the whole yeere 1539. passed When I set my selfe to write this Story considering the number of Colloquies some onely intimated and some held to compose the differences in religion I doubted whether it was fit to make mention of all hauing concluding reasons for the one part and the other In the end considering that I haue proposed to my selfe to relate all the causes of the Councell of Trent and obseruing that none hath beene intimated or held but to hinder or diuert or delay or to hasten and accelerate the Councell I resolued to make mention of euery one especially for the fruit which may be gathered from 1540 PAVL 3. CHARLES 5. HENRY 8. FRANCIS 1 1540 the knowledge of the notable particulars which happened in them as in that which was appointed the yeere following which had his beginning thus The Emperour went to the low Countries by the way of France to accommodate those seditions and Ferdinand mett him there where one of the most principall businesses conferred of betweene them both was to finde a way of composition for matters of religion in Germanie which being exactly handled by the body of the Emperours Councell all did incline to institute a Colloquie herein This comming to the eares of Farnese who was Legate there and had accompanied Cardinal Farnese the Popes Legate dissuadeth the Colloquie the Emperour in the voyage which Cardinall though a youth vnder the age of twentie yeers yet had in his company many persons fit for businesse and amongst others Marcellus Ceruinus Bishop of Nicastro who after was Pope and called Marcellus the second hee opposed this resolution and treating with the Emperour Ferdinand and with al those of the Councel he put them in mind that the Protestants had beene often dealt withall for peace beginning ten yeeres since in the Diet of Ausburg but still without effect And in case any conclusion had beene made it would haue beene vaine and fruitlesse For they dayly change their opinion not following any certaine doctrine and haue opposed euen their owne Augustan confession That they are slipperie as Eeels First they were desirous that the abuses and vices should be remooued now they will not haue the Papacie amended but extinguished and the Apostolicall Sea rooted out and all Ecclesiasticall iurisdiction abolished And if euer they were petulant they would be then much more when the peace was not well confirmed with France and the Turke threatned Hungarie That there was no hope to perswade them because the controuersies were vpon innumerable doctrines And because there are many Sects among them it is impossible to accord with all besides that the greater part of them hath no other end but to possesse the goods of others and bereaue the Emperour of his authoritie It was true that the instant Turkish warre perswaded an agreement in Religion but this was not to be done in particular or Nationall Diets but in a generall Councell which might immediately be intimated For where Religion is in question no mutation can be made without common consent That Germany is not onely to bee respected but France Spaine Italie and other people without whose counsell if Germany shall make a change there will arise a dangerous diuision of that Prouince from the rest That it was a most ancient custome euen from the time of the Apostles to compose controuersies with a Councell onely and that now all Kings Princes and godly men desired it That peace may now easily be concluded betweene the Emperor and the King of France immediatly after a councel called and in the meane space indeauours may be vsed to increase the number and power of the Catholique league of Germany which by intimidating the Protestants will cause them to submit themselues to the Councell or at the least they will bee enforced by the Catholiques and when it shall be necessary to resist the Turke the Catholique league being strong may constraine the Protestants to contribute which in case they will not doe it was necessarie of two euils to chuse the lesser it being a greater fault to offend God by abandoning the cause of Religion then to want the assistance of one part of a Prouince And the rather because it is not easie to iudge who are more contrary to Christ the Protestants or the Turkes For these desire to inthrale our bodies but those both bodyes and soules together All the discourses and parlies of the Cardinal had for their conclusion that it was fit to call a Councell and to begin it that same yeere and not to treate of Religion in the Diets of Germanie but to labour or augment the Catholique league and to make peace with the King of France The Emperour after much deliberation concluded that he would labour for a concord and gaue order for a Diet to be held in Germany where Ferdinand thought good inuiting the Protestant Princes to be there in person and promising publike securitie vnto all Cardinall Fernese hearing of this The Legate departeth conclusion made without his knowledge went immediately away and passing by Paris obtained of the King a seuere edict against the heretiques and Lutherans which being published was executed in that citie and after throughout all France with much rigour In Germanie the Diet was called by Ferdinand in Aganoa where the Catholigue The Diet of Aganoa about Religion Doctors and many Protestant Preachers and Ministers met together and the Elector of Triers the Palatine Duke Lewis of Bauaria and William Bishop of Argentina were deputed for mediators betweene the parties The Protestants being required to present the heads of the doctrine in controuersie answered that they had giuen vp their cōfession in Ausburg ten yeers since and an Apologie in defence of it that they perseuered in that doctrine and were ready to giue an account thereof vnto all men and not knowing what the aduersaries reprehended they had no more to say but expected to vnderstand from them what it was they esteemed contrary to trueth for so the matter will come to a conference and themselues wil not faile to set peace before their eies The Catholiques tooke them suddenly at their word assenting to what the others proposed inferred that it was fit to esteem for approued all things passed in that Diet and to account the Decree firme and stable which was published in the Recesse and to lay before them the forme of reconciliation begun in that Diet. The Protestants knowing their disaduantage in case they followed that forme and the preiudice which that decree would haue inferred vrged for a new forme and to haue all the preiudices taken away On the other side the Catholiques demaunded that in regard all preiudice was to be remoued those things that the Protestants had done should be rectified and the Church goods taken by them restored The Protestants replyed that the goods were not taken away but by renouation of the true doctrine were reapplyed to those lawfull and honest vses vnto
Saint Iames did vnderstand the ancients for age and not the Priests ordained by the Bishop But if any maruaile why it is said in the first head of the doctrine that 14. Articles of reformation are handled in which the Presidents of the Synod the Bishops haue diuers ends this Sacrament is insinuated by CHRIST our Lord in Saint Marke and published in Saint Iames whereas the antecedence and consequence of the words did require that it should not bee sayd insinuated but instituted hee may know that it was first so written but a Diuine hauing obserued that the Apostles who anoynted the sicke of whom Saint Marke speaketh were not Priests because the Church of Rome holdeth that Priesthood was conferred vpon them onely in the last Supper it seemed a contradiction to affirme that the Vnction which they gaue was a Sacrament and that Priests onely are ministers of it Whereunto some who held it to bee a Sacrament and at that time instituted by CHRIST did answere that CHRIST commanding them to minister the Vnction made them Priests concerning that acte onely As if the Pope should command a simple Priest to giue the Sacrament of Chrisme he made him a Bishop for that acte Yet it was thought too dangerous to affirme it absolutely Therefore in stead of the word Institutum they put Insinuatum Which word what it may signifie in such a matter euery one may iudge who vnderstandeth what Insinuare is and doeth apply it to that which the Apostles then did and to that which was commanded by Saint Iames and to the determination made by this Councell But in matter of reformation as hath beene said fourteene Articles were proposed all belonging to Episcopall iurisdiction whereof when they had vnderstood the opinion of the Canonists in