advantage of education in your University how to value the deserts of men of your qualities and degrees so could they not be more willing to cherish you then my self who will make amends for my want of Schollarship in my love to the Professors of it and to the source from whence it cometh having now most just cause more cheifly to employ my utmost endeavors with what favor I enjoy from a Royal Master to the maintaining of the Charters Priviledges and Immunities of your University in general and to the advancing of the particular merits of the Students therein And since I am so far engaged to you I will presume upon a further courtesie which is That you will be pleased to supply me with your advice and suggest a way unto me as my self likewise shall not fail to think on some means how we may make Posterity remember you had a thankful Chancellor and that both really loved you and your University Which is a resolution writ in an honest heart by him that wanteth much to express his Affection to you who will ever be Your faithful Friend and humble Servant George Buckingham Also the King was pleased to write to the University of Cambridge in approbation of the said Election Trusty and Well-beloved We greet you well WHereas upon Our pleasure intimated unto you by the Bishop of Durham for the choice of your Chancellor you have with much duty as We expected highly satisfied Us in your Election We cannot in Our Princely Nature who are much possessed with this Testimony of your ready and Loyal Affections but for ever let you know how much you are therein made partakers of Our Royal Approbation And as We shall ever conceive that an Honor done to a Person We favor is out of a Loyal respect had unto Our Self And as We shall ever justifie Buckingham worthy of this your Election so shall you finde the fruits of it For We that have found him a faithful Servant to Our dear Father of Blessed memory and Our Self cannot but undertake that he will prove such a one to you and will assist him with a Gratious Willingness in any thing that may concern the good of the University in general or the particular Merits of any Students there Given under Our Signet at Our Pallace of Westminster the Sixth of June in the Second year of Our Raign Iune 8. Before the Duke gave in his Answer on that day unto the House of Peers to the Impeachment of the House of Commons he made this ensuing Speech My Lords IN a case of pressure considered by it self I have a fair beginning it is a due debt to your Lordships for this Honorable Favor in leaving it to my choice whether I would answer to the particulars in the Aggravation or not I may without lessening my Obligation say The favor is greater at first it may be yours or your Posterities hereafter I have in a manner tied my self to my charge hoping if I give your Lordships satisfaction in that the Aggravations will fall of themselves I could not well have followed the Aggravations being composed of words which I hope my actions have not deserved and I am sure my ears have not been made acquainted with without some distraction of spirit yet I have left nothing of them unanswered that is material I have used as much speed to come to an answer as conveniently I could without prejudice of my cause having my Reputation too long upon the stage and had your Lordships called for it sooner I had been as ready as now I was desirous to detain your Lordships as little as may be with the expectation of my particular from weightier business I was also grieved that my business should be a cause of the loss of this year from foreign attempts and the hindrance of those resolutions that would have comforted our Friends abroad and secured our selves at home But in this my Lords I am sure you will easily acquit me in your thoughts When I look upon my Charge in general as they did without searching into the integrity of mine own heart and actions which are yet unknown to most of them I wonder not so much at their proceedings the particulars not being voted against me nor unanimously but had they taken the means to have been better and trulier informed of the particulars or have given me cause to have informed them I assure my self they had not troubled your Lordships with this Charge But I confess there hath been that contestation in the House of Commons concerning my Justification that I cannot but acknowledge much favor there from many And if the actions of some others in that House do not conclude me of a worse disposition then I shall hereafter be found there is none but may say with me I am at peace with all I shall onely for the present apply my self to the clearing of my Reputation and for the future of those actions and endeavors which may repossess me of that I have counted one of my greatest losses their good opinions I would not speak nor profess this before your Lordships if Reason and my own disposition did not warrant the performance of it For first Who accused me Common Fame Who gave me up to your Lordships The House of Commons The one is too subtile a Body if a Body the other too great for me to contest with and I am confident when my cause shall be tried neither the one or the other or part of either will be found to be my enemy But as Fame is subtle so it is often and especially in accusations false therefore the House of Commons have not wronged me Yet I am confident it will at length be found that Common Fame hath abused both them and me I presume the House of Commons have proceeded against me out of an hearty and zealous affection to do their King and Country service I hope out of Christian Charity to punish and amend my faults if fame could have proved them and not to envy my Reputation or destroy my Fortune I shall never call such proceedings wrong if seeking to cure my errors give me opportunity to clear and publish my innocency For the State it self I have little to say it is but a little I will not abuse your Lordships patience I was born and bred in it I ow it my self I have been raised to Honors and Fortunes in it I freely confess beyond my Merits what I wanted in sufficiency and experience for the service of it I have endeavored to supply by care and industry And could there be the least alienation hereafter in my heart from the service of the State for any thing that hath past I should be the ungratefullest man living should but such a thought stain my heart I should be content it were let blood If my Posterity should not inherit the same fidelity I should desire an inversion in the course of Nature and be glad to
strength of the Enemies Forces now in the Palatinate Moreover The King to encourage the Princes of the Union and to keep them in Arms sent them Thirty thousand pounds yet withall resolved to treat for Peace and dispatched Sir Edward Villers into Silesia to fetch the Palsgraves Submission to the Emperor upon Conditions to be conceived according to equity and conveniencie Never did the Spaniards more flatter King Iames then after the Defeat at Prague They affirm that he shall ordain according to his pleasure in the Palsgrave's Restitution and be obeyed That the Infanta's Portion was preparing and that the Pope was obliged to grant the Dispensation from whom they resolve to take no denial Cottington the Agent in Spain now attested the Honesty of Gondomar's Dispatches hither and cryed him up for a Cordial man and well deserving His Majesties favor This notable Spanish Engine had so wrought himself into the Kings affections that he gained the accoss of a Favorite rather then of an Ambassador from a Foreign Prince Some in the English Court were then suspected to be Pensioners to Spain as may be gathered from the Spanish Ambassadors Instructions received from the King his Master BEsides that which I enjoin you in your General Instructions given you for England whither I send you to reside I thought good to advertise you apart by themselves of the chiefest things of Importance which you shall there negotiate and endeavor to further and advance It is well known that I have desired and endeavored to favor the Cause of the Catholicks of that Kingdom and to further it to their best advantage as well in the time of the Queen deceased who did so much prosecute and oppress them as since the time that the present King hath succeeded yet that calamity still continues upon them by reason of the ill offices done unto them by the Puritans and Protestants of whom the greater part of that Kings Council doth consist Howbeit because it is a thing that I could not well urge or press without breeding jealousies and so cause thereby a greater harm to the Catholicks I have proceeded on my part with that wariness and dissimulation as is fit D.A. shall inform you of what hath passed in this matter as also in what estate things are at this present and how you shall govern your self for the time to come according to the orders given unto him whose example we wish you to follow And of this take special heed That although it be believed that we may be very confident of the trustiness of those Catholicks by whose means the business of the rest is undertaken that they will be secret notwithstanding lest any Heretick shall come in the name or shew of a Catholick only to make some discovery It shall be fit that in all speeches you shall have with them concerning that which shall touch the Catholicks that you tell them how much I desire to see them freed from those pressures under which Queen Elizabeth put them and that God would inspire the Kings heart that he may reduce himself to the obedience of the Roman Catholick Church And advise them to endeavor to win the King unto them by shewing themselves good and loyal and obedient Subjects in temporal duties and not to meddle any thing against his State that by their deeds he may see what security may be expected from them and may also bind himself to favor them these being things that do no way contradict the observing the Catholick Religion and are due from them to the dignity of their King and Natural Lord And for the same reason they ought to abstain from all ill practices or unfitting speech or actions against his Person as is said some heretofore have used especially seeing no good hath or can come thereof and thereby they shall justly provoke him against themselves and by holding this course they shall win the Kings good will and the Peace shall be preserved and by the Peace by little and little be won and attained that which is desired By this manner of proceeding it is certain there can come no inconvenience But in case that this your manner of dealing shall come to the Kings knowledge as possibly it may it will breed a great obligation of brotherhood and friendship between us when he shall see that I carry my self in this sort in his affairs and consequently will be the more confident of our amity and will thereby be induced the better to subdue all malice in them that shall endeavor to perswade the contrary And therefore you shall have a special care to do this dexteriously in due time and season and to inform your self very particularly from the said D. A. concerning those with whom you may deal confidently and how far you may trust the Negotiants for the Catholicks though you shall do well alway to proceed with the aforesaid caution and wariness You shall understand from the said D.A. what Pensions are allotted to certain Ministers of that King and to other persons It will be necessary to inform your self throughly of all that concerns this point and that you know both the Persons and Pensions to serve your self of them and to make the best use of them in all occasions that shall be most behoveful for your better direction in the Businesses given you in charge and all others that may be offered of consequence seeing the said Pensions were appointed to that end Whatsoever of the said Pensions you shall find unpaid for the time past D. A. is to discharge and you shall undertake for the time to come telling every one what his Pension is to the end they may be deceived of no part thereof by the Third person who conveys it unto them and let it be punctually paid at the days that their good payment may bind them to persevere and do their service punctually for the which you shall be furnished with all that shall be necessary And have a special care to advertise me how such persons employ themselves in the things that shall occur disguising their names in such manner as D.A. doth Above all You must take great care to dive into the estate of the affairs of that King What his Treasure is In what Estimation he is with his Subjects and what Correspondeneie and good meaning there is betwixt them How the English Scotch and Irish stand affected among themselves and one towards another and towards their Neighbors and how they are bent against me and my Common Estates or any of my particular Kingdoms whence they draw their Intelligences and particularly what amity and correspondencie that King entertaineth with France and with the Neutrals of Holland and Zealand and with the Venetians and upon what causes it is founded what matters they treat of what designs they have in hand All which is very necessary to be known for the attaining of which D.A. will open unto you some ways which you must follow besides those
necessity to use their Subjects put them into that necessity as they refuse to do for him All this is Pride of the Perswader as Socrates saith In the second I will clear the Parliament in which I was a Member of an ungratefull aspersion cast upon it that is to say That the Parliament was a cause to draw his Majesty into a War and failed on their parts to contribute to it These have been often repeated and the Parliament accused the contrary hath been as often reiterated and the truth expressed how far the Parliament proceeded therein But to stop the mouths of such false Reports and to free the Parliament of such a calumniation I must use this Argument At the Assembly of Oxford the Parliament being Prorogued thither Money was required of us towards the furnishing of his Majesties Fleet then preparing upon many reasons alleadged too tedious now to repeat with one consent it was refused Whereupon there was offer made by him that next the King seem-to have best Authority That if they would but contribute Forty thousand pounds they should choose their Enemy Whereupon I infer That before that Proposition there was no Enemy and therefore no Wars The motion for Money being denied the Parliament instantly brake up and seeing no Enemy was nominated nor Money consented unto by us I see not how the House can be taxed for Peace-breakers but rather the name to be cast upon some young men for youth by nature is prone to pride especially where experience wants They are credulous in what they hear that pleaseth them and incredulous in what is told them by wise men They are despisers of others counsels and very poor in their own They are dangerous for Princes to relie on for self-will is of greater force then Precepts Now to proceed In October following the Fleet put to Sea and what they did is apparent by a Relation written by a their General at his Return The Voyage being ended another followed the next Summer under the command of that noble Lord the Earl of Lindsey which through the weakness and disability of the Ships was not able to perform what he had in charge and what he desired The last and most lamentable was that to the Isle of Rhee which I likewise refer to a man I have seen and to the Books printed and extant These with that to Algeir to make up Mess of Island Voyages I wish might be referred to the examination of choice and experienced Soldiers by Land and by Sea to report their opinions of it That so their Errors their wastefull Expences their Negligences their weak Designs and want of experience may appear with the Success that might have proved if Advice and Counsel had had preheminence above Will and Arrogancy For he that is ignorant of truth and knowledge and led away with pride of his own opinions must needs err After it hath past your approbation it is worthy his Majesties view who then shall see the difference of Actions well mannaged and rash and heady Enterprises undertook by ignorance and performed by folly Business of so great a consequence ought to be considered of with Counsel and not onely of the necessity profit and honor but of the possibility that was like to follow for an Action well begun is half ended My experience in Discipline of War by Land and Sea can say no more then to refer it to others for t is a Course I never was bred to in my youth and now too late in mine age to practice Onely one thing I observe that in the two journeys of Cadiz and Rhee in the first a Land Souldier commanded at Sea who knew not what belonged thereunto and the other was carried by him that was Souldier neither by Land nor by Sea and the success proved accordingly in both yet their errors were never questioned but they both highly advanced And it is no marvel for according to the old saying The best Fencer is not always the best Fighter the fairer Tilter not the best experienced Souldier nor the eye of a Favorite at Court the best General of an Host And whosoever takes upon him that command without knowledge beholds himself in a false glass that makes him seem what he is not As on the contrary Experience is the mother of Prudence and Prudence will take counsel lest she joyn her will with her will hastiness causeth repentance and frowardness causeth hinderance Of the Evils that followed upon these two voyages your selves are sufficient Witnesses and can judge of them As namely the billeting of Soldiers in the Country and bringing their Ships into Harbors not abating the entertainment of the one nor the wages of the other And yet notwithstanding this needless cost and charges our Ships and Coasts are daily infested in such sort as we dare not peep out of Harbor Were the carriage of things now answerable to the Prudence and Presidents of former times we cannot pretend a fear of invasion because our Ships are divided into several Harbors and our Soldiers billetted in Inland Countries beside the season of the year giveth no opportunity to an Enemy to attempt it Here is a mass of wealth curiously consumed whether the King or Subject bear it and no man bettered but onely those that have the titles of Soldiers yet never had the happiness or honor to see what appertained to service Their example of disorder encourages the other to follow their Liberty People that were wont to live poorly yet safely are now by these Fellows and their Followers robbed and spoiled and no remedy for Redress The rich stand upon their guard and dare not resort to their Church lest in their absence their Houses be surprised and Rifled The Enemy giveth a sudden attempt and returneth the others do every day rob and spoil The Enemy surpriseth with fear the others have neither fear nor shame The first lessening the greatness of the Roman Empire was by the insolency of Soldiers and the first raising of the House of Ottoman was by permission and conniving at his Army What man is so old in England that hath seen or what youth so young that ever thought to see Scottish men and Irish men Garrisoned in England and no Enemy appear against us Or who could have imagined he should ever have seen our own people tyrannized over in our own Kingdom by these of our own Nation and those Scottish and Irish and not dare so much as complain Would our forefathers have thought it safety or Policy to draw Two thousand Scotish men and Irish men into the Isle of Wight for their defence against France when they of the Isle desired it not nay when they opposed it Would they have thought it wisdom that Two thousand Mouthes besides the Inhabitants should live on the food of that Island and so bring themselves into want and penury of victuals if they should in earnest be attempted by an Enemy Would they have thought fit the charge of
Propositions from either side to give distaste and lessen the Friendship between the two Crowns The Duke returned answer that all assurance and satisfaction shall be given concerning this Alliance And after Sir Digby's arrival at the Court of Spain he protested to him solemnly that the King desired it and swore for himself that he desired nothing more Hereupon Digby debated with him That the remembrance of their former Demands was yet unpleasing in England the difference of Religion the Opinions of Divines and the Cases of Conscience were still the same insomuch that his Majesty and his Servants had just cause to cease for ever from all thoughts this way Nevertheless they did not slight nor disrelish an Alliance with Spain for many of the greatest eminency in England judge it equally valuable with any other of Christendom though it be esteemed a matter of infinite difficulty Here the subtil Spaniard might perceive our forwardness though our Ambassador seemed to speak aloof off and with reservation The debate had this result that the difficulties should be digested into certain Heads and select Persons appointed for Conference but the Intent thereof was that the Kings on either side should not be interessed nor their names therein used till by the clearing of particulars there should be great appearances that the business would take effect Now because the difference of Religion was supposed the onely difficulty of moment it was thought fit to break the matter to the Cardinal of Toledo and the Kings Confessor and one Father Frederick a learned Jesuite having the repute of a Moderate man Upon the review of these proceedings Sir Iohn Digby advised the King not to suffer his other resolutions to be interrupted by this Overture which might be set on foot as a meer device to stagger the French Treaty and to keep his Majesty from declaring himself opposite to Spain in the business of Cleves and Iuliers which still remained uncompounded nevertheless he might be pleased for a while to suspend the conclusion of the Match with France and entertain this motion and to this end he desired from him not a formal Commission to treat but onely a private Instruction for his Direction and Warrant Such remote Conferences made way for that solemn slow-paced Treaty of the many years following wherein the advantage lay on the Spaniards side who were indeed very formal and specious in it but no way vehement and vigorous if we might suppose them in any sort real But the King of England having a prevalent inclination this way when he was once drawn in and elevated with hope was so set upon it that he would grant all things possible rather then break it off and was impatient of dissembling his own eagerness The business was mainly carried on by Conde Gondomar who was exquisitely framed for it and by facetious wayes taking the King in his own humor prevailed mightily The King removes all blocks that lie in the way of this Darling Design and studies all the wayes of rendring himself acceptable to Spain The Wall of this Island the English Navy once the strongest of all Christendome now lyes at road unarmed and fit for ruine Gondomar as was the common voice bearing the King in hand that the furnishing of it would breed suspition in the King his Master and avert his minde from this alliance Moreover the Town of Flushing the Castle of Ramakins in Zealand and Brill in Holland which were held by way of caution from the united Provinces to insure their dependency upon England the King resolved to render up as being meerly cautionary and none of his Propriety He rid his hands of those places to prevent requests and Propositions from the King of Spain who claimed the propriety in them and Gondomar put hard for them being accounted the Keys of the Low Countries Such was the Kings care and contrivance to keep faith with those Confederates and not offend Spain And to render this a politick action it was urged that the advantage of those Holds was countervailed by the vast expence in keeping them Howbeit the power of the English Interest in that State was by this means cut off and taken away and the alienation between King Iames and the United Provinces which appeared in latter times and was nourished by Bernevelt the head of the Arminian Faction and a Pensioner of Spain is now increased by the discovery and observation of these late Spanish compliances But the King of Spain and his Ministers had given but slender proof of any great affection yea or of sincere intention and upright dealing in this great affair For Sir Iohn Digby received certain Articles in matter of Religion after a Consultation had with their Divines which appeared very unworthy and were utterly rejected by him Yet afterwards upon a private Conference between him and some others to whom the cause had been committed a Qualification was therein conceived though not delivered as a matter there approved And the same Speeches after his return into England proceeded between him and Gondomar and were brought to that Issue that the King thought fit to acquaint a select number of his Council therewith who having heard the report of the former proceeding delivered their opinion That they found very probable ground for him to enter into a publike Treaty with as much assurance of good success as in such a case might be expected whereupon Sir Iohn Digby by Commission under the Great Seal was authorized to treat and conclude the Marriage and because the matter of Religion was in chief debate those qualified Articles that were brought out of Spain were sent back signed with the Kings hand who added something to them by way of clearer explanation They were to this effect THat the Popes Dispensation be first obtained by the meer Act of the King of Spain That the Children of this Marriage be not constrained in matter of Religion nor their Title prejudiced in case they prove Catholikes That the Infanta's Family being Strangers may be Catholikes and shall have a decent place appointed for all Divine Service according to the use of the Church of Rome and the Ecclesiasticks and Religious persons may wear their proper Habits That the Marriage shall be celebrated in Spain by a Procurator according to the Instructions of the Council of Trent and after the Infanta's arrival in England such a solemnization shall be used as may make the Marriage valid according to the Laws of this Kingdome That she shall have a competent number of Chaplains and a Confessor being Strangers one whereof shall have power to govern the Family in Religious matters In the allowing of these Articles the King thus exprest himself Seing this Marriage is to be with a Lady of a different Religion from us it becometh us to be tender as on the one part to give them all satisfaction convenient so on the other to admit nothing that may blemish our Conscience or
