the whole Work as one compleat piece within the same Divine beginning and Divine end knit together by the same Divine influence running equally through all parts and making all one The Lord hath made all things for himself yea even the Wicked for the day of evil 2. The effect in this particular instance is remarkable This effect is every wicked person under the formality of a wicked person As a Creature an Angel or a Man he cannot be the subject of any question or doubt The evil of sin by which he is constituted and denominated wicked is clearly designed by this emphatical instance I have often already expressed the manner of the influence and operation of the Divine Power and Providence upon the evil of sin and so of a Sinner under the formality of sin All evil being a defect depends upon the first Cause together with all intermediate Causes in their deficiency only and in the ordination of circumstances 3. This instance brings in this particular effect in its inseparable connexion with its subordinate end The day of evil The Lord hath made all things for himself yea even the wicked person who becomes wicked by the evil of sin He hath made the inseparable connexion between the evil of sin and the evil of sufferings He hath made this evil person by an inviolable Order for the day of evil the evil of Sufferings He hath made this evil person this evil of sufferings the connexion between these two as the effect and next subordinate end For himself the Ultimate and last end the blessed the glorious Crown of all I will finish this Subject with two or three brief and clear Observations drawn from this Text. 1. The beginning and the end of all things are the same God in his most glorious Essence the only the supream the universal the essential Good an infinite Good 2. The end is the first and chief Cause moving all other Causes and directing their motions from the first to the last motion 3. All things are bounded by these two The first beginning and the last end All things in every step of all effects of all subordinate ends are in motion and in the way to the last end They rest not they attain not their mark to which they are designed from the beginning by the first and universal Mover till they arrive at this their last end 4. â—…he last end gives amiableness beauty and perfection to all things as the means of bringing forth this end It gives this beauty and perfection to them three wayes 1. It self runs along through all things in their whole way to it as the first universal Mover as the first and universal virtue and force which moves in all and moves all throughout from the beginning to the end 2. It comprehends all in it as the bosom or nest in which the whole is designed and formed 3. It rests upon all things in every part of the work and step of the way as the life and light of the universal Order and Harmony which attracts directs and conducts all to it self 4. It gathers up all things at last into its self as the term and mark to which all things move in which alone all motions cease and are changed into rest Every thing in its Ultimate end gaineth its perfection its true and proper self Every thing is so far it self as it is perfect so far as it is imperfect it falls short of it self every imperfection being a privation of being and so to each self a privation of it self according to its degree This is the sweet and musical close This is the bright and beautiful crown of all things the beginning and the end meeting in one 5. The end it self as it is the first Mover so doth it last of all cease from its motions and terminate them in its own beatifical Rest. This is the end perfectly accomplished when all things tending to this end meet in the perfection of the end The end therefore never returns to its rest till it rests with its full perfection in every part of the Work in every particular form directed to it self Our Divines teach us That the Glory of God is the Ultimate end of all things not the essential but the manifestative Glory so the Glory of God then only finds rests when it rests with a full revelation of it self unvailing all its Beauties unfolding all its Sweetnesses in the bosom and face of each part of the whole Work of God So the Divine operation and motion ceaseth not in any part of this Divine Work until all rest in the bosom of this Glory perfectly displaying all its Pleasures and Delicacies upon it For this manifestative Glory is the end of all The end mutually gives to and takes from all the means to the end rest and perfection Thus God hath made all things all effects with all their subordinate ends yea even the wicked also for the day of evil his subordinate end for this Great and Ultimate end himself in the brightness and full out-shinings of his Glory I pass now to the third Scripture Rom. 11. If I deceive not my self I seem to my self to discern in this Scripture a rich Mine of Divinity of Divine Truth and Glory in which no Workman hath yet laboured But it is not agreeable to my present time or purpose to open or point out this Mine if I were furnished with an heavenly strength and skill sufficient for it I shall now only touch at some verses in this Chapter which contibute to my present Design verse 23. God hath shut up or as it is in the Greek God hath locked up together all in unbelief that he may have mercy upon all St. Paul in this Chapter sets before us God as the most skillful Painter sweetning and beautifying his Work in the whole and in the parts of it by the mixtures and interchanges of Light and Shades Grace and Severity still terminating all in the sweetness and light of the Divine Grace as the end of all From this Contemplation he raiseth himself into and loseth himself in the pleasant heighths of a Divine Extasy verse 33. O the depth of the Riches and the Wisdom and the Knowledg of God How unsearchable are his Judgments and his wayes past finding out Every Work of God hath a three-fold Depth of Riches 1. A Depth of Riches the riches of Power Purity Beauty Love Goodness Grace and Glory 2. A Depth of Wisdom of Divine Contrivance of perfect Harmony 3. A Depth of Knowledge comprehending all endless and infinite Varieties in a clear view at once In every part of the Work of God do all these Depths meet which swallow up the most capacious Spirits of Saints and Angels into themselves but can be fathomed by no Spirit The distinct judgment in which any one the least piece of this Work is wrought hath so boundless a depth heighth and compass in it that it is altogether unsearchable The way of