the particular Congregations and read all in the generall they came to frame the Decree Herein the ayme of the B B was to increase their authority to recouer that which the Pope had vsurped from them and of the Presidents to grant as little as they could But both parties did proceede cunningly and made shew to regard onely the seruice of God and the restitution of the ancient Ecclesiasticall discipline The Bishops thought they were hindered in executing their office For when they did suspend any from exercise of their orders or Ecclesiasticall degrees and dignities for causes knowen to themselues or did refuse to let them passe to higher degrees all was retracted by a Licence or Dispensation gotten at Rome which caused a disreputation of the Bishops damnation of soules and a totall ruine of discipline Concerning this the first head was made that such Licences and Restitutions should not bee offorce But the President for the honour of the Apostolique Sea would not haue the Pope named nor the chiefe Penitentiarie nor any ministers of the Court from whom such Licences were wont to bee obtained The titular Bishops did also hinder them who beeing depriued by a Decree published in the sixt Session of power to exercise the pontificall office in the Diocesses without leaue of the proper Bishop did retire themselues into a place exempt from all Bishopriques admitting those to holy orders who were before reiected as vnfit by their owne Bishops which they did by vertue of a priuiledge to ordaine any that offered himselfe vnto them This was prohibited in the second head but with this moderation that for reuerence of the Apostolike Sea mention should not bee made who granted the priuiledge And consequently in the third head power was giuen to the Bishops to suspend for what time they pleased any one ordained without their examination or with licence by facultie giuen by whomsoeuer These things the wiser sort of Bishops knew to bee of small weight because the Canonists doe hold that 344 Licences Priuiledges and Faculties granted by the Pope are neuer comprehended in generall words without speciall mention bee made of them But not beeing able to obtaine more they were content with this hoping that time might open them a way to proceede further It was also decreed in the same sixth Session that no secular Clerke by vertue of personall Priuiledge nor Regular dwelling out of the Monasterie by vigor of the Priuiledge of his order should bee exempt from the correction of the Bishoppe as Delegate of the Apostolike Sea Which some thinking not to containe the Canons of Cathedrall Churches and other Collegiate dignities who not by priuiledge but by ancient custome or by sentences put in execution or by Concordates with the Bishops established and sworne were in possession of not beeing subiect to Bishops and others also restraining it onely to visitation it was ordained in the fourth head that concerning secular Clerkes it should bee extended to all times and all sorts of excesses and declared that none of the things aforesayd should withstand Another disorder as great did arise because the Pope did grant a Iudge at the election of the supplicant to whosoeuer did seeke it by the ordinary meanes vsed in Court with authoritie to defend protect and maintaine him in possession of his rights and to remooue the molestation giuen him extending also this fauour to all his domestiques And this sort of Iudges were called Conseruators who did stretch their authoritie in place of defending the supplicant from molestations to withdraw him from iust corrections and also at their instance to molest and trouble the Bishops and other ordinary Ecclesiasticall superiours with censures The fifth point made prouision against this disorder ordaining that Conseruatorie graces should not helpe any body nor free him from inquisition accusation and conuention before the Ordinary in criminall and mixt causes and in ciuill also in which hee is plaintife and in other causes if the Conseruator bee suspected or difficultie arise betweene him and the Ordinary who is competent Iudge that arbitrators shall bee chosen according to the forme of the Law and that Conseruatory letters which comprehend domestiques shall bee extended but vnto two who doe liue at the charge of the Master of the familie and that these and the like graces shall not continue aboue fiue yeeres and that the Conseruators shall not haue Tribunals But the Synod did not meane to containe in this Decree Vniuersities Colledges of Doctours and Schollers places of Regulars and Hospitals Concerning which exception when this point was handled there was very great contention it seeming to the Bishops that against all right the exception was larger then the rule because the number of Doctors Schollers Regulars and Hospitalaries is greater then of all others who can haue Conseruatorie letters and that the prouision against any particular man was easie but the disorders of Vniuersities and Colledges were of the greatest importance The Legate gaue an account heereof to Rome where it beeing decided by that which was consulted vnder Paul the third that it was necessary for maintenance of the Apostolique Sea that the Friars and Vniuersities should totally depend on
whose opinion he followed because the Emperour had giuen him charge to consult with those two Cardinals in all matters After the ceremonie was ended in the Consistery with satisfaction of the Pope the Ambassadour begin to pray him in the first priuate audience in Caesars name to call the Councel to compose the dissensions of Germany was preuented by him with the Ambassadors great contentment who beleeuing that hee was to treat with the Pope about an And is well pleased that his Holinesse beginneth to speake of the Councell vnpleasing businesse was prepared to deliuer in sugered termes that it might be heard more willingly The Pope told him that the Cardinals being in the Conclaue consulted how they might set the Councell on foote againe in which consultation himselfe was a very principal partie and now being Pope was more confirmed in the same determination Yet he would not proceede blindely but so as that he might auoyd the difficulties which happened before and would bee sure of the necessarie preparatories that the desired fruit might succeed Hee sayd the like to the Ambassadours of France and Spaine and wrote to his Nuncij to impart it to their Kings hee spake of it also with the Ambassadours of the King of Portugal and of the Princes of Italie which were in Rome The Duke of Sauoy demandeth the Popes haue to hold a Colloquie After this the Duke of Sauoy sent one expresly to desire the Pope that by his fauour he might make a colloquie of religion to instruct his people of the Vallies who were generally alienated from the old religion These were a part of the Waldenses who 400 yeeres since forsooke the Church of Rome and in regard of the persecutions fled into Polonia Germany Puglia Prouence and some of them into the Valleys of Mountsenis Luserna Angronia Perosa and S. Martin These hauing alwayes continued in their separation with certaine ministers of their owne whom they called Pastors when the doctrine of Zuinglius was planted in Geneua did presently vnite themselues with those as agreeing with them in points of doctrine principall rites and when Piemont was vnder the French-men though they were forbid vpon paine of death to exercise their religion yet by little and little they made it publique so that when Countrey was restored to the Duke of Sauoy the exercise of it was almost free The Duke resolued to make them receiue the Catholike religion so that many were burned and put to death by other meanes and more condemned to the Galleys at the instigation of the Inquifitor Thomaso Iacomello a Dominican Friar This made them consult whether it were lawfull to defend themselues with Armes wherein their ministers did not agree Some sayd they might not oppose their Prince though it were to defend their own liues but might carry away their goods and reure into the mountaines Others said they might vse force in so desperate a case as this especially it being not so much against the Prince as against the Pope who abused the autoritie of the Prince Many of them did follow the first opinion and the others stood vpon their guard so that the Duke perceiuing they had not rebellious thoughts and that they might easily be gained by instruction receiued the counsell which was giuen him to institute a Colloquie to this end But because hee would not displease the Pope by proceeding without his knowledge he gaue him an