great eminence power and authority being impeached and accused of such high Crimes and Offences should yet enjoy his Liberty hold so great a part of the strength of the Kingdom in his hands sit as a Peer in Parliament and be acquainted with the Counsels thereof whereby inevitable mischief may suddenly fall upon the Kingdom Wherefore they have thought it their duty to recommend this their unanimous desire to their Lordships as agreeable to Law and reason That they would be pleased forthwith to commit the person of the said Duke to safe Custody Whereupon the Duke made this Speech in the Lords House My Lords IF I should hold my peace it would argue guilt If I should speak it would argue boldness being so foully accused Your Lordships see what Complaints are made against me by the House of Commons How well I stood in their opinions not long since your Lordships know it What I have done since to lose their good opinions I protest I know not I cannot so distrust my own Innocencie and my heart which abhors guilt as to decline any Course or Court of Justice And had not they brought my Cause to your Lordships it should have been my own work And they have done me a favor to deliver me out of their hands into your Lordships I will not speak any thing to cast dirt at those who have taken pains to make me so foul but to protest my innocencie in that measure which I shall ever hope to prove it being before such just Judges I desire my Trial may be hastened that I may no longer suffer then I must needs And now that my Accuser hath not been content only to make my Process but to prescribe to your Lordships the manner of your Judgment and to judge me before I am heard I shall not give way to any of their unjust Demands c. The Commons upon the Imprisonment of their Members and the offence taken by the King at the words spoken by those two Gentlemen in impeaching the Duke resolved to proceed in no other business till they were righted in their Liberties and ordered that the House be turned into a Grand Committee presently to sit and consider of the best way and means to effect the same and that no Member be suffered to go forth At which time Sir Dudley Carlton observing that unusual and as he termed it sullen silence of the House made this Speech I Find by a great silence in this House that it is a fit time to be heard if you please to give me the patience I may very fitly compare the heaviness of this House unto some of my misfortunes by Sea in my Travels For as we were bound unto Marseillis by oversight of the Mariners we mistook our Course and by ill fortune met with a Sand That was no sooner overpast but we fell on another and having escaped this likewise we met with a third and in that we stuck fast All of the Passengers being much dismaied by this disaster as now we are here in this House for the loss of those two Members At last an old experienced Mariner upon consultation affirmed That the speediest way to come out from the Sands was to know how we came there So well looking and beholding the Compass he found by going in upon such a point we were brought into that streight wherefore we must take a new point to rectifie and bring us out of danger This House of Parliament may be compared to the Ship the Sands to our Messages and the Commitment to the Sands that the Ship did stick fast in and lastly the Compass to the Table where the Book of Orders doth lie Then I beseech you let us look into the Book where the Orders are whether the Gentlemen did go no further then the Order did warrant them If they did not it is fit that we should defend them whom we imployed in our behests But if they have exceeded their Commission and delivered that which they had not warrant for it is just that we let them suffer for this presumption and this our Course will bring us from these Rocks I beseech you Gentlemen move not his Majesty with trenching upon his Prerogatives lest you bring him out of love with Parliaments You have heard his Majesties often Messages to you to put you forward in a Course that will be most convenient In those Messages he told you That if there were not Correspondencie between him and you he should be inforced to use new Counsels Now I pray you consider what these new Counsels are and may be I fear to declare those that I conceive In all Christian Kingdoms you know that Parliaments were in use antiently by which their Kingdoms were governed in a most flourishing manner until the Monarchs began to know their own strength and seeing the turbulent spirit of their Parliaments at length they by little and little began to stand upon their Prerogatives and at last overthrew the Parliaments throughout Christendom except here only with us And indeed you would count it a great misery if you knew the Subject in Foreign Countries as well as my self to see them look not like our Nation with store of flesh on their backs but like so many Ghosts and not men being nothing but skin and bones with some thin cover to their nakedness and wearing only woodden shoos on their feet so that they cannot eat meat or wear good clothes but they must pay and be taxed unto the King for it This is a misery beyond expression and that which yet we are free from Let us be careful then to preserve the Kings good opinion of Parliaments which bringeth this happiness to this Nation and makes us envied of all others while there is this sweetness between his Majesty and his Commons lest we lose repute of a Free-born Nation by our turbulencie in Parliament For in my opinion the greatest and wisest part of a Parliament are those that use the greatest silence so as it be not opiniotory or sullen as now we are by the loss of these our Members that are committed This good Correspondencie being kept between the King and his people will so join their love and favor to his Majesty with liking of Parliaments that his Prerogative shall be preserved entire to himself without our trenching upon it and also the Priviledge of the Subject which is our happiness inviolated and both be maintained to the support of each other And I told you if you would hear me patiently I would tell you what exception his Majesty doth take at those Gentlemen that are committed You know that Eight Members were chosen to deliver the Charge against the Duke but there were only Six imployed for that purpose insomuch that there was no Exception As for Sir Dudley Diggs his part that was the Prologue and in that his Majesty doth conceive that he went too far beyond his Commission in pressing the death of his
points of Grace to the people but also by the labor we took for the satisfaction of both Houses in those three Articles recommended unto us in both their names by the Right Reverend Father in God the Archbishop of Canterbury and likewise for the good Government of Ireland we are now in hand with at your request but not onely have we heard no news of all this but contrary great complaints of the danger of Religion within this Kingdom tacitely implying our ill Government in this point And we leave you to judge whether it be your duties that are the Representative Body of our people so to distaste them with our Government whereas by the contrary it is your duty with all your endeavors to kindle more and more a dutiful and thankful love in the peoples hearts towards us for our just and gratious Government Now whereas in the very beginning of this your Apology you tax us in fair terms of trusting uncertain Reports and partial Informations concerning your proceedings we wish you to remember that we are an old and experienced King needing no such Lessons being in our Conscience freest of any King alive from hearing or trusting idle Reports which so many of your House as are nearest us can bear witness unto you if you would give as good ear to them as you do to some Tribunitial Orators among you And for proof in this particular we have made your own Messengers confer your other Petitions sent by you with the Copy thereof which was sent us before Between which there is no difference at all but that since our receiving the first Copy you added a conclusion unto it which could not come to our hands till it was done by you and your Messengers sent which was all at one time And if we had had no Copy of it before-hand we must have received your first Petition to our great dishonor before we had known what it contained which would have enforced us to return you a far worse Answer then now we do for then your Messengers had returned with nothing but that we have judged your Petition unlawful and unworthy of an Answer For as to your conclusion thereof it is nothing but Protestatio contraria facto for in the Body of your Petition you usurpe upon our Prerogative Royal and meddle with things far above your reach and then in the conclusion you protest the contrary As if a Robber would take a mans purse and then protest he meant not to rob him For first you presume to give us your advice concerning the Match of our dearest Son with some Proâ—â—stant we cannot say Princess for we know none of these fit for hâ—m and disswade us from his Match with Spain urging us to a presenâ— War with that King and yet in the conclusion forsooth ye protest ye intend not to press upon our most undoubted and Regal Prerogative as if the Petitioning of us in matters that your selves confess ye ought not to meddle with were not a meddling with them And whereas ye pretend That ye were invited to this course by the Speeches of Three honorable Lords yet by so much as your selves repeat of the Speeches nothing can be concluded but that we were resolved by War to regain the Palatinate if otherwise we could not attain unto it And you were invited to advise forthwith upon a Supply for keeping the forces in the Palatinate from disbanding and to foresee the means for the raising and maintenance of the Body of an Army for that War against the Spring Now what inference can be made upon this that therefore we must presently denounce War against the King of Spain break our dearest Sons match and match him to one of our Religion let the World judge The difference is no greater than if we would tell a Merchant that we had great need to borrow Money from him for raising an Army that thereupon it should follow that we were bound to follow his advice in the direction of the War and all things depending thereupon But yet not contenting your selves with this excuse of yours which indeed cannot hold water ye come after to a direct contradiction to the conclusion of your former Petition saying That the honor and safety of us and our Posterity and the Patrimony of Our Children invaded and possessed by their enemies the Welfare of Religion and State of our Kingdom are matters at any time not unfit for your deepest considerations in Parliament To this generality we answer with the Logicians That where all things are contained nothing is omitted So as this Plenipotency of yours invests you in all power upon Earth lacking nothing but the Popes to have the Keys also both of Heaven and Purgatory And to this vast generality of yours we can give no other answer for it will trouble all the best Lawyers in the House to make a good Commentary upon it For so did the Puritan Ministers in Scotland bring all kinde of causes within the compass of their jurisdiction saying That it was the Churches office to judge of slander and there could no kinde of crime or fault be committed but there was a slander in it either against God the King or their Neighbor and by this means they hooked into themselves the cognisance of all causes Or like Bellarmines distinction of the Popes power over Kings in Ordine ad Spiritualia whereby he gives them all Temporal Jurisdiction over them But to give you a direct Answer to the matter of War for which you are so earnest We confess we rather expected you should have given us thanks for the so long maintaining a setled Peace in all our Dominions when as all our Neighbors about are in miserable combustion of War but dulce bellum inexpertis And we indeed finde by experience that a number of our Subjects are so pampered with Peace as they are desirous of change though they knew not what It is true that we have ever professed and in that minde with Gods grace we will live and die that we will labor by all means possible either by Treaty or by force to restore our Children to their ancient Dignity and Inheritance And whatsoever Christian Princes or Potentates will set themselves against it we will not spare any lawful means to bring our so just and honorable purpose to a good end neither shall the match of our Son or â—ny other worldly respect be preferred to this our resolution For by our credit and intervention with the King of Spain and the Arch-Dutches and her Husband now with God we preserved the Lower Palatinate one whole year from any further conquering in it which in eight days space in that time might have easily been swallowed up by Spinola's Army without any resistance And in no better case was it now at our Ambassador the Lord Digbies coming through Heidelburgh if he had not extraordinarily succored it But because we conceive that ye couple this War of the Palatinate with
into my hands not as an Attorney onely for the Prince But the King of Spain having taken the substitution of them by his Secretary of State entred in Legal form whereby that King was then become interessed in them by their occupation as well as the Prince by granting of them And becoming the Instrumentum stipulatum wherein they were both interessed they were deposited in my hands as an indifferent person trusted between the King of Spain and the Prince with a Declaration of the Trust. And now the Duke was returned out of Spain he plotted my ruine and put it in execution in this manner He concealed that the powers were to expire at Christmas and procured his Majesty to write a Letter not a direct Commandment but expressing a desire that the Desponsories should not be till one of the days in Christmas intending thereby to draw me into a Dilemma That if I proceeded in the Match this Letter should as now it is have been inforced against me as a breach of Instructions If I had not proceeded then I had broken my trust between the Prince and King of Spain overthrown the Marriage so long sought and labored it being the main scope of my Ambassage contrary to express Warrant and that upon a Letter I must needs know to be a mistake And when I had written into England to have a direct Warrant in the point the Duke then seeing that Plot would not take he dealt with divers great Lords as was well known to some of their Lordships there present to have me upon my arival in England committed to the Tower before I should ever come to speak with the King which the Spanish Ambassador here in England having gotten private notice of gave advertisement thereof to that King Who thereupon foreseeing my danger and consulting with his Council and Divines what were fit for him in Honor and Conscience to do in that Case they resolved That seeing my Sufferings grew by being an honest man and endeavoring to perform the trust reposed in me by that King as well as the Prince That King was bound both in Honor and Conscience not onely to preserve me from ruine but to make me a reparation for any loss I should sustain by occasion of the Trust Whereupon at his departure going to Court to take his leave the Conde de Olivares told me what was plotted against me in England and in respect of the danger by reason of the greatness of my Adversary pâ—rswaded me to stay there and in his Masters Name made an offer not in secret but in the presence of Sir Walter Aston Here he repeated those offers of Reward Honor and Preferment which we have mentioned before in order of time and at present pass it by he then proceeded and said Upon what grounds and hope came I to encounter with those dangers Not upon hope of my greatness in Court and strength of Friends there to bolster out an ill Cause no sure my strength was too weak and my adversaries too powerful But I knew my Conscience was clear and my Cause was good and trusted in God Almighty And to him now and to their Lordships judgments recommended my self and my Cause And then he delivered his Answer desiring their Lordships it might be after Recorded in Parchment that it might remain to posterity which being read by one of his Council the Lord Keeper asked him Whether he desired to say any more then he had done he answered That he had something more to say but knew not the order or whether Mr. Attorney would speak first but he being desired to speak He desired their Lordships he might put them in minde of what he conceived they had already promised which was That the Duke whom he accused in that House of far higher offences then any with which he was charged might be proceeded with as he was and that they might be upon equal Conditions And that such heads as he had delivered against the Duke being of such Matters as he met withal in his Negotiation as an Ambassador and which he had according to his duty acquainted the State withal might by their Lordships care and order be put into Legal form and prosecuted for so was the use when he had the honor to sit at the Council Table He said He conceived he had already done his part to inform and would be ready to make it good it concerning their Lordships to see it prosecuted it not being to be expected that he should solicit it or if he would he could not being under restraint And he desired likewise that the Judges might deliver their opinions Whether the matter charged against him were Treason that if it should not so be in their opinions he might not lie under so heavy a burthen He put their Lordships in minde that it was a strange manner of proceeding that upon a displeasure a Peer of the Kingdom complaining of those that had practised against him and had been the causers of his Sufferings should then and never but then be charged with Treason He told them it was not his case alone but it equally concerned them and their Posterity and it might be some others hereafter more then him now For he said he thanked God he had some experience in the World and thereby and by those things he had kept was able to make his innocency appear which perhaps would not be every mans hereafter and so many an honest heart in a good cause distracted with fears and abandoned of Friends might perish through the malice of a potent Adversary The Lords again asked him whether he had any thing more to say he answered No but desired leave onely to explain himself in two things one in his Speech now spoken and the other when he was first brought to the House That in his Speech this day was where he affirmed he had like to have been ruined in his Negotiation First For being a Puritan and now for being a Papist and both by one hand he explained it to be by the hand of the Duke of Buckingham And the other when he first came to the House saying there For Redress of former sufferings and meeting on the sudden with Treason charged upon him he spake in Passion expressing the Wrongs and Injuries done him by the Duke and told their Lordships he had used means to convey part of his Sufferings to the late King his Master who in the Dukes hearing sware he would after he had heard the Duke against him hear him also against the Duke for which his Majesty suffered much or to some such purpose Now he understandeth this Speech to reflect upon what was in Agitation in the Lower House but he said although he could not well excuse the Dukes indiscretion in that point yet he spake it not any ways to corroborate that opinion For howsoever the Duke were his enemy yet he could not think so dishonorably of him The Answer of the Earl of Bristol to
his late Majesty was pleased to give order to the Duke and Earl to proceed in the Business which his said Majesty would not have Treated till the said Marriage was concluded as will appear by a Letter of his said late Majesty joyntly to the Duke of Buckingham and the said Earl of the 23 Iuly 1623. Secondly It will appear by Letters of the said Lord Conway to the Duke of Buckingham bearing date September 4. 1623. That the said Duke had good assurance of the Conclusion of the said Match and upon this confidence were all things put in due execution in England as had been Capitulated And the Lord Conway and others faithfully agreed and setled all the Points of Immunity and Liberty for the Roman Catholicks for the use of their Religion as was set down in the Declaration August 9. 1623. hereafter mentioned in the Answers to the Fifth Article of this Charge Thirdly the very day his now Majesty and the Duke of Buckingham departed from the Escurial in Spain towards England the said Duke solemnly swore the Treaty of the said Marriage and the furtherance of it all that should be in his power upon the holy Evangelists in the presence of the said Earl and Sir Walter Aston Fourthly The Treaty of the said Marriage had been formerly signed sealed and solemnly sworne by the King of Spain And when his Majesty and that King took their leaves he did solemnly in the words of a King faithfully and punctually protest to perform all that had been capitulated in the Treaty of Marriage and thereupon imbraced his Majesty at his departure and sent the very next day a Letter written all with his own hand to his Majesty vowing and protesting to make all good that he had capitulated or promised unto his Majesty at his departure the day before So that if there were no true meaning on the part of Spain to make the Marriage as by Mr. Attorney is pretended yet certainly the Earl hath not been sleightly deceived neither can it be as he conceiveth any fault in him since not only his late Majesty but also his Majesty that now is and the Duke of Buckingham being then both upon the place did confidently believe and that upon other grounds then misinformations suggestions and perswasions of the said Earl that the Marriage was really intended And to that effect both his late Majesty of blessed memory and his most Excellent Majesty that now is after his return into England wrote unto him the said Earl several Letters assuring him that their intents and pleasures were to have the said Match proceeded in and thereupon the Proxies of his Majesty then Prince were again inrolled and sent unto the said Earl So that the said Earl having so many and so great causes to be assured that the Match was really intended on both sides he conceiveth it will be hard for Mr. Attorney to make good that part of his Charge wherein he affirmeth that the Earl should know the contrary or the Assurance to be upon false grounds as in the said Article is alleadged II. To the Second Article He directly denieth all the supposed Offences wherewith he stands charged by the said Article And for a clear declaration and manifestation of the truth and manner of his proceedings He saith First as to the continuing the Treaties upon Generalities That the Temporal Articles were by Agreements on both sides not to be treated or setled until such time as the Articles of Religion were fully agreed on For that it was held most proper and honorable for both sides first to see if the Difficulty of Religion might be removed before they passed to any further Engagements And the said Articles of Religion by reason of the Popes new Demands sent into England by Mr. Gage were not signed nor condescended unto by his late Majesty nor his Majesty that now is then Prince until Ian. 5. 1622. and were then sent away in Post out of England to the said Earl by Mr. Simon Digby who arrived with them at Madrid in Spain about the 25. of the same moneth But the Earls care was such to have no time spent in the setling of the Temporal Articles that before he would condescend so much as de bene esse unto the Articles of Religion that they should be sent back to Rome he procured the King of Spain to promise That within the time limited for procuring the Desponsories which was by March or April following the furthest all the Temporal Articles should be setled and agreed to the end that the Infanta might be delivered at the Spring as by the King of Spain his Answer in writing was declared to be the Kings intention And accordingly Sir Walter Aston and the said Earl did not deal in general but did most industriously labor to settle all in particular viz. That the Portion should be Two Millions it appearing that it was so agreed by the late King of Spain That the Dispensation coming the Desponsories should be within Forty days after And that Don Duarte de Portugal should be the man that should attend the Infanta in the Journey And all other Particulars necessary for the Conclusion of the said Treaties were by Sir Walter Aston and the said Earl and the Spanish Commissioners drawn up into heads in writing and after many Debates they were consulted with that King and 2 Martii 1623. stilo vet the Conde Gondomar and the Secretary Don Andreas de Prada were appointed to come home to the house of the said Earl to signifie unto Sir Walter Aston and himself as they did That the King of Spain had declared his resolution in all the Particulars and given them order to come to a speedy Conclusion with them in all things And that Kings Answer to that Conclusion the Earl saw and read all written with the King of Spain's own hand On the seventh day of the said moneth of March 1623. the Kings Majesty then Prince and the Duke of Buckingham arrived at Madrid And then the Spaniards took new laws and the Negotiation was put into a new form So that whereas it is objected against the Earl that he entertained and continued the Treaties so long upon Generalities He conceives it is not meant upon the Spiritual Articles for they were such as were sent from Rome into England and from thence they came to the Earl And for the Temporal Articles they were not to be setled and treated till the Articles of Religion were concluded He conceiveth it cannot be alleadged with any colour that his Majesty was entertained with Generalities since the time that the said Articles of Religion were brought unto the said Earl by Mr. Simon Digby being about the 25. of Ianuary There were but six weeks until March 7. following when his Majesty then Prince arrived in Madrid and in the interim all the above-mentioned Particulars were setled And the time that hath been spent in this Treaty hath not been through his the said Earls
of the People Certainly hereafter it will be conceived that an House of Parliament would not have made an unnecessary addition to this Petition of Right and therefore it will be resolved that the Addition hath relation to the Petition which will have such operation as I have formerly declared and I the rather fear it because the late Loan and Billeting have been declared to have been by Soveraign Power for the good of our selves and if it be doubtful whether this Proposition hath reference to the Petition or not I know not who shall judge whether Loans or Imprisonments hereafter be by that Soveraign Power or not A Parliament which is made a Body of several Writs and may be dissolved by one Commission cannot be certain to decide this question We cannot resolve that that the Judges shall determine the words of the Kings Letter read in this House expressing the cause of Commitment may be such that the Judges have not capacity of Judicature no Rules of Law to direct and guide their judgements in Cases of that transcendent nature the Judges then and the Judgements are easily conjectured it hath been confessed by the Kings Councel that the Statute of Magna Charta bindes the King it bindes his Soveraign Power and here is an Addition of Saving the Kings Soveraign Power I shall endeavor to give some Answer to the Reasons given by the Lords The first is That it is the intention of both Houses to maintain the Just Liberty of the Subject and not to diminish the just Power of the King and therefore the expression of that intention in this Petition cannot prejudice us To which I answer First That our intention was and is as we then professed and no man can assign any particular in which we have done to the contrary neither have we any way transgressed in that kinde in this Petition and if we make this addition to the Petition it would give some intimation that we have given cause or colour of offence therein which we deny and which if any man conceive so let him assign the particular that we may give answer thereunto By our Petition we onely desire our particular Rights and Liberties to be confirmed to us and therefore it is not proper for us in it to mention Soveraign Power in general being altogether impertinent to the matter in the Petition There is a great difference between the words of the Addition and the words proposed therein for reason viz. between just Power which may be conceived to be limited by Laws and Soveraign Power which is supposed to be transcendent and boundless The second Reason delivered by their Lordships was That the King is Soveraign That as he is Soveraign he hath power and that that Soveraign Power is to be left for my part I would leave it so as not to mention it but if it should be expressed to be left in this Petition as it is proposed it must admit something to be left in the King of what we pray or at least admit some Sovergain Power in his Majesty in these Priviledges which we claim to be our Right which would frustrate our Petition and destroy our Right as I have formerly shewed The third Reason given from this Addition was That in the Statute of Articuli super Chartas there is a Saving of the Seigniory of the Crown To which I give these Answers That Magna Charta was confirmed above thirty times and a general Saving was in none of these Acts of Confirmation but in this onely and I see no cause we should follow one ill and not thirty good Precedents and the rather because that Saving produced ill effects that are well known That Saving was by Act of Parliament the conclusion of which Act is that in all those Cases the King did well and all those that were at the making of that Ordinance did intend that the right and Seigniory of the Crown should be saved By which it appears that the saving was not in the Petition of the Commons but added by the King for in the Petition the Kings will is not expressed In that Act the King did grant and depart with to his People divers Rights belonging to his Prerogative as in the first Chapter he granted That the People might choose three men which might have Power to hear and determine Complaints made against those that offended in any point of Magna Charta though they were the Kings Officers and to Fine and Ransome them and in the 8.12 and 19. Chapter of that Statute the King departed with other Prerogatives and therefore there might be some reason of the adding of that Soveraign by the Kings Councel But in this Petition we desire nothing of the Kings Prerogative but pray the enjoying of our proper and undoubted Rights and Priviledges and therefore there is no cause to adde any words which may imply a Saving of that which concerns not the matter in the Petition The fourth Reason given by their Lordships was That by the mouth of our Speaker we have this Parliament declared That it was far from our intention to incroach upon his Majesties Prerogative and that therefore it could not prejudice us to mention the same resolution in an Addition to this Petition To which I Answer That that Declaration was a general Answer to a Message from his Majesty to us by which his Majesty expressed That he would not have his Prerogative straitned by any new Explanation of Magna Charta or the rest of the Statutes and therefore that expression of our Speakers was then proper to make it have reference to this Petition there being nothing therein contained but particular Rights of the Subject and nothing at all concerning his Majesties Prerogative Secondly That Answer was to give his Majesty satisfaction of all our proceedings in general and no man can assign any particular in which we have broken it and this Petition justifies it self that in it we have not offended against the Protestation and I know no reason but that this Declaration should be added to all our Laws we shall agree on this Parliament as well as to this Petition The last Reason given was That we have varied in our Petition from the words of Magna Charta and therefore it was well necessary that a Saving should be added to the Petition I Answer That in the Statute 5 E. 3.25 E. 3.28 E. 3. and other Statutes with which Magna Charta is confirmed the words of the Statute of Explanation differ from the words of Magna Charta it self the words of some of the Statutes of Explanation being that no man ought to be apprehended unless by Indictment or due process of Law and the other Statutes differing from the words of Magna Charta in many other particulars and yet there is no Saving in those Statutes 〈◊〉 much less should there be any in a Petition of Right There are the Answers I have conceived to the Reasons of their Lordships and the
