and the redressing of evill and where it stops in any and runs nor cleere there the guilt like filth or mud will lie Thirdly had it been the holy purpose of God to have established the doctrine and kingdome of his Son this way since his comming he would have furnished Common-weales Kingdomes Cities c. then and since with such temporall Powers and Magistrates as should have been excellently sit and competent for he that could have had legions of Angels if he so pleased could as easily have been and still be furnished with legions of good and gracious Magistrates to this end and purpose CHAP. XXXI IT is generally said that God hath in former rimes and doth still and will hereafter stirre up Kings and Queenes c. I answer that place of Isa. 49. 23. will appeare to be far from proving such Kings and Queenes Iudges of Ecclesiasticall causes and if not Iudges they may not punish In Spirituall things themselves are subject to the Church and censures of it although in Civill respects superior How shall those Kings and Queenes be supreme Governours of the Church and yet lick the dust of the Churches feet as it is there exprest Thirdly Gods Israel of old were earnest with God for a King for an Arme of Flesh for a King to protect them as other Nations had Gods Israel still have ever been restlesse with God for an Arme of flesh God gave them Saul in his anger and took him away in his wrath And God hath given many a Saul in his Anger that is an Arm of Flesh in the way of his Providence though I judge not all persons whom Saul in his Calling typed out to be of Sauls spirit for I speake of a State and outward visible Power only I adde God will take away such stayes on whom Gods people rest in his wrath that King David that is Christ Iesus the Antitype in his own Spirituall power in the hands of the Saints may spiritually and for ever be advanced And therefore I conclude it was in one respect that the Lord Iesus said Let them alone because it was no Ordinance for any Disciple of Iesus to prosecute the Pharises at Caesars Bar. Beside let it be seriously considered by such as plead for present corporall punishment as conceiving that such sinners though they breake nor Civill peace should not escape unpunished I say let it be considered though for the present their punishment is deferred yet the punishment inflicted on them will be found to amount to an higher pitch then any corporall punishment in the World beside and that in these foure respects CHAP. XXXII FIrst by just judgement from God false teachers are starke blinde Gods sword hath strucke out the right eye of their minde and spirituall underderstanding ten thousand times a greater punishment then if the Magistrate should command both the right and left eye of their bodies to bee bored or pluckt out and that in so many fearfull respects if the blindenesse of the soule and of the body were a little compared together whether we looke at that want of guidance or the want of joy and pleasure which the light of the eye affordeth or whether we looke at the damage shame deformity and danger which blindenesse brings to the outward man and much more true in the want of the former and miseris of the latter in spirituall and soule blindenesse to all eternity Secondly how fearfull is that wound that no Balme in Gilead can cure How dâ—eadfull is that blindenesse which for ever to all eye-salve is incurable For if persons be wilfully and desperately obstinate after light shining forth let them alone faith the Lord. So spake the Lord once of Ephraim Ephraim is joyned to Idolls let him alone Hos. 7. what more lamentable condition then when the Lord hath given a poor sinner over as a hopelesse patient incurable which we are wont to account a â—orer affliction then if a man were torne and rack'd c. And this I speake not that I conceive that all whom the Lord Iesus commands His servants to passe from and let alone to permit and tolerate when it is in their power corporally to molest them I say that all are thus â—â—curaâ—le yet that sometimes that word is spoken by Christ Jesus to â—is servants to be patient for neither can corporall or spirituall 〈◊〉 or Physicke ever heale or cure â—â—em Thirdly their end is the Ditch that bottomlesse pit of everlasting separation 〈◊〉 the holy and sweet Presence of the Father of Lights Goodnesse and Mercy it selfe enalesse 〈◊〉 in extremity universality and eternity of torments which most direfull and lamenâ—able downefall should strike a â—oly fear trembling into all 〈◊〉 see the Pit whithâ—◠〈…〉 are â—umbling and cause us to strive so far as 〈…〉 by the spirituall eye-salve of the Word of God to heale and 〈…〉 â—heiâ— soule-destroying blindenesse 〈◊〉 of those that fall into this â—â—eâ—â—full Ditch both leader and followers how deplorable in more especiall manner is the leaders case upon whose necke the followers tumble the ruine not only of his owne soule being horrible but also the ruine of the followers soules eternally galling and tormenting Peace Some will say these things are indeed full of horrour yet such is the state of all sinners and of many Malefactours whom yet the State is bound to punish and sometimes by death it selfe Truth I answer The Civill Magistrate beareth not the sword in vaine but to cut off Civill offences yea and the offendours too in case But what is this to a blinde Pharisce resisting the Doctrine of Christ who happily may be as good a subject and as peaceable and profitable to the Civill State as any and for his spirituall offence against the Lord Iesus in denying Him to be the true Christ he suffereth the vengeance of a dreadfull judgement both present and eternall as before CHAP. XXXIII Peace YEa but it is said that the blinde Pharises misguiding the subjects of a Civill State greatly sinne against a Civill State and therefore justly suffer civill punishment for shall the Civill Magistrate take care of outsides only to wit of the bodies of men and not of soules in labouring to procure their everlasting welfare Truth I answer It is a truth the mischiefe of a blinde Pharises blinde guidance is greater then if he acted Treasons Murders c. and the losse of one soule by his seduction is a greater mischiefe then if he blew up Parliaments and cuts the throats of Kings or Emperours so pretious is that invaluable Jewell of a Soul above all the present lives and bodies of all the men in the world I and therefore a firme Justice calling for eye for eye tooth for tooth life for life calls also soule for soule which the blinde-guiding seducing Pharisee shall surely pay in that dreadfull Ditch which the Lord Jesus speakes of but this sentence against him the Lord Jesus only pronounceth