another Bill among you against Informers I desire you my Lords that as you tender my Honor and the good of my People ye will put that Bill to an end as soon as you can and at your next meeting to make it one of your first works For I have already shewed my dislike of that kinde of people openly in Star-Chamber and it will be the greatest ease to me and all those that are near about me at Court that may be For I remember that since the beginning of this Parliament Buckingham hath told me he never found such quiet and rest as in this time of Parliament from Projectors and Informers who at other times miserably vexed him at all hours And now I confess that when I looked before upon the face of the Government I thought as every man would have done that the people were never so happy as in my time For even as at divers times I have looked upon many of my Coppices riding about them and they appeared on the outside very thick and well-grown unto me but when I turned into the midst of them I found them all bitten within and full of Plains and bare spots like an Apple or Pear fair and smooth without but when ye cleave it asunder you finde it rotten at the Heart Even so this Kingdom the External Government being as good as ever it was and I am sure as Learned Judges as ever it had and I hope as honest Administring Justice within it and for Peace both at home and abroad I may truly say more setled and longer lasting then ever any before together with as great plenty as ever So as it was to be thought that every man might sit in safety under his own Vine and Fig-Tree Yet I am ashamed and it makes my hair stand upright to consider How in this time my people have been vexed and polled by the vile execution of Projects Patents Bills of Conformity and such like which besides the trouble of my people have more exhausted their Purses then Subsidies would have done Now my Lords before I go hence since God hath made me the Great Judge of this Land under him and that I must answer for the Justice of the same I will therefore according to my place remember you of some things though I would not teach you For no mans Knowledge can be so good but their Memories will be the better to be refreshed And now because you are coming to give Judgment all which moves from the King that you may the better proceed take into your care two things 1. To do Bonum 2. To do it Bene. I call Bonum when all is well proved whereupon ye Judge for then ye build upon a sure Foundation And by Bene I understand that ye proceed with all Formality and Legality wherein you have fit occasion to advise with the Judges who are to assist you with their Opinions in cases of that nature and wo be to them if they advise you not well So the ground being good and the form orderly it will prove a course fitting this High Court of Parliament In Sentence ye are to observe two parts First To recollect that which is worthy of judging and censuring and secondly To proceed against these as against such-like crimes properly We doubt there will be many matters before you some complained of out of Passion and some out of just cause of Grievance Weigh both but be not carried away with the impertinent discourses of them that name as well Innocent men as guilty Proceed judicially and spare none where ye finde just cause to punish But let your proceedings be according to Law and remember that Laws have not their Eyes in their Necks but in their Foreheads For the Moral Reason for the punishment of Vices in all Kingdoms and Commonwealths is because of the Breach of Laws standing in force For none can be punished for Breach of Laws by Predestination before they be made There is yet one particular that I am to remember you of I hear that Sir Henry Yelverton who is now in the Tower upon a Sentence given in the Star-Chamber against him for deceiving my trust is touched concerning a Warrant Dormant which he made while he was my Attorney I protest I never heard of this Warrant Dormant before and I hold it as odious a matter as any is before you And if for respect to me ye have forborne to meddle with him in Examination because he is my Prisoner I do here freely remit him unto you and put him into your hands And this is all I have to say unto you at this time wishing you to proceed justly and nobly according to the Orders of your House and I pray God to bless you and you may assure your selves of my assistance Wishing that what I have said this day among you may be entred into the Records of this House The Lords pronounced Sentence upon Sir Giles Mompesson who was fled beyond Sea 1. THat he shall be degraded of the Order of Knighthood with reservation of the Dignity of his Wife and Children 2. That he shall stand perpetually in the degree of his person Outlawed for Misdemeanor and Trespass 3. That his testimony be received in no Court nor he to be of any Inquisition or Iury. 4. That he shall be excepted out of all General Pardons to be hereafter granted 5. That he shall be imprisoned during life 6. That he shall not approach within Twelve miles of the Court or Prince nor of the Kings High Court usually held at Westminster 7. And the Kings Majesty shall have the profit of his Lands for life and all his Goods and Chattels so forfeited and that he shall undergo Fine and Ransome which was set at Ten thousand pounds 8. Disabled to hold or receive any Offce under the King or for the Commonwealth 9. That he shall be ever held an infamous person 10. And his Majesty added thereunto perpetual Banishment Sir Francis Michel a Projector and Mompessons Compartner was fined One thousand pound degraded and imprisoned in the same place in Finsbury Fields which he had prepared for others For the Tower was thought too honorable for such a person He rode likewise from Westminster into London with his face to the Horse-tail Likewise the King revoked his Letter Patents Commissions and Proclamations concerning Inns and Ale-houses and the Manufactures of Gold and Silver Thred To these Reformations the King gave encouragement by his Third Speech in Parliament wherein he declared much against Corruption and Bribery in Judicatures professing That no person should be preferred before the publick good and that no offender should go unpunished In the same Speech he gave them thanks for the Subsidies given in the beginning of the Parliament and for the Title of the Grant and proceeded to open his present state in relation to his Son in Law the Prince Elector Palatine how the sums granted by the Act of Subsidy were taken up
declared for War he pursued Peace and resolved to close with Spain hoping to heal the Breach by that Alliance The House of Commons before they granted Subsides resolved to try the Kings Spirit by this Petition and Remonstrance which laid open the distempers of those times with their causes and cures Most Gratious and Dread Soveraign WE Your Majesties most Humble and Loyal Subjects the Knights Citizens and Burgesses now Assembled in Parliament who represent the Commons of Your Realm full of hearty sorrow to be deprived of the Comfort of Your Royal Presence the rather for that it proceeds from the want of Your health wherein we all unfeignedly do suffer In all humble manner calling to minde Your Gracious Answer to our former Petition concerning Religion which notwithstanding Your Majesties Pious and Princely intentions hath not produced that good effect which the danger of these times doth séem to us to require And finding how ill Your Majesties goodness hath béen requited by Princes of different Religion who even in time of Treaty have taken opportunity to advance their own ends tending to the subversion of Religion and disadvantage of Your Affairs and the Estate of Your Children By reason whereof Your ill affected Subjects at home the Popish Recusants have taken too much encouragement and are dangerously increased in their number and in 〈◊〉 insolencies We cannot but be sensible thereof and therefore humbly represent what we conceive to be the causes of so great and growing Mischeifs and what be the Remedies I. The Uigilancy and Ambition of the Pope of Rome and his dearest Son the one aiming at as large a Temporal Monarchy as the other at a Spiritual Supremacy II. The Devillish Positions and Doctrines whereon Popery is built and taught with Authority to their Followers for advancement of their Temporal ends III. The distressed and miserable estate of the Professors of true Religion in Foreign parts IV. The Disasterous accidents to Your Majesties Children abroad expressed with rejoycing and even with contempt of their persons V. The strange Confederacy of the Princes of thâ— Popish Religion aiming mainly at the advancement of theirs and subverting of ours and taking the advantages conducing to that end upon all occasions VI. The great and many 〈◊〉 raised and maintained at the charge of the King of Spain the 〈◊〉 of that League VII The expectation of the Popish Recusants of the Match with Spain and féeding themselves with great hopes of the consequences thereof VIII The interposing of Forein Princes and their Agents in the behalf of Popish Recusants for connivance and favor unto them IX Their open and usual resort to the Houses and which is worse to the Chappels of Foreign Ambassadors X. Their more then usual concourse to the City and their frequent Conventicles and Conferences there XI The education of their Children in many several Seminaries and Houses of their Religion in Forein parts appropriated to the English Fugitives XII The Grants of their just Forfeitures intended by Your Majesty as a Reward of Service to the Grantees but beyond Your Majesties intention transferred or compounded for at such mean rates as will amount to little less then a Toleration XIII The Licentious Printing and dispersing of Popish and Seditious Books even in the time of Parliament XIV The swarms of Priests and Iesuits the Common Incendiaries of all Christendom dispersed in all parts of your Kingdom And from these causes as bitter Roots we humbly offer to Your Majesty That we foresée and fear there will necessarily follow very dangerous effects both to Church and State For I. The Popish Religion is incompatible with ours in respect of their Positions II. It draweth with it an unavoidable dependency on Forein Princes III. It openeth too wide a gap for Popularity to any who shall draw too great a party IV. It hath a restless spirit and will strive by these Gradations if it once get but a connivancy it will press for a Toleration if that should be obtained they must have an equality from thence they will aspire to Superiority and will never rest till they get a Subversion of the true Religion The Remedies against these growing Evils which in all Humility we offer unto Your most Excellent Majesty are these I. That séeing this inevitable necessity is faln upon Your Majesty which no Wisdom or Providence of a peaceable and pious King can 〈◊〉 Your Majesty would not omit this just occasion spéedily and eâ—â—ectually to take Your Sword into Your hand II. That once undertaken upon so honorable and just grounds Your Majesty would resolve to pursue and more publickly avow the aiding of those of our Religion in Forein parts which doubtless would reunite the Princes and States of the Union by these disasters disheartned and disbanded III. That Your Majesty would propose to Your Self to manage this War with the best advantage by a diversion or otherwise as in Your déep judgment shall be found fittest and not to rest upon a War in these parts onely which will consume Your Treasure and discourage Your People IV. That the bent of this 〈◊〉 and point of Your Sâ—â—â—d may be against that Prince whatsoever opinion of potency he hath whose Armies and Treasures have first diverted and since maintained the War in the Palatinate V. That for securing of our Peace at home Your Majesty will be pleased to review the parts of our Petition formerly delivered unto Your Majesty and hereunto annexed and to put in execution by the care of choice Commissioners to be thereunto especially appointed the Laws already and hereafter to be made for preventing of dangers by Popish Recusants and their wonted evasions VI. That to frustrate their hopes for a future age our most Noble Prince may be timely and happily married to one of our own Religion VII That the Children of the Nobility and Gentry of this Kingdom and of others ill-affected and suspected in their Religion now beyond the Seas may be forthwith called home by your means and at the charge of their Parents or Governors VIII That the Children of Popish Recusants or such whose Wives are Popish Recusants be brought up during their Minority with Protestant Schoolmasters and Teachers who may sow in their tender years the Séeds of true Religion IX That Your Majesty will be pleased spéedily to revoke all former Licences for such Children and Youth to travel beyond the Seas and not grant any such Licence hereafter X. That Your Majesties Learned Council may receive Commandment from Your Highness carefully to look into former Grants of Recusants Lands and to avoid them if by Law they can and that Your Majesty will stay Your Hand from passing any such Grants hereafter This is the sum and effect of our humble Declaration which we no ways intending to press upon Your Majesties undoubted and Regal Prerogative do with the fulness of our Duty and Obedience humbly submit to Your most Princely consideration The glory of God whose cause it is
kept a footing in his ruined Country The Imperialists laughed to think that the English Garrison should expect Relief by the Orders sent from Spain to Bruxels And when the King had made an offer to sequester the Town of Frankendale into the Infanta's hands upon the same assurance from her which herself had offered before the loss of Manheim which was to restore the place whether a peace with the Emperor or a rupture followed she was fallen away from that proposition and would accept the sequestration only upon a simple trust to render it again at the expiration of eighteen moneths In this state of affairs the King wrote thus to his Ambassador in the Spanish Court. Concerning the unfortunate knotty affair of the Palatinate to say the truth as things now stand we cannot tell what you could have done more then you have already done Moreover he shewed That the reason of his late peremptory Instructions concerning a direct Promise of Restitution was the gross delay at Bruxels while Heidelburgh was taken and Manheim beleaguered As also Gages coming from Rome and in stead of the Dispensation presenting him with new demands to engage him in a Dispute or Treaty with the Pope which he said he never intended Wherefore at the instance and perswasion of his Council he was moved to urge the matter so as to bring it to a sudden period Not but that the precisest of them were always of opinion That if the Match were once concluded the other business would be accommodated to his satisfaction Then was the Ambassador required to stir up that King to use all effectual means for diverting the Translation of the Electorate in the present Diet Likewise to make him an offer of Frankendale by way of sequestration upon condition of restoring it in the case as now it stands whether the Peace succeed or not But in the Diet held at Ratisbone the Emperor declared the Palatine to be the Cause and groundwork of all those Wars and miseries and that the Electorate of this proscribed Enemy being devolved into his hands he had conferred it upon the Duke of Bavaria who in this Cause and service had spent his Treasure and hazarded his blood against his own Nephew the Palsgrave The Protestant Princes desired the Emperor to consider That in so high a Cause as the disposing of an Electorate and so principal a Person in the Colledge of Electors who uncited unheard and without all knowledge of the Cause hath been condemned and against all Equity oppressed by the Publication of the Ban His Imperial Majesty should not have proceeded so rigorously without the advice and consent of the other Electors as was agreed upon in the Capitulation Royal and Fundamental Law of the Empire And since the Diet was called for restoring the Peace of the Empire it were necessary in the first place ro remove the Obstacles those extreme Executions in Bohemia which may make that people desperate and which the Lutheran States following the Augustane Confession have their eyes upon And though it be given out that the severity there exercised is merely for private Justice yet it is so linked with the Publique Cause that unless it be speedily ended and the two Churches in Prague again opened and the free exercise of Religion permitted they can see no sure Peace but desolation and ruine like to follow And for the Prince Palatine seeing he is already sufficiently punished it were commendable in his Imperial Majesty to restore him upon submission to his Lands and Dignities otherwise there is no likelihood of restoring Peace And in transferring the Electorate if it must be so this main thing were to be considered Whether the exclusion of the Palsgrave's person doth exclude his Children who by the providence of their Ancestors before this act of their Father had an hereditary right thereunto Or whether that Prince's Brother or other of the Kindred who have no way offended should be in this case neglected This will be ill resented by the other Electors and Princes allied to the Palatine who have been quiet hitherto upon confidence of the Emperors clemencie But perceiving all hopes of recovering the Electoral Dignity to their Family taken away must needs have recourse to Arms. They further added That the Palatine was young and abused by evil Counsels and no way the Author of the stirrs in Bohemia Wherefore they give their advice That his restoring will quiet the otherwise endless troubles of the Empire and for ever engage him and all his Allies and the whole Electoral Colledge to his Imperial Majesty The Catholick Princes answered That the Palatinate being devolved upon the Emperor he may bestow it according to his own pleasure And that he cannot safely hold any terms of Amity with the Palatine That the impunity of so great an Offender will encourage others to offend And as for by-past sufferings there hath been little difference between his and the Emperors though the Cause were far different And that Mansfeld his General is yet in the Field and prosecutes his Cause by force of Arms. The other Party replied That the security of the Imperial Dignity and the safety of the Empire consisted in the Concord between the Emperor and the Princes Electors And if his Imperial Majesty shall use this rigor the Princes of Lower Saxony are of opinion that there can be no Peace established But this desired Reconciliation will give the Emperor a quiet possession of the Provinces recovered by the aid of the Electors and Princes otherwise there is a fair pretension left for the renewing of the War for that the Palatines Sons and Brother are passed by in the translation of the Electorate and the King of Great Britain cannot but take it ill to see his endeavors produce no better effect but that his onely Daughter and her Children are left in Exile The Emperor takes up the debate and sheweth That before the Ban was published he desired nothing more then that a Diet might be convoked which being impeded by the prosecution of the War he could do no less then publish this Proscription to repress the Palatine which some that now dispute it did then declare to be legal and necessary And this proscribed Enemy he will not restore to the Electoral Dignity nor yet defer to compleat the number of Electors Thus have we good words from Spain and miserable usage from all the rest of the House of Austria Sir Dudley Carlton Ambassador Resident at the Hague assured the Marquis of Buckingham That though the Spanish Ambassador D' Ognat in publique opposed the Emperor in transferring the Electorate yet the judgment generally made upon it was this That it was a meer Patelinage with a secret understanding to abuse King Iames his goodness Likewise the Emperor not content to have chased the Palsgrave out of Germany in the Propositions of the former Diet made this an Article to make War upon the United