present moment to the embraces of the Will which was condemned in the general Rules as a most dangerous evil a most certain ruine Two circumstances upon the place and in the moment of action are cast into the ballance upon the place or in the moment of an action or temptation which weigheth it down with a great force 1. One is the difficulty and pain in resisting the alluring evil 2. The other is a flattering hope of enjoying the false sweetness of the present Action and being delivered from the unhappy consequences threatned while they are looked up either as uncertain or contingent or capable of being diverted by the Divine Goodness or by a succeeding repentance and change especially for this one adventure We may seal up this Answer with the impression of this golden Truth mentioned formerly Good under the form of good is the Object of the Will This alone attracteth the Will this alone moveth it The connexion then is inviolable and immediate between the Ultimate proposals of the Understanding presenting any Object to the Will under the formality or appearance of good and the motions of the Will towards that Object to receive it with mutual embraces 6. Reason What do most persons upon this Subject say Can I not walk sit or stand when I will at my pleasure Can I not choose or refuse Can I not Will as I will Is not my Will then free Answ. This Argument indeed is formed Crassâ Minervâ from a very gross conceit from the want of distinguishing between a spontaneity in the Acts themselves and an vndeterminedness in the essential Principles from which the Acts flow The question is not concerning the power or pleasure of the Will in Actibus imperatis in governing the Loco-motive faculty and the Instruments of motion the members of our Body Neither is it about the Elicit Acts of the Will it s own immediate motions of loving or hating whether these be in the power and pleasure of the Will That which is the subject of the Controversie is the root of this power and pleasure in the Will which it putteth forth in its immediate or more remoâ—…e Acts the Essence the essential form and principles of the Will it self However the Will in its essential form and principle be determined by superior and universal Causes which as essential Principles and as nature it self are complicated in the essence and nature of the Will yet doth the Will move in all its Acts with no less power and agreeableness Yea rather the sweet and harmonious concurrence of the superior and universal Cause in the Essence and Operations of the Will by the combinations of all Coelestial Angelical Divine Virtues make the motions of the Will more potent and more pleasant In truth the Will of man in a temptation may be like a Ship in a storm The Ultimate dictates of the Understanding the appearances of good and evil in the moment of Action cloathed with all its circumstances may suddenly and violently vary They may be like contrary Winds and Waves carrying the Ship in several moments unto contrary motions As the last gust of Wind and the last motion of the Waves so the last dictates the last appearances of good carry the Will away whether it be upon a Rock or in a safe course to its Haven Yet still this is true which Aristotle saith 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Election or choice is a desirous Understanding or an Intellectual Desire or 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 A desire from deliberation 7. Reason I have met with this Argument for the freedom of the Will from a learned pen. The chief ground on which the predetermination of the Will is built hath been this Principle That sin is a privation and no positive Being Thus God is believed to be cleared from the evil of Sin in the Acts and Motions of the Will while evil being a deficiency is capable of no efficient Cause An instance is brought to overthrow this Principle from a Spirit hating God Here this Act of the Will the hatred as it is formally drawn forth by and terminated in this Object the Person and Nature of God is formally in its positive Being a sin Answ. 1. If sin in any Subject or Act be a positive thing I know not how by any skill or understanding Humane or Angelical God can be acquitted from being the Author of sin For this is without controversie the sense of all Divines of all sorts except the Manichees and those who with them establish two co-ordinate Godheads of Good and Evil that he who is the only true God is the first the universal Being the Fountain of all Being the Being of every Being 2. Here seemeth to be a plain mistake for want of distinguishing this individual Act of hating God as it is considered in genere moris and ingenereentis In its moral and in its natural capacity 1. While we look upon this Act of hatred in a complex proposition as it is determined upon this Object the Divine Essence we consider it not naturally but morally we rightly pronounce it to be morally evil But this moral evil ariseth from a moral circumstance which is the undue determination of the Act upon an undue Object The evil here lies in the irregularity and obliquity of this Act morally considered in the determination to its Object This irregularity and obliquity is a privation of the due rectitude in which principally consisteth a right determination of the Act upon a right Object Thus is the evil of sin no more any thing positive here but altogether privative 2. If you consider this Act ingenereentis in its natural capacity you abstract it from all its moral circumstances you take a naked view of it as it is a natural motion in the will of aversion or opposition Thus it is clearly good It hath a natural or physical goodness as it answereth the proper and immediate Principles of the Form or Essence from which it flows and those formal essential Principles by which it is constituted It hath also a metaphysical goodness as every thing that is is good in its conformity to the Divine Will which as the Seal setteth the impression of being upon every thing that hath Being 3. There is also in this case before us a deception of our Intellectual sense by a mist cast before our eyes in which appearances are taken for realities I humbly conceive that there is no greater contradiction to all Principles of Truth and Knowledge than this assertion That any Spirit hateth God as God as he appeareth in his own proper Form God is that which all things desire God alone is Good saith Jesus Christ. If God alone be good he is the first the supream the universal Good The general Good of the whole the proper good of each particular All Good in one the only Good in all the only Suitableness the only Agreeableness to every Spirit Person and Nature the Truth