Christian fellowship which doubtlesse they could not doe were the Magistrate supreme Governour under Christ in Ecclesiasticall or Church causes and so consequently the true heire and successour of the Apostles CHAP. CXXXVI Peace THe 15. Head runs thus viz. In what cases must Churches proceed with Magistrates in case of offence We like it well that Churches be flower in proceeding to excommunication as of all other so of Civill Magistrates especially in point of their Judiciall proceedings unlesse it be in scandalous breach of a manifest Law of God and that after notorious evidence of the fact and that after due seeking and waiting for satisfaction in a previous Advertisement And though each particular Church in respect of the Government of Christ be independent and absolute within it selfe yet where the Common-weale consists of Church members it may be a point of Christian wisedome to consider and consult with the Court also so far as any thing may seeme doubtfull to them in the Magistrates case which may be further cleered by intelligence given from them but otherwise we dare not leave it in the power of any Church to forbear to proceed agree upon that on Earth which they plainly see Christ hath resolved in his Word and will ratifie in Heaven Truth If the scope of this Head be to qualifie and adorne christian impartialitie and faithfulnes with christian wisdome and tendernesse I honour and applaud such a Christian motion but whereas that case is put which is no where found in the patterne of the first Churches nor suiting with the Rule of Christianitie to wit that the Commonweale should consist of Church members which must be taken privatively to wit that none should be admitted members of the Commonweale but such as are first members of the Church which must necessarily run the Church upon that Temptation to feele the pulse of the Court concerning a delinquent Magistrate before they dare proceed I say let such Practices be brought to the Touchstone of the true frame of a civill commonweale and the the true frame of the Spirituall or Christian commonweale the Church of Christ and it will be seen what wood hay and stubble of carnall policie and humane inventions in Christs matters are put in place of the precious stones gold and silver of the Ordinances of the most High and only wise God CHAP. CXXXVII Peace DEare Truth We are now arrived at their last Head the Title is this viz. Their power in the Liberties and Priviledges of these Churches First all Magistrates ought to be chosen out of Church-members Ezod 18. 21. Deut. 17. 15. Prov. 29. 2. When the Righteous rule the people rejoyce Secondly that all free men elected be only Church-members 1. Because if none but Church members should rule then others should not choose because they may elect others beside Church members 2. From the patterne of Israel where none had power to choose but only Israel or such as were joyned to the people of God 3. If it shall fall out that in the Court consisting of Magistrates and Deputies there be a dissent between them which may hinder the common good that they now returne for ending the same to their first principles which are the Free men and let them be consulted with Truth In this Head are 2 branches First concerning the choice of Magistrates that such ought to be chosen as are Church members for which is quoted Exod. 18. 21. Dut. 17. 15. Proverbs 19. 29. Unto which I answer It were to be wished that since the point is so weighty as concerning the Pilots and Steeresmen of Kingdoms and Nations c. on whose abilitie care and faithfulnesse depends most commonly the peace and safety of the commonweales they fall in I say it were to be wished that they had more fully explained what they intend by this Affirmative viz. Magistrates ought to be chosen out of Church members For if they intend by this Ought to be chosen a necessitie of concenience viz. that for the greater advancement of common utilitie and rejoycing of the people according to the place quoted Prov. 29. 2. it were to be desired prayed for and peaceably endeavored then I readily assent unto them But if by this Ought they intend such a necessitie as those Scriptures quoted imply viz. that people shall sin by choosing such for Magistrates as are not members of Churches as the Israelites should have sinned if they had not according to Iethro's counsell Exod. 18. and according to the command of God Deut. 18. chosen their Iudges and Kings within themselves in Israel then I propose these necessary Quaries First whether those are not lawfull Civill combinations societies and communions of men in Townes Cities States or Kingdoms where no Church of Christ is resident yea where his name was never yet heard of I adde to this that Men of no small note skilfull in the state of the World acknowledge that the World divided into 30 parts 25 of that 30 have never yet heard of the name of Christ If their Civill polities and combinations be not lawfull because they are not Churches and their Magistrates Church members then disorder confusion and all unrighteousnes is lawfull and pleasing to God Secondly whether in such States or Commonweales where a Church or Churches of Christ are resident such persons may not lawfully succeed to the Crown or Government in whome the feare of God according to Iethroes councell cannot be discerned not are brethren of the Church according to Deut. 17. but only are fitted with Civill and Morall abilities to manage the Civill affaires of the Civill State Thirdly since not many Wise and Noble are called but the poores receive the Gospel as God hath chosen the poore of the World to be rich in Faith 1 Cor. 1 Jam. 2. Whether it may not ordinarily come to passe that there may not be found in a true Church of Christ which sometimes consisteth but of few persons persons fit to be either Kings or Governours c. whose civill office is no lesse difficult then the office of a Doctor of Physick a Master or Pilot of a Ship or a Captaine or Commander of a Band or Army of men for which services the children of God may be no wayes qualified though otherwise excellent for the feare of God and the knowledge and Grace of the Lord Iesus 4. If Magistrates ought that is ought only to be chosen out of the Church I demand if they ought not also to be dethroned and deposed when they cease to be of the Church either by voluntary departure from it or by excommunication out of it according to the bloody tenents and practice of some Papists with whom the Protestants according to their principles although they seeme to abhor it doe absolutely agree 5. Therefore lastly I ask if this be not to turne the World upside down to turne the World out of the World to pluck up the
