that grosse error which the Romanist now makes an article of his beliefe to wit that works animate or at least casually perfect faith as the soule of man doth his bodie And wheras Caluin most acutely and orthodoxally infers that if faith without works or charity bedead it is not properly but equiuocally called faith They reply workes or charitie do not informe faith intrinsecally as the reasonable soule doth man for so it would follow that as he is not a man but a dead trunk which hath no soule so it should not bee true faith but an image or dead picture of faith which wants vvorkes or charitie How then do they perfect faith Extrinsecally as the soule doth the body or other halfe of man which remaines a true body though no true man after the soules departure For application of this distinction they adioine when Saint Iames affirmes faith to be dead without workes he tearmes it dead in such a sense as we say a body is dead by the soules absence and yet remains a true bodie Whence sayth Valentian the sectaries haue furnished vs with an argument against themselues Rather this answere is contrary to Valentians and his fellowes assertions for were his illustration true and pertinent workes or faith should constitute one grace and qualitie as the body and soule make one man which no Papist dare affirme of the habite of faith and charitie being graces in their iudgements specifically distinct And Valentian who stands most vpon the former illustration expresly denies that charity much lesse workes can be any proper forme of faith either intrinsecall as the reasonable soule is of man or extrinsecall as whitenesse is of the body Some perfection notwithstanding Charitie giues to Faith in which respect it may by analogie to true and proper formes bee metaphorically said to informe saith The perfection it giues hee so expresseth that the Latine Reader by his words cited at full in the margine for I will not trouble the text with them may plainly perceiue hee was desirous to say somewhat but he knew not what Arias Montanus who better vnderstood Saint Iames his phrase by the analogie of faith and forme of wholsome doctrine then Valentian did himselfe or this fictitious analogie betwixt Charitie naturall formes interprets the former place in part to our purpose To liue as Philosophers say is to operate and vitall operation proceedeth not from the bodie but from the spirit nor doth â—â—e Apostle say workes are the spirit of faith where he speakes only of the appellation or name of life His meaning is that faith without workes is as truely reputed dead as the body without the spirit is rightly sayd as it truely is dead But if wee will not wrest the letter against the Apostles meaning but rather gently apply his words to his intent the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 implies onely breath or motion enspired from the soule for workes in their nature are operations and are more fitly compared to breathings or motions then to the substantiall spirit or soule or the faculty whence these flow which last in proportion best answeres to faith Now as the readiest waie to â—et breath in one fallen in a swound or raise one vp out of a dead â—it is to reuiue the spirits by which vitall motions are inspired and managed so the onely way to bring forth liuing workes or fruites of righteousnes is to quicken or strengthen faith which liuely in it selfe and able to performe it proper acts as firmly to apprehend Gods power iustice and mercie will vndoubtedly giue life to all other powers and affections and impell them to their proper functions The Romanist as ignorant as the Iew of this righteousnesse which is by faith preposterously seekes to make vs new men in Christ not by reuiuing faith which is as the animall spirit by whose influence works become vitall but as if one from this principle in nature man is dead vvithout breath and motion should seeke to bring men out of swounds or dead fits by blowing breath into them with a quill or making them moue by deuises so he grosely mistaking that saying of S. Iames as the body without the spirit so faith without workes is dead also hence seekes to raise vp such as die in Adam after the same manner we haue seene them raised which fall downe dead in an anticke first by wagging one arme then another vntill the whole body moue The anticke
how long or short while after he knowes not receiue for an inheritance and he went to it not knowing whither Yet comâ—e to his iournies end he might in wisdome haue requested eiâ—â—er better assurance or leaue to returne whence he came But the same faith which moued him to go he knew not whither binds him there to expect Gods leasure for the time when he or his seed should enioy the benefit of the bequest content in the meane time with what estate the diuine prouidence should allot him For by faith he soiourned in the land of promise as in a strange land dwelling in Tabernacles or as Saint Steuen more significantly notes God gaue him none inheritance therein no not so much as to set his foote in onely he promised that he would giue him a possession for his seed after him when as yet he had no child Long delay of accomplishing this promise might well occasion Sarahs distrust to proue the Mother of a mighty nation The tentations to withdraw her Assent from the