Vide Epist ad Ctesiphontem advers Pelagium Item Dialog adv pelag librum primum Hiero Epist To. 2. as the wind is unto a vessel under sail and ready upon the motion of the stream to lanch forth as light is to an open eye yet in the dark The Necessity of the concurrence of the first cause with the second in the operations thereof appears thus All creatures depend upon God in respect of their Being Conservation and Operation For in him we live and move and have our being Acts 17.28 We have our being there is our dependance in respect of our Creation we live there is our dependance in respect of our Conservation we move there is our dependance in respect of our Operation Creatures depend no less upon God in respect of operations then in respect of their beings because the operations of things in both instants viz. both of being and of operation are equally beings of participation 2. From the perfection of the first Cause such is the nature of the first Cause being God and the nature of the second cause being a creature as that thence necessarily followeth the amplitude of Perfection in the first Cause and a universal and subordinate dependance in the second cause in respect of its efficiency In this regard Plato called the second causes the instruments of the first Cause which though in some respect it holdeth not Rhetorf Ex. 3. c. 2. de effi grat because instruments properly so called have no proper efficiency yet so far it is a truth as that every creature universally dependeth more upon God then any creature upon its fellow-creature 3. It implyeth a contradiction Omnia pendent a Deo essentialiter immediatè intrinsicè absolutè aeque ac aequalitèr that the creature should be able to act without dependancy upon the Creator 1. Because the agent being a creature is depending therefore its power to act is depending the power of acting holds proportion with the agent 2. Because the action proceeding from this agent is a being by participation it is impossible for the creature to have other then a depending being 4. As the conserving influence of God is unto the conservation of the creature so is the assisting influence of God unto the operation of the creature If God doth but meerly cease his conserving influence the creature ceaseth to be if God ceaseth his assisting influence the creature ceaseth to act The insensible cessation of the influence of the first Cause without any further violence or hurt done puts a period to the being or stoppeth the operation of the second cause respectively In the Concurse of the first Cause Of the manner of the concurrence of the first Cause with the second 1. Foregoing the influence or concurence thereof 1. Foregoeth the operation of the second cause in order though it be together with it in time The concurring influence of the Creator is the action of the first Cause the operation of the creature following thereupon is the action of the second cause and an effect of that concurring influence Now such an operation of the second cause must needs follow the concurrence of the first because of the order of Causes the first is before the second Of the dignity of the first Cause the first is more worthy then the second Of the dependance of the second cause the second cause depends on the first Of the essential subordination of the second Cause that which is essentially i. e. by absolute necessity of Nature subordained is consequent to that whereto it is subordained And lastly it is manifest in the operation of the creature as an effect thereof the concurring influence of the Creator is the first Cause the effect is after the cause 2. 2. Co-working It is by way of Co-operation or co-working with the second cause in this co-operation Concurse as was now intimated is the action of the first Cause the operation is the action of the second cause from both conjoyned proceedeth the effect Though the effect wrought by means of the operation of the second cause and the operation by means whereof the effect is wrought are both the effects of the first Cause yet in the producing of such effects as are wrought by means of the creature as the second cause cannot produce such an effect without the first Cause so the first Cause will not produce such effects-without the second cause the conjunction of the operation of the first Cause with the second in bringing forth such effects is the co-operation here spoken of In this Co-operation of the first Cause with the second necessary it is that the co-operation of the second cause with the first which necessarily followeth thereupon is absolutely subordinate not co-ordinate with the first Cause A co-ordinate Cause worketh of it self not depending upon its co-working cause or causes A subordinate cause is that which dependeth upon its superior Cause in respect of its working as the Officer upon the Magistrate An absolute subordinate Cause is that which dependeth absolutely upon its superior Cause in respect of its working so all second causes depend upon the first Cause The concurrence of the first Cause with the second 3. Immediate is immediate both in respect of the immediation of its virtue and the immediation of his presence When we say the first Cause concurreth immediately with the second the meaning is that in the co-operation thereof it so works with and upon the second cause as it intimately reacheth it and so as nothing is interposed as it is with two things that touch one another between which there is nothing Immediateness of presence is when things so act one upon another as that the beings or substances of the things are present with one another and touch one the other So fire burning the stubble doth immediately touch it not only with the immediation of its virtue but also with the immediation of its present substance Immediateness of virtue is when notwithstanding the things that act one upon another touch not one another in respect of their beings yet the virtue of the one reacheth and as it were toucheth the other otherwise there could be no working of one thing upon another all acting being by contact i. e. mutual touching either really and virtually or virtually though not really So the fire that warmeth though it reacheth not him that sitteth by it with its substance for then it would burn him Deus agit indistanter Deus corporeus non est sed incorporeus Et ubique diffusus omnia penetrans ad omnē effectum non mod immediatione virtutis sed immediati ne suppositi pertingens Twi Cr. 3. l. 2. yet it reacheth him with its virtue otherwise it could not warm him Now though it be many times a truth concerning the working of second causes one upon another that they work immediately in respect of their virtue but not in respect of the presence of their
his ways dothneither good nor evil He doth no good therefore there is no Heaven because of a double incapacity First In respect of Nature he that neither understandeth willeth remembreth or is affected all those are action is uncapable of blessedness blessedness consisting in the vision and fruition of the chief good Secondly In respect of the way to Heaven namely obedience which man not being a subject of action is uncapable of without action there cannot be obedience and as he doth no good so neither doth he any evil therefore sinneth not therefore there ought to be no conscience of sin nor punishment for sin The Sum is from hence it followeth That man may do what he lists he neither sinneth nor obeyeth There is neither Heaven nor Hell without the actions of man there could be no obedience of man if there could not be the obedience of man there could not be the obedience of Christ who is God-man if there could be no obedience of Christ Christ could be no Saviour nay if there were no actions of man the very reasonable soul by just consequence supposing action it would infer that there were no man and consequently no Christ Christ being both God and man See then and be astonished at that heap of transgression and confusion in this opinion that denyeth the Efficiency of the second cause It is against all experience against the whole order of the creature it takes away the vegetative sensible and rational souls with all other operations it takes away all difference between creatures in those respects it alloweth man and devils to do what they will it denyeth that there is either