I heartily subscribe and know the God the Spirit the Prince the Angels and all the true awaked Sons of Peace will call thee blessed Truth How sweet and precious are these contemplations but oh how sweet the actions and fruitions Peace Thy lips drop as the Honey-combe Honey and Milke are under thy Tongue oh that these drops these streames might flow without a stop or interruption Truth The glorious white Troopers Rev. 19. shall in time be mounted and he that is the most High Prince of Princes and Lord Generall of Generalls mounted upon the Word of Truth and Meeknesse Psal 45. shall triumph gloriously and renew our meetings But harke what noise is this Peace These are the dolefull drums and shrill sounding trumpets the roaring murthering Canons the shouts of Conquerours the grones of wounded dying slaughtered righteous with the wicked Deare Truth how long how long these dreadfull sounds and direfull sights how long before my glad returne and restitution Truth Sweet Peace who will beleeve my true report yet true it is if I were once beleev'd blest Truth and Peace should not so soone be parted Peace Deare Truth what welcome hast thou found of late beyond thy former times or present expectations Truth Alas my welcome changes as the times and strongest swords and armes prevaile were I beleeved in this that Christ is not delighted with the blood of men but shed his owne for his bloodiest enemies that by the word of Christ no man for gainsaying Christ or joyning with his enemy Antichrist should bee molested with the civill sword Were this foundation laid as the Magna Charta of highest liberties and good security given on all hands for the preservation of it how soone should every brow and house be stucke with Olive Branches Peace This heavenly invitation makes mee bold once more to crave thy patient eare and holy tongue Errourâ—s impatient and soon tyred but thou art Light and like the Father of Lights unwearied in thy shinings Loe here what once againe I present to thy impartiall censure A MODEL of CHURCH and CIVIL Power Composed by Mr. COTTON and the MINISTERS of NEW-ENGLAND And sent to the CHURCH at SALEM as a further Confirmation of the bloody Doctrine of PERSECUTION for cause of CONSCIENCE Examined and Answered CHAP. LXXXII Truth VVHat hast thou there Peace Here is a combination of thine owne Children against thy very life and mine Hâ—re is a Modell framed by many able learned and godly hands of such a Church and Common-weale as wakens Moses from his unknown Grave and denies Iesus yet to have seene the Earth Truth Begin sweet Peace read and propound My hand shall not be tyred with holding the ballances of the Sanctuarie doe thou put in and I shall weigh as in the presence of Him whose pure eyes cannot behold iniquitie Peace Thus then speakes the Preface or Entrance Seeing God hath given a distinct power to Church and Common-weale the one Spirituall called the Power of the Keyes the other Civill called the Power of the Sword and hath made the members of both Societies subject to both Authorities so that every soule in the Church is subject to the higher powers in the Commonweale and every member of the Commonweale being a member of the Church is subject to the Lawes of Christs Kingdome and in him to the censures of the Church the Question is how the Civill State and the Church may dispence their severall Governments without infringement and impeachment of the power and honour of the One or of the Other and what bounds and limits the Lord hath set betweene both the Administrations Truth From that conclusion deare Peace that every memâ— of the Commonweale being a member of the Church is subject to the Lawes of Christs Kingdome and in Him to the censure of the Church I observe that they grant the Church of Christ in Spirituall causes to be superiour and over the highest Magistrates in the World if members of the Church Hence therefore I infer may she refuse to receive and may also cast forth any yea even the highest if obstinate in Sin cut of her Spirituall society Hence in this Spirituall society that soule who hath most of Christ most of His Spirit is most spiritually honourable according to the Scriptures quoted Acts 15. 20. Isa. 49. 23. Gal. 3. 28. And if so how can this stand with their common tenent that the Civill Magistrate must keep the first Table set up reforme the Church and be Iudge and Governour in all Ecclesiasticall as well as Civill causes Secondly I observe the lamentable wresting of this one Scripture Sometimes this Scripture must prove the Power of the Civill Magistrates Kings and Governours over the Church in Spirituall causes c. Yet here this Scripture is produced to prove Kings and Magistrates in Spirituall causes to be censured and corrected by the same Church â—Tis true in severall respects he that is a Governour may be a subject but in one and the same spirituall respect to judge and to be judged to sit on the Bench and stand at the Bar of Christ Iesus is as impossible as to reconcile the East and West together CHAP. LXXXII The first head That both Iurisdictions may stand together Peace VVHereas divers affecting transcending power to themselves over the Church have perswaded the Princes of the World that the Kingdome of Christ in His Church cannot rise or stand without the falls of those Common-weales wherein it is set up we do beleeve and professe the contrary to this suggestion the government of the one being of this World the other not the Church helping forward the prosperity of the Commonweale by meanes only Ecclesiasticall and Spirituall the Commonweale helping forward her owne and the Churches felicity by meanes politicall or temporall the falls of Commonweales being knowne to arise from their scattering and diminishing the power of the Church and the flourishing of Commonweales with the well ordering of the people even in morall and civill virtues being observed to arise from the vigilant administration of the holy Discipline of the Church as Bodin a man not partiall to Church Discipline plainely testifieth The vices in the free estate of Geneva quae legibus nusquam vindicantur by meanes of Church Discipline sine vi tumultu coercentur the Christian liberty not freeing us from subjection to Authority but from inthrallment and bondage unto sinne Truth Ans. From this confession that the Church or Kingdome of Christ may be set up without prejudice of the Commonweale according to Iohn 18. 36. My Kingdome is not of this World c. I observe that although the Kingdome of Christ the Church and the Civill Kingdome or Government be not inconsistent but that both may stand together yet that they are independent according to that Scripture and that therefore there may be as formerly I have proved flourishing Commonweales and Societies of menâ— where no
