ex dignitate operis not for the worthiness of the works done it mââ be due ratione pacti by reason of the Covenant that God freely made to ââlievers in Christ but 't is not due ratione sacti that is 't is not due foâ the worthiness of the works done Obj. But against all this Bellarmine and * Debate p. 14. Dr. Patrick object Mat. 25. from 31. to the end but chiefly the 34 35 verses Come ye blessed of my Father inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world for I was ãâã ââungred and ye gave me meat I was thirsty and ye gave me drink I ãâã a stranger and ye took me in c. Hence Bellarmine and Dr. Patrick would infer that good works of regenerated men are meritorious or efficient causes of their eternal salvation and consequently of their justification Ans To which I answer 1. That good works are via ad regnum as St. Bernard speaks but not causa regnandi they are the way that God hath appointed us to walk in to the kingdom of Heaven but they are not the cause of our reigning there they may be conditions sine quibus non without which we cannot get thither but not efficient causes of our getting there 2. 'T is true that God requires good works at our hands as fruits and evidences of justifying faith and as ââedent conditions to our eternal salvation and as manifestations of our love and thankfulness to God for his abundant love to us in our election sâstification adoption sanctification and preservation c. but not as conditiââs of the Covenant of Grace or as efficient or meritorious causes of our Justification or salvation or foreseen moving causes of our election 3. That the word for doth not always shew the cause of a thing but sometimes it renders the reason of a thing which reason may be drawn from the effect as 't is in Luke 7. 47. Her sins are forgiven for she loved much where by for is shewed not the cause why but the reason to prove that her sins were forgiven For she loved much Mary her great love was not the cause why her sins were forgiven her but the effect sign and evidence thereof she liad received much love from God therefore she loved God very much So here God is merciful for he rewardeth the merciful to his members according to their works this reason from the word for here is not from the cause of our inheriting the kingdom of Heaven but from the effect to prove the cause The argument may be thus They that are the elected justified and adopted Children of God shall inherit the kingdom of Heaven but you at my right hand are such ergo ye shall inherit the kingdom of Heaven the Minor our Saviour provâs by their works thus They that are for Christs sake merciful to Christs Members and Ministers are the elected justified and adopted Children of God but you are merciful for Christs sake to Christ's Members and Ministers Ergo you are the elected justified and adopted Children of God the Minor viz. that they were merciful for Christs sake to Christs Members and Ministers Christ proves by their works For I was an hungred and ye gave me meat c. So that here you may see that the Particle for is not used here causally but rationally it doth not declare the cause of their salvation but it declares a reason to prove that they were the blessed Children of God and heirs of the kingdom of heaven for he here proves their election quoad quod sit but not quoad cursit that they were elected c. but not why they were elected and therefore it makes nothing for the proof of Bellarmines or Dr. Patricks Doctrine This Doctrine that Christ hath merited that our good works might merit is one of Antichrist's delusions to be taken heed of 2 Thes 2. 11. lest we be induced to believe a lie that is the whole Antichristian Faith and Religion which is a complicated lie 2. This Doctrine of theirs implies either that Christ hath not sufficiently merited eternal life for us or that our meriting is vain and needless for that which is sufficiently done to that end by Christ needs not that it should be done again by us to that end 3. That whatsoever Papists say to the contrary 't is evident that they do divide the glory of meriting eternal life between Christ and Christians because they give it not solely to that grace that is in Christ but also to that grace that doth inhere in us or is done by us to which also they ascribe our justification And for a further evidence they exhort people to do good works by this argument 'T is more honourable to merit Dr. Ames Bel. Enervat t. 4. c. 72. p. 206. by a mans self than by another and ' tââ more honourable to have eternal life by merit than by gift as Bellarmines Durands and Tappers following word set down by Dr. Ames do plainly shew magis honorisicum c. that is It is more honourable to have eternal life by merit than only of gift saith Bellarmine Far be it that righteous men should expect eternal life as ãâã poor man doth an alms for it is much more glorious that they as conqâârors and triumphers do possess it as crown due to their labours so saith Tapper Tapper in Art Lovan t. 2. art 9. It is more honourable to have a thiââ by a mans self or of a mans self thââ ãâã another or by another for be that hath any thing by his own proper merit ãâã a manner hath it by himself in as much as he hath made that thing due ãâã him by his own proper action saith Dârand Now let any unprejudiced mââ Durand in 3. d. 18. that understands common reason judg what the Papists mean and what their words do signifie when they say That Christ hath merited that regenerated persons good works might merit eternal life and whether this be not as I said one of their strong delusions by which they are deceived themselves and endeavour to deceive others and whether these Popish Grandees false heretical and blasphemous Doctrines above Ames Bellar. Enervat t. 4. l. 7. c. 2. p. 209. recited as Guido the Hermit confessed in his revocation of them that they were do not rob God of the honour of his free grace and Christ our blessed Saviour of the honour of his inestimable merits and overthrow the Gospel yea blow up Christianity it self under the pretence of advancing it and utterly destroy the souls and bodies of many well-meaning people and pick the pockets of many thousands to fill the proud Pope of Romes Coffers and satisfie if it be possible the covetous ambitious and malicious lusts of that man of sin and his adherents let the world judg ART XIII That there is a place after this life called Purgatory wherein the souls of believers dying since Christs