obedience or sin Heaven or hell Sic itaque administrat omni â— quae creavit ut etiam ipsa proprios exercere agere actus sinat Aug. de Civit. Dei cap. 30. Vna est actio Dei creaturaerespeclu operis non aâ—tem modi agendi Alsted Tom. 3. Metaph Pars 1. cap. 16. or that Christ is a Saviour yea upon point it denyeth that there is either man or Angel yea or Christ himself Confusion be upon that Tenet that brings all unto such confusion What more frequent in the Scripture then to ascribe Efficiency unto second causes For we are Labourers together with God 1 Cor. 3.9 So doth God administer all things which he hath created as that he also suffers them to exercise and act their proper Motions Obj. 2. Some operations of the second cause cannot be ascribed unto God as faith repentance we neither do nor may say God believeth or repenteth but man belieheth man repenteth Therefore God doth not work all things Ans Actions are done either efficiently or formally The Work of repentance is wrought by God efficiently 2 Tim. 2.25 by man formally 'T is God that worketh repentance not man 't is man that repents not God the very formal efficiency of the second cause in man is the effect of the first cause The formal efficiency of the second cause being the effect of and in all respects essentially depending upon the first cause is so far from denying of or detracting from the All-efficiency of the first cause as that it much commends and sets it forth The reason why works wrought by God efficiently are yet ascribed unto man are first because man God not for want of power but out of abundance of goodness being so far pleased to make use of him co-worketh with God therein Secondly Because man is the next formal efficient cause viz. in respect of the order of the ascent and descent of the causes Thirdly Because many operations of the second cause note imperfection as faith repentance c. Obj. 3. If the second cause be determined unto its operations by the concurse of the first cause then the second cause is not free Ans 1. The Will cannot be compelled to say That which is done willingly is done constrainedly is to affirm a contradiction namely that which is willing is unwilling God can determine the Will Sic itaque administrat omnia quae creavit ut etiam ipsa proprios exercere agere Motus sinat quamvis enim nihil esse possit sine ipso non tamen sunt ulla quod ipse Aug. de Civit. Dei lib. 7. cap. 30. Pertingit autem a fine uno ad alterum fortitèr disponit omnia utilitèr vel suavitèr Sap. 8.1 and not prejudice the Nature of the Will because he is an infinite Cause God determineth the Will sutably and agreeably to its own Nature i. e. freely He so determineth the Will as the Will determineth it self God so determineth the Will as a first free Agent as that the Will determineth it self as a second free Agent The Efficiency of God offereth no violence nor changeth the nature of things but governeth them according to their own natures it reacheth from one end to another mightily and sweetly ordereth all things The external transient efficacious Motion of God upon the Will determineth the will with a real determination the Will so moved moveth it self with a real and formal determination The Will in the sence of Composition that is Voluntas codem instanti quo agit habuit potentiaÌ„ actum suum suspendendi in sensu diviso Twiss de permiss lib. 2. crim 3. considered as subordinate to the Decree and Efficiency of God cannot but act in the instant of the determining Motion The Will considered in the sence of division that is as in it self without its subordination to the Decree and Efficiency of God may act or not act in the instant of the determining Motion The Will placed under this determining Motion of God inclineth it self freely to the Act and to that only whereunto it would have inclined it self if upon a supposition of impossibility there were no Decree nor physical or hyperphysical Determination thereof by God Deus ita utitur voluntate ut ipsa voluntas sese electivè vitalitèr expractico rationis judicio agat Rhetorf de gratia excercit 3. cap. 3. Against the All-governing Providence of God If the Decree of God hindered not the liberty of the second cause as we saw before then the Efficiency of God hindereth not the Liberty of the second cause Gods Efficiency being nothing else but the Execution of the Decree If the Decree of God be so far from being a hinderance unto liberty as that liberty cannot be without it nay is the effect thereof as its first cause then the Efficiency of God being but the Execution of the Decree will also be found to be so far from being a prejudice unto liberty as that liberty cannot be without it nay is the effect thereof as its next cause Obj. The Disorder of the second cause is often such as seemeth not to consist with the All-governing Providence of God Divine Government would not order things so disorderly Ans Order is two-fold either the Order of the Decree or the Order of the Command the whole
God governeth according to his Law nor how his Word and Works of Providence do agree the error is in our Judgment not in his Government We know that God is just in all his ways though the reason of the Justice of some of his ways we know not That Gods Word and his Works agree is manifest unto us though how they agree is sometimes hidden from us The seeming defects of Beauty or Justice in the Works of God proceed from the error of our understanding not from any want in Providence The offence that man takes at the Providence of God is taken not given A preservative against temptations arising from difficulties concerning the Justice of the Government of God is to captive Reason unto Faith and to hold these three Conclusions firm though we see not the reason of the premisses 1. That God is righteous Righteous art thou O Lord when I plead with thee yet let me talk with thee of thy Judgments Jer. 12.1 2. That godliness doth us good and no hurt Truly God is good to Israel even to such as are of a clean heart Psal 73.1 3. That sin doth us hurt and no good Though a sinner doth evil an hundred times and his days be prolonged yet surely I know that it shall be with well them that fear God which fear before him But it shall not be well with the wicked neither shall he prolong his days which are as a shadow because he feareth not before God Eccles 8.12 13. Obj. Some things in Scripture are ascribed unto Chance Eccles 9.11 Luke 10.31 therefore all things are not ordered by God Ans Chance is taken for an Event Túxn non legitur in N. T. Fortuna gentilium est blasphemia quam Diabolus expuit in divinaÌ„ providentiaÌ„ unde bea uÌ„ AugustinuÌ„ paenituit se toties impiâ hac voce usum fuisse supposed to fall out by a meer contingent efficiency or casual working of the second cause besides the intent and therefore without the Efficiency of the first Cause Such Events the Heathens ascribed unto Fortune in this sence there is no Chance It is not unworthy our observation that the word properly signifying Fortune is not used in the New Testament Or else Chance is taken for such an Event good or bad as falleth or meeteth a man in his way unlooked for viz. unexpectedly in respect of men but not unintendedly in respect of God The word used Ecclesiast 9. verse 11. is translated an occurrent 1 Kings 5.4 a Metaphor taken from something meeting of a man or one meeting another upon the way unexpectedly So that Solomons scope in the place objected is to shew that the event of humane affairs is not in the power of man however furnished thereunto with second helps but depends upon the Decree and efficient Providence of God This the Wise-man holdeth forth by an enumeration of some particulars whence as by several instances God would teach this truth by denying success to such persons who according to second causes might expect it and giving it to them who according to second causes could not expect it I returned and saw under the Sun that the race is not to the swift nor the battel to the strong neither yet bread to the wise nor yet riches to men of understanding nor yet favor to men of skill but time and chance happeneth to them all Eccles 9.11 The word used Luke 10.31 and translated it chanced is of the same signification with the Hebrew word used Eccl. 9.11 turned Chance and with that vers 2. turned Event 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 aeb Heb. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 unde 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Pisc in loc from the root whereof the Greek word is by some thought to come it is taken for a good event Ruth 2.3 for a bad event 1 Sam. 6.9 Those things that fall out casually or necessarily in regard of the second cause fall out alike infallibly and therefore alike intendedly in regard of Gods Decree Those effects which proceed from second necessary causes as heat from fire are said to fall out necessarily Those effects which proceed from second contingent causes that is such whose effects in respect of their second cause was likely not to be as to be as namely the elicit acts i. e. the free choyce of the will or the tyle falling from the house to alight upon the head of the passengers are said to fall out casually These modifications or qualifications of things namely Necessity and Contingency as they stand opposed one unto another are only found in things in respect of the second causes not in respect of the first Cause Those things which fall out most necessarily in regard of the second cause in respect of the first cause they may be said to fall out freely rather then necessarily In like manner those things which fall out contingently in regard of second causes upon supposition of the Decree so predetermining them may be said to fall out necessarily No necessary act of the creature is necessary simply an experiment whereof is the Babylonish furnace Every contingent act of the creature is necessary upon the supposition of the Decree The same effect is contingent and casual in respect of the second cause and necessary in respect of the Decree Contingent or casual because in respect of the natural agency or causality of the second cause it might not have been but necessary in respect of the Decree all whose volitions infer a necessity of infallibility The Doctrine of the Efficiency of God affords an Antidote or Preservative against many pestilent Errors concerning the Providence of GOD The Vse of this Doctrine The chief whereof are 1. Atheism concluding from the seeming disorder of second causes that there is no God 2. Epicurism concluding from the appearing confusion of humane affairs that God neither governs nor regards them and thereupon looks at it as the only good to take its fill of pleasure during life 3. Stoicism Non Deus est numen parcarum carceclausum Qâ—ale putabatâ—r stâ—icus esse Deus which maketh the first Cause to be depending upon and determined by the second causes in respect of their operations 4. Such who ascribe the administration of things unto Fortune that is neither unto the irresistable order of the second cause with the Stoicks nor unto God with the Truth but unto that blind Idol devised by the Heathen and justly censured to be the spittle of the Devil upon the face of divine Providence 5. Libertinism denying the Efficiency of the second cause and thereby introducing that Chaos of confusion and transgression Bellar. de amiss grat stat pec lib. 2. cap. 18. Vasquez in 3. disp 14. cap. 8. ex Twiss câ—im 3 Suarez Mâ—taph disp 22. Sect. 2. of which before 6. The Doctrine of the Jesuites who albeit they teach the concurrence of the first cause to be necessary unto each operation of the second cause yet so as
it doth not determine but is determined by the second cause thus Bellarmine So as not fore-going only accompanying of the second cause thus Vasquez So as it co-operates with the second cause not after the manner of a principle but after the manner of an action thus Suarez It determineth the second cause say they negatively Hurtado Phys disp 10. Sect. 4. N. 53. not by way of influence which mystical sence of the Jesusuits Hurtado himself also a Jesuite opens by a familiar comparison thus As saith he in case you can write with two pens and I holding one of them hinder you writing with it permitting you to write with the other this permission compelleth not you to write you are free to both but if you write it must be with that pen which I leave not with that which I hold in my hand 7. The Doctrine of the Arminians Profunda subtilitas Twiss de praed digr 10. Sect. 6. who with the Jesuites yeild a concurrence of the Spirit to be necessary unto each act of obedience yet so as they make it subsequent not antecedent following not fore-going lackquying not leading of the operations of the Will Whence according to them the beginning of every good work or act of new-obedience is from the creature As this Doctrine ministreth an Antidote against many pernicious errours so is it also a principle whence we may deduce many precious truths Amongst many take these God's Decree is the Rule of his Efficiency Who worketh all things according to the Counsel of his own will Ephes 2.11 God's Efficiency is answerable unto his Decree The universal Efficiency of the first cause and the subordinate Efficiency of the second cause consist together Workout your own salvation with fear and trembling For it is God which worketh in you to will and to do of his good pleasure Philip. 2.12 13. The second cause acts and doth its actions as properly really and formally as if upon a supposition which yet is impossible there were no first cause The first cause acts and doth all things as properly and really as if there were no second cause Notwithstanding the creature in regard of its formal free-efficiency is somewhat distinguished from a meer instrument yet even those effects wherein God useth the second cause as a subordinate free-agent depend upon and are determined by the first cause as much as where the second cause is a meer passive instrument because the free-efficiency of the second cause is the effect of the first cause And as much as those effects for the producing of which a man makes use of a meer instrument depend upon and are determined by the man who used that instrument Because an instrument being a creature cannot depend upon its fellow-creature so much as every creature depends upon its Creatour And hence it is that second free-agents are sometimes compared unto meer instruments Notwithstanding sin is wholly of man and subordinate efficiency in sinful actions belongs formally unto the second cause yet the infallible futurition and execution of all effects the infallible futurition and ordering the execution of all events is as fully ascribed unto God as if man had no hand therein So then it was not you that sent me hither but God Gen. 45.8 As it is a truth that God is not the Authour of any evil so it is a truth that God is the Authour of all good God is the Eternal and only Independent the creature is a time-dependent He is the only all we are of our selves nothing The second cause is in respect of its being Nam si tu lumen facici averteris a me Mox abeo in nihilum qui nihil antefui Non secus ac vultu substracto aufertur imago In speculo corpus cum later umbra perit and continuance in its being so also in respect of its operation essentially dependeth upon the first cause This is true in spiritual actions John 15.5 For without me you can do nothing In all actions both Natural Civil Moral and Holy For in him we live and move and have our being Acts 17.28 All disorder in the second cause falleth under the order of the first cause yea the most ungoverned actions of the reasonable creature are governed by the Creatour and that not only according to his Decree but also according to his Law prescribed to them where the Gospel hath not been heard According to both Law and Gospel where the Gospel hath been promulgated It is the duty of man to sanctifie God by acknowledging of and acquiescing in his Decree and his All-glorious essicient execution thereof By Creation and Providence applying our selves to the care of our duty and leaving unto him the care of the event to be effected according to the All-predetermining Counsel of God This is the substance of Hesters answer to Mordecai Go gather together all the Jews that are present in Shushan and fast ye for me and neither eat nor drink three days night nor day I also and my Maydens will fast likewise and so will I go in unto the King which is not according unto the Law and if I perish I perish Hest 4.15 16. See Gen. 43 14. 2 Sam. 10.12 Acts 21.14 Prov. 29.26 There is grace enough in the Promise In hac fiducia recumbere unicum est reelè agendì compendium Calv. Epist ante Pralect in Daniel to enable believers to run the race of Providence Let us run with patience the race that is set before us looking unto Jesus the Authour and Finisher of our faith Heb. 12.2 There is also comfort enough in the Promise to support believers so running concerning all events of Providence And we know that all things work together for good unto them that love God to them that are the called according to his purpose Rom. 8.28 So much hath God revealed as that he who believeth and walketh according to the rule needs not be afraid of his secret Will Both the Decree and the Execution thereof though yet unknown as touching infinite particulars are for them not against them Unmortified discontent at the Providence of God is an Argument of an ungodly man the character and disposition of a sinner Eccles 2.26 Contentment therewith is the special gift of God unto his Saints The character and life of the life of a godly man As concerning all the infallible changes that pass upon us in their appointed time according to Gods Eternal Decree I know there is no good in them but for a man to rejoyce and do good in his life and also that every one should eat and drink and enjoy the good of his labour this is the gift of God Eccles 3.11 12. To speak properly no man is content with his estate but a godly man no godly man but is content with his estate CHAP. VI. There are certain Preparatory works coming between the carnal rest of the soul in the state of sin and effectual vocation Or Christ in
〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Sicredideris particula si non est 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Buc. loc 21. q. 3. In which respect we are said to be chosen in him Ephes 1.4 Ascribing due glory unto the Father takes not from but adds to the glory of the Mediatour That Name above all names given unto the Mediatour is Jesus Christ the Lord Philip. 2.9 10 11. Gods Name is the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ 2 Cor. 1.3 Ephes 1.3 1 Pet. 1.3 Christ is all and in all Col. 3.11 God is all in all 1 Cor. 15.28 Christ is all and in all efficiently and meritoriously God is all in all essciently and originally Obj. 3. The active and passive Obedience of Christ is the condition of the salvation of the Elect Jes 53.10 As Adams personal and perfect obedience was a condition in the first Covenant therefore though grace be free in respect of election yet it is not free in respect of the Application of the good of Election Ans The Application both of grace and glory and all the good of the Covenant of grace are free to us though conditioned unto Christ Free-grace exciudes not Christs Merit but mans merit Obj 4. Faith is a condition though not of it self yet of salvation that in the Elect themselves therefore the Application of salvation seems not to be free in respect of the Elect. Ans A Condition is either a Condition properly so called i. e. an antecedent Condition Or a Condition improperly so called i. e. a consequent Condition A Condition properly so called is a Law or Observation annexed to a business the performance whereof lyeth upon the Covenant and accordingly the business becometh valid or null Such a condition was Works in the first Covenant If Faith were such a condition there would soon be an end of the Covenant of grace yea the Covenant of grace were indeed no Covenant of grace A Condition improperly so called or a Consequent Condition is such a condition whose performance by the Covenantee is absolutely undertaken for and irresistably wrought by the Covenantor and not left in suspence upon the Covenantee to be performed by his own strength Faith is a consequent condition not an antecedent condition So as this Proposition I will give Eternal life unto the Elect if they do believe is aequivolent unto this I will out of my absolute will give unto the Elect Eternal life because I will out of my absolute will give unto the Elect to believe The Condition of Faith depends not upon the Will of the Elect either to be or not to be but upon the absolute and gracious Will of God Obj. 5. Repentance and New-obedience are necessary to salvation Luke 13.3 Heb. 3.14 Therefore the Application of the good of Election seemeth not to be free in respect of us Ans Good Works which is also true of Repentance are necessary as the way appointed of God unto salvation but not as the cause this were to change the Covenant of grace into a Covenant of works Our good works are the effects of grace the reward of our good works is a reward of grace Good Works are necessary to salvation as the way not as an instrument or cause Faith is necessary as the way and as an instrument The term Special why diligently to be observed the active and passive Obedience of Christ is necessary as a Meritorious cause The Reason why the term Special is diligently to be observed in this Proposition is That we may the more distinctly conceive of the nature of grace and both discern and eschew the errour of the enemies of grace who so affirm it as in effect they deny it and whilest they seem to stand for grace they indeed withstand and overthrow it either by an equivocation in or by a sophistical interpretation of the term Grace * Pelagiani naturae vim gratiae nomine nuncupare solebant quo sententiāsuā occultarēt offensam hominū de gratia Dei sanctè sententiā e◠commodiùs vitarent Twiss vind grat errat 9. Sect. 9. The Pelagians Semi-pelagians Jesuits and Arminians all affirm this Proposition viz. That Faith is the Effect of Grace but understanding the word Grace therein in such a various and graceless sence as followeth The Pelagians understand by grace only the grace of nature that is the remainder of the Image of God in man after the fall whereby the Will without any further help from supernatural grace is able to believe Thus the Pelagians confound grace and nature The Semipelagians or Massilienses men of much account for learning their time whom Prosper in his Epistle to Augustine calleth the Reliques of the Pelagians understand by grace the conjunction of supernatural grace with free-will So as they both concure together as Joynt-workers and partial-causes i. e. fellow-causes in working of faith Which help of supernatural grace man according to them merits by the good use of his free-will The Jesuits understand by grace Facientiquod in se est presertim si vivat sub notitia Evangelii Deus non denegat auxilium primae gratiae Smising disp Theol. Tom. 1 Tr. 3. disp 6. Fidelis faciens quod ex se est ex congruo meritur gratiā justific antē idem 623. Justificatus potest de congruo mereri gratiam perseverandi idem 700. N. 518. Justificatus potest de condigno mereri salutem ibid. the conjunction of free-will and supernatural grace So as they both concur as joynt partial or fellow-causes in the working of faith Where also note That they understand not faith as we do but define their faith to be a general knowledge and certainty whereby they conclude the Word of God to be divine and true The Sum of their Doctrine comes to this To the natural man that doth what in him lyes especially if he liveth under the knowledge of the Gospel God will not deny the help of the first grace The believer that doth what in him lyeth merits with the merit of congruity justifying grace i. e. habitual grace according to them The justified person may merit with the merit of conguity the grace of perseverance The justified Person persevering may merit salvation with the merit of condignity The Arminians understand by grace the conjunction of supernatural grace yet that is but supernatural common grace with free-will So as both concur together as co-working joynt partial or fellow-causes of faith as it is with a man and a boy drawing the sameship together So as the work is not wrought by grace alone without free-will nor by free-will alone without grace but by both together Whence it followeth according to them which they also affirm that as much grace on Gods part may be put forth upon one that finally resisteth the motion of grace as there is upon one that yeildeth obedience thereunto And that the last and conclusive reason in such a case why one believeth and the other believeth not is from the free co-operation of