speculatiue truth whereon it was set Gods power were not terrible grieuous or painful yet not so easie to be foiled because they had got fast hold within her Barren shee was by naturall constitution and no better then dead hauing so long out-liued the naturall time of bearing children but he that without her consent or knowledge made her gaue his promise for reuiuing her dead womb and she could not continue doubtfull of the euent without distrusting his fidelity that had promised By faith therefore she receiued strength to beare seed and was deliuered of a child when she was past age The ioifull issue of her beliefe may serue as an earnest to assure vs of what Christ hath promised I am the resurrection and the life he that belieueth in me though he were dead yet shall he liue and whosoeuer liueth and belieueth in me shall neuer die He that truly iudgeth Christ faithfull in this as Sarah did God in the former promise shall see life spring from death But faithfull herein hee onely iudgeth Christ that esteemes the faithfull execution of his will deerer to him then all the pleasures of this life which is neuer without the checke of death By such a faith only as arms vs with constancy in Christs cause against all the terrors that accompany this last enemy wee are to deale withall shall we receiue strength to conceiue that immortall seede whose fruite is ioy peace and gladnesse euerlasting 5. Or if we consider the date of Abrahams life almost expired in it selfe but extraordinarily renewed in young Isaac how much more welcome had his owne cruel executioner been vnto him then the execution of this commaundement Take now thy sonne thine onely sonne Isaac whom thou louest and get thee into the land of Moriah and offer him there for a burnt offering vpon one of the Mountaines which I will tell thee of But some happely will reply God neuer puts any child of Abraham to such a desperate point of seruice as this wherein notwithstanding what was required which some Heathens haue not performed vnto their false gods The manner of training vp the father of the faithfull as it were by degrees vnto this giues vs all to vnderstand that throughout our whole course of life wee should esteeme whatsoeuer is most deare and neere vnto vs as base and vile in respect of Gods fauour of whose coÌ„tinuance none are capable but by faithfull performance of his will All his commaundements are Mercy and Truth iust and good vnto the party that vndertakes them by liuely faith which cannot rate either declination of any euill or execution of good incident to mortalitie at so high a price as obedience of which in cases wherein it is vnquestionably due it is so rigid an exacter as will admit no dispensation no not in case of grieuous sicknesse or extreamity of death So soueraigne and high a hand it likewise hath in marshalling and ranking all our affections for Gods seruice that for an aged father to kill his onely child at faiths designement becomes an act of mercy in the slayer and an exercise of pitty vppon the slaine for good it was to young Isaac to yeeld vp his life in obedience to his Father willing in obedience to his God to take it from him As CHRIST is the Way the Truth and Life so in this act of Abrahams faith fore-shadowing his future sacrifice we see an entrance opened vnto the path which must lead vs vnto this maine way of life for thither we come by treading the foot-steps of our father Abraham The point of whose supportance in these tentations whereon all the motions of his will and other acts of his obedience reuolue as the dore vpon the hinges or the heauens vpon the poles was his firme Assent vnto the Article of Gods omnipotent power For the holy Ghost assigning the cause why he that had receiued the promises should offer vp his only begotten Sonne of whom it is sayd that in Isaac shall his seed be called sayth he considered that God was able to raise him vp euen from the dead from whence also he receiued him in a figure His beliefe as hath been declared was of an obiect vnseene perhaps vnheard of in the world before but grounded vpon an euidence of the pledge exhibited in Isaacks miraculous birth We that referre all that befalls vs vnto naturall causes or contriuances of our own or others wit neuer sensibly feeling the finger of God in the procurement of our good vsually faile in the performance of seruices conditionally annexed to diuine promises And albeit we pitch our faith where Abraham did his yet when stormes of tentations arise our sensuall desires draw it being destitute of firm grounds after them as ships in great winds do their anchors cast in loose grauell or stony chanels 6. Many of our times could discourse more plausibly of Gods omnipotency more distinctly vnfold the seueral branches therof and bring arguments to conuince deniers of it more forcible then Abraham could which cannot conuince their owne diffidence or distrust in easier trials because not accustomed to rely vpon Gods prouidence or to traine their affections to obedience in lesser matters Should the practice of some duty nothing so difficult or distastfull to humane affections but altogether as subordinate to the diuine power be enioyned vs by expresse commaund from heauen we would not directly deny that God were able to effect his will but question rather whether it were he that called vs or so perswaded with those in the Poâ—â— seeke a milder interpretation of the oracle Aut fallax ait est solertia nobis Aut pia sunt nullumque nefas or acula suadent Our cunning failes if oracles should counsell vs to ill They holy are and would not we should sacred reliques spill What should they cast their mothers bones behind their back God forbid sure the oracle had some other meaning Magna