necessary and edificative of the whole flock of Christ but are only made or said to be so by the will of man carrying a real appearance of evil and are scandalous to Papists and Protestants and establish such modes of Religious worship as are most conformable to the Gospel-rule and primo-primitive practise and not too like to and inductive of the Government and form of worship of the Apostatical and Antichristian Church of Rome I verily believe they would have more dutiful Sons and good Friends than now they have and the Church and Kingdom would have more peace and prosperity to which God of his great mercy incline their hearts However I beseech them to let their moderation be known to all men And I intreat all people without making any tumults upon any pretence whatsoever in their own places and callings quietly to endeavour and earnestly expect and pray for an amendment of what is amiss in Church and State to fear God and honour the King and submit to those that are in authority under him And so God keep you all Septemb. 29. 1673. R. R. B. D. The particular Doctrines renounced are these I. THat the Bread and Wine in the Lords-Supper after the Priests pronouncing these words with intention This is my Body and this is my Blood are turned or transubstantiated into the substance of Christs Body and Blood II. That Christ is really more present on the high Altar or Communion-Table as on his Throne or Chair of State than in the Pulpit or Font c. and that therefore more corporal bowing or more bodily reverence is due to the Altar or Communion-Table than to the Pulpit or Font. III. That mens persons are justified or accounted righteous before God for their own good works that follow Faith either in part or in whole and not for the merits of Jesus Christ alone IV. That Faith that doth justifie Believers persons before God is a bare and naked assent to the truth and that so and as an act habit or work in us it justifies V. That the persons of true Believers in Christ are not justified before God by the righteousness of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ imputed to them on Gods part and apprehended and applied by Faith alone on their part VI. That mens foreseen faith repentance good works c. were the true causes moving God to elect them to eternal Salvation VII That men unregenetate or in the state of nature have by their own free will power sufficient of themselves to turn themselves to God to believe in Jesus Christ repent and do good workâ acceptable to God when they will and also finally to resist the efficacious grace of God in converting an elected sinner to himself VIII That truly regenerated persons cannot be certain of their eternal Salvation but may totally and finally fall away from the acts and habits of saving Grace before they die and be eternally damned IX That the corruption of our nature commonly called Original sin which remaineth in truly regenerated persons after Baptism is not properly sin X. That meer men in this life since Adams fall can perfectly fulfill Gods whole Moral Law and also voluntarily do good works besides and above Gods Commandments which they call works of Supererogation which are as they say greater and holier than the works of the Moral Law and do merit remission of sin and eternal life not only for themselves but also for others XI That unregenerated mens own good works do make them meet to receive grace from God or as the School Doctors say deserve grace of congruity XII Thât the good works of ââregenerated men do ex condigno merit at Gods hands eternal life XIII That there is a place after this life called Purgatory wherein the souls of believers dying since Christs Resurrection are purged from sins by penal satisfaction which were not purged in this life so fully as they ought that they may enter into Heaven XIV That the Pope of Rome successively or the Papacy is not the Antichrist of which the Scripture writes XV. That it is lawful to set up and suffer Images of the Sacred Trinity of God the Father of God the Son or Crucifixes Of God the Holy Ghost or of Saints departed this life which have been worshipped in Temples or Churches where Gods people do usually meet to worship God XVI That those Books which are commonly called Apocryphal Scriptures as Tobit Judith c. are the pure word of God and in all things agreeable thereunto XVII That the Pope or Bishop of Rome is the supreme Head of the Universal Church of Christ above all Emperours Kings Princes Pastors People and Churches The Articles of Lambeth The Doctrine of the Churches of England and Ireland Arminianism is not the Doctrine of the Church of England Notes taken out of King James his Declaration against Vorstius King James no friend to Arminianism A Renunciation OF SEVERAL Popish Doctrines BECAUSE Contrary to the Doctrine of the Church of ENGLAND IN general I renounce and detest all Popish false Doctrine and all Popish Superstitious and Idolatrous Worship and practises and the real appearances thereof and in particular I renounce and detest these that follow ARTICLE I. That the Bread and Wine in the Lords-Supper after the Priests pronouncing these words with intention This is my Body and this is my Blood are turned or transubstantiated into the substance of Christs Body and Blood This I renounce because it is contray to the Doctrine of the Church of England which Article 28th faith thus Transubstantiation or the change of the substance of bread and wine in the Supper of the Lord cannot be proved by holy Writ but is repugnant to the plain words of Scripture overthroweth the Nature of the Sacrament and hath given occasion to many Superstitions The Body of Christ is given taken and eaten in the Supper only after an heavenly and spiritual manner and the mean whereby the Body of Christ is received and eaten in the Supper is faith And Homily of the worthy receiving the Sacrament it saith thus It is well known that the meat we seek for in the Supper is spiritual food the nourishment of our souls an heavenly refection and not earthly invisible meat and not bodily a ghostly substance and not carnal p. 200. It 's also contrary to the Church of England's declaration concerning kneeling at the end of the Communion-service The Sacramental bread and wine remain still in their very natural substances therefore may not be adored for that were Idolatry to be abhorred of all faithful Christians and the natural body and blood of our Saviour Christ are in heaven and not here it being against the truth of Christs natural body to be at one time in more places than one This declaration is not only against the Papists Transubstantiation but also fully against the Lutherans Consubstantiation viz. That Christs body and blood is really and corporally in the bread and wine Both which
for the merits of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ * That is applied by faith as the Thirtyfourth Article of the Church of Ireland explains it by faith and not for our own good works That we are justified by faith only is a most wholsome Doctrine As more largely is expressed in the Homily of Justification 2. In her Homilies as Homily for Salvation of Mankind p. 13 14 15 16. No man by his own acts works or deeds seem they never so good can be justified and made righteous before God but every man is of necessity constrained to seek for another righteousness or justification to be ââceived at Gods own hands that is to say forgiveness of his ãâã And this justification or righteousness whiââ we so receive of Gods mercy * Vide 34. Article of the Church of Ireland and Christs âârits imbraced by Faith is taken accepted ãâã allowed by God for our perfect and full justiââcation On our part we are justified by Faith ãâã the merits of Christ which is not ours ãâã by Gods working in us We are justified freely by Faith withoââ the works of the Law Ambrose saith That is the Ordinance of Goââ that they which believe in Christ should be saved without worââ by faith only freely receiving remission of their sins And p. 18 ãâã Faith putteth us from it self and remitteth or appointeth us ãâã Christ for to have only by him remission of our sins or justificatioââ So that our Faith doth as it were say to us It is not I that take ââway your sins but it is Christ only and to him only I send you ãâã that purpose forsaking therein all your good vertues wordââ thoughts and works and only putting your trust in Christ bâbâcause Faith doth directly send us to Christ for remission of our siââ and that by Faith given us of God we embrace the promise of Goâ mercy and of the remission of our sins which thing none otheâ of our vertues or works properly doth therefore the Scriptuââ useth to say That Faith without works doth justifie Faith onlâ justifieth us is all one with St. Paul Faith without works justifietâ us And in her Homily of Christs Death and Passion T. 2. p. 186 187 The only mean or instrument of Salvation required of our part iâ Faith that is a sure trust and confidence in the mercies of God whereby we perswade * This Mr. Fowler calls a strong fancying and thereby labours to scoff us out of our Religion and Faith p. 127 130. of his Free Discourse our selves that Goâ both hath and will forgive our sins that he hath accepted us again into his favour and that he hath released us from the bonds of damnation and received us into the number of his Elect-people not for our deserts but only and solely for the merits of Christs Death and Passion who became man for our sakes and humbled himself to sustain the reproach of the Cross that we thereby might be saved and made inheritors of the Kingdom of Heaven and Faith shall be imputed to us for righteousness as well as it was to Abraham Isaac and Jacob. And Ibid. p. 188. 't is said thus Faith is the only instrument of Salvation now left unto us By which 't is clear that it justifieth not as an act habit or work âut only as an instrument apprehending and applying the righteousness of Christ Observe that the word Faith in this Proposition We are âustified by faith is to be understood relatively with relation to or coâotation of its object and is sense equivalent to this We are justified by Christs merits or righteousness apprehended and applied by faith Here is a Metonimie where the effect of the principal cause Christ is attriâuted to the instrumental cause Faith as the Plow is said to enrich the husbandman and eating is said to nourish that is instrumentally it 's the corn that enricheth and the meat that is eaten nourisheth the Plow and eating are but the instruments So 't is said We are saved by hope that is by Christ in whom we do hope so here 't is said that faith justifieth that is Christs righteousness received and applied by Faith to the Believer justifieth him in Gods sight 2. Because 't is contrary to the judgment and declared Doctrine of all those learned and Orthodox Divines and * Vide Latter Confession of Helvetia p. ãâã King James in his pious Meditations upon certain Verses of Revel 20. saith the Pope is Antichrist and Popery the loosing of Satan which he proves by several marks among the rest this is one Blasphemeth he not in denying us to be saved by the imputation of Christ his righteousness p. 78. And K. James also saith That Christs sealed ones have washed their garments made themselves white in the blood of the Lamb for they by vertue of his deaâh are made righteous by imputation whose blood is the only full purgation of us from our sins In his Par. on Rev. c. 7. p. 22. Confessions I named before as may be seen before Yea and 't is contrary to the Doctrine of the Reformed Churches as Mr. Pemble very fully and learnedly manifesteth against Papists and Arminians and Socinians in his Treatise of Justification Sec. 2. c. 1. p. 159. where he sheweth that the sentence of the Reformed Churches concerning the manner how Faith justifieth consisteth in two Branches 1. That a sinner is justified by faith not properly as it is a quality or action which by its own dignity and merit deserves at Gods hands remission of sins or is by Gods favourable acceptance taken for the whole and perfect righteousness of the law which is otherwise required of a sinner but only in relation unto the object of it the righteousness of Christ which it embraceth and resteth upon 2. That a sinner is justified by faith in opposition unto the righteousness works in the fulfilling of the Law whereby no man now can be justified Where interpreting this Proposition a man is justified by faith faith We must understand all things relatively thus a sinner is justified the sight of God from all sin and punishment by faith that is by the obeââence of Jesus Christ believed on and imbraced by a true faith And this ââterpretation of that Proposition the Reformed Churches do admit and ãâã other rejecting as erroneous and contrary to the Scriptures such gloââ as ascribe any thing to the * As Dr. Heylin Dr. Hammond Dr. Patrick and Mr. Fowler do as I have declared before dignity faith or make any combination betwâââ faith and works in the point of our Jusââfication Amongst which there are thâââ erroneous assertions touching mans Juâââfication by faith which they reject 1. That faith justifieth us per modum causae efficientis meritoââ as a proper efficient and meritorious cause which by its own worth and âânity deserves to obtain Justification remission of sins and the grace well doing this is properly Popish which he refutes
* This is an old Pelagian Error as St. Aug. shewed l. 2. de Predest Sanct. c. 18. Alvarez de Auxil Div. Gracââ Disp 1. p. 12. n. 16. Faith repentance good works and perseverance were the true causes moving God to elect them to eternal Salvation THis I renounce Because 1. 't is contrary to the Doctrine of the Church of England Homily of Christs Death and Passion T. 2. p. 2. p. 186. Christs death was caused by mans sin and Gods mercy proccedeed from Gods free love to mankind without any merit or desert on our part And a little before in the same Homily p. 1ââ Our acts and deeds are full of imperfectness and infirmities and therefore nothing worthy of themselves to stir God to any favour And therefore I conclude that it proceeded not from mans foreseen good-will or Gods foresight that he would use his will well as believe in Christ and persevere in well-doing c. but from Gods own good will to him 2. 'T is contrary to Sacred Scripture for the holy Scriptures do every where where they treat of this Election ascribe it to Gods ãâã ãâã ãâã ãâã ãâã Purpose good-will or free-grace as Ephes 1. 4. 5. According as he hath chosen us in him before the foundations of the world That we should be holy and without blame before him in love having predestinated us unto the adoption of children by Jesus Christ to himself according to ãâã good pleasure of his will to the praise of the glory of his grace where he hath made us accepted in the beloved Where 't is clear that we are ââcted to holiness and not for our holiness of which Faith is a chief paââ So verse the ninth of the same Chapter Having made known unto the mystery of his will according to his good pleasure which he hath pââposed in himself So v. 11. Being predestinated according to the purpose him who worketh all things after the counsel of his own will So 2 Tim. 1ââ Not according to our works but according to his own purpose and grace which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began So Rom. 9. 1ââ 16. I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy and I will have compââ on on whom I will have compassion So then it is not of him that willeth ãâã of him that runneth but of God that sheweth mercy So Rom. 9. 