Selected quad for the lemma: cause_n

Word A	Word B	Word C	Word D	Occurrence	Frequency Band	MI	MI Band	Prominent
cause_n	bring_v	good_a	let_v	1,459	5	4.0417	3	false

Text snippets containing the quad

ID	Title	Author	Corrected Date of Publication (TCP Date of Publication)	STC	Words	Pages
A93702	Rome ruin'd by VVhite Hall, or, The papall crown demolisht: containing a confutation of the three degrees of popery, viz. papacy, prelacy, and presbitery; answerable to the triple crowne of the three-headed Cerberus the Pope, with his three fold hierarchies aforesaid. With a dispelling of all other dispersed clouds of errour, which doth interpose the clear sun-shine of the Gospel in our horrizon. Wherein the chiefe arguments each of them have, for the vindication of their erronious tenents are incerted, and refuted; with a description of such whem [sic] the true Church of Christ doth consist of: as also how, and by whom, they may be gathered, and governed, according to the will, and appointment of Jesus Christ, and his apostles, in the primative purity thereof. / By Iohn Spittlehouse, assistant to the Marshall Generall of the Army, under the command of his Excellency, the Lord Generall Fairfax. Imprimated by Theod. Jennings, and entred in the Stationers Hall.	Spittlehouse, John.	1649 (1649)	Wing S5013; Thomason E586_2; ESTC R203633	304,213	396

13. neither hath he commanded it but forbidden it in his Law neither doth he worke with them that doth evill for all that God doth is good and so there is none good but God Mark 10. 19. neither doth the Lord approve sin being done Psal 84. Thou art a God that hatest wickednesse So then if God neither move to sin nor commend it being done nor yet assist the actors of it he can in no wise be said to be the author of sin 3. If God should cause sin then every man should sin of necessity and so his punishment should be unjust being forced to sin but God who cannot be deceived hath not brought upon any a necessity or willingnesse of sinning for it cannot be that by whom men rise from sin by him they should fall into sin God that is good cannot be said to be the cause of evill for then he should be contrary to himself Again if God should be any waies the Author of sin then it should be no sin for whatsoever God doth is good nay not to doe that which the Lord willeth is sinne Yet seeing 1. God is said in Scripture to harden the heart which betokeneth an action and likewise in other termes as God is said to give some over to vile affections as in Rom. 1. 26. and to send upon some strong delusions that they should not beleeve the truth 2 Thes 2. 11. and to make the heart fat the eares heavie and to shut the ●yes Isa 6. 10. all which phrases implyeth an action or opperation it is therefore requisite to shew what the hardnesse of heart is 2. By what meanes it is effected or procured and 3. In what respect God may be said to work in the action SECT 2. 1. IT may be described negatively by the unaptnesse of it to any The qualities and inseparable adjuncts of a hard heart Reader examine thy selfe by these ten Simptomes thing that is good being neither passive active or apprehensive of any good thing it is neither moved by prayers nor giveth way to threats it is unthankfull for benefits unfaithfull in Counsell unshame fac'd in evill things there is no activity at all to any good thing it remembreth nothing that is past but wrongs and injuries nor hath any fore-cast for the time to come unlesse it be to seeke revenge 2. It may be described by the inseparable companions thereof viz. the blindnesse of the mind for as ignorance blindeth the understanding so hardnesse of heart blindeth the will and affections as the Apostle saith speaking of the Gentiles Having their cogitations darkned through the ignorance that was in them because of the hardnesse of their hearts Eph. 4. 18. both which concurred in Pharaoh who shewed his blindnesse in saying he knew not Jehovah and his hardnesse of heart in adding neither will I let Israel goe Exod. 5. 3. The third property of the hardnesse of heart is thi● that it not only a great and grievous sin but also the punishment of sin 1. That it is a sin the Apostle sheweth Heb. 3. 12. where he saith Take heed brethren least therein at any time in you be an evill heart to depart from the living God And that it is a punishment of sin the Apostle testifieth also Rom. 1. 21. because saith he when they knew God they did not glorifie him as God And therefore it followeth ver 29. That God gave them over to their own hearts lusts Now the qualities and inseparable adjuncts of hardning the heart are these viz. 1. Blindnesse of judgement and understanding as Isa 6. 10. where the Lord saith Make the heart of this people fat c. lest Reader examine thy selfe by these Simptomes they should see with their eyes and heare with their eares and understand with their hearts and be converted and I should heale them 2. They are obstinate and wilfull and refuse to be admonished and instr●cted and say unto God Depart from us we desire not the knowledge of thy wayes Job 1. 14. 3. They delight in doing of evill and make a sport of sin Prov. 2. 14. which rejoyce in doing of evill and delight in the frowardnesse of the wicked 4. They regard not to doe things honest in the sight of God but contrarily contemne and despise them that doe such things as Prov. 18. 3. When the wicked commeth then commeth contempt 5. They are incorrigible and past all hopes of amendment Prov. 1. 30. They would none of my counsell but despised all my corrections 6. They are not ashamed of most vile sins as Jer. 3. 3. Thou hast a Wh●res forehead and wouldest not be ashamed 7. When the Lord smiteth them they feele i● not neither have they any feare of Gods judgements whom the Wise man compareth to those that sleep on the Mast of a Ship and as drunken men that are stricken and knoweth it not Prov. 23. 