death Thus much of true faith and the errors concerning the Nature of it It remaines we intreate of misperswasions concerning the possession or presence of it with the right vse of it and other spirituall graces that attend it SECTION 2. Of immature perswasions concerning mens present estate in grace with the meanes to rectifie or preuent them CHAP. I. The generall heads or springs of hypocriticall perswasions with briefe rules for their preuention 1. HHappy were we whom God hath appointed to sowe good seede in others hearts because not altogether without hope to see some fruits of our labours if this censorious age would permit vs to strike as freely at the rootes of Atheism infidelity or hypocrisy as it is ready to censure Atheists Infidels Hereticks or Hypocrites To me it hath often seemed a question very doubtfull but farre aboue my capacity to determine whether such as reuolt from the orthodoxall Church vpon obseruation of monstrous dissonancy betweene the truthes professed in it and the professors liues or resolutions be in case better or worse then such as embrace true religion vpon no better grounds then they or their confederates oppugne it Thus much the word of God will warrant that the portion of hypocrites shall be the bitterest in the life to come And yet hypocrisie if it be of that stampe which our Sauiour so much condemnes is alwaies moulded in that deepe notice or strong perswasion which men haue of their owne loue and others opposition vnto diuine truthes of their owne diligence and others negligence in performance of sundry duties expresly required by Gods lawe And this is a miserie of miseries peculiar to the hypocrite that whereas the height of others impiety ariseth from their opposing the way of truth and godlinesse this monster the more he detests falsehood and error or the impietie whether of others practises or opinions the more still he increaseth his owne corruption and warres vnwittingly against his owne soule For seeing loue to himselfe indulgence to his deare affections or carnall glorying in prerogatiues perhaps spirituall is the common roote as well of his imaginary loue vnto such points of truth as haue some kinde of coniunction with his humours as of the detestation he beares to others obliquities that in life or profession ill consort with him the oftener he lookes either on their knowne transgressions or his owne precise obseruance of such duties as by nature hee is addicted or otherwise accustomed to by both meanes he more pampers and nourishes that vicious habit whence the forementioned bad fruites did growe And thus at length by vsing the helpe of strong but impure vnruly affections to abandon particular errors he ouerthrowes his owne soule as the ancient inhabitants of this land did their state by vsing the Saxons aide to driue out the Picts 2. After this manner the Iew by nursing a loathsome conceit of Publicanes and open sinners dissoluâ—nessesse not tyed vnto so much as any solemn acknowledgement of their misdeeds or set forme of repentance tooke a surfet of those outward ceremonies which God had ordained as sauees to sharpen not as foode to satiate his appetite of sauing health Other-whiles fiercely bending his indignation against the idolatrie of the heathen by too much depression or debasement of their folly he sublimated his owne naturall inclination vnto pride and haughtinesse into presumptuous boasting in the purity of that lawe which God had giuen him by Moses Whence in the fulnesse of time sprung an irreconcileable hatred of the long expected Messias desperate contempt of his Gospell and wilful refusall of saluation preached in his name But howsoeuer the deadlinesse of this disease was most conspicuous in the fall of Gods chosen people whom wee may without suspition of slaunder seeing the holy Ghost hath written the obseruatioÌ„ safely charge with the infection yet the danger of it amongst all professors of true religion throughout euery age and nation continues the same as hauing a perpetuall cause in nature For whether wee speake of contraries morall or phisicall the enmities of the extreames is alwaies greater then betwixt them and the meane from which they alwaies so much further decline as they more eagerly entend their force each against other The greater strength heate and cold from their vicinity gather whether by mutual irritation or a secret kinde of daring each other to combate or by a stricter vnition of the materiall parts wherein their forces lodge the more both disagree with the luke-warme temper The more likewise the prodigall detests the niggards manners or the niggard his the farther both roaue the one ouer the other short from that marke whereat they aime but which truly liberality only hits And as the mutuall discord of extreames grows greater by the increase of their seueral strengths so the hastie or violent introduction of the one into a subiect