account hereof and asked his consent The Pope beeing angry that in Italy also euen vnder To instruct the people of his Valleys whom before he had perseceted his nose his authority should be questioned answered that hee would consent by no meanes but if those people had neede of instruction hee would send a Legate with authority to absolute them who would bee conuerted accompanied with Diuines who might giue them instruction But But his Holinesse refuseth to grant it hee sayd hee had little hope to conuert them because the heretikes are obstinate and whatsoeuer is done to exhort them to acknowledge their fault they expound to bee a want of force to compell them That it cannot bee remembred that any good was euer done by this moderation but that experience is taught that the sooner iustice is vsed and force of Armes when that other is not sufficient so much the better the successe is If hee would proceed thus hee would send him assistance but if he thought it not fit all might bee deferred vntill a generall Councell which he would suddenly call And therefore the Duke taketh Armes against them The Duke did not like the sending of a Legat because it would haue prouoked them more and forced him to proceed according to the interests of others thinking it better to take Armes which the Pope commended more and promised assistance Therefore there was warre in these Valleys all this yeere and part of the next whereof we will speake in the time when it ended There was a great conspiracie in many parts of France into which many A great conspiracie in France the causes of it were entred and the maior part for cause of Religion disdaining to see poore people drawen euery day to the stake to bee burned guilty of nothing but of zeale to worship GOD and to saue their owne soules To these were ioyned others who thinking the Guisards to be the cause of all the disorders of the Kingdome iudged it an heroike acte to deliuer it from oppression by taking the publike administration out of their hands There were also ambitious persons desirous of change who could not worke their will but in the middest of troubles Both these couered themselues with the cloake of Religion to gaine more followers and the better to confirme their mindes caused the Principall Lawyers of Germany and France and the most famous Protestant Diuines to publish in writing that without violating the Maiestie of the King and dignity of the lawfull Magistrate they might oppose with Armes the violent domination of the house of Guise who offended true Religion and lawfull iustice and kept the King as it were in prison The Conspirators prepared a great multitude who should appeare before the King without Armes to demand that the seuerity of the iudgements might be mitigated and liberty of conscience granted designing they should bee followed by Gentlemen who should make supplication against the gouernement of the Guisards The conspiracie was discouered and the Court retired from Blois an open place fit for the execution of such a purpose vnto The Conspirations are discouered and many of them executed and the rest pardoned Amboise a strong fortresse This troubled the Conspiratours who while they were thinking of a new course some of them who tooke Armes were beaten and slaine and others taken and sentenced to die and to appease the tumult pardon was granted by the Kings Edict dated the eighteenth of March to all who simply moued with zeale of Religion had entred into the
not it should bee sayd that faith is formed with charity because that kind of speach is not vsed by Saint Paul but onely that faith worketh by charity Others vnderstood that iustifying faith was faith in generall not saying it was either liuely or dead because they doe both iustifie after diuers manners either compleatly as the liuely or as a beginning or foundation as the historicall faith and of this Saint Paul speaketh when he attributeth iustice vnto it no otherwise then as Philosophie is contained in the alphabet that is as in a basis which is as it were nothing the principall remaining that is to set the statue vpon it This second opinion was iointly maintained by the Dominicans and Franciscans the other by Marinarus and his adherents But the principall point of the difficulty was not touched that is whether a man is iust and then doth iustly or by doing iustly becommeth iust They all agreed in one opinion that to say onely faith doeth iustifie was a proposition of many fenses and all absurd For God and the Sacraments doe iustifie as causes in their seuerall kindes so that the proposition hath that and many other exceptions The preparation also of the soule to receiue grace is a cause in its kinde so that faith cannot exclude that sort of workes But the Articles concerning workes that goe before grace all which Luther condemneth for sinne the Diuines censured for hereticall rather by way of inuectiue then otherwise condemning likewise of heresie the opinion taken in generall that humane workes without faith are sinne thinking it a cleare case that many actions of men are indifferent neither good nor euill and that others there are which though they bee not acceptable to God yet are morally good as the honest actions of Infidels and Christians which are sinners which to call honest and sinnes implieth a contradiction and the rather because in this ranke are included the heroicall actions so much commended by antiquity But Catarinus maintained that man without the speciall helpe of God can doe no worke which may truely bee good though morally but sinneth Catarinus his opinion concerning the value of workes still Therefore the workes of the Infidels who are not excited by God to beleeue and of the faithfull who are sinners before God stirreth them vp to conuersion though they seeme honest to men euen heroicall yet are truely sinnes and hee that commendeth them doth consider them in generall and according to externall appearance but hee that shall examine the circumstances of euery one shall finde they are peruerse and that for this Luther was not to bee condemned notwithstanding hee sayd that the Articles ought to bee censured as they speake of workes that follow preuenting grace which are a preparation to iustification as an abomination of sinne feare of hell and other terrours of conscience For confirmation of his opinion hee brought the doctrine of Saint Thomas that to doe a good worke the concurrence of all circumstances is necessary but the want of one onely is sufficient for an ill So that howsoeuer among the workes considered in generall some are indifferent yet in the singular there is no medium betweene hauing all the circumstances and wanting some Therefore euery particular action is good or euill neither is there to bee found any one indifferent And because amongst the circumstances the end is one all workes referred to a bad end are infected so that the Infidels referring all to a bad end their actions are sins though they seeme heroicall to him that knoweth not their intention Neither doth it make any difference whether the relation to a bad end be actuall or habituall because the iust doth merit though hee referreth not the worke actually to God but habitually onely He said further alleaging Saint Austine that it is sinne not onely to refer the action to a bad end but also not to referre it to a good and because hee defended that without the speciall preuenting assistance of God a man cannot referre any thing to God he concluded that no good morall worke can bee before For this he alleadged many places of Saint Austine to shew that hee was of this opinion He alleadged also places of Saint Ambrose Saint Prosper S. Anselmus and of other Fathers He produced Gregory of Arimini the Cardinall of Rochester who in his booke against Luther was cleerely of the same opinion saying it was better to follow the Fathers then the Schoole-men who are diuided and rather to take the Scriptures for a ground from whence true Theologie is taken then the subtilties of Philosophy which the Schooles haue vsed that himselfe also was of that opinion but hauing studied the Scriptures and Fathers had found the trueth Hee alleadged the passage of the Gospel A bad tree cannot beare good fruit with the amplification which our Sauiour added saying Either make the tree good and the fruit good or the tree euill and the fruit euill He vsed also other arguments and especially the place of Saint Paul that nothing can be cleane to Infidels because their minde and conscience is spotted This opinion was very sharpely impugned by Soto proclaiming it hereticall Soto proclaymeth the