in this kind ought not to move us when their Pretence to Infallibility is destitute of the proper Proof and Evidence of it which is a Power of Miracles and when their Doctrines and Practices have neither the evidence of Reason or Scripture on their side For instance That the Church of Rome is the Mother and Mistress of all Churches which is one of the new Articles of Pope Pius the IVth's Creed and yet there is not one syllable in Scripture tending to this purpose And in Reason it cannot be that any but that which was the First Christian Church should be the Mother of all Churches and that the Church of Rome certainly was not and the Church of Jerusalem undoubtedly was And then that the Bishop of Rome as Successor of St. Peter there is the Supreme and Vniversal Pastor of Christ's Church by Divine appointment as he assumes to himself and that it is necessary to Salvation for every humane Creature to be subject to the Bishop of Rome as is declared in their Canon-Law by a Constitution of Pope Boniface the VIIIth which Constitution is confirmed in the last Lateran Council of all which there is not the least mention in Scripture nor any divine Appointment to that purpose to be found there And it is against Reason that all the World should be obliged to trudge to Rome for the Decision of Causes and Differences which in many and the most weighty Matters are reserved to the Decision of that See and can be determin'd no-where else And against Reason likewise it is to found this universal Supremacy in his being Successor of St. Peter and to fix it in the Bishop of Rome rather than at Antioch when it is certain and granted by themselves that St. Peter was first Bishop of Antioch and out of all question that he was Bishop of Antioch but not so that he was Bishop of Rome Nor is there any thing in Scripture for the Deliverance of Souls out of Purgatory by the Prayers and Masses of the Living The whole Thing is groundless and not agreeable to the constant Suppositions of Scripture concerning a future State Nor is there any Reason for it besides that which is not fit to be given the Wealth and Profit which it brings in The Invocation and Worship of the Blessed Virgin and of all the Saints departed is destitute of all Scripture-warrant or Example and confessed by themselves not to have been owned or practised in the Three first Ages of the Church because it looked too like the Heathen Idolatry which deserves to be well considered by those who pretend to derive their whole Religion from Christ and his Apostles by a continued and uninterrupted Succession And this practice is likewise destitute of all colour of Reason unless we be assured that they hear our Prayers in all places which we cannot be unless they be present in all places which they themselves do not believe or that God doth some way or other reveal and make known to them the Prayers which are made to them which we cannot possibly be assured of but by some Revelation of God to that purpose which we no-where find nor doth the Church of Rome pretend to it But I proceed to the 2 d Thing namely That we should much more hold fast the Profession of our Faith and Religion against the Confidence of Men contrary to Scripture and Reason and the common Sense of Mankind For these are the chief grounds of Certainty which we can have for or against any thing and if these be clearly on our side we ought not to be much moved by the Confidence of Men concerning any Doctrines or Practices of Religion which are plainly contrary to these If in Points wherein we have this advantage on our side we do not hold fast the Profession of our Religion our Error and Folly are capable of no excuse And this advantage we plainly have in several Points and Controversies betwixt us and the Church of Rome As in the Worship of Images which is as expresly and clearly forbidden in the Second Commandment and that without any Distinction as any other thing is forbidden in the whole Bible And that it is so forbidden in this Commandment and that this Commandment is still in force among Christians was the Universal Sense of the ancient Christian Church Prayers and the Service of God in an unknown Tongue are directly contrary to the very Nature and End of religious Worship which ought to be a Reasonable Service which it cannot be if it be not directed by our Understandings and accompanied with our Hearts and Affections But if it be performed in an unknown Tongue our Understanding can have no part in it and if we do not understand it it cannot move our Affections And this likewise is plainly contrary to Scripture namely to a large Discourse of St. Paul's almost throughout a whole Chapter where he purp sely sets himself to shew the Unprofitableness and gross Absurdity of Praying or Celebrating any other Part of Religious Worship in an unknown Tongue If any part of Our Religion had been half so clearly condemned in Scripture