24. 25. 8. They are growne to such an evill custome of sinning that they can doe no other as the Prophet saith Can the Black-a-more change his hew or the Leopard his spots then may they yet also doe good that are accustomed to doe evill Jer. 13. 23. So that the sins of such seeme to be inexpiable as the same Prophet saith that the sins of Judah were written with a Pen of Iron and with the point of a Diamond Chap. 17. 1. 9. They wax worse and worse of whom it is said Rev. 22. 11. He that is filthy let him be filthy still and as they increase in sins so doe they treasure up wrath against the day of wrath and so treasure up Gods judgements against themselves Rom. 2. 5. 10. They are rejected and cast out of the presence of God and left to themselves such an one was Saul of whom it was said That the Spirit of the Lord departed from him and an evill spirit from the Lord vexed him 1 Sam. 16. 14. And thus have I shewed what the hardnesse of heart is SECT 3. 2. IN the next place I am to shew by what meanes it is effected How the hardnesse of the heart is effected and procured of which subject there are varieties of opinions I shal give you the most materiall of them Some are of opinion that the Lord hardneth the heart by way of manifestation instansing in Pharaoh where the Lord by his plagues and judgements declared how hard Pharaohs heart was But this cannot be the sence of it for so God might be said to commit any other sins when he doth manifest them and bring to l●ght and though the expression might serve upon that occasion yet it faileth in other places as Deut. 2. 30. where it is said that God hardened the heart of Sihon King of the Amorites and Joshua 23. where the Lord is said to harden the hearts of the Can●a●it●s and Rom. 9. 15. God hath mercy on whom he will have mercy and whom he will h● hardneth in these places it cannot be expounded that God hardned that is

crea●ing power 2. As a particular direction by his regenerating grace But in the other motion he hath a stroke as a generall mover in the particular act of hardning as it is evill he concurreth not therefore according to that generall power the Lord is only said to be a mover not an hardner of the heart Now of these waies before rehearsed there are three chiefly to be made choise of viz. 1. That God hardneth the heart by leaving it to it self and depriving it of his necessary grace as he is said to have given over the unbeleeving Gentiles to their owne hearts lusts Rom. 1. 24. 2. That God causeth many things to be done which are not in themselves causes of the hardning of the heart yet the wicked take occasion thereby to be further indurate and hardned as the Apostle sheweth that the wicked abuse the patience and long suffering of God thereby to be further hardned 3. That God by his just judgement doth force them to their owne hurt whether they run headlong themselves even to the end For God as a just Judge seeing a mans heart bent upon wickednesse doth as a just Judge inflict upon him the spirit of induration and to this purpose one handling that place Rom. 1. 14. saith that some things there rehearsed are sins and no punishments as the pride and vanities of their minds ver 21. they were not thankfull but became vaine in their imaginations And some also punishments and no sin as eternall death which they were Worthy of ve●●● and that the rest that come betwixt are both sins and punishment SECT 12. Obj. VVHy should God take such a punishment of sin that the sinners thereby commit more sin Ans We answer with the Apostle Rom. 1. 27. where he saith Man with man wrought filthinesse and received such recompence to themselves as was meet for their errors so that God did not send them upon the Gentiles as they were sins but as they are considered as punishments of their sins for as God hath an hand therein he doth incline the wil being evil by its owne fault to sin by his just and secret Judgement as for instance There is but one kinde of heat in the Sun and according to Simile the matter it worketh upon some things it melteth and some things it hardneth the Wax it melteth the Clay it hardneth so God as the Sun hardneth the Clay is said to harden the heart which is earthly and muddy as also by the same worke of the raine the earth being wel tilled bringeth forth good fruit but being untilled thistles which is not of it self as it is raine but by reason of the nature of the thing concurring whereupon it worketh so by the working of God after a most secret and hidden manner the heart of the wicked are hardned but the cause thereof is in themselves Obj. Gods must needs be a worker of evill in hardning of mens hearts Ans God hardneth the heart without any touch of sin as God hardneth the heart without any to●ch of sin may be illustrated by this Simile as in the winter quarter the water is frozen until the Sun shine upon it and when the Sun is departed from it it is bound up with cold againe the Sun is not the cause of the freezing of the water but the coldnesse of the water bindeth it self so properly God causeth not the heart to be hardned but by the absence of his grace it becometh hardned Obj. Why doth the Lord suffer any to be hardned Ans That must be ascribed to the Judgement of God which are often hidden but never unjust it should suffice us as the Apostle saith to know and beleeve and that there is no iniquity with God SECT 13. Obj. NO man in this life can become altogether so impenitent incorrigible or without hope of grace or in such a desperate state as to be forsaken for God would have all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth and I will not the death of a sinner c. so then if mercy be offered to all then the way is open to all to repent and turne unto God Ans God indeed offereth himself to all and denyeth not the God offereth grace to all externall meanes to any if they had grace to apprehend them The Gospel hath been preached to all the world and so to the impenitent and reprobate God therefore offereth grace unto all but all will not receive it as one saith the wholsome medicine of admonition must be administred to all though the health of the sick be uncertaine But if he that is admonished belong to the predestinate it is to him a wh●lsome medicine if he doe not it is a penall torment Againe the argument followeth not God calleth all men to repentance ergo all may have grace to repent for the Scripture saith that many are called but few are chosen Grace doth prevaile with some but with others their obstinate natures resisteth to which purpose the Scriptures are very plentifull as in Act. 2. 