11 12 1â For the children being not yet born neither having done any good or ãâã that the purpose of God according to election might stand not of works ãâã of him that calleth It was said to her The elder shall serve the youngââ as it is written Jacob have I loved but Esau have I hated So Rom 8 ãâã 30. For whom he did foreknow he also did predestinate to be conformeâ ãâã the image of his Son that he might be the first-born among many brethââ mark it they were predestinated that they might be conformed to the image of Christ not because he foresaw they would be so themselves Moreover whom he did predestinate them he also called and whom called them he also justified and whom he justified them he also glorifiââ From whence I reason thus 1. If mens foreseen Faith good works and perseverance thereiâ did move God to elect them to Salvation then their Election was nââ of mercy and free grace but of justice seeing he did but chuse thââ to glory because he saw they were worthy and so their Electiââ was not of Gods free grace but of mans desert 2. If God elected men to eternal life because he did foresee thââ would believe and do good works c. then Election was of him thââ willeth and of him that runneth and not of him that sheweth mercy which is directly contrary to the express word of God 3. If Elect on was for foreseen Faith and good works then it follows that the object of Election was not fallen man and so miserable and an object of mercy as all our most sound Divines do commonly hold and which opinion the Popish Arminian party approââ of more than they do of the Superalapsarian way but man restored ãâã grace and justified which all sound Divines deny 4. The effect of Election was not cannot be the moving cause of Election But Faith and good works are the effects of Election and therefore they were not they cannot be the moving cause of Gods electing men to Salvation The Major is undensable because the cause is before the effect and the effect is after the cause The Minor is clear by express Scripture Act. 13. 48. And as many as were ordained to eternal life believed Where 't is evident that their believing is an effect or fruit of Gods ordaining them to eternal life So Ephes 1. 4. According as he hath chosen us in him before the foundations of the world that we should be holy and without blame before him And Rom. 8. 29 30. Whom he did foreknow that is eternally elect he also did predestinate to be conformed to the image of his Son Where conformity to the image of Christ is an effect of Predestination not a cause moving God to elect us and by conformity cannot be meant only of conformity to Christ in suffering afflictions or bearing the Cross as Arminians would falsely expound the place for so many of Gods elect Infants and others would be excluded out of the number of Gods Elect. For many of them pass out of this world without suffering of the Cross as Christ did and live here in this world in wealth and peace and honour And the next following words gainsay that gloss That he might be the first-born among many brethren Now Christ was not only the first-born among many brethren in regard of suffering affliction but also and chiefly in respect of holiness and happiness We his Elect-brethren are predestihated to be conformed to him in righteousness and holiness here and glory and happiness hereafter and consequently that we might believe and do good works and persevere therein For these are part of our inherent righteousness or conformity to Christ our elder Brother He was called properly the first-born for his superexcellent grace and in that our conformity to him here was predestinated from all eternity and also our Glorification with him in Heaven hereafter as the next words explain the former Whom he did predestinate them he also called justified and glorified Vocation Justification and Glorification are the things we are to be conformed to the Image of Christ And here may be observed that Vocation and Justification and Glorification whiâh include or presuppose Faith in Christ and good works and perseverance are fruits of Election and not causes 5. If our Election was of foreseen Faith and good works thââ Gods electing of us was in order of nature after and the fruit ãâã our electing of God and so we should be said to chuse him ãâã love him first which is directly contrary to Canonical Scripturâ Joh. 15. 16. Ye
attributed to faith because ãâã other graces are virtually therein contained and that is the principle froâ whence they are derived Whereas thâ truth is it is only ascribed to faith and that because it is the only grace thââ doth apprehend and apply the righteousness of Christ to the sinner as the Church of England teacheth iâ her Homily of Salvation of Mankind the third Part pag. 19. Faiââ only is said to justifie because it doth directly send us to Christ for remissioâ of sins and that by faith given us of God we embrace the promise of Goâ mercy and of the remission of our sins which thing NONE OTHER ãâã our vertues or works properly doth therefore the Scripture useth to say that faith without works doth justifie Who saitâ also That as * Free Discourse pag. 188. works signifie sincere obedience ãâã Christs Gospel neither I nor those Preacherr can account it any scandal to have it said of us that ãâã hold JUSTIFICATION BY WORKS he must mean it of Justification of mens persons before God else he beats the air or cunningly equivocates And indeed so he explains himself Nor need we so mince it as to say that faith justifieth our persons and good works our faith for understanding works I say for a * Pag. 189. working faith our persons if ever they be Socinians define justifying Faith to be obedience fides justificans est obedientia Catech Racov. c. 9. The old Photinian Hereticks called it a new creature Wendelin Ch. Theol. l. 1. c. 25. p. 476. compare Dr. H's Dr. P's and Mr. F's Doctrines of Faith and Justification with Socinians and Photinians c. must be justified by them Which is directly and expresly contrary to the Doctrine of the Church of England in heâ Articles and Homilies before alledged Sure I am that these mens Doctrine gives great advantage to Popery and is directly contrary to the prime design of Christianity which is to advance the glory of Gods free grace in giving us his only begotten Son Jesus Christ who died for our sins and rose again for our justification and sets up Justification by our own righteousness which is the same false and Antichristian Doctrine the Papists teach How Dr. â Just as the Semi-Pelagians do as Alvarez shews de auxil div grat disp 2. pag. 19 20. Heyliâ divideth Justification between faith and good works may be seen in his Introduction to his Cyprianus Anglicus p. 28. Sect. 29. What false Doctrine concerning Justification others of A. B. Laua's party have taught in his time may be seen in those two Books collected to your hands viz. Laudensium Autocatacrisis and Laudensium Apostasia One word to these men What Divine that understood himself and did not intend to cheat men into a Popish Photinian Socinian or Arminian belief of Justification by a mans own inherent righteousness and consequently denying of Christs by which alone our persons are justified before God ever went about to put good works or new obedience into the definition of Faith as it justifieth our persons before God What is it a cheat in Bishop Sanderson and all sound Logicians and Philosophers to define a man to be animal rationale becaus they make no mention of risibility which necessarily flows from his