opinion of Catarinus to bee hereticall for inferring that man had not libertie to doe well nor could obtaine his naturall end which was to denie Free-will with the Lutheranes Hee maintained a man might by that strength of nature obserue euery precept of the Law in regard of the substance of the worke though not in regard of the end which was enough to auoid sinne Hee said there were three sorts of humane actions one the transgression of the Law which is sinne another the obseruation thereof hauing charity for the end which is meritorious and acceptable to God the third mixt when the Law is obeyed for the substance of the precept which worke is morally good and perfect in its kinde because it accomplisheth the Law making euery worke good according to morality auoiding by that meanes all sin But he moderated this great perfection of our nature by adding that it was one thing to take heede of any one particular sinne and another to beware of all together and sayd that a man might auoid any one but not all by the example of him that had a vessell with three holes who could not stoppe them with two hands but could stop which two of them he would one remaining open of necessity This doctrine did not satisfie some of the Fathers For though it clearly shewed that all workes are not sinnes yet it did not wholly salue Free-will because it will necessarily follow that it is not free in auoiding all sinne But Soto giuing the title of good workes vnto these knew not how to determine whether they were preparatory to iustification It seemed to him they were in regard of the goodnesse of them and it seemed they were not considering the doctrine of Saint Austine approoued by Saint Thomas and other good Diuines
which maketh a iudiciall processe and saith that none can accuse or condemne GODs Elect because GOD doth iustifiethem where the iudiciall words to accuse and condemne doe shew that the word Iustifie is iudiciall also But the Franciscans approued habituall grace because charity it selfe is an habit And here was a sharpe disputation betweene them and the Dominicans whether the habit of Grace be the same with the habit of Charity as Scotus would or distinct as Saint Thomas and neither party yeelding they debated whether besides this Grace or inherent Iustice the Iustice of CHRIST also bee imputed to the iustified as if it were his owne which they did in regard of the opinion of Alvertus Pighius who confessing the inherent added that we must not trust in that but in the imputed iustice of CHRIST as if it were ours None doubted that CHRIST had merited for vs but some blamed the word to Impute and would haue it abolished because it was not to bee found in Fathers who contented themselues with the words Communication participation diffusion deriuation application computation and coniunction Others said that agreeing vpon the thing they ought not to differ vpon the word because it signifieth precisely the same that the others doe which though not by all and often yet sometimes was vsed For this the 109. Epistle of Saint Barnard was brought and Vega defended that though the word be not found in the Scriptures yet it is a most proper Latine word to say that the iustice of CHRIST is imputed to mankind for satisfaction and merit and that it is continually imputed to all that bee iustified and doe satisfie for their owne sinnes but hee would not haue it sayd it was imputed as if it were ours Whereunto it being opposed that Saint Thomas vseth to say that the passion of CHRIST is communicated to the baptized for remission as if himselfe had sustained it and died there was a long and great contention vpon his words The Heremite Generall held an opinion that in the Sacrament of Baptisme the Iustice of CHRIST is imputed because it is communicated wholly and intirely but not in penance when our satisfactions are also required But Soto sayd the word Imputation was most popular and plausible because it signified at the first sight that all should bee acknowledged from CHRIST but yet that he did euer suspect it in regard of the bad consequences which the Lutheranes draw from thence That is that this onely is sufficient without inherent righteousnes that the Sacraments doe not conferre grace that the punishment is abolished together with the guilt that there remaineth no place for satisfaction that all are equall in grace iustice and glorie whence they deduce also that abominable blasphemie that euery iust man is equall to the blessed Virgin This admonition begat such a suspicion in the hearers that there appeared a manifest inclination to condemne the word for hereticall though reasons were effectually replyed to the contrary The contentions betweene the Theologues did certainly arise from the immoderate affection they bare to their owne sect and were cherished by diuers for diuers ends By the Imperialists to constraine them to abandon iustification By the Courtiers to find a way to separate the Councell and so to auoid the imminent reformation And by others to free themselues from incommodities which they feared would be greater by reason of the dearth Contentions in the Councell are cherished by diuers for diuers ends A Iubily is published in Rome in which religion is declared to be the cause of the warâ—e against the Protestants and of the warre which approached and the rather because they had little hope to doe good But while they thus dispute in Trent the Pope published a Iubile in Rome the fifteenth of Iuly by which he eased the Princes of Germany of the paines to find out or perswade others the true cause of the warre For hauing largely declared in that Bull his pastorall affection and care for the saluation of men relating the perdition of soules by the increase of heresies and that to roote them out the Councell was alreadie begun hee bewailed aboue measure the obstinacie of the heretikes who contemne and refuse to obey it and to submit themselues to the determination thereof For remedie whereof he had made a League with the Emperour to reduce them to the obedience of the Church by force of Armes Hee therefore wished them all to haue recourse vnto GOD by prayers fastings confessions and communions that GOD of his Diuine Maiestie would giue a good issue to this warre vndertaken for his glory exaltation of the Church and extirpation of heresies The Emperour in conformity to his purpose of concealing the cause of The Emperours Bandâ— against the Sax on and Landgraue Religion the twentieth of the same moneth published a Bando against the Saxon and Landgraue laying to their charge that they had alwayes hindered his designes had neuer obeyed him made conspiracies against him mooued warre against other Princes of the Empire seased vpon Bishoprickes and other gouernments dispossessed many of their goods and couered all these things with the glorious and sweet name of Religion peace and liberty but hauing indeede rather any other end Therefore hee doeth prescribe them as perfidious rebels seditious guilty of high treason and enemies of the publike peace and commandeth that none doe assist them or be linked with them absolueth the nobility and people of their dominions from their Oath of fidelitie including all those in the Bando who perseuere to obey them The cause of the warre alleadged by the Emperour grieued the Pope and The Pope and the Emperour are offended one with another for alleadging diuers causes of the warre that of the Pope grieued the Emperor because both their ends were hindred For though the Pope pretended that he had published this Manifest that all the people of Christendome might implore the ayde of God to fauour the Emperours Armes yet both he and euery man of iudgement knew very well that it was to giue notice to Germany and the whole world that the warre was for Religion which the simpler sort also did know a little after For his letter to the Suisses before mentioned and a copie of the Capitulations made with Madruccio were published The Pope crossed Casar in this because hee desired the suppression of the Protestants without the exaltation of the Emperour and therefore to ballance them well hee meant to constraine all the professors of the new Religion to vnite against him And it is certaine that the Popes action hindered the Emperours designes For desiring the Suisses to continue their league with the house of Austria and Burgundy and not assist the rebels the Euangelikes answered that they would first be sure that the warre was not for Religion So it hapened that the warre being but newly begun diseords were already sowed betweene the Princes lately confederated The Potentates of Italie were amazed