THE Orthodox Evangelist OR A TREATISE Wherein many Great EVANGELICAL TRUTHS Not a few whereof are much opposed and Eclipsed in this perillous hour of the Passion of the Gospel Are briefly Discussed cleared and confirmed As a further help for the Begeting and Establishing of the Faith which is in Jesus As also the State of the Blessed Where Of the condition of their SOULS from the instant of their Dissolution and of their Persons after their Resurrection By JOHN NORTON Teacher of the Church at Ipswich in New England For I determined not to know any thing amongst you save Jesus Christ and him crucified 1 Cor. 2.2 Moreover I will endeavour that you may be able after my decease to have these things always in remembrance 2 Pet. 1.15 LONDON Printed by John Macock for Henry Cripps and Lodowick Lloyd and are to be sold at their shop in Popes head Alley neer Lombard street 1654. Norton's Orthodox Evangelist To the Church and Inhabitants of Ipswich in New-England Grace and Peace in our Emanuel Worshipful Reverend and dearly beloved in our Lord and Saviour PAuls desire to make known nothing but Christ unto the Corinths his Travail until Christ was formed in the Galatians with other like speeches of him that breathed nothing but Christ What were they else but the effects of that Savior-like disposition wherewith the Lord Jesus still inspires the Instrumental Saviours of Mount Sion 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 This Ministerial Spirit rested not only upon that great Doctor of the Gentiles but also rests and acts in its measure in all the Ministers of the Gospel for the calling and compleating of the Elect until we all come to be a perfect man So as there is not to be found a more vigorous effusion of the Bowels of Jesus in any of the hearts of the children of men then is in the souls of the Ministry no bowels either of civil or natural relations exceed theirs the love of them is wonderful surpassing the love of Ionathan that passed the love of women By the unbosoming hereof as with a key the Apostle in his Epistle opens the heart of the Reader whilst the Colossians behold the spirit of the writer Col. 2.2 I would to God ye knew what great conflict I have for you Hence I hope in its measure is this present labor for the truths sake for your sake for the sake of any that in the Lord shall accept thereof and for conscience sake To this end was I born and for this cause came I into the world to bear witness unto the truth So our Lord Jesus notwithstanding the Truth was that which the Jews then maligned and Pilate derided see the Spirit of Christ an Hypocrite and a Moralist the difference between piety Malignity and neutrality concerning the truth Nothing is more contended for nothing more contended against then the truth The Gospel truth as it is most dear to God so is it most oppugned by Satan As the Attribute of the Holy One is the Spirit of truth So the wicked one is called a lyar from the beginning Concerning it are the greatest thoughts of heart the most intense endeavors of Tongues Pens and Swords It being much more beloved of its followers then Life and more hated of its opposers then death Truth is the excellency of things where truth is there may be a bad action but where truth is not there cannot be a good action Paul supposeth a man may give his Body to be burned in a good cause and it profit him nothing 'T is not the suffering and the cause alone both suffering cause and Spirit must concur to make a Martyr In a bad cause it holds universally Who hath required these things at your hand Mans interpretation of the Scripture is not Gods mind but mans mistake To confess and suffer in testimony to an error is to be a false-witness not truths witness Pleaders for error not Pillars of the truth To add to the profession of error suffering for it is to add sin unto sin The latter error worse then the first Such sufferers are so far selfe-vassals not Christs Martyrs Such sufferings unto spoyling of goods bonds exile the wilderness or whatsoever are worse then lost a dead birth after sore travel is a double wo Such tears must be wept for again this ungodly sorrow is not to be undone without godly sorrow We may build and work but if it be Wood Hay Stubble we shall suffer loss our work must be burnt though our selves be saved yet as by fire The Scripture mentions Little children Children young-men men Fathers and a perfect man in Christ as concerning your selves unto whom the dreadful bond of office hath endebted me the weakest of many to make known unto you the truth of the Gospel what hath my soul longed or labored for more after your birth in Christ then that you should be not only Babes but men both sound and strong in the faith Sincere and distinct that Christ might not only be formed but perfected That you might not onely have a saving but a satisfactory knowledg of him in whom you beleeve The end of the Gospel is to be known the duty and disposition of the Beleever is to know Even Fundamental Truths which have been the same in all generations have been and shall be transmitted more clear from age to age in the times of Reformation until that which is perfect is come and that which is imperfect be done away Vid. Greynaei praefat locis com Zeged praefix pag. 5. The truth held forth is the same though with more of Christ and less of man Such addition is no innovation but an illustration not new light but new sight The looking glass slurred and cleared more or less is the same glass Columbus did not make a New World when he made a new discovery of the old World Truth wants so much of its glory as it is unseen The understanding wants so much of its perfection as it is short in seeing thereof The Members of the New man have their joynts joynts not fully set are painful and less useful All unbeleif is presumption not faith which hinders nourishment and genders humor Grace Glory and Glorification hold proportion with the truth Though knowledg may be without grace yet there can be no grace without knowledg According to the measure of our approach to an exact total and Adequate Union of the understanding with the truth of the Gospel So is the glory of the truth beleeved and the Communion of the Soul beleeving Men need strong meat at well as Babes need Milk though he who is but a Babe hath not the knowledg of a man yet he that is a Babe labours after the knowledg of a man Babes rest not in being Babes I have endeavored to say something that might entertain the stronger yet so as I hope I have scarce said any thing that weaker capacities may not with due attention attain unto Solid meat
affirmeth that one Act of Volition or Willing in God should be the object of another and then by the same reason that again may be the object of another and so in infinitum This Answer unto this Objection concerning faith foreseen may serve in like manner for an answer unto the objection concerning works foreseen being the cause of Election As also unto that of sin foreseen being the cause of Reprobation Good works are the way to salvation not the cause of Gods Decree to save Sin â—is the cause of punishment which is the actual execution of justice for sin but not of Gods intent to punish sin Sin is the cause of damnation and consequent of reprobation Election is not without the sight of faith and new obedience nor Reprobation without the sight of sin yet faith though it be the instrument and means of the application of salvation following thereupon is the effect not the cause of Election and sin though it be the cause of the application of all the evil of punishment yet is it the consequent not the cause of Reprobation Obj. 3. If sin followeth necessarily upon the Decree then God is the Authour of sin But sin followeth necessarily upon the Decree Therefore God is the Authour of sin Ans This blasphemous Inference is in effect the same with what the ancient Enemies of the Doctrine of the Decree of old calumniated the Teachers thereof with thereby through their sides blaspheming the Scriptures and God himself So objected the Adversaries of this great Truth against Paul the greatest Preacher thereof amongst those that were but men Rom. 9.19 Thou wilt say then unto me Why doth he yet find fault for who hath resisted his Will i. e. If Gods Will determining the being of sin be irresistable then man in committing sin is unblameable