principles and is really inseparable from him Did you never read nor hear of a praecisââe separation of a property from its proper subject that is a consideration of the subject without considering the property if not I shall not doubt but that you have studied Rhetorick more than Logick and Natural Philosophy though you brag much of your rational Discourses and Religion too Now if the subject may be defined without its proper passion pray may not the cause be considered and defined too without its effects Bishop Sanderson * Log. l. 3. c. 17. par 5. p. 64. teacheth us to define habits by their end and object And Philosophers tell us that Habitus distinguuntur per actus actus per objecta Habits must be distinguished by their acts and acts by their objects Now the proper act of faith as it justifies mens persons before God is not to work by love and resolve upon new obedience as you insinuate but to receive the proper object of Justification which is not Gods commands formally considered as you insinuate but the righteousness of Jesus Christ called the Lord our righteousness and do not Philosophers give us two definitions of the soul the one as 't is a form of the body thus Anima est ãâã ãâã ãâã ãâã ãâã corporis physici organici vitam habentis in potentia and the other as 't is the efficient cause of its operations thus Anima est principium quo vivimus sentimus movemur intelligimus primo what do they put a cheat upon the world and illusions because in the first they mention not its effects so here faith is in the Doctrine of Justification considered by our and your orthodox Divines as the form of Justification taken passively whereby believers lay hold on Christ with all his merits by the hand of faith and apply them to themselves Here I say they do not consider faith as an efficient principle or cause of either Bishop Davenant de justitia habituali c. 22. p 312. inward graces or outward good works for all these are excluded or to use our * Homily of Salvation of Mankind p. 16 17. Faith shutteth not out repentance hope love fear of God to be joined with faith in every man that is justified but it shutteth them out from the office of justifying c. Homilies word shut out from the business of Justification of sinners persons before God as I shewed before out of St. Paul's and the Church of England's Doctrine And they may reason thus that which Faith excludeth from justification of sinners persons before God cannot be put into the definition of Faith formally considered as so justifying but Faith formally considered as justifying sinners persons before God excludeth works from Justification of sinners persons before God For Faith and works are in this point opposed every where by S. Paul as was manifested before out of the Doctrine of the Church of England as well as St. Paul's Therefore good works cannot be put into the definition of faith as 't is justifying of sinners persons before God And 't is observable by the way too that Faith shutteth out repentance and fear of God as well as love from the office of justifying of sinners persons before God as our Homily quoted in the Margent plainly declareth And therefore it excludeth Mr. Fowler 's sincere resolution of obedience to all the precepts of the Gospel not only from the definition of Faith as justifying but also from the office of justifying mens persons before God In the point of justifying of mens persons before God these * Mr. Fowler 's Free Discourse p. 127. quarrelsome sottish men as you are pleased out of
grace aââ act or habit or quality inherent in us And if we be justified by the righteousness of Christ only which being out of us in him imputed to those who receive it by Faith which also * Lib. 4 5. before I invincibly proved then also it followeth by necessary consequence that we are justified by Faith only as it is the instrument or hand of the soul ãâã apprehend or receive Christ who is our righteousness wherefore where Faith is said to justifie it must of necessity be understood relatively and in respect of the object to which purpose both Justification and all other benefits which we receive by Christ are attributed to Faith as I have shewed ¶ L. 6. c. 4. Sec. 6. before Not that Faith worketh these things but because by it we receive Christ and with him aââ his merits and benefits And for the same cause the Faith of all the faithful though unequal in degrees in some greater in some less is ãâã ãâã ãâã ãâã ãâã alike precious in the righteousness of God and our Saviour Jesus Christ 2 Pet. 1. 1. which is an evidence That faith doth not justifie in respeââ of its dignity or worthiness but in respect of the object which it doth receive which being the most perfect righteousness of Christ untâ which nothing can be added is one and the same to all that receivââ it Of tâis see more Lib. 1. c. 2. Sec 10. 4. Bishop Reynolds upon Psal 110. 4. p. 443. saith thus So theââ between Christ and us there must be an unity or else there can be no imputation and therefore it is that we are said to be justified by faith and that faith is imputed for righteousness Rom. 4. 5. not the ãâã ãâã ãâã ãâã ãâã credere the act of believing as if that were in se accounted righteousness as it is a work proceeding from us by grace but because it is vinculum instrumentum unionis the bond of union between us and Christ and by that means makes way to the imputation of Christs righteousness unto us And the same reverend learned and orthodox Bishop in his most excellent Treatise of the Life of Christ p. 476. saith That preciousness of faith is seen chiefly in two respects 1. In regard of the Objects and 2. In regard of the Offices of it And p. 478. he saith That the Offices which are peculiar to faith are principally these three 1. To unite to Christ and give possession of him 2. The second office wherein consisteth * P. 480. the excellency of faith is the consequent of the former namely to justifie a man for there is no man righteous in the sight of God any further than he is taken into the * I have inserted this not only because it makes way for what I have chiefly to alledg but also that those Antichristian Popish Arminian Socinian men who call themselves Protestants and the dutiful Sons of the Church of England that do not only deny but deride and scoff at union and communion with Christ which is indeed the ground of all our happiness here and hereafter may take notice of what a learned Bishop of their party in two several Treatises saith and proveth unity of Christ and into the fellowship of his merits God is alone well pleased in Christ and ââll a man be a member of his body a part of his fulness he cannot a pear in Gods presence This was the reason why Christ would bave none of his bones broken or taken off from the Communion of his natural body Joh. 19 36. to note the indissoluble union which was to he between him and his mystical members So that now as in a natural body the member is certainly fast to the whole so long as the bones are firm and sound so in the mystical where the body is there must every member be too because the bones must not be broken asunder If then Christ go to heaven if he stand unblameable before Gods justice we all shall in him appear so too because his bones cannot be broken That which thus puts us into the unity of Christ must needs justifie our persons and set us right in the presence of God and this is our faith The Apostle gives two excellent reasons why our Justification should be of faith rather than of any other grace the first oâ Gods part that it might be of grace The second on the part of the promise that the promise might be sure to all the seed Rom. 4. 