perseuere without the speciall assistance of GOD or cannot with it 23. That the iust cannot sinne or can auoyde all veniall sinnes without a speciall priuiledge as the Church holdeth of the Virgin 24. That iustice is not preserued and increased by good workes but that they are fruits onely or signes 25. That the iust sinneth mortally or venially in euery worke 26. That the iust ought not to expect a reward for his good workes 27 That there is no mortall sinne but infidelity 28 That grace being lost faith is lost also or that the faith remayning is not true nor of a Christian 29 That man sinning after baptisme cannot be lifted vp by the grace of God or may recouer it by faith onely without the Sacrament of penanace 30. That euery fault and punishment is wholly remitted to euery penitent man there remaning no temporall punishment to bee indured in this life or in Purgatorie 31. That the iust sinneth if hee doe good onely in hope of an eternall reward 32. That the good workes of the iust are the gifts of God and are not withall the merits of the iustified 33. That this doctrine is derogatory to the glory of God and merits of CHRIST or that their glory is not made more illustrious by it When I had made this short narration of the Decree I began to thinke it superfluous seeing all the decrees of that Councel are printed in one volume The authors reason why he rehearseth the decrees though they be printed in a volume apart and in euery mans hands and that in the composition of the Actes that follow I might referre my selfe to that booke and I was about to teare this leafe But considering that some might desire to reade the whole continuation in one booke only and that if any thought it better to see the originall hee might omit this mine abbreuiation I resolued not to change but to obserue the same stile in the matters following and the rather because I am grieued when in Zenophon and Tacitus I see the narration of things most knowen to their times omitted which remaineth vnknowen to mee because there is no meanes to know it againe and I hold it for a maxime that one ought neuer to referre himselfe to another Therefore I come to the summe of the Decree of reformation Which did containe in substance 1. That the Synod being willing to The Decree of reformation amend the depraued manners of the Clergie and people thought fit to begin with the gouernours of the greater Churches Therefore trusting in God and his Vicar on earth that that charge shall be giuen to worthy men exercised from their youth in Ecclesiasticall discipline it doth admonish them to performe their duety which cannot bee executed without residing in the place where it is to bee done Yet many leauing the flocke and care of the lambes wander in Courts and apply themselues to secular businesse Therefore the Synod doth reuiue all the ancient Canons against non-residents and doth constitute besides that euery gouernour of a Cathedrall Church of what title or preeminencie soeuer who shall remaine sixe moneths together out of his Diocesse without a iust and reasonable cause shall lose the fourth part of the reuenues and if he perseuere sixe moneths more shall lose another fourth part and the contumacie increasing the Metropolitane vpon paine of not entring into the Church for three moneths shall delate him to the Pope who by his supreame authoritie may inflict greater punishment or prouide the Church of a more profitable Pastor And if the Metropolitan shall likewise offend the most ancient Suffragan shall bee bound to denounce him 2. But others inferiours to Bishops tyed to residence either by law or custome shall be compelled thereunto by the Bishops abrogating euery priuiledge which giueth a perpetuall exemption from residing But dispensations granted for a time for a reasonable cause true and prooued before the Ordinary shall remaine in force and the Bishop as Delegate of the Apostolike Sea shall take care that a sufficient Vicar bee prouided for the charge of soules with a conuenient portion of the reuenues notwithstanding any priuiledge or exemption 3. Beside that no Clerke by personall priuiledge or regular dwelling out of the Monasterie by priuiledge of his order shall bee exempt from beeing punished if hee offend or visited or corrected by his Ordinary 4. Likewise that Chapters of Cathedrall and other Collegiate Churches shall not by vertue of exemption customes oathes and agreements bee freed from the visitation of their Bishops and greater Prelates when there shall be neede 5. In fine it did ordaine that no Bishop might exercise Pontificall actes in the diocesse of another by pretence of priuiledge without his leaue and The next Session to bee held the third of March. onely ouer his subiects And the day of the next Session was appointed the third of March. In Rome the Decree of faith ministred no matter of discourse in regard it was not new as well because it had beene seene and examined publikely as hath beene sayd as because all men knew that the Germane opinions were to bee condemned But the Court Bishops who had beene afraid a long time of the Article of residencie which was handled did rest content assuring themselues that the Decree of the Councell could worke no greater effect then the Popes Decretals had done before But the inferiour The inferiour Courtiers are discontented with the reformation Courtiers were discontented seeing the Bishop had power to compell them They lamented their owne misery who were to serue all their life to gaine their liuing and after so much paines taken for a reward must be confined in a village or by a base Canonry subiected to a greater slauery in obeying the Bishops who will not onely keepe them as it were tied to a stake but with visitations and pretence of corrections will bring them to a miserable subiection or hold them in perpetuall vexations and charge But elsewhere and especially in Germanie when the Decrees were seene The Decrees are censured in Germany that of faith was more spoken of which must bee read ouer and againe with much attention and speculation because it could not bee vnderstood without a perfect knowledge of the inward motion of the mind and without knowing in whom it is actiue in whom passiue things most subtile and for the diuers appearance they make euer accounted disputable all the doctrine of the Councel turning vpon this hinge whether the first obiect of the will worke vpon the will or the will vpon the obiect or whether they bee both actiue and passiue Some pleasant wits said that if the Astrologers not knowing the true causes of the celestiall motions to salue the appearances haue inuented Eccentriques and Epicicles it was no wonder if the Councell desiring to salue the appearances of the super-celestiall motions did fall into excentricitie of opinions The Grammarians did not cease to admire and scoffe
it in a Mercuriall so they call the iudicature instituted to examine and correct the actions of the Counsellors of Parliament and Iudges of the King held in Paris the 15. of Iune where they were to treate of Religion after the Congregation was assembled entred in person Hee said hee had established peace in the whole world by the marriages of his sister and daughter that hee might prouide against the inconueniences bred in his Kingdome about Religion which ought to bee the principall care of Princes Therefore vnderstanding they were to treat of this subiect hee exhorted them to handle Gods cause with sinceritie And hauing commaunded them to prosecute the things begun Claude Viole one of them spake much against the manners of the Court of Rome and the bad customes growen to bee pernicious errours which haue caused the new sects Therefore it was necessary to mitigate the seuere punishments vntill the differences of religion were remooued and the Ecclesiasticall discipline amended by authority of a Generall Councell the onely remedie for these euils as the Councels of Constance and Basil haue iudged commanding that one should bee celebrated euery ten yeeres His opinion was followed by Ludouicus Faber and some others Anne du Bourg did adde that many villanies were comitted condemned by the Lawes for punishment whereof the rope and fire were not sufficient as frequent blasphemies against God periuries adulteries not onely secret but euen cherished with impudent licence making himselfe to be plainely vnderstood that hee spake not onely of the Grandies of the Court but of the King himselfe also adding that while men liued thus dissolutely diuers torments were prepared against those who were guilty of nothing but of