is linkt by heavenly embraces to Jesus Christ Jesus Christ to God the Father of Lights and the spring of Loves Homer tells us of a Chain fastned to the Throne of Jupiter which reacheth down to the Earth He speaketh to Neptune Minerva and the rest of the Powers about him which reign in the Skies in the Seas in the Earth in Hell below If ye should all hang with your whole weight upon the end of this Chain I would at my pleasure draw you all up to my self The Throne of the most High God is a Throne of Grace of Love Like a Chain doth the whole Nature of things descend from this Throne having its top fastned to it What-ever the weights may be of the lowermost links of this Chain yet that Love which sits upon the Throne with a Divine delight as it lets down the Chain from it self so draws it up again by the Order of the successive Links unto a Divine Ornament an eternal Joy and Glory to it self All things of Nature in its Beauties all things of Nature in its Ruine Life and Death in all forms are a Saints a Saint is Christs Christ is Gods But gentle Reader this is enough to set forth the suitableness between the two Subjects of my Epistle and my Book the Divine Love and the VVill of Man the Daughter and the Bride of this Love by its immortal Birth and Espousals essentially inevitably determined to its heavenly Father and Bridegroom To this Love the only Good in all appearances of it the Will turns it self as the Needle toucht with the Loadstone to the North-pole Beautiful and blessed is this Will when it s own Bridegroom shines upon it and attracts it by beams by sweet glimpses of it self spread through all things more clear or more obscure but true Then do her beauty and blessedness both change into deformity and misery when by hellish enchantments she is deluded and drawn into the embraces of a wrinkled VVitch or a Spirit from the darkness below transformed into the likeness of her heavenly Love There are now a few things only remaining of which I would briefly give thee some accompt 1. Persons engaged on both sides in this question which is the ground of my Treatise are highly honoured by me and truly dear to me in an high degree A natural Understanding Ingenuity Integrity Learning VVisdom Knowledge an heavenly mind set a great price and lustre upon them The ends at which these persons on both parts profess to aim are truly Spiritual and Divine It is the design of one part to beighten the Grace of God by its freedom and peculiarity Of the other to enlarge the Glory of this Grace by its extent and amplitude One admires and adores the absoluteness the soveraignty of God the other his goodness On one side is an holy jealously for the Unity and the Beauty of the Divine Nature lest God should be imagined like the natural day in the Creation made up of two Contraries co-ordinate and equally predominate as Day and Night Love and VVrath a ground of Holiness and a ground of Sin The others are equally jealous of the same Unity and Beauty of the Divine Nature lest the eternal Power and so the Godhead should be divided between the Creator and the Creature least in effect two Gods should be set up like those of the Manichees a Fountain of Good and a Fountain of Evil lest the Divine Glory should be darkned in its work and the Harmony broken in which the Divine Unity and Beauty most sweetly shine by taking away in any part of the work the fix'd subordination of Causes and Effects O what Joy and Glory would crown the Earth and the Church of God on Earth if those Divine Persons who have fix'd to themselves ends so Divine instead of opposing each other in their way perhaps sometimes mistaken to those ends would unite their Divine Will and Forces mutually to advance the ends each of other St. Paul saith If the falling away of the Jews be the bringing in of the Gentiles what shall the return be but life from the dead If the dividings the disputes of these Parties have brought much light to the Church what will the reconciling and uniting of their glorious ends and their Spirits in the glory of those ends be but as a Marriage-day shining from on high which shall fill the Angels themselves with a new joy The day will come when men shall say Blessed is he who comes in the Name of the Lord Who reconciletâ—… the freedom and peculiarity of the Grace of God unto a full amplitude and extent so raising its sweetness to a perfect heighth who shall bring into mutual embraces the soveraignty or absoluteness of God and his goodness that the soveraignty the absoluteness may be soveraignly and absolutely good that the goodness alone may be absolute and soveraign who through the whole compass of the Divine Nature and the works of God shall discover to the eyes of men in the evidence of a Divine Light the Unity the Beauty of the Godhead in their clearest Purity their highest Perfection springing and shining through all making all in the whole one entire piece pure and pleasant perfect in the Beauties of Holiness The Rules which I have desired to govern my self by in this Discourse are these Right Reason the universally acknowledged Principles of all sober Philosophy and sound Divinity the Analogy of Faith the Letter of the Scriptures the Spirit of Christ in the Head of the Church Christ himself in the Scriptures in the Church in the Spirits and experiences of each Saint As all these answer each other in a mutual Harmony like the several strings upon a well-tuned Lute So shall I ever as I humbly believe take it for granted That what-ever jars upon any of these strings is also out of tune to all the rest That what-ever is not conformable to any one of these Rules crosseth them all If any thing of this kind shall have faln from me I do here humbly repent of it and recant it I humbly desire all those who shall stoop to read what I have written to believe that no Gift can be so acceptable to me as the displacing of any Errour or Falshood in my Mind with the gentle hand of Love by bringing in the Truth which it hath counterfeited and vailed If any Errour have seemed sweet beautiful or desirable to me in any kind I humbly undertake to have a confident assurance of this That the Truth it self shining forth will bring along with it far more transcendent Sweetnesses Beauties Agreeablenesses and Satisfactions to all my Desires excelling it in all the impressions of a Divine Pleasantness Power and Profit as the true Sun doth a Parelius or a counterfeit Image of the Sun in a Cloud If any shall undertake to answer this Discourse with reviling and reproachful Language I shall endeavour to imitate the example of the Marquess de Rente fixed with