41. Act. 16. 14. 13. 45. c. Obj. So long as men are in this life they are in the way and are not deprived of all grace nor utterly forsaken untill they be in Hell Ans Everlasting punishment in Hell is the end and execution Man in this life may be in the state of damnation of damnation but men in this life may be in the state of damnation and be utterly forsaken of Gods grace as Saul and Judas and they whom the Apostle saith God gave over to a reprobate sence Rom. 1. 28. Erg● SECT 14. Obj. IF any man in this life had been utterly excluded from grace Pharaoh of all other had been most like yet his estate was not desperate seeing he was in the same case with Nebuchadnezzar who repented and confessed God Ans This reason is flatly against the Apostle who pronounceth Pharaoh as a vessell of wrath prepared for destruction Rom. 9. 17. now if there be hope for a vessel of wrath to come to grace then there was hope for Pharaoh The Apostle maketh these two distinct things God hath mercy on whom he will and whom he will he hardneth Rom. 9. 18. so then as God hardneth not those on whom he hath mercy so neither sheweth he mercy on those whom he hardneth 2. Nebuchadnezzar and Pharaoh were most unlike for the one had not so many wonders shewed as had the other neither so often dallied and made shew of repentance as did the other which sheweth their state to be most different for if Pharaoh had been no more hardned then Nebuchadnezzar was he would likewise have repented as Nebuchadnezzar did Obj. We are to despaire of none in this life therefore it is probable for all to repent Ans Such as we see and know commit a sin unto death The sin against the holy Ghost unpardonable which is the irremissable sin against the Holy Ghost

crafts-men the Cardinals Jesuits Abbots Monkes Fryers and the rest of that Hierarchy in vindication of their Goddess●-like Diana of Popery whom all Rome and the World worshipeth SEeing this massie logge of Popery lyeth yet so crosse in the way The Preface towards a full Reformation I will therefore bend my utmost power to remove it by hewing it in peeces with that Sword which proceedeth out of the mouth of the Lambe being the very means appointed for that purpose Rev. 19. 21. and in prosecution thereof I will propound the weightiest of their Argument● which they use in the vindication of such their assertions and so return an answer to each of their objections whereby the most ignorant of them may apparently see to come forth of that dundion of darknesse and superstition in which they have been so long kept by slavish thraldome CHAP. IIII. Treateth of Idol-worship with the confutation thereof Question WHether do you conceive it to be a stubborn wilfulnesse or a grosse ignorance that causeth them to retain so many Errors and Heresies Answ I hold the cause to be the same in the Pope and the rest of his Hierarchy as was in the aforesaid Ephesians who because their Idol was of an ancient standing and withall beneficiall they therefore will set down their staffe with a desire that it might not be removed and like as L●t regarding more the firtility of the place then the corruption of the people contented himself to be in Sodeme so those Popelings I have named finding with Demetrious and ●●i●e and cove●o●snesse the chief supp●rters of Popery his fellow crafts-men much gaine to redound unto them by the use of it are exceeding loath to have their Diana dispised or brought to contempt but in that the Lay-people retain that Idolatrous worship is meerly out of ignorance and accustomed blindnesse the Idol of the Masse being to them as Diana was to the Ephesians or Bell to the Babilonians rather a cause of expence then any way beneficiall Quest Is there any hopes to reclaime them Answ I hope the Lord hath many Dionissiousses and Damarisses amongst them with whom the truth will prevaile yea that many of their Epicurian and Stoicall opinionists will thereby be drawn to the knowledge of the truth though in the attempt I shall seeme unto them as one setting forth a new doctrine Q. Can you tax them as Paul did the Athenians with an ignorant worshipping of an unknown God A. Yea and as justly as Paul did them witnesse their Idolatrous worshipping of stocks and stones SECT 2. Q. VVHat doe you terme Idolatry A. Idolatry is when any Divine worship either internall What Idolatry ●● or externall is given to any Image or Idol set to represent God of what kind or fashion soever it be Obj. There is a difference betwixt an Image and an Idol for an Idol is a representation of a thing that is not neither hath any being in the world as if one should make the Image of a mans body with the head of a dogge or a body with two faces being such a shape as the eye hath not seen but the minde imagined but an Image is of such a thing as may be seen in the world Ans The difference betwixt a graven Image and a similitude The difference betwixt an Image and a Similitude is this the graven Image is a picture proportioned and fashioned out of wood stone or metall and so carved or graven and a similitude is an Image painted in plain Tables therefore that distinction is vain Obj. Man is the Image of God but it is lawfull to make the Image of the Image of God ergo the Image of God Ans Man is made the Image of God in his Soul and not in his Body which Image the Apostle saith consisteth in righteousnesse and true holinesse Eph. 4. 