publishing to the world the vices of the Church of Rome and desiring an amendment of them In opposition of all this Egidius Magister the prime President spake against the new sects concluding that there was no other remedie but that which was formerly vsed against the Albigenses of whom Philippus Augustus put to death sixe hundred in one day and against the Waldenses who were choked in the caues whither they retired to hide themselues When all the voyces were giuen the King said he had now heard with his owne eares that which before was told him that the contagion of the Kingdome doth hence arise 1559 PIVS 4. FERDINAND PHILIP 2. ELIZABETH HENRY 2. And coÌ„mandeth some of the Counsellors of Parliament to bee imprisoned that there are in the Parliament who doe despise the Popes authoritie and his that he well knoweth they are but few but the cause of many euils Therefore hee exhorted those who are good subiects to continue in doing their duety and immediatly gaue order that Faber and du Bourg should be imprisoned and afterward caused foure more to bee apprehended in their houses which did much daunt those who embraced the new religion For the Counsellors of Parliament in France beeing reputed most sacred and inuiolable who notwithstanding were put into prison for deliuering their opinion in publike Assembly they concluded that the King would pardon none But examples of great feares are alwayes ioyned with others of equall boldnesse 15â—9 The Reformatists hold a Synod in Paris For at the same time as if there had beene no danger at all the ministers of the Reformed for so the Protestants are called in France assembled in Paris in the suburbes of Saint German made a Synode in which Franciscus Morellus the chiefe man amongst them was President ordayning diuers constitutions of the manner of holding Councels of remoouing the domination in the Church of the election and office of Ministers of censures of marriages of diuorces of degrees of consanguinitie and affinitie that throughout all France they might not onely haue an vniforme faith but discipline also And their courage did increase because the fame of the seuerity vsed in France comming into Germanie the three Electors and And are encouraged by the intercession of the Protestant Princes of Germanie other Protestant Princes sent Ambassadours to the King praying him to proceede with pietie and Christian charitie against the professors of their Religion guiltie of nothing but of accusing the corrupted manners and the discipline peruerted by the Church of Rome which had bene done more then an hundred yeeres since by other godly Doctors of France For that Kingdome beeing now in quiet the differences of Religion may easily bee composed by the disputation of able men desirous of peace who may examine their confession by the rule of holy Scripture and of the ancient Fathers suspending in the meane time the seueritie of the sentences which they will receiue as a thing most gratefull and remaine much obliged to him for it The King gaue a courteous answere in generall wordes promising Which did them no good to giue them satisfaction and to send one expresly to signifie so much vnto them Yet he remitted nothing of the seueritie but after the Ambassadours were parted hee deputed foure Iudges of the body of the Parliament in the causes of the prisoners with the Bishop of Paris and the Inquisitor Antonie de Mocares commaunding them to proceede with all expedition The Pope vnto whom all these things were knowen as hee was much discontented with the progresse of the new doctrine in the States of both the Kings so hee was pleased that those Princes did thinke of it and mooued them by his Nuncij and by their Ambassadours residing with him to doe so still But hee would not haue any other meanes then that of the Inquisition which he thought the onely remedie as he said vpon all occasions iudging that the Councell would doe as formerly it had done that is reduce all into a worse state While he was possessed with these cogitations and weake of body the King of France died the second of Iuly by a wound in the eye running at Tilt for which hee seemed very sorrowfull and was so indeede For although hee suspected and with reason the intelligence betweene the 1559. PAVL 4. FERDINAND ELIZABETH FRANCIS 2. Henry the second dyeth the second of Iuly two Kings yet hee had still hope to separate them But the one being dead he saw he was at the discretion of the other alone whom he more feared because he was more offended by him and was of a more close nature hard to be sounded Hee feared also that in France a gate would be set wide open to let in sectes which might bee confirmed before the new King could get so much wisedome and reputation as was necessary to oppose so great difficulties Hee liued some few dayes afflicted with these cogitations but now laying aside all hopes which had vntill then kept him aliue hee died the eighteenth The Pope Iyeth the 18. of August recommending to the Cardinals nothing but the office of the Inquisition of August recommending to the Cardinals nothing but the office of the Inquisition the onely meanes as he said to
Councell was not intermitted for all The Articles of the Sacrament of Order this For the Articles concerning the Sacrâ—ment of Order were presently giuen foorth to be disputed by the Diuines the disputants elected and distinguished into foure rankes each of them being to di 〈…〉 two For they were eigh◠〈◊〉 Whether Order be truely and properly a Sacrament instituted by CHRIST or an humane inuentions or Rite to elect Ministers of the word of GOD and of the Saoâ—â—ments 〈◊〉 Whether Order bee one Saorament onely and all others bee meanes and degrees vnto Priesthood 3. Whether there be an Hierarchie in the Catholique Church consisting of Bishops Priests and other Orders or whether all Christians bee Priests or whether the vocation 〈◊〉 consent of the people or secular Magistrate bee necessary or whether a Priest may become a Laicke 〈◊〉 Whether there be a visible and externall Priesthood in the new Testament and a power to consecrate and offer the body and blood of CHRIST and to remit sinnes or onely the baâ—e Ministery to preach the Gospel so that those who preach not are not Priests 〈◊〉 Whether the holy Ghost is giuen and receiued in ordination and a Character imprinted 6. Whether Vnction and other ceremonies be necessary in consering Order or superfluous or pernicious 〈◊〉 Whether Bishops bee super 〈…〉 to Priests and haue peculiar power to confirme and ordaine and whether those who are brought in by any other meanes then Canonicall ordination are true Ministers of the Word and Sacraments◠〈◊〉 W 〈…〉 the Bishops called and ordained by the Pope be lawfull 〈◊〉 the those bee true Bishops who come in by any other way then Canonicall institution The 〈◊〉 of the moneth the Congregations of the Diuines 〈◊〉 gaâ— and were held twice la day and ended the second of October I will according 〈◊〉 vse â—â—late those opinions onely which are remarkeable 〈◊〉 ther for singularity o◠〈◊〉 among themselues In the first Congregation foure Dillines of the Pope spake who did all Are disputed in the Congregations 〈◊〉 in 〈…〉 ning that Order was a 〈◊〉 by places of Scripture 〈◊〉 ally by that of S 〈◊〉 The thing â—hich 〈◊〉 from God are 〈◊〉 then by the â—â—adition of the Apoâ—â—le sâ—yings of the 〈◊〉 vâ—â—iso 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and aboue all by the Councell of Florence adding also this reason that the Church would bee a confusion if there were not gouernnment and obedience But Friar Peter Soto was copious in shewing that there were seuen Orders and each properly a Sacrament and all instituted by CHRIST saying it was necessary to make a declaration herein because some Canonists passing the limits of their profession haue added two more the first Tonsure and the Bishopricke which opinion may cause many other errors of greater importance He likewise shewed at large that CHRIST had when hee was on earth exercised all these Orders one after another all whose life as it was addressed to the last of these Sacraments so it is plaine that all the others serue onely as a ladder to climbe vp to the highest which is the Priesthood But Ierolamus Brauus a Dominican Friar hauing protested that hee constantly held that there were seuen Orders and each of them a Sacrament and that the vse of the Church ought to be obserued to proceed from the inferiour to the superiour and so to the Priesthood he added that hee was not of opinion that so particular a declaratioÌ„ ought to be made in regard of the difference betweene the Diuines