Lordships according to the unanimous Advice of all the Iudges of England and his Majesties pleasure signified therein That the First Article propounded viz. You shall do all your pain and diligence to destroy and make to cease all manner of Heresies and Errors commonly called Lollaries within in your Bayliwick from time to time to all your power and assist and be helping to all Ordinaries and Commissioners of the Holy Church and favor and maintain them as oftentimes as you shall be required shall be left out in the Oath to be given to Sir Edward Cook and shall ever hereafter be left out in all Oaths to be given to the High Sheriffs of Counties hereafter And their Lordships do likewise Order according to the unanimous Advice of all the Iudges of England That the other thrée Articles doubted of shall stand in the said Oath to be ministred to the said Sir Edward Cook and to all other High Sheriffs as heretofore hath béen accustomed and that the Lord Keeper do give order to such Officers and Clerks in the Court of Chancery to whom it appertained to make out the Oath for the time to come according to present Order The expectation of a Parliament gave encouragement to the Bishop of Lincoln who yet retained the name of Lord Keeper notwithstanding his Sequestration several moneths before from the presence of the King the Council Table and the custody of the Seal to make an Address to his Majesty for a favorable interpretation of his actions But his carriage towards the Duke at the Parliament at Oxford was fresh in memory where the Bishop told the Duke in Christ-Church upon the Dukes rebuking him for siding against him That he was engaged with William Earl of Pembroke to labor the Redress of the Peoples Grievances and was resolved to stand upon his own Legs If that be your resolution said the Duke Look you stand fast and so they parted and shortly after that he was sequestred though the Seal was not disposed from him till the Thirtieth of October at which time it was given to Sir Thomas Coventry at Hampton-Court who was that day sworn of the Privy Council and sate there and sealed some Writs and afterwards came to the Term at Reading and sate there as Lord Keeper and heard Causes The King being pressed with his own Necessities and the Cry of the Nation against the Fruitless Voyage of Cadiz summoned a Parliament to meet in February and before the time of meeting his Majesty enjoyned the Archbishops and Bishops in both Provinces to proceed against Popish Recusants by Excommunication and other Censures of the Church and not to omit any lawful means of bringing them to Publick Justice especially he recommended to their vigilant care the unmasking and repressing of those who were not professed Papists yet disaffected to the true Religion and kept close their evil and dangerous affection and by secret means and slights did encourage and advance the growth of Popery This Command was seconded by a Proclamation requiring That all Convicted Papists should according to the Laws of this Realm remain confined to their dwelling places or within five miles thereof unless upon special Licences first obtained in Cases necessary Immediately before the Parliament Bishop Laud procured the Duke of Buckingham to sound the King concerning the Cause Books and Tenets of Mr. Richard Montague and understanding by what the Duke collected That the King had determined within himself to leave him to a Tryal in Parliament he said I seem to see a Cloud arising and threatning the Church of England God for his Mercy dissipate it About the same time the King declared his purpose to celebrate the Solemnity of his Coronation on Candlemas-day at the Palace of Westminster and required all persons who by reason of their Offices and Tenures were bound to perform any Duties at the Solemnitie to give their attendance and to be furnished in all respects answerable to an action of so high State according to their places and dignities Wherefore by a Commission under the Great Seal of England Sir Thomas Coventry Lord Keeper of the Great Seal Iames Lord Say High Treasurer of England Edward Earl of Worcester Keeper of the Privy Seal Thomas Earl of Arundel and Surrey Earl Marshal of England William Earl of Pembroke Lord High Chamberlain Edward Earl of Dorset and Sir Randol Crew Cheif Justice of the Common Pleas were authorised to receive and determine the Claims exhibited by any Person concerning Services to be performed at the approaching Coronation And the more to credit the Solemnity the King resolving to make certain of his Servants and other Subjects in regard of their Birth good Service and other Qualities Knights of the Bath Authorised Thomas Earl of Arundel and Surrey and Earl Marshal of England William Earl of Pembroke Lord Chamberlain to perform in his Majesties Name and behalf all the Rites and Ceremonies belonging thereto At the same time Writs were directed to all Sheriffs in the Realm of England and Dominions of Wales commanding them to make Proclamation That all such as had Forty pounds a year or more of Lands or Revenues in their own hands or the hands of Feoffees for their use for the space of Three years and are not yet Knights do at their perils prepare to present themselves in his Majesties Presence by the One and thirtieth of Ianuary to receive the Order of Knighthood Upon the asswaging of the great Pestilence through the Mercy and Goodness of God in withdrawing and almost removing the Scourge the King by His Royal Authority ordained a Publick and General Thanksgiving to be celebrated upon the Nine and twentieth of Ianuary being the Lords day in the Cities of London and Westminster and the places adjacent and on the Nineteenth of February in all other places of the Kingdom the manner and form whereof was prescribed by a Book composed by the Bishops according to his Majesties special Direction The Contagion ceasing the restraint enjoyned to the Citizens of London from resorting to Fairs for a time was taken off The number of those that died this year within and without the Walls of the City of London and in the Liberties and Nine out Parishes from the Sixteenth of December 24. to the Fifteenth of December 25. Was in Total Fifty four thousand two hundred sixty and five whereof of the Plague Thirty five thousand four hundred and seventeen On Candlemas-day King Charls was Crowned Bishop Laud had the cheif hand in compiling the Form of the Coronation and had the honor to perform this Solemnity instead of the late Lord Keeper Williams who through the Kings disfavor was sequestred from this Service which belonged to his place as he was Dean of Westminster Mr. Iohn Cosens as Master of the Ecclesiastical Ceremonies kneeled behinde the Bishop when the Prayers were read and directed the Quire when to answer The Ceremony in going to and all the
impaired the same I would you would hasten for my Supply or else it will be worse for your selves For if any ill happen I think I shall be the last shall feel it Afterwards the Commons fell upon the Duke as the chief Cause of all Publick Miscarriages Doctor Turner a Physitian propounded in the House these Questions which were then commonly called Queries against the Duke of Buckingham and were grounded upon Publick Fame 1. Whether the Duke being Admiral be not the Cause of the loss of the Kings Royalty in the Narrow-Seas 2. Whether the unreasonable exorbitant and immense Gifts of Money and Lands bestowed on the Duke and his Kindred be not the Cause of impairing the Kings Revenue and impoverishing of the Crown 3. Whether the Multiplicity of Offices conferred upon the Duke and others depending upon him whereof they were not capable be not the Cause of the Evil Government of this Kingdom 4. Whether Recusants in general by a kind of Connivencie be not borne out and increased by reason of the Dukes Mother and Father-in-law being known Papists 5. Whether the Sale of Honors Offices and Places of Judicature and Ecclesiastical Livings and Promotions a scandal and hurt to the Kingdom be not through the Duke 6. Whether the Dukes staying at home being Admiral and General in the Fleet of the Sea and Land-Army were not the Cause of the bad success and overthrow of that Action And whether he did give good direction for that Design All these are famed to be so Hereupon two Questions were moved in Parliament 1. Whether the Six Heads delivered by Doctor Turner to be the Cause of the Evils that were grounded upon Common Fame be to be debated in Parliament 2. Whether an Accusation upon Common Fame by a Member of this House be a Parliamentary way It was declared by Sir Tho. Wentworth Mr. Noy and other Lawyers in the Debate That there was a difference between Common Fame and Rumor For the General voice Vox populi is Common Fame And if Common Fame might not be admitted as an Accuser Great men would be the onely safe men for no Private person dare adventure to enquire into their Actions But the House of Commons is a House of Information and Presentment but not a House of Definitive Judgment So the House came to this Resolution That Common Fame is a good ground of Proceeding for this House either by Enquiry or presenting the Complaint if the House finds cause to the King or Lords The Commons the next day proceeding in that Debate Sir Richard Weston delivered to the House this Message from his Majesty THat his Majesty had taken notice of a seditious Speech uttered in the House by Mr. Clement Cook The words are said to be to this effect That it were better to die by an Enemy then to suffer at home Yet his Majesty in his wisdom hath forborne to take any course therein or to send to the House about it not doubting but the House would in due time correct such an Insolence But his Majesty hath found that his patience hath wrought to an ill effect and hath imboldened one since to do a strange act in a strange way and unusual that is Doctor Turner who on Saturday last without any ground of knowledge in himself or Proof tendred to the House made an Enquiry of sundry Articles against the Duke of Buckingham as he pretended but indeed against the Honor and Government of the King and his late Father This his Majesty saith is such an Example that he can by no means suffer though it were to make Enquiry of the meanest of his Servants much less against one so neer unto himself and doth wonder at the foolish impudencie of any man that can think he should be drawn out of any end to offer such a Sacrifice much unworthy the greatness of a King and Master of such a Servant And therefore his Majesty can no longer use his wonted patience but desireth the Justice of the House against the Delinquents not doubting but such course will be taken that he shall not be constrained to use his Regal authority to right himself against these two Persons Upon this Message Doctor Turner made a short Explanation of himself desiring to know wherewith he was charged What he said he said the House can witness and what he said he spake for the general good of the Commonwealth and not upon the least reflection of any in particular This he thought a Parliamentary way warranted by antient Presidents To accuse upon Common Fame he finds warranted first by the Imperial Roman Laws and the Canons of the Church which allowed Common Fame sufficient to accuse any man And they that are learned amongst them give two reasons First for Greatness Next for Cunning. Our Ancestors within these walls have done the like and that to a Duke the Duke of Suffolk in the time of King H. 6. who was accused upon Fame And lastly he said Mr. Chancellor himself did present the Common Undertakers upon Particular Fame and why he should not have as ample priviledge in this place he knew no reason to the contrary The Commons having appointed another day for the Debate of this Business in the mean time came this Letter from Doctor Turner to the Speaker SIR THese Lines first Petition you to signifie to the Honorable House of Commons That my desires are still the same to have made my personal appearance before you but my ability and strength to perform it are not the same And therefore that I humbly desire them to excuse me on that part and to accept of this my Answer unto the matter I shall speak to I do confess that on Saturday last in the afternoon I did deliver in certain Accusations of Common Fame into the House of Parliament against my Lord Admiral and that out of so many all bearing the signiture of Vox populi I chose out some few not because they were greater or more known Grievances but because they did seem to direct us to find out the Griever or the first Cause For I did think it was then full time to agree the Agent and the Actions and that it was time also to leave considering Grievances in Arbitration I do now also agree unto you that which hath been reported unto you by Mr. Wandesford and by that if you shall think sit will put my self unto your Censure hoping and assuring my self that you will find my design to include nothing else within it but duty and publick service to my Country and also that my addressing those Accusations unto the House of Parliament shall by you be found to be done by a mannerly and Parliamentary way But howsoever it becomes me to submit my Cause to your Wisdoms and equal Iudgments which I do heartily and whatsoever you shall please to appoint me I shall dutifully satisfie when God shall be pleased to restore me able to attend your service I doubt
upon the Priviledges of the Peers of this Land and upon mine and their safety hereafter For if the Writ be not obeyed the Law calleth it a Misprission and highly fineable whereof we have had late examples and a missive Letter being avowed or not is to be doubted would not be adjudged a sufficient discharge against the Great-Seal of England On the other side if the Letter be not obeyed a Peer may De facto be committed upon a Contempt in the interim and the Question cleared afterwards so that in this case it is above mine abilities I can onely answer your Lordship that I will most exactly obey and to the end I may understand which obedience will be in all kindes most suitable to my duty I will presently repair to my private Lodging at London and there remain until in this and other Causes I shall have petitioned his Majesty and understand his further pleasure For the second part of your Lordships Letter where your Lordship saith That his Majesties meaning is not thereby to discharge any former directions for restraint of your Lordships coming hither but that you continue under the same restriction as before so that your Lordships personal attendance here is to be forborne I conceive your Lordship intendeth this touching my coming to Parliament onely for as touching my comning to London I never had at any time one word of prohibition or colourable pretence of restraint but on the contrary having his late Majesties express leave to come to London to follow my affairs out of my respect to his Majesty then Prince and to the Duke of Buckingham I forbore to come until I might know whether my coming would not be disagreeable unto them whereunto his Majesty was pleased to answer both under the hand of the Duke and of Mr Secretary Conway That he took my respect unto him herein in very good part and would wish me to make use of the leave the King had given me since which time I never received any Letter or Message of restraint onely his Majesty by his Letter bearing date June the last commandeth me to remain as I was in the time of the King his Father which was with liberty to come to London to follow mine own affairs as I pleased as will appear unto your Lordship if you will afford me so much favor as to peruse them I have writ this much unto your Lordship because I would not through misunderstanding fall into displeasure by my coming up and to intreat your Lordship to inform his Majesty thereof And that my Lord Conway by whose Warrant I was onely restrained in the late Kings time of famous memory may produce any one word that may have so much as any colourable pretence of debarring my coming up to London I beseech your Lordship to pardon my desire to have things clearly understood for the want of that formerly hath caused all my troubles and when any thing is misinformed concerning me I have little or no means to clear it so that my chief labor is to avoid misunderstanding I shall conclude with beseeching your Lordship to do me this favor to let his Majesty understand that my coming up is onely rightly to understand his pleasure whereunto I shall in all things most dutifully and humbly conform my self And so with my humble service to your Lordship I recommend you to Gods holy protection and remain Your Lordships most humble Servant BRISTOL Sherborn April 12. 1626. Hereupon the Lord Keeper delivered this Message from the King to the House of Lords THat his Majesty hath heard of a Petition preferred unto this House by the Earl of Bristol so void of duty and respects to his Majesty that he hath great cause to punish him That he hath also heard with what duty and respectfulness to his Majesty their Lordships have proceeded therein which his Majesty conceiveth to have been upon the knowledge they have that he hath been restrained for matters of State and his Majesty doth therefore give their Lordships thanks for the same and is resolved to put the Cause upon the honor and justice of their Lordships and this House And therefore his Majesty commanded him the Lord Keeper to signifie to their Lordships his Royal pleasure That the Earl of Bristol be sent for as a Delinquent to answer in this House his Offences committed in his Negotiations before his Majesties being in Spain and his Offences since his Majesties coming from Spain and his scandalizing the Duke of Buckingham immediately and his Majesty by reflection with whose privity and by whose directions the Duke did guide his Actions and without which he did nothing All which his Majesty will cause to be charged against him before their Lordships in this House The Lords appointed a Committee to attend the King and to present their humble thanks to his Majesty for the trust and confidence he had placed in the honor and justice of their House About this time the Marshal of Middlesex petitioned to the Committee of the House of Commons touching his resistance in seising of Priests goods A Warrant was made by Mr Attorney General to Iohn Tendring Marshal of Middlesex and other therein named to search the Prison of the Clink and to seise all Popish and Superstitious matters there found A Letter also was directed to Sir George Paul a Justice of Peace in Surrey to pray him to take some care and pains to expedite that service On Good Friday April 7. Sir George Paul was ready by six a clock in the morning five or six Constables being charged and about an hundred persons to aid and assist them The Marshall being attended with the persons named in the Warrant and divers others of his own servants and the Aid being provided by Sir George Paul came to the Clink and finding a door open without any Porter or Door-keeper at all entred without resistance at the first appearing But immediately upon discovery of his purpose the Concourse of people without and his unexpected entrance giving occasion thereto the Porter steps up shuts the door and keeps the Marshal and some few that entred together with him within and his Aid without resisting them that would enter their Warrant being shewed notwithstanding until by force another door was broken open by which the other persons named in the Warrant the Marshals men with the Constables and others appointed for their assistance with Halberts did enter also leaving sufficient company without to guard the three several doors belonging to the House Being within the Marshall gave direction to his followers to disperse themselves into several parts of the House to the end that whilest he did search in one part the other parts and places might be safely guarded and so he proceeded in his search in the prosecution whereof he found four several Priests in the house viz. Preston Cannon Warrington Prator Preston was committed to the Clink about 16 years since and discharged of his imprisonment about
the Clink But I am of opinion that if you had curiously enquired upon the Gentleman who gave the Information you should have found him to be a Disciple of the Iesuites for they do nothing but put tricks on these poor men who do live more miserable lives then if they were in the Inquisition in many parts beyond the Seas By taking the Oath of Allegiance and writing in defence of it and opening some points of high consequence they have so displeased the Pope that if by any cunning they could catch them they are sure to be burnt or strangled for it And once there was a plot to have taken Preston as he passed the Thames and to have shipt him into a bigger Vessel and so to have transported him into Flanders there to have made a Martyr of him In respect of these things King James always gave his protection to Preston and Warrington as may be easily shewed Cannon is an old man well-affected to the Cause but medleth not with any Factions or Seditions as far as I can learn They complain their Books were taken from them and a Crucifix of Gold with some other things which I hope are not carried out of the house but may be restored again unto them For it is in vain to think that Priests will be without their Beads or Pictures Models of their Saints and it is not improbable that before a Crucifix they do often say their prayers I leave the things to your best consideration and hope that this Deed of yours together with my Word will restrain them for giving offence hereafter if so be that lately they did give any I heartily commend me unto you and so rest Your very loving Friend G. Canterbury By this time the Commons had prepared an Humble Remonstrance to the King in Answer to his Majestie 's and the Lord Keeper's Speech Most Gracious Soveraign WHereas your Majesty hath béen pleased of late at sundry times and by several means to impart unto us your Royal pleasure touching some passages and procéedings in this present Parliament We do first with unspeakable joy and comfort acknowledge your Majesties grace and favor in that it hath pleased you to cause it to be delivered unto us by the Lord Kéeper of your Great Seal in your own Royal presence and before both Houses of Parliament That never King was more loving to his people nor better affected to the right use of Parliaments withal professing your most gracious resolution to hear and redress our just Grievances And with like comfort we acknowledge your Majesties goodness shining at the very entrance of your glorious Reign in commanding the Execution of the Laws established to preserve the true Religion of Almighty God in whose service consisteth the happiness of all Kings and Kingdoms Yet let it not displease your Majesty that we also express some sense of just Grief intermixed with that great Ioy to sée the careful procéedings of our sincere Intentions so misreported as to have wrought effects unexpected and we hope undeserved First touching the Charge against us in the matter concerning Mr. Cook We all sincerely protest That neither the words mentioned in your Maiesties Message nor any other of seditious effect were spoken by him as hath béen resolved by the House without one Negative voice Howsoever in a Spéech occasionally uttered he let fall some few words which might admit an ill construction whereat the House being displeased at the delivery of them as was expressed by a general and instant Check he forthwith so explained himself and his intention that for the present we did forbear to take them into consideration which since we have done And the effect thereof had before this appeared if by important businesses of your Maiesties service we had not béen interrupted The like interruption did also befall us in the Case of Doctor Turner wherein the Question being formerly stated a Resolution was ordered to have béen taken that very day on which we received your Maiesties command to attend you But for our own procéedings We humbly beséech your Maiesty to be truly informed That before that Overture from Doctor Turner out of our great and necessary care for your honor and welfare of your Realm We had taken into serious Consideration the Evils which now afflict your people and the Causes of them that we might apply our selves unto the fittest remedies In the pursuit whereof our Committées whatsoever they might have done have in no particular proceeded otherwise then either upon ground of knowledge in themselves or proof by examination of Witnesses or other Evidence In which course of service for the publick good as we have not swerved from the Parliamentary ways of our Predecessors so we conceive that the discovery and reforming of Errors is so far from laying an aspersion upon the present Time and Government that it is rather a great honor and happiness to both yielding matter to great Princes wherein to exercise and illustrate their noblest vertues And although the grievous Complaints of the Merchants from all parts together with the Common service of the Subiects well-affected to those who profess our Religion gave us occasion to debate some businesses that were partly Forein and had relation to affairs of State yet we beseech your Maiesty to rest assured it was exceeding far from our intention either to traduce your Counsellors or disadvantage your Negotiations And though some examples of great and potent Ministers of Princes heretofore questioned in Parliament have been alleadged yet was it without paralleling your Maiesties Government or Councils to any Times at all much less to Times of Exception Touching the Letter of Your Majesties Secretary it was first alleaged by your Advocate for his own Iustification and after by direction of the Committée produced to make good his Allegation And for the search at the Signet Office the Copy of a Letter being divulged as in your Majesties Name with pregnant cause of suspition both in the Body and Direction thereof to be supposititious the Committée out of desire to be cléered therein did by their Order send some of themselves to the Signet Office to search whither there were any Records of Letters of that nature without Warrant to the Officer for any much less for a general search But touching Publick Records we have not forborn as often as our businesses have required to make search into them wherein we have done nothing unwarranted by the Laws of your Realm and the constant usage of Parliaments And if for the ease of their Labors any of our Committées have desired the help of the Officers Repertories or Breviats of Direction We conceive it is no more then any Subject in his own affairs might have obtained for ordinary Fées Now concerning Your Majesties Servants and namely the Duke of Buckingham We humbly beséech Your Majesty to be informed by us your Faithful Commons who can have no private end but your Majesties Service and the good of