proceeded and said You have heard his Charge made up by his own words and withall I doubt not but you seem to hear the voice of that wicked one Quid dabitis what will you give me and I will betray this State Kingdom and Commonwealth But there are two Observations I might adde a third which is like unto a threefold Cord which cannot be easily broken will draw the Charge more violently upon him The first is of the Time when this Doctrine of destruction was set forth it was Preached in the heart of the Loan and it was Printed in the beginning of that Term which ended in a Remittitur So that you might guess there might be a double Plot by the Law and Conscience to set on fire the frame and estate of this Commonwealth And one of these intailed Foxes was Mr. Manwaring Another note may be taken of the time that is the unseasonableness of it for this Doctrine of the Loan in case of necessity was the year after an assent in Parliament to four Subsidies and three Fifteens which might serve for a sufficient stopple for the Doctors mouth to keep in his Doctrine of Necessity A second observation may be of the Means by which he seeks to destroy this Commonwealth his means are Divinity yea by his Divinity he would destroy both King and Kingdom The King for there can be no greater mischief to a Prince then to put the opinion of Deity into his ears for if from his ears ti should have passed to his heart it had been mortal You know how Herod perished Now this man gives a participation of Divine Omnipotence to Kings and though a part may seem to qualifie yet all doth seem again to fill up that qualification and very dangerously if we remember that God saith of himself I am a jealous God He goes about to destroy the Kingdom and Commonwealth by his Divinity but do we finde in Scripture such a destroying Divinity Surely I finde there that God is a God of order and not of confusion and that the Son of God came to save and not to destroy By which it seems he hath not his Divinity from God nor from the Son of God And that we may be sure he went to Hell for Divinity he names sundry Jesuits and Fryers with whom he consulted and traded for his Divinity But not to belye Hell it self the Jesuits are honester then he for if he had not brought more hell unto them then he found with them he had not found this Divinity in them which he hath brought forth yea in his quotations he hath used those shifts and falshoods for which Boyes are to be whipt in Schools and yet by them he thinks to carry the Cause of a Kingdom But for a conclusion to give the true Character of this man whom I never saw I will shew it you by one whom I know to be contrary to him Samuel we know all to be a true Prophet now we read of Samuel that he writ the Law of the Kingdom in a Book and laid it up before the Lord. And this he did as one of Mr. Manwarings own Authors affirms that the King may know what to command and the People what to obey But Mr. Manwaring finding the Law of this Kingdom written in Books tears it in pieces and that in the presence of the Lord in a Pulpit that the King may not know what to command nor the People what to obey Thus Mr. Manwaring being contrary to a true Prophet must needs be a false one and the Judgement of a false Prophet belongs to him I have shewed you an evil Tree that bringeth forth evil fruit and now it rests with you to determine whether the following sentence shall follow Cut it down and cast it into the fire ABout this time the Mayor of Plimouth certified to the Burgesses serving for that Town in Parliament the Examination of Le Brun a Frenchman Captain of the Mary of Rotchel taken the 16 of May 1628. viz. The Examinate saith That on Sunday being the 17 of April last past he departed from Plimouth Harbor in company with the English Fleet whereof the Earl of Denbigh is General and on the first day of May then following the said Fleet arrived and came at Anchor at Charleboy in the Rode of Rotchel about four of the Clock in the afternoon where at the said arrival they found twenty sail of the King of France his Ships whereof six were Ships of about 300 Tuns and the rest were small Shâ—ps and forthwith with the said French Ships put themselves to sail and went in nearer to the fortifications where they also anchored within two Canon shot of the English Fleet and saith That one of his Majesties Ships shot off one piece of Ordinance and no more and that the said French Ships as they returned from the English Fleet shot off oftentimes to them and that the same Fleet remained there until the eighth day of the said moneth of May in which time there was a Wherry sent from the Fleet into Rotchel wherein there were two English and one Frenchman to inquire the state of the said Town and that if they were there safe arrived they should make a fire upon one of the Towers of the Town to give notice thereof which accordingly they did and also to make so many fires more on the Walls of the said Town as they have moneths victuals there but they made not any answer thereof whence it was collected that they had but a small quantity of victuals and said That the said English as he hath heard promised to sink the said French Ships when the waters did increase and the wind came at West-north-west it being then Neap-tides and about two days after the waters did increase and the winds came accordingly and being then intreated to fight with them yet did not but came away without fighting or relieving the Town and saith That on the eighth day of May the said English Fleet weighed Anchor and set sail to depart and four of the French great Ships weighed Anchor also and came after them and shot divers times at the said Fleet and the said Fleet shot at them again and the said Examinate came in company with the said Fleet as far as Bell Isle where he departed from them on the tenth of this instant and lastly saith That during all the time the English Fleet was there the Town of Rotchel shot to the King of France his Ships and Fort but chiefly upon the arrival of the said Fleet there This Examination being communicated to the Councel Table it procured this ensuing Letter from the Privy Councel to the Duke dated the 30 of May 1628. viz. WHereas it is his Majesties pleasure that the Earl of Denbigh shall return back to relieve the Town of Rotchel with the Fleet under his Charge We do therefore pray your Grace to signifie this his Majesties pleasure unto the said Earl and to give him
special Charge and Direction so soon as the said Fleet or the greatest thereof shall be reassembled and joyned together then presently with the first opportunity of wind taking into his Charge also the Ships stayed and prepared at Portsmouth and Plimouth together with such fire Ships and other Vessels as shall be provided for this expedition to return to Rotchel with all possible diligence and do his best endevor to relieve the same Letting his Lordship know that order is taken for the victualling of the Fleet by Petty warrant so long as it remaineth in Harbor for the sparing and lengthening of the Sea victuals And if it so fall out that the Earl of Denbigh do set forward on his voyage towards Rotchel before the whole Fleet shall be joyned with him we pray your Grace to give him such Direction that he may leave order that the Ships which are behind shall follow him with all speed Monday 2 Iune The King came to the Parliament and spake thus in brief to both Houses Gentlemen I Am come hither to perform my duty I think no man can think it long since I have not taken so many days in answering the Petition as ye spent weeks in framing it And I am come hither to shew you that as well in formal things as in essential I desire to give you as much content as in me lies After this the Lord Keeper spake as followeth MY Lords and ye the Knights Citizens and Burgesses of the House of Commons his Majesty hath commanded me to say unto you That he takes it in good part that in consideration of setling your own Liberties ye have generally professed in both Houses that ye have no intention for to lessen or diminish his Majesties Prerogative wherein as ye have cleared your own intentions so now his Majesty comes to clear his and to subscribe a firm League with his People which is ever likely to be most constant and perpetual when the Conditions are equal and known to be so These cannot be in a more happy estate then when your Liberties shall be an ornament and a strength to his Majesties Prerogative and his Prerogative a defence of your Liberties in which his Majesty doubts not but both he and you shall take a mutual comfort hereafter and for his part he is resolved to give an example in the using of his power for the preservation of your Liberties that hereafter ye shall have no cause to complain This is the sum of that which I am to say to you from his Majesty And that which further remains is That you hear read your own Petition and his Majesties gracious Answer The Petition Exhibited to his Majesty by the Lords Spiritual and Temporal and Commons in this present Parliament assembled concerning divers Rights and Liberties of the Subjects with the Kings Majesties Royal Answer thereunto in full Parliament To the Kings most Excellent Majesty HUmbly shew unto our Soveraign Lord the King the Lords Spiritual and Temporal and Commons in Parliament assembled That whereas it is Declared and Enacted by a Statute made in the time of the Reign of King Edward the first commonly called Statutum de Tallagio non concedendo That no Tallage or aide shall be laid or levied by the King or his Heirs in this Realm without the good will and assent of the Archbishops Bishops Earls Barons Knights Burgesses and other the Freemen of the Commonalty of this Realm And by Authority of Parliament holden in the five and twentieth year of the Reign of King Edward the third it is Declared and Enacted That from thenceforth no person should be compelled to make any Loans to the King against his will because such Loans were against Reason and the Franchise of the Land and by other Laws of this Realm it is provided That none should be charged by any Charge or Imposition called a Benevolence nor by such like Charge by which the Statutes before mentioned and other the good Laws and Statutes of this Realm your Subjects have inherited this Freedom That they should not be compelled to contribute to any Tax Tallage Aid or other like Charge not set by common censent in Parliament Yet nevertheless of late divers Commssions directed to sundry Commissioners in several Counties with instructions have issued by means whereof your People have been in divers places assembled and required to lend certain sums of Money unto your Majesty and many of them upon their refusal so to do have had an Oath administred unto them not warrantable by the Laws or Statutes of this Realm and have been constrained to become bound to make appearance and give attendance before your Privy Councel and in other places and others of them have been therefore Imprisoned Consined and sundry other ways molested and disquieted And divers other charges have been layed and levied upon your People in several Counties by Lords Lieutenants Deputy Lieutenants Commissioners for Musters Iustices of Peace and others by command or direction from your Majesty or your Privy Councel against the Laws and free Customs of the Realm And where also by the Statute called The great Charter of the Liberties of England It is declared and enacted That no Freeman may be taken or imprisoned or be disseised of his Freeholds or Liberties or his free Customs or be Outlawed or Exiled or in any manner destroyed but by the lawful Iudgement of his Peers or by the Law of the Land And in the eight and twentieth year of the reign of King Edward the third it was declared and enacted by Authority of Parliament That no man of what Estate or condition that he be should be put out of his Land or Tenements nor taken nor imprisoned nor disherited nor put to death without being brought to answer by due process of Law Nevertheless against the tenor of the said Statutes and other the good Laws Statutes of your Realm to that end provided divers of your Subjects have of late been imprisoned without any cause shewed and when for their deliverance they were brought before your Iustices by your Majesties Writs of Habeas Corpus there to undergo and receive as the Court should order and their Keepers commanded to certifie the Causes of their detainer no cause was certified but that they were detained by your Majesties special Command signified by the Lords of your Privy Councel and yet were returned back to several Prisons without being charged with any thing to which they might make answer according to the Law And whereas of late great companies of Soldiers and Mariners have been dispersed into divers Counties of the Realm and the Inhabitants against their wills have been compelled to receive them into their houses and there to suffer them to sojourn against the Laws and Customs of this Realm and to the great grievance and vexation of the people And whereas also by Authority of Parliament in the 25 year of the reign of King Edward the third
read in the success 3. Witness the last voyage to Rotchel which needs no observation and is fresh in memory 4. Head is the ignorance and corruption of our Ministers Survey the Court survey the Countrey the Church the City the Bar the Bench the Courts the Shipping the Land the Seas all will yield variety of proofs The Exchequer is empty the reputation thereof gone the ancient Lands are sold the Jewels pawn'd the Plate ingaged the debt still great almost all charges both extraordinary and ordinary by Projects 5. The oppression of the Subject it needs no demonstration the whole Kingdom is a proof and that oppression speaks the exhausting of our treasures what waste of our Provisions what consumption of our Ships what destruction of our men have been witness the voyage to Algier witness that of Mansfield witness that to Cales witness the next witness that to Ree witness the last witness the Palatinate witness the Turks witness the Dunkirks witness all we were never so much weakned nor had less hopes how to be restored These Mr. Speaker are our dangers these are they do threaten us and those are like that Trojan Horse brought in cunningly to surprize us in these do lurk the strongest of our enemies ready to issue on us and if we do not now the more speedily expel them these are the sign the invitation to others These will prepare their entrance that we shall have no means left of refuge or defence for if we have these enemies at home how can we strive with those that are abroad if we be free from these no other can impeach us Our ancient English vertue that old Spartan valor cleared from these disorders being in sincerity of Religion once made friends with Heaven having maturity of Councels sufficiency of Generals incorruption of Officers opulency in the King Liberty in the People repletion in Treasures restitution of Provisions reparation of Ships preservation of Men Our ancient English vertue thus rectified I say will secure us and unless there be a speedy reformation in these I know not what hopes or expectations we may have These things Sir I shall desire to have taken into consideration that as we are the great Councel of the Kingdom and have the apprehension of these dangers we may truly represent them unto the King wherein I conceive we are bound by a treble Obligation of duty unto God of duty to his Majesty and of duty to our Countrey And therefore I wish it may so stand with the Wisdom and Judgement of the House that they may be drawn into the body of a Remonstrance and therein all humbly expressed with a Prayer unto his Majesty for the safety of himself and for the safety of the Kingdom and for the safety of Religion That he will be pleased to give us time to make perfect inquisition thereof or to take them into his own Wisdom and there give them such timely reformation as the necessity of the Cause and his Justice doth import And thus Sir with a large affection and loyalty to his Majesty and with a firm duty and service to my Countrey I have suddenly and it may be with some disorder expressed the weak apprehension I have wherein if I have erred I humbly crave your pardon and so submit to the censure of the House IT seemed to others not sutable to the wisdom of the House in that conjuncture to begin to recapitulate those misfortunes which were now obvious to all accounting it more discretion not to look back but forward and since the King was so near to meet him that the happiness expected might not be lost and these were for petitioning his Majesty for a fuller Answer IT was intimated by Sir Henry Martin that this Speech of Sir Iohn Elliot was suggested from disaffection to his Majesty and there wanted not some who said it was made out of some distrust of his Majesties Answer to the Petition but Sir Iohn Elliot protested the contrary and that himself and others had a resolution to open these last mentioned Grievances to satisfie his Majesty therein onely they stayed for an opportunity Which averment of Sir Iohn Elliots was attested by Sir Thomas Wentworth and Sir Robert Phillips WHilst Sir Iohn Elliot was speaking an interruption was made by Sir Humphrey May expressing a dislike but he was commanded by the Commons to go on and being afterward questioned for a Passage in that Speech viz. That some actions seemed to be but conceptions of Spain he explained himself That in respect of the affairs of Denmark the ingagement of that unfortunate accident of Ree he conceived was a conception of Spain rather then to have any motion from our Councel here IN this Debate Sir Edward Cook propounded That an humble Remonstrance be presented to his Majesty touching the dangers and means of safety of King and Kingdom which Resolution was taken by the House and thereupon they turned themselves into a Grand Committee and the Committee for the Bill of Subsidies was ordered to expedite the said Remonstrance A Message was brought from the King by the Speaker THat his Majesty having upon the Petition exhibited by both Houses given an Answer full of Justice and Grace for which we and our posterity have just cause to bless his Majesty it is now time to grow to a conclusion of a Session and therefore his Majesty thinks fit to let you know That as he doth resolve to abide by that Answer without further change or alteration so he will Royally and Really perform unto you what he hath thereby promised and further That he resolves to end this Session upon Wednesday the 11 of this Moneth and therefore wisheth that the House will seriously attend these businesses which may best bring the Session to a happy conclusion without entertaining new matters and so husband the time that his Majesty may with the more comfort bring us speedily together again at which time if there be any further Grievances not contained or expressed in the Petition they may be more maturely considered then the time will now permit After the reading of this Message the House proceeded with a Declaration against Doctor Manwaring which was the same day presented to the Lords at a Conference betwixt the Committees of both Houses of Parliament and Mr. Pimm was appointed by the House of Commons to manage that Conference The Declaration of the Commons against Dr. Manwaring Clerke and Doctor in Divinity FOr the more effectual prevention of the apparent ruine and destruction of this Kingdom which must necessarily ensue if the good and fundamental Laws and Customs therein established should be brought into contempt and violated and that form of Government thereby altered by which it hath been so long maintained in peace and happiness and to the Honor of our soveraign Lord the King and for the preservation of his Crown and Dignity The Commons in this present Parliament assembled do by this their
Religion the precedency of Tunnage and poundage And in the Commitee Mr. Pymme spake as followeth TWo diseases there be said he the one old the other new the old Popery the new Arminianism there be three things to be inquired after concerning Popery 1. The cessation of the Execution of Laws against Papists 2. How the Papists have been imployed and countenanced 3. The Law violated in bringing in of superstitious ceremonies amongst us especially at Durham by Mr. Cozens as Angels Crucifixes Saints Altars Candles on Candlemas day burnt in the Church after the Popish manner For Arminianisme let it be advised 1. That a way be open for the truth 2. That whereas by the Articles set forth 1562. and by the Catechism set forth in King Edward the sixths days and by the writing of Martin Bucer and Peter Martyr who were employed in making our Articles and by the constant professions sealed by the blood of so many Martyrs as Cranmer Ridley and others and by the 36. Articles in Queen Elizabeths time and by the Articles agreed upon at Lambeth as the Doctrine of the Church of England which King Iames sent to Dort and to Ireland and were avowed by us and our State his Majesty hath expressed himself in preserving unity in Religion established though his royal intention notwithstanding hath been perverted by some to suppresse the truth Let us shew wherein these late opinions are contrary to those setled truths and what men have been since preferred that have professed these Heresies what pardons they have had for false doctrine what prohibiting of Books and writings against their doctrine and permitting of such books as have been for them Let us inquire after the Abettors Let us enquire also after the pardons granted of late to some of these and the presumption of some that dare preach the contrary to truth before his Majesty It belongs to the duty of Parliament to establish true Religion and to punish false we must know what Parliaments have done formerly in Religion Our Parliaments have confirmed general Councels In the time of King Henry 8. the Earl of Essex was condemned for countenancing books of Heresie For the convocation it is but a Provincial Sinod of Canturbury and cannot bind the whole Kingdom As for York that is distant and cannot do any thing to bind us or the Laws For the High-Commission it was derived from Parliament Wednesday 28. Secretary Cook delivered another message to the House concerning the precedency of Tunnage and Poundage declaring that his Majesty intends not thereby to interrupt them as to Religion so that they do not intrench on that which belongs not to them which message was seconded by Sir Thomas Edmonds in these words I am sorry the House hath given cause to so many messages about Tunnage and Poundage after his Majesty hath given us so much satisfaction you may perceive his Majesty is sensible of the neglect of his businesse we that know this should not discharge our duties to you if we should not perswade you to that course which should procure his Majesties good opinion of you You your selves are witnesses how industrious his Majesty was to procure you gracious Laws in his fathers time and since what inlargement he hath made of our Liberties and still we give him cause to repent him of the good he hath done Consider how dangerous it is to alienate his Majesties heart from Parliaments Master Corriton replied WHen men speak here of neglect of duty to his Majesty let them know we know no such thing nor what they mean And I see not how we do neglect the same I see it is in all our hearts to expedite the Bill of Tunnage and Poundage in due time our businesse is still put back by these Messages and the businesse in hand is of God and his Majesties affairs are certainly amisse and every one sees it and woe be to us if we present them not to his Majesty The House resolved to send an answer to the King that these messages are inconvenient and breed debates and losse of time and did further resolve that Tunnage and Poundage arising naturally from this House they would in fit time take such a course therein as they hoped would be to his Majesties satisfaction and honour and so again agreed to proceed at present in matters of Religion Sir Iohn Eliot upon this occasion spake to this purpose I have always observed said he that in the proceedings of this House our best advantage is order and I was very glad when that noble Gentleman my Country-man gave occasion to state our proceedings for I fear it would have carried us into a Sea of confusion and disorder and having now occasion to present my thoughts in this great and weighty businesse of Religion I shall be bold to speak a few words There is a jealousie conceived as if we meant to dispute in matters of faith it is our profession this is not to be disputed it is not in the Parliament to make a new Religion nor I hope shall it be in any to alter the body of the truth which we now professe I must confess amongst all those fears we have contracted there ariseth to me not one of the least dangers in the Declaration that is made and publisht in his Majesties name concerning disputing and preaching let not this my saying bear the least suspition or jealousie of his Majesty for if there be any misprision or Error I hope it is those Ministers about him which not only he but all Princes are subject unto and Princes no doubt are subject to mis-informations and many actions may be intitled to their Names when it is not done by themselves Antiochus King of Asia sent his Letters and missives to several Provinces that if they received any dispatches in his name not agreeable to justice Ignoto se litteras esse scriptas ideoque iis non parerent and the reason of it is given by Gratian because that oftentimes by the importunity of Ministers Principes saepe constringuntur ut non concedenda concedant are drawn to grant things by them not to be granted and as it was in that age so it may be in this And now to the particular in the Declaration we see what is said of Popery and Arminianism our Faith and Religion is in danger by it for like an Inundation it doth break in at once upon us It is said if there be any difference in Opinion concerning the seasonable interpretation of the 39. Articles the Bishops and the Clergy in the Convocation have power to dispute it and to order which way they please and for ought I know Popery and Arminianism may be introduced by them and then it must be received by all a slight thing that the power of Religion should be left to the persons of these men I honour their profession there are among our Bishops such as are fit to be made examples for
d. interfecit I. S. upon prepensed malice is good for the nature of the thing is expressed although the formall word be wanting but out of the Return the substance of the offence ought alwaies to appear which appears not here But it hath been said by the other side That let the cause in the Return be as it will yet is it not traversable 9 H. 6.54 and I confesse it But as C. 11. James Baggs case is the Return ought to have certainty so much in it that if it be false the party grieved may have his action upon the case And the grievance complained of in the Petition of Right is that upon such Return no cause was certified that is no such cause upon which any Indictment might be drawn up for we never understand that the party shall be tryed upon the Habeas Corpus but that upon the matter contained within it and Indictment shall be made and he shall have his tryall upon it And yet it is clear and it hath been agreed of all hands in the Argument of the grand Habeas corpus Mich. 3. Car. in this Court that if the cause be certified upon the Return of the Habeas corpus that the Court may judge of the legality of that cause 2. Consider the parts of this Return as they are coupled together for notable contempts by him committed against Our Self and Our Government and for stirring of sedition against Us Upon the entire Return the King joynes sedition with notable contempts so that it is as much as if he had said that Sedition is one of the notable contempts mentioned in the first part of the Return so that he makes it but a contempt For the generality and incertainty of the Return I refer my self to the cases put by Mr. Ask and I will not waive any of them True it is if the Return had been that it was for Treason he had not been bailable but by the discretion of the Court and such Return would have been good but it is not so of sedition Gard. 157. Treason is applyed to a petty offence to the breach of trust by a Guardian in Socage but it is not treason And so sedition is of far lesse nature then treason and is oftentimes taken of a trespasse it is not treason of it self nor seditiosè was never used in an Indictment of treason It was not treason before the 25 of Edw. 3. nor can it be treason for 25 E. 3. is a flat Barre as I have said before to all other offences to be treason which are not contained within the said Act or declared by any Statute afterwards And there are offences which are more heinous in their nature then sedition is which are not treason as Insurrections c. which see in the Statute 11 H. 7. cap. 7. 2 H. 5. cap. 9. 8 H. 6. cap. 14. 5 R. 2. cap. 6. 17 R. 2. cap. 8. and by 3 and 4 E. 6. cap. 5. the assembly of twelve persons to attempt the alteration of any Law and the continuance together by the space of an hour being commanded to return is made treason which Act was continued by the Statute of 1 Mar. cap. 12. and 1 Eliz. cap. 16. but now is expired by her death and is not now in force although the contrary be conceived by some which I pray may be well observed By the Statute of 14 Eliz. cap. 1. rebellious taking of the Castles of the King is made treason if they be not delivered c. which shewes clearly that such taking of Castles in its nature was not treason But the said Statute is now expired and also all Statutes creating new treasons are now repealed But for a conclusion of this part of my Argument I will cite a case which I think expresse in the point or more strong then the case in question And it was M. 9. E. 3. roll 39. B. R. Peter Russells case he was committed to prison by the Deputy-Iustice of North-Wales because he was accused by one William Solyman of sedition and other things touching the King And hereupon a Commission issued out of the Chancery to enquire if the said Peter Russell behaved himselfe well or seditiously against the King and by the Inquisition it was found that he behaved himself well And upon an Habeas Corpus out of this Court his body was returned but no cause But the said Inquisition was brought hither out of Chancery and for that no cause of his caption was returned he prayed Delivery but the Court would not deliver him till it knew the cause of his Commitment Therefore taking no regard of the said Inquisition they now send a Writ to the now Iustice of Wales to certifie the cause of his commitment And thereupon he made this Return That the foresaid Peter Russell was taken because one William Solyman charged him that he had committed divers seditions against the Lord the King and for that cause he was detained and for no other And because the Return mentions not what sedition in speciall he was bayled but not discharged And I desire the baylment of the prisoner onely and not his deliverance I desire that the case be well observed In the said case there was an actuall sedition against the King here is onely a stirring up of sedition The words of the said Award are Videtur curiae which are the solemn words of a Iudgment given upon great deliberation There it was for other things concerning Us This is all one as if it had said for other things against Us Concerning the King and Against the King are all one as appears by 25 E. 3. c. 4. de Clero Stamf. 124. Westm. 1. c. 15. Bracton f. 119. 14 Eliz. c. 2. And the words of the Iudgment in the said case were not dimittitur but ideò dimittendus which imply the right of the party to be bayled The said case in some things was more particular then our case and more strong for there was an Accuser to boot which wants in our case There true it is that he was committed by the Iustice of Wales and here by the King himself but this makes no difference as to this Court for be the commitment by the King himself or by any other if it be not upon just cause the party may be bayled in this Court. And for the Inquisition which is mentioned it was no Tryall in the case nor did the Court give any regard thereto To detain the prisoner by the command of the King singly is against the Petition of Right but it being coupled with the cause the cause is to be considered and the truth of the cause is to be intended as well where it is mentioned to be by an inferiour Iudge as where by the King himself for it is traversable neither in the one nor other And 22 H. 8. roll 37. B. R. and 1 H. 8 roll 8. Harrisons case resolv'd that a man committed by the command of the King is
Cases at the Council Table when great Causes were heard before the King and Council And when matters were agitated at a greater distance I was there also and went on purpose out of a curiosity to see and observe the passages at the Camp at Berwick at the Fight at Newborn at the Treaty at Rippon at the great Council at York and at the meeting of the Long Parliament The Observations I made during all the said time shall be further known if I be encouraged to proceed and that this my Forlorn be not repelled and defeated Thus have I good Reader acquainted thee in plain English with the Lines and rude Draughts of what hath been and what is like to be multorum annorum opus in which as I never did approve so neither could I perswade my self to tread in their Steps who intermingle their Passion with their stories and are not content to write of unless they write also for a Party or to serve an Interest and so declare themselves far better Advocates then Historiansâ—â— I profess that in singleness of heart I aim at truth which to me has alwayes seemed hugely amiable even without the tires and advantages of Wit and Eloquence And therefore in order to my greatest purpose I have esteemed the most unaffected and familiar Stile the best Altum alii teneant And so irresistible is the force of Truth and the Divine Providence so great that howsoever all possible diligence may have been used to carry things in secret and to act by colourable Pretences men often acting like Tumblers that are squint-eyed looking one way and aiming another Yet hath God in these our dayes brought to light such Secrets of State such private Consultations such strâ—nge Contrivances discovered by Letters Papers and Cabinet-memorials seised on in time of the War as otherwise probably neither we nor our Posterity should have ever known I conclude with the learned Spaniards opinion Satis est Historiae si sit vera quae ut reliqua habeat omnia si veritatem non habet obtinere nomen suum non potest J. RUSHWORTH 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 h.e. Anglorum leges Suadam consulta Senatus ausáque cuncta loquor tempore quaeque suo Excipis adverso si pectore ore maligno pluribus invideas Zoile nemo tibi The Printer to the Reader BEing obliged to get this Book finished against the ensuing Term I was constrained to make more haste then ordinary so that possibly some Faults have escap'd which I request the Courteous Reader to Pardon and Amend as they shall be met with VALE The right high and most mightie Monarch â—AMES by the Graâ—ce of God King of great Britaine Fraunce and Ireland c Defendor of the Faith Historical Collections THe grand business of State in the latter times of King Iames was the Spanish Match which had the Kings heart in it over-ruled all his Counsels and had a mighty influence upon the Universal State of Christendom This King affecting the name of a King of Peace and Peace-maker as his chief glory had designed what in him lay the setling of a general Peace in Europe and the reconciling of all Parties and professed that if the Papists would leave their King-killing and some other grosser Errors he was willing to meet them half way moreover he was ever zealous for the honor and height of regal Majesty and to maintain the glory of it in his Successors 't was his chief desire and care to match his Son with some Princess of most high descent though of a different Religion There had been a Treaty of Marriage between the late Prince Henry and a Daughter of Spain which on the Spaniards part was found a meer Complement carried on by the accustomed gravity and formality of that Nation For Cecil Earl of Salisbury the great States-man of that time pursued and drove the matter to that point that the Duke of Lerma finding no evasion disclaimed the being of a Marriage Treaty Nevertheless the Spanish Ambassador to acquit himself to this State and to clear his own honesty at a full Council produced his Commission together with his Letters of Instruction given under the Duke's hand Such manner of dealing might have been sufficient Cause of just Indignation against any future motion of this Alliance After death of Prince Henry the King set his thoughts upon a Daughter of Henry the Fourth late King of France as the fittest Match for Prince Charles and by Sir Thomas Edmonds his Legier Ambassador endeavored to know the minde of that State but could not discern their affections and was not willing to discover his own At length taking occasion to send the Lord Hayes Extraordinary Ambassador to the French King to Congratulate his Marriage with Anne the Infanta of Spain he resolved to make a thorow Trial The matter was put forth and in appearance well taken but proved of no effect For the Duke of Savoy was before-hand and prevailed for his Son the Prince of Piedmont During this Negotiation of Alliance with France the Duke of Lerma frequently intimated unto Sir Iohn Digby Ambassador Resident in Spain an extraordinary desire in the King his Master not onely to maintain Peace and Amity with the King of great Britain but to lay hold on all means that might be offered for the nearer uniting of their Majesties and their Crowns as also a disposition in this regard to match his second Daughter to the Prince of Wales The Ambassador replyed that His Majesty had little reason to give ear to this overture having not long since in the Treaty for the late Prince received such an unexpected Answer and Demands so improper and unworthy and that there needed more then ordinary assurance to induce him to believe that there was now so great a change and the match desired in good earnest and not propounded meerly to divert the match with France wherefore he expected the proposal of such terms of advantage and certainty as might gain a belief of their sincere Intentions Lerma promised a further Conference But by reason of a strong report that the Match with France was absolutely concluded and within few dayes to be published the business lay asleep until Sir Iohn Digby going for England was desired by the Duke to give him notice of the state of this Affair From hence Digby gives him to understand that there was no cause of dispair concerning this new overture unless the difficulty of the Conditions should make it desperate but if the Demands in point of Religion were no more then what would satisfie another Catholick Prince and to which his Majesty might yeild with Honor he knows that divers persons not of the meanest power were well inclined and ready to give their helping hand He said further that it were much better not to revive this motion then by impossible and unfitting