capable of both makes waie for the others entertainment and excludes the meane which findes no entrance but where it is vshered by moderation So water too much or too violently heated is more apt to freeze then to retaine the middle temper Young prodigalls we often see turne old niggards seldome liberall vnlesse their education haue been exceeding good their naturall discretion extraordinary or the seeds of vertue in them very strong And what more vsuall then for a niggards feast because not agreeable to his ordinary disposition to smell of waste and prodigalitie Buzzards by naturall constitution through extreamity enforced to take heart and turne againe ouerrunning valour boisterously rush into fury And desperate hotshots once made to feele the smart of their folly become afterwards basely timerous The Cynicke could spurne at his fellow Philosophers pride but so as his scornfull heeles did bewray his preposterously proud ambitious heart 3. Are these obseruations true in workes of nature or morall affections onely and not in perswasions of religion Yes euen in these also for hath not the vntimely heat of indiscreete precisenesse disposed sundry in our daies to freeze the sooner in the dregges of Popery Haue not others mounted so high in groundlesse and presumptuous confidence that their sudden fall hath made them sinke for any helpe man could affoord without recouery into the very suds of melancholy and desperation Others vpon a dislike of their former hot enforced zeale haue changed their wonted confidence into carelesnesse and become open professors of licentiousnesse like the possessed childe in the Gospell falling sometimes into the fire sometimes into the contrary element And experience prooues it so common a thing for young Saints such I meane as affect to be ripe in holinesse ere well growne in ordinary discretion or common honesty to prooue old diuels that the bent of nature vnseasonable or too much curbed in the parents oftentimes burst out in the vnbridled affections of their children 4. The reason of the experiments whether in nature moralities or religion is as perspicuous as they are true For contrarie exstreames alwaies
cause of iustification by which our sinnes are formally remitted is as if we should aske one of their young pupils what were Latine for manus Iustification taken as we doe it for remission of sinnes not by inherent righteousnesse or ought within vs immediatly incompetible with them but by the externall merits of Christ is a forme or entity as simple as any formall cause can be and simple or vncompounded entities can neither haue formall causes or ought in proportion answearing to them Wherefore as I said it is either the follie or knauery of our aduersaries to demaund a formall cause of their iustification that deny themselues to beformallie iust in the sight of God For so to be iust and to bee iust onely by acceptance or non-imputation of vniustice are tearmes as opposite as can bee imagined Hee alone is formallie iust which hath that forme inherent in himselfe by which he is denominated iust and so accepted with God as Philosophers deny the same to be formally hot because it hath no forme of heate inherent in it but onely produceth heat in other bodies To be formally iust we for these reasons attribute onely vnto Christ who alone hath such righteousnesse inherent in himselfe as by the interposition of it betweene Gods iustice and sinfull flesh doth stop the proceeding of his iudgements as Phinehas zeale did stay the plague otherwise ready to deuoure the host of Israell Our aduersaries in that they acknowledge inherent righteousnesse to be the sole formall cause of iustification doe by the same assertion necessarily graunt it to be the sole true immediate cause of remission of sinnes of absolution from death and admisâ—ion to life This is the onely point from which they cannot start at which neuerthelesse whiles they stand they may acknowledge Christ come in the flesh crucified dead and buried or perhaps ascended into heauen but denie they doe the power of his sitting at the right hand of God the vertue of his mediation or intercession and more then halfe euacuate the eternity of his Priesthood as shall be shewed after this briefe explication of our assertion 2. When we teach iustification by faith and not by workes our meaning is by the doctrine of faith wee are bound to acknowledge and confesse that CHRIST IESVS by his eternall Priesthood whose offices in their seuerall places shall bee expressed is not onelie the sole meritorious cause of all graces or righteousnesse inherent requisite to finall absolution but these supposed in the party to bee absolued hee is likewise the sole immediate cause of finall absolution or iustification The latter part of this assertion may admit this ilustration Suppose a man not destitute of other senses yet ready euery moment to droupe or fall into some deadly fit vnlesse his spirits were refreshed by pleasant musicke we might truely say one in this case did liue by the sense of hearing for deafe hee should quickly die yet were musicke the sole immediate cause of his preseruation without actuall application of whose sound euen this sense it selfe by whose meanes his spirits refreshed better enable his other senses to their proper functions would foorthwith