16. First Justification that is by faith is of meer grace and favour no way of work or merit sor the act whereby faith justifies is an act of humility and self-dereliction a holy despair of any thing in our selves and a going to Christ a receiving a looking towards him and his all-sufficiency so that as Mary said of her self so we may say of faith the Lord hath respect unto the lowliness of his grace which is so far from looking inward for matter of Justification that it self as it is a work of the heart Tâ credere doth not justifie but only as it is an apprehension or * This Mr. Fowler saith is false in his Free Discourse p. 129. taking hold of Christ For as the hand in the very receiving of a thing must needs first make it self empty if it be full before it must let all go erâ it take hold of any other thing so faith being a receiving of Christ Joh. 1. 12. must needs suppose an emptiness iâ the soul before Faith hath two properties as a hand to work and to receive when faith purifies the heart supports the drooping spirits worketh by love carries a man through afflictions and the like these are the works of faith wheâ faith accepts of righteousness in Christ and receives him as the gift of his Fathers love when it embraceth the promises afar off Heb. 11. 13. and lays hold on eternal life 1 Tim. 6. 12. this is the receiving act of faith Now faith justifies not by working * This is directly against Mr. Fowler 's Doctrine before mentioned and against Dr. Heylin's too lest the effect should not be wholly of grace but partly of grace and partly of works Ephes 2. 8 9. but by bare receiving and accepting or yielding consent to that righteousness which in regard of working was the righteousness of Christ Rom. 5. 18. and in regard of disposing imputing appropriating unto us was the righteousness of God Rom. 3. 21. 1 Cor. 1. 30. Phil. 3. 9. Pag. 480 481 482. 3. The third Office of faith is to give us with Christ all things 5. I might alledg the Testimony of Luther Calvin Beza Peter Martyr Zanchy Musculus Pareus Polanus Tilenus Vrsinus Wendelinus Wollebius Festus Hominius Amesius Junius Macrobius Sharpius Piscator Threââ and many more of our own Writers but those you usually answer by slighting saying they were particular men and Presbyterians or Nonconformists therefore I forbear but I
have not chosen me but I have chosen you and ãâã dained you that ye should go and bring forth fruit and that your frââ should remain Where 't is clear that the Apostles who reprsented not only Ministers of the Gospel but also all Gods Churcâ which consists only of his Elect did not chuse God first but ãâã chose them first And that he did not ordain them to eterâââ life because he did foresee that they would go and bring for t fruit and persevere in well-doing but that they and by conââquence we might do so So 1 Joh. 4. 10. Herein is love not that ãâã loved God but that he loved us That is first as the 19 verse ãâã pounds this tenth We love him because he loved us first 6. Gods Election of man to Salvation cannot be from his foâ seeing that man would believe and do good works for ãâã hath not since his Fall sufficient power of himself to will to bâlieve or do good works for it is God that worketh in us both ãâã will and to do Ephes 2. 13. Yea the Apostle speaks plainly Epââ 2. 8. That we are saved by grace through faith and that that faith is not ãâã our selves but that 't is the gift of God And so holds the Churââ of England frequently in her Book ãâã Homilies For it is the Holy Ghost ãâã Homil. of the Nativity of Christ T. 2. p. â67 no other thing that doth quicken ãâã minds of men stirring up good and gââ motions in their hearts which are agreeable to the will and commanâment of God such as otherwise of their own crooked and perverse ââture they should never have That which is born of the flesh is fleââly as who should say man of his own nature is fleshly and câânal and corrupt and naught sinful and disobedient to Gââ without any spark of goodness in him without any vertuous or goââ motions only given to evil thoughts and wicked deeds as for the fruit of the Spirit the fruit of faith charitable and godly motions if he haââ any at all in him they proceed only of the Holy Ghost who is the ãâã worker of our Sanctification and maketh us new men in Christ Jesââ ãâã Homily concerning the coming down of the Holy Ghosâ p. 209. We must needs agree that whatsoever good thing is in us either of grace or nature or fortune is of God only as the only authââ and worker Verily that holy Prophet Isaiah beareth record and saitâ O Lord it is thou of thy goodness that bast wrought all our works in us not we our selves And to uphold the truth in this matter against all justitiaries and hypocrites which rob Almighty God of his honour and ascribe it to themselves St. Paul bringeth in his belief We be not saith he sufficient of our selves as of our selves once to think any goodthing but all our ableness is of Gods goodness for he it is in whom we have all our being our living and moving It is meet to think that all spiritual goodness cometh from God above only Homily for Rogation-Week p. 217. 3. 'T is contrary to the Doctrine of the reformed Churches The French Church saith thus We believe that out of this universal corruption and damnation wherein by nature all men are drowned God did deliver and preserve some whom by his eternal and immutable counsel of his own goodness and MERCY WITHOVT ANY RESPECT OF THEIR WORKS he did choose in Christ Jesus and others he left in that corruption and damnation in whom he might as well make manifest his justice by condemning them justly in their time as also declare the riches of his mercy in the others The Confession of the Church of Belgia is this We believe that God after the whole off-spring of Adam was cast head-long into perdition and destruction through the fault of the first man hath declared and shewed himself to be such a one as he is indeed namely both merciful and just merciful in delivering and saving those from condemnation and from death whom in his eternal counsel of HIS OWN FREE GOODNESS he hath Aliud est in Christo legi aliud in Christo esse in Christo elegi est ex mundo numero periuntium ãâã Christo ut redemptus ab ipso fide donatus in ipso Mac. red Th. Pol. ãâã 7. q. 4. p. 67. chosen in Jesus Christ WITHOUT ANY REGARD AT ALL OF THEIR WORKS Harmony of Confessions Sect. 5. p. 86 87. The Church of Ireland in the 14th Article of her Confession of Faith saith thus The cause moving God to predestina te unto life is not the foreseeing of faith or perseverance or good works or of any thing which is in the person predestinated but only the good pleasure of God himself for all things being ordained for the manifestation of his glory and his glory being to appear both in the works of his mercy and of his justice it seemed good to his heavenly Wisdom âo chuse out a certain number towards whom he would extend his undeserved mercy leaving the rest to be spectacles of his justice And ãâã former part of this Article is the Doctrine of the Church of Eââland also in express terms set down in the second Article of ââbeth to be seen in the end of this