as this is which yet is the constant and general Practice of the Church of Rome we must have lain down in our shame and confusion would have covered us and we must either have rejected the Authority of the Bible or have renounced that Point of our Religion what-ever it had been Though it had been dear to us as our right Hand and our right Eye we must upon such plain Evidence of Scripture against it have cut it off and plucked it out and cast it from us The like may be said of Locking up the Scriptures from the people in an unknown Tongue contrary to the Command of the Scriptures themselves and to the great End and Design of Almighty God in the Writing and Publishing of them and contrary to the perpetual Exhortations and Counsels of all the Ancient Fathers of the Christian Church for a great many Ages not one excepted They are hardly more frequent and copious and earnest in any Argument than in perswading People of all Ranks and Conditions to the constant and careful Reaing of the Holy Scriptures And contrary to the Common Reason and Sense of Mankind For what should Men be perswaded to be acquainted withal if not with That which is the great Instrument of our Salvation That Book which was written on purpose to reveal and convey to Men the Knowledge of God and of his Will and their Duty What should Men be allowed to know if not That which is the best and most effectual Means to direct and bring them to Heaven or turn them from Sin and to preserve them from Eternal Misery When our Saviour would represent the best and most effectual Means of bringing Men to Happiness and saving them from the Eternal Torments of Hell in the Parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus He brings in Abraham giving the best Advice he
be carried about with every Wind of Doctrine by the slight of Men and the cunning Craftiness of those that lie in wait to deceive For when he is attempted he will either defend his Religion or not If he undertake the Defence of it before he hath examined the Grounds of it he makes himself an easie Prey to every crafty man that will set upon him he exposeth at once himself to Danger and his Religion to Disgrace If he decline the defence of it he must be forced to take Sanctuary in that Ignorant and Obstinate Principle that because he is of an Infallible Church and sure that he is in the right therefore he never did nor will examine whether he be so or not But how is he or can he be sure that he is in the right if he have no other Reason for it but his Confidence and his being wiser in his own conceit than Seven men that can render a Reason It is a shameful thing in a wise man who is able to give a good Reason of all other Actions and parts of his Life to be able to say nothing for his Religion which concerns him more than all the rest 2. To examine and understand the Grounds of our Religion will be a good means by the assistance of Gods Grace to keep us constant to it even under the fiery Tryal When it comes to this that a man must suffer for his Religion he had need to be well established in the Belief of it which no man can so well be as he that in some good measure understands the Grounds and Reasons of his Belief A man would be well assured of the Truth and Goodness of that for which he would lay down hīs Life otherwise he dies as a Fool dies he knows not for what A man would be loth to set such a Seal to a Blank I mean to that which he hath no sufficient Ground and Reason to believe to be true which whether he hath or not no man that hath not examined the Grounds of his Religion can be well assured of This St. Peter prescribes as the best Preparative for suffering for Righteousness sake the 1st Ep. of Peter 3. 14 15. But if ye suffer for righteousness sake happy are ye And be not afraid of their terror neither be troubled But sanctifie the Lord God in your hearts that is make him the great Object of your Dread and Trust and be ready always to give an answer to every man that asketh you a reason of the hope that is in you 2. The holding fast the Profession of our Faith without wavering doth not imply that Men should obstinately refuse to hear any Reason against that Religion which they have embraced and think to be the true Religion As Men should examine before they chuse so after they have chosen they should be ready to be better informed if better Reason can be offered No Man ought to think himself so infallible as to be priviledged from hearing Reason and from having his Doctrines and Dictates tryed by that Test. Our Blessed Saviour himself the most Infallible Person that ever was in the World and who declared the Truth which he had heard of God yet He offered himself and his Doctrine to this Tryal John 8. 