honoured with that mysticall and glorious Title of the Anointed 〈◊〉 Christ of the Lord Lam. 4. 20. the Breath of our Nostrils the Anointeâ— of Iehovah was taken in their pits c. Which anoynting and title however the Man of Sinne together with the Crowne and Diademe of Spirituall Israel the Church of God he hath given to some of the Kings of the Earth that so he may in lieu thereof dispose of their Civill Crownes the easier yet shall we finde it an incommunicable priviledge and prerogative oâ— of the Saints and people of God For as the Lord Iesus himselfe in the Antitype was not annointed with materiall but spirituall oyle Psal. 45. with the oyle of Gladnes and Luke 4. 14. from Isa. 61. 1. with the spirit of God The spirit of the Lord is upon me the Lord hath annointed me to preach good tidings c. So also all his members are annointed with the holy spirit of God 2 Cor. 1. 21. 1 John 2. Hence is it that Christians rejoyce in that name as carrying the very expresse title of the Anointed of the Lord which most superstitiously and sacrilegiously hath been applied only unto Kings Peace O deare Truth how doth the great Searcher of all Hearts finde out the thefts of the Antichristian World how are men caried in the darke they know not whither How is that heavenly charge Touch not mine Anointed c. Psal. 105. common to all Christians or anointed with Christ their Head by way of Monopoly or priviledge appropriated to Kings and Princes Truth It will not be here unseasonable to call to minde that admirable Prophecie Ezek. 21. 26 27. Thus saith Iehovah God Remove the Diadem take away the Crowne this shall not be the same exalt him that is low and abase him that is high I will overturne overturne overturne untill he come whose right it is and I will give it him The matter is a Crown and Diadem to be taken from an Vsurpers head and set upon the head of the right Owner Peace Doubtlesse this mystically intends the spirituall Crowne of the Lord Jesus for these many hundreth yeares set upon the heads of the Câ—mpetitours and Corrivals of the Lord Iesus upon whose glorious head in his Messengers and Churches the Crown shall be established The anointing the title and the crown and power must returne to the Lord Iesus in his Saints unto whom alone belongs his power and authoritie in Ecclesiasticall or Spirituall cases CHAP. CXVII Truth I Therefore proceed to a third difference between those Kings and Governours of Israel and Iudah and all other Kings and Rulers of the Earth Looke upon the Administrations of the Kings of Israel and Iudah and well weigh the Power and Authoritie which those Kings of Israel and Iudah exercised in Ecclesiasticall and spirituall causes and upon a due search we shall not find the same Scepter of Spirituall power in the hand of Civill Authoritie which was setled in the hands of the Kings of Israel and Iudah David appointed the Orders of the Priests Singers he brought the Arke to Ierusalem he prepared for the building of the Temple the patterne whereof he delivered to Salomon yet David herein could not be a type of the Kings and Rulers of the Earth but of the King of Heaven Christ Iesus for First David as he was a King so was he also a Prophet Acts 2. 30. and therefore a type as Moses also was of that great Prophet the Son of God And they that plead for Davids Kingly power must also by the same rule plead for his Propheticall by which he swayed the Scepâ—er of Israel in Church affaires Secondly it is expresly said 1 Cron. 28. 11. 12. 13. verses that the patterne which David gave to Salomon concerning the matter of the Temple and Worship of God he had it by the Spirit which was no other but a figure of the immediate inspiration of the spirit of God unto the Lord Iesus the true Spirituall King of Israel John 1. 49. Rabbi thou art the Son of God Rabbi thou art the King of Israel Againe What Civill Magistrate may now act as Salomon a type of Christ doth act 1 King 2. 26. 27. Salomon thrust out Abiathar from being Priest unto Iehovah Peace Some object that Abiathar was a man of death ver 26. worthy to die as having followed Adonijah and therefore Salomon executed no more then Civill justice upon him Truth Salomon remits the Civill punishment and inflicts upon him a spirituall but by what right but as he was King of the Church a figure of Christ Abiathar his Life is spared with respect to his former good service in following after David but yet he is turned out from the Priesthood But now put the case suppose that any of the Officers of the New-England Churches should prove false to the State and be discovered joyning with a French Monsieur or Spanish Don thirsting after conquest and dominion to further their invasions of that Countrey yet for some former faithfull service to the State he should not be adjudged to Civill punishment I aske now might their Governours or their Generall Court their Parliament depose such a man a Pastour Teacher or Elder from his holy Calling or office in Gods House Or suppose in a partiall and corrupt State a Member or Officer of a Church should escape with his life upon the commission of marther ought not a Church of Christ upon repentance to receive him I suppose it will not be said that he ought to execute himselfe or that the Church may use a Civill sword against him In these cases may such persons spar'd in civill punishments for some reason of or by partialitie of State be punished spiritually by the Civill Magistrate as Abiathar was Let the very Enemies of Zion be Judges Secondly If Salomon in thrusting out of Abiathar was a pattern and president unto all Civill Magistrates why not also in putting Zaâ—â—k in his roome ver 35. But against this the Pope the Bishops the Presbyterians and the Independents will all cry out against such a practice in their severall respective claimes and challenges for their Ministries We find the Libertie of the subjects of Christ in the choice of an Apostle Act. 1. of a Deacon Act. 6. of Elders Act. 14. and guided by the assistance either of the Apostles or Evangelists 1 Tim. 1. Tit. 1. without the least influence of any civill Magistrate which shewes the beauty of their liberty The Parliaments of England have by right free choice of their Speaker yet some Princes have thus farre beene gratified as to nominate yea and implicitely to commend a Speaker to them Wise men have seene the evill consequences of those influences though but in civill things how much farre greater and stronger are those snares when the golden Keyes of the Sonne of God are delivered into the hands of civill Authority Peace You know the noise