amongst which one can hardly find two of the same minde For which cause Caietan in his old age wrote that he that collecteth the things taught by the Doctours and in the auncient and moderne Pontificals will see a great confusion in all other Orders but Priesthood The Master of the Sentences maintayned that Sub-deaconship and inferiour Orders were instituted by the Church and the Scripture seemed to haue instituted the Deaconship as a ministery of Tables and not as one of the Altar The difference concerning inferiour Orders in the old Pontificals where that which is in one is not in another doeth shew they are Sacramentall and not Sacraments And reason doth lead vs hereunto For the actions which one ordained doth may be done by one not ordained and are of the same validitie effect and perfection Saint Bonauenture also though hee thinketh that all seuen are Sacraments yet he holdeth two other opinions to be probable one that onely Priesthood is a Sacrament and the inferiours being imployed about corporall things as to open doores reade Lessons light Tapers and the like doe not seeme to expresse any celestiall matter and are therefore onely dispositions to Priesthood The second that the three holy Orders are Sacraments and concerning the common saying that the inferiour are degrees to the superiour Saint Thomas affirmeth that in the Primitiue Church many were ordained Priests immediatly without passing by the inferiour Orders and that the Church did ordaine that this passage should be made for humiliation onely It appeareth plainely in the Actes of the Apostles that Saint Matthias was immediatly ordayned an Apostle and the seuen Deacons did not passe by the Subdeaconship and the inferiour Orders Paulinus saith of himselfe that hauing a purpose to apply himselfe to the seruice of GOD in the Clergie he would for humiliation passe by all Ecclesiasticall degrees beginning from the Ostiarie but while hee was thinking to begin beeing yet a Laicke the multitude tooke him by force in Barcelona on Christmas day caried him before the Bishop and caused him to be ordained Priest at the first which would not haue beene done if it had not beene the vse in those times Therefore this Brauus concluded that the Synod ought not to passe beyond those things which are agreed on by the Catholiques and that it was better to begin with the Order of Priesthood which would make a connexion betweene this Session and the last which handled the Sacrifices and to passe from Priesthood to Order in generall not descending to any particularitie The Congregation being ended and most of the Prelates departed Fiue Churches with his Hungarians and some Polonians and Spaniards taried behinde to whom he made a speach and sayd that the Emperour being freed from all suspicion of warre by the truce concluded with the Turke tooke The Bishop of Fiue Churches maketh a speech concerning reformation nothing so much to the heart as the reformation of the Church which would surely be effected if some of the Prelates in the Councell would assist Therefore he exhorted and prayed them for Gods sake and for the charitie which euery Christian oweth to the Church that they would not abandon so honest iust and profitable a cause that euery one would put downe in writing what hee thought might be constituted for the seruice of God without any respect of man not reforming one part but the whole body of the Church both in the head and in the
onely giue his voice with modestie and serue the Legats out of his loue in any honest worke as farre as he was able And Madruccio did not forbeare to say that there was a secret Councell within the Councell which did arrogate more authoritie A Councell within the Councell The Legates perceiuing that euery thing turned against them caused the Congregations to be omitted Neither was this sufficient For the Prelats Practises to dissolue the Councell made priuate congregations amongst themselues and the Legats continuall consultations The Arch-bishop of Otranto and others who aimed at the Cardinalitie of which they thought themselues assured if the Councell were separated agreed together to oppose euery thing to make some tumult arise and went passionately about euen in the night also making practises and causing men to set their hand to papers Which though in effect it pleased the Legats yet for the manner it displeased the most of them as beeing of bad example which might giue scandall And on the contrary side there wanted not those who desired a dissolution But each partie expected an occasion that the cause of it might be attributed to the other so that the suspicions did encrease on both sides The Cardinall of Loraine complained to all that plots were laid to dissolue the Synod and especially to the Ambassadours of Princes desiring them to write to their Masters to perswade the Pope that the Councell may bee continued that the practises might bee moderated and the Fathers left to their libertie saying that otherwise a composition would bee made in France that Of which the Card of Loraine complaineth euery one might liue as hee would vntill a free Councell as this was not in which nothing could be resolued but as pleased the Legates nor by the Legates but as the Pope listed that he would be patient vntill the next Session And of the want of libertie in Councell and then if he sawe not things goe better hee would make his protestations and together with the Ambassadours and Prelates returne into France to make a Nationall Councel in which perhaps Germanie would concurre with them a thing which would be displeasing vnto himselfe in regerd of the danger that the Apostolique Sea would not bee acknowledged any more In those dayes many Curriers passed betweene Rome and Trent For the Legates As did also the French-men in Rome aduised the frequent contradictions and the Pope sollicited the proposing of the Canons which he sent And the French-men in Rome made the same complaint to the Pope which Loraine had done in Trent and vsed the same threats of a Nationall Councell and the assistance of Germanie But The Pope answereth resolutely the Pope who had been vsed to these things said hee was not daunted with words was not afraid of Nationall Synods did knowe that the French Bishops were Catholiques and that Germanie would not subiect it selfe to their Councels He said that the Councell was not onely free but might be called licentious that the practises of the Italians in Trent were not with his knowledge but did arise because the Vltramontans would tread the Popes authoritie vnder their feete that hee hath had three good occasions to dissolue the Councell but was willing it should continue hoping that GOD would not abandon his Church and that euery attempt against it would come vpon the head of the Innouators Fiue Churches departed and went to the Emperours Court in the time of these confusions to giue his Maiestie an account of the state of the Councel and of the combination of the Italian Prelates and it was discouered that Granata and his adherents had desired him to perswade the Emperour to write to the Catholique King concerning the Reformation and Residence that both in those and in other occasions they might speake freely according to their conscience all which the Legates did beleeue to proceede from Loraine And therefore for a counterpoise themselues also a few dayes after sent the Bishop Commendone to the Emperour vpon pretence to excuse and render the causes why the demands of his Maiesty could not as yet be proposed And they gaue him commission to exhort the Emperour to be content not to demand of the Councel bot of the Pope himselfe those points of his petition which concerne his authoritie as also other instructions such as seemed them good But Martinus Crame 〈…〉 Bishop of Vormis Ambassadour of the King of Polonia to the Emperour being come to Trent vpon pretence to visit the Cardinall of Varmia his ancient and in ward friend there was a great suspicion that he was sent by the Emperor to be an eye-witnes of the proceedings in Councell and to relate them to him All these things made the Legates doubt that the Councell would be dissolued in some manner dishonourable to the Pope and themselues obseruing that it was desired by many euen by some of the Papalins themselues and that disorders were purposely procured by others to iustifie themselues in case it should happen They sent vnto all the Ambassadours a writing which conteined the present difficulties and desired their counsell But the French Ambassadours answered vpon this occasion that which they desired to say many dayes before