faile him In this sort doe sinfull men drawe life from CHRIST by faith alone by which likewise and not by workes wee are sayd to abide in him as being vnited in spirit to him albeit by abiding so vnited our other faculties are strengthened and viuificated to bring forth the fruits of righteousnesse The former instance notwithstanding doth not exemplifie the first part of our Assertion for musicke only continues life naturall which is supposed to haue another originall But if we speake of life spirituall maintained by saith and of which faith it selfe is a part it was originally and wholly deriued from CHRIST on whom faith and all other graces whatsoeuer tam in fieri quam infacto as well in the first production as during the time of their continuance and preseruation depend as essentially and perpetually as the light of the moone or other participated or reflected splendor doth on the brightnesse of the Sunne Nor may wee imagine that this borrowed and variable righteousnesse in vs though thus depending on the Sonne of righteousnesse is or can be euen whiles it remaines without eclipse or in such fulnesse as in this life the best men at any time are capable of sufficient for the time being to acquit or absolue vs if God should enter into iudgement with vs. This strict dependence of such righteousnesse as we haue on CHRISTS righteousnesse presupposed faith is said to iustifie vs not by any effects in vs deriued from him but by its transeunt acts reciprocally lifting vp our hearts to the fountaine whence grace and spirituall life doth flow and reflecting the beames or raies of our mindes thus illuminated vnto our mysticall head still deâ—iuing vertue from his crucified body to stint the deadly issues of sinne not vtterly to expell all reliques of vnrighteousnesse For when we take the eyes of faith of him albeit the habite of faith and other graces remaine as intire in vs as euer they were the very memory of transgressions past or the sight of sinnes inherent whilest we look on them deiect vs. According to this disferent aspect euen the best men liuing whilest this brittle glasse of mortality and mutability is in running may bee subiect to the like subalternation of hopes and feare the exiled Poâ—t hath expressed Spes mihi magna subest dum te mitissime Caesar Spes mihi respicio dum mea facta cadit Strength to my hopes doth still accrewe whil'st Caesars mildnesse I do vie we But mine owne facts whilest I beholde my heart doth faile my hopes growe colde But though sinne may often sting vs by fits and bring vs almost to deaths dore by vicissitude of despaire or dismaâ— yet we recouer as presently by faithfull looking on the glorious author as the Israelites did by beholding the visible signe of saluation 3. The controuersie hitherto proposed and declared in as scholasticke forme as our English tongue well can beare may be reduced in fewest tearmes and fittest for popular instruction vnto the right vse and immediate end of faith and other sanctifying graces We of reformed Churches with vnanimous consent of heart and minde belieue and teach and thou O CHRIST our Lord our life and strength giue iudgement out of thy throne of Maiestie whether not more agreeable to thy minde then shee which sits as Queene of heauen and brags as if she were thy best beloued Spouse or her children do That our Faith our Hope and Charitie or whatsoeuer pledges of thy fathers loue and fauour towards vs we through thy merits haue obtained were giuen vs not to alter but to better that plea we made before we had them Being by nature the sonnes of wrath and groning vnder the heauie burden of our sinnes with teares and sighes by thy precious blood by thy death and passion wee daily besought Him for
the gifts and graces of the spirit or not right vsing them to his glory that gaue them Thus much euery conscience that hath tasted of Gods mercy and goodnesse in Christ will be ready to confesse and this truth now deliuered by vs was in effect the doctrine of the learned and religious Bucer in his conference at Ratisbone with our aduersaries Although he that is iustified hath righteousnesse through Christ inherent the faithfull soule notwithstanding doth not rely on it but onely on the righteousnesse of Christ wherewith wee are endowed without which there neither is nor can be any righteousnesse A more full declaration of his opinion in this controuersie vasquez * out of the same conference hath ready gathered to our hands When certaine propositions which the Author of that conference cals ambiguous were brought vnto him amongst which this was the first faith is the beginning of iustification his answer was if this speech be meant of inchoated righteousnes renouation of the mind which consists in faith hope and charitie with other vertues we admit it for such righteousnesse wee grant to bee a gift yea a new creature in Christ of which we participate by faith yea faith is the first part of it seeing we can neither loue God nor conceiue true hope in Him vnlesse we first know him by faith This righteousnesse of renouation notwithstanding is not that by which we become so righteous in the sight of God as life eternall should be due vnto vs for it seeing it is imperfect and cannot satisfie the Law of God during the time of this mortall life another righteousnesse is