beforehand for the defence of the Palatinate and the maintenance of his Children expelled out of their Countrey and for the raising of an Army for that recovery That he had procured a short Truce and did hope to obtain a general peace But the charges of sending Ambassadors over Christendom or an Army into the Palatinate in case a peace were not setled could not be borne but by the Grant of more Subsidies Moreover he protested before God That he would not dissolve the Parliament till the matters in agitation were finished Soon after the Lord Chancellor Bacon was proceeded against and a Conference of both Houses was held concerning him Where first the Commons observed his incomparable good parts which they highly commended secondly They magnified the place he held from whence Bounty Justice and Mercy were to be distributed to the Subjects whither all great Causes were drawn and from whence there was no Appeal in case of injustice or wrong done save to the Parliament Thirdly He was accused of great Bribery and Corruption in this eminent place and the particulars were laid open Then they concluded that this matter which concerned a person of so great eminency might not depend long before their Lordships but that the Examination of Proofs be expedited that as he shall be found upon tryal either he or his accusers might be punished After this the Marquess of Buckingham Lord Admiral declared to the House of Lords That he had received a Letter from the Chancellor expressing that he was indisposed in health but whither he lived or died he would be glad to preserve his Honor and Fame as far as he was worthy desiring to be maintained in their good opinions without prejudice till his cause was heard that he should not trick up Innocency with cavillation but plainly and ingenuously declare what he knew or remembred being happy that he had such Noble Peers and Reverend Prelates to discern of his Cause That he desired no priviledge of greatness for subterfuge of guiltiness but meaned to deal fairly and plainly with their Lordships and to put himself upon their Honors and Favors But the Charge came home upon him insomuch that he abandoned all defence and onely implored a favorable judgment in this humble Submission and Supplication to the House of Lords May it please your Lordships I Shall humbly crave at your hands a benign interpretation of that which I shall now write For words that come from wasted spirits and oppressed mindes are more safe in being deposited to a noble construction then being circled with any reserved Caution This being moved and as I hope obtained of your Lordships as a protection to all that I shall say I shall go on but with a very strange entrance as may seem to your Lordships at first For in the midst of a state of as great affliction as I think a mortal man can endure Honor being above Life I shall begin with the professing of gladness in some things The first is That hereafter the greatness of a Iudge or Magistrate shall be no sanctuary or protection to him against guiltiness which is the beginning of a Golden Work The next That after this example it is like that Iudges will flie from any thing in the likeness of Corruption though it were at a great distance as from a Serpent which tends to the purging of the Courts of Iustice and reducing them to their true honor and splendor And in these two points God is my witness though it be my fortune to be the Anvile upon which these two effects are broken and wrought I take no small comfort But to pass from the motions of my heart whereof God is my Iudge to the merits of my Cause whereof your Lordships are Iudges under God and his Lieutenant I do understand there hath been heretofore expected from me some justification and therefore I have chosen one onely justification instead of all others out of the justification of Job For after the clear submission and confession which I shall now make unto your Lordships I hope I may say and justifie with Job in these words I have not hid my sin as did Adam nor concealed my faults in my bosome This is the onely justification which I will use It resteth therefore That without Fig-leaves I do ingenuously confess and acknowledge that having understood the particulars of the Charge not formally from the House but enough to inform my conscience and memory I finde matter sufficient and full both to move me to desert my Defence and to move your Lordships to condemn and censure me Neither will I trouble your Lordships by singling these particulars which I think might fall off Quid te exempta juvat spinis de pluribus uva Neither will I prompt your Lordships to observe upon the proofs where they come not home or the scruple touching the credits of the Witnesses Neither will I represent to your Lordships how far a Defence might in divers things extenuate the Offence in respect of the time and manner of the guilt or the like circumstances but onely leave these things to spring out of your more noble thoughts and observations of the evidence and examinations themselves and charitably to winde about the particulars of the Charge here and there as God shall put into your minde and so submit my self wholly to your Piety and Grace And now I have spoken to your Lordships as Iudges I shall say a few words unto you as Peers and Prelates humbly commending my Cause to your noble mindes and magnanimous affections Your Lordships are not simply Iudges but Parliamentary Iudges you have a further extent of Arbitrary power then other Courts and if you be not tyed by ordinary course of Courts or Precedents in points of strictness and severity much less in points of Mercy and Mitigation And yet if any thing which I shall move might be contrary to your honorable and worthy End the introducing a Reformation I should not seek it But herein I beseech your Lordships to give me leave to tell you a story Titus Manlius took his Sons life for giving battel against the Prohibition of his General Not many years after the like severity was pursued by Papitius Cursor the Dictator against Quintus Maximus who being upon the point to be sentenced was by the intercession of some particular persons of the Senate spared Whereupon Livie maketh this grave and gratious observation Neque minus firmata est Disciplinae Militaris periculo Quinti Maximi quà m miserabili supplicio Titi Manlii The Discipline of War was no less established by the questioning of Quintus Maximus then by the punishment of Titus Manlius and the same reason is in the Reformation of Iustice. For the questioning of men in eminent places hath the same terror though not the same rigor with the punishment But my Cause stays not there for my humble desire is That his Majesty would take the Seal into his hands which is
from us What can we look for if the whole shall be in his hands and possession who amuzing us with a Treaty of Cessation and protracting it industriously as we have reason to believe doth in the mean time seize himself of the whole Countrey Which being done our Ambassador shall return with scorn and we remain in dishonor And therefore as we have heretofore sundry times promised in testimony of the sincerity of our proceedings and of our great desire to preserve the Amity inviolable between us and the whole House of Austria that in case our Son in Law would not be governed by us that then we would not onely forsake him but take part and joyn our forces with the Emperors against him So you may fairly represent unto that King That in like manner we have reason to expect the same measure from him That upon the Emperors aversness to a Cessation and Accommodation he will likewise actually assist us for the recovery of the Palatinate and Electoral Dignity to our Son in Law as it hath been often times intimated from Spain Yet our meaning is to carry all things fair with that King and not to give him any cause of distrust or jealousie if you perceive that they intend to go really and roundly on with the Match Wherein nevertheless we must tell you That we have no great cause to be well-pleased with the diligencies used on that part when we observe that after so long an expectance of the Dispensation upon which the whole business as they will have it depends there is nothing yet returned but Queres and Objections We have thought fit to let you know how far we are pleased to enlarge our self concerning those points demanded by the Pope And further then that since we cannot go without much prejudice inconvenience and dishonor to our self and our Son we hope and expect that the King of Spain will bring it instantly to an issue without further delay which you are to press with all diligence and earnestness But if respite of time be earnestly demanded and that you perceive it not possible for them to resolve until an answer come from Rome We then think it fit that you give them two moneths time after your Audience that we may understand that Kings final Resolutions before Christmas next at the furthest Likewise the Conde Gondomar who was lately called home is roused by a Letter from England on this manner HEre is a King and a Prince and a faithful Friend and Servant Buckingham besides a number of other Friends to whom every day seems a year till the Match be accomplished all things are prepared on our parts Priests and Recusants are at liberty and the Prisons are filled with zealous Ministers Orders are published for the Universities and Pulpits that none shall hereafter be medling but that all Preach Christ crucified His Majesty never looked to the rising or falling hopes of his Son in Laws fortunes but kept in the same course that seems most agreeable to Honor and Justice and the Peace of Christendom And Gondomar did beseech the King to suffer himself once to be deceived by Spain and promised when the Match was first moved and the King perswaded to break with France That he should be prest to nothing but what might stand with Conscience and Honor and the love of his people And whereas the Pope would know what Bonum Publicum will be granted We remit it to your Conscience whither the favors daily granted to Catholicks which the King resolves to continue if not to increase be not a real publick good considering if the Match break off his Majesty will be importunately urged by his people to whose assistance he must needs have recourse to give life and execution to all Penal Laws now hanging over the heads of Catholicks According to the Kings direction the Earl of Bristol presented a Memorial to the King of Spain and from him and his Ministers received this return That for the accomplishing of the Match on their part there should not one day be lost for the dispatch thereof imported them no less then the King of Great Britain And for the Palatinate they will seek his intire satisfaction and they refer it to his own just judgment whether their forces were called out of the Palatinate with an evil intention or meerly for the defence of Flanders which otherwise had been put in great hazard by Count Mansfield That the besieging of Heidelburgh was no way by their consent or knowledge but was generally disapproved by them And if it should be taken and the Emperor refuse to restore it or to condiscend to such Accommodation as should be adjudged reasonable the King of Great Britain shall be infallibly assisted with the Arms of Spain for the restoring of the Palatine And as concerning the Match Bristol seemed so confident as to declare to the King his Master That he should not willingly give his Majesty hope upon uncertain grounds so he would not conceal what the Spanish Court professed which was to give his Majesty both real and speedy satisfaction And he affirmed If they intended it not they were falser then all the Devils in Hell for deeper Oaths and Protestations of Sincerity could not be made But in the mean while the Town and Castle of Heidelburgh were taken and the English Companies put to the Sword and Sir Edward Herbert the Governor was slain after he had broken four Pikes in charging the Enemy The besieging of Manheim and the blocking of Frankendale followed the loss of Heidelburgh King Iames provoked by the continual progress of these Indignities was impatient of staying for a Reply from Spain to his former Letters but seconded those Resolutions with a vehement new dispatch the Third of October in a peremptory stile as it well became him Commanding the Earl of Bristol to let that King understand how sensible he was of the Emperors proceedings towards him and withal not a little troubled to see that the Infanta at Bruxels having an absolute Commission from the Emperor to conclude a Cessation and Suspension of Arms should now at last when all Objections were answered and the former solely pretended Obstacles removed not onely delay the Conclusion of the Treaty but refuse to lay her Commands upon the Emperors Generals for abstaining from the Garisons during the Treaty upon a pretext of want of Authority So as for the avoiding of further dishonor he hath been forced to recal both his Ambassadors as well the Chancellor of his Exchequer from Bruxels as also the Lord Chichester whom he intended to have sent unto the Emperor to the Dyet at Ratisbone He further enjoyned his Ambassador That having delivered his sense of things he should demand of the King of Spain a promise under his Hand and Seal that the Town and Castle of Heidelburgh shall be delivered to the Palatine within seventy days after the Audience and the like for Manheim and
as no Ceremony or other thing intervene which shall be contrary to the Roman Catholick Apostolick Religion III. That the most Gratious Infanta shall take with her such Servants and Family as are convenient for her service which Family and all persons to her belonging shall be chosen and nominated by the Catholick King So as he nominate no Servant which is Vassal to the King of Great Britain without his will and consent IV. That as well the most Gratious Infanta as all her Servants and Family shall have free use and publick Exercise of the Roman Catholick Religion in manner and form as is beneath capitulated V. That she shall have an Oratory and Decent Chappel in her Palace where at the pleasure of the most Gratious Infanta Masses may be celebrated and in like manner she shall have in London or wheresoever she shall make her abode a Publick and Capacious Church near her Palace wherein all Duties may be solemnly celebrated and all other things necessary for the Publick Preaching of Gods Word the Celebration and Administration of all the Sacraments of the Catholick Roman Church and for burial of the Dead and Baptizing of Children That the said Oratory Chappel and Church shall be adorned with such decency as shall seem convenient to the most Gratious Infanta VI. That the Men-servants and Maid-servants of the most Gratious Infanta and their Servants Children and Descendents and all their Families of what sort soever serving her Highness may be freely and publickly Catholicks VII That the most Gratious Infanta her Servants and Family may live as Catholicks in form following That the most Gratious Infanta shall have in her Palace her Oratory and Chappel so spatious that her said Servants and Family may enter and stay therein in which there shall be an ordinary and publick door for them and another inward door by which the Infanta may have a passage into the said Chappel where she and other as abovesaid may be present at Divine Offices VIII That the Chappel Church and Oratory may be beautified with decent Ornaments of Altars and other things necessary for Divine Service which is to be celebrated in them according to the custom of the Holy Roman Church and that it shall be lawful for the said Servants and others to go to the said Chappel and Church at all hours as to them shall seem expedient X. That the care and custody of the said Chappel and Church shall be committed to such as the Lady Infanta shall appoint to whom it shall be lawful to appoint Keepers that no body may enter into them to do any undecent thing XI That to the Administration of the Sacraments and to serve in Chappel and Church aforesaid there shall be Four and twenty Priests and Assistants who shall serve weekly or monethly as to the Infanta shall seem fit and the Election of them shall belong to the Lady Infanta and the Catholick King Provided That they be none of the Vassals of the King of Great Britain and if they be his will and consent is to be first obtained XII That there be one Superior Minister or Bishop with necessary Authority upon all occasions which shall happen belonging to Religion and for want of a Bishop that his Vicar may have his Authority and Jurisdiction XIII That this Bishop or Superior Minister may Correct and Chastise all Roman Catholicks who shall offend and shall exercise upon them all Jurisdiction Ecclesiastical And moreover also the Lady Infanta shall have power to put them out of her service whensoever it shall seem expedient to her XIV That it may be lawful for the Lady Infanta and her Servants to procure from Rome Dispensations Indulgences Jubilees and all Graces as shall seem fit to their Religion and Consciences and to get and make use of any manner of Catholick Books whatsoever XV. That the Servants and Family of the Lady Infanta who shall come into England shall take the Oath of Allegiance to the King of Great Britain Provided That there be no clause therein which shall be contrary to their Consciences and the Roman Catholick Religion and if they happen to be Vassals to the King of Great Britain they shall take the same Oath that the Spaniards do XVI That the Laws which are or shall be in England against Religion shall not take hold of the said Servants and onely the foresaid Superior Ecclesiastical Catholick may proceed against Ecclesiastical persons as hath been accustomed by Catholicks And if any Secular Judge shall apprehend any Ecclesiastical person for any offence he shall forthwith cause him to be delivered to the aforesaid Superior Ecclesiastick who shall proceed against him according to the Canon Law XVII That the Laws made against Catholicks in England or in any other Kingdom of the King of Great Britain shall not extend to the Children of this Marriage and though they be Catholicks they shall not lose the right of Succession to the Kingdom and Dominions of Great Britain XVIII That the Nurses which shall give suck to the Children of the Lady Infanta whither they be of the Kingdom of Great Britain or of any other Nation whatsoever shall be chosen by the Lady Infanta as she pleaseth and shall be accounted of her Family and enjoy the priviledges thereof XIX That the Bishop Ecclesiastical and Religious persons of the Family of the Lady Infanta shall wear the Vestment and Habit of their Dignity Profession and Religion after the Custom of Rome XX. For security that the said Matrimony be not dissolved for any cause whatsoever The King and Prince are equally to pass the Word and Honor of a King and moreover that they will perform whatsoever shall be propounded by the Catholick King for further confirmation if it may be done decently and fitly XXI That the Sons and Daughters which shall be born of this Marriage shall be brought up in the company of the most Excellent Infanta at the least until the age of Ten years and shall freely enjoy the right of Successions to the Kingdoms as aforesaid XXII That whensoever any place of either Man-servant or Maid-servant which the Lady Infanta shall bring with her nominated by the Catholick King her Brother shall happen to be void whether by death or by other cause or accident all the said Servants of her Family are to be supplied by the Catholick King as aforesaid XXIII For security that whatsoever is capitulated may be fulfilled The King of Great Britain and Prince Charls are to be bound by Oath and all the Kings Council shall confirm the said Treaty under their hands Moreover the said King and Prince are to give their Faiths in the Word of a King to endeavor if possible That whatsoever is capitulated may be established by Parliament XXIV That conformable to this Treaty all these things proposed are to be allowed and approved of by the Pope tâ—at he may give an Apostolical Benediction and a Dispensation necessary to effect the Marriage The Oath taken
of your Honors and mine own I must intreat you likewise to consider of the Times we are in how that I must adventure your lives which I should be loth to do should I continue you here long and you must venture the Business if you be slow in your resolutions Wherefore I hope you will take such grave Counsel as you will expedite what you have in hand to do Which will do me and your selves an infinite deal of honor You in shewing your love to me and me that I may perfect that work which my Father hath so happily begun Last of all Because some malicious men may and as I hear have given out that I am not so true a Keeper and Maintainer of the true true Religion that I profess I assure you that I may with S. Paul say that I have been trained up at Gamaliels feet And although I shall be never so arrogant as to assume unto my self the rest I shall so far shew the end of it that all the World may see that none hath been nor ever shall be more desirous to maintain the Religion I profess then I shall be Now because I am unfit for much speaking I mean to bring up the fashion of my Predecessors to have my Lord Keeper speak for me in most things Therefore I have commanded him to speak something unto you at this time which is more for formality then any great matter he hath to say unto you Then the Lord Keeper Coventry declared That the Kings main reason of calling the Parliament besides the beholding of his Subjects faces was to mind them of the great Engagements for the Recovery of the Palatinate imposed on his Majesty by the late King his Father and by themselves who brake off the two Treaties with Spain Also to let them understand That the succeeding Treaties and Alliances the Armies sent into the Low-Countries the repairing of the Forts and the Fortifying of Ireland do all meet in one Centre The Palatinate And that the Subsidies granted the last Parliament are herein already spent whereof the Accompt is ready together with as much more of the Kings own Revenue His Lordship further commended three Circumstances First The Time All Europe being at this day as the Pool of Bethesda the first stirring of the waters must be laid hold on Wherefore his Majesty desires them to bestow this Meeting on him or rather on their Actions and the next shall be theirs as soon and as long as they please for Domestick business Secondly Supply If Subsidies be thought too long and backward his Majesty desires to hear and not to propound the way Thirdly The Issue of Action which being the first doth highly concern his Majesties Honor and Reputation for which he relies upon their Loves with the greatest confidence that ever King had in his Subjects witness his Royal Poesie Amor Civium Regis Munimentum And he doubts not but as soon as he shall be known in Europe to be their King so soon shall they be known to be a loving and loyal Nation to him Iune 21. The Commons presented Sir Thomas Crew Knight and Serjeant at Law for their Speaker who was also Speaker in the last Parliament of King Iames and his Majesty approved the Choice After the House of Commons had setled their General Committees there were various Debates amongst them Some insisted upon the Grievances mentioned but not redressed by King Iames in the last Parliament others pressed for an accompt of the last Subsidies granted for recovery of the Palatinate others for the putting of Laws in execution against Priests and Jesuits and such as resorted to Ambassadors Houses and the questioning of Mr. Richard Montague for his Book intituled An Appeal to Caesar which as they said was contrived and published to put a jealousie between the King and his well-affected Subjects and contained many things contrary to the Articles of Religion established by Parliament and that the whole frame thereof was an encouragement to Popery Others again declared how the King no sooner came to the Crown but he desired to meet his people in Parliament it being the surest way to preserve a right understanding between him and them that since he began to reign the Grievances are few or none and when he was Prince he was observed to be very instrumental in procuring things for the Subjects benefit Wherefore it will be the wisdom of this House to take a course to sweeten all things between King and People and to express their duty to the King by giving Supply and therewith to offer nothing but a Petition for Religion that Religion and Subsidies may go hand in hand And whatsoever they did it was needful to do it quickly considering how greatly the Plague increased and the Bell was tolling every minute while they were speaking The Commons moved the Lords to joyn in a Petition to the King for a Publick Fast whereunto their Lordships readily concurred and the King consenting a Proclamation was issued forth for a Fast throughout the Kingdom Several particular Committees were appointed One to enquire of the Subsidies given the last Parliament another to consider of Tonnage and Poundage The Imposition on Wines was Voted upon the Merchants Petition to be presented as a Grievance Sir Edward Cook went to the House of Peers with a Message from the Commons desiring their concurrence in a Petition concerning Religion and against Recusants which being agreed unto and presented to the King his Majesty answered That he was glad that the Parliament was so forward in Religion and assured them they should finde him as forward that the Petition being long could not be presently answered Mr. Richard Montague was brought to the Bar of the Commons House for his fore-named Book This Cause began in the One and twentieth of King Iames when he had published a former Book which he named A New Gagg for an Old Goose in answer to a Popish Book entituled A Gagg for the New Gospel The business was then questioned in Parliament and committed to the Archbishop of Canterbury and ended in an Admonition given to Montague Afterwards the Bishops of the Arminian Party consulting the Propagation of the Five Articles condemned in the Synod of Dort concluded that Mr. Montague being already engaged in the quarrel should publish this latter Book at first attested by their Joynt-Authorities which afterwards they withdrew by subtilty having procured the Subscription of Doctor Francis White whom they left to appear alone in the Testimony as himself ofttimes complained publickly The Archbishop disallowed the Book and sought to suppress it nevertheless it was Printed and Dedicated unto King Charles whereby that party did endeavor to engage him in the beginning of his Reign The House appointed a Committee to examine the Errors therein and gave the Archbishop thanks for the admonition given to the Author whose Books they Voted to be contrary to the Articles established by
impaired the same I would you would hasten for my Supply or else it will be worse for your selves For if any ill happen I think I shall be the last shall feel it Afterwards the Commons fell upon the Duke as the chief Cause of all Publick Miscarriages Doctor Turner a Physitian propounded in the House these Questions which were then commonly called Queries against the Duke of Buckingham and were grounded upon Publick Fame 1. Whether the Duke being Admiral be not the Cause of the loss of the Kings Royalty in the Narrow-Seas 2. Whether the unreasonable exorbitant and immense Gifts of Money and Lands bestowed on the Duke and his Kindred be not the Cause of impairing the Kings Revenue and impoverishing of the Crown 3. Whether the Multiplicity of Offices conferred upon the Duke and others depending upon him whereof they were not capable be not the Cause of the Evil Government of this Kingdom 4. Whether Recusants in general by a kind of Connivencie be not borne out and increased by reason of the Dukes Mother and Father-in-law being known Papists 5. Whether the Sale of Honors Offices and Places of Judicature and Ecclesiastical Livings and Promotions a scandal and hurt to the Kingdom be not through the Duke 6. Whether the Dukes staying at home being Admiral and General in the Fleet of the Sea and Land-Army were not the Cause of the bad success and overthrow of that Action And whether he did give good direction for that Design All these are famed to be so Hereupon two Questions were moved in Parliament 1. Whether the Six Heads delivered by Doctor Turner to be the Cause of the Evils that were grounded upon Common Fame be to be debated in Parliament 2. Whether an Accusation upon Common Fame by a Member of this House be a Parliamentary way It was declared by Sir Tho. Wentworth Mr. Noy and other Lawyers in the Debate That there was a difference between Common Fame and Rumor For the General voice Vox populi is Common Fame And if Common Fame might not be admitted as an Accuser Great men would be the onely safe men for no Private person dare adventure to enquire into their Actions But the House of Commons is a House of Information and Presentment but not a House of Definitive Judgment So the House came to this Resolution That Common Fame is a good ground of Proceeding for this House either by Enquiry or presenting the Complaint if the House finds cause to the King or Lords The Commons the next day proceeding in that Debate Sir Richard Weston delivered to the House this Message from his Majesty THat his Majesty had taken notice of a seditious Speech uttered in the House by Mr. Clement Cook The words are said to be to this effect That it were better to die by an Enemy then to suffer at home Yet his Majesty in his wisdom hath forborne to take any course therein or to send to the House about it not doubting but the House would in due time correct such an Insolence But his Majesty hath found that his patience hath wrought to an ill effect and hath imboldened one since to do a strange act in a strange way and unusual that is Doctor Turner who on Saturday last without any ground of knowledge in himself or Proof tendred to the House made an Enquiry of sundry Articles against the Duke of Buckingham as he pretended but indeed against the Honor and Government of the King and his late Father This his Majesty saith is such an Example that he can by no means suffer though it were to make Enquiry of the meanest of his Servants much less against one so neer unto himself and doth wonder at the foolish impudencie of any man that can think he should be drawn out of any end to offer such a Sacrifice much unworthy the greatness of a King and Master of such a Servant And therefore his Majesty can no longer use his wonted patience but desireth the Justice of the House against the Delinquents not doubting but such course will be taken that he shall not be constrained to use his Regal authority to right himself against these two Persons Upon this Message Doctor Turner made a short Explanation of himself desiring to know wherewith he was charged What he said he said the House can witness and what he said he spake for the general good of the Commonwealth and not upon the least reflection of any in particular This he thought a Parliamentary way warranted by antient Presidents To accuse upon Common Fame he finds warranted first by the Imperial Roman Laws and the Canons of the Church which allowed Common Fame sufficient to accuse any man And they that are learned amongst them give two reasons First for Greatness Next for Cunning. Our Ancestors within these walls have done the like and that to a Duke the Duke of Suffolk in the time of King H. 6. who was accused upon Fame And lastly he said Mr. Chancellor himself did present the Common Undertakers upon Particular Fame and why he should not have as ample priviledge in this place he knew no reason to the contrary The Commons having appointed another day for the Debate of this Business in the mean time came this Letter from Doctor Turner to the Speaker SIR THese Lines first Petition you to signifie to the Honorable House of Commons That my desires are still the same to have made my personal appearance before you but my ability and strength to perform it are not the same And therefore that I humbly desire them to excuse me on that part and to accept of this my Answer unto the matter I shall speak to I do confess that on Saturday last in the afternoon I did deliver in certain Accusations of Common Fame into the House of Parliament against my Lord Admiral and that out of so many all bearing the signiture of Vox populi I chose out some few not because they were greater or more known Grievances but because they did seem to direct us to find out the Griever or the first Cause For I did think it was then full time to agree the Agent and the Actions and that it was time also to leave considering Grievances in Arbitration I do now also agree unto you that which hath been reported unto you by Mr. Wandesford and by that if you shall think sit will put my self unto your Censure hoping and assuring my self that you will find my design to include nothing else within it but duty and publick service to my Country and also that my addressing those Accusations unto the House of Parliament shall by you be found to be done by a mannerly and Parliamentary way But howsoever it becomes me to submit my Cause to your Wisdoms and equal Iudgments which I do heartily and whatsoever you shall please to appoint me I shall dutifully satisfie when God shall be pleased to restore me able to attend your service I doubt