10. chapters CHAP. CXXV Peace DEare Truth You know the noyse is made from those prophecies Isa. 46. Kings and Queenes shall be nursing Fathers c. and Revel 21. the Kings of the Earth shall bring their Glory and Honour to new Ierusalem c. Truth I answer with that mournfull Prophet Psal. 74. I see not that man that Prophet that can tell us how long How many excellent Pen-men fight each against other with their pens like swords in the application of those prophecies of David Isa. Ier. Ezekiel Daniel Zacharie Iohn when and how those Prophecies shall be fulfilled Secondly When ever those prophecies are fulfilled yet shall those Kings not be Heads Governours and Judges in Ecclesiasticall or Spirituall causes but be themselves judged and ruled if within the Church by the power of the Lord Jesus therein Hence saith Isaiah those Kings and Queenes shall lick the Dust of thy feet c. Peace Some will here aske What may the Magistrate then lawfully doe with his Civill horne or power in matters of Religion Truth His horne not being the horne of that Vnicorne or Rhinocerot the power of the Lord Iesus in Spirituall caseâ— his sword not the two-edged sword of the Spirit the word of God hanging not about the loines or side but at the lips and proceeding out of the mouth of his Ministers but of an humane and Civill nature and constitution it must consequently be of a humane and Civill operation for who knowes not that operation followes constitution and therefore I shall end this passage with this consideration The Civill Magistrate either respecteth that Religion and Worship which his conscience is perswaded is true and upon which he ventures his Soule or else that and those which he is perswaded are false Concerning the first if that which the Magistrate believeth to be true be true I say he owes a threefold dutie unto it First approbation and countenance a reverent esteeme and honorable Testimonie according to Isa. 49. Revel 21. with a tender respect of Truth and the professours of it Secondly Personall submission of his owne Soule to the power of the Lord Iesus in that spirituall Government and Kingdome according to Mat. 18. 1. Cor. 5. Thirdly Protection of such true professours of Christ whether apart or met together as also of their estates from violence and injurie according to Rom. 13. Now secondly if it be a false Religion unto which the Civill Magistrate dare not adjoyne yet he owes First permission for approbation he owes not to what is evill and this according to Matthew 13. 30. for publike peace and quiet sake Secondly he owes protection to the persons of his Subjects though of a false worship that no injurie be offered either to the persons or goods of any Rom. 13. Peace Deare Truth in this 11 head concerning the Magistrates power in Worship you have examined what is affirmed that the Magistrate may doe in point of Worship there remaines a second to wit that which they say the Magistrate may not doe in Worship They say The Magistrate may not bring in set formes of prayerâ— Nor secondly bring in significant ceremonies Nor thirdly not governe and rule the acts of worship in the Church of God for which they bring an excellent similitude of a Prince or Magistrate in a ship where he hath no governing power over the actions of the mariners and secondly that excellent propheciâ— concerning Christ Iesus that his government should be upon his shoulders Isa. 9. 6 7. Truth Unto all this I willingly subscribe Yet can I not passe by a most injurious and unequall practice toward the Civill Magistrate Ceremonies Holy dayes Common Prayer and what ever else dislikes their consciences that the Magistrate must not bring in Others againe as learned as godly as wise have conceived the Magistrate may approve or permit these in the Church and all men are bound in obedience to obey him How shal the Magistrates conscience be herein between both torn and distracted if indeed the power either of establishing or abolishing in Church matters bee committed to him Secondly me thinkes in this case they deale with the Civill Magistrate as the Souldiers dealt with the Lord Iesus First they take off his owne clothes and put upon him a purple Robe plat a Crowne of Thornes on his head bow the knee and salute him by the name of King of the Iewes They tell him that he is the Keeper of both Tables he must see the Church doe her duty he must establish the true Church true Ministry true Ordinances he must keepe her in this purity Againe hee must abolish superstition and punish false Churches false Ministers even to banishment and death Thus indeed doe they make the blood run downe the head of the civill Magistrate from the thorny vexation of that power which sometimes they crowne him with whence in great States Kingdoms or Monarchies necessarily arise delegations of that spirituall power High Commissions c. Anon againe they take off this purple robe put him into his own clothes and tell him that he hath no power to command what is against their conscience They cannot conforme to a set form of prayer nor to Ceremonies nor Holy dayes c. although the civill Magistrate that most pious Prince Edw 6. â— and his famous Bishops afterwards burnt for Christ were of another conscienceâ— which of these two consciences shall stand if either Magistrate must put forth his civill power in these cases the strongest arme of flesh and most conquering bloody sword of Steele can alone decide the Question I confesse it is most true that no Magistrate as no other superiour is to be obeyed in any matter displeasing to God yet when in matters of worship we ascribe the absolute headship and government to the Magistrate as to keepe the Church pute and force her to her duty Ministers and People and yet take unto our selves power to judge what is right in our owne eyes and to judge the Magistrate in and for those very things wherein we confesse he hath power to see us doe our duty and therefore consequently must judge what our duty is what is this but to play with Magistrates with the soules of men with Heaven with God with Christ Iesus c. CHAP. CXXVI Peace PAsse on holy Truth to that similitude whereby they illustrate that Negative Assertion The Prince in the Ship say they is governour over the bodies of all in the Ship but hee hath no power to governe the Ship or the Mariners in the Actions of it If the Pilot manifestly erre in his Action the Prince may reprove him and so say they may any Passenger if hee offend against the life or goods of any the Prince may in due time and place punish him which no private person may Truth Although deare Peace wee both agree that civill powers may not