Prideaux Lect. 1. de absoluto Decreto Bellarmine de Amiss gratiae cap. 4.5 6 7. why is fault found with that which was unavoydable So the Pelagians against Augustin An absolute Decree necessarily concludeth God to be the Author of sin So Bellarmine against Zuinglius Calvin Beza and other Orthodox Divines slandering their Doctrine of the Absoluteness of the Decree with these horrid Criminations viz. That thence it followeth that God is the Author of sin 2. That God sinneth truly and properly 3. That God is the only sinner 4. That sin is not sin For satisfaction of the Objection we must distinguish of Necessity There is a necessity of Coaction and a necessity of Infallibility Sin followeth not the Decree by a necessity of Coaction or Compulsion in which sence the Objection only holdeth but by a necessity of Infallibility which consisteth with and hindereth not the liberty of sin of which afterwards Hence the Decree though it be the antecedent that is the foregoer of sin yet it is not the cause of sin and sin though it be the consequent that is somewhat infallibly following upon the Decree yet it is not the effect thereof The day goeth before the following night and the night foregoeth the following day yet night and day are far from being causes one of another The diligent attending to the difference between an Antecedent and a Cause and between a Consequent and an Effect for the clearing of which sufficient hath been spoken before is of great use to unty many knots in this place But meeting here with this Satanical and abominable Sophism of imputing unto God the being of the Author of sin it will not be unseasonable to remove other Arguments disputing for the same Conclusion though not all of them upon the same grounds Arg. 1. If God hath absolutely fore-determined all Events then God hath willed sin if God hath willed sin then God is the Author â—f sin Answ Though sin as sin he evil yet the being of sin for a better end is good God doth not will sin as sin For thou art not a God that hast pleasure in iniquity neither shall evil dwell with thee Psal 5.4 yet God hath willed the permission of the being of sin for a better end In peceato actus volendi in Deo non transit in rem permissaÌ„ sed in permissionem Twisse Cr. 3. l. 3. Rivet disp 1. Th. 24. Cum dicitur Deus vult peccatuÌ„ esse hoc refugit pia mens non quia quod dicitur non bene dicitur sed quia quod bene dicitur malè intelligitur Vide Twisse Cr. 3. l. 2. The Jews Acts 4.27 did what God had determined to be done in his Decree when they did what he forbad to be done in his Command Those who give their Kingdom to the Beast Revel 17.17 in so doing fulfilled the word of the Decree yet brake the word of his Command The water whilest it runneth his own course serveth the end of the Artificer in turning about the Mill according to his intent For who hath resisted his Will In the mystry of sin the Decree of God saith a learned and judicious Author passeth into the permission but not into the evil that is permitted that is God willeth the permission of sin but he doth not will sin as sin That better End in order unto which God willeth the being of sin is the manifestation of his own Glory the glory of his Mercy upon the Elect the glory of his Justice upon the Reprobate The manifestation of the glory of God is a greater good then the transgression of man is an evil Had not there been sin there had not been a Gospel had not there been sin there were no need of a Saviour if there had been no sin Jesus Christ had not been Arg. 2. If God ascribeth unto himself the doing of actings that are sinful then God is the Author of sin But God ascribeth unto himself the doing of actions that are sinsul Therefore Concerning the selling of Joseph by his Brethren the Scripture saith It was not you that sent me hither but God Of the Egyptians hatred against the Israelites He turned their heart to hate his people to dâ—al subtilly with his servants Psal 105.25 Of the Incest of Absalom I will do this thing before Israel and before the Sun 2 Sam. 12.12 Of the Rebellion of the ten Tribes and Jeroboam This thing is from me 1 Kings 12.24 Of the cruel plunder of the Babylonians I will send them against an hypocritical Nation and against the people of my wrath will I give him a charge to take the spoyl and to take the prey and to tread them down like mire in the street Isa 10.6 the like is to be seen in many other places Answ We must distinguish between the action and the evil of the action God is so the Author of the action Acts 17.28 as that he neither is nor can be the Author of the evil of the action James 1.14 It is impossible either that God should not be the Author of all good or that he should be the Author of any evil The act or effect hath
an efficient Cause now God is the cause of all Efficiency the evil cleaving to the action is a defect therefore hath no efficient Kâ—ck Log. lib. 1. sect 1. cap. 15. but a deficient Cause Now God cannot be a deficient Cause because he is the first and absolutely perfect Cause therefore cannot be the cause of a non-ens i. e. a nullity or or that which is defective To say God is the cause of sin is to deny God to be the first and absolutely perfect Cause The Rider that causeth the Horse to go is the cause of his going but not of his halting The ready Scribe that writes upon bad paper is the cause of the letter but not of the blot The Musician that playeth upon an Instrument out of tune is the cause of the sound but not of the untuneableness The heat of the Sun that attracts the secret virtues of the Earth is not the cause of the stink of the dunghil His similibus dictu bo minum Satanae mala opera adse â—ibuistur Deo non absâ—lute sed secundum quid in juantum per eadem occulta sua judicia perfecit Parcus in Apocal. cap. 17. The upper wheel of a Clock going well and turning about the lower wheel out of kilter is the cause of its going but not of its going amiss The child illegitimately begotten is the good creature of God its illegitimation is of its parents Notwithstanding God is no way the Author of the evil of the action yet God ascribeth unto himself the doing of these actions that are sinful 1. Because he is the Author of the act wholly 2. Because he is the fore-determiner Orderer and Governor of the sinfulness of the action to his own glorious and blessed End The action is ascribed to him absolutely the sin cleaving to the action not absolutely but only in such sort and respects That Proposition of Aquinas viz. that the act of sin is of God Twisse Cr. 3. l. 2. is by some conjectured probably to have been the occasion why the unlearned Libertines not distinguishing between the act and the defect did infer that God was the Author of sin Arg. 3. Shimei's cursing of David was a sin Exod. 22.28 God bade Shimei curse David 2 Sam. 16.10 therefore God is the Author of sin Answ The bidding in the text is not a bidding properly i. e. a moral Command obliging Shimei thereunto for God had expresly forbidden the thing that he did and the contrary thereunto was his duty but it is a bidding improperly i. e. a natural Command a part of the Decree a Command as some call it of Providence and intends no more then that God by denying the assistance of his grace and leaving Shimei to his own heart and temptations whereupon sin infallibly and inexcuseably followed did so order the cursing of Shimei as that he used his tongue as scourge to chasten David justly in the self-same action wherein he himself abused his tongue to revile David sinfully These Sophisms thus removed it may be also useful upon this occasion to confirm our hearts with some Arguments in the contrary truth namely that God is not the Author of sin From Scripture God makes a Law against the commission of sin Gen. 2.17 smiteth with a curse for sin in all Gen. 3.17 condemned sin in the flesh of his Son Rom. 8.3 gave Christ for the destroying of sin in all his Rom. 6.6 1 John 3.8 therefore God is not the Author of sin Lo this only have I found that God hath made man upright Eccles 7.29 For all that is in the world the lust of the flesh the lust of the eyes â—â—us nemineÌ„ teniat tentatione ad peccatuÌ„ formaliter Twisse Cr. 3. and the pride of life is not of the Father 1 John 2.16 Let no man say when he is tempted I am tempted of God for God cannot be tempted with evil neither tempteth he any man scil by inticing and moving him unto sin James 1.13 love God The children of God would be troubled if grace should fail though their priviledges should not be cut off you are sure of both For as grace is sure so are also the priviledges of grace This was figured under the Law an Israelite could never wholly alienate his inheritance and title to the Land Levit. 