our Countrey That it hath béen the antient constant and undoubted Right and Usage of Parliaments to question and complain of all persons of what degree soever found grievous to the Commonwealth in abusing the power and trust committed to them by their Soveraign A course approved not onely by the examples in your Fathers days of famous memory but by frequent presidents in the best and most glorious Reigns of your Noble Progenitors appearing both in Records and Histories without which liberty in Parliament no private man no servant to a King perhaps no Counsellor without exposing himself to the hazard of great enmity and prejudice can be a means to call great Officers into question for their misdemeanors but the Commonwealth might languish under their pressures without Redress And whatsoever we shall do accordingly in this Parliament we doubt not but it shall redound to the Honor of the Crown and welfare of your Subjects Lastly We most humbly beseech Your Majesty gratiously to conceive that though it hath been the long Custom of Parliaments to handle the matter of Supply with the last of their businesses yet at this time out of extraordinary respect to your Person and care of your Affairs We have taken the same into more speedy consideration and most happily on the very day of your Majesties Inauguration with great alacrity and unanimous consent After a short Debate we grew to the Resolution for a present Supply well-known to your Maiesty To. which if Addition may be made of other great things for your Service yet in Consultation amongst us we doubt not but it will appear That we have not receded from the Truth of our first Intention so to supply you as may make you safe at home and feared abroad especially if your Maiesty shall be pleased to look upon the way intended in our promise as well as to the measure of the gift agreed With like humility we beseech your Majesty not to give ear to the officious reports of private persons for their own ends which hath occasioned so much loss of time nor to judge our proceedings whilst they are in agitation but to be pleased to expect the issue and conclusion of our labors which we are confident will manifest and justifie to your Majesty the sincerity and Loyalty of our hearts who shall ever place in a high degree of happiness the performing of that duty and service in Parliament which may most tend to your Majesties Honor and the good of your Kingdom Unto this Remonstrance the King said He could give no present answer but desired the House to adjourn for a week as the Lords had done and they adjourned accordingly In the interim it was intimated in Writing to the Duke that he should procure his Majesty to signifie to a certain number of Lords that he hath endeavored to divert the Charge against the Duke because his Majesty hath had sound knowledge and experience of his service and fidelity That his Majesty may let them know that he is now pleased to reveal some secrets and mysteries of State That the King his Father finding the Palatinate more then in danger to be lost and his Majesty being in Spain and there deluded and his abode and return both unsafe it was a necessity of State to sweeten and content the Spaniard with the hope of any thing which might satisfie and redeem those Engagements And that therefore the King willed the Duke to yield discreetly to what he should find they most desired and this was chiefly the point of Religion So as in this and all of the like kind the Duke upon his Majesties knowledge was commanded and but the Instrument trusted by the King in this Exigent or if you will say Extremity Upon the same ground though not in so high a degree the sending of the Ships to Rochel may be excused Touching the vast Creation of Nobility his Majesty may declare that his Father who was born a King and had long experience of that Regiment found that this State inclined much to popularity and therefore thought fit to enlarge the number of his Nobles that these being dispersed into several Counties might shine as Lamps of Soveraignty in protecting their own degrees and at their own chaâ—â—e inure the people with respect and obedience to greatness And the King may protest that this was a child of his Fathers best Judgment and the Duke the Instrument thereof And if you say there was money many times given for these Honors nay if you say that money hath been given for places of Clergy and Judicature take this of me it is so in all other Countreys as in France and Spain c. though I am not satisfied in this opinion And if it be said the King should have had the money which the Duke took to his own use I beleeve this last may the King say is more then any man can prove Neither will I deliver what I know therein onely this I will say I know the Dukes particular service and affection towards me and that he and his will lay down themselves and all they have at my feet Is it for a King to use his Servant and Instrument as he doth his Horses and being by hard riding in his service foundred and lame to turn them out to Grass or to the Cart I must therefore may the King say in right of the King my Fathers Honor protect a man though justly seeming guilty yet in my own knowledge innocent Will you therefore deny the King to favor whom he pleaseth which the King never denied to you that are his Subjects Well commend me to my Lords and tell them that if any thing hath been formerly done amiss by others I have power and will to redress it and to prevent the like At this time the King commanded all the Bishops to attend him and when they were come before him being fourteen in number he reprehended them that in this time of Parliament they had not made known unto him what might be profitable for the Church whose cause he was ready to promote And he laid this Charge upon them that in the Cause of Bristol and Buckingham their Consciences being their Guides they should follow onely proofs and not rumors The Commons sent again to the Duke by Sir Iohn Epsley to let him know that they were passing Articles against him and that they had given the Messengers leave to take Notes thereof out of the Clerks Book whereof he might take a Copy if he pleased and that they expected his Answer that day before ten of the Clock if he pleased to send any This the Duke signified to the Lords who did not think fit that he should answer as appears by the ensuing Report made by Sir Iohn Epsley This day his Grace gave us this Answer after he had moved the Lords that he should with great care make all due acknowledgment of your respect and favors in giving him this notice
his gracious acceptance of his service as in his Letters of November 24. 1622. written as followeth Viz. Your Dispatches are in all points so full and in them we receive so good satisfaction as in this we shall not need to inlarge any further but onely tell you we are well pleased with this diligent and discreet imployment of your endeavors and all that concerneth our service so are we likewise with the whole proceedings of our Ambassador Sir Walter Aston Thus we bid you heartily farewel Newmarkeâ— Novemb. 24 1622. And afterwards his Majesty was likewise pleased in his Letters of 8 Ianuary 1622. a little before our gracious Soveraign Lord the King then Prince his coming into Spain Viz. as followeth Concerning that knotty and unfortunate Affair of the Palatinate to say the truth as things stand I know not what you could have done more then you have done already And whereas it is objected the Palatinate should be lost by the hopes he the said Earl gave by his Letters out of Spain it is an Objection of impossibility for there was nothing left but Mainheim and Frankendale when his first Letters out of Spain could possibly come to his late Majesties hands for he did not begin to Negotiate that business until August 1622. and about that time Heidelberg and all but Mainheim and Frankendale was lost and Mainheim he had saved by his industry had it not been so suddenly delivered as is by his Majesty acknowledged by Letters of 24 November 1622. written thus Viz. And howsoever the Order given to the Infanta for the relief of Mainheim arrived too late and after the Town was yielded to Tilly yet must we acknowledge it to be a good effect of your Negotiation and an Argument of that Kings sincere and sound intention And Frankendale being by the said Earls means once saved was again the second time saved meerly by the said Earls industry and procuring a Letter from the King of Spain dated the second of February 1623. whereupon followed the Treaty of Sequestration which hath since continued And he the said Earl was so far from hindring Succors by any Letter or Counsel of his that he was the Sollicitor and in great part the procurer of most of the Succors that had been sent thither as is formerly set down And when his Royal Majesty that now is and the Duke of Buckingham arrived at the Court of Spain they found the Business of the Palatinate in so fair a way that the Spanish Ministers told them the King should give his late Majesty a Blank in which we might frame our own Conditions and the same he confirmeth unto us now and the like touching this Blank was likewise acknowledged by the Duke of Buckingham in his Speech in Parliament after the return of his Majesty out of Spain And it will appear by the Testimony of Sir Walter Aston and by his and the said Earls Dispatches that the said Earl wanted not industry and zeal in the business insomuch as the last Answer the said Earl procured herein from the King of Spain was fuller then he the said Earl was ordered by his late Majesties latest Letters to insist upon So as by that which hath been alledged the said Earl hopeth your Lordships will be satisfied not onely that he wanted neither will nor industry but that he hath with all true zeal and affection and with his own means faithfully served their Majesties and the Prince Palatine in this Cause And for assurance in that Affair he had all that could be between Christian Princes and if in the said Assurances there hath been any deceit as by the said Article is intimated which he never knew nor believed he referred it to God to punish their wickedness For betwixt Princes there can be no greater Tye then their Words their Hands and Seals all which he procured in that behalf and both the said Earl and Sir Walter Aston were so confident that the business would be ended to his late Majesties satisfaction that in a joynt Dispatch to his late Majesty of 24 November 1623. after his now Majesties return into England they wrote as followeth Viz. We hope that your Majesty may according to your desire signified to me the Earl of Bristol by the Letters of October 8 give to your Majesties Royal Daughter this Christmas the comfortable news of the near expiring of her great troubles and sufferings as unto the Prince your Son the congratulation of being arrived to a most excellent Princess And having thus given your Lordships an Accompt of his Proceedings touching the Palatinate he will by your Lordships good favors proceed to the other part of that Charge concerning the Marriage And first touching his hopes and assurances that he is charged to have given to his late Majesty and Ministers of State here in England of the Spaniards real proceedings in the said Match when he said he knew they never meant it He saith he never gave any hopes of their proceedings but such and the very same that were first given to him without adding or diminishing neither could he have done otherwise either with honesty or safety And he further saith That the hopes he gave were not upon any Intelligence but as well in that of the Match as the other of the Palatinate his Advertisements were grounded upon all the Assurances both of Words and Writing that could possibly pass between Christians as will be made evidently appear by his Dispatch of 9 September 1623 which he humbly desires may be read if the length of it may not displease The substance being to shew all the Engagements and Promises of the King of Spain that he really intended the Match And the causes why the Conde Olivares pretended to the Duke of Buckingham that the Match was not formerly meant was onely thereby to free himself from Treating any longer with the said Earl to the end that he might treat for larger Conditions in point of Religion with the said Duke The said Conde Olivares taking advantage of having the Person of his Majesty then Prince in his hands And with this Dispatch the said Earl acquainted his Majesty that now is in Spain before he sent it And by this Dispatch the Earl doubteth not but that it will appear to this Honorable Court that whilest the Treating of this business was in hand he proceeded in that not onely with care and industry but with some measure of vigilancy And for clearing an Objection that hath been alleadged that the Match was never meant before the Dukes coming into Spain nor after the Earl craveth leave to set down some few Reasons of many which caused him to believe that the said Match was and had been really meant and that it was so conceived by both their Majesties and the King of Spain and their Ministers on both sides For first The Duke of Buckingham certified his late Majesty that the business of the Marriage was brought to a happy Conclusion whereupon
that publick Trust reposed in him when the Proxies were deposited in his hands with publick and legal Declaration with an instrument by a Secretary of State to the King of Spain leading and directing the use of them and the same being then instrumentum stipulatum wherein as well the King of Spain was interessed by the acceptation of the substitution as the Prince by granting of the Proxies he could not in honesty fail the publick Trust without clear and undoubted warrant which as soon as he had he obeyed So as the Case standing thus the said Earl is very confident that the supposed Countermands Directions and Restrictions when they should be perused and considered of will appear to have been very slender and insufficient warrant against the aforesaid Orders and Reasons before specified And is also as confident That what is assured out of his the said Earls Dispatches will also appear to be misunderstood and that if he had proceeded to the execution of the Desponsories before he received direct and express commandment to the contrary by the aforesaid Letters November 13. 1623. which he readily and punctually obeyed he had not under favor broken his Instructions or deserved any blame for lack of assurance of the restitution of the Palatinate and Temporal Articles And first of the Palatinate his said Majesty did not send to the said Earl express Directions not to dispatch the Desponsories until a full conclusion were had of the other Treaty of the Palatinate together with that of the Marriage as by the said Article is alledged onely his late Majesty by the aforesaid Letters of October 8. required the said Earl so to endeavor that his Majesty might have the joy of both at Christmas Whereas his Instructions of May 14. 1621. were express that he should not make the business of the Palatinate a condition of the Marriage And his late Majesties Letters of December 30. 1623. were fully to the same effect Yet did the said Earl according to what was intimated by the said Letters of October 8. so carefully provide therein as that before the Proxies were to be executed he had an absolute answer in the business of the Palatinate the same should be really restored according to his late Majesties desire and the Conde Olivarez both in his Majesties name and in his own desired the said Earl and Sir Walter Aston that they would assure his Majesty of the real performance of the same and intreated if need were they should engage their honor and life for it as by their joynt Dispatches of November 23. 1623. will appear and so much the said Sir Walter Aston and the said Earl agreed should be delivered to them in writing before they would have delivered their Proxies and so the said Earl declared it the which Answer in writing should have been the same which since was given them of Ianuary 8. 1623. And both Sir Walter Aston and the said Earl were confident therein as they by their said Letters of November 23. wrote to his late Majesty as followeth Viz. That his Majesty might according to his desire signified to the said Earl by his Letters of October 8. give as well to his Majesties Daughter that Christmas the comfortable news of the expiring of her great troubles and sufferings as to his Son the Prince the Congratulation of being married to a most worthy and excellent Princess By which it will evidently appear he meant not to leave the business of the Palatinate loose when he intended to proceed to the Marriage but he confessed that he was ever of opinion that the best pawn and assurance his late Majesty could have of the real proceedings of the Palatinate was That they proceeded really to the effecting of the Match and of the same opinion was his late Majesty also and the Lords Commissioners here in England as appeareth by his Instructions dated March 14. 1621. which opinion still continued in them as appeareth by his late Majesties Letters of Ianuary 7. 1622. And as for the Temporal Articles the said Earl saith when the Desponsories were formerly appointed to have been as he remembreth on Friday August 29. before the departure of his Majesty then Prince out of Spain which was onely hindred by the not coming of the Dispensation the Prince appointed him and Sir Walter Aston to meet with the Spanish Commissioners and they drew up the heads of the Temporal Articles wherewith the Prince and the Duke of Buckingham were acquainted and in case the Dispensation had come and the Desponsories been performed on that day there had been no other provision made for them before the Marriage but presently upon the Prince his departure he the said Earl caused them to be drawn into form and sent them to his late Majesty September 27. 1623. desiring to understand his Majesties pleasure with all speed especially if he disapproved any thing in them but never received notice of any dislike thereof until the aforesaid Letters of November 13. 1623. which put off the Desponsories So as it appeareth the said Earl was so far from breaking his Instructions or from having any intention to have proceeded to the execution of the Desponsories before his Majesty and the Prince were satisfied of this point of the Infanta entring into Religion or before convenient assurance as well for the restitution of the Palatinate as performance of the Temporal Articles that he deserveth as he conceiveth under favor no blame so much as in intention but if he had erred in intention onely as he did not the same being never reduced into Act the Fault as he conceiveth was removed by his obedience before the intention was put into execution For so it is in Cases towards God And as to the matter of aggravation against him that he appointed so short a time for the Desponsories as that without extraordinary diligence the Prince had been bound he thereto saith as he said before that he set no day at all thereunto nor could defer it after the Dispensation came from Rome without a direct breach of the Match so long labored in and so much desired yet he and Sir Walter Aston having used all possible industry to discover how the motion of deferring the Match would be taken and finding an absolute resolution in the King of Spain to proceed punctually and to require the Proxies according to the Capitulations within ten dayes after the coming of the Dispensation and that time also getting advertisement from Rome that the Dispensation was granted and would presently be there he the said Earl to the end in so great a Cause he might have a clear and undoubted understanding of his late Majesties pleasure sent a Dispatch of November 1. with all diligence unto his Majesty letting his Majesty know that it could not be possible for him to protract the Marriage above four dayes unless he should hazard the breaking for which he had no warrant But that this was no new Resolution nor the
memory did procure of the said King the Office of High Treasurer of England to the Lord Vicount M. now Earl of M. Which Office at his procurement was given and granted accordingly to the Lord Vicount M. And as a Reward for the said procurement of the same Grant he the said Duke did then receive to his own use of and from the said Lord Vicount M. the sum of 20000 l. of lawful money of England And also in or about the moneth of Ianuary in the sixteenth year of the Reign of the said late King did procure of the said late King of famous memory the Office of Master of the Wards and Liveries to and for Sir L. C. afterward Earl of M. which Office was upon the same procurement given and granted to the said Sir L.C. And as a reward for the same procurement he the said Duke had to his own use or to the use of some other person by him appointed of the said Sir L.C. the sum of Six thousand pounds of lawful money of England contrary to the Dignity of our Soveraign Lord the King and against the duty that should have been performed by the said Duke unto him These as also the Eleventh Article were enlarged and aggravated by Mr. Pym in this manner My Lords ALthough I know that I shall speak to my own disadvantage yet I shall labor to speak with as little disadvantage to the matter as I can I have no learning or ornament whereby I might shew my self and I shall think it enough plainly to shew the matter For all that I aim at is that I may lose nothing of the Cause And therefore my Lords I shall apply my self with as much convenient brevity as one that knows that your Lordships time is much more precious then my words Your Lordships being such Judges as will measure things by true and natural proportions and not by the proportion of the action or expression The first entrance into my service must be reading the Articles My Lords This Charge for matter of Fact is so notorious and apparent that it needs no proof that these Honors have been procured And therefore I will only insist upon the Consequence First I will shew That by this fact the Duke hath committed a great Offence And secondly That this Offence hath produced a great Grievance to the Commonwealth And I will conclude in strengthening the whole by some Presidents of former times that Parliaments have proceeded in that course in which your Lordships are like to proceed First to prove it a fault or an offence I must prove that there was a duty for every fault presupposeth a duty And in this case the first work is to shew that the Duke was bound to do otherwise For which I need to alleage nothing else then that he is a sworne Servant and Counsellor to the King and so ought to have preferred his Majesties honor and service before his own pride in seeking to Ennoble all that Blood that concerned him And it is not enough to say that it is not questionable For there have been Great men questioned in the like cases There be some Laws made that are particular according to the temper and occasions of several States There are other Laws that be coessential and collateral with Government and if those Laws be broken all things run to disorder and confusion Such is that Rule observed in all States of suppressing Vice to encourage Vertue by apt Punishment and Rewards And this the fittest Law to insist upon in a Court of Parliament when the Proceedings are not limited either by the Civil or Common Laws but matters are adjudged according as they stand in opposition or conformity with that which is suprema lex Salus populi 2. By this late Law whoever moves the King to bestow Honor which is the greatest reward binds himself to make good a double proportion of Merit in that Party who is to receive it The first of value and excellence the second of continuance and durableness And as this Honor sets men up above others so they should be eminent in vertue beyond others As it is perpetual not ending with their persons but descending upon their posterity so there ought to be in the first root of this Honor some such active merit in the service of the Commonwealth as might transmit a vigorous Example to his Successors whereby they may be raised to an Imitation of the like Vertues He said he would for bear to urge this point further out of a modest respect to those persons whom it did collaterally concern professing his Charge to be wholly against the Duke of Buckingham 3. From the consideration of Honor together with the price of Money The which being compared together may be reduced to two heads may it please your Lordships The one being earthly and base may be bought with a proportionable price of white and red earth Gold and Silver The other which is spiritual which is sublime to which Money cannot be a proportionable price Honor is transcendent in regard it was held a sacred and divine thing insomuch that there was a Temple dedicated to her by the Romans And so I conclude by prescription that Honor is a divine thing for the Scripture calls Kings Gods and then those that are about Kings must needs be resembled to those Powers and Principalities that attend next to the Throne And if Honor be such a divine thing it must not then be bought with so base a price as Money 4. Lastly Honor is a Publick thing it is the reward of Publick Deserts And thus your Lordships have seen that the sale of Honor is an offence unnatural against the Law of Nature Now what an offence this is your Lordships may discern considering the kinds of the offence and the Adjuncts which I now fall upon 1. It extremely deâ—lowers the Flowers of the Crown for it makes them cheap to all beholders 2. It takes from the Crown the most fair and frugal Reward of deserving Servants For when Honor comes to be at so mean a rate as to be sold there is no Great man will look after it 3. It is the way to make a man more studious for lucre and gain then of sufficiencie in Vertue when they know that they shall be preferred to Titles of Honor according to the heaviness of purse and not for the weightiness of their merit 4. It introduceth a strange confusion mingling the meaner with the more pure and refined metal 5. Lastly It is a prodigious scandal to this Nation as the House of Commons think For Examples and Presidents I am confident there are none and your Lordships can look for none because it is not parallel'd to any President But certainly it is now a fit time to make a President of this man this great Duke that hath been lately raised to this transcendent height in our Sphere who thinketh he cannot shine enough unless he dim your Lordships Honors in
his hands great sums which were intendded by his Majesty to be disbursed for the preparing furnishing and victualling of his Royal Navy by which secret and colourable devices the constant and ordinary course of the Exchequer hath been broken there being no means by matter of Record to charge either the Treasurer or Victualler of the Navy with those sums which ought to have come to their hands and to be accompted for to his Majesty and such a confusion and mixture hath been made between the Kings Estate and the Dukes as cannot be cleared by the Legal Entries and Records which ought to be truely and faithfully made and kept both for the safety of his Majesties Treasure and for the indempnity of his Officers and Subjects whom it doth concern And also in the Sixteenth year of the said King and in the Twentieth year of the said King he did procure to himself several Releases from the said King of divers great sums of the Money of the said King by him privately received and which he procured that he might detain the same for the support of his Places Honors and Dignities And these things and divers other of the like kinde as appeareth in the Schedule annexed hath he done to the exceeding diminution of the Revenues of the Crown and in deceit both of our Soveraign Lord the King that now is and of the late King Iames of famous memory and to the detriment of the whole Kingdom Before Mr Sherland entred to open and enlarge upon the Twelfth Article he discoursed in general concerning Honors mentioned in the preceding Article and spake as followeth My Lords IT hath pleased God who hath the disposing even of all things in his hands to cast this service now upon me who did formerly my endeavor to decline it considering the weightiness of the business the greatness of this presence and my manifold defects best known to my self But another that should have with better contentment I doubt not performed this service being fallen now sick there is a necessity imposed on me by the House of Commons wherein I shall be very plain and short according to the warning I had yet I shall deal plainly and faithfully according to the sense of that House by whose command I now appear And since I am now thrust as a Bush into the Gap I hope your Lordships will not expect such a composure and strength of Speech which you have had from others of my Companions The Subject that falls to my lot to speak of before your Lordships are Honor and Iustice two great Flowers of the Crown I confess my self exceeding unfit and unable to speak of these Points before so great an Assembly of such Persons of so great Honor and such Superior Judges of this Kingdom but I must take my Lot It pleaseth your Lordships as in Sphere to take knowledge of the Grievances presented by the Commons House which I desire and hope your Lordships will not take presumption May it please your Lordships the parts of this Charge as you discern upon the reading of it are two the one general the other particular The general is perverting the ancient and noble course of attaining to the Titles of Honor. 2. The other the compulsion or inforcement of men unwilling to purchase Honor. For the first by way of Protestation I am commanded by the House of Commons to say that they repine not at their advancement upon whom those Honors were conferred but they think them worthy thereof yet they wish for their sakes and the safety of this Nation their vertues had solely raised them and that they had not been forced and constrained to contribute to this bottomless Gulf to attain their Titles They complain again of this unworthy way brought in by this great man they fall upon this in this manner and found the Evils under which the Commonwealth suffers and the Causes of them being two principal Evils which are the decay and stopping of the Trade and the Determination of Honor. In examination of which second Evil the Trade and Comerce of Honor we have as the Commons do conceive confitentem reum For he endeavouring to colour the matter sayes for himself That he was not the onely introducer and first bringer in of this but they finde that he was the first that defiled this Virgin of Honor so publickly making an accompt that all things and persons should stoop and subject themselves to his vain desires and extravagancy Now that this comerce of Honor is an Offence then to prove what kinde of Offence it is is the onely thing I shall trouble your Lordships with 1. And first that it is an Offence I shall draw my first Argument from the Nature of Honor Honor is a Beam of Vertue now this Honor can be no more fixed upon an undeserving Person for Money then Fire can be struck out of a Stick 2. From the Suject of Honor which is Merit for the which no price ought to be paid to any great man by any undeserving person for the same but their own merit and desert Then he passed to the Grievances which are caused by the selling of Titles and they are Three 1. First it is prejudicial to the Noble Barons of this Kingdom 2. To the King by disabling him to reward extraordinary vertues 3. To the Kingdom which comprehends both King Lords and people For the first He said he would not trouble their Lordships with recital how Ancient how Famous the Degree of Barons hath been in these Western Monarchies He said the Baronage of England hath longer upheld that Dignity and doth yet retain a greater height then in any other Nation they are great Judges a Court of the last resort they are great Counsellors of State and not onely for the present but as Law-makers Counsellors for the time to come and this not by Delegacy and Commission but by Birth and Inheritance So that when any man shall be made a Member of this great Body who is not qualified for the performance of such noble Functions it must needs be a prejudice to the whole body and dishonor to the head As if a little water be put into a great vessel of Wine as it receives spirit and strength from the Wine so it doth impart some degrees of its own infirmity and coldness to the Wine Secondly It is prejudicial to the King not that it can disable him from giving Honor for that is a power inseparable but by making Honor ordinary it becomes as an incompetent Reward for extraordinavertue when men are made noble they are taken out of the Press of the common sort and how can it chuse but fall in estimation if Honor it self be made a Press Thirdly It is prejudicial to the Kingdom the Stories and Records are full of the great assistance which the Crown hath received from the Barons both in Forein and Domestick Actions not onely by their own persons but by their Retinue and