24. and therefore that in man wherein he is like unto God is spirituall and invisible and therefore cannot by a visible Image be deciphered Obj. They doe not worship the Image but the thing represented by the Image Ans That was the Gentiles pretence in maintaining their Idolatry as also the Israelites in making their golden Calfe Psal 81. 11. 12 Rom. 1. 23 24 1 Sam. 7. 3 4 5 had relation unto God for they proclaimed an holy day Exod. 32. 5. yet their pretext excused them not God therefore forbiddeth Idolatry under any pretence whatsoever and if they doe not worship the Idol it selfe why doe they give divers kinds of worship unto Images as to the Image of Christ more and to the Image of Saints lesse Obj. The honour of the signe redoundeth to the thing signified Ans If the signe be pleasing to him that is signified but if it be such as he forbiddeth and condemneth it is rather a dishonour then an honour and so the adoring of Images is a dishonour to God Obj. The contumely and dishonour offered to the Image of God is a dishonour to God himself therefore the honour thereof redouneth unto God Ans If any man with a spightfull intention against Christ doe deface his Image or Picture it is contumelious against Christ because of the evill intention of the heart but if any doe it out of a zealous minde against Idolatry and Superstition it is no dishonour unto Christ in which zeal against Idolatry and Superstition Epiphanius is said to have rent a certain cloth in a Church which had on it the picture of Christ in which sence also Constantius and Theodotius destroyed Images in every place and therefore that Argument holdeth no better then the other SECT 3. Object IMages may be tollerated in Churches because they are an ornament unto it Ans 1. Churches as you terme them are for the living Images Deut. 16 22. Against Images in Churches of God and not for dead Images 2. The adorning of Churches must not be otherwise then God hath appointed and so to his dishonour nor to the offence of the members of Christ 3. As a man would not have his wife decked in Harlots apparell so is it not fit such places should borrow ornaments for Idolaters Obj. Moses caused Ch●rubins to be made over the Arke and a brazen Serpent to look upon and Solomon made Images of Oxen in the Temple for the brazen Laver to stand upon ergo it is lawfull to have Images in such places now Ans 1. These Images had Gods speciall command 2. They were not in the view of the people which were in the Temple or Tabernacle but there where the High Priest had only accesse neither were they set up aloft as Images are to be worshipped but only set forth the work of the Tabernacle and Temple 3. The brazen Serpent was used as a figure of Christ which figures doe now cease the body being come which is Christ Col. 2. 17. Obj. Images are Lay-mens Books that they which cannot read may learn by the History what was done Ans This was the very reason

so that it maketh directly against the Pelagians who deny sinne to be a deprivation of nature but say it is a corrupt imitation whereas it appeareth by the Text that even in the very youth and first age when we are not so apt to imitate there is evill and corruption in the heart Again sinne is the cause of death for if Adam had not sinned he had not dyed but it is most evident that Infants dye which if sinne were not the cause then were the Scriptures false which The death of Infants an evident demonstration of originall sinne saith the wages of sinne is death Now what other sinne can procure an infants death which hath not sinned according to the similitude of Adams transgression viz. actually unlesse it be originall sinne which certainly is a most infallible demonstration that children are borne in originall sinne In the next place I will shew you what it is SECT 3. Originall sinne described ORiginall sinne is an inherent corruption of our nature powred out into all the parts of the minde by the guilt of Adam who was not only the Progenitor but also as it were the root of mans nature for the Lord committed those gifts to Adam which he intended to bestow upon mans nature which when he had lost he lost them not only for himself but also for his while posterity by meanes of which we bring forth the workes which are called the workes of the flesh Gal. 5. 19. Now to the further description of originall sinne we finde in Scripture the cause the subject and the effect of it 1. The cause as I said before was Adams fall as we may see The cause of originall sin Rom. 5. 15. 1 Cor. 15. 21. as also by the suggestions of the Devell Gen. 3. 4. as also through Adams Free-will whereas he might have refused 2. The subject of it we take to be the old man with all his The subject of originall sin power minde will and heart for in the minde there is darknesse and ignorance of God and his Will as appeareth by the words of our Saviour Mat. 12. 34. O generation of vipers how can ye being evill speake good things The Apostle also saith that the carnall minde is at emnity with God for it is not subject to the Law of God neither can be Rom. 8. 7. The Apostle James also testifieth the same in these words Let no man say when he is tempted that he is tempted of God for God cannot be tempted with evill neither tempteth he any man but every man is tempted when he is drawne away of his owne lusts and inticements then when lust hath conceived it bringeth forth sinne c. Jam. 1. 13 14 15. 