relations from the Creature to it self Thus doth the Divine goodness in the Divine VVill terminate the relation of every created VVill to it self in the agreeableness or disagreeableness of every Act. This supream goodness then hath in it self the measure of this agreeableness and disagreeableness which it receiveth not from without but hath originally in it self So all the acts of the VVill according to their conformity with or deformity from the first goodness derive themselves from their proper Original in that goodness Accordingly the Goodness and the Will of God hath a complacency in every Act of the VVill if it be agreeable to it or an aversion from it if it be disagreeable Thus is the created VVill in all its motions with their several most exact distinctions the Object of the eternal VVill in its love or hatred Every faculty or power hath an essential relation to its proper object and dependance upon it It is drawn forth by it into the most proper Acts of its essence and receiveth from it the perfection of its essence which consisteth in its Activity The supream VVill the supream Goodness being perfectly eternally in Act hath all its Acts all its Objects by which it is actuated perfectly eternally from and in it self Object You will say How can this be Can the Divine VVill which is infinitely pure in the beauties of Holiness in the joys of all blessedness comprehend in it self Good and Evil agreeableness and disagreeableness to it self which are the proper measures and essential forms of all good and evil Can it comprehend in it self Objects of Love and Hatred Can this Fountain send forth from it self sweet and bitter waters How is it holy if there be these mixtures How is it happy if it be thus divided within it self Answ. The Flats and Sharpes the Bases and Trebles the Concords and Discords of Musick are all comprehended by the spirit of the Musician in one Act of Harmony in one simple and undivided Act of Harmony This single Act of Harmony by its proper force first invented and formed all Musical Instruments prepared them for it self through all the diversity of touches and motions actuated them that it might compleatly figure and display upon them and upon all things round about them it self in its own full sweetness according to all those rich varieties virtually and eminently comprehended within it self in one simple Act. So in one indivisible Act or Idea of beauty in the Spirit of the Painter lie together all the differing lines lights shades and colours by which that Idea reflecteth it self in Picture upon the eyes and spirits of the Beholder In like manner the far greater perfection the Will of God being a simple 〈◊〉 of Goodness supreamly indivisible and eternal containeth originally eminently within it self complacency and aversion love and hatred with their several objects in their several forms and degrees in their several risings and fallings most properly and harmoniously suited to each other From it self doth this supream Goodness bring forth its own Objects like tuned Instruments wound up or let down every way prepared for the diffusion and discovery of it self upon them in those Varieties of love and hatred complacency and aversion with their several steps or modifications which as so many distinct forms or virtues of the Divine Goodness dwell together there in the highest and most absolute Variety as in the fullest and most unconfined Unity The Will of God is commonly and rightly distinguished into positive and permissive Evil is by the permissive Good from the positive Will of God All the determinations and motions of the Will in every Spirit are at least from the permission of the Divine Will I will not now enquire how the most perfect Goodness can be permissive in that in which it is positive This only I take which is universally granted That there is no permissive Will in God without a positive Act. He permitteth nothing without a positive Act of his Will for that permission If the permission of any Act in the will of man antecede that Act then is that act or motion of the humane will the Object of a positive Act of the Divine Will for the permission of it before it be brought forth here below This objective existence in the Divine Will is either the Copy or the Original to that motion in the will of the Creature If it be universally received by all Understandings from the universal Harmony and principles of Truth that the Divine Nature can take no Copy receive no Impression of any thing from any thing without it self it necessarily followeth that all motions in the will of man flow from that antecedent existence which they have in the Divine Will as the Objects of that Thus that I may not be too long upon this Head of Arguments drawn from the Divine Nature I have contracted three sorts of Arguments into one Those from the Will the Goodness the Power of God being drawn together under that of the Divine Power I have in it built upon this sure ground The VVill of God is the first the supream the essential Goodness The Goodness of God is his Power As every thing depends upon the VVill of God in its permission or positive Act As all things in their measures of Good or Evil lie together in the Divine Goodness the Original the eternal measure of all Good and Evil so have all Powers all Acts and Motions of Power their first spring their exact form and rule in the Power of God 5. Argument The fifth Argument is the Knowledge of God This is in our present cause a most celebrated Argument I shall therefore endeavour to represent the state of it with all exactness clearness and integrity that I can bring to it I shall divide this Argument into two parts 1. The first is the perfection of the Divine Knowledge 2. The second is the Original 1. Part. The first part is the perfection of the Divine Knowledge This consisteth in two things 1. The Comprehensiveness 2. The distinctness of the Knowledge VVe then know perfectly when we know all things capable of being known when we know each thing in its proper distinction in all its distinct forms properties and relations Shall not He who made the eye see Shall not the Fountain of Knowledge contain all Knowledges after the most exact and eminent manner Shall not He know all things most accurately by whom all things know and are known St. Peter saith to Jesus Christ as to God Lord Lord thou knowest all things thou knowest that I love thee See two things remarkable here 1. The universality of Christ's Knowledge extending its self to all things 2. A confirmation of this by a particular instance Thou knowest that I love thee The instance is most pertinent to our present purpose It is that peculiar Object of Knowledge which is the ground and subject of this Discourse the Will of Man the motions of the will the freest