Scotland and Ireland and they will tell you Sejanus pride was so excessive as Tacitus saith he neglected all Councel mixed his businesses and service with the Prince seeming to confound their Actions and was often stiled Imperatoris laborum socius How lately and how often hath this Man commixed his Actions in Discourses with ACtions of the Kings My Lords I have done you see the Man onely this which was conceived by the Knights Citizens and Burgesses should be boldly by me spoken That by him came all these evils in him we finde the Cause and on him we expect the Remedies and to this we met your Lordships in Conference to which as your Wisdom invites us so we cannot doubt but in your Lordships Wisdom Greatness and Power we shall in due time finde Judgment as he deserves I conclude by presenting to your Lordships the particular Censure of the Bishop of Ely reported in the 11 Rich. 1. and to give you a short view of his faults He was first of all noted to be Luxurious secondly He married his own Kinred to Personages of highest rank and places thirdly No mans business was done without his help fourthly He would not suffer the Kings Council to advise in Matters of State fifthly He grew to such a height of Pride that no man was thought worthy to speak unto him and lastly His Castles and Forts of Trust he did obscuris ignotis hominibus tradere his doom was this Per totam insulam publicè proclamatur periat qui perdere cuncta festinat opprimatur ne omnes opprimat Sir Dudley Diggs having made the Prologuâ— and Sir Iohn Elliot the Epilogue in the Impeachment of the Duke they were both by the Kings Command committed to the Tower Upon the Impeachment of the Duke a Paper was privately conveyed to the King importing THat this great opposition against the Duke was stirred up and maintained by such as seek the destruction of this free Monarchy Because they finde it not yet ripe to attempt against the King himself they endeavor it through the sides of the Duke The persons agreeing in this one mischeif are of divers sorts and humors First Medling and busie persons who love popular Speeches Secondly Govetous Landlords Inclosers Depopulators c. who being of the Parliament ease themselves in Subsidies and lay it on the true Commons and cry out the grievances are caused by the Duke Thirdly Recusants who hate the Duke for the breach of the Spanish Match Fourthly Persons indebted who by priviledge of Parliament avoid payment Fifthly Puritans and Sectaries though two of them scarcely agree in what they would have Haters of Government and would have the Kings power extinguished in matters Ecclesiastical and limited in Civil Sixtly Male-contents who look upon the Duke with an evil eye because themselves are not preferred Seventhly Lawyers who are very fit in Parliaments to second any Complaint against â—oth Church and King and all his Servants with their Customs Antiquities Records Statutes Presidents and Stories Eighthly Merchants and Citizens who deceive the King of Custom Ninethly Innovators Plebicolae That since the time of Henry the Sixth these Parliamentary discoursings might never be suffered as being but certain symptomes of Subsequent Rebellions Civil Wars and the dethroning of our King and no one Patriot daring to oppose them least he incur the reputation of a Fool or Coward in his Countreys Cause His Majesty therefore strengthned himself ever with some Favorite as whom he might better trust then many of the Nobility tainted with this desire of Oligarchy It behoveth without doubt his Majesty to uphold the Duke against them who if he be but decourted it will be the Corner Stone on which the demolishing of his Monarchy will be builded For if they prevail with this they have hatched a thousand other demands to pull the Feathers of Royalty They will appoint him Counsellors Servants Alliances Limits of Expences and accompt of his Revenue cheifly if they can they will now dazle him in the beginning of his raign Lastly King James and King Charls are the Dukes Accusers in all the Aspersions that are laid upon him King James for the Money destined for the Wars in his time spent in Treaties c. And his Majesty can testifie for the things done in his time And all these though actions of the King are imputed to the Duke Who if he suffer for obeying his Soveraign the next attempt will be to call the King to accompt for any thing he undertakes which doth not prosperously succeed as all men would desire it If it please his Majesty to remove and set aside all these disadvantages he shall find the Charge against the Duke very empty and of small moment And if his Majesty and the Dukes Grace think it no impeachment to their Honors all that the Parliament hath objected against the Duke except two or three things that may receive an Answer is pardoned at the Kings Coronation which benefit every poor Subject enjoyeth May 11. The King came to the Parliament and spake to the House of Peers as followeth My Lords THe cause and onely cause of my coming to you this day is to express the sense I have of all your Honors for he that toucheth any of you toucheth me in a very great measure I have thought fit to take order for the punishing some insolent speeches lately spoken I have been too remiss heretofore in punishing such speeches as concern my self Not that I was greedy of their monies but that Buckingham through his importunity would not suffer me to take notice of them lest he might be thought to have set me on and that he might come the forwarder to his Trial. And to approve his innocencie as touching the matters against him I my self can be a Witness to clear him in every one of them I speak not this to take any thing out of your hands but to shew the reason why I have not hitherto punished those insolent speeches against my self And now I hope you will be as tender of my Honor when time shall serve as I have been sensible of yours And so his Majesty was pleased to depart The same day this following Message was brought from the Commons to the Lords by Sir Nathanael Rich. THe Commons taking into serious consideration the many mischiefs and inconveniences which this renowned Kingdom doth now suffer threatening apparent danger to the King and Common-wealth have by search and disquisition into the Causes thereof found that they do principally flow from the exorbitant power and abusive carriage of the Duke of Buckingham whereof he hath this Parliament béen impeached before their Lordships by the Commons besides an accusation of a Péer in their own House who hath charged him as they are informed of High Treason They therefore with one voice make an entire Declaration That they hold it a thing of dangerous Consequence both for the present and future times that a man of so
in Parliament and in particular touching the Earl of Arundel whereupon we received a gracious Answer That in convenient time we should receive a fuller Answer which we have long and dutifully attended And now at this time so great a business being in handling in the House we are pressed by that business to be humble suitors to your Majesty for a gracious and present Answer Which being read was approved of by the House and the said Committee appointed to present the same unto his Majesty from the House at such time as the Lord Chamberlain shall signifie unto them that his Majesty is pleased to admit them to his presence The 11 of May the Lord President reported the Kings Answer to the said Petition That he did little look for such a Message from the House That himself had been of the House and did never know such a Message from the one House unto the other Therefore when he received a Message fit to come from them to their Soveraign they shall receive an Answer The Lord President further Reported That the Lords Committees appointed to deliver the Petition to the King did thereupon withdraw and required him humbly to desire his Majesty to be pleased to let them know unto what point of the said Petition he takes this Exception and that his Majesty willed him to say this of himself viz. The Exception the King taketh is at the peremptoriness of the Term To have a Present Answer And the King wonders at their impatience since he hath promised them an answer in convenient time Hereupon the House altered their former Petition leaving out the word Present and appointed the former Committee humbly to deliver the same to his Majesty The 13 of May the Lord President reported the Kings Answer to the Petition viz. It is true the word Present was somewhat strange to his Majesty because they did not use it from one House to another but now that his Majesty knows their meaning they shall know this from him that they shall have his Answer so soon as conveniently he can And this his Majesty will assure them it shall be such an Answer as they shall see will not trench upon the Priviledges of the House The Lords having agreed on another Petition to the King wherein they acknowledged him to be a Prince of as much goodness as ever King was The 19 of May the Lord Chamberlain signified to their Lordships That his Majesty being acquainted therewith is pleased that this House attend him at two of the Clock this day in the Afternoon at Whitehall On which day the Lords delivered the Petition to his Majesty who upon the 20 May returned this Answer My Lords I See that in your Petition you acknowledge me a King of as much goodness as ever King was for which I thank you and I will endeavor by the Grace of God never to deserve other But in this I observe that you contradict your selves for if you believe me to be such as you say I am you have no reason to mistrust the sincerity of my Promises For whereas upon often Petitions made by you unto me concerning this business I have promised to give you a full Answer with all convenient speed by this again importuning of me you seem to mistrust my former promises But it may be said there is an Emergent cause for that I have delivered a Member of the Lower-House In this My Lords by your favour you are mistaken for the Causes do no way agree for that he that was committed of the House of Commons was committed for words spoken before both Houses which being such as I had just cause to commit him yet because I found they might be words onely misplaced and not ill meant and were so conceived by many honest men I was content upon his interpretation to release him without any suit from the Lower-House whereas my Lord of Arundel's fault was directly against my self having no relation to the Parliament yet because I see you are so impatient I will make you a fuller Answer then yet I have done not doubting but that you will rest contented therewith It is true I committed him for a cause which most of you know and though it had been no more I had reason to do it yet my Lords I assure you that I have things of far greater importance to lay to his charge which you must excuse me for not no tell you at this time because it is not yet ripe and it would much prejudice my service to do it and this by the word of a King I do not speak out of a desire to delay you but as soon as it is possible you shall know the cause which is such as I know you will not judge to be any breach of your Priviledges For my Lords by this I do not mean to shew the power of a King by diminishing your Priviledges This Answer being read it was ordered That the Committee for Priviledges should meet and consider how farther to proceed with dutifull respect to his Majesty and yet so as it may be for the preservation of the Priviledges of the Peers of this Land and the Liberties of the House of Parliament The 24 of May the Lord President reported the Petition agreed on by the Lords Committees for Priviledges c. to be presented to the King which was in haec verba May it please your most Excellent Majesty WHatever our care and desire is to preserve our right of Péers yet it is far from our thoughts either to distrust or to press any thing that stands not with the affection and duty of most dutiful and loyal Subjects And therefore in all humility we cast our selves before your Majesty assuring our selves in the word of a King that with all conveniencie possible your Majesty will please either to restore the Peer to his place in Parliament or express such a cause as may not infringe our Priviledges The Petition was generally approved and ordered to be presented to his Majesty by the whole House and the Earl of Carlisle and the Lord Carlton to go presently to know the Kings pleasure when they shall attend his Majesty Who being returned reported That his Majesty hath appointed that Afternoon at two of the clock for the same The 25. of May the Lord Keeper delivered the Kings Answer unto the said Petition to be read in haec verba viz. My Lords YOur often coming to me about this matter made me somewhat doubt you did mistrust me But now I see you rely wholly on me I assure you it shall prevail more upon me then all importunities And if you had done this at first I should have given you content And now I assure you I will use all possible speed to give satisfaction and at the furthest before the end of this Session of Parliament This being read the House was moved the second time That all businesses might be laid
by the Books of our Laws that Liberty is a thing so favored of the Law that the Law will not suffer the continuance of a man in prison for any longer time then of necessity it must And therefore the Law will neither suffer the Party Sheriffs or Judges to continue a man in prison by their power and pleasure It doth speak of the delivery of a man out of prison with as reasonable expedition as may be And upon this reason it hath been resolved that howsoever the Law alloweth that there may be a Term between the Teste of an Original Writ and the Return of the same where there is only a Summons and no Imprisonment of the body yet the Law will not allow that there should be a Term between the Teste of a Writ of Capias and the Return of the same where the body of a man is to be imprison'd insomuch that it will give no way that the party shall have power to continue the body of a man longer time in prison then needs must so tender is the Law of the Subjects Liberty Monday the 27. of November the Attorney-General argued for the King That this was a very great Cause and hath raised great expectation and he was afraid that those Gentlemen whom it concerns have rather advised their Councils then their Councils them For the first Exception That the Return is not positive but hath relation to some others He did conceive it was positive enough For said he the words are Quod detentus est sub custodia mea per speciale mandatum Domini Regis The other words mihi significatum they follow after but are not part of the affirmation made before it And if they will have it as they seem to understand it then they must return the words thus Quod significatum est mihi per Dominos Privati Consilii quod detentus est per speciale mandatum Domini Regis And then it had not been their own proper Return but the signification of another the Lords of the Council The turning of the sentence would resolve this point the thing it self must speak for it self It is clear it is a positive Return that the detaining is by the command of the King and the rest of the Return is rather satisfaction to the Court then any part of the Return And for the other Exception That the Cause of the Cause is returned and not the Cause it self He said Among the Logicians there are two Causes there is Causa causans and Causa causata The Causa causans here in this Case is not the Warrant from the Lords of the Council for that is Causa causata But the primary and original Cause which is Causa causans is Speciale mandatum Domini Regis the other is but the Councils signification or testification or Warrant for him that made the Return And for the other Exception The Cause is imperfect because it shews only the Cause of detaining in Prison and not the Cause of the first Commitment He conceives it is sufficient for an Officer of the Law to answer That the Writ is a Command to make a Return of the detaining of the Prisoner and he accordingly makes a Return of the Detention and if the Keeper of the Prison had only said they were detained per speciale mandatum c. it had been good Then he proceeded to the matter of the Return and to answer the Book-Cases and Records that had been cited by the Council for the Prisoners and to produce Presidents on the Kings behalf which are extant in Print to which the Reader is referred Afterwards Sir Nicholas Hide Chief Justice Justice Dodderidge Justice Iones and Justice Whitlock being upon the Bench and Sir Iohn Heveningham and the forementioned Prisoners being brought to the Bar Sir Nicholas Hide Lord Chief Justice by the consent and direction of the Judges spake to this purpose That the Court hath seriously considered what hath been spoken by either side and are grown to a resolution And that his Brothers have enjoined him to deliver unto you the resolution of the whole Court And therefore said he though it be delivered by my mouth it is the resolution of us all I am sure you expect Justice from hence and God forbid we should sit here but to do Justice to all men according to our best skill and knowledge as it is our oaths and duties so to do But this is a Case of very great weight and great expectation and requires more solemn Arguments then the time will now permit The Exceptions which have been taken to this Return are two the one for the form the other for the substance First for the form because it is not returned as they say positively and absolutely but with reference to a Warrant of the Lords of the Council Now the Court is of opinion That this is a positive and absolute Return upon this reason That the Keeper of the Prison first returns that they are detained by the special command of the King And if they had ceased there it had been positive And for that which follows That it was signified to him by the Lords of the Council this is only to certifie the Court that he returned the Cause truly and not to shew us that he had no knowledge of the Cause but by the signification of the Lords of the Council There is not one word in the Writ that demands the cause why they were taken but why they are detained So that that point in the Writ is sufficiently answered which was only to certifie the cause of the detention And therefore we resolve That the form of this Return is good The next thing is the main point in Law Whether the substance or matter of the Return be good or no Where in the substance is this He doth certifie that they are detained in Prison by the special command of the King And whether this be good in Law or no is the Question Here the Lord Chief Justice did mention the several Presidents and Book-Cases cited by each side too long to be here related And concluded That that which is now to be judged by us is this Whether one that is committed by the Kings authority and no Cause shewn of his Commitment according as here it is upon this Return whether we ought to deliver him by Bail or to remand him back again Where by the way you must know that we can take notice only of this Return That when the Case appears to us no otherwise then by the Return we are not bound to examine the truth thereof but the sufficiencie of the Return We cannot judge upon rumors or reports but upon that which is before us on Record which is examinable by us whether it be sufficient or not Mr. Attorney hath told you That the King hath done it And we trust him in great matters And we make no doubt but the King if you seek to him knowing the cause why you
spits and spues out its own rankor and venom You remember how that famous and immortal Statesman the Count of Gondomar fed King James his fancy and rocked him asleep with the soft and sweet sound of Peace to keep up the Spanish Treaty Likewise we were much bound to some Statesmen of our own Country for gaining time by procuring those most advantagious Cessations of Arms in the Palatinate and advancing the Honor and Integrity of the Spanish Nation and vilifying the Hollanders remonstrating to King James That that State was most ungrateful both to his Predecessor Queen Elizabeth and his Sacred Majesty That the States were more obnoxious then the Turk and perpetually injured his Majesties loving Subjects in the East-Indies and likewise they have usurped from his Majesty the Regality and unvaluable profit of the Narrow-Seas in fishing upon the English Coast c. This great Statesman had but one principal means to further their great and good designs which was to set on King James that none but the Puritan-Faction which plotted nothing but Anarchy and his Confusion were averse to this most happy Union We steered on the same Course and have made great use of this Anarchical Election and have prejudicated and anticipated the Great one that none but the Kings Enemies and his are chosen of this Parliament c. We have now many strings to our Bow and have strongly fortified our Faction and have added two Bulwarks more For when King James lived you know he was very violent against Arminianism and interrupted with his pestilent Wit and deep Learning our strong Designs in Holland and was a great Friend to that old Rebel and Heretick the Prince of Orange Now we have planted that Soveraign Drug Arminianism which we hope will purge the Protestants from their Heresie and it flourisheth and bears fruit in due season The Materials which build up our Bulwark are the Projectors and Beggers of all ranks and qualities Howsoever both these Factions cooperate to destroy the Parliament and to introduce a new species and form of Government which is Oligarchy Those serve as direct Mediums and Instruments to our end which is the Universal Catholick Monarchy Our foundation must be Mutation and Mutation will cause a Relaxation which will serve as so many violent diseases as the Stone Gout c. to the speedy distraction of our perpetual and insufferable anguish of body which is worse then death it self We proceed now by Councel and mature deliberation how and when to work upon the Duke's Iealousie and Revenge And in this we give the honor to those which merit it which are the Church-Catholicks There is another matter of Consequence which we take much into our consideration and tender care which is to slave off the Puritans that they hang not in the Duke's ears They are impudent subtile people And it is to be feared lest they should negotiate a Reconciliation between the Duke and the Parliament T is certain the Duke would gladly have reconciled himself to the Parliament at Oxford and Westminster But now we assure our selves we have so handled the matter that both Duke and Parliament are irreconcileable For the better prevention of the Puritans the Arminians have already locked up the Duke's ears And we have those of our own Religion which stand continually at the Duke's Chamber to see who goes in and out We cannot be too circumspect and careful in this regard I cannot choose but laugh to see how some of our own Coat have accoutred themselves you would scarce know them if you saw them And 't is admirable how in speech and gesture they act the Puritans The Cambridge-Scholars to their woful experience shall see we can act the Puritans a little better then they have done the Jesuites They have abused our sacred Patron Saint Ignatius in jest but we will make them smart for it in earnest I hope you will excuse my merry digression For I confess unto you I am at this time transported with joy to see how happily all Instruments and means as well great as less cooperate unto our purposes But to return unto the main Fabrick Our foundation is Arminianism The Arminians and Projectors as it appears in the premisses affect mutation This we second and enforce by probable Arguments In the first place we take into consideration the Kings honor and present necessity and we shew how the King may free himself of his Ward as Lewis the Eleventh did And for his great splendor and lustre he may raise a vast Revenue and not be beholden to his Subjects which is by way of Imposition of Excise Then our Church-Catholicks proceed to shew the means how to settle this Excise which must be by a Mercenary Army of Horse and Foot For the Horse we have made that sure They shall be Foreiners and Germans who will eat up the Kings Revenues and spoil the Country wheresoever they come though they should be well paid What havock will they make there when they get no Pay or are not duly paid They will do more mischief then we hope the Army will do We are provident and careful that this Mercenary Army of Two thousand Horse and Twenty thousand Foot shall be taken on and in pay before the Excise be setled In forming the Excise the Country is most likely to rise If the Mercenary Army subjugate the Country then the Soldiers and Projectors shall be paid out of the Confiscations If the Country be too hard for the Soldiers then they must consequently mutiny which is equally advantagious unto us Our superlative design is to work the Protestants as well as the Catholicks to welcom in a Conqueror and that is by this means We hope instantly to dissolve Trades and hinder the building of Shipping in devising probable Designs and putting on the State upon Expeditions as that of Cadiz was in taking away the Merchant Ships so that they may not easily catch and light upon the West-India Fleet c. The Parliament being assembled the Seventeenth day of March His Majesty began with this Speech My Lords and Gentlemen THese Times are for Action Wherefore for Examples sake I mean not to spend much time in Words expecting accordingly that your as I hope good Resolutions will be speedy not spending time unnecessarily or that I may better say dangerously For tedious Consultations at this conjuncture of time are as hurtful as ill Resolutions I am sure you now expect from me both to know the cause of your meeting and what to resolve on Yet I think there is none here but knows that Common danger is the cause of this Parliament and that Supply at this time is the chief end of it So that I need but point to you what to do I will use but few perswasions For if to maintain your own Advices and as now the case stands for the following thereof the true Religion Laws and Liberties of this State and the just Defence of our true
onely an Award and no Judgement and in the L. Chief Justice his Argument there was no word spoken that the King might commit or detain without cause For the King to commit a man is indignum Regi Mercy and Honor flow immediately from the King Judgement and Justice are his too but they flow from his Ministers the Sword is carried before him but the Scepter in his hands These are true Emblems of a good King The Law admits not the King power of detaining in Prison at pleasure In antient times Prisons were but pro custodia carceres non ad poenam sed ad custodiam Admit the King may commit a man yet to detain him as long as he pleaseth is dangerous and then a man shall be punished before his offence Imprisonment is a Maceration of the body and horror to the minde it is vita pejor morte Mr Selden last of all produced the Statutes Presidents and Book-Cases which were expresseâ— in point to the Question in hand and the House commanded that Case in the Lord Chief Justice Andersons Book all of his own hand-writing to be openly read And for the Presidentâ— cited by the Kings Council in 34 years of the Queen as the Opinion of all the Judges certainly there was a great mistake in it and the mistake was the greater when it passed as currant by the Judges of the Kings-Bench in the last Case of the Habeas Corpus And that the truth of the Opinion may clearly appear let us read the words out of the Lord Chief Justice Andersons Report out of the Book written with his own hand which will contradict all those Apocrypha Reports that go upon the Case The words of the Report were these Divers persons fueront committes a several temps a several prysons sur pleasure sans bon cause parte de queux estiant amesnes en banck le Roy. Et parte en le Commune banck fuerunt accordant a le ley de la terre mise a large discharge de le imprisonment pur que aucunt grands fueront offendus procure un commandment a les Iudges que ils ne fera ainsi apres Ceo nient meins les Iudges ne surcease mes per advise enter eux ils fesoint certain Articles le tenour de queux ensus deliver eux al seignieurs Chancelor Treasurer eux subscribe avec touts lour mainies les Articles sont come erisnoint We her Majesties Iustices of both Benches and Barons of the Exchequer desire your Lordships that by some good means some order may be taken that her Highness Subjects may not be committed or detained in prison by commandment of any Noble man or Councellor against the Laws of the Realm either else to help us to have access to her Majesty to the end to become Suitors to her for the same for divers have been imprisoned for suing ordinary Actions and Suits at the Common-Law until they have been constrained to leave the same against their wills and put the same to order albeit Iudgement and Execution have been had therein to their great losses and griefs for the aid of which persons her Majesties Writs have sundry times been directed to sundry persons having the Custody of such persons unlawfully imprisoned upon which Writs no good or lawfull cause of imprisonment hath been returned or certified Whereupon according to the Laws they have been discharged of their imprisonment some of which persons so delivered have been again committed to prison in secret places and not to any common or ordinary Prison or lawfull Officer or Sheriff or other lawfully authorized to have or keep a Goal So that upon complaint made for their delivery the Queens Courts cannot tell to whom to direct her Majesties Writs and by this means Iustice cannot be done And moreover divers Officers and Serjeants of London have been many times committed to Prison for lawfull executing of her Majesties Writs sued forth of her Majesties Court at Westminster and thereby her Majesties Subjects and Officers are so terrified that they dare not sue or execute her Majesties Laws her Writs and Commandments Divers others have been sent for by Pursevants and brought to London from their dwellings and by unlawfull imprisonment have been constrained not only to withdraw their lawfull suits but have been also compelled to pay the Pursevants so bringing such persons great sums of money All which upon complaint the Iudges are bound by Office and Oath to relieve and help by and according to her Majesties Laws And where it pleaseth your Lordships to will divers of us to set down in what Cases a Prisoner sent to custody by her Majesty or her Councel are to be detained in Prison and not to be delivered by her Majesties Court or Iudges We think that if any person be committed by her Majesties command from her person or by order from the Council board and if any one or two of her Council commit one for high Treason such persons so in the Cases before committed may not be delivered by any of her Courts without due Trial by the Law and Iudgement of acquittal had Nevertheless the Iudges may award the Queens Writ to bring the bodies of such Prisoners before them and if upon return thereof the causes of their commitment be certified to the Iudges as it ought to be then the Iudges in the Cases before ought not to deliver him but to remand the Prisoner to the place from whence he came which cannot conveniently be done unless notice of the cause in general or else in special be given to the Keeper or Goaler that shall have the Custody of such a Prisoner All the Iudges and Barons did subscribe their names to these Articles Ter. Paschae 34 Eliz. and delivered one to the L. Chancellor and another to the L. Treasurer after which time there did follow more quietness then before in the Cause before mentioned After the reading of this Report Sir Edw. Cook said That of my own knowledge this Book was written with my L. Andersons own hand it is no flying report of a young Student I was Solicitor then and Treasurer Burley was as much against Commitment as any of this Kingdom It was the White Staves that made this stir Let us draw towards a conclusion The Question is whether a Feeman can be imprisoned by the King without setting down the cause I leave it as bare as Aesops Crow they that argue against it Humores moti non remoti corpus destruunt It is a Maxime the Common-Law hath admeasured the Kings Prerogative that in no Case it can prejudice the Inheritance of the Subjects had the Law given the Prerogative to that which is taken it would have set some time to it else mark what would follow I shall have an Estate of Inheritance for life or for years in my Land or propriety in my Goods and I shall be a Tenant at will for my liberty I shall have