book how and by whom Arââ bishop Whitgift and several Bishops Fletcher Elect of London Vââhan Elect of Bangor Tindale Dean of Eli Dr. Whitaker Mr. Perkiââ Mr. Chaderton c. and upon what account Dr. Heylin in part shââ in his Cyprianus Anglicus lib. 3. p. 2â 204. viz. Peter Baroes venting Arâânian It cannot be denied but that the same Doctrine is maintained by Arminius and that it is the very same with that of the Church of Rome as appears by the Council of Trent Coââ 3 4. Heylins Introduction to his Cyp. Anglicus p. 36. which as Dr. Heylin himself câââfesseth is agreeable to Franciscan ââpish Doctrine and which the Parliment of 1628. remonstrated to the ãâã and Kingdom to be a cunning ãâã bring in Popery the professors of ãâã opinions being common disturbers of ãâã Protestant Churches and incendiarieâ ãâã those States wherein they have gotteââ head being Protestanis in shew but Jesuits in opinion and practise ãâã Angl. l. 3. p. 181. Now that the Articles of Lambeth are the seââ of the Doctrine of the Church of England may be gathered not ââly from A. B. Vshers taking these Articles into the Articles of Religââ of Ireland and King James his approving of them but also by ãâã declarations of the Commons Assembled in Parliament in or abââ the year 1628 June 14. We ãâã Commons of England now Assembââ Declaration of the Commons in Parliament do claim profess ãâã aver for truth the sense of the Aââcles of Religion which were established in Parliament the ãâã year of Queen Elizabeth which by the publick Acts of the Churcââ of England and the general and current exposition of the
Writer of our Church have been delivered to us and we reject the sââ of the Jesuits Arminians and all others wherein they differ frââ us To be seen in Dr. Heylins Cyprianus Anglicus l. 3. p. 190. Aâ the Parliament afterward declared ãâã presly the Articles of Lambeth to be ãâã Articles of Lambeth declared to be the Doctrine of the Church of England Doctrine of this Church of England ãâã that all that did oppose them were to ãâã called in question which declaratioâ Heylin informs us of in his Cyp. Angliââ l. 3. p. 197. The Synod of Dort in which were several of our Learnââ and Orthodox Divines as Bishop Carleton Davenant Hall Dr. Ward Dr. Belcanquall in their 1st Chapter and 9th Article say thus This said Election was made not upon foresight of faith and the obedience of faith holiness or of any other good quality or disposition as a cause or condition before required in men to be chosen but unto faith and the obedience of faith holiness c. and therefore Election is the fountain of all saving-good from whence faith holiness and the residue of saving-gifts lastly everlasting life it self do flow as the fruits and effects thereof according to that of the Apostle Ephes 1. 4. He hath chosen us not because we were but that we should be holy and without blame before him in love And therefore Error the 5th they reject as erroneous the Doctrine of them who teach That the incompleat and not peremptory Election We deny any such incompleat Election of singular persons is made by reason of foreseen Faith Repentance Sanctity and Godliness begun or continued for some time but the compleat and peremptory Election by reason of the final perseverance of foreseen Faith Repentance Sanctity and Godliness and this is the gracious and evangelical worthiness by which he that is chosen becomes worthier than he that is not chosen and therefore that faith the obedience of faith sanctity godliness and perseverance are not the fruits and effects of unchangeable Election unto glory but conditions and causes sine quibus non that is to say without which a thing is not brought to pass before required and foreseen as already performed by those who are compleatly to be chosen A thing repugnant to the whole Scripture which everywhere beats into our ears and hearts these and such-like sayings Rom. 9. 11. Election is not of works but of him that calleth Act. 13. 48 As many as were ordained unto life-eternal believed Ephes 1. 4 He hath chosen us that we should be holy John 15. 16 Ye have not chosen me but I have chosen you Rom. 11. 6 If of grace not of works 1 John 4. 10 Herein is love not that we loved God but that he first loved us and sent his Son c. The Church of Scotland saith That those of manking that are predestinated unto life God before the foundations of the world were laid according to his eternal and immutable purpose and the secret counsel and good pleasure of his will hath chosen in Christ unto everlasting glory out of his meer free-grace and love without any foresight of faith or good works or perseverance in either of them or any other thing in the creature as conditions or causes moving hiâ thereunto and all to the praise of his glorious grace Whiââ Confession may be seen in the Confession of Faith made by the ãâã learned Assembly of Divines c. 3. Art 5. 4. 'T is contrary to the Doctrine and Confession of our godly Maâtyrs Robert Clover Master of Arts and Martyr in answer to ãâã Devil objecting against him his own unworthiness saith That ãâã Fathers before him were no bringers of any goodness to Goâ but altogether receivers they choââ not God first but God chose thââ Fox his Acts and Monuments in one Folio p. 1618. 2 Col. first they loved not God first ãâã he loved them first yea he boââ loved and chose them when thââ were his enemies full of sin and corruption and void of ãâã goodness And that stout and learned and orthodox Martyr Mr. John Philpot in answer to Dr. Saverson and saying thââ Where is there one of your Synagogues of Rome that ever hââ been able to answer any of the godly learned Ministers of ãâã many who have disclosed your counterfeit Religion Which ãâã you all at this day is able to answer Calvins Institutions whâââ is Minister of Geneva To whom Dr. Saverson said A goââ Minister indeed of Cut-purses and Runnagate Traitors and of ãâã I can tell you there is such contention fallen between him and ãâã own Sects that he was fain to fly ãâã Town * A gross lye or mistake which Hooker in his Preface to his Eccles Pol. confutes about Predestination ãâã whom and which John Philpot ãâã swereth thus I am sure you blaspheââ that godly man and that godly Cââ where he is Minister as it is your Churches condition when you ãâã not answer men by learning to oppress them with blasphemies and ãâã reports for in the matter of Predestiââtion * Fox Acts and Monuments in one Volume p. 1697. 2 Col. HE IS IN NO OTHER OPINION THAN ALL THE DOCTORâ OF THE CHURCH BE AGREEING TO THE SCRIPTURES Mark ãâã words for the matter of Predestination he that is Calvin is of ãâã other opinion than all the Doctors of the Church be and agreeiââ to the Scriptures And in answer to the Bishop of Coventrey ãâã said plainly thus * Fox Acts and Monuments in one Volume p. 1721. 1 Col. I allow the Church of Geneva and the Doctrine of the same for it is una Catholica Apostolica and doth follow the Doctrine the Apostles did teach And when his Keeper at Newgate his old acquaintance promised him all kindness and favour if he would recant his Heresie he answered resolutely and plainly thus I will never recant whilest I have my life that which I have spoken for Fox Acts and Monuments in one Volume p. 1722. 2 Col. it is a most certain truth and in witness whereof I will seal it with my blood which he did few days after Now what Calvin held concerning Predestination in general may be seen at large in his Institutions and what of this one particular may be found there lib. 3. c. 22. Sect. 1 2 3. clear against the Doctrine of Papists concerning Gods electing man to salvation for his foreseen faith c. and Sect. 6. may be seen his Doctrine clearly against Popish and Arminian Writers exposition of the 9th Chapter to the Romans where Mr. Fowlers shifts and glosses are answered too which he hath cunningly and perniciously inserted in pag. 263 c. of his free Discourse too large now here to be inserted I have been the larger in setting down these Confessions because Archbishop Laud in his too much applauded Relation of his Conference with Fisher p. 36. saith thus The Church of Rome and Protestants set not up a different Religion