from the beginning to the end He presents himself to the Soul as its Idea its Original Image its beginning its way and itsend in whose bosome the Soul hath alwayes lien there meeting with every change every scene of things springing up within it in that bosome while the same Jesus hath lien in its bosome as the seed of its Being and of every Change This is the Souls Father Brother Bridegroom and Perfection As Jesus Christ thus appears and unvails himself within the Soul he at once gathers up the Soul into the most intimate the most entire Union with it self He transforms it into the likeness of the same Image with himself in the full Glory of the Divine the Universal the eternal Harmony in the Unity of the same Spirit the Spirit of this Harmony and Glory The Lord Jesus as he is the universal the eternal Image and Harmony of the Divine Nature of all Variety in the Divine Nature as he is the Idea of Ideas thus is he the Original Image the Idea of the Intellectual Soul or of Man As then he forms himself in this Soul he also formeth all things in it that man comes forth from the bosome of his Idea replenished with the Ideas of all things He is now the whole Creation the universal Nature within himself This Jesus then being risen springs up into Man in the virtue of his Resurrection and together becomes the Resurrection of all things in man to man In like manner through man as the head of all he riseth again in all the particular Forms of things as they stand without man in themselves in their own proper Existencies In the Lord Jesus God through Christ the universal Image inhabiteth in the proper Ideas of each Creature with the fulness of his Divine Glories in the Unity of the blessed Spirit According to this Original Jesus Christ the Universal Harmony through the humane Nature his immediate his full Image his compleat Birth and Bride rests entirely and distinctly upon each form of things as the Divine Race of this heavenly Marriage-Bed in the Resurrection As all together make up the Universal Harmony in the Soul in Christ the end of them all So each one enjoyeth the whole Harmony in it self being upon its own proper Form cloathed with the Universal Form the Form of the heavenly Man and of Christ in Glory So all dwell together in the Unity of the same Divine Spirit the Spirit of a Saint and of Christ. In the Unity of this Spirit all mutually are Divine Palaces each to other clearly compleatly comprehending and comprehended by each other eternally feasting upon the heavenly Beauties and Virtues drinking in the Sweetnesses the Lives the Spirits of each other And of Jesus Christ of God the Unity and the Variety in all This is the Kingdom of God which is Righteousness Peace and Joy in the Holy Ghost Jesus Christ the essential Image of God the Divine and eternal Harmony is the Righteousness the mutual Peace and Joy of this Kingdom In this Kingdom Jesus Christ cometh with his own Glory the Glory of his Father and of all his holy Angels united in one in each form of things The lowest form of things here is an Angel an Angel made new in the Resurrection of Christ where each Angel being only a distinct part of the Harmony yet hath the Universal Harmony resting upon that part This is that new Jerusalem where the street the lowest form of things is as Gold and Glass The pure Glory of the eternal Spirit as the finest Gold shineth in each Creature like the Cherubim or the Angels standing up out of the Mercy-Seat made of the same piece of massy Gold together with it The lowest Creature here is an Angel of Glory the street that sustains us is composed of Angels Angelical Glories In every Angel as a particular Glory all the Angels with their several Varieties of Glory the Glory of Christ and all the Saints which is the full the Universal Glories of the Divine and Humane Nature the Original and its best beloved Image in Union The Glory of God as the Father in its simplicity in its paternity and transcendency over all meet all in one This Unity of the Spirit in each Creature renders it divinely transparent like the finest glass In the beauty of every Face we have the prospect of Eternity We see in each single Face fresh Beauties all Beauties with an endless Variety opening themselves one within another one beyond another all equally clear present and pleasant in every one Thus Jesus Christ becomes according to St. Paul the first-born from the dead and the first-born among his Brethren the Saints The Saints in the Language of St. James are the first-fruits of the Creation which is brought forth in its proper time and order into the liberty of the Glory of the Sons of God Thus is our Jesus the great Jubilee where all Debts are remitted all Servants go free all persons return to their Inheritances to the free Possession the full fruition of themselves and them In the Resurrection of the Lord Jesus from him as the Root springing up into the Body of the Saints through them into the rest of the Creatures as Branches of the same Tree All Sins are pardoned the whole Creation is set free from its bondage to Vanity and Corruption All things return to a free fruition of themselves of all Beauties and Joys in their native Inheritance their Original Images their proper Ideas in Christ first Christ then the Saints through them Heaven and Earth and the Seas with all things in them are made new by being married anew by being newly reinvested with the Glories of their Original The Reader is again desired to take Notice That neither the remainder of this Fourth Argument nor any thing upon his Fifth could be found amongst the Authors Papers A DISCOURSE OF THE Freedome of the Will The SECOND PART Wherein the Arguments for it are considered and answered HAving finished those Arguments ranked under their several Heads in opposition to that Liberty of the Will which is placed in the determining of its power received from the first cause unto a Contrariety or Contradiction in its actings with an independency upon the first cause the order and connexion of Causes and the Understanding We pass now to a consideration of the Reasons upon which that Opinion of this Freedome is established These Reasons are taken 1. From the Will it self 2. From the nature of Sin and the Divine Justice 3. The Language of the Scripture 4. From the end of Laws 5. From the order and nature of things 1. Reason The Prerogative and Excellency of the Will consisteth in this Liberty 1. How otherwise doth man excel bruit Creatures and natural Agents 2. How otherwise is man free and not necessitated in all his Actions To that I shall give two several Answers 1. Answ. This Freedome of the Will of which we speak and which is opposed to necessity