46. Which of you convinceth me of sin that is of Falsehood and Error And if I speak the truth why do ye not believe me He was sure he spake the Truth and yet for all that if they could convince him of Error and Mistake he was ready to hear any Reason they could bring to that purpose Though a Man be never so sure that he is in the true Religion and never so resolved to continue constant and stedfast in it yet Reason is always to be heard when it is fairly offered And as we ought always to be ready to give an Answer to those who ask a Reason of the Hope and Faith that is in us so ought we likewise to be ready to hear the Reasons which others do fairly offer against our Opinion and Persuasion in Religion and to debate the matter with them that if we be in the right and they in the wrong we may rectifie their Mistakes and instruct them in meekness if God peradventure may give them repentance to the acknowledgement of the truth We are not only to examine our Religion before we peremptorily fix upon it but after we are as we think upon the best Reason establisht and settled in it Tho we ought not to doubt and waver in our Religion upon every slight and trifling Objection that can be brought against it yet we ought always to have an Ear open to hear Reason and consider any thing of Weight and Moment that can be offered to us about it For it is a great Disparagement to Truth and argues a distrust of the Goodness of our Cause and Religion to be afraid to hear what can be said against it As if Truth were so weak that in every Conflict it were in danger to be baffled and run down and go by the worst and as if the Reasons that could be brought against it were too hard for it and not to be encounter'd by those Forces which Truth has on its side We have that honest Confidence of the Goodness of our Cause and Religion that we do not fear what can be said against it And therefore we do not forbid our people to examine the Objections of our Adversaries and to read the best Books they can write against it But the Church of Rome are so wise in their Generation that they will not permit those of their Communion to hear or read what can be said against them Nay they will not permit the people the use of the Holy Scriptures which they with us acknowledge to be at least an Essential Part of the Rule of Faith They tell their people that after they are once of their Church and Religion they ought not to hear any Reasons against it and though they be never so strong they ought not to entertain any doubt concerning it because all doubting is a Temptation of the Devil and a Mortal Sin But surely that Church is not to be heard which will not hear Reason nor that Religion to be much admired which will not allow those that have once embrac'd it to hear it ever after debated and examined This is a very suspicious Business and argues that either they have not Truth on their side or that Truth is a weak and pitiful and sneaking Thing and not able to make its party good against Error I should now have proceeded in the Second place to shew Positively what is implied in holding fast the Profession of our Faith without wavering and then to have considered the Argument and Encouragement hereto because he is faithful that promised But I shall proceed no farther at this time A SERMON ON HEB. X. 23. Let us hold fast the profession of our Faith without wavering for he
was discovered 3. The Decretal Epistles of the Ancient Popes a large Volume of Forgeries compiled by Isidore Mercator to countenance the Usurpations of the Bishop of Rome and of which the Church of Rome made great use for several Ages and pertinaciously defended the Authority of them till the Learned Men of their own Church have at last been forced for very shame to disclaim them and to confess the Imposture of them A like instance whereto is not I hope to be shewn in any Christian Church This is that which St. Paul calls 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the slight of Men such as Gamesters use at Dice for to alledge false and forged Authors in this case is to play with false Dice when the Salvation of Mens Souls lie at stake 11. Our Religion hath this mighty advantage that it doth not decline Tryal and Examination which to any Man of ingenuity must needs appear a very good Sign of an honest Cause but if any Church be shy of having her Religion Examined and her Doctrines and Practices brought into the open light this gives just ground of Suspicion that she hath some distrust of them for Truth doth not seek corners nor shun the light Our Saviour hath told us who they are that love darkness rather than light viz. they whose deeds are Evil for every one saith he that doth Evil hateth the light neither cometh he to the light lest his deeds should be reproved and made manifest There needs no more to render a Religion suspected to a wise Man than to see those who profess it and make such proud boasts of the Truth and Goodness of it so fearful that it should be examin'd and lookt into and that their People should take the liberty to hear and read what can be said against it 