3. The fruits of originall sinne are either internall or externall The fruits of originall sin internall as ungodly affections or evill concupisence which the Apostle termeth Idolatry 2. Externall as wanton lookes prophaine speeches and devillish actions as in Mat. 15. 19. Out of the heart proceedeth evill thoughts c. which procureth a cauterised conscience the which procureth the wrath of God and eternall damnation as the Apostle testifieth where he saith that the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodlinesse and unrighteousnesse of men that holdeth the truth in unrighteousnesse for which thing sake the wrath of God is come upon the Children of disobedience Col. 3. 16. Joh. 8. 24. Rom. 5. 12. 18. Jam. 1. 15. SECT 4. Of Concupisence THe Pelacians doe hold this tenent in the generall that Concupisence was not sinne in any man and so doe the Papists generally in particulars viz. that concupisence after Baptisme is not properly sinne nor forbidden by Commandement and that it is not verily and properly a sinne in the regenerate but that it is only so called because it comes of sinne and inclineth to sinne each of their Objections shall be propounded and answered Questions propounded and answered touching Concupisence And first in answer to the Pelagians objection that hold it in the generall that concupisence which is the first fruit of originall sinne being to will or to desire without the externall action is no sinne to which purpose they argue thus viz. Obj. Such things as are naturall are not evill but concupisence or to will is naturall therefore it is not evill nor consequently sin Ans The Apostle saith that we are all by nature the children of wrath therefore because we are so by nature by the same reason it should be no discommodity unto us to be the children of wrath which would be a meere madnesse to conceive Obj. Even in our nature as it now standeth corrupt the appetite or desire of such things as tend to the conservation of nature and to decline and shun the contrary are not evill but such is the concupisence to meat and drink and the like ergo Ans Such motions and appetites of themselves are not evill Concupisence how evill and how not evill as they are naturall motions but if they be inordinate motions and exceed a just measure they are evill as to have an immoderate desire to meat and drink for as it was naturall for Eve to desire to eate of the fruit of the tree yet to desire it against the Commandement of God was evill so it is likewise with these naturall motions if they be immoderate and inordinate they are evill SECT 5. How Sinne is to be measured Obj. THat which is not in mans power to avoyd is no sinne but not to covit is not in mans power ergo it is no sin Ans Sin is not measured by the necessity and liberty of Nature How sin is to be measured but by the disagreement which it hath with the Will of God 2. When God first printed the Law in mans nature before his fall then were the precepts of God given unto him in his power to keepe 3. Though man by his voluntary corruption hath lost his power and liberty yet God fore-goeth not his power and right in commanding but that Concupisence is sinne Concupisence is sinne it is most evident by the Morall Law that would not forbid it unlesse it were sinne As also the Apostle who urgeth the same argument saying I had not known sin but by the Law for I had not known lust except the Law had said thou shalt not covit Rom. 7. 7. Thus much touching the objections of the Pelagians next in answer to the Popish objections Obj. The objection which the Papists make touching concupisence is viz. That it is taken away by Baptisme to whom I returne this answer viz. Ans The subjects which they and many other Societies admit Popish objections touching concupisence answered to Baptisme are not at that time of their admittance fit members or subjects to receive that Sacrament of initiation into the Church of Christ which in its due place I shall fully prove But as to such persons as are meete Members

declared their hearts to be hard Others expound it by way of permission because those that are hardned God depriveth of his grace and leaveth them to themselves as God is said to shut up all in unbelief and that he gave them 〈◊〉 spirit of slumber eyes that they could not see c Now these sayings say they are not to be taken as though God did these things but that he suffered them to be done As I wil harden the heart of Pharaoh that is suffer it to be hardned as that he gave them up to a reprobate sence is nothing else but that he permitted it as a Captaine leaving his Souldiers in the midst of a Battell may be said to deliver them up to his enemies hands But although this be most true that God suffereth such to continue in the hardnesse of their hearts yet this is not all for so the Lord suffereth all other sins to be done for there is nothing done in the world unlesse the omnipotent God will have it done either by suffering it to be done or doing it of himself againe if so The Lord goeth further in the act then by his permission the Lord might as wel be said to steale or the like because he suffereth such things to be done but the Lord doth not only concurre in the hardning of the heart by permission or suffering it to be hardned but according to his owne power and action not by the which immediately the hardnesse of the heart is made but whereby many things are done by the which a sinner by his own corruption doth conceive the hardnesse of the heart Now the induration of the heart is two waies to be taken or The Induration of the heart two wayes taken considered 1. As it is a sin 2. As it is a punishment of sin In the first of these God hath no part but for the other as he is a just Judge he inflicteth the hardnesse of the heart as a punishment as the Apostle sheweth Rom. 2. 28 For as the Gentiles regarded not to know God so God delivered them up to a reprobate minde And 2 Thes 2. 