Head its inward Principle 3. The Soul of man in its Restitution by Christ hath Jesus Christ as a quickning Spirit in him as the principle of its Life as its life it self I saith Christ am the Resurrection and the Life I saith St. Paul by the Law am dead to the Law I am crucified with Christ and now I live yet not I but Christ liveth in me He saith St. Paul that is joyned to the Lord is one Spirit Man is now become the heavenly Image of God and one Spirit with Jesus Christ in Glory As he hath now the Understanding of Christ according to St. Paul so hath he also the Will of Christ. This heavenly Bridegroom and heavenly Bride are one Divine Spirit bear one Divine Image have one Life one Righteousness one Glory one Understanding one Will and dwell together in one Light as God is Light in one Love as God is Love in one immortal Joy unspeakable and glorious The Soul now is a chast and spotless Bride which bringeth forth all the rich and heavenly fruits of her Spirit her Understanding her Will her whole Life inward and outward by her own heavenly Husband alone by the sweet force of her Union with him and the Divine Virtue of his embraces that they may be fruits to God that is Divine Fruits having the life virtue and sweetness of the Divine Nature in them the form and beauty of the Divine Nature upon them for a feast of Joys and Glory to God himself to feast both his Eyes and his Heart If then the Soul restored be one Spirit with Christ as in the Spirit of Christ so in the Spirit of a Saint the most pleasant liberty and most potent necessity meet in one The Divine Harmony of the supream and universal good is at once the spacious and blissful Field of this Paradisical freedom and the golden Chain of this most grateful and most glorious necessity The Spirit of Christ is eternity it self which as it spreads it self beyond and above all consinements to a Variety endlesly fresh and flourishing is the sweetest Liberty As it comprehends all things in a most entire undivided Unity the supream Crown and Circle of all true Life and Glory is the highest necessity Eternity hath nothing past or to come in respect to it self being far above all Changes all Beginnings and Ends of things It is the supream Power which rules them all and the supream Wisdom which measures them The Soul then now become one Spirit with Christ is in that Spirit together with Christ seated upon the Throne of Eternity by its Union with this Spirit it reigns upon this Throne over all things by having this Spirit in it self by being one Spirit with this Spirit it hath in it self that soveraign Power and supream Wisdom it is one with that soveraign Power and supream Wisdom which rules and measures all things Thus the glorious Bride of Eternity having her heavenly Bridegroom in her embraces cloathed and crowned with the same heavenly Image being now in the true state of her own proper person in her sirst and last state in her own proper unvailed Substance and Original here with her Bridegroom is her own rule and measure in this heavenly Image which is her true substantial self her Eternity She is also a rule and measure to her self in the earthly and shadowy Image and in all her Pilgrimage through the Regions of time below whether they be the sweeter shadows of the Light above or the melancholy shades of a deeper Darkness This is the true Liberty of Man and the freedom of his Will which is as the liberty and freedom of the true eternal good diffusing it self into all the unsearchable riches of its manifoldly various Varieties varying setting off sweetning and heightning it self by all the ravishing excesses of Harmony of Light of Love by all the extreams of Darkness Discord Contrariety and hate reducing and binding up these also into a most ravishing Harmony by the excesses by the victories and triumphs of the Divine Light and Love So keeping together with this sportful Liberty the golden the firm Adamantine necessity of being it self still through all that is good the true and eternal good This Divine Liberty of the spiritual Bride which is her Kingdom in her self over all is divinely expressed by the blessed Bridegroom himself in that most mysterious Song of himself and his Love composed by himself in the Person of Solomon He there in one place chargeth the Daughters of Jerusalem that is all the holy Angels and spotless Spirits by which the affairs of the whole Creation are administred By the Roes and Hindes of the field that is by all those Pleasures Loves and Lovelinesses with which he sports himself in the midst of them in the Paradise above who alone is the lovely Roe and the lovely Hind That they awake not nor stir up his Love until he please Cant. 2. 7. Thus it is manifestly in the Hebrew although our Translators have changed the Feminine into the Masculine and set the Bridegroom in the place of the Bride But the sense which the words grammatically import is this That as the heavenly Bride is one Spirit with her Bridegroom she sits above together with him upon his Throne in eternity from thence together w th him gives to all the heavenly Ministers their Commissions that nothing moves in her own person or round about her here below as she is in her shadowy disguise and pilgrimage but as it is ordered by her self above in the bosome of her Bridegroom And according to that order executed by the heavenly attendance which wait continually round about the Throne of her Bridegroom 2. Reason If the Will of Man be not free and do not freely determine it self in all moral Actions being undetermined in its own Principles or by any superior Causes what entrance doth sin find How doth any thing of a stain or guilt lie upon the Soul How is God just in the effects of his Wrath upon those that sin if they sin by an inevitable necessity of Nature and a predetermination by the connexion of Causes or by the immediate and intimate operation of the first and universal Cause I shall give my Answer by several steps 1. Sin hath no positive being if it hath God who is the first and universal Being the Fountain of Being is directly by himself and not by accident only the Author of Sin in its formality as Sin Otherwise we must with Manes set two Gods upon two distinct Thrones one of Light or Good the other of Darkness or Evil. Or we shall be forced with some Heathen Philosophers to establish two first Beings equally Uncreated and eternal One God the Agent The other Matter the Patient So where the Agent subdues the matter to it self all Forms of Goodness Beauty Life and Joy spring forth where the matter invincibly resisteth the power of the Agent there are the Regions of all Evil Darkness Death