toleration of conscience ibid. Protestant partiality in the cause of persecution 108 Pills to purge out the bitter humour of persecution ibid. Superstition and persecution have had many votes and suffrages from Gods owne people 109 Soul-killing discussed ibid. Phineas his act discussed 111 Eliah his slaughters examined ibid Dangerous consequences flowing from the civill Magistrates power in Spirituall cases 114 The world turned upside downe Page 114 The wonderfull answer of the Ministers of New England to the Ministers of Old ibid. Lamentable differences even amongst them that feare God 115 The doctrine of persecution ever drives the most godly out of the world 116 A Modell of Church and Civill power composed by Mr. Cotton and the Ministers of New England and sent to Salem as a further confirmation of the bloody doctrine of persecution for cause of conscience examined and answered 118 Christs power in the Church confest to be above all Magistrates in Spirituall things 119 Isa. 49. 23. lamentably wrested ibid. The civill Commonweale and the Spirituall Commonweale the Church not inconsistent though independent the one on the other 120 Christ ordinances put upon a whole city or Nation may civilize them and moralize but not Christianize before repentance first wrought 121 Mr. Cottons and the New English Ministers confession that the Magistrate hath neither Civill nor Spirituall power in Soul matters 122 The Magistrates and the Church by Mr. Cottons grounds in one and the same cause made the Iudges onthe Bench and delinquents at the Bar. 123 A demonstrative illustration that the Magistrate cannot have power over the Church in Spirituall or Church causes 124 The true way of the God of Peace in differences between the Church and the Magistrate 125. The tearms Godlinesse and Honesty explained 1 Tim. 2. x. and honesty proved not to signifie in that place the righteousnes of the second Table 127 The forcing of men to Gods worship the greatest breach of civill peace 129 The Roman Caesars of Christs time described ibid. It pleased not the Lord Iesus in the institution of the Christian Church to appoint and raise up any Civill Governours to take care of his worship 130 The true custodes utriusque Tabulae and keepers of the Ordinances and worship of Iesus Christ. ibid. The Kings of Aegypt Moah Philistia Assyria Niâ—â—vch were not charged with the worship of God as the Kings of Iudah were 131 Masters of families not charged under the Gospel to force all the consciâ—uces of their families to worship 132 Gods people have then shined brightest in Godlines when they have enjoyed least quietnesse pag. 134. Few Magistrates few Men spiritually good yet divers sorts of commendable Goodnes beside spirituall ibid. Civill power originally and fundamentally in the People Mr. Cotton and the New English give the power of Christ into the hands of thâ— Commonweale 137 Lawes concerning Religion of two sorts 138 The very Indians abhor to disturbe any Conscience at Worship 139 Canons and constitutions pretended Civill but indeed Ecclesiasticall ibid. A threesold guilt lying upon Civill powers commanding the Subjects Soule in Worship 143 Persons may with lesse sinne be forced to marry whom they cannot love then to worship where they cannot beleeve ibid. As the cause so the weapons of the Beast and the Laâ—â— be are infinitely different 146 Aâ—taxerxes his Dicree examined 147 The summe of the Examples of the Gentile Kings decrees concerning Gods worship in Scripture 149 The Doctrine of putting to death Blasphemers of Christ cuts off the hopes of the Iewes partaking in his blood 18â— The direfull effects of fighting for Conscience 151 Errour is confident as well as Truth 152 Spirituall prisons 153 Some Consciences not so easily healed and cured as men imagine 154 Persecuters dispute with Hereticks as a tyrann call Cat with the poore Mouse And with a true Witnes as a roaring Lyon with an innocent Lambe in his paw 155 Persecuters endure not tho name of Persecuters 156 Psal 101 concerning cutting off the wicked examined 158 No difference of Lands and Countries since Christ Iesus his comming ib. The New English seperate in America but not in Europe 159 Christ Iesus forbidding his followers to permit Leaven in the Church doth not forbid to permit Leaven in the World 160 The Wall Cant. 8. 9. discussed 161 Every Religion commands its professors to heare only its own Priests or Ministers 162 Ionah his preaching to the Ninevites discussed 162 â—â—aring of the Word discussed ibid. Eglon his rising up to Ehuds message discussed ibid. A two-fold Ministrie of Christ First Apostolicall properly converting Secondly Feeding or Pastorall pag. 162 The New English forcing the people to Church and yet not to Religion as they say forcing them to be of no Religion all their dayes 163 The Civill State can no more lawfully compell the Consciences of men to Church to heare the Word then to receive the Sacraments 164 No president in the word of any people converting and baptizing themselves 166 True conversion to visible Christianitie is not only from sins against the second Table but from false Worships also ibid. The Commission Mat. 28 discussed 167 The Civill Magistrate not be trusted with that Commission ibid. Iehosaphat 2 Chron. 1â— a figure of Christ Iesus in his Church not of the Civill Magistrate in the State 168 The maintenance of the Ministrie Gal. 6. 6. examined ibid. Christ Iesus never appointed a maintenance of the Ministrie from the iâ—penitent and unbelieving 169 They that compell men to heare compell them also to pay for their hearing and conversion ibid. Luc. 14. Compell them to come in examined ibid. Naturall men can neither truly worship nor mainteine it 170 The Nationall Church of the Iewes might well be forced to a setled maintenance but not so the Christian Church 171 The maintenance which Christ hath appointed his Ministrie in the Church 172 The Vniversities of Europe causes of universall sins and plagues yet Schooles are honourable for tongues and Arts. 173 The true Church is Christs Schoole and Believers his Scholars ibid. Mr. Ainsworth excellent in the Tongues yet no Vniversitie man 174 K. Henry the 8. set down in the Popes chaire in England 175 Apocrypha Homilies and Common Prayer precious to our forefathers ib. Reformation proved fallible 176 The president of the Kings of Israel Iudah largely examined 178 The Persian Kings example make strongly against the doctrine of Persecution 179 1. The difference of the hand of Canaan from all lands and countries in 7 particulars ibid. 2. The difference of the people of Israel from all other peoples in 7 particulars 183 Wonderfull turnings of Religion in England in twelve yeares revolution Page 185 The Pope not unlike to recover his Monarchy over Europe before his dowâ—fall ibid. Israel Gods only Church might well renew that Nationall Covenant and ceremoniall worship which other Nations cannot doe 187 â— The difference of the Kings and Governours of Israel from all Kings and Governours of the world