the other Knight being Robert Clifford it was agreed in Parliament that he should have the voices of both because the other must of necessity be absent And they both amongst other things petitioned the Council that if the King in his Person should come on the Sea they might have such a liberty to wait upon him as they might make their Lieutenant during the time for the service of their places But the Council that allowed the rest or most of their demands answered to that Le Councel ne pent faire Then he estimated the nature of the offence by the consequences which follow the not guarding of the Seas viz. 1. The losses already shewed 2. The prevention of Trade which gives life to the wealth of the Kingdom 3. The weakning of the Naval strength the Merchants being thereby discouraged from building ships which they cannot use In 1 Rich. 2. the Commons opened the two chief and almost whole Causes of the weakning the Kingdom at that time the neglect of Chivalry and eminent vertue not regarded nor rewarded the decay of Trade since the Navy was grown weak besides all the loss of quiet possession of so large a Territory as the Seas of England and Ireland by the free use of which the ancient glory and greatness of the Crown of England hath so constantly subsisted Then he instanced in Michael de la Pool Lord Chancellor who in 9 Rich. 2. mis-spent Subsidies given pro salva custodia maris as appears in the Roll and was adjuged in Parliament though for other offences because some other Lords of the Council had been trusted with him and it was not fit to impeach him sans les companions they taking it for a crime without question fit to be complained of Secondly in William Duke of Suffolk who for the same fault being Admiral onely in the right of Henry Earl of Exeter his Ward was by the King extraordinarily commanded into banishment Then he brought examples of such who had been put to death and confiscated for not safe-guarding Towns and Castles and Forts which are of like nature with not safe-guarding the Seas and with losing the possession of the Crown To the Fifth he said The staying of the ship called the Peter of Newhaven and detaining part of the goods was against the Marine Laws of England against the Common Laws against the Laws of Merchants and consequently the Law of Nations By the Marine Laws agreeable to the Civil Laws sentence given by any Subject or other against the King may upon new proof be revoked but not without new proof He made by his Patent a Judge of all Maritine Causes as well as Keeper of the Seas his Jurisdiction was to be exercised juxta leges nostras civiles Maritimas and accordingly to hear all Causes and generally to proceed ex officio mero mixto promoto secundum leges nostras Civiles Maritimas Against the Common-Laws All Justices and all other deputed to do Law or Right are commanded by Act of Parliament to permit the course of ordinary Justice and although they be commanded to do the contrary that they do execution aright and according to justice as far as in them lies and so for any Letters of Commandment which may come unto them from us or from any other or by any other cause Against the Law of Nations Against what is agreed by the Leagues between us and Forain Nations That the Subjects of Nations in Amity with us shall be well used and permitted without Molestation for what cause or occasion soever according to the Laws and Customs of the places where they shall be Lastly against the Laws of Merchants which is to have Celerem justitiam The Consequences of this Offence are 1. Great damage to our English Merchants that have suffered by reason of it in Forain Parts as they alleadge 2. It is a discouragement to those that are Subjects to the Marine Jurisdiction 3. An example that may serve hereafter to justifie all absolute Authority in the Admiral without Law or Legal course over the ships and good of all Merchants whatsoever and so no security to Merchants Lastly He instanceth in the Duke of Suffolk who was adjudged in Parliament for Treason and among other offences it was laid to his charge that he took to his own use goods Piratically taken and expresly against the Order determined by the Lord Protector and the whole Council whereunto his hand had been for the restitution of them Next were read the Sixth Seventh and Eighth Articles viz. VI. Whereas the honor wealth and strength of this Realm of England is much increased by the Traffick chiefly of such Merchants as imploy and build great warlike Ships a consideration that should move all Counsellors of State especially the Lord Admiral to cherish and maintain such Merchants The said Duke abusing the Lords of the Parliament in the One and twentieth year of the late King Iames of famous memory with pretence of serving the State did oppress the East India Merchants and extorted from them Ten thousand pounds in the subtil and unlawfull manner following About February in the year aforesaid he the said Duke hearing some good success that those Merchants had at Ormus in the parts beyond the Seas by his Agents cunningly in or about the moneth aforesaid in the year of the said late King endeavored to draw from them some great sum of money which their poverty and no gain by that success at Ormus made those Merchants absolutely to deny whereupon he the said Duke perceiving that the said Merchants were then setting forth in the course of their Trade four Ships and two Pinaces laden with goods and merchandise of very great value like to lose their voyage if they they should not speedily depart The said Duke on the first of March then following in the said year of the said late King did move the Lords then assembled in the said Parliament whether he should make stay of any Ships which were then in the Ports as being high Admiral he might and namely those ships prepared for the East India voyage which were of great burthen and well furnished which motion being approved by their Lordships the Duke did stay those ships accordingly but the fifth of March following when the then Deputy of that Company with other of those Merchants did make suit to the said Duke for the release of those Ships and Pinaces he the said Duke said he had not been the occasion of their staying but that having heard the motion with much earnestness in the Lords House of Parliament he could do no less then give the order they had done and therefore he willed them to set down the reasons of their suit which he would acquaint the House withall yet in the mean time he gave them leave to let their said ships and Pinaces fall down as low as Tilbury And the tenth of March following an unusual joynt action was by his procurement entred
aside and that Consideration might be had how their Priviledges may be preserved unto posterity And the House was put into a Committee for the freer Debate thereof and afterwards resumed And it was ordered That the House be adjourned till to morrow and all businesses to cease The 26. of May the Lord Keeper delivered this Message from the King to the House of Lords viz. THat his Majesty hath willed him to signifie unto their Lordships That he doth marvel his meaning in his last Answer should be mistaken And for the better clearing of his intention hath commanded him to signifie unto their Lordships his further Answer which is That their Lordships last Petition was so acceptable to his Majesty that his intent was then and is still to satisfie their Lordships fully in what they then desired Whereupon it was ordered That all businesses be adjourned till that day seven night At the same time the Duke of Buckingham signified unto their Lordships his desire to have the Kings Council allowed him to plead his cause But the Lords would not hear him because they would entertain no business And so the House was adjourned to the second of Iune At which time the House sitting again the Lord Keeper delivered this Message from the King to the House of Lords viz. HIs Majesty hath commanded me to deliver unto your Lordships a Message touching the Earl of Arundel That his Majesty hath thought of that business and hath advised of his great and pressing affairs which are such as make him unwilling to enter into dispute of things doubtful And therefore to give you clear satisfaction touching that Cause whereby you may more cheerfully proceed in the business of the House he hath endeavored as much as may be to ripen it but cannot yet effect it but is resolved that at the furthest by Wednesday sevennight being the fourteenth of Iune he will either declare the Cause or admit him to the House And addeth further upon the word of a King That if it shall be sooner ripe which he hath good cause to expect he will declare it at the soonest And further That if the occasion doth enforce to stay to the time prefixed yet he doth not purpose to set such a short end to the Parliament but that there shall be an ample and good space between that and the end of the Sessions to dispatch affairs This Message being delivered the House was adjourned ad libitum and put into a Committee And being resumed it was agreed That all businesses should cease but this of the Earl of Arundel's concerning the Priviledges of the House and the House to meet thereon to morrow morning and to be put into a Committee to consider thereof And so the House was adjourned to the next day Then the Lord Keeper delivered this Message from the King Viz. THat in the matter concerning the Earl of Arundel his Majesty hath been very careful and desirous to avoid all jealousie of violating the Priviledges of this House that he continueth still of the same mind and doth much desire to find out some Expedient which might satisfie their Lordships in point of Priviledge and yet not hinder his Majesties service in that particular But because this will require some time his Majesty though his great affairs are urgent and pressing is unwilling to urge their Lordships to go on therewith till his Majesty hath thought on the other And therefore hath commanded him to signifie his pleasure That his Majesty is contented their Lordships adjourn the House till Thursday next and in the mean time his Majesty will take this particular business into further consideration Hereupon the Lords agreed That the Lord Keeper do render unto his Majesty from the House their humble thanks for his gracious respect unto their Priviledges Then the Lord Keeper demanded of the Lords whether their Lordships would adjourn the House till Thursday next Whereupon it was agreed by the Lords and the House was so adjourned On Thursday Iune 8. the Lord Keeper delivered this Message to the Lords from his Majesty viz. THat on Saturday last his Majesty sent word to the House That by this day he would send them such an Answer concerning the Earl of Arundel as should satisfie them in point of Priviledge And therefore to take away all dispute and that their Priviledges may be in the same estate as they were when the Parliament began his Majesty hath taken off the restraint of the said Earl whereby he hath liberty to come to the House The Earl of Arundel being returned to the House did render his humble thanks unto his Majesty for this gracious favor towards him and gave their Lordships also most hearty thanks for their often intercessions for him unto the King and protested his Loyalty and faithful service unto his Majesty Much about this time Mr. Moor a Member of the House of Commons having spoken some words which seemed to reflect upon his Majesty they were reported to the House viz. That he said We were born free and must continue free if the King will keep his Kingdom Adding these words Thanks be to God we have no occasion to fear having a just and pious King The House for these words committed Mr. Moor to the Tower of London And his Majesty shortly after sent a Message That he had passed by his offence Whereupon he was released While the Duke stood charged in the Parliament the Chancellorship of Cambridge became void by the death of the Lord Howard Earl of Suffolk who died on Whitsonday the 28. of May 1626. The University having understood by several hands That it was the Kings express will and pleasure that the Duke should be chosen in his stead were ambitious and forward to express their obedience to his Majesty in that behalf well knowing that in regard of their multitude and worthy Judgment and wisdom that is esteemed and ought to be in those Electors this was one of the most honorable Testimonies of Worth and Integrity that the Nation can afford And that whereas all other the Dukes Honors did but help the rather to sink him with their weight this would seem to shoar and prop him up Letters were pretended to be sent from his Majesty to the intent to disencourage all opposers But though the pretence of Letters served mainly to effect their ends yet the producing of them would have prejudiced the chief intendment of the Election namely the honor of the Testimony in it which chiefly lying in the freedom of the Votes had by Letters been cut off Many Heads of Houses bestirr'd themselves according to their several power and interest in their respective Societies and Trinity-Colledge alone the Master whereof was Doctor Maw one of the Kings Chaplains supplied the Duke with Forty three Votes the third part of those which served the turn for he had in all One hundred and eight He was chosen the Thursday following the
some of the Bishops that were about London and some Divines and Civilians that by a good presence Causes might be handled for the reputation of the action and willed me therewithal to imitate therein the Lord Archbishop Whitgift who invited weekly some of the Judges to dinner the rather to allure them thither This advice proceeded from the Bishop of Durham that now is which was not ill if it came from a good intention I obeyed it singly and did that which was enjoyned But whereas in those times the Commissioners were but few since that time there hath been such an inundation of all sorts of men into that Company that without proportion both Lords Spiritual and Temporal Commissioners and not Commissioners resorted thither and divers of them brought so many of their men that it was truly a burthen to me I think it may by my Officers be justified upon Oath That since I was Archbishop the thing alone hath cost me out of my private estate One thousand pounds and a half and if I did say Two thousand pounds it were not much amiss besides all the trouble of my Servants who neither directly nor indirectly gained six pence thereby in a whole year but onely travel and pains for their Masters honor and of that they had enough My Houses being like a great Hostry every Thursday in the Term and for my expences no man giving me so much as thanks Now this being the true Case if the Church and Commonwealth be well provided for in the Administration of Justice and regard be had of the Publick can any discreet man think that the removing of me from this molestation is any true punishment upon me I being one that have framed my self to Reality and not to Opinion and growing more and more in years and consequently into weakness having before surfeited so long of worldly shews whereof nothing is truly gained temporally but vexation of spirit I have had enough of these things and do not dote upon them The world I hope hath found me more stayed and reserved in my Courses Nevertheless whatsoever was expedient for this was dispatched by me while I lived at Lambeth and Croyden albeit I went not out of door Yea but you were otherwise inutile not coming to the Star-chamber nor to the Council-Table My pain or weakness by the Gout must excuse me herein When I was younger and had my health I so diligently attended at the Star-chamber that for full seven years I was not one day wanting And for the Council-Table the same reason of my Indisposition may satisfie But there are many other things that do speak for me The greatest matters there handled were for Money or more Attempts of War For the one of these we of the Clergy had done our parts already the Clergy having put themselves into Paiments of Subsidy by an Act of Parliament not only for these two last years when the Temporalty lay in a sort dry but yet there are three years behind in which our Paiments run on with weight enough unto us And no man can justly doubt but my hand was in those Grants in a principal fashion And concerning the Provisions for War I must confess mine ignorance in the Feats thereof I knew not the grounds whereupon the Controversies were entred in general I thought that before Wars were begun there should be store of Treasure That it was not good to fall out with many great Princes at once That the turning of our Forces another way must needs be some diminution from the King of Denmark who was engaged by us into the Quarrel for the Palatinate and Germany and hazarded both his Person and Dominions in the prosecution of the Question These matters I thought upon as one that had sometimes been acquainted with Councils but I kept my thoughts unto my self Again I was never sent for to the Council-Table but I went saving one time when I was so ill that I might not stir abroad Moreover I was sure that there wanted no Councellors at the Board the Number being so much increased as it was Besides I had no great encouragement to thrust my crasie Body abroad since I saw what little esteem was made of me in those things which belonged to mine own Occupation With Bishopricks and Deanries or other Church-Places I was no more acquainted then if I had dwelt at Venice and understood of them but by some Gazette The Duke of Buckingham had the managing of these things as it was generally conceived For what was he not fit to determine in Church or Commonwealth in Court or Council in Peace or War at Land or at Sea at Home or in Foreign parts Montague had put out his Arminian Book I threee times complained of it but he was held up against me and by the Duke magnified as a well-deserving man Cosens put out his Treatise which they commonly call The Seven Sacraments which in the first Edition had many strange things in it as it seemeth I knew nothing of it but as it pleased my Lord of Durham and the Bishop of Bath So the World did read We were wont in the High-Commission to repress obstinate and busie Papists In the end of King Iames his time a Letter was brought me under the Hand and Signet of the King That we must not meddle with any such matter nor exact the Twelve-pence for the Sunday of those which came not to the Church with which Forfeit we never medled And this was told us to be in contemplation of a Marriage intended with the Lady Mary the Daughter of France After the death of King Iames such another Letter was brought from King Charls and all Execution against Papists was suspended But when the Term was at Reading by open divulgation in all Courts under the Great Seal of England We and all Magistrates are set at liberty to do as it was prescribed by Law And now our Pursuvants must have their Warrants again and take all the Priests they can whereof Mr. Cross took fourteen or fifteen in a very short space Not long after all these are set free and Letters come from the King under his Royal Signet That all Warrants must be taken from our Messengers because they spoiled the Catholicks and carried themselves unorderly unto them especially the Bishops Pursuvants Whereas we had in all but two Cross my Messenger for whom I did ever offer to be answerable and Thomlinson for whom my Lord of London I think would do as much But the Caterpillers indeed were the Pursuvants used by the Secretaries men of no value and shifters in the world who had been punished and turned away by us for great misdemeanors But truth of Religion and Gods service was wont to overrule humane Policies and not to be overruled And I am certain that things best prosper where those courses are held But be it what it may be I could not tell what to make of this variation of the Compass since
by the Books of our Laws that Liberty is a thing so favored of the Law that the Law will not suffer the continuance of a man in prison for any longer time then of necessity it must And therefore the Law will neither suffer the Party Sheriffs or Judges to continue a man in prison by their power and pleasure It doth speak of the delivery of a man out of prison with as reasonable expedition as may be And upon this reason it hath been resolved that howsoever the Law alloweth that there may be a Term between the Teste of an Original Writ and the Return of the same where there is only a Summons and no Imprisonment of the body yet the Law will not allow that there should be a Term between the Teste of a Writ of Capias and the Return of the same where the body of a man is to be imprison'd insomuch that it will give no way that the party shall have power to continue the body of a man longer time in prison then needs must so tender is the Law of the Subjects Liberty Monday the 27. of November the Attorney-General argued for the King That this was a very great Cause and hath raised great expectation and he was afraid that those Gentlemen whom it concerns have rather advised their Councils then their Councils them For the first Exception That the Return is not positive but hath relation to some others He did conceive it was positive enough For said he the words are Quod detentus est sub custodia mea per speciale mandatum Domini Regis The other words mihi significatum they follow after but are not part of the affirmation made before it And if they will have it as they seem to understand it then they must return the words thus Quod significatum est mihi per Dominos Privati Consilii quod detentus est per speciale mandatum Domini Regis And then it had not been their own proper Return but the signification of another the Lords of the Council The turning of the sentence would resolve this point the thing it self must speak for it self It is clear it is a positive Return that the detaining is by the command of the King and the rest of the Return is rather satisfaction to the Court then any part of the Return And for the other Exception That the Cause of the Cause is returned and not the Cause it self He said Among the Logicians there are two Causes there is Causa causans and Causa causata The Causa causans here in this Case is not the Warrant from the Lords of the Council for that is Causa causata But the primary and original Cause which is Causa causans is Speciale mandatum Domini Regis the other is but the Councils signification or testification or Warrant for him that made the Return And for the other Exception The Cause is imperfect because it shews only the Cause of detaining in Prison and not the Cause of the first Commitment He conceives it is sufficient for an Officer of the Law to answer That the Writ is a Command to make a Return of the detaining of the Prisoner and he accordingly makes a Return of the Detention and if the Keeper of the Prison had only said they were detained per speciale mandatum c. it had been good Then he proceeded to the matter of the Return and to answer the Book-Cases and Records that had been cited by the Council for the Prisoners and to produce Presidents on the Kings behalf which are extant in Print to which the Reader is referred Afterwards Sir Nicholas Hide Chief Justice Justice Dodderidge Justice Iones and Justice Whitlock being upon the Bench and Sir Iohn Heveningham and the forementioned Prisoners being brought to the Bar Sir Nicholas Hide Lord Chief Justice by the consent and direction of the Judges spake to this purpose That the Court hath seriously considered what hath been spoken by either side and are grown to a resolution And that his Brothers have enjoined him to deliver unto you the resolution of the whole Court And therefore said he though it be delivered by my mouth it is the resolution of us all I am sure you expect Justice from hence and God forbid we should sit here but to do Justice to all men according to our best skill and knowledge as it is our oaths and duties so to do But this is a Case of very great weight and great expectation and requires more solemn Arguments then the time will now permit The Exceptions which have been taken to this Return are two the one for the form the other for the substance First for the form because it is not returned as they say positively and absolutely but with reference to a Warrant of the Lords of the Council Now the Court is of opinion That this is a positive and absolute Return upon this reason That the Keeper of the Prison first returns that they are detained by the special command of the King And if they had ceased there it had been positive And for that which follows That it was signified to him by the Lords of the Council this is only to certifie the Court that he returned the Cause truly and not to shew us that he had no knowledge of the Cause but by the signification of the Lords of the Council There is not one word in the Writ that demands the cause why they were taken but why they are detained So that that point in the Writ is sufficiently answered which was only to certifie the cause of the detention And therefore we resolve That the form of this Return is good The next thing is the main point in Law Whether the substance or matter of the Return be good or no Where in the substance is this He doth certifie that they are detained in Prison by the special command of the King And whether this be good in Law or no is the Question Here the Lord Chief Justice did mention the several Presidents and Book-Cases cited by each side too long to be here related And concluded That that which is now to be judged by us is this Whether one that is committed by the Kings authority and no Cause shewn of his Commitment according as here it is upon this Return whether we ought to deliver him by Bail or to remand him back again Where by the way you must know that we can take notice only of this Return That when the Case appears to us no otherwise then by the Return we are not bound to examine the truth thereof but the sufficiencie of the Return We cannot judge upon rumors or reports but upon that which is before us on Record which is examinable by us whether it be sufficient or not Mr. Attorney hath told you That the King hath done it And we trust him in great matters And we make no doubt but the King if you seek to him knowing the cause why you