25.23 His title to the Land shall not be cut off nor sold for ever This was a type of our spiritual inheritance in Christ which cannot be alienated from us he might for a while pass it away but it was to return again so those that are made coheirs with Christ are never dis-inherited 'T is true we forfeit it by the merit of our actions but God doth not take the advantage of every offence 'T is true we lose the evidences that are in our keeping peace of Conscience and joy in the Holy Ghost but the estate it self is undefeasible and cannot be made away from us Sometimes we are under a kind of sequestration and there is a suspension of comfort and grace as the Israelite might make away his inheritance for a time but we shall recover possession again though not by our selves yet by our Goel our kinsman or him that is next of blood As under the Law if a person were not able to redeem the inheritance the kinsman was to redeem it so Jesus Christ our kinsman after the flesh he is our Goel he interposeth by his merit and reconcileth us to God Well then You see grace is kept and the priviledges of grace are kept in Christ But now because comforts are never prized but in their season and men that have not been exercised in spiritual conflicts nauseate these sweet truths they know not what it is to be left to uncertainty when troubles come like waves one in the neck of another therefore let us see when this truth will be most sweet and seasonable 1. In great troubles when God seemeth to hide his face Oh how sweet is it to hear him say I will not forsake thee till I have perform d all that I promised thee Gen. 28.15 all this shall better thy heart and hasten thy glory In times of distress we are apt to think that God hath cast us off and will never look after us more though formerly we have had real experiences of his grace What a foolish creature is man to weaken his assurance when he should come to use it to unravel all his hope and experiences in times of trouble which is the only season to make use of them 2. In the hour of temptation and hard conflicts with doubts and corruptions when we are sensible of the power of sin and how difficult it is to remove it out of the heart we are apt to say as David after all his experiences I shall one day perish by the hand of Saul 1 Sam. 27.1 and many times out of distrust give over the combate Oh then remember now you are preserved in Christ and
beings themselves as appeared but now from the instance of fire and may further be seen in the example of the Sun which whilest experience witnesseth to warm and heat us upon Earth with the presence of its virtue yet Sense and Reason shews to be far absent in respect of its body being in the Heavens Yet such is the nature of the first Cause as that wheresoever it worketh it worketh immediately both with the immediation of his virtue without which there could be no effect and with the immediation of his presence because he is in every place Although the first Cause worketh immediately in respect of the immediation of its being and virtue yet in respect of those things which it acts by means of second causes whether by the mediation of the beings themselves Ames Med. lib. 1. cap. 9. or of their virtues into which things the second agents do send their influence by virtue of their proper forms I say in respect of such things it worketh mediately whence the first Cause is said to be a mediate cause in respect of the order of the second causes Vna estactio I ei creaturae respectu operis sed non respectu modi agendi 4. Determining For though as the beings so the operations of the second causes are from the first Cause efficiently yet they are from their next causes formally God causeth the burning of the fire yet we do not say God burneth but the fire burneth God worketh repentance in the Soul yet it is not a truth to say God repenteth but man repenteth God is the next efficient Cause but not the next formal Cause 4. The first Cause so concurreth as it determineth the second cause in its operation This is readily granted in natural agents in free-rational agents it is proved thus If the futurition of the operation of the second cause is determined by the Decree of God then the operation it self is determined by the Efficiency of God 1. Because the Efficiency is adequate to the Decree 2. Because there can be but one absolute Determiner 3. If the operation of the second cause were not absolutely determined by the Decree God might suffer disappointment in respect of the Decree Either the Will is determined by God in its operation or else it would follow either that there were not an essential subordination of the second cause unto the first that is of man to God which were repugnant to the nature of the second cause it being imperfect and dependent or that the first Cause were subordinate to the second which were repugnant to the nature of the first Cause being perfect and universal If as often as the Will doth not will it therefore doth not will because God hath not determined that it should will then as often as it willeth any thing it therefore willeth because God hath determined that it should will But as often as the Will doth not will it therefore doth not will because God hath not determined that it should will Therefore the Minor appeareth in two particulars 1. As often as the Will doth not will God hath not determined it to will 2. The Non-determination or Suspension of the Determination of God is the Antecedanious Cause in respect of God this cause cannot be positive A positive cause cannot be terminated in a Non-ens such as mans Non-volition i. e. Not-willing is it must therefore be suspensive The meer Suspension or withholding of the Influence of God without any positive action sufficeth to the annihilation of the creature that is Twiss lib. 2. crim 3. therefore the Suspension of the Determination of God sufficeth to the preventing of that operation of the creature which yet is not Obj. 1. If All-efficiency be from the first cause Against the All-Efficiency of God then the second cause hath no efficiency it doth nothing neither good nor evil man neither sinneth nor obeyeth no difference between good and evil the high way to confusion Thus the Libertines Ans Causes are either co-ordinate namely such as in respect of their Efficiency depend not upon their co-working cause or subordinate namely such as in respect of their efficiency depend upon their co-working cause In co-ordinate causes the Argument holds but second causes in respect of the first being subordinate and therefore as in their being so also in their working depending upon the first cause the Argument is of no force To deny the Efficiency of the second cause Tho. Part. 1. q. 105. art 5. Calvin contra libert c. 13 14 15 16 Suarez Metaph Tem. 1. disp 17. S. 1. is to deny that which experience proclaimeth namely That the Sun shineth or the fire burneth The denyal of the proper and formal efficiency or working of the second cause is repugnant to the whole Order of Nature Things that have not life it depriveth of their first qualities which are nothing else but active principles as power to heat in the fire power to cool in the water It disinables us from collecting effects from second causes or second causes from effects because it denyeth all such causes and effects It makes void all those dispositions in several creatures that tend to action Vain is the disposition in fire to ascend or in the earth to descend if there be no motion of ascent nor descent by them It takes away all perfection from those creatures as also from all other which consists in action Lastly If action be only the first cause in the presence of such a creature and not by the second cause we can no better conclude that the fire is hot from its burning nor that the water is cold from its coolness then we can conclude that the fire is cold or that the water is hot from such operations of heat and cold The reason is the first cause can as well make hot in the presence of water or make cold in the presence of fire as the contrary It takes away all difference between things that have life and things that have no life that which takes away action takes away life Take away action from the second cause and you take away the vegetative soul and its operations from living creatures You take away the sensitive soul and its operations from the sensitive creature The reasonable soul and its operations from the reasonable creature There is no difference to be found between reasonable creatures and sensible creatures between reasonable sensible and those creatures which are vegetative only having life Between reasonable sensible and vegetative and those that are lifeless in respect of their formal and most noble difference which is a principle of action with the operations thereupon ensuing There remains indeed a difference between them in respect of their outward shape but not in regard of the respect fore-mentioned It takes away the distinction between good and evil actions for that which denyeth actions simply denyeth all kind of actions whether good or evil therefore man in all