mouth will I judge thee For what can be said more heavenly by the tongues of Men and Angels to shew the heavenly meek temper of all the Souldiers of the Lambe of God as also to set forth what are the Spirituall weapons and ammunition of the holy war and battle of the Gospell and Kingdome of Iesus Christ for the subduing of the Nations of the World unto him Peace And yet out of the same mouth which should not be faith Iames proceeds good and evill sweet and sowre for he addes But this doth not forbid them to drive ravenous wolves from the sheepfold and to restraine them from devouring the sheepe of Christ. Truth In these words according to the judgement here maintained by him he fights against the former truth to wit that by spirituall weapons Christ Iesus will subdue the Nations of the Earth to the obedience of the Gospel for by driving away these Wolves hee intends not onely the resistance and violence which the Shepherds of Christ ought spiritually to make but the civill resistance of the materiall Swords Staves Guns c. Whenceâ— I argue that same power that forceth the evill or Wolves out forceth the good the Sheepe in for of the same or like things is the same or like reason as the same arme of flesh that with a staffe beats off a Wolfe with a Rod and Hooke brings in the Sheepe the same dog that assaulteth and teareth the Wolfe frighteth and forceth in the straggling Sheep CHAP. XLII Peace BVt for the clearer opening of this mystery I pray explicate that Scripture where the Spirit of God is pleased to use this similitude of Wolves Acts 20. 29. out of which keeping to the Allegory I shall propose these Quaeries First what Wolves were these Paul warnes of Truth Answ. Wolves literally he will not say Nor secondly persecutors of the Flock such as the Romane Emperours were Magistrates under him Therefore thirdly such as brought other Religions and Worships as the Spirit of God opens it vers 30. Such as amongst themselves should speake perverse things as many Antichrists did and especially The Antichrist And I aske whether or no such as may hold forth other Worships or Religions Iewes Turkes or Antichristians may not be peaceable and quiet Subjects loving and helpfull neighbours faire and just dealers true and loyall to the civill government It is cleare they may from all Reason and Experience in many flourishing Cities and Kingdomes of the World and so offend not against the civill State and Peace nor incurre the punishment of the civill sword notwithstanding that in spirituall and mysticall account they are ravenous and greedy Wolves Peace 2. I quaere to whom Paul gave this charge to watch against them vers 31. Truth They were not the Magistrates of the City of Ephesus but the Elders or Ministers of the Church of Christ his mysticall flock of sheepe at Ephesus Vnto them was this charge of watching given and so consequently of driving away these Wolves And however that many of these charges and exhortations given by that One Shepherd Christ Iesus to the Shepherds or Ministers of Churches be commonly attributed and directed by the Answerer in this discourse to the civill Magistrate yet I desire in the feare and holy presence of God it may bee inquired into whether in all the Will or Testament of Christ there bee any such word of Christ by way of command promise or example countenancing the Governors of the civill State to meddle with these Wolves if in civill things peaceable and obedient Peace Truly if this charge were given to the Magistrates at Ephesus or any Magistrate in the World doubtlesse they must bee able to discerne and determine out of their owne officiall abilities in these spirituall Law questions who are spirituall Sheep what is their food what their poison what their properties who their Keepers c. So on the contrary who are Wolves what their properties their haunts their assaults the manner of taking c. spiritually and this beside the care and study of the Civill Lawes and the discerning of his owne proper Civill Sheep obedient Sheepe c. as also wolvish oppressors c. whom he is bound to punish and suppresse Truth I know that Civill Magistrates in some places have declined the name of Head of the Church and Ecclesiasticall Judge yet can they not with good conscience decline the name if they doe the worke and performe the office of determining and punishing a meerly spirituall Wolfe They must be sufficiently also able to judge in all spirituall causes and that with their owne and not with other mens eyes no more then they doe in civill causes contrary to the common practice of the Governours and Rulers of Civill States who often set up that for a Religion or Worship to God which the Clergie or Churchmen as men speake shall in their Consciences agree upon And if this be not so to wit that Magistrates must not be Spirituall Iudges as some decline it in the title Supreme Head and Governour why is Gallio wont to be exclaimed against for refusing to be a Iudge in such matters as concerned the Iewish Worship and Religion How is he censured for a Prophane person without conscience c. in that he would bee no Iudge or Head for that is all one in point of Government Peace In the third place I quaerie whether the Father who gave and the Sonne who keepes the Sheepe bee not greater then all Who can pluck these Sheepe the Elect out of his hand which answers that common objection of that danger of devouring although there were no other weapons in the world appointed by the Lord Jesus But CHAP. XLIII FOurthly I ask Were not these Elders or Ministers of the Church of Ephesus sufficiently furnished from the Lord Iesus to drive away these mysticall and spirituall Wolves Truth True it is against the inhumane and uncivill violence of Persecutors they were not nor are Gods children able and provided but to resist drive away expell and kill spirituall mysticall Wolves by the word of the Lord none are fit to be Christs Shepherds who are not ableâ— Tit. 1. 9. 10. 11. The Bishop or Overseer must be able by sound doctrine both to exhort and to convince the Gainsayers which Gainsayers to be by him convinced that is overcome or subdued though it may be in themselves ever obstinate they were I say as greedy Wolves in Crete as any could be at Ephesus for so saith Paul vers 10. they were unruly and vaine talkers deceivers whose mouthes must bee stopped who subverted whole houses and yet Titus and every ordinary Shepherd of a flocke of Christ had ability sufficient to defend the flock from spirituall and mysticall wolves without the helpe of the Civill Magistrate Peace In this respect therefore me thinks we may â—itly allude to that excellent answer of Iob to Bildad the Shuhite Iob 26. How