the best way for Reformation And will not this be a happy union if the whole body concur to reduce all into regularity if Laws be our Birth-rights we shall hereby recover them and their splendor this will have good aspect abroad and it will give courage to our men that have been despised and will prevent practises to continue divisions amongst us both at home and abroad The first Sower of seeds of distractions amongst us was an Agent of Spain Gondomar that did his Master great service here and at home Since that we have had other Ministers that have blown the fire The Ambassador of France told his Master at home what he had wrought here the last Parliament namely divisions between King and people and he was rewarded for it Whilst we sit here in Parliament there was another intended Parliament of Jesuites and other well-willers within a mile of this place that this is true was discovered by Letters sent to Rome The place of their meeting is changed and some of them are there where they ought to be if you look in your Calendar there is a day of St. Ioseph it was called in the Letter the Oriental day and that was the day intended for their meeting I speak this to see Gods hand to work our union in their division they are not more rent from us then they are from themselves I desire the meanest judgement to consider what may follow by giving precedency to his Majesty and by so doing we shall put from our selves many imputations If we give any occasion of breach it is a great disadvantage if otherwise it is an obligation to his Majesty which his Majesty will not forget Then he made a motion that the same Committee may hear Propositions of general heads of Supply and afterward go to other businesses of the day for Grievances Others preferred the Consideration of Grievances as a particular root that invades the main liberty of the Subject It is the Law said they that glorious fundamental Right whereby we have power to give we desire but that his Majesty may see us have that right therein which next to God we all desire and then we doubt not but we shall give his Majesty all supply we can The time was when it was usual to desire favors for sowing discords as Gondomar did for Raleigh's head But the debates of this day came to no Resolution The day following Mr Secretary Cook tendred the House certain Propositions from the King touching Supply and told them That his Majesty finding time precious expects that they should begin speedily lest they spend that time in deliberation which should be spent in action that he esteems the Grievances of the House his own and stands not on Precedence in point of honor Therefore to satisfie his Majesty let the same Committee take his Majesties Propositions into consideration and let both concur whether to sit on one in the forenoon or the other in the afternoon it is all one to his Majesty Hereupon the House turned themselves into a Committee and commanded Edward Littleton Esquire unto the Chair and ordered the Committee to take into Consideration the Liberty of the Subject in his Person and in his Goods and also to take into Consideration his Majesties Supply In this Debate the Grievances were reduced to six Heads as to our Persons 1. Attendance at the Council Board 2. Imprisonment 3. Confinement 4. Designation for Forein Imployment 5. Martial-Law 6. Undue Proceedings in matter of Judicature The first matter debated was the Subjects Liberty in his Person the particular instance was in the Case of Sir Iohn Heveningham and those other Gentlemen who were imprisoned about Loan-money and thereupon had brought their Habeas Corpus had their Case argued and were nevertheless remanded to Prison and a Judgment as it was then said was entred Whereupon Mr. Creswell of Lincolns-Inn spake to this purpose Justice said he is the Life and the Heart-blood of the Common-wealth and if the Commonwealth bleed in the master vein all the Balm in Gilead is but in vain to preserve this our Body of Policy from ruin and destruction Justice is both Columna Corona Reipublicae She is both the Columne and the Pillar the Crown and the Glory of the Commonwealth this is made good in Scripture by the Judgement of Solomon the wisest King that ever Raigned upon Earth For first She is the Pillar for he saith By Justice the Throne shall be Established Secondly She is the Crown for he saith That by Justice a Nation shall be Exalted Our Laws which are the rules of this Justice they are the ne plus ultra to both the King and the Subject and as they are the Hercules Pillar so they are the Pillar to every Hercules to every Prince which he must not pass Give me leave to resemble her to Nebuchadnezar's Tree for she is so great that she doth shade not onely the Palace of the King and the House of Nobles but doth also shelter the Cottage of the poorest Begger Wherefore if either now the blasts of indignation or the unresistable violater of Laws Necessity hath so bruised any of the Branches of this Tree that either our Persons or Goods or Possessions have not the same shelter as before yet let us not therfore neglect the root of this great Tree but water it with our Tears that so these bruised Branches may be recovered and the whole Tree again prosper and flourish I know well that Cor regis inscrutabile and that Kings although they are but men before God yet they are gods before men And therefore to my gracious and dread Soveraign whose vertues are true qualities ingenerate both in his judgment and nature let my arm be cut off nay let my soul not live that day that I shall dare to lift up my arm to touch that forbidden Fruit those Flowers of his Princely Crown and Diadem But yet in our Eden in this Garden of the Commonwealth as there are the Flowers of the Sun which are so glorious that they are to be handled only by Royal Majesty So are there also some Daysies and wholesom Herbs which every common hand that lives and labors in this Garden may pick and gather up and take comfort and repose in them Amongst all which this Oculus Diei this bona libertas is one and the chief one I will now descend to the Question wherein I hold with all dutiful submission to better judgments that these acts of Power in imprisoning and consining of his Majesties Subjects in such manner without any Declaration of the Cause are against the fundamental Laws and Liberties of this Kingdom The first from the great favor which the Law doth give unto and the great care which it hath ever taken of the Liberty and safety of this Kingdom To proceed therefore in maintenance of my first reasons I find our Law doth so much favor the Subjects Liberty of
his person that the body of a man was not liable to be arrested or imprisoned for any other Cause at the Common-Law but for force and things done against the Peace For the Common-Law being the preserver of the Land so abhorreth force that those that commit it she accounteth her capital Enemies and therefore did subject their bodies to imprisonment But by the Statute of Marlebridge cap. 24. which was made 35 H. 3. who was the eighth King from the Conquest because Bailiffs would not render accompts to their Lords it was enacted that their bodies should be attatched And after by the Stat 23 E. 3.17 who was the eleventh King after the Conquest because men made no conscience to pay their Debts it was enacted that their bodies should likewise be attached But before those Statutes no mans body was subject to be taken or imprisoned otherwise then as aforesaid whereby it is evident how much the Common-Law favored the Liberty of the Subject and protected his body from imprisonment Here he enforced the Reason by a Rule in Law and mentioned some Cases in Law upon that rule and so proceeded to a second Reason drawn by an Argument à majore ad minus I frame it thus said he If the King have no absolute power over our Lands or Goods then à fortiori not over our Persons to imprison them without declaring the cause for our persons are much more worth then either Lands or Goods which is proved by what I have said already And Christ himself makes it clear where he saith An non est corpus supra vestimentum Is not the Body of more worth then the Raiment Nay I may well say that almost every leaf and page of all the Volumes of our Common-Law prove this right of Propriety this distinction of meum and tuum as well between King and Subject as one Subject and another And therefore my conclusion follows that if the Prerogative extend not neither to Lands nor to Goods then à fortiori not to the Person which is more worth then either Lands or Goods as I said And yet I agree that by the very Law of Nature service of the Person of the Subject is due to his Soveraign but this must be in such things which â—re not against the Law of Nature but to have the body imprisoned without any cause declared and so to become in bondage I am sure is contrary unto and against the Law of Nature and therefore not to be inforced by the Soveraign upon his Subjects 3. My next Reason is drawn ab inutili incommodo for the Statute de frangentibus prisonám made 1 E. 2. is Quod nullus qui prisonam fregerit subeat judicium vitae vel membrorum pro fractione prisonae tantum nisi causa pro qua captus imprisonetur tale judicium requirat whence this conclusion is clearly gathered that if a man be committed to prison without declaring what cause and then if either Malefactor do break the Prison or the Gaoler suffer him to escape albeit the Prisoner so escaping had committed crimen laesae Majestatis yet neither the Gaoler nor any other that procured his escape by the Law suffer any corporal punishment for setting him at large which if admitted might prove in consequence a matter of great danger to the Commonwealth 4. My next Reason is drawn ab regis honore from that great Honor the Law doth attribute unto Soveraign Majesty and therefore the rule of Law is that Solum Rex hoc non potest facere quod non potest justè agere And Hussey chief Justice 1 H. 7. saith that Sir Iohn Markham told King E. 4. he could not arrest a man either for Treason or Felony as a Subject might because that if the King did wrong the party could not have an Action against him and if the Kings Writ under his Great-Seal cannot imprison the Subject unless it contains the cause shall then the Kings Warrant otherwise do it without containing the cause that his Judge upon the return thereof may likewise judge of the same But I will conclude with that which I finde reported of Sir Iohn Davis who was the Kings Serjeant and so by the duty of his place would no doubt maintain to his uttermost the Prerogatives of the King his Royal Master And yet it was by him thus said in those Reports of his upon the Case of Tavistry-Customs That the Kings of England alwayes have had a Monarchy Royal and not a Monarchy Seignoral where under the first saith he The Subjects are Freemen and have Propriety in their Goods and Free-hold and Inheritance in their Lands But under the later they are as Villains and Slaves and have propriety in nothing And therefore said he When a Royal Monarch makes a new conquest yet if he receives any of the Nations ancient Inhabitants into his Protection they and their heirs after them shall enjoy their Lands and Liberties according to the Law And there he vouched this President and Judgment following given before William the Conqueror viz. That one Sherborn a Saxon at the time of the Conquest being owner of a Castle and Lands in Norfolk the Conqueror gave the same to one Warren a Norman and Sherborn dying the heir claiming the same by discent according to the Law it was before the Conqueror himself adjudged for the heir and that the gift thereof by the Conqueror was void Upon this and other Arguments made in this Case of the Habeas Corpus the House referred the whole Business to a Committee to examine all the Proceeding Concerning which Mr Selden afterward made report to the House that Mr Waterhouse a Clerk in the Crown Office being examined before the Committee did confess that by direction from Sir Robert Heath the Kings Attorney-General he did write the draught of a Judgement in the Case before mentioned which was delivered to Mr Attorney And Mr Keeling being examined before the Committee did confess that after Mich Tâ—â—m last the Attorney General wished him to make a special Entry of 〈◊〉 Habeas Corpus To which he answered he knew no special Entry in those Cases but onely a remittitur But said to Mr Attorney that if he pleased to draw one and the Court afterwards assent to it he would then enter it The Attorney did accordingly make a draught and the Copy thereof Mr Keeling produced to the Committee And further said that he carried this draught to the Judges but they would not assent to a special Entry Nevertheless the At. General divers times sent to him and told him there was no remedy but he must enter it Yet a week before the Parliament the Att. General called for the draught again which accordingly he gave unto him and never heard of it more Sir Robert Philips upon this Report gave his opinion That this intended Judgement in the Habeas Corpus was a draught made by some man that desired to strike us all from our Liberties but
onely an Award and no Judgement and in the L. Chief Justice his Argument there was no word spoken that the King might commit or detain without cause For the King to commit a man is indignum Regi Mercy and Honor flow immediately from the King Judgement and Justice are his too but they flow from his Ministers the Sword is carried before him but the Scepter in his hands These are true Emblems of a good King The Law admits not the King power of detaining in Prison at pleasure In antient times Prisons were but pro custodia carceres non ad poenam sed ad custodiam Admit the King may commit a man yet to detain him as long as he pleaseth is dangerous and then a man shall be punished before his offence Imprisonment is a Maceration of the body and horror to the minde it is vita pejor morte Mr Selden last of all produced the Statutes Presidents and Book-Cases which were expresseâ— in point to the Question in hand and the House commanded that Case in the Lord Chief Justice Andersons Book all of his own hand-writing to be openly read And for the Presidentâ— cited by the Kings Council in 34 years of the Queen as the Opinion of all the Judges certainly there was a great mistake in it and the mistake was the greater when it passed as currant by the Judges of the Kings-Bench in the last Case of the Habeas Corpus And that the truth of the Opinion may clearly appear let us read the words out of the Lord Chief Justice Andersons Report out of the Book written with his own hand which will contradict all those Apocrypha Reports that go upon the Case The words of the Report were these Divers persons fueront committes a several temps a several prysons sur pleasure sans bon cause parte de queux estiant amesnes en banck le Roy. Et parte en le Commune banck fuerunt accordant a le ley de la terre mise a large discharge de le imprisonment pur que aucunt grands fueront offendus procure un commandment a les Iudges que ils ne fera ainsi apres Ceo nient meins les Iudges ne surcease mes per advise enter eux ils fesoint certain Articles le tenour de queux ensus deliver eux al seignieurs Chancelor Treasurer eux subscribe avec touts lour mainies les Articles sont come erisnoint We her Majesties Iustices of both Benches and Barons of the Exchequer desire your Lordships that by some good means some order may be taken that her Highness Subjects may not be committed or detained in prison by commandment of any Noble man or Councellor against the Laws of the Realm either else to help us to have access to her Majesty to the end to become Suitors to her for the same for divers have been imprisoned for suing ordinary Actions and Suits at the Common-Law until they have been constrained to leave the same against their wills and put the same to order albeit Iudgement and Execution have been had therein to their great losses and griefs for the aid of which persons her Majesties Writs have sundry times been directed to sundry persons having the Custody of such persons unlawfully imprisoned upon which Writs no good or lawfull cause of imprisonment hath been returned or certified Whereupon according to the Laws they have been discharged of their imprisonment some of which persons so delivered have been again committed to prison in secret places and not to any common or ordinary Prison or lawfull Officer or Sheriff or other lawfully authorized to have or keep a Goal So that upon complaint made for their delivery the Queens Courts cannot tell to whom to direct her Majesties Writs and by this means Iustice cannot be done And moreover divers Officers and Serjeants of London have been many times committed to Prison for lawfull executing of her Majesties Writs sued forth of her Majesties Court at Westminster and thereby her Majesties Subjects and Officers are so terrified that they dare not sue or execute her Majesties Laws her Writs and Commandments Divers others have been sent for by Pursevants and brought to London from their dwellings and by unlawfull imprisonment have been constrained not only to withdraw their lawfull suits but have been also compelled to pay the Pursevants so bringing such persons great sums of money All which upon complaint the Iudges are bound by Office and Oath to relieve and help by and according to her Majesties Laws And where it pleaseth your Lordships to will divers of us to set down in what Cases a Prisoner sent to custody by her Majesty or her Councel are to be detained in Prison and not to be delivered by her Majesties Court or Iudges We think that if any person be committed by her Majesties command from her person or by order from the Council board and if any one or two of her Council commit one for high Treason such persons so in the Cases before committed may not be delivered by any of her Courts without due Trial by the Law and Iudgement of acquittal had Nevertheless the Iudges may award the Queens Writ to bring the bodies of such Prisoners before them and if upon return thereof the causes of their commitment be certified to the Iudges as it ought to be then the Iudges in the Cases before ought not to deliver him but to remand the Prisoner to the place from whence he came which cannot conveniently be done unless notice of the cause in general or else in special be given to the Keeper or Goaler that shall have the Custody of such a Prisoner All the Iudges and Barons did subscribe their names to these Articles Ter. Paschae 34 Eliz. and delivered one to the L. Chancellor and another to the L. Treasurer after which time there did follow more quietness then before in the Cause before mentioned After the reading of this Report Sir Edw. Cook said That of my own knowledge this Book was written with my L. Andersons own hand it is no flying report of a young Student I was Solicitor then and Treasurer Burley was as much against Commitment as any of this Kingdom It was the White Staves that made this stir Let us draw towards a conclusion The Question is whether a Feeman can be imprisoned by the King without setting down the cause I leave it as bare as Aesops Crow they that argue against it Humores moti non remoti corpus destruunt It is a Maxime the Common-Law hath admeasured the Kings Prerogative that in no Case it can prejudice the Inheritance of the Subjects had the Law given the Prerogative to that which is taken it would have set some time to it else mark what would follow I shall have an Estate of Inheritance for life or for years in my Land or propriety in my Goods and I shall be a Tenant at will for my liberty I shall have
and ought not to be denied and is directeâ— to the Keeper of the Prison in whose custody the Prisoner remains commanding him that after a certain day he bring in the body of the Prisoner cum causa detentionis and sometimes cum causa captionis and he with his return filed to the Writ bringeth the Prisoner to the Bar at the time appointed and the Court judgeth of the sufficiency or insufficiency of the retuâ—n and if they finde him baylable committitur Marescallo the proper Prison belongeth to the Court and then afterward traditur in ball But if upon the return of the Habeas Corpus it appear to the Court that the Prisoner ought not to be bayled nor discharged from the Prison whence he is brought then he is remanded and sent back again to continue till by due course of Law he may be delivered and the entâ—y of this is remittitur quousque secundum legem deliberatus fuerit or remittitur quousque c. which is all one and the highest award of Judgement that ever was or can be given upon a Habeas Corpus Your Lordships have heard the resolution of the House of Commons touching the enlargement of a man committed by the command of the King or the privy Councel or any other without cause shewed of such commitment which resolution as it is grounded upon Acts of Parliament already shewen the reason of the Law of the Land being committed to the charge of another to open unto unto you so it is strengthened by many Precedents of Records He then produced twelve Precedents full and directly in the point to prove that persons so committed ought to be delivered upon bayl which were distinctly opened and read to their Lordships then he also offered to their consideration other kind of Precedents which were solemn resolutions of Judges things not of Record but yet remain in Authentick Copies which Precedents and Authorities we omit for the length thereof He then proceeded and said The House of Commons desiring with all care to inform themselves fully of the truth of the resolution of the Judges in the 34. year of the Queen cited in the case of Sir Iohn Heveningham by the Kings Councel as Arguments against his not being bayled have got into their hands a Book of select Cases collected by the reverend and learned Judge Chief Justice Anderson all written with his own hand which he caused to be read being the same which hath been already mentioned in the Collections of this Parliament which Precedents saith he do fully resolve enough for the maintenance of the ancient and fundamental point of Liberty of the Person to be regained by Hab. Corp. when any is imprisoned Then he concluded that having thus gone through the charge committed to him by the House of Commons he should now as he had leave and direction given him lest their Lordships should be put to much trouble and expence of time in finding and getting Copies at large of those things which he had cited offer also to their Lordships Authentick Copies of them all and so left them and whatever else he had said to their Lordships further consideration LAst of all Sir Edward Cook took up the Argument as to the rational part of the Law and began with this Introduction Your Lordships have heard 7. Acts of Parliament in point and 31. Precedents summarily collected and with great understanding delivered which I have perused and understand them all throughly 12. of the Precedents are in terminis terminantibus a whole Jury of Precedents and all in the point I am much transported with joy because of the hope of good success in this weighty business your Lordships being so full of Justice and the very Theme and Subject doth promise success which was Corpus cum cansa the freedom of an English man not to be imprisoned without cause shewn which is my part to shew and the reason and the cause why it should be so wherein I will not be prolix nor copious for to guild Gold were idle and superfluous And after he had cleared some doubts made of the Statute of Westminster which saith That the Sheriffs and others in some cases may not replevin men in Prison he proceeded further and said That all those Arguments offered unto your Lordships in this last conference are of a double nature 1. Acts of Parliament 2. Judicial Precedents For the first I hold it a proper Argument for your Lordships because you my Lords temporal and you my Lords spiritual gave your assent unto those Acts of Parliament and therefore if these cannot perswade you nothing can For the second which are Judicial Precedents it is Argumentum ab authoritate and Argumentum ab authoritate valet affimative that is I conceive though it be no good Argument to say negatively the Judges have given no opinion in the point 3. It is good Law which I fortifie with a strong Axiome Neminem oportet sapientiorem esse legibus Now these two arguments being so well pressed to your Lordships by my Colleagues I think your Lordships may wonder what my part may be it is short but sweet it is the Reason of all those Laws and Precedents and Reason must needs be welcome to all men for all men are not capable of the understanding of the Law but every man is capable of Reason and those Reasons I offer to your Lordships in affirmance of the antient Laws and Precedents made for the Liberty of the Subject against Imprisonment without cause expressed 1. A re ipsa 2. A minore ad majus 3. From the remedies provided 4. From the extent and universality of the same 5. From the infiniteness of the time 6. A Fine The first general Reason is a re ipsa even from the nature of Imprisonment ex visceribus causae for I will speak nothing but ad idem be it close or other Imprisonment and this Argument is three-fold because an imprisoned man upon will and pleasure is 1. A Bond-man 2. Worse then a Bond-man 3. Not so much as a man for mortuus homo non est homo a Prisoner is a dead man 1. No man can be imprisoned upon will and pleasure of any but he that is a Bond-man and villain for that Imprisonment and Bondage are Propria quarto modo to villains now Propria quarto modo and the species are convertible Whosoever is a Bond-man may be imprisoned upon will and pleasure and whosoever may be imprisoned upon will and pleasure is a Bondman 2. If free men of England might be imprisoned at the will and pleasure of the King or his commandment then were they in worse case then Bondmen or villains for the Lord of a villain cannot command another to imprison his villain without cause as of disobedience or refusing to serve as it is agreed in the year books And here he said that no man should reprehend any thing that he said out of Books or Records he said he would prove