truth c. 12 p. 281 Peace of conscience what c. 14. 324 The state of the beleever is a state of perfect peace with the grounds thereof c. 14. p. 324 325 Perfection in God what c. 1. p. 20 The perfection of the whole creature is in God eminently c. 15. p. 332 A person in the Divine Nature what c. 2. p. 22 What constitutes a person in God ibid. Difference between a created and an increated Person c. 2.23 A Person how distinguished from a Person c. 2. p. 27 A created Person what c. 3. p. 37 The Person of Christ what c. 11. p. 249 The soul by faith receiveth the Person of Christ yet not personally but objectively c. 11. p. 250 A Personal property what c. 2. p. 28 The Personal notions in number five and which c. 2. p. 30 Positive Attributes what in number six c. 1. p. 16 Poverty legal and preparatory before faith and saving after faith c. 8. p. 184 185 Preparatory work what c. 6. p. 130 Preparatory work taken in its extent what c. 7. p. 141 Works Preparatory properly or in the judgement of charity c. 6. p. 129 130 Preparatory works by way of meer order c. 6. p. 130 Four objections against Preparatory work answered c. 6 p. 139 140 Preparatory work no whit darkneth free grace c. 6. p. 139 The heads whereunto the Preparatory work of the Gospel may be referred c. 7. p. 152 Three cases of conscience concerning Preparatory work c. 7. p. 160 161 c. The notion Preparatory as concerning preparatory work distinguished c. 8. p. 164 The peculiar wayes of Gods Presence with divers creatures c. 1. p. 8 A preservative against temptations concerning the justice of God c. 5. p. 122 Actuall Providence what c. 52 p. 102 Q. Soul-Qualifications what c. 8. p. 163 Saving-Qualifications taken properly or improperly c. 8. p. 164 165 Taken properly what c. 8. p. 164 The variety of Judgements touching the relations that Qualifications before faith have unto conversion c. 8. p. 165 Texts of Scripture against the ascertaining salvation to any Qualification before faith c. 8. p. 166 167 Ten arguments to the same effect c. 8. p. 167 to 175 Our best Qualifications as also our operations before faith are sin c. 8. p. 174 Authorities against ascertaining salvation upon a Qualification before faith c. 8. p. 175 to 179 Nine Objections against the not ascertaining salvation upon some Qualification or Qualifications before faith fully answered c. 8. p. 179 to 190 The four Celestial Qualities of the glorified body opened c. 15. p. 350 351 352. R. Receiving Christ is either active or passive c. 12.267 Reconciliation twofold one before the other after our conversion c. 14. p. 316 The Ministry and Word of Reconciliation why so styled 2 Cor. 5 18 19. c. 9. p. 215 Relative Attributes in number seven c. 1. p. 10 Relative Attributes put no change in God ibid. Repentance legal or saving c. 7. p. 153 Preparatory or legal Repentance what c. 7. ibid Repentance legal or preparatory before faith or saving after faith c. 8. p. 184 185 Reprobation is not an act of Justice c. 4. p. 66 67 68 Reprobation is not the cause of sin though the antecedent thereof c. 4. p. 69 None in this life can ordinarily conclude they are Reprobate c. 4 p. 84. The Gospel why called a Revelation c. 7. p. 152 Revelation of Christ so far as is necessary to salvation what c. 7. ibid. The Law not the Decree is the Rule of life c. 4. p. 80 81 Seven Rules to be observed in propounding of the Doctrine of the Decree c. 4. 82 83 84 85 S. Faith in what sense it is affirmed to be a part of Sanctification c. 11. p. 255 256 To ascertain salvation before faith is to ascertain it to a worke or as it were to a worke c. 8. p. 174 Saving faith what c. 10. p. 219 Saving faith the effect of Election c. 10. p. 199 Before the grace of faith there is nothing that is saving c. 8.170 Seeking Christ without faith and with faith what c. 7. p. 159 Though we cannot seek Christ in faith yet it is our duty to pray c. 7. p. ibid. Jesus Christ findeth the soul while it so seeks him as yet it cannot seek him c. 7. p. 160 The souls selling of all is either legal or saving legal what and how distinguished c. 8. p. 182 183 Saving threefold and what ibid. Simplicity in God what c. 1. p. 5 Adams sin original sin actual sin what c. 7. p. 142 143 144 God is not the author of sin c. 4. p. 61 to 67 As God is not the author of sin so be is not a meer permitter thereof c. 4. p. 66 God delighteth not in the death of a sinner c. 4. p. 73 Man is the cause of sin c. 4. p. 70 Sin is the cause of punishment c. 4. p. 71 Acknowledgement of the Sovereignty of God in point of shewing or not shewing mercy is a point of our humiliation c. 7. 158 The term special to be attended in this Proposition faith is the effect of sperial grace c. 10. p. 228 The Spirit of Christ received by beleevers what and why so called c. 11. p. 249 150 How the soule receives the Spirit of Christ c. 11. p. 250 The Angels and Spirits of the just made perfect how they speak one unto another c. 15. p. 347 T. High cause of Thankfulnesse to be seen in the Decree c. 4. p. 99 A Trance what c. 15. p. 339 The usefulnesse of the doctrines of the Trinity c. 2. p. 31 32 33 34 What Terms are to be avoyded in speaking of the Trinity c. 2. p. 29 V. The effects of the beatifical Vision c. 15. p. 334 The fault of Vnbelief lyeth wholly upon our selves c 9. p. 205 206 It is impossible for an Unbeleever how ever qualified to please God c. 8. p. 173 Every Vnbeleever is in such a condition to which the Scripture speaks wrath c. 8. ibid. God to be taken in the best sense in his tender of grace to an Vnbeleever c. 9. p. 215 T is a truth concerning every Unbeleever how ever qualified that if Christ sheweth him mercy it is meer mercy if hee doth not shew them mercy he doth them no wrong c. 8. p. 172 173 The Vnderstanding of God Angels and men in respect of the manner thereof how distinguished c. 1. p. 16 17 The Personal Vnion what c. 3. p. 38 The manner of the Personal Union c. 3. p. 40 Three most eminent Unions and which c. 13. p. 283 284 The Union betwixt Christ and the Beleever held forth in Scripture under divers lively metaphors c. 13. p. 284 Union between Christ and the Beleever what c. 13. p. 285 The whole Person of Christ is Vnited to the whole Person of the Beleever c. 13. p. 286 Vnion between Christ and the Beleever is reall substantial and supernatural c. 13. p. 290 Union followeth Vocation in order of Nature c. 13 p. 291 Vocation what c. 12. p. 257 Vocation is wrought in an instant c. 12. p. 282 283 W. Waiting on the Lord Jesus in the use of means with preparatory hope what c. 7. p. 159 The Will of God is the first and universal cause of all things c. 4. p. 91 The Will of God is one c. 4. ibid. The Will of God is absolute c. 4. p. 93 No motive of Gods Will besides or without himselfe c. 4. p. 58. seq The All-decreeing and All-disposing Will of God is a ground why we should sanctifie him in all our changes c. 4. p. 99 The distinction of the absolute and conditional as also of the antecedent and consequent Will in God both unsound c. 1. p. 17 18 The Will is determined by God in its operations c. 5. p. 110 and 114 Wisdome in God what c. 1. p. 16 Christ as God-man the object of Divine Worship c. 3. p. 47 FINIS