11. because they received not the love of the truth c. therfore God sent them strong delusions that they should beleeve lyes in which places the Apostle sheweth how the Lord punished them with blindnesse of heart because of their former sins as also Sam. 12. 11. Behold I will raise up evill upon thee out of thine owne house which was verified in Absol●m that rose up against his father as also in the act of Shimei in cursing David whom David saith The Lord bid curse him Now concerning this rebellion of Absolom and rayling of Shimei they are not to be ascribed to God as they were sins in Absolom and Shimei but as they were punishments of the sins of David they were sent of God SECT 4. Obj. IF God be the Author of the induration of the heart as it is a punishment of sin then he may as well be said to be the Author of other sins when as a man falleth into them as the punishments of his former sins Ans All such sins proceed from the hardnesse of the heart Popish objections answered that confirmeth and setleth a sinner in his wickednesse and therefore God cannot be said to be a cause of those sins for a man by continuing in sin hath his heart hardned by the just judgement of God and then out of the hardnesse of his owne heart he bringeth forth other sins of himselfe Obj. The hardnesse of the heart as it is a great and horrible sin so is it the punishment of former sins wherefore if God doe cause it to be a punishment he also causeth it as it is a sin Ans In this Argument there are ambiguous termes for in the first clause this note of similitude as is taken for the being of the thing the bardnesse of the heart as it is a sinne so it is the punishment of sin that it could not be the punishment of sin unlesse it were sin this we grant in the first part but the same word as signifieth also the manner of being Therefore if the first be taken in the same sense for one and the same manner of being we deny that the hardnesse of the heart in the same respect is both sin and the punishment of sin It is both in respect of the subject and being but not both in the same quality affection and manner of being Obj. All punishments of sin because they are just stand with the will of God now hardnesse of heart being a sin if it should stand with the Will of God then it would follow that sin should stand with the Will of God Ans If sin should no way stand with the Will of God then it should not be committed in the world for against his will can nothing be so that we must admit a distinction of Gods will which The will of God two-fold is twofold viz. his will of approbation and his will of providence by the first he willeth not sin but by the second he willeth it to be in the world because he knoweth how to dispose of sin even unto good Many things are done without Gods Wil nothing without his providence Providence is that whereby he disposeeth of things Will whereby he willeth or nilleth any thing and therefore it is good that evill should be done because thereby Gods power and goodnesse is seen in turning evill unto good If therefore God did not see how to turne evill unto a good end he would not suffer evill to be done in the world So then retaining the formes distinction stil hardnesse of heart as it is a sin God willeth it not but as it is a punishment of sin it standeth very wel with the Justice of God SECT 5. THere be also severall other opinions concerning the manner Other opinions touching Gods ●●●d●ing the heart how God hardneth the heart which being very profitable will not be amisse to be rehearsed As that God doth it by way of patience and long suffering because say they the Lord doth suspend his Judgements and doth not presently punish the wicked whereupon they abusing Gods patience As by way of patience and longsuffering and long suffering are hardned and this exposition they ground upon that place of Scripture Rom. 2. 4. Despisest thou the riches of his bountiousnesse patience and long suffering not knowing that the goodnesse of God leadeth thee to repentance but thou after thy hardnesse and heart that cannot repent heapest up against thy self wrath against the day of wrath Of which patient forbearance they make a figurative Locution Like say they as a Simile Master should say to his servant that abuseth his gentlenesse it is I that have made the thing because I did not punish thee Again As the Sun say they hardneth the Clay and mollifieth Why ●he Lord useth such great patience the Wax

so the goodnesse of God hardneth the vessels of wrath and mollifieth the vessels of mercy And this is true that God doth use a great patience and long suffering toward sinners and that for these reasons 1. That thereby Gods goodnesse and mercy may appeare and the great malice and frowardnesse of mens hearts that cannot be drawn to repentance by the Lords rich and bounteous mercy 2. By this Gods Judgements appeare to be most just when he punisheth the hard-hearted and incorrigable as it is evident in the example of Pharaoh 3. By this also God teacheth his children to be patient and long suffering one towards another 4. This patience of God though some abuse it yet others profit by it and their hard hearts are mollified for though Pharaohs heart by Gods sparing of him became more obstinate yet Nebuchadnezzar at length by the Lords lenity goodnesse and fatherly correction was brought to know himselfe and confess the true God 5. Though the evill and wicked should reap no profit by the Lords wonderfull patience yet the Elect and such as are ordained to salvation are thereby called and brought to Grace as the Apostle sheweth of himself For this cause saith he was I received unto mercy that Jesus Christ should shew on me all long suffering unto the example of them who in time to come should beleeve on him 1 Tim. 1. 