12. We perswade Men to our Reliligion by Human and Christian ways such as our Saviour and his Apostles used by urging Men with the Authority of God and with Arguments fetcht from another World The promise of Eternal Life and Happiness and the threatning of Eternal death and Misery which are the proper Arguments of Religion and which alone are fitted to work upon the Minds and Consciences of Men the terror and torture of death may make Men Hypocrites and awe them to profess with their Mouths what they do not believe in their Hearts but this is no proper means of converting the Soul and convincing the Minds and Consciences of Men and these violent and cruel ways cannot be denyed to have been Practised in the Church of Rome and set on foot by the Authority of Councils and greatly countenanced and encouraged by Popes themselves Witness the many Croisades for the extirpation of Hereticks the standing Cruelties of their Inquisition their occasional Massacres and Persecutions of which we have fresh Instances in every Age. But these Methods of Conversion are a certain Sign that they either disturst the Truth and Goodness of their Cause or else that they think Truth and the Arguments for it are of no force when Dragoons are their Ratio ultima the last Reason which their Cause relies upon and the best and most effectual it can afford Again we hold no Doctrines in defiance of the Senses of all Mankind such as is that of Transubstantiation which is now declared in the Church of Rome to be a Necessary Article of Faith so that a Man cannot be of that Religion unless he will renounce his Senses and believe against the clear Verdict of them in a plain sensible matter but after this I do not understand how a Man can believe any thing because by this very thing he destroys and takes away the Foundation of all Certainty if any Man forbid me to believe what I see I forbid him to believe any thing upon better and surer Evidence St. Paul saith that Faith cometh by hearing but if I cannot rely upon the certainty of Sense then the means whereby Faith is conveyed is uncertain and we may say as St. Paul doth in another case Then is our Preaching vain and your Faith also is vain Lastly To mention no more particulars as to several things used and Practised in the Church of Rome we are on the much safer side if we should happen to be mistaken about them than they are if they should be mistaken for it is certainly Lawful to read the Scriptures and Lawful to permit to the People the use of the Scriptures in a known Tongue Otherwise we must condemn the Apostles and the Primitive Church for allowing this Liberty It is certainly Lawful to have the publick Prayers and Service of God celebrated in a Language which all that joyn in it can understand It is certainly Lawful to administer the Sacrament of the Lords Supper to the People in both kinds otherwise the Christian Church would not have done it for a Thousand Years It is certainly Lawful not to Worship Images not to pray to Angels or Saints or the Blessed Virgin otherwise the Primitive Church would not have forborn these Practices for Three Hundred Years as is acknowledged by those of the Church of Rome Suppose a Man should pray to God only and offer up all his Prayers to him only by Jesus Christ without making mention of any other Mediator or Intercessor with God for us relying herein upon what the Apostle says concerning our High Priest Jesus the Son of God Heb. 7 25. That he is able to save them to the utmost who come unto God by him i. e. by his Mediation and Intercession since he ever liveth to make Intercession for them might not a Man reasonably hope to obtain of God all the Blessings he stands in need of by Addressing himself only to him in the Name and by the Intercession of that one Mediator between God and Man the Man Christ Jesus Nay why may not a Man reasonably think that this is both a shorter and more effectual way to obtain our requests than by turning our selves to the Angels and Saints and importuning them to solicite God for us especially if we should order the matter so as to make ten times more frequent Addresses to these than we do to God and our Blessed Saviour and in comparison of the other to neglect these we cannot certainly think any more able to help us and do us good than the great God of Heaven and Earth the God as St. Paul styles him that heareth Prayers and therefore unto him should all flesh come We cannot certainly think any Intercessor so powerful and prevalent with God as his only and dearly beloved Son offering up our Prayers to God in Heaven by vertue of that most acceptable and invaluable Sacrifice which he offered to him on Earth we cannot surely think that there is so much Goodness any where as in God that in any of the Angels or Saints or even in the Blessed Mother of our Lord there is more Mercy and Compassion for Sinners and a tenderer sense of our Infirmities