alledged must be such as may be determined by our Iudges of our Courts of Westminster in a Legal and ordinary way of Iustice whereas the Causes may be such as those Iudges have not capacity of Iudicature nor Rules of Law to direct and guide their Iudgement in cases of that transcendent nature which hapning so often the very incroaching on that constant Rule of Government for so many ages within this Kingdom practised would soon dissolve the very Foundation and Frame of our Monarchy Wherefore as to our Commons we made fair Propositions which might equally preserve the just Liberty of the Subject so my Lords we have thought good to let you know that without the overthrow of Soveraignty we cannot suffer this Power to be impeached notwithstanding to clear our conscience and just intentions this we publish That it is not in our heart nor will we ever extend our Royal Power lent unto us from God beyond the just rule of Moderation in any thing which shall be contrary to our Laws and Customs wherein the safety of our People shall be our onely aim And we do hereby Declare our Royal pleasure and resolution to be which God willing we shall ever constantly continue and maintain That neither we nor our Privy Council shall or will at any time hereafter commit or command to Prison or otherwise restrain the persons of any for not lending Money to us nor for any cause which in our conscience doth not concern the publique good and safety of us and our people we will not be drawn to pretend any cause wherein our judgement and conscience is not satisfied with base thoughts we hope no man can imagine will fall into our Royal breast and that in all cases of this nature which shall hereafter happen we shall upon the humble Petition of the party or address of our Iudges unto us readily and really express the true cause of their Commitment or Restraint so soon as with conveniency and safety the same is fit to be disclosed and expressed and that in all Causes Criminal of ordinary Iurisdiction our Iudges shall proceed to the Deliverance or Bailment of the Prisoner according to the known and ordinary Rules of the Laws of this Land and according to the Statute of Magna Charta and those other Six Statutes insisted upon which we do take knowledge stand in full force and which we intend not to abrogate and weaken against the true intention thereof This we have thought fit to signifie the rather to shorten any long Debate upon this great question the season of the year being so far advanced and our great Occasions of State not lending many more days for longer continuance of this Session of Parliament Given under our Signet at our Palace at Westminster 20º Maii the Fourth year of our Reign The same day the Kings Letter was communicated to the House of Commons they laid it aside and Sir Thomas Wentworth said it was a Letter of Grace but the people will onely like of that which is done in a Parliamentary way besides the Debate of it would spend much time neither was it directed to the House of Commons and the Petition of Right would clear all mistakes For said he some give out as if the House went about to pinch the Kings Prerogative But the further Debate of this matter took up several days May 17. the Lords propounded at a Conference an Addition to be made to the Petition of Right which was delivered by the Lord Keeper to this purpose THat whereas at the late Conference of both Houses there were some things propounded that came from their Lordships out of a desire the Petition might have the easier passage with his Majesty not intending to violate in any maner the substance of the Petition but it was then thought fit that there was another part of the Petition of as great importance and weight My Lords since the time of that Conference have imployed themselves wholly to reduce the Petition to such a frame and order that may give both to you and them hope of acceptance And after many deliberations and much advice taken my Lords have resolved to represent to you something which they have thought upon yet not as a thing conclusive to them or you and according to their desires having mentioned it in the beginning have held it fit to conclude of nothing till that you be made acquainted with it and that there may be a mature advisement between you and them so that there may be the happier conclusion in all their business This being the determination of the Lords that nothing that is now offered unto you should be conclusive yet they thought it convenient to present it unto you This alteration and not alteration but addition which they shall propound unto you to be advised and conferred upon which is no breach of the frame they think it meet if it shall stand with your liking to be put in the conclusion of the Petition which I shall now read unto you WE present this our humble Petition to your Majesty with the care not onely of preserving our own Liberties but with due regard to leave intire that Soveraign Power wherewith your Majesty is trusted for the Protection Safety and Happiness of the People This is the thing the Lords do present unto you this subject of this Conference concerning the adding of this in the conclusion of the Petition and that they know that this is new and that you cannot presently give an answer to it therefore they desire that you do with some speed consider of it and their Lordships will be ready this afternoon This Addition produced several Speeches LEt us look said he into the Records and see what they are what is Soveraign Power Bodin saith That it is free from any Condition by this we shall acknowledge a Regal as well as a Legal Power Let us give that to the King that the Law gives him and no more I Am not able to speak to this question I know not what it is All our Petition is for the Laws of England and this Power seems to be another distinct Power from the Power of the Law I know how to adde Soveraign to his Person but not to his Power Also we cannot leave to him Soveraign Power we never were possessed of it WE cannot admit of those words with safety they are applicable to all the parts of our Petition It is in the nature of a Saving and by it we shall imply as if we had incroached on his Prerogative all the Laws we cite are without a Saving and yet now after the violation of them we must adde a Saving Also I have seen divers Petitions and where the Subject claimed a Right there I never saw a Saving of this nature THis is Magnum in parvo this is propounded to be a conclusion of our Petition It is a matter of great weight and to speak plainly it
of the People Certainly hereafter it will be conceived that an House of Parliament would not have made an unnecessary addition to this Petition of Right and therefore it will be resolved that the Addition hath relation to the Petition which will have such operation as I have formerly declared and I the rather fear it because the late Loan and Billeting have been declared to have been by Soveraign Power for the good of our selves and if it be doubtful whether this Proposition hath reference to the Petition or not I know not who shall judge whether Loans or Imprisonments hereafter be by that Soveraign Power or not A Parliament which is made a Body of several Writs and may be dissolved by one Commission cannot be certain to decide this question We cannot resolve that that the Judges shall determine the words of the Kings Letter read in this House expressing the cause of Commitment may be such that the Judges have not capacity of Judicature no Rules of Law to direct and guide their judgements in Cases of that transcendent nature the Judges then and the Judgements are easily conjectured it hath been confessed by the Kings Councel that the Statute of Magna Charta bindes the King it bindes his Soveraign Power and here is an Addition of Saving the Kings Soveraign Power I shall endeavor to give some Answer to the Reasons given by the Lords The first is That it is the intention of both Houses to maintain the Just Liberty of the Subject and not to diminish the just Power of the King and therefore the expression of that intention in this Petition cannot prejudice us To which I answer First That our intention was and is as we then professed and no man can assign any particular in which we have done to the contrary neither have we any way transgressed in that kinde in this Petition and if we make this addition to the Petition it would give some intimation that we have given cause or colour of offence therein which we deny and which if any man conceive so let him assign the particular that we may give answer thereunto By our Petition we onely desire our particular Rights and Liberties to be confirmed to us and therefore it is not proper for us in it to mention Soveraign Power in general being altogether impertinent to the matter in the Petition There is a great difference between the words of the Addition and the words proposed therein for reason viz. between just Power which may be conceived to be limited by Laws and Soveraign Power which is supposed to be transcendent and boundless The second Reason delivered by their Lordships was That the King is Soveraign That as he is Soveraign he hath power and that that Soveraign Power is to be left for my part I would leave it so as not to mention it but if it should be expressed to be left in this Petition as it is proposed it must admit something to be left in the King of what we pray or at least admit some Sovergain Power in his Majesty in these Priviledges which we claim to be our Right which would frustrate our Petition and destroy our Right as I have formerly shewed The third Reason given from this Addition was That in the Statute of Articuli super Chartas there is a Saving of the Seigniory of the Crown To which I give these Answers That Magna Charta was confirmed above thirty times and a general Saving was in none of these Acts of Confirmation but in this onely and I see no cause we should follow one ill and not thirty good Precedents and the rather because that Saving produced ill effects that are well known That Saving was by Act of Parliament the conclusion of which Act is that in all those Cases the King did well and all those that were at the making of that Ordinance did intend that the right and Seigniory of the Crown should be saved By which it appears that the saving was not in the Petition of the Commons but added by the King for in the Petition the Kings will is not expressed In that Act the King did grant and depart with to his People divers Rights belonging to his Prerogative as in the first Chapter he granted That the People might choose three men which might have Power to hear and determine Complaints made against those that offended in any point of Magna Charta though they were the Kings Officers and to Fine and Ransome them and in the 8.12 and 19. Chapter of that Statute the King departed with other Prerogatives and therefore there might be some reason of the adding of that Soveraign by the Kings Councel But in this Petition we desire nothing of the Kings Prerogative but pray the enjoying of our proper and undoubted Rights and Priviledges and therefore there is no cause to adde any words which may imply a Saving of that which concerns not the matter in the Petition The fourth Reason given by their Lordships was That by the mouth of our Speaker we have this Parliament declared That it was far from our intention to incroach upon his Majesties Prerogative and that therefore it could not prejudice us to mention the same resolution in an Addition to this Petition To which I Answer That that Declaration was a general Answer to a Message from his Majesty to us by which his Majesty expressed That he would not have his Prerogative straitned by any new Explanation of Magna Charta or the rest of the Statutes and therefore that expression of our Speakers was then proper to make it have reference to this Petition there being nothing therein contained but particular Rights of the Subject and nothing at all concerning his Majesties Prerogative Secondly That Answer was to give his Majesty satisfaction of all our proceedings in general and no man can assign any particular in which we have broken it and this Petition justifies it self that in it we have not offended against the Protestation and I know no reason but that this Declaration should be added to all our Laws we shall agree on this Parliament as well as to this Petition The last Reason given was That we have varied in our Petition from the words of Magna Charta and therefore it was well necessary that a Saving should be added to the Petition I Answer That in the Statute 5 E. 3.25 E. 3.28 E. 3. and other Statutes with which Magna Charta is confirmed the words of the Statute of Explanation differ from the words of Magna Charta it self the words of some of the Statutes of Explanation being that no man ought to be apprehended unless by Indictment or due process of Law and the other Statutes differing from the words of Magna Charta in many other particulars and yet there is no Saving in those Statutes 〈◊〉 much less should there be any in a Petition of Right There are the Answers I have conceived to the Reasons of their Lordships and the
our House hath taken this very Session in these words I A. B. do utterly testifie and declare in my conscience That the Kings Highness is the Supreme or Soveraign Governor of this Realm in all Causes c. and to my utmost Power will assist and defend all jurisdictions Priviledges Preheminencies and Authorities granted or belonging to the Kings Highness or united or annexed to the Imperial Crown of this Realm c. So that your Lordships need not to borrow from our Protestations any Exhortations to us to entertain a Writing in assistance of the Kings Soveraign Power since we stand obliged by the most sacred Bond of a solemn Oath to assist and defend the same if cause and occasion so required So that the onely question between your Lordships and us is whether this Clause should be added to our Petition and received into it as part thereof which to do your Lordships reasons have not perswaded us because so to admit it were to overthrow the fabrick and substance of our Petition of Right and to annihilate the Right pretended by us and the Petition it self in effect For these words being added to our Petition viz. we humbly present this Petition c. with due regard to leave entire your Soveraign Power c. do include manifestly an Exception to our Petition and an Exception being of the nature of the thing whereunto it is an Exception Exceptio est de regula must of necessity destroy the Rule or Petition so far as to the case excepted Exceptio firmat regulam in casibus non exceptis in casibus except is destruit regulam Then this Construction followeth upon our Petition thus enlarged that after we have petitioned that no freeman should be compelled by imprisonment to lend or contribute money to his Majesty without his assent in Parliament nor receive against his will Soldiers into his house or undergo a Commission of Marshal Law for Life or Member in time of Peace we should adde Except his Majesty be pleased to require our monies and imprison us for not lending and send Soldiers into our houses and execute us by Marshal Law in time of Peace by vertue of his Soveraign Power which construction as it followeth necessarily upon this inlargement so it concludeth against our right in the Premises and utterly frustrateth all our Petition neither may it seem strange if this Clause additional which of it self in quality of a Proposition we confess being added to our Petition which also is true should overthrow the very frame and fabrick of it seeing the Logicians take knowledge of such a Fallacy called by them Fallacia a bene divisis ad male conjuncta Horace the Poet giveth an instance to this purpose in a Painter who when he had painted the Heaâ— of a man according to Art would then joyn to it the neck of a Horse and so mar the one and the other whereas each by it self might have been a piece of right good workmanship The second branch of my Lord Keepeâ—s rational part was enforc'd out of the last words of this addition by which his Lordship said that they did not leave intire all Soveraign Power but that wherewith his Majesty is trusted for the Protection Safety and Happiness of the People as if his Lordship would infer that Soveraign Power wherewith c. in this place to be Terminum diminuentem a Term of diminution or qualification and in that consideration might induce us to accept it But under his Lordships correction we cannot so interpret it For first we are assured that there is no Soveraign Power wherewith his Majesty is trusted either by God or man but onely that which is for the Protection Safety and Happiness of his people and therefore that limitation can make no impression upon us but we conceive it rather in this place to have the force Termini adaugentis to be a Term of important advantage against our Petition a Term of restriction and that wheresoever his Majesties Soveraign Power should be exercised upon us in all and every the particulars mentioned in the Petition we should without further enquiry submit thereunto as assuming and taking it pro concesso it induced to our Safety and Happiness c. Since therefore as the Petition is now conceived it carrieth the form and face of a Picture which representeth to the life the pressures and grievances of the people with the easie remedies And therefore we hope that his Majestie casting upon it a gracious eye will compassionate his poor Loyal Subjects and afford a comfortable answer I do humbly pray your Lordships not to mar or blemish the grace and face of this Picture with this unnecessary addition and unnecessary I prove it to be according to that Rule Expressio ejus quod tacite inest nihil operatur And Soveraign Power in cases where it hath place and ought to be used is always necessarily understood and though not expressed yet supplyed by reasonable intendment or by the opinion of all Learned men And therefore as it neither is nor can be by us expresly included especially in this Petition where the addition thereof would make such a confusion of the whole sense and substance The Kings Soveraign Power and Prerogative is always able to save it self and if it were not we must without this addition save it to our utmost powers if we will save our Oath and save our selves the true state of the cause thus standing between your Lordships and us the House of Commons doth not a little marvel upon what grounds your Lordships are so earnest to urge upon them this addition to be inserted into their Petition they nothing doubt but that the same proceeded out of a sollicitude and fear which your Lordships have lest otherwise the simple and absolute passage of this Petition might be construed hereafter in prejudice of his Majesties Soveraign Power And this your Lordships sollicitude and fear proceedeth from your love as the Poet saith Res est solliciti plena timoris Amor. But I humbly pray your Lordships to examine with us the grounds of this your sollicitude and fear which grounds needs must be laid either upon the words of the Petition or the intention of the Petitioners Upon the words there is no possibility to lay them for therein is no mention made of the Soveraign Power and were the words doubtful as thus We pray the like things be nor done hereafter under pretext of your Majesties Soveraign Power yet in respect of the Protestations preceding concomitant and subsequent to the Petition such doubtful words ought reasonably to be interpreted onely of such Soveraign Power as was not appliable to the Cases wherein it was exercised and of such Soveraign Power as should be justly practised but there are no such doubtful words and therefore it followeth that your Lordships fear and sollicitude must be grounded upon the intention of the Petitioners Now your Lordships well know that the House of Commons is not