That the free Subjects of this Realm ought not to be imprisoned without cause shewed But by this Clause a Soveraign Power will be admitted and left intire to his Majesty sufficient to control the force of Law and to bring in this new and dangerous Interpretation That the free Subjects of this Realm ought not by Law to be imprisoned without cause shewed unless it be by Soveraign Power In a word this Clause if it should be admitted would take away the effect of every part of the Petition and become destructive to the whole for thence will be the Exposition touching the Billeting of Soldiers and Mariners in free mens houses against their wills and thence will be the Exposition touching the Times and Places for execution of the Law Marshal contrary to the Laws and Statutes of the Realm The scope of this Petition as I have before observed is not to amend our Case but to restore us to the same state we were in before whereas if this Clause be received in stead of mending the condition of the poor Subjects whose Liberties of late have been miserably violated by some Ministers we shall leave them worse then we found them in stead of curing their wounds we shall make them deeper We have set bounds to our desires in this great Business whereof one is not to diminish the Prerogative of the King by mounting too high and if we bound our selves on the other side with this limit not to abridge the lawful Priviledges of the Subject by descending beneath that which is meet no man we hope can blame us My Lords as there is mention made in the additional Clause of Soveraign Power so is there likewise of a trust reposed in his Majesty touching the use of Soveraign Power The word Trust is of great Latitude and large extent and therefore ought to be well and warily applied and restrained especially in the Case of a King There is a trust inseparably reposed in the Persons of the Kings of England but that trust is regulated by Law for example when Statutes are made to prohibite things not mala in se but onely mala quia prohibita under certain forfeitures and penalties to accrue to the King and to the Informers that shall sue for the breach of them The Commons must and ever will acknowledge a Regal and Soveraign Prerogative in the King touching such Statutes that it is in his Majesties absolute and undoubted Power to grant Dispensations to particular persons with the Clauses of Non obstante to do as they might have done before those Statutes wherein his Majesty conferring grace and favour upon some doth not do wrong to others but there is a difference between those Statutes and the Laws and Statutes whereon the Petition is grounded by those Statutes the Subject hath no interest in the penalties which are all the fruit such Statutes can produce until by Suit or Information commenced he become intituled to the particular forfeitures whereas the Laws and Statutes mentioned in our Petition are of another nature there shall your Lordships finde us to rely upon the good old Statute called Magna Charta which declareth and confirmeth the ancicient Common Laws of the Liberties of England There shall your Lordships also finde us also to insist upon divers other most material Statutes made in the time of King E. 4. and E. 3. and other famous Kings for explanation and ratification of the Lawful Rights and Priviledges belonging to the Subjects of this Realm Laws not inflicting Penalties upon Offenders in malis prohibitis but Laws declarative or positive conferring or confirming ipso facto an inherent Right and Interest of Liberty and Freedom in the Subjects of this Realm as their Birthrights and Inheritance descendable to their Heirs and Posterity Statutes incorporate into the Body of the Common Law over which with reverence be it spoken there is no Trust reposed in the Kings Soveraign Power or Prerogative Royal to enable him to dispense with them or to take from his Subjects that Birthright or Inheritance which they have in their Liberties by vertue of the Common Law and of these Statutes But if this Clause be added to our Petition we shall then make a dangerous overture to confound this good destination touching what Statutes the King is trusted to controll by dispensations and what not and shall give an intimation to posterity as if it were the opinion both of the Lords and Commons assembled in this Parliament that there is a Trust reposed in the King to lay aside by his Soveraign Power in some amergent cases as well of the Common Law and such Statutes as declare or ratifie the Subjects Liberty or confer Interest upon their persons as those other Penal Statutes of such nature as I have mentioned before which as we can by no means admit so we believe assuredly that it is far from the desire of our most Gracious Soveraign to affect so vast a Trust which being transmitted to a Successor of a different temper might enable him to alter the whole frame and fabrick of the Commonwealth and to dissolve that Government whereby his Kingdom hath flourished for so many years and ages under his Majesties most Royal Ancestors and predecessors Our next Reason is That we hold it contrary to all course of Parliament and absolutely repugnant to the very nature of a Petition of Right consisting of particulars as ours doth to clog it with a general Saving or Declaration to the weakning of the Right demanded and we are bold to renew with some confidence our Allegation that there can be no Precedent shewed of any such Clause in any such Petitions in times past I shall insist the longer upon this particular and labour the more carefully to clear it because your Lordships were pleased the last day to urge against us the Statutes of 25 and 28 of E. 1. as arguments to prove the contrary and seemed not to be satisfied with that which in this point we had affirmed True it is that in those Statutes there are such Savings as your Lordships have observed but I shall offer you a clear Answer to them and to all other Savings of like nature that can be found in any Statutes whatsoever First in the general and then I shall apply particular Answers to the particulars of those two Statutes whereby it will be most evident that those examples can no ways sute with the matter now in hand To this end it will be necessary that we consider duely what that question is which indeed concerneth a Petition and not an Act of Parliament This being well observed by shewing unto your Lordships the difference between a Petition for the Law and the Law ordained upon such a Petition and opening truly and perspicuously the course that was holden in framing of Statutes before 2 H. 5. different from that which ever since then hath been used and is still in use amongst us and by noting the times wherein these Statutes
People to pray for him hoping that God would enable him by some satisfactory benefit to make amends and comfort his Subjects for those pressures To these temporal Precedents of antient times which were alledged he added an Ecclesiastical Precedent out of a book called Pupilla Oculi being published for the instruction of Confessors in the Title De participantibus cum excommunicatis fol. 59. All the Articles of Magna Charta are inserted with this direction Hos articulos ignorare non debent quibus incumbit confessiones audire infra provinciam Cantuariensem He likewise remembred the Proclamation 8. Iac. for the calling in and burning of Doctor Cowel's book for which these reasons are given For mistaking the true state of the Parliament of the Kingdom and fundamental constitution and priviledges thereof For speaking irreverently of the Common Law it being a thing utterly unlawful for any Subject to speak or write against that Law under which he liveth and which we are sworn and resolve to maintain From these Precedents he collected that if former Parliaments were so careful of false rumors and news they would have been much more tender of such doctrines as these which might produce true occasions of discord betwixt the King and his People If those who reported the King would lay Impositions and break his Laws were thought such hainous offenders how much more should this man be condemned who perswaded the King he is not bound to keep those Laws If that great King was so far from challenging any right in this kinde that he professed his own sorrow and repentance for grieving his Subjects with unlawful charges If Confessors were enjoyned to frame the Consciences of the People to the observance of these Laws certainly such Doctrine and such a Preacher as this would have been held most strange and abominable in all these times The third general part was the conclusion or prayer of the Commons which consisted of three Clauses First they reserved to themselves liberty of any other accusation and for this he said there was great reason that as the Doctor multiplied his offences so they may renew their accusations Secondly they saved to themselves liberty of replying to his Answer for they had great cause to think that he who shifted so much in offending would shift much more in answering Thirdly they desire he might be brought to examination and judgement this they thought would be very important for the comfort of the present age for security of the future against such wicked and malitious practises And so he concluded that seeing the cause had strength enough to maintain it self his humble suit to their Lordships was That they would not observe his infirmities and defects to the diminution or prejudice of that strength NOt long after the Commons by their Speaker demanded Judgement of the Lords against the Doctor who not accounting his submission with tears and grief a satisfaction for the great offence wherewith he stood charged gave this Sentence 1. That Dr. Manwaring Doctor in Divinity shall be imprisoned during the pleasure of the House 2. That he be fined one thousand pounds to the King 3. That he shall make such submission and acknowledgement of his offences as shall be set down by a Committee in writing both at the Bar and in the House of Commons 4. That he shall be suspended for the time of three years from the exercise of the Ministery and in the mean time a sufficient preaching Minister shall be provided out of his livings to serve the Cure This suspension and provision to be done by the Ecclesiastical jurisdiction 5. That he shall be hereafter disabled to have any Ecclesiastical Dignity or secular Office 6. That he shall be for ever disabled to preach at the Court hereafter 7. That his said Book is worthy to be burnt and that for the better effecting of this his Majesty may be moved to grant a Proclamation to call in the said Books that they may be all burnt accordingly in London and both the Universities and for the Inhibiting the printing thereof upon a great penalty Doctor Manwarings submission was in these words MAy it please this Honorable House I do here in all sorrow of Heart and true Repentance acknowledge the many Errors and Indiscretions which I have committed in preaching and publishing those two Sermons of mine which I called Religion and Allegiance and my great fault in falling upon this Theame again and handling the same rashly and unadvisedly in my own Parish Church of St. Giles in the Fields the fourth of May last past I do humbly acknowledge those three Sermons to have been full of many dangerous Passages Inferences and scandalous Aspersions in most part of the same And I do humbly acknowledge the Justice of this Honorable House in that Judgement and Sentence passed upon me for my great offence And I do from the bottom of my Heart crave pardon of God the King and this Honorable House and the Church and this Common-wealth in general and those worthy Persons adjudged to be reflected upon by me in particular for these great Errors and Offences Roger Manwaring Another Message was brought from his Majesty by the Speaker Tuesday 5 of June HIs Majesty wished them to remember the Message he last sent them by which he set a day for the end of this Session and he commanded the Speaker to let them know that he will certainly hold that day prefixed without alteration and because that cannot be if the House entertain more business of length he requires them that they enter not into or proceed with any new business which may spend greater time or which may lay any Scandal or Aspersion upon the State-government or Ministers thereof SIr Robert Phillips upon this occasion expressed himself thus I perceive that towards God and towards man there is little hope after our humble and careful endeavors seeing our Sins are many and so great I consider my own infirmities and if ever my Passions were wrought upon then now this Message stirs me up especially when I remember with what moderation we have proceeded I cannot but wonder to see the miserable straight we are now in What have we not done to have merited Former times have given wounds enough to the peoples Liberty we came hither full of wounds and we have cured what we could and what is the return of all but misery and desolation What did we aim at but to have served his Majesty and to have done that that would have made him Great and Glorious if this be a fault then we are all Criminous What shall we do since our humble purposes are thus prevented which were not to have laid any aspersion on the Government since it tended to no other end but to give his Majesty true information of his and our danger And to this we are enforced out of a necessity of duty to the King our Countrey and to Posterity but we
House fearing a sudden dissolution fell into consideration of the weak estate of the Kingdom and of our Friends and Allies abroad of the great strength of the House of Austria and the King of Spains ambition aspiring to an universal Monarchy and his present great preparations for war Hereupon the House was moved to name a select Committee to represent these things to his Majesty with the danger like to insue to this Kingdom if the Parliament be dissolved without a happy conclusion But being satisfied by the Lords of the privy Councel that there was no such cause of fear as the House apprehended the naming of a Committee was for that time deferred Having met in our Collections with a Letter of Mr. Allureds to old Mr. Chamberlain of the Court of Wards and being a concurrent proof to the Passages this day in the House We have thought fit here to mention it viz. Sir YEsterday was a day of desolation among us in Parliament and this day we fear will be the day of our dissolution Upon Tuesday Sir John Elliot moâ—ed that as we intended to furnish his Majesty with money we should also supply him with Counsel which was one part of the occasion why we were sent by the Countrey and called for by his Majesty And since that House was the greatest Councel of the Kingdom where or when should his Majesty have better Counsel then from thence So he desired there might be a Declaration made to the King of the danger wherein the Kingdom stood by the decay and contempt of Religion the insufficiency of his Generals the unfaithfulness of his Officers the weakness of his Councels the exhausting of his Treasure the death of his men the decay of Trade the loss of Shipping the many and powerful Enemies the sew and the poor Friends we had abroad In the enumerating of which the Chancellor of the Dutchy said it was a strange language yet the House commanded Sir John Elliot to go on then the Chancellor desired if he went on that himself might go out whereupon they all bad him begon yet he stayed and heard him out and the House generally inclined to such a Declaration to be presented in an humble and a modesâ— manner not prescribing the King the way but leaving it to his Iudgment for reformation So the next day being Wednesday we had a Message from his Majesty by the Speaker that the Session should end on Wednesday and that therefore we should husband the time and dispatch the old businesses without entertaining new intending to pursue their Declaration they had this Message yesterday morning brought them which I have here inclosed sent you which requiring not to casâ— or lay any aspersion upon any Minister of his Majesty the house was much affected to be so restrained since the House in former times had proceeded by finding and committing John of Gaunt the Kings Son and others and of late have medled with and sentenced the Lord Chancellor Bacon and the Lord Treasurer Cranfield Then Sir Robert Philips spake and mingled his words with weeping Mr. Prynne did the like and Sir Edward Cook overcome with passion seeing the desolation likely to ensue was forced to sit down when he began to speak through the abundance of tears yea the Speaker in his Speech could not refrain from weeping and shedding of tears besides a great many whose great griefs made them dumb and silent yet some bore up in that storm and incouraged others In the end they desired the Speaker to leave the Chair and Mr. Whitby was to come into it that they might speak the freer and the frequenter and commanded no man to go out of the House upon pain of going to the Tower Then the Speaker humbly and earnestly besought the House to give him leave to absent himself for half an hour presuming they did not think he did it for any ill intention which was instantly granted him then upon many Debates about their Liberties hereby infringed and the eminent danger wherein the Kingdom stood Sir Edward Cook told them he now saw God had not accepted of their humble and moderate carriages and fair proceedings and the rather because he thought they dealt not sincerely with the King and with the Countrey in making a true Representation of the causes of all these miseries which now he repented himself since things were come to this pass that he did it not sooner and therefore he not knowing whether ever he should speak in this House again would now do it freely and there protested that the author and cause of all those miseries was the Duke of Buckingham which was entertained and answered with a chearful acclamation of the House as when one good Hound recovers the scent the rest come in with a full cry so they pursued it and every one came on home and laid the blame where they thought the fault was and as they were Voting it to the Question whether they should name him in their intended Remonstrance the Sole or the Principall cause of all their miseries at home and abroad The Speaker having been three hours absent and with the King returned with this Message That the House should then rise being about eleven a clock and no Committees stould sit in the afternoon till to morrow morning What we shall expect this morning God of Heaven knows We shall meet timely this morning partly for the businesse sake and partly because two days since we made an Order that whosoever comes in after prayers payes twelve pence to the poor Sir excuse my hast and let us have your prayers whereof both you and we have here need So inscribling haste I rest Affectionately at your service Thomas Alured This 6. of June 1628. The Message mentioned in this Letter of the 6. of Iune is already before expressed Friday 6. Iune Mr. Speaker brings another Message from the King the day following IN my service to this House I have had many undeserved favours from you which I shall ever with all humbleness acknowledge but none can be greater then that testimony of your confidence yesterday shewed unto me whereby I hope I have done nothing or made any representation to his Majesty but what is for the honour and service of this House and I will have my tongue cleave to my mouth before I will speak to the disadvantage of any Member thereof I have now a Message to deliver unto you Whereas his Majesty understanding that ye did conceive his last Message to restrain you in your just Priviledges to complain of any of his Ministers These are to declare his intentions that he had no meaning of barring you from what hath been your Right but only to avoid all scandals on his Councel and Actions past and that his Ministers might not be nor himself under their names taxed for their Counsel unto his Majesty and that no such particulars should be taken in hand as would ask a longer time of consideration then what
he hath prefixed and still resoves to hold that so for this time all Christendom might take notice of a sweet parting between him and his people Which if it fall out his Majesty will not be long from another meeting when such if there be any at their leisure and convenience may be considered Mr. Speaker proceeded I will observe somewhat out of this Message ye may observe a great inclination in his Majesty to meet in this House I was bold yesterday to take notice of that liberty ye gave me to go to his Majesty I know there are none here but did imagine whither I went but that I knew ye where desirous and content that I should leave you I would not have desired it give me leave to say this Message bars you not of your Right in matter nay not in manner but it reacheth to his Councels past and for giving him Councel in those things which he commanded It is not his Majesties intentions to protect any Abetter of Spain The end of this was that we might meet again sweetly and happily The House of Lords likewise received this Message by the Lord Keeper MY Lords his Majestie takes notice to your great advantage of the proceedings of this house upon the hearing of his Majesties message yesterday He accounts it a fair respect that ye would neither agree of any Committee or send any Message to his Majesty though it were in your own hearts but yeild your selves to his Majesties Message and defer your own resolutions till you meet again at the time appointed by his Majesty Yet his Majesty takes it in extream good part to hear what was in your heart and especially that ye were so sensible of the inconvenience that might ensue upon the breach of this Parliament Which if it had happened or shall hereafter happen his Majesty assures himself that he shall stand clear before God and men of the occasion But his Majesty saith ye had just cause to be sensible of the danger considering how the estate of Christendom now stands in respect of the multitude and strength of our Enemies and weakness on our part All which his Majesty knows very exactly and in respect therereof called this Parliament the particulars his Majesty holds it needless to recite especially to your Lordships since they are apparant to all men Neither will it be needfull to reiterate them to his Majesty whose cares are most intentive upon them and the best remedy that can be thought on therein is if his Subjects do their parts Therefore his Majesty gives you hearty thanks and bad me tell you that nothing hath been more acceptable to him all the time of this Parliament then this dutiful and discreet carriage of your Lordships which he professeth hath been a chief motive to his Majesty to suspend those intentions that were not far from a resolution Sir Robert Philips assumed the Debate upon the Message delivered by the Speaker and said I rise up with a disposition somewhat in more hope of comfort then yesterday yet in regard of the uncertainty of Councels I shall not change much In the first place I must be bold without flattering a thing nor incident to me to tell you Mr. Speaker you have not only at all times discharged the duty of a good Speaker but of a good man for which I render you many thanks Another respect touching his Majesties Answer to our Petition First if that Answer fall out to be short I free his Majesty and I believe his Resolution was to give that that we all expected But in that as in others we have suffered by reason of interposed persons between his Majesty and us But this day is by intervenient accidents diverted from that but so as in time we go to his Majesty Therefore let us remove those jealousies in his Majesty of our Proceedings that by somâ— men over-grown have bin mispresented we have proceeded with temper in confidence of his Majesties goodness to us and our fidelity to him and if any have construed that what we have done hath been out of feare let him know we came hither free men and will ever resolve to endure the worst and they are poor men that make such interpretations of Parliaments in this way and method we proceeded and if any thing fall out unhappily it is not King Charles that advised himself but King Charles misadvised by others and misled by misordered Councel it becomes us to consider what we were doing and now to advise what is fit to be done We were taking consideration of the State of the Kingdome and to present to his Majesty the danger he and we are in iâ— since any man hath been named in particular though I love to speak of my betters with humility let him thank himself and his Councels but those necessary jealousies gives us occasion to name him I assure my self we shall proceed with temper and give his Majesty satisfaction if we proceed in that way his Majesties message is now explanatory in point of our liberties that he intends not to barre us of our rights and that he would not have any aspersion cast on the Councels past let us present to his Majesty shortly and faithfully and declare our intentions that we intend not to lay any aspersion upon him but out of a necessity to prevent the eminent dangers we are surrounded with and to present to him the affaires at home and abroad and to desire his Majesty that no interposition of mis-information of men in fault may prevaile but to expect the issue that shall be full of duty and Loyalty The Commons sent a message to the Lords that they would joyne in an humble request to the King that a clear and satisfactory answer be given by his Majesty in full Parliament to the petition of Right whereunto the Lords did agree Afterward the House was turned again into a Committee and considered of some more heads to be inserted into the Declaration or Remonstrance as the designe to bring into this Nation Forreign Forces under the command of Dolbeir And Burlemack was called into the House who confessed he received thirty thousand pound by Privy seal for the buying of Horses that one thousand of them are levied that those Horse and their Riders are to come over and Armes are provided for them in Holland but he â—eares a Countermand is gone to stay them The Privy Seal is in these Words CHarles by the Grace of God King of England Scotland France and Ireland Defender of the Faith c. To the Treasurer and under Treasurer for our Exchequer for the time being Greeting We do hereby will and command you out of our Treasury remaining in the receipt of our said Exchequer forthwith to pay or cause to be paid unto Philip Burlemack of London Merchant the summe of thirty thousand pounds to be paid by him over by Bill of Exchange into the Low-Countreys and Germany unto our Trusty and
Circumstance must be dispensed with rather then the Substance be lost and hazarded And herein our will and pleasure is that You or as many of You from time to time as can be spared from attemdance upon Our Person or other our necessary Services doe use all diligence by your frequent meetings and serious considerations And when ye have brought any thing to maturity ye make report thereof unto us for the advancement of this greatt service which with the greatest affection we can we recommend to your best care and judgement whereof ye must not fail as ye tender Our honour and safety of our Dominions and People And for the doing hereof these Presents shall be to you and every of you a sufficient warrant and discharge in that behalâ— In witness whereof we have caused these Our Letters to be made Letters Patents Witness Our self at VVestminster the last day of February in the third year of Our Reign Per ipsum Regem Sir Edward Cook observed some circumstances in the Commission FIrst it was after the Summons to the Parliament Sure some thought the Parliament should not be 2. There is a Pudor in it it was kept secret some great Lords never knew it 3. The end of it was Excises for they are Impositions and to be sure he would have the word otherwise wherefore his advice was to go up to the Lords and desire a Conference to complain of the Commission and desire it may be Cancelled and if there be any inrolment of it to cancel that also and that the Projector may be found out and punished Hereupon there ensued a Conference with the Lords which was thus managed by Sir Edward Cook My Lords The subject of this Conference is a Commission therefore we shall desire your Lordships to hear it read which was done accordingly That which I shall deliver is certain Observations out of the Patent First The Persons to whom it is directed 2. The Authority that is committed 3. The great penalty laid on them if they do it not 4. The Time 1. The Persons to whom it is directed are twenty three Lords and other of his Majesties Councel 2. The Authority commmitted unto them is to consider how Money may be Leavied by Impositions or otherwise It is true it is but a Power to Leavy Money by Imposition We doe not find any thing raised that is left to your Lordships but a Commission to leavy money by Imposition or otherwise give us leave to fear that Excise and what ever is comprehended in it was intended Sure I am it is against the Law it is a very high breach of your Lordships and our the poor Commons Liberties and yet this being ill in it self may produce a happy effect the King and both Houses have given a Judgment the greatest that ever was against this in the Petition of Right and when this Judgment is given see how Gods goodness hath brought it to pass that this Patent shall be part of Execution of that Judgement to dam it for the punishment I do utterly dislike that clause as you tender the Kings Honour That that must come to a thing of this nature and it is strange to me I cannot dive into it I leave it to your Lordships for the time It came out seven days after the Summons of Parliament all knew the Parliament would descry this but I hope it will now turn to good I will not say it was kept secret That which I am to demand of your Lordships first is that as we haveing considered of this Commission finding it ex diametro against the late Judgment in the Petition of Right have condemned it So your Lordships would concurre with us as hitherto ye have done 2. Thâ—t this Commission as a thing against Law may be cancelled 3. That if it be inrolled a Vote may be made of it and if not that Order be taken that it be not inrolled 4. That the warrant may be damned and destroyed 5. That it would please your Lordships in your wisdoms to take into consideration who is the Projector of this device and if he could be found out that some exemplary punishment may be according to justice inflicted on him The Lords accepted the motion and promised to present the same to his Majesty This done the House of Commons Voted that the Commission the not guarding the narrow Seas the decay of Trade and other particulars be inserted in the Remonstrance THe House having well nigh finished the several particulars of grievances of most moment resumeth the former motion to declare who was the cause of all those evils which in a Committee of the whole House was mentioned before The Debate was as hot as ever and the crimes so frequently objected against the Duke were brought in afresh as if they had never been proposed in the House One made a distinction that the Duke was The cause of some and A. cause of other grievances For the first he instanced in the disaster of the Armies the decay of Ports Trade Ships and Mariners For the second he instanced in Religion First his Mother was a Recusant and a fosterer of Recusants Secondly Papists have honour in his own employments and Papists Captains are placed by him And as for Arminians York House is a place of consultation for Mountague and others from whence is like to follow Innovation in Government Another in pursuit of the Argument that Papists were imployed by the Duke named Dalbeer as the man who betrayed our men at the Isle of Ree where all was carried by the advice of private men and some ill affected in Religion and in assault before they came away 500. men were lost and in the Retreat Dalbeer was to make a Bridge which did so intangle them as they could make no defence and all contrary to the advice of the rest of the Commanders Sir Robert Philips was of opinion to have the Declaration run thus We conceive the greatness and power of the Duke of Buckingham is the chief cause of all these evils We are not in a way of Charge but of a Remonstrance Sir Iohn Elliot Sir Edward Cook and Mr. Selden were positively to name the Duke as the cause of our evils for so said they he had been already declared in the last Parliament since when the causes are multiplied and he hath deserved nothing better of the Common-wealth In this Debate there wanted not Mediators which did desire the House for their own ends and happiness to be sparing in that kind Sir Humphrey May put them again in mind of the Kings desire that all personal aspersions might be forborn that his Majesty will take it as an argument of their moderation and judgment if they forbear in this Sir Henry Martin advised that the Remonstrance be so framed as to make it passable to his Majesties judgment and affection Let him be perswaded that it comes from a publick sence and not from private