16. so that this is true which is affirmed by the Authors but this is not all God hath yet a further stroke in the hardning of the heart then by connivance and long animity towards it 2. There be others also who hold that the Lord hardneth the By withdrawing his grace heart subtrahendo gratiam by with-drawing his grace God say they giveth men over to a reprobate sence to harden the heart to blinde c. not because these things are done by God which proceed of mens malice but because whilst God doth justly forsake men these things doe happen unto them the Lord therefore hardneth whom he will not mollifie and blindeth them whom he will not illuminate SECT 6. Obj. WHerein consisteth the blinding and hardning of the heart Ans In two things as 1. The internall act of the minde adhearing H●rdness● of heart implyeth 2 things unto evil and in this respect God is not the Author thereof 2. In subtraction of grace whereby it commeth to pass that the minde is not illuminated to see God And in this respect God is the cause of the duration but yet this is not all that seemeth to be contained in Gods hardning of the heart There is also another interpreting the manner of Gods hardning of the heart and it is occasionalliter by way of occasion as when the wicked take occasion by such things as fall out and are done by Gods providence to be more hardned and confirmed in their sins 1. For as all things viz. prosperity adversity life death fulnesse want and whatsoever else doe work together unto good to All things fall out for the good of them that feare God and for evill to the wicked them that feare God as the Apostle affirmeth Rom. 8. 28. so on the contrary all things fall out unto the worst unto the wicked and impenitent and so the wonders which God wrought in Egypt served to confirme the Hebrewes in their faith but Pharaoh by his owne malice was thereby hardned 2. The things which the Lord doth whereby the wicked doe The wicked take occasion by three things to be hardned also take occasion to be hardned are of three sorts as First either inwardly in the minde as by stirring their affections as of anger feare hope desire which they by their corruption turne to evil 2. On such things as are done about them as admonitions corrections mercies benefits which also they ungratefully abuse 3. Or they are things externall or without them as the objects of pleasure honour and such like whereby their hard heart is polluted puffed up and swelled and all these things being good of themselves they through the hardnesse of their hearts pervert unto their destruction as the Apostle Peter speaking The wicked pervert their owne heart of some which through ignorance and unbelief pervert the Scriptures 2 Pet. 3. 16. The Apostle Paul also sheweth that sin tooke occasion by the Commandement and wrought in hïm all manner of concupisence Rom. 7. 8. Pharaoh also was hardned by reason of Gods workes the plagues and wonders that were shewed in Aegypt By the wonders because he saw the Magicians could doe the like by the Plagues because they touched not him but hapned without they came not also at once but with some intermission and respit between and because he saw they continued not long but were soone removed Therefore in that Pharaoh had such a heart as could not be moved by the patience of God unto piety it was his owne fault but that such things were done whereby his heart being evill of it self did resist the Commandement of God it was by the divine dispensation but there is something further yet to be considered in Gods concurring in the hardning of the heart SECT 7. AGaine there is another Exposition which declareth that The event oft times taken for the cause God hardneth the heart as the event is taken for the cause as it is often taken in Scripture as Joh. 17. 12. None of them perished but the childe of perdition that the Scriptures might be fulfilled Here the Scriptures putteth that for the cause which was the event of the cause for Judas did not perish that the Scriptures might be fulfilled but so it fell out that the Scriptures in Judas perishing was fulfilled There is also the like instance in the 51. Psal Against thee only have I sinned and done evill in thy sight that thou mightest be justified in thy sayings and cleare when thou art judged But David did not sin to that end that God might be justified God had no need of his sin to set forth his glory but so it fell out that God spared David and by his mercy over-came his sin and yet David sinned not to that end Like as when a man being at work and one of his acquaintance Simile commeth to see him he desisteth from working he should say My friend came to day to hinder my work whereas he had no such end in his comming So Jacob said to his Son Why dealt ye so ill with me as to tell the man ye● had yet a brother Gen. 34. 6. whereas Jacobs Sons in so saying intended no evill or hurt to their Father but so it fell out c. The wicked also are said to hate their owne soule and to procure unto themselves eternall death whereas simply they hate not their owne soules neither would be damned but upon their committing of sin it so falleth out that their soules perish by their meanes as if they hated them An unruly Patient that wil not obey his Physitian