and Hell But this Heathenism and Manicheism are exploded as by the universal consent of all sober Christians so by the voice of reason it self For if there be two first Beings these agree in Being they differ in being two Being it self as it is One making both these one in its self as it is pure is before and above that state in which it is allayed and abased by being mixt and compounded with those differences which make it two This then alone is the first and supream Being the eternal One the only true God 2. If God then be not properly and directly the Author of Sin Sin is no positive Being but a privation only So the Scriptures express it which call it 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 an irregularity a falling short of the Glory of God a missing of the mark 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Divines generally teach us That the Sin consisteth not in any Act but in the Deordination in the privation a want of the due order appertaining to the Act. Sin then being nothing positive but a meer privation can have no efficient but a deficient Cause only This deficient Cause is that defectibility which is inseparable from every created Nature Darkness is the privation or absence of Light which naturally and necessarily accompanieth obscure and opact Bodies as the Air the Water and the Earth While the Sun shines upon them this deficiency or want of Light discovereth not it self All things are illuminated and the natural obscurity of these Bodies illustrated by the Sun-beams when these beams are withdrawn or intercepted then the defect of Light natural to these substances appeareth and so the darkness is predominant Thus every Creature hath in it self a tendency to annihilation being of it self like the Earth before the beautiful work of the first day which was light void and without form Thus the Soul of Man in its Understanding and in its Will hath naturally of it self a tendency to unreasonableness which is a degree of Annihilation the privation of that two-sold Beauty Truth in the Understanding and goodness in the Will While the Face of God shines upon the face of the Soul by a continued irradiation as in the first moment of the Creation these Intellectual Forms of Divine Beauty Truth and Goodness flourish in the Soul binding up the natural defectibility both of the Understanding and the Will in the golden Chains of an heavenly Light and heavenly Love but in that moment in which God turns away his Face with-draws his beams in the same moment the Soul of Man is left naked its natural defectibility prevails the privation or absence of Truth is now the darkness the deformity of folly and falshood The privation or absence of Goodness is now the evil and the disorder into which as a bottomless pit the Understanding and the Will and the whole Soul with these miserably endlesly sinks This is that horrible pit out of which sin ariseth the defectibility or nothingness of the Creature in it self This is the way by which it ariseth upon the Soul over-spreading it and carrying it back into that pit of horrour the deflectibility or nothingness of the Creature prevailing in the absence of the Divine beams The Royal Prophet divinely sings the penury of the Creature and the Praises of the great Creator in this Mystery Psal. 104. 29. Thou hidest thy Face they are troubled thou takest away their Breath or Spirit they die and return to their dust Thou sendest forth thy spirit they are created and thou renewest the face of the Earth It is a truth asserted by all Philosophers and Divines That the Understanding acteth necessarily being infallibly and irresistably reduced into act by its Object duly presented The Scripture manifestly teacheth us that sin entreth into the Soul by the Understanding Those two places which I have cited above are clear The woman being deceived was first in the Transgression Sin deceived me and so slew me St. Paul speaketh in both these places of the first entrance of sin into the World in the person of the first Woman and in his own person set as a figure of all Mankind as it was collectively and representatively in the first Adam Musaeus joyns these together 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The Light going out and Leander perishing Man is deceived and so slain by sin As the Light of Truth goes out in the Understanding the Life of Goodness dies in the Will As the sight and light of the eye from the natural composition of the eye faileth as the irradiations from the Sun which it enjoyeth either mediately or immediately from the body of the Sun it self or from other luminous bodies depending upon the Sun are obscured So is the Souls eye the Understanding obscured according to the proportion in which the Divine illuminations in the way of Grace or Nature cease In these two first steps I have endeavoured to make clear the nature of Sin and the way of its entrance into the World in which we see a most genuine conformity to the dependance of the Will and of the whole Soul in all its changes and motions upon the first Cause as a link in the mystical Chain of the order of Causes The beauty and goodness of the Soul in its Understanding and its Will flow in the golden Pipe of the order of Causes as golden Oyl from the first cause as the Olive-Tree flourishing upon the Mount of Eternity As this golden stream from its Well-head fails beauty and goodness are no more in the Soul The deficiency or privation of these is the evil of Darkness Deformity Sin and Death to this intellectual and immortal Spirit But the knot seems to be tyed stronger by this discourse man sins inevitably by the necessity of his nature The first and free withdrawings of the Divine influence give way for the deflectibility of the Creature to spring up into those defects which are properly and formally the evils of Sin the first and greatest evils the fountains of all evils How then doth shame or guilt lie upon the Creature Why is God yet angry How is he just in punishing Is not the evil of sin from these grounds clearly cast upon God as the Author of it I shall endeavour to answer these Objections and to remove these Difficulties in the three following steps 3. I shall endeavour here to bring in some clear light into the obscure shades of this doubt how shame and guilt lie upon the Soul when it falls inevitably from the necessity of its nature Shame is a fear of Infamy from a sense of Deformity Deformity is the absence of the Divine Form originally present and so proper to the subject The subject of the form or beauty while it is present is also in its absence the subject of the privation and deformity To the deformity is annexed the reproach or disesteem Esteem or disesteem is a right judgment and so a value of each thing according to its proper state