Subjects by being secure from all undue Charges be the more incouraged chearfully to proceed in their course of Trade by the increase whereof your Majesties Profit and likewise the strength of the Kingdom would be very much augmented But not being now able to accomplish this their desire there is no course left unto them without manifest breach of their duty both to your Majesty and their Countrey save onely to make this humble Declaration That the receiving of Tunnage and Poundage and other Impositions not granted by Parliament is a breach of the Fundamental Liberties of this Kingdom and contrary to your Majesties Royal answer to the said Petition of Right And therefore they do most humbly beseech your Majesty to forbear any further recieving of the same and not to take it in ill part from those of your Majesties loving Subjects who shall refuse to make payment of any such Charges without Warrant of Law demanded And as by this forbearance your most excellent Majesty shall manifest unto the world your Royal Iustice in the observation of your Laws So they doubt not but hereafter at the time appointed for their coming again they shall have occasion to express their great desire to advance your Majesties Honor and Profit MR. Noy after the reading hereof moved the House that his Majesty might be requested that the Merchants might ship their goods without a Cocket otherwise they do forfeit their goods Iune 26. The Speaker being sent for to the King at Whitehall came not into the House till about nine a clock And after Prayers the Remonstrance concerning Tunnage and Poundage being ingrossed was a reading in the House and while it was a reading the King sent for the Speaker and the whole House and the King made a Speech as followeth IT may seem strange that I came so suddenly to end this Session before I give my assent to the Bills I will tell you the cause though I must avow that I owe the account of my actions to God alone It is known to every one that a while ago the House of Commons gave me a Remonstrance how acceptable every man may judge and for the merit of it I will not call that in question for I am sure no wise man can justifie it Now since I am truly informed that a second Remonstrance is preparing for me to take away the profit of my Tunnage and Poundage one of the chiefest maintenances of my Crown by alleadging I have given away my right thereto by my Answer to your Petition This is so prejudicial unto me that I am forced to end this Session some few hours before I meant being not willing to receive any more Remonstrances to which I must give a harsh Answer And since I see that even the House of Commons begins already to make false constructions of what I granted in your Petition least it be worse interpreted in the Countrey I will now make a Declaration concerning the true intent thereof The profession of both Houses in the time of hammering this Petition was no ways to trench upon my Prerogative saying they had neither intention or power to hurt it Therefore it must needs be conceived that I have granted no new but only confirmed the Antient Liberties of my Subjects Yet to shew the clearness of my intentions that I neither repent nor mean to recede from any thing I have promised you I do here declare my self that those things which have been done whereby many have had some cause to expect the Liberties of the Subjects to be trenched upon which indeed was the first and true ground of the Petition shall not hereafter be drawn into example for your prejudice and from time to time in the word of a King ye shal not have the like cause to complain But as for Tonnage and Poundage it is a thing I cannot want and was never intended by you to ask nor meant by me I am sure to grant To conclude I command you all that are here to take notice of what I have spoken at this time to be the true intent and meaning of what I granted you in your Petition But especially you my Lords the Judges for you only under me belongs the interpretation of Laws for none of the Houses of Parliament either joint or separate what new Doctrine soever may be raised have any Power either to make or declare a Law without my consent After this Speech ended the Bill of Subsidie was delivered to the Speaker standing at the Bar in the Lords House who made a short Speech and shewed that it was the greatest gift that ever was given in so short a time And so craving pardon for the errors of the House and his own which he knew to be very many he desired the King to give his Royal Assent The King came so suddenly and unexpectedly to the House that the Lords were not in their Robes and the Commons had given no direction or Order for the Speaker to deliver the Bill of Subsidies Neither was it brought down to the Commons House as it was used but the Bills were read and the Bill for the Sabbath for Recusants children for Alehouse-keepers for continuance of Statutes for the Clergies Subsidie for the Lay of Subsidie all passed But for the Bill for explanation of the Statutes 3. Iac. about Leases of Recusants Lands The King said that in this short time he had not time sufficient to consider thereof but he said he found many Errors therein though the Title be faire and if at the next meeting they would amend those Errors it should pass Many private Bills passed also and after they were all read their Titles and the Kings Answer to them which to the publique Bills was Le Roy le veult to the private Soit fait come il est desire The Lord Keeper said it is his Majesties pleasure that this Session now end and that the Parliament be prorogued till the twentieth of October next At this Parliament which begun at Westminster the 17. of March Anno Regni R. Caroli 3. These Acts were passed FIrst An Act for further reformation of sundry Abuses committed on the Lords day called Sunday 2. The Petition exhibited to his Majesty by the Lords Spiritual and Temporal and Commons in this present Parliament Assembled concerning divers Rights and Priviledges of the Subject with the Kings assent thereunto in full Parliament 3. An Act for repressing of all unlicenced Alehouses 4. An Act to restrain the sending over of any to be popishly bred beyond the Seas 5. An Act for establishing of Suttons Hospital c. 6. An Act for the Establishing of the Tenants Estates of Bromfield and Yale in the County of Denbigh c. 7. An Act for the continuance and repeal of divers Statutes c. 9. An Act for five entire Subsidies granted by the Clergy 10. An Act concerning the Title c. of Earl of Arundel and for the annexing of the Castle of Arundel
Laud look to thy self be assured thy life is sought as thou art the fountain of wickedness repent of thy monstrous sins before thou be taken out of the world and assure they self neither God nor the world can endure such a vile Counsellor or whisperer to live The other was as bad against the L. Treasurer Weston The King purposing to proceed against the Members of the House of Commons who were committed to Prison by him in the Star-Chamber caused certain Questions to be proposed to the Judges upon the 25 of April WHereupon all the Judges met at Sergeants-Inne by command from his Majesty where Mr. Atturney proposed certain Questions concerning the offences of some of the Parliament-men committed to the Tower and other prisons at which time one Question was proposed and resolved viz. That the Statute of 4 H. 8.8 intituled An Act concerning Richard Strode was a particular Act of a Parliament and extended onely to Richard Strode and to those persons that had joyned with him to prefer a Bill to the House of Commons concerning Tynners And although the Act be private and extendeth to them alone yet it was no more then all other Parliament-men by priviledge of house ought to have viz. Freedom of speech concerning those matters debated in Parliament by a Parliamentary course The rest of the Questions Mr. Atturney was wished to set down in writing against another day Upon Munday following all the Judges met again and then Mr. Atturney proposed these Questions 1. Whether if any Subject hath received probable Information of any Treason or treacherous attempt or intention against the King or State that Subject ought not to make known to the King or his Majesties Commissioners when thereunto he shall be required what Information he hath received and the grounds thereof to the end the King being truly informed may prevent the danger And if the said Subject in such Case shall refuse to be examined or to answer the Questions which shall be demanded of him for further inquiry and discovery of the truth whether it be not a high contempt in him punishable in the Star-Chamber as an offence against the general Iustice and Government of the Kingdom Sol. The resolution and answer of all the Justices That it is an offence punishable as aforesaid so that this do not concern himself but another nor draw him to danger of Treason or contempt by his answer 2. Whether it be a good answer or excuse being thus interrogated and refusing to answer to say That he was a Parliament-man when he received this Information and that he spake thereof in the Parliament-house and therefore the Parliament being now ended he refused to answer to any such Questions but in the Parliament-house and not in any other place Sol. To this the Judges by advise privately to Mr. Atturney gave this Answer That this excuse being in Nature of a Plea and an errour in judgement was not punishable until he were over-ruled in an orderly manner to make another answer and whether the party were brought in Ore tenus or by Information for this Plea he was not to be punished 3. Whether a Parliament-man committing an offence against the King or Council not in a Parliament way might after the Parliament ended he punished or not Sol. All the Judges una voce answered He might if he be not punished for it in Parliament for the Parliament shall not give priviledge to any contra morem Parliamentarium to exceed the bounds and limits of his place duty And all agreed That regularly he cannot be compelled out of Parliament to answer things done in Parliament in a Parliamentary course but it is otherwise where things are done exorbitantly for those are not the Acts of a Court. 4. Whether if one Parliament-man alone shall resolve or two or three shall covertly conspire to raise false slanders and rumours against the Lords of the Council and Iudges not with intent to question them in a Legal course or in a Parliamentary way but to blast them and to bring them to hatred of the people and the Government in contempt be punishable in the Star-Chamber after the Parliament is ended Sol. The Judges resolve that the same was punishable out of Parliament as an offence exorbitant committed in Parliament beyond the office and besides the duty of a Parliament-man There was another Question put by Mr. Atturney viz. Whether if a man in Parliament by way of digression and not upon any occasion arising concerning the same in Parliament shall say The Lords of the Council and the Judges had agreed to trample upon the Liberty of the Subject and the priviledges of Parliament he were punishable or not The Judges desired to be spared to make any answer thereunto because it concerned themselves in particular The next day Mr. Atturny put the Judges another Case It is demanded of a Parliament-man being called Ore tenus before the Court of Star-Chamber being charged that he did not submit himself to examination for such things as did concern the King and the Government of the State and were affirmed to be done by a third person and not by himself if he confess his hand to that refusal and make his excuse and plead because he had priviledg of Parliament Whether the Court will not over-rule this plea as erronious and that he ought to make a further answer It is the justest way for the King and the party not to proceed Ore tenus because it being a point in Law it is fit to hear Counsel before it be over-ruled and upon an Ore tenus by the Rules of Star-Chamber Counsel ought not to be admitted and that it would not be for the Honor of the King nor the safety of the subject to proceed in that manner Pasca 5 Car. upon a Habeas Corpus of this Court to bring the body of William Stroud Esq with the cause of his imprisonment to the Marshal of the Kings Bench It was returned in this manner That Mr. William Stroud was committed under my custody by vertue of a certain Warrant under the hands of twelve of the Lords of the Privy-Council of the King the tenor of which Warrant followeth in these words YOu are to take knowledge that it is his Majesties pleasure and commandment that you take into your custody the Body of William Stroud Esq and keep him close prisoner till you shall receive other order either from his Majesty or this Board for so doing this shall be your Warrant Dated this 2 of April 1629. And the direction of the Warrant was To the Marshal of the Kings Bench or his Deputy He is also detained in prison by vertue of a Warrant under his Majesties hand the tenor of which Warrant followeth in these words C.R. WHereas you have in your custody the Body of William Stroud Esq by Warrant of Our Lords of our Privy-Council by Our special Command you are to take notice that this
for a word and lay a snare for him that reproveth in the gate and turn aside the just for a thing of nought Blame not before thou have examined the truth understand first and then rebuke answer not before thou hast heard the cause neither interrupt men in the midst of their talk Doth our Law judge any man before it hear him and know what he doth King Agrippa said unto Paul Thou art permitted to speak for thy self Thou shalt not wrest the judgment of the poor in his cause thou shalt not respect persons neither take a gift for a gift doth blind the eyes of the wise and pervert the eyes of the righteous Woe to them that devise iniquity because it is in the power of their hand and they covet fields and take them by violence and houses and take them away so they oppress a man and his house even a man and his heritage Thus saith the Lord God Let it suffice you O Princes of Israel remove violence and spoyl and execute judgment and justice take away your exactions from my people saith the Lord God If thou seest the oppression of the Poor and violent perverting of judgment and justice in a Province marvel not at the matter for he that is higher then the highest regardeth and there be higher then they Per me Richard Chambers Afterwards in the Term of Trinity the 5 yeer of King Charls it is found in the great Roll of this year that there is demanded there of Richard Chambers of London Merchant 2000 l. for a certain fine imposed on him hither sent by vertue of a writ of our said Lord the King under the foot of the great Seal of England directed to the Treasurer and Barons of this Exchequer for making execution thereof to the use of the said Lord the King as is there contained and now that is to say in the Utas of the Blessed Trinity this Term comes the said Richard Chambers in his own proper person and demands Oyer of the demand aforesaid and it is read unto him and he demands Oyer also of the Writ aforesaid under the foot of the Great Seal of England hither sent and it is read unto him in these words CHarls by the Grace of God of England Scotland France and Ireland Defender of the Faith c. To his Treasurer and Barons of his Exchequer health The extret of certain fines taxed and adjudged by Us and our said Council in our said Council in Our Court of Star-Chamber in the Term of St Michael the Term of St. Hillary and the Term of Easter last past upon Thomas Barns of the Parish of St. Clements Danes in the County of Middlesex Carpenter and others severally and dividedly as they be there severally assessed We send unto you included in these presents commanding that looking into them you do that which by Law you ought to do against them for the levying of those fines Witness our Self at Westminster the 21 of May in the yeer of Our Reign the 5 Mutas And the tenor of the Schedule to the said Writ annexed as to the said Richard Chambers followeth in these words IN the Term of Easter the fifth year of King Charles of Richard Chambers of London Merchant 2000 l. which being read heard and by him understood he complains that he is grievously vexed and inquieted by colour of the Premises and that not justly for that protesting that the said great Roll and the matter therein contained is not in Law sufficient to which he hath no need nor is bound by Law to answer yet for Plea the said Richard Chambers saith That he of the demand aforesaid in the great Roll aforesaid mentioned and every parcel thereof ought to be discharged against the said Lord the King for that he said That he from the time of the Taxation oâ— the aforesaid Fine and long before was a Freeman and a Merchant of this Kingdom that is to say In the Parish of the blessed Mary of the Arches in the Ward of Cheap London And that by a certain Act in the Parliament of the Lord Henry late King of England the Third held in the ninth year of his reign it was provided by Authority of the said Parliament That a Freeman shall not be amerced for a little offence but according to the manner of the said offence and for a great offence according to the greatness of the offence saving to him his Contenement or Freehold and a Merchant in the same manner saving unto him his Merchandize and a Villain of any other then the King after the same manner to be amerced saving his Wainage and none of the said Amercements to be imposed but by the Oaths of good and lawful men of the Neighbourhood And by a certain other Act in the Parliament of the Lord Edward late King of England the first held in the Third year of his reign it was and is provided That no City Burrough or Town nor any man should be amerced without reasonable cause and according to his Trespass that is to say A Freeman saving to him his Contenement A Merchant saving to him his Merchandize and A Villan saving to him his Wainage and this by their Peers And by the same Act in the Parliament of the said Lord Henry late King of England the Third held in the ninth year of his reign aforesaid it was and is provided by Authority of the said Parliament That no Freemen should be taken or imprisoned or disseized of his Freehold or Liberties or free Customs or outlaw'd or banish'd or any way destroyed And that the Lord the King should not go upon him nor deal with him but by a lawful judgement of his Peers or by the Law of the Land And by a certain Act in the Parliament of the Lord Edward late King of England the Third held in the fifth year of his reign it was and is provided by the Authority of the said Parliament That no man henceforward should be attached by reason of any Accusation nor pre-judged of Life or Member nor that his Lands Tenements Goods or Chattels should be seized into the hands of the Lord the King against the form of the great Charter and the Law of the Land And by a certain Act in the Parliament of the Lord Henry late King of England the seventh held in the third year of his reign reciting that by unlawful Maintenances given of liveries signes and tokens and retainders by Indentures Promises Oaths Writings and other Imbraceries of the Subjects of the said Lord the King false Demeanors of Sheriffs in making of Pannels and other false returns by taking of money by Jurors by great ryots and unlawful assemblies the policie and good Government of this Kingdom was almost subdued and by not punishing of the said inconveniences and by occasion of the Premises little or nothing was found by Inquisition by reason thereof the Laws of
and condition he died in Summer 1658. being about the age of seventy years Trinity 5. Car. Banco Regis The first day of this Term upon a Habeas Corpus to Sir Allen Apsley the Lieutenant of the Tower to bring here the body of Iohn Selden Esq with the cause of Detencer he returned the same cause as was in Mr. Stroods Case And Mr. Littleton of the Inner-Temple of Counsel with Mr. Selden moved that the Return was insufficient in substance therefore pray'd that he might be bayled and said that it was a matter of great consequence both to the Crown of the King and to the Liberty of the Subject But as for the difficulty of Law contained in it he said under favour the Case cannot be said Grand And so proceeded to his Argument which for the Reasons before mentioned we have postponed and concluded that the Prisoner ought to be bailed The same day Sir Miles Hubbord Benjamin Valentine Denzil Holles Esq were at the Bar upon the Habeas Corpus directed to several Prisons And their Counsel were ready at the Bar to have argued the Case for them also But because the same Return was made for them as for Mr. Selden they all Declared they would rely on this Argument made by Mr. Littleton Some few days after Sir Robert Heath the Kings Atturney General argued that this Return was good and that Mr. Selden and the rest of the parties ought not to be bailed and that within the Return there appears good cause of their commitment and of their detaining also He said The Case is great in expectation consequence and concerns the Liberty of the Subject on one part whereof the Argument is plausible and on the other part it concerns the safety and Soveraignty of the King which he said is a thing of greater weight and that the consideration of both pertains to you the Judges without flighting the one or too much elevating the other and so proceeded to his Argument of which more at large hereafter and concluded that the Prisoners ought to be remanded When the Court was ready to have delivered their opinions in this great business the Prisoners were not brought to the Bar according to the Rule of the Court. Therefore Proclamation was made for the keepers of the several Prisons to bring in their Prisoners but none of them appeared but the Marshal of the Kings Bench who informed the Court that Mr. Strood who was in his custody was removed yesterday and put in the Tower of London by the Kings own warrant and so it was done with the other Prisoners for each of them was removed out of his prison in which he was before But notwithstanding it was pray'd by the Counsel for the Prisoners that the Court would deliver their opinion as to the matter in Law but the Court refused to do that because it was to no purpose for the Prisoners being absent they could not be bailed delivered or remanded The evening before there came a Letter to the Judges of this Court from the King himself informing the Court with the Reasons wherefore the Prisoners were not suffered to come at the day appointed for the resolution of the Judges These were the words of the Letter To our Trusty and welbeloved Our Chief Justice and the rest of Our Justices of Our Bench. C. R. TRusty and welbeloved we Greet you well Whereas by our special commandment we have lately removed Sir Miles Hubard Walter Long and William Stroud from the several prisons where they were formerly committed and have now sent them to our Tower of London understanding there are various constructions made thereof according to the several apprehensions of those who discourse of it as if we had done it to decline the course of Iustice We have therefore thought fit to let you know the true Reason and occasion thereof as also why we commanded those and the other Prisoners should not come before you the last day We having heard how most of them a while since did carry themselves insolently and unmannerly both towards us and your Lordships were and are very sensible thereof and though we hear your selves gave them some admonition for that miscariage yet we could not but resent our Honour and the Honour of so great a Court of Iustice so far as to let the world know how much we dislike the same And having understood that your Lordships and the rest of our Iudges and Barons of our Court of Common Pleas and Exchequer whose advices and judgments we have desired in this great business so much concerning our Government have not yet resolved the main Question we did not think the presence of those Prisoners necessary and until we should find their temper and discretions to be such as may deserve it we were not willing to afford them favour Nevertheless the respect we bear to the proceedings of that Court hath caused us to give way that Selden and Valentine should attend you tomorrow they being sufficient to appear before you since you cannot as yet give any resolute opinion in the main point in Question Given under our Signet at Our Mannor at Greenwich this 24 Iunii in the 5 yeer of our Reign Within three hours after the receit of those Letters other Letters were brought unto the said Judges as followeth To Our trusty and well-beloved Our Chief Justices and the rest of Our Justices of Our Bench. C. R. TRusty and well-beloved we greet you well Whereas by our Letters of this days date we gave you to understand our pleasure That of those prisoners which by our Commandment are kept in our Tower of London Selden and Valentine should be brought tomorrow before you now upon more mature Deliberation we have resolved That all of them shall receive the same treatment and that none shall come before you until we have cause given us to believe they will make a better demonstration of their Modesty and Civility both towards us and your Lordships then at their last appearance they did Given under our Signet at our Mannor at Greenwich this 24 day of Iune in the fifth year of our Reign So the Court this Term delivered no opinion and the imprisoned Gentlemen continued in restraint all the long Vacation Note That in this Term a Habeas Corpus was prayed to the Pursevant of Arms for four Constables of Hertfordshire to whose custody they were committed by the Lords of the Privy-Council and the Habeas Corpus was granted on their behalf but then they were committed to the Custody of other Pursevants and so upon every Habeas Corpus they were removed from Pursevant to Pursevant and could have no fruit of their Habeas Corpus all this Term. There wanted not some who upon the Kings dissolution of this Parliament and his ill success in two former Parliaments did advise that his Majestie for the future might be no more troubled with the impertinencies of Parliaments holding out for example the like
per Annum by raising a certain value upon their Lands and some other impositions which requiring a long Discourse by it self I will omit it here setting it down in my Instructions it will save your Majesty at least One hundred thousand pounds per Annum to make it pain of death and confiscation of goods and lands for any of the Officers to cousen You which now is much to be feared they do or else they could not be so rich and herein to allow a fourth part benefit to them that shall find out the cousenage Here is not meant Officers of State as the Lord Treasurer c. being Officers of the Crown The summe of all this account amounteth unto two Millions or Twenty hundred thousand pounds per Annum Suppose it be but one Million and a Half as assuredly your Majesty may make by these courses set down yet it is much more then I promised in my Letter for your Majesties service Besides some sums of mony in present by the courses following Imprimis By the Prince's Marriage to make all the Earls in England Grandees of Spain and Principi with such like priviledges and to pay twenty thousand pounds apiece for it 2. As also if you make them Foeditaries of the Towns belonging to their Earldoms if they will pay for it besides as they do to the King of Spain in the Kingdom of Naples And so likewise Barons to be made Earls and Peers to pay ninteen thousand pounds a piece I think might yield five hundred thousand pounds and oblige them more sure to his Majesty 3. To make choice of two hundred of the richest men of England in estate that be not Noble-men and make them Titulate as is used in Naples and paying for it that is a Duke thirty thousand pounds a Marquis fifteen thousand pounds an Earl ten thousand pounds and a Baron or Viscount five thousand pounds It is to be understood that the antient Nobility of Barons made Earls are to precede these as Peers though these be made Marquesses or Dukes this may raise a Million of pounds and more unto your Majesty To make Gentlemen of low quality and Francklines and rich Farmers Esquires to precede them would yield your Majesty also a great sum of mony in present I know another course to yield your Majesty at least three hundred thousand pounds in mony which as yet the time serveth not to discover untill your Majesty be resolved to proceed in some of the former courses which till then I omit Other courses also that may make present mony I shall study for your Majestie 's service and as I find them out acquaint you withall Lastly to conclude all these discourses by the application of this course used for your profit That it is not onely the means to make you the richest King that ever England had but also the safety augmented thereby to be most secure besides what shewed in the first part of this Discourse I mean by the occasion of this Taxation and raising of monies your Majesty shall have cause and means to imploy in all places of the Land so many Officers and Ministers to be obliged to you for their own good and interest as nothing can be attempted against your Person or Royall State over land but some of them shall in all probability have means to find it out and hinder it Besides this course will detect many disorders and abuses in the publick Government which were hard to be discovered by men indifferent To prohibite gorgeous and costly apparell to be worn but by persons of good quality shall save the Gentry of the Kingdom much more mony then they shall be taxed to pay unto your Majesty Thus withall I take my leave and kiss your gratious hands desiring pardon for my error I may commit herein Pasc. 5. Caroli Regis B. R. The Reports of the following Arguments were taken by Mr. Widdrington of Gray's-Inn UPon the Habeas Corpus out of this Court to bring here the body of one William Stroud Esq with the cause of his imprisonment to the Marshall of the Kings Bench it was returned in this manner That William Stroud Esq was committed under my custody by vertue of a certain Warrant under the hands of twelve Lords of the Privy Councill of the Lord the King the tenour of which Warrant followeth in these words You are to take knowledge that it is his Majesties expresse pleasure and commandment that you take into your custody the body of William Stroud Esq and keep him close-prisoner untill you shall receive other order either from his Majesty or this Board for so doing this shall be your Warrant Dated the 2 d of April 1629. And the Direction thereof was To the Marshall of the King's Bench or his Deputy He is likewise held in prison by vertue of a certain Warrant under the hand of the King himself the tenour of which Warrant followeth in these words Carolus Rex Whereas you have in your custody the body of William Stroud Esq committed by the Lords of Our Privy Councill by Our speciall command you are to take notice that his commitment was for notable contempts by him committed against Our Self and Our Government and for stirring up of Sedition against Us For which you are to detain him in your custody and keep him close-prisoner untill Our pleasure be further known concerning his deliverance Given at Greenwich the 7 th of May 1629. in the 5 th year of Our Reigne And the direction was To Our Marshall for Our Bench for the time being And these are the causes of the taking and detaining of the foresaid William Stroud c. And upon another Habeas Corpus to the Marshall of the Houshold to have the body of Walter Long Esq he made the same Return as above Ask of the Inner Temple of Counsell with Mr. Stroud moved That the Return was insufficient The Return consists upon two Warrants bearing severall Dates which are the causes of the taking and detaining of the Prisoner For the first Warrant which is of the Lords of the Councill that is insufficient because no cause is shewn of his commitment which is expresly against the resolution of the Parliament and their Petition of Right in the time of this King which now is to which he had likewise given his assent so his taking by vertue of the said Warrant is wrongfull And for the second Warrant it is insufficient also and that notwithstanding that it be the Kings own for the King himself cannot imprison any man as our Books are to wit 16 H. 6. F. Monstrance de faits 1 H. 7.4 Hussey reports it to be the opinion of Markham in the time of Edw. 4. and Forrescue in his Book de laudibus Legum Angliae cap. 18. And the reason given is because no action of false imprisonment lies against the King if the Imprisonment be wrongfull and the King cannot be a wrong doer The Statute
King 2. It stands not with the dignity of the King to arrest any man C. 4. 73. The King makes a Lease for years rendring rent with condition of re-entry for non-payment he shall take advantage of the condition without any demand and the reason there given is that a decorum and conveniency might be observed So it is not befitting for the King in person to arrest any man but the King may command another to do it Bracton lib. 2. de acquirendo rerum Dominio fol. 55. sayes That the Crown of the King is to do justice and judgment and facere pacem without which the Crown it self cannot subsist Severall constructions are to be made upon those severall words and the last words facere pacem imply that the King hath a coercive power Britton f. 1. amongst the Errata The King said in person Because we are not sufficient in person to do every thing We divide the charge into many parts We are the peoples Iustice and a Iustice implies one that hath power to do justice in every kind to wit by imprisonment or otherwise 20 H. 7.7 C. 11.85 it is said That the King is the chief Iustice. And Lambert in his Justice of Peace fol. 3. saies That in antient Histories the chief Iustice of England is called Capitalis Justicia Prima Justicia after the King in England So that the King hath the same power of Iustice as the Chief Iustice had This imprisonment here which is before conviction for any offenâ— is not used towards the Subject as imprisonment for any fault but is rather an arrest or restraint to avoid further inconveniencies 14 H. 7.8 A Iustice of Peace may arrest men riotously assembled for prevention of further mischief And the Book also saies That he may leave his servants there to arrest men for safeguard of the peace It is a case well known that if a house be set on fire every man may pull down the next house for prevention of greater mischief so it seems concerning the Incendiaries of the State they ought to be restrained and supprest lest others should be stirred up by them to the same combustion 22 ass 56. and 22 E. 4.45 in false imprisonment the Defendant justifies because the Plantiff was mad and out of his wits and that he had done some harm and that he had bound and beat him to avoid further harm which might have happened by his madnesse And the justification was held good So it is in matter of Government to avoid commotions the King ought to use his coercive power against those that are enraged The objection was that this course was against the Petition of Right But I answer That this case is out of the words of that Petition the words of the Petition were Whereas by the Statute called The great Charter and by the Statute of 28 E. 3. no free-man may be taken or imprisoned yet against the tenour of the said Statute c. divers of your subjects have of late been imprisoned without any cause shewed and when for their deliverance c. they were brought before the Iustices by Writs of Habeas corpus there to undergo and receive as the Court should order and their Keepers commanded to certifie the cause of their deteyner and no cause was certified but that they were detained by your Majesties speciall command signified by the Lords of your Council and yet were returned back to severall prisons without being charged with any thing to which they might make answer according to Law These last words are observable Without being charged with any thing to which they might make answer These words do not refer to the Return of the Habeas Corpus for the cause returned therein cannot be traversed 9 H. 6. 54. but the Court took it as true But the setting forth of the cause and the answer to the same cause is to be upon other proceedings to wit upon the indictment for the offence or otherwise And there is great difference between the return of a Writ to which a man may answer and the return of an Habeas corpus 10 E. 4. 3 H. 7.11 are that if the Sheriff return Rescous all certainties of every circumstance ought to be shewed because it is fitting that a thing certain be brought into judgment And upon shewing of the grievance as above the Petition is that no free-man in any such manner as before is mentioned be imprisoned or detained such and it hath relation to such imprisonment which is mentioned in the premises And imprisonment mentioned in the premises of the Petition is where no cause at all was mentioned then where any cause is shewed is out of the Petition and that such is the word relative appears by C. 11 62. where many cases are put to the same purpose which see The third objection was That the Return was generall and uncertain The Counsell on the other side had divided the words of the Return but that is to offer violence thereunto for an exposition shall not be made by fractions but upon the whole matter For the first words notable contempts It hath been said that the addition of the word notable is but to make a flourish But I say That notable is not the emphasis of the Return but it onely expresseth the nature of the offence and yet notable is a word observable by it self in the Law and implyes that the thing is known and noted By 27 E. 1. Sheriffs shall be punished that let notorious offenders to bayl and by the Statute of 4 H. 4. chap. 3. a notorious or common thief shall not make his purgation and 26 E. 3.71 in a trespasse for fals imprisonment the Defendant said That the Plantiff came into the Town of Huntington and because he was seen in the company of R. de Thorby who was a notorious thief he as Bailiff of Huntington took him upon suspition I confesse that for contempts is generall yea it is genus generalissimum and within the Petition of Right but the words are against Our Self It hath been said That this might be by irreverent words or gestures and Our Government It hath been said that this might be by contempt to the Kings Writ or by Retraxit as Beechers case is To this I answer That those words which are spoken to one purpose ought not to be wrested to another and this is against the common meaning of the words C. 4. Thou art a murderer the Defendant shall not afterwards explain it to be a murderer of Hares for the highest murder is intended So here the highest Government is intended 4. It hath been objected that for stirring up of sedition against Us may perhaps be but an offence Finable But those words joyned with the former words shew this to be an offence of the highest nature sedition is a speciall contempt And although sedition in it self may be but a generall offence yet here it is Sedition against Us and Our Government which makes