we are to observe that where Wherein the Apostle injoyne● women sil●●ce in the Church the Apostle is said to allow of the Prophecying of women 1 Cor. 11. 5. is meant of the extraordinary gift and function of Prophecying wherein he did not dis-allow the act but the manner willing that it should be done with comlinesse and order And as concerning the place where you object that silence is inioyned women the Apostle speaketh of the ordinary calling of preaching or prophecying which women ought not any way to usurp but for the extraordinary calling which the Lord hath sometimes given to women there is no doubt but they accordingly used the same and may now use if so inspired As for other conference in the Church I see no cause women having the same need of Pastors for their Soules as men but that they may have a voyce in the election of their Minister as any man whatsoever as no doubt but many of the rest had Acts 1. 14. SECT 4. Obj LEt us leave the women in silence did the rest of the people voyce in that election of Matthias Ans For any thing I know to the contrary or you either doe you read that any of the Assembly was forbidden to voyce But if there were any that were not capable of the businesse in hand we doe not read that they procured any disorder or fraction amongst the multitude Obj. The text doth not punctually make out that the people made choyse of Barnabas and Matthias but that they viz. the Apostles and Elders and the Church Officers and if you would have it otherwise you are to prove it from the text otherwise I neither can nor will beleeve you Ans But if I can prove it from the text then you both can and will beleeve me and so renounce your errour Obj. I promise you I will but I feare you will faile of your expectation Ans Call to minde the 15. ver of that Chapter and compare it with the 2● ver where Barnabas and Matthias is appointed and then judge whether it be not more likely that they were chosen by them to whom Peter spake unto in the 15. ver then to any other parties mentioned in any part of the Chapter for in the 15. ver the Disciples are not only numbred but Peter also beginneth his speech unto them which he continueth unto the very election of Barnabas and Matthias not diverting it from them to whom he began it which in the 15. ver is said to be the Disciples who were about 120 how can you then with modesty deny that Matthias was chosen by any other then by the Parties there mentioned and if granted then it must consequently follow that Matthias had the peoples appr●bation before the Apostles acceptation SECT 5. Obj. I Conf●●se that it doth appeare that Barnabas and Matthias was chosen by the multitude mentioned in the 15. ver but whether that number of Disciples mentioned were the reall or the representative Church I am not yet satisfied Ans Doe you read of any other part of the Church then at Jerusalem beside that number Obj. Suppose I grant you that the election of Church Officers doth belong to the promiscuous multitude yet do● I not hold that they have any Ecclesiasticall power in Judicature Ans I thought I had heretofore satisfied you that the Church The reall Church hath power os Judicature of Christ hath sufficient power in it selfe and that by the authority of Scripture to decide all matters of controversie touching it selfe viz. of a spirituall cognizance but if you scruple at it I will further inlarge my selfe in the point for proofe of which I could instance all Pauls Epistles but for brevity sake I will consine my selfe to the passage of the Apostle to the Corinthians in his first Epistle and fifth Chapter where writing touching the ejecting of the incestious person doth not attribute the powes thereof to his owne particular person or to more Apostles and Elders joyned with him but solely to that Church at Corinth in these words Doe not ye judge them that are within vers 12. he doth not say Doe not we the Apostles of Christ judge them that are within or we of the Classicall Provinciall and Nationall Sinod judge them but doe not yee c. viz. the reall body of the Church to whom he writ his Epistles yea he further ratifieth it in the 13. ver viz. therefore put away from your selves that wicked person And the like order have they also sor his reception upon his humiliation 2 Cor. 6 7 8. by which two texts of Scripture the Apostle ●leerly sheweth whom they be that the Church hath power over and whom the civill Magistrate hath to rule over as also what have I to doe to judge them that are without doe not ye judge them that are within Againe them that are without God judgeth intimating by the first that Christ hath given the rule of such as are without viz. not members of the Church to the rule of the civill Magistrate as in Rom. 13. and the latter sort viz. such as are members of the Church to the rule and government of the Covenanted members of the Church it selfe viz. to the reall body whereof they are members Obj. Hath the Civill Magistrate nothing to doe in Church-government Ans As he is meerly a civill Magistrate he hath not for his The Civill Magistrate hath nothing to doe in Church government power as a civill Magistrate is confined without the Church as I have formerly shewed neither is the Law viz. the Morall Law given to a righteous man but for the unrighteous Rom. 13. 3. and therefore so long as a member of the Church continueth his integrity and without running himselfe into a Morall offence he is without the verge of the civill Magistrate Obj. Hath not a civill Magistrate being a member of the Church a greater power then the rest of the members Ans Not at all as he is a member of the Church for there is no respect of persons with God whether they be Jewes or Gentiles bond or free rich or poore they are all one in Christ Jesus Leut. 10. 17. Act. 10. 38. Rom. 2. 11. Gal. 2. 6. Ephes 6. 9. Col. 3. 11. Rom. 12. 5. c. 1 Cor. 12. 12 13 14 c. Obj. What things be they which you ascribe as things proper to be done by the Church Ans They chiefly consist in these particulars viz. as in election The chiefe actions which concerne the Church of Pastors and Church Officers as I have proved as also in matters of advice and counsell as I have also proved as also in sending of Messengers from Church to Church to advise and to hold correspondency together as being all members of one universall Church as in Act. 15. 2. 22. 2 Cor. 1. 18 19. 1 Cor. 16. 3. 10. Act. 18. 37. As also in receptions of members into the Church as in Rom. 16.