in both from the meeting and blissful embraces of these two this Love and Loveliness in the Divine Nature his Joy and Complacency is alike in both equally full equally at the heighth A Divine Philosopher with a pleasant and beautiful Allegory teacheth us That the expansion of Light in the heavenly Bodies which is the Act of the Angelical World in this their most beautiful Figure is Risus Coelorum the laughter of the Heavens God maketh every thing beautiful in its proper place and time to kill as to make alive unformed deformed privations as the fairest and most flourishing forms In every Act of Providence in every accident from the beginning to the end of things he equally preserveth and perfecteth the Divine Order and Harmony This golden Harmony extended like the sweet Light of Heaven over all things is as a Divine laughter the complacency of the Divine Nature in its Work in its Image in it self I have yet one thing more to say before I take my other step We learn from Philosophers That heat and cold which continually fight in the Elements below are in the heavenly Bodies but after so eminent a manner that there they meet and enfold each other with a most harmonious agreeableness By the Laws of Divinity we are answerably taught That Anger and Love as all forms of things most discordant in the Creatures are first in the Divine Nature But they are there with an eminency with a transcendency in which they are refined and heightned far above all imperfections Here they all meet as most grateful and most agreeable Varieties in the entire and undivided Unity of the same eternal Light of the same eternal Love of the same eternal God As from this heighth of a most perfect Unity these Divine Varieties bring forth their various effects in shadowy resemblances here below they make the figure of the whole divinely one and divinely beautiful As Divine Seals they likewise impress the figure of their own Divine Unity upon each single effect Thus the whole work in general each single effect in particular is a divinely beautiful figure of the Divine Beauty shining with delightful beams upon those Eyes and Spirits which anointed with a Divine Knowledge see the golden and secret Seal this glorious and sacred impression of the Divine Unity upon it Thus we have spoken of the shame and guilt of Sin as also of Anger and in part of the Justice of God concerning which there remaineth more to be said 5. Step. We have yet before us that great Deep which swalloweth up all Understandings the face of which seemeth covered with a thick and impenitrable darkness Let us pray to the Father of Lights for irradiations from his eye that so this unfathomable Deep may discover it self to us as a blissful Deep of purest clearest and sweetest Glory If God first from the counsel of his own Will alone withdraw those beams which are all our Light and Beauty and we then by the inevitable necessity of our Natures wander as deformed shades in a wild darkness through the Regions of Sin Death and Hell Is not God now in a moral sense clearly and fully the sole Author of Sin and Evil This is the knot which indeed standeth in need of the Rosy Fingers of the heavenly Morning the beams of the eternal Day to unty it How shall we in this place vindicate the Justice and Goodness of God I have here three things to propound 1. Let us impartially and ingeniously consider whether the freedome of the VVill to determine it self absolutely in all its Acts reflect a greater Glory upon the Justice and Goodness of God than the VVill predetermined in its Essence in its superior Causes in the first and universal Cause That we may make a clearer judgment in this case let us compare these two different states of the VVill together with several Antecedents and Consequencies by placing them both in our view one by another as plainly within as narrow a compass as we can Let us set that Free-will in our eye after this manner God brings forth an Intellectual Spirit with a Divine Light of Truth in its heavenly Beauties shining upon its Understanding with a Divine Love of the true Good with all its heavenly Sweetnesses springing in its VVill. He now sets down the will of this Spirit upon such a ground of indifferency and absoluteness in it self that being undetermined into any forms of good or evil the most heavenly or the most hellish it is equally free for it in the face of all this blessed Light shining in the Understanding in the midst of all the heavenly sweetnesses flowing from the bosome of the true Good through the VVill it self to cast it self forth from the bosome of the eternal Good Appearing thus in its own naked and Divine Form and to cast it self into the embraces of the foulest evil the fountain of all evil presenting it self as evil in its own most direful and haggish shapes A great part of Intellectual Spirits far the greatest part of humane Spirits placed by the Divine Providence in this state refuse the good choose the evil so render themselves obnoxious to the Divine Justice and become by the pursuits and inflictions of that Avenger the lost Subjects of all horror and woes without end Let us now in the like manner cast our eye upon the Will predetermined in its Causes God brings forth an Intellectual Spirit compounded Ex aliquo Dei ex aliquo sui With something of God something of its own That of God in it is all the good of it the clear Face of the eternal Truth shining in its Understanding as in a Christal Mirror the sweet flame of pure Goodness and as pure a love to this Goodness burning in its VVill as upon the golden Altar in the Temple of God the beams of this Beauty and the flames of this Love unitedly spreading varying and forming themselves through the whole Person and Life of this Spirit into all Divine Virtues and Joys by which it becomes as God himself descended into a God-like Image of God himself This is that of God in the Creature That which is ofits own in this Intellectual Spirit is beneath all this heavenly beauty and goodness a deflectibility inseparable from the nature of the Creature bound up only by the heavenly charms of this Divinity resting upon the Person of this Spirit God in the depth of a design perhaps too blessed and too glorious to be penetrated and fathomed by us as the eternal Sun ascends up on high going away from this Spirit and carrying away with him his whole train of immortal beams with a Divine Light Heat and Virtue Now like a mournful and hated darkness from below the natural defectibility of this Spirit covers the whole face of it making it like Hell it self the seat of all evils both of Sin and Suffering which lie eternally upon innumerable multitudes Let us now consider the two-fold Law or