that it is but a Finable offence yet by the said Statute those which are imprisoned for open and notorious naughtinesse shall not be bayled the same naughtinesse is there intended high and exorbitant offence 2. It is fit to restrain the prisoners of their liberty that the Common-wealth be not damnifâ—ed It is lawfull to pull down a house to prevent the spreading mischief of fire it is lawfull to restrain a furious man And by the 14 H. 7. a Iustice of peace may restrain one rout Then the restraint of dangerous men to the Common-wealth is justifiable and necessary 24 E. 3.33 p. 25. Sir Thomas Figet went armed in the Palace which was shewed to the Kings Councell wherefore he was taken and disarmed before the chief Iustice shard and committed to the prison and he could not be bayled till the King sent his pleasure and yet it was shewed that the Lord of T. threatned him Out of which case I observe two things First that the Iudge of this Court did cause a man to be apprehended upon complaint made to the Council that is to the Lords of the Privy Council 2. That although he did nothing he is not mayn-pernable untill the King sent his pleasure because he was armed and furiously disposed So here UUherefore I pray that the Prisoners may be sent back again Davenport argued to the same intent and purpose and therefore I will report his Argument briefly 1. He said That the Return here is sufficient The Counsell on the other side have made fractions of this Return and divided it into severall parts whereas the genuine construction ought to have been made upon the entire Return for no violence ought to be offered to the Text. 7 E. 4.20 In false imprisonment the Defendant did iustifie and alledged severall reasons of his justification to wit because a man was killed and that this was in the County of S. and that the common voice and fame was that the Plaintiff was culpable And this was held a good plea although Bryan did there object That the plea was double or treble and the reason was because twenty causes of suspition make but one entire cause and indivisible unity in this ought not to be divided So C. 8.66 Crogates In an action of trespasse the Defendant justifies for severall causes and held good because upon the matter all of them make but one cause C. 8.117 It is said That it is an unjust thing unlesse the whole Law be looked into to judge and answer by propounding any one particular thereof and if it be unjust in the exposition of a Law it is uncivill in a Return to make fractions of it in the construction thereof especially it being a Return for Information and not for Accusation 2. Although the Counsell on the other side have taken this case to be within the Petition of Right yet this is Petitio principii to take that for granted which is the question in debate He said That he would not offer violence to the Petition of Right to which the King had assented and which shall really be performed But the question here is Whether this Return be within it and the Iudges are keepers not masters of this pledge and it seems that this Return is out of the letter and meaning of the said Statute 3. He said That this was the actuall commitment of the Lords of the Privy Councill and the habituall or virtuall commitment of the King But because upon these two matters he put no case nor gave any reason but what had been put or given in the Argument of the grand Habeas corpus Mich. 3 Caroli and afterwards in the House of Commons which was reported to the Lords in the painted Chamber all which Arguments I heard I have here omitted them And for the great respect which the Law gives to the commands of the King he put these cases 7 H. 3. Attachment of waste against the Tenant in Dower and the waste was assigned in the taking of fish out of a pond and the carrying them away The Defendant pleaded That her second husband by the command of the Lord the King took all the fish out of the said pond to the use of the Lord the King and held a good justification which proves that the command of the King there to her husband excused her of the said waste And yet it is clear that Tenant in Dower is liable to an action of waste for waste done in the time of her second husband But contrary is it where a woman is Tenant for life and took a husband who made waste and dyed no action lies against the wife for that waste And F. N. B. 17. A. If the Tenant in precipe at the grand cape makes default the King may send a UUrit to the Iustices rehearsing that he was in his service c. commanding them that that default be not prejudiciall to him and this command of the King excuseth his default be the cause true or no. 4. For the particulars of the Return it is for notable contempts against the Government But as to that it hath been said that the King hath sundry governments to wit Ecclesiasticall Politicall c. and it is not shewn against which of them This is but a cavilling exception they might as well have excepted to this Return because it is not shewen that these contempts were after the last generall Pardon that had been a better exception The last words of the Return are raising sedition against Us But as to this it hath been said That Seditio is not a word known in the Law and is alwaies taken either Adverbially or Adjectively and is not a Substantive To this he said That although it is not a Substantive for the preservation yet it is a Substantive for the destruction of a Kingdom And he said that he found the word Seditio in the Law and the consequent of it likewise which is seductio populi But it is not ever found to be taken in a good sense it is alwaies ranked and coupled with treason rebellion insurrection or such like as it appears by all those Statutes which have been remembred on the other side Therefore he prayed likewise that the Prisoners might be sent back Trin. 5 Car. B. R. THe first day of the Term upon Habeas Corpus to Sir Allen Apsley the Lieutenant of the Tower to bring here the body of John Selden Esq with the cause of detention He returned the same cause as above and Littleton of Counsell with him moved that the Return was insufficient in substance therefore he prayed that he might be bayled It is true that it is of great consequence both to the Crown of the King and to the liberty of the Subject But under favour for the difficulty of Law contained in it the case cannot be said Grand In my Argument I will offer nothing to the Court but that which I have seen with these eyes and that which
in tertio Caroli that generall Returns that were committed by the command of the Lord the King are not good and that those Arguments remain as Monuments on record in the Upper House of Parliament but I will not admit them for Law But I will remember what was the opinion of former times 22 H. 6.52 by Newton a man committed by the command of the King is not replevisable And the opinion cannot be intended of a Replevin made by the Sheriff because the principall case there is upon a Return in this Court 33 H. 6.28 Poyning's case where the Return was That he was committed by the Lords of the Councill and it was admitted good It is true that this opinion is grounded upon Westm. 1. cap. 15. but I will not insist upon it But the constant opinion hath alwaies been that a man committed by the command of the King is not baylable In 9 H. 6.44 it is said That if one be taken upon the Kings suit the Court will not grant a Supersedeas The contrary opinion is grounded upon Magna Charta which is a generall Law and literally hath no sense to that purpose and it is contrary to the usuall practise in criminall causes in which the imprisonment is alwaies lawfull untill the tryall although it be made by a Iustice of Peace or Constable And that a man committed by the command of the King or Privy Councill is not baylable he cited 1 Jacobi Sir Brocket's case 8 Jac. Sir Cesar's case 12. Demetrius's case 43 Rinch's case And in the case M. 36 Eliz. and 4 and 5 Thimelby's case And said that there are innumerable presidents to this purpose M. 21 and 22 Eliz. upon the return of an Habeas corpus it appears that Michael Page was committed by the command of the Lord the King but was not delivered and after was arraigned in this Court and lost his hand And at the same time Stubbs was committed by the command of the Lord the King for seditious words and rumors and he lost his hand also upon the same tryall M. 17 and 18. Eliz. Upon Habeas corpus for John Loan it was returned That he was committed for divulging sundry seditious writings and he was remanded And 7 H. 7 roll 6. Rugs case and roll 13. Chase's case where the Return was that they were committed by the command of the Lord the King and they were not delivered and this was also the opinion in this Court M. 3. Car. And after the said time the Law is not altered and so I hope neither are your opinions But to consider the particular cause mentioned in the Return I will not rely upon the first part of the words although they be of great weight but onely upon the last words for stirring up of sedition against Us But it hath been objected that Sedition is not a word known in the Law But I marvell that the signification of the word is not understood when it is joyned with the words agains Us this ought to be understood Sedition against the King in his politick capacity Sedition hath sundry acceptations according to the subject handled as it appears C. 4. Lord Cromwel's case which hath been cited If it be spoken of a man that he is seditious if it be of a company in London it shall be understood sedition in the Company if it be spoken of a Souldier it shall be taken for mutinous Mr. Littleton who argued this case very well said That Tacitus useth this word and it is true and he saies That there are two manners of Seditions Seditio armata togata and the last is more dangerous then the former But couple it with the subsequent words here against Us the interpretation and sense thereof is easie loquendum ut vulgus Mr. Littleton shewes the acceptation of this word in divers places of Scripture and I will not reject them for they make for me 20 Numb 3. the Latine is populi versi sunt in seditionem and it is Englished murmuring but clearly it was high treason against their Governour and God himselfe 26 Numb 9. in seditione Corah it is manifest that that was a great Insurrection 12 Judg. 1. Facta est ergo seditio in Ephraim The Ephramites rose against Jephta and he at the same time was their Iudge and Governour so it was the heighth of Insurrection It is true that in 15 Act. 2. Facta est seditio and in some Translations it is Orta est repughantia non parva for it may be taken in severall senses 19 Acts 40. the Town-Clerk there knew not how to answer for this daies sedition or insurrection and no doubt he was in great perill for it was a great insurrection and I wish the greater ones were as circumspect as he was 24 Act. 5. Tertullus accused Paul of sedition and doubtlesse it was conceived a great offence if you consider the time and other circumstances for they were Heathens and Romans And although he in very truth taught the Gospell of God yet he was taken for a pestilent fellow and as a perswader to shake off Government Bracton lib. 3. de Corona c. 2. rancks Sedition amongst the crimes laesae Majestatis But it hath been objected that if it be a capitall offence it ought to be felony or treason To this I say That it cannot be felony but it may be treason for any thing that appears It is true that by the statute of 25 E. 3. treasons are declared and nothing shall be said treason which is not comprised within the said Statute unlesse it be declared so by Act of Parliament But upon indictment of treason such sedition as this may be given in evidence and perhaps will prove treason And the Return is not That he was seditious which shewes onely an inclination but that he stirred up sedition which may be treason if the evidence will bear it In divers Acts of Parliament notice is taken of this word Seditio and it is alwaies coupled with Insurrection or Rebellion as appears by the Statutes of 5 R. 2. c. 6. 17 R. 2. c. 8. 2 H. 5. c. 9. 8 H. 6. c. 14. 3 4. E. 6. c. 5. 2 R. 2. c. 5. 1 and 2 Phil. Mar. c. 2. 1 Eliz. c. 7. 13 Eliz. c. 2. 23 Eliz. c. 2. 27 Eliz. c. 2. and 35 Eliz. c. 1. all which were cited before and they prove that Sedition is a word well known in the Law and of dangerous consequence and which cannot be expounded in good sense Wherefore the nature of the offence I leave it to the Court But out of these Statutes it appears that there is a narrow difference between it and treason if there be any at all 3 ly As to the Objections which have been made I will give a short answer to them 1. It was objected That every imprisonment is either for custody or punishment the last is alwaies after the judgment given for the offence and if it be but for custody the
favor of Roman Catholicks A difficulty concerning the Popes title on the Kings part Another on the Ambassadors part concerning prayers in the Kings Chappel A titular Bishop of Calcedon sent into England Preparations for conducting the Infanta into England No mention made in the Capitulations of restoring the Palatine Mr. Allured his Letter to the Duke The French jealous of this conjunction Pope Vrban to K. Iames. Pope Vrbans Letter to Prince Charls The Treaty begins to tend to a rupture The Prohibition to the Judges and Bishops in behalf of the Catholicks suspended Some of the English in Spain dislike the Match and Religion The Duke disgusted in Spain Buckingham and Bristol run different ways The Palatine by his Secretary labors to engage the Prince against the Marriage The Spaniard continues new delays The English Papists perplexed The Prince ready to depart from the Court of Spain leaves a Proxy with the Earl of Bristâ—l The Duke and Olivares part not Friends The Prince universally â—steemed His departure solemn The Prince feasted the Dons aboard his Ship and bringing them back again to the shore a storm surprises them Expressions of joy for the Princes safe return into England Private Instructions delivered to Bristol contrary to the Proxy Bristol in a Letter gives the Prince a good account of the business King Iames falls off and for a Condition of the Mariage demands the Restitution of the Palatinate Bristol and Asâ—â—n demur upon the new Instructions Sir Walter Aston endeavors to reconcile the Dâ—ke to Spain Advice to the King touching the Duke The Earl of Bristol is commanded by the King to follow the new Instructions King Iames puts the Palatine in hope by Proposal of new terms The Palatines Answer to those Terms proposed by the King The Netherlands appear ready to embrace the antient Union with England The Ratifiâ—â—â—ication come from the new Popâ— and when all is ready for the E 〈◊〉 ls thâ—n is the Maâ—ch dasht by order from England Bristol sends his Apology to K. Iames for having demurred upon the new Instructions Olivares offers Bristol large Preferments in the Kings name when he was to take his leave Bristols Answer to those Profers The Spaniards prepare for a War with England The L. Kensington sent Ambassador into France to feel the pulse of that Court touching a Match renders an account of his acceptance The King advised to call a Parliament The Kings Speech to the Parliament The King approves Sir Tho. Crew for Speaker who made this Speech The Dukes Narrative Both Houses of Parliament justifie the Duke in his Narrative His Majesties Answer to that Justification Both Houses of Parliament concur that the King may not honorably proceed in tâ—e Treaty of the Prince's Marriage and the Palatinate The Kings Speech 〈◊〉 Parliament perswaâ—â—â—â— him to break off the two Treaties of the Match and of the Palatinate Sir Edw. Sackvile's Speech Sir Edw. Sackvile's Speech The Parliaments Answer to the Kings Speech The Parliament offers his Majesty Three Subsidies and Three Fifteens if he break off both Treaties His Majesties Reply The King declares his Resolution to dissolve the Treaties The King accepts the aid proffered him King Iames his Letter to Secretary Conway touching a Petition against the Papists The Petition His Majesties Answer to the Petition The Spanish Ambassadors accuse Buckingham to the King of matters of high concernment The issue of those Accusations The Earl of Bristol protests against the Dukes Narration is imprisoned in the Tower The Speakers and the Kings Speech at the Adjournment of the Parliament Kings Iames demands the Town of Frankendal deposited in the Archducâ—hess hands Spinola marches out of the Town and immediately Re-enters King Iames very desirous of a Match with France The Match with France concluded Count Mansfield arrrives in England 12000 Foot and 200 horse raised to go under his command Scarce the third part of Count Mansfields Army came safe to Land Richard Smith made Bishop of Calcedon and sent into England with Episcopal Jurisdiction * The Duke of Buckingham Instructions to Mr Drummond The Privy-Counsellors present themselves to King Charles King Charles proclaimed at Theobalds At Whitehall In London The old Privy-Council new sworn The Councils advice to the King Proclamation concerning Persons in Office c. Proclamation of Government Resolution taken by the King concerning King Iames Funeral and his own Marriage A Parlamenâ— summoned King Iames Funeral Duke of Buckingham continues Favorite to King Charles Religion considered A general Muster Souldiers levied for the Palatinate Proclamation against disorders committed by Souldiers Articles of the marriage with France signed by the King Private Articles in favor of the Catholicks The Marriage solemnized in France The Duke sent into France for the Queen A Royal Navy sent to Bolâ—ign to transport the Queen The Marriage consummated at Canterbury The Trained Bands of Kent commanded to attend the Queen The King and Queen come to London A Chappel built at Somerset-house for the Queen A great Plague in London The Parliament opened The Kings Speech in Parliament The Lord Keepers Speech in Parliament Sir Tho. Crew Speaker Debates in the House of Commons A Fast. Committees chosen Message to the King touching Religion and his Answer Mr. Montague brought to the Bar. The Arminian party assert his cause The King takes Montagues businâ—â—â— into his own hand Two Subsidies presented to the King The King accepts them and desires more A short Answer to the Petition touching Religion The Parliament adjourned to Oxford The Exchequer removed to Richmond The Vantguard and seven other Ships employed against Rochel The Parliament meets again at Oxford Grievances Mr. Montague Summoned to appear His Cause recommended by the Bishops to the Duke The Appeal to Caesar disputed The Kings Speech in Christ-Church Lord Conway and Secretary Cook by the Kings Command declare the present slate of Affairs Lord Treasurer proceeds in that subject Debates in the House of Commons touching the present state of Affairs Complaints against Papists favored notwithstanding the Kings Answer to the Petition against them The Petition concerning Religion together with his 〈…〉 The Duke renders an account to both Houses of the Fleet. He speaks by way of Objection and Answer * The Earl of Bristol The Dukes Relation accasioned variety of Opinions in Parliament The Kings Message to the Commons Debates upon the Kings Message The Commons Declaration The Parliament dissolved The King follows his Design of War The Kings Proclamation to recal home children of Recusants The Kings Letter to the Lieutenants for the Loan of Money upon Privy-Seals Privy-Seals issued forth to certain Persons Warrants for disarming Recusants Letters directed to Lords Recusants Concourse of Papists prevented Viscount Wimbleton Commander in Chief in the Voyage to Cadez Lord Cromwels Letter to the Duke touching the Fleet. The Earl of Warwick secures Langer-Point in Essex English and Dutch Fleet before Dunkirk dispersed by a storm The General examined before the Council The
a free man imprisonable upon command or pleasure without cause expressed to be absolutely in worse case then a villain and if he did not make this plain he desired their Lordships not to believe him in any thing else and then produced two Book Cases 7. Edw. 3. fol. 50. in the new print 348. old print A Prior had commanded one to imprison his villain the Judges were ready to bayl him till the Prior gave his reason that he refused to be Bayliff of his Manour and that satisfied the Judges 2d Case 33. Edw. 3. title Tresp 253. in Faux imprisonment it was of an Abbot who commanded one to take and detain his villain but demanded his cause he gives it because he refused being thereunto required to drive his Cattel Ergo free men imprisoned without cause shewn are in worse case then villains that must have a cause shewn them why they are imprisoned 3. A Free man impisoned without cause is so far from being a Bondman that he is not so much as a man but is indeed a dead man and so no man imprisonment is in Law a civil death perdit domum familiam vicinos patriam and is to live amongst wretched and wicked men Malefactors and the like And that death and imprisonment was the same he proved by an Argument ab effectis because they both produce the like immediate effects he quoted a Book for this If a man be threatned to be killed he may avoid seoffment of Lands gifts of goods c. so it is if he be threatned to be imprisoned the one is an actual the other is a civil death And this is the first general Argument drawn a re ipsa from the nature of imprisonment to which res ipsa consilium dedit The second general Reason he took also from his books for he said he hath no Law but what by great pains and industry he learnt at his book for at ten years of age he had no more Law then other men of like age and this second reason is a minore ad majus he takes it from Bracton Minima poena corporalis est major qualibet pecuniaria But the King himself cannot impose a fine upon any man but it must be done judicially by his Judges per justitiarios in Curia non per regem in Camera and so it hath been resolved by all the Judges of England he quoted 3. R. 2. fo 11. The third general Reason is taken from the number and diversity of remedies which the Laws give against imprisonment Viz. Breve de homine replegiando De odio atia De Habeas Corpus An appeal of Imprisonment Breve de manucaptione The latter two of these are antiquated but the Writ De odio atia is revived for that was given by the Statute of Magna Charta Cha. 26. and therefore though it were repealed by Statute of 42. E. 3. by which it is provided that all Statutes made against Magna Charta are void now the Law would never have given so many remedies if the free men of England might have been imprisoned at free will and pleasure The fourth general Reason is from the extent and universality of the pretended power to imprison for it should extend not onely to the Commons of this Realm and their Posterities but to the Nobles of the Land and their progenies to the Bishops and Clergy of the Realm and their Successors And he gave a cause why the Commons came to their Lordships Commune periculum commune requirit auxilium Nay it reacheth to all persons of what condition or sex or age soever to all Judges and Officers whose attendance is necessary c. without exception and therefore an imprisonment of such an extent without reason is against reason The fifth general Reason is drawn from the indefiniteness of time the pretended power being limited to no time it may be perpetual during life and this is very hard to cast an old man into prison nay to close prison and no time allotted for his coming forth is a hard case as any man would think that had been so used And here he held it an unreasonable thing that a man had a remedy for his Horse or Cattle if detained and none for his body thus indefinitely imprisoned for a Prison without any prefixed time is a kinde of Hell The sixth and last Argument is a Fine and sapiens incipit a Fine and he wisht he had begun there also and this Argument he made three-fold Ab honesto This being less honourable Ab utili This being less profitable A tuto This Imprisonment by will and pleasure being very dangerous for King and Kingdom 1. Ab honesto It would be no honour to a King or Kingdom to be a King of Bond-men or Slaves the end of this would be both Dedecus Damnum both to King and Kingdom that in former times hath been so renowned Ab utili It would be against the profit of the King and Kingdom for the execution of those Laws before remembred Magna Charta 5. Ed. 3. 25. Ed. 3.28 Ed. 3. whereby the King was inhibited to imprison upon pleasure You see quoth he that this was vetus querela an old question and now brought in again after seven Acts of Parliament I say the execution of all these Laws are adjudged in Parliament to be for the common profit of the King and People and he quoted the Roll this pretended power being against the profit of the King can be no part of his Prerogative He was pleased to call this a binding Reason and to say that the wit of man could not answer it that great men kept this Roll from being Printed but that it was equivalent in force to the printed Rolls 3. A Reason a tuto It is dangerous to the King for two respects first of loss secondly of destroying of the endeavors of men First if he be committed without the expression of the cause though he escape albeit in truth it were for treason or felony yet this escape is neither felony nor treason but if the cause be expressed for suspicion of treason or felony then the escape though he be innocent is treason or felony He quoted a Cause in print like a reason of the Law not like Remittitur at the rising of the Court for the Prisoner traditur in ballium quod breve Regis non fuit susficiens causa The Kings Command He quoted another famous Case Commons in Parliament incensed against the Duke of Suffolk desire he should be committed The Lords and all the Judges whereof those great Worthies Prescot and Fortescue were two delivered a flat opinion that he ought not to be committed without an especial Cause He questioned also the name and etymologie of the Writ in question Corpus cum causa Ergo the Cause must be brought before the Judge else how can he take notice hereof Lastly he pressed a place in the Gospel Acts 25. last verse which Festus conceives is an
absurd and unreasonable thing to send a Prisoner to a Roman Emperor and not to write along with him the Cause alledged against him send therefore no man a Prisoner without his causes along with him Hoc fac vives and that was the first reason a tuto that it was not safe for the King in regard of Loss to commit men without a Cause The second Reason is That such commitments will destroy the endeavors of all men Who will endeavor to imploy himself in any profession either of War Merchandise or of any liberal knowledge if he be but Tenant at will of his Liberty for no Tenant at will will support or improve any thing because he hath no certain estate Ergo to make men Tenants at will of their Liberties destroys all industry and endeavors whatsoever And so much for these six principal Reasons A re ipsa A minore ad majus A remediis From the extent and universality From the infiniteness of the time A fine Loss of Honor. Loss of Profit Loss of Security Loss of Industry These were his Reasons Here he made another Protestation That if remedy had been given in this Case they would not have medled therewith by no means but now that remedy being not obtained in the Kings Bench without looking back upon any thing that hath been done or omitted they desire some provision for the future onely And here he took occasion to adde four Book Cases and Authorities all in the Point saying That if the learned Councel on the other side could produce but one against the Liberties so pat and pertinent oh how they would hug and cull it 16. H. 6. tit monstrance de faits 82. by the whole Court the King in his Presence cannot command a man to be arrested but an action of false imprisonment lieth against him that arresteth if not the King in his royal Presence then none others can do it Non sic itur ad astra 1. Hen. 7.4 Hussey reports the opinion of Markham chief Justice to Edw. 4. that he could not imprison by word of mouth and the reason because the party hath no remedy for the Law leaves every man a remedy of causless imprisonment he added that Markham was a worthy Judge though he fell into adversities at last by the Lord Rivers his means Fortescue Chap. 8. Proprio ore nullus Regum usus est to imprison any man c. 4. Eliz. Times blessed and renowned for Justice and Religion in Pl. 235. the common Law hath so admeasured the Kings Prerogative as he cannot prejudice any man in his inheritance and the greatest inheritance a man hath is the liberty of his Person for all others are accessary to it for thus he quoted the Orator Major haereditas venit unicuique nostrum a Jure legibus quam a parentibus And these are the four Authorities he cited in this point Now he propounded and answered two Objections First in point of State Secondly in the Course held by the House of Commons May not the Privy Councel commit without cause shewed in no matter of State where secrecie is required would not this be an hinderance to his Majesties service It can be no prejudice to the King by reason of matter of State for the cause must be of a higher or lower nature if it be for suspicion of Treason misprision of Treason or Felony it may be by general words couched if it be for any other thing of smaller nature as contempt and the like the particular cause must be shewed and no individuum vagum or uncertain cause to be admitted Again if the Law be so clear as you make it why needs the Declaration and Remonstrance in Parliament The Subject hath in this Case sued for remedy in the Kings Bench by Habeas Corpus and found none therefore it is necessary to be cleared in Parliament And here ends his Discourse And then he made a recapitulation of all that had been offered unto their Lordships That generally their Lordships had been advised by the most faithful Counsellors that can be dead men these cannot be daunted by fear nor muzled by affection reward or hope of preferment and therefore their Lordships might safely believe them particularly their Lordships had three several kinds of Proofs 1. Acts of Parliament judicial Precedents good Reasons First you have had many ancient Acts of Parliament in the Point besides Magna Charta that is seven Acts of Parliament which indeed are thirty seven Magna Charta being confirmed thirty times for so often have the Kings of England given their royal Assents thereunto 2. Judicial Precedents of grave and reverend Judges in terminis terminantibus that long since departed the world and they were many in number Precedents being twelve and the Judges four of a Bench made four times twelve and that is forty eight Judges 3. You have as he tearmed them vividas rationes manifest and apparent Reasons Towards the conclusion he declared to their Lordships That they of the House of Commons have upon great study and serious Consideration made a great manifestation unanimously Nullo contradicente concerning this great liberty of the Subject and have vindicated and recovered the Body of this fundamental Liberty both of their Lordships and themselves from shadows which sometimes of the day are long sometimes short and sometimes long again and therefore we must not be guided by shadows and they have transmitted to their Lordships not capita rerum Heads or Briefs for these compendia are dispendia but the Records at large in terminis terminantibus and so he concluded that their Lordships are involved in the same danger and therefore ex congruo condigno they desired a Conference to the end their Lordships might make the like Declaration as they had done Commune periculum commune requirit auxilium and thereupon take such further course as may secure their Lordships and them and all their Posterity in enjoying of their ancient undoubted and fundamental Liberties The two next days were spent in the Debate about Billeting of Soldiers upon the Subject against Law THursday the 10. of April Mr. Secretary Cook delivered this Message from the King That his Majesty desireth this House not to make any recess these Easter Holidays that the world may take notice how earnest his Majesty and we are for the publique affairs in Christendom the which by such a recess would receive interruption THis Message for non-recess was not well pleasing to the House SIr Robert Phillips first resented it and took notice That in 12. and 18. Iac. upon the like intimation the House resolved it was in their power to adjourn or sit hereafter said he this may be put upon us by Princes of less Piety let a Committee consider hereof and of our right herein and to make a Declaration And accordingly this matter touching his Majesties pleasure about the recess was referred to a Committee and to consider