Laud look to thy self be assured thy life is sought as thou art the fountain of wickedness repent of thy monstrous sins before thou be taken out of the world and assure they self neither God nor the world can endure such a vile Counsellor or whisperer to live The other was as bad against the L. Treasurer Weston The King purposing to proceed against the Members of the House of Commons who were committed to Prison by him in the Star-Chamber caused certain Questions to be proposed to the Judges upon the 25 of April WHereupon all the Judges met at Sergeants-Inne by command from his Majesty where Mr. Atturney proposed certain Questions concerning the offences of some of the Parliament-men committed to the Tower and other prisons at which time one Question was proposed and resolved viz. That the Statute of 4 H. 8.8 intituled An Act concerning Richard Strode was a particular Act of a Parliament and extended onely to Richard Strode and to those persons that had joyned with him to prefer a Bill to the House of Commons concerning Tynners And although the Act be private and extendeth to them alone yet it was no more then all other Parliament-men by priviledge of house ought to have viz. Freedom of speech concerning those matters debated in Parliament by a Parliamentary course The rest of the Questions Mr. Atturney was wished to set down in writing against another day Upon Munday following all the Judges met again and then Mr. Atturney proposed these Questions 1. Whether if any Subject hath received probable Information of any Treason or treacherous attempt or intention against the King or State that Subject ought not to make known to the King or his Majesties Commissioners when thereunto he shall be required what Information he hath received and the grounds thereof to the end the King being truly informed may prevent the danger And if the said Subject in such Case shall refuse to be examined or to answer the Questions which shall be demanded of him for further inquiry and discovery of the truth whether it be not a high contempt in him punishable in the Star-Chamber as an offence against the general Iustice and Government of the Kingdom Sol. The resolution and answer of all the Justices That it is an offence punishable as aforesaid so that this do not concern himself but another nor draw him to danger of Treason or contempt by his answer 2. Whether it be a good answer or excuse being thus interrogated and refusing to answer to say That he was a Parliament-man when he received this Information and that he spake thereof in the Parliament-house and therefore the Parliament being now ended he refused to answer to any such Questions but in the Parliament-house and not in any other place Sol. To this the Judges by advise privately to Mr. Atturney gave this Answer That this excuse being in Nature of a Plea and an errour in judgement was not punishable until he were over-ruled in an orderly manner to make another answer and whether the party were brought in Ore tenus or by Information for this Plea he was not to be punished 3. Whether a Parliament-man committing an offence against the King or Council not in a Parliament way might after the Parliament ended he punished or not Sol. All the Judges una voce answered He might if he be not punished for it in Parliament for the Parliament shall not give priviledge to any contra morem Parliamentarium to exceed the bounds and limits of his place duty And all agreed That regularly he cannot be compelled out of Parliament to answer things done in Parliament in a Parliamentary course but it is otherwise where things are done exorbitantly for those are not the Acts of a Court. 4. Whether if one Parliament-man alone shall resolve or two or three shall covertly conspire to raise false slanders and rumours against the Lords of the Council and Iudges not with intent to question them in a Legal course or in a Parliamentary way but to blast them and to bring them to hatred of the people and the Government in contempt be punishable in the Star-Chamber after the Parliament is ended Sol. The Judges resolve that the same was punishable out of Parliament as an offence exorbitant committed in Parliament beyond the office and besides the duty of a Parliament-man There was another Question put by Mr. Atturney viz. Whether if a man in Parliament by way of digression and not upon any occasion arising concerning the same in Parliament shall say The Lords of the Council and the Judges had agreed to trample upon the Liberty of the Subject and the priviledges of Parliament he were punishable or not The Judges desired to be spared to make any answer thereunto because it concerned themselves in particular The next day Mr. Atturny put the Judges another Case It is demanded of a Parliament-man being called Ore tenus before the Court of Star-Chamber being charged that he did not submit himself to examination for such things as did concern the King and the Government of the State and were affirmed to be done by a third person and not by himself if he confess his hand to that refusal and make his excuse and plead because he had priviledg of Parliament Whether the Court will not over-rule this plea as erronious and that he ought to make a further answer It is the justest way for the King and the party not to proceed Ore tenus because it being a point in Law it is fit to hear Counsel before it be over-ruled and upon an Ore tenus by the Rules of Star-Chamber Counsel ought not to be admitted and that it would not be for the Honor of the King nor the safety of the subject to proceed in that manner Pasca 5 Car. upon a Habeas Corpus of this Court to bring the body of William Stroud Esq with the cause of his imprisonment to the Marshal of the Kings Bench It was returned in this manner That Mr. William Stroud was committed under my custody by vertue of a certain Warrant under the hands of twelve of the Lords of the Privy-Council of the King the tenor of which Warrant followeth in these words YOu are to take knowledge that it is his Majesties pleasure and commandment that you take into your custody the Body of William Stroud Esq and keep him close prisoner till you shall receive other order either from his Majesty or this Board for so doing this shall be your Warrant Dated this 2 of April 1629. And the direction of the Warrant was To the Marshal of the Kings Bench or his Deputy He is also detained in prison by vertue of a Warrant under his Majesties hand the tenor of which Warrant followeth in these words C.R. WHereas you have in your custody the Body of William Stroud Esq by Warrant of Our Lords of our Privy-Council by Our special Command you are to take notice that this
and condition he died in Summer 1658. being about the age of seventy years Trinity 5. Car. Banco Regis The first day of this Term upon a Habeas Corpus to Sir Allen Apsley the Lieutenant of the Tower to bring here the body of Iohn Selden Esq with the cause of Detencer he returned the same cause as was in Mr. Stroods Case And Mr. Littleton of the Inner-Temple of Counsel with Mr. Selden moved that the Return was insufficient in substance therefore pray'd that he might be bayled and said that it was a matter of great consequence both to the Crown of the King and to the Liberty of the Subject But as for the difficulty of Law contained in it he said under favour the Case cannot be said Grand And so proceeded to his Argument which for the Reasons before mentioned we have postponed and concluded that the Prisoner ought to be bailed The same day Sir Miles Hubbord Benjamin Valentine Denzil Holles Esq were at the Bar upon the Habeas Corpus directed to several Prisons And their Counsel were ready at the Bar to have argued the Case for them also But because the same Return was made for them as for Mr. Selden they all Declared they would rely on this Argument made by Mr. Littleton Some few days after Sir Robert Heath the Kings Atturney General argued that this Return was good and that Mr. Selden and the rest of the parties ought not to be bailed and that within the Return there appears good cause of their commitment and of their detaining also He said The Case is great in expectation consequence and concerns the Liberty of the Subject on one part whereof the Argument is plausible and on the other part it concerns the safety and Soveraignty of the King which he said is a thing of greater weight and that the consideration of both pertains to you the Judges without flighting the one or too much elevating the other and so proceeded to his Argument of which more at large hereafter and concluded that the Prisoners ought to be remanded When the Court was ready to have delivered their opinions in this great business the Prisoners were not brought to the Bar according to the Rule of the Court. Therefore Proclamation was made for the keepers of the several Prisons to bring in their Prisoners but none of them appeared but the Marshal of the Kings Bench who informed the Court that Mr. Strood who was in his custody was removed yesterday and put in the Tower of London by the Kings own warrant and so it was done with the other Prisoners for each of them was removed out of his prison in which he was before But notwithstanding it was pray'd by the Counsel for the Prisoners that the Court would deliver their opinion as to the matter in Law but the Court refused to do that because it was to no purpose for the Prisoners being absent they could not be bailed delivered or remanded The evening before there came a Letter to the Judges of this Court from the King himself informing the Court with the Reasons wherefore the Prisoners were not suffered to come at the day appointed for the resolution of the Judges These were the words of the Letter To our Trusty and welbeloved Our Chief Justice and the rest of Our Justices of Our Bench. C. R. TRusty and welbeloved we Greet you well Whereas by our special commandment we have lately removed Sir Miles Hubard Walter Long and William Stroud from the several prisons where they were formerly committed and have now sent them to our Tower of London understanding there are various constructions made thereof according to the several apprehensions of those who discourse of it as if we had done it to decline the course of Iustice We have therefore thought fit to let you know the true Reason and occasion thereof as also why we commanded those and the other Prisoners should not come before you the last day We having heard how most of them a while since did carry themselves insolently and unmannerly both towards us and your Lordships were and are very sensible thereof and though we hear your selves gave them some admonition for that miscariage yet we could not but resent our Honour and the Honour of so great a Court of Iustice so far as to let the world know how much we dislike the same And having understood that your Lordships and the rest of our Iudges and Barons of our Court of Common Pleas and Exchequer whose advices and judgments we have desired in this great business so much concerning our Government have not yet resolved the main Question we did not think the presence of those Prisoners necessary and until we should find their temper and discretions to be such as may deserve it we were not willing to afford them favour Nevertheless the respect we bear to the proceedings of that Court hath caused us to give way that Selden and Valentine should attend you tomorrow they being sufficient to appear before you since you cannot as yet give any resolute opinion in the main point in Question Given under our Signet at Our Mannor at Greenwich this 24 Iunii in the 5 yeer of our Reign Within three hours after the receit of those Letters other Letters were brought unto the said Judges as followeth To Our trusty and well-beloved Our Chief Justices and the rest of Our Justices of Our Bench. C. R. TRusty and well-beloved we greet you well Whereas by our Letters of this days date we gave you to understand our pleasure That of those prisoners which by our Commandment are kept in our Tower of London Selden and Valentine should be brought tomorrow before you now upon more mature Deliberation we have resolved That all of them shall receive the same treatment and that none shall come before you until we have cause given us to believe they will make a better demonstration of their Modesty and Civility both towards us and your Lordships then at their last appearance they did Given under our Signet at our Mannor at Greenwich this 24 day of Iune in the fifth year of our Reign So the Court this Term delivered no opinion and the imprisoned Gentlemen continued in restraint all the long Vacation Note That in this Term a Habeas Corpus was prayed to the Pursevant of Arms for four Constables of Hertfordshire to whose custody they were committed by the Lords of the Privy-Council and the Habeas Corpus was granted on their behalf but then they were committed to the Custody of other Pursevants and so upon every Habeas Corpus they were removed from Pursevant to Pursevant and could have no fruit of their Habeas Corpus all this Term. There wanted not some who upon the Kings dissolution of this Parliament and his ill success in two former Parliaments did advise that his Majestie for the future might be no more troubled with the impertinencies of Parliaments holding out for example the like
per Annum by raising a certain value upon their Lands and some other impositions which requiring a long Discourse by it self I will omit it here setting it down in my Instructions it will save your Majesty at least One hundred thousand pounds per Annum to make it pain of death and confiscation of goods and lands for any of the Officers to cousen You which now is much to be feared they do or else they could not be so rich and herein to allow a fourth part benefit to them that shall find out the cousenage Here is not meant Officers of State as the Lord Treasurer c. being Officers of the Crown The summe of all this account amounteth unto two Millions or Twenty hundred thousand pounds per Annum Suppose it be but one Million and a Half as assuredly your Majesty may make by these courses set down yet it is much more then I promised in my Letter for your Majesties service Besides some sums of mony in present by the courses following Imprimis By the Prince's Marriage to make all the Earls in England Grandees of Spain and Principi with such like priviledges and to pay twenty thousand pounds apiece for it 2. As also if you make them Foeditaries of the Towns belonging to their Earldoms if they will pay for it besides as they do to the King of Spain in the Kingdom of Naples And so likewise Barons to be made Earls and Peers to pay ninteen thousand pounds a piece I think might yield five hundred thousand pounds and oblige them more sure to his Majesty 3. To make choice of two hundred of the richest men of England in estate that be not Noble-men and make them Titulate as is used in Naples and paying for it that is a Duke thirty thousand pounds a Marquis fifteen thousand pounds an Earl ten thousand pounds and a Baron or Viscount five thousand pounds It is to be understood that the antient Nobility of Barons made Earls are to precede these as Peers though these be made Marquesses or Dukes this may raise a Million of pounds and more unto your Majesty To make Gentlemen of low quality and Francklines and rich Farmers Esquires to precede them would yield your Majesty also a great sum of mony in present I know another course to yield your Majesty at least three hundred thousand pounds in mony which as yet the time serveth not to discover untill your Majesty be resolved to proceed in some of the former courses which till then I omit Other courses also that may make present mony I shall study for your Majestie 's service and as I find them out acquaint you withall Lastly to conclude all these discourses by the application of this course used for your profit That it is not onely the means to make you the richest King that ever England had but also the safety augmented thereby to be most secure besides what shewed in the first part of this Discourse I mean by the occasion of this Taxation and raising of monies your Majesty shall have cause and means to imploy in all places of the Land so many Officers and Ministers to be obliged to you for their own good and interest as nothing can be attempted against your Person or Royall State over land but some of them shall in all probability have means to find it out and hinder it Besides this course will detect many disorders and abuses in the publick Government which were hard to be discovered by men indifferent To prohibite gorgeous and costly apparell to be worn but by persons of good quality shall save the Gentry of the Kingdom much more mony then they shall be taxed to pay unto your Majesty Thus withall I take my leave and kiss your gratious hands desiring pardon for my error I may commit herein Pasc. 5. Caroli Regis B. R. The Reports of the following Arguments were taken by Mr. Widdrington of Gray's-Inn UPon the Habeas Corpus out of this Court to bring here the body of one William Stroud Esq with the cause of his imprisonment to the Marshall of the Kings Bench it was returned in this manner That William Stroud Esq was committed under my custody by vertue of a certain Warrant under the hands of twelve Lords of the Privy Councill of the Lord the King the tenour of which Warrant followeth in these words You are to take knowledge that it is his Majesties expresse pleasure and commandment that you take into your custody the body of William Stroud Esq and keep him close-prisoner untill you shall receive other order either from his Majesty or this Board for so doing this shall be your Warrant Dated the 2 d of April 1629. And the Direction thereof was To the Marshall of the King's Bench or his Deputy He is likewise held in prison by vertue of a certain Warrant under the hand of the King himself the tenour of which Warrant followeth in these words Carolus Rex Whereas you have in your custody the body of William Stroud Esq committed by the Lords of Our Privy Councill by Our speciall command you are to take notice that his commitment was for notable contempts by him committed against Our Self and Our Government and for stirring up of Sedition against Us For which you are to detain him in your custody and keep him close-prisoner untill Our pleasure be further known concerning his deliverance Given at Greenwich the 7 th of May 1629. in the 5 th year of Our Reigne And the direction was To Our Marshall for Our Bench for the time being And these are the causes of the taking and detaining of the foresaid William Stroud c. And upon another Habeas Corpus to the Marshall of the Houshold to have the body of Walter Long Esq he made the same Return as above Ask of the Inner Temple of Counsell with Mr. Stroud moved That the Return was insufficient The Return consists upon two Warrants bearing severall Dates which are the causes of the taking and detaining of the Prisoner For the first Warrant which is of the Lords of the Councill that is insufficient because no cause is shewn of his commitment which is expresly against the resolution of the Parliament and their Petition of Right in the time of this King which now is to which he had likewise given his assent so his taking by vertue of the said Warrant is wrongfull And for the second Warrant it is insufficient also and that notwithstanding that it be the Kings own for the King himself cannot imprison any man as our Books are to wit 16 H. 6. F. Monstrance de faits 1 H. 7.4 Hussey reports it to be the opinion of Markham in the time of Edw. 4. and Forrescue in his Book de laudibus Legum Angliae cap. 18. And the reason given is because no action of false imprisonment lies against the King if the Imprisonment be wrongfull and the King cannot be a wrong doer The Statute
that it is but a Finable offence yet by the said Statute those which are imprisoned for open and notorious naughtinesse shall not be bayled the same naughtinesse is there intended high and exorbitant offence 2. It is fit to restrain the prisoners of their liberty that the Common-wealth be not damnifâ—ed It is lawfull to pull down a house to prevent the spreading mischief of fire it is lawfull to restrain a furious man And by the 14 H. 7. a Iustice of peace may restrain one rout Then the restraint of dangerous men to the Common-wealth is justifiable and necessary 24 E. 3.33 p. 25. Sir Thomas Figet went armed in the Palace which was shewed to the Kings Councell wherefore he was taken and disarmed before the chief Iustice shard and committed to the prison and he could not be bayled till the King sent his pleasure and yet it was shewed that the Lord of T. threatned him Out of which case I observe two things First that the Iudge of this Court did cause a man to be apprehended upon complaint made to the Council that is to the Lords of the Privy Council 2. That although he did nothing he is not mayn-pernable untill the King sent his pleasure because he was armed and furiously disposed So here UUherefore I pray that the Prisoners may be sent back again Davenport argued to the same intent and purpose and therefore I will report his Argument briefly 1. He said That the Return here is sufficient The Counsell on the other side have made fractions of this Return and divided it into severall parts whereas the genuine construction ought to have been made upon the entire Return for no violence ought to be offered to the Text. 7 E. 4.20 In false imprisonment the Defendant did iustifie and alledged severall reasons of his justification to wit because a man was killed and that this was in the County of S. and that the common voice and fame was that the Plaintiff was culpable And this was held a good plea although Bryan did there object That the plea was double or treble and the reason was because twenty causes of suspition make but one entire cause and indivisible unity in this ought not to be divided So C. 8.66 Crogates In an action of trespasse the Defendant justifies for severall causes and held good because upon the matter all of them make but one cause C. 8.117 It is said That it is an unjust thing unlesse the whole Law be looked into to judge and answer by propounding any one particular thereof and if it be unjust in the exposition of a Law it is uncivill in a Return to make fractions of it in the construction thereof especially it being a Return for Information and not for Accusation 2. Although the Counsell on the other side have taken this case to be within the Petition of Right yet this is Petitio principii to take that for granted which is the question in debate He said That he would not offer violence to the Petition of Right to which the King had assented and which shall really be performed But the question here is Whether this Return be within it and the Iudges are keepers not masters of this pledge and it seems that this Return is out of the letter and meaning of the said Statute 3. He said That this was the actuall commitment of the Lords of the Privy Councill and the habituall or virtuall commitment of the King But because upon these two matters he put no case nor gave any reason but what had been put or given in the Argument of the grand Habeas corpus Mich. 3 Caroli and afterwards in the House of Commons which was reported to the Lords in the painted Chamber all which Arguments I heard I have here omitted them And for the great respect which the Law gives to the commands of the King he put these cases 7 H. 3. Attachment of waste against the Tenant in Dower and the waste was assigned in the taking of fish out of a pond and the carrying them away The Defendant pleaded That her second husband by the command of the Lord the King took all the fish out of the said pond to the use of the Lord the King and held a good justification which proves that the command of the King there to her husband excused her of the said waste And yet it is clear that Tenant in Dower is liable to an action of waste for waste done in the time of her second husband But contrary is it where a woman is Tenant for life and took a husband who made waste and dyed no action lies against the wife for that waste And F. N. B. 17. A. If the Tenant in precipe at the grand cape makes default the King may send a UUrit to the Iustices rehearsing that he was in his service c. commanding them that that default be not prejudiciall to him and this command of the King excuseth his default be the cause true or no. 4. For the particulars of the Return it is for notable contempts against the Government But as to that it hath been said that the King hath sundry governments to wit Ecclesiasticall Politicall c. and it is not shewn against which of them This is but a cavilling exception they might as well have excepted to this Return because it is not shewen that these contempts were after the last generall Pardon that had been a better exception The last words of the Return are raising sedition against Us But as to this it hath been said That Seditio is not a word known in the Law and is alwaies taken either Adverbially or Adjectively and is not a Substantive To this he said That although it is not a Substantive for the preservation yet it is a Substantive for the destruction of a Kingdom And he said that he found the word Seditio in the Law and the consequent of it likewise which is seductio populi But it is not ever found to be taken in a good sense it is alwaies ranked and coupled with treason rebellion insurrection or such like as it appears by all those Statutes which have been remembred on the other side Therefore he prayed likewise that the Prisoners might be sent back Trin. 5 Car. B. R. THe first day of the Term upon Habeas Corpus to Sir Allen Apsley the Lieutenant of the Tower to bring here the body of John Selden Esq with the cause of detention He returned the same cause as above and Littleton of Counsell with him moved that the Return was insufficient in substance therefore he prayed that he might be bayled It is true that it is of great consequence both to the Crown of the King and to the liberty of the Subject But under favour for the difficulty of Law contained in it the case cannot be said Grand In my Argument I will offer nothing to the Court but that which I have seen with these eyes and that which