required to wit the rightousnesse of God through which wee haue confidence in our Lord CHRIST and are established in the assurance of saluation The like resolution or state rather of this controuersie he gathers out of Chemnitius words as they are related by his aduersary Tiletan We teach not that beleeuers are iustified without righteousnesse for such iustification God himselfe hath pronounced to bee an abhomination in his sight Prou. â—â— ver 15. Isa 5. ver 23. but we thinke it necessary that in iustification righteousnesse should interceed or interpose and that not euery sort of righteousnesse but such as is sufficient in the iudgement of God such as is worthy of eternall life Now seeing that righteousnesse which consists in the internall renouation of our mindes by reason of carnall imperfection and vncleannesse adherent is not such necessary it is there should be another righteousnesse through whose interuention or intercession we are iustified in the sight of God 5. From this learned writer the Diuines of Colen and many Schoolemen acknowledged by the Romish Church for her children in other points did but a little dissent as the Iesuite grants and their words are so plaine that euery one may see might these men haue been chiefe delegates in this cause the controuersie had bin quickly ended The only difference can be picked by this curious inquisitor is but this Chemnitius and Bucer made our inherent righteousnesse as he wrongfully charges them a sin the diuines of Colen made it onely imperfect or no righteousnes without the merits of CHRIST to which it serued but as an instrument by their confession CHRIST righteousnesse was not only the efficient or meritorious cause for whose sake this righteousnesse innerent was bestowed vpon vs but the sorme which did so consummate it that is our iustification was accomplished by addition of his righteousnesse vnto ours Vnto this opinion amongst the rest euen Pighius himselfe who made so light accompt of originall sinne did subscribe not induced thereto as is pretended with the sweet discourses of his aduersaries but with the euidence of the truth they taught Indeed Pighius consequently to his error concerning the nature of originall sinne did hold our righteousnesse inherent imperfectionly for the quantity whereas Chemnitius and Bucer did hold it vnsufficient besides for the quality not that it was a sin but that it had sin so adherent as it could not make vs cleane and pure though but in imperfect measure in Gods sight We wil be content to take these Diuines mentioned with that troupe of most famous schoolemen as well antient as moderne expresly yeelded vs by Vasquez as more then fully sufficient either for worth or number to ouersway the authoritie of such later Pontificians as in the conference at Ratisbone or Auspurge or in that booke exhibited vnto Charles the fift before the Trent Councell maintained the contrarie opinion now established Vnto the Trent Councels authoritie because it hath determined for these later and obscurer against the former Schoolemen and vs we will oppose the authority of Scripture and principles of faith directly acknowledged by all but indirectly ouerthrowne by the Councels decree In examining of which it may excuse our boldnesse that so many of their writers should without censure before and some I take it sinte the promulgation of it teach the contrarie The sole formall cause of iustification is the righteousnesse of God not by which he is righteous but wherby hee makes vs righteous to wit that wherewith once endued we are renewed in the spirit of our minde and are not onely reputed iust but truely denominated iust as indeed we are by receiuing righteousnesse euery one according to that measure which the holy Spirit imparts vnto vs as he pleaseth and according to our seuerall proper dispositions or cooperations The formall cause or if that be not enough the sole formall cause of our iustification is righteousnes inherent which as the Romane Catechisme set out by the authoritie of the same Councell in plaine tearmes auoucheth must be so perfect as to leaue no staine or blot of sinne inherent in vs able to present our soules if I mistake not the meaning of it truely glorious at least splendent and beautifull in the sight of God Whatsoeuer else I haue charged their doctrine with they willingly grant to be necessarie consequences of the Councels determination and condemne vs as Heretickes for contradicting them And least we should suspect it might be a matter not altogether vnpossible for the Trent fathers to erre in that peremptory decree late Iesuties would perswade vs it were a matter altogether impossible for God almighty although he should vse his absolute power to iustifie vs by any other meanes then the Councell hath defined Some in their Chuch of no meaner note then the famous victoria and Melchior Canus with other of Aquinas followers publique professors too were not ashamed or afraid to teach that grace inherent did not make vs iust or acceptable in the sight of God by it meere entity or quallity that the value or estimate of it did depend vpon the will and pleasure of him that gaue it content to accept or pronounce vs once partakers of it as iust and holy though not such in our selues or though the inherent vertue of it as money is valuable not