of jusââ fication or to commit the sin unââ death or against the Holy Ghost oââ to be altogether forsaken of him and throw themselves headlong into everlasting destruction c. 7. For first ãâã all in these slips he preserveth ãâã them that his immortal seed bâ which they were once born again that it die not nor be lost by them afterward by his Word and Spirit he effectually and certainly reneweth them again unto repentance so that they do heartily and according unto God grieve for their sins committed and with a contrite heart by faith in the blood of the Mediator craving forgiveness of them obtain it recover the apprehension of the favour of God reconciled unto them adore his mercies and faithfulness and from thenceforward more carefully work out their salvation with fear and trembling Canon 8. So not by their own merits or strength but by Gods free mercy they obtain thus much That they neither totally fall from faith and grace nor continue to the end in their falls and perish which in regard of themselves not only full easily might but doubtless would come to pass yet in respect of God it cannot so fall out since neither his counsel can be changed nor his promise fail nor the calling according to his purpose be revoked nor Christs merit intercession and custody be made of none effect nor the sealing of the holy Spirit be frustrated or defaced 4. That they that are predestinated unto everlasting life be or shall be effectually called according to Gods purpose by his Spirit working in due season they through grace obey the calling they be justified freely they be made Sons of God by adoption and they be made like the Image of his only begotten Son Jesus Christ they walk religiously in good works and at length by Gods mercy they attain to everlasting felicity Which Doctrine is not only contrary to that false Doctrine of the Papists and Arminians before renounced but 't is also agreeable to the Doctrine taught by St. Paul Rom. 8. 30. Whom he did predestinate them he also called Rom. 8. 15 16 17. Gal. 4. 6 7. and whom he called them he also justified and whom he justified them he also glorified and therefore they cannot fall away from saving grace totally and finally and be damned 5. That 't is of the meer will or purpose or good pleasure of God that some men are in Christ Jesus elected and not others unto salvation for here you see this Election is called Gods purpose and his counsel to deliver from damnation those whom he hath chosen in Christ out of mankind and to bring them by Christ to everlasting salvation Which is not only contrary to that erroneous Doctrine of the Papists before confuted and renounced viz. That God did elect men unto salvation for their foreseen faith good works and perseverance that would be in them but ãâã also consonant to canonical Scripture Rom. 9. 11 15. Luke 12. ãâã Ephes 1. 5. 2 Tim. 1. 9. Agreeable to this is the second Articlââ Lambeth The moving or efficient cause of Predestination unto life ãâã the foresight of faith or of perseverance or of good works or of ãâã thing that is in the person predestinated but only the good will and ãâã sure of God Agreeable to which is also the 14 Article of Religââ of the Church of Ireland drawn up by A. B. Vsher as Dr. Hââ tells us to which King James gave his consent and approbatioâ Heylins Cypr. Anglicus l. 4. p. 271. 6. That the godly consideration of Predestination and our electioââ Christ is full of sweet pleasant and unspeakable comfort to godly perââ confirms our faith and fervently kindles our love to God But the Doctrine of the Papists who hold that true believers in Christ may totally and finally fall away from all the acts and habits of savââ grace and become damned reprobates is full of bitter unplââ and unspeakahle sorrow and vexation even to godly persons ãâã doth not confirm and establish their faith of eternal salvation ãâã be enjoyed through Christ but rather fill their souls with doââ of their salvation and fears of their damnation and doth ãâã fervently kindle but rather quench the fire of their love to God ãâã they shall be taught that Gods love to them dependeth not upon ãâã self but upon their uncertain love to him from which they say ãâã may totally and finally fall away and be therefore eternally damned ãâã any Doctrine that ever was preached or printed did binder Piety ãâã true Christianity and comfortable walking with God this of the Paââ falling away totally and finally from saving-grace is one and ãâã well be put among the chief causes of the decay of Piety amongst ãâã and put into that golden book so intituled and its contrary put ãâã of it Further I might draw an argument or two more from what ãâã Church of England saith in her old book of Common Prayers whiââ she offers to Almighty God as in the Collect for St. Simon and Jââ Apostles she saith this Almighty God which hast builded thy ãâã gregation upon the foundation of the Apostles and Prophets Jesâs Cââ himself being the head corner-stone And the next Collect for All-Sââ day where she saith this Almighty God which hast knit togethââ thy elect in one communion and fellowship in the mystical body of thy ãâã Jesus Christ our Lord from which this argument might be frame They that are built upon the sure foundation or rock Jesus Christ and are inseparably knit together in one communion and fellowship in the mystical body of Jesus Christ cannot totally and finally fall away from Christ and his Church and be damned but according to the Church of England Gods elect truly regenerated persons are so built and so united Ergo they cannot totally and finally fall away from Christ and his Church and consequently not from saving-grace by which they are so built and knit together the major is undeniable and clear by Matth. 7. 24 25. Therefoye saith Christ whosoever heareth these sayings of mine and doth them I will liken him unto a wise man which built his house upon a rock and the rain descended and the floods came and the winds blew and beat upon the house and it fell not for it was founded upon a rock Upon which place * Pareus in locum Veram fidem super petra aedificatam nunquam deficere sed semper conjunctam esse cum perseverentia Pareus hath this note That a true faith built upon the rock doth never fail but is always joyned with perseverance and Mat. 16. 18. I say unto thee Thou art Peter and upon this rock that is which thou hast confessed will I build my Church and the gates of Hell that is all the power and policy of the Devil and his instruments shall not prevail against it the Minor is the Doctrine of our Church in the two Collects before alledged and Gods elect regenerate true members of