that as the Councell was assembled to remedie abuses so some were willing to make vse A free speech vsed by the French Ambassadours of it to encrease them that before any thing else were done it was fit to withstand such manifest practises that they were intolerable that if they were remoued and euery man had libertie to speake freely what hee thought a good accord would easily bee made that the Pope was Head of the Church but not aboue it that he was to gouerne and direct the other members but not to domineere ouer the body that to remedie the differences it was necessary to follow the Councell of Constance which hauing found the Church most disorderly by meanes of these opinions did reduce it into tolerable tearmes They sayd that one cause of discord was because the Secretary Seconded by the Imperialists did not set downe their voyces faithfully so that the greater part seemed in the acts to be the lesser and that could not be taken for a resolution which was concluded by the common opinion and therefore that it was fit to ioyne another with him The Imperialists said almost the same things and were more earnest for another Secretary The other Ambassadors stood vpon generall tearmes desiring a continuation of the Councell and an vnion of mindes Things standing thus Ventimiglia redispatched by the Pope returned The B of Ventimiglia returneth to Trent to Trent the nine and twentieth of Ianuary who made a relation of his credence to the Legates and by their aduice sought to remooue two opinions spread in the Councell one that the Pope could not liue long the other that hee desired a dissolution of the Councell Hee testified the desire of his Holinesse that laying aside
members Granata did second him shewing the necessity and opportunity thereof thanking the Bishop of Fiue Churches for his admonition and said they would consult amongst themselues For this cause the Spaniards being assembled together discoursed of And is seconded by the Spaniards the necessitie of reformation and the hope thereof in regard of the Emperours inclination from which their King also who was most piously addicted would not disseut and the French Prelates who would shortly be there would vndoubtedly promote and assist the worke in earnest They repeated diuers abuses and shewed that the fountaine of them all was the Court of Rome which is not onely corrupt in it selfe but the cause of deformation in all Churches and particularly the vsurpaâ—ion of the Episcopall authoritie by reseruations which if it were not restored and the Court depriued of that which they haue taken from Bishops it would bee impossible the abuses should bee redressed Granata considered that it beeing necessary to lay a good foundation for so noble a Fabrique a way was open for them now that they were to speake of the Sacrament of Order if it bee determined that the authority of Bishops is instituted by CHRIST because it will follow by consequence that it cannot bee diminished by which meanes that will bee restored to the Bishops which hauing been giuen them by CHRIST hath by the ambition of others and their owne negligence been vsurped from them Braganza added that it was so much the more necessary because the Episcopall authority was brought to nothing and the Order erected superiour to Bishops vnknowen to the Church in former ages that is the Cardinals who at the first were esteemed in the number of Priests and Deacons and after the tenth age began to exalt themselues aboue their degree Notwithstanding they were still accounted inferiour to Bishops vntill the yeere 1200 since which time they haue so farre aduanced themselues that they hold Bishops as seruants in their houses and it will bee impossible to reforme the Church vntill both of them bee reduced to their due places These propositions and discourses were heard with applause so that they resolued to elect sixe of them to put in writing the things necessary and fit as well for the reformation in generall as particularly for this point of the institution of Bishops whence they purposed to begin Oranata Iasper Cornante Archbishop of Messina the Bishop of Segouia and Martin di Cardoua Bishop of Tortosa were named the last of which was cause why the proiect did not proceed For hauing secret intelligence with the Papalins he excused himselfe alleadging his owne insufficiencie and the vnfitnesse of the time adding that Fiue Churches was not mooued with pietie and had no other end then to make vse of them to constraine the Pope by meanes of the reformation to grant the vse of the Cup wherein they had beene auerse And seeing they were disposed to heare him hee preuailed so much with them that they passed no further for the present but interposed a delay Notwithstanding it was not long deferred For Granata Braganza Messina and Segouia hauing obtained audience of the Legates desired that they might handle the Articles proposed heretofore by Cardinall Crescentius in this same Councell and concluded though not published that is that the Bishops are instituted by CHRIST and are superiour to Priestes iure diuino The Legates after they had conferred together answered that the Lutherans hauing affirmed that a Bishop and a Priest is the samething it was fit to declare that a Bishop is superiour but that it was not necessary to say quo iure nor by whom a Bishop is instituted because there is no controuersie of it Granata replyed that there was a controuersie and that if the Diuines did dispute it the necessity of deciding this point would be knowne The Legates would not consent by any meanes and after some few sharpe words on both sides the Spaniards departed without hauing obtained any thing yet resolued still to perswade some of the Diuines to bring this particular into The Legates wiâ—l not sulter the instâ—tution of Bishops to be discussed the discussions and to make mention of it when they were to giue voices in congregation But the Papalins vnderstanding hereof did cause it to be voyced amongst the Diuines that the Legates did forbid all speach of that question But to returne to the congregation when the second ranke spake consisting of Diuines and Canonists Thomas Passius a Canon of Valentia said that all doubt made of the Ecclesiasticall Hierarchie did proceede from grosse ignorance of antiquity it being a thing most knowne that in the Church the people hath alwayes beene gouerned by the Clergie and in the Clergie the inferiours by the superiours vntill all be reduced vnto one vniuersall Rector which is the Pope of Rome And hauing declared the proposition at large he added that there was no need to doe any thing herein but to make this trueth appeare by remoouing the contrary errours which haue bin brought in by the Schoolemen who sometimes by too much subtiltie doe make plaine things obscure opposing the Canonists who place the first tonsure and the Bishopricke in the number of Orders Of the latter he said it seemed strange to him how they could confesse that confirmation ordination and so many other consecrations doe so peculiarly belong vnto it that they cannot possibly bee done by any else and yet deny it to bee an Order when as they giue that name to the keeping of the doore which may as well be done by a Lay-man For the first tonsure he hath euer heard the Diuines say that a Sacrament is an externall signe which signifieth a spirituall grace and that the tonsure is the signe and the thing signified is the deputation to the seruice of God and therefore hee wondered why they would not haue it to be a Sacrament and the rather because one entreth into the Clergie by it and doth participate of Ecclesiasticall exemptions so that if it were not instituted by CHRIST it could not be said that either Clergiship or the exemption thereof were de iure Diuino that it was plaine that the Hierarchie consisteth in the Ecclesiasticall Orders which is nothing but an holy order of superiors and inferiors which can neuer bee well established without making as the Canonists Of Ecclesiasticall Hierarchie doe the Tonsure the lowest and the Bishopricke the highest which being done the Hierarchie is all established because the first and last being giuen those of the middle will necessarily follow which cannot subsist without the former Concerning the other part of the Article they said it was very plaine by the Canons that in the choyce of Bishops and deputation of Priests and Deacons the people of al sorts was present gaue voice or approbation but this was by the Popes tacit or expresse consent because no Laicke can haue authority in matters Ecclesiasticall but by priuiledge from him And this