Church of Christ abideth and secondly the Commonweale may be in perfect peace and quiet notwithstanding the Church the Commonweale of Christ be in distractionsâ— and spirituall oppositions both against their Religions and sometimes amongst themselves as the Church of Christ in Corinth troubled with divisions contentions c. Secondly I observe it is true the Church helpeth forward the prosperity of the Commonweale by spirituall meanes Ier. 29. 7. The prayers of Gods people procure the peace of the City where they abide yet that Christs Ordinances and administrations of Worship are appointed and given by Christ to any Civill State Towne or City as is implied by the instance of Geneva that I confidently deny The Ordinances and Discipline of Christ Iesus though wrongfully and prophanely applied to naturall and unregenerate men may cast a blush of civillity and morality upon them as in Geneva and other places for the shining brightnesse of the very shadow of Christs Ordinances casts a shame upon barbarisme and incivillity yet withall I affirme that the misapplication of Ordinances to unregenerate and unrepentant persons hardens up their soules in a dreadfull sleep and dreame of their owne blessed estate and sends millions of soules to hell in a secure expectation of a false salvation CHAP. LXXXIV The second head concerning Superiority of each Power Peace BEcause contention may arise in future times which of these Powers under Christ is the greatest as it hath been under Antichrist we conceive first That the power of the Civill Magistrates is superiour to the Church policie in place honours dignity earthly power in the World and the Church superiour to him being a member of the Church Ecclesiastically that is in a Church way ruling and ordering him by Spirituall Ordinances according to God for his soules health as any other member so that all the power the Magistrate hath over the Church is temporall not spirituall and all the power the Church hath over the Magistrate is spirituall not temporall And as the Church hath no temporall power over the Magistrate in ordine ad bonum spirituale So the Magistrate hath no Spirituall power over the Church in ordine ad bonum temporale Secondly the delinquencie of either party calleth for the exercise of the power of terrour from the other part for no Rulers ordained of God are a terrour to good works but to evill Rom. 13. 3. So that if the Church offend the offence of the Church câ—lleth upon the Civill Magistrate either to seeke the healing thereof as a nursing father by his owne grave advice and the advice of other Churches or else if he cannot so prevaile to put forth and exercise the superiority of his power in redressing what is amisse according to the quality of the offence by the course of civill Justice On the other side if the Magistrate being a member of the Church shall offend the offence calleth upon the Church either to seek the healing thereof in a brotherly way by conviction of his sinne or else if they cannot prevaile then to exercise the superiority of their power in removing of the offence and recovering of the offendour by Church censures If the end of Spirituall or Church power is bonum spirituale a spirituall good and the end of Civill or State power is bonum temporale a temporall good And secondly if the Magistrate have no spirituall power to attaine to his temporall end no more then a Church hath any temporall power to attaine to her Spirituall end as is confest I demand if this be not a contradiction against their owne disputes tenents and practices touching that question of persecution for cause of conscience For if the Magistrate be supreme Iudge and so consequently give supreme judgement sentence and determination in matters of the first Table and of the Church and be custos utriusque Tabule keepers of both Tables as they speake and yet have no Spirituall power as is affirmed how can he determine what the true Church and Ordinances are and then set them up with the power of the Sword How can he give judgement of a false Church a false Ministery a false Doctrine false Ordinances and with a Civil Sword pull them down if he have no Spiritual power authority or commission from Christ Iesus for these ends and purposes Further I argue thus If the civill officers of State must determine judge and punish in Spiritual causes his power authority and commission must be either Spirituall or Civill or else he hath none at all and so acts without a commission and warrant from the Lord Iesus and so consequently stands guilty at the Bar of Christ Iesus to answer for such his practice as a transcendent Delinquent Now for civill power these worthy Authors confesse that the Government of the civill Magistrate extendeth no further then over the bodies and goods of the Subject and therefore hath no civill power over the Soule and therefore say I not in Soule-causes Secondly It is here confest in this passage that to attaine his Civill end or Bonum temporale he hath no Spirituall power and therefore of necessitie out of their own mouths must they be judged for provoking the Magistrate without either Civill or Spirituall power to judge punish and persecute in Spirituall causes and to feare and tremble lest they come neere those frogs which proceed out of the mouth of the Dragon and Beast and false Prophet who by the same Arguments which the Authours here use stirre up the Kings of the Earth to make warre against the Lambe Christ Iesus and his Followers Revel 17. CHAP. LXXXV IN the next place I observe upon the point of Delinquencie such a confusion as Heaven and Earth may stand amazed at If the Church offend say they after advice refused in conclusion the Magistrate must redresse that is punish the Church that is in Church offences and cases by a course of Civill justice On the other side if the Civill Magistrate offend after Admonition used and not prevailing in conclusion the Church proceeds to censure that is to Excommunication as is afterward more largely proved by them Now I demand if the Church be a Delinquent who shall judge It is answered the Magistrate Againe if the Magistrate be a Delinquent I aske who shall judge It is answered the Church Whence I observe which is monstrous in all cases in the World that one person to wit the Church or Magistrate shall be at one time the Delinquent at the Bar and the Iudge upon the Bench. This is cleere thus The Church must judge when the Magistrate offends and yet the Magistrate must judge when the Church offends and so consequently in this case must judge whether she contemne Civill Authority in the Second Table for thus dealing with him Or whether she have broken the rules of the first Table of which say they God hath made him Keeper and Conserver And therefore though the