d. interfecit I. S. upon prepensed malice is good for the nature of the thing is expressed although the formall word be wanting but out of the Return the substance of the offence ought alwaies to appear which appears not here But it hath been said by the other side That let the cause in the Return be as it will yet is it not traversable 9 H. 6.54 and I confesse it But as C. 11. James Baggs case is the Return ought to have certainty so much in it that if it be false the party grieved may have his action upon the case And the grievance complained of in the Petition of Right is that upon such Return no cause was certified that is no such cause upon which any Indictment might be drawn up for we never understand that the party shall be tryed upon the Habeas Corpus but that upon the matter contained within it and Indictment shall be made and he shall have his tryall upon it And yet it is clear and it hath been agreed of all hands in the Argument of the grand Habeas corpus Mich. 3. Car. in this Court that if the cause be certified upon the Return of the Habeas corpus that the Court may judge of the legality of that cause 2. Consider the parts of this Return as they are coupled together for notable contempts by him committed against Our Self and Our Government and for stirring of sedition against Us Upon the entire Return the King joynes sedition with notable contempts so that it is as much as if he had said that Sedition is one of the notable contempts mentioned in the first part of the Return so that he makes it but a contempt For the generality and incertainty of the Return I refer my self to the cases put by Mr. Ask and I will not waive any of them True it is if the Return had been that it was for Treason he had not been bailable but by the discretion of the Court and such Return would have been good but it is not so of sedition Gard. 157. Treason is applyed to a petty offence to the breach of trust by a Guardian in Socage but it is not treason And so sedition is of far lesse nature then treason and is oftentimes taken of a trespasse it is not treason of it self nor seditiosè was never used in an Indictment of treason It was not treason before the 25 of Edw. 3. nor can it be treason for 25 E. 3. is a flat Barre as I have said before to all other offences to be treason which are not contained within the said Act or declared by any Statute afterwards And there are offences which are more heinous in their nature then sedition is which are not treason as Insurrections c. which see in the Statute 11 H. 7. cap. 7. 2 H. 5. cap. 9. 8 H. 6. cap. 14. 5 R. 2. cap. 6. 17 R. 2. cap. 8. and by 3 and 4 E. 6. cap. 5. the assembly of twelve persons to attempt the alteration of any Law and the continuance together by the space of an hour being commanded to return is made treason which Act was continued by the Statute of 1 Mar. cap. 12. and 1 Eliz. cap. 16. but now is expired by her death and is not now in force although the contrary be conceived by some which I pray may be well observed By the Statute of 14 Eliz. cap. 1. rebellious taking of the Castles of the King is made treason if they be not delivered c. which shewes clearly that such taking of Castles in its nature was not treason But the said Statute is now expired and also all Statutes creating new treasons are now repealed But for a conclusion of this part of my Argument I will cite a case which I think expresse in the point or more strong then the case in question And it was M. 9. E. 3. roll 39. B. R. Peter Russells case he was committed to prison by the Deputy-Iustice of North-Wales because he was accused by one William Solyman of sedition and other things touching the King And hereupon a Commission issued out of the Chancery to enquire if the said Peter Russell behaved himselfe well or seditiously against the King and by the Inquisition it was found that he behaved himself well And upon an Habeas Corpus out of this Court his body was returned but no cause But the said Inquisition was brought hither out of Chancery and for that no cause of his caption was returned he prayed Delivery but the Court would not deliver him till it knew the cause of his Commitment Therefore taking no regard of the said Inquisition they now send a Writ to the now Iustice of Wales to certifie the cause of his commitment And thereupon he made this Return That the foresaid Peter Russell was taken because one William Solyman charged him that he had committed divers seditions against the Lord the King and for that cause he was detained and for no other And because the Return mentions not what sedition in speciall he was bayled but not discharged And I desire the baylment of the prisoner onely and not his deliverance I desire that the case be well observed In the said case there was an actuall sedition against the King here is onely a stirring up of sedition The words of the said Award are Videtur curiae which are the solemn words of a Iudgment given upon great deliberation There it was for other things concerning Us This is all one as if it had said for other things against Us Concerning the King and Against the King are all one as appears by 25 E. 3. c. 4. de Clero Stamf. 124. Westm. 1. c. 15. Bracton f. 119. 14 Eliz. c. 2. And the words of the Iudgment in the said case were not dimittitur but ideò dimittendus which imply the right of the party to be bayled The said case in some things was more particular then our case and more strong for there was an Accuser to boot which wants in our case There true it is that he was committed by the Iustice of Wales and here by the King himself but this makes no difference as to this Court for be the commitment by the King himself or by any other if it be not upon just cause the party may be bayled in this Court. And for the Inquisition which is mentioned it was no Tryall in the case nor did the Court give any regard thereto To detain the prisoner by the command of the King singly is against the Petition of Right but it being coupled with the cause the cause is to be considered and the truth of the cause is to be intended as well where it is mentioned to be by an inferiour Iudge as where by the King himself for it is traversable neither in the one nor other And 22 H. 8. roll 37. B. R. and 1 H. 8 roll 8. Harrisons case resolv'd that a man committed by the command of the King is
the liberties and priviledges of Parliament shall onely be discussed there and not in other Courts nor by the Common nor Civill-Law see this case more at large in Selden's Notes upon Fortescue f. 42. 11 R. 2. Roll of the Processe and Iudgment An appeal of treason was exhibited against the Arch-bishop of Canterbury and others and there the advice of the Sages of the one Law and the other being required but because the appeal concerned persons which are Peers of the Realm which are not tryed else-where then in Parliament and not in an inferiour Court 28 H. 6. numb 18. There being a question in Parliament concerning Precedency between the Earl of Arundell and the Earl of Devon the opinion of the Iudges being demanded they answered That this question ought to be determined by the Parliament and by no other 31 H. 6. numb 25 26. During the prorogation of the Parliament Thorp that was the Speaker was out in Execution at the Suit of the Duke of York and upon the re-assembly of the Parliament the Commons made Suit to the King and Lords to have their Speaker delivered Upon this the Lords demand the opinion of the Iudges who answer That they ought not to determine the priviledges of the High Court of Parliament 4 ly This accusation in Parliament is in legall course of justice and therefore the accuser shall never be impeached 13 H. 7. and 11 Eliz. Dy. 285. Forging of false deeds brought against a Peer of the Realm Action de scandalis Magnatum doth not lie C. 4.14 Cutler and Dixy's case where divers cases are likewise put to this purpose 35 H. 6.15 If upon the view of the body the slayer cannot be found the Coronâ—r ought to enquire Who first found the dead body and if the first finder accuse another of the murder that is afterward acquit he shall not have an action upon the case for it was done in legall manner So it is the duty of the Commons to enquire of the grievances of the Subjects and the causes thereof and doing it in a legall manner 1â— H. 6.19 8 H. 4.6 in conspiracy it is a good plea that he was one of the Indictors And 20 H. 6.5 that he was a grand-Iury-man and informed his companions And 21 E. 4.6 7. and 35 H. 6.14 that he was a Iustice of Peace and informed the Iury 27 ass p. 12. is to the same purpose And if a Iustice of Peace the first finder a Iuror or Indictor shall not be punished in such cases à fortiori a Member of the House of Commons shall not who as 1 H. 7.4 is a Iudge 27 ass p. 44. may be objected where two were indicted of conspiracy because they maintained one another but the reason of the said case was because Maintenance is matter forbidden by the Law but Parliamentary accusation which is our matter is not forbidden by any Law C. 9.56 there was conspiracy in procuring others to be indicted And it is true for there it was not his duty to prefer such accusation 2 The accusation was extra-judicial and out of Court but it was not so in our case 3 Words spoken in Parliament which is a superiour Court cannot he questioned in this Court which is inferior 3 E. 3.19 and Stamford 153. will be objected where the Bishop of Winchester was arraigned in this Court because he departed the Parliament without license there is but the opinion of Scroop and the case was entred P. 3. E. 3.19 And it is to be observed that the plea of the Bishop there was never over-ruled From this I gather that Scroop was not constant to his opinion which was suddain being in the same Term in which the plea was entred or if he were yet the other Iudges agreed not with him and also at last the Bishop was discharged by the Kings Writ From this I gather that the opinion of the Court was against the King as in Pl. 20. in Fogassas's case where the opinion of the Court was against the King the party was discharged by privy Seal 1 and 2 Phil. and Mar. hath been objected where an Information in this Court was preferred against Mr. Ployden and other Members of the House of Commons for departing from the House without license But in that case I observe these matters 1. That this information depended during all the life of the Queen and at last was sine die by the death of the Queen 2. In the said case no plea was made to the Iurisdiction of the Court as here it is 3. Some of them submitted themselves to the Fine because it was easie for it was but 53. 4 d. But this cannot be urged as a president because it never came injudgment and no opinion of the Court was delivered therein And it is no argument that because at that time they would not plead to the jurisdiction therefore we now cannot if we would 4 These offences were not done in the Parliament House but else-where by their absence of which the Country may take notice but not of our matters being done in Parliament And absence from Parliament is an offence against the Kings Summons to Parliament 20 R. 2. Parliament-Roll 12. Thomas Hacksey was indicted of high-treason in this Court for preferring a Petition in Parliament but 1 H. 4. num 90. he preferred a Petition to have this Iudgment voided and so it was although that the King had pardoned him before And 1 H. 4. numb 104. all the Commons made Petition to the same purpose because this tends to the destruction of their priviledges And this was likewise granted 4 H. 8. c. 8. Strood's case That all condemnations imposed upon one for preferring of any Bill speaking or reasoning in Parliament are void And this hath alwaies been conceived to be a generall Act because the prayers time words and persons are generall and the answer to it is generall for a generall act is alwaies answered with Le Roy voit and a particular Act with Soit droit fait al partyes And 33 H. 6.17.18 A generall Act is alwaies inrolled and so this is 2 ly For the second matter the contempt to the command of the Adjournment 18 Jac. it was questioned in Parliament Whether the King can adjourn the Parliament although it be without doubt that the King can prorogue it And the Iudges resolve that the King may adjourn the House by Commission and 27 Eliz. it was resolved accordingly But it is to be observed that none was then impeached for moving that question 2 It is to be observed that they resolve that the adjournment may be by Commission but not resolved that it may be by a verball command signified by another and it derogates not from the Kings prerogative that he cannot so do no more then in the case of 26 H. 8.8 that he cannot grant one acre of land by parol The King himself may adjourn the House in person or under the great Seal but not by verball message
favor of Roman Catholicks A difficulty concerning the Popes title on the Kings part Another on the Ambassadors part concerning prayers in the Kings Chappel A titular Bishop of Calcedon sent into England Preparations for conducting the Infanta into England No mention made in the Capitulations of restoring the Palatine Mr. Allured his Letter to the Duke The French jealous of this conjunction Pope Vrban to K. Iames. Pope Vrbans Letter to Prince Charls The Treaty begins to tend to a rupture The Prohibition to the Judges and Bishops in behalf of the Catholicks suspended Some of the English in Spain dislike the Match and Religion The Duke disgusted in Spain Buckingham and Bristol run different ways The Palatine by his Secretary labors to engage the Prince against the Marriage The Spaniard continues new delays The English Papists perplexed The Prince ready to depart from the Court of Spain leaves a Proxy with the Earl of Bristâ—l The Duke and Olivares part not Friends The Prince universally â—steemed His departure solemn The Prince feasted the Dons aboard his Ship and bringing them back again to the shore a storm surprises them Expressions of joy for the Princes safe return into England Private Instructions delivered to Bristol contrary to the Proxy Bristol in a Letter gives the Prince a good account of the business King Iames falls off and for a Condition of the Mariage demands the Restitution of the Palatinate Bristol and Asâ—â—n demur upon the new Instructions Sir Walter Aston endeavors to reconcile the Dâ—ke to Spain Advice to the King touching the Duke The Earl of Bristol is commanded by the King to follow the new Instructions King Iames puts the Palatine in hope by Proposal of new terms The Palatines Answer to those Terms proposed by the King The Netherlands appear ready to embrace the antient Union with England The Ratifiâ—â—â—ication come from the new Popâ— and when all is ready for the E 〈◊〉 ls thâ—n is the Maâ—ch dasht by order from England Bristol sends his Apology to K. Iames for having demurred upon the new Instructions Olivares offers Bristol large Preferments in the Kings name when he was to take his leave Bristols Answer to those Profers The Spaniards prepare for a War with England The L. Kensington sent Ambassador into France to feel the pulse of that Court touching a Match renders an account of his acceptance The King advised to call a Parliament The Kings Speech to the Parliament The King approves Sir Tho. Crew for Speaker who made this Speech The Dukes Narrative Both Houses of Parliament justifie the Duke in his Narrative His Majesties Answer to that Justification Both Houses of Parliament concur that the King may not honorably proceed in tâ—e Treaty of the Prince's Marriage and the Palatinate The Kings Speech 〈◊〉 Parliament perswaâ—â—â—â— him to break off the two Treaties of the Match and of the Palatinate Sir Edw. Sackvile's Speech Sir Edw. Sackvile's Speech The Parliaments Answer to the Kings Speech The Parliament offers his Majesty Three Subsidies and Three Fifteens if he break off both Treaties His Majesties Reply The King declares his Resolution to dissolve the Treaties The King accepts the aid proffered him King Iames his Letter to Secretary Conway touching a Petition against the Papists The Petition His Majesties Answer to the Petition The Spanish Ambassadors accuse Buckingham to the King of matters of high concernment The issue of those Accusations The Earl of Bristol protests against the Dukes Narration is imprisoned in the Tower The Speakers and the Kings Speech at the Adjournment of the Parliament Kings Iames demands the Town of Frankendal deposited in the Archducâ—hess hands Spinola marches out of the Town and immediately Re-enters King Iames very desirous of a Match with France The Match with France concluded Count Mansfield arrrives in England 12000 Foot and 200 horse raised to go under his command Scarce the third part of Count Mansfields Army came safe to Land Richard Smith made Bishop of Calcedon and sent into England with Episcopal Jurisdiction * The Duke of Buckingham Instructions to Mr Drummond The Privy-Counsellors present themselves to King Charles King Charles proclaimed at Theobalds At Whitehall In London The old Privy-Council new sworn The Councils advice to the King Proclamation concerning Persons in Office c. Proclamation of Government Resolution taken by the King concerning King Iames Funeral and his own Marriage A Parlamenâ— summoned King Iames Funeral Duke of Buckingham continues Favorite to King Charles Religion considered A general Muster Souldiers levied for the Palatinate Proclamation against disorders committed by Souldiers Articles of the marriage with France signed by the King Private Articles in favor of the Catholicks The Marriage solemnized in France The Duke sent into France for the Queen A Royal Navy sent to Bolâ—ign to transport the Queen The Marriage consummated at Canterbury The Trained Bands of Kent commanded to attend the Queen The King and Queen come to London A Chappel built at Somerset-house for the Queen A great Plague in London The Parliament opened The Kings Speech in Parliament The Lord Keepers Speech in Parliament Sir Tho. Crew Speaker Debates in the House of Commons A Fast. Committees chosen Message to the King touching Religion and his Answer Mr. Montague brought to the Bar. The Arminian party assert his cause The King takes Montagues businâ—â—â— into his own hand Two Subsidies presented to the King The King accepts them and desires more A short Answer to the Petition touching Religion The Parliament adjourned to Oxford The Exchequer removed to Richmond The Vantguard and seven other Ships employed against Rochel The Parliament meets again at Oxford Grievances Mr. Montague Summoned to appear His Cause recommended by the Bishops to the Duke The Appeal to Caesar disputed The Kings Speech in Christ-Church Lord Conway and Secretary Cook by the Kings Command declare the present slate of Affairs Lord Treasurer proceeds in that subject Debates in the House of Commons touching the present state of Affairs Complaints against Papists favored notwithstanding the Kings Answer to the Petition against them The Petition concerning Religion together with his 〈…〉 The Duke renders an account to both Houses of the Fleet. He speaks by way of Objection and Answer * The Earl of Bristol The Dukes Relation accasioned variety of Opinions in Parliament The Kings Message to the Commons Debates upon the Kings Message The Commons Declaration The Parliament dissolved The King follows his Design of War The Kings Proclamation to recal home children of Recusants The Kings Letter to the Lieutenants for the Loan of Money upon Privy-Seals Privy-Seals issued forth to certain Persons Warrants for disarming Recusants Letters directed to Lords Recusants Concourse of Papists prevented Viscount Wimbleton Commander in Chief in the Voyage to Cadez Lord Cromwels Letter to the Duke touching the Fleet. The Earl of Warwick secures Langer-Point in Essex English and Dutch Fleet before Dunkirk dispersed by a storm The General examined before the Council The
Soldiers commanded not to disband Trade prohibited with Spain Trained Bands exercised Part of Michaelmas Term adjourned The Term at Reading Hopes of a Parliament Sir Edward Cook High Sheriff his exceptions to the Sheriffs Oath The Seal taken from Bishop Willâ—ams sequestred formerly and given to Sir Thomas Coventry A Parliament Summoned Recusants to be Excommunicated The King resolved to leave Mr. Montague to the Parliament Preparations for the Kings Coronation A Proclamation for all that have Forty pound per annum to come and receive the Order of Knighthood A Thanksgiving for the Plagues ceasing Number of those who died of the Plague The Ceremonies at the Kings Coronation Archbish. P.P. The Kings Answer A Second Parliament meets The Lord Keepers Speech Sir Hennage Finch chosen Speaker His Speech Grievances taken into consideration Grievances laid open Articles against Mr Montague People prohibited for going to Mass at Ambassadors Houses The Atturney's Letter to the Judges concerning Recusants The Council of War for the Palatinate questioned in the House of Commons The Earl of Pembroke at a Conference presseth Supply Reports from the Committee concerning Evils and Remedies A Committee of the Lords House to consider of the safety of the Kingdom comunicated to the Commons Not well resented The Kings Letter to the Speaker Sir Richard Westons Message The Commons Answer to the Kings Message by Sir Richard Weston The Kings Reply Doctor Turners Queries against the Duke Another Message from the King by Sir Richard Weston Dr. Turners Explanation Dr. Turners Letter to the Speaker Sir W. Walters opinion of the Cause of Grievances Sir Iohn Eliot pursues the Argument against the Duke Three Subsidies and Three Fifteens Voted Debate concerning the Duke resumed The Kings Speech March 29. The Lord Keepers Speech The King proceeds The Duke at a Conference explains the Kings late Speech and the Lord Keepers Declaration The Duke renders an account of his Negotiation in the Low-Countreys The Lord Conway vindicates the Duke A List of Moneys disbursed for the War The Lords Petition touching Precedency chalenged by Scots and Irish Nobles The Lord Conways Letter to the Earl of Bristol The Earl of Bristols Letter to the Lord Conway The Earl of Bristol petitions the House of Lords The Petition referred to the Committee of Priviledges The Kings Letter to the Earl of Bristol The Earl of Bristol Petitions the Lords upon receipt of his Writ A Message from the King to the House of Lords The Marshal of Middlesex's Petition touching Priests The Commons Remonstrance to the King in Answer to his Majesties and the Lord Keepers Speech The House adjourned for a week Private advice given to the Duke The Bishops commanded to attend the King The Dukes answer to a Message from the Commons reported Glanviles report from the Committee The Kings Message touching new matter against the Duke The Earl of Bristol brought to the bar of the Lords House Articles against the Earl of Bristol The Earl of Bristols expressions at the time of his Accusation The Earl of Bristols speech at the Bar of the Lords House at the delivery of his Articles against the Duke He layes open his Case to the Parliament The Lord Chamberlain attests the truth of what the Earl had said The Earl proceeds The Earl of Bristols Articles against the Duke The Earl of Bristols Articles against the Lord Conway A Message from the King to the Lords concerning Bristol's Articles against the Duke The Reasons The Earl of Bristols Speech by way of Introduction before he gave in his Answer His Service to the Palatinate when he was Ambassador to the Emperor His Service to the Palatinate before his Ambassie to the Emperor His arrival in Spain and behavior there His carriage concerning the Match Means to shew that the Match was intended by the Spaniard Bristol not the cause of the Delays in Spain He never disswaded the King to take Arms. He advised both King and Prince to a Protestant Match He never moved his Majesty to set Priests at liberty A Declaration signed by my Lord Conway in behalf of Roman Catholicks He perswaded not the Prince to change his Religion He advised both King and Prince if they will Match with a Catholick rather to Spain then France but cheifly to a Protestant Princess He constantly professed the Protestant religion King Iames proposeth a Match to the Prince Palatine between his eldest son and the Emperors daughter The Earls Reasons why he was forward to consummate the Match til warrant came to the contrary The restitution of the Palatinate promised by the King of Spain and Olivarez The advantages of the Spanish Match to England The Commons Articles against the Duke His ingrossing many Offices Plurality of Offices His buying of Offices His buying the Cinque 〈◊〉 the Lord Zouch The first Article enlarged by Mr. Herbert The second and third enlarged by him His neglect of guarding the Seas His taking a Ship called St Peter of Newhaven The fourth Article enlarged by Mr Selden The Fifth Articles enlarged by Mr Selden His delivering Ships into the hands of the King of France Those ships to be used to his knowledge against Rochel Mr. Glanvile enlargeth the Sixth Article Mr. Glanvile inlarges the Seventh and Eighth Articles Mr. Pym enlargeth the 11. Article The 10. Article enlarged His imbezling and engrossing the Kings money and Lands Mr Sherland enlarges the Ninth Article He enlargeth the Twelfth Article The Thirteenth Article enlarged by Mr. Wandesford Sir Ioh â—llâ—â—â—â— speech concluding the Dukes Impeachment Sir Iohn Elliot and Sir Dudley Diggs committed to the Tower Private Suggestions to the King in behalf of the Duke Kings Speech concerning the Duke The Commons Message by Sir Nath. Rich to seeure the Duke The Dukes Speech against the Commons The Commons discontented at the imprisonment of their Members Sir Dudley Carleton's Speech The Commons Protestation touching words imputed to Sir Dudley Diggs Sir D. Diggs released out of prison protests he never spake the words charged on him The King is satisfied that the words were not spoken The Duke dissatisfied Thirty six Lords protest they heard not the words supposed to be spoken at a Conference Sâ—r Iohn Elliot is released out of the Tower Is charged by Sir Dudley Carlton for his Speech against the Duke He dischargeth himself The Lords Petition to the King about the Earl of Arundel imprisoned in the time of Parliament The Kings Message to the Lords touching the Earl of Arundel The Lords resolved to maintain their priviledges A Remonstrance and Petition of the Peers in behalf of the Earl of Arundel The Kings first Answer to the Remonstrance and Petition The King promiseth to answer the said Remonstrance The Lords are urgent for an Answer The King returns another Answer to the Lords touching the Remonstrance Another Petition to the King touching the Earl of Arundel The King takes exception at the Petition The Lords desire to know of his Majesty to what part of the Petition he takes